Professional Documents
Culture Documents
in
POLITICAL SCIENCE
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 0_Introduction.indd 1 12-09-2018 19:40:45
www.tntextbooks.in
Content Creation
The wise
possess all
II
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 0_Introduction.indd 2 12-09-2018 19:40:45
www.tntextbooks.in
Introduction QR Code
To motivate the students to
A brief abstract of the unit. further explore and enrich the
concept
Activity Reference
To explore further about the List of books that can be referred
subject in order to get better when there needs a better
understanding of the subject. understanding.
Conversation ICT
Exchange of ideas which will Lead to improved students
give better clarity to the subject. learning and better teaching
methods.
Quotable quote
Q uotable
uote Quotes of eminent political
thinkers that helps to bring
Key Terms
Helps the students to know
enlightenment among students. the Tamil translation of
key terms.
III
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 0_Introduction.indd 3 12-09-2018 19:40:46
Career Opportunities in Political Science
There are plenty of career opportunities available to the students of political science. The options
and opportunities can be detailed in two categories of higher education and employment
POLITICAL SCIENCE
IV
state as well as in our country 5. Alagappa University, Karaikudi (Correspondence course in Public Administration)
Bachelor of Arts (BA) 6. Tamil Nadu Open University, Chennai
Master of Arts (MA) 7. Manonmaniam Sundaranar University, Tirunelveli (Correspondence Course)
Master of Philosophy (MPhil)
A.3) Central Universities
Doctor of Philosophy (PhD).
www.tntextbooks.in
There are number of central universities across India where students can learn
A.1) Tamil Nadu Government and Aided Colleges political science.
1. The University of Delhi
1. Presidency College, Chennai.
2. Pondicherry University
2. Government Arts College, Coimbatore.
3. University of Hyderabad
3. Thiruvalluvar Government Arts College, Rasipuram, Namakkal District.
4. Gandhigram Rural Institute (Deemed to be University), Dindugal and
4. Loganatha Narayanasamy Government Arts College, Ponneri, Thiruvallur District.
5. Indira Gandhi Open University, New Delhi
5. Periyar Government Arts College, Cuddalore.
6. Jawaharlal Nehru University(JNU), New Delhi
6. Government Arts College, Thiruvarambur, Trichy.
7. Government Arts College, Salem-0
A.4) Integrated program
8. Rajeswari Vedachalam Government Government Arts College, Chengalpattu.
9. Madras Christain College, Tambaram, Chennai The Department of Social Sciences and Humanities in Indian Institute of Technology,
10. Pasumpon Muthuramalinga Thevar College, Usilampatti, Madhurai –25 Madras offers the five year integrated MA Program in two streams of Development
11. Pasumpon Thiru Muthuramalinga Thevar Memorial College, Studies and English Studies
Kamuthi, Ramanathapuram
12. SIET College for Women, Teynampet, Chennai.
13. Anna Adarsh College for Women, Chennai
12-09-2018 19:40:46
A.5) Jawaharlal Nehru University(JNU), New Delhi B. Employment Opportunities
National Institutional Ranking Framework (NIRF) of the Human Resources
Development Ministry has ranked JNU as the second best university in the country. The students of Political Science have bright career prospects. They can choose their
It offers Post Graduation, Master of Philosophy (MPhil), Doctor of Philosophy career in
degrees in Political Science. Administration
While the School of Social Sciences (SSS) provides these programs in Political Politics
Science the School of International Studies (SIS) conducts these programs in Mass media
VV
Merit cum Means scholarship is available for students. B.1) Civil Service Exam of Union Public Service Commission (UPSC)
The university has a well equipped library consisting of nine floors situated in a lush The Union Public Service Commission conducts numerous competitive exams to
green environment of the Aravali Hills. It is a central university, with a truly national recruit officers for union government. The civil services exam is meant to recruit
character as students hail from almost all the states of our country. officers for Indian Administrative Service (IAS), Indian Police Service (IPS), Indian
Foreign Service (IFS), and Indian Revenue Service (IRS) etc.
www.tntextbooks.in
12-09-2018 19:40:47
In Mains Test:
B.4) Teaching Career in Colleges and Universities
There are seven countable papers in the second stage, Main Exam. The syllabus of the
General studies second paper exclusively contains Indian polity and international There are three kinds of faculty positions in universities available for the aspirants of an
relations and carries 250 marks. The essay paper normally contains questions from academic career in Tamil nadu and India. They are Professor, Associate Professor and
Indian politics and international relations and has 250 marks. The students can choose Assistant Professor. There are two levels of faculty positions (Assistant Professor and
political science and international relations as their Optional Subject and the two Associate Professor) in the colleges in our state.
optional subject papers have 250 marks each. Therefore the students with political The candidates should get through the State Eligibility Test (SET) conducted by the
VIVI
devotes a greater amount of attention to the topics and issues of political science and
international relations. schools should write Tamil Nadu Teachers Eligibility Test (TNTET). The candidates
who want to join as the Postgraduate Assistants in Government Higher Secondary
schools in Tamil Nadu Higher Secondary Educational Service should write the second
B.3) TNPSC Exams exam. The Teacher Recruitment Board (TRB) conducts the above mentioned
recruitment tests.
www.tntextbooks.in
The Tamil Nadu Public Service Commission recruits officers and personnel to Tamil
Nadu government. It conducts around seventy different exams. The important exams B.6) Opportunities in Media
include Group 1 Services Examination, Group 1-A Services Examination, Combined
There are plenty of opportunities in mass media for students of Political Science. They
Subordinate Services Examination-1(CSSE-1) and Combined Subordinate Services
can branch into print journalism, television news channels and digital media. The news
Examination-2 (CSSE-2) etc. All these exams have a general knowledge paper.
media preponderantly deals with politics, society, environment, culture and
Around twenty percent of questions in the question papers will originate from Indian
international issues and a good grounding in Political Science and international
polity and international relations.
relations can intellectually empower and enrich a career in media. After graduation in
The Group One exam is conducted for recruiting officers to the top services in the political science the interested students can do a course in media in institutions like
state like Deputy Collector, Deputy Superintendent of Police, District Employment
1. Indian Institute of Mass Communication, New Delhi
Officer, District Fire Officer and Assistant Commissioner in Commercial Services. The
2. Asian College of Journalism in Chennai and become successful in media.
Deputy Collectors after eight to ten years of service will be promoted as IAS officers.
Similarly the Deputy Superintendent of Police will be promoted as IPS officers after
B.7) Police Service
eight to ten years of service.
They can enter police department as Sub Inspectors after getting through the Tamil
There are three stages in the Group 1 exam. They are preliminary test, main test and
Nadu Uniformed Services Recruitment Board (TNSURB) exam for the recruitment of
personal interview. Indian constitution, politics, international politics and Indian foreign
Sub Inspectors or as Constables after cracking police constable recruitment exam of
policy are very important in all three stages of the exam and students of political science
TNUSRB.
can attend these questions confidently. The other recruitment tests of TNPSC also
contain a certain percent of questions from Political Science
12-09-2018 19:40:47
B.7) Career in Law In United kingdom
Political Science and Law are closely related disciplines. The students of Political 1. the University of Oxford
Science after 12th standard can study the five year integrated law course Bachelor of 2. London School of Economics and Political Science
Arts and Bachelor of Legislative Law (B.A.LL.B) or after graduation can pursue the 3. University of Cambridge
three year Bachelor of Legislative Laws (LL.B) degree. The important entrance exams
include Common Law Admission Test (CLAT) and All India Law Entrance Test
VII
Political Science is like the skill set of a swimmer. The person with swimming skills
VII
5. Government Law College, Mumbai
6. Faculty of Law in Delhi University, are among the top institutions in the country. can swim in any water body whether it is a pond or a lake or an ocean. A political
science student with apt knowledge, attitude and skills can join any career of general
After completing the law degree the candidates can practice as lawyers or become
nature.
judges in courts. They can aspire to become the judges in the District Courts, High
Courts and Supreme Court. There are constitutionally prescribed qualifications for
Websites of Political Science institutions:
www.tntextbooks.in
12-09-2018 19:40:47
www.tntextbooks.in
CONTENT
8.1 Liberalism
8.2 Communism
Unit 8:
8.3 Socialism
Political 1
8.4 Nationalism
Ideologies - Part I
8.5 Fascism
8.6 Nazism
9.1 Anarchism
Unit 9 : 9.2 Feminism
Political 9.3 Communitarianism 41
Ideologies - Part II 9.4 Postmodernism
9.5 Environmentalism
VIII
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 0_Introduction.indd 8 12-09-2018 19:40:47
www.tntextbooks.in
IX
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 0_Introduction.indd 9 12-09-2018 19:40:47
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 0_Introduction.indd 10 12-09-2018 19:40:47
www.tntextbooks.in
UNIT
Introduction
Ideology refers to a set of inter-related ideas dealing with
politics, society and economy. Political ideologies are very
important in Political Science and are considered as heart and
soul of Political Science. They deal with the nature and origin
of the state, relationship between state and society,
forms of government, basis of state authority
and sphere of state action. Numerous ideologies
operate in our subject and we will examine them
in the forth coming two chapters.
Learning Objectives
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 1 12-09-2018 19:35:19
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 2 12-09-2018 19:35:19
www.tntextbooks.in
B. Positive Liberalism
Negative liberalism metamorphosed
into Positive liberalism in the 20th
century. Even though Negative Liberalism
contributed to the generation of
unprecedented wealth in the western
countries it had also inflicted enormous
Economically, Negative Liberalism pain on common people. Glaring
supports free market economy based on inequalities among people, appearance
demand and supply. It prohibits the State of slums in the cities and exploitation of
from interfering with the economic the workers exposed the deficiencies of
activities. The State is akin to a cricket Negative Liberalism. Humanist thinkers
umpire in its powers and functions. The like Ruskin protested against the misery
umpire does not play the game but watches of the people.
whether the players are playing the game
in accordance with the laws of the game. In this backdrop, Negative Liberalism
Similarly the State should not interfere in changed into Positive Liberalism because of
the economy as market alone determines two important factors i.e. Democracy and
its activities. Marxism. Nineteenth century witnessed
the gradual spread of democracy whereby
the common people came to be provided
The Wealth with voting rights. They demanded
of Nations fundamental changes in politics. The
- Adam Smith second factor is the advent and rise of
Marxism that appealed to the workers
to overthrow the exploitative inequality-
Negative Liberalism believes in the laden Negative Liberalism. Subsequently,
concept of natural rights. When Mother under pressure from democracy and
Nature created man, it endowed him with Marxism, Negative Liberalism changed
basic rights that are called Natural Rights. into Positive Liberalism.
The State should not erode or undermine
3
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 3 12-09-2018 19:35:19
www.tntextbooks.in
Positive Liberalism brought out the new concept of Social Welfare State. This concept
projects the State as a positive instrument for the promotion of social welfare. The role of
the State is to provide social service to the people. It should construct and maintain
hospitals, educational institutions, factories and industries, infrastructural facilities like
roads, railway tracks and ports. The State also came to be known as Social Democratic
State, a nomenclature that explains the significance of democracy in the constitution of a
positive State.
ACTIVITY
Discuss about the contributions of John Stuart Mill to the concept of Liberalism
Functions of State
Positive Liberalism
Fair Price
Education Health Industries Transport Shop
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 4 12-09-2018 19:35:20
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 5 12-09-2018 19:35:20
www.tntextbooks.in
M.Oakeshott, Karl Popper, Milton second half of the 20th century and in the first
Friedman, Nozick and Nock are important half of the 21st century. It believes in the worth
among the supporters of libertarianism. and importance of individuals. It advocates
individual freedom as indispensable for the
There is all the difference in the world life of man. It staunchly supports the concept
between treating people equally and of ‘Personal Autonomy’ whereby every
attempting to make them equal. human being is provided with complete
- Friedrich Hayek freedom of choice to make decisions in their
life as they want. It restricts the domain of
the State to maintenance of law and order.
A Society that puts equality before Nozick famously coined the slogan ‘Minimal
freedom will get neither. A society State is Inspiring as Well as Right’. He
that puts freedom before equality
criticised any more functions of the State
will get a high degree of both.
as unjustified and unwarranted. Another
- Milton Friedman proponent of Libertarianism, Oakeshort
commented that the government merely
Libertarianism is a re-invention and pursues peace.
re-application of Classical Liberalism in the
Functions of state
Positive Liberalism
Philosophers Leaders
P.V.
Friedrich Albert Jay Milton Ronald Margaret Mikhail
M. Oakeshott Narasimha
Hayek Nock Friedman Reagan Thatcher Rao Gorbachev
Albert Jay
Nock, a Libertarian
Karl Popper described Plato as even went to the
a enemy of open society in his work extent of titling his
“Open society and its' enemies”. book “Our Enemy
the State”
The libertarians argue that the increase
ACTIVITY in the functions of the State in the name
of development and social welfare leads
Relate Karl Popper comment with inevitably to emergence of collectivism and
Plato’s philosopher king concept that resultant concentration of power in the
you have studied in 1st volume. hands of the State leading to the destruction
of personal liberties of man.
6
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 6 12-09-2018 19:35:20
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 7 12-09-2018 19:35:21
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 8 12-09-2018 19:35:21
www.tntextbooks.in
De c
t i on
in every industry and factory by a
i s i on
Central Unit
E lec
small group of workers who possess
s
knowledge of Revolutionary Marxism. State Units
They must possess qualities and abilities
District Units
like dedication, commitment and hard
work. The members of the Communist Village & Town Units
Party should mobilize the workers
ideologically to conduct the revolution.
Imperialism
Lenin asserted that the party must be in
the vanguard of the proletariat that is the Imperialism refers to the system
forefront of the Proletariat Revolution. where European countries subjugated
and exploited the Asian and African
It was expounded that the countries through military conquest and
Communist Party should be organised force. Lenin expounded a new insight
on the basis of an innovative concept linking imperialism and capitalism in his
called Democratic Centralism. As the book ‘Imperialism: The Highest Stage
name indicates there are two features of Capitalism’. He argued that capitalism
in the organisational structure of had not faced self- destruction as Marx
the Communist Party, democracy and predicted. The capitalist countries exploit
centralism. Democratically, the lower the subjugated Asian and African countries
organs of the party organisation must and through this looted wealth capitalism
elect the members of the higher organs of sustains itself in their home countries. There
the party. The party units in villages must should be two revolutionary struggles,
elect the party units of the district and one the struggle of Asian-African countries
State units are to be elected by the district against the imperialist Europe and another
units of the party and the central unit will revolutionary struggle of working class
be elected by the State units. in the western countries. Once these two
struggles become successful, the two inter
The element of centralism in the -linked exploitative forces of capitalism
Communist Party means that the decisions and imperialism will be destroyed
of the higher unit must be accepted and and communist society of equality and
implemented by the lower units. The State fraternity will be born internationally.
units should accept the decisions of the
9
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 9 12-09-2018 19:35:21
www.tntextbooks.in
10
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 10 12-09-2018 19:35:21
www.tntextbooks.in
11
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 11 12-09-2018 19:35:21
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 12 12-09-2018 19:35:21
www.tntextbooks.in
Maoism continues to be the ruling Its ideas are repeatedly driven into
ideology of the People’s Republic of China the minds of the people. Only when it fails
in the twenty first century in a changed to create the consent of the people, it starts
milieu. The paramount leader Deng using brutal force to carry out its activities.
Xiaoping introduced massive changes in Gramsci also argues that, to destroy
Chinese economy after 1978. Its economy the capitalist State, the revolutionaries
has been infused with liberalization and should use organic intellectuals and
globalization modifying fundamentally the Communist Party. The organic
the communist economy of Mao period. intellectuals will analyze the strength
But politically, the Communist Party of of the State and elucidate the means of
China continues to exercise monopoly destroying the State. The Communist
of power. Party will carry out the revolution and
establish the ideal state of communism.
13
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 13 12-09-2018 19:35:22
www.tntextbooks.in
Conversation
Teacher : You are correct. It was a mammoth political entity in the world. It
symbolized the ideology of Marxism.
Student 3 : Sir, what happened to it? Why don’t we hear anything about it nowadays?
Teacher : Dear students, it does not exist anymore. It faced internal disintegration
in 1991 and disappeared from the face of the world.
Teacher : The communist country collapsed due to many reasons. There was
an unsolvable economic crisis. Politically rights were not available to
the people. It had to maintain a very expensive military. The cold war
between the United States and U.S.S.R was destroying the economic
capacity of the country.
Student 2 : Sir, if a great country suddenly imploded it must have surely left
repercussions on the world. What was the impact of its collapse?
Teacher : Yes, my dear student. It left a number of short term and long term
repercussions. Positively it made the advent of democracy in Russia. It
ended the cold war and eliminated the threat of nuclear war. It also led
to the birth of fifteen new, independent nations.
Teacher : Of course, it left many negative effects too. For example, communism as
an ideological alternative of hope for humankind was weakened heavily.
It created rivalry between the successor nations. The world came to be
dominated by one powerful nation. Russia lost its stature among the
nations of the world. India lost a traditional friend.
14
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 14 12-09-2018 19:35:22
www.tntextbooks.in
15
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 15 12-09-2018 19:35:22
www.tntextbooks.in
8.3 Socialism
Socialism is an ideology that
supports public ownership of property ST. SIMON ROBERT OWEN CHARLES FOURIER
16
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 16 12-09-2018 19:35:23
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 17 12-09-2018 19:35:23
www.tntextbooks.in
and expert leadership to promote social in Italy, Bauer in Austria. It argues for an
welfare. evolutionary change in capitalism. It
"Revolutions have never believes that along with economic factors
lightened the burden of non-economic factors are also important
tyranny. They have only to explain human life. Democratic
shifted it to another soul" Socialism and Evolutionary Socialism are
- George Bernard Shaw inter-related. Marxism attacked
Evolutionary Socialism as ‘revisionism’
and ‘broker’s view of socialism’.
