Professional Documents
Culture Documents
No. 477
$4.00
Happy
New Year!
UFO Journal
In this
issue
Recognizing Women
in Ufology 3
CMS Rankings 21
Spotlight on...
UFO Marketplace 23
Night Sky 24
Women in
Ufology
Columns
Director’s Message 2
MUFON Volunteer
Richard Moss 12
Stan Friedman:
An Open Letter 16
Filers Files 18
January 2008 Number 477
Director’s Message
By James Carrion
MUFON I am pleased to announce that the cases. Starting in the next Journal, the
MUFON 39th International Symposium will Journal will include a special section for
UFO Journal be held July 24 – 27, 2008 in San Jose, presenting files from MUFON Pandora
California at the Doubletree Hotel. To kick archives. If you are a MUFON Field
off the Symposium, Thursday, July 24 th will Investigator, it is important that you
(USPS 002970)
be dedicated to forward to MUFON HQ a copy of your
(ISSN 02706822)
MUFON Field completed investigations with a written
Investigator case summary for inclusion in this special
Mutual UFO Network training sessions. section.
155 E. Boardwalk Drive If you have been
Suite 300 putting off taking UFO Hunters
Fort Collins, CO 80525 the MUFON Field MUFON is in the process of trade-
Tel: 970-232-3110 Investigator exam, marking the phrase “UFO Hunters” along
Fax: 866-466-9173 this is your with a corresponding logo. We are
hq@mufon.com opportunity to get James Carrion publishing a new web site
quality training www.ufohunters.org that will be brought
International Director from world class online to coincide with the History
Ufologists, pick up Channel’s release of their new reality TV
James Carrion, M.A.
a copy of the new MUFON Field Investi- series, also titled “UFO Hunters.” The
155 E. Boardwalk Drive, Suite 300 new web site will contain a timeline
gator Manual and even take your Field
Fort Collins, CO 80525 history of UFO sightings as well as
Investigator exam on the same day. The
Tel: 888-817-2220 planning committee is in the process of background history on the major UFO
Fax: 866-466-9173 speaker selection, so look for more details investigative organizations that have
jcarrion@mufon.com to come in future MUFON Journals. come and gone through the years.
Designed to inform the public about
Editor Journal Changes Coming
MUFON’s mission and goals, the new site
Sally Petersen, M.A. Many of you have written in asking will soon become an important portal for
Tel: 888-817-2220 why the MUFON Journal doesn’t include the latest UFO information on the Internet.
Editor@mufon.com more of MUFON’s own investigated Continued on page 22
Phyllis Budinger
State Section Director, Ohio MUFON events. Frontier Analysis, Ltd.
Owner of Frontier Analysis, Ltd. was launched in March 2000.
Phyllis Budinger was born and raised in northeast Ohio. Since then, the laboratory has
She holds two degrees in chemistry: B.S. from Baldwin- examined numerous UFO
Wallace College and an M.S. from Miami University. She trace samples from all over
joined Sohio, the original Standard Oil Company, in 1964. the world. These include
Through a series of mergers and takeovers the company samples from abductions,
ultimately became BP/Amoco. Phyllis retired with the rank of cattle mutilations, crop circles,
Research Scientist from BP/Amoco in August 1999. UFO deposits, and angel hair.
Her 35 years of experience has been in analytical chem- Some highly visible cases
istry. Most of her analytical industrial experience has been for which analyses have been Phyllis Budinger
devoted to some facet of trouble shooting and problem provided include: soil traces from the Delphos Kansas
solving for BP businesses. She has extensive experience in landing event; bedding material from a 2002 alleged abduc-
analyses using spectroscopic techniques (Infrared and tion case in Brazil; the Betty Hill dress; assorted samples
Nuclear Magnetic Resonance), and has a working knowledge from Stan Romanek’s experiences.
of most other analytical techniques. The results of these analyses have created media inter-
A life-long interest in the mystery of the UFO phenom- est. She has been interviewed on national radio talk shows
enon was the impetus for her to establish a small laboratory and television. Recently she has appeared in episodes for the
dedicated to the study of physical traces related to UFO History Channel’s “UFO Files” series.
Pamela Cisneros
Charleston, South Carolina
MUFON Webmaster
“I have always pondered ‘the big questions’ even as a since childhood, Pamela has a
child,” said Pamela Cisneros. “Reading Carl Sagan at a young fresh, bold style that ensures
age, I became fascinated with outer space and the possibility all Zafari projects are eye-
of other life forms. I am a avid seeker of knowledge and catching, visually dramatic
have found that ufology opens the door to many unexpected and audience-focused com-
areas of inquiry, although most ufologists don’t like to go munication tools. Prior to
down those paths. The more I learn about ufology and other Zafari, Pamela spent over 15
‘esoteric’ topics, the more commonalities and points of years in Washington, D.C.,
intersection I find.” and Denver, Colorado, as an
The original designer (along with her husband) of the information technology
current MUFON logo, website and other marketing materi- consultant serving govern-
als, Pamela has been involved as a member of State MUFON mental and corporate clients. Pamela Cisneros
organizations in Colorado and in South Carolina. Originally from Winston-
Pamela is President of Zafari, Inc., a creative services Salem, North Carolina, Pamela is a College of Charleston
firm she founded in 2000 in Denver, Colorado with her Honors Program Alumnus with a graduate degree from Penn
husband, Christopher. After nearly four successful years in State. Pamela lives and works just outside Charleston with
Denver, her desire to return ‘home’ to South Carolina, her husband/business partner, Christopher, and their three
prompted the relocation of the firm. An accomplished artist four-legged canine children Dixie, Sedona and Beau.
