Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract—Accurate prediction of temperature variation of tromagnetic design, electrical design, materials selection, me-
power semiconductor devices in power electronic circuits is im- chanical layout, electromagnetic interference (EMI), thermal
portant to obtain optimum designs and estimate reliability levels. management, manufacturing process development, reliability,
Temperature estimation of power electronic devices has generally
been performed using transient thermal equivalent circuits. In the and cost strategies are addressed sequentially and often sadly in
presence of varying load cycles, it has been typical to resort to a an isolated manner. By nature, such a serial process is plagued
time-domain electrical simulation tool such as P-Spice or SABER by concealed and competing tradeoffs, which obscure the path
to obtain a time series of the temperature profiles. However, for toward an optimal solution. Unfortunately, it is virtually impos-
complex and periodic load cycles, time-series simulation is time sible to make objective design decisions based on unified ana-
consuming. In this paper, a fast Fourier analysis-based approach
is presented for obtaining temperature profiles for power semi- lytical solutions. Nevertheless, as economic pressures to meet
conductors. The model can be implemented readily into a spread- stringent performance/cost ratio keep mounting, the need for a
sheet or simple mathematical algebraic calculation software. The better understanding and visualization of the design space is be-
technique can be used for predicting lifetime and reliability level ing felt. It is therefore crucial to fill these gaps in knowledge and
of power circuits easily. Details of the analytical approach and integrate them into the power electronics design process. Only
illustrative examples are presented in this paper.
then can modern enterprise practices like integrated product
Index Terms—Fourier techniques, power semiconductor device and process development be successfully applied to the field of
reliability, thermal analysis. power electronics, leading to cost reductions and performance
improvements.
I. I NTRODUCTION This paper represents a small step toward solving this fun-
damental issue in power electronics systems by proposing a
D ESIGN of power electronic systems involve numerous
tradeoffs as is common in most engineered systems. It
proceeds through a careful selection process for various para-
simple evaluation tool to analyze the thermal properties of
power electronics designs in a fast and accurate manner. Simple
solutions of thermal equivalent circuits that are commonly used
meters and technologies starting with the electrical design and
to predict maximum junction temperatures become less useful
culminating in manufacturing process design. The electrical-
for predicting lifetime and reliability figures accurately when
design phase results in the selection of power electronic circuit
the operating load cycles are complicated and the design needs
components, which is relatively mature and well established.
to be optimized for particular load cycles.
However, rendering well-conceived electrical designs into
Finite-element analysis (FEA) tools can be used for obtaining
reliable and low-cost products suitable for any application
requires a substantial amount of additional engineering effort. detailed thermal profiles. They are generally based on computa-
The physical design proceeds further beyond the electronic cir- tional fluid dynamics (CFD) programs such as the finite-volume
cuit design, accounting for magnetic devices, current densities, method. However, for most applications, the use of FEA is
dielectric isolation requirements, semiconductor power losses, limited by its difficulty of use and length of calculation time,
thermal management methods, thermomechanical stresses, die- and furthermore, the accuracy of most models have not been
attach processes, electromagnetic interference, etc. Aforesaid definitively established [1]. Many publications have imple-
factors that affect the design are coupled through complex inter- mented a time-domain electrothermal simulation of the thermal
relationships. Design activity encompasses several engineering circuit concurrently with the electrical simulated circuit using
domains including magnetic, electrical, mechanical, thermal, time-domain circuit simulation tools [1]–[6]. However, under
material processing, and manufacturing sciences. long time-load cycles, time-domain simulation becomes very
Traditionally, these conditions lead to a serial approach cumbersome. The Federal Urban Driving Schedule (FUDS)
toward product design and development. Issues related to elec- cycle would be impractical to perform loss calculations using
commercial electrical simulation packages due to the immense
Manuscript received February 26, 2004; revised February 29, 2005. Abstract
amount of time required [7]. Furthermore, the time-series re-
published on the Internet January 25, 2006. sults have limited use in developing lifetime predictions.
J. J. Nelson is with the Hybrid Development Center, DaimlerChrysler AG, An analytical method to evaluate transient junction tempera-
Troy, MI 48083 USA.
G. Venkataramanan is with the Department of Electrical and Computer ture of semiconductor devices using Fourier techniques in fre-
Engineering, University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI 53706 USA (e-mail: quency domain is presented in this paper. Simple mathematical
giri@engr.wisc.edu). analysis computer software that can solve basic mathematical
A. M. EL-Refaie is with the Electric Machines and Drives Laboratory, GE
Global Research Center, Niskayuna, NY 12309 USA. functions can be used to implement the model. Frequency-
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TIE.2006.870714 domain analysis procedure resolves problems for applications
Fig. 1. Possible (a) T-model thermal equivalent circuit and (b) π-model thermal equivalent circuit for IGBT module.
