You are on page 1of 60

Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.

htm

`jP]f
; spd; ngauhy;... ,g;gbAk; rpy `jP]f
; s;!?
Mrphpau;: K.M. Kfk;kJ KifjPd; cytp> ntspaPL: ijkpa;ah gg;spNf\d;];> kJiu.

gjpg;Giu
Kd;Diu
1. kf;fhit tpl kjPdh rpwe;jjh?
2. `[;[{f;F ele;J nrd;why; mjpf ed;ikah?
3. tpgr;rhuk; nra;jhy;...!
4. Fjpiuf; fwp cz;zf;$lhjh?
5. cyfj;jpy; gw;ww;W tho;tJ?
6. njhOifapy; ifia cau;j;jyhkh?
7. Nfhop MlhFkh?
8. [{k;M `[;[hFkh?
9. kiwTWg;igg; ghu;j;jhy;..!
10. jiyg;ghifAld; njhOjhy;...!
11. nra;jp $Wk;NghJ Jk;kyhkh?
12. ngz;fspd; Ngr;irf; Nfl;fyhkh?
13. ngz;Zf;F khW nra;tJ?
14. jyhf; $wNt $lhJ?
15. ,uz;lh? ehd;fh?
16. cz;Zk; Kd;Gk; gpd;Gk; x@?
17. cSr; nra;j gpwF 97tJ mj;jpahak; XJjy;?
18. nts;spad;W...?
19. `a;a myy; /gyh`; vd;W $Wk;NghJ...?
20. nts;spf;fpoik NjhWk;...
21. mq;Nf ahrPd; mj;jpahak; Xjpdhy;...
22. rigapy; ,Ue;J vOk;NghJ...
23. njhOJ nfhz;Nl jhd; ,Uf;f Ntz;Lkh?
24. Rg;`{ njhOifapy; 94 kw;Wk; 105 tJ mj;jpahaq;fis XJjy;?
25. flypy; gazk; nra;ayhkh?
26. cykhf;fis gpd;gw;wj; jhd; Ntz;Lkh?

1 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

27. kpk;ghpy; ,Uf;Fk;NghJ Ngryhkh?


28. tpgr;rhuf; Foe;ijfs;
29. egp(]y;) mtu;fis Nehpy; fhz Ntz;Lkh?
30. egp(]y;) mtu;fis fdtpy; fhz Ntz;Lkh?
31. Nfhgk; Vw;gl;lhy;...?
32. kiof; fhyq;fspy; jhd; kdpjdpd; cs;sk;?
33. mugp nkhop NgRgtd; /ghu;]p nkhopNgrf;$lhJ?
34. gl;L nkj;ijapy; mkuyhkh?
35. ,fhkj; thrfk; xU jlit kl;Lk; $wpdhy; Fw;wkh?
36. mRj;j ,lk; ][;jh nra;jhy; Rj;jkhFkh?
37. jpUkzj;jpw;F Kd; `[; nra;jhy;?
38. Foe;ijf;F K`k;kJ vd ngahplhtpl;lhy;..
39. ngz;fs; tpisahl;L nghUl;fs;?
40. moF> gzk;> ghuk;ghpak; ,tw;wpw;fhf jpUkzk; nra;ayhk;?
41. mofpa Kfk; ,Ug;gpd;...
42. Gwk;NgRtJ?
43. k/hpGf;Fg; gpd; cghpj; njhOif...!
44. jhdpaq;fspy; ]fhj; kjpg;gPL msT vd;d?
45. mwpthsp MfNtz;Lkh?
46. ghtkd;dpg;Gf; fl;lhakhdjy;y!
47. rpye;jpahf khw;wg;gl;l i\j;jhd;?
48. ,ilj;jufu; ,y;iy!?
49. muG kf;fis ntWf;fyhkh?
50. /ghu;]p nkhop rpwe;jjh?
51. mugp jhd; nrhu;f;f nkhopah?
52. tpahghhpAk; tptrhapAk; nfl;ltu;fsh?
53. egp(]y;) Nehpy; re;jpj;j ed;ik ngw...
54. K`k;kJk; K`k;kjpd; je;ijAk; nrhu;f;fk; nry;tu;?
55. egp(]y;) ,Wjp egpah? ,y;iyah?
56. gpufhrpf;Fk; ,Us;?
57. egp(]y;) mtu;fs; VO Jzpfshy; fgdplg;gl;lhu;fsh?
58. ]`u; Neuk; vJtiu?
59. nts;is epwr; Nrtiy cz;zhjPu;?
60. ghtpfSld; Nru;e;Jz;zy;!?
61. ,ukshdpy; Vw;gLk; fLk; rg;jk;?
62. ukshd; vd;W $wf;$lhjh?
63. Fspg;G flikahdtd; fly; ePhpy; Fspf;fyhkh?

2 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

64. Fspg;Gf; flikahdtd; Fspayiwapy; Fspf;fyhkh?


65. m]u; njhOifia jhkjpf;fj;jhd; Ntz;Lkh?
66. uf;mj;fspy; Xjhky; U$c> ][;jh Kiwahf ,Ue;jhy; kl;Lk; NghJkh?
67. fhJfs; tiu ifia cau;j;JtJ gpj;mj;jh?
68. Y`u;> m]hpy; Xj Ntz;lhkh?
69. njho itg;gtu; mofhf ,Uf;f Ntz;Lkh?
70. njhO Neha;f;fhd fhuzk;?
71. ghu;itapd; $u;ikf;F...
72. Mz;fs; nfl;Lg; Nghf ngz;fNs fhuzk;?
73. Mz;fs; eufk; nry;y fhuzk; ngz;fNs!
74. ,iwtdpd; tpNuhjpfs; ngz;fshtu;?
75. k`Uf;F msTz;lh?
vr;rhpf;if!

gjpg;Giu
Gfo; midj;Jk; my;yh`;tpwN; f!
my;yh`;tpd; khngUk; fpUigapdhy; jw;NghJ `jP]; E}w;fspd; jkpohf;fq;fs; ntsptUk; fhyk; ,J.
gy;NtW jiyg;GfspYk; ,];yhkpa E}w;fs; ntspte;J> ,];yhkpar; rpe;jidia jkpo; NgRk; kf;fSf;F
ngUk; gad; mspf;Fk; fhyKk; $l.
,e;j tifapy; fle;j khjk; vkJ Kjy; ntspaPlhf ''egp(]y;) Nghjpj;j ew;gz;Gfs;'' vd;w E}iy
Kjy; ntspaPlhf Kd; itj;Njhk;. jw;NghJ ,uz;lhk; ntspaPlhf '',g;gbAk; rpy `jP];fs;'' E}iy
cq;fs; Kd; itj;Js;Nshk;.
Nghypahd `jP];(?)fisAk; $l ek;gp nray;gLk; mwpQu;fs; cz;L. ,jdhy; ,];yhkpar; rl;lq;fspy;
Nfypf; $j;jhdit-Kl;lhs;jdkhditfs; $l Eioe;Jtpl;ld. åju;fspd; rjpapd; Kaw;rpf;Ff; fpilj;j
ntw;wp ,J vdyhk;.
MdhYk; Mapuf;fzf;fhd `jP];fs; ,l;Lf; fl;lg;gl;L> Gidag;gl;L cs;sd. mit midj;ijAk;
,q;Nf Fwpg;gpLtjhdhy; gy thy;åk;fs; jhd; mr;rpl Ntz;baJ tUk;. xU ghid Nrhw;Wf;F xU NrhW
gjk; vd;ghu;fs;. ,jdhy; rpy `jP];fs; kl;Lk; cq;fs; ghu;itf;F!
,tw;iwg; Ghpe;J nfhz;lhNy `jP];fspd; ngauhy;... $wg;gLk; rpy jtwhd nra;jpfs; tp\aj;jpy;
c\huhf ,Uf;fyhk;. xU rpyu; tuk;G kPwp> ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l `jP];fs; cs;sjhy;> `jP];fNs
Ntz;lhk;> Fu;Md; kl;LNk NghJk; vd;gu;. ,JTk; jtwhd ek;gpf;ifahFk;.
,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l `jP];fis milahsk; fz;L> jpUf;Fu;Md; kw;Wk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd egptopg;gb
nray;gl KidNthkhf!
- ijkpa;ah gg;spNf\d;];
kJiu

Kd;Diu
Gfo; midj;Jk; my;yh`;tpwN; f!
Fu;MDk;> `jP]{k; jhd; jk; tho;f;ifapd; topfhl;b. mijg;gpd;gw;w jtwpaJ jhd;> ehk; topNfl;by;

3 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

Ngha;tpl fhuzkhdJ vd;gijg; Ghpe;J nfhz;ldu; K];ypk;fs;.


Fu;MDk;> `jP]{k; mugpapy; cs;sjhy; mijj; jkpopy; juNtz;baJ muG nkhop mwpej
; mwpQu;fs;
kPJs;s flikahfpd;wJ. Fu;Md; 50 tUlq;fSf;F Kd;Ng jkpopy; jug;gl;Ltpl;lJ. Mdhy; jw;NghJ
jhd; `jP];fs; KOikahf nkhopngau;g;G nra;ag;gl;L tUfpd;wJ.
åj> fpUj;Jtu;fs;> mtu;fsJ iff;$ypfs; J}a;ikahd ,];yhj;ij fsq;fg;gLj;j Ntz;Lk; vd;W
vz;zp ,];yhj;jpy; ,y;yhj> my;yh`;Tk; mtdJ J}jUk; $whj gy nra;jpfis gug;gpdu;. Fu;Mdpy;
jq;fsJ ifruf;if mtu;fshy; Eiof;fKbatpy;iy. fhuzk; mJ KOikahf ghJfhf;fg;gl;L
tUfpd;wJ. Mdhy; `jP];fNsh mg;gb ghJfhf;fg;gltpy;iy. ,J ,];yhj;ij fsq;fg;gLj;j
vz;zpNahUf;F ngUk; tha;g;ghf mike;Jtpl;lJ. jq;fs; ,\;lj;jpw;F ''`jP];fspd; ngauhy;'' gy
tp\aq;fis egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf gug;gptpl;L tpl;lhu;fs;.
,jd; tpisT `jP]; fiy mwpQu;fs; `jPi] jq;fspd; E}y;fspy; gjpT nra;Ak;NghNj `jP]pd;
juj;ijAk; vOjpdu;.
,J ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ.
,J Gidag;gl;lJ.
,J gytPdkhdJ
vd;nwy;yhk; milahsk; fhl;bdu;. Mdhy; K];ypk;fs; me;j ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l> gytPdkhd nra;jpfis
jq;fisAk; mwpahky; nray;gLj;jp tpl;ldu;. `jPi] kl;Lk; Nghjpj;J tpl;L> `jP]py; cs;s
Gidag;gl;litfis Nghjpf;fj; jtwpajpdhy; kt;ytpfSk; $l jukpoe;j `jP];fis `jP]pd; ngauhy;
kf;fSf;F Nghjpj;J tUfpd;wdu;.
`jP];fis nkhop ngau;g;G nra;Ak; NghNj mjd; juj;ijAk; jw;NghJ nkhop ngau;g;gtu;fs; Fwpg;
gpl;lhYk;> `jP];fspd; ngauhy; ,l;Lf;fl;lg; gl;lijAk; jdp E}w;fshf je;jhy; jkpo; K];ypk;fs;
tpopg;Gld; ,Ug;gu;. ,JNghd;w `jP];fis $WNthhplk; vr;rhpf;ifAld; ele;J nfhs;tu;; vd;gjhy; jhd;
ap`jP];fspd; ngauhy;... ,g;gbAk; rpy `jP];fs;'' vd;w E}iyj; njhFj;Js;Nsd;.
,e;E}y; ntsptu MNyhrid toq;fpa Fitj; rNfhjuu;fs; kt;ytp S.K.rk;RjPd; kw;Wk; K.jh[{j;jPd;
M.A.> MfpNahUf;F vd; kdkhu;e;j ed;wpiaj; njhptpj;Jf; nfhs;fpNwd;.
ehk; `jP];fis ed;fwpe;J> cz;ikapy; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf cs;s ]`P`hd `jPi]Na
gpd;gw;wp tho ty;y my;yh`; mUs;Gthdhf!
,tz;>
K.M. Kfk;kJ KifjPd;
14-02-2005
ey;Y}u;> kJiu.

1. kf;fhit tpl kjPdh rpwe;jjh?

ku;thd; ,g;D `fk; mtu;fs; kf;fhtpy; ciuahw;wpf; nfhz;bUe;jhu;fs;. mg;NghJ kf;fhitg; gw;wpAk;
mjd; rpwg;igAk; $wpf; nfhz;bUe;jhu;fs;. mg;NghJ kpk;gUf;F mUfpy; ,Ue;J uhgpT ,g;D `jP[;
mtu;fs;> apePu; kf;fhitAk;> mjd; rpwg;igAk; $wpdPu;. mJ ePu; $wpagbNa cs;sJ jhd;. Mdhy; ePu;
kjPdhitg; gw;wp $Wtij ck;kplk; ehd; Nfl;ftpy;iyNa. (Vd; $wj;jtwpdPu;?) 'kf;fhit tpl
kjPdhNt kpfr; rpwe;jJ' vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wp ,Ug;gij ehd; Nfl;ljw;F rhl;rp $WfpNwd;''
vd;W $wpdhu;fs;.
,g;gb xU rk;gtk; ele;jjhf GfhuP mtu;fs; jdJ 'jhFy; fgPu;' vDk; E}ypYk;> jg;uhdp mtu;fs; jdJ
fgPYk;> Kgo;oYy; [{d;jp mtu;fs; 'gohapYy; kjPdh' vDk; E}ypYk; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.

4 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

,jpy; kpf Kf;fpakhf ftdpf;fg;gl Ntz;baJ 'kf;fhit tpl kjPdhNt kpfr; rpwe;jJ' vd;w
thrfj;ijj; jhd;.
,r;rk;gtj;ij mwptpf;Fk; mwptpg;ghsu; njhlhpy; ,lk;ngWk; K`k;kJ ,g;D mg;Ju; u`;khd; my; Mkp
vd;gtu; rhpahdtu; my;yu;.
',tu; gykhdtu; my;y' vd;W mg+`hjk; mtu;fSk;> ',tuJ gy mwptpg;Gfs; ghJfhf;fg;glhjit' vd;W
,g;D mjP mtu;fSk; $Wfpwhu;fs;.
'kf;fhit tpl kjPdhNt kpfr; rpwe;jJ' vd;w thrfKk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fSf;F khw;wkhf
cs;sJ. kjPdhTf;F vd;W jdpr;rpwg;Gfs; cz;L vd;gij ehk; kWf;ftpy;iy. mjw;nfd jdpr;rpwg;Gfs;
cz;L vd;gjw;F gpd;tUk; `jP];fs; Mjhukhf cs;sd.
Iu;> ]t;u; Mfpa ,uz;L kiyfSf;fpilNa cs;s kjPdh rpwg;Gkpf;f gFjpahFk; vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs;
$wpajhf myP(uyp) mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;
',iwth! kf;fhtpy; eP Vw;gLj;jpa mgptpUj;jp Nghd;W ,uz;L klq;Ffis kjPdhtpYk; Vw;gLj;Jthahf!'
vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf md];(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;
'kjPdhtpd; ,uz;L vy;iyfSf;F cl;gl;l gFjpfspy; mjd; Gw;g+z;Lfis (Njitapy;yhky;) ntl;b
vwptijAk;> mjd; Ntl;ilg; gpuhzpfs; nfhy;yg;gLtijAk;> ehd; `uhkhf Mf;FfpNwd;. kjPdh khefuk;
jhd; mtu;fSf;F rpwe;jJ. ,ij mtu;fs; mwpaf; $lhjh? ahNuDk; kjPdhit ntWj;J mij tpl;Lk;
nrd;why; my;yh`; mtiu tpl rpwe;jtiu mjw;Fg; gfukhf jq;f itj;J tpLthd;. ahNuDk; grpf;
nfhLikiaAk;> rpukj;ijAk; jhq;fpf; nfhz;L cWjpahf kjPdhtpNyNa ,Ue;jhy; fpahk ehspy;
mtDf;F ehd; ghpe;Jiu nra;gtdhf MNtd;' vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf ]/J(uyp) mtu;fs;
mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: K];ypk;
,e;j `jP];fs; kjPdhtpd; rpwg;Gf;fis mwptpg;gjpy; ,Ue;Nj kjPdhtpd; rpwg;Gf;fs; cau;e;jit vd;gJ
njspthdhYk; mNj rkak; kf;fhtpd; rpwg;Gfs; vd;gJ mijAk; tpl kpfr; rpwe;j xd;whFk;. ,ij
gpd;tUk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fs; %yk; tpsq;fyhk;.
'kw;w ,lq;fspy; Mapuk; njhOiffisj; njhOtij tpl vdJ ,e;jg; gs;spapy; xU njhOif
njhOtJ rpwe;jJ. Mdhy; k];[pJy; `uhk; (f/gh Myak;) jtpu. k];[pJy; `uhkpy; xU njhOif
njhOtJ> vdJ ,e;jg; gs;spapy; njhOk; 100 njhOiffis tplTk; rpwe;jJ' vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs;
$wpajhf mg;Jy;yh`; ,g;D ]{igu;(uyp) mwptpf; fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: m`;kj;> ,g;D`pg;ghd;
'k];[pJy; `uhk; jtpu> vdJ ,e;jg; gs;spapy; xU njhOif njhOtJ kw;w ,lq;fspy; njhOk; 1000
njhOiffis tplTk; NkyhdJ' vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+`{iuuh(uyp)
mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;
',e;j Ciu (kf;fhit) thdq;fs;> g+kpiag; gilj;jjpy; ,Ue;Nj my;yh`; fz;zpag;gLj;jptpll ; hd;.
my;yh`;Nt fz;zpag;gLj;jp tpl;ljhy; fpahkehs; tiuapYk; ,J fz;zpakpf;fjhFk;' vd;W egp(]y;)
mtu;fs; $wpajhf ,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;
,e;j `jP];fs; kjPdhit tpl kf;fhTf;F kpf rpwg;G cz;L vd;gij mwptpg;gjhy; kjPdh> kf;fhit
tpl rpwe;j Cu; vd;gJ kpifg;gLj;jg;gl;ljhFk;.
NkYk; 'Cu;fspd; jha;'> 'ck;Ky;Fuh' vd;W my;yh`; kf;fhit Fwpg;gpLfpwhd;.
,J> jha; fpuhkj;ij (kf;fh)itAk;> mijr; Rw;wp As;stu;fisAk; (K`k;kNj!) ePu; vr;rhpgg
; jw;fhf
ehk; mUspa Ntjk;. ghf;fpak; ngw;wJk;> jdf;F Kd; nrd;wtw;iw cz;ikg; gLj;jf; $baJkhFk;.
kWikia ek;GNthu; ,ij ek;Gfpd;wdu;. mtu;fs; jkJ njhOifapy; NgZjyhfTk; cs;sdu;.
my;Fu;Md; 6:92
NkYk; kf;fhtpy; f/gh> `[Uy; m];tj;> kfhNk ,g;uh`Pk;> [k;[k; ePu; Cw;W> ]gh> ku;th kiyf;Fd;W
Nghd;w khz;GkpF jyq;fSk; cz;L.
,JNghd;w vz;zpylq;fh rpwg;Gfs; kf;fhtpw;F cz;L. kjPdhtpw;F vd rpwg;Gfs; cz;L vd;whYk;>

5 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

'kf;fhit tpl kjPdhNt kpfr; rpwe;jJ' vd;w thrfk; jtwhdJ. vdNt Nkw;fz;l nra;jp egp(]y;)
mtu;fspd; ngauhy; ,l;Lf;fl;lg; gl;ljhFk;.

2. `[;[{f;F ele;J nrd;why; mjpf ed;ikah?

''thfdj;jpy; Vwp `[; nra;ar; nrd;wtUf;F mtuJ thfdk; vLj;J itf;Fk; xt;nthU mbf;Fk; 70
ed;ikfs; cz;L. (Mdhy; `[; nra;a) ele;J nry;gtUf;Nfh mtu; itf;Fk; xt;nthU mbf;Fk; 700
ed;ikfs; cz;L.''
,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf ,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. jg;uhdP mtu;fs; jd; fgPy;
gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.
,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk; ngWk; a`;ah ,g;D Riyk;> Kfk;kJ ,g;D K];ypk; ,UtUk;
rhpahdtu; fsy;yu;. ',t;tpUtUk; gytPdu;fs;' vd ,khk; m`;kj; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;. ,e;j ,UtUk;
xUKiw jq;fSf;F ,g;wh`Pk; ,g;D ik]puh mwptpj;jjhfTk;> kw;nwhU Kiw ,];khaPy; ,g;D
cikah mwptpj;jjhfTk; $wp> mwptpg;gtu;fs; thpiriaf; Fog;gf; $batu;fshf cs;sdu;.
NkYk; ,Nj K`k;kJ ,g;D K];ypk; topahf fPo;f;fz;l `jPi] ,g;D mjP mtu;fs; jd; E}ypy; gjpT
nra;Js;shu;fs;.
'xUtu; thfdj;jpy; nrd;W `[; nra;jhy; mtUf;F xt;nthU vl;Lf;Fk; xU ed;ik cz;L. xUtu;
ele;J nrd;W `[; nra;jhy; mtUf;F `ukpd; ed;ikfspypUe;J xt;nthU mbf;Fk; 70 ed;ikAz;L'
vd;W egp(]y;) $wpdhu;fs;. `ukpd; ed;ikfs; vd;why; vd;d? vd;W xUtu; Nfl;lhu;. 'mjd; xU
ed;ik xU yl;rk; ed;ikf;Fr; rkkhFk;' vd;W gjpy; $wpdhu;fs;.
,e;j `jP]py; mg;Jy;yh ,g;D K`k;kJ my;Fj;jhkP vd;gtUk; ,lk; ngWfpwhu;. ,tUk; rhpahdtuy;y
vd;W ,g;D mjP mtu;fNs $wTk; nra;fpwhu;fs;.
xUKiw egp(]y;) mtu;fsplk; kjPdhtpypUe;J xU $l;lKk;> `{ijy; gFjpapypUe;J xU $l;lKk;
te;jdu;. ',iwj;J}ju; mtu;fNs! kf;fnsy;yhk; thfdj;jpd; kPJ Vwp (`[; nra;ar; nry;Yk; epiyapy;
ehq;fNsh kf;fhtpw;F ele;Nj nry;fpd;Nwhk;' vd;W $wpdhu;fs;. mg;NghJ egp(]y;) mtu;fs;> 'ele;J
nry;gtUf;F 30 `[; nra;j $yp cz;L' vd;W $wpdhu;fs;.
,ij mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpgg
; jhf jg;uhdP mtu;fs; jdJ mt;]j;jpy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.
,jpy; ,lk;ngWk; K`k;kj; vd;gtu; ngha;au;; `jP]; fiyapduhy; iftplg;gl;ltu; vd;W i`jkP mtu;fs;
$Wfpwhu;fs;. vdNt ,J gytPdkhd `jP]hFk;.
`[; nra;a thfdj;jpy; nry;tij tpl> ele;J nry;tij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; rpwg;gpj;Jf; $wpajhf ve;j
xU Mjhug; g+u;tkhd `jP]{k; ,y;iy. NkYk; mjw;F vd jdpr;rpwg;G ,Ue;jpUe;jhy;> egpj;Njhou; gyu;
`[; nra;Js;sdu;. mtu;fs; ele;J nry;tij Nju;e;njLj;jpUg;ghu;fs;. ,g;gb rpwg;G fUjp egpj;Njhou;
vtUk; ele;J nrd;W `[; nra;jjhf ve;j xU Mjhug;g+u;tkhd nra;jpiaAk; ehk; mwpatpy;iy.
NkYk; ele;J nrd;W `[; nra;tjpy; rpwg;G cs;sJ vd;W ,Uf;Fkhdhy; ,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fSk;
nra;jpUg; ghu;fs;. Mdhy; egp(]y;) mtu;fNsh thfdj;jpy; nrd;W jhd; `[; nra;Js;sdu; vd;gij
gpd;tUk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fs; %yk; mwpaKbfpwJ.
''ehd; egp(]y;) mtu;fspd; xl;lfj;jpy; mtu;fSf;Fg; gpd;dhy; mku;e;J mughtpypUe;J kpdh tiu
nrd;Nwd;. [k;uJy; mfghtpy; fy;nywpAk; tiu mtu;fs; jy;gpah $wpf; nfhz;NlapUe;jhu;fs;'' vd /go;Y
,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;> m`;kj;> mg+jh¥j;> e]aP> jpu;kpjP
ehq;fs; filrp `[;[pd; NghJ egp(]y;) mtu;fSld; `[; nra;Njhk;. mg;NghJ gpyhy;(uyp)>
c]hkh(uyp) Mfpa ,Uty; xUtu; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; xl;lfj;jpd; fbthsj;ijg; gpbj;Jf; nfhz;lhu;.
kw;nwhUtu; mtu;fs; kPJ ntapy; glhky; jdJ Milia cau;j;jpg; gpbj;Jf; nfhz;lhu; vd;W ck;Ky;
`{i]d;(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: K];ypk;> m`;kj;

6 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

ehd; mughtpy; egp(]y;) mtu;fspd; gpd;Nd xl;lfj;jpy; mku;e;jpUe;Njd;. mtu;fs; jkJ iffis
cau;j;jp gpuhu;j;jid nra;jhu;fs;. mtu;fspd; xl;lfk; mtu;fis FYf;fpaJ. mjdhy; mjd; fbthsk;
fPNo tpOe;Jtpl;lJ. xU ifahy; mij vLj;jhu;fs; vd c]hkh ,g;D i]j;(uyp) mwptpff ; pdw
; hu;fs;.
E}y;: e]aP
egp(]y;) mtu;fs; kpdhtpy; `[; ngUehs; jpdj;jpy; jkJ ms;gh vDk; xl;lfj;jpd; kPjku;e;J (Fj;gh)
ciu epfo;j;jpaij ehd; ghu;j;jpUf;fpNwd; vd `pu;kh]; ,g;D ]pahj;(uyp) mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. E}y;fs;:
m`;kj;> mg+jh¥j;
thfdj;jpy; mku;e;J egp(]y;) mtu;fs; `[;[pd; fphpia fis epiwNtw;wpAs;sdu; vd;gJ kl;Lky;y
egpj;Njhou;fSk; thfdj;jpy; nrd;Nw `[; nra;Js;sdu;.
xU kdpju; ,`;uhk; fl;bapUf;Fk;NghJ mtuJ thfdk; mtiuf; fPNo js;spaJ. clNd mtu;
,we;Jtpl;lhu;. mg;NghJ egp(]y;) mtu;fs; jz;zPuhYk;> ,ye;ij ,iyahYk; mtiuf; Fspg;ghl;Lq;fs;.
mtuJ ,U Milfspy; mtiu fgdpLq;fs;. mtuJ Kfj;ijNah> jiyKbiaNah %lNtz;lhk;.
Vnddpy; fpahkj; ehspy; jy;gpah $wpatuhf vOg;gg;gLthu; vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs; vd
,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. E}y;fs;: K];ypk;> m`;kj;> e]aP> ,g;Dkh[h
`];mk; Nfhj;jpuj;ijr; Nru;e;j xU ngz;kzp my;yh`;tpd; J}jNu! vd; je;ij xl;lifapd; KJfpy;
mku ,ayhj taJilatuhf ,Uf;Fk;NghJ> mtUf;F `[; vDk; my;yh`;tpd; flik Vw;gl;Ltpl;lJ
vd;W $wpdhu;. mjw;F egp(]y;) mtu;fs; 'mtUf;fhf eP `[; nra;' vd;W mthplk; $wpdhu;fs;. E}y;fs;:
GfhuP> K];ypk;> mg+jh¥j;> e]aP> jpu;kpjP
vdNt ele;J nrd;W `[; nra;jhy; jdp ed;ikAz;L vd;gjhf tUk; Nkw;fz;litfs; mwptpg;ghsu;
njhlhpy; cs;s FiwghLfshy; kl;Lk; rhpahdjhf ,y;iy vd;gjy;y! Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fspd;
epiyf;Fk; khw;wkhf cs;sJ.

3. tpgr;rhuk; nra;jhy;...!

'tpgr;rhuk; nra;tJ Vo;ikia Vw;gLj;Jk;' vd;W egp(]y;) $wpajhf mg;Jy;yh`; ,g;D cku;(uyp)
mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;.
K];dJ\;\p`hg; vDk; jdJ E}ypy; fshaP mtu;fs; ,ijg; gjpT nra;Js;shu;. ,e;j `jP]py;
,lk;ngWk; iy]; ,g;D mgPRiyk; vd;gtu; gytPdkhdtu;. NkYk; khsP ,g;D K`k;kJ vd;gtu;
ahnud;Nw mwpag;glhjtu;.
,khk; Råj;jp mtu;fSk; ,Nj `jPi] jd; [hkp,y; gjpT nra;Jtpl;L ,J gytPdkhdNj vd;W
cWjpg; gLj;Jfpwhu;fs;. ig`fP ,khk; mtu;fSk; jdJ E}ypy; gjpT nra;Jtpl;L> ,jd; mwptpg;ghsu;
thpirapy; ,lk; ngWk; khsP ,g;D K`k;kJ vd;gtiu `jP]; fiyapy; kWf;fj; jf;ftu; vd;W
$Wfpwhu;fs;.
,JNghy; ,g;D mgP`hjk; mtu;fs; jdJ ,yy;' vDk; E}ypy; ,e;j `jP]; gw;wp ''vd; je;ij
(mgP`hjk;) mtu;fsplk; Nfl;Nld;. mjw;F mtu;fs;> ,J jtwhd `jP];. ,g;gb xU `jPi] ehd;
mwpatpy;iy'' vd;W Fwpg;gpl;lhu;fs; vd gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.
tpgr;rhuk; nra;tij cq;fSf;F vr;rhpf;fpNwd;. tpgr;rhuk; nra;jhy; MW tpisTfs; Vw;gLk;. %d;W
,t;Tyfj;jpYk;> kw;w %d;W kWikapYk; epfOk;. cyfj;jpy; Vw;gLk; %d;W epiyfs; 1. re;Njhrk;
Ngha;tpLk;> 2.Vo;ik Vw;gLk;> 3. mgptpUj;jp FiwAk;. kWikapy; Vw;gLk; %d;W epiyfs; 1. ,iwtdpd;
Nfhgj;ij Vw;gLj;Jk;> 2. Nfs;tp fzf;F fLikahFk;> 3. epue;ju NtjidAz;L
vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf `{ijgh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;.
,ij ,g;D mjP> mg+ eaPk; MfpNahu; gjpT nra;Js;sdu;. ,jpy; ,lk;ngWk; m`;k\; vd;gtu; kdd
rf;jp Fiwthdtu;; kWf;fj;jf;ftu; vd ,g;D mjP mtu;fs; $Wfpwhu;fs;. m`;k\; topahf tUk; ,J
mg+u;tkhdjhFk;. NkYk; ,jpy; tUk; k];ykh vd;gtu; gytPdkhdtu; vd;W mg+eaPk; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.

7 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

',l;Lf;fl;baitfs;' (kt;@Mj;) vDk; E}ypy; ,khk; ,g;Dy; [t;]P gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;. ,e;j
`jP]{f;F vt;tpj mbg;gilAk; ,y;iy vd ,g;D `pg;ghd; $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,khk; ig`fP mtu;fs;
jdJ \{/Gy; <khdpy; ,ijg; gjpT nra;Jtpl;L> ',jpy; ,lk;ngWk; k];ykh `jP]; fiyapduhy;
iftplg;gl;ltu;; mg+ mg;Ju;u`;khd; my;$gP vd;gtu; ahnud;Nw mwpag;glhjtu;' vd;W Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.
tpgr;rhuk; nra;tij cq;fSf;F vr;rhpf;fpNwd;. tpgr;rhuk; nra;tjpdhy; MW tpisTfs; cz;L. %d;W
,t;Tyfj;jpYk; %d;W kWikapYk; Vw;gLk;. Kf moF Ngha;tpLjy;> cztpy; mgptpUj;jp Fiwjy;>
kuzk; rPf;fpuk; tUjy; ,k;%d;Wk; cyfj;jpy; tUgitahFk;. ,iwtdpd; Nfhgk;> Nfs;tp fzf;F fLik
my;yh`; ehbdhNy jtpu epue;ju eufk; Mfpa %d;Wk; kWikapy; epfo;gitahFk;. vd;W egp(]y;)
$wpajhf md];(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;.
,JTk; ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lNj! ,jpy; ,lk; ngWk; f/G ,g;D mk;U ,g;D [/gu; vd;ghu; rhpahdtuy;y vd
fjPg; $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,ij ,khk; ,g;Dy; [t;]P mtu;fs; jdJ 'kt;@Mj;' vDk; E}ypYk;
Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.
tpgr;rhuk; nra;tij vr;rhpff
; pNwd;. mjdhy; ehd;F tpisTfs; Vw;gLk;. 1.Kf moF Ngha;tpLk;>
2.czT gQ;rk; Vw;gLk;> 3.,iwtdpd; Nfhgk; Vw;gLk;> 4. epue;jukhd eufk; cz;L. vd;W egp(]y;)
mtu;fs; $wpajhf ,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) $Wfpwhu;fs;.
,ij jg;uhdP jdJ m];tj;jpYk; ,g;D [t;]P mtu;fs; kt;@Mj;jpYk; gjpT nra;Js;sdu;. ,jd;
mwptpg;ghsu;fspy; xUtuhd ,g;D [{iu[; topahf mk;U ,g;D [kPc vd;gtiuj; jtpu vtUk;
mwptpff; tpy;iy vd jg;uhdP $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,e;j mk;U ,g;D [kPc vd;gtu; ngUk; ngha;au; vd ,g;Dy;
[t;]P $Wfpwhu;fs;. jg;uhdpapd; mt;]j; E}ypy; gjpT nra;ag;gl;Ls;s `jP]pd; mwptpg;ghsy; xUtuhd
mk;U ,g;D [kPc vd;gtu; `jP]; fiyapduhy; iftplg;gl;ltu; vd;W i`]kP jdJ k[;kctpy;
$Wfpwhu;fs;.
nghJthf tpgr;rhuk; nra;tJ vd;gJ ,];yhj;jpd; ghu;itapy; fLk; Fw;wk; jhd;. jpUkzk; nra;ahjtu;
tpgr;rhuk; nra;jhy; firab nfhLf;f Ntz;Lk;. jpUkzk; nra;jtu; tpgr;rhuk; nra;jhy; fy;yhy; vwpeJ
;
nfhy;yg;glNtz;Lk; vdf; $wg;gLk; msTf;F khngUk; nfhba Fw;wk; jhd;. vdpDk; ,jw;fhf egp(]y;)
mtu;fs; $whj xd;iw $wpajhf $wg;gLtijNa ngha; vd;fpNwhk; vd;gij epidtpy; nfhs;f!

4. Fjpiuf; fwp cz;zf;$lhjh?

''Fjpiu> NfhNtWf; fOij> fOij Mfpatw;wpd; ,iwr;rpia cz;gJ `yhy; (mDkjpf;fg;gl)


,y;iy.''
,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fsplkpUe;J jhd; Nfl;ljhf fhypj; gpd; tyPj; (uyp) mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. ,J
mg+jh¥j;> e]aP> ,g;Dkh[h> j`htPapd; \u`{y; kMdp> ig`fP> m`;kj;> jg;uhdP Mfpa E}y;fspy;
,lk;ngw;Ws;sJ.
',ij mwptpf;Fk; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk; ngw;wpUf;Fk; ]hyp`; ,g;D a`;ah vd;gtu; FiwghL
ilatuhf ,Uf;fpwhu;' vd ,khk; GfhuP Fwpgg ; pLfpwhu;fs;. j`gP> ,g;D`[u; MfpNahUk; ,tiu
gytPdkhdtu;fs; gl;baypy; Nru;f;fpwhu;fs;.
,tu; gw;wpa mwpKfk; VJk; fpilf;ftpy;iy. NkYk; ,tuJ je;ij gw;wpa mwpKfKk; fpilf;ftpy;iy.
,tuJ ghl;ldhu; kpfj ; hk; ,g;D k`;jPfu;G vd;gtiuj; jtpu. ,tNuh> ,tuJ je;ijNah mwpag;glhj
egu;fshf cs;sdu; vd %]h ,g;D `h&d; vd;ghu; $Wfpwhu;. ,tu; jd; je;ij a`;ah %yNk jtpu
NtW vtu; %yKk; `jP];fis mwptpg;gjpy;iy vd> kP]hdpy; j`gP Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.
jd; ghl;ldhhplk; jhNd Nfl;lJ Nghd;Wk;> jd; je;ij jd; ghl;ldhhplk; Nfl;L jdf;F jd; je;ij
$wpaJ Nghd;Wk; ,tu; topahf ,e;j `jP]; mwptpf;fg;gLfpwJ. ,g;gb mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapYk; FsWgb
cs;sJ.
NkYk; ,e;j `jPi] egp(]y;) mtu;fs; ifgu; Nghu; rkaj;jpy; $wpajhf fhypj; gpd; tyPj; (uyp)

8 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

mtu;fs; $wpajhf ,lk; ngw;Ws;sJ. Mdhy; ,e;j egpj;Njhou; mtu;fNsh ifgu; Nghu; rkaj;jpy;
K];ypkhftpy;iy. kf;fh ntw;wp nfhz;l tUlj;jpy; jhd; K];ypkhdtu; vd;gJ Fwpg; gplj;jf;fJ. ,ij
,g;D `[u; mtu;fSk; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.
NkYk; ,J Nghd;w xU `jPi] [hgpu;(uyp) mtu;fs; NtW $Wfpwhu;fs;. fhypj; (uyp) mtu;fs; jhd;
ifgu; Nghu; rkaj;jpy; K];ypkhftpy;iy. Mdhy; [hgpu;(uyp) mtu;fs; mg;gbapy;iyNa; vdNt [hgpu; (uyp)
mtu;fspd; `jPi] itj;J fhypj(; uyp) mtu;fspd; topahf mwptpf;fg;gLk; `jPi] '`]d;' vd;w
me;j];j;jpw;F cau;j;jyhNk vd;W rpyu; $Wtu;.
Mdhy; [hgpu;(uyp) mtu;fs; topahf mwptpf;fg;gLk; `jP]{k; gytPdkhdJ jhd;. ,jpy; ,lk; ngWk;
,f;kh gpd; mk;khu; vd;ghu;> a`;ah ,g;D mgPfjPu; topahf mwptpf;Fk; ve;j `jP]{k; rhpahdjy;y. ,ij
a`;ah ,g;D ]aPj; my; Fj;jhd; $Wfpwhu;fs;. a`;ah topahf ,f;kh mwptpfF ; k; `jP]; ',o;jpuhg;'
MFk; vd GfhuP $Wfpwhu;fs;. vdNt [hgpu(; uyp) mtu;fs; ngauhy; mwptpff ; g;gLk; `jP]{k; rhpahdjy;y
vd;gjhy; me;j `jPi] itj;Jf; nfhz;L ,e;j `jPi] '`]d;' Mf Mf;f KbahJ.
NkYk; ,e;j [hgpu;(uyp) mtu;fs; ,Nj fUj;Jf;F khw;wkhf NtW Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jPi]
mwptpf;fpwhu;fs; vd;gJ Fwpg;gplj;jf;fjhFk;. NkYk; Nkw;fz;l `jP]; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fSf;F
khw;wkhf cs;sjhYk; ,J gytPdkhd `jP]hFk;. Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fs; ,Njh;
ifgu; Nghd; NghJ egp(]y;) mtu;fs; tPl;Lf; fOij (cz;z) jil nra;jhu;fs;. Fjpiu ,iwr;rpia
(cz;z) mDkjpj;jhu;fs;. mwptpg;gtu;: [hgpu;(uyp)> E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;> e]aP> mg+jh¥j;
egp(]y;) mtu;fs; vq;fSf;Ff; Fjpiuf; fwpia cz;zj; je;jhu;fs;. fOijapd; fwpia cz;z jil
nra;jhu;fs;. E}y;: jpu;kpjP
egp(]y;) mtu;fSld; ehq;fs; gazk; nra;Js;Nshk;. mg;NghJ ehq;fs; Fjpiuf; fwpia cz;zf;
$batu;fshfTk;> mjd; ghiyf; Fbg;gtu;fshfTk; ,Ue;Njhk;. E}y;: jhuFj;dP
egp(]y;) mtu;fs; fhyj;jpy; ehq;fs; kjPdhtpy; ,Ue;j NghJ Fjpiuia mWg;Nghk;. mij cz;Nghk;
vd m];kh gpd;j; mg+gf;fu;(uyp) mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;
Fjpiuf; fwpia cz;zyhk; vd ,e;j `jP];fs; $Wfpd;wd. Mdhy; Nkw;fz;l `jPN]h mij `uhk;
vdf; $WfpwJ. Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]{f;F khw;wkhf ,Ug;gjhYk;> ,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpir
rhpapyy
; hjjhYk; ,J gytPdkhd `jP]hFk; vd;gij epidtpy; nfhs;f!
,e;jj; jtwhd `jPi] itj;Jj; jhd; `dgP kj;`gpy; Fjpiuf; fwp cz;zyhfhJ vd;fpd;wdu;. xU
jtwhd `jPi] itj;J ehk; mky; nra;ayhfhJ.