Susan Swiatek
Fairfax, Virginia
State Director, MUFON Virginia the abyss of Budd Hopkins’
Susan Swiatek was born in Washington, DC, spent her seminal work, Missing Time.
childhood near Denver, Colorado, and is today living again She has worked in several
near the nation’s capital. She is currently serving as Virginia aspects of the electronic
State Director for MUFON and is also active with the Fund publishing field, never taking
for UFO Research (FUFOR). her mind’s eye off the UFO
Her early years were spent reading such books as subject for long.
Mysterious Fires and Lights by Vincent Gaddis and Charles A long-time MUFON
Fort’s collections of anomalies. When Betty and Barney Hill’s member, Susan hosted the 1999
“Interrupted Journey” exploded unto the scene in 1966 with MUFON Symposium near
a Look Magazine article, Susan was hooked on the UFO and Washington, DC. She has
abduction mystery. Even as a young child, Susan felt the lectured at various conferences Susan Swiatek
story the Hills were telling about alien visitors in a spaceship including FUFOR events,
had the ring of truth to it. She sensed the serious nature of MUFON of Los Angeles and Aztec, New Mexico. She has
“flying saucers.” created artwork for several book projects, such as Richard
Susan’s artistic abilities led her to a fine arts degree at Hall’s The UFO Evidence-Part II, and Ron Story’s The
the Maryland Institute College of Art in Baltimore. While at Encyclopedia of ExtraterrestrialEncounters (both 2001).
college, many a night was spent pacing the floor, falling into Continued on page 5
4 MUFON UFO Journal January 2008
women in ufology
LuLin (Lin) Simpson
Parker, Colorado
MUFON Director of Special Projects went to Iraq, then to Saudi
I’ve been interested in UFOs since my sighting in the late Arabia where I joined him
1960s. Always wanted to believe that there was other life but for a year, promoting
thought that books available then were not that credible. In MUFON to other West-
the late 80s and early 90s my passion grew as I read more erners during my stay.
credible books, such as Linda Moulton Howe’s Alien Harvest I was an assistant
and so many others. Linda was a Denver Channel 7 reporter state director for three
in the mid 80s. Her investigations and books, along with a years in the 1990s under
speaker that I heard at the University of Denver, sparked then state director,
such an interest that I set on a journey to meet the research- Michael Curta. We held
ers, to make my own determinations about their credibility state meetings at the
and research, and to get an answer to the nagging question of University of Denver,
“are we alone in the universe?” where I was employed,
Initially, I was the PR/Marketing Director for another and brought great speak-
Denver organization, arranging public relations coverage for ers to the campus. I was Lin Simpson
Linda Moulton Howe, Budd Hopkins, Stanton Friedman and a temporary state director
Don Ecker. When I eventually found MUFON, my husband for Colorado for more than a year before Leslie Varnicle took
Bob and I became lifetime members. Meeting John over in 2002.
Schuessler was a pivotal moment for me; we were both Reed Hall and I produced seven one-on-one in-depth
extremely impressed with his credentials and his depth of interviews, “Profiles in Ufology,” which were aired on
knowledge on this subject. At John’s request, Bob became a Boulder PBS in 1999-2000. I also planned two trips and
business board member and I became the Membership drove several people to Roswell, New Mexico. During the
Director. I also was the symposium chairperson for three second trip, for the 50th Anniversary, I was fortunate to have
years. met Col. Corso, over lunch at the Dairy Queen.
My husband and I housed all the MUFON files after the I studied English, Journalism and Sociology at the
closing of the MUFON headquarters office, initially helping— University of Denver, Central State College in Oklahoma and
along with many MUFON volunteers—to get the Pandora Arapahoe Community College. I am currently writing a book
Project off the ground. James Carrion took over after Bob on my experiences in Saudi Arabia.
I believe the MUFON mission to educate the public is an
important aspect to ridding ourselves of the ridicule so that
ufology will be taken seriously and so scientists and re-
Sue Swiatek searchers can get the important funding necessary. Learning
Continued from page 4 that we are not alone in the universe is crucial to our future
evolution on planet earth. I’d like for the youth on our planet
Susan has done covers and helped edit various UFO to yearn to learn more about science and math, as well as
publications, including these published by FUFOR: The space and our place in it.
Roswell Debris Field, by Robert Galganski, 2002 (cover),
Delphos: A Close Encounter of the Second Kind, by Ted
Phillips, 2002 (cover), and Grassroots UFOs: Cases from the
Timmerman Files, by Michael D. Swords, 2006 (editing).
More recently, Susan was a founding editor of JAR, the
Read about more
Journal of Abduction Research. Susan and Virginia MUFON Amazing Women in Ufology
were recently featured in an article in the Washington Post in the February issue of the
(Oct 2007), which was quite fair and amazingly lengthy for a
paper of such caliber. Her focus continues to be collecting MUFON UFO Journal!
and communicating evidence of UFO close encounters, and
reassuring witnesses that they are “not alone.”
Debbie Lowery
Rochester, Illinois
Assistant State Director, MUFON Illinois had a few cases that seemed more like an alien visitation than
a ghostly appearance. Ufology is a whole different world that
I have an Associate Degree in Computer Technology, and I enjoy learning more about.
work in this field with the local government. I’m pleased and honored to be Assistant State Director
The existence of ghosts has always intrigued me. When I for MUFON Illinois. Most of the men who hold an official
was growing up, many times a MUFON title live in northern Illinois and around Chicago, but
phenomenon would happen that I live in Central Illinois. These men that I work with are the
no one would or could explain. I best, and State Director Sam Maranto does everything he
had an avid need to know more. can to include me. I’m proud to be on the same team with all
In 2000 I formed the Springfield of them.