In India Jawaharlal Nehru is an
ardent champion of Fabian Socialism
Evolutionary Socialism
Fabianism believed that socialism
and democracy are complementary and - Eduard Bernstein
supplementary to each other. They are to
be appreciated as noble ideals of equality
and justice are dearer to them. The Fabians E. Guild Socialism
did not advocate the abolition of private
property. On the contrary, they supported It is a kind of evolutionary socialism
existence of limited right to property that emerged in Great Briton in the first
governed by the principle of social welfare. two decades of the 20th century. The
English political thinker and the founder
Fabianism as an evolutionary of National Guilds League in England, D
socialism rejected Communist H Cole was the leading advocate of this
revolutionary methods of change. It brand of socialism. He wrote the book
supported peaceful methods of change in ‘Guild Socialism: A Plan for Economic
society. The Fabian ideologues depended Recovery’ to propagate the tenets of Guild
on persuasion tactics to realize socialism. Socialism. Guild Socialism criticized the
exploitation of workers by the capitalists
D. Evolutionary Socialism in the western world and arose as a protest
ideology against capitalism
Evolutionary Socialism was initially
advocated by Lassalle, one of the earliest
Guild Socialism
leaders of the German Social Democracy
A Plan for Economic
tradition. The ideals of Evolutionary
Democracy
Socialism were formally expounded in the
Gothe Programme in 1875, an important - G.D.H. Cole
document in the evolution of socialism in
Germany and Europe. Later on, Eduard The word guild refers to the
Bernstein wrote the book ‘Evolutionary association of craftsmen and artisans of
Socialism’ that attracted the many a particular profession in the medieval
supporters like Jaures in France, Anseele
18
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 18 12-09-2018 19:35:23
www.tntextbooks.in
19
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 19 12-09-2018 19:35:23
www.tntextbooks.in
Communism Socialism
1. Revolution is the mid-wife of change 1. Evolutionary changes are more enduring
and beneficial
2. The state is an instrument of exploitation of 2. The state should not be abolished. It should
the property-less class by the rich class and be made more democratic and social
therefore should be abolished welfare oriented.
3. Class struggle is the fundamental force of 3. Violent class struggle is unnecessary.
change in human history.
4. The right to private property must be 4. T he right to private property must be
abolished. modified and limitations must be imposed
for social welfare
5. Historical materialism can explain human 5. Historical Materialism is not adequate
history. Economy alone drives human to explain human history. Apart from
history. economy, other factors like culture, politics
and religion are also important to explain
human history
F. Socialism in India
The 42nd Constitutional
The Indian kind of socialism is Amendment Law introduced socialism as
known as Socialistic Pattern of Society that an official feature of the Preamble of our
was adopted by the Indian State in the mid Constitution. The 44th Constitutional
1950s. Provision of all basic necessities Amendment Act removed the Right to
to all people irrespective of caste, creed, Property from the list of Fundamental
religion, race and gender and elimination Rights and made it an ordinary right
of poverty, inequality and illiteracy are the in Part XII of the Constitution. The
objectives of Indian Socialism. Parliament Directive Principles of State Policy in
passed a resolution for the establishment Part IV of the Constitution contains
of Planning Commission In 1950. The many provisions that are designed to
strategy of Five Year Plan was implemented promote socialistic objectives like Right
to promote development with socialist to Work and avoidance of concentration
content from 1951. We adopted a Mixed of wealth in the hands of a few people.
Economy where both private and public India had adhered to socialism from the
sectors were allowed to operate. We year of independence to 1991 when we
provided the commanding heights of the launched our New Economic Reforms
economy to the public sector to achieve that favored liberalization, privatization
development and equality. and globalization.
20
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 20 12-09-2018 19:35:23
www.tntextbooks.in
21
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 21 12-09-2018 19:35:23
www.tntextbooks.in
who identify with and agree on a common most paramount factor in the evolution
descent. The people consider themselves and operation of nationalism. They
as belonging to an extended family. For argue that though nations and nationalist
them, the nation is the family writ large. sentiments existed in the medieval period,
Nationalism is a blend of both rationalism nationalism blossomed fully only in the
and irrationalism. It is a ‘primitive mind modern period with the emergence of the
with modern techniques’. As for as the modern State. Anthony Giddens argued
roots are concerned nationalism relies on that the advent of French Revolution
the past. But on its relations with other engineered the birth and growth of
groups it is contemporary. Nationalism nationalism all over Europe.
shows the face of ethno centrism towards
the members of the group and xenophobia Michael Mann articulated that there
to the members of the other groups and are four sources of social power. They are
nations. 1) Ideological power 2) Economic power
3) Military power and 4) Political power.
Post-Ideological Theory of Nationalism These four sources, often in combination
A number of theorists propounded acted historically to produce nationalism
the post-ideological theories of in different periods. The ideological factor
nationalism. Anthony Giddens, Paul Brass in the form of religion promoted the birth
and Michael Mann are the main authors of infant nations as in the case of England
of this theory. in the 16th century. The second phase
saw the economic, especially commercial
power contributing to the birth of
Ec nationalism in Western Europe. The
er on
ow
c al P om military power influenced the origin of
ol ogi ic
Po nationalism in the third phase and finally
Ide w political power shaped the evolution of
er
nationalism.
i li
ow
Po
ca
er of nationalism.
l
Po
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 22 12-09-2018 19:35:23
www.tntextbooks.in
23
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 23 12-09-2018 19:35:23
www.tntextbooks.in
the same thoughts and ideas leading to the Michael Hechter, Miroslov Hroch
creation of the idea of community in their and Tom Narim are the important Marxist
minds. Capitalism helped in the process theorists to analyze nationalism.
of creation of imaginary community. The
capitalists wanted to earn profits and Indian Nationalism
printed books in large quantities and sold Indian nationalism emerged in the
them. The print capitalism (the combined second half of the 19th century. All Indians
forces of capitalism and printing press) began to think of nationalist feeling
contributed to the advent of nationalism transcending their religious, regional,
in the minds of the people. linguistic, ethnic differences and barriers.
There are two kinds of factors responsible
Marxist Theory of Nationalism
for the emergence of Indian nationalism.
Marxism considers nationalism as They are internal and external factors.
an offspring of capitalism. Nationalism
was created by capitalism to protect the Internally speaking, the concept
exploitative capitalist order. Karl Marx of Indian unity is always ingrained in
contended that the ruling ideas are the minds of the people. Though the
essentially the ideas of the ruling class that Indian subcontinent for many centuries
owns the means of production. The was politically fragmented it continued
capitalist class possesses private property to be culturally unified. The concept
and indulges in the exploitation of the of unity in diversity exists in Indian
property-less class. Nationalism was tradition since ancient period. The seeds
conceived and created by the bourgeois of modern nationalism germinated and
class for its own benefit to numb the grew luxuriantly in the fertile soil of this
feelings of the workers. “Nationalist centuries-old cultural unity.
consciousness is quintessentially a false
consciousness deliberately created Externally, the impact of British
perpetuate and legitimize class colonial rule facilitated the growth of
exploitation”. Marx commented, ‘The Indian nationalism. The major forces are;
Proletariat has no fatherland’. He issued a
A. Colonialism carried out the
clarion call in the ‘The Communist
political, administrative, economic and
Manifest’ to the workers of the world to
communication unification of India. India
conduct revolution for ending capitalism
was a politically divided subcontinent in
and establishing socialism all over the
eighteenth century with over 700 different
world. He favoured internationalism and
territories and rulers. The British unified
opposed nationalism.
them into one country. India followed
Karl Marx village-based economy. Colonialism
introduced modern economy and market
“The Proletariat has no
system unifying the country economically.
fatherland”
The British rule introduced modern
means of communication like railways,
24
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 24 12-09-2018 19:35:23
www.tntextbooks.in
telegraphs, uniform postal system-making period. They reacted against the concept
transport and movement of people, goods of the White Man’s Burden flaunted by
and ideas easier and faster throughout the the colonial rulers. It refers to idea that
subcontinent. The newly unified India in the white people are the most advanced
the 19th century was conducive for the and civilized race in the world and their
emergence of the modern political force mission in India is to civilize the Indian
called nationalism. people. Indian leaders repudiated this
racial myth and mobilized Indian people
B. Western education was introduced through the medium of nationalism.
in India by colonialism. Indians learned
modern political ideas like liberty, F. The patently exploitative and
equality, sovereignty in the classrooms and flagrantly arrogant rule of the Governor
demanded that our motherland should be General Lord Lytten spurred the faster
empowered with those modern political emergence of Indian nationalism. He
values. imposed discrimination on Indian
vernacular press. Measures were taken
C. English became the lingua franca to promote the import of goods from
of India during colonialism. India is a England and to restrict the export of
polyglot nation as it speaks more than Indian goods to England. No active relief
a thousand languages and political was provided by the colonial government
unity was derailed. In this backdrop the when millions of people suffered and
English language became the language even died under severe drought. There
of communication among nationalists was an unnecessary war with Afghanistan
facilitating the growth of nationalism. in which thousands of Indian soldiers
died. Indian nationalism grew as a result
D. The 19th century witnessed of anger against the maladministration of
the emergence of many socio-religious Lord Lytten.
reform movements like Brahmo Samaj
of Raja Ram Mohan Roy, Prarthana G. Lord Ripon was a notable
Samaj, etc. They strove to sow the seeds Governor General of India. Along with
of renaissance and reform in Indian the Law Member Ilbert, the Governor
society. They also revived the memories of General introduced a Bill granting powers
centuries-old great Indian civilization even to Indian judges to sit in the trial of cases
while articulating the need for reforming involving Europeans. There was a huge
Indian society and eliminating evils like protest organized by racist people and the
sati, caste system and untouchability. government was forced to backtrack on
its proposal. Indians were disappointed at
E. Racialism of British rulers and the behaviour of Europeans in India. The
authorities created bitterness among Ilbert Bill controversy taught Indians the
Indian people. Indian nationalism grew art and science of political agitation against
as a protest movement against the racial the negative actions of the government.
humiliation of Indian people in the colonial
25
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 25 12-09-2018 19:35:23
www.tntextbooks.in
Indigenous Factors
Art
Culture Philosophy Civilization
and
Factors of Colonialism
Architecture
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 26 12-09-2018 19:35:24
www.tntextbooks.in
27
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 27 12-09-2018 19:35:24
www.tntextbooks.in
28
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 28 12-09-2018 19:35:24
www.tntextbooks.in
ACTIVITY
Understanding globalisation
What is globalisation?
Trade Liberalisation -
This involves removal of
barriers to international trade, such
as tariffs and import quotas, and the
prioritization of export production.
Some experts argues that the Rich
Nations
Courtesy : Women’s Rights, Geraldine Terry, Pluto Press, Oxfax, Palgrave Macmillan,
Fernwood Publishing.
29
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 29 12-09-2018 19:35:24
www.tntextbooks.in
ideology in the 21st century too. The end exit of Britain from the European Union
of nationalism is not observable even in and the exit of United States from 2015
the distant horizon. The State still retains Paris Accord of the United Nations
with itself the priceless feature of Framework Convention on Climate
sovereignty. The ultimate deciding factor Change on grounds of national interests
of internationalism is still nationalism reveal the relevance and resilience of the
and national interests. The BREXIT or ideology of nationalism.
Sub-Nationalism or
Extra National
Ethno-Nationalism
Challenges
or Secessionism
International
International United Radical Environmental Information
WTO Regional
Migration Nationals Ideologies problems Technology
Organizations
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 30 12-09-2018 19:35:25
www.tntextbooks.in
31
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 31 12-09-2018 19:35:25
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 32 12-09-2018 19:35:25
www.tntextbooks.in
Core Features
Nazism believed in totalitarianism.
It adhered to the historical slogan of the
German philosopher Friedrich Hegel that
‘the State is the march of God on earth’.
Complete obedience was demanded from Nazisim implemented a brutal
the citizens. campaign of persecution against the Jews
that resulted in the killing of millions
Nazism resorted to systematic of people which is now observed as
glorification of war. Hitler said, ‘War the Holocaust. Nazism suppressed Jews
is eternal, war is universal. War is life. holding them responsible for the misery
War is the origin of all things’. This war- of German people. The disproportionately
mongering precipitated the Second World higher representation of Jews in the
War and inflicted misery on mankind. wealthy classes and their lower percentage
presence in lower sections of society
Perhaps the one of the most invited the wrath of the Nazi State. They
controversial principles of Nazism is its were subjected to inhuman conditions in
racial superiority and purity myth. Hitler places of detention known as concentration
considered the Aryan race as the most camps.
intelligent and superlative one calling it
the master race of mankind. He detested Nazism was expansionist. Germany
other races living among or in the vicinity wanted to capture colonies so that the
of German nation especially Jews and Slav surplus population can be exported and
races. A set of laws known as Nuremberg it could overtake England as the colonial
Laws were enacted in 1934 to preserve the giant of the world.
racial purity of the Aryan race. Marital
33
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 33 12-09-2018 19:35:25
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 34 12-09-2018 19:35:25
www.tntextbooks.in
Glossary
35
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 35 12-09-2018 19:35:25
www.tntextbooks.in
Primordialism : The belief that the people Globalization : The integration of the
of a particular language, region, religion, world in economic and commercial
race etc. have developed a great intra- domains
group affinity as they inhabit together Fascism : In Italian language Fasci means
since ancient period. the bundle of rods signifying unity and
Imagined Communities : Benedict strength.
Anderson introduced the terms to argue Concentration Camps : The places where
that the nation is an imagined community the hapless Jews were imprisoned without
exiting only in the mind, imagination of trial, exploited and killed mercilessly by
the people. the Nazi army
Evaluation
I Choose the Correct Answer:
1. Which ideology considered the state as a necessary evil?
a) Negative Liberalism b) Positive Liberalism
c) Marxism d) Anarchism
2. Positive Liberalism viewed the state as an instrument of
a) Law and Order b) Exploitation
c) Social Welfare d) Revolution
3. Libertarianism was supported by
a) Nock b) Nozick
c) F.A. Hayek d) All the Above Thinkers
4. The concept of Hegemony was advocated by
a) Karl Marx b) Lenin
c) Antonia Gramsci d) Mao
36
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 36 12-09-2018 19:35:25
www.tntextbooks.in
5. T
he perspective that the communist party must be the vanguard of the communist
revolution was propagated by
a) Karl Marx b) Lenin
c) Mao d) Stalin
6. The major contribution of Mao to the communist ideology is found in the form of
a) Sinification of Communism b) Historical Materialism
c) Surplus Value d) None of the Above
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 37 12-09-2018 19:35:25
www.tntextbooks.in
16. A
ssertion: Gramsci advocated hegemony.
Reason: The developed nations can exercise control and domination over the
developing counties.
(a) Both A and R are true and R is the correct explanation of A.
(b) Both A and R are true but R is not the correct explanation of A.
(c) A is true but R is false.
(d) A is false but R is true.
38
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 38 12-09-2018 19:35:25
www.tntextbooks.in
29. C
omment on the statement that Nazism and Fascism are the enemies of a
democratic, peaceful and egalitarian world.
30. Enumerate the causative factors of Indian nationalism
IV Answer the following questions in detail
31. Analyze the ideology of Libertarianism
32. Examine the main characteristics of the ideology of Mao
33. Describe the salient features of Fabian Socialism
34. Provide a detailed account on the theories of Nationalism
35. Discuss the chief components of Fascist Ideology
Reference Books
1. A
nderson, B. (1983) Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origins and
Spread of Nationalism. London: Verso
2. G
auba, O.P. (2009) An Introduction to Political Theory, New Delhi: Macmillan
Publishers India Ltd.
3. H
eywood, Andrew(2003) Political Ideologies: An Introduction, London:
Macmillan
4. IGNOU Political Science Study Materials, B.A and M.A
5. R
ajeev Bhargava & Ashok Acharya (Ed) (2016) Political theory: An Introduction,
New Delhi: Thomson press.
6. R
amasamy, Sushila (2009) “Political Theory – Ideas and Concepts, Chennai:
Macmillan India Ltd.
39
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 39 12-09-2018 19:35:25
www.tntextbooks.in
ICT CORNER
Steps 3
Step 1
Steps 4
Step 2
Download Link
*Pictures are indicative only.
*If browser requires, allow Flash Player or Java Script to load the page.
URL: http://www.histropedia.com/
40
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 8.indd 40 12-09-2018 19:35:28
www.tntextbooks.in
UNIT
Introduction
We have learnt a few political ideologies in the previous
chapter. Now we will study the remaining ideologies. The
domain of political ideologies is very fertile and new ones
germinate and blossom regularly. Our subject has witnessed
the emergence of many new ideologies in the last four decades.
9.1 Anarchism
Learning Objectives
Anarchism is a political ideology
To understand the etymology,
that advocates the model of self-governed
characteristics, kinds and thinkers
societies based on innate cooperative
of Anarchism
instincts of man. Etymologically,
To comprehend the meaning,
anarchism is derived from the Greek word
emergence and diverse schools of
'anarchos' meaning 'without authority'.
Feminism
One of the earliest political philosophers
To know a few measures of the
of anarchism was Pierre Joseph Proudhon
Indian State to promote women
who famously described profit as theft.
empowerment
To have knowledge about
the emergence, thinkers Where there is authority,
and main characteristics of there is no freedom
communitarianism especially its - Peter Kropotkin
stand on Man, Society, Rights and
Justice
Russian thinker Peter Kropotkin and
To grasp the meaning and thinkers
Russian author Leo Tolstoy are among
of Post Modernism and also to
the other important advocates of this
examine its views on multiplicity
philosophy.
of truth, particularism and identity
politics Anarchism as an ideology seeks to
To know the basic concepts like abolish all authority and emancipate man
Deep Ecology, Shallow Ecology from the State, property and religion. It
and Ecological Political Theory alternatively visualizes a society based on
To identify a few important voluntary association of human beings.
Ecological Movements of India
Anarchism considers the State as an
unnecessary evil. State is an evil because
41
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 9.indd 41 12-09-2018 19:36:01
www.tntextbooks.in
it suppresses rights and liberties of man Anarchism does not champion the
hindering his moral development. Unlike cause of disorder and disunity. On the
the negative liberalists who called the contrary, it claims to embody order and
State necessary even though it is an evil, unity. Human beings are naturally provided
anarchism rejects the State as an with cooperative instincts. They can lead
unnecessary institution. They argue that a life of happiness and fulfilment guided
the state does not perform any useful by the instinct of voluntary cooperation.
function in society and, therefore, it must But the artificial institution of the State
be exterminated immediately. Bakunin, suppresses the cooperative instincts of
another famous anarchist thinker asserted man. It endangers freedom and rights
that if there is a State, there must be of man. Anarchism aspires to destroy
domination and subjugation of one class the State and implant in its place a new
by another class and therefore all States system of voluntary associations. Every
must vanish. man will voluntarily and enthusiastically
participate in public life. Anarchy does
Anarchy not mean a society without rules, rather
(Noun) a theory holding all forms without rulers.
of governmental authority to be
unnecessary and undesirable and Anarchism believes in the principles
advocation a society based on voluntary of self-determination and self-ownership.
cooperation and free association of Every human being has the right to self-
individuals and groups determination and can decide his or her
Anarchy is not chaos life based on his wishes and freedom.
