Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1
with his development initiatives. Displaying the alliance bonhomie, Nitish
Kumar also spoke highly of Modi’s performance as Prime Minister.
“While Narendra Modi’s nationalism pitch has superseded all other issues,
in Bihar, people have a favourable disposition towards Nitish Kumar’s
commitment for development and these two factors have struck an
emotional connect. This has resulted in decimating the Opposition,” said
DM Diwakar, former director, AN Sinha Institute for Social Studies, Patna.
With barely a year to go for assembly polls in Bihar, the J D(U) with a
100% strike rate will sit on the negotiating table with a lot of confidence and
command. Nitish Kumar will undoubtedly remain the chief ministerial
candidate and the J D(U) is likely to retain its image of the elder brother in
the state.
For Bihar, the India Today-Axis My India exit poll has predicted 38-40
seats for NDA and 0-2 seats for UPA.
In the 2014 elections, BJP had emerged as the single largest party in
the state (Bihar), winning 22 seats with a vote share of 29.9 per cent. Lalu
Prasad’s Rashtriya Janata Dal was the second-biggest in terms of votes
polled, with a share 20.5 per cent, but it was third in terms of seat tally (4).
2
Poll of polls prediction in Rajasthan, Maharashtra, Jharkhand:
In the 2014 Lok Sabha elections, BJP had emerged as the single
largest party, winning 23 seats in Maharashtra. In Rajasthan, BJP won all
25 seats with a vote share of 55.6%. In Jharkhand, BJP emerged as the
single largest party with 12 seats and vote share of 40.7 per cent.
With Banerjee’s party only leading in 25 seats (down from the 34 the
party won in 2014), her biyallishe biyallishe (42 of 42) war cry now sounds
almost as empty as Congress s promise of NYAY.
Two days before the results of the Lok Sabha elections, West
Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee announced stipends to purohits in
crematoriums. Going by the Lok Sabha election trends in the state —
where the BJP is leading in 17 of the 42 seats, up from the two it won in
2014 the stipend move, Banerjee’s attempt to counter the spread of
Hindutva in her state, may have come too late for Trinamool Congress.
3
News18’s IPSOS - TMC 25-28 | BJP 3-7 | Others- 5-7
IN 2014, Lok Sabha elections, BJP bagged only 2 seats (Asansol and
Darjeeling) with 17 per cent vote share.
Among the major states where it has a presence, the BJP has got
more votes than in 2014 in are Gujarat, Haryana, Jharkhand, Himachal
Pradesh, Karnataka, Madhya Pradesh, Delhi, Odisha, Rajasthan, Uttar
Pradesh, Uttarakhand, and West Bengal. [Twelve states]
For Lok Sabha, three exit polls had predicted a big win for the NDA.
Two exit polls said the BJP-led NDA will win more than 300 seats and
return to form its second successive government. Times Now-VMR says
NDA will win 306 and UPA 132 seats.
In the 2014 elections, the NDA together won 336 seats. The BJP
swept all seats in Gujarat, Rajasthan, Delhi, Uttarakhand, Himachal
Pradesh, Goa, and virtually won all of Chhattisgarh, Uttar Pradesh (71 out
of 80) as well as Bihar with allies.
4
Times Now-VMR predicts BJP will win 23 seats in Gujarat: NDA: 23;
UPA: 3
In the 2014 Lok Sabha elections, the Bharatiya Janata Party had won
all of the state’s 26 seats with a vote share of 60.1 per cent. Congress was
the second in terms of vote share at 33.5 per cent.
The two big takeaways from the vote share are: an improvement in
Uttar Pradesh from the 41% it got in 2014, and a doubling in West Bengal
to 39% from the 18% it got in 2014. It ensured that the party held on to the
bulk of its seats in UP, and made huge gains in Bengal.
The only good news for the Congress is in Punjab and Kerala. In
Kerala, the Congress-led UDF appears to be sweeping the poll, leading in
19 out of 20 seats. This appears to be in line with party leaders’
assessment that the party could do well due to the presence of Rahul
Gandhi as a candidate in Wayanad.
5
However, Rahul Gandhi himself lost in Amethi. His confidants
Jyotiraditya Scindia (Guna), Deepender Hooda (Rohtak), Gaurav Gogoi
(Kaliaburg) and Sushmita Dev (Silchar) are al either trailing or lost.
Many exit polls showed that the Modi-Shah duo has been able to
convince the voters that it is better suited to govern the country than
the Congress-led Opposition.