Fig. 3. (a) SaberSketch π-thermal equivalent circuit from junction-to-case of TO-247 MOSFET device under test. (b) Thermal simulation result (only a few
seconds to simulate).
junction-to-ambient thermal response in the π-thermal model was derived from the π-model given by the manufacturer [8].
is equivalent to the T-model; however, no knowledge exists The π-model is appropriate because only junction temperature
of each layer in the physical device. The advantage of the variations are required in this analysis.
π-thermal model is the ease of obtaining it compared with the It is important to note that this thermal model technique
complexity of obtaining the T-thermal model. There are many still leaves several nonlinear phenomena, for instance, heat
techniques available for determining accurate T- and π-thermal spreading, voids, crack propagation, inhomogeneous temper-
models for power devices [1]–[6] and [9]–[12]. ature distribution on the chip caused by the influence of the
The implementation of thermal profiling using Fourier tech- bond wires, and second-order effects [1], [13], [14]. However,
niques can use either the T- or π-models. Whereas the T-model their effects may be included through further modification of
retains one-to-one correspondence to the actual physical device, the technique using multidimensional networks and Fourier
the π-model has fictitious nodes unrelated to the physical device solutions of the heat-flow equations.
and hence can be used only when the junction temperature is
required. The frequency-domain representation of the thermal
B. Fourier Analysis
impedance of the system is required for application with the
Fourier analysis technique presented in this paper. Fig. 2 shows The proposed technique transforms the time-dependent de-
the thermal impedance over frequency for the TO-247 package vice power loss waveform to a frequency-dependent representa-
MOSFET used in the analysis in Sections II and IV and tion. The advantage of working in the frequency domain is that
524 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INDUSTRIAL ELECTRONICS, VOL. 53, NO. 2, APRIL 2006
Fig. 6. (a) Diagram of the calculated power losses and the measured output current of the IGBT module. The top waveform corresponds to the total calculated
power loss, the next corresponds to both IGBT calculated power losses, the next waveform to the measured output current, and the bottom waveform to both diode
calculated power losses. (b) Equivalent thermal T-model for diode and IGBT used in evaluation [20].
a known input function. This time difference only becomes equations used are based on standard electrical loss models
greater when a long time-load cycle is introduced. [19] and are used along with data from the manufacturer’s data
The effects of thermal capacitance play an important role in sheets. The power module input was 600 VDC with a 1.2-Ω
time-varying loads. Fig. 5 illustrates the comparison of only resistive load. The switching frequency was time dependent
considering a resistive thermal model and the complete resistive and could range from 5 to 15 kHz. The measured current and
and capacitive thermal model. In both situations, the average Tj calculated power losses are shown in Fig. 6(a). The thermal
are identically 23.05 ◦ C. However, average Tj does not provide lump parameter model shown in Fig. 6(b) was derived from
adequate information to make proper reliability and maximum an FEA thermal model and experimental validation of the
temperature analysis. When the thermal capacitance is ignored, test bed [20].
the Tj has a temporal difference of over 45 ◦ C. Using the more Fig. 7(a) shows nearly perfect agreement between the ex-
accurate model with thermal capacitance, the Tj difference perimental junction temperature and the calculated junction
lowers to below 25 ◦ C. This has a significant impact on the temperature using the FFT method. Because of the fast nature
reliability analysis of the power device. of this method, the effects of changing the heat sink can easily
be performed without much effort. With a 100 times increase
in the heat sink thermal capacitance, the temporal temperature
III. E XPERIMENTAL V ALIDATION OF THE F AST F OURIER
delta lowers by less than 1 ◦ C. A 50% reduction in the heat
T RANSFORM (FFT) M ETHOD
sink thermal resistance provides nearly 20 ◦ C drop in absolute
The described FFT method has been validated with exper- maximum temperature, but presents roughly no change in the
imental measurements. A half-bridge configured Fuji IGBT temporal temperature delta. Fig. 7(b) shows the simulated
power module with two IGBTs and two antiparallel diodes was effect of ignoring the spatial temperature effect from the anti-
used in the validation [18]. The IGBT and diode power loss parallel diode.
