Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Edited by Sarah Tennant1, Karen Pearce1, Chris Turney2 and Katherine Harle3
This document is based on Building a future on knowledge from the past: what palaeo-science can reveal
about climate change and its potential impacts in Australia, a scientific report prepared for the Department of
Climate Change. The full report, including a comprehensive reference list of the scientific papers cited, can
be obtained at www.climatechange.gov.au
The scientific report was prepared by CSIRO in association with scientific collaborators:
Katherine Harle3, David Etheridge3, Mike Barbetti4, Roger Jones3, Brendan Brooke5, Penny Whetton3, Tas van
Ommen6, Ian Goodwin7 and Simon Haberle8
1
Australian Climate Change Science Programme
2
GeoQuEST Research Centre, University of Wollongong
3
CSIRO
4
University of Queensland
5
Geoscience Australia
6
Australian Antarctic Division & ACE CRC
7
University of Newcastle
8
Australian National University
9
Australian Nuclear Science and Technology Organisation
10
Macquarie University
11
Monash University
12
Bureau of Meteorology
TABlE OF CONTENTS
Palaeo-records in Australia_____________________________________________________________________ 8
Terrestrial records ________________________________________________________________________ 8
Tree rings ____________________________________________________________________________ 8
Cave deposits _________________________________________________________________________ 9
Wetland sediments ____________________________________________________________________ 9
River, lake and dune geomorphology ___________________________________________________10
Coastal sediments ____________________________________________________________________11
Glacial deposits ______________________________________________________________________12
Marine records__________________________________________________________________________12
Corals_______________________________________________________________________________12
Ocean sediments _____________________________________________________________________13
Antarctic records ________________________________________________________________________14
ExECUTIvE SUMMARy
Climate leaves an imprint on the planet – in the chemical and physical structure of its oceans, life and land. In
much the same way that archaeologists reveal past cultures by looking at artefacts, or detectives reconstruct a
crime by piecing together evidence found at the scene, scientists gather evidence stored in the environment to
reconstruct the history of Earth’s climate over hundreds of thousands – and in some cases millions – of years.
When combined with observations of Earth’s modern climate, evidence from the past can help us understand
our present climate and predict what future climates might be like.
In Australia, high quality instrumental climate records only extend back to the late 19th century, providing just
a brief snapshot of our climate’s natural state and its variability. To understand the nature of our present climate
and, in turn, predict our future climate we need data that go back far beyond the instrumental record. This is
where palaeo-science comes in.
Palaeo-science provides the means to extend climate records back tens to thousands of years. Palaeo (meaning
‘ancient’) records include direct and indirect (proxy) evidence of past atmospheric, terrestrial and marine
conditions. The records are derived directly from the environment itself, rather than from historical documents
and instrumental measurements. This evidence is wide ranging, including landscape features (such as ancient
lake shorelines), and biological, chemical and isotopic material stored in sediments, ice sheets, tree rings, cave
deposits and corals. Palaeo-records provide a powerful tool for reconstructing not only past climates, but also
the drivers of climate change (including atmospheric concentrations of greenhouse gases), and the impacts
that climate change has had on the environment.
We now have the geographic coverage and temporal resolution
from palaeo-records to identify and understand cycles of climate
Palaeo-records provide us variation and change across the Australasian region that are not
with the means to understand evident in the instrumental records. This presents an opportunity to
test and improve not only our understanding of climate change and
the degree to which current variability in Australia, but also the processes driving climate change.
climate change is due to This knowledge in turn can be used to test the ability of models to
natural cycles and human simulate climate, improving that ability of scientists to predict future
climatic conditions. Palaeo-records provide the length of records
influences. necessary for testing climate models that instrumental records are
simply too short to provide.
Importantly, palaeo-records provide us with the means to understand the degree to which current climate
change is due to natural cycles and to human influences. Critical to this has been the measurement of
greenhouse gases trapped in air bubbles in ice sheets (especially from Antarctica and Greenland). This direct
evidence of atmospheric composition (a key driver in climate change) has allowed scientists to determine the
variation in atmospheric greenhouse gases over the last 700,000 years, demonstrating clearly that the current
concentrations are not only well above ‘natural’ levels but that they are also accumulating at faster rates.
Similarly, palaeo-records have been used to identify the roles that aerosol concentrations, solar irradiance and
land cover change have had in climate forcing, both pre and post-industrial times (~1750 AD).
