Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/233650668
CITATIONS READS
19 5,125
3 authors:
Onuralp Yucel
Istanbul Technical University
234 PUBLICATIONS 681 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
PRODUCTION OF TiB2 BASED ADVANCED TECHNOLOGY CERAMICS BY UTILIZING DOMESTIC RAW MATERIALS View project
FIRE ASSAY OPTIMIZATION OF KEBAN REGION PYRTIC REFRACTORY GOLD ORES View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Serdar Aktas on 01 June 2014.
Abstract — Waste radiographic films can act as potential source materials for the recovery of valuable
silver. In this study, a chemical processing scheme was adopted to recover silver metal from waste
radiographic films. The films were dissolved in 1 M nitric acid (HNO3) solution for 3 hours at 70°C to
convert silver into silver nitrate (AgNO3(aq)). Subsequently, the silver nitrate solution was treated using
two different methods. The first involved cementation with fine iron powder and with fine zinc powder.
These two well-known cementators were compared to each other with respect to purity of the final
product and the recovery efficiency. The second method was sodium hydroxide (NaOH) precipitation.
The treatment with Fe powder and Zn powder resulted in the formation of metallic silver powder in just
one step. Ag2O obtained via NaOH precipitation was then treated using two different methods: a
treatment with a mixture of glucose (C6H12O6) and NaOH to yield metallic silver and a heat treatment,
in which Ag2O was converted to silver metal at 500°C. TGA analysis revealed that at 400°C Ag2O
decomposes into silver and oxygen. With the exception of the powder produced by glucose reduction, all
the powders would easily find industrial application. In addition, by using relatively inexpensive
chemicals these applied processes show promise for further scaling up.
Résumé — Les films radiographiques usés peuvent agir comme source potentielle de matériaux pour la
récupération de l’argent de valeur. Dans cette étude, on a adopté un schéma de traitement chimique pour
récupérer l’argent métallique des films radiographiques usés. On a dissous les films dans une solution d’acide
nitrique (HNO3) 1M pendant 3 heures à 70°C pour convertir l’argent en nitrate d’argent (AgNO3(aq)).
Subséquemment, on a traité la solution de nitrate d’argent en utilisant deux méthodes différentes. La première
impliquait la cémentation avec une poudre fine de fer et une poudre fine de zinc. On a comparé ces deux
agents de cémentation, bien connus, l’un à l’autre par rapport à la pureté du produit final et au rendement de
récupération. La seconde méthode impliquait la précipitation à l’hydroxyde de sodium (NaOH). Le
traitement avec la poudre de Fe et la poudre de Zn a entraîné la formation de poudre d’argent métallique en
une seule étape. Par la suite, on a traité l’Ag2O obtenu par précipitation au NaOH en utilisant deux méthodes
différentes: un traitement avec un mélange de glucose (C6H12O6) et de NaOH pour produire de l’argent
métallique et un traitement thermique, dans lequel l’Ag2O était converti en argent métallique à 500°C.
L’analyse par TGA a révélé que l’Ag2O se décomposait à 400°C en argent et en oxygène. Avec l’exception
de la poudre produite par réduction au glucose, toutes les poudres pourraient facilement trouver une
application industrielle. De plus, en utilisant des produits chimiques relativement peu coûteux, ces procédés
d’application sont prometteurs pour amplification future.
INTRODUCTION of the world’s silver needs are supplied by recycling and that
75% is obtained from photographic waste [2]. In terms of the
Silver, with a price around $500 per kilo [1], is one of the environment and economy, it is important that silver be
precious and noble metals. It is used in large quantities for recovered from photographic waste.