Anarchy is not lawlessness. Similarly, every person has complete
ownership of himself or herself and this is
Aanrchy is based upon the principle of the most basic form of property. The State
self-ownership. threatens these two important principles
The idea that you are the and therefore should be discarded.
exclusive controller
of your own body ACTIVITY
and life.
Co-operative Life Demonstration
Anarchists are peaceful
people who reject initiated Anarchism believes in co-operative
aggression against anyone instinct of human beings. So, the students
without exception. can form a co-operative organization in
the class and look after the day to day
functioning like keeping the board clean,
ACTIVITY
class room neat and keeping drinking
Recall your understanding of the water. Demonstrate that co-operation,
concept “State as necessary evil” that not coercion makes people work and live
you have studied earlier. Compare and better.
contrast liberalism with Anarchism.
42
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 9.indd 42 12-09-2018 19:36:02
www.tntextbooks.in
ACTIVITY
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 9.indd 43 12-09-2018 19:36:02
www.tntextbooks.in
C. Radical Feminism
There are no innate differences
A. Liberal Feminism between men and women and women
came to be subjugated deliberately for the
The feminist movement, in its purpose of exploitation, is the ideological
infant stage in the late 19th century, crux of Radical Feminism.
advocated equal political rights for
women. It believed that the subordination
of women in society could be rectified " A Woman is not born
with electoral enfranchisement of women but made"
and endowment of other political and - Simone de Beauvoir
economic rights. The State was considered
to be a gender neutral institution.
Therefore granting of voting rights to Simone de Beauvoir, the famous
women will culminate in the fruition of radical feminist and author of the work
women development. The greatest feat of “The Second Sex”, asserted that “A woman
liberal feminism lies in winning voting is not born but made”. Both woman and
rights to women in the democratic western man are endowed with same capacities
countries. when they are born. Male-dominated
44
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 9.indd 44 12-09-2018 19:36:07
www.tntextbooks.in
society and culture known as patriarchy between man and women in personal
creates through indoctrination the domain is not always characterised by the
inequality between them. The differences considerations of love and affection. Even
in gender are created artificially and here struggle, competition and domination
unjustly. We can understand this assertion operate. For example the relations between
when we note the enormous differences in husband and wife and a brother and sister
the status and position accorded to women are not always friendly and affectionate.
among the cultures of the world.
ACTIVITY
Creative Skill
Personal is Political
Women form one half of
- Carole Hanisch
humankind. Their safety and welfare
are very important.
Carole Hanisch, a famous Radical
Dear Students, each student in the
Feminist, brought out the most important
class must think creatively and come
slogan of Radical Feminism - Personal is
up with suggestions to make the world
Political - to reveal patriarchal domination
safe for women as Mothers, Sisters,
over women. The liberal politics divides
Classmates, Friends, Neighbours and
the activities of humankind into personal
Strangers.
and public domains. The personal domain
is considered to be a sphere of personal Struggle and competition can also
life where family operates. It is believed be found in them. Therefore, we should
that there is no scope for conflict and speak about politics, women rights, gender
domination in this sphere and only equality in personal domain too. Radical
love, affection and empathy are relevant. Feminism argues for a revolutionary re-
Women live in the personal sphere and ordering of society and politics to implant
therefore there is no need for political gender equality in personal and public
rights, power and authority for women. domains.
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 9.indd 45 12-09-2018 19:36:08
www.tntextbooks.in
"We are either going and Ethel Crowley are important Post-
to have a future where Colonial Feminists.
women lead the way to
Audre Lorde said, “To imply, however,
make peace with the earth
that all women suffer the same oppression
or we are not going to have
simply because we are women is to lose
a human future at all."
sight of the many varied tools of patriarchy.
- Vandana Shiva
It is to ignore how those tools are used by
There are two schools of thought women without awareness against each
in Eco Feminism. They are Radical other… As an African-American woman in
Feminism and Cultural Feminism. White patriarchy, I am used to having my
Radical Feminism asserts that patriarchy archetypal experience distorted and
or male-dominated system subjugates and trivialised.”
degrades both environment and women.
Male domination of society must be
eliminated to realise the twin objectives of
environmental preservation and women
empowerment.
46
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 9.indd 46 12-09-2018 19:36:08
www.tntextbooks.in
REAL MAN
DON'T HIT
End Domestic violence.
47
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 9.indd 47 12-09-2018 19:36:08
www.tntextbooks.in
48
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 9.indd 48 12-09-2018 19:36:08
www.tntextbooks.in
Communitarianism Meaning
Rights Responsibilities
In short Balancing the Rights and Responsibilities of Individual with Rights and Responsibilities
of Community.
49
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 9.indd 49 12-09-2018 19:36:09
www.tntextbooks.in
For example a child born in Tamil on a new concept of rights where common
Nadu speaks Tamil language fluently good is given importance. They strongly
and not Japanese where as a child born contend that the common good of the
in Japan speaks Japanese fluently and community has supremacy and priority
not Tamil. A man living in a community over the rights of the individuals as it is
where computer technology is already prior to them. Every person may have his
available in developed form may become own conception of good but such
a skilled person in software domain. On individual good must be subordinated to
the contrary, a man living in a remote the idea of common good. A new concept
community that has not witnessed the of positive rights is propagated where in a
growth of information technology will not wide variety of rights like State-subsidised
have adequate software skills. education, State-subsidized housing, safe
environment, universal healthcare are
Concept of State demanded for the community members.
A synthesis between rights and
Communitarianism considers the
responsibilities is advocated by certain
State as a positive instrument that promotes
thinkers who belong to Responsive
the idea of the common good. The concept
Communitarianism.
of common good is present in every
community. The community develops a
set of goals, practices and measures that ACTIVITY
collectively promote the fundamental
Become a Member:
welfare of all. The State should promote
the realisation of the common good and There are many community
act against the activities that promote organizations in your neighbourhood
individual good in contradiction with like Youth Service Centres. Go to their
common good. It should protect and meeting and even enroll yourself in
promote those cultural traditions of the some of these organizations. Observe
community that symbolise and sustain and participate in their activities.
the common good. Communitarianism Analyze and prepare a report on the
supports a State that is democratically functioning of these community level
elected and constituted. They strongly organizations devoid of caste and
aspire for a State that is responsible and religious affiliations and discuss with
responsive to demands of the community. your friends.
Concept of Rights
Positive Rights of Communitarianism
Communitarianism believes that
rights and responsibilities are intimately
related. It rejects the excessive reliance of State State Universal
Clean
libertarianism on the concept of individual Subsidized
Education
Subsidized
Housing
Environment
Health
Care
autonomy and rights. Instead, it focuses
50
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 9.indd 50 12-09-2018 19:36:09
www.tntextbooks.in
Concept of Justice
God is dead.....
Communitarians attack John Rawls and we have
and other libertarian thinkers on the killed him
concept of justice. They reject universalism
of libertarianism, their argument that - Friedrich Nietzsche
the concept of justice is universally
applicable as it is based on reason. On
Fredrick Nietzsche is called Father of
the contrary, communitarians articulate
Post Modernism. He famously said “God
the particularistic view of justice. Every
is dead”. He argued that man should stop
community develops its own notions of
the search for the ultimate truth to explain
justice and therefore it differs from society
human life. It is beyond our capacity.
to society.
Modernity believes in universalism
Therefore, we can conclude that
and reductionism. It explains all the
Communitarianism as a political doctrine
phenomena through a single factor or one
believes in the indispensability of
ultimate truth. For example, Karl Marx
community for the development of the
said human life depends on economy and
‘situated and embedded man’. The positive
all problems can be solved by eliminating
State should concentrate on the provision of
the right to private property. Similarly
positive rights to community and its people
Fredrick Hegel, the German philosopher
so that common good can be preserved
argued that the world is nothing but the
and promoted. But Libertarianism still
embodiment of World Spirit.
criticises Communitarianism as preparing
Postmodernism, in contrast, advocates
the path for the emergence of collectivism
that the world and our life is complex and
and authoritarianism.
cannot be explained by a single factor. A
9.4 Postmodernism host of factors like culture, language,
religion, politics, and economy decide
Postmodernism refers to a variety human life and this world.
of ideas that criticize modernity and
emerge as its successor and rival. The
major proponents of Postmodernism
include Fredrick Nietzsche, Jean-Francois
Lyotard, Michel Foucalt and Jacques
Derrida. Modernity has dominated the
political theory in the last 200 years.
Rationality, universalism, reductionism
are among the dominant principles of
modernity. Postmodernism challenges
these principles and advocates alternatives.
It emerged in the last three decades in Postmodernism believes that truth is
western political theory. not singular but plural. There are multiple
51
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 9.indd 51 12-09-2018 19:36:09
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 9.indd 52 12-09-2018 19:36:09
www.tntextbooks.in
usually the weak, vulnerable and under- and therefore protecting the environment
privileged communities who organise assumes paramount significance
themselves under the banner of their own
caste, race, and gender to resist domination
of other groups over them. The members
of these groups call themselves ‘we’ and
oppose the activities of others, ‘they’.
Postmodernism and Identity Politics
promote the empowerment of local,
specific communities.
9.5 Environmentalism
The advent of modern science and
technology driven development had
devastated the planet’s environment
Gandhiji says that there is enough for
precipitating several ecological crises like
everyone’s need but not for anyone's
ozone depletion, climate change and acid
greed.
rain. Environmentalism arose as a protest
movement and ideology against the
perilous destruction of the earth. We have There exists a profound debate
only one habitable planet in the entire in philosophy about the relationship
universe and there is no alternative home between man and ecology, development
53
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 9.indd 53 12-09-2018 19:36:10
www.tntextbooks.in
EGO ECO
Reduce
Reuse The non-human biological forms also
54
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 9.indd 54 12-09-2018 19:36:10
www.tntextbooks.in
vital needs by making careful use of this We should change our technology,
biodiversity. Preservation of biodiversity is philosophy, economy and politics so that
indispensable. The interference of human ecological crises can be rectified and
beings on the domain of the non-human averted in the future. The human beings
sphere of the planet so for, is destructive, are ‘ecological selves’ the materialistic and
excessive and unacceptable. There is an consumerist life style must be changed
urgent need to limit the population of the and a new ecologically-sensitive social
world as the current population explosion and economic order must be created. We
has injected enormous stress on the ecology. should reduce our ‘ecological footprint’ by
adopting a meager resources based life
style. As the nomenclature indicated deep
"Humans are part of the environment ecology asks deeper questions of how and
and not conquerors of it." why examining philosophically the impact
- Aldo Leopold of human life as one part of the ecosphere
on other components.
3. Humans should use other beings only to 3. Humans should always use all resources for
satisfy their basic needs. their material and economic advantage.
4. The health of non-humans depends on 4. The human population can increase without
decreasing the number of humans. restraint.
6. Human policy (economics. technology and 6. Materialism and consumerism should govern
ideology) must change radically. human society.
8. Every human who believes in these points 8. Leave environmental problems for the experts
must work for change. to solve.
55
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 9.indd 55 12-09-2018 19:36:10
www.tntextbooks.in
1. Eco-Socialism
The Earth dose not belong to us:
we belong to the Earth. Rudolph Bahro in his book ‘From
- Marlee Martlin Red to Green’ supported eco-socialism.
It considers capitalism as the enemy of
Political Theory and Ecology ecology. By breeding materialism and
consumerism capitalism has inflicted
The words environment and ecology horrific destruction on the environment.
are synonymous. Andrew Heywood, the The unlimited right to private property,
noted political scientist classifies ecology the cardinal principle of capitalism
in political theory into three kinds endangers the precious health and wealth
of the planet’s ecology. The nature is seen
Social Ecology only as a commodity to be traded in the
market and consumed by the man. Eco-
Modernist Ecology
socialism propounds a new approach
Deep Ecology in politics that combines socialism and
ecologism. Socialism alone can nurture
Ecology in political theory environment. The state must be imparted
with a socialist content and direction to
end the evil of capitalism and to protect
environment
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 9.indd 56 12-09-2018 19:36:10
www.tntextbooks.in
havoc on ecology. Therefore, we should inherit the earth from our previous
create a new society based on voluntary generations but borrowed it from the
instincts to protect man and ecology future generations of humanity and
therefore, there is a moral responsibility
3. Eco-feminism to protect and preserve the earth for their
life in the future. The concept of
Carolyn Merchant in the book ‘sustainable development’ is a basic
‘The Death of Nature’ propounded eco- characteristic of modernist ecology. It
feminism. This perspective considers argues that ‘getting richer faster’ should
patriarchy as the enemy of ecology and not be the goal of human world rather
feminism as its beloved friend. Patriarchy ‘getting richer slower’ should be its guiding
means domination of man over women. approach.
Eco-feminism argues that patriarchy
created the domination of man over
not only women but over nature also.
Patriarchy follows instrumental reason
whereby both women and ecology are
seen merely in terms of use value, as The modernist ecology is not a
objects to be exploited and not as subjects homogenous ideology. On the contrary,
endowed with life and intrinsic worth. it is heterogeneous. There are different
Eco- feminism demands gender and perspectives and prescriptions. Certain
ecology sensitive politics so that a new followers have called for the establishment
world of justice and sustainability can be of a totalitarian ‘Green State’ to protect
established. ecology. Another group of supporters
demanded ‘Green Capitalism’. The majority
B) Modernist Ecology of advocates and supporters of modernist
ecology suggested the green tilted State
Modernist ecology is synonymous
intervention in market to protect ecology
with shallow ecology. It attempts to
and satisfy human interests.
promote a new harmony between
liberalism and ecology. The liberal tenets C) Deep Ecology
and approach should be reformed so that
the menace of ecological destruction can It advocates a new style of politics,
be avoided. It advocates a new ‘enlightened policy and political attitude towards
anthropocentricism’ where man, being nature. It argues for a fundamental shift
the centre of the planet must consider the in the relationship between politics
long-term interests of humanity and and nature. Politics must understand,
ecology in his developmental activities respect and protect the element of inter
and should not be driven solely by short- connectedness found in ecology linking
term interests. Modernist ecology believes the human beings, other biological forms
in the concept of "inter-generational and the inanimate world.
justice" and argues that we did not
57
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 9.indd 57 12-09-2018 19:36:10
www.tntextbooks.in
58
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 9.indd 58 12-09-2018 19:36:11
www.tntextbooks.in
Quotable
uote
- successful fusion of three major ideologies
of feminism, environmentalism and
“A chopped head is cheaper than a Gandhism
felled tree.”
B. Chipko Movement
59
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 9.indd 59 12-09-2018 19:36:11
www.tntextbooks.in
60
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 9.indd 60 12-09-2018 19:36:11
www.tntextbooks.in
61
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 9.indd 61 12-09-2018 19:36:11
www.tntextbooks.in
Evaluation
62
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 9.indd 62 12-09-2018 19:36:11
www.tntextbooks.in
c) We should speak about the political rights of women in family and politics
d) We should ignore the personal life of politicians
63
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 9.indd 63 12-09-2018 19:36:11
www.tntextbooks.in
15. The school of Feminism more apt for the women of countries like India, Namibia is
a) Post-Colonial Feminism b) Liberal Feminism
c) Radical Feminism d) Marxian Feminism
16. A
ssertion : The Deep Ecology concept advocates Biocentric Equality
Reason: Man is not superior to other biological forms in this planet. All forms of life
including man are equal
(a) Both A and R are true and R is the correct explanation of A.
(b) Both A and R are true but R is not the correct explanation of A.
(c) A is true but R is false.
(d) A is false but R is true.
64
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 9.indd 64 12-09-2018 19:36:11
www.tntextbooks.in
Reference books
65
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 9.indd 65 12-09-2018 19:36:11
www.tntextbooks.in
UNIT
Introduction
This chapter focuses on the meaning and evolution of the Party
system as adopted in various countries of the world. Tracing the
emergence of party system in modern democracies we seek to explain
the nature, characteristics, types and functions of political parties
especially in a democracy. Deriving from this general background,
the evolution of the party system in India at the national
and regional levels are studied, with a specific focus on
Tamil Nadu. The chapter also presents the meaning and
importance of public opinion and its role in the effective
working of a democracy
making
Learning Objectives
possible version
cool
Lippmann
public opinions function
To define the meaning of party journalist
opinion
system
control make social
To identify the role, function and
press
Science
types of party system within a two news
world
assume
democracy picture knowledge
people
To trace the historical evolution of
the party system in modern times.
To outline the structure of the party
system in India at the national and others with similar beliefs. In short it is
regional levels the collective views of the people, their
To evaluate the importance of public attitudes and opinions.
opinion in the effective functioning
of a democracy It is the people’s collective preferences
To assess the impact and limitations on matters relating to government and
of the party system politics. It is based on the premise that
collective individual opinions matters in
10.1 Defining Public Opinion: a democracy and public opinion should
carry more weight than individual opinion.
Public opinion can be defined as Others opine that public opinion can be
a psychological and social process in influenced and controlled by organized
which the behaviour of each member groups, government leaders, and media
of the public is conditional to that of all elite.
66
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 10.indd 66 12-09-2018 19:36:42
www.tntextbooks.in
ACTIVITY
PUBLIC OPINION
Read the following article by one of the senior political leaders late
Madhu Dandavate carefully and answer the questions.
At the 44th session of the Indian National Congress held on the banks of river Ravi
at Lahore, a resolution demanding complete independence was passed on December
31, 1929. Jawaharlal Nehru presided over the session and Mahatma Gandhi made a
memorable speech while moving the main resolution. However, Gandhi did not rest
content with merely delivering a speech. He led the famous Dandi March starting from
the Sabarmati Ashram on March 12, 1930, culminating in the Salt Satyagraha at Dandi,
a coastal village in Gujarat, on April 6, 1930.
Gandhi had a definite strategy and perspective about the Dandi March and the
Salt Satyagraha. He did not want the march to be too massive to remain under control.
At the same time, he did not want it to be too small to have any perceptible impact.
These considerations made Gandhi reject Vallabai Patel's suggestion of a massive march
to Delhi. He also did not approve of the romantic idea of Nehru to set up a parallel
government. Gandhi proposed a march of 78 dedicated and disciplined satyagrahis from
Sabarmati to Dandi village to offer Salt Satyagraha. Gandhi chose salt as the symbol of
satyagraha because it was the lowest common denominator of the food consumption
of the nation. The rich needed salt for a change of taste and the poorest of the poor
needed it for mixing with water so that they could dip their dry and stale bread in
the mixture as an alternative to the rich man's spicy curry. During the Dandi March,
some overenthusiastic admirers of Gandhi brought for him and his fellow pilgrims large
quantities of fresh fruit and wholesome milk from dairies.