Ghost Society beginning with We have big plans for Illinois MUFON. Currently I’m
four people; there are now well the only Assistant State Director covering activity from
over 75 members. Our group is Central Illinois to the Southern tip. We are having a member-
very active which gives us the ship drive to increase our state membership. Believe or not,
opportunity to interview many there are people living in Illinois who have a need for our
people. Not everything they tell services and don’t realize MUFON exists. Our goal is to
me coincides with what we reach these people to offer our services and let them know
might consider ghostly activity, there is help and support available for them. I am very
so I decided I wanted to learn pleased to have the opportunity to be involved in MUFON
Debbie Lowery more about ufology. We have during this exciting time.
Leslie Kean
Investigative journalist
Co-founder, Coalition for Freedom of Information information campaign in
cooperation with a law firm in
Leslie Kean is an investigative journalist who has worked Washington, DC. The effort,
in print and broadcast media. Her feature stories and news focused on obtaining govern-
analysis pieces have appeared in newspapers and magazines ment documents about the
around the world and her stories have been widely syndi- crash of an unknown object
cated. For many years, she was a producer and co-host for in Kecksburg, Pennsylvania,
an investigative news program on KPFA Radio in Berkeley, in 1965, has the public
California. Kean is the co-author or author of several pub- backing of President Clinton’s
lished books and essays. former chief of staff, John
In May 2000, Kean published an investigative feature for Podesta. The group’s work
the Boston Globe about the authoritative French study by the has received favorable and Photo by Farah Yurdozu
COMETA group called “UFOs and Defense: What are we respectful press coverage
Prepared For?” In 2001, her story about pilot sightings of Leslie Kean
from major TV and print media,
unidentified aerial phenomena and possible aviation safety and Kean provided unique insight into the significance of this
concerns was widely syndicated; in 2002, she published a effort through an widely distributed op-ed piece. In Decem-
story about peer-reviewed scientific studies on crop circles ber 2003, CFi filed a lawsuit against NASA due to the
showing some could not have been created by hoaxers (both agency’s improper withholding of documentation relating to
articles, Providence Journal). In 2002, Kean was commis- the Kecksburg incident, for which Kean is the plaintiff.
sioned by the SCI FI Channel to prepare a research report Recently, in 2007, Kean reached an unprecedented
titled “Science and the Failure to Investigate Unidentified settlement of the NASA lawsuit in U.S. District Court for the
Aerial Phenomena.” District of Columbia, filed as result of NASA’s refusal to
She co-founded the Washington-based advocacy group, release its records concerning the 1965 Kecksburg UFO
the Coalition for Freedom of Information (CFi), for which incident and subsequent stonewalling. The settlement requires
she is Director of Investigations. CFi’s mission is achieving NASA to comb through hundreds of documents in specified
scientific, congressional and media credibility for the study locations and provide copies to Kean under the watchful eye
of unexplained aerial phenomena while working for the of the courts. NASA is required to declassify relevant
release of official information and physical evidence (see documents, explain any redactions, and to pay Kean’s legal
www.freedomofinfo.org). fees.
Since then, Kean has spearheaded CFi’s freedom of Continued on page 8
Leslie Kean re-open its investigation—which the Air Force shut down
Continued from page 7 over 30 years ago—in cooperation with other governments
Kean co-organized a Washington Press Conference in currently dealing with this unusual and controversial phe-
November 2007 with filmmaker James Fox. Former Arizona nomenon. (See the December 2007 MUFON UFO Journal,
Governor Fife Symington III moderated a distinguished panel or www.freedomofinfo.org. for more information).
of former high-ranking government, aviation, and military Kean is currently working as a producer on a new UFO
officials from seven countries to discuss close encounters documentary directed by James Fox, and has begun the
with UFOs. Representatives from seven countries called for process of sifting through hundreds of documents from
the US Government to join in an international dialogue and NASA.
Richard Moss
State Director, Minnesota MUFON
By Lorna Hunter
Field Investigator, MUFON MN followed them for a short dis-
tance then disappeared. After
At the tender age of 13, Richard returning to the same place at the
Moss walked into the drugstore in his same time for several evenings
hometown of Wahpeton, North Dakota, and never seeing that light in the
and spotted Donald Keyhoe’s book The sky again, Richard realized he too
Flying Saucers are Real. That little 25 had been a witness to that same
cent paperback launched a lifelong UFO.
fascination with ufology. Richard has been a MUFON
Richard spent 39 years as a High member for 24 years and is a life
School Chemistry and Physics instruc- member, but he was promoting
tor. In that capacity he introduced UFO awareness even before
thousands of students (including becoming a member. Richard Moss calls to order a MUFON
myself) to the mystery of UFOs. His As Minnesota State Director, Minnesota Board of Director’s meeting in
Physics classes were especially popular Richard presides over monthly June. The sparkle in his eyes and mischie-
because he’d show the UFO films! MUFON meetings in the Minne- vous grin indicate that he’s doing what he
Even after retiring from 30 years in the apolis/St. Paul area as well as bi- enjoys—leading a MUFON meeting!
Long Prairie, Minnesota, school system monthly meetings in greater
he is still invited back each year to “take Minnesota. He is also an active Field
over” the last week of the Astronomy Investigator. His enthusiasm is unwavering and
class. He never fails to lecture on the contagious! He has been an inspiration
Richard is adamant about the im- importance of membership at each and a mentor to many Field Investiga-
portance of educating the public, meeting. His goal is to increase Minne- tors.
especially the younger generation, about sota membership into the hundreds. In his spare time Richard is an avid
the UFO phenomenon. In addition to For several years Richard and his photographer, waterfowl hunter and
lecturing at the high school each year, wife have assisted with the filming of train enthusiast.
he has taught several Community Ed guest presentations at both the UFO
courses and manned the MUFON Congress in Laughlin, Nevada, and the
booths at county fairs throughout MUFON International UFO Sympo-
Central Minnesota. siums. Richard can be found manning a
He taught in Page, North Dakota, camera or copying equipment, while
from 1964–1967. It was during this Rogene sells tapes in the lobby. Richard
time that he saw what turned out to be and Rogene have traveled countless
Leave a Legacy
a UFO. One typical North Dakota miles and contributed countless hours
winter night (20 degrees below zero), to MUFON.
to MUFON
he stopped to pick up a fellow member
of the bowling league. In the clear Allow your work to live on. . .
