EXHIBITS DOCUMENT

“B” Certificate of Publication in the Official Gazette;

“C” Certificate of Posting by the Sheriff, dated June 5, 1979, found on Page 69 of Court record;
“HH” A copy of Land Tax Decl. No. 03618, in the name of Leoncio Laspona;
A sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification from the City Assessor’s Office
“HH-1”
of Toledo City (the “Assessor’s Office”), Official Receipt Number and the amount paid;
A copy of Deed of Absolute Sale executed by Andica Vda. De Laspona, widow of the late Leoncio Laspona, in
“J”
favor of Atlas Consolidated Mining and Development Corporation;
A sub-marking found on page two (2) of same, showing the certification from the Assessor’s Office, Official
“J-1”
Receipt Number and the amount paid;
A copy of Confirmation of Deed of Sale executed by the three (3) children of the late Leoncio Laspona,
“L”
namely; Balbina, Veronica and Mercedes, all surnamed Laspona;
A sub-marking found on the reverse of page two (2) of same, showing registration of the document with
“L-1”
the Register of Deeds of Toledo
“K” A copy of Affidavit executed by Andeca Vda. De Laspona, declaring the correct area of the land;
A sub-marking found on page two (2) of same, showing the certification from the Assessor’s Office, Official
“K-1”
Receipt Number and the amount paid;
A copy of Land Tax Declaration No. 10127 in the name of Atlas Consolidated Mining and Development
“II”
Corporation for the year 1957;
A sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification from the Assessor’s Office,
“II-1”
Official Receipt Number and the amount paid;
“NN” A copy of Land Tax Declaration No. 09809 in the name of Teofilo Dela Cerna for the year 1945;
A sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification from the Assessor’s Office,
“NN-1”
Official Receipt Number and the amount paid;
“OO” A copy of Land Tax Declaration No. 09810 in the name of Teofilo Dela Cerna for the year 1954;
A sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification from the Assessor’s Office,
“OO-1”
Official Receipt Number and amount paid;
A copy of Deed of Absolute Sale executed by Teofilo Dela Cerna in favor of Atlas Consolidated Mining and
“M”
Development Corporation;
A copy of Land Tax Declaration No. 16332 in the name of Atlas Consolidated Mining and Development
“PP”
Corporation for the year 1963;
A sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification from the Assessor’s Office,
“PP-1”
Official Receipt Number and amount paid;
A copy of Land Tax Declaration No. 40351 in the name of Atlas Consolidated Mining and Development
“QQ”
Corporation for the year 1973;
A sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification from the Assessor Office,
“QQ-1”
Official Receipt Number and the amount paid;
A copy of Land Tax Declaration No. 19743 in the name of Atlas Consolidated Mining and Development
“RR”
Corporation for the year 1974;
Sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification from the Assessor’s Office,
“RR-1”
official receipt number and amount paid;
“SS” A copy of land Tax Declaration No. 00068 in the name of Ignacio Abella for the year 1950;
A Sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification from the Assessor’s Office,
“SS-1”
Official receipt of number & amount paid;
A copy of Deed of Absolute Sale executed by Spouses Ignacio Abella & Arcadia Tabelin in favor of Atlas
“N”
Consolidated Mining & Development Corporation.
A sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification from the Assessor’s Office,
“N-1”
Official Receipt Number & amount paid;
“TT” A copy of land Tax Declaration No. 10129 in the name of ACMDC for the year 1957;
A sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification from the Assessor’s Office,
“TT-1”
official receipt number & amount paid;
“WW” A copy of Land Tax Declaration No. 00084, in the name of Tomas Abella for the year 1950;
A sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification from the Assessor’s Office,
“WW-1”
Official Receipt and amount paid;
A copy of Deed of Absolute Sale executed by Tomas Abella in favor of Atlas Consolidated Mining and
“O”
Development Corporation;
A sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification from the Assessor’s Office,
“O-1”
Official Receipt and amount paid thereof;
A copy of Land Tax Declaration No. 10134 in the name of Atlas Consolidated Mining and Development
“XX”
Corporation for the year 1957;
A sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification from the Assessor’s Office,
“XX-1”
Official Receipt and amount paid thereof;
“UU” A copy of Land Tax Declaration No. 00076, in the name of Miguel Abella for the year 1945;
A sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification from the Assessor’s Office,
“UU-1”
Official Receipt and amount paid thereof;
“Q” A copy of Extra-Judicial Settlement of Estate by Heirs of Miguel Abella;
A sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification from the Assessor’s Office,
“Q-1”
Official Receipt and amount paid;