67
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 10.indd 67 12-09-2018 19:36:43
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 10.indd 68 12-09-2018 19:36:43
www.tntextbooks.in
(a) Poverty: The poor in any country are general public on issues concerning the
easily influenced by the false promise society and state and they also prescribe
of political leaders and cast their votes alternatives. Through propaganda they
subjectively. Sound and objective public educate people on political issues and
opinion is possible only by alleviating garner their support for their policies
poverty. and programme. In legislative bodies
(b) Racist and Caste based they represent organized opinion of the
Discrimination: Sentiments that provoke voters. In parliamentary democracies the
discrimination based on caste, creed party or an alliance of parties can win a
and religion create a divide among the majority of seats in legislature and forms
masses that are often manipulated by the ministry (executive) examples: UK,
political parties for their advantage. Social India. In presidential democracies, the
disharmony in the country is detrimental chief executives (president) are elected on
to the effective working of a democracy. party basis (USA, France). In any system
political parties function as intermediaries
(c) Freedom of speech and the media:
between the government and people.
There is consistent competition
between the various political parties
and this competition ensures the mature
functioning of a democracy.
ACTIVITY
Political parties are indispensable Follow the newspaper for one month and
instruments in a democratic system. They collect news items related to the various
are formed with definite ideologies, and functions of political parties
programme of action. They enlighten the
69
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 10.indd 69 12-09-2018 19:36:43
www.tntextbooks.in
Quotable
uote
In a democracy public opinion is
according to specific party objectives and
agenda, it helps sustain good governance.
harnessed through political parties.
A political party is a group
10.4 Functions of Political Parties of people who come together to
In a democracy, political parties contest elections and hold power
serve as an integral link through which in the government. They agree on
government and the public can interact. some policies and programmes
Political Parties act as a foundation that for the society with a view to
orients the people towards political promote the collective good.
initiatives and public experience. Political (Symbols or Flag of different political
Parties work to influence political parties )
thought and opinion with the intention of Three components of a Political
mobilizing votes. They provide a platform Party – Leaders, Active Members and
for political, economic and social activism Followers.
that serves as a training ground for future
regional and national leadership. In the Types of Party Systems
long run they hold leaders accountable
for their actions through rigorous debate Different types of party system have
and queries both within the party as well evolved in various parts of the globe
as through opposition parties. Thus the depending on the particular elements of
people are presented with a diverse choice democracy practiced. By and large the
of candidates, ideologies and approaches quality of a democracy is determined by
to various issues governing the nation. how the government is representative of its
Their confidence in democracy is thus people, how accountable the government
reinforced in the knowledge that they can is to its people, how human rights and
bring about change and transformation equality of status and opportunity is
should a majority of the population desire guaranteed to all citizens and the level
a transformation in the way they are of political participation exercised by
governed. the people. The various types of party
system address these issues in different
The Party System ways, thereby determining the quality of
The party system helps to operate democracy practiced.
and stabilize governments and they are
particularly relevant for the effective
functioning of democracies. The party One Party
System
system provides a system of checks and
balances against the government’s policies.
By soliciting popular support among
the masses and providing a structure for Two Party Multi Party
leadership and dialogue within the party System System
70
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 10.indd 70 12-09-2018 19:36:43
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 10.indd 71 12-09-2018 19:36:43
www.tntextbooks.in
10.5 R
ole of Political Parties in a
Topic for Pair 2:Why do we need Democracy
at least two parties in a democratic
The existence of political parties is
system?
largely responsible for ensuring the quality
Topic for Pair 3: If all the decision and effectiveness of a democracy. In a
of a political party are made by a federal multicultural and plural societies
single family and all other members such as the United States of America and
are neglected, then what challenge is India, the maintenance of peace, unity
being faced by that party? and communal harmony are vital for
social-economic progress. While single
Topic for Pair 4: Do you think that party system may have greater flexibility
dynasty (family) politics is confined towards quicker decisions making and
to only a few states or parties? cohesive action, these decisions may not
represent mass opinion and thus it would
create greater opposition and dissent for
the government.
In the dual party system due to the Citizenship training and greater civic
nature of the party structure and participation, youth in democratic nations
leadership, this usually result in public can play a greater role in political parties
policies and decisions blocked in political thereby fostering more mature and wider
polarization rather than collaboration. democratization in countries.
While in Multi party systems, the
performance is on the basis of deliberation
and negotiation between coalition
Quotable
uote
Political parties are the drivers of a
members, and issues are mostly settled by democracy.
reaching a mutually derived consensus
after debate and discussion. Thus, political Politicians exercised oratorical and
parties are the drivers of a democracy that leadership skills to create public
are necessary to safeguard the rights and opinion.
freedoms of the people. Through effective
72
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 10.indd 72 12-09-2018 19:36:43
www.tntextbooks.in
73
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 10.indd 73 12-09-2018 19:36:43
www.tntextbooks.in
74
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 10.indd 74 12-09-2018 19:36:44
www.tntextbooks.in
N
W E of the freedom struggle against British
S
rule. While Indian politics today represent
a multi-party system, for long periods in
Atlantic Ocean
Indian political history, one party has
dominated the political stage. The Indian
Map not to scale
National Congress (INC) was established
in 1885 by A. O Hume, as the indigenous
In African countries, political parties base for the political
were at first formed to secure participation of
decolonization. In many decolonized Indians in legislative
African countries, political parties are and political wings.
struggling hard against militarism. It demanded political
reforms in gradual
The Constitution of stages. After the
South Africa non-cooperation
Universal adult suffrage vote at 18 movement (1921-23) Indian National
A national common voters roll Congress began to demand absolute
75
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 10.indd 75 12-09-2018 19:36:44
www.tntextbooks.in
political freedom. In the 20th century, the with the British government. Gradually
parties with communal agenda have also the Indian National Congress evolved to
come up i.e. The All India Muslim League play a pivotal role in the development of
in 1906 and Hindu Maha Sabha in 1916. India’s political party system. After the
In the Madras Presidency the South Indian partition of Bengal in 1905, the Indian
Liberal Federation (Justice Party) was National Congress was divided between
formed to project their interest of the the Moderates (policy of petitions) and the
Non-Brahmins (Dravidian). Extremists (aggressive militant strategy).
The formation of the Muslim league in
ACTIVITY 1906 resulted in the era of conflicting
political bargaining, reflected the true
beginnings of the Indian party system.
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 10.indd 76 12-09-2018 19:36:46
www.tntextbooks.in
Communist Party, formed in the new parties have emerged that represent
1920’s by the efforts of M. N. Roy were the and seek to address the trans formative
other major political parties. challenges faced by various diverse
sections of the people. Since the 1990’s
There were a number of political we see a federalization of politics with
parties which carry on political campaigns regional parties gaining greater influence,
and propaganda, but do not contest representative of regional aspirations
elections, they function as pressure against the dominance of the Centre.
groups. Till 1977, the Communist
Party, the socialist parties, and the right N
77
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 10.indd 77 12-09-2018 19:36:46
www.tntextbooks.in
78
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 10.indd 78 12-09-2018 19:36:46
www.tntextbooks.in
Party System in Tamil Nadu independent India. There are very clear
socio-economic, cultural and historical
In Tamil Nadu, like most Indian
reasons for this development. The long
states, the early independence period was
history of rationalist and social justice
dominated by the Congress party.
movements from the colonial era and the
However, issues of caste hierarchy, and the
mobilization of Dravidian consciousness
rising North South divide eroded the
since the beginning of 20th century have
popularity of Congress leadership in the
fundamentally transformed the nature of
state. The Dravidian movement
politics and the future of party system in
regenerated in Tamil Nadu under Periyar
state politics.
E.V Ramasamy and garnered popularity
on assertion of Dravidian Rights and ACTIVITY
Dignity and through an anti-North, anti-
Hindi, anti-Brahmin social agenda. Anbu, Kumaran, Rajumar and
Amuthan were friends. They went
N
to watch a film that showed the hero
W E becoming Chief Minister for a day
S and making big changes in the State.
Anbu said this what the country needs.
Kumaran said this kind of a personal
rule without institution is dangerous
Rajkumar said all this is a fantasy. No
minister can do anything in one day.
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 10.indd 79 12-09-2018 19:36:47
www.tntextbooks.in
80
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 10.indd 80 12-09-2018 19:36:47
www.tntextbooks.in
lobbying, influence both the government actual results. Yet they are important in
and the administrative policies. generating opinions among the unsure
and undecided as well as help to sustain a
"Leadership and learning
balance in voting practices for all parties
are indispensable to each
concerned.
other."
John F. Kennedy Glossary
81
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 10.indd 81 12-09-2018 19:36:47
www.tntextbooks.in
Election Commission: The Election Electoral System: The general name for
Commission is an independent autonomous all the rules concerning elections, i.e. the
entity responsible for the administration voting system, boundaries, registration of
of Parliamentary and State Legislature electors, candidacy, campaign spending,
Assembly elections and related works. broadcasting, etc.
Ballot box : The box at a polling place Majority Government; A government made
into which a stamped ballot paper is to be up of one or more political parties is formed
dropped. by a political party which has absolute
Coalition:A Government is formed by more majority in legislature.
than one party when no single party sets Democracy: Government by the people,
absolute majority. through free, fair and periodical elections.
Electoral roll: The list of all the registered
electors for a particular electorate kept by
the Registrar of Electors.
Evaluation
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 10.indd 82 12-09-2018 19:36:47
www.tntextbooks.in
15. A
ssertion: Political parties mobilize public opinion.
Reason: Public opinion influences election results.
Directions: Given below are two statements labelled as Assertion (A) and Reason (R)
in the context of the two statements which of the following is correct?
(a) Both A and R are true and R is the correct explanation of A.
83
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 10.indd 83 12-09-2018 19:36:47
www.tntextbooks.in
(b) Both A and R are true but R is not the correct explanation of A.
(c) A is true but R is false.
(d) A is false but R is true.
Reference books
84
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 10.indd 84 12-09-2018 19:36:47
www.tntextbooks.in
ICT CORNER
1. Use the URL or QR code to open the How the state government works page.
2. An activity window will open, click the navigation key on the bottom right corner of
the activity window.
3. After a small introduction story, an explanation of state government will start.
4. Explore the different aspects of the state government by clicking the forward navigation
button.
Step 3
Step 1
Step 4
Step 2
Download Link
*Pictures are indicative only.
*If browser requires, allow Flash Player or Java Script to load the page.
URL: mocomi.com/how-does-state-government-work/
85
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 10.indd 85 12-09-2018 19:36:49
www.tntextbooks.in
UNIT
86
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 11.indd 86 12-09-2018 19:37:11
www.tntextbooks.in
Democratic Electoral System and change them if they wish to do so. This
Let us study the most essential features of mechanism is called Election. Therefore,
a democratic electoral system. A elections are considered essential in our
democratic electoral system can be said to times for any representative government.
be one where… Hence in most democracies, people rule
through their representatives.
In an election the voters make many
choices:
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 11.indd 87 12-09-2018 19:37:12
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 11.indd 88 12-09-2018 19:37:12
www.tntextbooks.in
are found primarily in the UK and those districts while at the same time, increasing
countries historically influenced by the role of political parties compared with
Britain. Along with the UK, the other FPTP and strengthening those parties
countries are Canada, India and the USA. which demonstrate most coherence and
FPTP is also used by a number of organizational structure.
Caribbean countries, Bangladesh, Burma,
India, Malaysia, Nepal and small island C. Party Block Vote (PBV)
countries of the South Pacific. PBV is simple to use, encourages
strong parties and allows for parties to put
up mixed slates of candidates in order to
FPTP is the simplest form of
facilitate minority representation. It can be
plurality/majority electoral system.
The winning candidate is the one used to help to ensure balanced ethnic
who gains more votes than any other representation. Dijibouti, Singapore,
candidate, even if this is not an Senegal, Tunisia use the PBV method.
absolute majority of valid votes. The
system uses single-member districts
and the voters vote for candidates Party-Block Vote is a plurality/
rather than political parties. majority system using multi- member
districts in which voters cast a single
B. Block Vote (BV) party-centered vote for a party of
The Block –Vote is common in choice, and do not choose between
countries with weak or non-existent candidates
political parties. The Cayman Islands,
The Falkland Islands, Guernsey, Kuwait, D. The Alternative Vote (AV)
Laos, Lebanon, the Maldives, Palestine, This system enables voters to express
the Syrian Arab Republic etc use Block their preferences between candidates
Vote electoral systems. rather than simply their first choice.
Hence it is known as ‘Preferential Voting’.
Block Vote is a plurality/majority AV is used in Australia, Fiji and Papua
system used in multi-member Guinea. By transferring ballots, it enables
districts. Electors have as many votes the votes of several candidates to
as there are candidates to be selected. accumulate, so that diverse but related
The candidates with the highest vote interests can be combined to win
totals win the seats. Usually voters
representation.
vote for candidates rather than parties
and in most systems may use as many,
or as few,of their votes as they wish
The Alternative Vote is a
preferential plurality system that voters
The Block Vote is often applauded
use in single member districts. Voters
for retaining the voter’s ability to vote
use numbers to mark their preference
for individual candidates and allowing
on the Ballot paper.
for reasonably-organized geographical
89
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 11.indd 89 12-09-2018 19:37:12
www.tntextbooks.in
90
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 11.indd 90 12-09-2018 19:37:12
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 11.indd 91 12-09-2018 19:37:12
www.tntextbooks.in
ACTIVITY
Time Sequence
Arrange the different election related activities mentioned in the left side of the
table given below in a time sequence, beginning with the first activity and ending with
the last.
Disorder Order
Releasing election manifesto
Preparing the voter’s list
Counting of votes
Election campaign
Declaration of election results
Filing nomination
Ordering of re-poll
Casting of votes
Announcing election schedule
92
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 11.indd 92 12-09-2018 19:37:12
www.tntextbooks.in
93
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 11.indd 93 12-09-2018 19:37:13
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 11.indd 94 12-09-2018 19:37:14
www.tntextbooks.in
not limited to these two weeks only. Use government vehicles, aircrafts and
Political parties start preparing for officials for elections
elections months before they actually take
Once elections are announced,
place.
Ministers shall not lay foundation
stones of any projects, take any big
ACTIVITY policy decisions or make any promises
of providing public facilities.
Prepare a list of what the candidates
and parties said and did in the last
ACTIVITY
election campaign in your constituency.
Draw a cartoon here about the
In election campaigns, political model code of conduct for the guidance
parties try to focus public attention on of political parties and candidates during
some big issues. They want to attract the elections.
public to that issue and get them vote for
their party on that basis. In a democracy 11.3 Free and Fair Elections
it is best to leave political parties and The true test of any election system
candidates free to conduct their election is its ability to ensure a free and fair
campaigns the way they want to. But electoral process. If we want democracy
it is sometimes necessary to regulate to be translated into reality on the ground,
campaigns to ensure that every political it is important that the election system is
party and candidate gets a fair and equal impartial and transparent. The system
chance to compete. of election must allow the aspirations of
According to our election law, no the voter to find legitimate expression
party or candidate can: through the electoral results. Elections
in India are basically free and fair. The
Bribe or threaten voters party that wins an election and forms
Appeal to them in the name of caste or government does so because people have
religion chosen it over its rivals. This may not
Use government resources for election be true for every constituency. A few
campaign candidates may win purely on the basis
of money power and unfair means. But
If they do so, their election can be the overall verdict of a general election
rejected by the court even after they have still reflects popular preference. But still
been declared elected. In addition to the if deeper questions are asked , the picture
laws, all the political parties in our country looks different. Are people’s preferences
have agreed to a model Code of Conduct based on real knowledge? Are the voters
for election campaigns. According to this getting a real choice? Is election really a
no party or candidate can: level playing field for everyone? Can an
ordinary citizen hope to win elections?
Use any place of worship for election
propaganda
95
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 11.indd 95 12-09-2018 19:37:14
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 11.indd 96 12-09-2018 19:37:14
www.tntextbooks.in
Election Commission which is entrusted state legislatures and to the offices of the
with the superintendence, direction and President and Vice –President of India.
control of all elections to Parliament,
DEBATE
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 11.indd 97 12-09-2018 19:37:14
www.tntextbooks.in
No. of Duration of
Election Dates
Elections the Assembly
1 1952-1957 1952 January 2, 5, 8, 9, 11, 12, 16, 21 and 25 (9days)
2 1957-1962 1957 March 1, 4, 6, 8 and 11 (5 days)
3 1962-1967 1962 February 17, 19, 21 and 24 (4 days)
4 1967-1971 1967 February 5, 16 and 21 (3 days)
5 1971-1976 1971 March 1, 4 and 7 (3 days)
6 1977-1980 1977 June 12 and 14 (2 days)
7 1980-1984 1980 May 20 and 31 (2 days)
8 1985-1986 1984 December 24 (1 day only)
9 1989-1991 1969 January 21 (1 day only)
10 1991-1996 1991 June 16 (1 day only)
11 1996-2001 1996 April 27 and May 2 (2 days)
12 2001-2006 2001 May 10 (1 day only)
13 2006-2011 2006 May 8 (1 day only)
14 2011-2016 2011 April 13 (1 day only)
15 2016-ongoing 2016 May 16 (1 day only)
98
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 11.indd 98 12-09-2018 19:37:14
www.tntextbooks.in
Powers and functions of the Election S ettles disputes and petitions referred
Commission of India to it by the President of India or the
Governor of a state.
P reparation of the electoral rolls
D ecides disputes pertaining to election
R evision of electoral rolls
symbol in the event of a split in the
A llotment of seats
political party.
C onduct of elections
H as power to impose ceiling on the
S uperintendence, direction and
election expenses of the contestants.
control of all matters pertaining to the
E ntrusted with the task of collecting
elections
affidavits from the contestants to the
G ranting of recognition of political
elections regarding their assets.
parties
H as the power and duty to disqualify
A llotment of symbols
a candidate if he/she fails to submit
E nsuring fair and free elections
election returns within the prescribed
T he Election Commission of India
period.
advises the President of India or
I t issues a notification after the
the Governor of the concerned
election is over, that the house is duly
state regarding all electoral matters
constituted.
including questions relating to
disqualifications of members.
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 11.indd 99 12-09-2018 19:37:15
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 11.indd 100 12-09-2018 19:37:16
www.tntextbooks.in
L
owering the voting age from 21 to 18 government aided institutions can
through the 61st amendment act of be requisitioned for deployment on
1988. election day.
O
fficers, and staff engaged in I n 1999, a provision was made for
preparation, revision and correction voting by certain classes of persons
of electoral rolls for elections to through postal ballot.
be on deputation to the Election
I n 2003, the facility to opt for voting
commission.
through proxy was provided to the
I ncrease of number of proposers to service voters belonging to the armed
10% of the electors of the constituency forces and members belonging to a
or 10 electors, whichever is less. force to which provisions of the Army
Act apply.