Eastern sky was a very bright light. Please remember MUFON in your
Thinking it was just the evening star he will. In addition to monetary be-
continued on his way to the bowling quests, you can also donate your
alley. The next day at school Richard’s MUFON Members UFO case files, books, periodicals,
wife, Rogene, overheard one of her Message Board etc. Don’t let your valuable research
students talking to classmates about the mufonmembers.proboards55.com end up at a flea market or estate sale.
bright light she’d witnessed the night
Password: Hynek1947 Please contact MUFON HQ at
before. The young lady said the light
(case sensitive) 970-232-3110 for more information.
came down over some snowmobilers,
Book Reviews
123456789012345678901234567890121234567890123456789012345678901212345678901234567890123456789012123456789012345678901234567890121234567890123456789012345678901212
123456789012345678901234567890121234567890123456789012345678901212345678901234567890123456789012123456789012345678901234567890121234567890123456789012345678901212
123456789012345678901234567890121234567890123456789012345678901212345678901234567890123456789012123456789012345678901234567890121234567890123456789012345678901212
123456789012345678901234567890121234567890123456789012345678901212345678901234567890123456789012123456789012345678901234567890121234567890123456789012345678901212
123456789012345678901234567890121234567890123456789012345678901212345678901234567890123456789012123456789012345678901234567890121234567890123456789012345678901212
123456789012345678901234567890121234567890123456789012345678901212345678901234567890123456789012123456789012345678901234567890121234567890123456789012345678901212
the following months he recalled most important factor is the individual these.
“bizarre snippets of that night.” performing the procedure. What is their Much is made of the fact that the
There it remained until more than a background and training in alien alleged abductions occurred under the
year later as the witnesses gradually abduction regression?” collective noses of the Secret Service,
discussed the details they consciously Dennett states, “Never has a case and there is even speculation that these
remembered from the Coronado Island involved so many witnesses and so government agents were doing more
and other personal incidents. Then they much physical evidence.” True, there than just preparing for an upcoming
agreed to hypnotic regression, and are four primary witnesses, all of visit by President Clinton.
additional details emerged for Mike, whom reportedly have a history of Laurie and Nancy, for example,
Nancy and Phil, but little was added to encounters, but there were four seemed to think that they were being
Laurie’s conscious recall of the inci- abductees in the famous Allagash case, observed and even followed by the
dent. several eyewitnesses in the Travis Secret Service. “They were talking to
Phil recalled seeing his wife taken Walton abduction, and at least three their watches a lot,” says Laurie. “All of
and returned in a beam of light. He also unrelated witnesses in the excellent a sudden we had three waiters. Nobody
reports hearing a man (Mike?) scream Kelly Cahill case. The Cahill case, of else in there had three waiters.”
from the hallway. Mike was unable to course, also included impressive It is, of course, significant that
recall being abducted, even through physical evidence. bright light encounters could reportedly
regression. All the witnesses had In the Coronado Island case, the occur within a block of the house
apparently experienced encounters both regressions indicate there were only which President Clinton was going to
before and after the Coronado Island two reported abductions (Nancy and visit, and not be seen by the Secret
incident. Patricia), although there may have been Service agents. Were the bright lights
The hypnosis of all the witnesses more. observed, and did this cause the Secret
was done by a woman who Dennett The most compelling physical Service to focus on the residents of the
calls Angel (pseudonym), who had evidence in this case has to be the rooms involved?
previously regressed Laurie, as noted alleged implant removed by Dr. Leir While not quite a smoking gun case,
above. While described as a from Nancy’s leg (Nancy is given the The Coronado UFO Incident was well
“hypnotherapist and UFO researcher” pseudonym of Annie by Dr. Leir). worth recording, and this book is well
who had handled many cases, the locale Nancy believes she received the implant worth reading—even without an index,
and extent of Angel’s training is not during the Coronado Island encounter. which would have been very helpful in
provided. It seems strange that an The removed object is anomalous, in this complicated case.
individual who has been very much the opinion of Dr. Leir, but final testing
involved in the UFO phenomenon has not been completed. See Dr. Leir’s
would not want her name and back- interesting book The Aliens and the
ground used in this book. Scalpel for more details on Nancy’s Corrections
Also muddying the water to some case and other implant removals.
extent is the fact that Angel was a Also presented as evidence is an Two people in December’s cover
mutual acquaintance of the four MRI of Mike’s head which supposedly photo were misidentified. The first
primary witnesses, and had accompa- shows three “foreign bodies” located in man seated at the left is Claude
nied them to the Coronado Island various parts of his brain. Other scans Poher, not Vasily Alexeyev. John-
meeting. Moreover, there is no tran- indicate objects in his leg. None of Charles Duboc should be Jean-
script of the hypnosis sessions whereby these have been removed, and there is Claude Duboc.
one could judge whether the witnesses no reference to a diagnosis by a named Page 3. The former governor of
were being led (although many re- surgeon or other medical authority as to
Arizona is Fife Symington III, not
searchers are convinced that witnesses what these images might be showing.
II. He saw the Phoenix Lights in
cannot be led under hypnosis). All four witnesses have reported a
1997, not 1977.