many purposes, particularly in the photographic industry due Compared to other films, waste X-ray photographic
to its photosensitive properties. It has been reported that 25% films contain an appreciable amount of silver to enhance
sensitivity to transmitted X-rays and there is 0.7 to 2.0% silver particle size less than 60 microns were employed to cement
by weight left behind in the emulsion on the polyester film the silver out of the solution. With this metallic replacement,
base, even after the development and fixing processes [2]. sub-micron metallic silver was precipitated after 1 hour at
These waste films are a good source of silver, which is reused room temperature in a shaking bath at 200 rpm. After the
for a variety of purposes, including light sensitive materials. cementation, excessive iron and zinc were reacted with 1 M
Various studies have been carried out over a long period HCl to clean the product. The morphology of all products
of time to recover valuable silver from these wastes and most was investigated using a scanning electron microscope
of them have been patented [3-7]. Silver recovery methods (SEM). X-ray analysis was also performed on the samples.
from waste films can be classified as a) burning the films In the hydroxide precipitation method, sodium hydroxide
directly, b) oxidation of the metallic silver followed by was employed to precipitate silver as silver oxide. At a pH
electrolysis and c) stripping the gelatine-silver layer using value of 11, a precipitation efficiency of 99.9% was attained
different solutions. The second and third methods have been after 60 minutes at room temperature in a shaking bath at 200
used more extensively than the first method [2]. In general, rpm. After silver was precipitated as silver oxide, two different
the methods reported for the recovery of silver from films routes were followed. In the first route, silver hydroxide was
involve two steps; the first one involves stripping the silver subjected to a reaction with a mixture of glucose and NaOH.
from the film and the second one is the recovery of the stripped This process resulted in porous metallic silver. In the second
silver by smelting or electrolysis. The first step is commonly route, silver hydroxide was heated to 500°C in a furnace under
leaching, which may be either microbiological [7-9] or argon atmosphere. It was possible to remove oxygen entirely
chemical [10]. Reagents such as sodium cyanide cause from silver oxide to yield metallic silver.
environmental problems. However, the process involving All the chemicals used in this study were of analytical
microorganisms is reported to be relatively slow [11-12]. grade. Oxygen content of the samples was measured with a
NOH-2000 determinator and concentrations of impurities
present in the products were determined by an atomic
EXPERIMENTAL WORK absorption spectrophotometer. The proposed process for
recycling waste radiographic films is shown in Figure 1.
Waste radiographic films containing 1.5% silver were For each experiment, 10 mL of the silver solution with
supplied from a hospital in Istanbul, Turkey. As mentioned in 4500 ppm was reacted with a cementator in a falcon tube to
the previous section, burning off the films is an option to avoid exposure to air; otherwise, due to the vortex that
recover silver from waste radiographic films. However, in enables air to diffuse into the solution silver can redissolve
this study, we did not prefer this method because it causes into the solution, resulting in lower efficiencies, as observed
environmental problems and leads to the loss of polymeric in the study by Aktas. [13]. In this manner, air was not able to
materials which can subsequently be recycled. diffuse into the system. Experiments were conducted in a
The waste radiographic films with dimensions of 297 temperature-controlled shaking water bath to ensure uniform
¥ 420 mm were cut manually into pieces with scissors; small heat convection at the surface of the falcon tube.
pieces with dimensions of 50 ¥ 50 mm were obtained and Solid/liquid separation was performed following each
these small films were subsequently placed in a borosilicate run. For the AAS analyses, the 10 mL filtered solution was
beaker. Three hundred grams of waste films were dissolved in
3 L of 1 M HNO3. Excessive water content was subsequently
evaporated and optimal dissolution parameters were
established. These are 3 hours at 70°C at an agitation rate of
300 rpm in a temperature controlled water bath. The
experiment was carried out in a fume cupboard. Nitrogen
oxide gases, which formed during the dissolution reaction,
were successfully neutralized with the help of the washing
unit of the fume cupboard and subsequently released to the
atmosphere. The reason the leaching time was so long was
because the films were so voluminous that they became
pasted to each other and hence made interaction with the acid
difficult. After the silver was dissolved in the nitric acid
solution, the concentrations of elements present in the
solutions were measured with an atomic absorption
spectrophotometer (AAS) (Perkin Elmer Analyst 800) at the
end of each experiment. After leaching with nitric acid, a
solution with 4.5 g/L silver was obtained.
