Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1 985
ii
ABSTRACT
Experi ment al thawing data for foods found in the l i t eratur e , w ere
l imi ted in val ue because the e xper i mental cond i t i ons wer e no t
suff i c i ently acc ur atel y meas ured , des cr i bed and controll ed to all ow
m ean i ngful tes t i ng of thaw i ng t i me pred i ct i on methods to be made . A
compr ehens i ve set of 1 82 e xper iment al measur ements of thawi ng time were
made over a w i de range of cond i ti ons usi ng r egul ar shapes made of
Tyl ose , a food anal ogue , and of minced l ean beef . Free z i ng and thawing
exper i ments for irr egu l ar shapes wer e also carr i ed out because of the
pauc i t y of publ i shed experimental data . U s i ng twelve d i f f er ent two
and thr ee- dimens i onal irregu l ar shaped obj ects 115 e xper i mental
free z i ng and thawi ng r uns were conducted . C omb i n i ng experimental
res ul ts wi th rel i abl e publ i shed e xper im ental dat a f or free z i ng , a dat a
set compri s i ng 5 93 e xperi ments was establ i she d aga i nst whi ch pr edi c t i on
methods wer e t es t ed .
The par t i al d i f f er ent i al equat i ons that mode l the actua l physi cal
process of heat conduct ion dur i ng free z i ng and thawi ng can be sol ved by
the f i ni te d i ff er ence and f i ni te e l ement methods . Tes t i ng of the
f i ni t e el ement method has not been extens i ve , par t i c ul arly f or
thr ee- d imens i onal shapes . Ther efor e a general formul at i on of the
f i ni te el ement method for one- , two- and thr ee-d i mens i onal shapes was
made and impl emen t ed . Both numer i ca l methods accur at el y pr edi ct e d
free z i ng and thawi ng t im es for regular shapes . Suff i c i ently small
spat i al and t i me step i nt er vals cou l d be used so that errors ar i s i ng
f r om the i mpl ement ation of the methods w er e negl i g i bl e compared wi th
exper i men tal and thermal property data uncer t a i nt i es . Gui de l i nes wer e
es tabl i shed to choose s pace and time gri ds i n appl i cation of the f i ni te
el ement method for i rr egu l ar shapes . Adher ence to thes e gu i de l ines
ens ured that pr edi c t i on method error was i nsi gn i f i cant . A s i mpl i f i e d
f i n i t e el ement method was formulat ed and impl emen t ed . ·rt had l ow er
comput ation cos ts but was l ess accurat e than the general formul ation .
Abstract iii
No accur ate , general , but s impl e method for pred i c t i ng thawi ng times
was found i n the l i teratur e . Four poss i bl e appr oaches f or a generally
appl i cabl e , emp i r i cal pr edi ction f o rmul a w er e i nv es ti gated . Each coul d
be used to pred i ct e xper i m ental dat a f or s i mpl e shapes to w i th i n ± 1 1 . 0%
at the 95% l evel of conf i dence . This acc urac y was e qui val ent to that
d i s played by s i m i l ar f ormul ae f or free z i ng t i me pred i ct i on , and was
onl y sl i ghtly i nf e r i or to the accuracy of the best numeri cal metho ds.
A l l four methods ar e recommende d as accurat e pred i ctors .
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
- The Un i v ersi ty Grants Commi t tee and New Z eal and Meat Pr oduc ers ' Board
wh ich p rov i ded fi nanc i a l support in the form of scholarsh ips .
- The Mas sey Un i v ers i ty PRIME 750 compu ters for many m i l l ion seconds of
the ir t i me .
- F ami l y and fr i end s for the ir con t i nual support and he lpfulness .
TAB LE OF CONTENTS
ABSTRACT • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • ii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 1v
TABLE OF CONTENTS • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • v
LIST OF TABLES . • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • xi
L I ST OF F I GURES • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • xvi
INTRODUCTI ON • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 1
8 PREDI CTION OF FREEZING AND THAWIN G TIMES FOR MULT I -DI MENSIONAL
S HAPES BY NUMERI CAL METHODS • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 1 68 ·
8. 1 INT RODUCTION • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 1 68
8.2 PREDI CTI ONS FOR REGU LAR SHAPES • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 1 68
8.3 PREDI CT IONS FOR TWO-DIMENS IONAL I RREGU LAR SHA P ES • • • • • • • • • • • • 1 70
8.4 PREDICTI ONS FOR THREE- DIMENSI ONAL I R REGULAR S HAP ES • • • • • • • • • • 1 71
8.5 FIN ITE ELEMENT METHOD USER GUI DELINES • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 1 76
8.6 SUMMARY • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 1 7 7
9 PREDI CTION OF FREE ZING AND THAWING TIMES FOR MU LTI-DI MENSIONAL
REGULAR SHAPES BY SIMPLE METHODS • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 1 80
9.1 ANALYTICAL TREATMENT OF THE EFFECT OF GEOMETRY • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 1 80
9.2 FEAS IBLE GEOMETRI C FACTORS • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 1 81
9.3 VERI FICATION OF THE EFFECT OF ENVI ROMENTAL CONDITIONS
ON GEOMETRIC FACTORS • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 1 83
9.4 DEVELOPMENT OF IMPROVED GEOMETRI C FACTOR S FOR
MULTI- DIMENSI ONAL REGU LAR SHAP ES • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 1 84
9.5 TESTING OF IMPROVED GEOMETRI C FACTOR S AGA INST EXPERI MENTAL
DATA FOR MULT-DI MENSI ONAL REGULAR SHAP ES • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 1 89
9.6 TESTING OF IMPROVED GEOMETRIC FACTORS IN COMBINATION WITH
SIMPLE PREDICTION FORMU LAE • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 1 91
/
Tabl e of C ont ents ix
9.7 SUMMARY • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 1 92
1 0 PRE DI CTION OF FREE Z ING AND THAWIN G T I MES FOR MU LT I -DI MENSIONAL
I R RE GU LA R SHAP ES BY SIMPLE METHODS • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 1 98
1 0 . 1 INTRODUCT ION • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 1 98
1 0 . 2 GEOMETRY PARAMETERS • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 1 9 9
1 0 . 3 DEVELOPMENT OF GEOMETRI C FACTOR S FOR MULT I-D I MENS IONAL
I RREGU LAR SHAPES • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 200
1 0 . � TESTING OF GEOMETR I C FACTORS AGAINST E XP ERI MENTA L DATA
FOR MULT I - DI MENSI ONAL SHAPES • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 2 03
1 0 . � . 1 Rectangu l ar Bri ck F reezi ng and Thaw i ng • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 203
1 0 . � . 2 Free zing and Thawing of Two-D imensi onal
I rr egul ar Shapes • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 203
1 0 . � . 3 Free zing and Thawi ng of T hree-D imension al
I rr egu l ar Sha pes . • . • • . • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 204
1 0 . � . � C ompari son of Slab Predi ction M ethods • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 206
1 0 . � . 5 Anal y s i s of Geomet r i c F actor s • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 206
1 0. 5 SUMMARY • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 207
1 1 TESTIN G OF P REDI CTION METHODS FOR OTHER MATE RI A LS AND DATA SETS • • 2 1 5
1 1 . 1 I NTRODU CT I ON • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 2 1 5
1 1 . 2 NUMERI CAL P REDI CTION METHODS • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 21 5
1 1 . 3 SIMPLE P REDICT I ON METHODS • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 2 1 7
1 1 • 4 SUMMAR Y • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 2 1 9
13 CONCLUSIONS • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 23-4
NOMENCLATURE • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • 236
APP ENDI X C . GEOMETRI C FACTOR DATA FOR MU LT I -DI MENS IONA L S HA P ES • • 276
APP ENDI CES D and E are i nc l uded on mi cr of i che at the end of APP ENDI X c.
xi
L IST OF TABLES
3.2 Cond i t i ons R equ i red For D er i vat i on of S impl e Freezi ng and
Thawi ng T ime Pred i c t i on Formul ae 3 6.
5.1 Thermal Pro per t y D at a Used I n C al c ul ati ons By N umeri cal M ethods 61
6.5 Exper i ment a l Data For Thaw i ng of R ec t angu l ar Bri cks of Tyl os e 1 32
6. 7 Exper imental Data For Freezing and Thawi ng of Thr e e-D i mensional
Irregu l ar Sha pes of Tyl ose 1 36
8.2 Summar y of Per cent age D if f er ences Bet ween Exper i mental Free z i ng
and Thawing T imes For T yl ose Thr ee-D imensional Irr egul ar
Shapes and Freezi ng and Thawi ng T imes Calcul at ed By the
F i ni t e El emen t Method 179
L i s t of Tabl es x1 1 i
1 2 . 2 C om par i son of the Esti mat ed Exper imen t al U ncer t a i nt y Bounds and
the Means and 95% Conf i dence Bounds For the Numeri cal and
S impl e F ree z i ng and Thaw i ng T ime Pred i ct i on Methods 233
A.2 Appro x imat e Anal y t i cal Sol u t i ons For Slabs Assuming a U n i que
Phase C hange Temper a t ur e 262
A.3 Appro x imat e Anal y ti cal Sol u t i o ns For Radi al Geometry Assum i ng
a U n i que Phase Change T emperatur e 265
A.4 Appro x imate Anal y t i cal Sol utions For Mul t i-D imensional Shap es
Assumi ng a U n i que Phase Change Tempera t ur e 266
A.5 Emp i ri cal Sol u t i o ns Assumi ng a U ni que Phase Change T emper at ur e 267
A.6 Approxi mat e Anal y t i cal Solut i ons For Alloy Sol i d if i ca t i on 268
L IST OF F I GU R ES
5.3 Schemat i c D i agram of the Exper i mental Slab Thaw i ng Equ i pmen t 69
5. 4 Construction o f T es t Slabs 70
5.5 Pred i ct i on o f Sur f ace H eat Transf er Coef f i c i ents For Slab
Thawi ng Exper iments 71
5.9 Schematic D iagr am of the Syst em U sed To Hol d and Osc i l l ate
the I n f i n i t e C yl i nders and Two- D imens i onal I rregu l ar Shapes
i n the L i qu i d I mmer sion Tank 80
,
L i st of F i gur es xv i i
5 . 1 1 Schemati c D i a gr am Showi ng the Arr angement of the Pol yst yr ene Foam
Caps and Thermocoupl es L eads For Inf i ni t e Cyl i nder Exper i ments 81
5 . 2 4 The Pyr ami d Thr e e-D imens i onal Irregul ar Shape F i n i t e El ement
Method Gri d 114
5 . 28 The Sampl e Osc i l l ator and Thr ee-D imensional Irr egul ar Shapes
Used i n the L i qu i d Immer s i on T an k 119
6.4 A Ty p i cal T emper atur e/Time Prof i l e For Thawing of R ect angul ar
Bri cks of Tyl os e 1 39
6.6 A Typi cal Temper atur e/T ime Prof i l e For Free z i ng or Thawing of
t he Tyl ose Two-D imens i onal Irregu l ar Sha pe N umber Two 1 40
6.7 A Ty p i cal Temper atur e/T ime Prof i l e For Free z i ng or Thawing of
the Tyl ose Two-D i mensi onal I rregu l ar Shape N umber Thr e e 1 41
6.9 A Ty p i cal Temper atur e/T ime Prof i l e For Free z i ng or Thawi ng of
the Tyl ose Two-D imen s i onal I rregu l ar Shape N umber F i ve 1 42
Low temperatur e i s one of the mos t important and common means of f ood
p reserv a t i on . For New Zealand , whose economy is b ased on p rimary
i ndus tr i es and export of peri shable products to d i s t an t mark e t s , th i s
is espec ially tru e . Freez i ng , co ld storag e and sub se quent thaw i ng are
all op erati ons on the froz en food cha i n in wh i ch los ses of food qual i ty
can b e s i g n i f i can t . I mportant roles for the food eng i ne er are
therefore to des i g n , op erate and control equ i pment that ma i nta i ns
p rodu c t qual i ty wh ilst k eep ing p rocess i ng costs low .
I n the p ast , freez i ng has b een more impor tant commerc ially than thaw i ng
as tha w i ng has been p r edom i nately a domes t ic p r ac t i c e . Ex tens i v e
research i nt o the phy si cal aspec ts o f freez i ng has p roduced methods to
pred i c t freez i ng t i mes that are sat i sfac tory f or many p r ac t i cal
s i tua t i ons . However , in general , the se methods ar e e i ther spec if i c to
i nd iv i dual f ood p roducts or app l y only to . s i mp l e r egul ar g eome tr i es .
Many fro z en foodstuffs are irregular i n shap e s o further research i s
warranted t o deve l op , tes t and val i date a gen eral me thod that pred i c ts
freez ing t imes for a wide var i et y of shap es .
thawi ng as the reverse of freez i ng, but the val idi ty of th i s app roach
is ques t i onab l e as it has not b een p rov en that accurate thawi ng
p red i c t i ons w i l l be ob ta ined . As for freez ing, much of the research
i nto thaw i ng rate and t i me pred i c t ion has been for ind i v i dual p r oduc ts .
There remains the need for research to f i nd a general method f or
pred i c t ion of thawi ng t i mes . I deal l y , the me thod would b e simi l ar to
those used to p red i c t freez i ng t imes . It may i ncorporate the same
t echn i ques to account for p r oduct g eomet ry . Th i s would al l ow the
ent i r e area of p red i c t i on of phase chang e in f oods to b e consi dered as
a whol e .
Food stuffs are a comp lex system of wa ter , so lutes and macromo l ecules
but are of ten cons i dered for eng i neer i ng pu rpo ses as two frac t ions ; an
aqueou s so lu t i on and a so l i d comp onen t . Phase chang e i n food s inv olves
i ntr i cate int erac tions b etween the aqueou s and so l i d frac tions . In
many so- cal l ed ''h igh mo is ture" sol i d foods ( for examp l e mea t ,
veg e tab l es and f i sh ) the wa ter i s bound i n a so li d matr ix and there i s
a l mos t n eg l ig ible migra t ion o f wa ter dur i ng freez i ng or thawi ng . Phase
chang e inv ol v es ma inly the aqueou s part chang i ng from i ce to water or
v i c e v er s a , wi th the sol id b e i ng relat ively iner t . The interac t ions i n
the food cause con t i nuou s freez ing point dep ress i on a s i ce sep arates
from the aqu e ous phase , so l a tent heat i s released or absorb ed ov er a
rang e of temp era tures dur i ng phase chang e ( Rolfe 1 9 68 p . 1 8 4 , D i ck erson
1 977 ) .
The therma l conduc t i vity and spec ifi c hea t cap ac i ty of wa t er vary by a
fac tor of ab out thr ee from tho se of i c e . La tent heat i s rel eas ed or
ab sorbed as water chang es phase , wh ilst the sol i d fra c tion is
ess ent ial l y unchange d . There fore the thermal proper t i es of food are
h ighly dep endan t on the frac t i on of i ce in the food ( Me ll or & Sepp i ng s
1 976 , Heldman 1 982 ) . The l atent heat can b e " lumped" t oge ther wi th the
sensible heat to g iv e .an " ap p arent " ( effec tive ) spec ific hea t cap acity
( Comini & Bonacina 1 97 4 ) . For a typical solid high mois tur e food the
relationship b et ween ice frac t i on , the rmal conduc tivity , app arent
specific heat c apaci ty and en thalpy as a func tion of temperature are
shown in Fig s . 2.1 to 2 . 4 ( Me llor 1 978 ) . The area under the p eak in
the specific heat c apacity c u rv e , excl uding the sensibl e heat
L i t er ature Rev iew 4
�
8... 0.5
Li:
0�-----r----�--�
-•o -30 -20 -10 0 10 20
Temperaf\.re (•c)
Fig . 2 . 1 Ice Frac t ion of Freez ab l e Wat er Data For a Typ ical Food s tuf f .
U'
0
I 1.5
�
>
-
·:;::
+=
0
�c
0
U.
�
E o.s
ID .
.c
�
0�-----r----�---.---.
-•o -lO -20 -10 0 10 20
Temperature (•c)
1,000
0'
1...,
:::1
� 100
>.
-
·c:;
CJ
a.
CJ
u
-
CJ
•
I 10
-�
-
·c:;
•
a.
Vl
1
--40 -30 -20 -10 0 10 20
Temperature (°C)
Fig. 2.3 Apparent Volumetri c Specific Heat Capacity Data For a Typical
Foodstuff.
400
300
-
l...,
�
lOO
>-
-8"
.c
-
�
100
0��---r----�--r---�---r---,
-40 -30 -20 -10 0 10 20
Temperature (•c)
c ::- : [ :: ] :y [ :; ] : [ :: ]
. k + k + . k + Q ( 2 .1 )
L i terature Rev i ew 7
f 2 ( T , ma ter i a l )
x, y,z � dis tance in the three ax i a l d ir e c t i ons (m)
Q = internal hea t g enerat ion ( W m- 3 )
f 3 ( T , mater i a l )
Non-l i nea r i t y ar ises from the temp erature var i ab l e therma l p roper t i es
and the comp l ex nature of the boundary cond i tions appl i ed . App rox i mate
methods must there fore be u sed , or simp l i fy i ng assump ti ons made , to
enab le an analy t i cal so l u t ion to be found . One such assump t ion i s tha t
the latent hea t i s transferred at a un ique temperature ( T if ) and
thermal p rop er t i es undergo a step chang e in va lues at th is temp era ture
( Carslaw & J a eg er 1 955 , p . 282 ) . The formulat ion b ecomes that of a
mov i ng boundary ( St e fan) p rob lem and the p osi t ion of the phase chang e
v
front ( boundary) i s determined by E q . ( 2 . 1 ) sub j ec t to :
L
a
at
1
.. k +
[ ay az
aT
ax
1
X
+ ax a z
aT
ay
l y + a x ay
aT
az
lz ] lv�
- k-
[ ay az
aT
ax
l x + ax az
aT
ay
1y + a x ay
ar
az
lz ] lvl (2 .2 )
I n freez i ng and thaw i ng of foods a var i e ty of ini t ial and sur face
b oundary cond i t i ons can app ly . Mathema t i c ally , Eq. ( 2 . 1 ) is sub j ec t to
the f i rst k i nd of boundary cond i t ion ( p rescr ibed sur fac e temperatur e ) :
[ aT aT aT
k - 1
ax X
+- 1 y +- 1 z
ay az J = 4> on surfac e , S 2 , for t>O (2 . 4 )
the th ird k i nd of boundary cond it ion ( conv ec t i v e and rad iat i v e cool i ng
[
or hea t i ng ) :
k
aT
ax X
aT
- 1 +-
ay
1
y + ] •
� con• � rad on surfac e , s ,, for t>O (2 .5 )
2.2.2.2 I n i t ial Cond i t ions Both uni form and non-un iform initial
temp era ture cond it i ons oc cur in p rac t i c e . To der i v e a simple
analy t i cal ty pe of so lut ion a uni form i n i t ial temperature d i s t r ibu t i on
must u sually b e assumed . Numer i cal solu t i ons can handle e i ther u n i f orm
or non-un i form i n i t ial cond i t ions . Use of a me an bulk temperature
( L oe ffen et al 1 98 1 ) all ows the effect of a non-uni form init ial
temperature d i s t r ibut ion on a freez i ng or thaw i ng t i me to be
app rox imated , i f a simple me thod u si ng a uniform i n it i al temperature is
used for calculat ions .
The non-d i s t i nc t phase chang e reg ion for foods p rec ludes th is
def i n i t ion . The b est al ternat ive is to cons i der the proc ess comp l ete
when the thermody nami c centre reaches a certa in tempera ture , or when a
certa i n mass av erage temperature is reached ( Purwada r i a & He ldman
1 98 3 ) . The d i sadvantage of usi ng a mass averag e temp erature end p o i nt
i s that the mean bulk temperature i s d i ff icult to measure or es t i mate
i n p rac t i ce wi thou t ex tens i ve temperature data ( Khatchaturov 1 958 ) . In
cont ras t us i ng a spec i f ied f i nal thermodynamic c entre temperature as
the end p oint means:
the phase chang e oper a t i on i s generally conserv a t i vely desi gne d as
the mass average temperature is l ess l i m i t ing than the thermodynam i c
centre temp erature
- a cho i c e of f i nal centre temp erature can be mad e to app ro x imate any
des i red equ i l ibrat ion temperature
- unl ess the thermodynami c cent re mov es ( Fl emi ng 1 9 70 ) there is no
doub t that phase chang e i s comp l e te thr oughout the mate r i a l when the
centre re aches the endpoint temp erature
th i s means of de term i n i ng the end p o i nt is the mos t common and easy
to use .
For these reasons i t was u sed i n the p rese nt work .
For thaw i ng , an ob v iou s cho ice for the f i na l cen tre temperature i s 0 °C .
L arge non-equ i l ibr ium e f fects are unl ik e ly to occur so phase chang e
mu st b e complete at th is temp era ture , ev en i f the food b ehaves c l os ely
to pu re water , as T i f is alway s l ess than or equa l to 0 °C . Further , in
mos t thawi ng si tua t i ons thaw ing throughou t the mater i al is demanded
( for examp l e , so the ma ter ial can be d i v i ded or used immed iately i n
further p rocesses ) , yet the lowest mass av erag e temp erature i s desi red
to minimise pos t- thaw i ng qual i ty los ses ( James et al 1 976 ) . A
temp erature of 0 °C meets both these c r i t er i a . A b ov e 0 °C only se ns i b l e
heat effec ts need to be cons idered . I f p r ed i c t ions to o ther f i nal
centre temp eratures ar e requ ire d , then s i m i l ar methods to those
ava i l ab l e to adj ust freez i ng ti me pred i c t ions for d i fferent f inal
temp era tures can p robably b e u sed .
[ ]
and ( 2 . 5 ) b ecome:
aT
ra k- ( 2 .8 )
[
at ay
aT
ra k (2 .9 )
ar
[
and
ra k
aT
ar
lr +
aT
ay
ly ] • ra [ � con + � rad ] (2 . 1 0 )
k
[ aT
-- 1 +
aT
1
y +
ar
lz
] z 0 on surface , S 5 , for t>O ( 2 . 1 1 )
ax X ay az
2.3 SOLUT IONS USING THE ASSUMPT ION OF A UN IQUE PHASE CHANGE
TEMP ERATURE
To fac i l i tate analy s i s further phy si ca l assump tions and l i mi tat ions ar e
neces sary ar i s i ng b o th from the ma thema t i c s and from the phy s i cal
p roper t i e s of food s . Generally the dens i ty d ifference b etween the
phases is ignored and a uni form i n i t i al temperature d i str i but i on is
assumed . Only simple geometr i c shap es ( slab s , infi n it e cy l i nders ,
sphere s , i n f i n i te rods and rect angular b r i c k s ) are cons idered. Also
analy s i s is often rest r i c ted to the s impler f i rst and second boundary
c ond i t ions and the i n i t i a l cond i t ion that the ma t er ial i s at the pha se
chang e temperature ( no sup erhea t i ng for freez ing or subcoo l i ng for
thaw i ng ) . Var i a t ion of boundary cond i t ions wi th t i me i s general ly not
ex ami ned excep t by numer i ca l method s or some form of t ime-averag ing
techn i qu e . A l l of the se assump t ions reduce the rang e of appl i c ab i l i ty
of the resul t i ng so lution. Many of the solu t i o ns are not ap p rop riate
for food freez i ng or thaw i ng proc ess e s , al thoug h they may b e in other
phase chang e si tua t ions such as pure metal cast i ng , or melt i ng and
sol i d i f icat ion of pure sub s tanc es . In add i t i on some ana ly t i cal l y
der i v ed so lu t i ons may require numer i cal eva lua t ion by compu ter s o th ere
are b o th phy s i cal assump t ions and numer i cal t runcat io n or round i ng
errors i n these case s . In con t rast , finite d if ference and fi nit e
For slab s the app rox ima te analy ti cal solu t ions can be c l assed i nto
thre e group s : heat bal anc e integ ral and variat ional techn i ques ,
p er turbat i on and ser i es solu t i o ns , and other ana ly tical app roaches .
These are summari sed i n Tab l e A . 2 .
cons i der only the first or second k i nd of boundary con d i t i on and the
semi - inf i n i te rather than the f i ni te s l ab , th ey r equ ire nume r i cal
evaluat i on , or they app ly on ly where the i n i t i a l temp era ture i s equa l
to the phase change temperature . The only solut ions for the th ird k i nd
of boundary cond i t i o n that do not requ ire nu me r i ca l i n t egra t i on are
tho se due to Goodman ( 1 958 ) , for a semi - inf i n i te slab where i n i t ial
sup erhea t i ng or subcoo l i ng ar e ignored , and Hrycak ( 1 963 , 1 9 67 ) who
ex tends th i s to the case wi th superheat i ng or subcool i ng for b oth a
homog eneous and strat i f i ed semi - i n fi n i t e mat e r i a l . Hrycak ap p l i es the
quasi -s teady state as sump t i on ( l i near tempera ture prof i l e b etween the
surface and the internal mov i ng phase chang e b oundary ) and assumes tha t
the movement o f the phase change front and the heat pene t ra t ion fro nt
are p roport ional .
assump t io n , that sens ible heat c apac i ty i n the phase between the ou ter
surface and the phase chang e front is neg l ig ib l e . The temp eratu re
prof i le i n th i s r eg ion is therefore l inear and a s i mp l e analy t i cal
solu t i on i s ob ta ined for the th ird k ind of b ou ndary cond it i on but w i th
the ma t er ial ini t ia l ly at the phase change temperature . Bo th the se
assump tions w i l l tend to y i e ld low p red i c t i ons of phase chang e t imes .
Rutov ( 1 9 36 ) cons i dered the s ens ible heat c apac i ty of the phase change
mater ial a fter phase chang e and derives a correc t i on factor to account
for i t . Cochran ( 1 955 ) and Kre i th & Rom i e ( 1 955 ) b o th cons i dered the
sens i b l e hea t capac i ty lump ed a t a mid-point in the slab , but were
unab le to arr ive at a s i mp l e solu t ion ex cep t for unduly restr i c t i v e
b oundary cond it ions . Ker n ( 1 97 7 ) and Gl asser & Ker n ( 1 978 ) der i v e
bounds for the so lut ion by cons ider i ng the effec t o f th e quas i -s teady
state assump tion and ap p rox imat ing the i nteg ra t ion , by assumi ng
d i f f erent temp erature prof i l es be twe en the sur face and the mov i ng
b oundary .
2.3.3 App rox ima te Solu tions for Rad ial Geome t ry
Many of the app rox ima te techniques u sed to get solu tions for slab s hav e
b een ex tended to the case of rad ial heat f l ow i n inf ini te cy l inde rs· and
spheres , bu t reta in the same p robl ems when app l i ed to food phase
chang e . These so lut ions are l i s ted in T ab l e A.3. For a boundary
cond i t i on of the th ird k ind w i th no i n i t i a l sup erhea t i ng or subcool i ng
Pl ank ( 1 9 1 3 ) , London & Seban ( 1 9 4 3 ) , Kor om i & H i ra i ( 1 970 ) , Sh ih & Chou
( 1 97 1 ) , Sh ih & Tsay ( 1 97 1 ) , T i en ( 1 9 80 ) , Seen iraj & Bose ( 1 98 2 ) and
H i l l & Kuc era ( 1 98 3 ) have der ived solu t ions . Chuang & Szekely ( 1 97 2 )
solve for fusion of i n f i n i t e cy l i nders w i th the i n i t i a l temperature not
equal to the phase change temp erature and the th ird k ind of boundary
cond i t i o n , bu t the method requ ires nu mer i ca l i nt eg ra t i o n of the
r esul t i ng ord inary d i f f eren t ial equa t i o n .
l i mi ted p rac t ical i mpor tanc e b ecause of the ini t ial and b oundary
cond i t i ons u sed . Tab l e A . 4 summar ises av a i l ab le method s .
Sol u t i ons o f p rac t i cal i mportance for foods are tho se due to Pl ank
( 1 941 ) , T anak a & N i sh imoto ( 1 95 9 , 1 9 6 0 , 1 9 6 4 ) and Shamsundar ( 1 9 8 2 ) .
All u se the quas i -s teady state assump t ion and assume that the sur face
of the obj ec t is i sotherma l . The gene ral ap p roach is to f i nd geometr i c
fac tors that mod i fy so lu t ions for s l ab s . Plank f i nds app r op r i ate
fac tors for phase chang e in infi n i t e rod and rec tangular b ri ck shap es
subj ec t to the th i rd k i nd of bounda ry cond i t i on and the i n i t ial
temp er ature equa l to th e phase chang e temperature , by assuming that the
mov i ng boundary rema i ns paral lel to the ou ter surfac e . Tanak a &
N i sh imoto ex tend th is analy s i s for con i cal shap es , f i n i t e cy l i nders and
t rap ez o i dal bod i es . Shamsundar employs a s i m i lar approach for th e same
p roblem bu t all ows d i ff eren t con figura t i ons of the phase chang e front
to b e cons i dere d . Us i ng mathema t i cally def i ned geome tr i e s , conduc t i on
shap e fac tors suggest simple analy ti c solu t ions s i mi lar to those of
Pl ank . Hahne & Gr igul l ( 1 975 ) tabu late the conduc t i on shape fac tors
for a w i de rang e of reg ular shap es and assumed i nt er fac e geometr i es .
However for mos t mul t i -d i mens ional shapes the temperature is no t the
sa me ov er the surface at any t i me , and the shap e of the interfac e w i l l
change a s phase change p r ogr ess es, so the accuracy of the der i ved
g eome t r i c f ac tors i s sub j e c t to doub t .
solut ions for heat conduc t i on w i thout change o f phase wi l l approx i mate
me l t i ng or so l i d if i ca t ion . Baxter ( 1 96 2 ) , for slab s and i n f i n i t e
cy l i nders and Tao ( 1 968 ) , for s l ab s , i nf i n i t e cyl i nder s and sphere s ,
stud ied free z i ng subj e c t to the th ird k i nd o f boundary cond i t ion b u t
wi th no superhea t i ng or subcool i ng us i ng f i n i te d i f ferenc e s . The i r
results are d isplay ed as reg ress i on equa t ions and chart s . Bax ter ' s
so lut ion i s s im i l ar in form to Pl ank ' s equat ion. Shamsundar &
S c r i v isan ( 1 97 9 ) and Shamsundar ( 1 98 1 ) der i v e a si mi larity ru l e so
numer i cal resul ts can be app l i ed ov er a w i de rang e of cond i t i ons
wi thou t add it ional compu tat ions .
None of these solu tions apply wh ere l a tent hea t is not relea sed or
ab sorb ed at a un ique temperature as is the case for foods .
B e fore the use of v ersa t i l e d ig i tal compu ters b ec ame common and
p ower ful numer i cal me thods were avai l ab l e , ana l ogue and g r aph i cal
solu t i ons for pha se chang e were u sed . Using elec tr i c al analogues
London & Seban ( 1 9 43 ) , Cochran ( 1 955 ) , Krei th & Rom i e ( 1 955 ) and Horvay
( 1 96 0 ) inv est igated sens ible heat eff ec ts neg lec ted by the quasi - s teady
s tate assump t ion us i ng a lumped heat capac i ty me thod . L i eb man ( 1 956 )
and St ephan ( 1 96 9 ) a lso worked wi th e lec tr i cal ana logues for phase
chang e he at t ransf er wh i le Hashemi & Sl i ep cev i ch ( 1 967b ) deve lop ed a
d iffus ion ana logue . Some graph i cal methods for phase chang e are due to
Ede ( 1 9 49 ) , Ke l l e r & Bal lard ( 1 956 ) , He i ss ( 1 958 ) , Longwe l l ( 1 958 ) ,
Sunder land & Grosh ( 1 96 1 ) and Sokulsk i ( 1 97 2 b) .
Graph i cal and ana l ogue me thods for so lv i ng freez i ng and thaw i ng
p rocesses ar e no longer important b ec au se o f the relat i ve ease and
accuracy of us i ng numer ical me thods on d ig i tal compu t ers .
[ ] [ ] [ ]
b ecomes:
aH = � aT +
a aT +
a
k
aT +
Q (2 . 12 )
k k
at ax ax ay ay az az
where H - en tha lpy
I: c dT
f 1 1 ( T , pos i tion )
N ormal fi n i t e d i f ference ap p ro x imat i ons to E q . ( 2 . 1 2 ) can b e u sed
throughou t th e reg ion ( Pr i ce & Slack 1 95 4 , Bax ter 1 96 2 , Lockwood
1 966 , Shamsundar & Sparrow 1 975 ) . The me thod has been re f i ned by
u si ng interpol a t i on to determine the temp erature d istr ibu tion and
i n ter fac e posi t ion more accurately between spac e grid p o i n ts
( Shamsundar & Spar row 1 9 7 6 , Voller & Cross 1 9 8 1 a , 1 98 1 b , 1 9 8 3 , B e ll
1 982 ) . Ich ikawa & K i kuch i ( 1 979 ) and K i kuch i & Ich ikawa ( 1 979 )
u sed the simi lar method of var iat i onal i ne qua l i t i es .
( e ) The i so therm migra t ion me thod t r ansforms the p roblem from that of
determ i n i ng the dep endent var i ab l e , temp erature , as a f unc t ion of
pos i t ion and t i me to that of determ i n i ng the dependen t var i ab l e ,
p os i t i on , as a func tion of time and temperature ( Crank & Gup ta
1 975 , Talmon & Dav i s 1 98 1 , Talmon et a l 1 98 1 , Tal mon et al 1 98 3 ,
Gup ta & Kumar 1 9 8 4 ) .
e l emen t me thod and include spec ial e l ements or nodes a t the phase
chang e front tha t approx i mate the latent he at e f fe c t by a heat
source or s i nk d i s tr ibu ted ov er the e l ement . A l l en & Severn ( 1 9 6 2 )
u se a r e lax ation method and model l atent hea t r e l ea se as mov ing
heat g enera t i on .
2.4 SOLUT IONS FOR PHASE CHAN GE OVER A RAN GE O F TEM PE RATURES
The second way that phase chang e in food can b e t ak en into account is
by mak i ng ma thema t i ca l a l l owanc e for phase change ove r a range o f
temp eratures . Phase chang e ov er a rang e of temp era tures is the ac tua l
s i tua t ion occurr i ng in food freez i ng and thawi ng . The mos t ge neral
app roach wou ld tak e account of any var i a t ion in apparent volume t r i c
sp ec i f ic heat c apac i ty , C, and the therma l conduc t iv i ty , k, in
E q . ( 2 . 1 ) me an i ng tha t n o phy si c a l assump tions ab ou t the phase chang e
process need b e made . For foods the apparen t volume t r i c spec i f i c heat
cap ac i ty is de f ined at any temp era ture as :
dH
c - (2 . 1 3 )
dt
S impler semi -ana ly ti c al and emp ir i ca l app roaches have a lso b een tak en .
2.4.1 Appr ox i mate Ana lyt i cal Solut ions for A l l oy Sol id i f icat ion
Approx i mate analy t ical so lut ions for al l oy sol i d i f i ca t ion are
summar i sed in Tab l e A .6 . In alloy sol i d if i ca t i on it i s normally
assu med that l atent heat is released u n i formly ov er an ex tended
temp erature rang e . Error w i l l oc cur in u si ng the se so lutions for phase
change i n food becau se foods do not have constant laten t he at release
w i th resp ec t to chang e i n temp erature .
t •
�H
I T a-T i f l
[ p �
h
+ R �
k
2
] (2 . 1 4 )
or i n d imension less form ( Tch igeov 1 958 ) :
p R
Fo - --- + (2 . 1 5 )
Bi Ste S te
where Mi • chang e in enthalpy during the p rocess ( J m- 3 )
Ta - amb i ent temperature ( oc )
Tif - i n i t i a l freez ing temperature ( oc )
P ,R • geome t r i c fac tors dep end ing on obj e c t shap e
D • ful l th i ck ness or d iameter
h • surface heat transfer coe ff i c ient
Fo • F our i er numb er
• at/D 2
81 • Biot numb er
• hD/k
L i teratu re Rev i ew 22
Var iou s app rox i mate me thod s hav e b een emp loy ed to acc ount for
non-cons tan t thermal p r opert ies , s ens ible heat ef fec ts b o th ab ove and
b elow the phase chang e temp erature rang e and the non- i sothermal latent
he at rel ease or ab sorp t io n . Some f i t experi mental data wh i l e others
attemp t correc t i ons b ased on theor e t i cal g rou nd s . Al though some t imes
der ived for a spec i f i c p roduc t or cond i t ion many of the me thod s c an b e
mad e t o apply t o a w i der rang e o f p robl ems . Ki nder & Lamb ( 1 97 4 ) and
Cleland ( 1 97 9 ) rev iew the re l a t i v e mer i ts of these formu l ae for food
freez ing .
