You are on page 1of 8

Mašinstvo 1(14), 3 – 10, (2017) A.

Žiga at al: STRESS STATE IN ROTARY KILN SUPPORT ROLLERS

NAPONSKO STANJE U NOSEĆIM VALJCIMA ROTACIONE PEĆI

STRESS STATE IN ROTARY KILN SUPPORT ROLLERS


Alma Žiga Originalni naučni rad
Josip Kačmarčik
REZIME
Mašinski fakultet, U radu je sprovedena analiza napona koji se javljaju u nosećim valjcima
rotacione peći. Naponi u nosećem valjku izazvani su temperaturnim
Univerzitet u Zenici
gradijentom, steznim spojem s osovinom i kontaktom s nosećim prstenom.
Analiza napona je urađena analitički i numerički, te su dobiveni rezultati
Ključne riječi: uspoređeni.
noseći valjak, obodni
napon
Original scientific papar
Keywords:
kiln roller, circumference SUMMARY
stress In the paper stress analysis of rotary kiln support rollers is conducted.
Stress state in the support rollers is caused by temperature gradient, shrink-
Paper received: fit connection between shaft and roller and by the contact with kiln ring.
23.10.2016. The stress analysis is done analytically and numerically, and the results
Paper accepted: obtained are compared.
16.01.2017.

1. UVOD 1. INTRODUCTION
Noseći prstenovi i valjci su elementi na koje se Riding rings and rollers are supporting elements
oslanja rotaciona peć i uslijed toga su izloženi of rotary kilns and therefore are subjected to
različitim dinamičkim opterećenjima. various dynamic stresses. These stresses are
Opterećenja potiču od same težine peći, zasipa, caused by loads from the kiln weight and row-
rotacije peći i temperaturnih gradijenata. Da bi mix feed, rotation of the kiln and by temperature
se predvidjelo ponašanje valjaka i procjenio gradients. In order to predict the rollers
njihov radni vijek neophodno je izračunati ove behaviour and estimate their service life it is
napone. essential to calculate these stresses.
Postoji ograničen broj studija u literaturi koji There is a limited number of studies in the
ispituju stanje napona u nosećim prstenovima i literature that investigate stress state of the rotary
valjcima. Takvu analizu su proveli Xiao i oslali kiln rings and rollers in more details. Such
[1], koji su istraživali raspodjelu kontaknog analysis was carried out by Xiao et al. [1], who
pritiska i optimizaciju ugla koga valjci formiraju investigated contact pressure distribution and
s centrom peći, ali nisu uzeli u obzir uticaj support angle optimisation of kiln rings and
temperature. Dodatno, dosta studija istražuje rollers; but they did not include temperature
napone u rotacionoj peći, napone u prstenovima, effects. In addition, there are numerous studies
prenos toplote u peći, itd. [2-7], ali prema znanju investigating the rotary kiln’s stresses, stresses in
autora, ne postoje objavljena studije s detaljnom rings, heat transfer in kilns, etc [2-7], but to
teoretskom analizom i numeričkom simulacijom authors’ knowledge, there are no published
napona u nosećim valjcima. studies with the detailed theoretical investigation
Ovaj rad se fokusira na detaljnoj analizi napona and numerical simulations of the stresses in kiln
u nosećem valjku koji su izazvani kontaktom sa rollers.
prstenom, termičkim gradijentom i steznim This paper focuses on detailed analytical
spojem između osovine i valjka. Dodatno, analysis of the kiln roller stresses caused by
analiza napona u valjku bit će provedena contact with the ring, temperature gradients and
pomoću numeričkih simulacija. shrink-fit between shaft and roller. Additionally,
stress analysis in the roller will be conducted by
numerical simulations.