It is interesting that in his otherwise variety of physical effects, including
unremarkable and somewhat weird bruises, other injuries, blood pressure Page 24. The Night Sky should be
Foreward to this book, Dr. Roger Leir, changes, and even rapid healing. Again, January 2008, not 2007.
of implant removal fame, stated in there is no reported medical diagnosis The Editor regrets the errors and
regard to hypnotic regression: “The by a named physician involving any of feels very foolish.
Don’t be surprised that you haven’t heard many instances of huge very important sci- systems. Furthermore, each country would
of it. Fewer than 2% of the attendees at my entific programs conducted out of public want to keep other countries from learning
lectures have read it. Of course Dr. Shermer view. The operation of the first self-sus- what they have learned about the technol-
hadn’t either. taining nuclear chain reaction by Enrico ogy from sophisticated instruments moni-
You claimed that despite all the ama- Fermi and colleagues at the University of toring UFO flight characteristics from in-
teur astronomers out observing the sky, Chicago on December 2, 1942, was con- terceptor platforms and spy satellites, and
none have seen UFOs. Wrong again. You ducted in secret, despite its being of from examination of wreckage recovered
provided no basis for this claim either. earthshaking importance. There were near Roswell in 1947 (or elsewhere). Try
Have you searched the literature or even 12,000 people at Bletchley Park in England my book Crash at Corona: The Definitive
Google? Have you surveyed groups of during World War 2 intercepting secret Study of the Roswell Incident. Each coun-
amateur astronomers? I doubt it. Gert German military communications and— try would also want to determine what the
Herb conducted a survey of the mem- having broken the codes—deciphering, intelligence and scientific communities of
bership of the Astronomical League and translating and distributing the material other countries have learned. One of the
found that about 23.9% of amateur as- very carefully to those with an appropriate many serious implications of an announce-
tronomers had observed “an object which need-to-know. This was of great help in ment of flying saucer reality is that many
resisted (their) most exhaustive efforts at winning the worst war in history. Nothing people might want to think of themselves
identification.” 8.2% had a “high strange- was made public for 25 years. The Naval as Earthlings rather than keeping the old
ness sighting” (Astronomical League Research Laboratory developed and finally nationalistic labels. No government wants
Newsletter XXVIII No. 4, August 1979). successfully launched a number of Corona that. You might ponder the implications of
Do you have some reason for believing spy satellites. The first one in 1960 ob- orders issued to military pilots in 1952 to
that all could have been explained? About tained more information about Soviet mili- “shoot down UFOs if they don’t land when
15% of the amateur astronomers attend- tary installations than all the secret U-2 instructed to do so.” (See the new book
ing a lecture I gave at Griffith Park ad- flights that had preceded it. However, the Shoot Them Down by Frank Feschino Jun-
mitted they had seen a UFO. first public discussion was in 1995. The ior). I wrote the foreword and epilog.
You have also claimed, again falsely, huge Super Secret National Reconnais- I realize I have made some strong
that security cameras, despite their pres- sance Office, whose very existence was comments above. But claims from a
ence all over, have never observed a UFO. classified for many years, launched seven prominent government scientist deserve
Again no source is given. Did you actu- very expensive Poppy Satellites between much more investigation than you have
ally contact security organizations or have 1962 and 1971.The task was to monitor put forth. Dr. Shermer has arranged a
your people review a lot of film? If one Soviet ships at sea. The first public dis- number of debates at Beckman Audito-
puts [security camera UFOs] into Google, cussion was in 2005. In November of rium at Cal Tech. I would be happy to
one gets a huge number of hits. Admit- 2007 the New York Times and US News take either or both of you on in a formal
tedly, some of these hits refer to security and World Report reported on the can- public debate with a moderator, etc. I am
cameras which were made in a UFO-like cellation of NRO’s “Future Imagery Ar- sure I can find another scientist who has
shape. On just the first page, however, 7 chitecture” contract with Boeing, cost- studied the evidence to be on my side of
of the 10 items listed dealt with observa- ing an estimated $18.billion dollars. There the question, “Are Flying Saucers Real?”
tions of UFOs by security cameras. Since was no previous public discussion. The I would also be willing to speak at NASA
these are not normally used for such a development of the stealth fighter took Ames on an expenses-only basis. Feel free
purpose, it seems highly likely that that 10 years and $10 Billion and was done in to make a profit by charging admission.
many more were recorded but not noted. secret. There is plenty of information about me
Having worked as a nuclear physi- Now you and Dr. Shermer might say and flying saucers at my website
cist for 14 years on a wide variety of clas- “but these were all military programs.” I www.stantonfriedman.com .I can provide
sified advanced nuclear and space sys- suspect, judging by the SETI and Skepti- comments from satisfied customers.