5. cyfj;jpy; gw;ww;W tho;tJ?

''cyfj;jpy; gw;ww;W tho;tJ cs;sj;ijAk;> cliyAk; eyj;Jld; ,Uf;fr; nra;Ak;.''


,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. ,e;j `jPi] cifyP>
,g;D mjP> jg;uhdP MfpNahu; jq;fspd; E}y;fspy; gjpT nra;Js;sdu;.
,J gytPdkhd `jP]hFk;. ,jpy; ehd;fhtJ mwptpg;ghsuhf ,lk;ngWk;. ,\;m]{ ,g;DGuhR vd;gtu;
gytPdkhd eguhFk;. ,tuJ `jP]; Vw;fg;glj;jf;fjy;y vd ,khk; GfhuP $Wfpwhu;fs;. '`jP]; fiy
Nkijfshy; iftplg;gl;ltu;' vd ,khk; e]aP mtu;fs; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;. NkYk; %d;whtJ
mwptpg;ghsuhf ,lk;ngWk; myP ,g;D i]J vd;w ,g;D [j;Md; vd;gtUk; gytPduhthu;.
''cyfj;ij tpUk;gp tho;tJ> ftiyiaAk; ifNrjj;ijAk; mjpff;Fk;.''
,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf jh¥]; vd;ghu; mwptpf;fpd;whu;. ,tu; egpj;Njhouy;yu;. ,J
Ku;]yhFk;. ,ij ,g;D mgP Jd;ah vd;ghu; jd; E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;.
,jpy; ,lk;ngWk; K`k;kj; ,g;D K];ypk; vd;w mwptpgg
; hsu; kdd rf;jp FiwghLilatu; vd;gjhYk;
,J gytPdkhdjhFk;.

9 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

,Nj `jPi] ,Nj ,g;D mgP Jd;ah mtu;fs; NtW xU mwptpg;ghsu; topahfTk; ,ij gjpT
nra;Js;shu;fs;. mjpy; ,lk;ngWk; ,g;uh`Pk; ,g;D m];m]{ vd;gtUk; kdd rf;jp Fiwe;jtuhthu;.
,Nj `jPi] foh, mtu;fs; jdJ E}ypy; NtW mwptpg;ghsu; thpirAld; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.
MdhYk; mjpYk; gytPdu;fNs ,lk;ngWfpd;wdu;. m`;kj; ,g;D /gu;[{ vd;gtu; gytPdkhdtu;.
NkYk; gf;U ,g;D Fid]; vd;gtUk; gytPdu;. ,tiu gytPdu; gl;baypy; ,khk; j`gP
Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;. ,tu; iftplg;gl;ltu; vd jhuFj;dP mtu;fs; $Wfpwhu;fs;.
Nkw;fz;l `jP];fs; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; cs;s NfhshWfspdhy; kl;Lk; FiwAilaJ vd;W
$wpltpy;iy. mJ Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fSf;F khw;wkhfTk; cs;sJ. jpUkiwf;Fu;MDk; ,e;j
gw;ww;w tho;f;ifia Mjf;ftpy;iy.
,JNghd;w jtwhd-gytPdkhd `jP];fis itj;J rpyu; Jwtp Nt\k; Nghl;Lj; jphpfpd;wdu;. jpUkzk;
Nghd;w ma Rd;dj;ij-egptopiag; gpd;gw;wj; jtwptpLfpd;wdu;. fhL fspYk;> kiyfspYk;> FiffspYk;
Ngha; jdpikapy; mku;e;J nfhz;L ,iwtid milag; Nghtjhff; $wp> gpwF jq;fisNa flTshff;
fUjpf; nfhz;ltu;fSk; cz;L. ,g;gb gyu; topjtwpg; Nghff; fhuzk; ,e;j gytPdkhd `jP]; jhd;
vd;gij ehk; epidtpy; nfhs;s Ntz;Lk;.
...Jwtpj;jdj;ij ehk; mtu;fs; kPJ flikahf;ftpy;iy.. (my;Fu;Md; 57:27)
egp(]y;) mtu;fSld; ehq;fSk; rpWgilahf NghUf;Fr; nrd;Nwhk;. mg;NghJ jz;zPUk;> fPiufSk;
tsu;e;jpUf;fpd;w xU Fif topahfr; nry;Yk; NghJ ehd; ,t;Tyfj; njhlu;Gfis tpl;L Kw;wpYk; tpyfp>
me;jf; Fifapy; jq;fg; NghfpNwd; vdj; jdf;Fj;jhNd xU kdpju; vz;zpf; nfhz;L> mjw;fhf
egp(]y;) mtu;fsplk; mDkjp Nfl;lhu;. mjw;F egp(]y;) mtu;fs;> åju;fis Nghd;Nwh> fpwpj;jtu;fisg;
Nghd;Nwh (kidtp> kf;fSld; thohky; FiffspYk;> Njthyaq;fspYk; jdpj;J jq;fp thOkhW) ehd;
mDg;gp itf;fg;gltpy;iy. khwhf njspthd khu;ff ; j;ijf; nfhz;L mDg;gg;gl;Ls;Nsd; vdf; $wp
egp(]y;) mtu;fs; mtUf;F mDkjp kWj;Jtpl;ldu;. (,q;Nf `jP]pd; fUj;Nj jug; gl;Ls;sJ) ,ij
mg+ckhkh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: m`;kj;
vq;fisj; jpUkzk; nra;Ak;gb VtpaJld;> jpUkzk; nra;ahjpUg;gij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; fLikahf
vr;rj;jhu;fs; vd md];(uyp) mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. E}y;: ,g;D`pg;ghd;
egp(]y;) mtu;fsJ kidtpfsplk; %d;W Ngu; te;J> egp(]y;) mtu;fspd; tzf;f Kiw gw;wpf; Nfl;L
mwpe;jJk;> ',dp ehd; J}q;fhky; tzf;fk; GhpNtd;' vd xUtUk;> 'ehd; njhlu;e;J Nehd;G itg;Ngd;'
vd xUtUk;> ehd; jpUkzk; nra;a khl;Nld; vd xUtUk; $wpdu;. ,ij mwpej ; egp(]y;) mtu;fs;
mk;%tiuAk; mioj;J> ehd; xU ehs; Nehd;G itj;J kWehs; tpl;L tpLfpNwd;. J}q;fTk; nra;fpNwd;.
tzf;fKk; GhpfpNwd;. jpUkzKk; nra;Js;Nsd; vd;W $wp tpl;L> ',it vd; topKiw. ,ijg;
Gwf;fzpg;gtd; vd;idr; Nru;e;jtdy;y' vd;Wk; $wpdhu;fs;. ,ij md];(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;:
GfhuP
,q;Nf ehk; vLj;Jf;fhl;bAs;s trdk; kw;Wk; Mjhug; g+u;tkhd `jP];fSf;F khw;wkhfNt Muk;gj;jpy;
cs;s gytPdkhd `jP];fs; cs;sd.
jpUkzk; nra;jhy;> ehk; kidtp-kf;fs; vd;w FLk;g tl;lj;jpy; rpf;fp ,iwtid kwe;JtplNtz;b tUk;
vd;W $wp tho;Nthu; jtwhd tho;fi; fNa tho;fpd;wdu;.
cyf tho;f;if vd;gJ kWik tho;f;iff;F ek;ikj; jahu;gLj;jpf; nfhs;Sk; fskhFk; vd;gijNa xU
%kpd; GhpeJ
; nfhz;lhy;> ,JNghd;w jtwhd `jP]f
; s; $wg;gl;lJk;> ,J jtwhdit vd;W clNd
tpsq;fptpLk;.

6. njhOifapy; ifia cau;j;jyhkh?

''njhOifapy; jd; ,UiffisAk; xUtu; cau;j;jpdhy; mtUf;Fj; njhOifNa fpilahJ. (mjhtJ


mtuJ njhOif tPzhfptpLk;.)''

10 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

,J ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jpahFk;. ,ij ,g;D jh`pu; mtu;fs; jdJ> 'jj;fpuj;Jy; kt;SMj;' vDk;
E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;. ,e;jr; nra;jpia mwptpg;gtu;fspy; xUtuhf ,lk;ngWk; 'k/%d; ,g;D
m`;kj; my;`u;tP vd;gtu; `jPi] ,l;Lf; fl;lf;$ba khngUk; ngha;au;' vd;W ,g;D jh`pu; mtu;fNs
Fwpg;gplTk; nra;fpwhu;fs;.
NkYk; gpd;tUk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]{f;Fk; khw;wkhfTk; ,J cs;sJ.
''egp(]y;) mtu;fs; njhOiff;fhf epw;Fk;NghJ jdJ ,uz;L Njhs;G[q;fs; tiu ,U iffisAk;
cau;j;Jthu;fs;. U$Tf;F jf;gPu; $Wk; NghJk; ,Nj Nghy; nra;thu;fs;. U$tpypUe;J vOk;NghJk;
,t;thW nra;thu;fs;'' vd mg;Jy;yh`; ,g;D cku; (uyp) mwptpff
; pdw
; hu;fs;. E}y;: GfhuP
njhOifapy; ,Uf;Fk;NghNj U$tpw;F Kd;Gk; gpd;Gk; iffis cau;j;jNtz;Lk; vd;W Mjhug;g+u;tkhd
,e;j `jP]; mwptpf;fpwJ. Mdhy; NkNy ehk; Fwpg;gpl;l nra;jpNah> ,jw;F khw;wkhf cs;sJ.
,jpypUe;J ,J ,l;Lf;fg;gl;l xd;W jhd; vd;gijg; Ghpayhk;.

7. Nfhop MlhFkh?

''Nfhop vdJ rKjhaj;jpy; cs;s ViofSf;Fhpa MlhFk;. [{k;M vdJ rKjhaj;jpy; cs;s
ViofSf;Fhpa `[;[hFk;.''
,e;j `jPi] ,g;D cku;(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpg;gjhf ,g;D `pg;ghdpy; cs;sJ. ,ijg; gjpT
nra;Js;s ,g;D `pg;ghd; mtu;fNs> ''ve;j mbg;gilAk; ,y;yhj NkhrkhdJ ,J NkYk; ,jd;
mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; tUk; `p\hk; ,g;D cigJy;yh vd;gtu; Mjhukhf nfhs;sj; jf;ftu; my;y''
vdf; $Wfpwhu;fs;.
',e;j `jP]; ngha;ahdJ. ,jpy; ,lk;ngWk; k`;k\; vd;w mwptpg;ghsu; `jPi] ,l;Lf;fl;Lgtu;' vd
jhuFj;dP (u`;) mtu;fs; $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,e;j nra;jpfis kt;@Mj; vDk; jdJ E}ypy; ,g;Dy;
[t;]P(u`;) mtu;fs; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.
ML> khL> xl;lfk; ,itfis Fu;ghdp nfhLf;f mDkjp cs;sJ. xU Vio jdf;F ML thq;f trjp
,y;iy vd;gjhy; `[; ngUehs; md;W xU Nfhop thq;fp mWj;jhy; Ml;il mWj;J Fu;ghdp nfhLj;j
ed;ik fpilf;Fkh? fpilf;Fk; vd;gijj; jhd; Nkw;fz;l `jP]; njhptpf;fpwJ. ,g;gb xU jtwhd
fUj;ijj; jUk; nra;jpia egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wp ,Ug;ghu;fsh? vdNt ,e;j `jP]; ,l;Lf;fg;gl;l
xd;Nw!

8. [{k;M `[;[hFkh?

''[{k;M ViofSf;Fhpa `[;[hFk;.''


,ij ,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) mwptpg;gjhf ,g;D m]hfpu;> fshaP> ,g;Dy; ]d;[tpah> `h]; ,g;D mgP
c]hkh MfpNahu; $Wfpwhu;fs;.
,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; njhlhpy; ,lk;ngWk; <]h ,g;D ,g;uh`pKy; `h\pk; vd;gtUk;> Kfhjpy; vd;gtUk;
gytPdkhdtu;fs; vd KiwNa `hgpo; ,uhfp mtu;fSk;> ,khk; ]`htP mtu;fSk; $Wfpwhu;fs;.
NkYk; ,khk; GfhuP> ,khk; e]aP MfpNahUk; <]h ,g;D ,g;uh`pk; vd;gtiug; gw;wp $Wk;NghJ '`jP];
fiyapy; Vw;Wf; nfhs;sg;glj; jfhjtu;' vd;W $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,J ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l `jP]; vd ,khk;
]MdP mtu;fs; jdJ 'my; m`hjP]py; kt;@Mj;' E}ypy; ,ijg; gjpT nra;Js; shu;fs;.
[{k;M vd;gJ Vio> gzf;fhud; vd tpj;jpahrk; ,d;wp midtu; kPJk; cs;s flikahFk;. ,ij 62:9
trdk; mwptpf;fpwJ.
Mdhy; `[;N[h trjpahdtu;fs; kPJ kl;LNk flik vd;gij 3:97 trdk; mwptpf;fpwJ. ,e;j `jP]py;
cs;s thrfk; Viofs; jhq;fSk; `[; nra;a Ntz;Lk; vd;W vz;Ztij> Kaw;rpg;gij jil

11 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

nra;fpwJ. ,JNghy; kf;fhtpy; `[; nra;a te;j ekf;F [{k;M flik ,y;iy. [{k;M jhd;
ViofSf;Fhpa `[;jhNd! me;j ed;ikia mtu;fNs milal;Lk;. ehk; NtW Vd; [{k;M njho
Ntz;Lk;? vd;W `[; nra;J te;Js;s gzf;fhuu;fs; vz;zTk; fhuzkhfptpLfpwJ. ,g;gb Kd;Df;Fg;
gpd; Kuzhd tifapy; cs;s xd;iw egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpapUf;fkhl;lhu;fs;. ,J åju;fspd;
ifthpirahy; `jP]; vd;w ngauhy; ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ vd;gNj njspT.
'my;[{k;M `[;[{y; Gfuhc ([{k;M Viofspd; `[;)' vd;w ,e;j `jPi] \hgp kj;`igg;
gpd;gw;WNthu; njhOk; gs;spapy; [{k;M md;W ,khk; kpk;ghpy; VwpaJk; gs;spapy; Kmj;jpd; (Nkhjpdhu;)
vOe;J ifj;jbia gpbj;j tz;zk; $Wthu;. gpd;G me;j ifj;jbia ,khkplk; ju> mjd; gpd;Ng mtu;
Fj;gh epfo;j;Jthu;.
,jpy; Ntbf;if vd;dntd;why; ,ij mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mwptpg;gjhfTk;> ,J GfhuP> K];ypkpy;
cs;sjhfTk; $Wthu;. ,J gr;irg; ngha;ahFk;.
Nkw;fz;l ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l `jPi]Na \hgp kj;`gpdu; $wpr; nra;fpd;wdu;. ',g;gb ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l
gytPdkhd `jP];fs; jhd; kf;fsplk; rl;lkhf;fg;gl;Ls;sd' vd;gij kf;fs; czu;e;J ]`P`hd
`jP];gb elf;f Kd; tu Ntz;Lk;.

9. kiwTWg;ig ghu;j;jhy;...!

''cq;fspy; xUtu; jd; kidtpaplNkh> mbikg; ngz;zplNkh clYwT nfhz;lhy; mtspd;


kiwTWg;igg; ghu;f;fNtz;lhk;. Vnddpy; mg;gbg; ghu;g;gJ (fz;iz) FUlhf;fptpLk;.''
,ij ,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpg;gjhf ,g;D mjP(u`;) mtu;fs; $Wfpwhu;fs;. me;j `jPi]
'kt;@Mj;' (,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;litfs;) vDk; jkJ E}ypy; ,khk; ,g;Dy; [t;]P(u`;) mtu;fs; gjpT
nra;Js;shu;fs;.
,e;j `jP]; mwptpg;ghsu;fspy; xUtuhf ,lk; ngWk; gfpa;ah vd;gtu; ngha;au;fspy; xUtu;. NkYk;
xUthplk; Nfl;fhkNyNa mthplk; Nfl;ljhf mwptpg;gtu; vd ,g;D `pg;ghd;(u`;) mtu;fs; $Wfpwhu;fs;.
clYwT nfhs;Sk; xUtu; jd; kidtpapd; kiwTWg;ig ghu;f;fhky; ,Uf;f ,ayhJ. mg;gbg; ghu;j;jhy;
mJ fz;iz FUlhf;fptpLk; vd;W $Wtijg; ghu;j;jhy; Mz;fspy; 99% Ngu; FUlu;fshfj; jhd; Mfp
,Uf;f Ntz;Lk;. NkYk; ,d;iwa kUj;Jtu;fs; ,];yhj;ijf; Nfypf;Fhpajhfj; jhd; ghu;g;ghu;fs;.
vj;jidNah lhf;lu;fs;> ngz; kUj;Jtu;fs;> gpurtk; ghu;f;Fk;NghJ xU ngz;zpd; kiwTWg;ig
ghu;f;fNt nra;thu;fs;. ,tu;fSf;nfy;yhk; fz; FUlhfp tpl;ljh? jtwhd fUj;ijg; gpujpgypf;Fk; ve;j
nra;jpiaAk; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wNt khl;lhu;fs;. vdNt mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; kl;Lk; ,J NfhshW
cilajy;y. mwpTg;g+u;tkhfTk; $l Vw;Wf; nfhs;s Kbahj `jPN]ahFk;.
kidtpapd; kiwTWg;igg; ghu;f;ff;$lhJ vd;w ,e;j ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l `jP];> gpd;tUk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd
`jP]{f;Fk; Kuz;gLfpwJ.
ehDk; egp(]y;) mtu;fSk; xNu ghj;jpuj;jpy; Fspg;Nghk;. vdf;F (nfhQ;rk; jz;zPu;) itAq;fs;.
vdf;F (nfhQ;rk; jz;zPu); itAq;fs; vd;W ehd; nrhy;Yk; msTf;F egp(]y;) mtu;fs; vd;dplk;
Nghl;b NghLthu;fs; vd Map\h(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;
fztDk; kidtpAk; xNu ,lj;jpy;> xNu ghj;jpuj;jpy; ,Ue;J ,UtUk; Nru;e;J jz;zPu; ms;sp
Fspf;Fk;NghJ xUtUf;nfhUtu; jq;fspd; kiwTg; gFjpiag; ghu;f;f Ntz;baNj Vw;gLk;. mg;gbg; ghu;j;j
egp(]y;) mtu;fSf;Nfh> Map\h(uyp) mtu;fSf;Nfh fz;zpy; Fiw VJk; Vw;gltpyi; y. NkYk; ,e;j
`jPi]Na Map\h(uyp) mtu;fs; kiwTWg;ig ghu;f;fyhk; vd;gjw;F Mjhukhff; nfhz;Ls;shu;fs;
vd;gij gpd;tUk; rk;gtk; njspTgLj;JfpwJ.
xUtu; jd; kidtpapd; kiwTWg;igg; ghu;f;fyhkh? vd ehd; mjhc mtu;fsplk; Nfl;Nld;. mjw;F
mtu;fs; ,Nj tp\aj;ij ehDk; Map\h(uyp) mtu;fsplk; Nfl;lNghJ mtu;fs;> jhDk; egp(]y;)
mtu;fSk; xNu ghj;jpuj;jpy; Fspj;j `jPi] $wptpl;L> ',e;j `jPN] xU ngz; jd; fztdpd;

12 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

kiwTWg;igg; ghu;g;gJk;> fztd; kidtpapd; kiwTWg;igf; fhz;gJk; $Lk; vd;gjw;F MjhukhFk;'


vd;W Map\h(uyp) $wpajhf mjhc mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: ,g;D `pg;ghd;
vdNt kiwTWg;igg; ghu;g;gjhy; fz; FUlhfptpLk; vd;Ws;s `jP]; ngha;ahd `jP]hFk;.

10. jiyg;ghifAld; njhOjhy;...!

''jiyg;ghif mzpeJ; xU (uf;mj;) njhOtJ> jiyg;ghif mzpahky; 25 (uf;mj;) njhOtjw;Fg;


gfukhFk;. jiyg;ghif mzpe;J xU [{k;M njhOtJ> jiyg;ghif mzpahky; 70 [{k;M
njhOtjw;Fg; gfukhFk;. kyf;Ffs; [{k;Mtpy; jiyg;ghif mzpe;Nj fye;J nfhs;thu;fs;. md;W
jiyg;ghif mzpeJ ; nfhs;gtUf;F #hpad; kiwAk; tiu JMr; nra;thu;fs;.''
jiyg;ghif mzpe;jpUe;j mg;Jy;yh ,g;D cku;(uyp) mtu;fsplk; ehd; nrd;Nwd;. mJ rkak; mtu;fs;
vd;dplk;> kfNd! jiyg;ghif mzpe;J nfhs;tij tpUk;gpf; nfhs;. kfNd! jiyg;ghif mzpe;J
nfhs;! eP fz;zpak; ngWtha;! cau;T miltha;; kjpg;G ngWtha; vd;W $wptpl;L> Nkw;fz;l nra;jpia
egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhfTk; $wpdhu;fs;.
,ij mg;Jy;yh ,g;D cku;(uyp) mtu;fspd; kfd; ]hypk; vdf;F mwptpjj ; hu; vd k`;jP ,g;D ik%d;
mwptpf;fpd;whu;. ,ij ,g;D e[;[hu; mtu;fs; jdJ E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;sdu;.
,e;j `jP]; gw;wp `hgpo; ,g;D `[u; (u`;) mtu;fs; 'yprhDy; kP]hd;' vDk; jkJ E}ypy; ,e;j
`jP]; ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ vd;Wk; ,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; cs;s rpyu; ahnud;Nw mwpag;glhjtu;fs;
vd;Wk; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;. NkYk; ,khk; Råj;jp(u`;) mtu;fSk; ,ij ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l `jP]; vd
mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;.
''jiyg;ghif mzpe;J ,uz;L uf;mj; njhOtJ> jiyg;ghif ,y;yhky; 70 uf;mj; njhOtij tpl
rpwe;jJ.''
,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf [hgpu;(uyp) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs;. ,e;j `jPi] ,khk; Råj;jp(u`;)
mtu;fs; jkJ 'my;[hkpc]; ]fPu;' vDk; E}ypy; nfhz;L te;J ',J ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ' vd
milahsk; fhl;Lfpwhu;fs;.
,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk; ngWk; jhf; ,g;D mg;Jw;w`;khd; vd;gtu; rhpahdtu; my;y vd
,khk; e]aP (u`;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf j`gP(u`;) mtu;fs; jdJ 'Ymgh/' vDk; E}ypy;
Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;. ,e;j `jP]; rhpay;y vd ,khk; ]`htP(u`;) mtu;fs; $Wfpwhu;fs;.
''jiyg;ghif mzpe;J njhOtJ> 10 Mapuk; ed;ikfs; nra;tjw;Fg; gfukhFk;.''
,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf md];(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. mijAk; Råj;jp(u`;)
mtu;fs; jdJ 'm`hjPjpy; kt;@Mj;' vDk; E}ypy; nfhz;L te;J ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ vd milahsk;
fhl;Lfpwhu;fs;. ,khk; ]`htP> ,khk; kD}/gP> ,khk; ,g;D `[u; MfpNahUk; ,J ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l
`jP]; vd;Nw Fwpg;gpLfpd;wdu;.
Nkw;fz;l `jP];fspd; fUj;Jk; ed;F rpe;jpj;jhy; jtW vd;gJ tpsq;Fk;. jiyg;ghif> njhg;gp
,y;yhky; gy rkak; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; njhOJs;sjw;F epiwa `jP];fs; cs;sd. jiyg;ghif
mzpe;J njhOtjhy; mjpf ed;ik fpilf;Fk; vd;wpUe;jhy; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; vg;NghJk; jiyg;ghif
mzpeN; j njhOjpUf;f Ntz;Lk;. Mdhy; mtu;fs; jiyiaj; jpwe;j epiyapy; njhOjjpy; ,Ue;Nj ,e;j
nra;jpfis ahNuh ,l;Lf;fl;bapUf;fpwhu;fs; vd;gJ njspthFk;.
jiyiaj; jpwe;j epiyapy; njhOtJ egp(]y;) mtu;fSf;F kl;LNk cs;s jdpr;rYif vd;W $l rpyu;
thjplyhk;. Mdhy; egpj;Njhou;fs; gyu; jiyia jpwe;j epiyapy; njhOjjhf `jP];fs; cs;sdNt.
,e;j `jP];fs; cz;ik vd;wpUe;jhy; `jP];fis mg;gbNa gpd;gw;wp tho;e;j ]`hgpfs; jiyg;ghif
mzpahky; njhOjJ %yk; Rd;dj;jpw;F khw;wk; nra;jpUg;ghu;fsh? vdNt Nkw;fz;l `jP]f; Sk;
,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;litfNs!

13 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

11. nra;jp $Wk; NghJ Jk;kyhkh?

''xUtd; xU nra;jpiar; nrhy;Yk;NghJ (mtNdh my;yJ NtW ahNuh) Jk;kpdhy; mr;nra;jp


cz;ikahFk;.''
,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. ,r;nra;jpia mg+a/yh>
jg;uhdP MfpNahu; gjpT nra;Js;sdu;. ,khk; ,g;Dy; [t;]P(uyp) mtu;fs; jdJ kt;@Mj; vd;w E}ypy;
,ijf; nfhz;L te;J ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ vd;W milahsk; fhl;Lfpwhu;fs;.
,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk;ngWk; KMtpah vd;gtu; Kw;wpYk; gytPdkhdtu; vd ,g;DKaPd;>
mg+`hjk;> e]aP MfpNahu; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. ig`fP mtu;fs; jdJ E}ypy; gjpT nra;Jtpl;L 'Vw;Wf;
nfhs;sg; glj;jf;fjy;y' vd;Wk; $Wfpwhu;fs;.
ve;jg; Ngr;rpd; NghJ Jk;kg;gLNkh me;jg; Ngr;Nr kpf cz;ikahdJ.
,r;nra;jpia egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs; vd md];(uyp) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs;. jg;uhdP mtu;fs;
jdJ E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;. ,e;j `jPi] `hgpo; i`jkP mtu;fs; jdJ E}ypy; gjpT nra;J>
'jtwhd `jP];' vd Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;. ,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk; ngWk; ckhuh ,g;D ]hjhd;
vd;gtu;> jhgpj; vd;gtd; topahf md];(uyp) $wpajhf Vw;Wf; nfhs;sj;jfhj epiwa `jPi]
mwptpj;Js;shu; vd ,khk; m`;kj;(u`;) $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,e;j `jP]{k; jhgpj; topahf ckhuh
mwptpg;gjhFk;.
Nkw;fz;l ,uz;L `jP]f ; Sk; cz;ikahdJ jhd; vd xUtd; nrhd;dhy; ehk; ,e;E}ypy;
vLj;Jf;fhl;Lk; Nghyp `jP]f ; Sk; rhp> ,d;Dk; gy vz;zw;w Nghyp `jP]f ; Sk; rhp midj;Jk;
nrhy;yg;gLk; NghJ> xUtd; Jk;kptpl;lhy; mitfSk; ey;yjhfptpLk;. nfhiy nra;j xUtd; ehd;
nfhiyahsp my;y vdr; nrhy;Yk; NghJ vtNuDk; Jk;kptpll ; hy; mtd; nfhiyahsp ,y;iy vd;W
nrhy;y KbAkh? ,g;gb xt;nthd;whf Nahrpj;Jg; ghUq;fs;. vd;d epiy Vw;gLk;? ,J Nghd;w jtwhd
fUj;ijg; gpujpgypf;Fk; xd;iw egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpapUg;ghu;fsh?
Jk;kpdhy; nra;ag;NghFk; fhhpak;> epidf;Fk; fhhpak; elf;fhJ vd;W K];ypky;yhjtu;fs; nrhy;thu;fs;.
mtu;fSf;F khw;wkhf ehk; vijahtJ nrhy;y Ntz;Lk; vd;W vz;zp Nkw;fz;l tp\aj;ij ,l;Lf;fl;b
tpl;lhu;fs; Nghy; njhpfpwJ.

12. ngz;zpd; Ngr;irf; Nfl;fyhkh?

''ngz;fSf;F fl;Lg;gl;L (mtu;fsJ Ngr;irf; Nfl;L) elg;gJ ifNrjj;jpw;FhpajhFk;.''


,J i]j; ,g;D ]hgpj;(uyp) mtu;fs; %yk; mwptpf;fg; gLk; `jP]hFk;. ,ij ,g;D mjp mtu;fs; jd;
E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;. ,e;j `jP]py; ,lk;ngWk; 'md;g]h ,g;D mg;Ju;u`;khd;' vd;gtu;
rhpahdtuy;y vd;gjhy; mJ gytPdkhd `jP]hFk;.
,tu; `jP];fis ,l;Lf;fl;b $Wgtu; vd ,khk; mg+`hjk; $Wfpwhu;fs;.
',J rhpahd `jP]; my;y. ,e;j md;g]h vd;gtUk; rhpahdtuy;y' vd;W ,e;j `jPi] gjpT
nra;Js;s ,g;D mjPNa $Wtjhf ,khk; ,g;Dy; [t;]P jd; 'kt;@Mj;' vDk; E}ypy; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.
,NjNghy; Map\h(uyp) mtu;fs; $Wtjhf xU `jPi] cifyP> ,g;D mjP> ,g;D m]hfPu; MfpNahu;
jq;fs; E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;sdu;.
,e;j `jP]{k; $l gytPdkhdJ jhd;. fhuzk;> ,e;j `jP]pd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk;ngWk;
K`k;kJ ,g;D Riykhd; ,g;D mg+fuPkh vd;gtu; jhd;.
,tUf;F Ke;ija mwptpg;ghsuhf ,lk;ngWk; `p]hk; ,g;D cu;th %yk; $Wk; ,tu;> rpy `jP];fs;
jtwhdjhf ,Uf;Fk;. 'mJNghd;w mbg;gilaw;w `jP]; jhd; ,J' vd;W cifyP mtu;fs;
$Wfpwhu;fs;.

14 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

`p]hk; %yk; ,tu; mwptpf;Fk; ,e;j `jP]; gytPdkhdNj! ,Nj `jPi] `p\hk; %yk; fhypj; ,g;D
tyPj; my;kf;]{kP vd;gtUk; mwptpf;fpwhu;. ,tu; Nkw;$wpa K`k;kJ ,g;D Riykhd; ,g;D mg+fkhit
tpl kpfTk; gytPdkhdtu; vd;W ,g;D mjP $Wfpwhu;fs;.
egp(]y;) mtu;fSf;F Kjd; Kjyhf t`P te;jNghJ> jpLf;Fw;wtu;fshf> gae;jtu;fshf> jkJ
tPl;bw;F te;J> md;id fjP[h(uyp) mtu;fsplk; te;J ele;j nra;jpfisf; $Wfpwhu;fs;. clNd
fjP[h(uyp) mtu;fs; tufh ,g;D et;gy;(uyp) mtu;fsplk; mioj;Jr; nrd;W ele;jtw;iwf; $wpdhu;fs;.
mg;NghJ tufh ,g;D et;gy;(uyp) mtu;fs; ''egp(]y;) mtu;fs; xU ,iwj;J}ju;'' vd;w nra;jpia
$wpdhu;fs;. ,J Map\h(uyp) mtu;fshy; mwptpf;fg;gl;L GfhuPapy; cs;sJ. vdNt ngz;fspd; Ngr;irf;
Nfl;L elf;fyhk; vd;gjw;F ,J Mjhug;g+u;tkhf cs;sJ.

13. ngz;Zf;F khW nra;tJ?

''ngz;fSf;F khW nra;Aq;fs;. mtu;fSf;F khW nra;tjpy; guf;fj; cz;L. ngz;fsplk; MNyhrid
nra;Aq;fs;. mNj rkak; (mtu;fspd; MNyhridf;F) khW nra;Aq;fs;''
vd;W cku;(uyp) mtu;fs; $Wtjhf xU nra;jpAk; ,lk; ngWfpdw
; J. ,e;jr; nra;jpAk; $l rhpahdjy;y
,jpy; ,lk;ngWk; `g;]; ,g;D cJkhd; ,g;D cigJy;yh vd;gtu; ahnud;Nw mwpag;glhjtu;. NkYk;
mg+ cify; vd;w a`;ah ,g;D Kj;jtf;fpy; my; ckuP vd;gtUk; gytPdkhdtuhthu;.
ngz;fSk; MNyhrid ngwg;glj;jf;ftu;fNs! mtu;fsplk; MNyhrpj;J fhhpak; Mw;Wtjpy; vt;tpjj;
jtWkpy;iy.
xt;nthU ngz;fSk; (mtu;fspd; FLk;gj;jpw;F) nghWg;ghdtu;fs;. mtu;fspd; nghWg;G gw;wpAk; tprhhpf;fg;
gLk; vd;gJ egpnkhop (E}y;:GfhuP). ,e;j `jP]pypUe;J ngz;fSf;F nghWg;Gz;L vd;gijg; Ghpayhk;.
mtu;fs; nghWg;Gilatu;fs; vd;gjpypUe;Nj MNyhrid nra;ag;glj; jFjpAs;stu;fNs vd;gJ
njspthFk;. ,e;j mbg;gilapYk; $l ngz;fs; Ngr;ir Nfl;ff;$lhJ vd;gJk; mtu;fSf;F khW nra;a
Ntz;Lk; vd;gJk; jtW vd;gij tpsq;fyhk;. ,jd; %yKk; Nkw;fz;l `jP]; gytPdkhdJ vdg;
Ghpayhk;.

14. jyhf; $wNt $lhJ?

''ePq;fs; jpUkzk; nra;Aq;fs;. jyhf; (tpthfuj;J) nrhy;yhjPu;fs;. Vndd;why; jyhf; nrhy;tJ %yk;
mu;\; eLq;FfpwJ.''
,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf myP(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. ,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy;
,lk;ngWk; mk;U ,g;D [kPc vd;gtd; ngUk; ngha;ad;; Vw;Wf; nfhs;sj;jfhj gy `jP];fisAk;
mwptpg;gtd; vd fjPg;(u`;) njhptpf;fpwhu;fs;. ,ijNa ,khk; Råj;jp(u`;) mtu;fSk;
cWjpg;gLj;Jfpwhu;fs;.
,q;Nf ,lk;ngWk; kw;nwhUtuhd [{itgu; vd;gtUk; Kw;wpYk; gytPdkhdtu;. ,g;D [t;]P(u`;)
mtu;fs; ',r;nra;jp rhpahdjy;y' vd;W $Wfpwhu;fs;. ]Mdp(u`;) mtu;fs; jdJ 'kt;@Mj;' vDk;
E}ypy; ,ijg; gjpT nra;J> ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ vd milahsk; fhl;Lfpwhu;fs;.
NkYk; ,e;jr; nra;jp gy rhpahd `jP];fSf;Fk; Fu;Md; trdq;fSf;Fk; Kuz;gLfpwJ. jpUkiwapd;
2:227> 232> 236> 237> 241> 33:49> 38:6> 65:1 Mfpa trdq;fs; jyhf; rk;ge;jkhd rl;lq;fis nrhy;tjpy;
,Ue;Nj> jyhf; tplTk; nra;ayhk; vd;gJ njspthFk;.
,e;jr; nra;jp rpy egpj;Njhou;fspd; tho;f;ifiaAk; jtW vd;W nrhy;fpwJ. Mk;! egp(]y;) mtu;fshy;
tsu;f;fg;gl;l i]j;(uyp) mtu;fs;> i]dg;(uyp) mtu;fis jpUkzk; nra;jpUe;J> gpd;du; jyhf;
tpl;Ltpl;lhu;fs; vd;w rk;gtk; cs;sJ. NkYk; rpy egpj;Njhou;fs; jq;fs; kidtp jq;fSf;F cld;gl;L
tuhjjhy; tpthfuj;J nra;Js;sdu;. ,J cz;ik vd;W ,Uf;Fkhdhy; egpj;Njhou;fs; jyhf; nrhy;yp
,Ug;ghu;fsh?

15 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

NkYk; jdf;Fg; gpbf;fhj my;yJ jd;idg; gpbf;fhj fztdplkpUe;J jd;id capUld; jw;fhj;Jf;
nfhs;s ,e;j jyhf; cjtp nra;fpwJ. ngz;Zhpikia ,];yhk; toq;Ftijf; fz;l vhpr;rYw;w rpy
fatu;fs; ,];yhKk; ngz;fis mbikg;gLj;jNt nra;fpwJ. mjdhy; jhd; tpthfuj;ij $lhJ
vd;fpwJ vd;W nrhy;tjw;fhfTk; $l ,e;jr; nra;jpia ,l;Lf;fl;bapUf;f Ntz;Lk;.

15. ,uz;lh? ehd;fh?

''egp(]y;) mtu;fs; [{k;Mtpw;F Kd; ehd;F uf;mj;Jk;> mjd; gpd; ehd;F uf;mj;Jk;> me;j
uf;mj;JfSf;fpilNa gphpf;fhky; (xNu ]yhKld;) njhOthu;fs;.''
,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) mtu;fs; $wpajhf ,J ,g;Dkh[h tpy; ,lk;ngw;Ws;sJ. ,jd; mwptpg;ghsu;fs;
njhlhpy; ,lk;ngWk; Kg\;\pu; ,g;D igJ vd;gtu; ,l;Lf;fl;lf; $batu;. NkYk; `[;[h[; ,g;D
mu;jhj;> mjpa;ah my;$gP Mfpa ,UtUk; gytPdu;fs; vd iyy< mtu;fs; Fwpg;gpL fpwhu;fs;. vdNt ,J
gytPdkhd `jP]hFk;.
',J jtwhd `jP];' vd ettP mtu;fSk; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;. NkYk; ,e;j `jP]; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd
`jP];fSf;F Kuz;glTk; nra;fpwJ vd;gjhYk; ,J gytPdkhd `jP]hFk;.
nghJthf [{k;Mtpw;F gs;spf;F tUgtu; ,khk; Fj;gh ciu epfo;j;jpf; nfhz;bUe;jhYk; ,uz;L uf;mj;
njho Ntz;Lk;. [{k;M Kbe;jJk; gs;spapy; ,Ue;jhy; ehd;F uf;mj;Jk; tPlb
; w;F clNd nrd;Wtpl;lhy;
mq;Nf ,uz;L uf;mj;Jk; njho Ntz;Lk;. ,ijg; gpd;tUk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fs;
njspTgLj;Jfpd;wd.
[{k;M jpdj;jpy; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; ciu epfo;j;jpf; nfhz;bUe;j NghJ xU kdpju; gs;spf;Fs;
Eioe;jhu;. ePu; njhOJ tpl;Buh? vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; Nfl;lhu;fs;. mtu; ,y;iy vd;whu;. ,uz;L
uf;mj;fs; njhOtPuhf! vd egp(]y;) mtu;fs; mthplk; $wpdhu;fs;. ,ij [hgpu;(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;.
E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk>; m`;kj;> mg+jh¥j;> e]aP> jpuk
; pjP> ,g;Dkh[h
'',khk; ciu epfo;jj
; pf; nfhz;bUf;Fk;NghJ vtNuDk; te;jhy; RUf;fkhf mtu; ,uz;L uf;mj;fs;
njho Ntz;Lk;'' vd;W egp(]y;) $wpajhf [hgpu;(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: K];ypk;
''cq;fspy; xUtu; [{k;M njhOjhy; mjd;gpd; mtu; ehd;F uf;mj;fs; njhol;Lk;'' vd;W egp(]y;)
mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: K];ypk;> m`;kj;> e]aP> mg+jh¥j;>
,g;Dkh[h
egp(]y;) mtu;fs; [{k;Mtpw;F gpwF tPl;bw;F nrd;W ,uz;L uf;mj;fs; njhOthu;fs; vd ,g;D
cku;(uyp) mwptpff
; pdw
; hu;fs;. E}y;: GfhuP
,e;j Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fs; mwptpf;Fk; nraYf;F khw;wkhfTk; NkNy $wpa ,g;D mg;gh];(uyp)
mtu;fspd; `jP];(?) mike;Js;sijf; fhzyhk;.

