Professional Documents
Culture Documents
40
atomic scale, based on the few reports of such exists for the original growth of chlorite-mica
phases in the literature (Lee ., 1984; Lee &
et al stacks as crystals parallel to bedding in a diagenetic
Peacor, 1985, Ahn & Peacor, 1986). Mixed-layering foliation at very low to low-grade metamorphic
of dioctahedral mica and trioctahedral chlorite is conditions, prior to deformation (Weber, 1981;
less common than mixtures between biotite and Greg, 1986).
trioctahedral chlorite, described on multiple occa- In this study we examined mixed-layer musco-
sions and considered to be the result of biotite vite-chlorite occurring in anchizonal slate from the
alteration (e.g. Veblen & Ferry, 1983; Eggleton & Puncoviscana Formation (Eastern Cordillera, NW
Banfield, 1985). As Lee & Peacor (1985) noted, Argentina). This material was first detected by
ordered mixed layering of this type should not be XRD, as it represents a major component of the
stable in large volumes, owing to the large clay fraction. In this slate, dioctahedral mica and
difference in and crystallographic dimensions
a b chlorite also form interleaved phyllosilicate grains
between dioctahedral and trioctahedral layers. Such that can be recognized at the optical scale. The
a mismatch implies that considerable strain must purpose of this work is to study in detail mixed-
exist across the layer boundaries. layer mica-chlorite by scanning electron microscopy
Different mechanisms of formation have been (SEM) and transmission electron microscopy
invoked to explain mixed-layer dioctahedral mica- (TEM) with the aim of determining their crystal-
trioctahedral chlorite. Lee & Peacor (1985) inter- lochemical characteristics, and to interpret their
preted the random mixed layering between 10 AÊ petrological meaning.
layers and 14 AÊ layers which they observed in a
transitional sample from mudstone to slate as an GEOLOGY AND SAMPLE
intermediate stage in the development of slaty DESCRIPTION
cleavage that would begin with the dissolution of
illite and chlorite grains, and probably I-S, parallel Mixed-layer mica-chlorite was identified by XRD,
to bedding. These authors considered that dissolu- as described below, in several Puncoviscana slates
tion and crystallization, rather than solid-state from Sierra de Mojotoro, in which they may
reactions, were the primary mechanism of transfor- represent a major or a subordinate phase.
mation. In turn, mixed-layer illite-chlorite occurring Anchizonal slate P90 (KI = 0.30) was chosen for
in volcanogenic sediments was interpreted by Ahn TEM observations because, according to X-ray
& Peacor (1988) as formed through crystallization data, it contains abundant interstratified musco-
following dissolution of smectite. In contrast, Knipe vite-chlorite; furthermore, it displays less evidence
(1981), in his study of slaty cleavage development, of retrograde alteration of clay minerals than other
interpreted the irregular mixed layering of chlorite slates of the area (Do Campo, 1999b; Do Campo &
layers inside mica packets as developed by solid- Nieto, 2003). This sample comes from an outcrop
state reordering of illite. of the Puncoviscana Formation (Turner, 1960)
On the other hand, the origin of muscovite- located near Chamical church in Sierra de
chlorite stacks was discussed extensively by Li et Mojotoro, Salta province, Argentina (Fig. 1). The
al . (1994), who carried out a TEM and AEM study Puncoviscana Formation, which constitutes the
of their occurrence in Lower Palaeozoic mudstones basement of the area, is mainly composed of a
of the Welsh Basin. Those authors concluded that pelite-greywacke turbidite sequence, with subordi-
these stacks were derived from a detrital precursor, nate sandstones and locally interbedded conglom-