tems at major companies, I was dumb- cal literature, that you have not even con- Most cordially and looking forward to
founded by your claim that if evidence sidered the national security aspects of your reply,
for aliens had been discovered, it would the flying saucer enigma. Surely you can Stanton T. Friedman
have been splashed all over the media. understand that the first country to du- cc Michael Shermer
How naïve can you get? I obviously have plicate the flight capability of flying sau-
no information indicating that you have cers, which can obviously fly circles
worked under security or have visited any around anything we Earthlings have fly-
of the 20 document archives I have visited. ing, would rule the world. They would
However, it doesn’t take much effort to find make great weapons delivery and defense
Note: These reports are presented in Tennessee sound in sky is terrifying and moved north
order to keep readers informed of some of of me and
CHATTANOOGA, TN—We heard an
the vast number of sightings being wrapped
unimaginable noise above our car on the
reported. Hoewever, these cases have not around to the
been officially investigated, unless noted. interstate. December 26, 2007, on 7:30
PM, the car shook. We saw lights in a west toward
row that moved at a high rate of speed Fort Worth. I
in sharp turns and went straight into the was looking
air. It happened too fast to get a picture. north and it
Investigator’s Notes: Did the wit- pretty much
nesses experience a low flying jet over moved east to
the freeway? This is not likely an west. George Filer
aircraft they are not supposed to fly The ball was
over 250 knots below 10,000 feet over about the size of a marble in the sky and
populated areas. Thanks to Bill Puckett seemed to be as high as an airplane. It
UFOS Northwest http://ufosnw.com took about 5 or 10 seconds to go across
the sky. I didn’t see where it finished
because there was a roller coaster ride
blocking our view. The tail was about 5
Best UFO Photo of 2007 times the length of the ball. It did not
REDONDO BEACH, CA—On make a sound. The guy next to me saw
March 31, 2007, the witness first sent it and said “you don’t see those every-
the photo and provided the following day. That was pretty awesome.” He said
one liner: “Saw silver object hovering it looked like a big green comet. I
over pier.” The witness later stated, mentioned that I saw a blue comet and
“The photo was taken on the dock he said that he saw it too except it
beside the Redondo Beach Pier at 150 looked more green to him. Thanks to
W. Torrance Boulevard. It was moving MUFON CMS
north to south at a high rate of speed Canada sightings
(similar to jet speed). The object then
Strange Tracks on Mars NORTH TRYON—When Tony
stopped and hovered for five seconds.”
It was during this time that the witness John Schuessler writes, these are Quigley and his wife Marie, just east of
took the photo. About two seconds later interesting tracks on Mars located at the Confederation Bridge, saw a dark
the object sped to the south and the 59.7N, 325.7E. NASA explains these are spiral in the sky they went for the video
witness lost sight of it. The camera dust devil tracks in along Nia Vallis in camera. “When we first saw it, it was
used was a Kodak Easyshare DX7440 4 the Argyre Basin. Image by NASA/JPL/ going so slow. We said, is it a meteorite,
megapixel model. MOLA or what the heck is it? So when we did
Investigator’s Notes: This photo is start to tape, it was above the cloud and
Texas blue ball flashes
one of the best photos that I have seen that’s the part we missed,” said Marie.
ARLINGTON – On December 29, Environment Canada and the Transpor-
of a classic silver flying disk. Not only
2007, I was at Six Flags over Texas tation Safety Board of Canada cannot
does the photo show a flying saucer,
assisting a man with his camera and explain just what it was a PEI couple
but the flight characteristics described
noticed a white flash like a camera filmed in the Island skies on Wednesday
by the witness defy conventional aerial
flash. We looked up and saw the blue evening. Thanks to Brian Vike, Director
motion because the object was moving
ball with a green glow around it with a of HBCC UFO Research, http://
rapidly, stopped, hovered, and then sped
white tail. It was moving across the sky www.hbccufo.org
off. Thanks to Bill Puckett UFOS
from the southeast around Duncanville Continued on page 19
Northwest http://ufosnw.com
18 MUFON UFO Journal January 2008
Filer’s Files The incident was reported at 23:30
hours. People living near the Tlatelolco
Continued from page 18
Unit stated that they heard loud explo-
sions within the plant shortly before the
blackout, which in turn caused several
flashes. A terrorist attack against the
facilities of the Luz y Fuerza company
has been officially discarded.
I had a personal sighting at 11:30 PM,
in the company of my family as I drove
along Avenida de los Cien Metros in the
Gustavo A. Madero district. An object
made up of two shining lights, one sphere
UFO over Mexico shot December 2007
above and another below, both of them
very large and shiny, traveling at relatively between chimneys of the power plant. I
PRINCE EDWARD ISLAND—Chris low altitude. The object remained static. It saw them with my naked eye. They were
Rutkowski wrote, I spoke with the was, however, difficult to capture it on the approximate size of ping-pong balls.”
witness of the UFO case. On December video due to the motion of the car and the The witness quickly grasped his digital
26, 2007, at about 5:30 PM, he and his impossibility of pulling over on an camera (Sony Cyber-shot DSC-H5) and
wife saw a dark object spiraling toward expressway. took photos of some of the elusive
the ground near the horizon. They It should be noted that this is not the objects. “After grasping the camera and
grabbed their video camera and began first time that the UFO phenomenon is applying zoom I noticed that those
filming, and what was caught on film is linked to blackouts in Mexico. Re- objects had whitish surface,” the witness
remarkable. A blackish object giving off nowned researcher Pedro Ferriz states said. “Then I began to photograph them
“smoke” was seen, which the witnesses that then-president Luis Echeverria told trying to catch a glimpse of them at the
likened to a “plane in trouble.” him that he and his wife were witnesses same time. I’d like to emphasize that the
The actual object was difficult to see, to a sighting during the blackouts in objects were disappearing at regular
but the witness thought it was shaped Cuernavaca, Morelos, on September 23, intervals (about 20 sec.) and then reap-
like a ball. It was descending at a 1965. Translation (c) 2007. S. Corrales, pearing. Their movement was steady and
shallow angle in a corkscrew motion, IHU. Special thanks to Ana Luisa Cid) firm. Finally, only one of those objects
moving west, away from the witnesses. Poland: Round objects over Power remained visible for the next 15 sec. Then
Eventually, a long, black contrail was Plant both objects were no longer visible and
formed. The witnesses lost sight of the disappeared in plain sight in the clear sky.
actual object, and it did not seem to BELCHATOW—On August 14, 2007, UFOs keeps appearing over manufac-
actually reach the ground before it a witness from Czestochowa was able turers and power plants all over Poland.