16. cz;gjw;F Kd;Gk; gpd;Gk; x@?

''cztpy; guf;fj; (mgptpUj;jp) vd;gJ> mjw;F Kd; x@r; nra;tjpy; ,Uf;fpwJ '' vd jt;uhj;jpy;
cs;sJ. ,ij ehd; egp(]y;) mtu;fsplk; $wpNdd;. mg;NghJ egp(]y;) mtu;fs;> ''cz;gjpy; guf;fj;>
mjw;F Kd;Gk; gpd;Gk; xSr; nra;tjpy; cs;sJ '' vd;W $wpdhu;fs;.
,ij ]y;khd;(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpg;gjhf jahyp]p mtu;fs; jdJ K];dj;jpy; gjpT nra;Js;sdu;.
mg+jh¥j;> jpuk
; pjP> `hfpk;> m`;kj; Mfpa E}y;fspYk; ,J cs;sJ.
,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk; ngWk; if]; ,g;D ugPc vd;gtu; gytPdkhdtu; vd;W mg+jh¥j;
$Wfpd;whu;fs;. ,tu; topahfNt jtpu (NtW topfspy;) ,e;j `jPi] ehk; mwpatpy;iy. ,tu; `jP];
Jiwapy; gytPdg; gLj;jg;gl;l tuhthu; vd;W jpu;kpjP mtu;fs; $Wfpwhu;fs;. j`gP> `hfpk; MfpNahUk;

16 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

,f;fUj;ijNa Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;. Kd;jpuP mtu;fs; ,tiu ''ey;ytu;'' vd;W $wpdhYk;> '',tu; kddrf;jp
Fiwe;jtu; jhd;'' vd;W Fwpg;gplj; jtwtpy;iy.
Ritj; ,g;D E/khd; (uyp) mtu;fs; ifgu; Aj;jk; ele;j tUlk; egp(]y;) mtu;fSld; ifgUf;Fr;
nrd;whu;fs;. ifgiu mLj;Js;s ]`;gh/ vd;w ,lj;ij mile;jJk; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; m]u;
njhOifiaj; njhOjhu;fs;. gpd;du; gaz czitf; nfhz;L tUkhW $wpdhu;fs;. mg;NghJ> khitj;
jtpu NtW vJTk; nfhz;L tug;gltpy;iy. mijf; Fiof;Fk;gb fl;lisapl;lhu;fs;. mJ
Fiof;fg;gl;lJk; mij egp(]y;) mtu;fSk;> ehq;fSk; rhg;gpl;Nlhk;. gpd;du; k/hpGj; njhOiff;fhfr;
nrd;whu;fs;. mg;NghJ thia (kl;Lk;) nfhg;gspjj
; hu;fs;. ehq;fSk; tha; nfhg;gspj;Njhk;. Gjpjhf xSr;
nra;ahkNyNa njhOjhu;fs;. E}y;: K];ypk;
,e;j `jP];> vijAk; rhg;gpl;l gpd;G x@r; nra;aj; Njitapy;iy vd;W mwptpf;fpd;wd. Mdhy; ehk;
NkNy Fwpg;gpl;Ls;s nra;jpNah> rhg;gpl;l gpd;G x@r; nra;a Ntz;Lk; vd;W $WfpwJ. Mjhug;g+u;tkhd
`jP];fSf;F Kuzhf cs;sjpy; ,Ue;Nj mJ ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jpahfj; jhd; ,Uf;f Ntz;Lk;
vd;w KbTf;F tuyhk;.
xl;lfj;jpd; ,iwr;rpia rhg;gpl;lhy; xS nra;a Ntz;Lkh? vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fsplk;
Nfl;fg;gl;lNghJ> mjw;fhf xSr; nra;Aq;fs; vd;W egp(]y;) $wpdhu;fs;. Ml;L ,iwr;rpia rhg;gpl;l
gpd;G x@r; nra;a Ntz;Lkh? vd;W Nfl;fg;gl;ljw;F mjw;fhf x@r; nra;a Ntz;lhk; vd;W $wpdhu;fs;
vd guh ,g;D M]pg;(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: K];ypk;> jpu;kpjP> mg+jh¥j;> m`;kj;>
,g;Dkh[h
x@Tld; rhg;gpLgtu; xl;lf ,iwr;rpia cz;lhy; kl;LNk x@r; nra;a Ntz;Lk; vd;W ,e;j `jP];
mwptpf;fpd;wJ. kw;w czTfs; cz;gjhy; cz;l gpd;G x@r; nra;a Ntz;bajpy;iy vd;gijg;
Ghpayhk;.
cz;gjw;F Kd; x@ mtrpak; vd;W ,Uf;Fkhdhy; cz;l gpd;G x@r; nra;aj; Njitapy;iy vd;W
jhd; KbTf;F tuNtz;Lk;. rhg;gpLk; Kd; nra;j x@ Kwpe;jhy; kl;LNk rhg;gpl;l gpd;G nra;jy; mtrpak;
vd;W ,Uf;f Ntz;Lk;. vijAk; rhg;gpl;lhy; x@ KwpAk; vd;W ,Uf;Fkhdhy; cz;Zk; Kd; x@r;
nra;a Ntz;bajpy;iy. ,J jhd; rhpahFk;.
rhg;gpl;lhy; x@ KwpAk; vd;W tUk;NghJ rhg;gpLk; Kd; x@r; nra;tJ vd;gJ mu;j;jkw;wjhfp
tpLfpd;wJ. mu;j;jkw;w nraiy egp(]y;) mtu;fs; nra;Ak;gb tw;GWj;jp ,Ug;ghu;fsh? vd;W Nahrpf;f
Ntz;Lk;. ,e;j mbg;gilapy; $l cz;Zk; Kd; x@r; nra;tjpy; guf;fj; cz;L vd;W $WtJ ngha;
vd;W Ghpayhk;.
egp(]y;) mtu;fs; Fspg;Gf; flikahd epiyapy; cz;zNth> cwq;fNth tpUk;gpdhy; x@r; nra;J
nfhs;thu;fs; vd Map\h(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: K];ypk;> m`;kj;> e]aP
egp(]y;) mtu;fs; Fspg;Gf; flikahd epiyapy; cwq;f tpUk;gpdhy; x@r; nra;J nfhs;thu;fs;.
cz;zNth> gUfNth tpUk;gpdhy; jk; ,UiffisAk; fOtp tpl;Nl cz;ghu;fs; vd;W Map\h(uyp)
mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: m`;kj;> e]aP
,e;j `jP];fs; Fspg;Gf; flikahdtu; cz;z tpUk;gpdhy; iffis fOtpdhy; NghJk;. MdhYk;
x@r; nra;tNj rpwg;G vd;W $Wfpd;wd. Fspg;Gf; flikahdtu; $l cz;Zk; Kd; x@r; nra;tJ
rpwg;G vd;W jhd; $wg;gLfpd;wJ.
vdNt> cz;gjw;F Kd;Dk;-gpd;Dk; x@r; nra;a Ntz;Lk; vd;W tUk; `jP]; rhpahdjy;y. mNj rkak;
xl;lff; fwpia cz;l gpd;G x@r; nra;a Ntz;Lk;. Fspg;Gf; flikahdtu; cz;Zk; Kd; x@r; nra;J
nfhs;tJ rpwg;ghFk; vd;gJ kl;LNk egptop.

17. cSr; nra;j gpwF 97tJ mj;jpahak; XJjy;?

''x@r; nra;j gpwF ,d;dh md;]y;dhF.. vd;W Jtq;Fk; 97tJ mj;jpahak; XjNtz;Lk;.''

17 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

,g;gbg;gl;l nra;jp xd;W gutyhf egp(]y;) mtu;fspd; $w;whfg; Ngrg;gl;Lk;> ,ij nray;gLj;jg; gl;Lk;
tUfpwJ. ,ij ]fhtP mtu;fs;> ve;j mbg;gilAkpy;yhj nra;jp ,J vd;W $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,J gpd;tUk;
Mjhug;g+u;tkhd nra;jpf;Fk; khw;wkhf cs;sJ.
cq;fspy; vtNuDk; x@r; nra;J Kbj;j gpd; ''m\;`J md;yhapyh` ,y;yy;yh`{ yh\uPf y`{
tm\;`J md;d K`k;kjd; mg;J`{ tu#Y`{'' vd;W $wpdhy; Rtu;ff ; j;jpd; vl;L thapy;fSk;
mtUf;fhfj; jpwf;fg;gLfpd;wd vd egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf cf;gh ,g;D Mkpu;(uyp) mtu;fs;
mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. E}y;: K];ypk;
Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]{f;F khw;wkhf ,J ,Ug;gjpy; ,Ue;Nj 97tJ mj;jpahaj;ij XjNtz;Lk;
vd;gJ ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l gr;irg; ngha; vd;gij tpsq;fyhk;.

18. nts;spad;W...?

''[{k;M ehspy; xUtu; Nehd;G itj;jtuhfTk;> Nehahspia Neha; tprhhpj;jtuhfTk;> (grpj;j) Viof;F
cztspj;jt uhfTk;> [dh]hit gpd;gw;wpatuhfTk; ,Ue;jhy; mtiu ehw;gJ tUlq;fspd; Fw;wq;fs;
milahJ.''
,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf [hgpu;(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. ,g;D mjP mtu;fs; jdJ
my;fhkpy; vDk; E}ypy; ghfk;-2> gf;fk;-122y; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;. ,g;Dy; [t;]p mtu;fSk; jdJ
my;kt;@Mj; vDk; E}ypy; ghfk;-2> gf;fk;-107y; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.
,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; fPo;f;fz;Nlhu; ,lk; ngWfpd;wdu;.
m) ,];khapy; ,g;D ,g;uh`Pk;
M) fyPy; ,g;D Ku;uh
,) mk;U ,g;D `k;]h my;g]uP
,tu;fs; rhpahdtu;fsy;yu;> gytPdu;fs; vd;W ,g;Dy; [t;]P mtu;fs; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.
''[{k;M ehspy; Nehd;ghspahf> Nehahspia tprhhpj;jtuhf> [dh]htpy; fye;J nfhz;ltuhf> VNjDk;
ju;kk; nra;jtuhf xUtu; ,Ue;jhy; mtUf;F Rtu;f;fk; flikahf;fg;gl;L tpl;lJ.''
,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf ig`fPapy; ,lk; ngw;Ws;sJ. ,jpYk; $l mg;Jy; m[P]; ,g;D
mg;Jy;yh my;cit]p> ,g;D Yi`M MfpNahu; ,lk; ngWtjhy; ,JTk; gytPdkhdjhFk;. mg;Jy;
m[P]; mtu;fis j`gP mtu;fs; jdJ 'my;Ymghc' vDk; E}ypy; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.
nghJthf Neha; tprhhpf;fNth> Viof;F cztspf;fNth> egpyhd Nehd;G Nehw;fNth> [dh]htpy;
fye;J nfhz;L mijg; gpd; njhlu;e;J nry;tNjh khu;f;fj;jpy; mDkjpf;fg;gl;Lj; jhd; cs;sJ. ,jw;F
epiwa `jP];fspy; Mjhuk; cz;L. Fwpg;ghf ,e;j `jP];fs; cs;s tp\aq;fs; midj;ijAk; xNu
ehspy; nra;tjhy; Rtu;f;fk; cz;L vd;gij Mjhug;g+u;tkhd gpd;tUk; `jP]; njspTgLj;JfpwJ.
,d;W cq;fspy; Nehd;ghspahf ,Ug;gtu; ahu;? vd egp(]y;) mtu;fs; Nfl;lhu;fs;. mg+gf;fu;(uyp)
mtu;fs;> ehd; vd;W $wpdhu;fs;. ,d;W cq;fspy; Nehahspia tprhhpj;jtu; ahu;? vd;W egp(]y;)
mtu;fs; Nfl;f> ehd; vd;W mg+gf;fu;(uyp) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs;. ,d;W cq;fspy; [dh]htpy; fye;J
nfhz;ltu; ahu;? vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; Nfl;f> ehd; vd;W mg+gf;fu;(uyp) $wpdhu;fs;. ,d;W Viof;F
cztspj;jtu; ahu;? vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; Nfl;f> ehd; vd mg+gf;fu;(uyp) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs;.
'xUthplk; xNu ehspy; ,e;j ew;nray;fs; Nru;ej
; hy; mtu; Rtu;f;fj;jpy; EioahjpUg;gjpy;iy' vd;W
mg;NghJ egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs;. ,ij mg+ `{iuuh(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;:
K];ypk;
,e;j Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]py; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; nts;spahd ,d;W vd;W $wtpy;iy. ,e;j
ew;nray;fis vd;iwf;Fk; vtu; nra;jhYk; Rtu;f;fk; cz;L vd;gijNa ,e;j %yk; `jP]; tpsq;f
KbfpwJ.

18 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

',d;W' vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpf; Nfl;l NghJ> md;W nts;spf;fpoikahf Vd; ,Uf;ff;$lhJ?
vd;W rpyu; $wp> Nkw;fz;l gytPdkhd `jPi] '`]d;' vd;w me;j];jpw;F nfhz;L tu Kaw;rpf;fyhk;.
Mdhy; md;W nts;sp jhd; vd;gjw;F mg+gf;fu;(uyp) rk;ge;jg;gl;l `jP]py; vt;tpjf; Fwpg;Gk; ,y;iy.
md;W nts;sp jhd; vd;W $WNthuhYk; Mjhuj;ijf; fhl;l ,ayhJ.
NkYk;> nts;spad;W kl;Lk; Nehd;G itf;f nghJthfj; jilAk; cs;sJ.
''nts;spf;fpoikf;F Kd;dhNyh my;yJ gpd;dhNyh Nehd;G itg;gtu; jtpu kw;wtu; nts;spf;fpoik
Nehd;G Nehw;f Ntz;lhk;'' vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+ `{iuuh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;.
E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;> jpu;kpjP
,e;j tifapYk; $l Nkw;Fwpg;gpl;Ls;s nra;jp jtwhdJ vd;gJ njspthfpwJ.

19. '`a;a myy; /gyh`;' vd;W $Wk;NghJ...?

''`a;a myy; /gyh`; vd;W Kmj;jpd; $Wtijf; Nfl;lhy; my;yh`{k;k[;mydh K/g;yp`Pd (,iwth!
vq;fis ntw;wpahsu;fshf Mf;fp itg;ghahf!)'' vd;W $wNtz;Lk;.
,ij KMtpah ,g;D mgP]{g;ahd;(uyp) mwptpf; fpwhu;fs;. ,ij ,g;D]{d;dp mtu;fs;> 'mkYy; at;kp
ty;iyyj;' vDk; jdJ E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.
,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk; ngWk; e];u; ,g;D juP/g; vd;gtuhy; ,J jtwhd nra;jpahfptpLfpwJ.
',tu; `jP]; fiyapduhy; iftplg;gl;ltu;' vd e]aP mtu;fSk; kw;wtu;fSk; $Wfpwhu;fs;. '`jPi]
,l;Lf;fl;Ltjpy; gpugy;a khd egu;fspy; xUtu; jhd; ,tu;' vd a`;ah ,g;DKaPd; $Wfpwhu;fs;.
,JNghy; ,jd; mwptpg;ghsy; ,lk; ngWk; mg;Jy;yh ,g;Dthfpj; vd;gtUk; Kw;wpYk; gytPduhFk;. ,tu;
`jP]; fiyapduhy; iftplg;gl;ltu; vd;Wk;> ,tu; gw;wpa ey;y fUj;ij vtUk; $wtpy;iy vd;Wk;
,khk; GfhuP $Wfpwhu;. ,tu; rhpahdtu; my;yu; vd e]aP $Wfpwhu;fs;. [uPu; mtu;fs; ',tiu gytPdu;'
vd;W Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.
,J gpd;tUk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]{f;Fk; khw;wkhf cs;sJ.
my;yh`{ mf;gu; my;yh`{ mf;gu; vd;W Kmj;jpd; $Wk;NghJ> cq;fspy; xUtu; my;yh`{ mf;gu;
my;yh`{ mf;gu; vd;Wk;> gpd;G m\;`J md;yhapyh` ,y;yy;yh`; vd;W $wpdhy;> m\;`J
md;yhapyh` ,y;yy;yh`{ vd;Wk;> gpdG; m\;`J md;d K`k;kju; u#Yy;yh`{ vd;W (Kmj;jpd);
$Wk;NghJ m\;`J md;d K`k;kju; u#Yy;yh`; vd;Wk;> gpd;G `a;a my];]yhj; vd;W (Kmj;jpd);
$Wk;NghJ> yh `t;y tyh Ft;tj;j ,y;yh gpy;yh`; vd;Wk;> `a;a myy; /gyh`; vd;W $Wk;NghJ>
yh `t;y tyh Ft;tj;j ,y;yh gpy;yh`; vd;Wk;> gpd;G my;yh`{ mf;gu; my;yh`{ mf;gu; vd;W
$Wk;NghJ my;yh`{ mf;gu; my;yh`{ mf;gu; vd;Wk;> yhapyh` ,y;yy;yh`{ vd;W $Wk;NghJ
yhapyh` ,y;yy;yh`{ vd;Wk; (,itfis) kdjpw;Fs; $wpdhy; mtu; Rtu;ff ; k; Eiothu; vd
cku;(uyp) $wpdhu;fs;. E}y;: K];ypk;
Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]py; 'yh `t;y tyh Ft;tj;j ,y;yh gpy;yh`;' vd;W jhd; '`a;a myy; /gyh`;'
vd;W $wg;gLk;NghJ $wNtz;Lk; vd Fwpg;gplg;gLtjhy; Nkw;$wpa nra;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l xd;Nw
vd;gij tpsq;fyhk;.

20. nts;spf;fpoik NjhWk;...

''xUtu; jd; ngw;Nwhu; ,UtuJ fg;iu my;yJ mt;tpUtu;fspy; xUtuJ fg;iu xt;nthU ([{k;M)
nts;spf;fpoikfspYk; ]pahuj; nra;tjhy; mtuJ Fw;wq;fs; kd;dpf;fg;gLk;. ed;ik vOjg;gLk;.''
egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. ,ij jg;uhdP mtu;fs; jdJ
]fPu;> mt;]j; E}y;fspy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.
,e;j xU mwptpg;ghsu; njhlhpy; kl;LNk mg+ `{iuuh(uyp) mwptpg;gjhf ,e;j `jP]; cs;sJ vd;W

19 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

jg;uhdP mtu;fs; Fwpg;gplTk; nra;fpwhu;fs;.


,jd; mwptpgg; hsu; njhlhpy; ,lk;ngWk; a`;ah ,g;D my;myhc my;g[yP vd;gtu; `jP]; fiyapduhy;
iftplg; gl;ltuhthu;.
,e;j a`;ah ngha;au; vd tfPc mtu;fs; $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,tu; ngha;au;; ,l;Lf;fl;Lgtu; vd ,khk;
m`;kj; $Wfpwhu;fs;.
,tuJ gy mwptpg;Gfs; gytPdkhdJ vd;gJ njspthd jhFk;. NkYk; ,tu; %yk; tUk; `jP];fs;
,l;Lf;fl;lg; gl;litfNs vd;W ,g;D mjP mtu;fs; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.
a`;ahTf;F ,r;nra;jpia mwptpj;j mg;Jy; fuPk; cika;ah mtu;fSk; gytPduhthu;. ,ij ,khk; Råj;jp
$Wfpwhu;fs;.
mg;Jy; fuPk; mtu;fis gytPdu; vdf; $Wk; mNj rkak; ,e;j a`;ahit ,d;dhu; vd njhpatpy;iy
vdTk; Råj;jp $Wfpwhu;fs;. Mdhy; Råj;jp mtu;fspd; ,f;$w;W rhpay;y!
fhuzk;> a`;ah vd;gJ ,d;dhu; vd;gJ Ge;jJ jhd;. mtu; ngha;au; vd;gJk; njspT.
,e;j `jP]pd; mwptpg;ghsu; njhlhpy; cs;s FiwghL fshy; kl;Lk; Fiw fhztpy;iy. ,J
Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]{f;Fk; $l khw;wkhfNt cs;sJ.
''fg;Ufis ]pahuj; nra;a ehd; jil nra;jpUe;Njd;. K`k;kJ (Mfpa ehd;) jd; jhahd; fg;iu
]pahuj; nra;a mDkjpf;fg;gl;lhu;. vdNt ePq;fSk; ]pahuj; nra;Aq;fs;. (mJ) kWikia
epidTgLj;Jk;'' vd;W (]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf Giujh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: K];ypk;>
jpu;kpjP
,e;j `jP]py; cs;s ]pahuj; nra;Aq;fs;> mJ kWikia epidTgLj;Jk; vd;w thu;j;ijia
ftdpf;Fk;NghJ> (egp) mtu;fs; nghJthf ]pahuj; nra;Aq;fs; vd;W $Wfpwhu;fNs jtpu> Fwpg;gpl;l
ehspy; Fwpg;gpl;l Neuj;jpy; ]pahuj; nra;Aq;fs; vd;W $wtpy;iy vd;gijg; Ghpayhk;.
NkYk; ,e;j `jP]py; 'kWikia epidTgLj;Jk;'vd;Wk;> kw;nwhU `jP]py; 'kuzj;ij epidTgLj;Jk;'
vd;W jhd; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $Wfpwhu;fNs jtpu> 'ghtq;fs; kd;dpf;fg; gLk; ed;ikfs; vOjg;gLk;'
vd;nwy;yhk; $wtpy;iy vd;gijAk; Ghpayhk;.
NtW Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]f ; spy; ,Uf;fyhky;yth? vd;why; mJTk; ,y;iy. vdNt ,J
,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l `jP]hFk;.

21. mq;Nf ahrPd; mj;jpahak; Xjpdhy;...

''xUtu; jd; ngw;Nwhu; ,Utd; fg;iuAk; xt;nthU nts;spf;fpoikAk; ]pahuj; nra;J mt;tpUtUk;
(mlf;fkhfp) cs;s ,lj;jpy; ahrPd; mj;jpahaj;ij Xjpdhy; me;j xt;nthU Maj;jpd; vz;zpf;if
msTf;F my;yJ mjd; vOj;Jf;fspd; vz;zpf;if msTf;Ff; Fw;wq;fs; kd;dpf;fg;gLk;''
vd;W egp(]y;) $wpajhf mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. ,ij ,g;DmjP> mg+eaPk; jq;fs;
E}y;fspYk;> mg;Jy;fdP my; Kfj;j]{ mtu;fs; jdJ Rdd;-Yk; gjpT nra;Js;sdu;.
,jd; mwptpg;ghsu;fspy; xUtuhd mk;U ,g;D ]pahuj; vd;gtu; rhpahdtuy;yu;; ',tu; `jP]f
; is
,l;Lf;fl;Lgtu;' vd jhuFj;dP mtu;fs; $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,g;Dy; [t;]P mtu;fSk; ,e;j `jPi]
(,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;litfs; vd;w ngaUila) jdJ 'my;kt;@Mj;' vDk; E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.
fg;iu nts;spf;fpoik ([{k;M) md;W ]pahuj; nra;jhy; Fw;wq;fs; kd;dpf;fg;gLk; vd;w thrfk;
jtwhdNj vd;gij tpsq;fpNdhk;.
,e;j `jP]pNyh> ahrPd; Xjpdhy; vd;W cs;sJ. ,t;thW fg;U nrd;W ahrPd; XJtjw;F
Mjhug;g+u;tkhd ve;j xU `jP]{k; ,y;iy. khwhf fg;iu ]pahuj; nra;ar; nrd;why; rpy thrfq;fis
nrhy;Yk;gb jhd; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpAs;shu;fs;. mjw;F gpd;tUk; `jP]; Mjhukhf cs;sJ.

20 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

egp(]y;) mtu;fs; kjPdhtpy; cs;s mlf;f];jyq;fis fle;J nrd;wNghJ mtw;iw Neuhf Nehf;fp>
''m];]yhK miyf;Fk; ah m`;yy; Fg+u;> a/gpUy;yh`{ydh tyFk; md;Jk; ]yGdh tE`;Dgpy;
m]u;'' vdf; $wpdhu;fs; vd;W Giujh(uyp) mwptpff
; pdw
; hu;fs;.
egp(]y;) mtu;fs; mlf;fj;jyj;jpw;F te;J> ''m];]yhK miyf;Fk; jhu ft;kpd; K/kpdPd ,d;\h
my;yh`{ gpFKy; yh`p$d;'' vd;W $wpdhu;fs; vd mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;:
K];ypk;> m`;kj;> e]aP
''m];]yhK miyf;Fk; m`;yj;jpahu; kpdy; K/kpdPd ty;K];ypkPd t,d;dh ,d;\h my;yh`{ gpFk;
yyh`p$d;. e];mYy;yh`ydh tyFKy; M/gpaj;j'' vd;W $Wk;gb mlf;fj;jyq;fSf;F
nry;NthUf;F egp(]y;) mtu;fs; fw;Wj; jUthu;fs; vd Giujh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: K];ypk;>
m`;kj;> ,g;Dkh[h
,e;j ]`P`hd `jP];fSf;F khw;wkhf Nkw;$wpa `jP]; ahrPd; XJk;gb $WtjpypUe;J ,J
,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l `jP];(?) vdg; Ghpayhk;.

22. rigapy; ,Ue;J vOk;NghJ...

''egp(]y;) mtu;fs; VjhtJ xU rigapy; ,Ue;J vOe;J tpl ehbdhy;> m];j/gpUy;yh`;


(,iwtdplk;) kd;dpg;Gf; NfhUfpNwd;) vd;W 10 Kjy; 15 jlit $Wthu;fs;''
,ij mg+ckhkh(uyp) mtu;fs; $wpajhf g`;t>P ,g;D]d;d>P ,g;D mjP Nghd;Nwhu; jq;fsJ E}y;fspy;
gjpT nra;Js;sdu;. ,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; njhlhpy; ,lk; ngWk; [/gu; rhpahdtuy;y vd;gjhy; ,e;jr;
nra;jp gytPdkhd jhFk;. ,tu; ngha;au; vd;W \{/gh $Wfpwhu;fs;.
,tu; `jP]; fiyapduhy; iftplg;gl;ltu; vd;W ,khk; GfhuP $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,tuJ `jP]f
; s;
gytPdkhdit vd;gJ njspthdJ vd;W ,g;D mjP mtu;fSk; $Wfpwhu;fs;.
egp(]y;) mtu;fs; rigapy; ,Ue;J vOk;NghJ 20 jlit m];j/gpUy;yh`; $Wgtu;fshf ,Ue;jdu;
vd;W mg;Jy;yh ,g;D eh]p`; my;`s;ukP mtu;fs; $wpajhf ,g;D]d;dP mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;.
,ij mwptpf;Fk; mg;Jy;yh ,g;D eh]p`; mtu;fs; egpj;Njhou; my;y vd;W mg+eaPk; mtu;fs;
Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;. ,e;j tifapy; ,r;nra;jp Ku;]yhFk;.
e];u; ,g;D Fi]kh vd;gtu; ,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirj; njhlhpy; ,lk; ngWfpwhu;. ,tiug; gw;wpf;
Fwpg;G VJk; fpilf;ftpy;iy vd;gjhYk; ,r;nra;jp gytPd khdjhFk;.
egp(]y;) mtu;fs; xU rigapypUe;J vOk;NghJ ,Wjp apy;> ]{g;`hdfy;yh`{k;k tgp`k;jpf m\;`J
md; yhapyh` ,y;yh md;j;j m];j/gpUf;f tmJ}G ,iyf vd;W $Wgtu;fshf ,Ue;jdu;. mg;NghJ
xU kdpju;> my;yh`;tpd; J}jNu! ,jw;F Kd;G nrhy;yhj xU nrhw;nwhliu ePq;fs; $wpdPuf ; Ns! vdr;
nrhy;y mJ me;j rigapy; epfo;e;jtw;wpw;F gfhukhfptpLfpwJ vdf; $wpdhu;fs; vd;W mg+gu;]h(uyp)
mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: mg+jh¥j;> `hfpk;
rigapy; ,Ue;J vOk;NghJ ,jidj;jhd; $w Ntz;Lk; vd;W njspthf egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpapUf;f
,jw;F khw;wkhf NkNy Fwpg;gpl;l nra;jpfs; ,Ug;gjpy; ,Ue;Nj> mitfs; ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;litfs; jhd;
vd;gjpy; re;Njfkpy;iy.

23. njhOJ nfhz;Nl jhd; ,Uf;f Ntz;Lkh?

''xU mbahd; njhOifapy; ,Uf;Fk;NghJ ,iwtdpd; ,U fz;fSf;fpilNa ,Uf;fpwhd;. njhOifia


Kbj;J jpUk;gpdhy; Mjkpd; kfNd! eP ahu; gf;fk; jpUk;Gfpwha;? vd;id tpl cdf;F rpwe;jtd; gf;fkh
(jpUk;gp tpl;lha;) Mjkpd; kfNd! cd; njhOifapd; gf;fk; (kPz;Lk;) eP th! eP vtu; gf;fk;
jpUk;GfpwhNah mtiu tpl ehd; cdf;Fr; rpwe;jtd;.''

21 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. ,r;nra;jpia cifyp mtu;fs;


jd; 'mo;Om/gh' vd;w E}ypYk; g];]hu; mtu;fs; jdJ K];dj; tpYk; gjpT nra;Js;sdu;.
,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk;ngWk; ,g;uh`Pk; ,g;D a]Pj; my;$gp vd;gtu; rhpahdtu; my;y vd;W
,g;D KaPd; $Wfpwhu;fs;. `jP]; fiyapy; iftplg;gl;ltu; ,tu; vd m`;kj;> GfhuP> e]aP MfpNahu;
$Wfpwhu;fs;.
,JNghd;w `jP];fis itj;Jj; jhd; rpyu; FLk;gj;ij kwe;J> cwit kwe;J> r%f tho;it kwe;J
rjh NeuKk; njhOfpNwhk; vd;w ngay; ,Ue;J Kw;wpYk; topnfl;Lg; Ngha; tpLfpdw
; du;. kiyapd;
FiffspYk;> kuj;jbfspYk; jpahdk; vd;w ngay; topnfl;Lg; Nghdtu;fs; ,J Nghd;w `jP];fspd;
ngauhy; cs;s nra;jpfis itj;Jj;jhd;.
egp(]y;) mtu;fsJ kidtpau; xUthplk; %d;W Ngu; te;J> egp(]y;) mtu;fspd; tzf;fk; gw;wp Nfl;L
mwpe;jJk;> ,dp ehd; J}q;fhky; tzf;fk; GhpNtd; vd xUtUk;> ehd; njhlu;e;J Nehd;G itg;Ngd; vd
xUtUk;> ehd; jpUkzNk nra;a khl;Nld; vd xUtUk; $wpdu;. ,ij mwpe;j egp(]y;) mtu;fs;
mk;%tiuAk; mioj;J> ehd; xU ehs; Nehd;G itj;J kWehs; tpl;L tpLfpNwd;. J}q;fTk; nra;fpNwd;.
tzf;fKk; GhpfpNwd;> jpUkzKk; nra;Js;Nsd;; vd;W $wptpl;L ,it vd; topKiw. ,ijg;
Gwf;fzpg;gtd; vd;idr; Nru;e;jtd; my;yd; vd;W $wpdhu;fs; vd md];(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;:
GfhuP
egp(]y;) mtu;fSld; ehq;fs; rpWgilAld; NghUf;Fr; nrd;Nwhk;. mg;NghJ jz;zPUk;> fPiufSk;
tsu;e;jpUf;fpd;w xU Fif topNa nry;Yk;NghJ> 'ehd; ,t;Tyfj; njhlu;Gfis tpl;L Kw;wpYk; ePq;fp>
me;jf; Fifapy; jq;fg; NghfpNwd;' vd jdf;Fj;jhNd xU kdpju; vz;zpf; nfhz;L> mjw;fhf egp(]y;)
mtu;fsplk; mDkjp Nfl;lhu;. mjw;F egp(]y;) mtu;fs; åju;fisg; Nghd;Nwh> fpUj;jtu;fisg; Nghd;Nwh
(kidtp> kf;fSld; thohky;) FiffspYk; Njthyaq;fspYk; jdpj;J jq;fp tpLkhW ehd; mDg;gp
itf;fg;gltpy;iy. khwhf njspthd khu;f;fj;ijf; nfhz;L mDg;gg;gl;Ls;Nsd; vdf; $wp> egp(]y;)
mtu;fs; mtUf;F kWg;Gj; njhptpj;Jtpl;ldu; vd;W mg+ckhkh(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;:
m`;kj;
njhlu;e;J njhOJ nfhz;Nl ,Ue;jhy; ,iwtdpd; md;G fpilf;Fk; vd;W vjpug; hu;jj
; hy; mJ kpfTk;
jtwhFk;. Iq;fhyj; njhOifiaj; njhOtJ jhd; fl;lhaf; flikahFk;. cghpahd njhOiffisg;
nghWj;jtiu ,ju flikfis epiwNtw;Wtjw;F ,ilåwhf ,y;yhj Neuj;jpy; jhd; cghp
tzf;fq;fs; nra;a Ntz;Lk;. cghp tzf;fq;fis nra;fpNwhk; vd;w ngay; kidtp kf;fSf;F nra;a
Ntz;ba flikfis Gwf;fzpf;fj; J}z;baJk; ,JNghd;w nra;jpfs; jhd;.
xNu xStpy; 40 tUlk; me;j ,khk; njhOjhu;> ,e;j ,khk; ,unty;yhk; epd;W nfhz;Nl Fu;Mid xNu
,utpy; Xjp Kbj;jhu; vd;W fijfs; $wg;gl ,e;j nra;jp jhd; fhuzkhf mike;jJ.
vdNt> Nkw;$wpa mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpg;g jhf $wg;gLk; ,r;nra;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ
vd;gNj cz;ikahFk;.

24. Rg;`{j; njhOifapy; 94 kw;Wk; 105 tJ mj;jpahaq;fis XJjy;?

''Rg;`{j; njhOifapy; myk; e\;u`;...vd;W Jtq;Fk; 94tJ mj;jpahaj;ijAk;> myk; ju


if/g...vd;W Jtq;Fk; 105tJ mj;jpahaj;ijAk; xUtd; Xjpdhy; mtd; e\;lkila khl;lhd;.''
,g;gbAk; xU nra;jpia egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf gutyhf $wg;gl;Lk;> nray;gLj;jg;gl;Lk; tUfpwJ.
Mdhy; ]fhtP mtu;fs; jdJ E}ypy; 200k; gf;fj;jpy; ,J vt;tpj mbg;gilAkw;wJ vd;W
Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;. NkYk; ,J Mjhug;g+u;tkhd gpd;tUk; `jP];fSf;Fk; khw;wkhfNt cs;sJ.
egp(]y;) mtu;fs; Y`y;> 'ty;iyyp ,jh a`;\h' vd;W Jtq;Fk; 92tJ mj;jpahaj;ij XJthu;fs;.
m]Yk; mJ Nghd;w #uhit XJthu;fs;. Rg;`py; mijtpl kpf ePz;l #uhf;fis XJthu;fs; vd
[hgpu; ,g;D ]Kuh(uyp) mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. E}y;: K];ypk;> m`;kj;

22 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

g[;hpd; ,uz;L uf;mj;jpNyh my;yJ mjd; ,uz;bd; xd;wpNyh 60 Kjy; 100 trdq;fs; tiu XJthu;fs;
vd mg+gu;]h(uyp) mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. E}y;: K];ypk; (789)
,JNghd;w ,d;Dk; gy `jP];fspy; Rg;`{j; njhOifapy; Xjpa #uhf;fs; gw;wpf; Fwpg;gplg;gLfpwJ.
Mdhy; 94tJ> 105tJ mj;jpahaq;fs; gw;wp $wg;glNtapy;iy.
Rg;`pd; gu;S jhd; mJ. ,e;j `jP]py; $wg;gl;lNjh g[;hpd; Rd;dj; njhOif gw;wpaJ vd;W $l rpyu;
$wyhk;. Mdhy; me;j thjKk; itf;f ,ayhJ vd;gijg; gpd;tUk; `jP];fs; njspTgLj;JfpwJ.
g[;hpd; Rd;dj; njhOifapy; Kjy; uf;mj;jpy; gfuhtpd; '$Y} Mkd;dhgpy;yh`p tkh cd;rpy ,iydh'
vd;w trdj;ijAk; ,uz;lhk; uf;mj;jpy; 'Mkd;dh gpy;yh`p t\;`j; gp md;dh K];yp%d;' vd;w
trdj;ijAk; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; Xjp te;jdu; vd ,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) mwptpf; fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: K];ypk;
egp(]y;) mtu;fs; g[;hpd; Rd;dj;jpy; 'Fy;ah ma;A`y; fhgp&d> Fy;`{ty;yh`{ m`j;' Mfpa
mj;jpahaq;fis Xjp te;jdu; vd mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mwptpff ; pdw
; hu;fs;. E}y;fs;: K];ypk>; mg+jh¥j;>
,g;Dkh[h> e]aP
Mjhug;g+u;tkhd ve;j `jP]pYk; 94> 105tJ mj;jpahaq; fisg; gw;wpf; $wg;glhjjhy; Nkw;fz;l nra;jp
,l;Lf; fl;lg;gl;lNj vd;gJ njspthFk;.

25. flypy; gazk; nra;ayhkh?

