Professional Documents
Culture Documents
______________________________________________________________________________________
Abstract : Integrated geophysical techniques involving VLF – EM and the Electrical Resistivity Sounding
methods have been used to map Oda town with a view to determine the groundwater potential of the town.
The qualitative interpretation of VLF – EM results identified areas of hydro-geologic importance and form
basis for Vertical Electrical Sounding (VES) investigation. Thirty-nine Vertical Electrical soundings (VES)
were carried out across the area using the Schlumberger electrode array configuration, with half-current
electrode separation (AB/2) varying from 1m to 100m.
The geoelectric sections obtained from the sounding curves revealed 2-layer, 3-layer and 4-layer earth
models respectively. The 2-layer model with 7.7 percentage of occurrence occurs where the depth-to-
bedrock is very shallow. The 3-layer (61.5%) and 4-layer (30.8%) models show the subsurface layers
categorized into the topsoil, partially weathered/ weathered/fractured layers and the fresh bedrock.
The weathered basement and fractured basement are the aquifer types delineated for the area.
On the basis of geoelectric parameters the study area is zoned into good, intermediate and poor
groundwater potential zones.
Key Words : Very Low Frequency –Electromagnetic (VLF-EM), Electrical Resistivity, Aquifer,
Groundwater Potential, Depth-to-bedrock.
______________________________________________________________________________________
INTRODUCTION
Rapid industrialization recently witnessed by the Akure metropolis has resulted in population increase and
has resulted in urbanization of satellite villages and settlements of which the ancient Oda settlement is one
(Figure 1).
The people of Oda depend solely on surface water from streams and hand dug wells for their domestic use.
However, these sources of water are highly vulnerable to pollution thereby making the people to be
susceptible to water borne diseases. Furthermore, rapid population growth of Oda occasioned by the influx
of people from nearly congested city of Akure has also made these sources of water inadequate for its
dwellers, and the need for good quality and readily available portable groundwater in this area forms the
basis for this research.
Oda town is underlying by Basement Complex rocks of the southwestern Nigeria and groundwater in this
environment is usually contained in the weathered and/or fractured basement rocks or alluvial deposits
within flood plains as mentioned by some authors among whom are Wright (1992) and Olorunfemi and
Fasuyi (1993).
333
Ozean Journal of Social Sciences 2(4), 2009
The basement aquifers are often limited in extent both laterally and vertically (Satpathy and Kanugo, 1976).
This discontinuous nature of the basement aquifer system makes detailed knowledge of the subsurface
geology, its weathering depth and structural disposition through geological and geophysical investigations
inevitable.
Geophysical survey involving electrical resistivity, gravity, seismic and electromagnetic methods
constitutes the most reliable means, outside direct mechanical drilling, through which basement structures
such as ancient river channels, basement depressions and fractured zones that are of hydrogeological
significance can be mapped (Eaton and Watkins, 1970; Vanderberghe, 1982). However, the most
commonly applied geophysical technique for ancient river channel exploration is the electrical resistivity
method (Minasian, 1979). This is a consequence of the usually significant resistivity contrast between the
deposit within the channel and the underlying bedrock (Ako and Olorunfemi, 1989).
The Very Low Frequency Electromagnetic (VLF – EM) method has found useful application in
groundwater investigation in basement terrain, most especially as a reconnaissance tool (Amadi and
Nurudeen, 1990; Olorunfemi et. al., 1995).
Figure 1: Geological map of the study area [After Geological Survey of Nigeria (GSA), sheet 61, 1964]
334
Ozean Journal of Social Sciences 2(4), 2009
This method of geophysical prospecting was primarily developed for the delineation of sheet – like metallic
conductors, which are often concentrated within fault and fracture zones which are known to be good
groundwater aquifers, particularly when the fracture frequency is high (Olorunfemi et. al., 1995). The
technique may be applied indirectly to the location of sites with appreciably thick overburden to the
mapping of geological structures such as fault and fracture zones that are favourable to groundwater
accumulation (McNeil, 1980; Palacky et. al., 1981; Olorunfemi et. al., 1995).
