Professional Documents
Culture Documents
FIGHTER RADARS
SPECIAL REPORT
2010
IN ASSOCIATION WITH
Raytheon AESA
Active Electronically Scanned Array Radar
Day and night, Raytheon’s proven multi-mode, multi-platform AESA technology can simultaneously guide
multiple weapons to multiple targets widely spaced in azimuth, elevation and range, with unprecedented
precision. It provides today’s aircraft with a revolutionary level of situational awareness and the vast
operational advantages that go with it.
www.raytheon.com
Keyword: TACAESA
© 2010 Raytheon Company. All rights reserved.
“Customer Success Is Our Mission” is a registered trademark of Raytheon Company.
FOREWORD
elcome to Flightglobal Insight’s Fighter Radars Special Report 2010, brought to you in association with
W Raytheon. Prepared using data from Flightglobal’s MiliCAS database, plus information gathered by Flight
International journalists and material from manufacturer’s product data, the report provides an overview of one
of the most vital elements of a new-generation combat aircraft: the fire control radar.
Avionics equipment typically accounts for around one-third of the total purchase cost of a new fighter, and with
budget pressures currently being felt more acutely than ever by many, buyers are demanding greater capability,
improved reliability and reduced operating costs from such systems.
In the fighter radar business area, the recent rise of active electronically scanned array (AESA) technology offers
the potential to satisfy such demands. Comprising hundreds of transmit/receive (T/R) modules, each acting
like individual radars, the AESA holds the promise of delivering improved performance, but with minimum main-
tenance demands. Such sensors could last for the entire service life of a fighter, with the small percentage of
individual modules that will fail over this time to have no or little effect on overall system performance: a trait
referred to as “graceful degradation”.
Crucially, industry officials now believe that AESA technology has reached a point where systems can cost the
same to manufacture as a mechanically-scanned array; the benchmark for fighter radar design for the last sev-
eral decades. Perhaps more importantly than their support benefits, active, or ‘E-scan’ arrays also offer opera-
tional advantages, by delivering increased detection range and more agile beam-forming, which reduces the risk
of a host platform being identified when using its primary sensor. Once combined with new-generation beyond
visual-range air-to-air missiles, an AESA system could be a true battle winner, by delivering a vital “look first,
shoot first” capability.
But with air-to-air engagements having become extremely rare in today’s operational environment, further advan-
tages must be offered. Ground mapping is already possible using an AESA, and emerging developments could
also see such devices used for applications such as jamming other radars and performing electronic attacks.
Such multifunction capability has a clear attraction for cash-strapped air forces looking to get the most out of their
small fleets of combat aircraft. Accordingly, E-scan systems have swiftly moved from being an expensive market
fad to a must-have item for fighter manufacturers keen to secure hard-fought orders on the global stage.
More innovation is also emerging, such as Selex Galileo’s work to increase the area of regard delivered by a fixed
AESA through the use of a so-called “swashplate repositioner”. Having already drawn interest from airframers
including Saab and the Eurofighter consortium, this advance could also be considered by other radar manufactur-
ers over the coming years. As T/R modules become more readily available and less expensive to manufacture,
nations may also opt to add active arrays to some fighter types already in established use.
With some models, such as early Block-number Lockheed Martin F-16s, having at least 20 years of life left in
them, radar suppliers are now offering AESA designs as “drop-fit” replacements for outdated avionics. Raytheon
and Northrop Grumman are already going head-to-head for potential business, but face competition from Israeli
suppliers and others.
This report focuses on products currently available or being developed by Western and Russian manufacturers.
It excludes radar technologies being pursued by China, which will become an increasingly credible force in the
fighter arena, including as an export player, during the coming decade. Types such as Russia’s developmental
PAK-FA and China’s planned Chengdu J-12 could well present “near peer” rivals for Western designs such as the
Lockheed F-35 Joint Strike Fighter during this time, and place even greater importance on investment in radar
technology.