such as volcanogenic biotite, and other ferromagne- erates, shelf limestones, and volcanic rocks
sian minerals, which underwent considerable (Omarini, 1983; Omarini & Baldis, 1984; Jezek,
textural change in response to diagenesis and very 1990). The Neoproterozoic Puncoviscana Formation
low-grade metamorphism. According to Li ., et al was affected by polyphase deformation due to
(1994), most intergrowths of chlorite and mica in superposed folding. Mon & Hongn (1991, 1996)
stacks formed by mica replacement of chlorite and have identified two NS belts with different tectonic
altered biotite along cleavage fissures. A coincident styles (Fig. 1) in the basement of northwestern
model was proposed by Giorgetti . (1997) to et al Argentina. According to these authors, Sierra de
explain the origin of the widespread IPG occurring Mojotoro corresponds to the eastern Lules-
in low-grade Verrucano metasediments of the Puncoviscana belt, which is characterized by
northern Apennines (Italy). However, evidence asymmetric folds overturned to the west, with
metamorphic grade established via KI indicated preferred alignment that causes a continuous slaty
medium anchizonal to epizonal grade meta- cleavage in clay-rich laminae and leads to
morphism for the Puncoviscana Formation in the disjunctive anastomosing cleavage in quartz-plagi-
Sierra de Mojotoro. In addition, the parameter ofb oclase-rich silt laminae. In thin section, tabular to
lenticular interleaved phyllosilicate grains (IPG) up y = 1.15 ÿ 0.01 ( 2 = 0.989). Polished thin
x R
to 110 m long, sometimes bent or folded, are
m sections were employed for optical observations and
abundant, especially in clay-rich laminae. The IPG SEM study using back-scattered electron (BSE)
aspect ratio (length/width) ranges from 0.7 to 5.3, imaging and X-ray dispersive (EDS) analysis.
with a mean of 2.8. Alternating chlorite-like and Analyses were carried out with a LINK QX2000
mica-like packets are always subparallel and can be microanalyzer attached to a ZEISS DSM 950
easily distinguished when both kinds of layers make scanning electron microscope. The following
up a similar volume of the IPG (Fig. 2a). In other compounds were used as calibration standards:
cases, chlorite packets clearly predominate, and albite (Na), orthoclase (K), periclase (Mg), wollas-
then the IPG resemble pure chlorite grains under tonite (Si), and synthetic oxides of Al2O3 (Al),
the optical microscope and even in backscattered Fe2O3 (Fe) and MnTiO3 (Ti and Mn).
SEM images (Fig. 2b). Chlorite shows slight green Representative areas for TEM observations were
pleochroism and very weak birefringence. The IPG chosen based on prior observations by optical
are preferentially orientated with chlorite and microscopy and SEM of thin sections. The sample
muscovite (00l) planes at high angle to the slaty was prepared as a Canada-balsam-mounted thin
cleavage but also oblique to S0, which in turns section oriented approximately normal to bedding.
forms an angle of 70ë with the former. It was further thinned using a Gatan 600 ion mill
and carbon-coated for TEM observation with a
ANALYTICAL TECHNIQUES Philips CM-20 scanning transmission electron
microscope (STEM) equipped with an ultra-thin
The clay mineralogy was studied by XRD using window EDX detector (Centro de InstrumentacioÂn
oriented mounts, with Cu- radiation, employing a
Ka CientõÂfica, C.I.C., Granada University). Quantitative
Philips PW1050 diffractometer (INGEIS) operated analyses (AEM) were obtained only from thin
at 40 mA and 30 kV, and a Bruker D8 Advance edges, using a 70 AÊ beam diameter and a
operated at 40 mA and 40 kV (Centro de 1000 200 AÊ scanning area, with the long axis
6
FIG. 2. BSE images of P90 slate: (a) IPG composed of alternating muscovite and chlorite packets; (b) IPG with a
predominance of chlorite packets, resembling a pure chlorite grain.
