Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Petronić at all Analiza geometrijskih značajki rupa bušenih ND:YAG impulsnim laserom u limovima superlegure Nimonik 263
ISSN 1330-3651
UDC/UDK 621.95 : 621.375.826
Analiza geometrijskih značajki rupa bušenih ND:YAG impulsnim laserom u limovima superlegure Nimonik 263
Prethodno priopćenje
Zbog svojih odličnih mehaničkih i fizikalnih značajki, superlegure su najpogodniji materijal za uporabu u toplim sekcijama zrakoplovnih motora. U
konstrukcijskim dijelovima strojeva treba izbušiti tisuće rupa, za što se kao najučinkovitija pokazala laserska tehnika. Bušenje laserom koristi se za proizvodnju
malih promjera, točno pozicioniranih rupa, s malim oštećenjima u području oko njih i u različitim materijalima. Učinkovita uporaba lasera za bušenje rupa
visoke kvalitete za kritične primjene uvelike ovisi o ispravnom izboru i optimiranju parametara bušenja laserom. U ovom radu, rupe su izbušene Nd3+:YAG
impulsnim laserom, uz maksimalnu prosječnu snagu od 160 W, u limovima superlegure nikla Nimonic 263, debljine 0,7 mm i 1,2 mm. Rupe su promatrane
optičkim i skenirajućim elektronskim mikroskopom. Istražene su i analizirane geometrijske značajke laserski bušenih rupa, koje ovise o parametrima lasera.
Cilj ovog istraživanja bio je pronaći optimalne parametre lasera koji bi omogućili što pravilnije rupe.
laser power was 128 W, and the drilling parameters such as Dmin
Ci = (2)
pulse frequency – 5, 7 and 9 Hz and pulse duration – 0,5; 0,7; Dmax
1,0; 1,2 and 1,8 ms, were combined. The holes were drilled
three times by the same processing parameters and the
average values were calculated. where Dmax is the maximum diameter of the hole, and Dmin is
the minimum diameter of the hole.
Table 2 Specification of HTS Mobile LS-P160 Nd:YAG laser The aerospace industry has been using laser drilling for
Tablica 2. Specifikacija HTS pokretnog LS-P160 Nd:YAG lasera producing high quantity of closely spaced holes [9].
Laser parameter Parameter range However, laser drilled holes are associated with a number of
Max. mean laser power 160W defects [11], and spatter is one of them. It is ejected, molten
Pulse peak power 7,5 kW or vaporised material, that is not completely expulsed but
Max. pulse energy 80 J resolidified and adhered around the hole periphery. The
Pulse duration 0,2 - 20 ms formation of spatter is undesirable, especially in specific
Pulse frequency 1,0 - 20 Hz applications such as effusion cooling, whereby the flow and
Focal diameter 0,2 - 2,0 mm efficiency of the cooling air is dependent on the
characteristics of the holes, and causes a modification to the
original surface characteristics. Removal of the spatter
The holes were observed by optical microscopy –
through additional finishing process needs additional
model KEYENCE VH-Z100 and by scanning electron
production time and costs [12]. Spatter, as well, may reduce
microscope (SEM) – model JEOL JSM-5800. Performed
consistency/repeatability of the process [13].
operations were analysed. Entry side and exit-side of hole
Spatter deposition can be reduced with the proper
diameters and spatter area were measured using
selection of laser drilling process parameters, but
AUTOCAD 2009, geometrical characteristics were
unfortunately, cannot be totally avoided.
calculated and presented by plots for easier understanding
Figures 1 and 2 show the variation entry-side hole and
comprehension.
exit-side hole diameters, respectively, with pulse duration
for various values of pulse frequency. Entry side hole
3 diameters are assigned with Dent and exit side with Dex. Cost-
Results and discussion effective laser drilled holes are up to 1,5 mm [1]. With
Rezultati i diskusija increasing of pulse duration the diameters increase as well,
while with increasing of pulse frequency the diameters
Laser application for the processes of laser drilling decrease.