In the recovery step, two different precipitation methods
were studied: cementation and hydroxide precipitation. Since
they are common cementators, Fe and Zn powders with a Fig. 1. The proposed recycling process for waste radiographic films.
introduced into the machine with an appropriate dilution. The As can be seen from the figure, optimal dissolution
efficiency of this recovery process was calculated from the efficiency can be attained at an agitation rate of 300 rpm.
percentage of silver recovery using the following equation: Without agitation, a poor efficiency is obtained although
efficiency increases up to 300 rpm. After this point, the
Recovery Efficiency (%) = (Co – Ct) ¥ 100 / Co (1) efficiency is observed to drop due to the fact that films are
pasted to each other resulting in poor contact of nitric acid
where Co is the initial silver concentration (4500 ppm) and Ct with the films. Thus, an agitation rate of 300 rpm was chosen
is the concentration at the end of the experiment. for further experiments.
Fig. 2. The effect of agitation rate on the dissolution efficiency of silver Fig. 3. The effect of temperature on the dissolution efficiency of silver (1M
(1M HNO3, 1 hour, room temperature). HNO3, 300 rpm, 1 hour).
Fig. 4. The effect of time on the dissolution efficiency of silver (1M HNO3, Fig. 5. Silver recovery efficiency with respect to changing weight ratio
300 rpm, 70°C). (200 rpm, room temperature, 1 hour).
decomposition of silver oxide with respect to temperature. Metallic Silver Production by Glucose Reduction: Organic
As shown in Figure 7, at around 350°C silver oxide reducers such as tartaric acid, glucose and formaldehyde etc.,
rapidly begins to decompose and this decomposition reaction are used in various applications. An organic reducer, glucose
is complete at 400°C, which results in pure metallic silver. (C6H12O6), reduces silver oxide to metallic silver when it
The theoretical silver content of the silver oxide compound is reacts with the Ag2O in the presence of sodium hydroxide.
93.09%. As shown in the figure, it was successfully achieved. This was also observed in a study carried out by Wieczorek et
al. [16]. Following the precipitation, the silver oxide powder
was subjected to a reaction with glucose in the sodium
hydroxide media. By this treatment, silver oxide was
converted to silver by glucose [17]. Figure 8 displays the
conversion efficiency of silver oxide to metallic silver by the
help of glucose in the sodium hydroxide medium. The
pertinent reaction is presented below. (Equation 6)
At room temperature, over 99.97% silver conversion
efficiency was attained in 30 minutes at 200 rpm. As can be
seen from the figure, increasing amount of glucose results in
higher conversion efficiency of silver oxide to silver. It
should also be noted that sodium hydroxide should be present
in order to convert silver oxide to silver. Otherwise, glucose
cannot make this conversion alone.
Fig. 7. Decomposition of silver oxide with respect to temperature. Fig. 8. The conversion efficiency of Ag2O to Ag (%) with respect to chang-
ing weight ratio of Ag2O/glucose (200 rpm, room temperature, 1/2 hour).
(6)
during the cleaning process, were neutralized with the help of 70°C so as to convert silver into silver nitrate (AgNO3). The
sodium hydroxide and then they were discharged in line with polymer substrate, which is left over after the treatment of
the regulations of the Istanbul Municipality. nitric acid, can be further recycled. The prepared AgNO3 was
To determine the purity of the powders that were treated with two different methods: 1) cementation with zinc
produced in this study, potentiometric titration was carried and iron powders and 2) precipitation by sodium hydroxide.
out. The samples produced by zinc cementation and heat With a metallic replacement reaction by zinc and iron
treatment were found to contain 99.99% silver, whereas those powders, sub-micron-sized metallic silver powder was
obtained via iron cementation and glucose reduction were produced. With this method fine silver powder was produced.