A copy of Deed of Absolute Sale executed by Victor Abella in favor of Atlas Consolidated Mining and
“P”
Development Corporation dated March 14, 1956;
A copy of Land Tax Declaration No. 10100 in the name of Atlas Consolidated Mining and Development
“YY”
Corporation for the year 1957;
A sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification of the Assessor’s Office, Official
“YY-1”
Receipt and amount paid thereof;
“ZZ” A copy of Land Tax Declaration No. 09826 in the name of Apolonio Villacencio for the year 1957;
A sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification from the Assessor’s Office,
“ZZ-1”
Official Receipt Number and amount paid thereof;
A copy of Deed of Absolute Sale executed by Apolonio Villacencio in favor of Atlas Consolidated Mining and
“R”
Development Corporation, dated March 12, 1956;
A sub-marking found at the bottom of same, showing the certification from the Assessor’s Office, Official
“R-1”
Receipt Number and amount paid thereof;
A copy of land Tax Declaration No. 10104 in the name of Atlas Consolidated Mining and Development
“AAA”
Corporation for the year 1957;
A sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification from the Assessor’s Office,
“AAA-1”
Official Receipt Number and amount paid thereof;
“BBB” A copy of land Tax Declaration No. 09862 in the name of Andres Alferez for the year 1945;
A sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification from the Assessor’s Office,
“BBB-1”
Official Receipt Number and amount paid thereto;
“CCC” A copy of land Tax Declaration No. 09863, in the name of Andres Alferez for the year 1954;
A sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification from the Assessor’s Office,
“CCC-1”
Official Receipt Number and the amount paid thereof;
A copy of Deed of Absolute Sale executed by Spouses Andres Alferez and Mercedes Laspona in favor of
“S”
Atlas Consolidated Mining and Development Corporation;
A sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification from the Assessor’s Office,
“S-1”
Official Receipt Number and the amount paid thereof;
A copy of land Tax Declaration No. 10105, in the name of Atlas Consolidated Mining and Development
“DDD”
Corporation for the year 1957;
 A sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification from the Assessor’s Office,
“EEE-1”
Official Receipt Number and the amount paid thereof;
A copy of Deed of Absolute Sale executed by Spouses Montano and Maxima Gimenez in favor of Atlas
“T”
Consolidated Mining and Development Corporation;
A sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification from the Assessor’s Office,
“T-1”
Official Receipt Number and amount paid thereto;
A copy of land Tax Declaration No. 10101, in the name of Atlas Consolidated Mining and Development
“FFF”
Corporation for the year 1957;
A sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification from the Assessor’s Office,
“FFF-1”
Official Receipt Number and the amount paid thereof;
A copy of land Tax Declaration No. 07109 in the name of Eulalio Villacencio and declared the land for
“GGG”
taxation purposes, a Filipino citizen and qualified to own land under Philippine laws, to apply land title;
A sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification from the Assessor’s Office,
“GGG-1”
Official Receipt Number and amount paid thereof;
A copy of Deed of Absolute Sale executed by Eulalio Villacencio in favor of Atlas Consolidated Mining and
“U”
Development Corporation;
A sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification from the Assessor’s Office,
“U-1”
Official Receipt Number and amount paid thereof;
A copy of land Tax Declaration No. 10139 in the name of Atlas Consolidated Mining and Development
“HHH”
Corporation for the year 1957;
A sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification of the Assessor’s Office, Official
“HHH-1”
Receipt Number and amount paid thereof;
A copy of land Tax Declaration No. 40306 in the name of Atlas Consolidated Mining and Development
“III”
corporation for the year 1973;
A sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification from the Assessor’s Office,
III-1”
Official Receipt Number and amount paid thereto;
A copy of land Tax Declaration No. 41665 in the name of Atlas Consolidated Mining and Development
“JJJ”
Corporation for the year 1973;
A sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification from the Assessor’s Office,
“JJJ-1”
Official Receipt Number and amount paid thereto;
A copy of land Tax Declaration No. 19620, in the name of Atlas Consolidated Mining and Development
“KKK”
Corporation;
A sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification from the Assessor’s Office,
“KKK-1”
Official Receipt Number and amount paid thereof;
“LLL” A copy of land Tax Declaration No. 00072 in the name of Lorenzo Abella for the year 1950;
A sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification from the Assessor’s Office,
“LLL-1”
Official Receipt Number and amount paid thereto;
A copy of Deed of Absolute Sale executed by Tranquilina Vda. De Abella in favor of Atlas Consolidated
“W”