In this work, integrated geophysical mapping of Oda town was carried out using both VLF-EM and
electrical resistivity prospecting techniques with a view to evaluating its groundwater potential and
ultimately recommend the appropriate way of providing adequate and good quality water for the people of
the area.
335
Ozean Journal of Social Sciences 2(4), 2009
o
o 5 14 38 E
5 14 28 E
Fr
o o
om
7 10 42.24 E 7 10 42.24 E
A
ku
re
Sch
V3
V1Saw Mill
V2
file1
M Pro
V21
E
V25
V22 V23
V4
2
ile
of
V5 P/S
Pr
LEGEND
V9
EM
V20 V27
V28
V26E
M
Road/EM Profiles
Palace P ro
file
3
VES position
V29
V11 V7 V8
P/S
Police station
V38 V10 GPM
Sch
God 's power Mission
EM Profile 4
V19
EM Profile 7
V13
5
V12 V14
V6
le
V18
V24
ofi
Pr
V37 V36
V35 V34
EM
V15
V16
V39 V17
To
Og
be
Hig
h Sc
V32 V33 ho
6GPM o l,O
da
ile
of
Pr
V31
EM
V30
o o
7 10 4.8 E 7 10 4.8 E
o o
5 14 28 E 0m 200m 400m 600m 5 14 38 E
Figure 2: Location map of the study area showing the VES points and VLF-EM profiles
336
Ozean Journal of Social Sciences 2(4), 2009
337
Ozean Journal of Social Sciences 2(4), 2009
338
Ozean Journal of Social Sciences 2(4), 2009
36 250,85,4413 1.1,13.9
37 234,58,1879 0.6,10.3
38 62,25,5408 2.7,4.7
Table 1 Cont’.
Geoeletric Curve VES Resistivity Thickness Number of Percentage Layer Resistivity Thickness Characteristic Lithology
earth layer Type Num (Ohm-m) Occurrence of Occurrence Range Range
(m)
model type (%) (Ohm-m)
(m)
4-layer KH 1 287,543,90,2036 1, 1.5, 8.4 7 17.95 1 28-313 0.3-1.4 Topsoil (Clayey to sandy)
339
Ozean Journal of Social Sciences 2(4), 2009
[a]
40
VLF-EM Profile 1
Raw Real Data
Fraser Filtered Data
20
F1 F4
F2 F3 F5
Response (%)
0 NE
-20
SW
-40
[b]
VES 2 VES 3
VES 22 VES 21 VES 1
Figure 3: [a] VLF-EM profile along traverse 1, and [b] Karous and Hjelt Pseudo Section of the Inverted
VLF-EM Real component of the Profile.
340
Ozean Journal of Social Sciences 2(4), 2009
[a]
40
F1 VLF -E M Profile 2
Ra w re al d ata
20 F ra se r filte re d da ta
F3
F2
Response (%)
SW
0 NE
-2 0
-4 0
0 50 1 00 1 50 20 0
D is ta n ce (m )
[b]
VES 5
VES 26
Figure 4: [a] VLF-EM profile along traverse 2, and [b] Karous and Hjelt Pseudo Section of the
Inverted VLF- EM Real component of the Profile.
341
Ozean Journal of Social Sciences 2(4), 2009
[a]
20
VLF-EM Profile 3
Raw real data
Fraser filtered data
10
F1
Response (%)
NW SE
0
-10
-20
VES 26
Figure 5: [a] VLF-EM profile along traverse 3, and [b] Karous and Hjelt Pseudo Section of the
Inverted VLF- EM Real component of the Profile.
342
Ozean Journal of Social Sciences 2(4), 2009
[a]
VLF-EM Profile 4
10 F1
Raw real data F5
F2 Fraser filtered data
F3 F4
Response (%)
0 W E
-10
[b]
VES 10 VES 38
Figure 6: [a] VLF-EM profile along traverse 4, and [b] Karous and Hjelt Pseudo Section of the Inverted
VLF- EM Real component of the Profile.