XRD patterns of the EG-treated and heated subordinate phase in the matrix. Mixed-layer
specimens were not included in the figure because muscovite-chlorite appears in IPG grains
they register minimal changes. After EG treatment, 20ÿ110 m long and interleaved in chlorite crystals.
m
illite-muscovite basal reflections do not show The dominant polytype in dioctahedral micas is
significant changes: the shoulder at 7.35 AÊ persists 2 , although 1 and three-layer sequences where
M Md
and the irrational series of basal reflections remains c* is perpendicular to * (or equivalent crystal-
b
almost unchanged except for the reflection at lographic directions), therefore interpreted as 3 , T
12.45 AÊ, which decreases in intensity. In the same were also recognized (Fig. 4a). Dioctahedral mica is
pattern, a weak reflection visible at 17.5 AÊ becomes present in defect-free packets 15ÿ470 layers thick,
unobservable after heating, and must thus corre- exhibiting straight and continuous 10 AÊ or 20 AÊ
spond to smectite (<5%). After heating, the peak at lattice fringes. Up to four consecutive coherent
12.45 AÊ shifts towards 11.95 AÊ and increases in packets of muscovite have been observed, and, less
intensity, resembling the behaviour of odd reflec- commonly, low-angle boundaries are also present.
tions of chlorite under this treatment. Taking into Some isolated 14 AÊ layers interlayered inside thick
account the optical observations of thin sections, mica packets were seen in a few cases.
this irrational series of basal reflections was The SAED patterns obtained for the mixed-layer
interpreted as due to irregular muscovite-chlorite muscovite-chlorite have the following reflections in
mixed-layering. the 001 row (CV = coefficient of variation):
The reflections attributed to the mixed-layer Fig. 4b: 12.0, 7.4, 5.9, 4.6, 3.7, 3.2, 2.8, 2.6, 2.3, 1.9,
phase are broad and asymmetrical, suggesting that 1.8 AÊ. (CV = 2.6%).
reflections from two or more phases may overlap. Fig. 4c: 22.2, 12.0, 7.7, 6.1, 4.7, 3.9, 3.4, 2.9, 2.6, 2.3,
In order to investigate this further, a decomposition 2.2, 2.0 AÊ (CV = 2.6%).
program ( ) was applied to the low-angle
MacDiff
Fig. 4d: 12.2, 7.8, 6.2, 4.8, 3.5, 3.0, 2.7, 2.4, 2.0,
region (3ÿ14ë2 ) of the air-dried XRD pattern 1.7 AÊ (CV = 1.6%).
(results shown in Fig. 3b). The peak at 12.45 AÊ can
y
be decomposed into two peaks attributed to The coincidence between the XRD and the
smectite (1) and mixed-layer muscovite-chlorite (2), SAED data is quite good, although the shape and
in accordance with the changes observed in XRD position of the first peak in the XRD traces (002
diagrams after EG and heat treatments. Meanwhile, reflection) seems to be affected by the presence of
the peak at 7.99 AÊ can be resolved into three peaks smectite. In both cases, reflections appear at
attributed to mixed-layer muscovite-chlorite (4), 7.3ÿ7.4 AÊ (underlined in the spacing list), possibly
FIG. 3. XRD patterns: (a) of the <2 m air-dried oriented mount of slate P90; (b) decomposition of the low-angle
m
region of the air-dried pattern (obtained using ); (c) simulated pattern for a mixture of 60% chlorite
MacDiff
layers and 40% muscovite layers with R=1 (obtained using ). MULCALC
FIG. 7. (a) Lattice-fringe image of a fine-scale IPG made up of packets of random mixed-layer muscovite-chlorite
(A and B), chlorite and muscovite. (b) Detail of chlorite and mixed-layer packet A; black arrows indicate
elongate lenticular fissures which are probably a consequence of layer collapse caused by the TEM vacuum.
intense peaks at 7.54 AÊ and 7.19 AÊ, interpreted as to a one-layer polytype (1L). In addition, this
mixed-layer muscovite-chlorite very rich in chlorite pattern shows spots corresponding to 10 AÊ periodi-
layers and a chlorite (002) reflection, respectively. city superimposed in the (001) row that could be
The lattice-fringe images shown in Figs 6 and 8 correlated with mica. Figure 9 depicts a fine-scale,
are bidimensional, meaning that, in addition to the IPG composed of three subparallel packets of
basal fringes, they show cross-fringes corresponding chlorite, a random mixed-layer muscovite-chlorite,
to imaging (0 0) or (110) rows of reflections. These
k and muscovite. The mixed-layer packet shows 24,
cross-fringes show continuity along 5 to 10 28 and 20 AÊ fringes with a 24 AÊ:14 AÊ ratio of 3:10;
successive 14 AÊ layers or 10 AÊ layers. This moreover, some lenticular voids, as consistent with
feature indicates the existence of crystallographic layer collapse caused by the TEM vacuum, were
continuity along (or equivalent directions such as
b observed. Only four packets of chlorite without
<110>) for both kinds of layers, which means that interleaved 10 AÊ layers were identified (packets
this mixed-layer sequence has crystallographic labelled Chl in Figs 7b and 9).