Sector specific news – learn how your sector of the market is performing and the
issues that will affect you
Brand perception & advertising effectiveness – find out how your customers and
potential customers view your company and how much ROI your advertising is delivering
FIGHTER RADARS SPECIAL REPORT 2010
Content
Flightglobal Insight is the research division of Flightglobal, the world’s longest established aviation publishing
group. This special report is published by Flightglobal Insight and brought to you in association with Raytheon.
With access to a wealth of information from Flightglobal’s premium services portfolio and industry expertise,
Flightglobal Insight publishes special reports and tailored analysis covering numerous sectors of the aerospace in-
dustry.
TO FIND OUT MORE ABOUT FLIGHTGLOBAL INSIGHT AND SPONSORSHIP OPPORTUNITIES, CONTACT:
www.flightglobal.com
FIGHTER RADARS SPECIAL REPORT 2010
It has become essential for new build fighters to be equipped with active © Raytheon
electronically scanned array radar technology. Bob Mason, vice-president
marketing and sales for Selex Galileo, recently told Flightglobal that it was
crucial for the Eurofighter Typhoon to upgrade with an E-scan radar for the
export market.
© Northrop Grumman
ELBIT SYSTEMS
Elbit Systems is a defence electronics manufacturer and systems inte-
grator. Established in 1967, and based in Haifa, Israel, Elbit has over
10,000 employees.
Elbit Systems
Advanced Technology Center, Haifa 31053, Israel © Elbit Systems
Tel: +972 4 831 6404 Fax: +972 4 831 6944 Web: www.elbitsystems.com
ELTA SYSTEMS
Elta Systems is a subsidiary of Israel Aerospace Industries. Elta products
are designed for Intelligence, Surveillance, Target Acquisition and Recon-
naissance, Airborne Early Warning & Control, Homeland Security, Self-Pro-
tection and Self-Defence, and fire control applications.
The EL/M-2032 radar was designed for multimission fighters, oriented for
both air-to-air and surface strike missions. IAI is currently installing the sen-
sor on secondhand Kfir fighters for the Colombian air force. The EL/M-2052
is an AESA radar which offers air-to-air, air-to-ground and air-to-sea operating
modes. © Elta Systems
South Korea has selected the EL/M-2032 for the F/A-50 light attack and
trainer jet, which is produced by Korea Aerospace Industries in partnership with Lockheed Martin.
The United States is against promotion of Israeli AESA radars for products that are competing with US aircraft
because they contain American technologies.
Elta Systems
Israel Aerospace Industries Ltd, Ben-Gurion International Airport, 70100, Israel
Tel: +972 3 935 3343 Fax: +972 3 935 8278 Web: www.iai.co.il
EURORADAR
The Euroradar consortium consists of Selex Galileo, EADS Defence &
Security and Indra. Euroradar’s Captor is a mechanically scanned radar
which is still used on the Eurofighter Typhoon. Selex produces over 50% of
the Captor system. EADS conducted test flights with the Euroradar Caesar
active array using a Eurofighter development aircraft in 2007, and Selex
has also previously supplied AESA systems to the UK Ministry of Defence
for evaluation in fast jet types such as the Panavia Tornado. Provisions
for an AESA array could be made during Tranche 3A production of the Eu-
rofighter for Germany, Italy, Spain and the UK. © Euroradar
Euroradar
Eurofighter Jagdflugzeug GmbH, Am Söldnermoos 17, 85399 Hallbergmoos, Germany
Tel: +49 811 80 0 Fax: +49 811 80 1557 Web: www.eurofighter.com
PHAZOTRON
Phazotron is a Russian company which develops and produces
multiple technology systems including radars and radar weapon
and defence control systems for aircraft plus gun-missile ground-
based and shipborne air defence systems. Phazotron employs an
estimated 5,000 employees.
Phazotron
123557, Moscow, Electrichesky per 1, Russia
Tel: +7095 253 0495 Fax: +7095 253 0495 Web: www.phazotron.com
RAYTHEON
Raytheon is a defence contractor and industrial corporation with core
manufacturing concentration in defence systems and defence and
commercial electronics. The company has around 73,000 employees
worldwide.