The information provided by palaeo-research is invaluable in helping explain how and why our climate
has changed in the past and, ultimately, in helping us to assess and plan for climate change in the future.
Surrounded by oceans, Australia’s location in the Southern Hemisphere puts us in a unique position to
contribute to the global understanding of climate change. There has recently been a push to bring together
the growing number of palaeo-records to carry out cross-regional, national scale analyses to fill important
geographical and chronological gaps in the climate record. This would allow the production of an Australian
data set to rival that of the Northern Hemisphere, providing valuable information of past climate variation in
the Australian region.
This overview is an introduction to the value of palaeo-science in the understanding of climate change in
Australia. It is based on a technical report prepared for the Department of Climate Change by CSIRO in
association with collaborators from other scientific institutions. The technical report should be referred to for
a comprehensive analysis of the potential of palaeo-science to contribute to understanding climate change in
Australia.
AN INTRODUCTION TO PAlAEO-RECORDS
Scales of evidence
The palaeo-climate records that are currently available in the
Australian region cover a range of scales in time and space
In Australia, high quality instrumental climate (see Table 1).
records only extend back to the late 19th century.
The range of spatial scales is limited by the location of
environments suitable for palaeo-records to form, such as
the presence of suitable cave deposits and moister climates for wetlands and bogs.
The timescales covered by palaeo-records range from the seasonal through to the millennial. Corals, tree
rings and some coastal Antarctic ice cores have provided records showing seasonal changes. They have also
produced records spanning decades and even millennia, as have some terrestrial sediment archives.
Other palaeo-records, both on land and in the ocean,can only provide longer-term records. This is in part
due to inadequacies in the sampling technique or the dating resolution, but in many cases is due to the
nature of the record itself.
Decadal/ subdecadal
Greenhouse gases
Ocean circulation
Sediment budget
vegetation & fire
Wind strength
Temperature
Precipitation
temperature
Evaporation
Sea surface
Ice volume
Hydrology
Millennial
Seasonal
Sea level
coNTiNUoUS
Antarctic ice cores 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
corals 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Tree rings 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
cave deposits 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Marine sediments 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
Wetland sediments 3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
diScoNTiNUoUS
coastal deposits 3 3 3 3 3
River, lake & dune
3 3 3 3 3 3 3 3
geomorphology
Glacial deposits 3 3 3 3
Table 1: Summary of the types of evidence palaeo-records can provide about past climates and climate change impacts.
With recent advances in sample collection, dating and analysis, it is now possible to produce high resolution,
high quality records capable of extending our climate records considerably beyond the instrumental records.
Although some geographical gaps exist for key periods, the range of palaeo-records available means that
we are now in a position to compare evidence for past climate change and variability both across the
Australasian region and globally. This will significantly improve our understanding of the Earth’s climate
system.
Dating palaeo-records
Providing an age framework for palaeo-records using dating techniques is essential to our ability to use
palaeo-records to understand the processes, drivers and cycles of past climate change and variability.
Standard dating techniques used in Australia are based on:
• the decay of radioactive elements
• the accumulation over time of trapped electrons
• time-dependent chemical reactions
• the counting of annual layers, such as in trees and corals.
large widespread events, such as volcanic eruptions or radioactive testing, can also be used as time markers
The most common dating methods used in Australia are shown in Table 2.
• oceanic
• continental.
These records can then be compared to provide a holistic picture of past climate change.
Due to our location surrounded by several major oceanic and atmospheric controls, Australia’s palaeo
records also provide information on a range of climate-influencing factors including:
• the West Pacific Warm Pool
• the Indian Ocean Dipole
• the El Niño-Southern Oscillation (ENSO)
• tropical monsoon flow
• mid-latitude westerlies
• Southern Ocean circulation.
Finally, sites in the Australian region provide valuable data about climate change and climate change impacts
on a global scale, for example:
• ice cores provide valuable information about changes in greenhouse gas concentrations
• tree rings can be used to explore changes in the global carbon budget
• corals and microfossils in marine environments help reconstruct past sea level changes.
Overall, Australia is in a unique position to contribute to a regional and global understanding of how climate
systems have operated and how shifts in global climate systems have impacted on our regional climates in
the past.
