Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Texmati = Basmati?
fdouglas@cox.net
I. Introduction
The Indian government seeks to have the U.S. revoke the patent as
A. Patents
1
A patent for an invention is a grant of a property right by
from the date on which the patent application was filed in the
into the U.S.4 What is granted is not the right to make, use,
offer for sale, sell or import, but the right to exclude others
invention.5
B. Trademark
2
mark can also demonstrate that the labor on the goods or services
USDA agrees that the plant variety is new, distinct from other
crops and 25 years for trees, shrubs, and vines. The breeder has
stability of the new variety. The applicant may: list the single
variety and describe how the new variety differs from it; list a
3
describe how it differs from that group; or, describe how the
and private varieties. The plant variety examiner uses these and
variety's distinctness.
property.14
4
settlement system.15 TRIPs covers copyrights, trademarks,
However, if the country does not allow plant patents, the country
5
provisions.27 The least developed countries have until 1 January
stable, and novel.31 The plant variety must not have been
application date.32
6
A. Neem -- Natural Pesticide
pesticides.46
farmers' method.48
than the normal two week period.51 The European Patent Office
7
B. Turmeric -- Yellow Spice With Pharmaceutical Uses
C. A Successful Compromise
8
people in India, for many years, to treat fatigue.66 The
found that the plant had properties that enhance the human
process patent on the medicine, the Institute sought out the Kani
its rights to a drug company for a sum plus a royalty for the
D. Rice
9
The U.S. is a major producer and exporter of rice.78 Rice is
in the U.S.85
of US$50087 per metric ton.88 Indian basmati goes for US$1200 per
rice from companies like Uncle Ben's over Indian basmati rice.92
10
hybrid of aromatic rice and regular long grain rice,93 sold by
grows in Texas.
The patent also describes a method based on the starch index for
A. Indian Patents
11
regarding food, but does allow patents for food manufacturing
the invention.105
century ago.
12
rupees per ton into this fund.108 The government will use the tax
government will claim that the USPTO should revoke the rice
TIFAC says that the Indian Patent Office granted a 1986 patent
RiceTec's claim for this process along with the other patent
claims.
13
has enforced several phytosanitary specifications for every
use trademarks including "basmati" for rice that does not come
14
Basmati Development Fund is actively involved in opposing the
other trademarks.127
savvy."129 The CSIR formed a team that identified 400 herbs with
medicinal uses.130 Now the CSIR plans to seek patents for these
remedies.131
However, the USPTO may cancel a patent for a limited period after
novel, useful, or obvious, then the PTO may cancel the patent.134
anyone.136
15
If the rice provides no substantial benefits over natural
RiceTec's rice is the same type of rice grown in India for many
not novel. If the rice is not the same, then India may lose a
protection.
16
law soon, India may pursue international protection of indigenous
plants.
industry today.
for future disputes. The TRIPs agreement requires that any laws
legislation.139
17
does not have a registered trademark of "basmati" anywhere. In
countries.
certified mark may indicate to consumers that the rice was grown
rice growers.
D. Marketing
18
If store shelves stocked Indian and American basmatis side-by-
than Indian basmati rice.144 The Indian basmati rice was more
share.
rice, may give a higher yield than any current Indian basmati
19
hauled in trucks, stay fresh for longer time periods, and even
of flavor.
basmati-like rice.154
E. Do Nothing
20
If India were to do nothing regarding RiceTec's patent,
of international agreements.
21
* Follow Malaysia's practice of conducting research and
XI. Conclusion
22
1
Web site of U.S. Patent and Trademark Office,
http://www.uspto.gov/web/offices/pac/doc/general/whatispa.htm, accessed March 7, 1999.
2
Id.
3
Id.
4
35 U.S.C. § 101 (1994).
5
U.S. P.T.O. web site.
6
Id. at http://www.uspto.gov/web/offices/tac/tmfaq.htm#DefineTrademark accessed March 7, 1999.
7
Id.
8
Id.
9
Id. at http://www.uspto.gov/web/offices/tac/tmfaq.htm#DefineCertMark accessed March 7, 1999.
10
Id. at http://www.uspto.gov/web/offices/tac/tmfaq.htm#DefineCollMark accessed March 7, 1999.