''`[; nra;gtu; my;yJ ck;uh nra;gtu; my;yJ ,iwtopapy; Nghu; Ggtu; MfpNahu; jtpu NtW vtUk;
flypy; gazk; nra;af;$lhJ. Vndd;why; flypd; fPo;(euf) neUg;G cs;sJ.''
,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg;Jy;yh`; ,g;D mk;U(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. ,J mg+jh¥j;
E}ypy; cs;sJ. fjPg; mtu;fs; jdJ jy;fP]; E}ypYk;> ig`fP mtu;fs; jdJ E}ypYk; gjpT
nra;Js;sdu;.
,jpy; ,lk;ngWk; G\;u; mg+mg;Jy;yh vd;gtUk; g\Pu; ,g;D K];ypk; vd;gtUk; ahnud;Nw mwpag;
glhjtu;fs; vd ,g;D`[u; mtu;fs; jdJ 'jf;uPg;' E}ypy; $Wfpwhu;fs;. 'kP]hd;' vDk; E}ypy; $l
mt;thW jhd; Fwpg;gplg; gl;Ls;sJ.
NkYk; ,e;j `jP]py; ,o;jpuhy; cs;sJ. mg;Jy;yh`; ,g;D mk;U(uyp) topahf g\Pu; mwptpg;gjhfTk;>
mtu;fs; topahf mwptpf;fg;gLfpwJ vd jdf;F nra;jp fpilj;jJ vd;gjhfTk;> mtu;fs; topahf xU
kdpju; mwptpg;gjhfTk; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; FsWgb cs;sJ. ,ij Kd;jpu; mtu;fs; jdJ
'K];j]uP];]{dd;' vDk; jdJ E}ypy; $Wfpwhu;fs;.
,e;j `jP]; rhpay;y vd;W GfhuP mtu;fs; $Wfpwhu;fs;. ig`fP mtu;fSk; ,t;thNw $Wfpwhu;fs;.
,g;Dy; Ky;fPd; mtu;fs; jdJ 'Fyhgh' E}ypy; midj;J ,khk;fSk; ,ij gytPdkhdJ vd;W
$Wfpd;wdu; vd;W Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;. fjhgP mtu;fs;> ,ij `jP]; fiy mwpQu;fs; ,jd; mwptpg;ghsu;
thpirfis gytPdg;gLj;jpAs;sdu; vd;W $Wfpwhu;fs;. mg+jh¥j; mtu;fs; ,e;j (G\;u;> g\Pu;) ,UtUk;
ahnud mwpag;glhjtu;fs; vd;W $Wfpwhu;fs;.
''`[; nra;gtu; my;yJ ck;uh nra;gtu; my;yJ ,iwtopapy; Nghu; Ggtu; jtpu (kw;wtu;) flypy; gazk;
nra;af;$lhJ''
vd;w thrfk; kl;Lk; `h]; ,g;D myP c]hkh mtu;fspd; ]thapj; E}ypYk; cs;sJ.
,JTk; rhpahdjy;y. ,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk;ngWk; fyPy; ,g;D ]fa;ah vd;gtu;
rhpahdtuy;yu; vd;gjhy; ,J gytPdkhd nra;jpahFk;.
,g;D mt;d;> `gPg; ,g;D \`Pj; Mfpa ,Utu; topahf ,tu; epiwa jtwhd `jP];fis mwptpj;Js;shu;
vd ,g;D]; ]f;D $Wfpwhu;fs;.
ek;gfkhdtu;fs; topahf gy jtwhd `jP];fis mwptpg;gtu; ,tu; vd;W cifyP $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,tu;
`jP]; fiyapduhy; iftplg;gl;ltu; vd jf;uPgpy; ,g;D `[u; $Wfpwhu;fs;.

23 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

Mjhug;g+u;tkhd nra;jpfF
; k; $l ,J khw;wkhf cs;sJ vd;gjhYk; ,J rhpahd nra;jpapy;iy.
''my;yh`;tpd; J}jNu! Fiwe;j msT jz;zPiu vLj;Jf; nfhz;L ehq;fs; flypy; gpuahzk;
nra;fpNwhk;. ehq;fs; me;jj; jz;zPiu x@r; nra;ag; gad;gLj;jpdhy; jhfj;jhy; rpukg;gLNthk;. vdNt
fly; ePuhy; x@r; nra;ayhkh?'' vd;W xU kdpju; egp(]y;) mtu;fsplk; Nfl;lhu;. 'fly; ePu; Rj;jg;
gLj;j Vw;wjhFk;. mjpy; nrj;jitfSk; (cz;z mDkjpf;fg; gl;ljhFk;)' vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs;
$wpdhu;fs; vd mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;.
E}y;fs;: m`;kj;> mg+jh¥j;> e]aP> ,g;Dkh[h> jpuk
; pjP> ,g;DFi]kh> ,g;D `pg;ghd;> `hfpk;>
jhuFj;dP> ig`fP
tu;j;jf uPjpahd gpuahzq;fis egpj;Njhou; gyu; fg;gypy; Nkw;nfhz;Ls;sdu; vd;gjw;F ,d;Dk; gy
`jP];fs; cs;sd. vdNt Nkw;fz;l nra;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lNj!

26. cykhf;fis gpd;gw;wj;jhd; Ntz;Lk;!

''cykhf;fis gpd;gw;Wq;fs;; epr;rakhf mtu;fs; cyfj;jpd; xspahtu;. kWikapd; tpsf;Ffshtu;''


vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf md];(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. 'K];dJy; gpu;jt;];' vDk; E}ypy;
,khk; ijykP mtu;fSk;> 'my;[hkpc];]fPu;' vDk; E}ypy; Råj;jp mtu;fSk; ,e;j `jPi] gjpT
nra;Js;sdu;.
,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; fh]pk; ,g;D ,g;uh`pk; my;Ky;jP vd;gtu; ,lk; ngWfpwhu;. ',tu; ngha;au;'
vd jhuFj;dP mtu;fs; $Wfpwhu;fs;.
NkYk; ,J jpUkiw trdq;fSf;Fk; Mjhug; g+u;tkhd `jP];fSf;Fk; khw;wkhf cs;sJ
(kdpju;fNs!) cq;fs; ,iwtdplkpUe;J cq;fSf;F ,wf;fg;gl;lijg; gpd;gw;Wq;fs;. mtidad;wp
(NtnwtiuAk;) ghJfhtyu;(fshf;fpf; nfhz;L mtu;)fis gpd;gw;whjPu;fs;. ePq;fs; nrhw;gkhfNt
ey;Yzu;T ngWfpwPu;fs;. (my;Fu;Md; 7:3)
<khd; nfhz;ltu;fNs! ePq;fs; my;yh`;Tf;F topgLq;fs;. ,d;Dk; (,iwj;) J}jUf;Fk; fl;Lg;gLq;fs;.
(kw;wtu;fisg; gpd;gw;wp) cq;fs; nray;fis ghohf;fp tplhjPu;fs;. (my;Fu;Md; 47:33)
,it my;yh`;tpd; tiuaiwahFk;. vtu; my;yh`;Tf; Fk;> mtd; J}jUf;Fk; fPo;gg
; be;J elf;fpwhNuh
mtiu Rtdgjpfspy; gpuNtrpf;fr; nra;thd;. (my;Fu;Md; 4:15)
ahu; my;yh`;Tf;Fk;> (mtdJ) J}jUf;Fk; fPo;g;gbe;J elf;fpwhu;fNsh mtu;fs; my;yh`;tpd; mUisg;
ngw;w egpkhu;fs;> ]pj;jpfPd;fs;> (rj;jpathd;fs;) capu; jpahfpfs;> ew;fUkq;fSilatu;fs;
Mfpatu;fSld; ,Ug;ghu;fs;. ,tu;fs; jhk; kpf;f mofhd Njhou;fs; Mthu;fs;. my;Fu;Md; 4:69
cku;(uyp) mtu;fs; egp(]y;) mtu;fsplk; jt;uhj;jpd; xU gFjpia nfhz;L te;jhu;fs;. ,iwj;J}ju;
mtu;fNs! ,J jt;uhj;jpd; xU gFjpahFk; vd;W $wpdhu;fs;. egp(]y;) mtu;fs; NgrhjpUe;jhu;fs;.
cku;(uyp) mtu;fNsh ,ijg; gbf;f Muk;gpj;jhu;fs;. egp(]y;) mtu;fs; KfNkh (Nfhgj;jhy;) khwj;
Jtq;fpaJ.
mg;NghJ mg+gf;fu;(uyp) mtu;fs; cd;id f\;lq;fs; milal;Lk;. egp(]y;) mtu;fs; Kfj;ijg;
ghu;f;ftpy;iyah? vd;W $wpdhu;fs;. egp(]y;) mtu;fspd; Kfj;ijg; ghu;jj
; cku;(uyp) mtu;fs;>
'my;yh`;Tila Nfhgj;ij tpl;Lk;> mtdpd; J}jd; Nfhgj;ij tpl;Lk; my;yh`;tplk; ghJ fhg;Gj;
NjLfpNwd;. my;yh`;it ,iwtdhfTk;> ,];yhj;ij khu;f;fkhfTk;> K`k;kj;(]y;) mtu;fis
egpahfTk; ehk; xg;Gf; nfhz;Nlhk;' vd;W $wpdhu;fs;.
mg;NghJ egp(]y;) mtu;fs;> ',e;j K`k;kjpd; capiu ifapy; itj;jpUg;gtd; kPJ rj;jpakhf! %]h>
cq;fspilNa te;J vd;id tpl;L tpl;L mtiu ePq;fs; gpd;gw;wpdhy;> ePq;fs; Neu;topia tpl;Lk; Ngha;
tpLtPu;fs;. %]h (,t;Tyfpy;) capUld; ,Ue;jpUe;J> vd;id egpahf mtu; mile;jhy;> mtu; vd;idj;
jhd; epr;rak; gpd;gw;wp ,Ug;ghu;' vd;W $wpdhu;fs;. ,ij [hgpu;(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: jhukP

24 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

NkYk; (ek;) J}ju; cq;fSf;F vijf; nfhLf;fpd;whNuh mij vLj;Jf; nfhs;Sq;fs;. ,d;Dk; vij
tpl;Lk; cq;fis tpyf;Ffpd;whNuh mij tpl;Lk; tpyfpf; nfhs;Sq;fs;. (my;Fu;Md; 59:7)
cq;fspilNa ,uz;il tpl;Lr; nry;fpNwd;. me;j ,uz;ilAk; gpd;gw;Wk; tiu top jtwNt khl;Bu;fs;.
1) ,iwkiw Ntjk;> 2) vdJ topKiw vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs;. E}y;: my;Kmj;jh
Nkw;fz;l Fu;Md; trdq;fs;> egpnkhopfs; egp(]y;) mtu;fis gpd;gw;Wtjd; mtrpaj;ij
typAWj;Jfpd;wd. Mdhy; ,jw;F Neu; tpNuhjkhf cykhf;fis gpd;gw;Wq;fs; vd;W NkNy Fwpg;gpl;l
nra;jp $Wfpd;wJ.
cykhf;fis gpd;gw;w Ntz;Lk; vd;W kl;Lk; $wg;gl tpy;iy. mtu;fs; 'cyf xsp> kWik tpsf;F'
vd;W $wg;gL fpd;wJ. ,e;j thrfNk> cykhf;fshy; jhd; ,l;Lf; fl;lg;gl;bUf;f Ntz;Lk; vd;W
vz;zj; J}z;LfpwJ.
Fu;Md;-`jP]; mbg;gilapy; vtu; ve;jr; nra;jpia $wpdhYk; mij Vw;W elg;gJ jhd; xU K];ypkpd;
Ntiy. $Wgtu; cykhthfj;jhd; ,Uf;f Ntz;Lk; vd;W ve;j epge;jidAk; ,y;iy. $wg;gLk; nra;jp
Fu;MDf;Fk; `jP]{f;Fk; khw;wkhdjhf ,Ug;gpd; mijg; Gwf;fzpf;fTk; Ntz;Lk;. mijf; $wpatu;
vt;tsT ngatuhf ,Ue;jhYk; rhpNa!
,J Nghd;w `jP];fisf; $wp 'vq;fisg; gpd;gw;Wq;fs;' vd;W ,tu;fs; $wpajhy; K];ypk;fs;
cykhf;fs; nrhd;dhy; rhpahfj;jhd; ,Uf;Fk; vd;W vz;zj; jiyg;gl;L tpl;lhu;fs;.
,tu;fs; gytPdkhd `jPi]Ak; rl;lkhf;fyhk; vd;W vz;zpAs;sjhy; gytPdkhdJ vd;W
Rl;bf;fhl;bdhYk; Vw;gjpy;iy.
cykhf;fs; vd;w ngay; NghypfSk; ,];yhj;ijj; jtwhd Kiwapy; rpj;jhpfF ; k; egu;fSk; cz;L vd;W
Ghpe;J nfhz;lhYk; ,J ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jpahfj;jhd; ,Uf;f KbAk; vd;w KbTf;F tuyhk;.

27. kpk;ghpy; ,khk; ,Uf;Fk; NghJ Ngryhkh?

''cq;fspy; xUtu; kpk;ghpy; ,khk; ,Uf;Fk; epiyapy; gs;spapDs; Eioe;jhy; ,khk; mjpypUe;J ,wq;Fk;
tiu njhof;$lhJ; Ngrf;$lhJ.''
,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf ,g;D cku;(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. ,ij jg;uhdP mtu;fs;
jd; fgPy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.
,jd; mwptpgg
; hsu; njhlhpy; ma;åg; ,g;D Ei`f; vd;ghu; ,lk; ngWfpwhu;.
,tiug; gw;wp vd; je;ij (mg+`hjk;) mtu;fs;> ,tu; `jP]; Jiwapy; gytPdkhdtu; vd;W $wf;
Nfl;Ls;Nsd; vd;W ,g;D mgP`hjk; mtu;fs;> jdJ 'my;[u;c tj;j`;jPy;' E}ypy; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.
,tu; `jP]; fiyapduhy; iftplg;gl;ltu;. ,tiu midtUk; gytPdu; vd;fpd;wdu; vd jd;>
'my;k[;kc'tpy; ,khk; i`jkP Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.
,e;j `jP]; gytPdkhdJ vd;W ,khk; ,g;D `[u; mtu;fs; jdJ E}ypy; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.
''[{k;M ehsd;W njhOiff;fhf ,khk; te;J tpl;lhy; NgRtij tpl;LtplNtz;Lk;.''
,e;jf; fUj;jpy; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+ `{iuuh(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;Fk; ,r;nra;jp
ig`fPapy; ,lk;ngw;Ws;sJ. ,JTk; gytPdkhdJ jhd;.
Mjhug;g+u;tkhd gpd;tUk; `jP];fSf;Fk; ,J Kuz;ghlhf cs;sJ.
,khk; ciu epfo;j;jpf; nfhz;bUf;Fk;NghJ cq;fspy; vtNuDk; te;jhy; mtu; RUf;fkhf ,uz;L
uf;mj;fs; njho Ntz;Lk; vd;W egp(]y;) $wpajhf [hgpu;(uyp) mwptpf;fpd; whu;fs;. E}y;: K];ypk;
[{k;M ehsd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; ciu epfo;j;Jk; NghJ xUtu; gs;spf;Fs; Eioe;jhu;. ePu; njhOJ
tpl;Buh? vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; Nfl;lhu;fs;. mtu; ,y;iy vd;W $wpdhu;. ,uz;L uf;mj;fs;
njhOtPuhf! vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; mthplk; $wpdhu;fs;. ,ij [hgpu;(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;:

25 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

GfhuP> K];ypk;> m`;kj;> mg+jh¥j;> e]aP> jpu;kpjP> ,g;Dkh[h


,khk; kpk;ghpy; cl;fhu;e;J ,Uf;Fk;NghJ kl;Lkpd;wp> ciu epfo;j;Jk;NghJ $l njhoyhk; vd;W
Mjhug;g+u;tkhd ,e;j `jP]; $Wfpd;wJ. ,jw;F khw;wkhf Nkw;Fwpg;gpl;l `jP]; cs;sJ vd;gijg;
Ghpayhk;.
'njhof;$lhJ' vd;gjw;F> njhoyhk; vd;W Mjhug; g+u;tkhd `jP]; %yk; $wpdhYk; Ngrf;$lhJ
vd;gJ rhp jhNd; mjw;F gpd;tUk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]; Mjhukhf cs;sjy;yth!
'[{k;M ehsd;W ,khk; Fj;gh elj;Jk; Ntisapy; (NgRk;) ckJ Njhoiu NgrhNj vd;W eP $wpdhy;>
ePAk; jtwpioj;J tpl;lha;' vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf GfhuP> K];ypkpy; cs;s `jP];gb
'Ngrf;$lhJ' vd;w thrfk; rhpahdJ jhd; vd;W rpyu; $wyhk;.
xU `jP]; gytPdkhdJ vd;W $Wk;NghJ me;j `jP]pd; kw;nwhU thrfk; rhp vd;W $WtJ rhpay;y
mJ kl;Lky;y me;j `jP]py; kpk;ghpy; ,Uf;Fk;NghNj NgRtij tpl Ntz;Lk; vd;W $wg;gLfpwJ.
Mdhy; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]pNyh ,khk; Fj;gh elj;Jk; Ntisapy; vd;W $wg;gLfpwJ. vdNt ,khk;
Fj;gh elj;Jk;NghJ jhd; Ngrf;$lhJ. ,jw;F gpd;tUk; cku;(uyp) mtu;fs; fhyj;jpy; ele;j
epfo;r;rpAk; rhd;whf cs;sJ.
''cku;(uyp) mtu;fs; kpk;ghpy; mku;e;jpUf;Fk;NghJ ghq;F $Wgtu; jd; ghq;if epWj;Jk;tiu kf;fs;
Ngrpf; nfhz;bUg;ghu;fs;. kpk;ghpy; (cku;(uyp) mtu;fs; vOe;J epd;Wtpl;lhNyh mtu;fs; jdJ ,uz;L
Fj;ghf;fisAk; Kbf;Fk; tiu kf;fs; Ngrkhl;lhu;fs;.'' ,ij j/ygh ,g;D mgPkhypf; $Wfpd;whu;fs;.
E}y;: my;Kmj;jh
vdNt Nkw;fz;l `jP]; gytPdkhdjhFk;.

28. tpgr;rhuf; Foe;ijfs;

''tpgr;rhuj;jpd; %yk; gpwe;j Foe;ijfs; kWikapy; Fuq;Ffs;> gd;wpfs; cUtpy; (vOg;gp) xd;W Nru;f;fg;
gLthu;fs;.''
,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf ,g;D mk;U(uyp) mwptpj;jhu;fs;. ,r;nra;jpia cifyP mtu;fs;
jdJ my; 'Ymgh/' vDk; E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;. ,jpy; ,lk; ngWk; i]J ,g;D ,aho; vd;gtu;
rhpahdtuy;y ,tiug; gw;wp gpd;tUk; nra;jp> ,tiu gytPdu; vd milahsk; fhl;LfpwJ.
xUtu; xU `jPi] ma;åg; mtu;fsplk; $wpdhu;. mij epuhfj;j ma;åg; mtu;fs;> ,r;nra;jpia cdf;F
$wpatu; ahu;? vd;W Nfl;lhu;. K`k;kJ ,g;D th]pc (jhd; mwptpjj ; hu;) vd;W mtu; gjpy; $wpdhu;.
tpL mtu; rhpahdtNu. mLj;J vtu; %yk; mwptpjj
; Pu?; vd;W ma;åg; mtu;fs; Nfl;ljw;F> i[J ,g;D
,aho; vd;W $wpdhu;. eP (K`k;kJ ,g;D th]pc tiu epWj;jpf; nfhz;L mjw;F Nky; i[J ,g;D
,ahioAk; $wp) mjpfg;gLj;jhNj! vd;W ma;åg; mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs; vd ]yhk; ,g;D mgP KjP,
vd;gtu; $Wfpd;whu;.
vdNt i[J ,g;D ,aho; gytPdu; vd;gjhYk; ,J gytPdkhd `jP]hfpwJ. NkYk; ,jpy; ,lk;ngWk;
<]h ,g;D Fj;jhDy; Uf;fh\p vd;gtUk; rhpahdtuy;y ,tiu ,g;D `pgg
; hd; Nghd;Nwhu; rhp
fz;lhYk;> ,td; `jPi] Mjhukhf vLj;Jf; nfhs;sf;$lhJ vd;W ,g;D mg;Jy;gu; mtu;fs;
<]hitg; gw;wp Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.
,e;j `jPi] jdJ 'my;kt;@Mj;' vDk; E}ypy; ,g;Dy; [t;]P mtu;fs; vOjptpl;L> ',J ,l;Lf;
fl;lg;gl;lJ. vt;tpj mbg;gilAkw;wJ' vd;W Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;. Råj;jp mtu;fSk; mijNa jdJ E}ypy;
vOJfpwhu;fs;.
,J Mjhug;g+u;tkhd jpUkiw trdq;fSf;Fk; khWgl;Ls;sJ.
vtd; topNfl;by; nry;fpd;whNdh mtd; jdf;Nf NfL nra;J nfhz;lhd;. ve;j Mj;khtpd; ghtr;
RikiaAk; NtnwhU Mj;kh Rkf;fhJ. (my;Fu;Md; 17:15)
(kWik ehspy; jd; Rikiaj; jtpu) xU Mj;kh kw;nwhU Mj;khtpd; Rikia Rkf;fkhJ. fbdkhd

26 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

Rikiar; Rkf;Fk; Mj;kh mijr; Rkf;f (kw;nwhd;iw) mioj;jhy; mJ neUq;fpa cwtpduhf


,Ue;jhYk; mjpypUf;Fk; vijAk; Rkf;fg;glhJ. (my;Fu;Md; 35:18)
mNj fUj;jpNyNa 37:7> 53:38 trdq;fSk; mwptpf;fpd;wJ. ,t;trdq;fs;> vtd; ghtr;RikiaAk; vtUk;
mJTk; mtu; vt;tsT neUq;fpa cwtpdu;fshf ,Ug;gpDk; Rkf;f khl;lhu;fs; vd;W njspthf
mwptpf;fpd;wd.
ngw;Nwhu; nra;j Fw;wj;jpw;fhf ngw;nwLf;fg;gl;l Foe;ijfs; Fw;wthspfshf;fg;gl;L Fuq;Ffshf>
gd;wpfshf khw;wg;gLtu; vd;W $WtJ; NkNy ehk; Fwpg;gpl;Ls;s trdq;fSf;F Kuz;ghlhfNt mikAk;.
vdNt jpUkiwapd; trdq;fSf;F Kuz;ghlhf egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpapUf;fkhl;lhu;fs; vd;W KbT
nra;J> ,ij gytPdkhdJ> Vd;? ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ vd;Nw $wyhk;.

29. egp(]y;) mtu;fis Nehpy; fhz Ntz;Lkh?

''xUtu; [{k;M ,utpy; Fspj;J ,uz;L uf;mj; njhOJ me;j ,uz;L uf;mj;fspYk; 'Fy;`{ty;yh`{
m`j;..' (112tJ mj;jpahak;) vd;w #uhit 1000 jlit Xjp njhOJtpl;L gpd;G J}q;fpdhy; egp(]y;)
mtu;fisf; fhz;ghu;.''
,r;nra;jpia ,g;D\p`hg; mtu;fs; $wpajhf ,g;Dy; [t;]p mtu;fs; jdJ 'my;kt;@Mj;' vDk; E}ypy;
gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.
,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk; ngw;Ws;s K`k;kJ ,g;D cfh\h vd;gtu; gpd;tUkhW NkYk;
$Wfpwhu;.
xt;nthU [{k;M ,uTk; ehd; Fspj;J> ,uz;L uf;mj;fs; njhONtd;. egp(]y;) mtu;fis fdtpy;
fhz Ntz;Lk; vd;W #uhit XjpNdd;. Vwj;jho ,uz;L tUlk; ,t;thW nra;Njd;. xU ehs; Fspuhd
,uT md;W ehd; Fspj;Jtpl;L> 'Fy;`{ty;yh`{ m`J' vDk; #uhit 1000 jlit Xjp ,uz;L
uf;mj; njhONjd;; gpd;G gLj;Jtpl;Nld;. vdf;F ];fypjk; Vw;gl;lJ. ,uz;lhk; Kiwahf vOe;J
Fspj;Njd;. Fy;`{ty;yh`{ #uhit 1000 jlit Xjp ,uz;L uf;mj; njhONjd;. ]`u; Neuk; te;j
epiyapy; me;j ,uz;L uf;mj;fisAk; Kbj;J tpl;L ehd; Rtw;wpy; rha;e;jpUe;Njd;. mg;NghJ egp(]y;)
mtu;fs; vd;dplk; te;jhu;fs;. mtu;fs; kPJ ,uz;L Nghu;it ,Ue;jJ.
NkYk;> K`k;kJ (,g;D cfh\h)Nt! my;yh`; ckf;F MAis ePl;b itg;ghdhf vd;W egp(]y;) $wp
vd;id (tho;j;Jtjpy;) Ke;jpf; nfhz;lhu;fs;.
,JTk; ,g;Dy; [t;]p mtu;fspd; my;kt;@Mj; vDk; E}ypy; ,lk;ngw;Ws;sJ.
,r;nra;jpia mwptpf;Fk; ,g;D cfh\h ngUk; ngha;ad; vd;gjhy; ,r;nra;jpAk;> NkNy Fwpg;gpl;Ls;s
,g;D \p`hg; mtu;fsJ ngauhy; mwptpf;fg;gLk; nra;jpapd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,td; ,lk;
ngWtjhy; mr;nra;jpAk; 'ngha;> ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ vd;gij Ghpayhk;. ,td; ngha;ad;' vd jhuFj;dP
mtu;fSk; $Wfpwhhf;s;.
NkYk; ,r;nra;jp Fu;MDk;> Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]{k; $Wk; Kf;fpakhd epfo;Tf;F khw;wkhfTk;
cs;sJ. Mk;! kdpj tho;tpy; gpwg;G vg;gb cz;ikNah mJ Nghy; ,wg;G vDk; epfo;T cz;L.
ePq;fs; vq;fpUe;j NghjpYk; cq;fis kuzk; mile;Nj jPUk;. ePq;fs; kpfTk; cWjpahff; fl;lg;gl;l
Nfhl;ilapy; ,Ue;j NghjpYk; rhpNa. (my;Fu;Md; 4:78)
,t;trdk; kdpjDf;F fz;bg;ghf kuzk; cz;L vd;gijj; njspthfNt mwptpf;fpwJ. Mdhy; Nkw;fz;l
nra;jpNah egp(]y;) mtu;fis md;Wk; capUld; cs;sdu; vd;w fUj;ijj; njhptpf;fpd;wJ. egp(]y;)
mtu;fSk; $l kuzpg;gtu;fs; jhd; vd;gij gpd;tUk; trdk; njspthfNt $WfpwJ.
epr;rakhf ePUk; kuzpg;gtNu; epr;rakhf mtu;fSk; kuzpg;gtu;fNs! (my;Fu;Md; 39:30)
NkYk; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; kuzpj;Jtpl;lhu;fs;. Mdhy; kf;fNsh> cku;(uyp) mtu;fs; cl;gl egp(]y;)

27 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

mtu;fs; ,wf;ftpy;iy vd;W $wpf; nfhz;bUe;jdu;. mq;Nf te;j mg+gf;fu;(uyp) mtu;fs; egp(]y;)
mtu;fspd; Kfj;ij jpwe;J> new;wpapy; Kj;jkplL ; tplL; > egp(]y;) mtu;fs; ,we;Jtpl;l nra;jpia kpk;ghpy;
Vwp kf;fsplk; njhptpf;fpwhu;fs;. mg;NghJ mtu;fs;> ''xUtd; my;yh`;it tzq;fp ,Ue;jhy; my;yh`;
jhd; capUld; ,Ug;gtd;. mtd; kuzpg;gjpy;iy. K`k;kJ(]y;) mtu;fs; tzq;fp ,Ue;jhy; mtu;fs;
,we;Jtpl;lhu;fs;'' vd;W Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;. ,e;jf; fUj;jpy; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]; GfhuP> e]aP>
,g;Dkh[h> ig`fP> m`;kj; Mfpa E}y;fspy; ,lk;ngw;Ws;sJ.
,q;Nf mg+gf;fu;(uyp) mtu;fspd; mwpTiuia ftdj;jpy; nfhs;s Ntz;Lk;. xUtid tzq;Ftjhf
,Ue;jhy; mtd; ,wg;nga;ahjtdhf ,Uf;f Ntz;Lk;. mjhtJ flTs; kl;LNk ,wg;ig milahjtd;.
egp(]y;) mtu;fs;> kdpjNu! mtu;fSf;F kuzk; cz;L. mtu;fs; jw;NghJ kuzpj;J tpl;lhu;fs; vd;w
fUj;ijj; jhd; mg+gf;fu;(uyp) mtu;fspd; $w;W tpsf;FfpwJ.
egp(]y;) mtu;fs; kuzpj;Jtpl;lhu;fs; vd;gJ cz;ik vdj; njhpAk;NghJ> kuzj;ij jOtpa mtu;fs;
vg;gb Nehpy; tUthu;fs;? mJTk; ngha;ia ek;gr; nra;a Ntz;Lk; vd;w ce;Jjypy;> Nghu;it mzpe;J
te;jhu;fs; vd;Wk; ngha; $wg;gl;Ls;sJ.
vdNt kuzpj;jtu; tug;Nghtjpy;iy. tuKbahj epiyapy; cs;s xUtiu tUthu;fs; vd;W $WtJ
rhpay;y. ,J Fu;MDf;Fk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]{f;Fk; khw;wkhf cs;sJ vd;gjhy; ,r;nra;jp ,l;Lf;
fl;lg;gl;lJ jhd; vd ve;j xU K];ypKk; KbTf;F tuNtz;Lk;.

30. egp(]y;) mtu;fis fdtpy; fhz Ntz;Lkh?

''xU %kpd; nts;spf;fpoik ,uT ,uz;L uf;mj; njhOJ mjpy; xt;nthU uf;mj;jpYk;
Fy;`{ty;yh`{... #uhit 25 jlit Xjptpl;L> gpd;G ]yhk; nfhLj;Jtpl;L ']y;yy;yh`{ myh
K`k;kjpd; egpa;apy; ck;kpa;ap' vd;W Mapuk; jlit $wpdhy; md;iwa ,utpy; fdtpy; vd;id epr;rakhf
fhz;ghd;. kWthuk; nts;sp tUk; Kd; fdtpy; vd;idf; fhz;ghd;. vd;id xU thuk; ghu;j;Jtpl;lhy;
my;yh`; mtdJ Fw;wq;fis kd;dpf;fpwhd;.''
,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf ,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) mwptpf;Fk; xU nra;jpia ,g;Dy; [t;]P
mtu;fs; jdJ 'my;kt;@Mj;' vDk; E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.
,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ahnud;Nw mwpag;glhjtu;fs; mwpKfkw;w gyu; ,lk; ngWtjpypUe;Nj ,J
gytPdkhd nra;jp jhd; vd;gJ GydhFk;.
egp(]y;) mtu;fis fdtpy; ehk; fhz KbAkh? fhz KbAk; vd;gjw;F rpyu; fPo;f;fz;l `jP];fis
Mjhukhf itf;fpd;wdu;.
''ahu; vd;id fdtpy; fhz;fpwhNuh mtu; vd;idNa fz;lhu;. Vnddpy; i\j;jhd; vd; tbtpy;
tukhl;lhd;'' vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP>
K];ypk;
ahu; vd;idf; fhz;fpwhNdh mtd; cz;ikiaNa fz;lhd; vd;W egp(]y;) $wpajhf mg+fjhjh(uyp)
mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk>; m`;kj;
,e;j `jP];fs; NknyOe;j thahfg; ghu;f;Fk; NghJ egp(]y;) mtu;fis fdtpy; fhz KbAk; vd;W
njhpe;jhYk;> cz;ikapy; egp(]y;) mtu;fis fdtpy; fhz Ntz;Lkhdhy; mtu;fs; capUld; ,Uf;Fk;
NghJ fdtpy; fhz;gtu; egp(]y;) mtu;fisj; jhd; fz;L nfhz;lhu; vd;Wk; my;yJ ,Jtiu Nehpy;
fhzhjtu;> fdtpd; %yk; fz;lhy; ,dp NeYk; fhz;ghu; vd;Wk; jhd; KbTf;F tuNtz;Lk;. ',e;j
KbT jhd; Nkw;nfhs;s Ntz;Lk;' vd;gij gpd;tUk; `jP]; njspTgLj;JfpwJ.
'ahu; vd;id fdtpy; fhz;fpwhNuh mtu; (NeYk;) tpopg;gpYk; vd;idf; fhz;ghu;. Vndd;why; i\j;jhd;
vd; tbtj;jpy; tukhl;lhd;' vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;.
E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;
fdtpy; fz;lhy; NeYk; fhz;ghu; vd;why;> Nehpy; fhz;gJ mtu;fs; capUld; cs;s fhyj;jpNyNa

28 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

nghUe;Jk;. njspthd Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]; %yk; mtu;fs; capUld; trpf;fhj fhyj;jpy; cs;s
ek;ikg; Nghd;wtu;fshy; egp(]y;) mtu;fisf; fhz KbahJ vd;gJ njspthfpwJ.
,e;j Mjhug;g+u;tkhd epiyf;Fk; khw;wkhf cs;sjhYk; Nkw;fz;l nra;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ jhd;
vd;gJ GhpAk;.

31. Nfhgk; Vw;gl;lhy;...?

''epr;rakhf Nfhgk; (nfhs;tJ vd;gJ) i\j;jhd; (Fzq;fspy;) epd;WKs;sjhFk;. epr;rakhf


i\j;jhd; neUg;gpy; ,Ue;Nj gilf;fg;gl;Ls;shd;. jz;zPuhy; jhd; neUg;G mizAk;. vdNt cq;fspy;
xUtUf;F Nfhgk; Vw;gl;lhy; x@r; nra;J nfhs;sl;Lk;.''
egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf $wg;gLk; ,r;nra;jp m`;kj;> mg+jh¥j;> ,g;D m]hfPu; Mfpa E}y;fspYk;
GfhuP mtu;fspd; jh`; E}ypYk; gjpT nra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ.
,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; njhlhpy; ahnud;Nw mwpag;glhj ,Utu; ,lk;ngWfpd;wdu;. vdNt ,J rhpapy;yhj
`jP]hFk;. ,J Nghd;Nw kw;nwhU nra;jp KMtpah(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpg;gjhf tUfpwJ.
''Nfhgk; i\j;jhdpd; epd;WKs;sjhFk;. i\j;jhd; neUg;gpyhdtd;. jz;zPu; jhd; neUg;ig
mizf;Fk;. vdNt cq;fspy; vtUf;NfDk; Nfhgk; te;jhy; mtu; Fspff ; l;Lk;.''
,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wp> jhd; Nfl;ljhf KMtpah(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpj;jjhf mg+eaPk;> ,g;D
m]hfPu; MfpNahu; jq;fspd; E}y;fspy; gjpT nra;Js;sdu;.
,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; njhlhpy; ahrPd; ,g;D mg;Jy;yh ,g;D cu;th ,lk; ngWfpwhu;. ,tiug; gw;wp
mwpKfk; VJk; ,y;iy. mg;Jy; k[Pj; ,g;D mg;Jy; m[P]; vd;gtUk; ,lk; ngWfpwhu;. mtiug; gw;wp
,g;D `[u; mtu;fs; Fwpg;gpLk; NghJ> ',tu; cz;ikahsu; jhd;. vdpDk; jtW nra;gtu; vdf;
$Wfpwhu;fs;. ,tu; `jP]; fiyapduhy; iftplg; gl;ltu;' vd;W ,g;D `pg;ghd; $Wfpwhu;fs;. vdNt
,r;nra;jpAk; $l rhpaw;wjhFk;.
mg;gbahdhy; 'Nfhgk; nfhs;syhkh?' vd;W rpyUf;F vz;zj; Njhd;Wk;. mJ rhpay;y. Nfhgk;
nfhs;tjpy; jtwpy;iy vd;w fUj;jpy; ,r;nra;jpia tpku;rpf;ftpy;iy. Nfhgk; nfhs;sf;$lhJ vd;gjw;F
gpd;tUk; Mjhug; g+u;tkhd gy `jP];fs; cz;L.
vdf;F Nghjid nra;Aq;fs; vd;W xU kdpju; egp(]y;) mtu;fsplk; Nfl;lNghJ> Nfhgk; nfhs;shNj!
vd;wdu;. gy Kiw mtu; Nfl;lNghJk;> 'Nfhgk; nfhs;shNj' vd;Nw $wpdhu;fs; vd mg+`{iuuh(uyp)
mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: GfhuP
jhf;Fk; jpwd; mbg;gilapy; tPuid vil Nghlg;gL tjpyi; y. tPud; vd;gtd; Nfhgj;jpd; NghJ jd;idf;
fl;Lg;gLj;jpf; nfhs;gtNd vd egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs; vd mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;.
E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;
Nfhgj;ij jtpu;f;f Ntz;Lk; vd;gij Mjhug; g+u;tkhd `jP];fs; mwptpg;gjhy; Nfhgj;ij iftpl
Ntz;Lk;. mNj rkak; Nfhgj;ij iftplf; $Wk; topKiw jhd; rhpay;y vd;gNj ,q;Nf
tpku;rpf;fg;gLfpwJ.
Nfhgk; Vw;gl;lhy; x@r; nra;a Ntz;Lk; vd;Wk; Fspf;f Ntz;Lk; vd;Wk; $wg;gl;L tUk; nra;jpfs;
rhpay;y vd;gNj ,q;Nf ftdpf;fg;gl Ntz;ba epiy. Nfhgk; Vw;gl;lhy; vd;d nra;a Ntz;Lk; vd;gij
gpd;tUk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd nra;jp tpsf;FfpwJ.
''xUtu; epd;W nfhz;bUf;Fk;NghJ Nfhgk; te;jhy; cl;fhu;eJ
; tpll;Lk;> Nfhgk; Ngha;tpll; hy; r.
,y;iyNay; gLj;Jtpll;Lk;'' vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+ju;(uyp) mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. E}y;fs;:
m`;kj;> jpu;kpjP
vdNt> NkNy Fwpg;gpl;Ls;s x@ my;yJ Fspf;f Ntz;Lk; vd;w fUj;jpy; cs;s nra;jpfs; `jP];fs;
my;y `jP];fs; ngauhy; jpzpf;fg;gl;litNa.

29 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

32. kiof;fhyq;fspy; jhd; kdpjdpd; cs;sk;...?

''kdpjdpd; cs;sq;fs; kiof;fhyq;fspy; jhd; kpUJthf MFk;. Vnddpy; (Kjy; kdpjuhd) Mjk;
(miy) mtu;fis kz;zpypUe;J jhd; my;yh`; gilj;jhd;. kz;> kiof;fhyj;jpy; jhd; kpUJthf
,Uf;Fk;.''
,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf KMj; ,g;D [gy; (uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpwhu;fs; vd mg+eaPk;
mtu;fs; jdJ 'my;`{ah' vDk; E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.
,jd; mwptpgg
; hsu; njhlhpy; cku; ,g;D a`;ah vd;gtu; ,lk; ngWfpwhu;. ,tu; `jP]; fiyapduhy;
iftplg;gl;ltu;. ,g;D`[u; mtu;fs; ,tiug; gw;wp Fwpg;gpLk; NghJ ,e;j mk;U ,g;D a`;ah vd;gtu;
cku; ,g;D a`;ah ,g;D cku; ,g;D mgP]y;kh ,g;D mg;Ju; u`;khd; ,g;D mt;G vd;gtuhfj;jhd;
,Uf;f Ntz;Lk;. ,tiu jhuFj;dP mtu;fs; gytPdg;gLj;jpf; $Wfpd;wdu; vd;W $Wfpwhu;fs;.
NkYk; ,J mwpTf;Nf Vw;Wf; nfhs;shj tp\akhFk;. rhjhuz epiyapy; cs;std; $l ,J ngha;.
,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ jhd; vd;W tpsq;fp tpLthd;. ,];yhk; mwpthu;e;j khu;f;fk; vd;w $w;iw ngha;g;gLj;j
vz;zpatd; jhd; ,ij ,l;Lf;fl;b ,Uf;f Ntz;Lk; vd;gjpy; Iakpy;iy.

33. mugp nkhop NgRgtd; /ghu;]p nkhop Ngrf;$lhJ?