coherence. In other words, it is a crystal and not The AEM analysis of this IPG (P90-8) indicates a
merely a fortuitous stacking of layers (Dong & mixture of dioctahedral mica and trioctahedral
Peacor, 1996). chlorite with a predominance of chlorite layers, in
The unique diffraction pattern of ordered chlorite agreement with evidence from the lattice-fringe
obtained in this sample (Fig. 9, inset) corresponds image. However, the interlayer charge (K = 0.48) is
FIG. 9. SAED pattern along 100 of ordered chlorite one layer polytype (inset) and corresponding lattice-fringe
image showing a fine-scale interleaved phyllosilicate grain composed of three sub-parallel packets of chlorite,
random mixed-layer muscovite-chlorite and muscovite.
mixed-layer grains obtained by EDS and AEM, are all of the analyses plot to the left of the upper line
also plotted in Fig. 11. Representative analyses of that connects the muscovite and chlorite composi-
biotite and smectite, plus 0.5/0.5 mixtures of tions. Second, the low (Fe+Mg)/Si and
muscovite-chlorite, chlorite-smectite, and biotite- (K+Na+Ca)/Si ratios exhibited by some AEM, as
chlorite, are also included in Fig. 11 for reference. well as EDS analyses of mixed-layer muscovite-
Two main conclusions are inferred by this figure. chlorite is apparent, which can be attributed to some
First, the dioctahedral character of 10 AÊ layers in the extent to the illitic component of muscovite-like
mixed-layer sequence is clearly implied, as almost layers. However, smectite-like layers are probably
FIG. 10. Diagrams showing composition relations for dioctahedral micas from IPG and mx.
TABLE 2. SEM analyses of dioctahedral micas from matrix (mx), coarse grains (CG) and interleaved phyllosilicate
grains (IPG).
mx CG CG mx IPG mx
Element P90/2/3 P90/3/2 P90/5/3 90/6/2 P90/8/1 P90/8/3
SiIV 3.35 3.31 3.30 3.40 3.33 3.37
Al 0.65 0.69 0.70 0.60 0.67 0.63
VIAl 1.54 1.57 1.50 1.52 1.50 1.52
Mg 0.24 0.26 0.26 0.23 0.21 0.25
Fe 0.23 0.19 0.28 0.23 0.31 0.25
Ti 0.01 0.02 0.02 0.02 0.02 0.01
Mn 0.00 0.00 0.01 0.00 0.00 0.00
S oct. 2.03 2.04 2.06 2.00 2.04 2.04
K 0.81 0.87 0.83 0.86 0.80 0.79
Na 0.04 0.00 0.00 0.02 0.03 0.03
Ca 0.01 0.00 0.01 0.00 0.00 0.01
S int 0.85 0.87 0.84 0.88 0.83 0.82
mx CG mx mx IPG IPG
Element P90/13/3 P90/14/2 P90/14/3 P90/15/1 P90/16/2 P90/17/2
SiIV 3.32 3.22 3.32 3.53 3.27 3.23
Al 0.68 0.78 0.68 0.47 0.73 0.77
VIAl 1.58 1.57 1.65 1.51 1.61 1.65
Mg 0.18 0.17 0.13 0.24 0.22 0.22
Fe 0.23 0.25 0.21 0.21 0.18 0.14
Ti 0.01 0.03 0.02 0.02 0.03 0.02
Mn 0.00 0.00 0.01 0.00 0.00 0.00
S oct. 2.00 2.02 2.01 1.98 2.03 2.04
K 0.88 0.90 0.74 0.79 0.85 0.83
Na 0.05 0.04 0.08 0.01 0.02 0.04
Ca 0.00 0.00 0.01 0.01 0.00 0.01
S int 0.92 0.94 0.82 0.80 0.86 0.88
the third component of some of these mixed-layer their observations at TEM scale, they considered
sequences, which may account for their high Si and that random and ordered mixed-layer illite-chlorite
low (Fe+Mg) contents, their low interlayer charge in developed by dissolution of illite and chlorite
relation to theoretical interlayered muscovite- detrital grains, and probably I-S, parallel to
chlorite, and for the presence of Ca in interlayer site. bedding, followed by crystallization of the new
phyllosilicate parallel to the slaty cleavage. Lee &
DISCUSSION Peacor (1985) remarked that these complex mixed-
layer sequences are clearly indicative of a
The disordered mixed-layer muscovite-chlorites metastable state, because equivalent samples that
described in this study are analogous to those had been transformed into slate displayed no local
described by Lee . (1984) and Lee & Peacor
et al illite-chlorite mixed-layering.