343
Ozean Journal of Social Sciences 2(4), 2009
[a]
VLF-EM Profile 5
10
Raw real data
Fraser filtered data
F1 F2 F3 F4
Response (%)
0 SW NE
-10
[b]
VES 10 VES 36
Figure 7: [a] VLF-EM profile along traverse 5, and [b] Karous and Hjelt Pseudo Section of the Inverted
VLF-EM Real component of the Profile.
344
Ozean Journal of Social Sciences 2(4), 2009
[a]
VLF-EM Profile 6
10
Raw real data
Fraser filtered data
F1
F2 F3 F4 F5
Response (%)
0SW NE
-10
[b]
VES 30
VES 31 VES 33 VES 16
Figure 8: [a] VLF-EM profile along traverse 6, and [b] Karous and Hjelt Pseudo Section of the
Inverted VLF- EM Real component of the Profile.
345
Ozean Journal of Social Sciences 2(4), 2009
[a]
20
VLF-EM Profile 7
F4
Raw real data
Fraser filtered data
10 F1 F2
Resp on se (% )
F3
0 S N
-10
-20
[b]
Figure 9: [a] VLF-EM profile along traverse 7, and [b] Karous and Hjelt Pseudo Section of the Inverted
VLF-EM Real component of the Profile.
346
Ozean Journal of Social Sciences 2(4), 2009
Several other closures of conductive bodies are present on the section with each conductive body
coinciding with the points already identified on the profile, as fractures/joints.
The same process of qualitative interpretation was adopted for the remaining profiles and their
corresponding pseudo sections. Based on the interpreted VLF-EM profile the points of interest marked as
Fs (e.g. F1, F2, etc.) were among the points that were further investigated using the Vertical Electrical
Resistivity Sounding (VES).
In addition, the map of the filtered real component was prepared as equivalent current density map (Figure
10). The equivalent current density varies from -24 % to 8% with negative values characterizing the
resistive zones and the positive values the conductive zones. The conductive zones are located within some
parts of the northwestern, central and southeastern regions of the study area. Thus, additional VES
locations were sited in these regions (e.g., VES locations 20, 24, 25, 39 etc.).
347
Ozean Journal of Social Sciences 2(4), 2009
348
Ozean Journal of Social Sciences 2(4), 2009
V2 V1
340 V3
318 287
3619
543
543
20
20m
330
90
Elevation (m)
158
15
210 15
10
10
320 2036
2582
5
2726
0
310 0 25 50 75 100m
300
Top soil lateritic clay Weathered layer Fresh bedrock
Figure 12: 2D Geo-electric sections along: (a) West-Eastern, and (b) Southwestern-Northeastern cross sections.
350
Ozean Journal of Social Sciences 2(4), 2009
The underlying bedrock is characterized by resistivity values raging from 1232 Om-m to 4062 Ohm-m.
Low resistivity values are suggestive of fractured bedrock in the area.
Figure 12b also shows the geoelectric section drawn in the southwest – northeast direction across vertical
sounding points 2, 1 and 3. The top soil along the section has resistivity values ranging from 287 Ohm-m to
543 Ohm-m characteristic of sandy soil. Beneath the top soil layer towards the southwestern part the
relatively high resistivity values of 543 Ohm-m and 3619Ohm-m observed under the topsoil characterized a
lateritic unit (which shows as spots of massive body with low current density on figure 3), which does not
extend to VES 3 location. The next layer, recognized as the aquifer layer with unit resistivity values
between 90 Ohm-m and 210 Ohm-m is the presumed highly weathered layer. The basal unit with resistivty
values ranging from 2036 Ohm-m to 2726 Ohm-m is identified as the fresh bedrock along the section.
Figure 13a shows another geoelectric section in the southwest –northeast direction. Just as observed in
Figure 12b, the topsoil can be categorized as clayey to sandy soil, based on the resistivity values, which
vary from 75 Ohm-m to 308 Ohm-m. Under VES 11, the second layer resistivity value is diagnostic of the
lateritic unit observed at some VES locations. However, another layer recognized as weathered layer
aquifer extends from VES 11 location through VES 26 and VES 5, but not observed at VES 4 location.