''cq;fspy; vtNuDk; mugpapy; mofhf Ngrpdhy; mtu; ghu;]p nkhopapy; Ngrpl Ntz;lhk;. kPwp Ngrpdhy;
mJ eatQ;rfj; jd;ikia Vw;gLj;jptpLk;.''
,g;D cku;(uyp) mwptpg;gjhf ,r;nra;jp `hfpkpy; gjpT nra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ. ,jd; ehd;fhtJ mwptpg;ghsu;
cku; ,g;D `h&d; vd;gtu; rhpahdtuy;y! ,tiu ,g;D KaPd; gytPdu; vd;W $WtjhfTk;> ,ju
`jP]; fiyapdu; ,tiu iftpl;L tpl;ljhfTk; j`gP mtu;fs; $Wfpwhu;fs;.
mugp nkhop kPJ Nkhfk; nfhz;L> mNj rkak; /ghu;]p nkhopapy; Nfhgk; nfhz;ltdhy; jhd; ,r;nra;jp
,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;bUf;f Ntz;Lk;.
jw;NghJ vg;gb jkpo; nkhop kPJ gw;W nfhz;L ,e;jp nkhop NgRgtd; kPJ ntWg;Gld; rpyu; cs;sdNuh>
mJ Nghy; mugp nkhop kPJ Nkhfj;Jld; ,Ue;j xU $l;lk; jhd; ,r;nra;jpia ,l;Lf; fl;bf; $wpapUf;f
Ntz;Lk; vd;gjpy; re;NjfNk ,y;iy.

34. gl;L nkj;ijapy; mkuyhkh?

''egp(]y;) mtu;fs; gl;L tphpg;gpy; mku;e;jpUe;jdu;.''


,ij i]y< mtu;fs; jd; E}yhd 'e];Gu; u/ah'tpy; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;. `dgP kj;`G E}yhd
'`pjhah'tpYk; $l ,JNghd;Nw $wg;gl;Ls;sJ. gl;L tphpg;gpy; mkuyhk; vd `dgP kj;`G $wTk;
nra;fpwJ. Mdhy; ve;j mbg;gilAkw;w nra;jpahFk; ,J.
,J Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]{f;Fk; khw;wkhfj; jhd; cs;sJ.
jq;fk;> nts;sp ghj;jpuq;fspy; cz;gijAk;> Fbg;gijAk; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; vq;fSf;Fj; jil
tpjpj;jpUe;jdu;. gl;L Mil mzptijAk;> mjd; Nky; mku;tijAk; jil nra;jpUe;jdu; vd
`{ij/gh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: GfhuP
gl;L Milapy; mku;tij jil nra;Js;sjhf tUk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]{f;F khw;wkhfNt ,r;nra;jp
mike;Js;sJ. egp(]y;) mtu;fs; kl;LNk jdpNa rYif mspf;fg;gl;L ,Ue;jdu; vd;W vtNuDk;
$wpdhy; mjw;Fk; Mjhuk; fhl;lNtz;Lk;.
egptopf;F khw;wkhfj; jhd; kj;`Gfs; cs;sd vd;gjw;F ,e;j gl;L tphpg;gpy; mkuyhk; vd;w `dgP

30 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

kj;`gpd; $w;W> rhd;whf cs;sJ.


gl;L nkj;ijapNyh> tphpg;gpNyh mkuyhk; vd;w fUj;jpy; cs;s Nkw;fz;l nra;jp vt;tpj mbg;gilAkw;w
nra;jpAkhFk;.

35. ,fhkj; thrfk; xU jlit kl;Lk; $wpdhy; Fw;wkh?

'',fhkj; thrfj;ij xw;iwahf xUtu; $wpdhy; mtu; vd;idr; rhu;e;jty;iy.''


egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf ,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;w ,r;nra;jpia ,khk; ,g;Dy; [t;]P(u`;)
mtu;fs; jdJ kt;@Mj; E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.
,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,uz;lhk; mwptpg;ghs uhf o`;`hf; ,g;D k]h`pk; ,lk; ngWfpwhu;.
%d;whk; mwptpg;ghsuhf [{itgpu; ,lk; ngWfpd;whu;. NkYk; ahnud;Nw mwpag;glhj rpyUk; ,lk;
ngw;Ws;sdu;.
,uz;lhk; mwptpg;ghsu; o`;`hf; vd;gtu;> ,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) mtu;fsplk; vijAk; nrtpAwtpy;iy vd
mg+ ]u;M $Wfpwhu;fs;. k\h\; mtu;fsplk; ,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) mtu;fsplk; o`;`hf; vijAk;
Nfl;Ls;shuh? vd;W Nfl;l NghJ> mtiu mtu; xU NghJk; ghu;j;jNj ,y;iy vd;W gjpy; $wpdhu;fs;.
o`;`hf; vd;gthplkpUe;J Nfl;ljhf %d;whk; mwptpg;ghsu; [{itgpu; mwptpg;git> Nkhrkhdit vd
,g;D KaPd; $Wfpd;whu;fs;. NkYk; gpd;tUk; `jP]{f;Fk; khw;wkhfTk; cs;sJ.
''egp(]y;) mtu;fs; ghq;if ,uz;buz;lhfTk; ,fhkj;ij xt;nthd;whfTk; $Wk;gb gpyhy;(uyp)
mtu;fSf;F fl;lisapl;lhu;fs;'' vd md];(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;
egp(]y;) mtu;fspd; fhyj;jpy; ghq;F ,uz;buz;lhfTk; ,fhkj; xt;nthd;whfTk; vd ,Ue;jJ.
'fj;fhkjp];]yhj;> fj; fhkjp];]yhj;' vd;W eP (,uz;L jlit) $Wtijj; jtpu vd;W ,g;D
cku;((uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: e]aP
egp(]y;) mtu;fspd; fhyj;jpy; ,fhkj; thrfk; xU Kiw $wpajhf te;Js;sNghJ> xU Kiw $wpdhy;>
mtd; vd;idr; Nru;e;jtd; my;yd; vd egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $Wthu;fsh? vdNt ,J ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l
nra;jp vd;gij epidtpy; nfhs;f!

36. mRj;j ,lk; ][;jh nra;jhy; Rj;jkhFkh?

''egp(]y;) mtu;fs; njhOk; ,lj;jpy; mtu;fspd; cwTf;fhu; (fshd Nguu;)fs; `]d;> `{i]d;
,UtUk; kyk; fopj;jhu;fs;. mg;NghJ ehd;> ',iwj;J}ju; mtu;fNs! ePq;fs; njhOkplj;jpy; cq;fspd;
cwTf;fhu rpWtu;fs; `]d;-`{i]d; ky-[yk; fopf;fpwhu;fNs' vd;W Nfl;Nld;. mjw;F egp(]y;)
''mtu;fs; rpfg;G epwg;ngz;Nz! vd; rKjhaj;jpy; cs;s xUtu; jdJ new;wpia g+kpapy; itj;jhy; me;j
][;jh %yk; VO g+kp tiu my;yh`; J}a;ikahf;fptpLthd;. vdNt me;j ,lk; mRj;jj;ij Vw;Wf;
nfhs;shJ vd;W $wpdhu;fs;.''
,ij Map\h(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpj;J> ,g;D `pg;ghd;> jg;uhdP Mfpa E}w;fspy; ,lk; ngw;Ws;sJ.
,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ehd;fhtjhf ,lk; ngWk; g]Pf; ,g;D `];]hd; vd;gtu; ngha;
$Wgtuhthu;. ,r;nra;jpia ,g;D `pg;ghd; mtu;fs; jd; k[;&`Pd; vDk; E}ypy; gjpT nra;J tpl;L>
,tu; ey;ytu;fspd; ngau;fisg; gad;gLj;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jpfis $Wk; eguhthu; vd;Wk;
Fwpg;gpLwhu;fs;.
,g;D mjP mtu;fs; ',td; `jP];fs; epuhfg;gl Ntz;bait vd;Wk;> jhuFj;dP mtu;fs; ,td; `jP]f
; s;
xJf;fg;gl Ntz;bait' vd;Wk; $Wfpwhu;fs;.
,Nj `jP]; NtW mwptpg;ghsu; thpirAld; jg;uhdPapy; ,lk; ngWfpwJ. ,ij mwptpf;Fk; Map\h(uyp)
mtu;fis ,jd; ,uz;lhtJ mwptpg;ghsuhd Kmg;gj; vd;gtu; re;jpf;fNt ,y;iy. ,jdhy; njhlu;G

31 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

mWe;jit (Kd;fjp`;) vDk; me;j];j;ij mile;J gytPd `jP]hfpwJ.


,J kl;Lky;y. ,J Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]{f;Fk; Kuz;gl;L ,Uf;fpwJ.
fpuhkg;Gw mugp xUtu; kjPdh efu; gs;spthrypy; rpWePu; fopj;jhu;. (,ijf; fz;lJk;) mq;fpUe;j rpyu;
mtiu mbf;f neUq;fpdu;. mg;NghJ egp(]y;) mtu;fs; mtiu tpl;L tpLq;fs;. (mtu; rpWePu; fopg;gij)
jLf;fhjPu;fs; vd;W $wpdhu;fs;. mtu; (rpWePu; fopj;J) Kbj;jJk;> xU thsp jz;zPu; tutioj;J me;j
,lj;jpy; Cw;wpdhu;fs; vd md];(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: K];ypk;
njhOkplj;jpy; rpWePu; fopj;jjhy; fOtpAs;sdu;. Mdhy; Nkw;fz;l nra;jp cz;ikahdhy;> fOt
Ntz;bajpy;iy. njhOk;NghJ jhdhfNt Rj;jkhfp tpLk; jhNd! Mdhy; fOtp cs;sdu; vDk; NghJ
Nkw;fz;l nra;jp '`jP];fspd; ngauhy;' cUthf;fg;gl;Ls;sJ vdg; Ghpayhk;.

37. jpUkzj;jpw;F Kd; `[; nra;jhy;...?

''`[; nra;tJ jpUkzj;jpw;F Kd;G jhd;.''


,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. ,J Råj;jp mtu;fspd;
'my;[hkpc];]fPu;' vDk; E}ypy; gjpthfpAs;sJ. 'K];dJy; gpu;jt;];' vDk; E}ypy; ijykP mtu;fSk;
Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.
,jpy; fpah]; ,g;D ,g;uh`Pk; vd;gtu; ,lk; ngWfpwhu;. ,tu; `jP]; fiyapduhy; iftplg;gl;ltu; vd
j`gP $Wfpwhu;fs;. ikrpuh ,g;D mg;Ju;ug; vd;gtUk; ,lk; ngWfpwhu;. ,tu; ngUk; ngha;au; vd j`gP
$Wfpwhu;. Nkhrkhd ngha;au; vd fpah]; gw;wp ,g;D KaPd; $Wfpwhu;. ,ijNa mg+jh¥j; mtu;fSk;
$Wfpwhu;fs;.
''`[; nra;Ak; Kd; xUtu; jpUkzk; nra;J tpl;lhy; mtu; Fw;wk; nra;aj; Jtq;fpatuhthu;''
vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. ,ij ,g;D mjP
mtu;fs; gjpT nra;Js;sdu;.
,jd; mwptpg;ghsu;fspy; MwhtJ eguhf ,lk; ngWk; K`k;kj; ,g;D ma;åg; epiwa ,l;Lf;fl;b
mwptpg;gtu; vd;W ,g;Dy; [t;]p $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,ij Råj;jp mtu;fSk; jd; E}ypy;
cWjpg;gLj;Jfpwhu;fs;. '7tJ mwptpg;ghsuhd m`;kj; ,g;D [{k;`{u; ngha; $Wgtd;' vd Råj;jp
$Wfpwhu;fs;. NkYk; u[hc ,g;D&`; vd;gtu; gw;wpa Fwpg;igAk; ehd; fhztpy;iy vd Råj;jp
$Wfpwhu;fs;.
`[; vd;gJ njhOif> Nehd;G Nghd;w flik jhd;. mjpYk; trjp cs;stu;fs; kPJs;s fl;lhaf;
flikahFk;. ,Jgw;wp Fu;MDk;> Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fSk; $Wfpd;wd.
my;yh`;Tf;fhf ,e;j Myak; nrd;W `[; nra;tJ> kdpju;fspy; mjd;ghy; (nrd;Wtu) rf;jp ngw;wtu;
kPJ flikahFk;. (my;Fu;Md; 3:98)
kdpju;fNs! my;yh`; cq;fs; kPJ `[;i[f; flikahf;fp As;shd;. vdNt ePq;fs; `[; nra;Aq;fs;
vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; vq;fSf;F Mw;wpa ciuapd; NghJ Fwpg;gpl;lhu;fs; vd;W mg+`{iuuh(uyp)
mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. E}y;fs;: K];ypk;> m`;kj;> e]aP
,e;j trdKk; `jP]{k; nghJthf `[; flik vd;W jhd; $WfpwNj jtpu> jpUkzj;jpw;F Kd;Ng
nra;a Ntz;Lk; vd;W $wtpyi
; y. ,jpypUe;Jk; Nkw;$wpa nra;jpfs; ngha; vd;gijg; Ghpayhk;.
jpUkzk; nra;aj;jfhj Mz; cwtpdUld; jtpu ngz;fs; gazk; Nkw;nfhs;sf;$lhJ vd;W egp(]y;)
mtu;fs; jkJ nrhw;nghoptpy; Fwpg;gpl;lhu;fs;. mg;NghJ xUtu; vOe;J my;yh`;tpd; J}jNu! vd; kidtp
`[; nra;tjw;fhf Gwg;gl;Ltpl;lhu;. ehd; ,d;dd;d Nghu;fspy; <LgLj;jg;gl;L tpl;Nld; vd;W $wpdhu;.
mjw;F egp(]y;) mtu;fs; ePu; Gwg;gl;Lr; nrd;W ck; kidtpAld; `[; nra;tPuhf! vd;W $wpdhu;fs; vd
,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;> m`;kj;
jpUkzj;jpw;F gpd;Ng `[; nra;ar; nrd;Ws;sdu; vd;gij ,e;j `jP]; njspTgLj;JfpwJ. vz;zw;w

32 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

egpj; Njhou;fSk; NjhopaUk; jpUkzk; nra;j gpwF `[; nra;ar; nrd;Ws;sdu; vd;gij gy `jP];fs;
njspthfNt mwptpf;fpd;wd. egp(]y;) mtu;fSk;> ,ju egpj;Njhou;fSk; `[; nra;a nry;Yk; NghJ
jq;fsJ kidtpaiu mioj;Jr; nrd;wdu; vd;gijAk; gy `jP];fs; tpsf;Ffpd;wd.
vdNt jpUkzj;jpw;F Kd;Ng `[; nra;ar; nry;y Ntz;Lk;. mg;gb kPwp nra;jhy; Fw;wk; vd;nwy;yhk;
tUk; Nkw;fz;l nra;jpfs; ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;litNa!

38. Foe;ijf;F K`k;kJ vd ngahplh tpl;lhy;...?

''xUtUf;F %d;W Foe;ijfs; ,Ue;J> mtu;fspy; xUtUf;NfDk; K`k;kj; vd;W ngahplhtpl;lhy; mtu;
kilaNu!''
,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf ,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) mtu;fshy; mwptpf;fg;gl;L mJ jg;uhdP
(fgPu;)apy; gjpT nra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ.
,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk; ngw;Ws;s K];mg; ,g;D ]aPj; vd;ghu; rhpahdtuy;y vd;gjhy; ,e;j
`jP]{k; rhpahdjhf ,y;iy.
,e;j K];mg; ,g;D ]aPj;> ek;gfkhdtu; topahf gy jtwhd `jP];fis mwptpg;gtu; vd;W ,g;D mjP
mtu;fs; $Wfpd;whu;fs;.
,Nj `jP]; NtW mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; th]pyh ,g;D m];fc(uyp) topahfTk; kw;Wk; [/gu; ,g;D
K`k;kj; mtu;fs; jd; ghl;ldhu; topahfTk; mg;Jy; kypf; ,g;D `h&d; ,g;D md;jpuh mtu;fs; jd;
ghl;ldhu; topahfTk; mwptpg;gjhf ,lk;ngw;Ws;sJ. ,g;D Gifu; mtu;fs; ,e;j `jP];fis jdJ
E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.
th]pyh mtu;fs; mwptpf;Fk; `jP]py;> cku; ,g;D %]h my;t[P`p vd;w ,l;Lf;fl;bf; $Wgtu; ,lk;
ngWtjhy; me;j `jP]; gytPdg;gl;Lg; NghfpwJ.
[/gu; ,g;D K`k;kj; mtu;fs; jdJ ghl;ldhu; topahf mwptpf;Fk; `jP]py;> mg;Jy;yh ,g;D jh`pu;
mu;uh]P vd;gtu; ,lk; ngWfpwhu;. ,tiu ,g;Dy; [t;]P> j`gP MfpNahu; Fiw $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,e;j
`jP]{k; gytPdkhdjhfpwJ.
jdJ ghl;ldhu; topahf mwptpf;Fk; mg;Jy; kypf; ,g;D `h&d; vd;gtNu ngha;au;; ,l;Lf;fl;Lgtu;
vd;gjhy; me;j `jP]{k; gytPdkhdjhfpwJ.
gy egpj;Njhou;fSf;F %d;W Mz; Foe;ijfSf;F Nky; cs;sJ. Mdhy; mtu;fspy; vtUk; K`k;kj;
vd;W ngahpl;ljhf ve;j `jP]{k; ,y;iy. egp(]y;) mtu;fspd; nrhy;iy kpf cau;thf kjpj;J
gpd;gw;wp tho;e;j egpj; Njhou;fspd; xt;nthU FLk;gj;jpYk; K`k;kj; vd;W ngahplg;gl;Ls;stu;fs;
,Ue;jhu;fsh vd;why; mJTk; ,y;iy. ,e;j mbg;gilapYk; 'K`k;kj; vd;W jd; Foe;ijfspy;
vtUf;NfDk; xUtUf;F ngahplhjtu; kilaNu' vd;W tUk; nra;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lNj!
egpkhu;fspd; ngau;fshy; ngaLq;fs;. my;yh`;Tf;F kpfg; gphpakhd ngau; mg;Jy;yh. mg;Jw;w`;khd;
vd;gjhFk; vd egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+t`;G(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: mg+jh¥j;
,J Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]hFk;. ,J Nghd;W Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fshf> K`k;kj; vd;W ngahplf;
$Wk; `jP];fs; cs;sjh vd;why; mJTk; ,y;iy. vdNt Nkw;fz;l nra;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lNj
vd;gjpy; re;Njfkpy;iy.

39. ngz;fs; tpisahl;Lg; nghUl;fs;?

''ngz; tpisahl;Lg; nghUshths;. ePq;fs; ,\;lg;gb ele;J nfhs;Sq;fs;''


vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mk;Ug;Dy; M];(uyp) mtu;fs; $wpajhf `hfpk; E}ypy; gjpT
nra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ.

33 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk; ngWk; ,g;DYi`M vd;gtu; gytPdkhdtuhthu;. NkYk; ,jpy; ,lk;
ngw;Ws;s m`;t]; vd;gtUk; mk;U ,g;D M];(uyp) mtu;fSf;FkpilNa mwptpg;ghsu; thpir
tpLgl;Ls;sJ.
''ngz; tpisahl;Lg; nghUshths;. mtis tpisahl;Lg; nghUshf cgNahfpg;gtu; mofhf itj;Jf;
nfhs;sl;Lk;. ''
,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+gf;fu; ,g;D `];k; vd;ghu; $Wfpwhu;. ,ij `huP]; ,g;D myP
c]hkh mtu;fs; jdJ K];djpy; gjpT nra;Js;sdu;.
,ij mwptpf;Fk; mg+gf;fu; ,g;D `];k; ,tu;fs; egpj;Njhouy;y `p[;hp 120-y; ,we;jtu;. ,e;j tifapy;
,J Ku;]yhFk;. NkYk; ]{i`u; ,g;D K`k;kj; my;Fuh]hdP m\;\hkP vd;gtu; ,lk; ngWfpwhu;.
,tu; gytPduhthu;. NkYk; m`;kj; ,g;D a]Pj; vd;gtu; ,lk; ngWfpwhu;. ,tu; gw;wpa mwpKfk;
VJkpy;iy. vdNt ,JTk; gytPdkhd nra;jpNa!
,ij ngz;fis Nftyg;gLj;j Ntz;Lk; vd;Wk; ,];yhj;ij ,opT gLj;j Ntz;Lk; vd;Wk; vz;ZNthu;
jhd; ,l;Lf;fl;bapUf;f Ntz;Lk;.

40. moF> gzk;> ghuk;ghpak; ,tw;wpw;fhf jpUkzk; nra;ayhk;?

''xU ngz;iz mtspd; fz;zpaj;jpw;fhf xUtd; jpUkzk; nra;jhy; mtDf;F my;yh`; ,opitj; jtpu
(NtW vijAk;) mjpfg;gLj;j khl;lhd;. mtspd; gzj; jpw;fhf mtis jpUkzk; nra;jhy; mtDf;F
my;yh`; tWikiaj; jtpu (NtW vijAk;) mjpfg;gLj;jkhl;lhd;. mtspd; moFf;fhf mtis jpUkzk;
nra;jhy; mtDf;F ifNrjj;ijj; jtpu (NtW vijAk;) mjpfg;gLj;Jtjpy;iy. xUtd; xU ngz;iz
jpUkzk; nra;fpwhd;. mtd; jd; ghu;itia (gpw md;dpag; ngz;fisg; ghu;g;gij tpl;Lk;) jho;j;jpf;
nfhs;sTk; my;yJ jd; ku;k];jhdj;ij ghJfhf;fTk; my;yJ jd; cwtpdiu Nru;j;J thoTNk jtpu
NtW vjw;Fk; mtis jpUkzk; nra;atpyi ; y vd;why;> my;yh`; mtDf;F mtspd; tp\aj;jpy; guf;fj;
nra;fpwhd;. mtSf;Fk; mtd; tp\aj;jpy; guf;fj; nra;fpwhd;.''
,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf md]; ,g;D khypf; (uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpj;J jg;uhdp mtu;fspd;
my; mt;]j; E}ypy; gjpT nra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ.
,e;j nra;jpapd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; FsWgb cs;sjhy; ,J gytPdkhd nra;jpahFk;. ,uz;lhk;
mwptpgg
; hsuhd ,g;wh`Pk; ,g;D mgP mg;yh mtu;fs; topahf mg;J];]yhk; ,g;D mg;Jy; Fj;J}];
kl;LNk ,r;nra;jpia mwptpf;fpwhu;. Mdhy; ,e;j mg;J];]yhk; ,g;D mg;Jy; Fj;J}]; rhpahdtuy;yu;.
,tu; gytPdkhdtu; vd mg+`hjk; mtu;fs; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;. ,tuJ je;ij mg;Jy; Fj;J}];
rhpahdtuy;y. ,tiuAk; tpl ,tuJ kfd; mg;J];]yhk; kpf Nkhrkhdtu; vd mg+jh¥j;
Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.
,tu; epiwa ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jpia mwptpg;gtu; vd;Wk;> ,tu; ,g;wh`Pk; ,g;D mgP mg;yh topahfNt
,tu; mwptpg;ghu; vd;Wk; mo;Omghc vDk; E}ypy; ,g;D `pg;ghd; $Wfpwhu;fs;. i`jkP mtu;fs; ,tu;
gytPdkhdtu; vd;W $Wfpwhu;fs;. Kd;jpuP mtu;fs; jdJ mj;ju;fPg; E}ypy; gytPdu; vd;Nw
Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.
''ePq;fs; ngz;fis mtu;fspd; moFf;fhf jpUkzk; nra;ahjPu;fs;. mtu;fspd; moNf mtu;fis
ehrg;gLj;jTk; $Lk;. NkYk; mtu;fspd; nry;tq;fSf;fhfTk; mtu;fis jpUkzk; nra;ahjPu;fs;.
mtu;fspd; nry;tq;fNs mtu;fis topnfLf;fTk; $Lk;. vdpDk; mtu;fis khu;f;fj;jpw;fhf jpUkzk;
nra;Aq;fs;. khu;f;fk; mwpe;j fUg;G epw fhjWe;j xU mbikg; ngz;Nz (,ju ngz;fis tpl jpUkzk;
nra;a) kpfr; rpwe;jtu;.''
,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg;Jy;yh ,g;D mk;U (uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. ,g;Dkh[h>
ig`fP Mfpa E}y;fspy; ,J ,lk; ngw;Ws;sJ.
,jpy; ,/g;uPfP vd;gtu; ,lk;ngWfpwhu;. ,tuJ ngau; mg;Jw;w`;khd; ,g;D ]pahj; ,g;D m\;\{mghd;

34 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

vd;gjhFk;. ',tu; gytPdkhdtu;' vd jdJ 'm];]thapj;' vDk; E}ypy; g+]p mtu;fs; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.
vdNt ,JTk; gytPdkhd `jP]; jhd;.
`jP];fspd; ngauhy; cs;s Nkw;fz;l ,uz;L nra;jpfSNk eilKiwapy; rhj;jpag;glhj-,y;yhj
xd;iwNa mwptpf;fpd;wd.
fz;zpak; fUjp> FLk;g ghuk;ghpaj;jpw;fhf jpUkzk; nra;Ak; xUtDf;F ,opT jhd; kpQ;Rk; vd;W Kjy;
`jP]; $WfpwJ. fz;zpakhd FLk;gj;jpy; ,Ue;J jpUkzk; nra;Ak; midtUk; ,opthd epiyf;Fj;
jhd; Mshfp cs;shu;fsh? epr;rakhf ,y;iy. ,e;j `jP];gb ,ope;j epiyf;Fj; jhNd Mfp ,Uf;f
Ntz;Lk;. ,y;iy vd;why; `jP]pd; fUj;J ngha; vd;W jhNd MFk;. egp(]y;) mtu;fs; eilKiwapy;
fhzKbahj-nghUe;jhj nra;jpiar; nrhy;yp ,Ug;ghu;fsh? nrhy;ypapUf;fkhl;lhu;fs;. ,jpypUe;Nj
,r;nra;jp ngha; vd;gJ GhpAk;.
,JNghy; mtsplk; cs;s trjp fUjp xU ngz;iz jpUkzk; nra;jhy; mtd; Vioahfj;jhd; Mthd;
vd;fpwJ me;j `jP].; ,g;gb vtuhtJ jpUkzk; nra;jjhy; jhd; Vo;ikf;F Mshdhu;fsh? vd;why;>
mg;gb xUtiu fhz;gJk; mNj! ,jd; %yKk; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; ,ij $wpapUf;f khl;lhu;fs; vd;gij
mwpayhk;.
,JNghy; jhd; moFk;; mofpiaj; jpUkzk; nra;j midtUNk ifNrjk; mile;jjpy;iy vd;gij
vtUk; kWf;fkhl;lhu;fs;. ,jdhYk; ,J ngha; vd;gJ njspthFk;.
,t;thNw ,uz;lhtjhf ,q;Nf Fwpg;gplg;gl;Ls;s gytPdkhd nra;jpiag; ghUq;fs;.
''moFf;fhf jpUkzk; nra;jhy; moF mopaTk; $Lk;. trjpAs;s ngz;fis jpUkzk; nra;jhy; mtu;fs;
mjd; %yk; top nflTk; $Lk; vd;W mr;nra;jp $WfpwJ.''
moFs;s ngz;fs; midtUk; jq;fspd; mofpdhNyNa ehrkile;jtu;fSky;y. trjpkpf;f ngz;fs;
midtUk; mtu;fspd; nry;tj;jpdhNyNa topnfl;ltu;fSky;y. ,J jhd; cz;ik epiy. ,jpypUe;J
,uz;lhtJ nra;jp Gidag;gl;lNj vd;gJ GhpAk;.
NkYk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd nra;jpf;Fk; ,J Kuzhf cs;sJ. Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jPi]g; ghUq;fs;.
''xU ngz; mtsJ nry;tk;> FLk;gg; ghuk;ghpak;> moF> khu;f;ff; fy;tp Mfpa ehd;Ff;fhf jpUkzk;
nra;ag;gLfpwhs;. vdpDk; eP khu;f;fg; gw;Ws;s kq;ifiaNa kzKbj;J ntw;wp ngW'' vd;W egp(]y;)
$wpajhf mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;> ,g;Dkh[h> e]aP> mg+jh¥j;
,e;j Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jPi] ed;F rpe;jpf;f Ntz;Lk;. ,e;j `jP]py; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; ehd;F
fhhpaq;fSf;fhf mjhtJ gzk;> ghuk;ghpak;> moF> khu;f;ff; fy;tp Mfpatw;wpw;fhfNt xU ngz;
jpUkzk; nra;ag;gLfpwhs; vd;W $wptpl;L> 'khu;f;fk; mwpe;jtis eP jpUkzk; nra;! ntw;wp ngWtha;'
vd;W $Wfpwhu;fNs jtpu kw;w %d;iwAk; fUj;jpy; nfhs;tij mwNt $lhJ vd;W $wtpy;iy.
xU ngz;iz moFf;fhfTk; jpUkzk; nra;ayhk;; nry;t epiyapy; cs;sts; vd;gjw;fhfTk; jpUkzk;
nra;ayhk;. FLk;gg; ghuk;ghpak; fUjpAk; jpUkzk; nra;ayhk;. ,jpy; vg;gb Ntz;LkhdhYk; jpUkzk;
nra;jhYk; khu;f;ff; fy;tp mwpe;jtisNa jpUkzk; nra;tNj rpwg;G vd;gNj ,e;j Mjhug;g+u;tkhd
`jP]pd; epiy.
moF vd;W jpUkzk; nra;Ak;NghNj khu;f;ff; fy;tp cs;sjh? vd;W ghu;f;f Ntz;Lk;. ghuk;ghpak; fUjp>
trjp fUjp jpUkzk; nra;Ak; NghNj khu;f;f mwpT cs;sjh? vd;W njhpe;J nfhs;sTk; Ntz;Lk;. ,J
jhd; tho;f;ifia ntw;wpahf;Fk; vd;gijAk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]; tpsf;FfpwJ.
moF> ghuk;ghpak;> nry;tk; ,tw;iw fUj;jpNy nfhs;tijNa Nkw;fz;l gytPdkhd nra;jpfs; jil
nra;fpd;wd. Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]pd; fUj;Jf;Nf ,J khw;wkhFk;.
trjp cs;std; trjpahd FLk;gg; ngz;iz jpUkzk; nra;aNt tpUk;Gthd;. xU rpyu; tpjptpyf;F
ngw;wpUf;fyhk;. ,J Nghy; ghuk;ghpakpf;f FLk;gj;ijr; rhu;e;jtd; jdf;F ,izahd epiyapy;
cs;stisNa jpUkzk; Kbf;f vz;Zthd;. ,J $lhJ vd;W $wpdhy; jpUkzk; vDk; tho;f;if
xg;ge;jk; ,ilapNyNa rpy rkak; Kwpe;JtpLk;.

35 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

vdNt Nkw;fz;l ,uz;L nra;jpfSNk Gidag;gl;l ngha;r; nra;jpfshFk;.

41. mofpa Kfk; ,Ug;gpd;...

''epr;rakhf my;yh`; mofpa-ftu;r;rpahd Kfk; cs;stu;fis Ntjid nra;akhl;lhd;.''


,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs; vd md];(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpg;gjhf ijykP mtu;fs; jd; E}ypy;
gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.
,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk; ngWk; mg;Jy; khypf; ,g;D K`k;kj; mu;Uf;fh\P vd;gtu;
cz;ikahdtu;. vdpDk; ,tu; gf;jhj; vDk; CUf;F te;jNghJ mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapYk; `jP]pd;
thu;j;ijapYk; FsWgb nra;aj; Jtq;fpdhu;. ,tu; gw;wpa Fwpg;G 'j`;jPGj;j`;jPG' vDk; E}ypy; cs;sJ.
,e;j `jP]{k; mtu; nra;j FsWgbfSf;Fg; gpd;dhy; jhd; ,Uf;f Ntz;Lk;. NkYk; ,jd; mwptpg;ghsu;
thpirapy; ,lk;ngWk; gyu; ahnud;Nw mwpag;glhjtu;fshf cs;sdu;. ,tu;fSk; ,l;Lf;fl;b
,Uf;ff;$Lk;.
''mofpa> ftu;r;rpahd Kfq;fis> gw;wpf; nfhs;Sq;fs;. epr;rakhf my;yh`; mofpa Kfj;ij neUg;gpy;
Nghl;L Ntjid nra;a ntl;fkilfpwhd;.''
,JTk; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; ngauhy; ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ jhd;. ,ij ,g;Dy; [t;]P mtu;fs;
my;kt;@Mj; vDk; E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;. ,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk;ngWk; `]d; ,g;D
myp,g;D [fa;ah my; mj;tP vd;gtu; rhpahdtuy;yu; vd;W ,g;Dy; [t;]P $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,tu;
,l;Lf;fl;bf; $Wtjpy; gpugykhdtu;fspy; xUtu; vd;W Råj;jp mtu;fs; $Wfpwhu;fs;. ',e;j Nkhrkhd
nra;jpia ,l;Lf;fl;batd; kPJ ,iwtdpd; rhgk; cz;lhFk;' vd ,e;jr; nra;jp gw;wp $Wk;NghJ
m\;i\f; fh mtu;fs; $Wfpwhu;fs;.
,r;nra;jp NtW mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapYk; tUfpwJ. ,jpy; ,g;wh`Pk; ,g;D Riykhd; m];]pahj; vd;gtu;
,lk; ngWfpwhu;. ,tu; rhpahdtuy;yu; vd ,g;D mjP mtu;fs; $Wfpwhu;fs;. NkYk; K`k;kj; ,g;D
jy;`h my;f&fp> K`k;kJ ,g;D mg;Jy;yh ,g;D mgPGu;jh my;fhoP Mfpa ,UtUk; ahnud;Nw
mwpag;glhjtu;fs;. NkYk; yh`pf; ,g;D `{i]d; vd;gtUk; Nkhrkhdtu;. ',tu; ngUk; ngha;au;' vd
,j;u]
P ; `hgpo; $Wfpwhu;fs;.
Nkw;fz;l ,uz;L nra;jpfSk; mwptpg;ghsu; thpir fhuzkhf kl;Lk; FiwAilaJ my;y. khwhf
Fu;Mdpd; trdq;fSf;Fk;> Mjhug;g+u;tkhd egpnkhopfSf;Fk; khw;wkhf cs;sjhYk; ,itfs;
,l;Lf;fl;lg; gl;litNaahFk;.
,t;Tyfpy; kdpjd; Nkw;nfhs;Sk; tho;f;iff;F Vw;gj; jhd; kWik tho;tpd; #o;epiyAk; mikAk;.
,iwtDf;F kpf tpUg;gkhd fhhpaq;fis nra;J tho;e;J kuzpj;jhy; mtd; Rtu;f;fj;jpy; Eiothd;.
,iwtDf;F khW nra;J> mtDf;F Nfhgj;ij Vw;gLj;Jk; nray;fis xUtd; nra;jhy; mtd; eufpy;
Eiothd; vd;gJ jhd; ,];yhkpa mbg;gilf; nfhs;ifahFk;.
my;yh`; xt;nthU Mj;khTf;F mJ rk;ghjpj;jjw;fhd $yp nfhLg;gjw;fhfNt (mtu;fis my;yh`;
,t;thW nra;thd;) epr;rakhf my;yh`; Nfs;tp fzf;F Nfl;gjpy; kpfTk; jPtpukhdtd;. (my;Fu;Md;
14:57)
cq;fsplk; ,Ug;git jPu;e;JtpLk;. my;yh`;tplk; ,Ug;gNj (mopahJ> vd;nwd;Wk;) epiyj;jpUf;Fk;.
vtu;fs; nghWikAld; (f\;lq;fisr;) rfpj;Jf; nfhs;fpwhu;fNsh> mtu;fSf;F mtu;fs; nra;J
nfhz;bUe;jtw;wpypUe;J kpfTk; mofhd $ypia epr;rakhf ehk; nfhLg;Nghk;. (my;Fu;Md; 16:96)
(%kpd;fNs!) kWikapy; ePq;fs; tpUk;gpagbNah> my;yJ Ntjj;ijAilatu;fs; tpUk;gpagbNah
ele;JtpLtjpy;iy. vtd; jPik nra;fpwhNdh mtd; mjw;Fhpa jz;lid toq;fg;gLthd;. ,d;Dk; mtd;
(mq;F) my;yh`;itj; jtpu NtW vtiuAk; (jdf;Fg;) ghJfhtydhfNth> Jiz nra;gtdhfNth
fhzkhl;lhd;.
MfNt> MzhapDk; rhp> ngz;zhapDk; rhp> ahu; ahu; <khd; nfhz;ltu;fNsh> ew;fUkq;fs;

36 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

nra;fpwhu;fNsh mtu;fs; Rtdgjpapy; Eiothu;fs;. ,d;Dk; mtu;fs; ,k;kpNaDk; mepahak;


nra;ag;glkhl;lhu;fs;. (my;Fu;Md; 4:123> 124)
vtu; xUtu; xU ed;ik nra;fpwhNuh mtUf;F mJNghy; gj;J klq;F ed;ik cz;L. vtu; xU jPik
nra;fpwhNuh mijg; Nghd;w msTila $ypia nfhLf;fg;gLthu;. mtu;fs; mepahak; nra;ag;glTk;
khl;lhu;fs;. (my;Fu;Md; 6:160)
vtu; xU mZtsT ed;ik nra;jpUe;jhYk;> mj(w;Fhpa gy)id mtu; fz;L nfhs;thu;. NkYk; vtu; Xu;
mZtsT jPik nra;jpUe;jhYk; mj(jw;Fhpa gy)idAk; mtd; fz;L nfhs;thd;. (my;Fu;Md; 99:8)
,t;trdq;fs; midj;Jk;> jPikfSf;Nfw;gNt xUtd; jz;bf;fg;gLthd; vd;gij tpsf;Ffpd;wd.
mtdtd; nra;j gyid mtdtd; mile;Nj jPUthd;. mJ mZtsNtDk; ,Ug;gpDk; rhpNa vd;W
my;yh`; njspTgLj;Jfpwhd;. ,iwtdpd; ,e;jf; $w;Wf;F khw;wkhd Nkw;fz;l nra;jpfs;
,Ug;gjpypUe;Nj mit ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;litNa vd;gJ GhpAk;.
epr;rakhf my;yh`; cq;fspd; clk;igNah> Njhw;wj; ijNah fhz;gjpy;iy. khwhf mtd; cq;fspd;
,jaq;fisAk;> nray;fisAk; ghu;f;fpwhd; vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf K];ypkpy; `jP]; xd;W
cs;sJ. ,e;j `jP]{f;Fk; ,J khw;wkhfNt cs;sJ.
my;yh`; cs;sj;ij-nraiyg; ghu;f;fpwhNd jtpu> cUtj;ij-Njhw;wj;ijf; fhz;gjpy;iy vd;W
egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpAs;sJ Mjhug;g+u;tkhf cs;sjhYk;> ,jw;F khw;wkhd fUj;ijNa - mofpa Kfk;
cs;stu;fis fz;L jz;bf;fg; gLtjpy;iy vd;w fUj;ijNa - $WtjhYk; Nkw;fz;l ,uz;L
nra;jpfSk; ,l;Lf;fl;Lg;gl;l nra;jpfNs vd;gJ NkYk; GydhFk;.
NkYk; mofpa Kfk; cilNahiu jz;bf;f khl;lhd; vd;W $Wtjhy; mofpa Kfk; cilNahu; ve;j
jtW nra;jhYk; kd;dpf;fg;gLtu; vd;W njhpa tUfpwJ. mg;gbahdhy; mtu;fs; ,\;lg;gb thoyhk; vd;W
MfptpLk;. ,J rhj;jpag;gLkh? my;yh`; jdf;F ,iz itg;Nghiu jz;bg;ghd;. kd;dpf;fNt khl;lhd;
vd;W $Wfpwhd;. mofpa Kfk; cilNahu; ,iz itj;jhYk; jz;bf;fg; gl khl;lhu;fs; vd;W jhd;>
,e;j nra;jpfs; cz;ik vd;W $wpdhy; vz;zj; Njhd;Wk;. ,J kl;Lk; tpjptpyf;Fg; ngw;w rl;lk; vd;W
$wpdhy; ,jw;F ve;j Kfhe;jpuj;ijAk; ,e;j nra;jpfspy; ngw Kbatpy;iy.
,t;thW midj;J tif Fw;wq;fshd tpgr;rhuk;-Nghijg; nghUs; cz;Zjy; ,d;Dk; gy rl;lq;fis
kPWjy; Nghd;w jtwhd nray;fisr; nra;jhy; jz;lid VJ kpUf;fhJ vd;whfptpLk;. ,JTk;
rhj;jpag;glhj xd;Nw! ,e;j tifapy; ,itfs; ngha;ahd nra;jpNa vd;gJ tpsq;Fk;.
,e;j nra;jp cz;ikahf ,Ug;gpd; K];ypk;fs; kl;LNk mofpa Kfk; cilatu;fshf ,Uf;f Ntz;Lk;.
fhgpu;fs; tpfhuKilNahuhf ,Uf;f Ntz;Lk;. ,Uf;fpwjh? ,y;iy vd;gjpypUe;Jk; ,it ngha; vd;gJ
cWjpahFk;. ey;y-jPa Kbit mofpa-mrpq;fkhd Kfq;fSf;Nfw;g KbT nra;ag;gLtjpy;iy. khwhf
ey;y-jPa KbTf;Nfw;gNt Kfk; khWk; vd;W Fu;Md; $WfpwJ.
me;j ehspy; kdpjd; kpuz;L XLthd;. jd; rNfhjuid tpl;Lk;> jd; jhia tpl;Lk;> jd; kf;fis tpl;Lk;
md;W xt;nthU kdpjDf;Fk; mtdtd; (mty) epiyNa NghJ khdjhapUf;Fk;. me;ehspy; rpy Kfq;fs;
,yq;fpf; nfhz;bUf; Fk;. rpj;jitahfTk;> kfpo;TilajhfTk; ,Uf;Fk;. Mdhy; me;ehspy; (NtW) rpy
Kfq;fs; mtw;wpd; kPJ GOjp gbe; jpUf;Fk;. mtw;iwf; fUik ,Us; %bapUf;Fk;. mtu;fs; jhk;
epuhfj;jtu;fs;. (my;Fu;Md; 80:34-42)
,t;trdq;fs; midj;Jk; $Wk; fUj;Jf;F khw;wkhf Nkw;fz;l ,uz;L nra;jpfSk; cs;sj;jhy; mit
NkYk; gytPdg;gLtNjhL kl;Lkpy;yhky;> mit ,l;Lf;fl;lg; gl;litfshfTk; Mfpd;wJ.