Seban ( 1 9 4 3 ) exc ep t that the posi t ion of the lumped heat wi th in the
obj ec t is determine d by the B i ot nu mb er . For all these me thods therma l
p r op e r t ies are chos en or calculat ed by av erag i ng techn iqu e s to model
more acc urately the true hea t transfer cond it ions during each p e r i od .
For s i mi l ar reasons Mo tt ( 1 96 4 ) , Flem i ng ( 1 967 ) , Sokulsk i ( 1 972a ) ,
A l b i n et al ( 1 9 79 ) and Pham ( 1 9 8 4 a , 1 9 8 4 b ) a ll suggested the u se o f a
we igh ted av erage freez i ng temperature or temperature d i f fer ence in
solu t i ons b ased on a unique phase chang e temp era ture , whe n phase chang e
i s ov er a r a nge of temp er a tures such as i n food freez i ng a nd thawi ng .
Levy ( 1 9 8 3 b , 1 98 3 c , 1 9 8 4 ) also c onsider ed the free z i ng and thawi ng
p roc ess es i n three s tages and def ined effec t i v e heat c apac i t i es a nd
thermal conduc ti v i ti e s for each stag e f or use in solu t i o ns for he a t
conduc t ion w i th ou t phase chang e .
L i t erature Rev iew 23
D i f f erent ial forms of emp ir ically deve loped vers ions of P l ank ' s
equa t ion al low Loeffen et al ( 1 98 1 ) and Cl eland & Earle ( 1 9 8 2 c ) to
cons i der t i me var i ab l e boundary cond i t ions by s i mp l e numer ical me thod s .
A non-u n i form i n i tial temp era ture d is t ribu t ion wa s handled by
calculat ion wi th a me an in i t ial temperatur e .
For a range of regular shapes two r ec ent s tud i es ( Clel and & E ar l e
1 9 8 4 a , P ham 1 98 4 c ) have shown the methods t o p redic t freez ing times due
to Pham ( 1 98 3 , 1 98 4 a , 1 98 4 b , 1 98 4 c ) and Cleland & Ear l e ( 1 982 b) to b e
accurate by comp ar ison w i th a larg e comp os i te f r ee z i ng data set .
D i rec t numer ical app rox imat ion o f Eq. ( 2 . 1 ) is an ap p roach requir ing no
assump t ions ab out the phys ical proc es ses of freez i ng and thaw i ng .
Errors may ar i s e from imp rec ise thermal data , and from nu mer i cal
t ru ncat ion and round i ng error s . A wide rang e o f nume r i ca l me thods have
b een u sed .
Earle 1 9 7 7 b , 1 97 9 a ) .
Bonac ina & Comi n i ( 1 9 7 1 ) and Cl e land & Ear le ( 1 98 4 a ) c onsi dered the
d i f feren t f i ni te d i f fer ence sche mes and conc luded that the i mp l ic i t
three t ime l ev e l scheme due to Lees ( 1 9 6 6 ) is super ior in t e rms of
acc uracy . It is a lso stab l e and convergen t . The thre e t i me l evel
scheme p red i c te d freez ing data to with in ab ou t ± 1 0 % for slab s , i n f i n i t e
cy l inders , spheres and rect angular b r i ck shap es ( Clel and e t al 1 982 ) .
In numer ical me thods the calculated heat flow thr oug h the obj ec t
surfac e shou l d equa l the in ternal entha lpy chang e ov er the wh ole phase
chang e proces s . C lo se ag reemen t ( re ferred t o as a heat balanc e ) mus t
b e ach iev e d for a nu mer i ca l me thod t o b e cons idered b oth accurate and
val i d . To ensure a heat balanc e , a number of d i fferent methods to
ca l c ulate the thermal p rop er t i e s ( espec ially in th e l atent he at p eak
temp erature rang e ) hav e been propo sed ( Comi n i et a l 1 97 4 b , Com i n i & Del
Gu i d ic e 1 9 7 6 , Lemmon 1 9 7 9 ) . Morg an et al ( 1 9 78 ) suggest they may not
g iv e b enef i ts over d irec t evaluat ion. Cleland e t a l ( 1 982 ) , s tudy i ng
numer ical p re d i c ti on o f freez ing , d iscov er e d tha t the b et ter f in i t e
d i f ferenc e and f in i te element me thods are prob ably more l i mi ted by
thermal data unc erta inty than numer i ca l app rox i ma t i ons . Both the
f in i te element me thod and the f in i te d i f f er enc e me thod for cont inuously
var i ab l e therma l p roper t i es can model a u n ique phase chang e t emper ature
by appr op r iate cho i c e of the therma l p r operty func t ions ( Bo nac ina et al
L i terature Rev iew 27
1 9 73 ) .
2.5 THE EFFECT O F GEOMETRY ON FR EE ZING AND THAW ING TIME PREDICTIONS
B y assumi ng ( a ) a geome t r i cal descr i p tion for the phase chang e fro n t ,
( b ) that the sur face temperature i s constant b u t s t i l l t i me var i ab l e
ov er the surface and ( c ) tha t the qua s i -s teady state assump tion is
app l icab l e i n the pha se between the surfac e and the phase change fron t ,
P l ank ( 1 9 4 1 ) , Tanak a & N i sh imoto ( 1 9 59 , 1 96 0 , 1 964 ) and recently
Shamsundar ( 1 98 2 ) der ived geome t r i c fac tors to acc ount for the obj ec t
configura t i on for many regular shap es . Where the se cond assump tion i s
t rue and the phase chang e front i s para l l e l t o th e sur fac e , the fac tors
dep end d irec tly on the surface area t i mes th ick ness -to-v olume ( AD/ 2V )
rat i o . Ru tov ( 1 9 36 ) and Mot t ( 1 9 6 4 ) b oth ex tended the i de a to u s i ng
the rat i o o f p roduc t surfac e area t imes th i ck ness- to-volume as an i ndex
of the shape in calculat ions for all geome tr i es . Th i s app roach is
accurate f o r slab s , i n f i n i te cyl i nders and spheres w i th the th ird k ind
o f boundary cond i t ion as the surface i s a l ways i s o thermal . irresp ec t i v e
of Biot number . Cl e land & Ear le ( 1 9 8 2 a , 1 9 82b) show i t i s not acc urate
for o ther shapes when the Biot numb er i s non-z er o . Pham ( 1 9 84b) u s ed
the same g ener a l app roach bu t i nc ludes a correct i on to the Blot numb er
L i t era ture Rev i ew 28
b ased on the "mean heat conduc t i ng path " ( MC P ) fr om the c en tre to the
sur fac e of the obj ec t . A me thod to calculate the mean conduc t i ng p a th
l eng th i s g iven for freez ing of rec tangular b ri ck shap es b ased on fi t
to experi mental data . Sokulsk i ( 1 97 2 a ) u ses the AD/ 2V rat i o b u t only
consi ders a sec t i on of the obj e c t near the thermodynami c cen tre .
Cleland & E ar l e ( 1 982b) def ine EHT D ( equ ivalent heat t ransfer
d imens i onali ty ) as the ra t i o of the freez i ng t i me for a slab of
equ ivalent th i ckness to the freez i ng ti me of the shap e in ques t io n ,
under the same i n i t i a l and boundary cond i t ions . The v a lue o f EHT D i s
calculated from the rat ios of d i mens ions for rectangular b r i ck shapes
or from exp er imental data bu t is, like Pham ' s method , esse n t i ally
equ ivalent to the area t i mes th i ck ness -to-volume ra t io w i th a
correc tion for B i ot nu mb ers g reater than z ero .
Both the EHTD and MCP conc ep ts gav e accurate p red i c t ions of
exp er imental data for freez ing o f rec tangular b ri ck s when app l i ed i n
conj unc t ion wi th an accurate p red i c t ion me thod for freez i ng of the
simple slab shap e . N e ither method ha s a tot ally theore t i ca l b asi s , bu t
b oth cons i der the l i mi t i ng ca se s of Bi �o and B i � m . Goodness of f i t to
exper i mental data was also u sed in the i r der ivat ion . Bo th EHT D and MC P
have b een p ostulated as su i tab l e for irregular shap es , bu t th is has no t
b een v er i f i e d .
The therma l p rop er t i es requ ired to p red i c t phase chang e in food i nc lude
thermal conduc t iv i ty , k , volume t r i c spec i f i c heat c apac i ty , C, latent
hea t content , L, phase chang e temp erature , T if ' and spec i f i c hea t
g enera t i on , Q . N o me thod to p re d ic t freez ing or thaw i ng times for
food s tuffs can be accura te i f the food thermal propert i es requ i r ed by
the me thod cannot b e ob tained ac cura tely , or are not rep rese nta ti ve of
the who l e produc t . There has been a great deal o f r esear ch , rev i ewed
by Woolr i ch ( 1 9 6 6 ) , Woodams & Nowry ( 1 96 8 ) , Mor l ey ( 1 97 2 ) , Me llor
( 1 976 , 1 9 78 , 1 979 , 1 980 ) , Pol l ey e t al ( 1 9 80 ) and Me ffer t ( 1 98 4 ) , i nto
thermal p roperty data requ ired to calculate phase chang e for foods . A
comp l ied set of da ta for meat ( Mor l ey 1 972 ) demons t r a tes some
i ncons i stenc ies in the thermal p rop er ty data . S i mi lar i ncons i s tenc ies
in data c ould b e exp ec ted for other food s .
Collec tion of thermal p roperty data i s ted iou s and exp ens i ve b ecau se o f
the v ar i ab i l i ty o f foods tuffs i n compos i t ion and s t ruc ture and the w i de
rang e of temp erature for wh ich data is requ ired . Data for froz en food
are esp ec ially d i f f icult to determine b ecau se it is d i ff icul t to
ma inta in the app ro p riate , exp erimental cond i t i ons .
mode ls . The s implest models sum the e ffec t of the sol i d and l iquid
componen t p a r t s ( Com i n i e t a l 1 9 74 a , Lamb 1 9 76 , D i ckerson 1 9 77, L e ntz &
Van Den Berg 1 9 77, Mascheroni e t a l 1 9 77, Levy 1 9 8 1 , Levy 1 9 8 2 a ) . An
al terna t i v e i s to pred i c t the water and ice frac t io n from freez i ng
point dep ress i on equa t i o ns and re late th is to the chang es i n p ro p er t i es
from unfroz en values ( He ldman 1 9 74 b , Heldman & Gorby 1 9 75 , Schwa r tzberg
1 9 76 , Schwar tzb erg 1 9 77, Mascheron i & Ca lv elo 1 9 80 , Heldman 1 9 8 1 ,
Heldman 1 982 , Mascher on i & Ca lvelo 1 98 2 , Lark in e t a l 1 984 ) . A th i rd
app roach i s to u se emp ir i cal or reg ress i on equa t i ons to f i t the data
( Levy 1 9 79 , Chang & Tao 1 98 1 , Ramaswamy & Tung 1 98 1 , Levy 1 9 82 b , 1 982 c ,
1 983a) . All three app roaches are c l a imed to l ead to data of s i mi lar
ac curacy to that ob ta inabl e by d irec t measuremen t .
One of the mos t d iff icult parameters to de termine indep enden tly in food
freez i ng and thaw i ng proc es ses that i nvolve the th ird k i nd of boundary
cond i t ion i s the surface heat transfer coe ff i c ient b et ween the amb i ent
med ium and the p roduc t surfac e . Arce & Sweat ( 1 980 ) r ev iew tech n i ques
to est imate , and g iv e data for , surface hea t transf er coeff i c i e n ts in
many food heat t r ansfer s i tu a t i ons.
2 .7 SUMMARY
3 RESEARC H O BJECTIVES
The restr i c ted na ture of publ i shed data l ed to the formula t i o n of the
f i rs t two a i ms of the pr esent research :
( 1 ) to collec t thaw i ng data f or the b as i c s l ab , infi n i t e cyl i nder ,
sphere and r ec tangular b r i ck shapes
( 2 ) to coll ec t fr eez i ng and thawi ng data f or other ( ir r egular) shap es .
Resea rch Obj ec t i v es 34
T h i s expans ion of the data b ase was necessary to fac il i tate tes t i ng of
thawi ng t i me p red i c t ion me thods for s i mp l e shapes and pred i c t i on
methods app l i cab l e to i rregular geometr i es for both freez i ng and
thaw i ng .
Tab l e 3 . 1 g ives the des i rab l e attr i bu tes of any method for food
freez i ng and thawi ng t i me pred i c t ion d i scussed by Slatter & J ones
( 1 97 2 ) , Cl eland ( 1 97 7 ) and Cl eland & Ear le ( 1 9 77 a) . The methods
ava i l able are conv en i ently d iv i ded i nto two broad groups for fur ther
study :
Grou p ( I ) : Formulae requ i r i ng on ly hand calcul a t i on
Group ( II ) : Numer ical me thods requ i r i ng computer calcul ation.
These groups d iffer s l i gh tly from those u sed in Sec . 2 . 3 and 2 . 4 . Many
e ng i neers do not have the sp ec i al ised knowledge to impl ement nume r i cal
method s . They will not u se Group I I me thod s unl ess they ar e ava ilab l e
as computer packages . Such people therefore mus t often rely on the
simple formulae ( Group I) . The g rea ter soph ist i cation of numer i cal
me thods may jus t i fy the ir u se if comp l ex cond i t ions are to s tud ied and
more det a i l ed des i g n i n forma t i on is requ ired . Often imprec i s e
k nowledge o f the pha se change cond i t i ons and uncerta i nty in thermal
data me an that the more comp l ex numer i ca l methods are no more accurate
in p rac t ice than Gr oup I me thod s .
Tab l e 3 . 1 Desi rab l e Attr ibu tes of Freez ing and Thaw ing T i me Pred i c tion
Method s
T ab l e 3 . 2 Cond i t ions R equ i red For Der ivat ion of S i mpl e Fr eez ing and
Thawing T i me Pred i c t ion Formulae
I t was neccessary to develop some numeri cal free z i ng and thawi ng t ime
pred i ct i on methods beyond what has been reported in the l i t erature i n
order t o meet the f our th r es ear ch obj ect i ve defi ned i n Chap . 3 .
4.1 INTRODUCTION
Numer i cal methods requ i re no physi ca l assump ti ons about the phase
change process but mak e numeri cal approximati ons . For complex bo undar y
cond i t i ons , i rr egular shapes , non- homogeneous mater i als and where
t emperature prof i l es change rapidly wi th posi t i on , the f i ni t e el ement
method is abl e to make mor e exac t approx imat i ons than the f i n i t e
d i fference me thod . F o r these reasons only the f i ni t e el ement method
has been used extens i ve l y for i rregular shapes ( Comi ni et al 1 97 8 ) .
(4.2)
(4.3)
(4.4)
(4.5)
h con • E,
T ac and T ar ar e no l onger dependent on pos i t i on . I n phy si ca l
t erms , th i s means that no e l ement covers a reg i on made u p o f mor e than
one materi al type , and that boundary s urfaces are chos en so that
boundary var i ab l es $. h con • T ac and T ar can be ass umed cons tant f or
E,
that s urface , but not neccessar i l y the same as for other boundar y
s ur f aces . Knowl edge of these var i abl es i s often subj ect t o s i gn i f i cant
uncert ai nty . Therefore from a prac t i cal v i ewpoi nt the above
l im i tat i ons shoul d no t be restr i ct i ve . The dependence on t emperatur e
of k , C , Q , hrad • and on t i me of h con • �. T ac and T ar at each of the
s urfaces , r ema i ns .
J
aN j +
aN i aN j
- - -- W dV
ay az az
N j W dS 3 (4.6)
(4.7)
IS Ni w dS 2
ze
Is N i w dS 3 (4.8)
3e
T h i s requ i res the f urther assumpti ons that wi th i n each of the el emen t s
o r across each of the el ement s urfac es f o r wh i ch the summat ions are
made , that the proper t i es k , C , Q and h rad are cons tant wi th res pe c t to
temperature , but that these values can change from one t i me s tep to the
ne xt . Even though this is not physi cally accurate , if a val ue of these
proper t i es that is repres ent a t i v e of the whol e el ement or el ement
surface can be de termi ned , and if the e l ements ar e not l arge this
approach may be suff i c i ently accurate for many pur poses . G i ven that
the t i me s t ep i s control led so that temper ature changes per t i me s t ep
are small , the maj or di sadvantage of thi s s i mpl er formul a t i on is that
the proper t i es ar e not re- eva l ua t ed at each i nt egrat i on poi nt . I n the
full formul a t i on evalua t i on at each i nt egra t i on point hel ps accoun t f or
property vari at i on over the e l ement reg i on so that os c i l l atory
behav iour , espe c i al l y near the phas e chang e t emperatur es wher e thermal
proper t i es change rap i dl y , i s l ess l i kely ( C l el and et al 1 98 4 ) . The
advantage of the simpl er formul a t i on is that the i nt egra t i ons shown i n
Eq . ( 4 . 6 ) to ( 4 . 8 ) need only to b e calcul ated for the f i rs t t i me s t ep .
T hereafter the constant val u es resul t i ng from the i nt egra tion c an b e
stored and m ul ti pl i ed e l ement b y e l ement ( and s ur f ace by s ur f ace ) by
the appropriate proper t i es , and the s ummat i on compl et ed . T h i s requi res
f ar l ess computat i on t i me and computer memor y than f or the f ul l
f ormul a t i on .
The cho i ce of formul at i on must take i nto account the t rade- off between
loss in acc uracy and sav i ngs in comput at ion cos ts . As c omput a t i on
costs are usually f ar l es s than the cost of data preparati on ( S egerl i nd
1 97 6 ) , the sav i ng s may be qui t e smal l . Also uncert ai nti es in thermal
propert i es and bounda r y cond i ti on dat a are s ubstant i al ( Sec . 2. 6 ) .
Provi ded numeri cal errors are small compared wi th physi cal
uncer t a i nt i es no wort hwh i l e i ncrease i n pred i ct i on accuracy w i l l occur
N umeri cal Method Formul a t i ons 42
pur poses .
L ew i s 1 975 ) :
Ti-1 � ( T i - 1 +T i +T i + 1
= ) (4.10)
or reduc i ng the t i me step ( Segerl i nd 1 9 76 ) wi ll reduce these
os c i l lati ons . Too small a t i me s tep is undes i rabl e as computat i on
t i mes are i ncreased and computer round i ng errors can be come
s i gn i f i cant .
apparent i nt ernal
entha l py chang e
heat fl ow i nt ernal
in through + heat
the s ur f ac e genera t i on
dV] dt
T he programs can be used f or heat transf er probl ems i nvo l v i ng obj ects
of one , two or three- d imensions . T he a x i s ymmetri c featur e can be used
to s i mpl i f y probl ems wher e one or more axes of rota t i onal s ymmetry
exist . The el ements used ar e based on the rect angul ar "S erend i p i ty"
fami l y ( Z i en k i ewi cz 1 97 1 ) . L i near or quadrat i c i s oparametr i c and
super parame t r i c el ements are ava i l abl e . The high ord er el ements r educe
the total number of e l ements necessary and a l l ow curved e l ement
boundari es to b e use d t o model i rregul ar geomet r i es . The only s pe c i f i c
use of s ubparametr i c e l ements woul d be f or regul ar shapes wher e a
quadr at i c t emperature prof i l e i s required . A s quadra t i c i so parametri c
el ements ar e capabl e of handl i ng thi s case j us t as wel l , wi thout
Numer i cal Method F ormul at i ons 45
D 1 . 0 m , ks kl = = 1 . 0 W m - 1 °C - 1 , C S c
1
� 1 . o MJ m -3 oc - 1 ,
L 3
75 . 0 MJ m- , T a = 1 5 °C , T in - 1 5 °C .
=
e l ement programs .
Numer i cal Method Formulat ions 48
0 = 1 . 0 m, k = 1 . 0 W m - 1 oc - 1 , C = 1 . 0 MJ m -3 °C - 1 , 4> = 1 0 0 W m -2 ,
T i n = 1 00 °C . Values of tempera ture ( °C ) are tabu lated.
20 84 .04 83 . 83 92 . 09 9 2 . 90
40 77 . 4 3 77 . 28 86 . 0 4 85 . 90
60 72.36 72.24 81 . 22 81 10
•
80 68 . 09 67 . 98 77 . 09 76 . 99
1 00 64 . 3 2 64 . 22 73 . 43 73 . 3 4
1 1
D 1 .0 m, k 1 . 0 W m- °C - , C "' 1 . 0 MJ m - 3 °C - 1 , h = 1 .0 W m -2 oc - 1 ,
£ = 1 . 0 , Tac 0 K , T ar = 0 K. Values o f Y ar e tabul ated .
3
£ oT i n D / k
0 . 02 0 . 80 0 .79 1 . 00 1 . 00
0 . 06 0 . 70 0 . 70 1 . 00 1 . 00
0 . 20 0 . 58 0 . 58 0 . 94 0 . 93
0 . 40 0 . 50 0 . 50 0 . 80 0 . 80
1 . 00 0 . 33 0 . 32 0 . 50 0 . 50
2 . 00 0.16 0.15 0 . 23 0 . 23
3
£ oT i n D / k 4
0 . 02 0 . 70 0 . 69 1 . 00 1 . 00
0 . 06 0 .61 0 .61 1 . 00 1 .00
0 . 20 0 .5 1 0 .5 1 0.91 0.91
0 . 40 0 . 43 0 . 43 0 . 76 0 .7 6
1 . 00 0 . 29 0 . 28 0 . 44 0 . 45
2 . 00 0. 1 3 0 .1 4 0 . 20 0 .21
1 N ewman ( 1 9 3 6 )
2 Both the f u l l formu lat ion ( Eqs . ( 4 . 2 ) to ( 4 . 5 ) ) and the s i mp l i f i ed
Dev el opm ent of the f i n i te e l ement method has meant that the f i ni te
d i f f er ence me thod is mai nly us ed f or pre di c t i on of heat transf er i n
regul ar l y s haped obj ects . For probl ems w i th regul ar shapes , f in i t e
d i ff er en c es requ i r e l es s det a i l ed pr ogr am preparat ion and hav e l ower
compu ta t i on t i m es . Bonac i na & C om i ni ( 1 97 1 ) , C l el and ( 1 97 7 ) and
C l el and & E arle ( 1 97 7 a ) s t u d i e d f i ni t e d i f f er e nce methods and f ound the
thr ee t i me l evel i m pl i c i t L ee ' s s cheme t o be the bes t f or mod el l i ng
f r e e z i ng of food . C omp uter program s us i ng the L ee ' s scheme for
i nf i ni t e s l ab s ( C l el an d & Earl e 1 97 7 b ) , i nf i ni t e cyl i nders and s pheres
( C l el and & E arle 1 97 9 a ) , rect angular r o ds ( Cl el and 1 9 77 ) and
rec tangul ar b r i c k ( Cl el and & E ar l e 1 97 9b ) shapes are ava i l abl e and were
subsequently us e d . T hese programs have been shown to b e acc ur ate to
wi th i n about ± 1 0% compared w i th experi mental sl ab , i nf i ni t e c y l i nde r ,
sphere and r e ct angular b r i c k free z i ng data ( Cl el and et al 1 9 8 2 ) . T hey
also meet anal y t i ca l chec k s . T her e i s no r e as on why s i mi l ar pred i ct i on
a c c uracy c annot be expe cted us i ng these p rograms f or thawi ng of f ood .
N umer i cal Method F ormul at i ons 52
For the f i n i t e cyl i nder geometry the general heat co nduct i on equa t i on
is:
()T k ()T
[ :: ] [ :: ]
a a
c k + - - + k ( 4. 1 2)
at ar r ar ay
A l though the f i ni te cyl i nder i s thr ee- d i mensi onal , because i t h as an
ax i s of rotat i onal symm etry , i t can be cons i dered as two- d imens i o nal .
Bonac i na & C om i ni ( 1 9 7 3 ) hav e shown how the L ee ' s sc heme can be appl i ed
to probl ems in two d i mens i ons by usi ng s tandard a l ternat i ng d i r ec t i on
impl i ci t proc edur es . Equa t i on ( 4 . 1 2 ) can be appro x i mated by a L ees '
schem e :
i+ 1 i- 1
T j -T mj
ci . m
mJ
2H
+
�
k j
2m
m 1
+ +
( T i + 1 j -T i 1 j + T i + j - T i j + T i -
m- 1 m 1 m- 1
1 i- 1
m + 1 j -Tm- 1 j
)]
+
1 �
i i+ 1 i+1 i i i- 1 i-1
2 k mj + � ( T mj + 1 - T mj + T m j + 1 - T m j + T m j + 1 - T m j )
L
� 1 - T�j � 1 +T�j -T�j - 1 +T �j 1 -T�j � 1 )]
3 ( 6y )
�
+ k j � (T
-
( 4 . 1 3)
[
Second sweep ( i n y d i re c t i on ) :
i+1
- T mj -1
[
y ki
mj - i Jl + T mj r.l
i + 1 c i +Y ( i
mj
i
i mj - i
k mj + + k ) ] - T i+1
mj + 1
y ki
mj + l
J
i
= C mj i+1 *
T mj - y
�l mj
i i- 1
+ i ( T mj + 1 -T
i-1 )
mj -k
i ( i-1 i-1
mj - 1 T mj - T mj - 1
)] (4.15)
26t 26t *
where X = 2' Y = 2 and T are i nterme d i at e t emper at ures
3 ( 6r ) 3 ( 6y )
cal cul ated by the al ter nat i ng d i re c t i o n scheme that hav e no phy s i ca l
s i g n i f i canc e .
(4.17)
� �
set t i ng k -! j =k + ! j and T m- 1 j -T m + 1 j at al l t i me l ev el s . T he s econd
sweep i s unal tered f r om Eq . ( 4 . 1 5 ) .
A t the rad i al sur f ac e ( m=M ) :
aT
h ( T a -T w ) • k - (4.18)
or
N umer i cal M ethod F ormul at i ons 54
i[ i i i- 1 i-1 i i i i- 1 i- 1
+ Y k mj + � ( T mj + 1 -T mj + 2T mj + 1 - 2T mj ) - k mj - � ( T mj - T mj - 1 + 2T mj - 2T mj - 1
)] (4. 19)
The p r og r am i nc l udes the heat bal ance an d tem per atur e updat i ng
techn i ques d i scuss ed i n Sec . 4 . 2 . 2 for f i ni t e el ement me thods , i n or der
to p r event osc i l l at i on and to detect l atent heat peak " j ump i ng "
p ro bl ems . T o prevent osc i l l a t i on d u r i ng calcul a t i o n of phase change
Or =0 . 02 m , Dy =0 . 02 m , k = 0.617 W m- 1 °C - 1 , C = 3 . 6 9 MJ m
- 3 oc - 1 •
1 00 0 . 6 25 0 . 624 0 . 936 0 . 93 4
300 0 . 398 0 . 39 7 0 .626 0 . 6 25
500 0 . 260 0 . 259 0 . 40 9 0 . 407
700 0 . 1 69 0 . 1 69 0 . 266 0 . 265
900 0. 1 10 0. 1 10 0. 174 0 . 173
-1
h 1 000 . 0 W m - 2 oc
1 Newman ( 1 9 3 6 )
57
wi th experi ment al freez i ng and thaw i ng dat a , s ome lack of agr e ement i s
i ne v i tab l e . Th i s imp rec i s ion may ar i se f r om one o f three sources :
( a ) unc erta i n t y i n th ermal p roper t y dat a for th e mat e r i a l be i ng fr oz en
or thawed ( data error )
Second ly , there i s the error ar i s i ng from imp rec i s e knowl edge of the
expe r i mental cond i t ions . Hav i ng control l ed th e exper i ment a l cond i t i ons
dur i ng each run the mean values must be measur ed . Uncer t a i n t y can
a r i se as a d i f f er enc e between th e measure d va l ue o f a paramet er and t he
unknown true value . The uncer t a i nt y can be reduced by r ep l i cate
determ i nat ions , b u t measurement s are suspe c t i b l e to sys t ema t i c errors
wh ich r ep l icate determ i nat ions wi l l not d i scern. Syst ema t i c error
c annot be eas i l y quan t i f i e d an d can only be m i ni m i sed by ensur i ng that
the measur ement t echni ques used ar e val i d and accurat e . Sources of
sy stema t i c err or inc lude ; u nwan t ed e dge h eat t r ans f er , i ns t rument
E xper i mental Pro cedur e and Dat a C o l l e c t i o n 58
propert i es . Food mat e r i als are rar ely homogeneou s , each samp l e c an
on l y be u sed e xpe r i mental l y on ce or t w i ce , an d they t e nd to ha ve a w i de
var iat i o n in compos i t ion . Co nse quent ly therma l property data ar e often
i mp r ec i se . For these reasons ana l ogu es ha ve common l y b een u s ed ( R i ede l
adop ted for Group I ( s i mp l e ) methods . These are g iven in Tab l e 5 . 2 and
are cons i s te nt w i th Tab l e 5 . 1 .
Taylor Ins truments "Mu l t i-Scan Recorder " p oten t i ome ter operat i ng on a
T k T c H2
( oc ) (W m
-1 oc - 1 ) ( oc ) (MJ m - 3 o c - 1 ) ( MJ m - 3 )
Ty lose
- 40 . o 1 . 67 - 40 . 0 1 . 88 0.0
- 30 . 0 1 .6 7 -30 . 0 1 . 92 19 .0
-20 . 0 1 . 66 - 20 . 0 1 .95 �
8.3
-1 5 . 0 1 .6 4 -1 8 . 0 2 . 00 2.3
-1 0. 0 1 .63 -1 6 . 0 2 . 20 46 . 5
-9 . 0 1 . 61 -1 4 . 0 2. 0 � 51 .0
-8 . 0 1 . 60 -1 2 . 0 2. 0 56 . 1
-7 . 0 1 . 58 -1 0 .0 �
. 70 62 . 6
-6.0 1 .56 �
- .0 . 20 66 . 6
-5 . 0 1 .5 2 0 5 . 00 71 .2
�
-
•
-4 . 0 1 . 46 - .o 5 . 90 6.6
-3 . 0 1 . 35 l
- .0 7 . 20 3 .2
-2 . 5
-2. 0
1 . 28
1 . 18
�
- .0 1 1 00
1 7 . 00
• 92 .
1 06 .
�
- .0
-1 . 5 1 . 04 -3 . 0 25 . 00 1 27 . g
-1 .0 0 . 82 -2 .5 u 3 . 00 1 41 .
-0 . 8 0 .66 -2 . 0 5 . 00 1 61 3 •
-0 . 7 0 .55 -1 .5 70 . 0 0 1 90 . 1
-0.6 0 . 49 -1 . 1 00 . 00 207 . 1
0.0
20 . 0
0 . 49
0.56
-0 .
-0.5
6 1 00 . 00
1 9 .93
2 1 .1
2 J§
.1
40. 0 0 .6 2 0.0 3 .71 28 .o
1 00 . 0 0 .62 1 00 . 0 3 .7 1 660 . 0
- 40 . 0 1 .58 - 40 . 0 1 . 89 0.0
-24. 0
-1 2 . 0
1 .5 � -30 . 0 1 .91 1 .o �
1 .4 -25 . 0 2.02 2 .8
-8 . 0 1 .40 - 20 . 0 2 .7 0 40 . 6
-4.0 1 . 28 -1 5 . 0 �
.58 56 . 3
-2.0
-1 . 0
0 . 98
0 . 48
-1 0 . 0 . 55 �
6 .7
-8 . 0 5 . 26 6 .5
o.o
1 00 . o
0 .49
0 .50
-6 . 0 7 .71 9 .4 �
-5 . 0 1 0 . 40 1 0 .5
-4 .0 1 5 .7 0 1 21 .5
-3.0 3 1 . 20 1 45 . 0
-2 . 0 53 . 1 0 1a .1
-1 . 5 73 .70 21 . 8 A
-1 . 3 25 5 . 00 251 . 7
-1 . 2 25 5 . 00 2 77 . 2
-1 . 0 3 . 65
3 . 65
� 03. 1
1 00 . 0 71 . 7
ks ( W m - 1 oc - 1 ) 1 .65 1 . 55
kl ( W m - 1 oc - 1 ) 0 . 55 0 . 50
CS ( MJ m -3 oc - 1 ) 1 . 90 1 .90
c
l ( MJ m -3 oc - 1 ) 3.71 3.65
L ( MJ m -3 ) 209 . 0 20 9 . 0
tJi (MJ m- 3 ) 226 . 0 23 0 . 0
Tif ( oc ) -0 . 6 -1 . 0
T i fave ( oc ) -2 . 1 -2 . 5
k ave ( W m - 1 oc - 1 ) 1 . 2f
1 ot•
?
1.5
�
�
· · · · · · · •·
·· · ·
· ·· •
· · ·•
··
··
·· ·.
>-
··
··
•
-
·
•
·s;
•
.
.
:;: ·.
.
(J •
• Legend
-dc .
•
•
. A
0 .
.
u B
.
•
�
• .. . . . . . . . . •
.
•
.
E
�
0.5 ;;L---I'ftr.=
�
..c:.
I-
0 4-----�----�--��-
-20 -15 -10 -5 0 5 10
Temperature (•c)
Bee f ( B ) .
1,000
�
� Legend
� 100 A.
>-
a
1
···-·-·-
c
...............
I
u
;
u
,_.._______
cl
-20 -15 - 10 -5 0 5 10
Ter11*'oh.r• (•c)
F i g. 5 . 2 A pparent Volu met ric S pec ific Heat Capac it y Data Fo r T ylos e
The amb ient heat i ng or coo l i ng med ium was e i th er water or 29 % ca lc ium
chlor ide b r i ne he ld i n a 1 m3 i nsulated t ank ( F i g . 5 . 8 ) . The med ium
temperature was measur e d by two th ermocoupl es ; one pr ior to and one
aft er the ex per imental sec t io n . E xternal c ir c ulation of the med ium was
used for sl ab thaw i ng ex p er i men t s , in wh i ch c ase an add i t i onal
thermoco uple was locate d i n the return stream to the tank . In all
expe r i men ts there was no measur abl e d i f ferenc e in temperature b etween
the thermocouples b ec ause the c irculat ion rate of the med ium w i th in the
p i p i ng and ar ound the t an k was suff i c i en t l y h ig h .
The t ank t emperature was c ontrolled b y a RKC PN- 4 1 " Bl i nd Control ler"
act iv a t i ng bo th refr i g erat ion and heat i ng systems . Th e thermal
capaci t y o f the tank contents was l arge c ompared w i th the heat loss or
ga i n from the env ironmen t and from the obj ec t be i ng frozen or thawed .
Exper imental Procedure and Dat a Collec t i o n 65
Tak i ng r ecor der ca l ibrat ion error i nto account , the overal l err or in
temp era ture measurement and control was est ima ted a t l ess than ±0 . 5 °C .
sur face of the mater i a l . The brown paper , p laced betwe en the two
l ayer s of a luminium foi l so that i t rema ine d dry , prov ide d structura l
strength t o the wr ap p ing . The mate r i a l was f i l l ed sl ightly ab ov e the
level of th e po lystyrene i nsu l a t ion to ensur e the insulat ion wou l d not
h inder contact b etween the plates and the sur face of the s lab .