This aquiferous layer has resistivity values of 411 ohm-m, 507 Ohm-m and 274 Ohm-m at VES 11, VES
26 and VES 5 locations respectively. The thickness of the layer ranges from 5.2m to 16.2m. Beneath this
first aquifer unit is the next layer recognized as weathered/fractured layer aquifer, which has low resistivity
values of 53 Ohm-m, 50 Ohm-m and 53 Ohm-m at sounding locations VES 26, VES 5 and VES 4
respectively. This is also observed on the Karous and Hjelt pseudo sections of the inverted VLF-EM data
shown in Figures 4 and 5. Both figures show an extensive fractures beneath VES 5 and VES 26, which
extends into the bedrock at these locations (Figures 4 and 5). The underlying bedrock with resistivity values
of 559 Ohm-m at VES 5 is diagnostic of fractured basement as also observed on the VLF-EM profiles. This
indicates that the location is suitable for sitting bore hole in the area.
351
Ozean Journal of Social Sciences 2(4), 2009
V7 V 19
335 V 17
17
330 71
20
Elevation (m)
34 20m
325 326
15
1039 15
320
10
10
315 81
4062
5
5
310
0
2713 0 25 50 75 100m
Figure 13: 2D Geo-electric sections along: (a) Southwestern-Northeastern, and (b) North-South cross sections.
352
Ozean Journal of Social Sciences 2(4), 2009
Figure 13b shows a geoelectric sections depicting a weathering profile with topsoil having resistivity values
between 17 ohm-m at VES 19 and 71 Ohm-m at VES 17 depicting a clayey layer. Under the layer is the
aquifer layer which is recognized to be weathered layer with layer resistivity of 326 Ohm-m at VES 17, and
81Ohm-m at VES 7 recognized as fractured bedrock at VES 7 (Figures 13 and 19). The unit is absent at
VES 19 where the bedrock is very close to the surface. The bedrock is observed to be fractured which
appears as dipping and vertical conductors respectively on the VLF-EM profiles at VES 19 and VES7
respectively (Figure 9). However, there is no indication that the bedrock is fractured at VES 17.
Generally, the topsoil is relatively thin in most places, with resistivity values characteristically of clayey to
sand or lateritic soil. Across the entire study area, the topsoil resistivity value was found to vary between 17
Ohm-m to 1119 Ohm-m, while its thickness ranges between 0.3 and 9.4m.
The intermediate units could be categorized into lateritic, weathered or fractured bedrock. In some cases,
the weathered materials are presumed to be clayey based on the resistivity values (approximately between
20 Ohm-m and 100 Ohm-m). Some parts of the study area are also characterized by sharp resistivity values
between the topsoil and weathered bedrock diagnostic of lateritic unit. Furthermore, occurrence of low
resistivity value of 50 Ohm-m observed at approximate depth of 16.7m coinciding with a depression zone
beneath VES station 5 (Figure 13a) is diagnostic of fractured bedrock, thus making the VES point very
appropriate for locating borehole. The unit characterized as weathered/Fractured Basement based has
resistivity values ranging from 50 to 411ohm – m, with thickness ranging from 3.4 to 18.3m
The fresh Bedrock is observed to be characterized by resistivity varying between 559 Ohm-m and
25825ohm – m. Depth to the basement also varies from1.2m to 18.7m.
GEOELECTRIC CHARACTERISTICS
Weathered / Fractured Basement Aquifer Unit) Resistivity Map
Figure 14 shows the aquifer resistivity contour map of the delineated aquifer unit. The aquifer unit has
resistivity value varying from 15Ohm-m to 450Ohm-m. Based on the resistivity values of this unit, the
study area is zoned into three. The first zone characterized by resistivity values less than 100Ohm-m or
greater than 400Ohm-m is recognized as area of least groundwater prospect in this particular study. The
second classification is the zones of medium yield for groundwater prospect, characterized by resistivity
values ranging between 300Ohm-m and 350ohm–m in the area.
Areas with resistivity values between 150Ohm-m and 300Ohm-m are classified as zones of high
groundwater yield potential. Locations which fall within the zones recognized to have high yield potential
for groundwater development coincide with the conductive zones identified on the equivalent conductivity
map (Figure 10), indicating high degree of correlation between the two maps.