42. Gwk; NgRtJ...?

''Gwk; NgRtJ> x@itAk;> njhOifiaAk; Kwpj;JtpLk;.''


,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf ,g;D cku;(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. ,ij mg+eaPk; mtu;fs;
jd; E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.

37 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; njhlhpy; ,lk; ngWk; ,];khapy; ,g;D a`;ah ,g;D mg;Jy;yh`; vd;fpw mg+ a`;ah
mj;ijkP vd;gtu; ngUk; ngha;auhthu;.
,tiug; gw;wp jhuFj;dP mtu;fs; Fwpg;gpLk; NghJ> ,tu; khypf;> jt;uP ,d;Dk; gyu; topahf ngha;
$Wgtu; vd;W $Wfpwhu;fs;.
,tu; khypf;> k];¥J> ,g;D mgPjp`;G MfpNahu; topahf gy ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jpfis mwptpj;Js;shu;
vd;W `hfpk; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.
'`jPi] ,l;Lf;fl;Lgtu; ,tu;' vd fjPg; mtu;fSk;> ,r;nra;jpapy; gytPdk; cz;L vd ,g;Dk/$yh
mtu;fSk; $Wfpwhu;fs;.
,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) mtu;fs; $Wfpwhu;fs;:-
'',uz;L egu;fs; Y`iuNah> my;yJ m]iuNah njhOjdu;. me;j ,uz;L NgUNk Nehd;G
itj;jpUe;jdu;. egp(]y;) mtu;fs; njhOifia Kbj;j NghJ> (mt;tpUtUk; mioj;J) 'ePq;fs;
,UtUk; kPz;Lk; x@r; nra;J kPz;Lk; njhOq;fs;. cq;fspd; Nehd;igAk; tPzbj;Jtpl;Bu;fs;. mij
NtnwhU ehspy; kPz;Lk; epiwNtw;Wq;fs;' vd;W $wpdhu;fs;. my;yh`;tpd; J}jNu! Vd;? vd
mt;tpUtUk; Nfl;ldu;. ,d;d kdpjiug; gw;wp ePq;fs; ,UtUk; Gwk; NgrpdPu;fs; vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs;
$wpdhu;fs;.''
,r;rk;gtj;ij ig`fP mtu;fs; jdJ \{/Gy; <khd; vDk; E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;. ,J
kp\;fhJy; k]hgP`; E}ypy; 4783 vz;zpl;l `jP]hfTk; ,lk;ngw;Ws;sJ.
,r;nra;jpAk; $l ve;j mbg;gilAk;> Kiwahd mwptpg;ghsu; thpirAkpd;wp gjpT nra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ. vdNt
,JTk; ngha;r; nra;jp jhd;.
Gwk;NgRjy; vd;gJ ,];yhj;jpd; ghu;itapy; Fw;wkhFk;. gpwuJ Fw;wq;Fiwfs; gw;wp Ngrplf; $lhJ
vd;W ,];yhk; $WfpwJ.
%kpd;fNs! (re;Njfkhd) gy vz;zq;fspypUe;J jtpu;e;J nfhs;Sq;fs;. Vnddpy; epr;rakhf
vz;zq;fspy; rpy ghtq;fshf ,Uf;Fk;. (gpwu; Fiwfis) ePq;fs; JUtpj; JUtp Muha;e;J
nfhz;buhjPu;fs;. NkYk; cq;fspy; rpyu; rpyiug; gw;wp Gwk; NgrNtz;lhk;. cq;fsJ vtNuDk; jkJ
,we;j rNfhjud; khkprj;ij cz;z tpUk;Gthuh? (,y;iy). mij ePq;fs; ntWg;gPu;fs;. ,d;Dk;
ePq;fs; my;yh`;it mQ;Rq;fs;. epr;rakhf ghtj;jpypUe;J kPs;tij my;yh`; Vw;Wf; nfhs;gtd;; kpff;
fpUig nra;gtd;. (my;Fu;Md; 49:12)
egp(]y;) mtu;fs; kpk;ghpy; Vwp Fuiy cau;j;jp> ehthy; (kl;Lk;) ,];yhj;ij Vw;Wf; nfhz;L>
cs;sj;jpy; <khd; Eioahj $l;lj;jpdNu! K];ypk;fSf;Fj; njhy;iy juhjPu;fs;; mtu;fis Fiw
$whjPu;fs;. mtu;fspd; Fiwfisj; Njb miyahjPu;fs;; ahu; jkJ rNfhjud; Fiwfisj; Njb
miyfpwhNuh mtuJ Fiwia ,iwtd; NjLthd;. ahUila Fiwia my;yh`; Njlj; Jtq;fp
tpl;lhNdh mtu; jkJ tPl;bd; eLg;gFjpapy; ,Ue;jhYk; mtiu my;yh`; ,opTgLj;jptpLthd; vd;W
$wpdhu;fs;. ,ij ,g;D cku;(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. E}y;: jpu;kpjP
Gwk; NgRjy; vd;gJ ahJ? vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fsplk; Nfl;fg;gl;lJ. mjw;ftu;fs; 'ckJ rNfhjuu;
ntWf;ff;$ba xd;iw ePu; NgRtNj Gwk;' vd;whu;fs;. ehd; $WtJ mthplk; cz;ikapNyNa
,Ue;jhy;...? vdf; Nfs;tp Nfl;ltu; Nfl;lhu;. mjw;F egp(]y;) mtu;fs; 'eP $wf;$baJ mthplk;
,Ue;jhy; jhd; ePu; Gwk; NgrpatuhtPu;. mthplk; mf;Fiw ,y;iynadpy; ePu; mtJ}W $wpatuhtPu;' vd;W
tpsf;fpdhu;fs;. ,ij mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: jpu;kpjP
Gwk; NgRjy; rk;ge;jkhf gy `jP];fs; tUfpwJ. Gwk; NgRjiy jil nra;fpwJ. Mdhy; Gwk; Ngrpdhy;
x@ KwpAkh? Nehd;G tPzhFkh? vd;why; mjw;F ve;jnthU Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]{k; tutpy;iy.
vdNt Nkw;fz;l nra;jpAk; rk;gtKk; ngha;; ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ vd;gNj rhpahFk;.

43. k/hpGf;Fg; gpd; cghpj; njhOif...!

38 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

''k/hpGf;Fk;> ,\hTf;Fk; ,ilNa ,UgJ uf;mj;fs; xUtu; njhOtjhy; mtUf;F my;yh`;


nrhu;ff; j;jpy; xU tPl;il fl;Lfpwhd;.''
,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf Map\h(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpj;J ,g;Dkh[htpy; ,lk; ngw;Ws;sJ.
,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk;ngWk; a/$g; ,g;D tyPj; vd;gtu; rhpahdtuy;yu;. ,tiu
gytPdg;gLj;jpf; $Wtjpy; mwpQu;fs; xd;Wgl;Ls;sdu; vd;W g+]puP mtu;fs; m];]thapj;jpy;
Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;. ,tu; ngUk; ngha;au;fspy; xUtu;> `jP];fis ,l;Lf;fl;Lgtu; vd ,khk; m`;kj;
$Wfpwhu;fs;. NkYk; ,g;DKaPd;> mg+`hjk; MfpNahUk; ,tu; gw;wp Fiw $Wfpwhu;fs;.
''xUtu; k/hpG njhOiff;Fg; gpd; vijAk; NgRk; Kd; MW uf;mj;fs; njhOjhy; mtUf;F mjw;fhf
Ik;gJ tUl ghtq;fs; kd;dpf;fg;gLk;.''
,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg;Jy;yh ,g;D cku;(uyp) mtu;fshy; mwptpf;fg;gl;L fpahKy;iyyp
vd;Dk; E}ypy; ,g;D e]u; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.
,g;D mgP`hjk; mtu;fs; my;,yy; vDk; jkJ E}ypy; ,ijf; Fwpg;gpl;L tpl;L> ,jpy; ,lk; ngw;Ws;s
K`k;kj; ,g;D f];thd; mj;jpkp\;fP vd;gtu; `jP]; Jiwapy; kWf;fg;gl;ltu; vd;W mg+]u;M mtu;fs;
$wpaijAk; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.
''xUtu; k/hpGf;F gpd; MW uf;mj;fs; njhOJ mtw;wpw;fpilNa vJTk; NgrhjpUg;ghuhdhy; mtuJ
mj;njhOif gdpnuz;L tUlj;jpw;F tzf;fk; nra;jjw;F epfuhf;fg;gLk;.''
,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. ,J jpu;kpjP>
,g;Dkh[h> ,g;De];u;> ,g;D ]hifd;> Kf;yp];> m];fuP> ,g;D ]k;Cd;> my;thapy; MfpNahuhy;
mtutu;fsJ E}y;fspy; gjpT nra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ.
,jw; mwptpgg ; hsu; thpirapy; cku; ,g;D mgP`];mk; vd;gtu; ,lk; ngWfpwhu;. ,tu; jtwhd `jP];fis
mwptpg;gtu; vd ,khk; GfhuP $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,tu; topahf kl;LNk ,ij ehk; mwpfpNwhk; vd ,khk; jpu;kpjP
$Wfpwhu;fs;. ,tu; %yk; ,uz;L jtwhd `jP];fs; cz;L. ,jpy; ,JTk; xd;W vd;W j`gP
$Wfpwhu;fs;.
k/hpGf;Fg; gpd; mt;thgPd; vd;nwhU njhOif njhog;gLtJz;L. mjw;F ,ijNa Mjhukhff; nfhs;fpd;
wdu;. ,J gytPdkhd `jP]; vd;gjhy; ,ij itj;J mky; nra;af;$lhJ. NkYk; ,e;j MW
uf;mj;Njh> ,UgJ uf;mj;Njh k/hpGf;Fg; gpd; njhOtJ gw;wp tuf;$ba midj;JNk gytPdkhd
nra;jpfshfNt cs;sd.
NkYk; Nkw;fz;l %d;W nra;jpfSNk gpd;tUk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fSf;F khw;wkhfNt cs;sd.
,utpYk;> gfypYk; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; gj;J uf;mj;fs; njhOjij ehd; ftdpj;Js;Nsd;. Y`Uf;F Kd;
,uz;L uf;mj;fs;> Y`Uf;F gpd; ,uz;L uf;mj;fs;> k/hpGf;Fg; gpd; ,uz;L uf;mj;fs;> ,\hTf;Fg; gpd;
,uz;L uf;mj;fs;> g[Uf;F Kd; ,uz;L uf;mj;fs; (Mf gj;J uf;mj;fs;) vd `g;]h(uyp) mtu;fs;
jd;dplk; $wpajhf ,g;D cku;(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;> jpu;kpjP
k/hpGf;Fg; gpd; ,uz;L uf;mj;jpYk;> g[;Uf;F Kd; ,uz;L uf;mj;jpYk;> Fy;ah ma;A`y; fh/gp&d>
Fy;`{ty;yh`{ m`j; Mfpa mj;jpahaq;fis egp(]y;) mtu;fs; Xjpaij vd;dhy; fzf;fpl;Lr;
nrhy;y KbahJ vd ,g;D cku;(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpff ; pd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: K];ypk;> mg+jh¥j;> m`;kj;>
,g;Dkh[h
vdNt k/hpGf;Fg; gpd; ,uz;L uf;mj; njhOtNj egptop. mjw;F khw;wkhf mwptpf;fg;gLk; ,UgJ uf;mj;>
MW uf;mj; gw;wpa `jP];fs; ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;litfNs!

44. jhdpaq;fspy; ]fhj; kjpg;gPL msT vd;d?

''(jhdpa tiffspy;) mit Fiwthf ,Ug;gpDk;> mjpfkhf ,Ug;gpDk; mit thdj;J kio ePu; %yk;
tpise;J te;jpUg;gpd; gj;J rjtPjKk;> jz;zPiu Rke;J my;yJ ,iwj;J ePu; gha;r;rp fpilj;jpUg;gpd;
Ie;J rjtPjKk; ]fhj; cz;L ''

39 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

vd egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs;.


,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; gpd;tUkhW;-
1. egpj;Njhou; xUtu; (ngau; Fwpg;gplhky; xU kdpju; vd;Nw cs;sJ)
2. mghd; ,g;D mgP ,ah\;
3. mg+`dPgh
4. mg+KjPc my;g];fP
,e;j ehd;fhtJ mwptpg;ghsuhd mg+KjPctpd; ngau; my;`fk; ,g;D mg;Jy;yh`; vd;gjhFk;. ,tu;
,l;Lf; fl;Lgtu; vd [t;]yP ;fhdP vd;gtu; $Wfpwhu;fs;.
,e;j nra;jpia jdJ e];Gu;uhah vDk; E}ypy; i]y< mtu;fs; gjpT nra;J tplL ; > mg+`dPgh topahf
mwptpf;Fk; mg+KjPcy; ty;fP vd;gtd; $w;iwNa `dgP kj;`gpdu; Mjhuk; gpbf;fpwhu;fs; vd ,g;Dy;
[t;]p $wpajhfTk; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs.
,g;D KaPd>; m`;kj;> mg+jh¥j; MfpNahUk; ,e;j mg+KjPc my;gy;fP vd;gtiu FiwahfNt
Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;. NkYk; ,jpy; ,lk;ngWk; mghd; ,g;D mgP ,ah\; vd;gtUk; rhpahdtuy;y. ,tiu
\{/gh Nghd;Nwhu; gytPdg;gLj;jpf; $Wfpwhu;fs;.
,e;j `jP]pd; fUj;J> Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fspYk; cs;sNj. mg;gbahdhy; ,J `]d; vDk;
epiyf;F te;J tpLNk vd;W rpyu; $wp gpd;tUk; `jPi] Mjhukhff; $wyhk;.
kio kw;Wk; Cw;Wfs; tpistpj;jitfspYk;> epyj;jb ePiu kl;Lk; cwpQ;rp tpisgtw;wpYk; gj;J
rjtPjKk;> ePu; gha;r;rp tpistpf;fg;gl;ltw;wpy; Ie;J rjtPjKk; (]fhj;ij) egp(]y;) mtu;fs;
eilKiwg;gLj;jpdhu;fs; vd;W ,g;D cku;(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> e]aP> jpu;kpjP>
mg+jh¥j;> ,g;Dkh[h
kioePhpy; tpise;jjw;F 10% vdTk; ePu; gha;r;rp tpisar; nra;gtw;wpy; 5** vdTk; ]fhj; flik jhd;
vd;gjpy; re;Njfkpy;iy. Nkw;fz;l nra;jp mf;fUj;jpy; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd nra;jpf;F Kuz;glTkpy;iy
vd;gjpYk; re;Njfkpy;iy.
Mdhy; ,r;nra;jpapy; ,lk; ngw;Ws;s mit mjpfkhf ,Ug;gpDk; Fiwthf ,Ug;gpDk; vd;w thrfk;
jhd; gpur;ridf;FhpaNj! ,e;j thrfg;gb tpisAk; nghUl;fspy; ,d;d msT ,Ue;jhy; jhd; ]fhj;
flik vd;wpy;iy. vt;tsT tpisfpwNjh mJ Fiwthf ,Ug;gpDk; ]fhj; flik vd;W tpsq;f
KbfpwJ.
mNjrkak; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fNsh tpisAk; nghUl;fspYk; msit epu;zapf;fpwJ.
Ie;J xl;lfq;fSf;F Fiwthdtw;wpy; ]fhj; ,y;iy. Ie;J CfpahTf;F Fiwthd (nts;spapy;)
]fhj; ,y;iy. Ie;J t]f;if tpl Fiwthd (jhdpaj;)jpy; ]fhj; ,y;iy vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs;
$wpajhf mg+]aPj; my;Fj;uP(uyp) mg+`{iuuh(uyp)> ,g;D cku;(uyp)> [hgpu;(uyp)> mg;Jy;yh`; ,g;D
mk;U(uyp) MfpNahu; mwptpf;fpd;wdu;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;> jpu;kpjP
,e;j `jP]; jhdpa tiffspy; Ie;J t]f; ,Ue;jhy; jhd; ]fhj; flik vd;gij mwptpf;fpwJ. t]f;
vd;why; 60 ]hcthFk;. xU ]hc vd;gJ 51%3 uhj;jy; MFk;. Mf 300]hc(5t]f;) ,Ue;jhNy
[fhj; flik vd;W Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]; $WfpwJ.
Mdhy; ,e;j nra;jpNah Fiwthf ,Ug;gpDk; ]fhj; flik vd;fpwJ.
vdNt ,r;nra;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ jhd; vd;gjpy; re;Njfkpy;iy. ,e;j ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jp jhd;
`dgP kj;`Gf;F Mjhukhf cs;sJ vd;gijAk;> ,e;jr; nra;jpia xJf;fptpl;L 5 t]f; msit
Fwpg;gpLk; `jPi]Na mg+ `dPgh mtu;fspd; khztu; K`k;kj; mtu;fs; Mjhukhff; nfhs;fpwhu;fs;
vd;gijAk; epidtpy; nfhs;f!

40 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

45. mwpthsp MfNtz;Lkh?

''my;yh`;tpw;fhf ehw;gJ ehl;fs; xUtu; xJf;fpdhy; mtd; ehtpy; mwptpd; Cw;Wfs; ntspg;gLk;.''
,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs; vd mg+ma;åg; my; md;rhuP(uyp) mwptpff
; pdw
; ,r;nra;jp mg+eaPkpd;
my;`py;ah vDk; E}ypy; gjpT nra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ.
,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk; ngWk; ,uz;lhtJ mwptpg;ghsu; kf;`{y; vd;gtu;> egpj;Njhou;
mg+ma;åg; md;rhuP(uyp) mtu;fsplkpUe;J vijAk; nrtpAw;wjpy;iy vd ,g;Dy; [t;]P $Wfpd;whu;fs;.
%d;whtJ mwptpgg ; hsu; `[;[h[; vd;gtu; rhpapyy
; hjtu;. NkYk; Ie;jhtJ mwptpg;ghsu; K`k;kJ ,g;D
,];khaPy; vd;gtu; ahu; vd;Nw mwpag;glhjtu;. Råj;jp mtu;fs; ,r;nra;jpia fLikahfr; rhLfpd;whu;fs;.
,jpypUe;J ,r;nra;jp jtwhdJ vd;gij tpsq;fyhk;.
,e;jj; jtwhd nra;jpia Mjhukhff; nfhz;L rpyu;> my;yh`;tpd; ghijapy; ehw;gJ ehs; thUq;fs;
vd;W miof;fpd;whu;fs;. ,jw;F xU [py;yh vd;W ngaUk; itj;Js;sdu;. md;whlk; cioj;jhy; jhd;
FLk;gj;ij ghJfhf;f KbAk; vd;w epiyapy; cs;stu;fisf; $l thu;j;ij [hyq;fshy; kaf;fp>
jq;fs; fw;gid gazj;jpw;F mioj;Jr; nry;fpd;whu;fs;.
,jdhy; ghu;f;Fk; Ntiy Ngha;> nra;Ak; njhopy; erpe;J jd; FLk;gj;ij grp> gl;bdp vd;W Nghl;L tpl;L
miyAk; K];ypk;fs; cz;L. ,ij gpd;tUk; `jP]; fz;bf;fpwJ.
jhd; nghWg;gpy; cs;s egu;fis xUtd; ftdpf;fhky; ,Ug;gNj> mtd; ghtp vd;gjw;fhfr; rhd;whFk;
vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpAs;shu;fs;. E}y;: mg+jh¥j;
vdNt xUtd; khu;ff; mwpTngw my;yJ rhjhuz mwpT ngw my;yJ nkQ;Qhdk; vd;w ngay; Nghyp
mwpT ngw ehw;gJ ehl;fs; xJf;f Ntz;Lk; vd;w ek;gpf;if nfhs;s>Nkw;fz;l nra;jpia Mjhukhff;
nfhs;s KbahJ.

46. ghtkd;dpg;Gf; fl;lhakhdjy;y!

''my;yh`; jd;id ftdpj;Jf; nfhz;bUf;fpdw ; hd; vd;gij czu;e;jtuhf ghtr; nraiy xUtu;
nra;jhy;> mtu; ghtkd;dpg;Gf; Nfl;fhtpl;lhYk; mtiu my;yh`; kd;dpg;ghd;.''
,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf ,g;D k];¥j;(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;Fk; ,r;nra;jp jg;uhdP
(mt;]j;)y; cs;sJ.
,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk; ngWk; ,g;wh`Pk; ,g;D `puh]h vd;gtu; ngha;au; vd mg+jh¥j;
$Wfpd;whu;fs;. ,tiug; ngha;au; vd NkYk; gy mwpQu;fSk; $Wfpd;wdu;. vdNt ,J gytPdkhd
`jP]hFk;.
ehk; nra;Ak; ghtr; nraiy my;yh`; ftdpj;Jf; nfhz;bUf;fpd;whd; vd;gNj cz;ikahFk;. ,jpy;
vtUk; khw;Wf; fUj;Jf; nfhs;skhl;lhu;. ,e;j tifapy; ghtk; nra;Ak; xU K];ypk;> ghtk;
kd;dpf;fg;gl;ltdhf MfptpLfpd;whd;. ,ijNa Nkw;fz;l nra;jp $WfpwJ. Mdhy; K];ypk; xUtd;
kWikapy; ghtpahf-Fw;wthspahf epw;ghd;. mtdpd; Fw;wr; nraYf;F Vw;g eufk; nry;thd; vd
Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fs; $Wfpd;wd.
mJkl;Lky;y ghtkd;dpg;Gf; Nfhu Ntz;bajpy;iy. mJ fl;lhaKk; ,y;iy vd;Wk; ,e;jr; nra;jp
$WfpwJ.
(<khd; nfhz;l) tpRthrpfNs! my;yh`;tplk; fyg;gw;w Kiwapy; ghtkd;dpg;Gj; NjLq;fs;. (my;Fu;Md;
66:8)
,jd; %yk; ghtkd;dpg;Gf; NfhUq;fs; vd my;yh`; fl;lisapLfpwhd;. egp(]y;) mtu;fSk; $l xU
ehisapy; 100 jlitf;F Nky; ghtkd;dpg;Gf; Nfhhp cs;shu;fs;. mtu;fs; Kd;-gpd; ghtq;fs; midj;J
kd;dpf;fg;gl;ltu;fs;. mtu;fNs ghtkd;dpg;Gf; Nfhhp cs;s NghJ> Fw;wr; nray; GhpAk; ehk; ghtkd;dpg;G
NfhNa MfNtz;Lk; vd;gijg; Ghpayhk;.

41 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

my;yh`;tpd; Mizf;F khw;wkhf ,e;jr; nra;jp cs;sjhy; ,J ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jp vdg; Ghpayhk;.

47. rpye;jpahf khw;wg;gl;l i\j;jhd;?

''rpye;jpg;g+r;rp i\j;jhdhFk;. my;yh`;jhd; i\j;jhid (rpye;jpg; g+r;rpahf) cUkhw;wpdhd;. vdNt


mijf; nfhy;Yq;fs;!''
,t;thW egp(]y;) $wpajhf ,g;D cku;(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;Fk; ,r;nra;jp ,g;D mjPapd; my;fhkpy;
E}ypy; gjpT nra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ. ,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk; ngWk; k];ykh vd;gtd; midj;Jr;
nra;jpfSk; NfhshWfs; cilaitNa vd ,ij gjpT nra;j ,g;D mjP mtu;fNs Fwpg;gpLfpd;whu;fs;.
''my;yh`; vij cUkhw;wpdhNdh> mjw;F tk;rhtopNah> Foe;ijfNsh tpl;L itf;ftpyi ; y'' vd;W
egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf ,g;Dk];¥j;(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: K];ypk;> m`;kj;
cUkhw;wk; nra;ag;gl;l ve;j capdj;jpw;Fk; thrpy;iy vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $Wk;NghJ rpye;jpg; g+r;rp
cUkhw;wk; nra;ag;gl;bUf;Fkhdhy; mjw;F thR ,Uf;f tha;g;gpy;iy vd;whfptpLfpwJ. rpye;jpg;g+r;rpia
cUkhw;wk; nra;jjhf ve;j xU Mjhuf; FwpgG; k; ,y;iy. mg;gbNa cUkhw;wk; nra;jJ cz;ik jhd;
vd;gij Vw;Wf; nfhz;lhYk; khw;wg;gl;l rpye;jpNahL mJ xope;J tpLfpwJ. mjdhy; thRr; rpye;jp
iaj; jUk; tha;g;gpy;iy vd;gjhy; Nkw;fz;l nra;jp ngha; vd tpsq;fyhk;.
Mdhy; rpye;jpg; g+r;rpiaf; nfhy;yf;$lhJ vd;W $WNthUk; cz;L. mjw;Fg; gpd;tUk; nra;jpia
Mjhukhff; $Wthu;fs;.
''egp(]y;) mtu;fs; `p[;uj; nra;jNghJ> ]t;u; vDk; Fifapy; xspe;jhu;fs;. vjphpfs; Fifapd; gf;fk;
te;jdu;. mg;NghJ xU rpye;jpg;g+r;rp> Fif thapypy; tiy gpd;dpaJ. rpye;jp tiy mWglhky;
cs;sijf; fz;l vjphpfs; cs;Ns vtUk; ,y;iy vd;W fUjp jpUk;gpr; nrd;wdu;. ,jdhy; jd;idg;
ghJfhj;j rpye;jpiaf; nfhy;yf;$lhJ vd egp(]y;) $wpdhu;fs;.''
,Ug;gpDk; ,e;jr; nra;jpf;Fk; Mjhuk; ,y;iy. ,JTk; fw;gidNa. vdNt rpye;jpiaf; nfhy;yNth>
nfhy;yhky; ,Ug;gNjh vd;w Miz vJTk; egp(]y;) mtu;fshy; gpwg;gpf;fg;gltpy;iy vd;gNj cz;ik!

48. ,ilj;jufu; ,y;iy!?

''xU $l;lj;jpw;F i\fhf ,Ug;gtu;> xU ck;kj;jpw;F mDg;gg;gl;l egpiag; Nghd;wtuhthu;.''


,g;D cku;(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;Fk; ,r;nra;jp ,g;D `pg;ghdpy; cs;sJ. ,jpy; ,lk; ngWk; mg;Jy;yh
,g;D cku; ,g;D fh]pk; vd;gtu; gytPdu; vd ,g;D`pg;ghd; mtu;fNs $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ,tu; jhd;
khypf;(u`;) mtu;fsplk; Nfl;ljhff; $Wfpd;wdu;. Mdhy; ,tu; mthplk; vijAk; Nfl;ljpy;iy vdTk;
,g;D `pg;ghd; $Wfpd;whu;fs;. `hgpo; ,g;D`[u; mtu;fSk; jkJ (j`;jPGj; j`;jPg;) E}ypy; ,J
,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jp vd;W Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.
gpw rKjhaj;jpypUe;J te;J ,];yhkpar; rKjhaj;jpdu; te;J Nru;e;j Neha;fspy; N\F-KuPJ vd;gJk;
xd;whFk;. ,iwtdpd; Vn[z;l; vd xUtid kf;fs; ek;Gtu;. me;j ek;gg;gLk; Vn[z;ilNa N\F
vd;W miog;gu;.
,e;j N\F jd;id Vw;f tUNthUf;F jPl;ir toq;Fthu;. jPl;ir ngWk; egu;fs; KuPJ vd;W
miof;fg;gLtu;. ,e;j N\Ffs; jq;fspd; KuPJfSf;F-rPlu;fSf;F Nghjpf;Fk; Nghjidapy;
Fu;Md;-`jPi] ePq;fs; tpsq;fNt KbahJ. ntspg; nghUisj; jhd; ePq;fs; mwpayhk;. cs;nghUis
ehq;fNs tpsq;Fk; Mw;wy; ngw;wtu;fs; vd;W $Wtu;. ,ij ek;Gk; rPlu;fs; Fu;MidAk;-`jPi]Ak;
jpwe;Nj ghu;f;f khl;lhu;fs;.
N\Ffspd; fhypy; tpOtu;. N\FfSf;F kiwthd Qhdk; cz;L vd ek;Gtu;. N\Ff;F njhpahky;
vijAk; nra;a khl;lhu;fs;. kWikapy; jq;fis N\Ffs; nrhu;f;fj;jpy; Nru;g;ghu;fs;. N\Ffs;
njhohky;> Nehd;G itf;fhky; ,Ug; gijNah> ngz;fsplk; jdpj;J ,Ug;gijNah Fiwahff;

42 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

fUjkhl;lhu;fs;. ,Wjpapy; N\Ffis flTshf-flTspd; mtjhukhf-flTspd; Fzq;fisg; ngw;wtuhf-


flTspd; Vn[z;lhf fUJk; kdepiyf;Fj; js;sg;gLthu;fs;.
ahNuDk; N\F gw;wpAk;> mJ gpj;jyhl;lk; vd;gJ gw;wpAk; njhpa Muk;gpj;J> ntspNawptplf; $lhJ vd;w
Nehf;fpy; $wg;gl;lJ jhd; Nkw;fz;l ngha;r;nra;jp.
N\F vd;w mugpr; nrhy;Yf;F 'Kjpatu;'> 'mwpQu;' vd;w mstpy; jhd; nghUs; nfhs;s KbANk jtpu>
FU vd;W nghUs; nfhs;s KbahJ. xUNtis FU vd;Nw $wpdhYk; xU FUit egpf;Fr; rkkhf
fUjKbAkh? egp vDk; me;j];j;ij my;yh`; ehbatu; kl;LNk mila KbAk;. mJTk; egp(]y;)
mtu;fSld; Kbe;Jtpl;lJ.
Nghypr; nra;jpia cUthf;fp> N\F vd;gtiu egpahf;fp Gjpa rpj;jhe;jk; xd;iw ,tu;fs;
cUthf;fpaijj; jtpu NtW ve;jg; gaDk; ,e;jr; nra;jpahy; cUthftpy;iy vd;gij czu;eJ ; >
Nkw;fz;l nra;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jp vd;gijAk; cs;sj;jpy; epiy ngwr; nra;Nthkhf!

49. muG kf;fis ntWf;fyhkh?

''Fiw\pfis Nerpg;gJ <khdhFk;. mtu;fis ntWg;gJ ,iw kWg;ghFk;. mNugpaiu Nerpg;gJ


<khdhFk;. mtu;fis ntWg;gJ ,iwkWg;ghFk;. mugpfis tpUk;gpdhy; mtd; vd;id
tpUk;gpatdhthd;. mugpfis ntWg;gtd; vd;id ntWj;jtd; Mthd;.''
egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf ,ij md];(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. cifyP mtu;fs;> mo;O/`gh
vDk; E}ypYk;> jg;uhdP mtu;fs; jdJ 'my;mt;]j;' vDk; E}ypYk; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.
,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; k`;fy; ,g;D khypf;> i`]k; ,g;D [k;kh]; MfpNahu; ,lk; ngw;Ws;sdu;.
,jpy; k`;fy; vd;gtu; gytPdu; vd ,khk; j`gP $Wfpdw ; hu;fs;. NkYk; i`]k; vd;gtu; `jP]; Jiw
mwpQu;fshy; iftplg;gl;ltu; vd;W j`gP mtu;fSk;> e]aP mtu;fSk; $Wfpd;whu;fs;.
md];(uyp) mwptpg;gjhf ]hgpj; vd;gtu; topahf i`]k; kl;Lk; jhd; $Wfpwhu; vd jg;uhdP
$Wfpd;whu;fs;. i`]kpd; `jP];fs; rhpahdit my;y vd cifyP mtu;fs; $Wfpd; whu;fs;. ,tu;
gytPdkhdtu; vd ,g;D KaPd; $Wfpd;whu;fs;.
mugpia tpl mugp my;yhjtNdh> mugp my;yhjtid tpl muG nkhop NgRgtNdh rpwe;jtd; ,y;iy vd
egp(]y;) mtu;fs; kf;fh ntw;wpapd; NghJ> gpufldg;gLj;jpa Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]{f;Fk; ,J khw;wkhf
cs;sJ. vdNt ,J ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jp vd;W $WtNj rhpahFk;.
''mugpfis tpUk;GtJ <khdhFk;. mtu;fis Nfhgg;gLj;JtJ eatQ;rfkhFk;.''
,J egp(]y;) mtu;fspd; ngauhy; `hfpkpy; gjpT nra;ag; gl;Ls;sJ. ,e;j `jP]pYk; k`;fy; ,g;D
khypf;> i`]k; ,g;D [k;kh]; Mfpa ,U gytPdu;fNs ,lk; ngw;Ws;sdu;.
Kdh/gpf; jdk; (eatQ;rfk;) vDk; Fzhjprak; <khd; nfhz;Ltpl;ljhf ebf;Fk; ,iw
kWg;ghsu;fsplNk ,Uf;Fk;. ,e;j Kdh/gpf; jdk;> muG nkhop Ngrpa kf;fsplKk; ,Ue;jjhf `jP];fspy;
fhz;fpNwhk;. Kdh/gpf;Ffspd; jiytd; mg;Jy;yh`; ,g;D cig ,g;D rY}y; vd;gtd; mugp nkhop
Ngrpa mugp jhd;. muG nkhop NgRgtid ntWg;gJk;> Nfhgg;gLj;JtJk; jhd; Kdh/gpf; vd;why; muG
nkhop NgRgtNd Kdh/gpf; vd;W vg;gbf; $wKbAk;? Kdh/gpf; jd;ikf;Fk;> nkhopf;Fk; rk;ge;jk;
,y;iy vd;gNj cz;ik.
,J kl;Lky;y Kdh/gpf; ahu;? vd;gij gpd;tUk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]{k; njspTgLj;JfpwJ.
''Kdh/gpf; (eatQ;rfdpd;) milahsk; %d;whFk;. Ngrpdhy; ngha; NgRthd;. thf;FWjp je;jhy;
khWgLthd;. ek;gpdhy; Nkhrb nra;thd;'' vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+`{iuuh(uyp)
mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;
vdNt Nkw;fz;l nra;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lit vd;gJ tpsq;Fk;.

43 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

50. ghu;rp nkhop rpwe;jjh?

''my;yh`;tpd; mu;i\r; Rw;wpAs;s (J}a;ik kpFe;j thd)tu;fspd; nkhop ghu;rp nkhopahFk;. my;yh`;
,yFthd tp\aj;ij nrhy;y ehbdhy; ghu;rp nkhopapy; t`P mwptpg;ghd;. f\;lkhd tp\aj;ijr;
nrhy;y ehbdhy; mugp nkhopapy; t`P mwptpg;ghd;.''
,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+ckhkh(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;.
,e;j `jP]py; [`;gu; ,g;D [{igu; my;`dgP vd;gtu; ,lk; ngWfpd;whu;. ,tiug; gw;wp Fd;Ju;
mtu;fs; $Wk;NghJ ]Pg< vd;gtu; fOij xd;wpy; gazk; nra;J nfhz;bUe;jhu;. mthplk; ePq;fs; vq;Nf
nry;fpwPu;fs;? vd;W Nfl;Nld;. mjw;F mtu;fs; [`;gu; ,g;D [{igu; vd;gtd; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; kPJ
400 `jP];fis ,l;Lf; fl;bAs; shdhk;. mtdplk; rz;ilaplg; NghfpNwd; vd;W $wpdhu;fs; vdf;
Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.
',e;j egd; `jP]; vwpag;gl Ntz;Lk;' vd mg+]u;M $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ',td; `jPi] vLj;Jf;
nfhs;sNt $lhJ' vd ,khk; e]aP> jhuFj;dP MfpNahu; $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ',td; ,l;Lf;fl;Lgtd;' vd
,g;D`pg;ghd; $Wfpd;whu;fs;.
,NjNghy; m`;kj;> a`;$g;> ,g;D R/g;ahd;> ,g;D mjP mg+eaPk;> ,g;Dy; kj;adP> mg+jh¥j;> myP ,g;D
[{d;Jg;> a`;ah MfpNahUk; ,e;j egiuf; fLikahf tpku;rpf;fpwhu;fs;. vdNt ,e;j `jP];
gytPdkhd-,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jpahFk;.
xt;nthU J}jiuAk; mtd; r%fj;jhUf;F mtu; tpsf;fpf; $Wtjw;fhf mtu;fSf;Fhpa nkhopapNyNa ehk;
mDg;gp itj;Njhk;. (my;Fu;Md; 14:4)
mjhtJ vy;yh nkhop NgRk; egu;fSf;Fk; me;j me;j nkhop NgRk; egpkhu;fs; J}ju;fshf te;Js;sdu;
vd;gijNa ,e;j trdk; $Wfpd;wJ. ,e;j tifapy; mugp nkhop Ngrpa kf;fsplk; mugp nkhop Ngrpa
egp(]y;) mtu;fs; ,iwj; J}juhf mDg;gg;gl;lhu;fs;. ,jdhy; muG nkhopapNyNa ,iwr; nra;jp
te;jpUf;f Ntz;Lk;.
egp(]y;) mtu;fNshL ,iwj;J}ju; nghWg;G Kw;Wg; ngWtjhYk;> mtu;fNs vy;yh nkhop NgRk;
kf;fSf;Fk; nghJthd ,iwj;J}ju; vd;gjhYk; cyfk; KOJk; cs;s Fu;Md; %ynkhopahd mugp
nkhopapNyNa cs;sJ. ghu;rp nkhopapy; ,wq;fp ,Ue;jhy; ghu;rp nkhop trdk; vq;Nf vd;w Nfs;tp vOk;.
,jpypUe;Nj Nkw;fz;l nra;jp ngha; vd;W tpsq;fyhk;.
mugp nkhopapy; Fu;Md; cs;sjhy; mugpnkhopf;Fj; jdpr; rpwg;G vd;gJk; fpilahJ vd;gijAk; Ghpe;J
nfhs;s Ntz;Lk;.
vdNt Nkw;fz;l nra;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l ngha; vd;gJ Cu;[pjkhfpwJ.