became too dark to observe it, lasting to observe two round whitish objects Thanks to Piotr Cielebiaœ a UFO investi-
more than half an hour in total. The link that were constantly appearing and gator and writer. He lives in Poland and
to the video is at: reappearing for about 3 minutes over a reports on sightings in and around Poland
http://www.journalpioneer.com/ power plant in Belchatow—Europe’s and area. He is part of the NPN: http://
index.cfm?main=broadcast&bcid=751 largest thermal power plant located in www.npn.ehost.pl/ and the NOL the
Central Poland. The witness states, “I Eastern European UFO Journal http://
UFOs in Mexico City during recent saw two enormous round objects nol-polishufojournal. blogspot.com/
blackout
Ana Luisa Cid reports, On December Filer’s Files is copyrighted 2007 by
11, 2007, dozens of districts in the George A. Filer, all rights reserved. These
Mexi-an capital and some municipalities reports and comments are not necessarily
the OFFICIAL MUFON viewpoint. Send
in the state of Mexico were affected by
your letters to majorstar@aol.com.
a 25-minute blackout caused simulta- Sending mail automatically grants permis-
neous explosions in three electric power sion for us to publish and use your name.
stations. The Ministry of Civil Protec- Please state if you wish to keep your name
tion said causes of the explosions are or e-mail confidential.
unknown. They took place at the sub- www.nationalufocenter.com
stations of the Nonoalco and Tlatelolco
plants, as well as the one located in
Ecatepec.
Round objects over Poland power plant
January 2008 MUFON UFO Journal 19
June 5, 1969 four objects seen by the crew of the
commercial and military planes about
after blast. The Ottawa Citizen, p. 13.
Haines, R.F. (2000). Aviation safety in
Continued from page 11 125 miles south of the main flight path America – A previously neglected
were relatively small. Klass, who factor. National Aviation Reporting
mystery might hold clues concerning favored a “meteor” interpretation, Center on Anomalous Phenomena
the method of propulsion and suspen- suggested that the objects seen on the (NARCAP), Report 01-2000, case 65, p.
sion, which Hill, after considering the 62. Note: The entirety of this report is
radarscope in the St. Louis tower were
flight characteristics of many UFOs, available on the internet.
the two planes following flight 112.
attributed to an acceleration field. Klass Hill, P. (1995). Unconventional flying
However, it seems just as likely that the
interpreted the Missouri UFOs as objects: a scientific analysis. Hampton
St. Louis radar operator was referring to Roads, Charlottesville, VA. ISBN 1-
meteors, passing east to west from oncoming traffic.
Bloomington, Illinois, to Glenwood, 57174-027-9.
Conclusions: The combined Klass, P.J. 1975. UFOs Explained. Random
Iowa; a photograph of these was even evidence suggests unusual UFO activity House, Inc., New York. ISBN 0-394-
showcased on the jacket cover of his on June 5, 1969. The UFOs did not 49215-3.
1975 book. Interestingly, if the size of appear to be natural phenomena such as Library and Archives Canada. (2000).
the plasma can be taken as an indication meteors or man-made objects such as Unidentified Flying Objects.
of relative size, the leading “meteor” weather balloons. The large ellipsoidal Unpublished thematic guide. Revised in
was larger than the trailing “meteor,” and much smaller craft, which were September 2000. Retrievable from the
which is similar to the Ottawa case, in observed on this day by numerous Library and Archives website as follows:
which the leading object was observed witnesses in North and South America Home>Our Services>ArchiviaNet>
to be about twice the size of the smaller had characteristics which suggest that Thematic Guides>Unpublished Guides.
object. they were not manufactured using the My copy downloaded July18, 2005 from
I believe that the Missouri case can Earth-based technologies of the late http://www.collectionscanada.ca/
be reinterpreted as follows. Two archivianet/02012002/0201200210_e.html
1960s. The evidence suggests that
relatively large craft entered the atmo- (3 pages).
civilizations much more advanced than
sphere from Bloomington to Glenwood Meere, P. (1969, June 6). MPs in the dark:
ours exist in the Universe and that they Parliament Hill power cut off. The
from which smaller scout craft have perfected advanced high speed
separated or emerged. These smaller Ottawa Journal, p. 3.
interplanetary transportation NRC File N69-128. (1969). In: Herzberg
craft could explain the UFO reports technologies. Institute of Astrophysics. Planetary
north and south of the flight path of the
Acknowledgements Sciences Section. National Research
two large UFOs. Perhaps the UFO seen
Council of Canada RG 77, Vol. 306,
by the pilot and his friend at Cedar I thank the staff of the Library and File N69/128, 1 page. On Microfilm
Rapids, Iowa, 128 km (80 miles) north Archives, Canada for their help accessing Reel T-1741 at the National Archives of
of the main flight path, and estimated at the microfilm. In addition, I am grateful to Canada, Ottawa, Canada.
a height of 305 m (1000 feet), was one the personnel of the Ottawa Library and RCMP (1969, June 5). Royal Canadian
of these small scout crafts. In this the Ottawa Archives for retrieving Mounted Police Report 69-400-18
regard Harkrader, who took the photos microfilm of Ottawa newspapers. I thank “Unidentified Flying Object Sighting
of the two “meteors,” reported “seeing John Morris, Director of Communications From Parliament Hill, 5 June 69 (1
additional flaming fragments break off of Navcanada for making inquiries page). In: Herzberg Institute of
and go into trail behind the fireball” concerning old radar and paper records. Astrophysics. Planetary Sciences
(Klass). As in Ottawa a few hours later, Finally I appreciate the help of Dave Section. National Research Council of
Mitchell of CFRA radio for informing me Canada RG 77, Vol. 306, File N69/104,
perhaps these UFOs were attracted to
that their news transcripts were rarely 1 page. On Microfilm Reel T-1741 at the
the airport. Unfortunately, the FAA
archived. National Archives of Canada, Ottawa,
report based on the accounts of the two
witnesses is so vague that it is not References Canada.
possible to discriminate between UFOs UFOCAT (2005). UFOCAT.com – On This
Bon darchuk, Y. (1979). UFO sightings, Day – June 5. Retrieved Aug. 10, 2005
directly above the airport and the main landings and abductions: The from www.ufocat.com/on_this_day/
fireball over a hundred km away. In this documented evidence. Methuen, June05.html. Larry Hatch, citing the
regard, a typical fireball becomes visible Toronto. Brazilian O Dia newspaper.
at an altitude of about 130 km above Butler, J. (2007). Meteors and Meteorites.