3
Mašinstvo 1(14), 3 – 10, (2017) A. Žiga at al: STRESS STATE IN ROTARY KILN SUPPORT ROLLERS

Istraživanje je sprovedeno za slučaj rotacione The investigation is conducted for the case of the
peći Fabrike cementa u Kaknju, prikazane na rotary kiln in the Cement plant in Kakanj, shown
slici 1. To je čelična cijev dužine 70 m, in Fig.1. It is a 70 m long steel tube with inner
unutrašnjeg prečnika 4,4 m, nagiba 3,5° i brzine diameter of 4,4 m, slope of 3.5° and rotation
rotacije 2 obr/min. Masa peći, uključujući speed of 2 rpm. The mass of the kiln, including
oblogu i zasip iznosi oko 1000 t. Oslanja se na refractory line and feed, is around 1000 t. It is
tri oslonca koje čine prsten i valjci, raspoređeni supported by three ring-roller stations, spaced
duž peći. Osnovne dimenzije i podaci o along the length of the kiln. The main
opterećenju peći, neophodni za dalju analizu, dimensions and data for the kiln loading,
dati su u tabeli 1 i na slici 2. necessary for subsequent analysis, are given in
Tab. 1 and in Fig 2.

Slika 1. Rotaciona peć Fabrike cementa u Kaknju


Figure 1 Rotary kiln in the cement plant in Kakanj

Slika 2. Opterećenje rotacione peći


Figure 2 Rotary kiln loading

Tabela 1. Dimenzije rotacione peći


Table 1 Rotary kiln dimensions
Inner radius, Outer radius, Width, Roller Width, Inner radius, Outer radius,
Ring R1 R2 B Br Ru Rv
Ring
2318 2700 750
1
980 310 800
Ring
2323 2700 880
2, 3

2. REAKCIJE OSLONACA ROTACIONE 2. ROTARY KILN SUPORT REACTIONS


PEĆI In order to calculate support reactions, the kiln is
Kako bi se izračunale reakcije oslonaca, peć je divided into 17 segments, due to different shell
podijeljena na 17 segmenata usljed različite rigidity, supports and drive-gear positions, and
krutosti omotača, položaja oslonaca i pogonskog distributed loads, as shown in Fig.3.
zupčanika, te kontinuiranih opterećenja, kako je
prikazano na slici 3.

4
Mašinstvo 1(14), 3 – 10, (2017) A. Žiga at al: STRESS STATE IN ROTARY KILN SUPPORT ROLLERS

Peć je modelirana u programu MDSolids-u 3.2 The kiln is modelled in MDSolids3.2 software
sa sljedećim pretpostavkama: with following assumptions:
• zasip je ravnomjerno raspoređen duž peći sa • raw-mix is evenly distributed along the kiln
specifičnom težinom od 18,58 kN/m, length with specific weight of 18.58 kN/m,
• zasip je simetrično raspoređen oko vertikalne • raw-mix is symmetrically distributed around
ose peći (slika 4), the vertical axis of kiln (Fig. 4),
• temperatura ne utiče na krutost omotača. • temperature does not affect shell rigidity.
Specifična težina opeke na ulaznoj strani (dužine The specific weight of line bricks on the inlet
18,2 m), tj. na desnoj strani na slici 3. je 44 side (18.2 m length), ie. right-hand side in Fig. 3
kN/m. Ostali dio peći ima opeke sa specifičnom is 44 kN/m. The remaining part of the kiln has
težinom od 74 kN/m. Kontinuirano opterećenje line bricks with specific weight of 74 kN/m. The
na slici 3. odgovara dijagramu iz slike 2. Težina distributed loads in Fig.3 correspond to the graph
pogonskog zupčanika je FG=353 kN. Težine in Fig. 2. The weight of the gear ring is FG= 353
prstenova su: FR1=353 kN, FR2=406 kN, FR3=410 kN. The weights of the rings are: FR1=353 kN,
kN. FR2=406 kN, FR3=410 kN.
Kao rezultat analize, dobivene su reakcije u As a result of the analysis, roller support
osloncima (čvorovi 4, 9 i 15): F4=2183,7 kN, reactions are obtained (nodes 4, 9 and 15):
F9=4013,86 kN and F15=3154 kN. Koristeći F4=2183.7 kN, F9=4013.86 kN and
najveću vrijednost, na srednjem osloncu, može F15=3154 kN. Using the highest value, in the
se dobiti maksimalno opterećenje Q koje djeluje middle roller station, the maximum load, Q,
na valjke (slika 4) kao: acting on the rollers (Fig.4) can be obtained as:
F9 F9
Q= (1) Q= (1)
2cos30° 2cos30°

Slika 3. Model peći


Figure 3 Kiln model

Slika 4. Reakcije na valjcima


Figure 4 Roller reactions

3. NAPONI U NOSEĆIM VALJCIMA 3. STRESSES IN KILN ROLLERS


Kod nosećeg valjka, pritisna sila po jedinici Pressure force per unit length of support roller
dužine iznosi P=2635,88 N/mm i dobiva se iz has a value P=2635.88 N/mm and it is given by:
izraza: Q
P= (2)
Q B
P= (2)
B where Q is the force acting on the roller (1), and
gdje je Q sila opterećenja valjka (1), a B=880 mm is the ring width.
B=880 mm je širina prstena.