Raytheon currently builds the AN/APG-79 AESA for the Boeing F/A-
18E/F Super Hornet and the AN/APG-63(V)2/3 AESA for Boeing F-
15s. Raytheon is also developing the AN/APG-82(V)1 for the US Air
Force’s F-15E. © Raytheon
© Raytheon
Raytheon
Raytheon Company , 870 Winter Street, Waltham, Massachusetts, 02451-1449 USA
Tel: +1 781 522 3000 Web: www.raytheon.com
SELEX GALILEO
Selex Sensors and Airborne Systems and Galileo Avionica began operating
under the common brand name of Selex Galileo in January 2008. The company
is owned by the Italian conglomerate Finmeccanica.
The Vixen 1000E/ES-05 Raven AESA radar was first tested in flight using
Saab’s Gripen Demo airframe in October 2009. Selex says that flight tests of
its new AESA design, which uses a unique “swashplate” mounting to signifi-
© Selex Galileo
cantly boost the sensor’s area of coverage, will also support the technology’s
possible future integration with the Eurofighter Typhoon.
Early in 2009, the UK Ministry of Defence confirmed a desire to equip its Tranche 3A Typhoons with AESA radars,
and industry sources say a flight-test programme with the Selex design is expected to take place from 2012.
EADS has previously flown an AESA array on a Eurofighter development aircraft in Germany.
According to Selex, an AESA array could now be produced for the same cost as a mechanically scanned system,
but deliver a five to 10-times increase in mean-time between critical failures, reducing maintenance and other
through-life support costs.
Selex Galileo
Via Giulio Vincenzo Bona, 85 , 00156, ROMA, Italy
Tel: +39 06418831 Fax: +39 0641883219 Web: www.selexgalileo.com
THALES
Thales is a global technology provider for the aerospace, space, defence, security and transportation markets.
The company operates in 50 countries and has 68,000 employees.
The RBE2 is described as Europe’s first AESA radar. It replaces the con-
ventional antenna and its mechanical steering system, and has allowed
for greater reliability with respect to previous-generation radars. The
© Thales RBE2 will give the Rafale the capability to track all targets in the radar
field of view, irrespective of the relative location between targets and
host aircraft. Other operational benefits include the detection of targets
with low radar reflectivity and improved high quality ground imaging. The RBE2’s high performance air-to-air detec-
tion will make it possible to detect smaller targets and to detect them earlier.
The industrialisation phase for the RBE2 was launched in 2006. Final validation of software function is expected
to end in the first quarter of 2010, with delivery of the radars to Dassault Aviation.
Thales
45 rue de Villiers, 92526, Neuilly-sur-Seine, France
Tel: +33 1 57 77 80 00 Web: www.thalesgroup.com
TIKHOMIROV NIIP
Tikhomirov NIIP is one of the major Russian enterprises in the development
of weaponry control systems for fighter aircraft and mobile medium-range
surface-to-air missile systems.
The N011M Bars radar is fitted on the Sukhoi Su-30. The Bars is the most
advanced radar developed by the Russian industry during the 1990s. It is
unusual in being designed with a hybrid array arrangement, the receive path
using very similar technology to US and European AESAs, with similar sensi-
tivity and sidelobe performance, but using a Travelling Wave Tube and back- © Tikhomirov NIIP
plane waveguide feed for the transmit direction, a technology closest to the
Boeing B-1 and early Dassault Rafale radars.
The Tikhomirov Irbis-E radar system has been in development since 2004 and designed for the Su-35 multi-
purpose fighter aircraft. Tikhomirov developed the new radar based on the Bars system provided to Su-30MKI/
MKM/MKA aircraft. This system’s antenna contains more than 1,000 solid transmit/receive modules. The first
radar prototype entered flight tests onboard an Su-30MK2 aircraft acting as a test bed in early 2007. The Irbis-E
design is Russia’s second AESA system, following the Phazotron Zhuk-AE being developed for the MiG-35.
