Professional Documents
Culture Documents
185 views
Yamashita v. Styer
Uploaded by Anit Emerson on Sep
23, 2015
Full description
Yamashit
av.St
yer(
1945)
Moran,C.
J.
FACTS:
•Peti
ti
on erGe n.T omo y uk iYa ma sh it
a-t he“ Tig ero fMa la ya”-wa st hec omma nd ingg ener aloft he1 4thAr my
Groupo ftheJ apanes eI mp eri
al Ar myi nt hePhi li
p pines .
•Hec omma nd edt heJ ap anes ear myi nt heirr etreatf romt hePh ili
ppi nes( 194 4- 45),wh ereint heJ ap anesear my
commi tt
edar son,mur der ,rape,pi l
lage,andot herat roc itiesagai ns ttheFi lipinoandAmer i
canpeopl es.
•Sep.3 ,1 945–Fo llowi ngt h edef eato fJ apa n,Ya ma shi tas urre nd er e
dt oth eUSAr myi nBa gu i
o.Hebe camea
Unit
edSt a t
esPr ison ero fWa ra ndwa sh eldi nNe w Bi l
ibi dPr ison .
•Oct.1,1 94 5–Byc omma n do fr esp onde ntGe n.Wi lli
a m St yer( Co mma nd ingGe ne ra l
,USAr my ,We st
e rnPa ci
fic)
andpur s uan ttoaut h orizationf rom Gen er al Headquar t
er s ,Uni t
edSt atesAr myFor c es,Wes ternPac ific,aMi li
tary
Commi ss i
onwa sap po intedt ot ryY ama shita .
•Oct.2,1 94 5–Ac ha r gef orv iolationoft hel a wsofwarwa ss erv edu po nYa ma shita.
o Th ec har geal lege dt hatd uringth ep er i
odbe twe enOc t.9,1 94 4a ndSep t
.3 ,1945,Ya ma shit
a," wh il
e
comman deroft hear medf orcesofJ apanatwarwi tht heUni t
edSt at esandi t
salli
es ,unl awfull
y
disre gard eda ndf aile
dt od ischargehi sdu tyasc omman dert oc ont rolth eo perati
on so ft heme mb er sof
hisc ommand,per mi tt
ingt hem t oc ommi tbr utal atroc it
iesandot herhi ghc rimesag ains tthepeopl eoft he
Uni tedSt atesandi t
sal li
esanddependenc i
es ,par ticular l
yt hePhi lippines ."
•Oct.8,1945–Uponar r
aignment ,Yamas hitap leadedno tg uilt
y .Ont hesamed ate,t hepr osec utionfi l
edab ill
of
part
icularss pec i
fy i
ng6 4o ffe ns esc o mmi ttedb yYa ma sh ita.La ter12 3o ffe ns eswe read ded.
•Oct.19,1 945–Yama sh it
amo v edt od ismi sst hec ase ,a llegin g:
o thatt hec har ge–asmodi fiedbyt hebi l
l
sofpar t
ic ulars–f ail
edt os tateav iolati
onoft hel awsofwarby
Y ama shita;
o thatt heMi l
i
tar yCommi ss i
onhadnoj urisdictiont ot ryt hec as e.
•Oct.29,1 945–Yama sh it
a’smo ti
ont od ismi sswasde nie d.T ri
a lo fthec as eb eg ano nthes amed ay.
o Att heopeni ngoft hetr i
al,thepr osec ut i
ons tatedt hatt heUni tedSt atesdi dnotgi v enot iceoft het rialto
thepr otec ti
ngpowero fJ apan( Sp ain) ,suc hno tic eb ei ngr equi r
edb yAr ticle60oft heGene vaCon ven ti
on,
a ndbyp ar agr aph13 3o ftheRu le sofL an dWa r fare ,Un i
te dSt atesWa rDe pa rt
me nt.
o Thedef ens eobj ec tedt ot heintroduc tiont ot wopi ec esofev idenc e( bot hobj ecti
onswer eov erruled) :
!
Affida vi tofNauk ataUt sunomi a,ont hegr oundst hatAr ticl
eofWar25pr ohibitedt heintroduc t
ion
ofdepos it
ionsbyt hepr os ec ut i
oni nt rialsofc api t
al cas esbef oreac ourt-mar ti
al ormi l
itary
commi ssion;
!
Un sp ec ifiedpi e ceofh ea rsa yev iden ce ,o nt h egr o un dt hatt h ea dmi ssiono fh ea rsayev iden ce
Search
violatedAr t
icl
eofWar38aswel l ast her ulesofev i
denc einUSdi s tri
ctcour ts.