PAlAEO-RECORDS IN AUSTRAlIA
Terrestrial records
Australia is fortunate in that it has not been affected by widespread glaciations, which are responsible for
destroying much of the evidence for past environments in large areas of the Northern Hemisphere. Although
the variety, continuity and resolution of many Australian terrestrial records have been affected by the arid
nature of much of the continent and by slow rates of sedimentation, a wide range of evidence does exist
which can provide us with valuable insights into past climates and climatic processes.
Tree rings
Since tree growth is influenced by climatic conditions, patterns in tree ring widths, density and chemical
composition reflect variations in the climate. In temperate regions, where there is a distinct growing season,
trees generally produce one ring a year. This provides an annual record of climatic conditions. Trees can
grow to be hundreds, even thousands, of years old and can provide information about the environment and
climate conditions at both annual and seasonal scales. This study of tree rings is called dendrochronology.
Although most Australian tree species do not produce consistent annual rings, tree rings from some species
have been used to:
• investigate climate change and climate variability over the last 10,000 years
• collect information about changes in atmospheric CO2 levels
• establish relationships between climatic variables and atmospheric and land surface processes.
Cave deposits
As water runs through the ground it picks up minerals
such as calcium carbonate. When mineral-rich water
drips into caves, it leaves behind solid mineral
deposits which accumulate as icicle-like rocks that
hang from the ceiling (stalactites) and rounded
columns that grow from the floor (stalagmites). These
deposits are collectively termed speleothems.
Wetland sediments
The moist, low oxygen environments in which lake,
swamp and bog sediments are deposited are ideal for Taking a terrestrial core from Lynch’s Crater,
the preservation of a range of fossils including pollen, Atherton Tableland, north-east Queensland.
charcoal and animal remains. These sediments also store Photo: Chris Turney.
temperature
balance
Coastal sediments
Australian coastal sediments have much to tell us about the nature and impacts of past climate processes
and change in areas that are currently highly populated. Of particular importance are beach ridges and
coastal dunes.
Beach ridges are formed when waves and offshore winds move sediments, forming ridges parallel to the
shore. These provide useful records of the character and rate of beach sediment accumulation and of the
configuration of the coast under past climates and atmospheric circulation regimes. Sediments within these
deposits also provide a record of past sea level and the passage, frequency and magnitude of past storm
events such as cyclones.
Coastal dunes record the delivery of sand to beach systems by onshore winds. These deposits can provide
records of shoreline deposition and coastal landscape instability as well as ancient wind regimes and, in turn,
atmospheric circulation. Successions of dune deposits, such as those on the Coorong coastal plain of South
Australia, can provide long-term (over several hundred thousand years) records of dune mobility and long
quiescent periods when soil horizons were formed.
The great advantage of these records is they can provide a relatively detailed history of coastal
environmental change over tens to thousands of years. The disadvantage is that they provide non
continuous records of climate change.
Glacial deposits
Glacial deposits in the highland regions of mainland south-eastern Australia and Tasmania provide evidence
of climates during past ice ages, contributing to the understanding of past processes and drivers of climate
change.
The analysis of glacial and inter-glacial deposits has provided estimates of past temperatures and rainfall
during glacial periods, such as the last ice age. This has improved our understanding of the regional
hydrology of south-eastern Australia during ice ages and the response of the environment to significantly
colder climates.
The most significant limitation of Australian glacial deposits is their restricted distribution and discontinuous
nature. Additionally, uncertainties associated with dating and the combined role of rainfall and temperature
in glacier formation can complicate the interpretation of the evidence. The strength of these landscape
features, however, is that they are one of the few proxy indicators of temperature in a landscape dominated
by the effects of changes in moisture.
Marine records
Corals
Corals have hard, calcium carbonate skeletons that form in seasonal and annual bands. These bands contain
physical, isotopic and geochemical evidence of past atmospheric and oceanic conditions at annual and sub-
annual resolution.
Physical characteristics of the bands (such as skeletal density, tissue thickness and calcification rate) provide
time-series information about the environmental conditions that controlled coral growth, such as sea surface
temperature.
Measurement of stable isotopes and the geochemistry in corals can provide information about sea surface
temperature, sea surface salinity and the hydrological balance of oceans. In regions where the isotopic
composition of seawater correlates with precipitation, coral records can also be used to reconstruct
precipitation.
luminescent banding found in corals has been used to provide a proxy for precipitation and river run-off
from adjacent land masses. It has also been used in the identification of the movement of ocean surface
waters3,4.