11
7 U.S.C. 2321-2331, 2351-2357, 2371-2372, 2401-2404, 2421-2427, 2441-2443, 2461-2463; 2481-2486,
2501-2504, 2531-2532, 2541-2545, 2561-2570, 2581-2583 (1994).
12
Website of USDA, http://www.ams.usda.gov/science/pvp.htm accessed March 14, 1999.
13
Website of WTO, http://www.wto.org/about/facts6.htm accessed April 12, 1999.
14
Id.
15
Id.
16
Id.
17
Id.
18
Id.
19
Id.
20
Id.
21
"UPOV" is the customary abbreviation based on the initials of its name in French: Union pour la
Protection des Obtentions Végétales. See website of the UPOV, http://www.upov.int/eng/upov/union.htm
accessed April 12, 1999.
22
Website of WTO.
23
Business Line, Feb. 20, 1998, Section: Business.
24
Id.
25
Website of WTO.
26
Id.
27
Id.
28
Id.
29
Website of UPOV, http://www.upov.int/eng/brief.htm, accessed May 5, 1999.
30
Id.
31
Id.
32
Id.
33
Id.
34
Id.
35
BBC Summary of World Broadcasts, Part 3 Asia-Pacific, Aug. 27, 1997, Source: All-India Radio.
36
New Scientist, Feb. 8, 1997, p. 11.
37
Id.
38
Id.
39
Compass Newswire, Jun. 16, 1997, Section: In the News, "Neem Trees Set To Save Taj Mahal."
40
The Neem Foundation is based in Bombay, India. Compass Newswire, Jun. 16, 1997, Section: In the
News, "Neem Trees Set To Save Taj Mahal."
41
New Scientist, Feb. 8, 1997, p. 11.
42
The Tampa Tribune, Mar. 29, 1997, Section: Home and Garden, p. 1.
43
Id.
44
Bangor Daily News (Bangor, Maine), Dec. 5, 1997, "'Miracle tree' has promise."
45
Compass Newswire, Jun. 16, 1997.
46
The Tampa Tribune, Mar. 29, 1997, Section: Home and Garden, p. 1.
47
dihydro-azadirachtin
48
New Scientist, Feb. 8, 1997, p. 11.
49
Journal of Commerce (India), Aug. 26, 1997, Section: World Trade, p. 3A.
23
50
Id.
51
India Today, Sep. 8, 1997, Section: Science, p. 56.
52
Business Line, Oct. 30, 1997, p. 3.
53
The two researchers are of Indian ethnicity, Suman K. Das and Hari Har P. Cohly. India Today, Sep. 8,
1997, Section: Science, p. 56.
54
Journal of Commerce (India), Aug. 26, 1997, Section: World Trade, p. 3A.
55
Id.
56
Id.
57
India Today, Sep. 8, 1997, Section: Science, p. 56.
58
Journal of Commerce (India), Aug. 26, 1997.
59
Id.
60
Id.
61
Id.
62
Website of Law Journal Extra, http://www.ipww.com/may98/p09_india.html, accessed May 6, 1999.
63
Id.
64
Id.
65
Id.
66
Id.
67
Id.
68
Id.
69
Id.
70
Id.
71
Id.
72
Id.
73
KENWORTHY, LEONARD S., The Story Of Rice, Messner, N.Y. 1979 at 7.
74
Id.
75
Id. at 11.
76
Id.
77
Website of Worchester University, http://www.worc.ac.uk/departs/envman/FieldCourses/RFS/FCRice.html
accessed April 12, 1999.
78
KENWORTHY, at 32.
79
Id. at 35.
80
The Virginian-Pilot, F5, August 6, 1997.
81
Id.
82
Id.
83
FT Asia Intelligence Wire, February 18, 1998.
84
Business Line, Feb. 18, 1998, Section: Business.
85
Business Times (Singapore), Feb. 20, 1998, Section: Business, "India to cntest US firm's patent for basmati
rice.
86
Website of The Economic Times, http://www.economictimes.com/060399/06comm02.htm, accessed May
5, 1999.
87
Id.
88
A metric ton equals 1000 kilograms, approximately 2200 U.S. pounds.