51. mugp jhd; nrhu;ff


; nkhopah?

''my;yh`;tpw;F Nfhgkhd nkhop ghu;rpahFk;. ghu;rp nkhop i\j;jhdpd; nkhopahFk;. nrhu;f;f nkhop
mugpahFk;.''
,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. ,e;j `jP]py; ,g;D
]pahj; vd;gtu; ,lk; ngWfpd;whu;.
',td; j[;[hy; Nghy; ngha; $Wk; fpotd;. ,tidg; gw;wp Fiw $whky; ve;j E}Yk; vOjf;$lhJ'
vd;W ,g;D `pg;ghd; $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ',tdJ `jP]; epuhff;fg;gl Ntz;Lk;' vd;W ,g;D mjP
$Wfpd;whu;fs;.
ghu;rp nkhopiag; gpbf;fhj xU mNugpad; ,ij ,l;Lf; fl;bapUf;f Ntz;Lk;. my;yh`;tplk;
cUtj;jhNyh> nkhopahNyh> md;igNah> Nfhgj;ijNah xUtd; mile;J nfhs;s KbahJ vd;gNj
epiy.

44 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

my;yh`;tplk; cq;fspy; rpwe;jtu;> cq;fspy; ,iwar;r Kilatu;fs; jhd;. (my;Fu;Md; 49:13)


,iwar;r czu;T cs;std; kl;LNk ,iwad;igg; ngw KbAk; vd jpUf;Fu;Md; $Wk;NghJ> mugpnkhop
Ngrpatd; rpwe;jtd; vd;Wk;> mk;nkhop nrhu;f;f nkhop vd;Wk; $WtJ mgj;jkhFk;.
nrhu;f;fj;jpy; cyfk; Njhd;wpaJ Kjy; mopAk; tiu ,Ue;j kf;fspy; gyu; ,Ug;gu;. mtu;fspy; gy;NtW
nkhop NgRk; kf;fSk; ,Ug;gu;. mtutu; njhpe;j nkhopapy; jq;fSf;fpilNa Ngrpf; nfhs;tu; vd;gJ jhd;
rhpahf ,Uf;f KbAk;. muG nkhopNa nghJ nkhop vd ve;j xU Mjhug;g+u;tkhd nra;jpAk; ,y;iy.
vdNt mugp nrhu;ff ; thrpfspd; nkhop vd;gJk; mgj;jNkahFk;.
%]htpw;F Ntjj;ijf; nfhLj;Njhk;. mt;Ntjj;jpy; gD} ,];uNtyu;fSf;F Neu;topia itj;Js;Nshk;.
(my;Fu;Md; 3:4)
muGk;> ghu;]pAk; my;yhj nkhopapy; toq;fg;gl;l jt;uhj; Ntjk; ,wq;fpa nkhop Nkhrk; vd;W $wKbAkh?
,ju egpkhu;fs; Ngrpa nkhopfisj; jhd; Nkhrk; vd;W $w KbAkh? vdNt nkhopfF ; vd jdprr; pwg;G
VJk; ,y;iy vd;gJ cz;ik!
Mifahy; Nkw;fz;l nra;jp> ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l ngha;r; nra;jp vd;gJ cWjpahfpd;wJ.

52. tpahghhpAk; tptrhapAk; nfl;ltu;fsh?

''kdpju;fspy; nfl;ltu;fs; tpahghhpAk;> tptrhapAk; jhd;.''


egp(]y;) mtu;fs; ,t;thW $wpajhf md];(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;Fk; ,r;nra;jp 'kt;@Mj;' vDk; jdJ
E}ypy; ,g;Dy; [t;]P gjpT nra;Js;shu;.
,r;nra;jpapd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ahnud;Nw njhpahj gyu; ,lk; ngWfpd;wdu;. ,J egp(]y;)
mtu;fspd; ngauhy; ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jp vd ,g;Dy; [t;]P> Råj;jp MfpNahu; Fwpg;gpLfpd;whu;fs;.
''xU K];ypk; kuj;ij el;L my;yJ (VNjDk; gapiu) tptrhak; nra;J> mjpypUe;J gwitNah>
kdpjNdh> tpyq;fpdNkh rhg;gpl;Ltpl;lhy; mJ mtd; nra;j ju;kkhf (fzf;fply;) MFk;'' vd egp(]y;)
$wpdhu;fs; vd md];(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;
''epyk; itj;jpUg;gtu;> mjpy; tptrhak; nra;al;Lk;'' vd egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf [hgpu;(uyp)
mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: GfhuP
Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fspy; tptrhak; nra;tJ gw;wp egp(]y;) mtu;fs; typAWj;jpAs;sdu;. tptrhapfshf
gy egpj;Njhou;fs; ,Ue;Js;sdu;. ,JNghy; egp(]y;) mtu;fNs tpahghuk; nra;Js;shu;fs;.
egpj;Njhou;fspy; gyu; tpahghhp fshf> ngUk; tzpfuhf ,Ue;Js;sdu;. nrhu;f;fthjp vd milahsk;
fhl;lg;gl;l mg;Ju;u`;khd; ,g;D mt;/G (uyp) mtu;fSk; $l xU ngUk; tzpfNu!
vdNt Nkw;fz;l nra;jpapy; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirf; FsWgbfSk;> Mjhug;g+u;tkhd nra;jpfSf;F
Kuz;ghLk; cs;sJ. vdNt ,J gytPdkhd nra;jpahfpwJ. ,J gytPdkhd nra;jp vd;gij tpl
egp(]y;) mtu;fspd; ngauhy; ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jp vd;W $WtNj rhpahFk;.

53. egp(]y;) mtu;fis Nehpy; re;jpj;j ed;ik ngw...

''ehd; ,we;jg; gpd; xUtu; `[; nra;a te;J> vd; fg;iu ]pahuj; nra;jhy;> mtu; vd;id capUld;
(Nehpy;) re;jpj;jtu; Nghyhthu;.''
,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf ,g;D cku;(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;Fk; nra;jp> jg;uhdP(fgPu;> mt;]j;>
]fPu;) kw;Wk; jhuFj;dP> ig`fP> ,g;D mjP(fhkpy;) Mfpa E}w;fspy; gjpT nra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ.
,r;nra;jpapd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk;ngWk; %d;whtJ mwptpg;ghsu; iy]; ,g;D mg+Riyk; vd;gtu;
%is Fok;gpatu; Mthu;. ehd;fhtJ mwptpg;ghsu; `g;]; ,g;D Riykhd; vd;gtu; ngUk; ngha;au; vd;W
,e;j `jPi] gjpT nra;Js;s ,g;D mjP mtu;fs; $Wfpd;whu;fs;. `g;]; `jPi] ,l;Lf;fl;Lk; egu;

45 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

vd ,g;Dy; fuh]; $Wfpd;whu;fs;. NkYk; ,tu; gytPdu; vd jg;uhdP> ig`fP MfpNahUk;


$Wfpd;whu;fs;. vdNt ,J Mjhukw;w nra;jpahFk;.
Mdhy; ,ij Mjhukhff; nfhz;L rpyu; `[;[{f;Fr; nrd;Wtpl;L kjPdh nry;fpd;whu;fs;. kjPdhtpy;
mlf;fk; nra;ag;gl;Ls;s egp(]y;) mtu;fspd; fg;iu ]pahuj; nra;fpd;whu;fs;. ,J Mjhug;g+u;tkhd
`jP]{f;F khw;wkhf Tk; cs;sJ.
%d;W gs;spthrYf;Nf jtpu NtW vq;Fk; (ed;ikia ehb) gazk; Gwg;glf;$lhJ. 1) k];[pJy; `uhk;
2) vdJ ,e;jg; gs;spthry; 3) k];[pJy; mf;]h vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+`{iuuh(uyp)
mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;> e]aP
ed;ik fpilf;Fk; vd;w ngaYk; egp(]y;) mtu;fspd; fg;iu ]pahuj; nra;jhy; mtu;fis Nehpy; re;jpj;j
ed;ik fpilf;Fk; vd;w ngaYk; ,JNghd;w gazk; Nkw;nfhs;tJ $lhJ vd;gijNa Mjhug;g+u;tkhd
`jP]; $Wfpdw; J.
`[;[{ nra;Jtpl;L> kjPdh gs;spapy; njhOjhy; mjpf ed;ik cz;L vd;w ngay; jhd; kjPdh nry;y
Ntz;LNk jtpu kjPdhtpy; egp(]y;) mtu;fspd; fg;iu [pahuj; nra;a gazpj;jy; vd;w ngay; gazk;
nry;tJ $lhJ.

54. K`k;kJk;> K`k;kjpd; je;ijAk; nrhu;f;fk; nry;tu;?

''xUtUf;F Foe;ij gpwe;J> mjw;F guf;fj;ij ehb mtu; K`k;kj; vd;W ngahpl;lhy; mtUk;> mtd;
Foe;ijAk; nrhu;f;fj;jpy; ,Ug;ghu;.''
,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+ckhkh(uyp) mwptpf;Fk; ,r;nra;jp> ,g;D Gifu; mtu;fspd;
'/go;Y ,];K`{ m`;kj;> K`k;kj;' vDk; E}ypy; cs;sJ.
,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; `hkpj; ,g;D K`k;kj; vd;gtu; VohtJ mwptpg;ghsuhf ,lk;ngWfpd;whu;.
,tu; ,];`hf; ,g;D a]hu; topahf ,ij mwptpf;fpd;whu;. ,];`hf; topahf `hkpj; ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l
nra;jpfis mwptpg;ghu; vd;W j`gP $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ,g;D ifåk; mtu;fs; ,J jtwhd nra;jp vd;W
$Wfpd;whu;fs;.
ngaLtjd; Nehf;fk;> kdpju;fs; xUtUf;nfhUtu; mwpKfk; nra;J nfhs;sj;jhd;. ,ijAk; ,r;nra;jp
gho;gLj;J fpwJ. vy;NyhUk; K`k;kj; vd;w ngay; ,Ue;jhy;> vg;gb mwpKfk; nra;J nfhs;tJ?
,jpypUe;J ,J ngha;r; nra;jp vdmwpayhk;.
K`k;kj; vd ngau; cs;stUk;> mtUf;F itj;j mtd; je;ijAk; K`k;kj; vd;w ngaUf;fhfNt
nrhu;f;fk; nry;thu; vd;Wk; ,r;nra;jp $WfpwJ. ,jdhy; K`k;kj; vd;W ngaUs;stu; ve;j ew;nraYk;
nra;a Ntz;bajpy;iy. Vd;? mtd; je;ijAk; $l ew;nray; nra;a Ntz;bajpy;iy vd;whfptpLfpd;wJ.
<khd; nfhz;L ew;nray; nra;fpwtu;fs; jhd; nrhu;f;f thrpfshtu;. mtu;fs; mjpNy epue;jukhf
,Ug;ghu;fs;. (my;Fu;Md; 2:82)
FUlDk;> ghu;it cs;stDk; rkkhfkhl;lhu;fs;. (mt;thNw <khd; nfhz;L) ew;nray; nra;NjhUk;>
jPNahUk; (rkkhf khl;lhu;fs;). kpff; FiwthfNt ePq;fs; rpe;jpf;fpwPu;fs;. (my;Fu;Md; 40:58)
'epr;rakhf my;yh`; cq;fspd; cliyNah> ciliaNah ghu;g;gjpy;iy. cq;fspd; cs;sq;fisAk;>
nray;fisANk ghu;f;fpwhd;' vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mg+ `{iuuh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;.
E}y;: K];ypk;
ew;nray; nra;jhy; jhd; nrhu;f;fk; fpilf;Fk; vd;W trdq;fs; kw;Wk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]; $Wk;
NghJ K`k;kj; vd;W ngau; cs;sjhNyNa Rtu;ff ; k; nry;yyhk; vd;gJ vt;tsT nghpa Kuz;!
egp(]y;) mtu;fspd; ngau; K`k;kj; MFk;. Mdhy; mtu;fSf;F ngahpl;L kfpo;e;j mtd; jhNah> nghpa
je;ijNah> ghl;ldhNuh Vd;? gpwf;Fk; Kd; ,we;j je;ijNah nrhu;f;fthrpfs; my;yu; vd;gJ jhd;
cz;ikahFk;.

46 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

vdNt Nkw;fz;l nra;jp Gide;j nra;jp vd;gNj cz;ik.

55. egp(]y;) ,Wjp egpah? ,y;iyah?

''ehd; egpkhu;fspy; ,Wjpahdtd;. vdf;Fg; gpd; ve;j egpAk; ,y;iy. my;yh`; ehbdhNy jtpu.''
,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf md];(uyp) mwptpf;Fk; nra;jpia ,g;Dy; [t;]P mtu;fs; jdJ
kt;@Mj; E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.
,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; %d;whtJ mwptpg;ghs uhf K`k;kJ ,g;D ]aPj; m\;\hkP vd;gtu; ,lk;
ngWfpd;whu;. ,tu; ']dhjpfh' nfhs;ifAilatuhf ,Ue;j jhy; ,tiu mg+[`;/gu; nfhiy nra;jhu;fs;
vd;Wk; ,tu; ,l;Lf; fl;lg;gl;l nra;jpfis mwptpg;gtu; vd;Wk; ,khk; m`;kj; ,g;D `d;gy;
$Wfpd;whu;fs;. ',tu;> ]dhjpfh nfhs;if fhuzkhf rpYitapy; miwag;gl;lhu;' vd ,khk; GfhuP
$Wfpd;whu;fs;. ,tuJ `jP];fs; Gwf;fzpf;fg;gl Ntz;bait vd mg+]u;M $Wfpd;whu;fs;.
egp(]y;) mtu;fSf;Fg; gpd; egp fpilahJ vd;gJ ,];yhkpaf; nfhs;if ,e;jf; nfhs;ifia
cWjpg;gLj;Jk trdq;fSk;> `jP];fSk; Vuhskha; cs;sd.
...vdpDk; K`k;kj; my;yh`;tpd; J}juhfTk; egpkhu; fspd; ,WjpahdtuhfTk; cs;shu;. (my;Fu;Md;
33:40)
''vd; rKjhaj;jpy; rpy $l;lj;jpdu; ,iz itg;gtu; fSld; NrUthu;fs;. rpiyfisAk; $l
tzq;Fthu;fs;. NkYk; vd; rKjhaj;jpy; Kg;gJ ngha;au;fs; Njhd;Wthu;fs;. ,tu;fs; midtUk;
jd;id egp vd;Nw thjpLthu;fs;. ,e;j epiy Vw;gLk; tiu kWik ehs; tuhJ. ehd; jhd; ,Wjp egp.
vdf;Fg; gpd; egp fpilahJ'' vd;W egp(]y;) $wpajhf ]t;ghd;(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;.
E}y;fs;: K];ypk;> jpu;kpjP
''gD} ,];uNtyu;fsplkpUe;J njhlu;e;J egpkhu;fs; tUgtu;fshf ,Ue;jhu;fs;. xU egp ,we;Jtpl;lhy;
mjw;Fg; gfukhf ,d;ndhU egp tUthu;. Mdhy; vdf;Fg; gpd;dhy; ve;j egpAk; fpilahJ'' vd
egp(]y;) $wpajhf mg+ `{iuuh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;
,e;j trdk; kw;Wk; `jP];fs; egp(]y;) mtu;fSf;Fg; gpd; egpNa fpilahJ vd;W njhpspthf
mwptpff
; pdw
; d. Mdhy; Nkw;fz;l nra;jpapy; 'my;yh`; ehbdhNy jtpu' vd;w thu;j;ij jpl;lkplL
;
Gide;jjhFk;.
,jdhy; jhd; rpyu; jq;fis egp vd;W thjpl;ldu;. Mdhy; ,tu;fspd; thjk; vLglhky; NghdJ
vd;gNj cz;ik. fhjpahdp kjj;ijr; Nru;e;NjhUk; ,ijNa Mjhu khff; nfhz;Ls;sdu;.
Mdhy; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; jhd; ,Wjp egp vd;gjpy; vs;Kid mstpw;Fk; re;Njfkpy;iy. vdNt
Nkw;fz;l nra;jp ''Gide;jJ. ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ'' vd;gNj cz;ikahFk;.

56. gpufhrpf;Fk; ,Us;?

''egp(]y;) mtu;fs;> ntspr;rj;jpy; ghu;g;gijg; Nghy; ,UspYk; (,Uf;Fk; nghUl;fisj; njspthfg;)


ghu;g;ghu;fs;.''
,t;thW Map\h(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;Fk; nra;jpia ,khk; ig`fP jdJ 'jyhapYd;DGth' E}ypy; gjpT
nra;Js;shu;fs;. ,g;D mjP mtu;fspd; E}ypYk; cs;sJ.
,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; gytPdk; cs;sJ vd ,ijg; gjpT nra;j ,khk; ig`fP mtu;fNs $wTk;
nra;fpd;whu;fs;. ,jpy; Ie;jhtJ mwptpg;ghsuhf mg;Jy;yh ,g;D KfPuh ,lk; ngWfpd;whu;. ',tu;
mbg;gilaw;w nra;jpfis mwptpg;gtu;' vd cifyP $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ',td; `jP];fs; kWf;fg;gl
Ntz;bait' vd ,g;DåD]; $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ',r;nra;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ' vd j`gP $Wfpd;whu;fs;.
,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; MwhtJ mwptpg;ghsuhf Kmy;yh ,g;D`pyhy; vd;gtu; ,lk; ngWfpd;whu;.

47 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

,td; `jP];fs; iftplg; glNtz;bait vd ,khk; GfhuP $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ,tu; ngha;au;fspy;


gpugy;akhdtu; vd ,khk; KaPd; $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ,tu; ,l;Lf;fl;bf; $Wgtu; vd ,khk; e]aP
$Wfpd;whu;fs;. ,JNghyNt jhuFj;dP $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ,tu; ek;gpf;ifahd egu;fspd; ngaiug;
gad;gLj;jp ,l;Lfl;lg;gl;l nra;jpfisf; $Wgtu; vd;W ,g;D `pg;ghd; $Wfpd;whu;fs;.
Nkw;fz;l nra;jp NghyNt ,g;D m]hfpu; E}ypYk; NtW mwptpg;ghsu; thpirAld; xU nra;jp
,lk;ngw;Ws;sJ. mjpYk; FsWgb epiwe;j> Kftaw;w mwptpg;ghsu;fs; ,lk; ngw;Ws;sdu;.
,e;jr; nra;jpapy; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; ,Ul;Lg; gFjpapy; nrd;why; me;j ,lNk gpufhrpj;J tpLk; vd;gJ
Nghy; $wg;gLfpd;wJ. Mdhy; ,jw;F Neu; khw;wkhd nra;jpia gpdt ; Uk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];
$Wfpd;wJ.
ehd; xU ehs; ,uT ntspNa nrd;Nwd;. mg;NghJ egp(]y;) mtu;fs; jdpNa ele;J nrd;W
nfhz;bUe;jhu;fs;. (re;jpu xspapdhy; Vw;gl;l mtu;fspd; gpk;g) epoypd; gpd;dhy; ehd; ele;J nrd;Nwd;.
mg;NghJ egp(]y;) mtu;fs; jpUk;gp vd;idg; ghu;j;J tpl;L> ,J ahu;? vd;W Nfl;lhu;fs;. ehd; mg+ju;
vd;Nwd;. ,ij mg+ju;(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;
jd; mUNf ,Uspy; ele;J te;j jd; Njhou; mg+ju;(uyp) mtu;fis ,Uspd; fhuzkhf ahu; vdj;
njhpahky; ahu; mJ vd;W Nfl;l gpwNf tpsq;fpAs;shu;fs; vd;W ,e;j `jP]; $WfpwJ. ',Us;
xspahFk;> me;j xspapy; ghu;g;ghu;fs;' vd;gJ ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jp vd;gJ cWjpahfpdw
; J.

57. egp(]y;) mtu;fs; VO Jzpfshy; fgdplg;gl;lhu;fsh?

''egp(]y;) mtu;fSf;F VO Jzpfshy; fgdplg;gl;lJ.''


,r;nra;jpapy; myP(uyp) mtu;fshy; mwptpf;fg;gl;L m`;kj;> ,g;D mgP i\gh> ,g;D mjP> g];]hu; Mfpa
E}w;fspy; cs;sJ.
,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; %d;whtJ mwptpg;ghsuhf mg;Jy;yh ,g;D K`k;kJ ,g;D mfPy; vd;gtu;
,lk; ngWfpwhu;. ,td; `jP];fs; Gwf;fzpf;fg;gl Ntz;Lk; vd ,khk; m`;kj; ,g;D `k;gy; (u`;)
$Wfpwhu;fs;. ,td; `jP];fis Mjhukhff; nfhs;sf;$lhJ vd;W ,g;DKaPd; $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ehd;F
egu;fspd; `jP];fs; iftplg;gl Ntz;bait. ,e;j ehd;fpy; ,tUk; xUtu; jhd; vd ,g;D ciadh
$Wfpwhu;fs;.
`jP];fis mwptpg;gjpy; ,g;D mfPy; cq;fSf;F tpUg;gkhdtuh? M]pk; ,g;D cigJy;yh`;th? vd;W
,g;D KaPd; mtu;fsplk; ehd; Nfl;Nld;. ,UtiuAk; ehd; tpUk;Gtjpy;iy vd;W gjpy; $wpdhu;fs; vd
,khk; K];ypk; $Wfpd;whu;fs;.
'',tu;> mwptpg;ghsu; thpirfis Kuz;gl;Lf; $Wthu;'' vd mg+]u;M $Wfpwhu;fs;. ',tuhy;
mwptpf;fg;gLgtw;wpy; ngUk;ghyhdit E}jdkhf ,Uf;Fk;' vd [Pu;[hdp $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ',tu;
epidthw;wy; ,y;yhjtu;' vd fjPg; $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ',tu; gytPdu;' vd mg+`hjk;> ,khk; e]aP
$Wfpd;whu;fs;.
,g;gb ,jd; %d;whk; mwptpg;ghsu; `jP]; Jiwapduhy; fLikahf tpku;rpf;fg;gLtjhy; ,J
gytPdkhtNjhL> Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]{f;Fk; Kuz;gLfpwJ.
egp(]y;) mtu;fs; vkd; ehl;ilr; Nru;e;j kpUJthd %d;W Jzpfshy; fgdplg;gl;lhu;fs;. mjpy;
rl;ilNah> jiyg;ghifNah ,y;iy vd Map\h(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;> e]aP
vdNt VO Jzpfshy; fgdplg;gl;ljhf tUk; nra;jp rhpahdjy;y.

58. ]`u; Neuk; vJtiu?

''egp(]y;) mtu;fSld; ve;j Neuj;jpy; ]`u; nra;tPu;fs; vd `{ijgh(uyp) mtu;fsplk; Nfl;Nlhk;.


#hpad; cjpg;gjw;F Kd; fhiy Ntisapy; vd;W gjpy; $wpdhu;fs;.''

48 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

]u;,g;D i[]; mtu;fs; mwptpf;Fk; ,r;nra;jp e]aP E}ypy; ,lk;ngWfpwJ.


,jd; ,uz;lhtJ mwptpg;ghsuhf ,lk;ngWk; M]pk; ,g;D g`;jyh vd;gtu; gw;wp ,g;D ]`;J mtu;fs;
$Wk;NghJ ',tu; ey;ytu; jhd;. MdhYk; `jP]py; mjpfk; jtW nra;gtu;' vd;W Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.
a`;$g; ,g;D Rg;ahd; mtu;fNsh ,td; `jP];fs; FsWgb cs;sit vd;W $Wfpwhu;fs;. ',tu; Qhgf
rf;jpapy; Nkhrkhdtu;' vd mg+]u;M $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ,td; `jP];fspy; Gwf;fzpf;fg;gl Ntz;bait
cs;sd vd ,g;D fuh]; $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ',tu; jd; tho;ehspd; ,Wjpapy; %is Fok;gpatu;' vd
`k;khj; ,g;D ]ykh $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ,td; kdd rf;jp FiwthdJ vd jhuFj;dP $Wfpd;whu;fs;.
,tu; gw;wp tpku;rdk; rhpapy;yhjjhYk;> Mjhug; g+u;tkhd Fu;Md; trdj;jpw;Fk; egpnkhopf;Fk; khw;wkhf
cs;sjhYk; ,r;nra;jp gytPdg;gl;L tpLfpwJ.
g[;hpy; nts;isf; fapW fUg;Gf; fapiw tpl;Lk; (,uit tpl;Lk; mjpfhiy fpof;fpd; nts;is) cq;fSf;F
njspthFk; tiu cz;Zq;fs;. gUFq;fs;. (my;Fu;Md; 2:187)
ehq;fs; egp(]y;) mtu;fSld; ]`u; nra;Nthk;. gpwF (g[;u;) njhOiff;Fr; nry;Nthk; vd i]j;
,g;D ]hgpj; (uyp) $wpdhu;fs;. ,uz;Lf;Fk; kj;jpapy; vt;tsT NeukpUf;Fk;? vdf; Nfl;Nld;. ehd;
Ik;gJ trdq;fs; (XJk; msT) vd;W gjpy; $wpdhu;fs;. ,ij md];(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;:
GfhuP> jpu;kpjP
]`u; vd;gJ g[;Uj; njhOiff;Fk; Kd;G vd;wpUf;Fk;NghJ g[;Uf;Fg; gpd; vd;W $WtJ ngha; vd
tpsq;fyhk;.

59. nts;is epwr; Nrtiy cz;zhjPu;?

''nts;isr; NrtYf;F ePq;fs; fz;zpak; mspAq;fs;. Vnddpy; mJ vdf;Fj; NjhodhFk;. my;yh`;tpd;


giftDf;Fk; (i\j;jhDf;Fk;) giftdhFk;. nts;isr; Nrty; ,Uf;Fk; ve;j tPl;ilAk; i\j;jhNdh
#dpak; nra;gtNdh neUq;fkhl;lhu;fs;.''
,J egp(]y;) mtu;fshy; $wg;gl;L> md];(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fg;gl;L 'ig]y;' vDk; jdJ E}ypy;
`h]pkP gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.
,jd; ehd;fhtJ mwptpg;ghsu; Kmy;yy; ,g;D Gify; mtu;fSk;> Ie;jhtJ mwptpg;ghsu; \{/g;ghk;
vd;gtUk; ahnud;Nw mwpag;glhjtu;fs; %d;whtJ mwptpg;ghsu; K`k;kJ ,g;D K`;]pd; vd;gtd;
je;ij ngau; ,];`hf; vd;gjhFk;. ,td; jhj;jh ngau; jhd; K`;]pd;. ,Ug;gpDk; jhj;jh(ghl;ldhu;)
ngaNyNa ,izj;J miof;fg;gLfpwhu;. ,e;j K`k;kJ ,g;D K`;]pd; vd;gtu; ,l;Lf;fl;Lgtu; vd
jhuFj;dP $Wfpwhu;fs;. ',e;j egu; ngha;au;' vd i`]kP $Wfpd;whu;fs;.
,e;j ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jp %yk;> nts;isr; Nrtiy mWj;J cz;zf; $lhJ vd;gJ Nghy; Ghpa
KbfpwJ. ,J ,l;Lf;fl;lf; $ba eguhy; Gide;j nra;jp vd;gjhy;> ,ij eilKiwg;gLj;j
Ntz;bajpy;iy. Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]{f;Fk; ,J Kuz;gl;Lk; cs;sJ.
kpUfq;fspy; tp\g;gw;fs; cs;sij cz;zTk;> gwitapy; $a efk; cs;sij cz;zTk; egp(]y;)
mtu;fs; jil nra;jhu;fs; vd ,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) mwptpf;fpwhu;fs;. E}y;: K];ypk;
Nrty; vd;gJ Nfhop ,dkhFk;. Nfhop gwit ,dk; vd;gjhy; $a efk; ,Ue;jhy; kl;LNk
rhg;gplf;$lhJ. $a efk; ,Ue;J jd; fhyhy; kpjpj;J cz;Zk; gof;fk; cs;sjy;y Nfhop. vdNt
NfhopiaAk; mjd; Mz; ,dkhd NrtiyAk; cz;zj; jilapy;iy. Nfhopia egp(]y;) mtu;fs;
rhg;gpl;Ls;sjhf `jP]; $WfpwJ.
''ehd; mg+%]h(uyp) mtu;fsplk; te;Njd;. mtu; Nfhop rhg;gpl;Lf; nfhz;bUe;jhu;. mg;NghJ> mtu; 'ePAk;
,ij rhg;gpL!' egp(]y;) mtu;fs; Nfhopiar; rhg;gpLtij ehd; ghu;j;Js;Nsd;'' vd;W $wpdhu;fs; vd
]`;jkpy; [u;kpa;aP vd;gtu; $Wfpwhu;fs;. E}y;: jpu;kpjP
Nfhop tif cz;zyhk; vd;gjpypUe;Jk;> nts;isr; Nrtiy kl;Lk; cz;zf;$lhJ vd;w tpjptpyf;F
Mjhug;g+u;t khd `jP];fspy; ,y;iy vd;gjhYk; Nkw;fz;l nra;jp ngha; vd tpsq;fyhk;.

49 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

60. ghtpfSld; Nru;e;Jz;zy;!?

''ghtq;fs; kd;dpf;fg;gl;l xUtDld; Nru;e;J (mku;e;J) xUtd; rhg;gpl;lhy; mtDk;


kd;dpf;fg;gLthd;.''
,r;nra;jpia mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapd;wp rpy E}w;fspy; gjpthfpAs;sJ. ,ij cWjpg;gLj;j gpd;tUk;
Jizr; nra;jpAk; cs;sJ.
xU ey;ybahu; egp(]y;) mtu;fisj; jd; fdtpy; fz;lhu;. '',iwj;J}ju; mtu;fNs! (Nkw;fz;lthW)
ePq;fs; $wpdPu;fsh?'' vd;W Nfl;lhu;. ehd; ,g;gbf; $wNt ,y;iy. MdhYk; ,g;NghJ ,ijf;
$WfpNwd; vd;W gjpy; $wpdhu;fs;.
eh]pUj;jPd; my;ghdP mtu;fs; jd;> 'my;m`hjP]{y; saP/gh> ty;kt;@M' vDk; E}ypy; 315tJ `jP]hf
gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;. ,r;nra;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ vd ,g;D `[u;> ,g;Dy; fa;apk; MfpNahu;
Fwpg;gpLfpd;whu;fs;.
mjhtJ ,r;nra;jpapd; fUj;J Fw;wthspfSld; ghtpfSld; Nru;e;J cz;gJ $lhJ vd;gJ jhd;.
,J rhj;jpakhFkh?
,iw kWg;ghsu;fSf;F cjhuzkhf E}`pd; kidtpiaAk;> Y}j;jpd; kidtpiaAk; my;yh`;
Vw;gLj;jpAs;shd;. ,e;j ,UtUk; ek; ey;y mbahu;fspy; ,U ey;ybahu;fspd; kidtpauhf ,Ue;jdu;.
MdhYk; ,e;j ,UtUk; jq;fspd; fztUf;F Nkhrk; nra;jdu;. (my;Fu;Md; 66:10)
egpkhu;fspd; kidtpau; ,iwkWg;ghsu;fshf-ghtpfshf-Fw;wk; nra;gtu;fshf ,Ue;Js;sdu;. ,tu;fSld;
,Ue;jNghJ egpkhu;fs; mtu;fSld; Nru;e;Jz;Zk; epiy Vw;gl;bUf;Fk;. Fw;wkw;wtu;fSld; Nru;e;Jz;z
Ntz;Lk; vd;wpUf;Fkhdhy; ,tu;fSf;Fk; mJ nghUe;Jk; jhNd!
Ke;ija egpkhu;fSf;F ,J flikapy;yhky; ,Ue;jp Uf;fyhk;. ekf;F ,J flikahf ,Uf;fyhNk
vd;w Nfs;tp voyhk;. ,jw;F gpd;tUk; trdk; gjpyhf mikfpwJ.
ePu; mwpahj xd;iw vdf;F ,iz itf;f cd;id (cd; ngw;Nwhu;) epu;g;ge;jk; nra;jhy;> me;j
,UtUf;Fk; fl;Lg; glhNj! (Mdhy; kw;w fhhpaq;fspy;) mtu;fSld; ,t;Tyfpy; ey;ytpjkhf ,U!
(my;Fu;Md; 31:15)
ngw;Nwhu; ,iz itg;Nghuhf> ,iz itf;fj; J}z;LNthuhf - Fw;wk; nra;gtu;fshf ,Ue;jhy; mjpy;
kl;Lk; mtu;fSf;F fl;Lg;glhNj! ,ju fhhpaq;fspy; (cz;gJ cl;gl) ,ize;J ,zf;fkhf tho; vd
,t;trdk; $WfpwJ.
'Fw;wthspfshf cs;s ngw;NwhUf;F cztspj;jhYk;> Nru;j;Jz;zhNj' vd;W $wpapUf;f Ntz;Lk;.
Fw;wthspapd; Fw;wj;jpy; gq;Nfw;ff;$lhJ vd;gJ jhd; flikNa jtpu> Fw;wthspAld; gofNt $lhJ
vd;W ,];yhk; $wNt ,y;iy.
NkYk; xUtid Fw;wthsp vd;Nwh> Fw;wkw;wtd; vd;Nwh ehk; Ghpe;J nfhs;s KbahJ. ,d;W Fw;wk;
nra;gtd; ehis ey;ytdhf Mfyhk;. ey;ytd;> Fw;wthspahf khwyhk;. ek; fz; Kd; Fw;wthsp Nghy;
njhpe;jtd; my;yh`;tplk; cau;e;jtdhf Mfptplyhk;. Fw;wthsp> Fw;wkw;wtd; vd;gij mwpe;jtd;
my;yh`; kl;Lk; jhd;. ,ijAk; $l xUtd; epiy gw;wp kWikapy; jhd; ehk; njhpe;J nfhs;s KbAk;.
vdNt ghtq;fs; nra;ahjtd; vd vtiuf; $w KbAk;? ,jpypUe;Jk; $l ,r;nra;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ
vd;gJ GhpAk;. ,r;nra;jpia fdtpy; cWjpg;gLj;jpa ey;ybahu; ahu;? tpguk; ,y;iy. egp(]y;) mtu;fis
Nehpy; fz;ltu; kl;LNk fdtpYk; fhzKbAk; vd;gJ rl;lk;. egp(]y;) mtu;fis fdtpy; xU ey;ybahu;
fz;ljhf $WtJk; ngha;!
epiwT nra;ag;gl;l ,];yhj;jpy; FiwT ,Ue;jJ NghyTk;> ,e;jf; Fiwia gpd;du; egp(]y;) mtu;fs;
rhp nra;jJ NghyTk; ,e;jf; fdtpd; fUj;J mikfpwJ. ,J egp(]y;) mtu;fis
FiwTgLj;JtjhfNt mikfpwJ. vdNt ,e;j nra;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ vd;gjpy; re;Njfkpy;iy.

50 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

61. ukshdpy; Vw;gLk; fLk; rg;jk;?

''ukshd; khjj;jpy; (fLikahd) rg;jk; Vw;gLk; vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs;. ',iwj;J}ju;
mtu;fNs! mJ Vw;gLtJ> ukyhdpd; Muk;gj;jpyh? eLtpyh? filrpapyh?' vd;W egpj;Njhou;fs;
Nfl;lhu;fs;. '(mJ) ukyhd; khjj;jpy; eLg;gFjpapy; elf;Fk;. nts;spf;fpoik ,uT ukyhdpd; ghjp
,uthf ,Uf;Fk;NghJ> thdj;jpypUe;J (fLk;) rg;jk; Vw;gLk;. ,jd; %yk; 70>000 Ngu;
%u;r;irahfptpLthu;fs;. 70 Mapuk; Ngu; g+kpf;Fs; nrhUfg;gLthu;fs;. 70 Mapuk; Ngu; FUluhthu;fs;. 70
Mapuk; Ngu; nrtpluhthu;fs;' vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpaJk;> ',iwj;J}ju; mtu;fNs! cq;fspd;
rKjhaj;jpy; cs;stu;fs; ghJfhg;G ngWNthu; mJ rkak; vg;gb ele;J nfhs;tu;?' vd;W kf;fs;
Nfl;lhu;fs;. 'mJ rkak; jd; tPl;bypUe;J nfhz;L ][;jh nra;J ghJfhg;Gj; Njb> my;yh`{ mf;gu;
vd rg;jkpl;Lf; $Wk; egu; jhd; ghJfhg;Gg; ngWthu;'' vd;W egp(]y;) $wpdhu;fs;. gpwF kw;nwhU rg;jk;
Vw;gLk;. mJ i\j;jhdpd; mywy; MFk; vd;Wk; $wpdhu;fs;.
ig&]; mj;ijyk; vd;gtuhy; mwptpf;fg;gLk; ,r;nra;jp ,g;Dy; [t;]P mtu;fspd; 'kt;@Mj;' E}ypy;
cs;sJ.
,r;nra;jpia mwptpf;Fk; ig&]; mj;ijyk; vd;gtu; egp(]y;) mtu;fis ghu;j;jjpy;iy. Mdhy; mtu;
egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf mwptpf;fpwhu;. ,JNghy; ,uz;lhtJ mwptpg;ghsuhf ,lk;ngWk; cigjh
,g;D mg+ Yghgh vd;gtu;> ,e;j ig&]; mj;ijykPiag; ghu;j;jjpy;iy.
ehd;fhtJ mwptpg;ghsu; ,];khaPy; ,g;D mah]; mtu;fSk;> Ie;jhtJ mwptpg;ghsu; mg;Jy; t`;`hg;
,g;D o`;`hf; vd;gtUk; gytPdu;fshtu;. 'mg;Jy; t`hg; vd;gtu; ,];khaPy; vd;gthplkpUe;J
GJikahd nra;jpfis mwptpg;gtuhthu;' vd mg+m`;kj; $Wfpd;whu;fs;.
mwptpg;ghsu;fspd; thpirapy; ngUk; gytPdk; ,Ug;g NjhL> ,e;j `jP]; ,Jtiu ele;Jtpl;ljw;F
MjhukhfTk; ,y;iy. egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpapUg;gJ cz;ikahdhy; 1450 Mz;Lfs; fle;Jtpl;lJ. 15k;
ehs; ,uT nts;spf;fpoik vdTk; te;Js;sJ. Mdhy; ',g;gb xU g+fk;gk;-,b Kof;fk;-ngU rg;jk;
Vw;gl;L 70>000 Ngu; ,we;Jk; 70>000 Ngu; g+kpf;Fs; cs;spOf;fg;gl;Lk;> 70>000 Ngu; FUlhfpAk; 70>000 Ngu;
nrtplhfpAk; Nghapdu;' vd;w ve;jf; Fwpg;Gk; ,y;iy. ,Jkhjpahd rk;gtk; ele;jpUf;Fkhdhy; tuyhw;Wf;
Fwpg;G fshf gjpT nra;ag;gl;bUf;Fk;. 'xU Ntis ,dp elf;fyhk; jhNd. ,Jtiu elf;ftpy;iy
vd;gjhy; elf;fNt elf;fhJ vd;whfptplhJ jhNd' vd;w Nfs;tp vof;$Lk;. Mdhy; ukyhd; khjk;
mUs; epiwe;j khjk; vd Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]; $Wfpd;wJ.
'ukshd; (khjk;) te;jhy; nrhu;f;fj;jpd; thry;fs; jpwf;fg; gLfpd;wd. eufthry;fs; milf;fg;gLfpd;wd.
i\j;jhd;fs; tpyq;fplg;gLfpd;wdu;' vd;W egp(]y;) $wpdhu;fs;. ,ij mg+`{iuuh(uyp)
mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;
ukshd; khjk; mUs; epiwe;j khjk; vd ,d;Dk; gy `jP];fs; mwptpf;fpd;wd. Mdhy; 'mJ Mgj;jhd
khjk;. mJ vg;NghJ elf;Fk;? ,g;NghJ ele;JtpLNkh' vd;W vjpu;ghu;g;ig Vw;gLj;jp ftiyailar;
nra;Ak; khjk; vd;gJ Nghy; Nkw;fz;l nra;jp $WfpwJ.
,e;j fhuzj;jpw;fhfTk;> mwptpg;ghsu; thpir gytPdkhf cs;sjhYk; ,r;nra;jpAk; gytPdkhd nra;jpahf
cs;sJ.