Australian scientists are at the forefront of coral research, using high quality records gathered from around
Australia and the adjacent oceans to reconstruct:
• past changes in climate variability
• movement of ocean waters
• ocean-atmospheric interactions
Ocean sediments
Sediments deposited in ocean and lake basins each
year contain a variety of evidence for past climatic
conditions, including microfossils (fossils of tiny
marine organisms), and geochemical and isotopic
signatures. Analyses of the types and abundance
of fossil species, their chemical and isotopic
composition, and of the chemical composition
of the sediments themselves provide evidence of
changes in past:
• ocean circulation
• ocean productivity
• sea surface temperatures
• sea surface salinity
• sea levels
• global ice volume.
Marine cores can also capture information from
adjacent terrestrial environments. For example:
• The pollen and charcoal contained within
marine cores from around Australia have
provided evidence of shifts in vegetation
and fire regimes in response to climatic
fluctuations.
• variations in the dust content of cores
from the Tasman Sea have been used to
reconstruct past changes in aridity, wind
direction and velocity over the Australian
continent.
Deep sea sediment cores are particularly valuable,
and can be used to piece together past global
and regional changes in oceanic and climatic
conditions. They are widely distributed, can be
correlated across large distances, and provide some
of the longest, most continuous records of past
climates.
The major drawback of marine cores is that
sedimentation rates are generally low, limiting high
resolution analyses.
Antarctic records
There is increasing evidence that the climate of the southern high latitudes, in particular Antarctica, is
closely linked to the global climate system. Palaeo-records from Antarctica are therefore vitally important in
understanding the mechanisms of global climate change, including the influence of human activities.
Ice sheets are natural time capsules, preserving records of hundreds of thousands of years of past climate
change, variability and atmospheric composition. Each year, layers of snow fall over the ice sheets in
Greenland and Antarctica, trapping a wealth of information about the climatic and atmospheric conditions.
Depending on snowfall rates, ice records can cover
recent decades in great detail or extend back hundreds of
thousands of years. The longest records have been obtained
from the central regions of Antarctica and Greenland. Sample
resolutions on these longer cores tend to be fairly coarse
– in the order of tens of years or more – largely due to the
compaction of ice at these great depths. However, shorter
ice cores extracted from the coastal areas of Antarctica are
capable of providing much higher resolutions (up to two
weeks). The trade-off, however, is that such cores tend to
span much shorter time periods, generally of the order of
only 400 years.
Ice cores can provide an annual record of temperature,
precipitation, atmospheric composition, volcanic activity, and
Analysis of air bubbles in ice cores provides a wind patterns. For example, the thickness of each annual
means for identifying changes in atmospheric layer tells how much snow accumulated at that location
composition. during the year, providing proxy evidence of precipitation
changes, as well as an understanding of past changes in
the ice sheet mass-balance. This in turn can be used to
reconstruct past sea level variations. Analyses of fluctuations in the isotope content in ice cores have been
used to reconstruct changes in surface air temperatures over Antarctica and surrounding oceans through
time, as well as the changes in ice volume. Evidence for changes in ice volume has in turn been used to
reconstruct changes in sea levels through time. In addition, differences in cores taken from the same area
can reveal local wind patterns by showing where the snow drifted. This in turn can be used to reconstruct
changes in atmospheric circulation.
The aerosol content of Antarctic ice cores has also
been a valuable source of information about past
climate change and impacts. Aerosols are fine
particles suspended in the atmosphere, and they
Ice sheets are natural time capsules include:
• continental dust
• emissions from volcanic eruptions
• human-created sulphate and soot from biomass
burning.
Some of the ice core aerosol studies that have been carried have detected evidence of:
• changes in the extent of sea ice, conditions in the surrounding ocean, atmospheric circulation and
precipitation over Antarctica and Australia through analysis of changes in sodium concentrations,
largely produced by sea salt from the oceans surrounding Antarctica
• continental aridity, wind strength and trajectories, and indirectly, precipitation through analysis of dust
content
• biological productivity through time, which can be related to past climatic changes and sea ice extent,
through analysis of biogenic sulphur tracers.