526 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON INDUSTRIAL ELECTRONICS, VOL. 53, NO. 2, APRIL 2006
Fig. 8. The Federal Test Procedure (FTP) made up of the UDDS repeated by
the first 505 s, again of the UDDS.
Fig. 11. Junction temperature for a single MOSFET/body diode device from
top switches utilizing the thermal model of Fig. 6 and at 25 ◦ C ambient
temperature.
R EFERENCES
[1] P. Rodgers and V. Eveloy, “Prediction of microelectronics thermal behav-
ior in electronic equipment: Status, challenges and future requirements,”
in Proc. EuroSimE, Aix-en-Provence, France, Mar. 30–Apr. 2, 2003,
pp. 29–39.
[2] C. Yun, P. Malberti, M. Ciappa, and W. Fichtner, “Thermal component
model for electrothermal analysis of IGBT module systems,” IEEE Trans.
Adv. Packag., vol. 24, no. 3, pp. 401–406, Aug. 2001.
[3] P. Türkes, “Thermal network calculation for level-3 compact models,”
Corporate Technology Siemens AG, Munich, Germany, Aug. 8, 2001.
[4] J. Sigg, P. Türkes, and R. Kraus, “Parameter extraction methodology and
validation for an electro-thermal physics-based NPT IGBT model,” in
Conf. Rec. IEEE-IAS Annu. Meeting, 1997, vol. 2, pp. 1166–1173.
[5] P. Igic, P. Mawby, and M. Towers, “Physics-based dynamic electro-
thermal models of power bipolar devices (PiN diode and IGBT),”
in Proc. IEEE Int. Symp. Power Semiconductor Devices ICs, 2001,
pp. 381–384.
[6] D. Xu, H. Lu, L. Huang, S. Azuma, M. Kimata, and R. Uchida, “Power
loss and junction temperature analysis of power semiconductor devices,”
in Proc. IEEE Industry Applications Conf., 1999, pp. 729–734.
[7] B. Ozpineci, L. Tolbert, S. Islam, and M. Hasanuzzaman, “Effects
of silicon carbide (SiC) power devices on HEV PWM inverter
losses,” in Proc. IEEE Industrial Electronics Society Conf., 2001,
pp. 1187–1192.
Fig. 12. Power cycling results for IGBT module showing the number of
[8] HUFA75652G3—UltraFET Power MOSFET. (Fairchild Semiconduc-
cycles to failure Nf as a function of mean temperature Tm and delta junction
tor Data Sheet), Fairchild Semiconductor Corp., South Portland, ME,
temperature ∆Tj [23].
Dec. 2001.
[9] V. Blasko, R. Lukaszewski, and R. Sladky, “On line thermal model and
VI. C ONCLUSION thermal management strategy of a three phase voltage source inverter,”
in Proc. IEEE Industry Applications Soc. Conf., 1999, pp. 1423–1431.
This paper has presented a fast thermal profiling method of [10] G. Skibinski and W. Sethares, “Thermal parameter estimation using
recursive identification,” IEEE Trans. Power Electron., vol. 6, no. 2,
power semiconductor devices using Fourier techniques. The pp. 228–239, Apr. 1991.
method relies on the use of the classical transient thermal [11] J. Sofia, “Analysis of thermal transient data with synthesized dynamic
equivalent circuit to predict junction temperature variations models for semiconductor devices,” in Proc. Electro/99 Tech. Progam,
Jun. 15–16, 1999, pp. 117–224.
in the presence of varying load cycles common with power [12] U. Hecht and U. Scheuermann, “Static and transient thermal resistance
converters. Transient thermal impedances developed from such of advanced power modules,” in Proc. PCIM, Nürnberg, Germany, 2001,
equivalent circuits have been used in the past for thermal design pp. 229–305.
[13] J. Thebaud, E. Woirgard, C. Zardini, and K. Sommer, “High power
under pulsed loading of semiconductors. They have also been IGBT modules: Thermal fatigue resistance evaluation of the solder
used in conjunction with time-domain simulation techniques joints,” in Proc. IEEE Int. Workshop Integrated Power Packaging, 2000,
to obtain a time-series solution of junction temperatures. On pp. 79–83.
[14] Z. Khatir and S. Lefebvre, “Thermal analysis of high power IGBT
contrast, the approach presented here uses a frequency-domain modules,” in Proc. IEEE Int. Symp. Power Semiconductor Devices ICs,
representation of the semiconductor power loss along with the May 2000, pp. 271–274.
thermal equivalent circuit to represent the temperature profile [15] Synopsys, Inc. SaberSketch, Version 2.4. Mountain View, CA. [Online].