Th e s l a b th i ckn es s was measure d a fter equ i l ib rat ion over se vera l day s ,
i n both the frozen and unfroz en s t ates . Pr ior to thawi ng ex per i ments
th e s l ab s were fr oz en in a p l a te freezer t o ensure a flat sur face f or
good contact w i th the thaw i ng plates , even wh en so l i d and i n f l ex ib l e ,
and to g i ve the requ i r ed th i ck n ess . The th i ck ness of the Tyl ose sl ab s
was found to vary by up to 0 .5 mm across each slab . There was no
d i ff eren ce between the frozen and un froz en measureme nts for Tyl ose as
the dens i ty d id not change apprec iab l y . Thou gh the dens i ty change for
m i nc e d l e an bee f is of the or der of 4% some o f the var i a t i on i n vo lume
caused the poly styrene surround ing the slab to compress and d id no t
affect th e th i ck n es s t o th i s ful l ex ten t . The va l ues tak e n in the
froz en and unfr ozen s t ates wer e found to d i ffer by less than 0 . 5 mm
from the mean for meat . As the s ma l l es t s l ab th i ckness w i th mi nced
lean b ee f was 0 .024 m the er ror assoc iated w i th th is measur emen t i s
l es s than 2 % . Becau se a l l thermo coupl es wer e p l aced t owards the centre
of the 0 . 22 m d iameter s lab to avo i d edge effec t s in he at transfer ,
more empha s i s was p u t on th i ckness measuremen t s i n th i s reg i on .
5.4.3 Measurement and Control o f Sur face Heat Tr ansfer Coef f i c ients
In the plate thawi ng system use d the res is tanc e to heat transfer
between the s l ab surface and th e heat i ng medium was smal l , there were
no s i g n i f icant rad iat ion or mass transfer effec t s , and so th e boundary
cond i t io n was adequately descr i b ed by the th ir d k i nd of boundary
cond i ti o n . T o alter the surfac e heat transfer coeff ic ient ( h) vary ing
number s (0 to 1 0 ) of 1 . 5 mm th i ck , black " I nsert ion" rubber she ets w ere
placed on e i th er side of the test slab betwe en the p lates shown i n
F i g . 5 .3 . D iffer en t surfac e hea t t r ansf er coef f i c i e nts were obt a i ned
by alter i ng the number of sheets of rubber .
Exper imental Procedur e and Dat a Co l l ect ion 67
ru bber temperature was kept min imal compared w i th that n eeded to heat
the actual s l ab mater i a l in b oth tha w i ng e xper i me nts and runs to
determine h. If the heat ing of the rubber was s i g n i f i c an t , the
est i mated h val ues wou l d be lowe r than tho se ac tua l l y occur r i ng and
wou ld appear to vary w i th t ime . The later trend was no t ap parent for
any of the methods so th i s effect was cons i de r ed negl ig ib l e .
It i s poss i b l e that surface heat transfer coeff i c ients determi ned from
th e separat e ex per i ments are no t r ep r es entat i v e of h dur i ng thaw i ng
runs . However the heat transfer cond i ti ons dur i ng the separate
exper imen ts were s imi l ar to tho se dur i ng each thawi ng run , ex cep t for
the i n i t i a l stages i n the thawi ng runs where th e slab surfac e was st i ll
froz en . The s lab s were ini t ia l l y froz en i n a p l a te freeze r and the
rubber sheets mounted between the p lates and the slab i ts el f had some
f l ex ib i l it y . There fore the cont act between the plates and the s l ab
surface was considered cons tant throughout the thawi ng expe r i menta l
runs . Furthe r , pred i c t ions of surface temp erature by numer i cal methods
wer e as good i n i t i ally as they were later in the exper imental runs .
Th i s conf i rms that these est i mates of h were rep resentat i v e o f the
ac tual values throughout thawi ng . Us i ng a number of separate runs
Ex per i mental Proc edure a nd Data Co l l ec t io n 69
A
B
. .
0.10
0.08
.......
3: 0.06
�
E
u
0
�
..c 0.04
�
0.02
0 2 4 6 8 10
No. of Rubber Sheets
F i g . 5 . 5 Pred i c t ion of Sur face Heat Transfer Coe f f ic ien ts For Slab
Thaw ing Exper imen ts .
Exper i menta l Procedure and Da ta Co l l ec t i on 72
For the thawi ng of th e mi nced lean beef slabs the sur face heat transfer
was assumed to be the same as for the Tyl ose s l ab s . Ther e was no
reason to suspect that h wou ld be d iff eren t beca use mos t of the
r es i stan ce to h eat transf er was suppl i ed by the ru bb er sh ee ts , the same
slab cons truc t ion was used and the we ight ing of th e slabs ensured good
therma l con tac t for both mat er ia ls .
In a true one-d imens ional slab there i s no heat transfer i n the other
two d i mens ions . I n prac t i ce th i s i s i mposs i b l e t o ach i eve . To r educe
heat trans fer in the other two d irections three techn i ques were
emp l oyed :
( a ) the other two d i mens ions were mad e l arger than the slab th icknes s ,
wh i ch i s the cr i t ical d i mension b y a t leas t a f ac tor of 2 . 1 : 1
( b ) each s lab was surrounded on the edges by at l e ast 0 . 09m of
po lystyrene foam i nsu l at ion, and
( c ) the thermo co uples were placed near the centre of each 0 . 2 2m
d iame t er s l ab .
For the wor st case o f a l arge slab b e i ng thawe d slowly the effect of
edge e f f ects due to he at transfe r thr ough the i nsu l at i on ar e shown by
the analy s i s in App . B to decrease thawing t ime b y 4 . 6 % . Th is ana ly s is
took the most pess imi s t i c v ie w of the s i tuat io n . For a mor e t yp ic a l
case th e effect of edge heat transfer o n thawi ng t i mes was l ess than
1 .0%. The s l ow nature of thaw i ng means that edge heat t r ansf er c annot
be avo ided , so when data are interpreted i t must be r emember ed that
some exper i men t s wi th s l abs wer e not tru l y one - d i mens i ona l . I n onl y 6
out of 35 slab ex per i ments was the effec t on thaw i ng t i me s of h eat
t r ansf er through t he e dges , f ound to be mor e than 1 .0 % .
Exper imenta l Pr oc edur e and Dat a Co l l ec t ion 73
thermocouples at th e sur fac e and cen tre wh i l e mak ing the slabs i s
d if f i c ul t and m i gra t io n of the thermoc ou ples w i th in the gel aft e r
const r uc t ion is pos s ib l e . For these reasons more tha n o ne thermocouple
was u se d to me asur e each tempera tur e .
I t was i mposs i b l e for a the rmocoup l e to be ab ove the slab sur face
because of the plate confi gurat ion . Prov ided hea t transfer is
homogen eous acros s the sur face , the fastes t hea t i ng thermocoupl e w i ll
be the best est imate of the sur fac e temperature . A true est imate of
surface temperature wou l d be g i ven b y a th ermocoupl e j u s t touch i n g the
layer of alumi n i um fo i l , so any sl ower heat ing the rmo couple is l i k e ly
to b e below th e surface . Howeve r i n thaw i ng th ere is no de f in i t i ve
cr i t erion to d i s t i ngu ish between d i ffer enc es in temperature due to
i nhomogenei t y and tho se due to the rmocouple placemen t , such as the
su percoo l i ng behav iour observed in fr eez i ng by Cl e land ( 1 9 7 7 ) . Th e
only o th er cri t er io n that can be used is wh ether the surf ace
temp erature prof i les flat ten not icab ly ( plateau ) in the l atent heat
temperature range or no t . Becau se th e sur face i s th e f irst reg i on to
thaw and the temp erature change c an not be slowed by the presenc e of
lat ent heat add i t i on in r eg io ns ou ts i de th e surface, any the rmocouples
r i ght at the sur fac e will tend to "sl ide" through th e l atent heat
temperature r ange rathe r than show the ty p ical p l ateau effec t
char acter ised b y mo r e cen tral pos i t io ns . Unfortunat e ly , th e speed that
th e surface tempe rature pas ses throu gh th i s temperatur e range is
dependent on the ov era l l rate of heat transfer . As amb i ent
t emp eratures c l ose to the thaw i ng t emperatures wer e often u se d i t was
d if f i c ult to f i nd a c lear d is t i nc t ion b etwe en good and bad th ermo couple
pos i t i on i ng . For other amb i en t cond i t i ons some d i f fere nt ia t i on cou l d
be made . F i gure 5 . 6 shows typ i c al tempera ture prof iles f o r d i fferen t
thermocoup les near the sur fac e . Curve A i s typ ic a l of a we ll p l a ced
surfac e thermoco up l e . Its prof i l e i s bar ely a ffected by latent heat
release in the thaw i ng temperature range , but has a p l a teau at a
temper ature between th is and the amb ient temperature . Curve B i s for a
l ess prec i se l y pos i t ioned thermocoupl e . The temperature pro f il e
flattens c ons i derably due t o l atent heat before r i s ing becau se the
thermocoupl e i s be low the surfac e . Curve C i s for the very bad case
wher e the thermocou ple is we l l below the surface and the rate of
t emperature change w i th t i me is slowed marked l y by the absorp t i on of
E xper imental Pr ocedur e and Data Co l lec t io n 75
l atent h eat .
Hea t transfer cond it ions on b oth faces of the slab were as equ i va lent
as poss i b l e so th e geometr i c and thermodynami c c entres shou l d co i nc i de .
Any thermocou ple no t exac t ly at the cen tre w i l l change in temper ature
more qu i ck ly than one at the cen tre . Prov i ded he at transf er is
homogeneous across the slab sur fac e and w i th in the slab , the l as t
thermocoup l e to reach 0 °C w i l l g i v e the best est i mate of the slab
c entre temperatur e and the most accurate est imat e of the thaw i ng t ime .
10
.
.....
. ..
...
u .
. .
0
...__
0 t------:>,__ ___ / .. -- T; ,
-:#----� -
,.__ •
.. ..
.
I /
I !
•
I
=
-10
Legend
I A
I B
c
-20 �--�----r---�--.--.
nme
Fig. 5 . 6 Ty p i c a l T e mp e r a t u r e Pr o f i l e s For Th e r mo co u p l e s Pos i t io n e d A t
Or N e a r t h e Sur f a c e o f a Th a w i n g S l a b . A - at t h e s u r f ac e , B
T
if
= -0 . 6 °C .
3 .
·
.
.
.
•
.
.
.
2 :
1/
..·,
u t2
.
� .
«»
3 ....
.
- tl
0 •
L.. ..
• •
••
«» ..
!
••
0
Legend
-1 A
8
c
. . . . . . ...••
-2 �----r---��--�--.---T---r-
10 10.5 11 11.5 12 12.5 13 13.5
Time (hrs}
Fig . 5 .7 Break point Analy s i s to Es t i ma t e Thaw ing Times From
Thermocoup l es Not Posi t ioned Exac t l y at the Th ermod y namic
Centre . A - a th ermocouple at the thermodynam i c cent r e , B - a
thermocoup l e 0 . 0 05 m from the thermodynami c cent r e , C - a
· thermo c ouple 0 . 0 1 m from the thermodynamic centr e . D • 0 . 1 m,
h - 50 . 0 w m- 2 o c- 1 , T a • 1 3 .0 °C , T i n . - 20 . 0 °C , T i f 2 - 0 . 6 °C ,
t • est i ma ted thaw i ng t i me from A , t 1 • est i mated thaw i ng
t ime from B , t 2 • est i ma ted thaw i ng t i me from C .
E xp er ime ntal Procedure and Da ta Co l l ec t ion 78
centre the bre ak effec t w i l l be magn i f ied . Cl e land ( 1 977 ) showed that
a th ermo coup l e p l aced 1 0% of a spheres rad ius i n error , t he measur ed
freez ing t i me wou ld be 0 . 6 % in error e ven i f the ab ov e analy si s was not
used . Any err or in p l acemen t of th e c en t r e thermoc oupl e was h i gh l y
damp ed i n i t s effec t on fr eez ing t i me , and d id not s i gn i f icantly
i nc r ease the overa l l err or . For s l ab thaw i ng , th e err or for a 1 0%
d isp lac ement was found to i ncr ease as ( T a - T i f ) increased but by us ing
the b reakpoint me thod of analy s i s was only 0 . 1 % for T a = 1 3 °C . The
break point analy si s was therefore used for all shapes inv e s t i gated
where c entre the rmo coup les we re shown to be not acc urate ly plac ed at
the th ermodynamic centre .
An est i mate of the exper i mental er ror ar i s ing from imprec ise control of
experi mental cond i t ions for th e s l ab experi men t s was determin ed from
rep l i c ate thaw ing runs . As far as pos s ible , th e repl icates wer e
i ndep en den t of each oth er inc lud i ng the construc t i on of ne w s l ab s for
each run . After norma l i sa t ion of th e rep l i cates the variab i l i ty showed
that th e e xper imenta l error ar i s i ng fr om poor cont ro l corresponded to
95 % co nfidenc e bounds of ±5 . 2% . The total exper imen tal error wi l l be
h igher than th i s due to unc er tainty in measur ement of the e x per imental
cond i t ions and sour ces o f syst emat i c er ror .
To obta in un i form heat t ransfer cond i t ions at th e sur face for shap es
other than s l ab s a l iqu i d immers ion thaw i ng sys tem was u sed . Liqu i d
immer s ion g ives much less var iat ion of the surface heat transfer
coe f f i c i en t and amb i e nt temperatur e ar ound an obj ec t than th e a ir
thawi ng sy stem wh ich i s also commonly use d . A schema t i c d iagram o f th e
l iqu i d i mmer s i on t ank i s shown in Fig . 5 . 8 .
Thoug h the var i a t ion i n surface h eat trans f er cond i t ions shou l d be
sma l l in the l i qu id system , the test samp les were osc i l lated throughou t
the exp er imen ts to ensure tha t obj ec t or i enta t i on w i th in the flow
stream d id no t af fec t un i formi ty of sur fac e cond it ions . The obj e c t s
were tur ned throu gh an ang le of 300 ° every 30 se cond s . The sa mp l e
osc i l lator i s shown in Figs . 5 . 9 , 5 . 1 0 a n d 5 . 1 2 .
The c y l i nders were pack ed w i th Ty lose and thermo couples int roduc ed at
the c entre and surfac e pos i t ions from e ach end throug h i s othe rmal
reg ions . Two th ermocouples at the c entre and four at the surface were
used for each cyl inde r . To redu ce end he at trans f er e ffec ts ,
poly styren e foam insulat i o n cap s of at least 0 . 05 m th ick ness were pu t
on the end of each cyl i nder and th e c y l inder clamped in th e samp l e
holder for osc il lat i o n a s shown in Fi g s . 5 . 9 , 5.10 and 5. 1 1 . The
thermo coupl e ent r y points and the po lystyrene cap s wer e sea l ed to
prevent l i quid contac t w i th the Ty los e .
r
,.
� �
�
.,
� +
A B
�
� � tI C
/'
, D
,,
,,
E �
,, '•
,,
/
'• F
'• G
.,
'• ' '
Fig. 5 . 8 S c h e ma t i c D i a g r a m o f t h e L i q u i d Imme r s i o n Ta n k .
A p p r o x i ma t e sca l e 1 : 1 5 . A - h e a t i n g e l e me n t s , B - c oo l i n g
A
B
•
F
•
D E
E x pe r i men t s . No t t o s ca l e .
A - p o l y s t y r e n e f o a m cap s , B - t h e r mo c o u p l e l e a d s , c - p i pe
Ind iv idual sur face thermo co uples wou ld be affected by the ir prox im i t y
to the se voids . Henc e the va lue of h es t imat ed f rom sur face
temp erature me asurements would be affec ted and may no t be
r ep r es entat i v e of the t ru e average value . Becau se there was no
c r i terion to chos e wh ich thermocou ple mo s t c los ely resemb led the
av erage sur fac e cond i t ions th e me thods based on sur face temperature
cou ld not be rel i e d on to g i v e good e s t i mates of h .
A me thod that cons i dered th e c entre temperature was the re fore u sed . By
usi ng t h e cen tre temperature the effect of a ny var i a t io n in heat
transfer c ond i t ions at th e sur fac e was e f fec t i ve l y averaged and the h
value was more representat i ve o f the true valu e . Loca l i sed variat ion
in h is no t i mport ant i f i t i s re lat i ve l y smal l in magn i tude and i s
randomly d is tr i b uted ove r the surface. Th is was probably the case w i th
the sur face voids and i mper fe c t cont ac t .
The me thod use d t o est i ma t e the surface heat t ransfer coef f ic ient was
the h ea t p ene t ra t ion method ( Ar c e & Swea t 1 980 ) . For l ong t i mes the
analy t ical solution for heat transfer w i th cons tant the rmal propert ies
and the th ird k ind of b ounda ry cond i t ion ( Ca rslaw & Jaeg er 1 9 59 ) is
close ly ap prox imated by tak ing only the first term in the ser ies
so lu t ion . The sur fac e he a t t rans f er coeff ic i en t c an b e c a lculate d f rom
the slope of a plot of ln Ye versu s t i me ( Charm 1 9 6 3 , Bak er & Cha rm
1 9 6 9 , Kopelman e t a l 1 9 7 0 ) . An advan tage of th is me thod i s that i t is
i ndependent o f the exac t pos i t i on of th e thermoc oup l e wi th i n the
cyl inder . I f th e c entre th ermocou ple i s not p rec i s ely loc ated on the
c en tral ax i s , th i s does no t a f f ec t the est ima t i on o f h b y th i s metho d .
The rubb er shee t s gave a cons t an t add i t iona l res istan ce to heat
transfer over the whole cyl i nder sur face excep t for the j o i n t n ec essa ry
down th e leng th of the cyl inder . The rubb er was cut ac curate l y so that
th i s jo int was alway s less than 0 . 5 mm in w idth . For the sma l le s t
cyl i nder th is af fected 0 .3% of the sur face ar ea , wh i ch is
ins ign if icant . Wher e mu lt iple layer s of rubber were glued on , the
j o ints were no t over l apped so the change in sur fac e cond i t ions cau sed
by the jo ints wer e not compounded at one se ct ion of th e cyl inder
sur fac e . Th e contact adhes i ve used gave extreme l y good cont ac t b e tween
rubber layers and the p i pe walls w i th no a ir spaces so heat transfer
thr oug h the rubber l ayer s was uni form .
Thaw ing ex per i ments were carr i e d ou t wi th the amb ient me d ium
t emperatur e in the range : 5 . 0 °C to 4 5 . 0 °C . Al though the l iq u id
ve loc i t y ar ound the tank wa s constan t , some var i a t i on of the transport
proper t i e s of water and ther e fore the f i lm h eat transfer coeff ic ient
may occur wi th temperatur e . I n the tempera tur e range us e d th e changes
in l i qu i d propert i e s were small , and the b ulk of th e res i s tanc e to hea t
t r ansfer was i n th e p i pe wa ll and sheets o f rubb er anyw ay . Hen ce there
was no stat i s t i c al l y s i gn i f ic ant correlat ion of h w i th amb ient
temp erature .
Some o f the prob lems enc oun te red i n cy l inder expe r i ments we re s i m ilar
to those found for slab s . The leng th s of the test cyl inders were
a l way s great er than the d iame t er b y a fac tor of at l east thr ee , and
insula t i ng caps were used to m i n i mi s e the effect of heat transfer along
the leng th of the cy l inders . Us i ng a s i mi l ar ana ly s i s to that for
slabs ( Sec . 5 . 4 . 4 and App . B ) the end-e ffe c t heat transfer was found to
b e neg l ig i b l y small ( 0 . 2% decrease in thaw i ng t i me ) for the worst
si tuat ion use d in thawing runs . The test cyl inders th erefore
appr ox i ma t ed inf in i te cyl inder s very close l y .
Apart from the prob lems at the sur fac e , air voids that oc curred in the
mater ia l were no la rge r or more common than th ose found for slab s , so
the ir e ffec t wou ld not be ex pec ted to be any mo r e s ign i f ican t than the
effec t of the in ternal vo ids for slab s . Th i s was d i scussed in
Se c . 5 . 4 . 4 . Vo ids a t the surfa c e of th e cy l i nder s and imperfect
contac t predom inan t ly a f f ec ted the sur face h eat transfer a nd were
accounted for by the me thod d i sc ussed in Se c . 5 . 5 . 3 . A consequenc e was
that the geome t r i c and thermo dynami c c en t r e of the cy l inder may not
have co inc ided. As surface voidage was ev enly d is t r i b uted across the
cyl inder sur fac e s , averag i ng e f fects mean tha t th e c entral ax i s of the
cyl inders shou ld coinc ide closely w i th th e thermodynami c c en tre . It
w i l l b e shown below that e v en i f the thermodynamic c en t r e was m i sp laced
s l i ghtly , the thaw i ng t i me i s only min ima lly a lt ered .
prec is ion of thawi ng t i me pred ict ions whe r e centre thermoco uples were
poor l y pos i t ioned . For reasons d i scus sed in Sec . 5 . 5 . 3 the fastes t
chang ing ind i v idua l surface temperature measurement d id not n ec es sar i l y
r ep r es en t the ave r age h ea t transfer cond i t ions , and slower changes
could be due to placement below the sur fac e as well as lower h values
i n par t i c u l ar reg ions . Hen ce app l i cat ions of th e techn i q ues of
Se c . 5 . 5 . 3 p robab ly l e d to ex per i menta l ly measured surface t emperatures
nearer to the amb ien t temperature than th ose r epresen t i ng th e av erage
heat transfer cond i tions . Pr edic ted surface temperatures usi ng the
average h va lue would therefore be expec ted to l i e further fr om the
amb ient me d ium t emp erature than the me asured data.
5 .6 THAW I NG O F SPHERES
Imme r s io n Ta nk .
Exper imental Pr ocedur e and Dat a Collec t io n 89
The cons t ruc t ion of th e spheres in two ha lves , the f l ex ibi l it y of the
ho llow me tal she lls use d and the d i stor t ion in shap es due to water
i ngress and the co nsequ e nt densi ty chang e , mea nt that the spheres were
not cons tant in d iame t er . Some variat ion in d iameter occurred w i th
bo th p os i t ion ar ound the spher e and whe ther the spheres wer e in th e
frozen or un frozen sta t e . Measured v a r i a t i o ns in d iame ter ab ou t the
mean value were ± 1 . 0 mm ( 1 . 8 % ) for the sma llest sphere , ±3 . 0 mm (2 .7%)
for the me d ium s i z ed sphere and ± 2 . 0 mm ( 1 . 6 % ) for th e large sphere.
Th e sphe re vo lume was measur ed by d i splac eme nt of l iqu i d and conf i rmed
that the average values were accurate .
The same prob lems w i th therma l contac t and voids tha t were observed
wi th inf i n i t e cyl inder s ( Sec . 5 . 5 . 3 ) occur r ed for spheres. In
add it ion , exac t cont rol of the rubber c oa t i ng th ickness was not
poss i b l e and irregu l ar i t i es in the met a l j o in t bet ween th e s phere
halves a ffec ted heat t ransfer . Therefore some var i a t i o n i n the surface
heat t r an sfe r coeff ic i en t ove r th e sur f ace was exp ected . Es t imates of
h based on sur fac e t emperature me asureme n t a nd t h e methods for r a d i a l
geomet ry o f Cleland & Earle ( 1 97 9 a ) d id no t p rov i d e con s i s tent and
r e l iab l e r esult s . For these reasons , the heat penetrat ion method
( Charm 1 9 63 ) was u sed to me asure h us i ng the c en t r e temperature
pro f i l e s fr om independent heat i ng and c ool i ng exp e r i ments tha t involved
E xper i mental Procedur e and Data Co l l ec t i on 90
As se s smen t of sur face and c entre th ermo c oupl e plac eme nts and est i ma t i on
of thaw ing t i me from exper i men tal runs was ma de in th e same way as that
u s ed for inf ini t e cyl inder s ( Sec . 5 . 5 . 4 ) . The coa t i ng of rubbe r u sed
on the spheres was far less than that used for i n f i n i te cyl inder s , so
th e ef fec t of th e heat t aken up by the rubbe r and me t a l she l l s on the
over all hea t trans fer was ins ign i f ican t . The volume of water that was
abl e to pene tra t e each sphere ar ound th e th ermo c ouple leads was
ex tr eme ly sma l l and only affec ted the Ty lose in the imme d iate v ic in i ty
o f th e l eak . The maj or result was some loca l i sed expans ion when the
Ty lose was fr oz en . Th is affec ted the d imens ions and phy s i c al i n teg r i t y
of the j o i nt s . An avera ge d iame t er valu e for th e s phe res based o n b oth
froz en and un fr ozen s t ates was use d . Sph eres in wh ich th e j o i n ts
b ecame v i s ib l y damaged wer e remade be fore fur ther u se .
Ov era l l , ex per i men tal er ror for spheres was o f a s imi lar ma gn i tu de to
that for thaw i ng o f inf ini te cyl inder s .
Thermoc ouples were pos i t ioned a t the geome t r i c c entre o f each brick and
at four to s i x d i f feren t p l ac es on the sur fac e . Whe re po s s ib l e ,
surface th ermo cou ples were pos i t ioned a t the c en tre of th e b r ick faces .
The metal a nd po lypr opylene b r i ck s gave two d i f fer ent surface heat
transfer coeff ic ient values . To further alter the sur fac e heat
transfer coe f f ic i en t , rubb er shee t s were g lu ed to e ach fac e of the
rectangular b r i c k s in a s i mi la r manner to that use d for i n f in it e
cyl inder s . On e l ay er o f rubbe r was p u t on th e metal boxes and two
lay ers on the poly propylene box es . I n th is way fou r d i fferen t v alues
of h were obt a ined for the rect angul ar b r i ck geometry .
The analy t ical p roduc t solu t i o n for he at conduc t ion i n three d ime ns io ns
wi th the th ird k ind of boundary cond i t i on and constant therma l
prope r t i e s ( Newrnan 1 9 36 ) was th e se cond me thod use d . A s i mi lar
comp ut er p rogram to that us e d to es t i ma t e h from sur face temperature
pro f i les for radial geome t ry ( C l e la nd & Earle 1 9 7 9 a ) was u se d . The
pr ogram took v a l ues of t i me , sur fac e tempera tur e and p o s i t iona l
coord inates for the pos i t i o n of th e th ermoco uple where th e me asurements
were mad e , and u s ed an i tera t i v e loop t o pred i c t th e sur fac e heat
transfer coeffic ient needed to a t tain tha t temperature , at th at t i me ,
and i n that pos i t i on .
Both method s are o nly appl i cable for t imes b e fore the onse t of phase
change . As th i s t i me i s v er y shor t for thaw i ng expe r i men t s , separate
hea t i ng and cool i ng runs were c ar r i e d ou t w i th each rectangular bri ck
i n the unfroz en s t at e . There was no s i gn i f i can t var ia t ion i n es t i mated
h values betwe en bricks of the same wal l ma ter i a ls , betwe en analy se s
us i ng d i f fe rent thermo c ouples i n each b r i ck , or as amb i ent med ium
E xpe r i me ntal Pr ocedure and Da t a Co llect ion 94
Er ror s due to incons is tenc ies in heat transfer on each of the surfaces
of each rec tangular b r i ck wer e ma de n egl i g i b l e by us i ng th e l iqu i d
immer s ion tank , osc i l lat i ng the samples , and us ing th e rubber sheets to
a l te r th e sur f ace hea t transf er res ist anc e . The mean pred ic ted h va l ue
for poly propylene boxes had 9 5% conf idenc e bounds o f ± 1 . 5 % ( no ru bber )
and ±2 . 1 % ( wi th two she ets of rub ber ) . For the me tal boxes th e resul t s
wer e l ess acc urate th an those for th e po lypropylene box es becau se the
sur fac e heat tr ans fer coeff ic ients were larger and cons equen tly th e
t i me for each heat ing or cool i ng expe r i men t was sh ort er than for the
poly propy lene b r i ck s . The values of h were th erefore based on less
data . The 95% co nf idenc e bounds for th e mean values of ±7 . 5 % ( no
rubber ) and ±4 . 4% ( w i th one rubber she et ) for th e me tal b rick s , reflect
th i s t r end .
As for the slab ex per i ment s , th e h values for runs w i th minc ed lean
beef wer e assumed to be th e same as tho se measur ed for the Ty l ose
brick s . M i nc e lean beef undergoes s i g n i f icant dens i ty changes dur i ng
phase change and has a f ibrous mo i s t n a ture comp ared wi th th e dry
gel-l i k e nature of Ty los e . Th erefore a ir v o i d s w i th in the minced lean
b ee f were less l ike l y and i t was poss i b l e that the contac t r e s i s tanc e
was d i f fe r en t for the two mater ials . Henc e the assump t i o n o f equal h
v a lues may introduc e some extra uncer ta in ty for the m in ce l ean beef
exp e r i me n ts .
Pr ob lems had been found wi th imper fec t ther ma l conta c t for inf in i t e
cyl i nders and spheres . Si mi lar behav iour was no t ob se rv e d f o r th e
r ect angul ar br i cks . Therefore sur fac e tempe ratures and surface h eat
transfer could be analy sed in a si mi lar manner to that u sed for slab s
wi th out add i t ional er ror .
As was the c ase for spheres , th e volume of the rubber coa t i ng and box
wal l mat er ial for the r ectangular br i ck s was suff ic ien t ly smal l
compared w i th the volume o f the Ty lose b r i c k i tse l f t o mak e the effect
o f the heat ab sorbed by the rubber and wal l ma t er ia l un impor tant .
b
F i g . 5 . 1 3 Ty p ic a l R ectangular Br i ck Sh apes .
( a ) poly propylene box
( b ) meta l b ox wi th on e l ay er of rubbe r
( c) poly p rop y l e n e box on the sa mp l e osc i l lator ( p . 9 7 ) .
Exp er imen ta l Pr ocedur e and Data C o l l ec t i o n 97
-
-
c d
S c ale A [cm]
0 1 2
S c ale B [cm]
1 2
Scale [cm]
4
* - n od e s , * * - n od e s c o r r e s p o nd i n g t o t h e rmo c o up l e s
Scale [cm]
2
Fig. 5 . 1 8 C r o s s - s e c t i on and F i n i t e E l e me n t M e th od G r i d F o r t h e
T w o - D i me n s i o na l I r r eg u l a r Sh a p e N u mb e r Fo u r .
* - n od e s , ** - n o d e s c o r r e s p o nd i ng to t he r mo c o u p l e s
p os i t i o n s , - e l e me n t b ou n d a r i e s .
S c ale [cm]
S c ale [cm]
-'--
'----- -L
c D E
The l i qu id imme r s i o n t ank was use d . Bec ause b o th fr eez ing and thawi ng
expe r i men t s were ca rr i ed ou t , th e tank cont a ined 29% calc ium ch l or i de
b r i ne . Ac c urate temperature control across th e tempe rature range - 4 0 °C
t o 5 0 °C was ach ieved. The test samp les wer e osc i l lated to m i n i mi s e
l oca l v ar i a t ions o f the sur fac e he a t trans f er coe ff ic i e nt .
The charac ter i s t i c th ick ness for th e i r regu lar shap es is def ined as
e i th er the minimum th i cknes s measur ed throu gh the the rmodynam i c centre
or double th e minimum d is tanc e from the the rmo d ynami c c en tre to th e
sur fac e . For al l th e shapes i t was found tha t on l y one th ermo dynamic
centre ex i s t e d , because the surface cond it ions were u n i form a n d th e
geome t r i e s u sed were re l a t i ve l y uni form in sh ape . Th e cha rac t er i st i c
th icknesses determined fr om each def in i t ion were equa l . The pos i t i o n
o f th e the rmod y nami c c en tre w a s found by ana ly s i s us i ng the f in i te
e lement me thod (Se c . 4 . 2 ) for typ ical phase c hange cond i t i o ns .
For the i r r egul ar shapes s tud i e d there wer e no sat i sfactory me thods to
est ima t e th e sur fa c e heat transfer coeff ic ient d ir ec t ly from
exper i men ts for each shape . The two-d i mens iona l irregu l ar shapes were
r emou lded from PVC c y l inders for wh ich surfac e he at transfer
Experimental Pr oc edure and Dat a Co llection 1 05
To alter the surface heat transfer coeff ic ient two lay er s of sheet
rubber were g lued onto the sur fac e of a ll the irregul ar l y shap ed
obj e cts der i v ed fr om the 0. 1 m PVC p ipes . The chang e in exposed
sur fac e a r ea as mor e packa g i ng mate r i a l is add ed is sl i gh t l y d i f f er e nt
for a c y l inder and an i rregular shap e , so very small d i f ferenc es in h
values are poss i b l e , but these were w i th in the toleran ce o f the
measureme n t system. The e ffec t of the rubber and the abov e prob lems
Expe r i mental Procedure and Data Col l ect ion 106
The sur face heat trans fer coe f f ic ient for the minc ed l e an bee f
expe r i men t s was assu med to be the same as that de termine d for the
Tylose exp e r i me n ts w i th th e same shap e . As d iscu ssed in Sec . 4 . 8 . 3 for
rectangula r b r i cks , th i s poten t ia l ly l ead s to in creased ex pe r imenta l
uncer ta inty for the minced lean beef experiments b ecause th is
assu mp t ion abou t h may no t b e va l i d .
Experiments for i r r e gular shapes are subj ec t to the same e rror to thos e
for regu l ar shapes . Vo ids in the Ty lo se and inhomogenei t y cau sed by
thermoc oup l e wires had s i mi lar e ffects to those found in the i n f in i t e
cyl inder expe r i men t s , and wer e s i mi lar ly ins ignif ic ant .
Error i n the rmocou ple placemen t was not a major sourc e of unc er tainty
due to th e way the le ads were po si t ion ed and he l d in p l ace .
D i smantl i ng of th e obj e c t s showed that the thermo couple j unc t i o ns
rema ined wi th i n a 2 mm rad ius of th e recorded pos i t io n ov er a numb er of
runs . However , the me thod used to i nse rt th e thermocouples d id l e ad to
error s du e to heat conduc t ion a lo ng the w i res as they were not
i nt roduc ed along isoth ermal p aths . Ty pically , four th ermo co uples were
used to measure in terna l t emperatures for each obj ec t . On l y o ne of
these was located in close prox imity to th e thermodynamic c en tr e .
Conduc t ion along e ach thermocoupl e wou l d b e l es s than th e 0 . 8% o f the
total heat flow calc ulated for the centre thermocouple i n the sma llest
Exper imental Pr ocedure and Da ta Co llect ion 1 07
sphere u se d for thaw i ng ( Sec . 5 . 6 . 4 ) . The vo lume and sur fac e ar ea for
these two -d ime ns ional i r re gular shap es wer e l a rger that tho s e for the
sma l l es t spher e . Though up to four thermocoup l e w i res conducted heat
towar ds the cen tre , because all but one of th ese were pos i t ioned well
away from th e thermod ynamic c entre and t he ob j ec t vo lu me and sur f ace
ar eas were larg e , the e ffec t of heat co nduc t ion a long th e the rmo couple
w i res was cons idered ins i gn i f ican t . On ly 0 . 0 2 % to 0 . 0 3% of th e sur fac e
ar ea w i th in the c en tra l 1 00 mm l eng th of the p ipes was a ffected by th e
introduc t ion of th e th ermo c ouple w i r e throug ht the wa l l s . Th i s is
insign i f icantly sma l l .
Hea t transfer a long the l eng th of the ir regularly shap ed obj ec ts will
be of th e same ord er of magni tud e as that for th e equ i va l ent
cyl indr i c a l shapes due to th e insu lat ing cap s , th e h igh rat io of leng th
to th i ck n ess u sed a nd th e cen t ral pos i t io n used for temperature
mea surement . In Sec . 5 . 5 . 4 th is was shown to b e ins ign if ican t .
For i r r e gular shap es the pos i t ion of the the rmodynamic c en tre is not
k nown , and in f ac t it may mov e dur i ng a ny fr eez ing or tha w i ng run
( Fl eming 1 9 7 0 ) . For th is r e ason , th e pos i t ion of one the rmo couple was
located as c lo se as poss i b l e to th e pred i c t e d thermody nami c c entre of
the obj e c t s , as de t ermined by a f in i te e lement analy s i s ( Se c . 4 . 2 ) for
typ ic a l ex per i men ta l cond i t ions . Th i s may no t be the ex ac t
thermo dy namic c en tre so when the temperature p r of i les were analy se d ,
the b r e akpo in t ana lys i s d i scuss e d i n Sec . 5 . 4 . 4 was u se d t o increa se
the prec is io n o f th e exper ime n ta l ly determined thawing t i me where
n ec essary . Th i s ana lys i s i s as app l i cabl e to irregu la r shape s as it i s
to regular shapes . When c o ns ider i ng loc a t ions o f oth er the rmo co uples
Exper i ment a l Procedure and Da ta Col l ec t io n 1 08
i t was no t i mpor t an t where th ey were pos i t ioned as long as the pos i t ion
was acc urat e l y k nown . A r ange of a l terna t i v e posi t ions we r e u sed to
prov ide a numb er of ty p ical t emperature profi les f r om th rou ghout each
ob j ec t .