I n 1989, a provision was made to
facilitate the use of electronic voting I n 2003, the Election commission
machines in elections. issued an order for the declaration of
criminal antecedents, assets etc.
I n 1989, a provision was made for
adjournment of poll in case of booth I n 2003, Rajya Sabha elections were
capturing. reformed by removing the domicile of
the contesting candidate and further
L
isting the name of candidates as
introduction of open ballot system
candidates of recognised political
was introduced.
parties, candidates of registered–
unrecognized political parties and I n 2003, an exemption of travelling
other(independent) candidates. expenditure from being included in
the election expenses of the candidate
P
rohibition on the sale of liquor within
was made.
a polling area during the period of 48
hours ending with the hour fixed for F
ree supply of electoral rolls by the
the conclusion of poll. government.
O
n the death of a contesting candidate, I n 2009, restrictions were imposed on
the party concerned would be given an conducting exit polls and publishing
option to propose another candidate the results of exit polls.
within 7 days.
I n 2009, a provision was made for the
T
he registered voters are entitled for a disqualification of a person found
paid holiday on the polling day. guilty of corrupt practices which
provided for a three month time limit
P
rohibition of arms.
within which the specified authority
I n 1998 a provision was made whereby will have to submit the case of the
the employees of local authorities, person found to be guilty.
nationalized banks, universities, LIC,
A
ll officials have to be included in
government undertakings and other
corrupt practice.
101
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 11.indd 101 12-09-2018 19:37:16
www.tntextbooks.in
I ncrease in security deposit. the date on which he takes his seat in the
house.
A
ppointment of appellate authorities
within the district. B. Exceptions:
V
oting rights to citizens of India living Disqualifications on the ground of
abroad were provided in 2010. defection does not apply, if a member goes
out of his party as a result of a merger of
C
eiling on election expenditure was
the party with another party; if a member,
increased in 2011.
after being elected as the Presiding officer
Anti-Defection Law of the house, voluntarily gives up the
membership of his party or rejoins after
The 52nd Amendment Act of 1985 he ceases to hold that office.
provided for the disqualification of the
members of Parliament and the State C. Deciding Authority:
legislatures on the ground of defection Any question regarding
from one political party to another. disqualification arising out of defection is
For this purpose it added the Tenth to be decided by the Presiding officer of
Schedule to the Constitution. This act is the house.
often referred to as “Anti-defection law”.
Later the 91st Amendment Act of 2003 D. Rule making power:
made one change in the provision i.e., The Presiding officer of a house is
disqualification on ground of defection empowered to make rules to give effect
not to apply in case of split. to the provisions of the tenth schedule.
All such rules must be placed before
Provisions of the Act the house for 30 days. The house may
A. Disqualification: approve or disapprove them. Further he
may direct that any willful contravention
A member of a house belonging to any by any member of such rules may be dealt
political party becomes disqualified if he with in the same manner as a breach of
voluntarily gives up his membership or if privilege of the house.
he votes or abstains from voting contrary
to any direction issued by his political Evaluation of the Act
party without obtaining prior permission A. The tenth schedule of the constitution
of the party. is designed to prevent the mischief of
An independent member of the house political defections motivated by the
becomes disqualified to remain a member lure of office or material benefits
of the house if he joins any political party
after such election. B. It is intended to strengthen the fabric
of Indian Parliamentary democracy by
A nominated member of the house curbing unprincipled and unethical
gets disqualified if he joins any political political defections
party after the expiry of six months from
102
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 11.indd 102 12-09-2018 19:37:16
www.tntextbooks.in
C. It provides for greater stability in the the votes are counted, it is done on the
body politic by checking the propensity basis of first preference votes secured by
of the legislators to change parties each candidate; If after the counting of all
first preference votes, required number
D. It facilitates democratic realignment of candidates fail to fulfill the quota, the
of parties in the legislature by way of candidate who secured the lowest votes
merger of parties of first preference is eliminated and his/
E. It gives a clear cut constitutional her votes are transferred to those who are
recognition to the existence of political mentioned as second preference on those
parties. ballot papers. This process continues till
the required number of candidates are
declared elected.
DEBATE
Why did India adopt the FPTP System?
Some say that Anti-Defection law The answer is not very difficult to
has reduced the freedom of the elected guess. If you have read carefully the method
representatives in the Parliament/ of election of Rajya Sabha members,
Legislatures. Have a debate on it in you would have noticed that it is a very
your classroom. complicated system which may work in
a small country but would be difficult to
Let us learn about the Rajya Sabha work in a sub-continental country like
Elections…… India. The reason for the popularity and
Transferable Vote System is followed success of the FPTP system is its simplicity.
for Rajya Sabha elections. Every state has The entire election system is extremely
a specific quota of seats in the Rajya simple to understand even for common
Sabha. The members are elected by the voters who may have no specialized
respective State Legislative assemblies. knowledge about politics and elections.
The voters are the MLAs in that state. There is also a clear choice presented to
Every voter is required to rank candidates the voters at the time of elections. Voters
according to her or his preference. To be have to simply endorse a candidate or a
declared winner, a candidate must secure party while voting. Depending on the
a minimum quota of votes, which is nature of actual politics, voters may either
determined by a formula: give greater importance to the party or to
the candidate or balance the two.
103
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 11.indd 103 12-09-2018 19:37:16
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 11.indd 104 12-09-2018 19:37:16
www.tntextbooks.in
Today youth has the power to In its efforts of cleansing the political
transform our nation, and it will. The system, the Supreme Court of India upheld
responsibility of transformation, progress the right of voters to reject all candidates
and innovation lies on their shoulders. contesting the elections. The apex court
directed the Election Commission to have
105
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 11.indd 105 12-09-2018 19:37:16
www.tntextbooks.in
ACTIVITY
Interpretation of cartoon
ACTIVITY
106
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 11.indd 106 12-09-2018 19:37:17
www.tntextbooks.in
Evaluation
107
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 11.indd 107 12-09-2018 19:37:17
www.tntextbooks.in
5. The first delimitation commission act was passed in the year ______.
a. 1952 b. 1963
c. 1973 d.2002
7. Which Amendment Act reduced the voting age of Indian citizens from 21 to 18?
a. 61st b.42nd
c.91st d.73rd
8. Which Article of the Indian Constitution provides for a single Election Commission in India?
a. Art 324 b. Art 256
c. Art 370 d. Art 360
108
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 11.indd 108 12-09-2018 19:37:17
www.tntextbooks.in
14. First general elections in India took place in the year _____.
a. 1952 b.1951
c.1950 d. 1947
16. A
ssertion: Indian Parliament has a bicameral legislature.
Reason: Loksabha is the lower house and Rajya sabha is the upper house.
(a) Both A and R are true and R is the correct explanation of A.
(b) Both A and R are true but R is not the correct explanation of A.
(c) A is true but R is false.
(d) A is false but R is true.
109
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 11.indd 109 12-09-2018 19:37:17
www.tntextbooks.in
Reference books
1. J.C. Johari, Indian Polity, Lotus Press, New Delhi.
2. R.C. Agarwal, Political Theory, S. Chand and Company, New Delhi.
3. B.S. Raman, Indian Constitution, United Publishers, Mangalore.
4. Subash C Kashyap, Our Constitution, National Book Trust , India.
5. The New International IDEA Handbook
6. Democratic Politics-II, Class X Political Science Textbook.
7. Democratic Politics-I, class IX Political Science Textbook
8. Lakshmikant, Indian Polity, Tata Mcgraw and Hills.
Internet Sources:
www.britannica.com
www.quora.com
Search.my.way.com
Hindustan times.com.India
India.seminar.com
110
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 11.indd 110 12-09-2018 19:37:17
www.tntextbooks.in
ICT CORNER
Steps
1. Click the URL or scan the QR code to launch the “indiavotes” page.
2. For, Lok Sabha Elections Select “year”, “states” and Click “GO”. For Legislative
Assembly elections (State Elections), Select “State” and “Year” to know the details.
3. On having accurate details, Go for “Advanced search” and give in the details to fetch
the data.
4. Click “Election Maps” on the home page to check the same with maps by feeding in
the required on the left of the window.
Step 3
Step 1
Step 4
Step 2
Download Link
*Pictures are indicative only.
*If browser requires, allow Flash Player or Java Script to load the page.
URL : http://www.indiavotes.com/
111
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 11.indd 111 12-09-2018 19:37:23
www.tntextbooks.in
UNIT
12 Local Governments
Learning Objectives
12.1 Meaning, Nature and Importance birth or death of persons in the village
of Local Government or town. The local governments are the
Local Government means, the institutions, which issues certificates
government which manages services and of proof of residence, birth, death and
amenities in our villages, towns and cities incomes etc to the residents in that area.
with focus on local problems. The local In total, the local governments are the
governments normally functions within institutions which are responsible for
a specified limited territory of a village, a all such local needs of the people. They
town, a city and also a large metropolitan are the lowest unit of administration
city. The local governments function in the administrative structure of the
as the basic link between the people in government. The local government has
a village or town with the government. council, which is normally elected by the
As and when people have problems people of the village or town concerned,
such as road repairs, water stagnation which is responsible for the representing
in the streets, non functioning of street the problems of the citizens in the council
lights and construction of small water and find solutions to the problems. The
bodies recreation parks, etc. The local council representatives are elected once in
governments have the responsibility five years, or four years, depending upon
to attend to any emergency situations, the law in operation in the country.
112
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 12.indd 112 12-09-2018 19:37:59
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 12.indd 113 12-09-2018 19:37:59
www.tntextbooks.in
Local governments are classified as Critically think the need for local
Rural and Urban based local governments. government both in rural and
The Rural and Urban divide is made urban areas in India.
based on the nature of the occupation
of the residents viz; agriculture based or Critically view the responsibilities
non-agriculture based occupations. The of the citizens towards the local
agriculture based occupation means that governments in India.
almost or most of the residents of an area are
engaged in agriculture related occupation In India, the rural local governments
and the nature of the functions normally have given general name “Panchayati Raj”
would be farming, dairying, poultry, and which means the system of Panchayat
other similar types of activities. Whereas, institutions, that is, the institutions
in urban areas the citizens would engaged which does the panchayat, (deliberate,
in industrial, trade and business and other discuss, and deliberate). The Urban local
activities. governments in India are classified in to
various types depending upon the political
The urban areas are the places and economic basis of the formation of
where the people’s livelihood is based on the urban local governments such as,
occupations in industry, trade, commercial Municipal Corporations, Townships, Area
institutions and administration like Planning Committees and Cantonment
government offices and private company Boards. For example, in India the
offices. The urban areas are the link urban local governments are classified
between the outside world to the local into various types such, Municipal
villages. The local governments formed Corporations in metropolitan cities,
in rural and urban areas are called rural Municipalities in small towns, Townships
local governments and urban local in industrial towns, Cantonment Boards
governments respectively. in military establishments.
114
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 12.indd 114 12-09-2018 19:37:59
www.tntextbooks.in
ACTIVITY
"Corporate cleanliness can only be ensured if there is a corporate
conscience and a corporate insistence on cleanliness in public places"
115
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 12.indd 115 12-09-2018 19:37:59
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 12.indd 116 12-09-2018 19:37:59
www.tntextbooks.in
ACTIVITY
the central government for more
Design a poster
devolution of administrative and financial
Water bodies in your village powers to state as well as local governments.
or town or city often hear the brunt
of carelessness, with several lakes, 12.4 Origin and development of Local
ponds or rivers filled with plastic Governments in India
trash becoming the dump yards and
sewer drains. Our country is fast In tracing the origin and development
losing critical habitats. To reclaim lost of local governments in India, one finds
habitats and to ensure protection of the evidences of the existence of local
what is left, you organize an awareness governments even before the times of
programme aimed at cleaning major Christ (BCE). The period between 600
portion of the lakes or pond or beach BCE to C.E. 600 witnessed the rise and
to ensure a garbage free natural fall of republics. During this period, there
environment for all life forms. emerged Mahavira (founder of Jainism)
What can you do? and Buddha (founder of Buddhism).
You design a poster with catch Villages were classified according to
phrase and invite people from size and mode of habitation in Jain and
differ\rent walks of life to Buddhists literature.
eliminate trash from water bodies.
The religious orders founded by
Catch phrase: “Remove trash, Buddha and Mahavira observed highly
Secure the water bodies.” democratic procedures in arriving
Remember, any effort you make is at decisions. Kautilya’s Arthshastra
helpful for the future. (Treatise)gives a comprehensive account
ACTIVITY
Take some of the public facilities in your area such as water, electricity, drainage,
sanitation, etc., Is there any scope to improve these? What in your opinion should be
done? Complete the table.
Facilities Is it available? How can it be improved?
Water
Drainage
Sanitation
Electricity
Road
Public Transport system
117
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 12.indd 117 12-09-2018 19:37:59
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 12.indd 118 12-09-2018 19:37:59
www.tntextbooks.in
After the Battle of Plassey in A.D commission to enquire into the question
(C.E.) 1757, the British East India Company of administrative and financial relations
derived land taxing rights (Diwani rights) between the Government of India,
from Bengal ruler (Nawab), which was the Provincial governments and subordinate
first step in the ascendency of the British authorities under them so as to simplify
rule in India. The rural and the other urban and improve the prevalent system through
trading centers during the British East devolution or otherwise. With the passing
India company rule, was not under any of Government of India Act, 1919, the
control or supervision, except the three local governments were entrusted with
Presidency towns of Calcutta, Bombay the elected elements of the provincial
and Madras. The District administration government under the diarchy system of
under the charge of the district collector government.
was the king pin in the British control
over vast rural areas. The number of the village bodies in
Tamilnadu increased from 1417 in 1926 to
The important mile stone during the 6250 in 1937. There are three tier system
company rule was the establishment of the of rural local bodies viz; District Boards,
Municipal Corporations , as mentioned Taluk Boards, and Village Boards. The
earlier at Calcutta (Kolkata), Bombay District and Taluk boards have undergone
(Mumbai) and Madras (Chennai). changes by 1923, the non-official
Viceroy Lord Rippon in 1882 brought chairman in all provinces replaced
out a resolution, proposing a smaller unit official chairman. In Tamilnadu, most of
for constituting rural local boards, a sub the District Boards came to be dominated
division, tehsil (taluk) and district boards by Justice Party members, which stood
to supervise. at 545 in 1927. From 1937 upto 1947,
the rural local authorities faced many
Lord Rippon’s resolution emphasized challenges including the national freedom
that the institutions he proposed should movement.
have a majority of non-officials who
should be elected wherever it was feasible. After Indian Independence in 1947,
Nearly 500 rural boards were created with an attempt was made to revive local
a two third majority of non officials who governments in India. Mahatma Gandhi
depended upon the district magistrate argued for the decentralized administrative
(district collector) for the favour of system in India entrusting responsibility
nomination. The main activities of the of governance with the village panchayats
district boards till 1909 were police, public (self sufficient Gram Swaraj). Shrima
works, education and village sanitation. Naryan with blessings of Gandhiji
published a blue print of the Gandhian
The rural local government Constitution for Free India wherein
introduced by Lord Rippon faced many panchayats are the basic institutions for
criticisms and in the A.D (C.E.) 1907, organizing social, economic and political
the British government appointed a activities of the citizens. In addition to the
119
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 12.indd 119 12-09-2018 19:37:59
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 12.indd 120 12-09-2018 19:37:59
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 12.indd 121 12-09-2018 19:37:59
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 12.indd 122 12-09-2018 19:38:00
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 12.indd 123 12-09-2018 19:38:00
www.tntextbooks.in
124
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 12.indd 124 12-09-2018 19:38:00
www.tntextbooks.in
125
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 12.indd 125 12-09-2018 19:38:00
www.tntextbooks.in
such amount per capita per annum as President and Vice-President. As that of
may be specified by state government Town Panchayats, seats are reserved for the
from time to time. SCs and STs according to the proportion
of the population of SCs and STs to the
Municipality Grade Population total population of the municipal area. In
addition, 30 per cent of total seats are
Class A 1 Lakh or more
reserved for women including the SCs and
50,000 –
Class –B STs seats.
less than one lakh
Class – C Less than 50,000 The 74th Amendment provide
A Municipal Council or Municipality the constitution of ward committees
for example in Class-A, not less than 20 consisting of one or more wards within
and not more that 50 elected members; the territorial area of a Municipality,
Class-B 15-30, and Class-C, 10-15. The having a population of 3 lakhs or more. A
members of State Legislative Assembly member of a Municipality representing a
representing the constituencies lying ward with in the territorial area of the ward
within the municipal area are “Ex-Officio” committee shall be a member of the ward
members of the Municipal Council. Not committee. The Standing Committees
more than 3 members are nominated by shall be constituted for each Municipality
the state government. The nominated consisting of the President, senior Vice-
members do not have the right to vote in President, and Vice president and 4 other
the elections of the chairpersons and vice members in the case of Class- A, 2 in the
chairpersons. The members are elected case of Class-B from among the elected
through secret ballot. members for a period of 2 and half years.