5
Mašinstvo 1(14), 3 – 10, (2017) A. Žiga at al: STRESS STATE IN ROTARY KILN SUPPORT ROLLERS

Širina kontakte 2a=8,48 mm je proračunata The width of contact 2a=8.48 mm is calculated


pomoću izraza [8]: using [8]:
4PR 4PR
a= , (3) a= , (3)
π E* π E*
gdje je R =617,1 mm ekvivalentni radijus, a where R =617.1 mm is the equivalent radius and
E* = 15,385 GPa je ekvivalentni modul E* = 15.385 GPa is the equivalent modulus of
elastičnosti. elasticity.
Ekvivalentni radijus se računa prema [8]: The equivalent radius is given by [8]:
−1 −1
⎛ 1 1 ⎞ ⎛ 1 1 ⎞
R=⎜ + ⎟ , (4) R=⎜ + ⎟ , (4)
⎝ R2 Rv ⎠ ⎝ R2 Rv ⎠
gdje je Rv = 800 mm radijus valjka, a R2 =2700 where Rv =800 mm is the radius of roller, and
mm radijus prstena. R2 =2700 mm is the radius of ring,
Ekvivalentni modul elastičnosti je definiran s The equivalent modulus of elasticity is defined
jednačinom [8]: with the equation [8]:
1 1 −ν 2 1 −ν 2 1 1 −ν 2 1 −ν 2
= + , (5) = + , (5)
E* E1 E2 E* E1 E2
gdje su ν1=ν2=0,3 Poissonovi koeficijenti, a where ν1=ν2=0.3 are Poisson’ ratios, and
E1=E2=210 GPa moduli elastičnosti materijala E1=E2=210 GPa are the modules of elasticity of
valjka i prstena. Oznake 1 i 2 odnose se na valjak roller and ring materials. The subscripts 1 and 2
i prsten, slijedom. relate to the roller and the ring, respectively.
Maksimalna vrijednost pritiska je p0= 396 MPa Maximum contact pressure is p0= 396 MPa and
i locirana je na sredini kontaktne zone, a it is located in the middle of contact area, and it
dobivena je na osnovu izraza [8]: was calculated using [8]:
2P 2P
p0 = (6) p0 = (6)
πa πa
Pored pritisnog kontaktnog napona, u valjku se In addition to the contact pressure, there are
javljaju termički naponi usljed polja temperature thermal stresses in roller caused by temperature
i naponi usljed steznog spoja osovina-valjak. gradient and stresses caused by shrink-fit
Raspodjela termičkog napona u valjku dobivena between shaft and roller.
je na osnovu izraza (7), [9] i prikazana je na slici Thermal stress distribution in roller is obtained
5. U proračunu su korištene vrijednosti using the equation (7), [9] and is shown in Fig.
temperature unutrašnje i vanjske strane valjka: 5. In the calculation values for the inside and
tu=40 ºC, tv =100 ºC, te unutrašnjeg i vanjskog outside temperatures of the roller: tu=40 ºC, tv
radijusa valjka: Ru=310 mm i Rv=800 mm. =100 ºC, and the inside and outside radius of
roller: Ru=310 mm and Rv=800 mm, are used.