includes carefully analysed hole parameters such as:
entrance diameter, exit diameter, taper, barrelling, recast
entry side hole diameter (5 Hz)
layer, micro-cracking, entrance angle and drilling time. The 440 entry side hole diameter (7 Hz)
hole characteristics such as: entrance diameter, exit entry side hole diameter(9 Hz)
diameter, taper, aspect ratio, circularity of entrance and exit 435
hole and spatter area are carefully investigated and analysed
entry side hole diameter (mm)
275
exit side hole diameter (5 Hz) Cen (5 Hz)
exit side hole diameter (7 Hz) Cen (7Hz)
270 Cen (9Hz)
exit side hole diameter (9 Hz) 0.98
265
exit side hole diameter (mm )
0.96
260
Cen(/)
255
0.94
250
0.92
245
240
0.90
6.96
0.94
6.94
Cex (/)
6.92 0.93
taper - q (°)
6.90
6.88 0.92
6.86
0.91
6.84
6.82 0.90
6.80
6.78 0.89
0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2.0
6.76
pulse duration (ms)
6.74
0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2.0 Figure 6 Exit side hole circularity versus pulse duration for different
pulse frequencies for 0,7 mm thickness Nimonic 263 sheets
pulse duration (ms) Slika 6. Kružnost izlazne strane rupe u odnosu na trajanje impulsa
Figure 3 Taper versus pulse duration for different pulse frequencies za različite frekvencije impulsa za limove superlegure
for 0,7 mm thickness Nimonic 263 sheets Nimonic 263 debljine 0,7 mm
Slika 3. Konus u odnosu na trajanje impulsa za različite frekvencije
impulsa za limove superlegure Nimonic 263 debljine 0,7 mm 260
exit side hole diameter (5 Hz)
255
exit side hole diameter (7 Hz)
1.72
aspect ratio (5 Hz) exit side hole diameter (9 Hz)
aspect ratio (7Hz) 250
aspect ratio (9Hz)
exit side hole diameter (mm)
1.70
245
1.68 240
aspect ratio(/)
235
1.66
230
1.64
225
1.62
220
1.60 215
3.06
Figures 5 and 6 show values of enter and exit side hole
3.04 aspect ratio (5Hz)
circularity, respectively. Cen denotes enter side hole aspect ratio (7Hz)
3.02
circularity and Cex exit side hole circularity. 3.00
aspect ratio (9Hz)
2.98
260
exit side hole diameter (5 Hz) 2.96
255
exit side hole diameter (7 Hz) 2.94
aspect ratio(/)
exit side hole diameter (9 Hz)
2.92
250
2.90
exit side hole diameter (mm)
245 2.88
2.86
240 2.84
2.82
235
2.80
230 2.78
2.76
225 0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2.0
0.97
Cen (9Hz) 4.30
4.28
4.26
0.96
4.24
Cen (/)
4.22
0.95
4.20
4.18
0.94
4.16
0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2.0
0.91
Enter and exit side diameters increase with pulse
duration increasing, but decrease with pulse frequency
0.90 increasing. The values of taper increase with pulse duration
0.89
increasing and decrease with pulse frequency increasing.
Tapers formed in laser drilled holes in 1,2 mm sheets are
0.88 about 4–8,5 % higher than the ones formed in 0,7 mm
0.87
nimonic 263 sheets. The aspect ratio is highest in holes
drilled with 0,5 ms pulse duration, and then decreases. The
0.4 0.6 0.8 1.0 1.2 1.4 1.6 1.8 2.0 values of aspect ratio in 1,2 mm sheets are about 71–78 %
pulse duration (ms) higher than in 0,7 mm sheets. Also, the aspect ratio
Figure 10 Exit side hole circularity versus pulse duration for different decreases with pulse frequency increasing.
pulse frequencies for 1,2 mm thickness Nimonic 263 sheet
Slika 10. Kružnost izlazne strane rupe u odnosu na trajanje impulsa
za različite frekvencije impulsa za limove superlegure
Nimonic 263 debljine 1,2 mm
spatter area (5 Hz) power – 128 W, pulse duration – 0,7 ms and pulse frequency
0.08 spatter area (7 Hz) – 5 Hz. Geometrical characteristics were measured and
spatter area (9 Hz) calculated using AutoCAD 2009. All drilled holes were
0.07 analysed in the same way.