(1985) for a sample that is transitional between The sample under consideration is clearly an
mudstone and slate from Lehigh Gap in anchizonal slate (KI = 0.30 with a predominance of
Pennsylvania. Those authors pointed out that, even 2 muscovite) in which muscovite and chlorite
M
though the mudstone contained abundant phyllosi- appear interleaved from the lattice to the millimetre
licate grains with orientations parallel to bedding, scale. Mixed-layer packets appear in the IPG, which
mixed-layer illite-chlorite occurred only parallel to are oblique to S0, or associated with chlorite in the
the slaty cleavage of the adjacent slates. Based on matrix. Few chlorite packets without interleaved
mica-layers were identified by SEM and TEM in replacement of chlorite in stacks by dioctahedral
the IPG, forming coarse grains, or in the matrix. mica layers, probably in the presence of an aqueous
The studied mixed-layer sequences do not have a fluid. Such a mechanism has been described by
distinct composition, as opposed to the sum of Giorgetti . (1997) to account for 10 AÊ layers
et al
muscovite- plus chlorite-like layers. Therefore, they interleaved in predominant chlorite packets of the
do not represent an independent mineral phase, as, IPG in Verrucano metasediments, in which mixed-
for example, corrensite in relation to chlorite plus layer mica-chlorite represent a minor component.
smectite (Shau ., 1990). As regards their
et al As Giorgetti . (1997) pointed out; the proposed
et al
composition, the interstratified sequences of slate reaction involves significant chemical 2+changes
P90 differ from the mixed-layer mica-chlorite requiring a loss of divalent cations +(Mg , Fe2+4+)
described by RuõÂz Cruz (2001), which display and of H2O, and a gain of K and Si .
intermediate composition between muscovite- Furthermore, this reaction can be considered a
chlorite and biotite-chlorite. topotactic transformation as the newly formed mica
Textural relationships between chlorite and layers retain the crystallographic orientation of the
muscovite packets in IPG along with the observed previous chlorite. Thus, the proposed transformation
transformations from 14 AÊ to 10 AÊ along the layer mechanism seems to imply that 14 AÊ and 10 AÊ
are compatible with a prograde metamorphic layers that form the mixed-layer sequence are not
stratifications. , , 394ÿ398. Guidotti C.V., Sassi F.P. & Blencoe J.G. (1989)
American Mineralogist 67
Compositional controls on the and cell dimen-
Champness P.E., Cliff G. & Lorimer G.W. (1981)
a b
sions of 2 1 muscovite.
Quantitative analytical electron microscopy.
M European Journal of
Bulletin , , 71 ÿ84.
, 236ÿ240.
Mineralogy 1
de Mineralogie 104,
Jezek P. (1990) AnaÂlisis sedimentoloÂgico de la
Cliff G. & Lorimer G.W. (1975) The quantitative FormacioÂn Puncoviscana entre TucumaÂn y Salta.
analysis of thin specimens. ,
Journal of Microscopy Pp. 9ÿ36 in:
, 203ÿ207.