E ⎡1 r r 2 + Ru 2 Rv ⎤
σt =
1 −ν
⎢ 2
⎢⎣ r

Ru
α t ⋅ rdr +
r 2 ( Rv 2 − Ru 2 ) ∫Ru
α t ⋅ rdr − α t ⎥
⎥⎦
(7)
ΔT R
t= ln v + tv
R r
ln v
Ru

6
Mašinstvo 1(14), 3 – 10, (2017) A. Žiga at al: STRESS STATE IN ROTARY KILN SUPPORT ROLLERS

Slika 6. Raspodjela napona usljed preklopa


Slika 5. Raspodjela termičkog napona kroz
kroz debljinu valjka
debljinu valjka
Figure 6 Stress distribution caused by shrink-fit
Figure 5 Thermal stress distribution through
through roller thickness
roller thickness
Due to temperature, produced inside the kiln,
Usljed temperature, proizvedene unutar peći,
elongation of shaft and roller will occur. The
doći će do širenja osovine i valjka. Vrijednosti
values of elongation of the outer radius (0.1936
pomjeranja vanjskog vlakna osovine (0,1936
mm) and the inner radius of roller (0.381) can be
mm) i unutrašnjeg vlakna valjka (0,381) usljed
obtained by equation for elongation u(r), (8), [9].
širenja mogu se dobiti na osnovu izraza za
The difference between the elongations gives a
pomjeranje u(r) (8), [9]. Razlika pomjeranja daje
gap between these two elements which has a
zazor između ova dva elementa u vrijednosti od
value of 0.1874 mm.
0,1874 mm.
1 1 +ν
r
1
u (r ) = ∫
r 1 − ν Ru
α ⋅ t (r ) ⋅ rdr + C1 (r ) ⋅ r + C2 (r ) ⋅
r
R
1 +ν Ru 2 v

1 −ν Rv 2 − Ru 2 R∫u
C2 ( r ) = α ⋅ t (r ) ⋅ rdr (8)

R
1 +ν 1 v

1 −ν Rv 2 − Ru 2 R∫u
C1 (r ) = (1 − 2ν ) α ⋅ t (r ) ⋅ rdr

Prvobitan preklop od 0,26 mm (jednak je The original interference of 0.26 mm (equal to


maksimalnoj vrijednosti preklopa), usljed maximal interference value), due to temperature,
djelovanja temperature, smanjit će se i iznositi will be lowered and has a new value of
δp=0,0726 mm. Vrijednosti obodnih napona δp=0.0726 mm. Circumference stresses due to
usljed steznog spoja osovina-valjaka izračunate shrink-fit between shaft and roller are calculated
su na osnovu izraza (9), [9] i date su na slici 6. by expression (9), [9] and shown on Fig. 6.
R 2 + Ru 2 R 2 + Ru 2
σ θ ( Ru ) = p12 v 2 σ θ ( Ru ) = p12 v 2
Rv − Ru 2 Rv − Ru 2
(9) (9)
2 Rv 2 2 Rv 2
σ θ ( Rv ) = p12 2 σ θ ( Rv ) = p12 2
Rv − Ru 2 Rv − Ru 2
pri čemu je pritisak između osovine i valjka: wherein, the pressure between shaft and roller is:
Eδ p Rv 2 − Ru 2 Eδ p Rv 2 − Ru 2
p12 = (10) p12 = (10)
Ru 2 Rv 2 Ru 2 Rv 2
Zbirni obodni napon u vanjskom vlaknu valjka
prikazan je na slici 7. Maksimalni pritisni napon
u sredini zone kontakta superponira se s

7
Mašinstvo 1(14), 3 – 10, (2017) A. Žiga at al: STRESS STATE IN ROTARY KILN SUPPORT ROLLERS

termičkim naponom i naponom usljed preklopa pressure stress, in the middle of contact area, is
osovina-valjak i iznosi -463,8 MPa. superimposed with thermal and shrink-fit
stresses and it has a value of -463.8 MPa.
The total circumferential stress on the outside
radius of roller is shown in Figure 7. Maximal
30
-20 ϕ,°
Circumference stress, MPa 0 30 60 90 120 150 180
-70
Obodni napon, MPa

-67,8
-120
-170
-220
-270
-320
-370
-420
-463,8
-470
Slika 7. Obodni napon u vanjskom vlaknu valjka
Figure 7 Circumference stress on the outside raduis of roller