Mining and Development Corporation;
A copy of land Tax Declaration No. 16935, in the name of Atlas Consolidated Mining and Development
“MMM”
Corporation;
A sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification from the Assessor’s Office,
“MMM-1”
Official Receipt Number and amount paid thereto;
A copy of land Tax Declaration No. 40229 in the name of Atlas Consolidated Mining and Development
Corporation for the year 1973. This Tax Declaration fuses all previous Tax Declaration Nos. 10127, 19743,
“JJ”
10129, 10134, 10100, 10104, 10105, 10101,10139 and 16935 which are all in the name of Atlas
Consolidated Mining and Development Corporation;
“JJ-1” To prove its authenticity and same is on file with the Assessor’s Office;
A copy of land Tax Declaration No. 41598, in the name of Atlas Consolidated Mining and Development
“VV”
Corporation for the year 1973;
A sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification from the Assessor’s Office,
“VV-1”
Official Receipt Number and amount paid thereof;
A copy of land Tax Declaration No. 41599, in the name of Atlas Consolidated Mining and Development
“KK”
Corporation for the year 1973;
A sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification from the Assessor’s Office,
“KK-1”
Official Receipt Number and amount paid;
A copy of land Tax Declaration No. 19560, in the name of Atlas Consolidated Mining and Development
“LL”
Corporation for the year 1974;
“MM” A copy of Land Tax Declaration No. 28867, in the name of Constantino B. De Jesus for the year 1978;
A sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification from the Assessor’s Office,
“MM-1”
Official Receipt Number and the amount paid thereto;
A copy of Land Tax Declaration No. , in the name of Atlas Consolidated Mining and Development
“NNNN”
Corporation, for the year 1973;
A copy of AFFIDAVIT, executed by Atlas Consolidated Mining and Development Corporation Real Estate
“GG”
Administrator;
A sub-marking found on page two (2) of same, showing the signature of Real Estate Administrator of Atlas
“GG-1”
Consolidated Mining and Development Corporation;
A copy of Land Tax Declaration No. 24939, in the name of Constantino B. de Jesus, the Applicant in this
“KKKK”
instant case;
A sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing the certification from the Assessor’s Office,
“TTT-1”
Official Receipt Number and the amount paid thereto;
A copy of Land Tax Declaration No. 29885, in the name of Constantino B. de Jesus, revising previous Tax
“UUU”
Declaration No. 29884;
A sub-marking found on the reverse side of same, showing certification from the Assessor’s Office, Official
“UUU-1”
Receipt Number and the amount paid thereto;
“WWW” A copy of Land Tax Declaration No. 09485, in the name of Dolores R. de Jesus for the year 1956;
A copy of Land Tax Declaration No. 31852, in the name of Atlas Consolidated Mining and Development
“YYY”
Corporation for the year 1971, revising Tax Declaration No. 09690;
“CCCC” A copy of Land Tax Declaration No. 27068, in the name of Constantino B. de Jesus for the year 1977;
Tax Clearance Certificate issued by City Treasurer of Toledo bearing Tax Declaration No. 39726, duly signed
“RRRR”
by Manuel E. Gooyit, the issuing authority;
A sub-marking found on the same exhibit, showing Official Receipt of payment and documentary stamps
“RRRR-1”
affixed to same;
Tax Clearance Certificate issued by Office of City Treasurer of Toledo bearing Tax Declaration Nos. 39724,
“SSSS”
39725 and 39729, duly signed by Manuel E. Gooyit, the issuing authority;
A sub-marking found on the same, showing the Official Receipt of payment and documentary stamps
“SSSS-1”
affixed to same;
Tax Clearance Certificate issued by Office of City Treasurer of Toledo City, bearing Tax Declaration No.
“SSS-2“
27068 and duly signed by Ciriaco D. Dolino, the issuing authority and found on page_5_ of Court Record;
“SSSS-3” A sub-marking found on same, showing Official Receipt Number of amount paid thereto;
The Original Tracing Cloth Plan of Lot 10052, under Sgs-07-01-000031, as prepared for Constantino B. De
“DDDDD”
Jesus, the Applicant in this instant case.
“DDDDD-1’ Sub-marking showing the date of survey of the plan by Geodetic Engineer Benecio C. Cabanero
“DDDDD-2” Sub-marking showing the signature of Geodetic Engineer Benecio C. Cabanero.
 Sub-marking, showing the signature of Federico L. Payot, Chiefs, Survey Divisions, Bureau of Lands, Region
“DDDDD-3”
VII.
“DDDDD-4” Sub-marking, showing the date of Approval of the Plan which is December 21, 1976.
Sub-marking, showing the signature of Cornelio C. Albos, Regional Director of Bureau of Lands who
“DDDDD-5”
approved the Plan.
The Original Tracing Cloth Plan of Cad. Lot Nos. 6168 and 6219, under SWO-07-01-000739 as prepared for
“EEEEE”
Constantino B. de Jesus, the Applicant in this instant case.
“EEEEE-1” Sub-marking, showing an entry as prepared on November 19, 1976.
“EEEEE-2” Sub-marking, showing the signature of Geodetic Engineer Francisco E. de Guzman.
“EEEEE-3” Sub-marking showing an entry approved December 2, 1964.