The term of office of Municipality is five
The whole municipal area is years. The elected municipality can be
divided into wards, as per the number dissolved if it is not performing as per
of councilors to be elected , say 15 or 30 the provisions of law.
or 10 . The electoral rolls of the legislative
assembly in relation to municipal area The Municipal Council meets
are generally taken as the voters list. The at least once in a month, presided over
candidates contesting in the elections by the President or in his/her absence
are allotted symbols. The symbols of the Vice- President. The Municipal Council
recognized political parties are allotted with the increasing load of work, elects
only to the candidates sponsored or subcommittees comprising councillors
adopted by the them. from amongst itself to study a problem
in depth and make recommendation for
The Deputy Commissioner has to its solution. The sub committees are of
call the meeting of the elected members two types statutory committees and, non-
within 14 days of the notification of the statutory committees. Municipal bodies
election results to administer the Oath also appoint special sub committees for
of office and to hold the election of the certain specific purposes and follow the
126
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 12.indd 126 12-09-2018 19:38:00
www.tntextbooks.in
same procedure for their election as it municipal staff, and bringing to the notice of
adopts the constitution of standing sub the appropriate administrative head or to raise
committees. the matter in the council meetings. The powers
and responsibilities of municipalities are
A Municipal Council elects enshrined in the Twelfth Schedule of the
its President from amongst members Constitution. (See Box-2)
within one month of the constitution
of Municipal Council. The Municipal ACTIVITY
Council is constituted after elections
are held. The President is elected for a Examine why local governments
period of 5 years. The Municipal Council have been entrusted with the very
also elects one or two Vice- Presidents. important responsibilities provided
The Presidents of the municipalities in in the 11th and 12th Schedule of the
various states draw monthly salary in Constitution.
addition to travelling allowance . The
President convenes and presides over The 74th Constitutional Amendment
the meeting of the Municipal Council. He provided the constitution of committee
/ She is empowered to take disciplinary for district planning, to prepare a draft
action against offending councilors. The development plan for the district as a
President is the chief spokesperson of the whole. The Committee shall consolidate
Municipal Council and represents it at the plans prepared by the panchayats
official functions and also with regard to and municipalities in the district. The
correspondence with the government. composition of the District Planning
Committee as provided in the Act of 1992,
The state government in every consists of that not less than 4/5th of the
municipality appoints an Executive total members of the committee. They
Officer. The Executive Officer is the shall be elected by and from amongst the
principal executive authority and all elected members of the Panchayats at the
municipal staff is sub-ordinate to him/ district level and of the municipalities
her. He/ She is the important officer to in the district, in proportion to the ratio
execute, supervise monitor and report between the population of the rural areas
the activities of the Municipalities to and of the urban areas in the district.
the council. The Municipal Council is
the governing body of the Municipality, The Municipalities have been
responsible for Municipal Administration. provided with the power to raise revenue
It makes by laws the governing place and for discharging its duties and performing
time of council meetings, the manner of its functions such as the taxes, duties and
giving notices, the conduct of meetings. fees which could be levied and collected
by the Municipalities (For example: tax
The councilors are expected to keep on lands and buildings, scavenging tax
themselves in touch with the citizens and on octroi, a tax on advertisements, a fire
enquire about their grievances against tax, toll on roads and bridges etc) the 74th
127
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 12.indd 127 12-09-2018 19:38:00
www.tntextbooks.in
Amendment Act made it obligatory for (ii) Allocation of share of such proceeds
the state governments to Constitute State between the municipalities at all
Finance Commission within one year levels in the states;
from the commencement of Act. (iii)
Determination of taxes, duties
The State Finance Commission shall make tolls and fees to be assigned or
recommendations regarding: appropriated by the municipalities;
(i)
Distribution between the state (iv) G
rants-in-aid to fund the state;
government and municipalities of (v)
Measures needed to improve
the net proceeds of taxes, duties, the financial position of the
tolls and fees to be assigned or municipalities.
appropriated by the state;
128
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 12.indd 128 12-09-2018 19:38:00
www.tntextbooks.in
129
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 12.indd 129 12-09-2018 19:38:00
www.tntextbooks.in
or public places due to rain or other, from amongst the members. The Mayor
collection and removal of solid waste, shall be the chairperson of the Standing
provision of health immunization, services Committee. The Municipal Corporation
for the civic services in slum and lighting, also constitutes committees to deal with
repair of roads, maintenance parks drains subject matters such as water supply,
and etc.,. sewage etc.,. Each subject committee
shall consist of not less than three and not
A Municipal Corporation shall have more than five members.
a Standing Committee constituted by it,
consisting of Mayor, the senior deputy The term of the subject committees
Mayor and other councilors elected is one year. The Municipal Corporations
by the councilors of the Corporation have been provided with financial
resources to carry out its duties assigned
ACTIVITY
130
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 12.indd 130 12-09-2018 19:38:00
www.tntextbooks.in
131
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 12.indd 131 12-09-2018 19:38:00
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 12.indd 132 12-09-2018 19:38:00
www.tntextbooks.in
Glossary
Panchayati Raj (1959 – 2009)
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 12.indd 133 12-09-2018 19:38:00
www.tntextbooks.in
Evaluation
(a)1870 (b)1882
(c)1687 (d)1992
2. When was the Lord Rippon’s Resolution adopted ?
(a)1992 (b)1858
(c) 1882 (d) 1870
3. The dyarchy system was established for the first time under
(a) Government of India Act, 1909 (b) Government of India Act, 1919
(c) Government of India Act, 1935 (d) Government of India Act, 1958
5. W
hat is the percentage of reservation of seats in local bodies for women under 73rd
and 74th Constitutional Amendment Acts?
(a) 45 (b) 50
(c) P
roportionate to the percentage of (d) 20
population of women in the constituencies
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 12.indd 134 12-09-2018 19:38:00
www.tntextbooks.in
9. The Delhi Development Authority (DDA) was set up on 30 December 1957 under
(a) An act of Delhi Assembly
(b) An executive order of the President of India
(c) An Act of the Parliament
(d) The order of the Leivtenant Governor of Delhi.
10. W
hich of the following election has no place for political parties?
(a) Municipal Corporation Mayor Election
(b) Municipal Council Election
(c) Panchayat President and Panchayat Ward Member Election
(d) District Councillor Election
13.which are the Articles in the Constitution of India that deals with Local Government?
(a) Art. 40, Art. 243 to 243 O , Art. 243 p to 243 ZG
(b) Art. 300, Art. 300A
(c) Art. 3A , Art. 43 A
(d) Art. 31 , Art. 117 (1)
135
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 12.indd 135 12-09-2018 19:38:01
www.tntextbooks.in
14. Arrange the Three tier Panchayati Raj System as per the Constitutional Provisions
(a) Village Panchayat – Intermediate Panchayat – District Panchayat
(b) Panchayat Union – District Panchayat – Village Panchayat
(c) District Panchayat – village Panchayat – Intermediate Pachayat
(d) V
illage Panchayat – Town Panchayat – District Pachayat – Intermediate
Panchayat
15. A
ssertion: 73rd Amendment Act brought rural local bodies
Reason: Democracy reached grass root level through local governments
Directions: Given below are two statements labelled as Assertion (A) and Reason (R)
in the context of the two statements, which of the following is correct?
(a) Both A and R are true and R is the correct explanation of A.
(b) Both A and R are true but R is not the correct explanation of A.
(c) A is true but R is false.
(d) A is false but R is true.
16. What is the lowest unit of the Panchayati Raj system in Tamilnadu?
17. What are the days the Gram Sabha meets in a year?
18. What is the term of office of a Mayor of Municipal Corporation.
19. Describe the powers and functions of the State Finance Commission.
20. Does the local bodies in Russia have any executive powers to do anything?
21. Which committee recommended the establishment of Panchayati Raj
Institutions?
22. What are the sources of revenue of a village Panchayats?
23. Give at least two reasons for the need for the PRI institutions in India?
24. How many municipal corporations are there in the state of TamilNadu?
25. Who is levying and collecting Entertainment Tax?
136
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 12.indd 136 12-09-2018 19:38:01
www.tntextbooks.in
Reference
Internet Sources
137
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 12.indd 137 12-09-2018 19:38:01
www.tntextbooks.in
ICT CORNER
1. Click the URL or scan the QR code to launch the “Village maps” page and learn
the name of the districts and number of villages in the district.
2. “Click any “district” (For Example: Cuddalore) to know the sub districts of the
district and number of villages in it and click the “Map” on the right side to
have satellite view.
3. Click any “Sub-District” (For Example:Virudhachalam) to know the number of
villages pertaining to the sub district and click the “Map” on the right side to
have satellite view.
4. Click any “village” (For Example:Nallur) to know the map of the village.
Step 1 Step 3
Step 2 Step 4
Download Link
*Pictures are indicative only.
*If browser requires, allow Flash Player or Java Script to load the
page.
URL: http://villagemap.in/tamil-nadu.html
138
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 12.indd 138 12-09-2018 19:38:02
www.tntextbooks.in
UNIT
13 Social Justice
Introduction
Until the late 20th century, most philosophical discussions
of justice and equality were limited in scope to a single society.
Even Rawls’s theory of justice, for example, had nothing to say
about the distribution of wealth between societies. In the 1990s
philosophers began to think about the moral implications of
the vast inequality in wealth between the leading industrialized
countries and the countries of the developing world, some
of which were afflicted with widespread famine and disease.
The German-born philosopher Thomas Pogge argued that
affluent countries are responsible for increasing the poverty of
developing countries and thus for causing millions of deaths
annually.
Learning Objectives
T
he meaning and importance of C
aste discrimination and its
distributive justice. -Impact of consequences
Social hierarchy E
galitarian society
J ohn Rawls perspective of fair and R
eservation policy and its essentiality
just society
G
overnment’s role in upliftment
S ocial Justice Movements in Tamil
Nadu. P
rivileges and its impact
139
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 13.indd 139 12-09-2018 19:38:22
www.tntextbooks.in
13. 1 What do you mean by Social Justice? to capture the power sector. Among
different communities in a plural society,
The negative values which are
dominance of a single group is considered
made by the society results in inequality
as unfair and unjust. The dominant groups
and cleavation among people. Gender
activate racial, religious, caste, lingual and
inequality may be quite natural, if looked
cultural feelings and intend to misuse the
upon superficially. All along the centuries,
social rights of other groups that may end
women were subjugated and exploited
in permanent hostility between different
without an opportunity which portrays
groups. The struggle that is undertaken
them as weaker section. The negative
by the weaker groups in order to react for
attitude against blacks of Africa belongs to
establishing equal society is known to be
same category which is mentioned in the
Social Justice.
previous lines. Blacks were discouraged
and kept aside as knowledge less. This Background of Social Hierarchy
situation continued for many centuries and
The ancient Indian civilization had
factualised against the black community.
evolved with the “Varnashrama Dharma”
Same situation prevails also in India.
which kick-started the principle of
Many people were refused opportunities
hierarchy i.e. Upper and Lower strata. The
on the basis of caste and it is believed as
Varna system is also called as “Four Varna
natural one in the society. Every action
System” by which people were divided as
and reaction is fudged one in our country.
Brahmins, Kshatriyas, Vysyas and Shudras.
Power as a demon spread its tentacles in
all the sphere of the society, as stated by This division on the
so many experts and exponents. Social basis of birth has been
power is the dominant phenomenon inculcated and socialized
which leads to cut-throat competition and along different phases of
ends in absolute control of the subjects. It civilization from which
is in order to protect the social identity, inequalities surfaced in
the dominant communities endeavor the society.
140
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 13.indd 140 12-09-2018 19:38:22
www.tntextbooks.in
Article 15 (4) of Indian Constitution different groups of religion, race and other
factors can live with their social identity,
Article 29 (2) may not act as an
tolerance and shared power.
obstacle in making special policy decisions
for socially and educationally backward Economic condition and status
communities or SC/ST people. is one among the reason for the wedge
created in the European society. Whereas
Article 16 (4) of Indian Constitution in India, the division is on the basis of
This will not prevent any sort of purusasvktha of Rigveda and particularly
appointment or reservation among Four Varna System.
backward communities, if sufficient
This Varna System prevents
representation is not provided. India is a
individuals from their exercise of rights
sub-tropical, sub-continent with varied
and values. Indian Constitution in this
geographical atmosphere. People speak
regard is implementing all its supervisory
different languages and follow unique
mechanisms and also is delivering
hereditary values. Albeit of these factors,
distributive justice which is the motto
inequality is existing due to the Varna
of the largest democracy. This justice
System. It is in order to advance and
intended to weed out the caste distinction
develop the socio-economic conditions
(Varna System) and to establish equal
of the downtrodden communities; Indian
society in India.
Constitution is having its ideal guidelines
with strong structural foundation. The democratic values in Indian
Constitution protects and delegate power
According to Indian Constitution, to all the people equally to develop
States which are having low technological themselves in the socio-economic sectors.
development or inadequate natural Sticking on with this constitutional
resources can make their own special provisions may lead to social development
policies for holistic advancement. In and further give place for social freedom
accordance with the existing constitutional and justice. Hence, vibrant social justice
provisions, the downtrodden and in India protects National Integration
underprivileged communities were from which distributive justice and
provided with special laws and privileges democratic values are concretized.
in all the states.
DEBATE
Ideas like all inclusive development
and self-sufficient societal growth highly
Democracy is being
hinges upon social justice along with
misunderstood as in terms of numbers,
special arrangements for the marginalized
votes or the reflection of majority. All-
sections. Equal opportunity is the process
inclusive representation is the new
and social arrangement by which social
thought which is growing in the society.
democracy can sustain and pluralism
Democracy succeeds successfully only
will be strengthened. In such a society
in the all inclusive system.
141
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 13.indd 141 12-09-2018 19:38:22
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 13.indd 142 12-09-2018 19:38:23
www.tntextbooks.in
143
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 13.indd 143 12-09-2018 19:38:23
www.tntextbooks.in
our constitution has the obligation of This clearly conveys the meaning
ensuring one of the finest promises of our of what is the aim of providing equal
constitution itself – bringing in equality opportunity. When modern education
to our society. Therefore, it is legal, becomes the most significant resource
constitutional and moral on the part of and employment in government sector
the government to create a level playing remains a major source of livelihood,
ground for all its citizens especially those the concept of level playing ground or
who have been historically denied basic equal opportunity was advocated and
rights. subsequently this idea became an integral
part of our constitutional apparatus.
This level playing field or what we
popularly call ‘equal opportunity’ must There are several opinions in this
not be treated either as charity or as regard. How should we distribute the
philanthropic gesture of the government. resources and ensure equal opportunity/
It is the obligation on the part of the fair access to education and jobs to all
government to treat people differently in especially to the disadvantaged groups.
order to ensure Justice; more importantly Many especially people from the so called
it is a fundamental right enshrined in the upper echelon of the society tend to think
constitution for disadvantaged people to of treating people differently in order
seek legal, constitutional remedy. to ensure just distribution effectively
Similarly, level playing ground is aimed at amounts to discrimination. This opinion
creating equal opportunity only in slowly and steadily invokes strong passion
education and employment opportunities and at times results in violence too. The
for the disadvantaged communities. In fear of losing educational and employment
many realms of our everyday lives, there is opportunities among the privileged
virtually no demand from the marginalized communities was steadily growing as
sections to provide a level playing ground. the government planned to ‘reserve’
seats for people from marginalized and
underprivileged communities as part of
DEBATE its equal opportunity plan.
The idea of ‘merit’ would be
Do people ask the Government invoked by the privileged sections of
to provide a level playing field in our country to argue that any attempt
sports? to ‘reserve’ seats for the underprivileged
people would strongly damage merit
Does anyone seek similar
based output of our education system;
intervention from the government
thus it would subsequently affect the
in Private sectors, Armed forces?
professional abilities of the candidates.
Does anyone demand that people But as students of political theory, we
must be treated differently in our must be able to dispassionately examine
criminal procedural system? the issues involved in our quest to
understand Justice. Do you first of all
144
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 13.indd 144 12-09-2018 19:38:23
www.tntextbooks.in
The substantial point of debate while It defines just distribution when land
studying the concept of Justice would be or any other resources disbursed must be
how the resources would be distributed historically justified. Individuals who have
to all section of the society. In order to never had the ownership of land or other
understand this point more clearly let us resources can appropriate it by voluntary
dwell upon a few important perspectives transfer between and among themselves.
on the issue of Justice. In conventional Transfer of resources, for them, must be
understanding of politics, there are a few absolutely voluntary.
major theories of Justice being discussed
All these perspectives as it is evident from
at length. Equality of Resources, Common
the brief description do focus on both
Ownership theories and Entitlements are
resources and human ability. Resources
often referred while discussing Justice.
could be for example, land as well as
A. Equality of Resources knowledge; human ability also plays a
vital role for some theorists. There is a
This perspective defines distribution
grand consensus that Justice in a society is
of resources to be just; that is to say, if
possible only when it becomes distributive
every individual has the same effective
rather than retributive. How do we define
resources that amounts to Justice. If, for
retributive justice?
some given work, each person obtains the
same amount of wage or reward, that is D. Retributive Justice
how we must realize Justice. If inequality
exists it is singularly the result of individual The concept of retributive justice is
choices – to be a productive earner or to often invoked in several contexts. One can
be a person of leisure. This perspective understand the framework of this form of
effectively rejects self-ownership and justice by following certain principles.
resource ownership but strongly advocates
only responsibilities and obligations. i). Those who have committed wrongful
acts, serious crimes do deserve harsh
145
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 13.indd 145 12-09-2018 19:38:23
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 13.indd 146 12-09-2018 19:38:23
www.tntextbooks.in
likely no one would do that? Why? It is not exactly who he/she would be and what is
possible also to imagine people sacrificing going to benefit him/her. Each one of us
their personal ambitions and self-interest will imagine the future society from the
in a new society. People will immediately point of view of the worst off. We usually
think of their children and their grand tend to place ourselves with all privileges
children’s welfare. Why would people and entitlements. Now in the new
sacrifice the well-being of themselves imagined society, we really do not know
and their children? You may wonder how where and what we will be. In such a
this simple question would be the basis situation, what strikes people is, what if we
for John Rawls theory of Justice. There unfortunately are born in a disadvantaged
are strong foundations for this simple section of the society with a few or very
question and its plausible answer. minimal opportunities? Suddenly, we
try to create new system in which even
John Rawls tries to find out an answer persons from the most marginalized
for this question. He offers a hypothetical sections get reasonable opportunities and
situation for us to imagine. Yes, let’s resources.
imagine ourselves to be in a situation in
which we have to make decisions about Even though this is a moment of
how society should be organized although departure, it is not so easy to erase our
we do not know which position we would identities and think/imagine oneself under
ourselves occupy in that society. We may a veil of ignorance. Similarly, it is not easy
not know which family we would be born to expect people to be self sacrificing and
in and similarly no knowledge about our share their good future with unknown
caste, class, religion, gender and region people. However, the merit of the ‘veil
etc. Here Rawls argues that if we do not of ignorance’ framework is that it expects
know where we will be and what options people to just be their usual rational selves;
would be available for us in the future they are expected to think for themselves
society, we will most likely support a and choose what they regard to be in their
decision on the rules and organizations of interest.
that future society which would be fair for
all members. When we are quite uncertain But what is more important here is
about our future, we like to facilitate an that by wearing an imagined veil of
order in which all members would get a ignorance is the first step towards arriving
fair deal. at a system of fair laws and policies. It
tries to latch its trust in the human agency
This moment Rawls describes as of rationality among people in
thinking under a ‘Veil of Ignorance’. We contemporary world. The ethics of reason
are ignorant about our possible position will create, for Rawls, a new political
and status in society; each person would structure in which people will think of
decide the way they generally do – trying polices not to optimize their self interests
to have optimum self interest in the new but rather envisage society as a whole.
society. But surprisingly no one knows This comprehensive and holistic
147
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 13.indd 147 12-09-2018 19:38:23
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 13.indd 148 12-09-2018 19:38:23
www.tntextbooks.in
and anti-human thinking", exclaimed other benefit-less offices. They were not
E.V.Ramaswamy alias Periyar in permitted to occupy higher positions,
Tamilnadu. He out- rightly condemned because of their caste identity. Individuals
the cultural practices, habitual follow-ups and organization for the past centuries
and other so called values which refutes made onerous efforts to curb out in equal
equality in all its aspects. Periyar also was menace from the society.
against “Patriarchal Chauvinism” which
subjugated women all along the history. There some human communities
which needs special attention, since they
were totally ignored and exploited by the
DEBATE upper strata people.