For the two-d ime ns ional i r r e gular shape exper iments an iden ti c al
p rocedure to that u sed for thaw i ng o f regu l ar in f ini te cyl inder s was
adopted . Al thou gh the unc erta inty in measured sur fac e heat t ransfer
coe ff ic ients was lowe r than for th e inf in i te cyl inder th aw i ng
exper ime nt s , the inab i l i ty to control h to th e same value for all the
sh ap es introduced ex t r a unc er ta inty . The re i s a lso an add it iona l er ror
in measur ing and control l i ng the geometry so the ov e ra l l ex per i mental
error was es t i mated to b e of sl ight l y gre a t er magn i tude than tha t for
i n f i n i t e cyl inder thaw ing .
On ly thr e e d i fferent thr ee - d i mens ional obj e c t s were inv e s t igated due to
l i mi t a t ions in t i me a nd r es ourc e s . Each was rela t i v e l y un i form in
shap e , though i r regular compar ed w i th slab s , inf in i te c y l i nder s ,
spheres , inf ini t e rods or r ect angular br i ck s .
frustum of the square pyramid were uni form or flat s ided and cou ld be
accurate ly measur ed . Th e f i sh shape was natura l l y der i v ed and
irregular i n a l l r espects excep t for a leng thw i se plane of symme try
betwe en the two ha lves . To acc urate ly mode l i t , th e plaster ca st was
cu t and the c ross-s ec t i ons at th ir t een evenly d i s tr i b uted po i n ts a long
th e l eng th of th e ob j e c t mappe d . The sh ape of the f i sh sur f a ce was
then i n t erpolated between these c ros s-se c t i o ns . I t was found that each
of th e cross - sec t ions was c lo s l y appr ox i mated if a fur ther v er t i c a l
ax is of sy mme try was assume d . Hence only on e qua rter of the f i sh wa s
mode l le d . U s i ng these methods and be cau se the plas t i c mou l d c l ose l y
resemb le d t h e o r i g inal casts the error in de termin ing the sur face shap e
and c r i t i c al d imens ions was cons idered to b e ±2 mm a t any point for
both the f i sh and th e egg , ± 1 . 0 mm for the spheres and ±0 . 5 mm for the
py rami d .
The charac ter i s t i c th ick nes s was de termined from the grids shown in
Fig . 5 . 2 4 to 5 . 27 onc e th e the rmodynam i c c entre was p i npo in t ed by
f i n i t e e lement analy si s for typ ical phase change cond i ti ons . The
measuremen ts taken of f th e cas t s wer e conf irme d by some measurements on
the ac tual test obj e c t s . There was n o obse rv ab l e d i fferenc e in s iz e or
shape as the obj ec ts c hanged from th e fr oz en to th e un fr ozen s t a tes .
Sou rces of error for th e three-d i mens ional i r r egular shap es were
simi l ar to th ose for o th er sh apes . Pr ob lems wi th vo ids , inhomogene i t y
d u e to thermo co uple w i r es , heat conduct ion along thermo coup l e w i r es and
error s in p lac emen t of thermocoup l es wer e s i mi l ar to those for
two - d imens ional irregular shapes and were cons equen t ly c ons idered
n eg l i g ib l e . Becau se a the rmocoupl e c ou l d no t neces sari l y be lo cated
exac tly a t th e thermo dynamic c en tre ( but usu a l ly c lose by) , th e
b r eakpo in t ana ly s i s was u sed to accurate l y de t e rm in e ex p er i menta l
freez ing a nd thaw i ng t i mes .
E xpe r i me n tal Pr oc edure and Dat a Co llect ion 112
The three-d i mensiona l sh apes mean t tha t end he at transfer e f fec ts were
no t a prob lem. On ly the pyramid shap e was a ffected by the prese nc e o f
a bo l t inser t e d through the wa l l . As was th e ca se for rectangu l ar
brick thaw i ng , the p resenc e o f th is bolt was found to be ins ign i f ican t .
D i srup t ions due to th e modu l ar nature o f the p l as t i c mou lds a f f ec t ed
hea t trans f e r . The flange reta ined on each hal f of th e plas t i c mou lds
a l lowe d a s trong j o i n to be ma de a nd i t a lso a l lowe d th e att achme nt to
the sample osc i l la tor w i thou t fur ther d isrup tion to the obj e c t sur fac e .
The f la nge for the plas t i c mou l ded shapes ran in a l e ng thw i se
c ircumferenc e around each shap e . It therefore af fec ted part o f th e
sur fa ce area but the reg ions on th e sur face c l oses t to the
thermod ynam ic cen tre were only s l i g htly a f fec ted . The e f fec t of the
flange on the sur fac e h eat transfe r was cons idered unavoi dabl e . As has
bee n ind ica t e d , a lower d e gree of ac c uracy in th ese expe r i me n ts was
acc ep ted .
Imperfect co ntac t was a s i mi lar p rob lem for th e pla s t ic mou lded shapes
to that wh ich occ ur r ed for inf ini t e cyl inder s , spheres a nd the
two-d ime ns iona l ly ir regular shapes . As b e for e , it was cons i dered that
the e f fect was equa l ly fr equ en t for a l l sh apes a nd rand om l y d i s tr i bu ted
ov er th e surface so that th e ef fec t on surface or ov erall h eat transfer
was not sign i f i cant and cou l d b e acc urate l y ac coun t e d for by an a v erage
sur fac e heat transfer coeff ic ien t . Fi n i te e lement pred i c t i o ns for the
p las t i c shapes ( Sec . 8 . 4 ) tend to show tha t surface he at trans f er
cond i t io ns were no t un i form and that alter nat i v e me ans to con trol and
measur e h wou l d be need ed i f ex peri men ts wi th l e ss unc erta in t y were
con s i d ered esse n t i a l . In sp i t e of these problems , the shape o f the
temperature p rof i l e for a th ermocoup l e s i tuated near the thermo dyna mic
centre ( pred ic ted by f i n i te eleme n t analy s i s assuming un i form surface
h ea t t r ansfe r cond i t ions ) , sugges ted tha t th e non-un i formi t i es at the
sur fac e had not mov e d the th ermo dynamic centre much , and that thaw ing
t i me s cou l d be de term i ned from th i s th ermocoupl e by the br eakpo in t
analy s i s .
For three-d ime ns ional i r regu lar shap es the unc er taJnty assoc iated w i th
contro l l i ng the sur fac e hea t transfer cond i t ions by u se o f the plast i c
mou ld ing could not b e assessed . However the error i n me asur i ng h was
large and ther e are furth er s ign i f icant error s in measur i ng and
E xp e r imen tal Pr ocedure and Dat a Co l lec t io n 113
S c ale [ c m ]
1.__
--L.
_ _J_
_ t_____j
0 1 2
Fig . 5 . 25 The Sphere Three-d imens ional Irr eg ular Shap e Fi n i t e El eme n t
Me thod Gr ids .
( a ) and ( b ) the one- and two - d ime ns ional g r i d s ( p . 1 1 5 )
( c ) the thr ee - d i mens iona l gr i d . On l y a n oct ant i s mode l l ed .
Th e x , z and y , z faces are planes o f symmetry . Scale for the
thr ee-d imens iona l gr i d is 1 d iv is ion - 0 . 00635 m .
( 1 ) only the boundary surfaces are shown.
( 1 1 ) an exploded v i ew o f the ful l spher e gr i d ; each o f the
thr e e she l ls o f e lements are shown.
Exper imental Proc edure and Da ta Co l lect ion 1 17
2 4
b
F i g . 5 . 28 The Sa mp le Osc i l lator and Three- Di mens iona l Irregu lar Sh ap es
Use d i n the Liquid Imme r s i o n Tank .
( a ) pyrami d
( b ) sphere
( c ) egg ( p. 1 20 )
( d ) f i sh ( p . 1 20 ) .
Exper imental Pr ocedure and Dat a Co l lec tion 1 20
• •
d •
F i g . 5 . 28 The Sample Osc i l lator and Three-Di mens ional Irr egular Sh apes
Used in the Liquid Immers ion Tank .
( a ) pyramid ( p . 1 19 )
( b ) sphere ( p . 1 19)
( c ) egg
( d ) f i sh
121
Pham ( 1 983 ) used d imen s i onal analys i s to show that the six factors
other than shap e can be related by seven d imens ion l ess group s t o the
freez i ng or thaw ing t i me . These are the Four i er numb er , the B i ot
numb er , the Stefan number , the Plank number and three other
d imens ion l ess numbers . The Four i er numb er :
(6 . 1 )
t akes account of the obj e c t s i ze , the phase change t ime and the thermal
proper t i es of the mater ial in the state i t wi l l be i n after the phase
change p rocess has occurred . The Biot number :
hD hD
B i - - for fr eez i ng , B i for thawi ng
- -
(6 . 2 )
ks kl
i s the rat i o of i nt ernal t o external resi stances to heat transfer . The
Stefan number :
(6 . 3 )
Exper i menta l Des ign and Resul t s 1 22
accounts for the amb ient med i um temperature and re lates the heat
transfer after the phase change process to that due to latent heat
release or absor p t i o n i t se l f . The Plank number ( Cl e land & Earl e
1 976b ) :
C l ( T i n- T i f ) Cs ( T i f- Ti n )
Pk = for freez i ng , Pk for tha w i ng (6.4)
=
�H �
t ak es account o f the in i t ial superheat i ng or subcoo l i ng and relates i t
to the lat ent heat . F i na l ly , three other numb ers wh i ch take account o f
the f i nal the thermodynamic centre , T f i n • the i n i t ia l
temperature at
freez i ng temperature and o ther therma l propert i es of the food are :
C s ( T i f - Tf i n ) C l ( Tf i n - T i f )
N1 = for freez ing , N 1 = for thawi ng ( 6 .5 )
� �
cl kl
N2 = -- and N 3 = -- ( 6 . 6 ) and ( 6 . 7 )
cs ks
I n s i tua t ions where i t i s assumed that all l at ent heat i s released at a
un i que phase change temperature the entha l py change i n the phase change
temperature reg ion , �H . is defined as the latent heat of free z i ng or
thaw i ng , whe reas the entha lpy change between 0 °C and - 1 0 °C is used i n
all other cases . Th is def i n i t ion ensures that � inc ludes the maj or
phase change effect yet i s s imi l ar l y de f i ned and equa l l y re l ev an t for
both fr e e z i ng and thaw i ng analyses . For freez ing , the very s i m i l ar
defi n i t i o n of � as the entha lpy change from T i f t o - 1 0 °C has been used
( Cl e land 1 9 7 7 ) . Th i s def i n i t ion l eads to � values only 1 . 0 % d i f f erent
from � from 0 °C to - 1 0 °C and is therefore treated as be ing equ ivalent
i n th i s s t udy . Th i s def ini t ion is a lso commensura te wi th an
a l terna t i ve used by Hung & Thompson ( 1 9 83 ) where � was tak en as the
entha l py change from T in to T fin ·
were not cons i dered of maj or prac t i cal import anc e . Some runs w i th a
food mat e r i a l , minced l ean beef , were per formed to see if any
not i c eab l e effec t due to N2 or N3 could be observed . A study
encompass ing a range of mater ials ( C lel and & Ear l e 1 98 4 a ) showed l i t t l e
dev iat ion b etween pre d i c t ions for the d if ferent food mater i a ls used ,
con f i rm i ng th i s reason i ng .
Orthogonal exper imental des i gns i n t erms of Bi , Ste and Pk wer e not
f eas i b l e b ecause of phy s ical l imi t at ions in contro l l i ng the f our
var iables , espec ially h and D , to p re-selected values . The obj e c t s i ze
and the surface heat transfer coeff ic i en t s wer e , in mo s t cases ,
determi ned more by con s i derat i ons such as the ava i l ab il i ty of the
appropr i at e types of conta i ner and the i r wal l mater ial , than by cho i ce
to give a spec i f i ed Biot numb er . var i at ion in Bi was there fore
E xp er i men ta l Des ign and R esults 1 24
A t each level o f Biot numb er Ta and T in ' and hence Ste and P k , wer e
a l so var ied to cover as w i de a range and comb inat ions of cond i t ions as
poss i b l e . The bas i s for the experimenta l des i gn in these cases wer e
e i ther part or ful lfactor ial des igns wi th two or three l evels of T a
and T i n ' I t was dec ided not to at temp t t o control these two var i ab l es
exac t ly to the pre - se l ec ted l ev e ls ; p rov ided a va lue c lose to the
pre- se l ec ted level was ob tained, i t was cons idered sa t i sfac tory .
The resu l t s of the f u l l set of 3 5 slab thawi ng exper iments i nc lud ing
r ep l i cates to est i mate the exper imental error are shown in Tab l e 6 . 2 .
Typ i cal thaw i ng t emperature / t ime p ro f i l es are shown i n Fi g . 6 . 1 . The
rep l i cates were p er formed as independent ly from each o ther as pos s ible
to g iv e a true i nd icat i on of var iab il i ty due to experimental
t echn i qu es . The only var i able that could not be measured independent l y
from the other slab exper iments was the sur face heat transf er
coef f ic i en t . Any add i t ional uncerta inty i ntroduced by errors in
Exper imental Des i gn and Results 125
measurement , and due t o systema t i c error , cou l d not b e quan t i f ied from
the s pread of r ep l i cates .
For i n f i n i t e cyl inders the range of Biot numb ers that cou ld be
cons i dered was phy s i ca l ly l i mi ted by the cyl inder d i ameter s and p i pe
wal l mat er i a ls and th i ck nesses used . By use of both meta l and P VC
wal led cyl i nders and the add i t ion of rubber insulat ion a range of h
from 1 9 . 0 W m- 2 oc - 1 to 1 1 3 . 0 W m -2 oc - 1 was obtained in the l i qu id
i mmers ion system . In comb inat ion wi th d i fferent cyl inder d iameters
th i s gave s i x app rox imate l evels in B i from 1 .8 to 26 . 0 . At each l ev e l
a s im i lar des i gn t o that used for s l abs was s e t up to cover a w i de
range of amb i ent and i n i t i a l t emperature cond i t ions .
The 3 4 exper i menta l resu l t s for thawi ng inf i n i t e cyl i nders of Tyl ose
are g iven in Tab l es 6.3, and a typical thaw i ng curve is shown in
Fig. 6 . 2 .
and S2, can b e i ntroduced . The exper iments were des igned to cover a l l
the f i ve fac tors ( B i , Ste , P k , S1 and S 2) as w i de ly as was pract i cab l e .
were var i ed from 1 to 4 , th i s range cover i ng p rac t i cal appl icat ions .
The results for the 68 thaw i ng exper iments conduc ted are shown i n Tabl e
6 .5. A typ i ca l thawing c urve i s shown i n Fig . 6 . 4 . Four tha w i ng runs
wer e made w i th two d i fferent rec tangular b r i ck shapes u s i ng mi nced l ean
b ee f . These r esul ts is g i ven in Tabl e 6 .8 and a typ i ca l
temperature/t ime p ro f i l es i s shown in Fig . 6 . 1 8 .
E ight d i f f er ent t wo - d imens ional obj ects were used ; f our were
constructed by d i stort i o n of a 0 . 1 m d i ame ter PVC p i pe , and four from a
0 . 1 5 m d iame ter PVC p i pe . S i x of the obj ec ts were irregular i n shap e ,
wh i l e two were c y l i nd r i c a l ( one for each pipe s i ze ) . Figs. 5 . 1 5 to
5 . 2 1 show the cross- sect ional geome tr i es for these obj ec ts . For e ach
shape at l east four freez i ng and four thaw i ng runs were conducted .
For freez i ng three l eve l s o f the Ste fan number ( correspond i ng to values
o f Ta of abou t - 20 °C , - 28 °C and -35 °C ) and four l e vels o f the Plank
number ( correspon d ing t o T i n values o f abou t 4 °C , 1 0 °C , 20 °C a n d 30 °C )
were use d . A compl e t e fac tor i a l des i gn was not poss i b l e . The
comb inat ions of Ste and Pk used for i nd iv i dual exper i ments wer e chosen
Exper imental Des i gn and Results 127
s o that the Ste and P k levels were not stat i s t ically corre l ated over
the full data set . For thaw ing a s i mi l ar des i gn to that used for the
regular shapes was app l i ed for T a and T in · The three values of h for
each comb inat ion o f p i pe wal l th i ckness and rubber l ed t o e leven
d i f ferent l e vels of Biot number .
A tota l of 83 exper i ments wer e per formed w i th Ty los e . The results are
g i ven in Tab l e 6 . 6 and F ig s . 6 . 5 to 6 . 1 2 shown ty p i ca l temperatur e / t i me
pro f i l es at d i fferent pos i t ions w i th in each shap e . A s well , e i ght runs
were conduc ted wi th m i nced l ean beef for two of the irregular shap ed
obj ects . Tab l e 6 . 8 g i ves the results of these exper i ments . Fig. 6 . 1 9
shows typ i ca l temeperatur e / t i me pro f i l es for the minced l ean bee f runs .
E i ghteen ex per i men ts were conduc ted w i th the three three-d ime ns iona l
i rregul ar Ty lose obj ec ts chosen for s t udy . The shapes ar e shown i n
F i g s . 5 . 25 t o 5 . 27 . A n add i t iona l s i x runs wer e per formed usi ng two
s pher es . The exper imenta l des ign used was s im i lar to that u sed for
two-d imensional i r regular shapes . Each shape was b oth fr ozen and
thawed over a range of amb i ent and ini t ia l temperatur es . The B i ot
number was comp l e t e ly p re-set for each shape b y the mat e r i a l and size
o f construc t ion for each obj ec t . Tab l e 6 .7 g i ves the ful l s et o f
results . F i g s . 6 . 1 3 t o 6 . 1 6 show t y p i c al t emperature/ t i me pro f i l es .
E xperimental Des i gn and Resul t s 1 28
Tabl e 6 . 1 Typ i ca l Cond i t ions in Food Freez i ng and Thawing Proc esses
Free z i ng Thaw i ng
D ( m) 0 . 00 1 to 0 . 5 0 . 0 0 1 to 0 . 5
h (W m
-2 o c -1 ) 7 to 600 2 to 1 0 000
Bi 0 . 05 to 60 0 . 0 1 t o 1 000
( o
T c) -1 5 to - 40 5 to 50
a
Ste 0 . 1 2 to 0 . 3 5 0 . 07 to 0 . 9
( o
T. c ) 0 to 40 -1 0 to - 3 5
1n
Pk 0 to 0 . 6 0 . 0 6 to 0 . 3
( o
T c ) -1 0 to -30 0 to 1 0
fin
Nl 0 . 05 to 0 . 25 0 . 0 1 to 0 . 1
N2 1 . 7 to 2 . 0 1 . 7 to 2 . 0
N3 0 . 27 to 0 . 3 5 0 . 27 to 0 . 3 5
Exper imenta l Des i gn and Resul t s 1 29
Run D h T T. t
X a 1n exp
Number
-2 oc - 1 ) ( hr s )
(m) (W m ( oc ) ( oc )
*
ind i cates a run i n wh ich edge heat transfer was c a l c ulated to b e
greater than 1 . 0 % .
Experimental Des i gn and Results 1 30
Tab l e 6 . 3 Exper i mental Data For Thaw i ng of Inf i n i t e Cyl inder s of Ty lose
Run D h T T. t
r a 1n exp
Numb er
oc ( oc ) ( oc )
-2 -1
( m) (W m ) ( hr s )
C1 0. 158 23 . 5 43 . 3 -1 4 .0 7.34
C2 0 . 1 58 23 . 5 21 . 1 -20 . 6 1 2 . 43
C3 o. 1 5 8 23 . 5 5.1 -28 . 4 34 . 4 1
C4 0 . 1 56 90 . 7 43 . 2 -1 1 9
• 5.31
C5 0 . 1 56 90 . 7 1 3.0 -1 3 . 6 1 2 . 30
C6 0 . 1 56 90 . 7 5.1 -27 . 9 23 . 7 4
C7 0. 1 56 43 . 5 40 . 3 -21 . 2 6 .09
CB 0 . 1 56 43. 5 1 1 .9 -27 . 4 1 5 . 40
C9 0 . 1 56 43 . 5 8.2 -26 . 9 19 .21
C10 0 . 1 56 43.5 5.3 -1 4 . 9 25 . 70
c1 1 0 . 1 06 1 13 .0 43 . 3 -1 0 . 7 2 . 47
C1 2 0 . 1 06 1 1 3.o 8 .5 -20 . 2 7 . 94
C1 3 0 . 1 06 1 1 3 .o 5. 1 -28 . 8 1 1 . 36
C1 4 0 . 1 03 37 . 4 43 . 3 -30 . 5 3 . 26
C1 5 0 . 1 03 37 . 4 1 3 .0 -1 4 . 5 7 . 25
C1 6 0 . 1 03 37 . 4 5.3 -1 0 .6 1 3 . 89
C17 0 . 1 03 25 . 1 40 . 3 -1 0 . 6 3 .7 9
C18 0 . 1 03 25 . 1 1 8 .7 -1 4. 1 6 . 63
C1 9 0 . 1 03 25 . 1 1 3.2 -1 4 . 4 8 .84
C 20 0 . 1 03 25 . 1 5.3 -31 . 2 1 6 . 73
C21 0 . 1 03 1 9 .5 43 . 9 -26 . 9 4 . 33
C22 0 . 1 03 19.5 1 8.3 -1 4.9 7 . 54
C23 0 . 1 03 1 9 .5 5.8 -1 3. 1 1 8 . 20
C2 4 0 .05 1 46 . 5 44 . 0 -1 0 .6 0 . 87
C25 0 . 051 46 . 5 8 .5 -1 1 9
• 2 .93
C26 0 . 05 1 46 . 5 5.1 -10.0 4 . 22
C27 0 . 05 1 27 . 9 40 . 3 -1 1 8
• 1 . 30
C28 0 . 05 1 27 . 9 18.9 - 26 . 5 2 . 49
C29 0 . 05 1 27 . 9 1 3 .2 -1 8 .5 3 . 00
C30 0 . 05 1 27 . 9 5.3 -28 . 0 5 . 96
C31 0 . 05 1 1 9 .0 43 . 9 - 28 . 1 1 .64
C32 0 . 05 1 1 9 .0 1 4 .6 -18.2 3 . 76
C33 0 . 05 1 1 9 .0 9 .6 -28 . 2 5 .03
C34 0 . 05 1 19.0 5 .8 -1 2. 1 7. 15
Exper imental D e s i gn and Resu lts 131
Run D h T T. t
r a 1n exp
Number
-2 -1 ( hr s )
(m) (W m oc ) ( oc ) ( oc )
S1 0 . 1 28 246 . 2 43 . 3 -9.7 2 . 26
S2 0 . 1 28 246 . 2 21 . 1 -25 . 3 3 . 92
S3 0 . 1 28 246 . 2 1 3 .0 -1 9 .7 5 . 42
S4 0 . 1 28 74.8 44 . 0 -15. 1 2 . 66
S5 0 . 1 28 74.8 18.3 -1 8 . 8 4 . 78
S6 0 . 1 28 74.8 1 1 .9 - 23 . 1 6 . 39
S7 0 . 1 28 74.8 5.3 -26 . 5 1 1 . 33
S8 0 . 1 28 51 .6 43 . 3 -27 . 9 2 . 76
S9 0 . 1 28 51 . 6 22 . 0 -1 8 . 8 4. 31
S10 0 . 1 28 5 1 .6 1 4 .5 -20 . 3 5 . 81
s1 1 0 . 1 28 51 .6 5.1 -1 5 . 5 1 2 . 26
S1 2 0 . 1 28 41 . 9 43 . 6 -20 . 3 3. 13
S13 0 . 1 28 41 . 9 1 2 .0 -33 . 0 7 . 63
S1 4 0 . 1 28 41 .9 5 .5 -1 7 . 1 1 2 . 82
S1 5 0.1 12 76 . 0 43 . 9 -1 4.5 1 . 89
S1 6 0.1 12 76 . 0 8.0 -13 .9 5 . 96
S17 0. 1 1 2 76 . 0 5.3 -28 .0 7 . 87
S18 0.112 59 . 4 43 . 6 -27 . 1 2 .02
S1 9 0.1 12 59 . 4 1 4 .5 -1 6 . 6 4 .05
S20 0.112 59 . 4 5 .0 -18.2 9 . 02
S21 0. 1 1 2 45 . 7 43 . 6 -30 . 2 2 . 43
S22 0.1 12 45 . 7 8.9 -32 . 9 7. 18
S23 0. 1 1 2 45 .7 5.5 -1 7 . 4 9 . 67
S24 0 .056 1 37 . 2 18.3 -1 6 . 9 0 . 86
S25 0 . 05 6 1 37 . 2 1 1 .9 -1 3 . 4 1 . 15
S26 0 .056 1 37 . 2 5 .3 -2 3 . 5 2 . 08
S27 0 . 05 6 87 . 0 43 . 6 -1 4 . 2 0 .58
S 28 0 .056 87 . o 22. 2 -20 . 3 0 . 87
S29 0 . 05 6 87 . 0 1 4.5 -1 4 . 8 1 11•
S3 4 0 . 05 6 57 . 5 12.1 -21 . 7 1 . 58
S35 0 . 0 56 57.5 5.5 -1 6 . 3 2 . 67
Exper i mental Des i gn and Results 132
Run D D D h T T. t
X y z a 1n exp
Numb er
oc ( oc ) ( oc )
(m) -2 -1
( m) (m) (W m ) ( hrs )
• • • cont inued
Tab l e 6 . 5 cont inued • • •
1 33
Run D D D h T T. t
X y z a 1n exp
Number -2 -1
( m) (m) ( m) (W m oc ) ( oc ) ( oc ) ( hr s )
Tab l e 6 . 6 Exper i menta l Data For Freez ing and Thawing of Two- D i mens i onal
I r r egular Shapes of Ty lose
Run Shap e D h T T. t
a 1n ex p
Number Code
-2 oc - 1 ( oc ) ( hr s )
(m) (W m ) ( oc )
11 o. 1 5 25 28 . 0 21 . 1 -1 5 . 2 9 .95
12 0 . 1 5 25 28 . 0 20 . 8 -1 6 . 6 1 0 . 60
13 0 . 1 525 28 . 0 1 3 .7 -1 3 . 7 1 3 . 79
14 o . 1 5 25 28 . 0 13 6 • -17 . 2 16.1 2
15 0 . 1 5 25 28 . 0 5.6 -1 6.1 26 . 23
16 0 . 1 5 25 28 . 0 - .7
1 9 18.1 9 . 83
17 0 . 1 5 25 28 . 0 -23 . 6 2.8 6 .77
18 0 . 1 5 25 28 . 0 -25 . 0 33.6 7 . 88
19 0 . 1 52 5 28 . o -27 . 0 19 .4 7.34
110 0 . 1 5 25 28 . 0 -30 . 6 2 .7 5 . 82
11 1 0 . 1 525 28 . 0 -33 . 9 19 .4 5 . 45
112 0 . 1 5 25 28 . 0 -3 8 . 5 23.9 5. 18
113 2 0.1 1 15 28 . 0 40 . 6 -1 2 . 1 5 . 40
11 4 2 0.11 15 28 . 0 20 . 3 -31 . 3 9 . 98
115 2 0. 1 1 15 28 . o 1 3.7 -21 . 9 1 3 .28
116 2 0.1 1 15 28 . 0 1 3 .6 -1 7 .2 13. 1 1
117 2 0.1 1 15 28 . 0 5.6 -31 7• 24 . 9 8
118 2 0. 1 1 15 28 . 0 -19 .7 31 .8 9 .53
119 2 0.1 1 15 28 . 0 -23 . 7 4.3 6.31
1 20 2 0. 1 1 15 28 . 0 - 25 . 1 34.9 7 . 30
121 2 0.1 1 15 28 . 0 -26 . 9 20 . 0 6 .70
122 2 0. 1 1 15 28. 0 - 38 . 6 1 .8 3 . 96
1 23 3 0 . 1 370 28 . 0 20 . 3 -1 1 .2 10. 17
124 3 0 . 1 370 28 . 0 1 3 .7 -19.9 1 4 . 47
1 25 3 0 . 1 370 28 . 0 8.4 -1 9 . 4 1 8 .69
126 3 0 . 1 370 28 . 0 5 .6 -18.4 27 . 32
1 27 3 0 . 1 3 70 28 . 0 -1 9 .8 1 9 .5 9 .31
1 28 3 0 . 1 370 28 . 0 -26 . 9 20 . 1 7. 13
1 29 3 0 . 1 370 28 . 0 -30 . 5 32 . 8 6 . 90
130 3 0 . 1 370 28 . 0 -38 . 5 13.4 4 . 63
131 4 0 . 0 9 90 28 . 0 20 . 1 -21 . 5 8 .98
132 4 0 . 0990 28 . 0 1 3 .7 -3 2 . 5 1 2 . 28
1 33 4 0 . 0 990 28 . 0 8.4 -1 3 . 2 1 6 . 86
134 4 0 . 0 990 28 . 0 5 .6 -9 . 5 21 1 9 •
1 35 4 0 . 0 9 90 28 . 0 -1 9 . 8 18.1 7 .82
136 4 0 . 0990 28 . 0 -27 . 1 1 9 .9 6.17
137 4 0 . 0 990 28 . 0 -38 . 6 19.1 4 .0 4
• • • cont inu e d
Tab l e 6 . 6 cont inued • • •
1 35
Run Shape D h T T. t
a 1n exp
(o (o
Number Code
-2 oc- 1 c c)
( m) (W m ) ) ( hr s )
1 38 5 0 . 1 050 34 . 2 21 . 1 -1 5 . 7 5.1 3
1 39 5 0 . 1 0 50 34.2 13 .6 -1 2.7 7.19
1 40 5 0 . 1 050 34.2 8.5 -1 2 . 6 9 .35
141 5 0 . 1 0 50 34 . 2 5 .6 -32 . 5 1 5 . 17
1 42 5 0 . 1 050 34 . 2 -1 9 . 8 3.3 4.51
1 43 5 0 . 1 0 50 34 . 2 -27 . 2 1 .3
9 3 . 78
1 44 5 0 . 1 0 50 34 . 2 -30 . 6 3 .1 3.01
145 5 0 . 1 0 50 34 . 2 - 39 . o 32. 4 2.71
1 46 5 0 . 1 0 50 20 . 3 5.3 -28 . 1 1 8 . 83
1 47 5 0 . 1 0 50 20 . 3 -2 2 . 2 1 4 .9 6 . 27
1 48 5 o . 1 0 50 20 . 3 -34 . 1 1 9 .7 4.1 2
149 6 0 . 0850 34 . 2 40 . 4 -29 . 8 3.19
150 6 0 . 0 85 0 34. 2 20 . 2 -20 . 1 5 . 23
15 1 6 0 . 0850 34.2 1 3 .7 -20 . 9 7 14
•
Run Shape D h T T. t
a ln exp
Number
-2 -1
( m) (W m oc ) ( oc ) ( oc ) ( hr s )
Table 6 . 8 Exper i mental Dat a For Freez ing and Thaw ing of Slab s and
Mult i -D i mens ional Shapes of M i nced Lean Beef
Run Shap e 1 D D D h T T. t
X a 1n exp
Number & Code
y z
( m) (m) ( hr s )
M7 Br i ck 0. 152 0. 1 53 0 . 1 54 41 .0 27 . 0 -28 . 4 7 . 22
M8 Br i ck 0 . 1 52 0 . 1 53 0 . 1 54 41 .0 8.4 -1 5 .0 1 8 .01
M9 Br i ck 0 . 076 0 . 077 0 . 300 41 .o 1 3. 0 -22 . 3 5 . 23
M1 0 Br i ck 0 . 0 76 0 .077 0 . 300 41 .0 5.8 - 23 . 9 9 . 32
10
T.
0
'8
0 Tc
-
-
� -10
�
! -20 Legend
A
B
.........••
-30 �------r---�--�---.--,
0
Ta 1 3 . 4 °C , T in
= - 2 3 . 6 °C . A e x per imentally measured
= -
·
··
··
r.
··
··
··
· ··
··
10 ··
··
·
··
··
·
u
··
..
·
··
.e..,
·
·
·
··
·
··
··
�
·
�
-
0 0
�
�
a.
� Legend
A
-10
�--········
-20 �------�--r---��---,
0 2 4 6 8
Time (hrs)
F i g . 6 . 2 A Typ i cal Temperature/ Ti me Prof i le For Thaw i ng of In f ini te
Cyl inders of Ty lose.
Run C22 , Dr •0 . 1 03 m, h a 1 9 .5 W m - 2 oc- 1 , T a - 8 . 2 °C , =
20
10 T.
u
�
CD 0
"-
�
-
0
"-
CD
a. -10
E Legend
.,!
A
-20 B
..........•
-30 �----�--�
0 2 4 6 8
Time (hrs}
Fig . 6 . 3 A Typ ic a l Tempe ra ture / Ti me Prof i le For Th aw i ng of Spher es o f
Ty los e . Run S6 , D r = 0 . 1 28 m , h 7 4 . 8 W m-2 °C - 1 ,
T a = 1 1 . 9 °C , T in = - 2 3 . 1 °C . A - exper i me n tally me asured
temper atures , B - temperatures predic ted by th e s i mp l i f ied
f in i te e lemen t method . Resu l t s for a l l the nu mer ica l method s
ar e v ir tua l ly iden t i c a l .
40
u 20
�
CD
"-
�
-
0
Legend
"-
CD A
a.
E �--········
.,! 0
c
--
-20 �------�---r---,
0 2 3
Time (hrs)
Fig . 6 . 4 A Ty p ic a l Temp erature/ Time Pr ofi le For Thaw i ng of Rec tangular
Br i ck s of Tylo se . Run B7 , D x 0 . 1 04 m , D y - 0 . 1 25 m, D z
= •
0 . 1 52 m, h 50 . 4 W m
s
- 2 -1
oc , T a 45 . 0 °C , T in
• - 1 2 . 0 °C .
•
'U
�
-5
G)
-
� Legend
-10
� A
G)
a.
B
� -15 ...........
---
c
-20
-25
0 2 4 6 8
Time (hrs)
Fig . 6 . 5 A Typ ical Temperature / T ime Prof i le For Freez i ng or Tha w i ng o f
the Ty lose Two-Dimens ional Ir r egular Shape Numb er On e .
Run 1 7 , h = 28 .0 W m-2 °C -1 , T a = - 2 3 . 6 °C , T in = 2 . 8 °C .
A - e xpe r i mental ly measure d temperatures , B - tempe ratu res
pred ic ted by the full f i n i t e e lement me thod , C - temperatures
pred icted by th e s i mp l i f ied f i n i t e e lemen t me th od. Ca l culated
usi ng the two-d ime ns ional g r i d in Fi g . 5 . 1 5 .
20
10 Legend
'U A
�
G) B
...........
�
::s ..
-
0 0 ---
c
�
G) 3
a.
�
-10
-20 ;------.--�---,
0 5 10 15
Time (hrs)
Fig . 6 . 6 A Typ ical Tempera ture/ Ti me Prof i le For Freez i ng or Thaw i ng o f
the Ty lose Two- D i mens ional Ir r e gula r Shape Number Two .
Run 1 1 6 , h = 28 . 0 W m- 2 oc- 1 , T a = 1 3 . 6 °C , T in = - 1 7 . 2 °C .
A - expe r i ment a l ly measur ed t e mperatures , B - tempe r a tu res
pred icted by the ful l f i n i te e leme n t me thod , C - t empe ratures
pred i c t e d by th e s i mpl i f ie d f in i t e e leme nt method . Ca lcul ated
us ing the t wo-d i me ns io nal grid in Fi g . 5 . 1 6 .