0.06
2
0.04
0.03
0.02
0.06
spatter area (mm )
2
0.05
Figure 15 The entry side hole taken by optical microscope. Magnitude 50
Slika 15. Ulazna strana rupe dobivena optičkim mikroskopom. Uvećanje 50
0.04
0.03
0.02
5
References
Reference
[1] Yeo, C. Y.; Tam, S. C.; Jana, S.; Lau, M. W. S. A technical
review of the laser drilling of aerospace materials. // Journal
of Materials Processing Technology. 42, (1994), p.15-49.
[2] John, M. R. Laser selection for drilling. // SME. Conf. Lasers
in Manufacturing: SPOT 86, p. 37-48.
[3] Petronic, S.; Radovanovic, R.; Grujic, B. Applications of
Laser Techniques to Austenite Materials. // Proceeding of 9.
Int. Conf. DEMI 2009, Banjaluka, p. 201-206.
[4] Srećković, M.; Milosavljević, A.; Kovačević, A.; Gospavić,
R.; Trtica, M.; Ristić, Z.; Cvetković, N.; Čantrak, Đ.
Interaction of Lasers of Various Types with Alloys Based on
Ni and Ti.// FME Transaction. 36, 4, (2008), p. 167-173.
[5] Sona, A. Metallic materials processing: cutting and drilling,
in: O.D.D. Soares and M. Perez-Amor (Eds.). //Applied Laser
Tooling, (1987), p.105-113.
[6] Ng, G. K. L.; Li, L. The effect of laser peak power and pulse
width on the hole geometry repeatability in laser percussion
drilling. // Optics & Laser Technology. 33, (2001), p. 393-402.
[7] Bandyopadhyay, S.; Gokhale, H.; Sarin Sundar, J. K.;
Sundararajan, G.; Joshi, S. V. A statistical approach to Authors' address
determine process parameter impact in Nd:YAG laser drilling Adrese autora
of IN718 and Ti-6Al-4V sheets. // Optics and Lasers in
Sanja Petronić, mechanical engineer
Engineering. 43, (2005), p. 163-182. Innovation Centre
[8] Tam, S. C.; Williams, R.; Yang, L. J.; Jana, S.; Lim, L. E. N.; Faculty of Mechanical Engineering
Lau, M. W. S. A review of the laser processing of aircraft University of Belgrade
components. // Journal of Materials Processing Technology. Kraljice Marije 16, Belgrade, Serbia
23, (1990), p. 177-194.
[9] Yilbas, B.S. Parametric study to improve laser hole drilling Professor Dr Anđelka Milosavljević, metallurgical engineer
process. // Journal of Materials Processing Technology. 70, Faculty of Mechanical Engineering
(1997), p. 264-273. University of Belgrade
Kraljice Marije 16, Belgrade, Serbia
[10] Yilbas, B. S. A study of affecting parameters in the laser hole-
drilling of sheet metals. // Journal Mechanical Working Docent Dr Zoran Radaković
Technology. 13, (1986), p. 303-315. Faculty of Mechanical Engineering
[11] Scott, B. F. Laser machining and fabrication – A review, Proc. University of Belgrade
17th Int. Mach. Tool Des. Res. Conf, 335-339. Kraljice Marije 16, Belgrade, Serbia
[12] Thawari, G.; Sarin Sundar, J. K.; Sundararajan, G.; Joshi, S. V.
Influence of process parameters pulsed Nd:YAG laser cutting Predrag Drobnjak, mechanical engineer
of nickel-based superalloys. // Journal of Materials Politechnical Academy
Belgrade, Serbia
Processing Technology. 170, (2005), p. 229-239.
[13] Zhao, J. C.; Ravikumar, V.; Beltran, A. M. Phase precipitation Igor Grujić, electrical engineer
and phase stability in Nimonic 263. // Metallurgical and Simens d.o.o. Belgrade
Materials TransactionsA. 32, (2005), p. 1271-1282. Omladinskih brigade 21, Belgrade, Serbia