149
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 13.indd 149 12-09-2018 19:38:23
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 13.indd 150 12-09-2018 19:38:23
www.tntextbooks.in
Often, these people are disadvantaged for program in each executive department
historical reasons, such as oppression or and agency". In the U.S., affirmative
slavery. Support for affirmative action has action's basic purpose was to pressurize
sought to achieve a range of goals: bridging institutions into compliance with the
inequalities in employment and pay; nondiscrimination mandate of the Civil
increasing access to education; enriching Rights Act of 1964. Affirmation Action
state, institutional, and professional was extended to women in 1967.
leadership with the full spectrum of
society; redressing apparent past wrongs, United Nations
harms, or hindrances and in particular The International Convention on
addressing the apparent social imbalance the Elimination of All Forms of Racial
left in the wake of slavery and slave laws. Discrimination stipulates that affirmative
action programs may be required for all
For example, a 2017 study found that
countries that ratified the convention, in
affirmative action in the United States of
order to rectify systematic discrimination.
America "there is an increase in the share
It states, however, that such programs
of black employees over time: in 5 years
"shall in no case entail as a consequence
after an establishment is first regulated."
of unequal or separate rights for different
United States of America racial groups after the objectives are
achieved."
Though there were developments
in Liberty, Economy and Technology in The United Nations Human Rights
United States of America, still there were Committee states that "the principle of
sustained discrimination on the basis of equality sometimes requires State parties
colour till the later period of Twentieth to take affirmative action in order to
century. This raised Civil Rights agitations diminish or eliminate conditions which
there. cause or help to perpetuate discrimination
Following this Affirmation Action prohibited by the Covenant.
was introduced by John F.Kennedy in
Social Justice laws in South Africa
1960s in the United States of America.
This was called as Executive Order 10925. Following the transition to democracy
Through this order, Govt requested in 1994, South Africa chose to implement
the employers not to discriminate their affirmative action through legislations
employees or candidates on the basis of to correct previous imbalances. As such,
race, creed, colour, or national origin. all employers were compelled by law to
employ previously disenfranchised groups
This order was replaced by another (blacks, Indians, and Coloured). By this
order 11246 in the year 1965. By this the the companies employing more than 50
Federal Government commit "to promote people have to design and implement plans
the full realization of equal employment to improve the workforce demographics,
opportunity through a positive, continuing and report them to the Department of
151
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 13.indd 151 12-09-2018 19:38:23
www.tntextbooks.in
Labour. Employment Equity also forms British Empire. Laws like ‘Ryotwari’ were
part of a company's Black Economic made. Moreover, tax collecting system
Empowerment scorecard. Moreover, the was introduced. Further, military forces
Supreme Court has ruled that in principle were also instigated. In 1835, English was
blacks may be favoured. declared as official and administrative
language in India. Indians were appointed
China in the British Indian military forces.
China followed some sort of Majority of the people who joined in
affirmative action in education for military were non-Brahmins and deprived
minority nationalities. communities.
Russia
Quota systems existed in the USSR
for various social groups including ethnic
minorities, women and factory workers
for access to university education, offices
in the former Soviet union.
152
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 13.indd 152 12-09-2018 19:38:24
www.tntextbooks.in
said are “Caste Hindus”. “Caste Hindus” admission of children who belong to lower
domination in all villages greatly affected caste groups but the condition remains
the villages and particularly, the unchanged.
downtrodden communities were kept
Preferential Rights for the Downtrodden
aside from the lands in all villages of India.
In 1885, Madras Presidency
Government declared financial assistance
policies for the downtrodden communities
and also the government oriented new
schools for the lower caste people.
In the meantime, Tremancre,
collector of Chengalpet district submitted
a report on the downtrodden communities
of Chengalpet. Those excerpts are: People
In this connection, a British officer of downtrodden community were at low
‘Francis Ellis’ was appointed to submit the level in all aspects, particularly social-
status report regarding ‘Ryotwari System’. economic, educational spheres. Lands are
In similar way, another officer, ‘Thomas denied for them. They were not permitted
Munro’ also submitted a report related to to build houses for their own. Educational
the ‘Ryotwari System’. opportunities were rejected. They are sold
as slaves. Lots of lands are kept barren.
According to the reports, ‘Lands Due to this, income for the government
which were tilled by lower strata people, has been diminished. To increase the
were illegally occupied and acquired by income of the government, lands can be
‘Zamindars’ and ‘Landlords’ and thus distributed to the people.
caused quality-less farming and low level
of yields. It is also reported that Land There were so many
Income Tax was also affected due to this recommendations present in the officers’
acquisition. Moreover, the deprived and report. In 1892, this report was considered
downtrodden communities were checked- and accepted by the government.
out of their lands and also their children Accordingly 12 lakh acres were distributed
denied admissions in the schools and to the lower caste groups. These lands are
other educational institutions. called as “Panchami.” Schools for lower
caste groups are called as “Panchamer
In 1854, court delivered direction School”.
that there may not be any restriction to “Panchamer” means people who
admit children who belongs to lower caste are out of Varna System or excluded
groups. The Caste Hindus and other communities. ‘Ayothidasa’ and
dominant communities, however, didn’t ‘Singaravela’ opined that “Panchamer
obey the judgment of the court Schools” can be called as “Adidravidar”
proceedings. In 1865, Secretary of state schools. Since it is the traditional name
for India in British Parliament ordered for carved to the category.
153
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 13.indd 153 12-09-2018 19:38:24
www.tntextbooks.in
British India in the end part of 19th efforts in Maharastra for educating the
century supported Brahmin development depressed and downtrodden communities.
in all spheres, whereas minorities were
denied opportunities in education, society,
power and employment sectors.
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 13.indd 154 12-09-2018 19:38:26
www.tntextbooks.in
“Justice” was also published by this It is the red lettered day in Indian
Federation to express their thoughts and history, lower caste groups, who were
ideas. Later on, this Federation was suppressed and deprived of Social and
popularly known as “Justice Party”. Economical condition for many centuries
had fullest confidence to lead their life
with self-respect and dignity by this
decree.
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 13.indd 155 12-09-2018 19:38:26
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 13.indd 156 12-09-2018 19:38:26
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 13.indd 157 12-09-2018 19:38:26
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 13.indd 158 12-09-2018 19:38:27
www.tntextbooks.in
“I know much labour has gone into the writing of this report. But let me tell you
that today we have performed its immersion (visarjan) ceremon.”
Next ten years, the report lay in the Home Ministry’s office. Report was dusted
up by the then National Front Prime Minister Vishwanath Pratap Singh (1931 – 2008)
for implementation in 1990. Mandal Commission report became the single-most
burning topic of controversy and heated discussion. There was total confusion in the
national political arena and V.P. Singh was accused of indulging in the worst form
of opportunism. No major political party supported the implementation of Mandal
Commission recommendations.
Some section of people and associations opposed to this order filed a number of
cases in the court. Eleven judges of the Supreme Court heard arguments of both sides
and by a majority, the Supreme Court judges in 1992 declared that this was valid.
At the same time the Supreme Court asked the government to modify its original
order. It said that well-to-do persons among the backward classes should be excluded
from getting the benefit of reservation. Accordingly, the Department of Personnel
and Training issued another Office Memorandum on September 8, 1993. The dispute
thus came to an end and this policy has been followed since then.
One of the major recommendation made by the commission was that, besides
the SCs and STs, for other backward classes which constitute nearly 52% of the
population, 27% government jobs are be reserved so that total reservation for all,
SC,ST and OBCs, amount to 50%.
159
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 13.indd 159 12-09-2018 19:38:27
www.tntextbooks.in
No action was taken on the basis of the Mandal Report for long after it was
submitted, except that it was discussed in the Houses of Parliament twice, once in
1982and again in 1983.
On August 13, 1990, the V.P.Singh Government at the Centre issued an office
memorandum accepting the Mandal Commission recommendation and
announcing 27% reservation for the socially and educationally backward classes in
vacancies in civil posts and services under the Government of India.
160
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 13.indd 160 12-09-2018 19:38:27
www.tntextbooks.in
Minorities - people who belongs to a Panchamer - people who are out of the
group at less number in population Varna system
Evaluation
161
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 13.indd 161 12-09-2018 19:38:27
www.tntextbooks.in
162
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 13.indd 162 12-09-2018 19:38:27
www.tntextbooks.in
163
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 13.indd 163 12-09-2018 19:38:27
www.tntextbooks.in
Reference Books
1. Gauba. O.P, ‘Dimension of Social Justice’, National Publishing Co, New Delhi, 1983.
2. Rawls, John, ‘A Theory of Justice’, Universal Law Publishing Co. Pvt, Ltd, Delhi,
2000.
3. Rao, Priya, ‘Development & Social Justice - A Legal Perspective’; Kalpaz Publications,
Delhi, 2012.
4. Purohit . B.R; ‘Social Justice in India’, Rawat Publications, New Delhi, 2003.
5. Barry, Brain, ‘Why Social Justice Matters’ 1st Edition, Polity Publishers, 2005
164
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 13.indd 164 12-09-2018 19:38:27
www.tntextbooks.in
UNIT
Diary of Events
165
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 14.indd 165 12-09-2018 19:38:47
www.tntextbooks.in
Learning Objectives
To understand the nature of political discourses that took place in Madras
presidency during the 1900s.
To unravel the emergence of Non-Brahmin movement and how it had paved the
way for the Dravidian parties rule in the state of Tamil Nadu.
To explore the nature of centre-state relations during the rule of various political
parties in the state.
To study the welfare policies of the Dravidian parties and its significant impact on
the society.
To examine whether any state level political will has any impact on national politics.
The chief aim of the study is to understand various dimensions of the social welfare
policies of successive governments in the state.
To explore the reasons for the fragmentation in Dravidian politics and in
consequences.
14.1 Political History of Tamil Nadu by the "Brahmin – non – Brahmin conflicts".
Scholars and political thinkers believed
Compared with rest of India, Tamil that understanding the conflicts between
Nadu has had a healthy administrative these two groups, (the Brahmins and non –
and political culture, more or less stable Brahmins), is necessary to understand the
economic life, and continuity of traditions South Indian Politics and society.
from the hoary past to the present. Madras
Presidency of South India came into Madras Presidency
existence due to the administrative and Simultaneously a few members
political needs of the British. The Madras of Non-Brahmin caste groups sought
Presidency was formed in A.D (C.E.) employment in industries, commercial
1801. The Presidency, as it existed during enterprises etc., Significant but a portion
the 19th and 20th centuries, comprised of non-Brahmin caste groups migrated
of the present states of Andhra Pradesh, from rural areas to urban pockets of the
Malabar region of Kerala, Southern Presidency and wanted to ascertain their
Karnataka, Southern most part of Odisha identity as ‘Dravidian’ and ‘Tamils’ and
and Union Territory of Lakshadweep. gradually challenged the monopoly of
powers and privileges enjoyed by the
Madras Presidency politics in the Brahmins in politics, administration and
early part of 20th century was dominated society.
166
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 14.indd 166 12-09-2018 19:38:47
www.tntextbooks.in
167
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 14.indd 167 12-09-2018 19:38:48
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 14.indd 168 12-09-2018 19:38:50
www.tntextbooks.in
iv) To create public opinion infavour of the elections, but many congressmen
Non-Brahmins demand. contested the elections under different
banners.
169
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 14.indd 169 12-09-2018 19:38:50
www.tntextbooks.in
medical education. On an initiative from and then he was elected as the president of
Dr. Muthulakshmi and others, Devadasi Justice Party. In the same year, the Justice
system was abolished in Tami nadu and Party passed a resolution that Tamil Nadu
women were enfranchised. Co-operative should be made as a separate state loyal
societies were promoted. Mirasdari system to British government and it should be
was abolished, and a under the direct control of the Secretary
number of irrigation of State for India.
schemes were
Periyar E.V.Ramaswamy who played
introduced in 1923.
a pioneering role in the Madras Presidency
Annamalai University
Congress, had tried his best to make the
and Andhra
Tamilnadu Congress Committee adopt
University were
resolutions in favour of proportional
founded during their
representation for the non-brahmins
regime. It was the Justic Party which
in political arena. He gave an effective
provided the most successful government
leadership to the Vaikom Sathyagraha and
though they were assigned only a few
campaigned against caste-discrimination
departments.
in the Cheranmadevi Gurukula, founded
14.5 Periyar E.V. Ramasamy: by congress.
When all his efforts failed to make
Peiyar E.V. Ramasamy congress adopt his programme, he left
considered the congress and launched the self-respect
decision of Rajaji’s movement in 1925. He shunned electoral
government to impose politics and instead campaigned for social
Hindi as a compulsory reforms, especially for eradication of
subject as a move caste system, removal of indignities and
to establish ‘North Indian imperialism’ gender based restrictions on women,
and destroying the Tamil language and and rejection of hereditary priesthood.
culture. Periyar, further, maintained that The self-respect movement carried on
the imposition of Hindi was a calculated a vigorous campaign against age old
effort to sub judicate the Dravidians in superstitious beliefs and practices in
order to ascertain the supremacy of the every sphere and questioned the role of
Aryans. religion in justifying and sustaining such
Madras Presidency has witnessed irrational traditions and inequalities. The
massive anti-Hindi agitations and Self Respect Movement campaigned for
Periyar was imprisoned by the provincial rationalism, and against denial of dignity
government. It is significant to note that in and equal status of individuals (including
fifteen years he went to jail twenty- three women) under the garb of tradition and
times and got the nickname as ‘jailbird’ religion.
(Siraiparavai). In 1938, Periyar was The Self Respect Movement ordained
imprisoned for his Anti-Hindi agitation its members to give up caste surname and
170
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 14.indd 170 12-09-2018 19:38:50
www.tntextbooks.in
171
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 14.indd 171 12-09-2018 19:38:51
www.tntextbooks.in
172
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 14.indd 172 12-09-2018 19:38:51
www.tntextbooks.in
173
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 14.indd 173 12-09-2018 19:38:51
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 14.indd 174 12-09-2018 19:38:51
www.tntextbooks.in
Resistance as spectacle,
as political theatre,
has a history. Gandhi’s
salt march in 1930 to
Dandi is among the
most exhilarating examples. But the
salt march wasn’t theatre alone. It was In 1963, Kamaraj resigned (Kamaraj
the symbolic part of a large act of real Plan) his chief ministership to become the
civil disobedience. When Gandhi and President of Indian National Congress and
an army of freedom fighters marched M.Bhaktavatchalam took over the reins
to Gujarat’s coast and made salt from of the government. The Food shortage
sea water, thousands of Indians across and anti-hindi agitation caused the un-
the country began to make their popularity of his ministry.
own salt, openly defying imperial
Dravidian Parties Rule
Britain’s salt tax laws, which banned
local production in favour of British In the general elections of 1967,
imports. It was a direct strike at the the congress party was defeated. The
economic underpinning of the British Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam formed the
Empire. government.
(Arundhati Roy, An Ordinary Person’s
Guide To Empire, p.307.)
175
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 14.indd 175 12-09-2018 19:38:52
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 14.indd 176 12-09-2018 19:38:52
www.tntextbooks.in
Glossary
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 14.indd 177 12-09-2018 19:38:52
www.tntextbooks.in
Evaluation
178
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 14.indd 178 12-09-2018 19:38:52
www.tntextbooks.in
a) 1885 b) 1947
c) 1857 d) 1965
9. Matching items
A B
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 14.indd 179 12-09-2018 19:38:52
www.tntextbooks.in
12. A
ssertion: Karunanidhi entered the Tamil Nadu assembly by winning the Kulithalai
seat in the 1957 election.
Reason : Karunanidhi became the Chief Minister of the State.
Directions: Given below are two statements labelled as Assertion (A) and Reason (R)
in the context of the two statements, which of the following is correct?
13. A
ssertion -E.V. Ramasamy started the Self-Respect Movement.
Reason-The Self-Respect Movement is a movement with the aim of achieving a
society where Non-Brahmin castes have equal human rights
Directions: Given below are two statements labelled as Assertion (A) and Reason (R)
in the context of the two statements, which of the following is correct?
(a) Both A and R are true and R is the correct explanation of A.
(b) Both A and R are true but R is not the correct explanation of A.
(c) A is true but R is false.
(d) A is false but R is true.
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 14.indd 180 12-09-2018 19:38:52
www.tntextbooks.in
Reference Books
1. Baker, C.J. (1976). The Politics of South India 1820-1937, Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press.
4. M.S.S.Pandian, Brahmin and Non-Brahmin: Genealogies of the Tamil Political
Present, 2007.
9. V.Geetha, and S.V. Rajadurai, Towards a Non Brahmin Millenium - From
Iyothee Thass to Periyar, Calcutta, Samya, 1998.
11. Hardgrave, R.L. Jr. The Dravidian Movement, Bombay: Popular Prakashan,
1965.
181
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 14.indd 181 12-09-2018 19:38:53
www.tntextbooks.in
ICT CORNER
1. Click the URL or scan the QR code to launch the “Tamilnadu maps elections” page.
2. “Scroll the cursor” on the constituency map to know the representatives of that
constituency.
3. On the left window, click “Assembly Constituencies of Tamil Nadu” to know the
boundary of any legislative assembly constituency.
4. On the left window of the homepage, Click “Chief Ministers of Tamilnadu” to know
CM Time period.
Step 3
Step 1
Step 4
Step 2
Download Link
*Pictures are indicative only.
*If browser requires, allow Flash Player or Java Script to load the page.
https://www.mapsofindia.com/assemblypolls/tamil-nadu/election-
results.html
182
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 14.indd 182 12-09-2018 19:38:55
www.tntextbooks.in
UNIT
183
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 15.indd 183 12-09-2018 19:54:29
www.tntextbooks.in
evil, community, justice and kingdom) claims to have destroyed a ‘Tamil federation’
is a revelation of the Tamil polity. The which existed for 132 years. Similarly such
Sangam literary works have been grouped a Tamil federation of kings to fight foreign
into eight anthologies (Ettuthogai): invasion is also mentioned in ‘Agananooru’,
(1) Natrinai, (2) Kuruntogai, (3) Aingurunooru, a sangam literature. Hence the idea and
(4) Paditruppattu, (5) Paripadal, (6) Kalittogai, prevalence of Tamil nationalism is not simply
(7)Agananooru, and (8) Purananooru; and a consequence of colonialism. The roots of
there is a ninth group of poems called the Tamil nationalism are linked to the historical
Patthupattu (Ten Idylls).The early part of the role and significance of Tamil language and
first two books of Tholkappiyam, a work on culture in defining politics that could be
Tamil grammar, belongs to the same period. traced even in the Sangam age.