Exper i me n ta l De s ign and Resu l t s 1 41
40
20 Legend
'G' A
t_.,
a»
�
�--········
::::J
-
0 0 £._ __
�
a»
Q.
E
�
-20
-40 4-------r---�--,--.
0 2 4 6 8
Time (hrs)
Fig . 6 . 7 A Ty p ical Temperature/ Ti me Prof i l e For Fr eez i ng or Thaw i ng o f
th e Ty lose two-D i mens ional Irregular Shape Numb er Three.
Run I29 , h = 28 .0 W m-2 °C -1 , Ta - 3 0 . 5 °C , T in = 32 . 8 °C .
=
10
Legend
'G'
0 A
......_,
a» 0 8
� ..........•
::::J
- c
0 ---
�
a»
Q. -10
�
-20
-30
;---
0 2 4 6 8 10 12--.----r---r--�---,--�
Time (hrs)
F i g . 6 . 8 A Typ ical Temp erature/ T ime Prof i le For Freez i ng or Thaw i ng o f
the Ty los e Two-D i me ns io nal Ir r e gular Shape Number Fou r .
Run I 3 1 , h 28 .0 W m- 2 °C -1 , T a = 20 . 1 °C , T in = - 2 1 . 5 °C .
•
10
(]'
0
-
G)
-
3
0 Legend
e
G) A
! -10
B
...........
c
---
-20 ;-------�--r--�
0 2 4 6 8
Time (hrs)
Fig . 6 . 9 A Ty pical Temperature /Ti me Pr ofi le For Fr eez ing or Thaw i ng of
the Ty lo se Two- Di mens ional Irregular Sh ape Numb er Five .
Run 139 , h = 3 4 . 2 W m-2 °C -1 , T a 1 3 . 6 °C , T in = - 1 2 . 7 °C .
=
0
Legend
0"
0 A
._
G) -10 B
� ...........
:::J
- c
0 ---
�
G)
a. -20
E
t!!
-30
-40 1-----r--r--T---�--�
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5
Time (hrs)
Fi g . 6 . 1 0 A Typ ical Temp erature/ Ti me Pro f i le For Fr eez ing or Thawing of
the Ty l ose Two-D imens ional Irregular Shape Number S i x .
Run 156 , h • 3 4 . 2 W m -2 oc- 1 , T a - 39 . 1 °C , T in = 2 . 3 °C .
=
10
?
�
0
�
- Legend
�
Q) A.
-5
! �--········
-10
-15 �------�--r--,�---,--�
0 5 10 15 20 25
Time (hrs)
U'
0
0
..._,
�
- Legend
e
G A.
! - 20
9
..........•
-40 4---------�--r--,�--�
0 0.5 1 1.5 2
rme (hrs)
Fig . 6 . 1 2 A Typ ic a l Temp erature /Ti me Pr of i le For Fre ez ing or Thawing of
the Ty l ose Two- Di mens ional I r r egular Shape Number E i ght .
Run I77 , h = 3 4 . 2 W m -2 °C - 1 , T a - 3 8 . 7 °C , T in = 1 8 . 3 °C .
s
0
0'
0
'--"
Q)
L.
�
-
-10 Legend
e A.
Q)
Q.
E B
.....•...••
� c
--
-20
-30 4------r--�---�---r---.
0 0.5 1.5 2 2.5 3
Time (hrs)
Fig . 6 . 1 3 A Ty pical Te mp e rature /Time Prof i le For Fr eez ing or Thawing o f
the Ty l ose Thr ee- Di mens ional Irregu l ar Pyramid Shap e .
Run TI5 , h = 4 1 . 0 W m -2 °C -1 , T a = - 29 . 2 °C , T in = 5 . 1 °C .
A - expe r i mental ly measured temperatures , B - temperatures
pred ic ted by the fu l l f i n i t e e lement me thod , C - temp e ratures
pred i c t ed by the s impl i f ie d f i ni te e l emen t method .
Calc ulated us ing th e th ree-d i mens ional g r i d i n Fi g . 5 . 2 4 .
- at th e c entre o f the x, y fac e ( base) o f th e py rami d ,
2 - 0 . 07 65 m ( mi d-h e igh t ) above pos i t i o n 1 ( F i g . 5 . 24 ) .
15
10
0'
0 5
'--"
Q)
L.
�
-
c 0 Legend
L.
Q) A.
Q.
B
� -5 ...........
-10
-15 4-------r---�--�---,
0 2 4 6 8
Time (hrs)
F i g . 6 . 1 4 A Ty p i cal Tempera ture/ Ti me Prof i le For Freez i ng or Tha w i ng o f
the Ty lose Thr ee-Di mens ional Ir r e gular Sph ere Shap e .
Run TI 5 , h 5 1 . 4 W m- 2 °C -1 , T a
• 1 2 . 8 °C , T in = - 1 1 . 9 °C .
�
15
10 ·· ··
··
Legend
V'
�
5 A
G) B
'- .
•
•...•...•••
� •
- c
0 --
E
G)
! -5
-10
-15
0 5 10 15
Time (hrs)
30
20
Legend
'0 A
�
10
B
...........
�
- c
--
0 0
...
GJ
! -10
-20
-30
0 2 3 .. 5 6 7
Time (hrs}
Fig . 6 . 1 6 A TY p ical Te mpera ture/ T ime Prof i le For Freez i ng or Thaw i ng o f
the Ty lose Thr e e-D i me ns ional Irr e gula r Egg Shap e .
Run TI 1 6 , h = 5 1 . 4 W m - 2 °C -1 , T a = - 2 2 . 6 °C , T in = 20 . 6 °C .
A - ex pe r i ment a l ly measured tempe ratures , 8 - temperatures
pred icted by the fu l l f i n i te e lement me thod , C - tempe ratures
pred ic ted b y th e s i mp l i f ie d f i n i t e e l eme nt method .
Ca l c u lated us ing the th ree-d i mens ional g r i d i n Fi g . 5 . 26 b .
20
Legend
A
�--········
-30 4-----�--��--�-----,
0 0. 5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5
Time (lvs)
Fig . 6 . 1 7 A TY p i ca l Temp erature/ Ti me Prof i l e For Thaw i ng of Sl ab s o f
Minced Le an Bee f .
Run M4 , D x = 0 . 047 m, h 7 8 . 1 W m -2 °C -1 , T a
= 1 5 . 8 °C ,
=
-15 �----.---r--,
0 5 10 15 20
Time (hrs)
Fig . 6 . 1 8 A Ty p i ca l Temp e r a t u r e / T i me Pr o f i l e For Thaw i ng of Rect a ngu l ar
Br i c k s o f M i n c ed Le an B e e f .
Run M8 , D x = 0 . 1 52 m, D = 0 . 1 5 3 m, D z = 0 . 1 54 m ,
y
-2 -1
h 41 .0 W m oc , T
a
= 8 . 4 °C , T
in
= - 1 5 . 0 °C .
A - e xp e r i me n ta l l y mea s u r e d t e m pe r a t u r e s , B - t e mp e r a t u r e s
p r ed i c t e d by the f i n i t e d i f f e r e nc e me t h o d .
40
20 Legend
u
0
A.
�
B
...........
e
::J
- 0 c
0
�
�
a.
�
-20
- 40 4-----�--�---,
0 2 4 8 8 10
Time (hrs}
Fig . 6 . 1 9 A Typ i ca l Temperature / Ti me Prof i le For Freez i ng or Tha w i ng o f
a M i nc ed Le an Beef Two- D i me ns ional Irregular Shap e .
Run M1 4 , t wo-d i mensiona l irregular Shape No . 3 ,
h 28 .0 W m- 2 °C -l , T a - 30 . 2 °C , T in 24 .5 °C .
= =
7.1 VER IFIC AT ION OF A U NIFIED AP PRO ACH FOR SIM P LE SHAPES
W i th i n the tol er ance of the data , previous s tudies ( C leland & Ear l e
1 98 2 b , Pham 1 98 4 a ) sugges ted that there was n o ev idenc e that the rat io
was not constant at 6 : 3 : 2 . The pred i c t ions for al l the shapes showed
no trends w i th changes in shape or free z i ng cond i t ions ( Pham 1 98 4c ) .
The hyp o thes i s that the r a t io o f t slab = t cyl = t sph i s cons tant at 6 : 3 : 2
for b o th freez i ng and tha w i ng o f foods and that i t i s indepe nden t o f
env ironmental cond i t ions was tested mo re r i gorou sly b y use of n ume r i ca l
me thod s . The Tylose freez i ng data ( Cleland & Ear l e 1 97 6 b , 1 977 a ,
1 97 9 a , 1 97 9 b ) and the Ty lose thaw ing da t a ( Chap . 6 ) for th e slab ,
inf in i te cy l i nder and spher e shapes were pred i c ted us i ng the three
numer ical methods d i sc ussed in Chap . 4 - the f i n i t e d i fference method
and the two f i n i t e el ement me tho d formulat ions . For each exper ime ntal
run n i ne pred ict ions were made one for each comb i na t ion of the thr ee
numer ical me thods and the three geometry descr i p t ions . Each pred i c t ion
was mod i f ied by the ap prop r i at e rat i o and th e perc entage d i f ference
from the exper i mental t i me calculate d . For exampl e , an inf in i te
cy l i nder exper imen t al run was pred icted by results from slab , inf in i t e
cyl inder and spher e vers ions o f the three numer ical methods mu l t i p l i ed
by 0 . 5 , 1 . 0 and 1 . 5 respec t i vely . The perc ent age d if ferences were
ca lculated from :
pred ic ted t i me - exper i mental t ime 1 00
p ercentage d i fference (7 . 1 )
exper i mental t i me
The r es u l t s for b o th the freez i ng and thaw i ng data are summar i sed in
Tab le 7 . 1 . The f i n i te d i f ference method and the two f i n i te e lemen t
method formu l a t ions gave almost iden t ical resu lts s o only the f in i te
d i f f er enc e r esults are presented . The rat ios of n ume r i cally pre d i c t e d
t i mes :
t slab / t sph ' t slab / t cy l and t cyl / t sph w ere a lso exam i ned for
each set of exper imental runs . The mean va lues and 9 5 % con f i dence
intervals were 3 . 0 2 ±0 . 20 , 2 . 0 1 ±0 . 07 and 1 . 50 ±0 . 0 5 r espec t i ve ly for
freez ing and 3 . 00 ±0 . 37 , 2 . 00 ±0 . 1 5 and 1 . 50 ±0 . 0 7 r espec t i ve ly for
thawi ng .
The mean pred i c t ion accuracy was not s i gn i f icantly affected by the
c ho i c e o f geome t ry descr i p t i on used in the nume r i ca l calcula t ions .
Henc e , on average , the r a t io of 6:3:2 holds for b oth freez i ng and
thawi ng .
Pred i c t ion of Thawi ng T i mes 1 50
Var i a t ions of the 6:3:2 r a t i o fo r ind i v i dual exper i menta l runs aro se
from two fac tors - both the overall change in enthalpy from the i n i t i a l
temperature to a spec i f ie d f inal thermodynam i c c entre temper atur e and
the mean " e ffec t i ve" th erma l conduct i v i ty d i ffer w i th shape . These are
d i rec t l y consequ en t i a l on the d i fferent d i s t r i bu t ion of vo lume w i th
respec t to d i sp lacement from the geome t r i c centre i n the thre e shap es ,
wh i c h in turn a ffec ts the shape of the temper atur e/d i sp l ac ement
pro fi l e . These factor s mean that the t s l ab : t cy l : t sp h ra t io is
depende nt on Bi , Ste and Pk .
For freez ing the dependence of the ratio on Ste and Pk is weak . For
the ranges over wh ich Bi , Ste and Pk v ary in t yp ical free z i ng
operat ions ( Tab le 6.1 ) , there is no need to take account of these
trend s . The ratio can be cons idered constant at 6:3:2 w i thout
introduc ing any s i gn i f icant add it iona l unc ertainty into the
pred i c t ions .
For thaw ing the e f fec t o f Pk is ins ign i f icant because va lues of Pk
typ ically encoun t e r ed are sma l l ( Tabl e 6.1 ). Also thermal conduc t i v i ty
i s h igh and tempera ture d r i v ing forces are large when the sens ible heat
r epresented by Pk is transferred so th i s h eat transfer i s eas i l y
ach ieved. Converse ly , th e sens ible heat represented by Ste is
transferred mor e slowl y as temp erature d i f ferenc es a n d the thermal
conduc t i v i t i es are both lower at th is st age in the thawing process .
Typ i ca l ly i n thaw i ng Ste v a r i es over a wi de range so the Ste e f f ec t i s
larger . The B i e ffec t r e s u l t s from changes in the therma l conduc t i v i ty
wi th temper atur e and v ar i a t ion of the surface temperature and
temperature/d isp lacemen t p rof i l e at the end of the phase change p rocess
as 8i changes .
A w i de r ange of numer ical so lut ions to thaw i ng prob lems were d i scu ssed
in Chap s . 2 and 4 . The thr ee t i me l ev e l Lees ' f i n i t e d i fferenc e scheme
and f i n i te e leme nt method that ac counted for therma l prope r t i es
con t i nuou sly var i ab l e wi th t emper ature , were shown to be the bes t
numer ical me thods for pred i c t ion of phase change i n foods .
Apply ing the cr i ter i a of C l e land & Earle ( 1 984 a ) t o compari sons of the
numer ical pred i c t ions wi th the exper i mental resu l t s showed no trends i n
the data that m i ght suggest maj or systema t ic exper imental o r thermal
data errors . The exper i mental error bounds cou l d no t be determined
accurately but were es t i mated to be between ±5% and ±1 0 % ( Chap . 5 ,
Tab l e 1 2 . 2 ) for the slab , inf i n i t e cyl inder and sphere thawi ng
exper i me nt s . Th i s is of the same order of ma gn i tude as the total
l imi t s for the nume r i c a l pred i c t ions , sug ges t ing that only m i n imal
uncert a i n t y has ar i se n in the ap p l i ca t ion of the nume r i c a l me thods .
Pred i c t i on of Tha w i ng T i mes 1 52
Th is was ex pec ted because relat i vely fine space and t i me g r i ds cou l d be
u sed ( Chap . 4 ) .
Some slab runs had a cont r i bu t ion from edge heat transfer tha t was
es t imate d to exceed 1% ( Sec . 5 . 4 . 4 , App . B ) . The pred i c ted thaw i ng
t imes calculated by the thr ee n umer i ca l methods for these runs when
compared w i th the expe r i mental data agreed to w i th in 1 . 3 % ±8 . 4 % , 0 . 2%
±8 . 8% and 0 . 2% ±8 . 8 % respec t i vely . If edge heat tr ansfer was
s i gn i f icant compared wi th sourc es of random error then the means of
these percent age d i fferences shou ld be not i cab l y off set from the mean
of a l l the other p ercentage d i ff erenc es . I t was conc luded that the
e x tra exper imenta l uncer t a inty in these runs had no t s i gn i f i cantly
i ncreased the overall unc erta i nt y .
Numer ical me thods , i f formulated and impl emen ted correc t ly , are the
c lo s es t to exac t pred i c t ion me thods . Ther e fore as there is no
s i gn i f icant and iden t i f iab l e systemat ic tr end or correlat ion in the
expe r i mental data the error bounds of the nume r i c a l pred i c t ions a re the
best es t imate of the ov erall random ex p e ri menta l error ( due to
uncertainty in control and measuremen t of exper i mental cond i t i ons ) .
Pr e d i c t ions be tter than thos e achieved by the nume r i ca l methods cannot
be expec ted if the same exper i mental and therma l data ar e use d unl e ss a
more exact or soph i s t icated form of the nume r i c a l methods is used
( Heldman 1 983 , Cle l and & Ear l e 1 98 4a ) . Compa r i ng the numer i ca l
pred i c t ions for each shape i n d i v idua l ly ( Tab l e 7 . 3 ) g i ves est i ma t es of
the expe r i mental error for the exper i ments w i th each shape . The
average 95% confi dence bou nds of the observ ed d i fferences for the thr ee
nume r i c a l methods are on average ±7 . 1 % , ±5 . 0 % and ±1 1 . 3 % for slab s ,
inf i n i te c y l i nder s and s pheres respec t i ve l y . As expected the
uncer t ainty for s l ab s and i n f in i te c y l inders i s lower than for s pheres
as b e t t er control and measuremen ts of the exper i mental cond i t i ons ,
espec ially d imens ions and surface heat transfer coe f f i c ients , were
pos s ib l e ( Chap . 5 ) . The above uncerta i nt y b ounds are co nsi sten t w i th
exper i mental variab i l i ty measured by summing that measured i n rep l i cate
exper i men t s , and systema t i c error from other sources not ev i dent from
the rep l i c ates ( for examp l e , measurement of h) .
f in i te e lement me thod formu l a t ion was h igher than for the oth er two
methods . Th i s is due to the relat i vely crude way in wh ich variat ions
in the therma l proper t i es are i ncorpor at ed in to th i s method . For th is
method increas i ng the number of nodes and e l ements d id have some
benef i ts and reduced the d i f ferenc e in pred i c t ion compared wi th the
other me thods . I t is debat ab le wh ether the sav ing s in c omputat ion
cos ts j us t i f ies th i s loss in ac curac y as the decr ease in compu ter
memory s i z e requ iremen ts and increase in speed achie ved by us ing th e
s i mp l e formu l a t i on fo r one - d ime ns iona l work i s sma l l .
For the f i n i t e e lement methods some unex pect e d d e v iat ions of the
Pred i c t i o n of Thawing T i mes 1 54
Thaw i ng t i mes for the slab , i nf i n i t e cyl inder and sphere expe r i me nta l
data were calculated u s ing the me thods that cons i dered the th ird k ind
o f b oundary cond i t ion and that seemed most l ik e l y to l ead to r easonab l e
pred i c t ion accuracy . The percent age d i fferenc es between th e calculated
r esu l ts and the exper i mental thaw i ng t imes were found (Eq. (7 . 1 ) ) . A
summary of these values i s g i ven i n Tab le 7 . 2 .
Some emp i r ical formulae developed spec if ically for freez ing t ime
pred i c t ion wer e a lso tested . If it was poss i b l e the ana l ogous
emp ir ical formula was deve loped for thaw ing . Generally the methods
that could be adap t ed wer e those wi th a more comple te theor e t i ca l
bas i s . Other formulae were s i tuat ion o r p roduc t spec i f ic and cou ld not
be made app l i cab l e .
Pred ict ion methods that d id not pre d i c t the exper i mental thaw i ng data
wel l wer e l im i ted i n one or mor e of the fol low i ng way s .
( 1 ) Methods developed for semi - i n f in i te slab s cannot be app l ied to
f in i t e shape s if sens ibl e heat e f f ec ts p r io r to phase change are
s i gn i f icant . Th is is because heat transfer is ca lculated to occur
from a greater volume i n the semi - i n f i n i te s l ab than i s ac tua lly
present in the fi n i te geometry ( Geuze e t a l 1 97 2 , C l e land 1 97 7 ) .
( 2 ) Me thods assuming a un ique thaw i ng temper ature ( t ak en as equ a l to
the i n i t ial freez ing t emperature ) lead to overpre d ic t ion of thawing
t i me because much of the latent h eat ( as we l l as subcoo l i ng
sens i b l e heat ) i s ab sorbed over a range o f temperatures l ower than
Tif • There for e the ac tual temperatur e d r i v i ng force for h eat
transfer is greater than tha t used i n calculat ions .
( 3 ) Me thods that used the unfrozen phase thermal conduc t i v i ty dur i ng
the phase change p rocess t ended to overpred i c t the thawing t i me s .
The t ru e mean therma l conduc t iv i ty dur i ng the tha w i ng process is
greater than or equal t o the unfrozen value s o mor e heat t ransfer
P r ed ic t i on of Thaw i ng T i mes 1 56
Numer ical me thods that so lve the govern ing part i a l d i f feren t i a l
equat ion for heat transfer and t a k e accoun t of temperatur e dependent
therma l prop e r t i e s correc t l y model the thawing process phy s i ca l ly and
there for e g i ve pred i c t ions that are not affec t ed by the above f ac tors .
Compar i son wi th the results for the nume r i c a l me thods he lps to i dent i fy
how wel l a pred i c t ion method performs in try i ng to g i ve a phy s i c a l l y
correc t descr i p t ion of these factor s and how they af fect thawing t i me .
I t i s conven ient to u se the corre l a t ion coe f f i c ient (r) compar i ng
percentage d i fferences in the manner of C l e land & Earle ( 1 98 4 a ) .
Plank ' s ( 1 9 1 3 ) equa t ion ( Group B) was l im i ted by the l a tter four
factors . The compe nsatory natur e of ( 2 ) and ( 3 ) aga ins t ( 4 ) and ( 5 )
means that the mean p re d i c t ion error was + 6 . 0 % . Howe ver , the spread o f
the p r e d i c t ions was l arge ( ±4 3 % at the 9 5 % l ev e l o f conf i denc e ) and the
correlat ion wi th the f i n i t e d i fferenc e method r esu l t s was l ow . Th i s
i nd icates that the compensa t i on was not cons istent between runs w i th
d i fferent cond i t ions , render i ng the equa t ion unre l i abl e . In free z i ng ,
Plank ' s equa t ion cons i s tently underpredicted by 20% to 40% b ecause the
equ i valent prob l ems to f actors ( 2 ) to ( 5 ) a l l l ead to underp r ed i c t i on
for that process .
The analyt i c a l methods due to Rutov ( 1 936 ) , Goodman ( 1 958 ) , Sh ih & Chou
( 1 97 1 ) , Sh i h & T say ( 1 97 1 ) , Huang & Sh i h ( 1 975a , 1 975b ) , Ker n ( 1 977 ) ,
Glas s er & Kern ( 1 97 8 ) , Yan & Huang ( 1 979 ) , Cly ne & Garc ia ( 1 9 80 ) , Cho &
Sunder l an d ( 1 98 1 ) , Sol i man ( 1 98 1 ) and Hi l l & Kuc era ( 1 9 83 ) , and the
Pred i c t ion of Thaw i ng T i mes 1 57
emp i r i ca l methods of Bax ter ( 1 96 2 ) , Tao ( 1 967 , 1 968 ) and Good l ing &
Group D ar e the mod i f ied ana l y t ical methods ( semi-analy t i ca l ) tha t are
based on mu l t ipl icat i ve factors to ac coun t for sen s i b l e heat e f f ec ts
( factors ( 4 ) and ( 5 ) ) . They all tend to sub stan t i a l ly ov erpre d ic t
thaw i ng t i mes , and pred i c t ions tend to ha ve a la rge spr ead .
The Gro up F methods break the phase change p ro cess into three s tages
and at temp t to appro x i mate the heat transfer in each s t age . They
per form b e t ter than Group D because they mod e l the true phy s ic a l
cond i t ions mo r e rea l i s t i cal ly . To rema in s i mp l e these methods use some
avera ging t echn i ques . They tend to overpre d i c t th e thawing t i me s
usual l y b ecau se they do no t t ake accoun t of factor s (2 ) an d (3 )
proper ly .
The emp ir ic a l formulae deve loped for freez ing ( Group G) all tend to
overpred i c t thaw i ng t i mes as the emp i r i ca l corr ec t ion factor s are not
approp r i a t e for thaw i ng . The method of Succar & Hayakawa ( 1 984 ) was
not t es te d as it is poss i b l y unnec es sar i l y complex and y et was not
expected to be mor e accurat e , than the other me thods in th i s group .
The two emp i r i cal methods ( Gr oup H ) spec i f i cal l y developed for thawi ng
t i me pred i c t ion gave the bes t pre d i c t i o n ac curacy . Creed & Jame s
Pr ed ic t ion of Thaw i ng T i mes 1 58
The b es t methods were those due to Calvelo ( 1 98 1 ) and Creed & James
( 1 9 8 1 ) but both have the d isadvantage that they do not t ak e acc o un t of
d i f fere nt therma l proper t i es for d i fferen t foods tuf fs . Creed & James '
method was also indep endent of i n i t ial temperature . Pham ' s ( 1 9 8 4a )
me thod has the advant age of hav i ng a pre dom inate l y ana ly t ical bas i s .
I t has a low standard deviat ion due to the three stage approach
cons i der i ng all sources of thawing t i me v a r i a t ion but the mean
perc entage d i fference was offset from z ero.
Ear le 1 98 2 b , Hung & Thomp son 1 9 83 ) were invest igated because of the ir
s i mpl i c i t y and succ ess for freez ing t i me p r ed i c t ion . Also p r ed i c t i on
formulae s i m i lar to those of Calvelo ( 1 9 8 1 ) and Pham ( 1 984a, 1 9 84c )
were inves t i gated to see i f they could be impr oved and made appl i cable
to a w i der range of s i tuat ions . The Creed & James ' ap proach may have
y ie l ded an accurate product - spec i f ic formul a bu t was not cons idered as
su itable for de ve lopment of a general formula compared w i th th e other
me thods .
The fo llow i ng four predict ion formulae were found to be super ior to
o thers t r ied . The i r pred i c t ions are summa r i se d i n Table 7 . 3 .
( a ) Use o f the bas i c form of Calv e lo ' s ( 1 9 8 1 ) solution b ut represent ing
i t in terms of Fo , Bi , Ste and Pk so that all the therma l
proper t ies a r e i nc luded . Analy s i s of the exper imental dat a by
mu l t ip l e non-l i ne ar r egr ess ion gave the fo llow i ng pred i c t i on
equa t ion :
AD
Fo - = 1 . 4 29 1
[ 0 .5 0 . 1 25
+ --
] 1 . 0 2 48
Ste
0 . 27 1 2
Pk
0 .061 0
(7.2)
2V Bi Ste Ste
( b ) Use of we igh ted mul t i ple l i near regress ion to f ind mod i f ie d
formul ae for the shape factors i n Plank ' s equ a t ion i n a s i m i l ar
manner to that u se d. by C l e land & Earle ( 1 9 7 6 b , 1 97 7 a , 1 9 7 9 a , 1 97 9b ,
1 9 82b ) . The best formu l a deve l oped was :
AD p R
Fo - • + -- (7.3)
2V Bi Ste Ste
where p - 0 . 5 ( 0 .7754 + 2 . 2828 S t e Pk )
R - 0 . 1 25 ( 0 . 427 1 + 2 . 1 220 S t e - 1 . 48 4 7 Ste 2 )
Pred i c t i on of Thawi ng T i mes 1 60
[
pred i c t i on formula of th i s type was :
J
AD 3
Mi i D hD
t
2V
I T 2h
1
--
1 + -
4k i
(7. 4 )
� i
whe re llH 1 C s ( T i fave - T in )
�T 1 T a - ( T in + T i fave > 1 2
k1 ks
�H 2 L
�T 2 T a - T i fav e
k2 0 . 25 k s + 0 . 75 k 1 = 0 . 83 for Tyl ose
�H 3 C l ( T ave - T i fave )
�T 3 T a - ( T ave + T ifave > 1 2
k3 kl
T ave average f i na l temperatur e
= T r i n - ( T f i n - T a ) / ( 2 + 4k l /h/ D )
T i fav e = T i f - 1 . 5 = - 2 . 1 for Tyl ose
Pred i c t ion accuracy was sens i t i ve to the values of the mean
freez i ng temperature , the average thermal conduc t i v i ty i n the phase
change per iod and the average f i na l temperature . To retain the
ana l y t i cal bas i s the val ues of the mean thaw i ng temperature and the
avera ge f i nal temperature were calculated by the methods suggested
by Pham ( 1 98 4 a ) . For accurate pred i c t ions i t was nec essary to
emp i r i ca l l y f i t the value for the mean thermal conduc t i v i t y in the
phase change p er iod The we i ghted val ue for k 2 of 0 . 83
w m - 1 oc - 1 for the phase change per i od , although phy s i cally
reasonab l e , has no bas i s apar t from conven i enc e . Equat ion ( 7 . 4 ) is
c lose ly related to the methods of Pham ( 1 9 8 4a , 1 9 8 4c ) , wh i ch are
both of s im i la r pred i ct ion accuracy for freez i ng . Equat ion (7.4)
was cons i dered to be the emp i r i ca l thawi ng equ i valent of the Pham
( 1 9 8 4 c ) freez i ng approach , rather than the equ i valent of the Pham
( 1 98 4 a ) method as the l at ter has mor e substant ial ana ly t i cal bas i s .
( d ) D irect f i t t ing o f a correct ion t o Plank ' s equat ion gave :
Pred i ct i on of Thaw i ng T i mes 1 61
AD [ 0.5 0 . 1 25 1 �H
*
[ 0 .0244 Pk
+ 0 . 6 1 92 -
j ( 7 .5 )
Ste j
Fo = + 0 . 89 4 1 -
2V B i Ste �H Ste Bi
* 3
where �H =entha l p y change f r om - 1 0 °C to T (J m- )
ave
Equa t ion ( 7 . 5 ) i s s i m i l ar i n form to the free z i ng t ime p r ed i c t i o n
[ ]
not been publ i sh ed i n the l i te r a t ur e . I t is :
AD 0.5 0 . 1 25
Fo - = + -- [ 1 + 0 . 0 4 /( B i Ste ) + 1 . 2 7 /( Pk St e ) ] ( 7 . 6 )
2V Bi Ste Ste
Al l the me thods are s i m p l e and have some phy s i ca l bas i s th ough the i r
0 . 0 85 < St e < 0 . 7 68
0 . 065 < Pk < 0 . 27 2
Fo
AD
- = 1 .3179
[ 0 .5 0 . 1 25 0 . 957 6
+ -- Ste
]
0 . 0 5 50 0 . 00 1 7 Bi +0 . 1 7 2 7 Pk
10 (7 .7 )
2V B i Ste Ste
Equat ion (7 . 7 ) has a mean pre d i c t ion error of 0 . 1 % ±7 . 3 % at the 95%
conf i dence level and a corre lat ion coe f f i c ient o f 0 . 61 compared w i th
the f i n i t e d i f ferenc e method pre d i c t ions errors , when tested aga i nst
the freez i ng data of Cle land & Ear l e ( 1 977 a , 1 979a , 1 9 79 b ) . Th i s
compares favourab ly wi th th e pred ict ion acc uracy of the other prov en
freez i ng t i me p red i c t ion formulae ( C l e l and & Ear l e 1 9 82 b , Pham 1 9 8 3 ,
1 98 4 a , 1 98 4c ) .
W i th in the accuracy of the pres ent freez ing and thaw i ng data , it was
val i d to t ak e the ratio of phase change t i mes fo r s l ab s , in f in i te
cyl i nders and spheres to be cons tant at 6:3:2 j ust i fy ing a un i f ied
approac h for freez i ng a nd thaw i ng t i me p red i c t ion fo r these shapes .
N o p re v iously pub l i shed s i mp l e pred ict ion formu la was both suffic iently
accur ate an d su i t ab l y expr essed fo r i t to be ad op t ed as a genera l
thaw ing t i me pred ict ion me thod . Four improved formulae ( Eqs . ( 7 . 2 ) to
( 7 . 5 ) ) , that ga ve comparab l e resu l ts w i th the nu mer ical methods were
deve loped. Each of these formulae represents a d i fferent conc ep tual
approa ch i n mod i fy i ng th e wel l-known Pl ank ' s equa t ion i n way s tha t had
been previously suc c essful for fr eez ing t i me predict ion .
For both freez i ng and thaw i ng , al l the approaches y ie l ded formu lae that
are of s imi lar acc uracy and s imp l i c i ty . A l l are l i m i ted mor e by the
accuracy of the data from wh ich th ey wer e der i ved rathe r than the
inherent inaccuracy of the ap proach used . Within the l im i ts of the
t es t i ng a ga i ns t exper imental dat a , al l of these approac hes ar e of
comparab l e use fulness . It is u n l i k e ly that s i gn i f i cantly bet t er
me thods can b e deve loped that reta i n the adv antage of s i mp l ic ity .
s s 1 . 00 0.8 6. 1 -1 4 .6 9.3
c 0 . 98 -0 . 3 5.6 -1 4 . 1 7.4
Freez ing 5 SP 0 . 92 -0 . 8 5.2 -1 3 . 5 6.4
c s 0 . 97 -3 . 1 6.1 -1 5 . 9 5.6
c 1 . 00 -3.6 4.7 -1 4.1 3 .0
Freez ing 5 SP 0 . 93 -3 . 4 4.3 -1 3 . 3 1 .8
S , C , SP S 0 . 93 -1 . 3 6.1 -1 5 . 9 9.3
c 0 . 97 -2 . 0 5.1 -1 4 . 1 7 .4
Freez i ng 5 SP 0 . 93 -2 . 0 4.6 -1 3 . 5 6.5
Unmod . 1 . 00 -1 . 4 5. 4 -1 4 . 6 9.3
c s 0 . 45 -2 . 4 4.1 -9 . 6 4.8
c 1 . 00 -2 . 2 2.4 -6 . 8 3 .6
Thaw i ng 6 SP 0.71 -2 . 4 3.6 -8 . 3 6 .- 1
SP S 0.64 0. 4 8. 1 -1 3 .7 1 3 .7
c 0 . 92 -0 . 2 5.9 -9 . 0 10.4
Thaw i ng 6 SP 1 . 00 -0 . 9 5.5 -9 . 5 9.1
S , C , SP S 0 . 68 -o . 9 5.7 -1 3 . 7 1 3 .7
c 0 . 86 -0 . 6 5. 1 -9 . 0 1 3 .0
Thaw i ng 6 SP 0 .78 -0 . 6 6.1 -9 . 7 1 7 .7
U nmod . 1 . 00 -1 . 3 4 .0 -9 . 5 9.1
Group Me thod & Re fer enc e Mean Std Dev 1 Min 1 Max 1 Corr 2
(%) (%) (%) (%) FDM
• • • continued
Tab l e 7 . 2 cont inued • • • 1 66
Khatchaturov ( 1 95 8 ) 12.0 27 4
0 -45.7 86 . 6 -0 . 02
Gol ovk in et al ( 1 97 4 ) 7 .8 10 5
0 -1 3 .6 3 5 . 2 0 . 34
Schwartzberg ( 1 97 7 ) - 86 . 1 4.6 - 94 . 3 -71 . 8 -0 . 07
I
Church i l l & Gup ta ( 1 977 ) - 49 . 5 12.2 -73 . 5 -2 5 . 4 0 . 1 6
Levy ( 1 98 4 ) -35 . 8 9 .3 -6 4 . 8 - 1 7 . 7 0 . 30
Sastry ( 1 98 4 ) -57 . 4 10.7 -7 1 .8 -33 .0 0.31
S , C , SP -1 . 3 4 .0 -9 . 5 9.1 1 . 00
FDM s -0 . 8 3.5 -6 . 3 6.8 1 . 00
c -2 . 2 2.4 -6. 8 3 .6 1 . 00
SP -0 . 9 5.5 -9 . 5 9.1 1 . 00
S , C , SP 0. 1 5.7 -1 0 . 2 15.2 0 . 72
Eq . ( 1 . 2 ) s 0.4 6.0 -7 . 2 15.2 0. 71
c -1 . 6 3 .2 -1 . 1 5.2 0 . 66
SP 1 .5 6.9 -1 0 . 2 1 4 .6 0 . 76
S , C , SP -0 . 2 4.9 -9 . 2 1 2.0 0 . 80
Eq . ( 7 . 3 ) s -0 . 2 4 .5 -1 . 0 10.2 0. 72
c -1 .8 3 .3 -9 . 2 5.9 0 . 61
SP 1 .3 6.0 -9 . 0 12.0 0 . 89
8. 1 I NTRODUCT ION
The deve lopment of numer ical methods that solve the govern ing par t ial
d i ffer ent ial equat io n for heat conduc t i on w i th temperatur e dependent
thermal properties for obj ects o f any two or three-d imens iona l geometry
was d i scussed in Chap . 4 . The fini te d i fferen ce me thod is l i mi t ed by
prac t ical cons iderat ions to regular shaped obj ects ( in f i n i t e rods ,
f in i t e cy l i nde rs and rectangular b r i ck s ) , wher eas the fini te e lement
method can tak e account of the more complex , irregular ,
mul t i - d i mens ional geometr ies as wel l as the regu l ar shapes. Thermal
property data used in all the numer i c a l calculations are l is ted in
Table 5 . 1 .