353
Ozean Journal of Social Sciences 2(4), 2009
o o
5 14 28 E 5 14 38 E
o o
7 10 42.24 E 7 10 42.24 E
V3
V2 V1
380 Ohm-m
V21
V22 V23 V25
340 Ohm-m
V4
V5 300 Ohm-m
V20 V27
V28 V9
V26 260 Ohm-m
V29 V11
V38 V10 V7 V8 220 Ohm-m
V13 V19 180 Ohm-m
V6 V12 V18V14 V24
140 Ohm-m
V37 V35
V36V34
V15V16
V39 V17
100 Ohm-m
V32 V33
60 Ohm-m
V31 20 Ohm-m
V30
o o V12
7 10 4.8 E 7 10 4.8 E
o o
5 14 28 E 5 14 38 E Weathered
VES location /
0 1 2 3 4km Road
354
Ozean Journal of Social Sciences 2(4), 2009
o o
5 14 28 E 5 14 38 E
o o
7 10 42.24 E 7 10 42.24 E
V3
V2 V1
29m
V21
V22 V23 V25
V4 25m
V5
V20 V27
V28 V9 21m
V26
V29 V11
V38 V10 V7 V8 17m
V13 V19
V12 13m
V6 V18V14 V24
V37 V35
V36V34
V15V16 V 12
9m
V39 V17
V32 V33 5m
V31 1m
V30
o o
7 10 4.8 E 7 10 4.8 E
o
5 14 28 E
o
5 14 38 E VES location
0 1 2 3 4km Road
355
Ozean Journal of Social Sciences 2(4), 2009
Naturally, the groundwater flows from areas of high pressure (such as bedrock ridge) to area of low
pressure (such as bedrock depression). It is then expected that areas identified as depressions on the map
are the groundwater collection points which have significant role in groundwater development.
Groundwater Evaluation
At large, the groundwater evaluation of the area is based on various categories of maps; Aquifer resistivity,
aquifer thickness and bedrock relief maps in preparing the groundwater potential map of the area as
deduced from the primary geoelectric parameters (resistivity and thickness values) obtained from the VES
interpretation results. The groundwater potential map shown in Figure 17 was used to categorize the study
area into good, intermediate and poor groundwater potential zones.
356
Ozean Journal of Social Sciences 2(4), 2009
Comparison between the groundwater potential map and the bedrock relief map reveled that the area
categorized as fair to good groundwater potential zones coincide with the areas of basement trough
(depression) on the relief map, with substantively thick overburden and aquifer thickness. In contrary, areas
identified to be associated with the basement anticlines (or ridges) are recognized as areas of poor
groundwater potential, with characteristic thin overburden and aquifer thickness.
CONCLUSIONS
The geophysical methods used in this study have greatly assisted in evaluating groundwater potential of
Oda community, a suburb of an ancient town, Akure in Nigeria. Both the VLF – EM and Electrical probing
data over the area were inverted and interpreted in terms of the distribution of the geoelectrical parameters
in the area.
Interpretation of both the EM profiles and equivalent current density map identified some areas of
hydrogeologic importance in form of fractures and permeable zones, which were further probed using the
Electrical Resistivity survey.
357
Ozean Journal of Social Sciences 2(4), 2009
The geoelectric parameters obtained from the inverted Vertical Electrical resistivity Sounding data were
used to evolve various maps and cross sections which were analyzed in terms of hydro-geologic importance
of the area. The maps were used to categorize the study area into three groundwater potential zones as of
good, intermediate, and poor groundwater potential. The results also indicate that two types of aquifer (i.e.
weathered bedrock and fractured bedrock aquifer types) were identified in the study area. Other geologic
feature delineated from the distribution of the subsurface resistivity is the bedrock depression, which is of
significant hydro-geologic importance.
Results from the geophysical studies reveals that the community could play a significant role in
decongesting the ancient city of Akure, since the area can be exploited for groundwater resource.
Development of physical infra structures in the area will encourage people to relocate from Akure
metropolis into the area and thereby reduce the influx of people into the City.