Australian instrumental climate records, which generally extend back to the late 19th century, give evidence
of an Australia-wide warming trend since the 1950s.
From the instrumental record we know that Australia’s mean annual maximum temperatures have increased
by 0.06°C/decade and mean minimum temperatures by 0.12°C/decade over the period 1910 to 2004. Shifts
in rainfall have been less spatially consistent, although there has been a general trend for hotter droughts.
Climate model simulations indicate that the warming is likely to have been caused by both natural variability
and the enhanced greenhouse effect. To unravel how much of the 20th century warming can be explained
by natural causes and how much by human influences, we need to examine our climate over a longer
timeframe than the instrumental record allows, and use palaeo-records.
• Microfossil records from lakes and the oceans provide information on how aquatic fauna (freshwater
and marine) responded to shifts in climatic conditions.
• Coral cores give evidence of how corals have responded to changes in sea surface temperature, sea
surface salinity and river run-off.
• Palaeo-lake and river records provide an insight to the combined effects of changes in precipitation,
temperature and evaporation on water sources.
• Palaeo-river sequences provide evidence of erosion with high sediment loads interpreted as erosion
events associated with increased rainfall and possibly the interaction of aridity, rainfall and vegetation.
• Dust records provide valuable information about the influence of climate on erosion. For instance, dust
contained in marine records in the Tasman Sea has been used to reconstruct the scale of wind erosion
from the Australian continent under different climate regimes.
It is widely accepted that the main control of atmospheric carbon dioxide concentrations are processes
operating within the oceans, which include:
• changes in sea surface temperature and salinity (the solubility pump)
• the supply and removal of total carbon dioxide (the biological pump)
• alkalinity of surface waters (the alkalinity pump)
• surface winds
• variations in sea ice cover.
Palaeo-records enable the reconstruction of how these drivers of oceanic-atmospheric carbon dioxide
exchange have operated in the past. For example:
• Chemical analysis of marine cores has provided an insight into the operation of the biological pump in
the Southern Ocean during significant changes to our climate.
• Tree ring studies have identified an apparent shut-down of the flux of carbon dioxide from the ocean
into the atmosphere during El Niño events.
Palaeo-records also
indicate fluctuations in
atmospheric carbon under
different climate regimes
and, importantly, allow
us to investigate past
interactions between
carbon sinks and the
atmosphere.
Ice core evidence shows
significant fluctuations
in atmospheric carbon
dioxide levels in response
to the onset of glacial and
inter-glacial periods. These
levels typically increased
between 80 and 100
ppm as climates became
warmer in the transitions
Records indicate the ocean has been a sink of carbon dioxide throughout most from glacial to inter-glacial
of the past 200 years.
periods.
Evidence of carbon cycling over the last few hundred years using modelling of ice core data shows how the
terrestrial biosphere has changed from a carbon source to a sink in more recent decades. Natural climatic
variations, often connected with ENSO, have also influenced terrestrial carbon dioxide uptake. Records
indicate the ocean has been a sink of carbon dioxide throughout most of the past 200 years. How the
Australian terrestrial carbon sinks will respond to increasing carbon dioxide in the future is a new area of
uncertainty in future Australian climate change scenarios.
In recent years there has been significant progress in developing more sophisticated and higher resolution
palaeo-climate records. These advances are opening up exciting opportunities to extend climate records
back far beyond the instrumental records and improve our understanding of climatic variability. It will also
help determine how climate change affects terrestrial and marine environments. This information can, in
turn, provide valuable input to decisions on how to plan for the impacts of future climate change.
However, there are still many important gaps in our knowledge of past climates. This is particularly true for
records which provide information about short-term climate variations. The majority of records extend back
only a few thousand years, so do not encompass the full range of possible natural variability. In some cases
(such as with ice core and lake sediment records) there is potential for extension considerably further back in
time.
There also exists a distinct spatial bias in palaeo-records within the Australian region which needs to be
overcome. This is largely a factor of site suitability, but is also due to the relatively small number of
researchers working in the Australian region (relative to efforts in the Northern Hemisphere).
There are many sites and avenues of palaeo-science yet to be explored. More spatial information is required
to help understand the sources and sinks of greenhouse gases, while more accurate, high-resolution dating
is necessary to reveal the mechanisms of past climatic change. There is also much to be learnt from applying
new dating techniques to key palaeo-records that have already been obtained.