5. NUMERIČKA ANALIZA 5. NUMERICAL ANALYSIS


Numerička analiza je provedena koristeći Numerical analysis is carried out using
program ABAQUS [10]. U svim simulacijama, ABAQUS software [10]. In all simulations the
prsten i valjak modelirani su u ravni, sa samo ring and rollers are modelled in 2D, with only a
polovinom domena zbog simetrije, te su half of the domain modeled due to symmetry and
primjenjeni uslovi za ravno stanje deformacija. a plain strain condition is applied. The
Simulacije su statičke, tj. inercijalni efekti se simulations are static, i.e. inertia effects are
zanemareni zbog spore rotacije peći. Osobine neglected due to slow rotation of the kiln.
materijala za oba dijela su osobine čelika. Material properties for both parts are those of
Sistem je izložen djelovanju temperaturnog steel.
gradijenta i opterećen kao na slici 4. Osobine Ring-roller system is exposed to temperature
analize su: coupled temperature-displacement gradient and loaded as in figure 4. Analysis
step, steady-state response. Sistem prsten-valjak features are: coupled temperature-displacement
je izmrežen, s odgovarajućim osobinama step, steady-state response. Ring-roller system is
kontakta između dijelova. Za mrežu su korišteni meshed, with appropriate contact properties
pravougaoni elementi s osam nodova, tipa between parts. For the mesh, quadrilateral
CPE8T. Ukupan broj elemenata sistema prsten- elements with eight nodes, CPE8T type, are
valjak je 9 444 (slika 8). used. The total number of elements of the ring-
Mreža je u području kontakta usitnjena kako bi roller system is 9 444 (Fig. 8).
se postigla bolja tačnost rezultata. Osobine The mesh in contact area is refined in order to
kontakta su: penalty friction formulation achive better result accuracy. The contact
(koeficijent trenja je 0.1) i surface-to-surface properties are: penalty friction formulation
interaction with finite sliding formulation. (coefficient of friction is 0.1) and surface-to-
Nanesene su vrijednosti temperatura unutrašnje i surface interaction with finite sliding
vanjske strane valjka: tu=40 ºC, tv =100 ºC. Da bi formulation.
nastao preklop od 0,26 mm, osovini je povećan Temperature values on inside and outside radius
radijus za vrijednost preklopa. U prvom koraku of roller are applied: tu=40 ºC, tv =100 ºC. In
(General, Coupled temp-displacement), order to get interference of 0.26 mm, the radius
istovremeno s djelovanjem temperature, preklop of shaft is increased by this value. In the first step
se rješava uklanjanjem čvorova u preklopu. (General, Coupled temp-displacement),
simultaneously with action of temperature, the
interference is resolved by node removal from
the interference.

8
Mašinstvo 1(14), 3 – 10, (2017) A. Žiga at al: STRESS STATE IN ROTARY KILN SUPPORT ROLLERS

Slika 9. Obodni napon u prstenu i valjku –


Slika 8. Granični uslovi i opterećenje sistema lijevo, detalj kontakta –desno
prsten-valjak Figure 9 Circumference stress in the roller and
Figure 8 Boundary conditions and the load on the ring, detail of contact-right
the ring-roller system

30
ϕ,°
-20
0 30 60 90 120 150 180
Obodni napon u valjku, MPa

-70
Circumference stress, MPa

-67,8 -66,7
-120
-170 Teorija
-220 Abaqus
-270
-320
-370
-420 -443,5
-470 -463,8
Slika 10. Obodni napon u vanjskom vlaknu valjka-numerički i analitički
Figure 10 Circumference stress on outside radius of the roller- numerical and analitical

Obodni napon sistema prsten-valjak prikazan je The circumference stress of the ring-roller
na slici 9, s istaknutim detaljem napona u system is shown in Fig. 9, with the highlighted
područiju kontakta. Obodni napon na vanjskoj detail of stress in the contact. The circumference
površini valjka dat je na slici 10. U vanjskim stress on the outside radius of roller is shown in
vlaknima valjka djeluje skoro konstantan napon the Fig. 10. On the outside radius of roller, there
pritiska od -66,7 MPa, sa naglim skokom do is almost constant pressure in the amount of
vrijednosti od -443,5 MPa u području kontakta. -66.7 MPa with the peak value of -443.5 MPa in
Ukupno slaganje numeričkog i analitičkog the middle of contact area. Total agreement
rješenja je dobro. between analytical and numerical solutions is
good.