99.92% and 99.58% silver, respectively. The silver purities were found to be 99.99 and 99.92%,
Oxygen content of the samples was measured with a respectively, which can be directly used in various
NOH-2000 determinator and concentrations of impurities applications. It should also be noted that zinc proved to be a
present in the products were determined using an atomic better cementator than iron in terms of silver recovery
absorption spectrophotometer. The oxygen content of the efficiency.
samples for zinc cementation, iron cementation, heat After the silver oxide was precipitated via sodium
treatment and glucose reduction were found to be 0 ppm, 54.6 hydroxide, metallic silver powder was then easily produced
ppm, 0 ppm and 342 ppm, respectively. Other impurities for with two different methods: glucose reduction in alkali media
zinc cementation and iron cementation were 16 ppm Zn and and heat treatment at 500°C under argon atmosphere, which
740 ppm Fe, respectively. XRD analysis was also carried out results in pure silver with 99.99% purity. Three nine silver
on the samples, as shown in Figure 9. (99.90%) is acceptable in most silver industries. Since the
In the diffraction pattern, the peaks are clearly observed purity of silver produced by glucose reduction is less than
at 2q = 37.93, 44.14, 64.68, 77.55, 81.51 which are in good 99.90% (around 99.58%), it requires further purification.
agreement with the metallic silver peaks. With the exception of the powder produced by glucose
Figure 10 displays SEM images of the silver powders reduction, all the powders could easily find industrial
produced with each method. application. These powders can be employed in the
According to Figures 10a and 10b, SEM images of the production of silver nitrate which is used in anti-bacterial and
powders produced via cementation closely resemble one pharmacological applications, in the production of silver
another. These images were also obtained in a study carried cyanide, which is the main component of silver plating baths,
out by Abdel-Aal and Farghaly [18]. The particles are sub- in jewelry and as alloying elements, etc.
micron in size and have dendritical structure. Figure 10c Of these powders, the one produced by heat treatment
clearly shows that a porous nanoscale structure was attained is the most expensive as argon; a furnace is involved in the
although the powder produced by heat treatment is agglom- process, but it can be directly used in applications
erated due to sintering at 500°C (Figure 10d) making large mentioned above. Powders produced by cementation
silver particle, which was also observed by Abdel-Aal and exhibit similar properties and are quite inexpensive and
Farghaly [18] although the SEM images are quite different. straightforward to be produced, but effluent solutions
emerge following the reaction and need to be discarded in
an environmentally friendly way, which might be costly.
CONCLUSIONS The one that was produced using glucose is easy to be
produced and no harmful solutions are produced following
In the present work, a chemical processing scheme was the reaction, but the product quality is less in comparison to
adopted to recover silver metal from waste radiographic the other ones as silver content is 99.58% and thus it needs
films; it has been demonstrated that it is possible to recover to be further refined before the end user use it. But it still
the silver metal incorporated in spent radiographic films at a can be used as an alloying element in silver ornaments,
precipitation efficiency of more than 99%. The films were plates etc.
dissolved in 1 M nitric acid (HNO3) solution for 3 hours at
REFERENCES
1. http://www.kitco.com
2. N. Nakiboglu, D. Toscali and G. Nisli, “A Novel Silver Recovery
Method from Waste Photographic Films with NaOH Stripping Turk”, J
Chem., 2003, vol. 27, pp. 127-133.
3. V.I.E. Ajiwe and I.E. Anyadiegwu, “Recovery of Silver from Industrial
Wastes”, Cassava Solution Effects Separation and Purification
Technology, 2000, vol. 18, pp. 89–92.
4. P. Khunprasert, N. Grisdanurak, J. Thaveesri , V. Danutra and W.
Puttitavorn, “Radiographic Film Waste Management in Thailand and
Cleaner Technology for Silver Leaching”, Journal of Cleaner
Production, 2008, vol. 16, pp. 28-36.
5. H.L. Govani, American Patent 3,660,079, 1971.
Fig. 9. X-ray diffraction pattern of silver.
6. E. Wainer, American Patent 3,647,422, 1972.
a) b)
c) d)
Fig. 10. Scanning electron micrographs of silver powders produced via a) zinc cementation, b) iron cementation, c) glucose reduction and d) heat treatment.