89
Website of The Economic Times, http://www.economictimes.com/060399/06comm02.htm.
90
Id.
91
Id.
92
Id.
93
The Virginian-Pilot, F5, August 6, 1997.
94
Business India, April 20, 1998.
95
Technically, the patent is issued in the name of the inventors, Eugenio S. Sarreal, et al., with their
employer, RiceTec, recorded as the assignee. Almost always, an empoyer holds the complete patent rights to an
employee's inventions.
24
96
The patent is available from the database on the USPTO website, http://164.195.100.11/netacgi/nph-
Parser?Sect1=PTO1&Sect2=HITOFF&d=PALL&p=1&u=/netahtml/srchnum.htm&r=1&f=G&l=50&s1='
56 63484'.WKU.&OS=PN/5663484&RS=PN/5663484, accessed May 5, 1999.
97
Website of Business Line, http://www.indiaserver.com/bline/1998/04/25/stories/1425003a.htm, accessed
May 5, 1999.
98
Business India, April 20, 1998.
99
Website of Consulta Juris (Indian Law Firm), http://www.cj-law.com/ptc.htm, accessed May 5, 1999.
100
Id.
101
Id.
102
Id.
103
India Today, Sep. 8, 1997, Section: Science, p. 56.
104
Id.
105
Id.
106
Business Line, Feb. 18, 1998, Section: Business.
107
The Nation (Pakistan), April 9, 1999, available on Westlaw Service at 1999 WL 5870950.
108
Id.
109
Id.
110
BBC Summary of World Broadcasts, Part 3 Asia-Pacific, February 18, 1998.
111
New Straits Times (Malaysia), April 19, 1998, Section: National, p. 7.
112
Website of Business Line, http://www.indiaserver.com/bline/1998/04/25/stories/1425003a.htm, accessed
May 5, 1999.
113
Id.
114
Business India, April 20, 1998.
115
New Straits Times (Malaysia), April 19, 1998, Section: National, p. 7.
116
Website of Economic Times (India), http://www.economictimes.com/250399/25econ14.htm, accessed May
5, 1999.
117
Business India, April 20, 1998.
118
Id.
119
Website of Economic Times (India), http://www.economictimes.com/170399/17econ04.htm, accessed May
5, 1999.
120
Id.
121
Middle East News Items, September 13, 1998.
122
Id.
123
Website of India IP, http://www.indiaip.com/main/news/basmati_issue.htm, accessed May 5, 1999.
124
Id.
125
Website of Economic Times (India), http://www.economictimes.com/170399/17econ04.htm, accessed May
5, 1999.
126
Id.
127
Id.
128
BBC Summary of World Broadcasts, Part 3 Asia-Pacific, Aug. 27, 1997, Source: All-India Radio.
129
India Today, Sep. 8, 1997, Section: Science, p. 56.
130
Id.
131
Id.
132
Id.
133
USPTO Website, http://www.uspto.gov/web/offices/pac/doc/general/correct.htm, accessed May 7, 1999.
134
Id.
135
New Straits Times (Malaysia), April 19, 1998, Section: National, p. 7.
136
The Fort Worth Star-Telegram, May 25, 1998, p. 12.
137
Website of The Hindustan Times, http://www.hindustantimes.com/ht/nonfrm/230398/demat04.htm,
accessed April 8, 1999.
138
Id.
139
Id.
140
San Antonio Express-News, April 12, 1998, Editorial p. 2, part G.
141
Id.
25
142
Id.
143
Lundberg Family Farms of California also sells its own variety of basmati rice.
http://www.lundberg.com/variety.html, accessed May 7, 1999.
144
The Guardian (London), April 25, 1998, p. 55.
145
Id.
146
Business Line, May 23, 1998, Section: Business.
147
Website of The Times of India, http://www.timesofindia.com/180399/18busi4.htm, accessed April 13,
1999.
148
Id.
149
Id.
150
Id.
151
Id.
152
Id.
153
Id.
154
Id.
155
Id.
156
The Statesman (India), Aug. 28, 1997, Section: News.
157
Bernama (Malaysian National News Agency), Oct. 9, 1998, Section: News.
26