The only exper imental thawing data collected for mul t i -d i mens ional
regular shapes were those for Tylo se r ec tangular b r i ck s ( Tabl e 6 .5 ) .
The full f in ite element method formu lation ( Eqs . ( 4 . 2 ) to ( 4 . 5 ) ) was
not used as comp utat io n cos ts were too h ig h but the s impler f in i te
e lement method formulat ion ( Eqs . ( 4 . 5 ) t o ( 4 . 8 ) ) and the f in i te
d i fferenc e method were appl ied . Table 8 . 1 summar i ses the calcul a t ion
resu l t s .
was magn i f ied by the c oarse element grid used for pred i c t i o ns .
The ex per iment al fr eez ing and thawing t i me s for the two-d i mens ional
irr egu lar Tylo se shapes are g i ven in Tab l e 6 .6. Pred i c t ions were
carr ied ou t by both f in i te element me thod formulat ions us ing the gr ids
shown in F ig s . 5 . 1 5 to 5.21 . The gr i d s were pr epar ed from 8 node ,
quadrat i c , i soparame t r i c , rec tangular elements . These e lements allowed
curved b ound ar ies to b e appr ox imat ed by quad ratic func t io ns . The g r i ds
prepared ensured that at leas t f i ve elements ( 1 1 nodes ) e x i s ted betwe en
the thermo dynam i c c entr e and th e ou ts ide sur face of each ob j ec t , i n a l l
d ir ec t i o ns .
The results summar ised i n Table 8 . 1 show that both the finite element
formulat ions gave acc urate pred i c t ions of bo th fr eez i ng and thaw i ng
t imes ( w i th i n tolerances allowed for ex per i men tal error ) , for all the
shapes tested. The 95J conf i den ce b ounds for the p er centage
d i fferences of the full f in i te element formula t io n of -9 .7% to 1 0 .3%
Pr ed i c t i on of Fr eez ing and Thawing Times 171
8.4 PR ED ICT IONS FOR THREE-DIMEN SIONAL IRREGU LAR SHA PES
Tab l e 8 . 2 summar i ses the perc ent age d i f fer en ces between ex p er i menta l
freez i ng and thawing t i mes and th e pred i c t i o ns by the t wo f i n i te
e l emen t me thod formu l a t i ons for the three - d imens ional i r r egula r shapes .
The grid used for the f ir s t shap e ( th e fru stum of a sq uare pyram i d ) is
shown in Fig . 5 . 2 4 . Becau se of the s t ra ight s i des it is b as ica l l y the
same 7 x7 x7 node gr i d use d for the rec t angular bri ck pre d i c t ions , but
was d i s torted to the pyram i d d i mens ions . Be cau se of t he
three-d imens ional i r r eg ular i t y a ful l quadrant of the shape was
mode l l e d . Consequ en t l y th e grid was r a ther coarse wi th onl y three
l inear e lements between surface and centre a long the height of the
pyram i d . The exp er i menta l procedur e for the pyram i d was iden tical i n
a l l respec ts t o that u se d for the r e c t angular b ri ck shape so it was
cons i dered that the ex p er imenta l cond i t io ns wer e control l ed and
Pr ed i c t ion of Fr eez ing and Thawing T i me s 172
The p re d i c t ions have s i mi lar spread t o those for the rec t angular b r i ck
freez i ng and tha w i ng but the mean was off se t by ab ou t 1 0 % . Th e l ow
standard dev iat ion of th e pred i c t i on er ror s suggests that th e prob lem
is sy stema t i c , and no t random. Two po s s ible r easo ns are : ( a ) th e
coa rse gr i d lead ing to s i gn i f i cant pred ict ion inaccuracy and ( b) th e
assump t i on tha t h was the same for th e pyramid and rect angu l ar b r i ck
shap es may not hold .
The amount of offse t was greater for the freez ing runs where B i was low
sugges t i ng that th e second r eason was an important con tr i bu tor
accord ing to the cr i te r i a of Cleland & Ear le ( 1 9 8 4 a ) .
F i n i t e e lement method calc ulat ions for the pyramid shape were a ffec ted
in the manner j us t descr ibed, as a coar se gr i d o f l ine ar e l ements was
use d . Also the pos i t ion of the thermod ynam i c c en tre could not be
accurately determined p r ior to grid p reparat ion so the true
thermod ynamic centre was not necessar i ly c lose to a node . Therefore
the ob s erved under-pred i c t ion of freez i ng and thaw i ng t i mes was not
unex pec t e d . Pred i cted t emperatu r e p ro f i les were a dequate cons ider i ng
Pr ed i c t ion of Fr eez ing and Thawing T i me s 1 73
these prob l ems wi th the coa rse gr i d and the e xper imen ta l unc ert a i nty i n
thermo couple pos i tioni ng ( F i g . 6 . 1 3 ) .
The egg shap e has one axis of rota t i onal symme try so it cou ld be
mode l l ed b y ei the r a two- o r thr ee - d i mens iona l gr i d . Bo th the f i n ite
e l emen t method gr ids used are shown in Fig . 5 . 26 . The two-d i mens ional
gr i d i s s i mi lar to that u se for th e sphe re shape exc ep t that it was
d i storted to f i t the elliptical shape and a ha lf , r ather than a
qua rte r , of the cr oss - sect ional prof i l e was mode l le d . The
three-d i mens iona l g r i d used was a lso a d istorted dou ble vers i o n of
th e sphere three-d imens iona l gr i d . Th e fu l l qu adran t need ed was
desc r i b ed by 5 4 twenty node , qua dra t i c , i soparame t r i c , r ec t ang ular
e lemen t s . The f i sh shape thoug h irr egu l ar in a l l three d imen s ions was
c lose ly approx imated by a shap e w i th two p lanes of symme try so on ly a
quadran t was mode l l e d . The g r i d i s shown in F i g . 5 . 27 . I t i s th e same
bas i c thr ee-d imens ional gr i d used for the eg g shape but the gr i d po i n t
coord inat e s , espec i a l ly f o r the sur fac e nodes were mod i f i ed t o f i t t he
ac tual shap e .
For the egg and f ish shapes it was assumed that the surface he at
tranfer coeff i c ient was the same as that me asur ed on the mou ld e d
p l as t i c s pheres ( Sec . 5 . 9 . 3 ) . Th e inaccuracy introduc e d by th i s
assump t io n was no t eas i ly asse s se d . Var i a t io ns i n p last i c th i ck ness
and the presenc e o f a ir vo i d s and poor er or be t t er surface con tac t at
the surfac e of these obj e c t s may have contr i b ut ed to the unc ert aint i e s .
Th i s extra e xp er i men ta l unc erta inty , p lus the unc ert a in t y d ue to
d if f i cu l t i es in measur i ng and desc r ib ing these shap es mathemat i ca l ly ,
a s wel l as appr ox i ma t i ng th e shape wi th a coar se f in i t e e lemen t method
g r i d , meant that poorer pred i c t i o ns were expec t ed for the egg and f ish
Pr ed i c t ion of Fr eez ing and Thaw i ng T i me s 1 75
For the eg g shap e the me an pred ict ion error was c lose to zero so th e
assump t ion that the sur face he at transf er coeff ic ien t was th e same as
i t was for the sphere se emed reasonab l e . The h igher s t andard de v iat ion
of th e pred i c t ions for th e eg g shape compared w i th the py ram i d and
sphere shapes was ma inly th e result of the ex tra uncerta inty in the
exper i ment s rather than unc ert a inty due to th e implement at i on of the
f i n i t e e lement method . If a f i ner gr id ha d been use d , the f in it e
e l emen t method wou l d hav e introduced no s i gn i f ic an t pred i c t ion
inacc uracy .
For the f i sh shap e the pred i c t i o ns were cons i s tently h igh by 20% to 4 0 %
b u t th e s t andard dev iat io n o f pred i c t ion errors was compa r ab l e w i th
that for th e egg shap e . The off - se t mean was probably caused by
sy stemat i c err or in the surfac e heat transfer coeff ic i en t . Th e surface
heat trans fer coeff i c ient may not have b een th e same as that for th e
sph er e du e to : ( a ) a th inner plas t i c th i ckness ar i s i ng dur i ng mou ld i ng
and/or ( b ) better therma l conta ct between the Ty los e and the plas t i c
moul d for the f i sh shape than the spher e . As d i scussed in Sec . 5 . 9 . 4
the se factors cou ld not no t be quantat i v e ly assessed as i t was no t
poss ible to measure h d ir ec t ly for the f i sh shape . Howe ver ,
measurement of th e plast i c th ickness showed variat ions of up to 1 5 % of
the average to ta l th i cknes s ove r the surface of th e f i sh shape and
d if ferenc es of up to 1 0% i n the th ick ness b e t ween the f i sh and sphere
shapes . It was unknown whe ther these ob served va r iat ions were
suff i c i en t ly large to cause the d i fferences betwe en the pred icted and
Pred i c t ion of Fr eez i ng and Tha w i ng Ti mes 1 76
8 .6 SUMMARY
The sp reads of the nume r i c al me thod pred ict ions were low for a l l da t a ,
b u t mean pred i c t ion error s for some thr ee-d imensiona l irr egula r shapes
were of f-se t from z ero. Th is ind icates tha t systema t i c data er ror s ,
probab ly i n es t i ma t i on of surface heat t r ansfer coe ff ic i ent s , were
impor t ant compared wi th random exp er imental unce rtainty . Pr ed icted
tempera tur e prof i l es conf i rme d these t r end s .
The i mp lemen tations o f the f i n i t e element me thod used for both regular
and irregular mu l t i -d i mens iona l sh ap es do not lead to sign i f i cant
inacc uracy in p red i c t ions p rov ided the gu i d e l i nes in Se c . 8 . 6 ar e
fo llowed . U se of coarse gr i ds and /or the s i mpl i f i e d f in i t e e l ement
method formulat ion d id lead to s i g n i f i cant inac curracy in the
pred ic t ions and there fore wor sened overa ll agreemen t w i th ex pe r i mental
freez ing and thaw ing dat a .
Pr ac t i cal contra int s o n comp uta t i o n power me ans that use r s of the
f in i t e e leme nt me thod w i l l have to wor k c l ose to th e l i mi ts of g r i d and
method re f inement for wh ich p red i c t ion me thod uncertainty is
s ign i f ican t , so ca re mus t b e ex erc i sed in u s i ng these methods .
Pr ed ict ion of Fr e ez ing and Thawi ng T i mes 178
Tab l e 8 . 1 Summary o f Perc entage D i ffer enc es Bet ween E xperi menta l
Freez i ng and Thaw i ng Ti mes For Ty l ose Mul t i - D i mens i onal
Shapes and Freez i ng and Thaw i ng T i mes Ca lcula ted By Numer i ca l
Methods
Tab l e 6 . 6 0.3 5. 1 -1 1 . 4 1 1 .3
F ,T
( 83 runs ) 4 .2 6. 1 -9 . 1 21 .9
Tab le 6 . 6 1 .5 5.5 -7 . 1 1 1 .3
T
( 4 1 run s ) 5.8 7 .0 -6 . 7 21 . 9
Tab l e 8 . 2 Summary of Perc ent age D i f fer enc es Bet we en Exper i menta l
Freez i ng and Thaw i ng T i mes For Ty l ose Three-D i mens i ona l
I r r egular Shapes and Freez i ng and Thaw i ng T i me s Ca l cul ated By
the F i n i te El ement Method
-5 .5 6 .8 -1 2 . 1 5.3
3D
-1 2• 12.7 -1 6 . 1 13.9
0.4 6.7 -7 . 7 9 .6
10
2 .6 6.5 -4 .9 1 1 .6
5.2 1 3.0 -1 2 . 9 25 . 1
3D
Egg 9.8 14.9 -9 . 4 28 . 8
( 6 runs )
3 .7 1 3 .8 -1 6.1 24 . 7
2D
16.4 1 8 .7 -4 . 1 48 . 4
F i sh 35 . 3 8.9 20 . 8 44.2
3D
( 6 runs ) 33 . 5 1 6.3 8.6 58 . 4
I n Chap ter 9 Group I ( s impl e ) me thods for regu l ar mul t i - d i mens i onal
shapes are cons i dered . Th i s comp l etes the ana lysis requ ired for the
th ird research obj ec t i ve set in Chap . 3 .
For a l l two- and three-d imens ional sha p es ( apart from inf i n i te
cy l i nders and spheres ) the sur face i s not i sothermal w i th respect to
pos i t ion unl ess B i +O or B i � � . I n add it ion the phase change front shape
var i es wi th t i me . C onsequent ly the true geome t r i c factors for
mu l t i - d imens iona l shap es ar e in rea l i ty h i ghly dependent on the B lot
number . As B i +O the ratio of 2V/ AD ho lds for a l l shapes . For h igher
Bi values , some parts of the surface ar e more effec t i ve in transf err i ng
heat to or from the centre than others . There fore none of the
analyt i ca l developments based onl y on the area to volume r at io are
successful for freez i ng ( Cl eland & Ear le 1 98 2 b ) . The comp l ex i t y of the
heat transfer in mul ti - d i mens ional obj ects is such that an accurate
geometr i c fac tor is un l i k ely to b e der i ved analy t i ca lly .
Cl eland & Earle ( 1 982 b ) de f i ned the equ ivalent heat transfer
d i mens iona l i ty , EHTD , as :
t slab
EHTD = (9.2)
t
The formul a for rec tangu l ar b r i ck shapes :
Bi [ 0 . 625 + 0 . 6 251
(9.3)
+
Bi + 2 � a� J
where sl : rat io of second longest to shor test s i de l eng th
.. D y iD x
61 a rat i o of l ongest to shor test s i de l eng th
- D z /D x
• shor t est s i de l eng th (m)
• second longest s i d e l eng th ( m)
• longest s i de l eng th (m)
was deve loped by f i t t i ng exper imen tal data w i th B i in the range 0 . 5 to
22 . 0 . I t does not conform to the l im i t i ng case that EHTD•AD/2V a s B i +O
but does fit pub l i shed exper i mental data for rectangular b r i ck s
6 62
1
undergo i ng fr�e z i ng . I t covers ranges of Bi , and t yp ically
encount er ed in prac t i ce . Used i n conj unc t ion wi th the freez i ng t i me
pred i c t ion formula for slabs due to C l e land & Earle ( 1 982 b ) it
Pred i c t ion of Fr eez i ng and Tha w i ng T imes 1 82
pred i ct ed the ex per iment al Tylose rec tangu lar br i ck free z i ng data of
C l e l and & Ear l e ( 1 97 9 b ) wi th percentage d i fferenc es wi th a mean of
- 1 . 2% ±1 1 . 4% a t the 95% level of con f i dence .
Pham ( 1 98 4 b ) used the 2V/AD geometr i c factor but mod i f i ed the i n t ernal
conduc t i o n term in the s i mpl e pred i c t i on formula based on Plank ' s s l ab
equat i on by a factor ca lled the " mean conduc t i ng path leng th" , MC P .
MC P is based on the same p r i nc iple as the corr ect ions der i ved
ana ly t i ca l l y by P l ank ( 1 9 4 1 ) and Shamsundar ( 1 982 ) but b ecause it was
developed based on fit to ex per imenta l data it i nc ludes compensat i on
for ef fects such as the non- i so thermal sur fac e , that P l ank and
Shamsundar i gnored . For rec tangu lar b r i ck s the formula deve loped to
[(-1
ca lculate MC P was :
MC P
-- - 1
D
+
[( 1 .5/B, 1 )
-4 +
e1
+
1
-H1 + -)
s2
4
Bi
I] l
-4 0 . 25
(9.4)
For f i n i te cyl inders , an equ ivalent rec tangular b r i c k shape was de f i ned
so that Eq . ( 9 . 4 ) cou ld be used ( Pham 1 984 c ) . Equa t i on ( 9 . 4 ) , comb ined
w i th the slab pred i c t ion me thod of Pham ( 1 9 84 a ) , pred ic ted the Tylose
rec tangular b r i ck freez ing data ( Cl eland & Earle 1 97 9 b ) wi th 95%
con f i dence bounds of - 1 3 . 0 % to 1 3 . 0% and a mean p�ed i c t ion error c l ose
to zero , wh ich is s i m i l ar to the results for EHTD ( Pham 1 98 4 b ) .
MCP and EHTD are essen t i a l l y equ i val ent geome t r i c correc t ions to the
bas i c slab pred i c t ion methods but are i ncorporated into the s i mple
formulae in d i fferent manner s . EHTD i s a d i v i sor and can b e app l ied to
any slab pred i c t ion method by rearrangement of Eq. ( 9 . 2 ) to g i ve :
t slab
t = (9.5 )
EHTD
MC P can be d irectly incor porated into s i mple pred i c t ion formulae where
contr ibut i ons due to ex t ernal and internal r es istance to heat transfer
t
V
[
can b e separated ( such as Pl ank ' s equat ion ) , by the re lat ionsh i p :
[ ] [ -�
pred i c t ion me thod i s :
2V B i MC P Bi
t •
t s l ab - 1 + - -- I 1 + (9.7)
AD 4 D 4
Pred i c t ion of Freez ing and Thaw ing T i mes 1 83
[1 + ] [1 + - ]
The values for the two var i ab l es can be related by the equat ions :
AD Bi B i MC P
EHTD = - I -- (9.8)
2V 4 4 D
[
and
+1 1
J
MC P 4 AD 4
(9.9)
D
=
Bi 2V EHTD Bi
EHTD and MC P de f i ned by Eqns . ( 9 . 3 ) and (9.4) are both accurate
geome tr i c factors for the rec tangular brick shape wi th the intermed i ate
8 and B i va lues that occur in the rectangular b r i ck freez i ng da t a from
wh ich they were developed . For other cond i t i ons they may not be
accurate .
One pos s i b l e app roach for the current work was to seek to ex tend the
MC P and EHTD de f i n i t ions to a w i der range of geome t r i es and
env ironmental cond it ions to enhance the ir versat i l i ty . If th is was
succ essful then there wou ld be l i ttle bene f i t in seek i ng to develop
comp l etely d i f ferent geometr i c fac tors . The re fore the ap p roach taken
was to i nves t i gate the MC P and EHTD conc ep ts in deta i l , and then to
assess whether the ir l ack o f fit to data was suf f i c iently great to
j us t i fy cons i der i ng other a l t ernat i ve geome tr i c fac tor s .
could b e i gnored . For other mul t i -d i mens i onal shapes the B i effect
wou ld b e expec ted to b e larger because the surface is not i sothermal
wi th r espect to pos i t i on and the degree of approach t o a constant
sur fac e temperature is Biot number dependen t . Where mos t of the
resi stance is int ernal ( B i � m ) , sur face area not d irectly adj ac ent to
the thermodynam i c centre w i l l have l i ttle effect on the change in
temperature at the centre . Conv ersely i f mos t of the res i stance is
ex ternal ( B i � ) . then a l l the sur face ar ea of the obj ect is equa lly
e f fec t i ve and no fur ther correc t i on to 2V/ AD i s needed .
Free z i ng and thaw i ng t i mes were calculated for d i fferent B i , Ste and Pk
values u s i ng the f i n i te d i ff erence and f i ni te el ement me thod s .
Calculat ions were made for a range of di fferent i n f i n i t e rod , f i n i t e
cy l i nder and rectangular b r i c k shap es as we l l as for the equ i va l en t
slab shape so tha t the dependence of t slab /t on Bi , Ste and Pk cou ld be
exam i ned .
The f i n i t e d i f f erence method resul ts for free z i ng and thaw ing of two
i nf i n i te rod shap es are shown in Tab le 9 . 1 . These are typ i cal for al l
the shapes , for both free z i ng and thaw ing , and for both the numer i ca l
methods used . For each of the shap es t ested the effect of changes i n
Ste and P k , due t o changes in T a and T in ' wer e far less than the e ff ec t
of changes i n B i for the ranges of cond i t i ons typ i ca l l y encountered i n
prac t i ce . The Biot number effec t must be tak en i n t o account but the
Ste and Pk effects are smal l . The Ste and Pk effects were most
impor tant for thaw i ng , that process changed t slab / t by less
and for
than ±5 % over the full range of Ste and Pk va lues typ ically encountered
in prac t i c e . The i n i t i al approach was to ignore the Pk and Ste
effec ts .
The analysis of the p rev ious sect i on conf irmed that for regular
mul t i - d i mens i onal shapes , accurate geomet r i c factors can p robab l y b e
defined solely a s func t i ons o f B i and parameters that descr i b e the
shape , wi thout i ntroduc i ng s i gn i f i cant error into the pred i c t i on
method :
Pred i c t i on of Freez ing and Thawi ng T i me s 1 85
d imens ion was the character i s t i c d ime ns ion and had an e ffect equal to
that of a slab for i nf in i te rods , rect angul ar b r i cks and squat
cy l i nders ( f i n i t e cyl i nders w i th D r � D y ) , and an effect equal to that
of an i n f in i te cy l i nder for short cy l i nders ( f i n i t e cy l i nders w i th D r �
D y ) . The e ffec t of each of the other d imen s i ons on the rat io o f
t s lab / t f o r each shape cou l d b e separated . A number of trends were
ev i dent
( a ) the e ff ec t of the second d imens ion for infinite rods and
rectangular b r i cks was equal
( b ) the e ffect of the second and th ird d i mensi ons for the squat
cy l i nders ( cons i der i ng the th ickness as the f irst d i mens ion and the
d i ame t er as two equ ivalent d i mens ions ) were b oth the same , and were
equal to the e f fect of the second d i mens ion i n inf i n i te rods and
rec tangu lar bri ck s
( c ) the e ffec t of the th ird d imens ion i n short cy l i nders ( consi der i ng
the d i ame ter as the f i rst two d i mens ions and the hei ght or l ength
as the th ird ) was the same as the effec t of the th ird d i mens ion in
rec tangular b r i ck s , but was l ess than the effect of the second
d imens i on i n i n f i n i t e rods and rectangu lar b r i ck s .
The va lue of t slab / t changed wi th B i ot numb er . The va l ue o f B i at
wh ich the change with respect to B i was greatest depended on the rat io
o f d i mens ions :
( d ) as e 1 or e 2 i ncreased the change occurred at l ower Bi values
( e ) for h i gh e 1 and e 2 v a lues as B i ��, the values o f MC P and EHTD both
t ended to s l ab l i mi ts ( for inf ini te rod s , rec t angu lar b r i ck s and
squat c y l i nders ) or i n f in i t e cy l i nder l im i t s ( for sho r t cy l i nde r s )
( f ) for l ow e 1 and e 2 va lues as B i � � , the val ues of MC P and EHTD b oth
tend to some o ther l i mi ts wh i ch are frac t ions of the v a l u es as
B i +O .
( g ) as B i +O the values o f MC P and EHTD both depend only on 2 V / AD .
+ G3 [ r.,<e,l 82
+ (1 - f 1 2( 82) )
0 . 50
� (9.1 1 )
and
MC P
( 2 - G1 ) f ( f 1 3 ( G2 , ) 0 . 63 8iO .
39
34 8� 43 - 1 )
+
1 .. 81) (1 .
D
•
0 39 22
+ G3 f 1 .. ( f 1 3 ( G3 , 8 2 ) ) 0 . 63 8i · (1 . 51 8;· - 1 )
+ [ 1 - f 1 .. ( (f 1 3 ( G2 , 8 1 ) + f 1 3 ( G3 , 8 2 ) ) I ( G2 G3 + 1) ) ] .
[
( G1 + G2/ 8 1 + G 3 / 8 2 )
(9.12)
(G1 + G2 0 . 7 3 / 8�·50 + G3 0 . 5 0 / 8�· 69 )
1 . 77 1 1 . 34 . 77
where f 1 ( S) 2 . 32/ 8 (8i + 2 . 32/ 81 )
2
92
f 1 3( G, 8) G 2 . 00/ 81 ·
3
f I .
. ( X) x/ ( 8i 1 . 4 + x )
The p r i nc ip l es beh ind the methods to calcu l ate EHTD and MC P wer e
deve l oped from the ab ove observed trends i n the t s l ab / t data . For the
whereas for the EHTD c o nc ep t i t was inc luded i n the geome t r i c fac tor
i t se l f .
As 8i +oo the e ffect of each d i mens i on i s l ess than that sugge s t ed by the
and /or G3/ e 2 for EHTD and is greater than zero for MC P . The frac t ional
values , wh i ch are d i fferent for each d i mens ion because the ef fec t of
the th ird d i mens i on is l ess than the effect of the second d imen s ion ,
are g i ven b y 0 . 7 3/ e � · 50 and 0 . 5 2 / e � · 6 9 respec t i v e ly for EHTD .
For the EHTD concep t the exp ress ion is comp let ed by a B i ot nu mber
we igh t i ng func t ion that calculates the relat i ve con t r i b u t ion of the
Bi � and the B i � m t erms in the ef fect of each d imens ion . The equa t ion
can b e wr i t ten in general terms as :
EHTD = XI ( EHTD Bi � ) + ( 1 - x
l ) ( EHTD Bi � m ) (9.13)
where x
l Biot numb er we ight ing func t i on ( 0 � x
l � 1). The Bi va lue
at wh ich the max imum rate of change , from one t erm to the o ther , occurs
is dependent on the re lat i ve s i z e of tha t d imens ion compared w i th the
charac t er i s t i c d i me ns ion .
The p rev i ou s , and the i mp roved ver s ions o f the expr ess ions to calculate
MC P and EHTD were tested aga i nst the Ty lose rectangular b r i ck fr eez i ng
and tha w i ng data ( Cl e l and & Ear l e 1 97 9 b and Tab l e 6 . 5 ) . A summary o f
the p red i c t i o ns i s given i n Tabl e 9 . 4 .
For Ty lose rectangular b r i ck freez i ng the mean pred i c t ion error was
off-set from zero for both . the geometr i c fac tors . The full f i n i t e
d i ffer ence me thod resu l ts a l so d i sp l ayed an off-set mean pred i c t i on
error of the same magni t ude . Cl e land et a l ( 1 982 ) showed that th i s was
Pred ic t ion of Freez i ng and Thawing T i mes
probab ly due to non- equ il i b r i um freez ing rate effects not taken into
account i n calculat ions by the f in i te d i fference me thod . U s i ng the
f i n i t e d i f ference method as the slab pred i c t ion method wou ld there fore
b e expec t ed to l ead to a s im i lar off-set of the mean.
For freez i ng , the standard dev iat ion of pred i c t i ons was low , and the
corre lat ion coe f f i c i ent ( compared wi th the full f i n i te d i f ference
method results ) was h igh for both geometr i c fac tors . Th i s ver i f i es the
assump t i on that the Ste and Pk effec ts on t slab / t and hence EHTD and
MC P wer e suff i c ient ly sma ll to be ignored , and also prov i des
con f i rmat ion that for freez i ng the lack of fit of Eqs . ( 9 . 1 1 ) and
( 9 . 1 2 ) has not decreased the overa ll ag reement with exper i mental data .
For Tylose rec tangu l ar b r i ck thawi ng , the mean pred i c t ion errors for
Eqs . ( 9 . 1 1 ) and (9.12) were not s i g n i f i cantly d i f ferent from z er o .
However , the standard dev i a t i on o f the pred i c t ion error was h i gher than
that for the full finite d i f ference method pred i c t i ons and the
corre l a t i on coe f f i c i ent compared wi th the fu l l f i n i te d i ff erenc e method
results was low , for both the geometr i c factors . Th i s suggests that
the i naccuracy a r i s i ng from the improved EHTD and MC P formulae is
suff i c iently large to be d i s t ingu ished from the exper imen tal
uncerta i n ty . Two reasons ex i s t . F i rstly the rec tangular b r i ck tha w i ng
exper iments had less exper i mental uncer ta inty than the rec tangular
br i ck freez i ng data so the lack of f i t is more d i sc er n i b l e for thawi ng
but not for freez i ng . Secondly , i t was shown in Sec . 9 . 3 that the
e ffec t of Ste and Pk on t slab / t was a s much as ±5% dur i ng thaw i ng .
The se effects were ignored by Eqs . ( 9 . 1 1 ) and ( 9 . 1 2 ) , so correlat ion o f
p r ed i c t ion error s wi th S t e o r P k would ind i cate whe ther th i s was a
contr i b ut i ng fac tor . The correlat ion coe ff i c ients w i th Ste and Pk were
- 0 . 73 and 0 . 06 r espec t i ve l y , i nd i cat i ng that neg l ec t of the e f f ec t of
Ste was s i gn i f i cant .
Al though better pred i c t i ons for thaw i ng cou ld be ach ieved by add ing
terms i nvo lv i ng Ste, espec ial l y , i n to Eqs. ( 9 . 1 1 ) and ( 9 . 1 2 ) th i s s t ep
was not taken as the improvement would on ly be ev ident w i th very
accurate exper i mental data . In commerc i a l prac t i c e , food e ng i neers
mak i ng thawi ng t ime p red i c t i ons cannot determine data to represent the
cond i t i o ns as accurate l y as i s pos s i b l e in a researc h l aboratory , so
Pred i c t ion o f Freez ing and Thaw i ng T i me s 191
9.6 TEST I NG OF IM PRO VED GEOMETR IC FAC TOR S I N COMBI NAT ION WITH
S IM PLE PRED ICTION FORMU LAE
The pred i c t ions of the imp roved geometr i c fac tors in comb ina t ion w i th
the s i mp l e fr eez i ng and thawing t i me pred i c t ion me thods of Sec . 7 . 3 are
summar i sed i n Tab l e 9 . 5 .
The s i tuat ion for thawi ng t i me pred i c t ions was s im i l ar . All e i ght
method comb i na t i ons are comparab l e , but the neg lect of Ste and P k
e ffec t s o n EHTD and MCP has b o t h l owered the corr e l a t ion coeff i c i ent
with the f i n i t e d ifference method pred i c t ions , and l ed to the standard
Pred i c t ion of Freez i ng and Tha w i ng T i mes 1 92
dev iat ion b e ing s l ight ly h i gher than for the f i n i t e d i ff erence metho d .
1 .0 < 8 1 < 10
1 .0 < 82 < 10
The formulae may b e app l i cab l e outs i de these ranges but at the expense
of reduced ac curacy . Howe ver , v irtua l l y a l l p rac t ical food fr eezing
and tha w i ng s i tua t ions are covered .
9 .7 SUMM ARY
There are two useful conc ep ts to accoun t for geome try - EHTD and MC P .
Formulae to calculate both geometr i c factors for fr eez i ng of
rec tangular b r i c k shap es under a l i mi ted range of cond i t ions had been
prev iously dev e loped by emp ir i cally f i t t i ng rectangular bri ck freez ing
exper imental dat a .
Used in comb ina t ion w i th accurate slab fr eez ing and thaw i ng t i me
pred i c t ion me thods , b o th of the i mproved geome tr i c fac tors gave good
f i t to exper imental data for freez i ng and thaw i ng of rec tangular
b r i ck s . N e i ther of the geome t r i c factors introduc ed s i gnif i cant
p red i c t ion uncerta inty .
the two geometr i c conc ep ts ahead of the other ( s im i lar ly , none of the
slab pred i c t ion approaches stood ou t as b e ing s i gn i f i cantly more
accurate or s i mp l e to u se ) .
Tab l e 9.1 The Effec t of B i , Ste and Pk on the Rat io of Free z i ng and
Thaw i ng T i mes For I n f i n i t e Rods To the Times For the
Equ i va l ent Slab
B1 Bi Ta T in t slab /t Effect of
1 .0 0.1 - 40 . 0 20 . 0 1 . 99
1 .0 0.1 - 30 . 0 20.0 1 . 99 Ste
1 .0 0. 1 -20 . 0 20 . 0 2 . 00
1 .0 1 .0 -40 . 0 5.0 1 . 85
1 .0 1 .0 -30 . 0 20 . 0 1 .91 Ste and Pk
1 .0 1 .0 - 20 . 0 35 . 0 1 . 96
1 .0 1 .0 5.0 -1 0 . 0 1 .9
1 .0 1 .0 20 . 0 -20 . 0 1 . 8� Thaw i ng
1 .0 1 .0 35 . 0 -30 . 0 1 . 80
2.0 0.1 - 40 . 0 20 . 0 1 . 47
2.0 0.1 - 30 . 0 20 . 0 1 . 48 Ste
2 .0 0. 1 - 20 . 0 20 . 0 1 . 48
2.0 1 .0 - 40 . 0 5.0 1 . 26
2.0 1 .0 -30 . 0 20.0 1 .31 Ste and Pk
2.0 1 .0 -20 . 0 35 . 0 1 . 35
Shap e Gl G2 G3
S l ab s 0 0
I n f i n i te C y l i nder s 2 0 0
Spheres 3 0 0
F i n i te Cy l i nder s 2 0
o r ;:: D Y
F i n i t e C y l inders 2 0
or s Dy
I n f i n i t e Rods 0
Two- D i mens iona l 0
Irregular Shap es
Rec t angular Br i ck s
Three- D i mens iona l
Irregular Shapes
Pred i c t ion of Freez ing and Thaw ing T i mes 1 95
EHTD (9 . 3 ) 4 .9 8.2 -7 . 0 24 . 4
Rectangu l ar
Br icks EHTD (9.1 1 ) -0 . 5 1 .7 -4 . 4 5.3
( 90 runs ) MC P (9.4) 0.3 4.7 -7 . 6 1 2.5
MC P (9. 1 2) -0 . 7 1 .7 -6 . 0 3. 1
Data Geometr i c Equat ion Mean Std Dev 2 Min 2 Max 2 Corr 3
Fac tor (%) (%) ( %) (%) FDM
1 U s i ng the f i n ite d if ference method as the slab pred ict ion method .
2 Std Dev s tandard dev iat ion , Min min imum, Max
= = max imum. =
Data Slab Pred ict ion Geometr ic 1 Mean Std Dev 2 Min 2 Max 2 Corr 3
Me thod Factor (%) (%) (%) (%) FDM
T he prev ious three chap ters have covered the th ird and four th research
obj ect i ves set in Chap . 3 - assessment both of the accuracy of Group I
( s imp l e ) and Group I I ( numer i cal ) pred i c tion me thods for r egular shapes
and of Group II methods for irregular shapes . Chap ter 1 0 is concerned
wi th the f i fth obj ect i ve inves t i gat ion of the poss ib i l i ty o f
deve lop ing a Group I method t o pred ict freezing and thaw i ng t i mes for
irregular shapes .
10.1 I NTRODUCTION
No simp le methods suggested for ca lcu lat ion o f geometr i c fac tors from
f i rst p r i nc i p l es for freez i ng and thawing of irregular shaped obj ec ts
have proved accurat e . Rutov ( 1 936 ) and Mat t ( 1 964 ) used the AD/ 2V
ratio as a shape factor but it is known that th is i s not accurate when
Bi � . Smi th et al ( 1 967 ) , Smith et al ( 1 968 ) , Cl ary et al ( 1 968 ) ,
Smi th & Nelson ( 1 969 ) and Clary et al ( 1 97 1 ) def i ned a geometry i ndex
( the forerunner to EHTD ) , for the case of heat conduc t ion wi thout
change of phase and B i ��. For irregular geometr i es they calculated
the i r geometry i ndex from an e l l ipso ida l model shape that has equa l
orthogonal cross-sect ional areas and the same c haracter i s t i c th ickness
as those of the anoma l ous shape that it r eplac es .
The orthogonal
cross-secti ons taken were generally the smal l and largest that pass
through the thermodynami c c entre and l ie in the same p lane as the
character i st i c d imens ion . I t was unknown how th is method wou ld perform
for phase change and when B i -�.
For regular mul t i-d imens ional shapes use of the concepts of EHTD and
MCP led to accurate me thods to take accoun t of geometry in freez i ng and
thawing t i me pred i c tions . EHTD and MC P are calculated as funct ions o f
the Blot number and the two other geome try parameters C e 1 and e 2 ) that
d es cr ibe the regular geometr i es . It was cons i dered sens ib l e to try to
extend the methods to calculate EHTD and MC P t o irregular geometr i es .