At present, much of the research effort of the
Australian palaeo-science community and its
collaborators has been focused on the acquisition
There are many sites and of records, with only limited comparisons being
avenues of palaeo-science yet undertaken. In essence, only now is there sufficient
coverage to carry out multi-proxy, cross-regional
to be explored. comparisons and correlations. Some efforts are
being made in this area, but further coordination
between researchers would be of significant benefit.
So far, such efforts have largely been driven by researchers and data sets from the Northern Hemisphere.
In many cases, the Southern Hemisphere data is inadequately represented. We are now in the position to
bring together the growing number of palaeo-records in order to produce a climate reconstruction for the
Southern Hemisphere. Australia is the only country with the research capacity and infrastructure to lead
efforts in using palaeo-data to test climate models for our region.
Finally, there is a need for palaeo-scientists to improve the communication with policy makers and natural
resource managers. There is significant potential for palaeo-records to improve our understanding of the
climate system and provide an insight into how our environment will respond to future climate change.
Australia is well placed to make major contributions in the area of palaeo-science – which will ultimately play
a pivotal role in understanding and constraining uncertainties about future climate change and its potential
impacts for Australia.
FURTHER READING
More information is available in Building a future on knowledge from the past: what palaeo-science can
revealabout climate change and its potential impacts in Australia, a scientific report prepared for the Department
of Climate Change.
The full report, including a comprehensive reference list of the scientific papers cited, can be obtained at
www.climatechange.gov.au.
GlOSSARy
aerosol fine liquid or solid particles in the atmosphere, e.g. dust, smog, fog
albedo a measure of reflectivity
carbon sink a process taking in CO2 from the atmosphere
dendrochronology the analysis of annual tree rings
ENSO El Niño-Southern Oscillation
geomorphology characteristics of landforms
glacial the cold stage of a fixed cycle of warm and cool periods during a major
ice age (such as the Quaternary), during which glaciers advance across
much of the globe.
Indian Ocean Dipole anomalous warming and cooling of sea surface temperatures
inter-glacial the warm stage of a fixed cycle of warm and cool periods during a major
ice age (such as the Quaternary), during which climates ameliorates to
similar levels to those of today.
palaeo from Greek palaios meaning old, ancient or prehistoric. Commonly used
to denote evidence of past environments not contained in instrumental or
documented records (commonly known as historic records)
radioactive isotope a radionuclide is an atom with an unstable nucleus. The radionuclide
undergoes radioactive decay by emitting a gamma ray(s) and/or
subatomic particles.
radiocarbon Carbon-14
speleothem a mineral deposit of calcium carbonate that precipitates from solution in
a cave. The two most common forms are stalagmites (which extend up
from a cave floor) and stalactites (which extend down from a cave roof).
stable isotope an isotope of a chemical element which is not spontaneously radioactive
West Pacific Warm Pool a body of warm water extending through the waters off Sumatra, Java,
Borneo, and New Guinea, and into the central Pacific Ocean.
NOTES
1
After Williams, M., D. Dunkerley, Kershaw, P., Chappell, J. (1998). Quaternary Environments. london, Arnold. p 271.
2
Williams, M., D. Dunkerley, Kershaw, P., Chappell, J. (1998). Quaternary Environments. london, Arnold.
3
See Hua, Q., Woodroffe, C.D., Barbetti, M., Smithers, S.G., Zoppi, U. and Fink, D. (2004). Marine reservoir
correction for the Cocos (Keeling) Islands, Indian Ocean. Radiocarbon, 46(2): 603-610.
4
Hughen, K.A., Baillie, M.G.l., Bard, E., Beck, J.W., Bertrand, C.J.H., Blackwell, P.G., Buck, C.E., Burr, G.S., Cutler,
K.B., Damon, P.E., Edwards, R.l., Fairbanks, R.G., Friedrich, M., Guilderson, T.P., Kromer, B., McCormac, G.,
Manning, S., Ramsey, C.B., Reimer, P.J., Reimer, R.W., Remmele, S., Southon, J.R., Stuiver, M., Talamo, S., Taylor,
F.W.; van der Plicht, J. and Weyhenmeyer, C.E. (2004). MARINE04 marine radiocarbon age calibration, 0-26 cal kyr
BP. Radiocarbon, 46(3): 1059–1086.