“EEEEE-4” Sub-marking, showing the signature of the approving officer, Nicanor Jorge of Bureau of Lands.
“EEEEE-5” Sub-marking, showing the certification of Chiefs, Surveys Division.
“EEEEE-6” Sub-marking, showing the date February 22, 1988 that said Plan has no conflict.
“EEEEE-7” Sub-marking, showing the date March 5, 1988 certified that said lot has no conflict with other lot.
Sub-marking, showing certification that Cad. Lot Nos. 6168 and 6219 do not overlapped each other and the
“EEEEE-8” findings of no overlapping was confirmed as verified on April 20, 1993, April 29, 1993 and May 10, 1993 by
same Agency.
The Original Tracing Cloth Plan of Cad. Lot No. 6234, under SWO-07-01-000740, as prepared for
“FFFFF”
Constantino B. de Jesus, the applicant in this instant case.
“FFFFF-1” Sub-marking, showing the signature of Geodetic Engineer Francisco E. de Guzman.
“FFFFF-2” Sub-marking, showing the date December 2, 1964 which is the approval of the plan.
“FFFFF-3” Sub-marking, showing the signature of Nicanor Jorge, the approving officer.
Sub-marking, showing the certification of the Bureau of Lands, Region 7, certifying that the plan appearing
“FFFFF-4” herein is a reproduction of Lot 6234, Toledo Cadastre, the technical description of which was certified
correct as filed in said office.
The Original Tracing Cloth Plan of Cad. Lot No. 6230, under SWO-07-01-000741 as prepared for Constantino
“GGGGG”
B. de Jesus, the applicant in this instant case.
“GGGGG-1” Sub-marking, showing the signature of Geodetic Engineer Francisco E. de Guzman who prepared the plan.
“GGGGG-2” Sub-marking showing the date of approval of the Plan on dec. 2, 1964.
“GGGGG-3” Sub-marking showing the signature of Nicanor Jorge, Director of Lands, the approving authority.
Sub-marking showing the signature of Federico L. Payot and attested by Regional Director Cornelio C.
“GGGGG-4”
Albos.
Certification to the effect that the Geodetic Engineer’s Certificate is not required since the land is surveyed
“HHHHH”
under the cadastre which is found on page 77 of Court record.
Certification to the effect that the Geodetic Engineer’s Certificate is not required since the land is surveyed
“IIIII”
under the cadastre which is found on page 78 of Court record.
Certification to the effect that the Geodetic Engineer’s Certificate is not required since the land is surveyed
“JJJJJ”
under the cadastre which is found on page 79 of Court record.
Certification to the effect that the Geodetic Engineer’s Certificate is not required since the land is surveyed
“KKKKK”
under the cadastre which is found on page 80 of Court record.
Certificate of Publication issued by Vergara of Land Registration Commission found on page 96 of Court
“LLLLL”
record.
Certificate of Publication issued by Vergara of Land Registration Commission found on page 96 of Court
“MMMMM”
record.
Subpoena Duces Tecum and ad Testificandum addressed to one Beata D. Batadlan or her representative
“I-8-1A Amdt.”
Forester Elpidio B. Gelera, Jr.
Certified True Copy of Land Classification (LC) Map 1373 of of Toledo, Cebu consisting of two (2) Sheets,
“1-8-J Amdt.”
Sheet 1.
Certified True Copy of Land Classification (LC) Map 1373 of Toledo, Cebu consisting of two (2) Sheets, Sheet
“I-8-L Amdt.”
2
NAMRIA Certification dated July 18, 2013 to the effect that NAMRIA has no record of Forestry
“1-8-K Amdt.”
Administrative Order No. 4-519 dated December 6, 1939.
“I-8-K-1 Amdt.” Signature of Dr. Peter N. Tiangco, CESO I, NAMRIA Administrator.
“1-8-K-2” Amdt. Certified True Copy of Technical Description of Land Classification Map No. 2455.
Subpoena Duces Tecum and ad Testificandum addressed to one Dr. Peter N. Tiangco, CESO I, NAMRIA
“5O”
Administrator.
“5P” Certified True Copy of Land Classification (LC) Map 1373 of Toledo, Cebu.
Signature of Beata D. Batadlan, Chief of Land Classification Division, Resource Data Analysis Branch,
“5P-1”
NAMRIA.
NAMRIA Certification to the effect that NAMRIA has no record of Foestry Administrative Order No. 4-519
“5Q”
dated December 6, 1939.
“5Q-1” Signature of Dr. Peter N. Tiangco, CESO I, NAMRIA Administrator.
“5R” Certified True Copy of the Technical Description of LC Map 1373, Sheet 2.
Signature of Beata D. Batadlan, Chief of Land Classification Division, Resource Data Analysis Branch,
“5R-1”
NAMRIA.