Tikhomirov NIIP
3, Gagarina St., Zhukovsky, Russia 140181
Tel: +7 495 556 23 48 Fax: +7 495 721 37 85 Web: www.niip.ru
www.flightglobal.com/subscribe
FIGHTER RADARS SPECIAL REPORT 2010
Local industrial development and the related transfer of cutting-edge technologies are key requirements for many
nations which are considering committing themselves to a massive capital outlay and support costs which will
span at least four decades in most cases. India’s at least 126-aircraft medium multirole combat aircraft competi-
tion is one such example, with New Delhi currently assessing six designs for its long-term requirements.
For bidding companies Boeing (F/A-18E/F Super Hornet), Dassault (Rafale), Eurofighter (Typhoon), Lockheed
Martin (F-16), RSK MiG (MiG-35) and Saab (Gripen NG), the ability to outsource the production of high-value
equipment such as transmit/receive modules for active electronically scanned array (AESA) radars could prove
as vital a lure as raw airframe performance.
Once viewed as something of an extravagance, the inclusion of an AESA sensor is increasingly becoming part of
requests for information and requests for proposal issued by potential fighter-buying countries, as the technology
moves swiftly from the sidelines to the baseline.
AFRICA ASIA-PACIFIC
SOUTH AMERICA F-16: 201 F-15: 197
F-16: 37 MiG-29: 22 F-16: 488
MiG-29: 39 Su-27/30: 59 F-18: 79
Su-27/30: 24 MiG-29: 149
Su-27/30: 322
www.flightglobal.com
FIGHTER RADARS SPECIAL REPORT 2010
© Boeing
© USAF
© Raytheon © Boeing
DASSAULT RAFALE
The Rafale A first flew in 1986 as an aerodynamic
SPECIFICATIONS study. The first production-standard Rafale flew in
Height: 5.34 m 1998, and entered service with the French navy in
Length: 15.27 m 2004 in the F1 standard. Deliveries of the French air
Wingspan: 10.80 m force’s B and C model aircraft started in 2006. Since
2008, all Rafales have been delivered in the F3
Wing Area: 45.70 m2
standard. All aircraft delivered in earlier production
Empty weight: 20,000 kg standards will be brought up to the F3 configuration
MTOW: 24,500 kg over the next two years.
Powerplant: 2 x Snecma M88-2
Speed: Mach 1.8 The French forces plan to purchase 294 Rafales: 234
Radar: Thales RBE2 for the air force and 60 for the navy. Their Rafales are
set to replace seven legacy fighter types, and will
Source: Dassault
remain as France’s principal combat aircraft until at
least 2040.
© Dassault
© Dassault
EUROFIGHTER TYPHOON
Eurofighter is a multinational company formed of Alenia
SPECIFICATIONS Aeronautica, BAE Systems and EADS in 1986 that
Height: 5.28 m coordinates the design, production and upgrade of the
Length: 15.96 m Typhoon multi-role fighter. Production is on a workshare
Wingspan: 10.95 m basis, according to the number of aircraft each has ordered.
The Typhoon was introduced in 2003.
Wing Area: 50 m2
Empty weight: 11,000 kg The Typhoon is in service with the UK Royal Air Force, the
MTOW: 23,500 kg German Luftwaffe, the Italian Aeronautica Militare, the
Powerplant: 2 × Eurojet EJ200 Spanish air force and the Austrian air force - the first export
Speed: Mach 2 customer. Saudi Arabia is the only Typhoon operator outside
Radar: Euroradar Captor of Europe.
Source: Eurofighter
The mechanically scanned Euroradar Captor was designed
for the Typhoon. Euroradar is led by Selex Galileo and also
includes EADS and Indra.
© Eurofighter
© Eurofighter
© Northrop Grumman
© Lockheed Martin
© Lockheed Martin
© Lockheed Martin
In July 2009, the US Senate voted to end production of
F-22s after 2011.
© RSK MiG
© RSK MiG
© RSK MiG
© Allocer
© Saab
© Saab
SUKHOI SU-30MKI
The Sukhoi Su-30MKI is a variant of the Su-30. The
SPECIFICATIONS development of the variant started after India signed a
Height: 6.4 m deal with Russia in 2000 to manufacture 140 Su-30
Length: 21.9 m fighter jets.