Available: http://www.synopsys.com/
also in the frequency domain. The model can be implemented [16] Matlab. The MathWorks, Inc., Natick, MA. [Online]. Available: http://
using general-purpose mathematical analysis software. A prac- www.mathworks.com/
tical load cycle example of a hybrid vehicle application was [17] Mathcad. MathSoft Engineering & Education, Inc., Cambridge, MA.
[Online]. Available: http://www.mathcad.com/
used to demonstrate the application of the technique. Although [18] 2MBI150NB-120 2-pack IGBT, 150 A, 1200 V. (Fuji Data Sheet), Fuji
only MOSFETs were used in the illustrative example, the Electric Device Technology Co., Ltd, Tokyo, Japan, Mar. 2000.
technique can be extended for analysis of other devices and [19] J. W. Kolar, H. Ertl, and F.C. Zach, “Calculation of the passive and
active component stress of three-phase PWM converter systems with high
more complex geometries of thermal management systems. The pulse rate,” in Proc. Eur. Conf. Power Electronics Applications, Aachen,
technique can be used in conjunction with Fourier methods for Germany, Oct. 1989, vol. III, pp. 1303–1311.
heat conduction and convection studies to develop fast solutions [20] D. Murdock, “Active thermal control of power electronic modules,”
M.S. thesis, Dept. Elect. Comput. Eng., Univ. Wisconsin, Madison,
of thermal system to allow optimization of design parameters. Aug. 2002.
Furthermore, statistical analysis techniques can be coupled with [21] E. C. Lovelace, “Optimization of a magnetically saturable interior
the frequency-domain model to obtain reliability distributions. permanent-magnet synchronous machine drive,” Ph.D. dissertation, Dept.
Elect. Eng. Comput. Sci., MIT, Cambridge, MA, Jun. 2000.
[22] L. Tolbert, B. Ozpineci, S. Islam, and F. Peng, Impact of SiC Power
Electronic Devices for Hybrid Electric Vehicles. Warrendale, PA: SAE,
ACKNOWLEDGMENT 2002.
[23] M. Held, P. Jacob, G. Nicoletti, P. Scacco, and M.-H. Poech, “Fast power
The authors thank the Wisconsin Electric Machines and cycling test for IGBT modules in traction application,” in Proc. IEEE
Power Electronics Consortium (WEMPEC) and the Graduate Power Electronics and Drive Systems, 1997, vol. 1, pp. 425–430.
NELSON et al.: FAST THERMAL PROFILING OF POWER SEMICONDUCTOR DEVICES USING FOURIER TECHNIQUES 529
Jody J. Nelson received the B.S. and M.S. degrees Ayman M. EL-Refaie (S’95) received the B.Sc.
in electrical engineering from the University of Wis- and M.Sc. degrees in electrical power engineering
consin, Madison, in 2000 and 2002, respectively. from Cairo University, Cairo, Egypt, in 1995 and
Since 2002, he has been with DaimlerChrysler 1998, respectively, and the M.S. degree in electri-
AG, Stuttgart, Germany, working in research and cal engineering from the University of Wisconsin,
development. His work has focused on automotive Madison, in 2002. He is currently working to-
electromagnetic compatibility with emphasis on ward the Ph.D. degree at the University of Wiscon-
power electronics, including the hybrid and fuel cell sin in the Wisconsin Electric Machines and Power
vehicles. Electronics Consortium Group.
Between 1995–1998, he was an Assistant Lecturer
at Cairo University and the American University in
Cairo, Cairo, Egypt. He participated in many projects involving the design
of electrical power distribution systems. Since 1999, he has been a Research
Giri Venkataramanan (S’86–M’86) received the Assistant at the University of Wisconsin. His interests include electrical
B.E. degree from the Government College of Tech- machines and drives.
nology, Coimbatore, India, the M.S. degree from
the California Institute of Technology, Pasadena,
and the Ph.D. degree from the University of
Wisconsin, Madison, in 1986, 1987, and 1992,
respectively, all in electrical engineering.
After teaching electrical engineering at Montana
State University, Bozeman, he returned to the Uni-
versity of Wisconsin, Madison, as a Faculty Member
in 1999, where he continues to direct research in
various areas of electronic power conversion as an Associate Director of the
Wisconsin Electric Machines and Power Electronics Consortium. He is the
author or coauthor of a number of published technical papers and is the holder
of five U.S. patents. His interests are in the areas of microgrids, distributed
generation, renewable energy systems, matrix and multilevel power converters,
and ac power flow control.