El Ciclo Pampeano en el Noroeste
103
Argentino (F.G. AcenÄolaza, H. Miller & A.J. Toselli,
Do Campo M. (1999a) Metamorfismo del basamento en editors). Serie Correlacio n GeoloÂgica Në 4,
la Cordillera Oriental y borde oriental de la Puna. Pp. Universidad Nacional de TucumaÂn, Argentina.
41ÿ51 in: GeologõÂa del Noroeste de Argentina (G. Kisch H.J. (1991) Illite crystallinity: recommendations
GonzaÂlez Bonorino, R. Omarini and J. Viramonte, on sample preparation, X-ray diffraction settings,
editors). XIV Congreso GeoloÂgico Argentino, Salta, and interlaboratory samples.
Tomo I, Argentina.
Journal of
Metamorphic Geology , , 665ÿ670.
Do Campo M. (1999b)
9
MineralogõÂa, geoquõÂmica y Knipe R.J. (1981) The interaction of deformation and
geocronologõÂa de la Ân
Formacio Puncoviscana metamorphism in slates. , ,
Tectonophysics
y 25ë50 de
78
(Neoproterozoico) entre los 23ë30 ' ' 249ÿ272.
Latitud Sur, Noroeste de Argentina. PhD thesis Lee J.H. & Peacor D.R. (1985) Ordered 1:1 interstra-
(unpublished), Universidad de Buenos Aires, tifications of illite and chlorite. A transmission and
Argentina, 287 pp. analytical electron microscopy study. Clays and Clay
Do Campo M. & Nieto F. (2003) Transmission electron Minerals , , 463ÿ467.
microscopy study of the very low-grade meta-
33
372ÿ385.
MineralogõÂa de arcillas y metamorfismo de la Li G., Peacor D.R., Merriman R.J., Roberts B. & van der
FormacioÂn Puncoviscana en localidades de la Pluijm B.A. (1994) TEM and AEM constraints on
Cordillera Oriental y Puna, Argentina. Actas 10ë the origin and significance of chlorite-mica stacks in
Congreso Latinoamericano de GeologõÂa, Buenos slates: an example from Central Wales, U.K. Journal
Aires, Argentina , vol. II, pp. 217ÿ223. of Structural Geology , , 1139ÿ1157.
Dong H. & Peacor D.R. (1996) TEM observations of
16
Clay Minerals
40 , 93ÿ104. Victoria y adyacencias.
Omarini R.H. (1983)
Academia Nacional de
Ân litolo
Caracterizacio Âgica, difer- , , CoÂrdoba, pp. 163ÿ196.
Ciencias BoletõÂn 41
Ân y ge
enciacio  nesis de la Formacio
Ân Puncoviscana
Van der Pluijim B.A., Lee J.H. & Peacor D.R. (1988)
entre el Valle de Lerma y la Faja Eruptiva de la
. PhD thesis (unpublished), Universidad Analytical electron microscopy and the problem of
Puna
Nacional de Salta, Argentina, 202 pp. potassium diffusion. , ,
Clays and Clay Minerals 36
498 ÿ 504.
Omarini R. & Baldis B.A.J. (1984) SedimentologõÂa y Veblen D.R. & Ferry J.M. (1983) A TEM study of the
mecanismos deposicionales de la Formacio n biotite-chlorite reaction and comparison with petro-
Puncoviscana (Grupo Lerma, Preca mbrico- logic observations. , ,
CaÂmbrico) del noroeste Argentino. Pp. 384ÿ398 1160 ÿ 1168.
American Mineralogist 68
in: , Bariloche,
Warr L.N. & Rice A.H.N. (1994) Interlaboratory
Âgico Argentino
9th Congreso Geolo
Argentina.
RuõÂz Cruz M.D. (2001) Mixed-layer mica-chlorite in standardization and calibration of clay mineral
very low-grade metaclastites from the MalaÂguide crystallinity and crystallite size data. Journal of