Wingspan: 14.7 m
For the first time in the world, a production plane has a
Wing Area: 62 m2
radar with a phased antenna array (“Bars” developed by
Empty weight: 18,400 kg the Scientific Research Institute of Instrumentation
MTOW: 38,800 kg Technology). The Su-30MKI is fitted with the Tikhomirov
Powerplant: 2 x Lyulka AL-31FP NIIP N011M Bars (Panther) digital multi-mode dual
Speed: Mach 2.34 frequency band radar.
Radar: Tikhomirov NIIP N011M Bars
The N011M can function in air-to-air and air-to-land/sea
Source: Sukhoi
mode simultaneously while being tied into a high-precision
laser-inertial or GPS navigation system. It is equipped with
a modern digital weapons control system as well as anti-
jamming features. The N011M has a 350 km search
range and a maximum 200 km tracking range. The radar
can track 15 air targets and engage four simultaneously.
These targets can even include cruise missiles and
motionless helicopters.
© Sukhoi
© Sukhoi
© Sukhoi
SUKHOI SU-35BM
The Sukhoi Su-35BM is a multi-role fighter and variant of
SPECIFICATIONS the Su-27M/Su-35. There are currently over 500 in-
Height: 5.9 m service Su-27s worldwide.
Length: 21.9 m
Wingspan: 15.3 m The core of the Su-35 armament is the Irbis-E radar
control system with a phased antenna array developed
Wing Area: 62 m2
by Tikhomirov NIIP. In design, this is an X-waveband
Empty weight: 18,400 kg multi-role radar with a passive phased antenna array
MTOW: 34,500 kg mounted on a two-step hydraulic drive unit (in azimuth
Powerplant: 2 x Saturn 117S/AL-41F1A and roll). The antenna device scans by an electronically
Speed: Mach 2.25 controlled beam in azimuth and angle of elevation in
Radar: Tikhomirov Irbis-E sectors not smaller than 60°. The two-step electro-
hydraulic drive unit additionally turns the antenna by
Source: KNAAPO
mechanic means to 60° in azimuth and 120° in roll.
Thus, in using the electronic control and mechanical
additional turn of the antenna, the maximum deflection
angle of the beam grows to 120°.
© Sukhoi
© Sukhoi
© Sukhoi
Insight e-newsletters
Flightglobal Insight’s expert team of researchers and analysts
also compile a vast range of free e-newsletters each fortnight
including the following market sectors:
• Aircraft finance
• Airline maintenance
• Business aviation
• Defence
• Network planning
• Unmanned
Email: insight@flightglobal.com
Web: www.flightglobal.com/insight
FIGHTER RADARS SPECIAL REPORT 2010
Fighter upgrades
NORTHROP GRUMMAN AN/APG-68(V)9
The AN/APG-68(V)9 radar is an advanced capability system designed for the
F-16. It has autonomous 24-hour, all weather precision strike capability including
synthetic aperture. Seven countries have purchased it as standard equipment
on new F-16s or as upgrade kits for their existing F-16 fleets. To date, Northrop
Grumman has delivered more than 250 AN/APG-68(V)9 radars.
© Northrop Grumman
RAYTHEON AN/APG-63(V)2
The AN/APG-63(V)2 is a radar upgrade for the US Air Force’s F-15C and was
also the first AESA radar system to be operationally deployed on 18 USAF F-15C
for a cruise missile defence mission. Retaining controls and displays nearly
identical to those of its predecessor, the AN/APG-63(V)1, the new system adds
an AESA radar. Addition of AESA technology substantially increases pilot situ-
ational awareness, while enhancing reliability and maintainability.
This AESA radar has an exceptionally agile beam, and provides almost instanta-
neous track updates throughout the field of vision. Other benefits of the radar © Raytheon
include enhanced multi-target tracking capability and elimination of the need
for a hydraulic system. The AN/APG-63(V)2 is compatible with current F-15C weapon loads. It features upgraded
identification-friend-or-foe and environmental control systems, and enables pilots to take full advantage of AIM-
120 Advanced Medium-Range Air-to-Air Missile capabilities. It can simultaneously guide multiple missiles to
several targets widely spaced in azimuth, elevation, or range.