India Today-My Axis India exit poll shows that the Congress-led
United Progressive Alliance (UPA) will be able to win 77 to 108 seats in this
general election.
On May 23, the results of the 2019 Lok Sabha election confirmed
that the Congress is in deep trouble.
The Congress’ strategy to seize the narrative from the BJP came a
cropper as it could only win 51 seats, a slight improvement from its 2014
tally of 44 seats. Although its party chief Rahul Gandhi won the Wayanad
seat by a huge margin, he lost his Amethi seat to BJP candidate and Union
Minister Smriti Irani in the biggest upset of the election.
6
The Congress was also given a reality check in Hindi heartland states
of Chhattisgarh, Rajasthan and Madhya Pradesh where the party formed
the government six months ago.
Also, the regional parties are likely to win more seats specially in
southern states of Tamil Nadu, Telangana, Odisha and Andhra Pradesh.
The overall figures predicted by the India Today-My Axis India exit
poll shows that people in the five southern states-Karnataka, Tamil Nadu,
Kerala, Andhra Pradesh and Telangana-have voted against the BJP-led
NDA. However, the Congress too did not fare better except in Kerala.
The YSR Congress is expected to win 18-20 seats . The TDP, which
is the ruling party in Andhra Pradesh, has much to worry as the exit poll
predicts it to win 4-6 seats. In 2014, the TDP won 16 seats. Also, YSRC
won the assembly elections.
7
Meanwhile, the BJP may open its account in the state and get one
seat.
UTTAR PRADESH:
Uttar Pradesh, the state that sends the highest number of seats to the
Lok Sabha, appears to have voted to bring Narendra Modi back to power.
Uttar Pradesh sends 80 MPs to the Lok Sabha.
The India Today-My Axis India exit poll had shown that the BJP+ will
win 62-68 seats in Uttar Pradesh. The exit poll predicted that the SP-BSP
alliance will win 10-16 seats at best.
8
In the 2014 Lok Sabha election, the Congress won 2 seats, the SP 5
seats, BSP 0 and BJP+ 73 seats i Uttar Pradesh.
If it is bad news for the BJP in the South; the saffron party has
reasons to smile in the West. The party has been able to maintain its 2014
performance in big states like Gujarat, Rajasthan and Maharashtra.
Maharashtra brings good news for the BJP and Shiv Sena if the exit
poll figures stand on May 23. The BJP+ is likely to win 38-42 seats, while
the Congress will get 6-10 seats in Maharashtra. After Gujarat,
Maharashtra is another BJP-ruled state where the party has performed well
even in the 2019 general elections.
The last state in the West is Goa where again the BJP is expected to
make a clean sweep. Goa has two seats and both of them appear to go to
the BJP.
9
After projections for the South and West, we now focus on Central
India. The states here are Madhya Pradesh and Chhattisgarh.
Our exit poll shows that despite the fact that the Congress won the
state assembly election in December 2018, the Congress has not been
able to cash in on to its victory march.
The BJP is expected to win 7-8 seats, while the Congress may win 3-
4 seats.
Just like the West and Central India, North India too appears to be a
clean sweep for the Bharatiya Janata Party. Barring Punjab, all northern
states-Jammu and Kashmir, Himachal Pradesh, Uttarakhand, Delhi and
Haryana-are expected to bear good news for Narendra Modi.
10
In Himachal Pradesh and Uttarakhand, our exit poll shows that the
BJP will all 9 seats. There are four seats in Himachal Pradesh and five in
Uttarakhand. In 2014, the BJP had won all these 9 seats. If the exit poll
predictions hold true on May 23, the BJP will smile in the two Himalayan
states.
In Jammu and Kashmir, the BJP is slated to win 2-3 seats. Congress
is likely to get 0-1 seat and the National Conference 2-3 seats.
Haryana and Delhi are the two other northern states where the BJP is
winning hands down. In Delhi, the BJP is expected to win 6 seats while the
Congress may win 1. The Aam Aadmi Party is expected to suffer the most.
In 2014, BJP won all 7 seats in Delhi.
If the exit poll numbers hold true on May 23, the BJP will win 19-23 in
West Bengal, signalling a major loss for the Mamata Banerjee-led
Trinamool Congress which won 34 seats in 2014.
11
The TMC is expected to win 19-22 in West Bengal. The Left parties
appear to be defeated in all seats in West Bengal, a state which they ruled
for 34 years.