Upload EN
•Yamas hitat henfi l
edap eti
tionf orh abeascor pusandpr ohi biti
onagai ns tGen.St yer,prayin gthatheber eturned
topri
soner -
of -wars tatusandt hatt heMi li
tar yCommi ssi onbepr ohi bitedf rom t ry i
nghi scas e.
Home
I
SSUES+RULI
Download
NG:
Search document
Doest
heMi
l
it
aryCommi
ssi
onha
vej
uri
sdi
ct
iont
otr
yYamas
hit
a’
scas
e?YES.
• TheSupr emeCour t,beingac i
vi
l c
ourt,hasnoj ur
is
dicti
ontogr anttheremedi esbeingprayedfor
,asthet ri
ali
s
mil
i
taryinnatur
eandt heMi li
t
aryCommi s
sionhasno tbeenimpl eaded.
Saved TheSupr emeCour ts t
illhasnoj ur
isdictiont oentert
aint hepe ti
ti
one ve niftheMi l
it
aryCommi ssionis
i
mpl eadedasar espondent .
o Raquiz
av .Bradford:Anex er
ciseofj uri
sdi
cti
onbyt hec ivi
lcourt
sov ertheUni t
edStatesArmybef oret
he
expi
rat
ionofthes t
ateofwari sav iolati
onofthec ountr
y’sfait
h.Thisr ul
i
ngappl i
eswit
hgreaterforceto
Yamashit
a,whoi saccus edofc ommi t
ti
nghorri
bleatrocit
iesagains
tt heFil
ipinopeopl
e.
Bestsellers
Books
Audiobooks
You're reading a preview. Unlock full access with a free trial. Download
Snapshots Pages 2 to 3 are not shown in this preview. With Free
Trial
Magazines
Documents
Di
dthechar
• geagai
o ns tYamas hit
as tateav i
olati
onoft hel awsofwar ?YES.
Theoc harge,asmo difiedb ythet wobi l
lsofpar ti
c ulars,c l
earlyspec ifiestheoff ensesc ommi t
tedund erYamas hi
ta ’
s
c omomand .
•T
Ahmeos
neg“a
t
hl
el
eg
sed
e chir
ar
e
r
ggeu
sl
ar
–i
t
wie
hs
i
c”
h c
a n
r
eno
at
lld
oi
v
ffens
t
s t
eh
seaC
g o
aim
nsm
tti
s
h s
ei
on
l
awo
sfoit
s
fwj
u
a r
i
rs
ad
si
c
dt
i
eo
sn
c.r
iF
bu
er
dth
i
ner
Pmo
a
rr
ae
g,
rt
ah
pe
h3i
s
4sue
7 oc
fa
t
hn
eno
Rt
ub
lee
s
re vi
e
ofLanw ed
dWari
naf h
ara be
e-aras
e:corpus proce edi
ng .
brutal mas sacreofc ivi
li
annonc ombat ant s,includingba yonet i
ngofchildren
DI
SPOSITI ON:P reti
tion
apeofy d i
sm i
ss
ounggied
rl
s.
hateful pil
l
ageofpubl ic,pri
vate,andr eligiouspr operty
OZAETA,J. ,c oncur ringanddi sse nting:
Di
dt •T
heinh
te
r
odruli
cn
tg
i
oni
nofRiaa
nqui
dmza
i
s v
s.
i
bB
ler
aed
vf
o
idr
edd
ncoe
eos
v n
eo
rt
Yaa
pp
m al
y
s ht
o
i
tath
’
sisb
o ca
j
es
ce
t.
i
onThe
d r
epu
rl
i
vi
n
eghi
n
mt
i h
oa
ftc
har
i
ss e
i
ghw
ta
tsa
omfis
t
aa
rk
ite
rn
i
al,
?
Nf
or
Ot
.her ul
e
statedt hereina ssume st hatt herea ret wo s ov ereignc ountr
ies.The a r
mi eso fth e Unit
ed Statesa reint he
Ph il
ippinesb yv i
rtueo fUS s overeigntyo vert he Ph il
ippineisland sa ndn otb yp ermissi
on,h encet her ul
eof
internat i
onall aw ex emptingf oreignar miesfrom t hej urisdi
cti
onofc i
vi
landc ri
minalc ourt
soft hec ountr
iesthat
hos tedt hem wi thper missionoft heso verei
gnc ouldn ota pply.
•
Related Interests
Military Justice Military Occupation War Crime Law Of War Evidence (Law
Contact Us Publishers
Invite Friends
Gifts
Copyright © 2019 Scribd Inc. . Browse Books . Site Directory . Site Language: English