RAYTHEON AN/APG-63(V)3
The AN/APG-63(V)3 AESA radar is an upgrade of the AN/APG-63(V)2. It
provides powerful, adaptable radar technology, proven performance, and
tactical flexibility that F-15 pilots can rely on. It is the newest member of
Raytheon’s F-15 radar family.
RAYTHEON AN/APG-82(V)1
In September 2009, the F-15E Radar Modernization Program (RMP)
received the designation of AN/APG-82(V)1 from the US Air Force.
Raytheon will produce developmental and flight-test radar units to
support integration of the AN/APG-82 into the F-15E weapons sys-
tem. Flight tests begin in 2010, and Boeing expects the combination
to achieve initial operational capability during fiscal year 2014.
© Raytheon
RAYTHEON RACR
The Raytheon Advanced Combat Radar (RACR) AESA is, like Northrop’s SABR, on
offer for fighter upgrades. It has been designed as a drop-in upgrade for the F-16
and F/A-18 to minimise aircraft modification time and aircrew transition training.
The RACR has also been offered to South Korea for installation on the proposed
Korea Aerospace Industries F/A-50 light fighter. RACR shares about 90% of its com-
ponents with the Boeing F/A-18E/F Super Hornet’s current sensor.
© Raytheon
Night and day, Raytheon’s proven AESA technology enables various platforms to gather, process and
share information, air-to-air and air-to-ground, with a speed and reliability far greater than any other
radar. In short, it provides today’s aircraft with a revolutionary level of situational awareness and the
vast operational advantages that go with it.
www.raytheon.com
Keyword: TACAESA
© 2010 Raytheon Company. All rights reserved.
“Customer Success Is Our Mission” is a registered trademark of Raytheon Company.
Every day, Raytheon customers undertake vital missions across air, land, sea, space and cyber-
space. Our mission is to provide innovative, integrated technologies across these domains to
ensure customer success.
Raytheon’s combat-proven AESA technology gives pilots and aircrews the ultimate operational
edge. Designed for continual service in demanding flight conditions, Raytheon’s AESA ensures
that servicemen and women on the battlefield are responsive and ready to keep America and
its allies safe.
Revolutionary Capabilities: After designing and building the world’s first operational AESA fight-
er radar, fielded in 2000, Raytheon has remained at the forefront of radar evolution. Raytheon’s
AESA provides superior detection, targeting, tracking and self protection, as the most advanced
air-to-air, air-to-surface multimode radar. We are committed to providing only the best AESA capa-
bilities and mission support to servicemen and –women worldwide on aircraft such as the F-15,
F/A-18A-F, EA-18G, F-16, B-2 and ASTOR.
Innovative: Raytheon provides flexible AESA options to speed delivery of the right solution for
a variety of fighter aircraft. Our AESA radar family continues to evolve, ensuring longevity of the
technology while making state-of-the-art radar performance enhancements available at low risk
for decades to come. Raytheon also offers proven ability to scale or customize radar systems
for multiple combat aircraft platforms, domestic and international. We provide an affordable, low-
risk approach for customers worldwide.
Network-Centric Operations: Raytheon’s AESA radar systems have the ability to link fighters,
bombers and surveillance aircraft; service members in the air and on the ground; integrate data
from unmanned aerial vehicles; and provide non-traditional ISR to provide the right information
at the right time for the right mission.
Whatever the task – defense, ISR, or strike – pilots and aircrews rely on Raytheon’s AESA tech-
nology for optimal mission assurance.
Raytheon Company, with 2008 sales of $23.2 billion, is a technology and innovation leader spe-
cializing in defense, homeland security and other government markets throughout the world. With
a history of innovation spanning 87 years, Raytheon provides state-of-the-art electronics, mis-
sion systems integration and other capabilities in the areas of sensing; effects; and command,
control, communications and intelligence systems, as well as a broad range of mission support
services. With headquarters in Waltham, Mass., Raytheon employs 73,000 people worldwide.