There is good news again for the BJP in Bihar as it is expected to win
almost all Lok Sabha seats in the state. The India Today-My Axis India exit
poll shows that the BJP-led NDA will win 38-40 seats. The grand alliance of
Congress, Rashtriya Janata Dal and others is expected to win only 0-2
seats.
In Odisha, the Biju Janata Dal (which is the ruling party in the state) is
likely to win only 13 seats, against the 20 it won in 2014. The BJP on the
other hand is expected to win 8 seats and the Congress 0-1 seat.
India Today- Axis My India Exit Poll shows that the BJP presence in
the Northeast has grown stronger. The BJP-led NDA is expected to win
most of the 25 seats that the region sends to the Lok Sabha.
In Assam, which has 14 seats, the Congress is likely to win only 0-2
seats while the BJP sweeps 12-14 seats.
West Bengal:
12
The Modi wave has shaken Mamata Didi's citadel in West Bengal,
the exit poll results predict. The India Today-Axis My India Exit Poll put BJP
and Mamata Banerjee's Trinamool Congress in a neck-and-neck fight.
Out of 42 Lok Sabha seats in West Bengal, the exit poll results have
predicted 19 to 22 seats for the TMC and 19 to 23 seats for the BJP.
In terms of voter share, the TMC is likely to get 41 per cent votes,
almost as much as last elections in 2019. The big story here is the BJP,
which is projected to increase its vote share by 24 per cent to match the
TMC's 41 per cent.
The losers here are Congress and Left. With no seats expected to fall
in their kitty, they are also likely to lose their vote share by three and 20 per
cent, respectively.
Polling in West Bengal took place across all the seven phases of Lok
Sabha elections, starting from Coochbehar and Alipurduars parliamentary
constituencies on April 11.
In West Bengal, voting in the first phase of Lok Sabha polls was held
on April 11 for two seats, Coochbehar and Alipurduars.
The seats that voted in the second phase on April 18 were Jalpaiguri,
Darjeeling, and Raiganj.
13
A total of five Lok Sabha seats went to polls on April 23 during the
third phase of Lok Sabha elections. They included Balurghat, Maldaha
Uttar, Maldaha Dakshin, Jangipur, and Murshidabad.
In the fourth phase of Lok Sabha polls, voting took place on April 29
in Baharampur, Krishnanagar, Ranaghat, Bardhaman Purba, Bardhaman-
Durgapur, Asansol, Bolpur, and Birbhum Lok Sabha constituencies.
In the sixth phase of Lok Sabha elections on May 12, the seats that
voted were Tamluk, Kanthi, Ghatal, Jhargram, Medinipur, Purulia, Bankura,
and Bishnupur.
In the final phase of the 2019 Lok Sabha elections, a total of 11 seats
went to polls today. They include Dum Dum, Barasat, Basirhat, Jaynagar,
Mathurapur, Diamond Harbour, Jadavpur, Kolkata Dakshin, and Kolkata
Uttar Lok Sabha constituencies.
14
of 272 seats to form the government, the projections widely vary with
regard to the BJP s performance in three key states Uttar Pradesh,
West Bengal and Odisha which account for 143 seats.
The projections for the performance of the alliance of SP, BSP and the
RLD by different agencies vary considerably.
The projections for the performance of the alliance of SP, BSP and
the RLD by different agencies vary considerably.
15
West Bengal has 42 seats and is witnessing a fierce fight between
the Trinamool Congress and the BJP. Exit poll projections predict that the
BJP is set to make significant gains in the state. Aaj Tak s poll has given
both Trinamool and the BJP equal number of seats 19-22 to Trinamool and
19-23 to BJP.
The Times Now-VMR poll predicts a tally of 58 for the BJP and its
allies and 20 for the Mahagathbandhan. The exit poll by Today s Chanakya
for News 24 gives Mahagathbandhan 13 seats and predicts that the BJP
will sweep UP, winning as many as 65 seats. Projections by Aaj Tak-Axis
My India data predict that the NDA will win 62-68 seats in UP. None of the
pollsters predict more than two seats for the Congress in the state.
India's most populous state Uttar Pradesh holds the key for formation
of government at the Centre. It alone sends 15% or 80 of total 543
members in the Lok Sabha. BJP had bagged 71 of 80 seats in the state in
2014 Lok Sabha election, one fourth of the total 282 seats won by the party
nationwide.
Similarly, News18-IPSOS survey has projected the BJP will win 60-
62 seats in Uttar Pradesh, while SP-BSP-RLD alliance is expected to win
17-19 seats. According to News24-Chanakya BJP is expected to win 65
seats in the state.