Earth (Butler), suggesting that the Retrieved April 4, 2007, from Natural Franz W. Nentwich received B.Sc.
fireball in Iowa would have been visible Resources, Government of (Hon.), M.Sc., and Ph.D. degrees, all in
high above the horizon in Cedar Rapids. Newfoundland and Labrador – Canada
Geology. In addition, he obtained a B.Ed.
However, the Uba, Brazil UFO, which Web site: http://www.nr.gov.nl.ca/
degree and is currently teaching grades
was observed circling a car earlier the mines&en/geosurvey/education/
6-9 in Calgary, Alberta, Canada.
same day, was obviously relatively small meteors.stm
and definitely not a meteor. Similarly, the Fox, B. (1969, June 6). Downtown in dark
Here is December’s CMS Ranking 1 South Carolina Cheryl Ann Gilmore 100 % 12/12 9/9
2 Iowa Jim King 100 % 8/8 7/7
Report for all State Directors. Con- 3 Tennessee Steven Purcell 100 % 8/8 13/13
gratulations to Cheryl Ann Gilmore 4 Delaware Ralph P. Flegal 100 % 1/1 1/1
5 Kansas Tracey C. Smith 100 % 14/14 9/9
(South Carolina), Jim King (Iowa), 6 New Mexico Donald R. Burleson 100 % 13/13 22/22
Steven Purcell (Tennessee), for 7 Florida Bland Pugh 96 % 48/52 56/56
8 Wisconsin TG Whiteagle / DJ Watson 94 % 12/12 15/17
being 1st, 2nd and 3rd respectively in 9 Texas Kenneth E. Cherry 94 % 43/47 59/60
10 Illinois Samuel Maranto 91 % 43/44 35/41
the month of December. The top 10
State Directors are highlighted. 11 Georgia Walter Sheets 90 % 14/15 15/17
12 California Georgeanne Cifarelli 90 % 59/62 69/80
The report is based on our two 13 Pennsylvania John Ventre 89 % 28/28 23/29
measures of UFO Investigation 14 Indiana Jerry L. Sievers 85 % 41/45 37/46
15 Washington Laurence Childs 85 % 13/17 19/20
effectiveness: assigning reports within 16 West Virginia John Ventre 83 % 9/10 7/9
72 hours of receipt, and completing all 17 New Jersey George A. Filer, III 75 % 11/17 18/21
18 Nebraska John C. Kasher 66 % 4/9 8/9
investigations within 90 days of being 19 Colorado Leslie H. Varnicle 63 % 44/49 22/59
20 Utah Elaine Douglass 53 % 15/18 4/17
assigned. 21 Minnesota Richard D. Moss 52 % 6/19 14/19
The “Assigned” column is a six- 22 Oregon Thomas Bowden 49 % 23/45 29/61
23 North Carolina George E. Lund, III 43 % 6/22 10/17
month running average of the number 24 New York James G. Bouck, Jr. 41 % 41/52 3/62
of cases assigned within 72 hours 25 Michigan William J. Konkolesky 38 % 19/51 21/52
26 Connecticut Erik Kubik 37 % 5/13 5/14
divided by the total number of cases 27 Arkansas Norman D. Walker 33 % 4/11 3/10
received in that six month period. The 28 Ohio William Edward Jones 33 % 15/31 7/39
29 Louisiana Michael D. Sandras 31 % 6/15 2/9
“Completed” column is the number of 30 California Ruben J. Uriarte 31 % 17/66 31/84
31 Arizona George C. Parks 23 % 27/82 6/43
cases completed beginning sixty-two 32 Maryland Bruce S. Maccabee 16 % 0/16 6/18
(62) days back and going back six 33 Nevada Mark Easter 10 % 1/27 4/22
34 Wyoming Richard Beckwith 7 % 1/7 0/6
months from there (for a total of eight 35 Virginia Susan L. Swiatek 5 % 3/27 0/23
months back) divided by the total 36 Alabama Roy E. Patterson, Jr. 5 % 1/9 0/22
37 Massachusetts Greg S. Berghorn 5 % 1/17 1/24
number of cases reported in the same 38 Oklahoma Charles L. Pine 0 % 0/2 0/0
period. The “Weighted Rank” is just 39 Hawaii Puuloa M. Teves 0 % 0/4 0/5
40 New Hampshire Peter R. Geremia 0 % 0/4 0/9
the average of the two columns 41 Vermont Dan Lavilette 0 % 0/2 0/5
42 Washington Gerald E. Rolwes 0 % 0/2 0/4
expressed as a percent. 43 Missouri Bruce A. Widaman 0 % 0/8 0/12
State Directors can improve their 44 Idaho Robert Gates 0 % 0/13 0/12
scores by being sure to assign all 45 Kentucky Earle T. Benezet 0 % 0/14 0/16
Heads UP
Order from MUFON Headquarters, the MUFON.com
New Episodes of The Black Vault Radio every TUES-
website, or from the author at 14026 Ridgelawn Road,
Martinsville, IL 62442. $9.95 plus $2.00 shipping (single or
DAY and THURSDAY night! www.blackvault.com
multiple copies).