9
Mašinstvo 1(14), 3 – 10, (2017) A. Žiga at al: STRESS STATE IN ROTARY KILN SUPPORT ROLLERS

5. ZAKLJUČAK 5. CONCLUSION
Noseći valjak preuzima dio opterećenja The support roller takes one part of the rotary
rotacione peći preko kontakta dvije zakrivljene kiln loads over the contact of two curved
površine. Kontakt se ostvaruje po pravougaonoj surfaces. The contact is established on the
površini vrlo male širine, manje od 1 cm. Dužina rectangular area of a very small width, less than
površine kontakta, u idealnom slučaju, jednaka 1 cm. A length of contact area is, ideally, equal
je širini prstena, ali može biti smanjena zbog to a width of the ring, but can be lowered due to
trošenja i formiranja valovitosti površine. Osim wear and formation of surface waviness. In
ovog kontaknog napona pažnju treba obratiti i na addition to this contact stress, attention should be
napone koji su izazvani nejednakim paid to the stresses caused by unequal roller
zagrijavanjem valjka od strane peći. To stvara warming-up by the kiln. This creates significant,
značajne, obodne, termičke napone. circumference, thermal stresses. Warming up the
Zagrijavanje valjka utiče i na njegovo širenje. roller also causes its elongation. There is an
Dolazi do širenja unutrašnjeg vlakna valjka i elongation of the inside radius of roller and the
vanjskog vlakna osovine. Ova širenja utiču na outside radius of shaft. These elongations affects
smanjenje vrijednosti projektovanog preklopa the decrease in value of projected interference of
steznog spoja osovina-valjak. Ovo može biti shaft-roller shrink fit. It can be so significant that
toliko izraženo da valjak sklizne s osovine, što je the roller slides off the shaft, which is often
često zabilježeno u praksi. Analitička i observed in practice. The analytical and
numerička analiza daju mogućnost da se ovi numerical analysis provide the option to
naponi u fazi projektovanja predvide i uzmu u anticipate and take into account these stresses in
obzir prilikom izbora tolerancije steznog spoja. a stage of design when tolerance of the shrink-fit
is selected.
6. REFERENCES

[1] Xiao Y.; Pan D.; Lei X. Contact pressure [7] Yoges Sonavane, Eckehard Specht,
distribution and support angle optimization Numerical analysis of the heat transfer in the
of kiln tyre. //J. Cent. South Univ. Technol. wall of rotary kiln using finite element
13, 3, 6(2006), pp 246-250. method ANSYS, Seventh International
[2] A. Žiga, A. Karač, D. Vukojević: Analytical Conference on CFD in the Minerals and
and numerical stress analysis of the rotary Process Industries CISRO, Melbourne,
kiln ring, Tehnički vjesnik / Technical Australia,2009.
Gazette 20.6 (2013) [8] Johnson K.L. Contact Mechanics,
[3] Bowen A. E.; Saxer B. Causes and effect of Cambridge University Press, Cambridge,
kiln tyre problems. // IEEE transaction on 1985.
industry applications. IA-21,2, 3(1985), pp [9] Timoshenko S. Strength of Materials, part II,
344-355. Advanced Theory and Problems, D. Van
[4] K. Pazand,; M. Shariat Panahi,; M. Nostrand Company, New York, 1942.
Pourabdoli, Simulating the mechanical [10] ABAQUS 6.9-1, commercial FEA
behaviour of a rotary cement kiln using Software, product of Dassault Systèmes
artificial neural networks. //Materials and Simulia Corp., Providence, RI, USA.
Design 30 (2009), pp 3468-3473.
[5] J.J. del Coz Diaz,; F. Rodriguez Mazon,; P.J. Corresponding author:
Garcia Nieto,; F. J. Suarez Dominguez
Design and finite element analysis of a wet Alma Žiga
cycle cement rotary kiln. //Finite Elements in Faculty of Mechanical Engineering
Analysis and Design 39 (2002), pp 17-42. University of Zenica
[6] Chen Z.; Zeng F.; Fan T.; Xiao J.; Shen J. Fakultetska 1
Numerical analysis of static stress on the 72 000 Zenica
body of 10000t/d rotary kiln’s main body, Bosnia and Herzegovina
International Conference on Experimental E-mail: aziga@mf.unze.ba
Mechanics 2008, edited by Xiaoyuan H.,
Humin X., Yilan K.

10

You might also like