The famous post-Sangam literature The concept of State and the idea king
which was collected later as an anthology coincided with the territorial emphasis of
is known as the Kilkkanakku. There are 18 polity as the Greek city-state. The classical
works as part of this collection and the most Tamil country known as Tamizhagam
famous is Silappadikaram, Manimekalai and covered areas south of Tirupati hills up to the
Eighteen Minor Works (Pathinen kilkkanakku, tip of the Cape Comorin (Kanyakumari). The
which includes the Thirukkural) were written land was traditionally classified according
during this period. Prabandha literature to its nature into five geographical regions
consists of poetry of various forms: kovai, (tinai): the mountainous region (kurinji), the
in which the verses are arranged according forest areas(mullai), fertile plains (marudam),
to a particular theme (usually about love), coastal region (neidhal) and arid region
and kalambakam, in which the end of one (palai).
stanza/line formed the beginning of the next
Tamil speaking areas were divided
(usually about kings and bravery) and parani.
between the principalities of the Cholas (its
The best illustrations of this tradition are
capital at Uraiyur), the Pandyas (Madurai
the Pantikkovai, Nandikkalambakam, and
as capital), the Cheras in most of present
Kalingattup-parani.
Kongunadu (and Kerala) and the Pallavas
The ancient Tamil literature of (Kanchipuram as capital). Tamil country
Sangam age, Thirukkural, Silapathikaram, included several kingdoms ruled by kings
Manimegalai etc provide deep insights into (vendhar), major and minor chieftains (vel/
the nature of polity, society and culture. velar) who was less powerful than the crowned
Tamil language formed the core and essence kings. The Sangam poets sang songs of praise
of Tamil identity, culture, customs and about the velirs, especially the Seven Patrons,
traditions. Despite the diversity of land, for their generosity towards the poets. Kapilar
geography, rulers and chieftains spread across and Avvaiyar mention chieftains like, Aay,
the Tamil speaking areas the idea of Tamil Pari, Ori, Malayan, Elini, Pegan and Nalli..
country and confederation of Tamil speaking
The virtues of king did include the ideals
areas did exist. This literary finding(s) is
of Just Ruler with qualities of kindness towards
also substantiated by a stone inscription of
the subjects and bravery in the battlefield
Kalinga King Kharavela (BC(BCE) 165), who
184
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 15.indd 184 12-09-2018 19:54:29
www.tntextbooks.in
Extended Learning
Refer The Hindu website and read the article by Eric Miller. Share your views in
the classroom.
185
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 15.indd 185 12-09-2018 19:54:29
www.tntextbooks.in
against enemies. The sabhai or mandram the Cholas were represented by the tiger, the
was the highest court of justice presided by Cheras by the bow and arrow the Pandyas by
the king himself. Every village had its own the fish and the Pallavas by the lion.
mandram which met at a common public
The institution of ‘spy’ was considered as
place and was involved in organizing village
a necessary institution and the maintenance of
and community activities. Warriors were
peace and stability in the kingdom depended
respected, and a man who died in battle
on the effectiveness of this institution. Though
would have memorial stones erected in his
slavery as a form of institution was absent
honour and be worshipped in death. Even if a
yet capturing of slaves after invasions, and
warrior dies in battle field with a wound in his
slave trade or exchange for gifts did remain
back, it is considered derogatory in ‘Sangam’
as practice among the rulers to undertake
traditions.
construction and building works.
Lots of good practices of war find its
The practice of caste system or jati was
mention in sangam literature. Purananooru, a
unknown among ancient Tamils. The idea
sangam literature, hails the Pandyan king who
and concept of class with differences in status
announces all the women, children, sick and
based on professional distinctions did prevail.
elderly people, cattles, to move to safety zone
The caste system was alien and unknown to
before invading a country. The idea of justice
Sangam society. The division of society based
formed the conscience of State and king.
on class has been revealed by the Sangam
Justice is an essential element in a king’s rule.
poets who mention about social categories
A good king should never sacrifice justice.
(kudi): tudiyan, panan, and kadamban; or
Just rule and good deeds always will bring
arasar (rulers), vaishyar (traders), and velalar
everlasting fame to the king. An important
(farmers). Differences in status were accepted
political principle that prevailed was that
as inevitable, yet varna in the form of caste or
(Despite the nature of political system jati seems to be little known to Sangam society.
being monarchy) the legitimacy of the king
Though social stratification did prevail
rests with the consent of the people as long
yet legitimization of Manusmiriti or Aryan-
as he enjoys people’s support and he loses
Brahminical interpretation of caste as divine
legitimacy if he loses their support. Sangam
arrangement was not integral to the cultural
literature (Pattinappaalai) speaks about
universe or worldview of the ancient Tamils.
different types of taxations like customs duty,
The beginnings and early inroads of the
income tax, toll tax etc as specific source of
Aryan-Brahminical account of caste could
revenue to the State. Tamil kings and chieftains
be traced to later period of Sangam era.
ruled the land with simple administrative
The ancient religion of Tamils was based
structure of council of ministers, subordinates
on folk traditions. The worship of nature
and administrative officers. There were
and natural elements were more common.
officers to deal with foreign trade and customs
The worship of Murugan among the tribes
revenue which was an important part of the
of Tamil Nadu and the cult worship of
budget. Pandya inscriptions mention about
Murugan as the warrior God was based
officers for pearl fisheries (kalatika) and the
on folk culture. An earthly composition
chief scribes (kanatikan). In flags and coins,
186
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 15.indd 186 12-09-2018 19:54:30
www.tntextbooks.in
of God is rooted in the Tamil – Dravidian the results of this interaction as revealed by
traditions. It was only after the sixth century the themes and dedication of deity at temples.
AD(CE), inscriptions were written in Tamil
Women were highly respected and
as well as Sanskrit. Sanskritisation gradually
performed a variety of jobs and duties
spread to public space with the evoking of
including as bodyguards to the kings, yet
the doctrines of benevolence to Brahmin(s)
power and authority rested with men. Women
and divine blessings to the king .
participated in public assemblies but rulers
The seeking of blessings from the and administrators were mostly men. Women
Brahmin soon became a source of legitimacy formed significant part of social rituals and
for the Tamil king after this period. Along functioned as pivots of the family despite
with the Sanskritisation, Vedic rituals, the inheritance rights and formal authority
worship and orientation to social (caste) remained with men.
system as advocated in Manusmiriti found
In narrating the role and status of women
their passage to transform the professionally
in Tamil society we need to mention about the
stratified class structure of Dravidian society
tradition of Avvaiyar (meaning respectable
into a hierarchically classified social (caste)
women). More than a name, this was a title,
system with Vedic divine sanctions.
literary canon, given to distinguished women
The State and king were being seen as one who made contributions to Tamil literature.
and the same. The hereditary principle and There were as many as four to six women who
evoking of divine rights with earthly symbols held this Tamil literary canon title at different
were prevalent among the Tamil kings. The times based on different sources.
idea of territorial State provided inherent
Avvaiyars of Sangam age and Cholas
reconciliation to the changing dynasties
age are best known for their extraordinary
and geographical changes as boundaries of
influence upon literature, culture, moral
principalities were drawn and redrawn. The
universe, nature of polity, war, peace and the
governing principles of power and location of
art of diplomacy. Sangam age Avvaiyar lived
monarchy also moved from culture specific
during the 1st and 2nd century AD(CE). King
to power centric based on authority. Thus
Athiyaman Neduman Anchi of the Velir
in later period, during the post-Sangam era,
Dynasty was her chief patron and considered as
the king gradually became the sole source of
contemporary of literary legends Thiruvalluvar
authority.
and Kabilar with notable contribution of
The Pallavas maintained that as they verses in Natrinai, Kuruntogai, Akananooru
were the descendants of Brahma, the kingship and Purananooru. She is also credited as the
was of divine origin and was hereditary. The most gracious and scholarly diplomat who
Pallava period witnessed the penetration of undertook diplomatic missions for King
the Aryan culture of North India into the Adhiyaman Neduman Anchi. Avvaiyar, a
South as well as the assimilation of some poetess and friend of King Adhiyaman, ruler
of the patterns, ideas and institutions and of Tagadur, is supposed to have helped in
rejection or modification of certain other avoiding war between two kingdom states.
aspects. Tamil devotional culture was one of
187
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 15.indd 187 12-09-2018 19:54:30
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 15.indd 188 12-09-2018 19:54:32
www.tntextbooks.in
The definite part of thinkers is as follows: focuses on social justice. The political
ideologies in Tamil Nadu are a combination
Being the basis for the social changes and
of all three left, Right and centre ideologies.
subsequent events including the change in
the public minds; 15.2 Ancient Political Ideas
Having taken political decisions which had Thiruvalluvar
an impact on social turning points;
Serving as best brains behind the major
political decisions which has benefitted the
diversified communities;
To convert social ideas into common which
assisted people’s advancement belonging
to various communities
New political ideas are supported by
the activities of the political thinkers which
kindles interest and rational thinking of the
common people. The interaction of those
thinkers with the contemporary society makes
a new framework for the entire system.New
political decisions which intend to create great In Arathupal of Thirukkural, Valluvar
changes for the emerging generations were was a great enunciator of morals; In
undertaken.The day-to-day life of common Inbathupal, he has become a poet and
people may be engulfed with many changes by in Porutpal, he is known to be a political
the political decision of the thinkers.At world philosopher. The political philosophy of
level these kind of thinkers made changes
Thiruvalluvar is applicable across times
in the socio-political systems. Such great
even today.
thinkers made their extra-ordinary presence
throughout the past centuries in India in Seven Parts in Porutpal
general and Tamilnadu in particular.
Porutpal consists of 7 parts, further it
National political thinkers, Tamil political has 70 verses / couplets. They are Politics-25,
thinkers, Socialist thinkers, Thinkers of social Ministry-10, Defence-2, Wealth-1, Army-2,
justice are the different parts of modern
Friendship-17, and citizens-13 respectively.
categorization. In this part we can discuss
about different political thinkers of Tamilnadu “்றை குடி கூழ்அறமச்சு நட்்ரண் ஆறும்
who made out-standing contribution for the உறைொன அரெருள் ஏறு“ (குைள்: 381)
social changes.
“An army, people, wealth, a minister, friends, fort; six things
Political ideologies in Tamilnadu is rich Who owns them all, a lion lives amid the kings”
with ideas, beliefs, opinions and attitudes (Kural: 381)
towards society, polity and economy. This
is evident from the ancient political ideas Thus, in porutpal, at the first verse itself
of Thiruvalluvar, where as Bharathiyar is a valluvar differentiated the six categories
nationalist and Singaravelar is a communist. essential for a state. Thus, different parts
According to periyar, Dravidian ideology
189
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 15.indd 189 12-09-2018 19:54:32
www.tntextbooks.in
190
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 15.indd 190 12-09-2018 19:54:32
www.tntextbooks.in
to all in the kingdom. Moral and ethical indefinite agonies among the people. Those
life is quite essential for the ruling kings. tears are most powerful and may annihilate
Indicating “Respect” in a broad manner the entire kingdom.
relating it with nation, Valluvar gave priority
அல்லற்பட்டு ஆற்றாது அழுதகண் ணீரன்றே
for great honour which may be equated with
செல்வத்தைத் தேய்க்கும் படை (குறள் 555)
the courage. He stressed that king must be
loyal to the nation, it is the honour of nation. His people’s tears of sorrow past endurance, are not they
Sharp instrument to wear the marches wealth away.
Ideal State and Welfare of people
(Kural: 555)
In the monarchical rule, the integrity
Sad tears of suffering citizens may
and ideal governance for all periods were
dethrone and destroy the entire government,
advocated by Valluvar. People of all regions
says Thiruvalluvar. Tears were equated with
expect rain for their growth; likewise,
army, thus Valluvar’s visualization stands
citizens of a nation expect integrity and
unique among others.
ideal rule of the king.
Autocrats and Dictators like Hitler,
வான�ோக்கி வாழும் உலகெல்லாம் மன்னவன்
Mussolini and Czar were the negative
க�ோல்நோக்கி வாழுங் குடி. (குறள்: 542)
players for whom, Thirukkural served as a
All earth looks up to heaven where raindrops fall; funeral sound.
All subjects look to king that ruleth all.
Government’s Budget
(Kural: 542)
A king should be an able handed
In this couplet Valluvar indicates “Kol”
administrator in increasing the income of
as ideal rule which not only applies for
government. Further he should be an expert
monarchy but also for democracy.
in handling the budget.
குடிதழீஇக் க�ோல�ோச்சும் மாநில மன்னன்
In Iraimatchi, he said,
அடிதழீஇ நிற்கும் உலகு. (குறள் 544)
Whose heart embraces subjects all, lord over mighty land இயற்றலும் ஈட்டலும் காத்தலும் காத்த
Who rules, the world his feet embracing stands. வகுத்தலும் வல்ல தரசு. (குறள் 385)
(Kural: 544)
A king is be who treasure gains, stores up, defends,
This means that for a King, who protects And duly for his kingdom’s weal expends.
his citizens with love and affection, his feet (Kural: 385)
will be embraced by his subjects with love.
This is an everlasting phrase propounded by At first point, a king should search for
Valluvar related to good governance. the different sources of income. For this,
he calls it as “Iyatral”. Then, the second
Against Tyranny
point is that, all such resources should
In the chapter “Kodungonmai”, (Cruel be put together, which is called as “Ettal”.
Scepter) Valluvar explained it in negative Third, the resources thus collected must be
words. The suppressive and exploitative protected with all precautionary measures
rule of evil king may kindle unknown and which is called as “Kaathal”
191
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 15.indd 191 12-09-2018 19:54:32
www.tntextbooks.in
192
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 15.indd 192 12-09-2018 19:54:32
www.tntextbooks.in
193
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 15.indd 193 12-09-2018 19:54:32
www.tntextbooks.in
194
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 15.indd 194 12-09-2018 19:54:33
www.tntextbooks.in
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 15.indd 195 12-09-2018 19:54:33
www.tntextbooks.in
Bharathiyar – A Visionary
Bharathi as a poet, journalist, freedom
fighter and social reformer had made a The emergence of Swadeshi and Home
great impact not only on the Tamil society rule movement in India in the initial part of
but also on the entire human society. He 20th century aroused the thirst for freedom.
followed what all he preached and it is Reforms were made in Hindu religion in
here that his greatness is manifested. His accordance with the existing society. These
prophecy during the colonial period about movements played a key role in creating the
the independence of India came true after feeling of Indiannes and Nationalism in the
two and half decades after his demise. His political Scenario.
vision about a glorious India has been But these movements are religious in
taking a shape in the post-Independence nature. Moreover, those who participated
era. Bharathi did not live for himself but in these movements are from upper social
class. Freedom sought by these people are
political in nature neglecting the interests
and economic upliftment of farmers and
Bharathiyar passed away on 11th
labourers. This affected the majority
September 1921.It was a travesty that
Indians who are poor and belong to farmers
only 14 people attended his funeral,
community. Further, caste discrimination
fearing repercussion from the British
existed within Congress Party. Particularly,
and caste ostracisation.
in Tamilnadu there existed a clear difference
between brahmins and non-brahmins.
196
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 15.indd 196 12-09-2018 19:54:33
www.tntextbooks.in
197
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 15.indd 197 12-09-2018 19:54:33
www.tntextbooks.in
198
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 15.indd 198 12-09-2018 19:54:33
www.tntextbooks.in
199
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 15.indd 199 12-09-2018 19:54:33
www.tntextbooks.in
200
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 15.indd 200 12-09-2018 19:54:33
www.tntextbooks.in
201
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 15.indd 201 12-09-2018 19:54:33
www.tntextbooks.in
202
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 15.indd 202 12-09-2018 19:54:33
www.tntextbooks.in
not exist or cannot exist in the material world. Everyone has their own concept of “ideal
nation state”.
Welfare state : a system whereby the state undertakes to protect the health and well-being
of its citizens.
Evaluation
203
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 15.indd 203 12-09-2018 19:54:33
www.tntextbooks.in
204
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 15.indd 204 12-09-2018 19:54:33
www.tntextbooks.in
Reference
1. Padmaja, R, Purushothaman, V.P (2000). Sanga Kaala Mannargalin Kaala Nilai. Volume 1.
International institute of Tamil Studies: Chennai.
2. Pope .G.U , “Thirukkural: English translation and commentary”, Kazhagam 2017 edition.
3. Rajaram.M, “ I sing the glory of this Land: Translated verses of Bharathiyar”, Rupa Publica-
tions, Chennai, 2018.
4. Vasanthakumaran .P , ” The godfather of Indian labour : M. Singaravelar” , Chennai : Poorn-
ima Publishers, 2003.
5. Veeramani. K , “ Thoughts of Periyar”, DRAVIDAR KAZHAGAM PUBLICATIONS , chennai
,(2012),
6. Palanithurai. G, “ Caste Politics and Society in Tamilnadu”, South Asia Books (1 July 1994)
7. Puranannoru….. See ‘Purananooru, moolamum thelivum', Manimegalai prasuram, pg 82
Internet Sources:
http://15hsactn15.blogspot.com/2017/07/the-sangam-age-society.html
https://allmyearthlythoughts.wordpress.com/2017/06/02/avvaiyar-the-story-of-the-
many-women-who-carried-that-name/
http://vijeejournalist.com/2016/10/avvaiyar-the-diplomat/
205
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 15.indd 205 12-09-2018 19:54:34
www.tntextbooks.in
KEY TERMS
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 15_Aa_Glossary.indd 206 12-09-2018 19:54:05
www.tntextbooks.in
207
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 15_Aa_Glossary.indd 207 12-09-2018 19:54:05
www.tntextbooks.in
208
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 15_Aa_Glossary.indd 208 12-09-2018 19:54:05
www.tntextbooks.in
209
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 15_Aa_Glossary.indd 209 12-09-2018 19:54:06
www.tntextbooks.in
210
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 15_Aa_Glossary.indd 210 12-09-2018 19:54:06
www.tntextbooks.in
Political Science – XI
List of Authors and Reviewers
A. Appanasamy, Writer
P. K. Saravanan, Writer
Co-ordination
Ramesh Munisamy
11th Std Political Science Eng Medium Vol-2_Chapter 15_Acknowledgement.indd 232 12-09-2018 19:57:40