REFERENCES
AKO, B. D. and Olorunfemi, M. O., 1989, Geoelectric survey of groundwater in the newer basalts of Vom,
Plateau State. Journal of Mining and Geology, Vol. 25, Nos 1 and 2.
Amadi, U. M. P. and Nurudeen, S. I., 1990, Electromagnetic survey and the search for groundwater in the
crystalline basement complex of Nigeria. Journal of Mining Geology, 26, 45 – 53.
Bala, A.E., and Onugba, A, 2001. Premilary chemical assessment of groundwater in the basement complex
area within the Bunsuru and Gagere sub-basin, northwestern Nigeria. Journal of Mining and
Geology, vol. 37 (1), pp. 45-52.
Eaton, G. P. and Watkins, J. S., 1970, The use of seismic refraction and gravity methods in
hydrogeological investigations. Proc. Canadian Centennial Conf. Mining and Groundwater
Geophysics, Ottawa.
McNeill, J. D., 1980, Electromagnetic terrain measurement at low induction numbers. Technical note TN
– 6, 15p. Geonics Limited, Ontario, Canad.
Minasian, R. S., 1979, Prospecting for subsurface water in the central volcanic highland of Armenia by
Geophysical methods. Geophysical Prospecting, Vol. 27, No. 4, Pp. 808 – 814.
Nigeria Meteorological Agency, (NIMET), 2007, Daily weather forecast on the Nigerian Television
Authority. Nigerian Metrological Agency, Oshodi, Lagos.
Olayinka, A.I., and Olayiwola, M.A., 2001, Integrated use of geoelctrical imaging and hydrochemical
methods in delineating limits of polluted surface and groundwater at a landfill site in ibadan area,
southwestern Nigeria. Journal of Mining and Geology, vol. 37 (1), pp. 53-68
Olorunfemi, M. O. and Fasuyi, S. A, 1993, Aquifer types and the geoelectic/ hydrogeological
characteristics of part of the central basement terrain of Nigeria (Niger State). Journal African
Earth Science, 16, 309 – 317.
Olorunfemi, M. O., Dan – Hassan, M. A. and Ojo, A. S., 1995, On the scope and limitations of the
electromagnetic methods in groundwater prospecting in a Precambrian basement terrain a
Nigerian case study. Journal of Africa Earth Sciences, Vol. 20 No. 2, 151 – 160.
Palacky, G. J., Ritsema, I. L., and De Jong, S. J., 1981, Electromagnetic prospecting for Groundwater on
the Republic of Upper Volta. Geophysical Prospecting, Vol. 29, Pp. 932 – 955.
Pirttijärvi, M, 2004, KHFfilt program. A geophysical software for Karous-Hjelt and Fraser filtering on
geophysical VLF (very-low-frequency) data. Geopysics Devision, Department of Geosciences,
University of Oulu, Finland.
Rahaman, M. A., 1976, Review of the basement geology of southwestern Nigeria in Geology of Nigeria.
Elizabethan Publishing Company, Nigeria Pp. 44 – 58.
Reynolds, J. M., 1997, An introduction to Applied and Environmental Geophysics. Published by John
Wiley and Sons Ltd. Baffins Lane. Chichester, West Sussex PO191UD, England. 796pp.
358
Ozean Journal of Social Sciences 2(4), 2009
Satpathy, B. N. and Kanugo, D. N., 1976, Water exploration in hard terrain. A case history. Geophysical
Prospecting, 24, Pp. 725 – 736.
Telford, W. M; King, W. F. and Becker, A., 1977, VLF mapping geological structure. Geological Survey
of Canada, No. 76, 25pp.
Vander Velpen, B. P. A., 1988, Resist Version 1.0M.Sc Research Project, ITC, Delf Netherland.
Vanderberghe, J., 1982, Geoelectric investigations of a fault system in Quaternary deposits. Geophysical
prospecting, Vol. 30, Pp. 879 – 897.
Wright, C. P., 1992, The hydrogeology of crystalline basement aquifers in Africa. In: C. P. Wright and W.
C. Burgess (eds). Hydrogeology of Crystalline Basement aquifer in Africa. Geological Society of
London Special Publication No. 66 Pp. 1 – 27.
359