The Congress and some other parties had been keen on drafting a
pre-poll Common Minimum Programme (CMP) to showcase the strength of
the anti-NDA camp in the run-up to the Lok Sabha election. That initiative
didn’t go beyond preliminary discussions.
The Lok Sabha Polls 2019 saw tight competition between political
rivals and one of the biggest battles was fought in the Hindi heartland.
Times Now-VMR exit poll throws light on the road ahead. The Bharatiya
Janata Party (BJP) is trying to not just hold Congress in its tracks but also
fend off bitter fight offered by regional parties like Bahujan Samaj Party
(BSP), Samajwadi Party (SP), Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD), Janata Dal
(United), National Conference and Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) among
others. North India is particularly significant for the Lower House as a large
17
chunk of the seats are at stake with Uttar Pradesh alone bringing in 80
seats in the 543-seat Lok Sabha. Add to that Bihar (40 seats).
Even though the 2014 election was billed as the first presidential-style
contest, there is little doubt that when Jawaharlal Nehru or Indira Gandhi or
even an Atal Bihari Vajpayee were leading their parties in the election, a
key driver of voter motivation was national leadership. In 2014 too,
Narendra Modi's appeal swung voters towards the BJP, but this was also
laced with a very high degree of anti-incumbency.
But in 2019, the election was very clearly posited as one between
those who wanted Modi as prime minister and those who did not want
Modi. It was thus more a referendum than a presidential contest. The BJP
decided to just project Modi. A party strategist in UP mentioned to this
writer, with a smile, that he did not have to worry much, for Narendra Modi
was fighting in all the 80 seats of the state. Modi made it a point to remind
his audiences that a vote for kamal (the lotus, the BJP's symbol) would
come straight to him. The non-BJP camp, for its part, decided to emphasise
local issues and stitch together local alliances. If Modi indeed sweeps the
polls, then one could argue that this has been the most definitive election
fought solely on the question of national leadership in recent Indian history.
18
Alternatively, if he does not fare well, one could argue that India is too
complex for only one issue — a national leader — to prevail and the
parliamentary system inherently encourages diverse political players.
Over the past five years, Amit Shah has built an astonishing election
machine. The party has enrolled millions of new members; it has kept
booth committees operational between polls; it is relentless in using the
organisational apparatus to contact beneficiaries of government schemes;
it deploys enormous financial resources during campaigns; it dominates the
media space; it has the larger Sangh parivar to push out its message; and
while personal battles exist, the control is such that factionalism is not
allowed to manifest itself too strongly. A lot of this is possible because of
the presence of full-time cadres, a clear chain of command, and
micromanagement from the very top.
19
connect itself to its own workers, use data, build booth committees, but all
of this is work in progress. And then you have regional parties. The
Bahujan Samaj Party, Biju Janata Dal, DMK, and Trinamool Congress have
very robust, organised structures on to the ground. The outcome will tell us
which model of party organisation delivers better results in India.
Three: Is India voting as one, or will the diversity of Indian political traditions
and social structure and the distinctive history of each region continue to
throw up multiple players?
If the results reflect the exit polls, it is clear that the BJP's footprint
has expanded in areas which had been inhospitable earlier, particularly the
east. But it appears to have hit a roadblock in the south. On the other hand,
the Congress seems set to do well in the south, according to the exit polls,
but it is to be seen whether it can actually rebuild its strength in the north,
capitalise on gains it made in MP, Rajasthan and Chhattisgarh, and recover
any ground in the east. There is then the big variable of regional forces. If
the Mahagatbandhan is able to stop the saffron juggernaut in UP, and
Mamata Banerjee is able to do so in West Bengal, it will show the resilience
of locally rooted federal leaders. In UP, this would be driven by caste; in
Bengal, it would be driven by sub-nationalism and a strong, often violent,
party machine. The outcome will show whether across regional and social
diversity, there is backing for one idea, leader and a party, the growth or
decline in the footprint of national forces, and whether specific regional or
caste aspirations remain dominant factors.
20
FOUR: And finally: Is it time to conceptualise a new normal of Indian
politics where a single party can attain a majority or are we returning to the
1989-2014 normal with heterogeneity in the political sphere?
The exit polls predicted that Prime Minister Narendra Modi was set to
retain power with the NDA led by him likely to get seats in the range of 336
and 360 in the House of 542.
21