I t was dec i ded to ignore any vari ation o f these geome t r i c factors w i th
Ste and Pk as th i s var i at ion would probably be small c ompared w i th the
Pred i c t ion o f Freez ing and Thawi ng Ti me s 1 99
Poss ibly use ful measures of the effect of the second and th ird
d i mens ions are :
( a) The rat i o between the max imum d istance from the thermodynamic
centre to the surface and D/ 2 .
( b ) The rat io o f the major ax i s leng th to the minor ax i s l eng th for an
e l l i p t i ca l model cross-sect ions equal in area to the orthogonal
cross-sect ions o f the anoma lous shape ( Smith et a l 1 967 ) .
( c ) The ratio of the volume o f the obj ect compared w i th the volume for
a i n f in i te cyl inder ( two-d imens ional shapes ) or sphere
( three-d i mens ional shapes ) o f the same surface area .
These three parame t er s are h ighly correlated with each other as they
all measure in some way , the d i stor t ion of the shape from a inf i n i te
cylinder or sphere . Each has some d ifferent propert i es so all three
were inves ti gated to see if they could ind i v i dual l y , or i n comb ination ,
Pred ict ion of Freezing and Thaw ing T imes 200
Both EHTD and MC P are defined for any shape as B i � by the AD /2V rat io .
There fore the requ irement i s to develop a me thod to calculate the
change in these factors w i th B iot number , in as s impl e and as accurate
a manner as poss ib l e . The calculat ion me thod should only u se eas i l y
measured o r est imated geometry parameters such as those d iscussed in
Sec . 1 0 . 2 .
There are few experiment al data for free z i ng and thawing o f irregular
shaped obj ec ts ava i l ab l e in the l i terature , for wh ich the geometry and
cond it ions are suff i c iently accurate ly descr i bed , measured and
contro l l ed to a l l ow the ir u se in the pr esent s tudy . For thi s reason ,
the method of analysi s app l i ed was the same as that used for r egul ar
shap es ( Sec . 9 . 4 ) . I n i t ia l l y only the ratios of numerically calculated
freez ing and thawi ng t imes for the actual shape , and for the r eference
s l ab were used in the development of the geome tr i c factor s . Onl y the
var i at ions due to geometry and the e ffect of Bi were apparent in these
Pred i c t ion o f Freez ing and Thaw i ng T i me s 20 1
numer i ca l data were only c a l c u l ated for the e ight two-d i mens i ona l
The data are g i ven i n Tab le C . 2 . To suppl ement the data base , the
i n format ion about the geome t r y can be i ncorporated . The r egu l ar shape
data both i ncreased the range o f geome t r y t yp e s and added i n format ion
EHTD G1 + G2 [� - ]( 1 f 1 5( V 1 ) + (1 - f l 5( V l ) ) IV
1 .4
l 7
[ ](
=
2A 1
L ,D f l 5( V2 ) 2. 5
1
_
+ G3 + ( 1 - f l 5( V2 ) ) I V2 7 ( 10. 1 )
2A 2
(
and
MC P
1 + ( 2 -G 1 ) f1 1 f 1 6 ( G2 , V 1 ) ) 0 . 65 B i 0 · 39 ( V 1 · 39 - 1 )
(
=
+ G3 f l 1 ( f l , ( G3 , V 2 ) ) 0 . 65 B i 0 . 39 v; · 2 6 - 1
+
rAD
L2v
I ( G1 + G2 rL l D -
I_2A 1
]
1 1 vl · 4 7 + G3 rL 0
L2A 2
2
- J
1 i v� · 7 5 ) - 1 ] o
o
(1 - f1 1 ( ( f 1 , ( G2 , V 1 ) + f 1 , ( G3 , V 2 ) ) I ( G2 G3 + 1) )) (1 0 •2)
where f 1 5 ( V ) • 3 . 56 1 v1 • 77 I ( Bi 1 · 3 4 + 3 . 56 1 v 1 · 7 7 )
f 1 ,( G, V) • G 3 .08/ v •
1 90
Pred iction o f Freezing and Thawing T imes 202
• X I ( B i 1 · 35 + X )
z per imeter l eng th o f the first and second
orthogonal cross-sec t ions (m)
area of the f ir s t and second or thogona l
cross-sect ions
rat io o f major a x i s leng th to minor ax i s l eng th for
an e l l i p se mode l l i ng an or thogona l cross- sec t ion
4A I nD 2
1
4A 2 1 nO 2
and the va lues of G1 , G2 and G3 are g i ven i n Tabl e 9 . 2 . Tab l e 1 0 . 1
g i ves the geome try parame ters used in Eqs . ( 1 0 . 1 ) and ( 1 0 . 2 ) for the
shapes used in th is study ( Tab les 6 . 6 and 6 . 7 ) .
Th ese equat ions use the second o f the shape parameters d i scussed in
Sec . 1 0 . 2 y e t are st i l l defin ite extens ions o f the methods deve loped i n
Sec . 9 . 4 f o r regular shap es . The techniques are s imi lar to that o f
Smith et al ( 1 967 ) in that the or thogona l cross - sect ions that pass
through the thermodynamic centre are used and the contribut ions to the
geometr i c factor calculated from each cross- sec t ion are summed ( th i s i s
also the case i n Eqs . ( 9 . 1 1 ) and ( 9 . 1 2 ) ) . Due to the l ack o f data ,
accurate f i t t i ng of all the coef f ic ients was not poss ible so many of
the coe f f i c ients have b een defined by ana logy to the methods developed
for the regular shape geometric factors ( for example ,
3 . 081 v 1 · 7 7 approx i mates 2 . 3 21 a 1 · 77 and B i 1 · 3 4 is reta ined to g ive the
B iot number we igh t i ng func t ions in the equat ion for EHTD ) . Equa t i ons
( 1 0 . 1 ) and ( 1 0 . 2 ) are very s i m i lar to Eqs . ( 9 . 1 1 ) and ( 9 . 1 2 ) because V
Equat ions ( 1 0 . 1 ) and ( 1 0 . 2 ) can be used in conj unct ion w i th any of the
slab pred i c t ion me thod that had prev iously been used w i th Eqs . ( 9 . 5 )
and ( 9 . 7 ) , to pred i c t freez ing and thawi ng t imes for objects o f any
shape . Table 1 0 . 3 summar i ses the pred i c t ions aga i ns t the exper imental
data of C l eland & Ear le ( 1 979b) and Tab les 6 . 5 , 6 . 6 and 6 . 7 for
rec tangular b r i ck s , two- d i mens ional irregular shap es and
three-d imens iona l irregular shapes .
The pred ic t ions were almost iden t i cal to those d i splayed for E q . ( 9 . 1 1 )
and ( 9 . 1 2 ) in Tab les 9 . 4 and 9 . 5 . Th is con firms that for regular
shapes , the general calculat ion me thods for EHTD and MCP ( Eq s . ( 1 0 . 1 )
and ( 1 0 . 2 ) ) are equ ivalent to the spec ial i se d methods ( Eq s . ( 9 . 1 1 ) and
( 9 . 1 2 ) ) , and do not add s i gn i f icant unc erta inty to freez ing or thaw i ng
t ime pred ict ions .
10.4.2 Freez ing and Thaw ing of Two-D imensional Irregular Shapes
For the two-d imensiona l irregular shape dat a the mean pre d i c t ion errors
us i ng E q . ( 1 0 . 1 ) and ( 1 0 . 2 ) to descr ibe geometry were sl ightly off- set
from z ero for both the geometr i c factors , and for both freez i ng and
thaw i ng . The standard dev iat ion was low and the correl a t i on
coe f f i c ient ( compared with the full f in it e e l emen t method results ) was
h igh . The magni tude of the 9 5 % conf i dence bounds for the pred i c t i on
errors was s imilar to the est imated exper imental error bounds for th i s
data ( Sec . 5 . 8 . 4 , Tab le 1 2 . 2 ) . Hence for the two-d i mens ional irregu l ar
shapes used ( all of wh ich had curved , ova l surfaces ) the lack of f i t o f
the geome tr i c fac tors calculated by Eqs . ( 1 0 . 1 ) and ( 1 0 . 2 ) does not
s i gn i f i cantly worsen the over a l l agreement w i th exper i ment al data
a l though there i s a sl i ght sh i ft o f the mean.
Pred ict ion o f Freez ing and Thawing Times 20 4
I n general the accuracy o f pred i c t ions for the three-d i mens ional
irr egular shapes was poorer than for the other shapes . Th is was
expected due to a h i gher exper imental unc erta inty for these shapes
( Sec . 5.9.4). The st andard dev iat ion o f the pred ictions were s i m i lar
to those for the ful l f i n i te e lement method r esu lts and the corre l a t ion
coe ff i c ient of the percentage d ifferences were h igh.
However , the mean pred i c t ion errors d i splayed d ifferen t trends to those
for the full f in i t e element results ( Tabl e 8 . 2 ) . For the py rami d shape
the mean pred i c t ion error was closer to z ero compar ed wi th the
under-pred ict i on shown by the full f i n ite e lement method results . As
d i scussed in Sec . 8 . 4 the off-set for the numer ical results was partly
caused by use o f a coarse spat ial gr id for the ca lcu lat ions . The
s i mp l e slab pred i c t ion me thods and Eqs . ( 1 0 . 1 ) and ( 1 0 . 2 ) were not
affec ted by th is problem so , as expec ted , for an accurate slab
pred i c t ion me thod the mean pred i c t ion error was not s i gn i f icant l y
d i fferent from z ero .
The same explanat ion app l ies for the sphere shape results . The
pred i c t ions for the ful l f in i te e lement me thod us ing a
three-d imens ional g r i d were o ff-set from z ero , but both the pred ict ions
for the f in i te e l ement method us i ng a f iner one-d i mens iona l g r i d and
those for the s impl e predict ion methods were not .
For the egg and f i sh shapes d ifferent trends were observed . The mean
pred iction error was h igher for the s i mple pred iction methods than the
nume r i cal me thods for the egg shape , but l ower for the f i sh shape . It
was d if f icult t o assess whether the d if ferenc es i n the mean p red ict ion
error s were apparent due to systematic error in the geome t r i c factors
for these shapes , because the numer i cal ca lculat ions were i n f luenced by
factors such as the coar se spatial grid ( Sec . 8 . 4 ) , or becau se the
pred i c t ions were affec ted by systemat i c error in the value of the
surface heat transfer coeffic ient used in calculations ( Sec . 8 . 4 ) . All
three reasons probably cont r i bu ted i n b oth case s .
Pred i c t ion of Freez ing and Thawing T imes 205
Because the pred i c t ions for the two-d i mens ional irregu lar shapes were
based on data for shapes w i th both rectangular and ova l cross-sections
and were qu i te prec ise , it was cons idered that the effect of the second
d imens ion was accurately mode lled by Eqs . ( 1 0 . 1 ) and ( 1 0 . 2 ) for both
ovo id and rectangular shapes . There fore any uncerta inty d ue t o the
geometr i c factors for the egg and f i sh shapes was thought to be in the
mode l l i ng of the e ffect of the th ird d i mens ion . Thi s is not surpr i si ng
as there were very few data ava i lab le to ana ly s i s the e ffect o f the
th ird d imens ion in three-d i mens ional irregul ar shap es . The ma i n r eason
for th i s was the large computat ion costs involved in numer i ca l
calculat ion for three-d i mens iona l ly irregular shapes . A typ i cal
calculat ion using the full f i n ite e lement method for the f i sh shape
took 1 50 000 sec . proc ess t i me on a Pr i me 750 computer . Th is meant
that the ana ly s i s was forced to re ly heav i ly on the rectangular brick
and f i n i te cyl inder shape data . These regular shapes have rectangul ar
cross-sect ions in the th ird d imens ion , not ova l as found in the eg g and
f i sh shap es . Consequently the coe f f ic ien ts in Eqs . ( 1 0 . 1 ) and ( 1 0 . 2 )
f i t ted data for shapes w i th rec tangular cross-sect ions in the th ird
d i mens ion and do not seem to be as accurate for shapes wi th other
geometries . To deve lop more accurate methods to calcu late the
geome tr i c fac tor s , EHTD and MC P , more data are requ ired . I f more
three-d imens i ona l irr egular shape data were ava i l ab l e , inc lud ing data
for shapes w i th oval cross- sec t ions in the th i rd d i mens io n , i t was fe l t
that the princ iples o f the methods to calculate EHTD and MC P ( Sec . 9 . 4 )
woul d not need to be changed ; only the values o f the coe f f i c ients i n
Eq . ( 1 0 . 1 ) and ( 1 0 . 2 ) ( and poss ibly the geometry parameter u sed ) , wou l d
a l ter to f i t the data .
Overall , the off-se t o f the mean for the pred ict ions using Eq . ( 1 0 . 1 )
and ( 1 0 . 2 ) was not cons idere d large i n relation to the inaccurac y o f
the exper i menta l data and the lac k o f su i tab le data to deve lop and test
the geomet r i c factor expr ess ions for three-d i mens ional i rregular
shapes .
Pre d i c t ion o f Freez ing and Thawing Times 206
The expressions for EHTD and MC P gave a lmost ident i ca l freez ing and
thawi ng t ime pred i c t ions for a l l shapes and could not be d i ff eren t iated
by the accuracy c r i ter ion alone . The express ion for EHTD was sl ightly
l ess complex i n i ts f inal form than the express ion fo r MCP . Becau se o f
the peak in MCP values at intermed iate B iot numbers it was mor e
d i f f i cu l t to f ind and curve-fi t a su i table expr ess ion fo r MCP than i t
was for EHTD .
The way in wh ich the equat ions for EHTD and MCP take account o f the
effect of Bi was thought to be un i ver sa l ly correct so the l imi ts o f
app l icab i l i t y w i th regard t o th is parameter are the same a s for
Eqs . ( 9 . 1 1 ) and ( 9 . 1 2 ) for regular shap es :
0.0 < Bi < 1 00 .
1 0 .5 SUMMARY
The princ iples under ly ing the methods to ca lcu late geometr i c fac tors
u s l ng the EHTD and MCP conc epts were sat i sfactori ly extended to
irregular geometr ies . In a simi lar manner to that used for regular
shap es in Chap . 9 and by Sm i th et al ( 1 967 ) for irregular shap es , the
effect o f each d imens ion was calculated separately by cons ider ing each
of the orthogonal cross-sec t ions that pass through the thermodynam ic
centre . The parame t er �=4A/ no 2 for these cross-sect ions was s imilar to
the parameter 8 used for regular shapes and allowed expres s ions to
ca lcul ate the two geome tr i c factors to be developed along s imi lar l i nes
to those used for regular shapes .
Used i n conj unct ion w i th accurate slab freez ing and thawi ng t ime
pred i c t ion methods the express ions developed for EHTD and MCP both gave
pred ictions of s i m i l ar accuracy to those ach ieved by numer i ca l methods
for rectangu l ar b r i cks and two-d i mens ional irregular shapes . The
geometr i c factors d id not add s i gn i f i cant uncertainty to the
pred ic t ions for these shapes .
For the three- d i mens ional irregular shapes the accuracy of the
geome tr i c factors was l ower than for the two-d i mens ional irregular
shapes . Th i s was attribu ted to l ess accurate modell ing o f the e ffect
o f the th ird d i mens ion r ather than error in mode l l i ng of the effect o f
the second d imension o r because the princ iples o f the calcul at ion
method were i napprop r i ate as the pred i c t ions for the two-d i mens i onal
Pred ict ion o f Free z i ng and Thaw i ng Time s 208
The methods developed are accurate for most two-d imens iona l objects but
are rest r i c ted to three-d i mens ional obj ec ts w i th rectangular
cross-sections in the th ird d imens ion . For these shapes the methods do
not add s ign i f i cant ly to the pred i c t ion unc erta inty . For o ther shapes
lower accuracy was apparent .
The present ana l y s i s was l im i ted by the smal l data set , and by
d i ff icul t i es in obta i n i ng accurate exper imenta l measurements espec ially
for three-d imensiona l irregu lar shapes . More da ta wou ld enab l e more
accurate and un i ver sa l ly app l i cable express ions to ca lculate EHTD and
MC P to be deve loped . Sub stant ial comput i ng costs wou ld have to be
borne in order to do th i s wor k .
Pred ict ion of Freez ing and Thaw i ng T i me s �9
Table 1 0 . 1 Parame ters For Calculat ion of the Effec t of Geometry For
Irr egular Shap es
Shape 1 0
& Code
( m)
Dat a Slab Pred ict ion Geometr i c 1 Mean Std Dev 2 Min 2 Max 2 Corr 3
Me thod Factor ( %) (%) ( %) (%) FDM
• • • cont i nued
Tab l e 1 0 . 3 cont inued • • • 212
Data Slab Pred ict ion Geometr ic 1 Mean Std Dev 2 Min 2 Max 2 Corr 3
Method Factor (%) ( %) ( %) (%) FDM
FEM'' 1 .5 5.5 -7 . 1 1 1 .3 1 . 00
EIITD 5. 1 5.2 -6 . 7 19.0 0 . 79
FDM
MCP 5.0 5.3 -6. 7 1 9 .2 0 . 80
Two-
D imens ional EHTD 5.2 5.2 -6 . 7 1 9 .2 0 . 85
Irregular Eq. ( 7 . 2 )
MC P 5.2 5.3 -6 . 7 1 9 .3 0 . 86
Tha w i ng
EHTD 5.6 5.4 -7 . 4 16.5 0 . 82
( Tabl e 6 . 6 ) Eq . ( 7 . 3 )
MC P 5.6 5.5 -7 . 4 1 6. 7 0 . 83
( 4 1 runs )
EHTD 6.4 5.6 -7 . 8 1 8.9 0 . 82
Eq. ( 7 . 4 )
MC P 6.3 5.7 -7.8 19.1 0 . 83
EIITD 6.0 5.6 -5. 1 20 . 2 0 . 86
Eq. ( 7 .5 )
MC P 5.9 5.7 -5 . 1 20 . 3 0 . 87
or Eq. ( 7 . 5 ) MC P -2 . 2 8.8 -1 1 .3 1 0 .5 0 . 95
• • • cont inued
Tab le 1 0 . 3 con t i nued • • • 21 3
Data Slab Pred ict ion Geomet r i c 1 Mean Std Dev 2 Min 2 Max 2 Corr 3
• • • cont i nued
Tab l e 1 0 . 3 cont inued • . • 214
Data Slab Pred ict ion Geometr ic 1 Mean Std Dev 2 Min 2 Max 2 Corr 3
Method Factor (%) ( %) (%) (%) FDM
FEM .. 35 . 3 8.9 20 . 8 44 . 2 1 . 00
EHTD 15.3 7.3 6.2 24 .6 0 .88
FDM
MC P 12.3 7.0 2.5 20 . 4 0 . 89
Eq . ( 7 . 7 ) EHTD 1 7 .9 7. 1 7.7 28 . 5 0 . 72
or Eq . ( 7 . 2 )
F i sh MC P 1 4 .8 6.3 5.9 24 . 1 0 .79
( Tabl e 6 . 7 ) Cleland & EHTD 19. 1 10.3 2.9 34 . 8 0 . 67
Ear le 1 98 2 b
( 6 runs ) or Eq . ( 7 . 3 ) MCP 1 6 .0 9.3 1.1 30 . 2 0 73
•
In Sec . 6 . 1 it was dec ided to exclude var iat i o n o f N ( the ratio o f the
2
unfroz en to the fr ozen volumetric spec ific heat capac i ty ) , and N 3 ( the
ratio of the unfrozen to th e froz en thermal conductiv ity ) , in the ma in
thaw ing e x perimental des ign as the effect o f these factors was expected
to be smal l . Howe ver some t es t ing was requ ired to ensure that th i s was
the case . Also to comp lete the testing of freez ing and thaw i ng t i me
p r ed i ct ion me thods , a l l avai labl e accurate e xper imenta l data - for as
many geome tr i es , cond i t io ns and phase change materials as poss ib le
should be used .
In the l i terature no exper i mental thaw ing data for foods were found for
wh ich the cond i t ions and geome tr ies were suf f ic ien t l y acc urate l y
measured , descr i b ed and cont rol led for them t o b e use d t o test
pr ed ic t ion me thod s . Howe v er , in the present stu dy f our teen thaw i ng
exper iments were conducted w i th minced l e an beef ( Table 6 . 8 ) .
( Sec . 5 .7 . 3 )
The nume r i c al me thods to pre d ict freez ing and thawi ng t i me s had
prev i ously been compared wi th mo s t of the
compos i t e data set for
freez ing ( Cl e land & Earle 1 98 4a ) and for thaw ing of Ty lose ( Sec . 7 . 2
and Chap . 8 ) . Numer ica l me thod pred i c t ions were mad e for the rema i n i ng
thaw ing dat a for mi nced lean beef a nd the more r ecently publ ished
freez i ng dat a , ( marked in Tab l e 1 1 . 1 ) , to comp l e te the compar i son . The
f i n it e d i fference me thod was used for regular shapes and the f in i te
elemen t me thod for irregul ar shapes . The th erma l p roper ty dat a u sed
wer e those given by Cl e land & Earle ( 1 98 4 a ) . For Ty lose and m i nced
lean bee f these are cons is ten t wi th , a l though s l i ghtly d i f fer e nt to ,
the da ta in Table 5 . 1 . The pred ict ions are summa r i se d i n Table 1 1 . 2
( for thaw i ng o f minced lean bee f ) and Table 1 1 . 4 ( for freez i ng o f
mul t i -d imens ional shap es ) .
For the two-d imens ional irregular shapes the former was cons ide red most
l ik e l y . Measur ed rates o f temperature change w i th t ime were
con s i s tently under-pred icted by the f in i te e lement method thr oughou t
bo th the freez i ng or thaw i ng proc esses for b oth the shapes u sed
( Fi g . 6 . 1 9 ) . Al though thermocouple placement error may have
contr ibuted to oc ca s ional und er-pred i c t io n , the under-pred i c t io n was
too cons is tent for th is factor alone to expla i n the observed
t emperature prof i l es . Hen ce the assump t i on made in Sec . 5 . 8 . 3 that
both the contac t res i s ta nc e between the Tylose and the mou ld wall and
the contac t res is tan ce b etween the minc ed lean beef and the mould wall
were equal , may not be correct . The d if ference may have ari sen b ec ause
Tylo se i s a dry gel , whereas minced lean beef has a f ib r ou s , mo i s t
Test i ng of Pred ict ion Methods 21 7
nature ( Sec . 5 . 7 . 3 ) .
The o ther data set s for wh ich o ff se t s from z ero were s i g n i f icant were
al l t aken from th e l i terature . It was d if f icu lt t o as sess wh ether
inappro p r i ate therma l dat a , or ex per imental inaccuracy cause d the
problems in these data sets . I n several cases surfac e heat transf er
coe f f ic ients were not determi ned i ndependently of the freez ing
exper i men t s . It is v ery unl ike ly that p roblems in th e f in i te
d ifferenc e or f i n i te element method c alcu lat ions were th e cause as the
pr ograms were t es ted r i gorously ( Chap . 4 ) and i t has been demonstrated
in th is study that they performed well for 90% of the whole data se t .
The standa rd dev i a t ions o f pred i c t ion error s wer e general ly l arger for
food ex per i ments than for Ty lose exper iments ( for example - Ty los e slab
tha w i ng , 3 . 5 % ; min ced lean bee f s l a b th aw i ng , 5 . 9% ) . Th i s r e f l ec ts
the d i f f i c ult ies d isc ussed previously in exper imenting w i th food
mater ials ( Sec . 5 . 2 ) .
It shou ld be noted that some indiv idual se ts o f data are very sma l l
( l ess than s i x runs ) , s o pred i c t io n error means and standard dev i at i ons
calc ulated for these se ts are less mean ing ful than thos e for larg e data
set s . Simi lar l y , when simpl e pred i c t i on methods are eval ua ted in
Sec . 1 1 . 3 , the c orre lat i on coe f f ic ients bet ween these methods and th e
nume r ical method pred ic t i on resu l ts for such s ma l l data se ts shou l d be
v i ewed in the same way .
If the e ffec ts of N 2 and N 3 are un imp ortant , results calc ulated us ing
prev i ously-recommended s i mp l e pred i c t ion formulae ( Sec . 7 . 3 . 3 ) wou l d b e
expected to match results for the nume rical methods ( s imi lar mean
pred i c t io n error and h i gh corre lat io n coeff ic ients ) , as wel l a s be i ng
i n general a greemen t w i th the exper i mental t i me s . Very good agreement
wi th al l o f the exper i men t s w ould not b e ex pec ted in the l ig h t of the
poor n ume r i c a l method pred i c t i o ns for some data .
Tab l e 1 1 . 2 summar i ses the pred i c t io n acc uracy for the four simp l e slab
thawi ng t i me predi c t i o n formulae ( Eqs . ( 7 . 2 ) to ( 7 .5 ) ) u se d in
Tes t i ng of Pred i c t ion Meth ods 218
conj unc t io n w ith the two geometr ic factors ( Eqs . ( 1 0 . 1 ) and ( 1 0 . 2 ) ) for
the minced lean beef data ( Tab le 6 .8 ) . The thermal pr oper ty data u sed
ar e g i v en in Table 5 . 2 . As both the mean and standard dev iatio ns o f
the pred i c t ion error s ar e s i mi lar t o tho se for the numer i ca l me thods it
was conc luded that any inacc uracy a r i s ing from n eglect o f N2 and N 3 was
suff ic i en t l y smal l to be ignored .
Cleland & Earle ( 1 984a , 1 98 4 b ) and Pham ( 1 983 , 1 98 4 c ) use d the data of
Cle land & Ear l e ( 1 97 7 a , 1 97 9 a , 1 979b ) , de M i chel i s &
Ca lve lo ( 1 983 ) and
Hung & Thompson ( 1 983 ) to test methods to p redict freez ing t i mes . I t
was cons idered worthwhi le to ca lculate resu l t s equ iva l e nt to Tab l e 1 o f
Cl e land & Earle ( 1 98 4b) for Eq. ( 7 . 7 ) , th e o n e new freez ing me thod
under cons ide rat ion her e . The resu l t s a r e g i ven i n Table 1 1 . 3 . For
data to a f i nal thermodynamic centre temper ature other than - 1 0 °C , the
mod i f icat i on o f Cle land & Ear le ( 1 98 4 b) was used to correc t the
pred iction o f Eq. ( 7 . 7 ) wh ich i s based on a f inal th ermodynamic c entre
temperature o f - 1 0 °C . The therma l property data g iven by Cl e land &
Ea r l e ( 1 984a) were u se d to be cons is ten t w i th the prev i ously publ i sh ed
results .
S i rice the previous stud ies , some new slab data have been pub l i shed by
Succar & Hayakawa ( 1 9 84 ) . The se are a lso i nc l uded in Table 1 1 . 3 . W i th
the thermal property data use d , ne i ther these n i n e runs , nor resul t s
from the same l aboratory for o th er shapes ( Hawak awa e t a l 1 983a ) shown
in Table 1 1 . 4 co uld be predic ted accurately by any of the methods
cons idered , inc lud i ng the f in i te d i f ferenc e me thod .
mu l t i -d imens io na l shap e freez ing and tha w i ng data ( Chap . 1 0 and Tab l e
1 1 .2) . In Table 1 1 . 4 , the pred ict ion results of these s imple
pred i c t ion me thods ar e summar i se d for the rema in i ng mu l t i -d imens iona l
shap e dat a from the compos i te data se t of Tab le 1 1 . 1 . Becau se a l l four
s l ab approaches are app rox imate ly equ ival en t , only one was used in th is
analy si s . The method of Pham ( 1 98 4 c ) was arb itra r i ly chos en . Aga in ,
th e s imp l e pred ict i on me thod resu l ts c l ose ly fol low the numer i ca l
method pred ictions and ag ree a s well as cou ld b e expec ted w i th the
ex per imental dat a . No s ign i ficant d i f ferenc e in pred ict ion acc uracy
between MC P and EHTD cou ld be d iscerned .
1 1 .4 SUMMARY
Numer ical freez ing and thaw ing t ime pred ict ion me thods were sl igh t ly
l ess accurat e for food mater ials than for Tylo se due to l arger thermal
property dat a and expe r i mental uncertaint i es .
Tab l e 1 1 1 Composi te Data Set For Tes t ing of Freez i ng and Tha w i ng Ti me
•
Tylose Slab -1 0 . 0 43
Cleland & Ear l e 1 977a Le an Bee f Slab - 1 0 .0 6
Po tato Slab -1 0 . 0 6
Freez i ng
Cl e land & Ear le 1 97 9 a Ty lose Cy l inder - 1 0 .0 30
Cleland & Ear l e 1 979a Tylo se Sph ere -10.0 30
Cl e land & Ear le 1 97 9b Ty lose Br ick - 1 0 .0 72
Tylos e Slab -1 8 .0 23
Lean B ee f Slab - 1 8 .0 9
Freez ing Hung & Thompson 1 983 Potato Slab - 1 8 .0 9
Ground Beef Slab -18.0 9
Car p Slab -1 8 .0 9
• • • continued
Tab l e 1 1 . 1 con t inued • • • 221
Data Slab Pred iction Geometr ic 1 Mean Std De v 2 Min 2 Max 2 Corr 3
Method Factor ( %) ( %) ( %) (%) FDM
' Correlat ion coeff ic ient ( r ) compared w ith the perc entage d if ferences
for ei ther the full f in i te d i fferen ce method or the ful l f ini te
element method .
" Full f in i t e d iffer ence method or full f in it e f i ni t e e lement method .
Tes t ing of Pred i c t ion Methods 223
Sou rce Shape Mate r i a l Geometr i c Mean Std Dev 3 M i n 3 Max 3 Corr �
Fac tor 2 (%) (%) (% ) ( % ) FOM
Br ick
Lean Beef EHTD 4.2 6.9 - 1 2 .6 1 3 .6 0 .84
( 1 7 runs )
MC P 2.8 6 .0 - 1 2 .5 1 0 .0 0 .89
et a l
1 98 3 Finite FDM 5 66 . 9 1 9 .9 45 . 2 9 1 . 5 1 .00
Cyl inder
Ty lose EHTD 80 . 8 21 . 5 57 . 5 1 07 . 3 1 .0 0
( 6 run s )
MC P 80 . 9 22 . 3 56. 8 1 08 2 • 1 00•
It was also cons idered use ful t o compare pred ict ion method per formance
to est i mates of the random exper i mental unc erta inty . I n thi s s tudy an
est imate of the exper imenta l uncerta inty cou ld only be der i ved for the
exper i menta l work of Cleland ( 1 977 ) and the present work . Tab l e 1 2 . 2
compares the estimated random e xper imental uncerta inty w i th the 95%
conf idenc es bounds for the pred i c t ion error s o f both the best numer i ca l
and s imple pred ict ion methods , for each shape tested.
Throughou t the testing aga inst exper imenta l data ( summar i sed in Tab les
1 2 . 1 and 1 2 . 2 ) it has been shown that the f in i te d i fferenc e and f in i te
element numer ical methods do not introduce s i gn i f icant pred ict ion
unc ertainty prov i ded that they are correctly formu l ated and
implemented . The users of these methods need to meet the gu idel ines
for space and t i me s t ep int ervals est ab l i shed in Sec . 8 . 5 for the
f i n i te e l ement method .
The d i f ferenc e b etween the predict ion error 95% confi dence bounds for
the numer ical me thods and the es timated random expe r i mental uncerta inty
bounds in Table 1 2 . 2 g ive in most cases an ind icat ion o f the thermal
property unc erta inty .
The off-set mean error for the rectangular brick freez ing data and the
larger numer ical pred i c t ion error bounds for both the slab and
rec tangu lar brick freez ing data are most probab ly the resu lt o f
freez i ng rate e ffects that the numer ical me thod calcu l a t ions d i d not
take into account ( Cl e land et al 1 982 ) . The l arger spread of
pred i c t ion errors and the off- se t mean for the thr ee-d i mensional
irregular numer ical p red ict ions have p robab ly ar i se n as a result o f
b e i ng forced to use coarse spatial gr ids . They could a lso r e f l ect
substant ial systemat i c exper imental errors ( part i cular ly in measurement
Evalua t ion of Pred iction Methods 227
All four emp ir ical approaches gave similar pred ict ion accuracy for the
compo s i te data set for both freez ing and thaw i ng . The s impl e method
pred i c t i ons all generally matched the numer i ca l method pred ict ions , and
the mean pred i c t ion error s were not s i gn i f i can tly o ff- set from z ero .
For freez ing the formulae for the two approaches of Calv e lo ( 1 98 1 ) and
C l e l and & Ear le ( 1 976b ) ( Eq . ( 7 . 7 ) and Cleland & Earle ( 1 9 82 b ) ) , were
not quite as h ighly correlated with the numer i ca l method results as the
o ther approaches ; probably because these formulae were based on
curve- f i t t ing to a sma l ler data set than the other formulae .
Tabl e 1 2 . 2 shows that the confi dence bounds for the simple methods are
cons i stent wi th the numer ical pred i ct ions and wi th the exper imental
error bounds . Hence , there i s no ev idence in th i s tabl e that s impl e
pred ic t ion method inaccuracy i s s ign i f i can t compared t o exper i mental or
thermal proper ty data error .
Evaluat ion o f Pred ict ion Methods 228
The accuracy of al l four approaches was such that deve l opment of other
emp ir ical methods was not consi dered wor thwh i l e .
I t i s unl ikely that
s ign i f ican t l y better pred i c t ion accuracy could be ach ieved unl ess
better exper imen tal data are col lected . Marg ina l increases i n acc uracy
coul d be ach ieved i f further terms were added , but at the r i s k that a
systemat i c component o f the exper imenta l error was be ing f i t t e d .
Two way s o f calcu l a t i ng each of the geome t r i c fac tor s , EHTD and MCP ,
were proposed Eqs . ( 9 . 1 1 ) and ( 9 . 1 2 ) for EHTD and MC P respec t i vely
for regular shapes and Eqs . ( 1 0 . 1 ) and ( 1 0 . 2 ) r espec t i ve ly for
irregu lar shapes . For regular shapes the latter equat ions to ca lculate
EHT D an d MCP ( Eqs . ( 1 0 . 1 ) and ( 1 0 . 2 ) ) gave almost equal values as
Eqs . ( 9 . 1 1 ) and ( 9 . 1 2 ) . Therefore only Eq . ( 1 0 . 1 ) ( EHTD ) and
Eq. ( 1 0 . 2 ) ( MC P ) were compar ed d irectly .
The two g eometr i c factors gave v irtua lly ident ica l overa l l pred ict ion
accuracy for the compos i te data set as wel l as a l mo s t i den t i ca l
ind iv idual predict ions . The formula for EHTD ( Eq. ( 1 0 . 1 ) ) was l ess
complex than the formula for MCP because the MC P func t ion goes through
a max imum va lue at intermed iate B lot nu mber values , wh ich was d i ff icult
to curve- f i t i n a s i mp l e manner . I t was found eas i er t o f i t the EHTD
relat ionsh ip f i r s t and use the inter-relat ionsh ip between EHTD and MC P
to der i ve the MCP equat i ons .
There may be no need for other geometr i c concep ts because b oth EHTD and
MC P seem c apab l e of g iv i ng suff ic ient accuracy for a wide range o f
shapes . The proposed calculat ion formulae are l east accurate for
calcu l a t i ng the effect of the th ird d i mens ion in irregul ar shapes .
Th is s i tua t ion has ar i sen more from the spar s i ty o f su itab l e data , than
from inappr op r i ate p r i nc iples in the geome t r i c factor s themsel ves .
Collect ion o f the necessary data would be expens ive , but no problems in
mod i fy i ng the EHTD and MC P equations are env i saged because all the
present work has shown that the princ iples on wh ich they are based are
sound . Tab l e 1 2 . 1 inc ludes few data wi th irregular th ird d ime ns ions so
th is one area of weakness i s not apparent in i t .
The cho ice be tween the geome t r i c fac tors i s probably b est made by
ind i v i duals on the bas i s of ease of understand ing of the concep t s .
Some may f ind EHTD eas ier t o v i sua l i se and others MCP .
The desirab l e attr ibu tes of a freez ing or thaw ing t ime pred ict i o n
me thod other than accuracy a r e l i sted in Table 3 . 1 . Al l four s i mp l e
approaches invest i gated had some of these attr i bu tes . Each approach
led to freez i ng and tha w i ng t i me pred i c t ion formu l ae wi th s im i l ar forms
so that a un i f i ed approach for freez ing and thaw ing t i me pred ict ion
could be used .
Compar i sons of the me r i t s of numer ica l methods and simple formulae for
freez i ng and thaw i ng t i me pred i c t ions are ma de by Cleland ( 1 977 ) ,
C l e land & Earle ( 1 977 a , 1 98 4 a ) and Heldman ( 1 983 ) . Br i e f ly , nu mer i ca l
me thods ha ve the advantages o f flex ib i l i t y and re l i ab i l i ty for a wi de
range of cond i tions , whereas s i mp le me thods are l ess comp l e x , eas i er
and l ess cos t l y to u se i n ca lculat ions , have fewer thermal property
data requ ir ements but have a more rest r i cted range of app l i cab i l i ty .
Tab l es 1 2 . 1 and 1 2 . 2 show that the numer ical and s i mp l e pred i c t ion
methods gave comparab l e pred i c t ion accuracy . The s i mple method results
dev iated from the nume r i cal resu l t s for only three se ts o f dat a , but
these dev iat ions can be exp la ined . F i rs t l y , the nume r i cal results for
s l ab and rectangular b r i ck freez i ng wer e par t icular ly affected by rate
effects ( Cl e land et a l 1 982 ) . Second ly , coarse spat i a l gr i ds were used
in the cal c u l a t ions for three-d i me ns ional irregu l ar shapes , and th i s
introduc ed numer i c a l method error . T h i r d ly , the lack of su i t ab l e data
meant that the s i mpl e me thods geome t r i c factors were not as accurate
for three-d ime ns iona l irregular shapes as they may have been w i th an
extended data se t .
In Chap . 3 i t was dec ided tha t the ent i r e f i e ld of freez i ng and thaw i ng
t i me pred i c t ion cou l d not be c overed comprehe ns i ve ly . The present
s tudy therefore cons i dered on ly phase change w i th constant cond i t ions
Eva lua t ion o f Pred i c t ion Methods 23 1
12.7 SUMMAR Y
All four s i mpl e emp ir ical approaches in comb ina t i on w i th both EHTD and
MC P are accurate freez ing and thaw ing t i me p red ictors , per form ing very
s im i lar ly to the nume r i ca l me thod s . None of the me thods had attr i bu tes
that par t i cu larly recommended it so all ar e advocated as su itab l e for
rou t i ne use . The h i ghest leve l o f prec i s ion i s probably obta inable by
averag ing pred ict ion from more than one o f the me thods .
Evalua t i o n o f Pred i c t i o n Methods 2 32
Nume r i c a l 3 -0 . 8 7.9 1 . 00
E q . ( 7 .7 ) 1 .0 7 .3 0 .70 0 .5 7 .3 0 . 73
C l e land & Earle 1 9 82b 1 .8 7 .5 0 . 68 1 .3 7 .5 0 . 72
Pham 1 98 4 c 1 .8 7.4 0 . 80 1 .3 7 .6 0 .81
Pham 1 9 83 ( E q . ( 7 . 6 ) ) 0.8 7.4 0 . 86 0.3 7.6 0 . 87
THAW ING ( 23 2 ru ns )
Tab l e 1 2 . 2 Comp ar i so n o f the Est imated Expe r i ment a l Unc erta in t y Bounds
and the Means and 95 % Conf idenc e Bounds For th e Numer i c a l 1
and Simp le 2 Fr eez ing and Thaw ing T i me Pred ict ion Me thods
F ±4 . 2 7 0.8 ±1 2 . 2 1 .9 ±8 . 7
Slab
T ±5 . 3 -0 . 8 ±7 . 0 0.5 ±1 0 . 9
F ±6 . 5 7 -3 . 6 ±9 .5 -1 .0 ±8 . 4
Cy l i nder
T ±6 . 1 -2 . 2 ±4 . 7 -1 . 4 ±6 . 8
F ±7 . 0 7 -2. 2 ±6 . 9 -0 . 3 ±7 . 9
Sphere
T ±8 .0 -0 . 9 ±1 1 1 • 1 .1 ±1 3 . 0
F ±8 .0 7 -4 . 4 ±1 3 . 1 -0 . 9 ±1 2 . o
Br i ck
T ±5 . 4 0.6 ±6 . 3 -1 . 9 ±9 . 8
201 F ,T ±8 . 9 0.3 ±1 0 . 2 5.1 ±1 0 .5
Rect F ,T ±9 . 6 -10 .3 ±1 3 . 4 0.2 ±1 5 . 9
3D1 8
Ova l F ,T ±1 4 . 3 1 1 .7 ±40 . 2 1 2 .3 ±2 1 . 6
1 The f i n it e d i ffer enc e me thod for r egular shapes and the full f in i te
elemen t method for i rr egu l ar shape s .
2 Avera ge o f the four best slab pred ict ion methods , results were n early
i den t ic a l us i ng e i ther EHTD or MC P as th e geome t r i c fac tor .
3 Data fr om C l e land 1 97 7 and Tab les 6 . 2 , 6 . 3 , 6 . 4 , 6 . 5 , 6 . 6 , and 6 . 7 •
13 CONCLUSI ONS
The dat a measured i n the pr es ent wor k r e pr es ent a maj or addi t i o n to the
sets of accurat ely measur ed and cont r ol l ed e xper i ment a l data f or
free z i ng and thawi ng of foods . The 297 experiments i nclude 1 82 for
thaw i ng of regu l ar sha pes and 1 1 5 f or bot h free z i ng and tha w i ng of
i rr e gul ar shapes .
O f the numer i cal methods ava i l abl e thos e that take account of the
con t i n uousl y t emper atur e- variable thermal proper ti es model the t r ue
physi ca l behavi our dur i ng free z i ng and t haw i ng of foods mos t c l os el y .
T es ti ng showed that t h ese methods w ere acc ur ate pred i ctors of
temper ature/ t i me prof i l es .
The f i ni te d i ff er ence method is restri cted by pract i cal cons i derat i ons
to use f or regul ar sha p es . T es t i ng agai nst e x perimental data indi cated
that prov i ded suf f i c i en t l y small space and t i me steps wer e used i n a
corr ect l y f ormul at ed and impl emented comput er program , the predi ct i on
method uncer t a i nt y i n pred i c t i ng free z i ng and thawi ng t im es of r egul ar
shapes was i ns i gn i f i cant .
No accurate s i mpl e method t o pred i ct t haw i ng t i mes that was not pr oduc t
s pec i f i c was found i n the l i t erat ure . For thawi ng of slabs , i nf i n i t e
cyl i nders and s pheres , four s i mpl e but gener a l l y appl i cabl e formul ae
w er e develo ped . They were al l e qual l y acc urate wi th 95% conf i dence
Conclusi ons 23 5
When compar ed w i th the compos i te exper i mental freezi ng and t hawi ng dat a
s e t for a r ange of materi als , geomet r i es and condi tions , both t he
numer i ca l and s i mp l e pred i ct i on met hods gave accurate pred i ct i ons .
None of the four simpl e slab pred i c t i on method approaches has any
advant age t hat par t i cular l y r ecommended it so all ar e advocated as
sui tabl e for routine use . Both E HTD and MCP gave v i rt ual l y i denti cal
pred i ct i ons for mul ti - d imen s i onal shapes . U sers may w i sh to bas e t he
cho i c e of whi ch to use on their conceptual un derstan d i ng of t he
pr i nc i pl es i nvolved . I n pract i ce i t would be e xpected that any of the
predi c t i on methods advocated i n this s t udy would be l i mi ted more by t he
accuracy of dat a to be used i n the pred i ct i ons , than by l imi tat ions in
the acc uracy of the methods themsel ves .
236
NOMENCLATURE
N1 �
C s ( T if -T f i n ) / 6H for fre ez i ng
c 1 ( T f i n -T i f ) / 6H for tha w ing
N2 C l /C s
N3 = kl / ks
P geometr i c factor i n vers ions of Plank ' s equat ion
Pk c 1 T i n -T i f i / 6H , Plank number
Pk C l ( T in -T i f ) / 6H , Plank number for freezing
C s ( T i f -T i n ) / 6H , Plank number for thawi ng
Q internal heat gener at i on
r distanc e in rad ial direction m
R hal f th i ckness or rad ius m
R geometr ic fac tor i n vers ions of Plank ' s equat ion
S sur face area m2
c T -T I I �H , Stefan number
Ste I if a
Ste C s ( T i f - T a ) / �H , Ste fan number for free z i ng
C l ( T a -T if ) / �H , Stefan number for thawi ng
t time s or hrs
T temperature °C or K
I vector of nodal temperatures °C or K
V volume m3
W fac tor for axisymmetr i c f i n i te element integrat ions
X distance i n x d i rect ion m
X Biot number we i ght ing funct ion for EHTD and
MCP calcul a t i ons
X constant i n the FDM schemes
y d i s tance i n y d i rect ion m
Y frac t i onal unaccompl i shed temperature change
z ( T a-T ) / ( T a-T i n )
Y constant i n the FDM schemes
z distance i n z d irect ion m
Subsc r i pt s
a amb i e nt value
ac amb i ent convec t i ve value
ar amb i en t rad i at i ve value
ave average value
c centre va lue
con value for convect ion
cyl value for cyl i nder
e element or surface value
exp exper imental value
f for free z i ng
f ful l me thod
fdm value pred i c ted by the f i n i te d i f ference method
fern value pred i c t ed by the f i n i t e e l ement me thod
femf ful l f i n i te element method formulat ion
ferns s i mp l i f i ed f i n i t e e l ement method formula t i on
fin f i nal value
i denotes pos i t i on o f node in x d irec t i on
i val ue for i th node
if value a t i n i t i a l freez i ng point
in i n i t i a l value
j denotes pos i t ion o f node i n y d irect ion
j value for j th node
k denotes pos i t ion o f node i n z d irec t ion
1 unfrozen phase value
m denotes pos i t i on of node i n r d irec t ion
r value i n the r ad i al d irect ion
rad val ue for rad iat ion
s frozen phase value
s s impl i f i ed method
Nomencl at ure 23 9
Superscr i p ts
REFER ENCES
3 29
Chung , B . T . F . & Yeh , L . T . ( 1 9 76 ) : Freez i ng and mel t i ng of materials
wi th vari able thermal propert ies and arbitra r y heat f l ux es . AIAA J
..!2!. ( 3 ) :
•
388
References 2 43
..!. : 1 1 3
Cordel l , J . M . & Webb , D . C . ( 1 97 2 ) : The freez i ng o f i c e cr eam .
Pro c . I n t . Symp . Heat Mass Transfer Probl ems Food Engng 2 : 03 . 1
Cowan W . B . ( 1 9 58 ) : Freez i ng me thods and trends in C anada .
Bul i I . I . R . Annexe-1 : 65
•
Glasser , D . & Kern , J . ( 1 978 ) : Bo unds and approx ima t e solut i ons to
l i near probl ems w i th non-l i near boundary cond i tions : sol i d i f ic a t i on
of a slab . AIChE J . 2 4 : 1 6 1
Golov k i n , N . A . , Ge i n z , R . G . , Maslova , G . V . & Nozdrunkova , I . R . ( 1 97 4 ) :
Stud i es of mea t sub - freez l ng processes and it ' s appl i ca t ion for col d
storage of an imal p roduc t s . Proc . 1 3 th Int . Cong r . Refr i g . 1 = 2 2 1
Goodl i ng , J . S . & Khad er , M . S . ( 1 97 4 ) : Inward so l i d i f i c at i on w i t h
rad i a t ion-convect ion boundary condi t ion . J . Heat Transf er 9 6 : 1 1 4
Goodl i n� , J . S . & Khade r , M . S . ( 1 9 75 ) : Results of th e numer i ca l
so lut1 on of ou tward sol i d i f i cat ion w i th f l u x boundary cond i t ions .
J . Heat Transfer 97 : 307
Goodman, T . R . ( 1 95 8 ) : The heat balance i nt egral and i t s appl i ca t i o n
to problems i nvolv i ng a change o f phase . Trans A . S . M . E . 80 : 3 3 5
Goodman , T . R . & Shea , J . J . ( 1 9 60 ) : Th e me l t i ng of f i ni te sl abs .
J . Appl . Mech . 27 : 1 6
Goodma n , T . R . ( 1 96 1 ) : The heat balance integral - fur the r
cons i dera t i ons and ref ineme nts . J . Heat Transf er 8 3 : 83
Goodman , T . R . ( 1 96 4 ) : Applicat ion of int egra l methods to trans i ent
non - l l near heat transfer . Adv . Heat Transfer 1 : 5 1
Goodr i ch , L . E . ( 1 9 78 ) : Eff ic ient nume r i ca l techn ique for
one-d i mens iona l thermal probl ems wi th phase change . I nt . J . Heat
Mass Transfer 2 1 : 6 1 5
Goren flo , D . & Mertz , K . ( 1 9 7 5 ) : Exper i mental i nv est igat i o n i n to the
fr eez i ng of pack e ts of Tyl ose in domes t i c freezer s . L . W . T . Report
8 (4 ) : 1 85
Gu pta , R . S . & Kumar , D . ( 1 9 80 ) : A mod i f i ed var i able t i me s t ep method
for the one-d i mens ional Stefan p robl em .
Comp . Me th . A ppl . Mech . Engng 23 : 1 01
Gup t a , R . S . & Kumar , D . ( 1 98 1 ) : Var i ab l e t i me step methods for
one-d imensional St efan probl ems wi th m i x ed boundary cond i t i ons .
I n t . J . Heat Mass Transfer 2 4 : 25 1
Gup t a , R . S . & Kumar , D . ( 1 9 84 ) : An effic ient ap proach to i so th erm
m i grat ion i n two d imens ions . In t . J . Hea t Mass Transf er 27 : 1 9 39
Hahne , E . & Gr igul l , U . ( 1 975 ) : Shap e factor and shape r es i st ance for
steady mul t i - d i me ns ional heat conduc t ion. Int . J . Heat Mass Transfer
1 8 : 75 1
Haj i - She ikh , A . & S parrow , E . M . ( 1 967 ) : The solut ion of hea t
conduc t ion p robl ems by probab i l i ty me thods . J . Hea t Transf er 89 :
1 21
Hal e , N . W . & V i skan t a � R . ( 1 9 80 ) : Sol i d-l i qu i d phase change heat
transfer and int errace mo t ion i n ma ter i a l s cooled or heated f rom
above or b elow . I n t . J . Heat Mass Transfer 2 3 : 28 3
Hami l l , T . D . & Bankoff , S . G . ( 1 9 6 3 ) : Max imum and m i n imum bounds on
freez i ng-me l t i ng ra tes w i th ti me-d epend ent boundary condi t i ons .
AIChE J . 9 : 741
Hami ll , T . D . & Bank off , S . G . ( 1 964 ) :
· Si mi lari ty solut i o ns of the
plane me l t i ng problem w i th t emperature-d ependent thermal pr oper t i es .
I nd . Engng Chem . Fund . J ( 2 ) : 1 7 7
Hashem i , H . T . & S l i ep c e v ich , C . M . ( 1 9 67a ) : A nume r i ca l method for
solv i ng t wo-d i mens ional probl ems of heat conduc t i on wi th change of
phase . Chem . Engng Prog . Symp . Ser . 63 ( 7 9 ) : 3 4
Hashemi , H . T . & S l i ep c e vi ch , C . M . ( 1 9 67b ) : A d i f fu s ion-analogue
me thod for solv i ng problems of heat conduc t ion w i th change of phase .
Chem. Engng Prog . Symp . Ser . 63 ( 7 9 ) : 42
Referenc es 248
Laz ar i du s A . ( 1 970 ) : A numer ical solut ion of the mul t id imens ional
sol i d i f { c at ion ( or melt ing ) problem. I n t . J . Heat Mass Transf e r � :
1 45 9
Lederma n , J . M . & Boley , B . A . ( 1 970 ) : A x i symme t r i c me l t i ng or
sol i d i f i cat ion of c ir c u l ar cyl inder s . In t . J . Heat Mass Transfe r 1}:
413
Lees , M . ( 1 9 66 ) : A l i near three l ev e l d ifference scheme for
quas i -l inear par abol i c equ a t ions. Math s Comput . 2 0 : 5 1 6
Lemmon , E . C . ( 1 97 9 ) : Phase change tech n i ques of f i n i te e l ement
condu c t i o n codes . Numer i cal Me thods i n Thermal Probl ems , R . W . Lew i s
& K . Morgan , eds . , p . l�9. P1ner1nge Press , Swansea.
Len t z , C . P . ( 1 9 6 1 ) : The rmal conductivi ty of meat s , fat s , gel a t i n ge ls
and i c e . Food Technol . 1 5 (5 ) : 243
Lent z , C . P . & Van Den Berg , L . ( 1 97 7 ) : Thermal conduct i v i ty da t a for
foods : the i r s i gn i f i canc e a nd use . ASHR AE Trans 83 ( 1 ) : 5 3 3
Levy , F . L . ( 1 9 58 ) : Cal cula t i ng th e freez i ng t i me of f i sh i n a ir-bl ast
freez ers . J . Refr i g . 1 : 55
Levy , F . L . ( 1 9 7 9 ) : Enthalpy and spec i f i c heat capac i t y of meat and
f i sh in th e freez i ng ra nge . J . Food Technol . 1 4 : 549
__
APP END IX A
• Comments i nc lude product type and amb ient med i a , EXP • based on
e xper imen tal dat a , FDM • based on f i ni t e d i f ference me thod r esu l ts .
Append i x A 261
Table A . 1 Exac t Analy t i cal So lut ions Assuming a U n i que Phase Cha nge
Temperature
Stefan i n ss N
Car s l aw & Jaeger
1 95 9 . p . 2 82
Neumann i n ss N Churc h i l l & Evans 1 97 1
Ca rslaw & Jae ge r t ab u l a t e fun c t ions .
1 95 9 , p . 28 2
Danckwe r t s 1 95 0 ss � N Dens i ty of phases d i fferent .
Evans e t al 1 9 50 ss 2 p Ser i es solu t i on .
Landau 1 95 0 ss 2 N Abl a t i o n , transformat ion to
immob i l i se boundary .
Append i x A 26 2
• • • cont i nued
Table A . 2 cont inued • • • 2 63
Plank 1 9 1 3 s 3 N Q SS
Ru tov 1 9 36 s 3 N Mod i f ied P lank 1 9 1 3 for
sens i b l e h ea t remov a l .
London & s 3 N See Plank 1 9 1 3 .
Seban 1 9 4 3
Cochran 1 9 55 s •
N QSS , lumped capac i ty me thod .
Krei th & s 3 N See Pl ank 1 9 1 3 .
Rom i e 1 9 55
Chan e t al 1 9 8 3 ss 3 P Q SS , temperature prof i l e
approxi mated by i s othe rmal
boundary .
• • • con t i nued
Table A . 2 con t i nued • • • 2 6�
Hami ll & ss N AI
Ba nk off 1 9 64
Beaubouef & ss N AI
Ch ap man 1 967
Sav ino & ss N AI
Si ege l 1 969
Hirai & ss 3 p A PT
Komor i 1 97 1
Komo r i & s 3 .. p A PT
H ir a i 1 972
Cho & ss -- y APT , k t emperature
Sunderland 1 97 4 depende nt f dens i ty of
phases d i feren t .
M i kha i lov 1 9 7 6 ss -- N APT , mo i sture m igrat i o n .
Ha kash i & ss -- N A PT
omor i 1 97 9
Cl � ne & ss 3 N A PT , v ir tual adj unct
a rc ia 1 980 me thod .
Cho & ss 3 N A PT , tempera ture prof i l e
Sunder land 1 98 1 same a s for n o pha s e c hange .
A ppend i x A 265
Tab l e A . 3 Approx imate Analy t i c al Solutions For Rad ial Geometry As suming
a Uni que Phase Change Temperature
Table A . 4 Approx imate Analy t i ca l So lut ions For Mu l t i -D imens iona l Shapes
Assum ing a U n i qu e Phase Cha nge Temperature
A . 3 SOLUT IONS FOR PHASE CHA NGE OVER A RANGE OF T EMP ERATUR ES
Tab l e A . 7 Emp i r i cal So lutions For Phase Cha nge Over a Range of
Temperatures
• • • continued
Tab l e A . 7 con t inued • • • 270
Tab l e A . 8 Sol u t i ons U s ing Equ ivalent D i ameters to Accoun t For Irregular
Shape
APP ENDIX B
In the s imul at i on the mos t pess i m i s t i c v i ew that the cont act res i st ance
between the thaw i ng p l at e and the polystyrene foam i nsul at ion surface
was the same as that between the plate and the Tylose sur face was
t aken . I n the ac tual s i tuat ion i t should b e greater because of the
porous nat ure of the polystyrene and bec ause the Tylose th i ckness was
s l i ghtly larger than the surround i ng i nsul a t ion . Mos t of the contact
Append i x B 273
pressure was therefore between the Tylose and the plat e . The ex tent t o
wh i ch the ac tual con tact r es i st anc e f rom th e plate t o the i nsul at ion
was grea ter than that from the plate to the Tylose could no t be
measured or es t i mated , but g i ves a fur ther saf ety factor when
int erpre t i ng the resul t s of th is inves t i gat ion .
The cond i t ions invest i gated were those used i n th e slab thaw i ng runs
( Sec . 6 . 2 ) . For the runs mos t affec t ed by edge effects the cond i t i ons
used and the cal cul ated thaw i ng t i mes , b oth assumi ng perfect i nsul at ion
and wi th the poss i b i l i ty of heat transfer through the insul a t i on , ar e
g i ven in Tab l e B. 1 . The r esul ts show the six cases whe r e the
d i f ference in thaw i ng t i me was greater than 1 . 0 % . The effec t of the
edge heat transfer qu i ck l y reduc ed for h i gher amb i en t thawi ng
temp eratures , h i gher sur face heat transfer coef f i c ient s and sma l l er
slab th i cknesses . Consequen t l y , for th e other sl ab thaw i ng exper iments
the s i mulated thaw i ng t i mes wer e l ess than 1 . 0% d i fferent . These
r esul ts conf irm that a l though the edge heat transf er was not negl i g i bl e
i n all cases , for most of the slab thawing exper i ments it was sma l l
enough t o be tol erat ed . Par t icul ar care must be t aken in interpr e t i ng
resul ts for Runs T3 , T 1 6 and T3 .
Append i x B 27 4
*
R un 0 h Ta t exp tI
( m ) ( W m- 2 ° C - 1 ) ( °C ) ( hrs ) ( hr s ) ( hr s ) (%)
4 8
a
I"' I"' r' "'
A ----
4 8
Fig . 8. 1 The F i ni t e El ement Method Gri ds Used To I nv es ti gat e the Eff ect
of Edge Heat T ransf er D ur i ng Thaw i ng of Slabs of Tyl os e .
*
- no des , * * - no des wher e t emper atur e r ecor ded , - el em ent
boundar i es , == - pl anes of s ymmet r y , A - axi s of symmet r y .
Shaded r eg i ons s how el ements repr es ent i ng po l ys t yr en e ,
k 0 . 03 W m- 2
= °C - 1 , C
3 . 3 88 MJ m- 3 oc - 1 . Hor i zont al axi s
=
APP END I X C
0 . 1 6 5 m , Ta = - 3o . o oc , T in = 20 . 0 °C , T f i n - 1 0 . 0 °C .
.. .. 0 . 01 0 24 . 1 � 0 1 . 00 1 .00
.. .. 0 . 0 32 7 .6 8 1 . 00 1 .00
.. .. 0 . 1 00 2 . 4 79 1 . 00 1 . 00
.. .. 0 .31 6 0 . 833 1 . 00 1 .00
Slab .. .. 1 . 000 30 . � 90 1 .00 1 .00
.. .. 3 . 1 62 1 �. 20 1 . 00 1 . 00
.. .. 1 0 .000 . 4 45 1 .00 1 . 00
.. .. 31 . 6 20 6 . 866 1 .00 1 . 00
.. .. 1 00 . 000 6 . 3 88 1 .00 1 . 00
1 . 000 0 .0 1 0 8 .0 4 3 3 . 00 1 .00
1 . 000 0 . 032 2 . � 57 3 . 00 1 . 00
1 . 000 0 . 1 00 o . 27 3 . 00 1 .0 1
1 . 000 0 .316 0 . 279 2 . 98 1 .10
1 . 000 1 . 000 1 0 . 9 42 2.81 1 . 33
1 . 000 3 . 1 62 5 .3 1 5 2 .60 1 . 35
1 . 000 1 0 . 000 3 .3 6 5 2.5 1 1 . 27
1 . 0 00 3 1 .6 20 2 . 7 46 2 . 50 1 . 23
1 . 000 1 00 . 000 2.555 2 . 50 1 . 21
1 . 255 0.0 10 8 . 6 27 2 .8 0 1 . 00
1 . 255 0.032 2 . � 47 2.79 1 .0 5
1 . 25 5 0 . 1 00 0 . 89 2 .79 1 .1 2
1 . 255 0 . 31 6 0 . 302 2 .76 1 .18
1 . 255 1 . 000 1 1 . 99 0 2 . 57 1 . 45
1 . 255 3 . 1 62 5 . 8� 6 2 .35 1 . 4�
1 . 255 1 0 . 0 00 3 .7 9 2 . 23 1 .3
1 . 255 3 1 . 6 20 3 . 096 2 . 22 1 . 29
F i ni te 1 . 255 1 . 27
c r; l i nd er
1 00 . 000 2 . 884 2 . 22
r :s; D y 1 . 582
1 . 5 82
0 .0 1 0
0 .032
9 . 1 68
2 . 922
2 .6 3
2 .6 2
1 .00
1 .11
1 .582 0 . 1 00 0 . 9 44 2 .6 2 1 . 20
1 . 5 82 0.31 6 0 . 32 2 .57 1 . 35
1 . 582 1 . 0 00 1 2 . 992 2 . 3� 1 . 55
1 .582 3 . 1 62 6 . 3 45 2.1 1 . 47
1 . 582 1 0 . 000 4 .0 6 6 2 .08 1 . 37
1 . 5 82 31 . 6 20 3 . 31 2 2 .0 7 1 . 30
1 . 582 1 00 . 0 00 3 . 08 5 2 .07 1 . 28
2 . 5 03 0.010 1 0 . 054 2 .40 1 . 00
2 . 5 03 0 . 03 2 3 .210 2 . 39 1 .22
2 . 5 03 o. 1 00 1 . 045 2 . 37 1 . 48
2 . 503 0 .3 1 6 0 .366 2 . 27 1 .66
2 . 503 1 .000 1 4 . 53 0 2.12 1. 6
2 . 503 3 . 1 62 6 .9 00 2 . 00 1 . 4�
2 . 50 j 1 0 . 000 4 .2 1 8 2 . 00 1 .2
2 . 50 3 1 . 620 3 . 4§ 1 2 . 00 1 . 22
2 . 5 03 1 00 . 000 3.1 4 2 . 00 1 .21
• • • cont inued
Table C . l con t inued • • • 277
1 0 . 7 39 2 . 25 1 . 54
2 . 2�
4 . 000 0 .0 1 0
4 . 000 0 . 0 32 3 . 437 2 .09
4 . 000 0 . 1 00 1 1 �8
• 2. 1 2 .3 4
4 . 000 0 .31 6 0 .3 9 2 . 09 2 .0 7
4 . 000 1 . 000 1 5 . 1 82 2 . 03 1 . 55
4 . 0 00 3 . 1 62 6 .89� 2 . 01 1 . 28
4 . 000 1 0 . 000 4 .21 2 . 00 1 . 17
4 . 000 3 1 620
• 3 . 4 31 2 . 00 1 .14
4 . 000 1 00 . 000 3 . 194 2 . 00 1 .13
6 . 297 0.010 1 1 208
• 2. 1 5 2. 12
6 . 297 0 . 03 2 3 .6 1 0 2.12 3 . 10
6 . 297 0 . 1 00 1 . 207 2 . 05 3.10
F i n i te 6 . 297 0 . 31 6 0.41 2 2 .0 2 1 .92
cf? i nde r 6 . 297 1 . 0 00 1 5 . 2 7� 2 . 02 1 . 35
r :;;
Dy 6 . 29 7 3 . 1 62 6 . 87 2 .o 1 1 . 17
6 . 29 7 1 0 . 000 4 . 21 2 2. 0 1 1 .11
6 . 29 7 3 1 . 6 20 3 . 43 1 2 . 00 1 .0 9
6 . 29 7 1 00 .000 3 . 1 94 2 . 00 1 . 08
1 0 . 000 0 .o 1 0 1 1 . 5 62 2 . 09 3 . 50
1 0 .000 0 . 032 3 .730 2 .0 6 3 .7 3
1 0 . 000 0 . 1 00 1 2 31
• 2 . 01 2 . 77
1 0 . 000 0.316 0.410 2 .03 1 . 47
1 0 .000 1 .0 00 1 5 . 2 28 2 . 02 1 .19
1 0 .000 3 . 1 62 6 . 8 76 2 . 01 1 .1 0
1 0 .000 1 0 .000 4 .21 2 2 .0 1 1 . 07
1 0 . 000 3 1 . 6 20 3 . 4 31 2 . 00 1 . 06
1 0 .000 1 0 0 . 000 3 . 1 94 2 . 00 1 . 05
1 . 000 0.010 8 .0 4 3 3 . 00 1 . 00
1 . 00 0 0 . 032 2 .565 2 .99 1 . 00
0 . 1 00 0 . 829 2 . 9� 1 .0 4
1 .10
1 . 000
1 . 0 00 0 .31 6 0 . 279 2. 9
1 .000 1 . 000 1 0 . 942 2 .81 1 . 33
1 . 0 00 3 . 1 62 5.315 2 .60 1 . 35
1 . 00 0 1 0 . 000 3 . 36 5 2 .5 1 1 . 27
1 . 0 00 3 1 620
• 2 .7 4 6 2 . 50 1 . 23
1 . 00 0 1 0 0 . 000 2 .555 2 .50 1 . 21
1 . 582 0.010 1 0 . 658 2 . 26 1 . 00
1 .582 0 .032 3 .371
1 1 05
2 . 28
2 . 24
1 .14
1 . 38
1 .582 0 . 1 00
0 . � 82 1 52
•
1 . 5 82 0.31 6 2. 18 .
• • • continued
Table C . 1 con t inued • • • 278
6 . 300 0 .0 1 0 1 8 . 4 06 1 .31 2 .8 4
oo 0 . 082
g · � 00
• 0. 1 0
5 . 9 40
2.054
1 . 29
1 . 21 � :14
6 . 3 00 0 .31 6 0 . 76 7 1 . 09 3 . 92
6 . 300 1 . 0 00 30 . 5 1 5 1 .01 2 .5 3
6 . 3 00 3 . 1 62 1 g . 75 1 1 01• 1 . 70
6 . 300 1 0 .000 . 4 20 1 .00 1 .44
6 . 3 00 3 1 . 620 6 .8 5 9 1 . 00 1 . 36
F i n i te 6 . 300 1 00 . 0 00 6 . 388 1 . 00 1 . 33
Cyl inder
Dr � D y 1 0 . 0 00 0.010 20 . 260 1 . 19 4 .o �
1 0 . 000 0 . 03 2 6 . 6 68 1 . 15 6.4
1 0 . 000 0 . 1 00 2 . � 36 1 . 06 6 .�7
1 0 . 0 00 0 . 31 6 0 . 30 1 .00 3. 8
1 0 . 00 0 1 . 000 30 . � 29 1 . 00 1 . 99
1 0 .000 3 . 1 62 1 �. 06 1 .00 1 . 4�
1 0 . 000 1 0 . 000 . 4 45 1 . 00 1 .2
1 0 .000 31 . 6 20 6 . 86 6 1 . 00 1 . 23
1 0 . 00 0 1 00 . 0 00 6 . 388 1 . 00 1 . 21
• • • continued
Table C . 1 con t inued • . • 279
6 . 297 CD 0.010 20 . 8 92 1 . 16 2 . 32
6 . 297 CD 0 . 032 6 . 7 g2 1 . 14 3 . 22
6 . 297 CD 0 . 1 00 2 .2 8 1 . 09 3 . 47
6 . 297 CD 0.31 6 0.810 1 . 03 2 .74
6 . 297 CD 1 . 000 30 . � 29 1 .00 1 .7 8
6 . 29 7 CD 3 . 1 62 1 � . 20 1 . 00 1 .36
6 . 29 7 CD 1 0 . 000 . 4 45 1 . 00 1 .22
6 . 297 CD 3 1 . 6 20 6 . 866 1 . 00 1 . 18
I nf i n i te 6 . 29 7 CD 1 0 0 . 000 6 . 388 1 . 00 1 . 17
Rod
1 0 . 000 CD 0.010 22 . 0 7 7 1 .09 3 .5 7
1 0 . 000 CD 0 . 032 7 . 20 0 1 . 07 5.19
1 0 .000 CD 0. 1 00 2 . 4 30 1 .02 4 . 22
CD 0.316 0 . 828 1 01 2 . 29
30 . � 90
1 0 .000 •
CD 1 . 000 1 . 00 1 .50
1 . 2�
1 0 . 000
1 0 . 000 CD 3 . 1 62 1 g. 20 1 . 00
1 0 . 0 00 CD 1 0 . 000 . 4 45 1 . 00 1 .1
1 0 .000 OD 3 1 . 6 20 6 . 866 1 .00 1.11
1 0 .000 CD 1 00 . 000 6 . 3 88 1 .00 1 . 10
1 . 000 1 . 0 00 0.01 0 8 .0 4 3 3 . 00 1 . 00
1 . 000 1 . 000 0 . 032 2 .5 63 2 .99 1 .10
1 .000 1 . 000 0 . 1 00 0 . 8� 0 2 .99 1 18
•
1 . 000 1 . 582 3 1 . 6 20 1 . 83 1 . 49
1 . 000 1 . 582 1 00 . 000 3 . 85 1 . 83 1 . 45
1 . 000 2 .503 0 . 010 1 0 .071 2 . 40 1 . 59
1 . 000 2 . 5 03 0 . 0 32 3 . 2 20 2 .38 1 . 73
1 . 00 0 2 .503 o . 1 00 1 . 056 2 . 35 1 . 90
R ectangular 1 . 000 2 . 503 0 . 31 6 0 . 3 72 2 . 24 1 . 99
Br i c k · 1 . 0 00 2 . 5 03 1 . 000 1 5 . 273 2 .0 2 1 .95
4 .540 1 . 83
1 .4�
1 . 000 2 . 503 3 . 1 62 1 .7 0
1 . 000 2.503 1 0 . 000 .610 1 . 83
1 . 000 2 . 50 3 31 . 6 20 3 . 9 87 1 72
• 1 4
•
• • • continued
Table C . 1 cont inued • • • 280
------ - -
Append ix C 28 1
Shape 1 Bi EHTD MC P
& Code
o.o 2 . 00 1 . 00
2DI 1
92 . 4 2 . 00 1 . 00
0.0 1 61
• 1 . 00
2DI 2
67 . 6 1 . 34 1 . 20
0.0 1 . 84 1 . oo
2DI 3
83 . 0 1 .70 1 .08
0.0 1 .5 6 1 . 00
2DI 4
60 . 0 1 . 24 1 . 27
0.0 2 . 00 1 . 00
2DI 5
63 . 6 2 .00 1 . 00
0 .0 1 73
• 1 . 00
2DI 6
51 .5 1 .5 1 1 .16
o.o 1 . 82 1 . 00
2DI 7
55 . 2 1 . 65 1.11
0.0 1 .32 1 . 00
2DI 8
28 . 8 1 .05 1 . 30
o.o 2 .37 1 . 00
Pyram i d
50 . 0 1 . 48 1 . 72
0.0 3 . 00 1 . 00
Sphere
77 .0 3 .0 0 1 .00
0.0 2 .7 5 1 . 00
Egg
1 03 . 0 2 . 49 1.11
0.0 2 .23 1 . 00
F i sh
72 . 7 1 . 26 1 .82