62. ukshd; vd;W $wf;$lhjh?

''ukshd; vd;W $whjPuf


; s;. ukyhd; vd;gJ my;yh`;tpd; ngau;fspy; xd;whFk;. vdNt ePq;fs; \`;U
ukyhd; (ukyhd; khjk;) vd;W $Wq;fs;.''
egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs; vd mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mtu;fshy; mwptpf;fg;gl;L ,r;nra;jp ,g;D mjP>
,g;Dy; [t;]P MfpNahd; E}w;fspy; gjpT nra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ.
,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; %d;whk; eguhf ,lk;ngWk; mg+kp`;\u; vd;gtu; `jP];fis mwptpg;gjpy;
cWjpahdtu; my;y vd ,g;D KaPd; $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,g;Dy; [t;]P> j`gP> Råj;jp> \t;fhdP Nghd;Nwhu;

51 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

,tiu ,l;Lf;fl;Lk; egu;fspd; gl;baypy; Nru;f;fpwhu;fs;.


,e;j mg+ kp`;\u; rhpapy;yhj eguhf cs;sjhy; ,e;j `jP]; gytPdkhdjhFk;. NkYk; my;yh`;tpd;
ngau;fspy; xd;whf ukyhd; vd;gJk; xd;W vd Fu;MdpNyh> Mjhug;g+u;tkhd egpnkhopapNyh ,y;iy.
NkYk; ,J Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fSf;Fk; KuzhfTk; cs;sJ.
''ukshd; te;jhy; Rtdj;jpd; thapy;fs; jpwf;fg;gLfpd;wd. eufj;jpd; thapy;fs; %lg;gLfpd;wd.
i\j;jhd;fSf;F tpyq;fplg;gLfpd;wd'' vd egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs; vd mg+`{iuuh(uyp)
mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: GfhuP
''xUtu; ukshd; Nehd;G Nehw;W gpd;G \t;thypy; MW Nehd;ig Nehw;why; mtu; tUlk; KOJk; Nehd;G
Nehw;wtu; Nghyhthu;'' vd;W egp(]y;) $wpdhu;fs; vd mg+ ma;åg; (uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;.
E}y;: K];ypk;
egp(]y;) mtu;fs; ,q;F ukshd; khjk; vd;W $whky; ukyhd; vd;W $wpAs;sjhy; ukshd; vd;W
$wyhk; vd;W mwpaKbfpwJ. vdNt Nkw;fz;l nra;jp ngha;ahdJ vd;gJ cWjpahfpwJ.

63. Fspg;Gf; flikahdtd; fly; ePhpy; Fspf;fyhkh?

Fspg;Gf; flikf;F fly;ePu; gad;glhJ. mjpypUe;J c@r; nra;aTk; $lhJ. Vnddpy; flYf;Ff; fPo;
neUg;Gs;sJ. mjd; fPNo ,d;ndhU fly; cz;L. ,g;gb VO fly;> xU neUg;G cz;L.
,r;nra;jp mg;Jy;yh ,g;D mk;&(uyp) mwptpg;gjhf K];dj; mg;Ju;u]hf;> ig`fP> ijykP Mfpa E}w;fspy;
gjpthfpAs;sJ.
,r;nra;jpapd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; K`k;kJ ,g;D K`h[pu; vd;gtu; ,lk;ngWfpwhu;. ,tu;
,l;Lf;fl;Lk; egu; vd ,khk; j`gP> ,khk; \t;fhdP> ,khk; Råj;jp MfpNahu; Fwpg;gpLfpd;whu;fs;.
vdNt ,e;j nra;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jpahFk;. NkYk; gpd;tUk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd nra;jpf;Fk; Kuzhf
cs;sJ.
xU kdpju; egp(]y;) mtu;fsplk;> ,iwj;J}ju; mtu;fNs! ehq;fs; flypy; gazk; nra;fpNwhk;. mg;NghJ
Fiwe;j jz;zPiuNa nfhz;L nry;fpNwhk;. mjd; %yk; x@r; nra;jhy; (Fb jz;zPu; fhypahfp)
ehq;fs; jhfj;Jld; ,Uf;f Ntz;baJ tUk;. vdNt ehq;fs; fly; ePhpy; c@r; nra;J nfhs;syhkh?
vd;W Nfl;lhu;. mjw;F egp(]y;) mtu;fs;> fly; ePu; J}a;ikg;gLj;jf; $bajhFk;. mjpy; trpg;git
nrj;jpUe;jhYk; cz;z mDkjpf;fg;gl;ljhFk; vd;W $wpdhu;fs;. ,ij mg+`{iuuh(uyp)
mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: e]aP> mg+jh¥j;> jpu;kpjP> ,g;Dkh[h
fly;ePhpy; x@r; nra;ayhk;> Fspg;Gf; flikahdtu; Fspf;fyhk; vd;gijNa ,e;j `jP]; $WfpwJ.
vdNt Nkw;fz;l nra;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lit vd;gjpy; re;NjfNk ,y;iy.

64. Fspg;Gf; flikahdtd; Fspayiwapy; Fspf;fyhkh?

''Fspg;Gf; flikf;fhf Fspf;f> ,uz;L tif jz;zPu; gad;glhJ. mit fly; ePUk;> Fspayiw ePUk;
MFk; ''
egp(]y;) $wpajhf mg+`{iuuh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;.
,e;j nra;jp ,g;D mgPi\ghtpy; ,lk; ngw;Ws;sJ. ,e;j nra;jpapd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; K`k;kJ
,g;D K`h[pu; vd;gtu; ,lk; ngWfpwhu;. ,tu; `jP];fis ,l;Lf;fl;Lk; eguhthu;. ,jdhy; jhd; ,khk;
,g;Dy; [t;](P u`;) mtu;fs; jdJ 'kt;@Mj;' (,l;Lf;fl;lg; gl;lit) E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.
NkYk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd nra;jpfSf;Fk; ,J Kuz;gLk; tifapy; mike;Js;sJ vd;gjhYk; ,J
,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jpahFk;.
ck;K `gPgh (uyp) mtu;fs; jk; rNfhj i[dg; gpd;j; [`;\;(uyp) mtu;fSf;Fhpa jz;zPu; njhl;bapy;

52 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

mku;e;J Fspg;ghu;fs;. ,uj;jj;jpd; rptg;G epwk; jz;zPd; Nky; glUk; vd;W Map\h(uyp) mtu;fs;
mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: ,g;Dkh[h
jz;zPu; njhl;b vd;gJ tPl;bd; jdp miwapDs; jhd; ,Ue;jpUf;f Ntz;Lk; vd;gij mwpayhk;.
',iwj;J}ju; mtu;fNs! xUtu; jdpikapy; epu;thzkhf Fspf;fyhkh?' vd;W ehd; Nfl;Nld;. mjw;F
egp(]y;) mtu;fs;> 'kdpju;fsplk; ntl;fj;Jld; ele;J nfhs;tij tpl my;yh`;tplk; ntl;f
czu;Tld; ele;J nfhs;s my;yh`; jFjpkpf;ftd; Mthd;' vd;W $wpdhu;fs;. ,ij g`;]; ,g;D
`fPk; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: jpu;kpjP> mg+jh¥j;
kdpju;fsplk; ntl;fg;gl;L jdp miwapy; Fspf;f Mirg;gLtJ Nghy; mg;gb jdpNa Fspf;Fk; NghJk;
epu;thzkhf Fspf;ff;$lhJ vd;gjpYk; ftdk; ,Uf;f Ntz;Lk; vd egp(]y;) mtu;fs Nghjpf;fpwhu;fs;.
Nfl;gtUk; $l jdpikapy; Fspf;Fk; NghJ epu;thzkhf Fspf;fyhkh? vd;Nw Nfl;fpwhu;. jdpik vd;gJ
jdp miw vd;gijNa Ghpa KbfpwJ. vdNt jdpNa mike;Js;s Fspayiwapy; Fspf;fyhk; vd;w
Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fSf;F Kuzhf Nkw;fz;l nra;jp mike;Js;sij mwpf!

65. m]u; njhOifia jhkjpf;fj;jhd; Ntz;Lkh?

''m]u; njhOiff;F> ghq;F $Wk; egu; ghq;F $wpdhu;. ,khkj; nra;a mtrug;gl;lhu;. mg;NghJ
mq;fpUe;j mg;Jy;yh`; ,g;D uhgpc mtu;fs;> 'cdf;F ehrk; cz;lhfl;Lk;! m]u; njhOifiag;
gpw;gLj;Jq;fs;' vd egpj;Njhou;fSf;F egp(]y;) mtu;fs; fl;lisapl;lhu;fs; vd vd; je;ij $wpdhu;
vd;W $wpdhu;.''
mg;Jy; th`pj; vd;gtu; mwptpf;Fk; ,r;nra;jp jhuFj;dP> jhFy; fgPu;> ]fPu; (GfhuP)> k[;&`Pd;>
jj;fpuJy; kt;@Mj; Mfpa E}w;fspy; cs;sJ.
,jd; ,uz;lhtJ mwptpg;ghsu; mg;Jy; th`pj; ngha;au; vdf; $Wk; `jP]; Jiw mwpQu;fs; ,tuJ
`jP];fis epuhfj;Js;sdu;.
NkYk; ,tu; mg;Jy;yh`; ,g;D uhgpc mtu;fisg; ghu;j;jNj ,y;iy. vdNt mthplkpUe;J
,r;nra;jpiaf; Nfl;Fk; tha;g;gpy;iy vd ,khk; jhuFj;dP mtu;fs; $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ',tu; rpahthrpfs;
topahf ,l;Lf;fl;lg; gl;l nra;jpfis mwptpg;gtu;' vd ,khk; ,g;D `pg;ghd; $Wfpd;whu;fs;.
Mjhug;g+u;tkhd gpd;tUk; `jP];fs; $Wk; nra;jpf;Fk; ,J Kuzhf cs;sJ.
''ehq;fs; egp(]y;) mtu;fSld; m]u; njhONthk;. gpd;G xl;lfj;ij mWg;Nghk;. mijg; gj;J gq;F
itg;Nghk;. gpwF mij rikg;Nghk;. #hpad; kiwAk; Kd; rikj;j ,iwr;rpia cz;Nghk;'' vd ugPc
,g;D fjP[; (uyp) $Wfpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;
''egp(]y;) mtu;fs; m]u; njhOthu;fs;. #hpad; (ntspr;rk;) vdJ miwf;Fs;Ns ,Uf;Fk;'' vd
Map\h(uyp) mwptpff; pdw
; hu;fs;. E}y;: K];ypk;
''egp(]y;) mtu;fs; m]u; njhOifia njhOthu;fs;. mg;NghJ #hpad; cau;e;J gpufhrkhf ,Uf;Fk;.
mthyp tiu xUtu; nry;thu;. mg;NghJk; #hpad; cau;e;Nj ,Uf;Fk;. mthyp vd;gJ kjPdhtpypUe;J
ehd;F iky; mstpy; ,Uf;Fk;'' vd md];(uyp) $Wfpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;
ehq;fs; (njhOif Kbe;J) jpUk;gpa NghJ> md];(uyp) mtu;fs;> '',J (Neuk; gpw;gLj;jpj; njhOtJ)
Kdhgpf;Ffspd; njhOifahFk;. #hpad; i\j;jhdpd; ,uz;L nfhk;Gf;Fk; kj;jpapy; tUk; tiu (mjhtJ
kiwAk; tiu) vjpu;ghu;j;J mku;e;jpUg;ghd;. gpwF vOe;J ehd;F trdq;fis kl;Lk; Xjp (Kbg;ghd;)
my;yh`;it Fiwe;j mstpNyNa epidT $u;thd;'' vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhfTk; $wpdhu;fs;.
,ij ,];khaPy; vd;ghu; $Wfpd;whu;. E}y;: K];ypk;
m]u; njhOifia Kw;gLj;jpNa njho Ntz;Lk;. fhy jhkjk; nra;af;$lhJ vd rhpahd `jP];fs;
$Wfpd;wd. ,e;j tifapYk; m]u; njhOifia jhkjpf;f Ntz;Lk; vdf; $Wk; nra;jp>
,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ vd;gijg; Ghpayhk;.

53 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

66. uf;mj;fspy; Xjhky;> U$c> ][;jh Kiwahf ,Ue;jhy; kl;Lk; NghJkh?

''cku;(uyp) mtu;fs;> kf;fSf;F k`;G njho itj;jhu;fs;. mg;NghJ mtu;fs; 'XjNt ,y;iy.
(njhOJ Kbj;jJk;) ePq;fs; XjNt ,y;iyNa' vd;W Nfl;fg;gl;lJ. U$c> ][;jh vg;gb ,Ue;jJ?
vd;W cku;(uyp) Nfl;lhu;fs;. ed;whf ,Ue;jJ vd kf;fs; $wpaJk;> mg;gbahdhy; Fw;wkpy;iy'' vd
gjpy; $wpdhu;fs;.
mg+ ]ykh ,g;D mg;Ju;u`;khd; (u`;) mwptpf;Fk; ,r;nra;jp ',yy;> jy;fPRy; mghj;jPy;' Mfpa E}w;fspy;
cs;sJ.
,jpy; MwhtJ mwptpg;ghsuhf ,lk; ngWk; K`k;kJ ,g;D K`h[pu; vd;gtu; `jP];fis ,l;Lf; fl;Lk;
egu; vd ,khk; j`gP $Wfpd;whu;fs;.
''ghj;jp`h #uh XjhjtDf;F njhOif $lhJ'' vd egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf cghjh ,g;D
]hkpj; (uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;> e]aP> mg+jh¥j;> jpu;kpjP> ,g;Dkh[h
Mjhug;g+u;tkhd ,e;j `jPN]h> ghj;jp`h #uhitNaDk; Xjpahf Ntz;Lk; vd;fpwJ. Mdhy; Nkw;fz;l
nra;jpNah Xjhky; ,Ue;jhYk; guthapy;iy vd;fpwJ.
Mjhug;g+u;tkhd nra;jpf;Fk; Kuz;gl;Lk;> mwptpg;ghsu; ,l;Lf; fl;Lk; eguhfTk; cs;sjhy; ,ij
,l;Lf;fl;lg; gl;lit vd;gijg; Ghpayhk;.

67. fhJfs; tiu ifia cau;j;JtJ gpj;mj;jh?

''ePq;fs; cq;fspd; iffis njhOifapy; ,g;gb cau;j;JfpwPu;fsh? vd ,g;D cku;(uyp) Nfl;lhu;fs;.


(,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk;ngWk;) `k;khj; vd;gtu; jd; iffis fhJfs; tiu cau;j;jpf;
fhl;bdhu;. my;yh`;tpd; kPjhizahf ,J gpj;mj;jhFk;. egp(]y;) mtu;fs; ,ij tpl mjpfkhf xU
NghJk; cau;j;jpajpy;iy'' vd;W ,g;Dcku;(uyp) $wpdhu;fs;. me;j msit `k;khj; jdJ khu;G tiu
Rl;bf;fhl;bdhhu;.
gp\;u; ,g;D `u;G $wpajhf ,r;nra;jp ',yy;'> 'Kf;j]u; ,yy;' Mfpa E}w;fspy; cs;sJ.
,jd; Kjy; mwptpg;ghsuhf ,lk;ngWk; K\;u; ,g;D `u;G vd;gtu; gytPdu; vd ,khk; ,g;D KaPd;>
mg+`hjk;> mg+]u;M MfpNahu; $Wfpd;wdu;. ,tu; gykhdtu; my;y vd;W ,khk; m`;kj; $Wfpd;whu;fs;.
vdNt ,J gytPdkhd nra;jpahFk;.
Nkw;fz;l nra;jp njhOifapy; jf;gPu; $Wk;NghJ> iffis khu;G tiu jhd; cau;j;j Ntz;Lk; vd;Wk;>
fhJfs; tiu cau;j;JtJ gpj;mj; vd;Wk; $WfpwJ. Mdhy; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd gpd;tUk; `jPN]h
fhJfs; tiu cau;j;jyhk; vd;W $WfpwJ.
''egp(]y;) mtu;fs; jf;gPu; $wpaNghJ jdJ iffis fhJfs; tiu cau;j;Jthu;fs;'' vd khypf;
,g;Dy; `{it];(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;
vdNt Nkw;fz;l nra;jp gytPdkhdjhFk;.

68. Y`u;> m]hpy; Xj Ntz;lhkh?

''Y`u;> m]u; njhOifapy; XjNtz;bajpy;iy. (Vnddpy;) egp(]y;) mtu;fs; Xjpdhy; jhd; ehKk;
XjNtz;Lk;. mtu;fs; nksdkhf ,Ue;jhy; ehKk; kTdkhfNt ,Uf;f Ntz;Lk;.''
''Y`u; njhOifapy; Xj Ntz;bajpy;iy. Xj Ntz;Lk; vd;wpUe;jhy; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; (Xjp) ekf;F
Nfl;fr; nra;jpUg;ghu;fs;.''
,e;j ,uz;L nra;jpfisAk; ,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) mwptpg;gjhf ,khk; ,g;Dy; [t;]P(u`;) mtu;fs; jdJ
,yy; E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;.
,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; K`k;kj; ,g;D K`h[Pu; vd;gtu; ,lk; ngWfpwhu;. ,tu; ,l;Lf;fl;Lgtu;

54 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

vd ,khk; j`gP $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,Nj fUj;ij ,g;Dy; [t;]P mtu;fSk; $Wfpwhu;fs;. vdNt ,e;j
`jP]; rhpahdjy;y. NkYk; gpd;tUk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fSf;Fk; KuzhfTk; cs;sJ.
egp(]y;) mtu;fs; Y`u;> m]u; njhOiffspy; Kjy; ,uz;L uf;mj;fspy; ck;Ky; Fu;MidAk;
(ghj;jp`h #uhitAk;) NtW ,uz;L #uhf;fisAk; XJthu;fs;. rpy rkak; trdq;fis (rg;jkpl;L
Xjp) vq;fSf;F Nfl;Fk;gb nra;thu;fs;. Y`hpd; Kjy; uf;mj;ij rpwpJ ePl;Lgtu;fshf ,Ue;jhu;fs;
vd mg+fjhjh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: GfhuP
egp(]y;) mtu;fs; Y`u;> m]u; njhOifapy; Kjy; ,uz;L uf;mj;fspy; #uh ghj;jp`hTk; NtW xU
#uhTk; XJthu;fs;. rpy rkak; trdq;fis (rw;W rg;jkhf Xjp) vq;fis Nfl;Fk;gbr; nra;thu;fs;.
gpe;jpa ,uz;L uf;mj;fspy; #uh ghj;jp`h kl;Lk; XJthu;fs; vd mg+fjhjh(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;.
E}y;: K];ypk;
Y`u;> m]hpy; #uhf;fs; Xj Ntz;Lk; vd Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP];fs; $w Nkw;fz;l nra;jpfNsh
Ntz;lhk; vdf; $WfpwJ. vdNt Nkw;fz;l nra;jpfs; Gidag;gl;lit vd;gijg; Ghpayhk;.

69. njho itg;gtu; mofhf ,Uf;f Ntz;Lkh?

''mtu;fspy; mofpa Kfk; cs;stNu (jdJ) $l;lj;jpdUf;F ,khkj; nra;a Ntz;Lk;.''


egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs; vd Map\h(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpj;jjhf ,r;nra;jp ijykP> ,g;D mjP>
,g;Dy; [t;]P MfpNahu; jq;fs; E}w;fspy; gjpT nra;Js;sdu;.
,e;jr; nra;jpapd; ehd;fhtJ mwptpg;ghsuhf ,lk; ngWk; K`k;kJ ,g;D ku;thd; gykhdtu; my;yu; vd
a`;ah $Wfpwhu;fs;. ,tu; ngha;au; vd;Wk;> ,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpir ,Us; epiwe;jJ vd;Wk; j`gP
$Wfpd;whu;fs;. NkYk; ,tiug; gw;wp Ky;yh myPfhuP> Råj;jp> ,g;Dy; [t;]P> \t;fhdP Nghd;Nwhu;
fLikahf tpku;rdk; nra;fpwhu;fs;.
NkYk; MwhtJ mwptpg;ghsuhf ,lk; ngWk; `o;ukP vd;gtu; ahnud;Nw mwpKfk;> tpguf;Fwpg;G ,y;yhjtu;
Mthu;. vdNt ,e;j nra;jp gytPdkhd nra;jpahf cs;sJ. Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]{f;Fk; KuzhfTk;
cs;sJ.
mtu;fspy; ey;y Kiwapy; XJgtNu (jdJ) $l;lj;jpw;F ,khkj; nra;al;Lk;. XJjypy; midtUk;
rkkhd epiyapy; ,Ue;jhy; mtu;fspy; `p[;uj; nra;tjpy; Ke;jpatu;fs; ,khkj; nra;al;Lk;; `p[;uj;
nra;jjpy; rkkhdtu;fshf ,Ue;jhy; egptopia mwpe;jtu; ,khkj; nra;al;Lk;. egpnkhopia mwpe;jjpy;
rkkhdtu;fshf ,Ue;jhy; mtu;fspy; tajpy; %j;jtu; ,khkj; nra;al;Lk; vd;W egp(]y;) $wpdhu;fs;
vd mg+k];¥j;(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: K];ypk;
egp(]y;) mtu;fspd; epge;jidiaf; Fwpg;gpl;L tUk; `jP]py; mofpa Kfk; cs;stu; jhd; ,khkj;
nra;ayhk; vd;w fl;lis VJk; ,y;iy vd;gjhYk;> mwptpg;ghsu; thpir rhpapy;yhjjhYk; ,J
,l;Lf;fl;b $Wgtu;fshy; cUthdJ vd;W Ghpayhk;.

70. njhO Neha;f;fhd fhuzk;?

''ehd; #hpadhy; ePiu #lhf;fp itj;jpUe;Njd;. vd;dplk; te;j egp(]y;) mtu;fs;> rpte;jtNs! eP
,t;thW nra;ahNj! Vnddpy; mJ njhO Nehia cz;lhf;Fk; vd;W $wpdhu;fs;.''
Map\h(uyp) mwptpf;Fk; ,r;nra;jpia jhuFj;dP> ,g;D mjP> mg+eaPk;> ig`fP MfpNahu; gjpT
nra;Js;shu;fs;.
,jd; ehd;fhtJ mwptpg;ghsu; fhypj; ,g;D ,];khaPy; vd;gtu; ,l;Lf;fl;lf;$batu; vd ,g;DmjP
$Wfpd;whu;fs;. ,tiug; NghyNt t`;G ,g;D t`G vd;gtUk; mwptpf;fpd;whu;. ',tNuh> fhypj; ,g;D
,];khaPiy tplTk; Nkhrkhdtu;' vd ,g;D mjP $Wfpd;whu;fs;. mJNghyNt i`]k; ,g;D mjP
vd;gtu; topahf mwptpf;fg;gLfpwJ. 'mtu; ngha;au;' vd ,khk; a`;ah ,g;D KaPd; $wpajhf jhuFj;dP

55 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

$Wfpd;whu;fs;.
NkYk; ,Nj `jP]; K`k;kJ ,g;D ku;thD];]`;jP vd;gtu; topahfTk; mwptpf;fg;gl;L jhuFj;dPapd;
mt;]j; E}ypy; cs;sJ. ,tUk; `jP]; Jiwapduhy; epuhff;fg; gl;ltu; Mthu;. Nkw;fz;l nra;jpia
,khk; khypf; (u`;) mwptpg;gjhf mg+K`k;kj; my;[{itdp vd;gtUk; ,g;D]; ]g;gh`; vd;gtUk;
$Wfpd;whu;fs;. Mdhy; ,khk; khypf; $Wtjhf $Wtij ,khk; ig`fP kWf;fpd;whu;fs;.
''#hpadhy; #lhf;fg;gl;l jz;zPhpy; x@r; nra;tijAk;> mjpy; Fspg;gijAk; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; jil
nra;jhu;fs;. ,g;gbr; nra;jhy; njhONehia cz;lhf;Fk; vd;Wk; $wpdhu;fs;.''
,ij Map\h(uyp) $wpajhf jhuFj;dPapy; cs;sJ. ,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; Ie;jhtjhf ,lk;
ngWk; mk;U ,g;D K`k;kj; vd;gtd; `jP]; kWf;fj; jf;fJ vd gjpT nra;Js;s jhuFj;dP mtu;fNs
Fwpg;gpLfpd;whu;fs;. ,tu; ,l;Lf;fl;Lk; egu; vd ,g;D `pg;ghd; $Wfpd;whu;fs;.
,Nj `jP]; mg+jh¥j;> jpu;kpjPapYk; cs;sjhf K`k;kJ ,g;D KaPd; mj;jpkp\;fP $Wfpd;whu;fs;.
Mdhy; me;j E}w;fspy; ,g;gb xU `jPN] ,y;iy.
''cku;(uyp) mtu;fs; #hpadhy; #lhf;fg;gl;lj; jz;zPiu(g; gad;gLj;Jtij) ntWj;jhu;fs;. Vnddpy;
mJ njhONehia cz;lhf;Fk; vd;W $wpdhu;fs;.''
,r;nra;jpia [hgpu;(uyp) $Wtjhf ,khk; \h/gP gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;. ,jd; %d;whtJ mwptpg;ghsu;
rjfj;J ,g;D mg;Jy;yh`; vd;gtu;> `jP]; Jiw mwpQu;fs; midtuhYk; 'gytPdu;' vd;W Fiw
$wg;gLfpwhu;. NkYk; ehd;fhtJ mwptpg;ghsu; ,g;wh`Pk; ,g;D mg+a`;ah vd;gtu; ,l;Lf;fl;Lk; egu; vd
,khk; e]aP $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ehq;fs; ,tiu Fuhgh (Kw;fhyj;jpd; ngha; $Wk; Nfhagy;];) vd;W
ngahplb; Ue;Njhk; vd ,g;wh`Pk; ,g;D ]`;j; $Wfpd;whu;fs;. NkYk; ,tu; fj;ah> K`j]papaa ; h>
uhgp]paa; h> Nghd;w nfhs;ifia Vw;wtuhthu;. ,jdhy; ,thplk; epiwa gpjm
; j;fs; ,Ue;jd vd;W m[yP
$Wfpd;whu;fs;.
''xUtu; #hpadhy; #lhf;fg;gl;l jz;zPhpy; Fspj;J mjdhy; Neha; Vw;gl;lhy; mtu; jd;idj; jtpu
ahiuAk; Fiw $wNtz;lhk;.''
,g;D mg;gh];(uyp) $wpajhf ,J cs;sJ. ,jd; Kjy; mwptpg;ghsu; o`;`hf;> ,g;D mg;gh];(uyp)
mtu;fis re;jpj;jNj ,y;iy. NkYk; %d;whtJ mwptpg;ghsu; cku; ,g;D Rg;`{ vd;gtu; ngha;au;
Mthu;.
,Nj fUj;J md];(uyp) $wpajhf cifyP mtu;fs; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;. ,jpy; ,lk;ngWk;
]ythj;Jy; $gP vd;gtu; ahnud;Nw mwpag;glhjtu; Mthu;.
NkYk; ,khk; jhuFj;dP mtu;fs; 'm/g;uhj;' vDk; E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;. mjpy; ,lk;ngWk; [fa;ah
ngha;au; vd;W `jP]; Jiwapdu; Fwpg;gpLfpd;whu;fs;. ,g;D [t;]P mtu;fs; jdJ 'kt;@Mj;' vDk;
E}ypy; gjpT nra;Js;shu;fs;. ig`fP mtu;fs; jdJ 'k`;gh' vDk; E}ypy; gjpT nra;J tpl;L> ,ij
Vw;f KbahJ vd;Wk; Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.
,j;jiyg;gpy; tUk; ve;j `jP]{k; rhpahdjhf ,y;iy. ,J kl;Lky;y. fpuhkg;Gwq;fspy; #hpadhy;
#Nlw;wg;gl;l ePu;epiyfspy; Fbf;fTk;> Fspf;fTk; nra;fpwhu;fs;. Mdhy; mtu;fs; midtUf;Fk; njhO
Neha; Vw;gl;ljhf FwpgG; vJTk; ,y;iy.
eilKiwapy; epfohj xd;iw fw;gidahf;fp $Wk; fw;gid thjpay;y egp(]y;) mtu;fs;. vdNt
Nkw;fz;l nra;jpfs; midj;Jk; ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lNj MFk;.

71. ghu;itapd; $u;ikf;F...

''mofhd ngz;fspd; Kfj;ijAk;> gRikahdijAk; ghu;g;gJ ghu;itia $u;ikahf;Fk;.''


,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf [hgpu;(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;Fk; nra;jp> mg+eapkPd; 'my;`py;ah'tpy;
,lk; ngw;Ws;sJ. ,g;D [t;]P mtu;fspd; 'kt;@Mj;' vDk; E}ypYk; cs;sJ.

56 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk; ngWk; ehd;fhtJ mwptpg;ghsu; ,g;wh`Pk; ,g;D `{igg; vd;gtu;
gytPdkhd egu;fsplkpUe;J `jP];fis mwptpg;gtu; vd jhuFj;dP $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ,e;j nra;jp
\dhjpfhitr; Nru;e;j topnfl;l egu;fshy; ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lJ vd ,g;D ifåk; $Wfpd;whu;fs;.
(egpNa!) ,iw ek;gpf;if cs;s Mz;fsplk; mtu;fs; jq;fspd; ghu;itiaj; jho;j;jpf; nfhs;s Ntz;Lk;
vd;Wk; jq;fspd; kiwTWg;igg; Ngzpf; nfhs;s Ntz;Lk; vd;Wk; ,J mtu;fSf;F gRj;jkhFk; vd;Wk;
$WtPuhf! epr;rakhf my;yh`; mtu;fs; nra;gtw;iw ed;F mwpe;jtd;. (my;Fu;Md; 24:30)
topfspy; ePq;fs; mku;tij vr;rhpf;fpd;Nwd; vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpaJk;> ,iwj;J}ju; mtu;fNs!
ehq;fs; Kf;fpag; Ngr;Rfs; Ngrpl mku;tJ Njitahfpd;wJ vd;W ehq;fs; Nfl;Nlhk;. mjw;F egp(]y;)
mtu;fs;> 'ePq;fs; mg;gbj; jq;fpdhy; topf;Fhpa chpikfis toq;fp tpLq;fs;' vd;W $wpdhu;fs;. topapd;
chpik vd;d? vd;W Nfl;Nlhk;. ''ghu;itiaj; jho;j;jpf; nfhs;sy;> jPq;F jUk; nghUl;fis mfw;Wjy;>
]yhkpw;Fg; gjpy; $Wjy;> ed;ikia VTjy;> jPikiaj; jLj;jy;'' vd;W $wpdhu;fs;. ,ij
mg+]aPj;(uyp) mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;. E}y;: m`;kj;
Nkw;fz;l trdKk; `jP]{k; me;epag; ngz;fis ghu;g;gij tplL ; k; ghu;itiaj; jtpu;f;f Ntz;Lk; vd
mwptpf;fpd;wd. Mdhy; Nkw;fz;l ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;l nra;jpNah ngz;fisg; ghUq;fs;; ghu;it $u;ik
MFk; vd;fpd;wJ. Mjhug;g+u;tkhd nrajpf;Fk; Nkw;fz;l nra;jp Kuzhf cs;sijg; Ghpa KbfpwJ.
mofhd ngz;fis kidtpaiuj; jpUkzk; nra;j vj;jidNah Mz;fs; ghu;itia ,oe;jtu;fshf>
ghu;itf; Fiw Vw;gl;ltu;fshf cs;sijg; ghu;f;fyhk;. ,jpypUe;Jk; Nkw;fz;l nra;jp ngha; vd
tpsq;fyhk;.
NkYk; ,r;nra;jpapy; gRikiag; ghu;g;gJk; ghu;itia $u;ikahf;Fk; vd;W cs;sJ. kjPdh tptrhak;
epiwe;j gFjpahFk;. gRikf;F gQ;rkpy;iy. MdhYk; mq;F mg;Jy;yh ,g;D ck;kp kf;J}k; Nghd;w
fz; FUlhf ,Ue;j egpj;Njhou;fs; ,Ue;Js;sdu; vd;gjpypUe;Jk; ,J ngha; vd tpsq;fyhk;.

72. Mz;fs; nfl;Lg; Nghf> ngz;fNs fhuzk;

''ngz;fs; nrhy;iy Nfl;ltd; njhiye;jhd;''


,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf Map\h(uyp) mwptpf;Fk; ,r;nra;jp> ,g;D mjP> mg+eaPk;> `hfpk;
E}w;fspy; gjpthfpAs;sJ.
,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk; ngWk; gfhu; ,g;D mg;Jy; m[P]; vd;gtu; gytPdkhdtu; vd ,g;D
mjP $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ,tu; fzf;fpNyNa vLj;Jf; nfhs;sg;glj; jfhjtu; vd;W ,g;D KaPd;
$Wfpd;whu;fs;.
,J gytPdkhd nra;jpahFk;. NkYk; ,J> egptopf;Fk; khw;wkhd nra;jpahfTk; cs;sJ.
`{ijgpa;ah cld;gbf;if Vw;gl;l NghJ ,iw kWg;ghsu;fshd kf;fhthrpfspd; epge;jidg;gb ck;uh
nra;ahky; jpUk;Gk; epiy egp(]y;) mtu;fSf;F Vw;gLfpwJ. clNd egp(]y;) mtu;fs; Fu;ghdp
nfhLj;Jtpl;L mq;NfNa jiyiar; rpiuAq;fs; vd egpj;Njhou;fsplk; $wpdhu;fs;. ,e;j cld;gbf;if
Fwpj;J> ftiyAld; ,Ue;j egpj;Njhou;fs; ftiy fhuzkhf vijAk; nra;ahky; ,Ue;jhu;fs;.
,jdhy; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; jd; kidtp ck;K]ykh(uyp) ,Ue;j $lhuj;jpw;Fr; nrd;W> ele;jij jd;
kidtpaplk; $Wfpd;whu;fs;. mg;NghJ ck;K rykh(uyp) mtu;fs; ePq;fs; mq;Nf nrd;W vtUlDk;
Ngrhky; jiyiar; rpiuj;J> Fu;ghdp nfhLq;fs; vd;W $wpdhu;fs;. egp(]y;) mtu;fSk; mg;gbNa
nra;jhu;fs;. ,ijg; ghu;j;j egpj;Njhou;fSk; jiyia rpiuj;Jf; Fu;ghdp nfhLj;jhu;fs;. E}y;:
GfhuP(`jP]pd; fUj;J)
,e;j `jP]; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; jd; kidtp ck;K ]ykh(uyp) mtu;fsplk; MNyhrid nra;Js;sdu;
vd;gij tpsq;fplr; nra;fpwJ. ngz;fsplKk; Nfl;fyhk;. ey;y nra;jp ,Ug;gpd; Vw;fyhk; vd;gjw;F
epiwar; rhd;Wfs; cs;sd.

57 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

vdNt Nkw;fz;l nra;jp> ngha;ahdJ vd;gij mwpf!

73. Mz;fs; eufk; nry;yf; fhuzk; ngz;fNs!

''ngz;fs; kl;Lk; ,y;yhky; ,Ue;jhy; Mz;fs; (midtUk;) nrhu;f;fk; nrd;wpUg;ghu;fs;.''


,t;thW egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpajhf md];(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpj;J> ,g;D mjPapd; 'my;fhkpy;' E}ypy;
gjpT nra;ag;gl;Ls;sJ.
,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk; ngWk; gp\;u; ,g;D `{i]d; vd;gtu; ngUk; ngha;au; vd ,g;D
,uhf; Fwpg;gpLfpd;whu;fs;.
,e;j nra;jpiag; gbf;Fk; NghJ ngz;fs; vtUk; nrhu;f;fk; nry;ykhl;lhu;fs;. Mz;fisAk; nry;ytpl
khl;lhu;fs; vd;gJ Nghy; Ghpa KbfpwJ. Mdhy; ngz; fspYk; ey;ytu;fs; cs;sdu;. nrhu;f;fk; nry;tu;
vd Fu;Md; %yk; Ghpa KbfpwJ.
my;yh`;> <khd; nfhz;ltu;fSf;F cjhuzkhf gpu;mt;dpd; kidtpiaAk;> ,k;uhdpd; kfs; ku;ak;
mtu;fisAk; $Wfpd;whd;. (ghu;f;f my;Fu;Md; 66:10>11) mjhtJ gpu;mt;dpd; kidtpAk; ku;ak; mtu;fSk;
%kpd; fSf;F cjhuzkhthu;fs;. mtu;fspd; tho;itf; fUj;jpy; nfhz;L> gbg;gpid ngw Ntz;Lk;
vd;W $Wfpd;whd;.
Mz;fspy; ey;ytu;-nfl;ltu; cs;sJ NghyNt ngz;fspYk; ey;ytu;-nfl;ltu; cz;L vd;w mstpy; jhd;
ek;gpf;if ,Uf;f Ntz;LNk jtpu> midj;J ngz;fSk; Nkhrkhdtu;fs;; Mz;fis topnfLj;J eufpw;F
mioj;Jr; nry;gtu;fs; vd ek;Gjy; $lhJ.
ngz;fs; midtUk; nfl;ltu;fs; vdpy; mtu;fis eufpy; NghlNt ,iwtd; tpUk;Gthd;. Mdhy;
my;yh`; ngz;fis capUld; Gijj;jJ gw;wpAk;> ,jw;F ePjp toq;FNtd; vd;Wk; 16:58> 81:8 Mfpa
trdq;fs; %yk; mwptpf;fpd;whu;fs;.
eufk; nry;y cs;s ngz;fs; jhNd> tho;e;jhy; vd;d? nrj;jhy; vd;d? vd ,iwtd; vz;zp
,Ue;jpltpy;iy. khwhf mtu;fs; thog; gpwe;jtu;fs;> mtu;fs; tho;tijf; nfLj;j nfhiyfhu Mz;fs;
jz;bf;fg;gLthu;fs; vdf; Fwpg;gpL fpwhd;.
vdNt Nkw;fz;l nra;jp ngha;ahdJ> ,l;Lf;fl;lg; gl;lJ vd;gij mwpNthkhf!

74. ,iwtdpd; tpNuhjpfs; ngz;fshtu;?

''ngz;fs; kl;Lk; ,y;yhky; ,Ue;jhy; my;yh`;it rhpahd Kiwapy; tzq;fg;gl;bUf;Fk;.''


,t;thW egp(]y;) $wpajhf cku;(uyp) mtu;fs; mwptpf;Fk; ,r;nra;jp ,g;D mjPapd; my;fhkpy; E}ypy;
gjpT nra;ag; gl;Ls;sJ.
,r;nra;jpapd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; ,lk;ngWk; ehd;fhk; mwptpg;ghsu; mg;Ju;u`Pk; ,g;D i]j; my;mk;kP
vd;gtd; `jP]f ; s; epuhff;fg;gl Ntz;bait vd mg+`hjk; $Wfpd;whu;fs;. Nkhrkhd ngUk; ngha;au;
vd ,tiu Kg;D KaPd; fLikahf tpku;rpf;fpwhu;fs;. Gfh ,khk; cl;gl gyUk; tpku;rpf;fpwhu;fs;. ,ijg;
gjpT nra;j ,g;D mjP mtu;fSk; ,J Gwf;fzpf;fg;gl Ntz;ba nra;jp vd;W $Wfpd;whu;fs;.
,e;j `jP];> ngz;fs; ,iwtid tzq;Ftij tpl;Lk; jLf;ff; $batu;fs;. mjhtJ ,iwtdpd;
tpNuhjpfs; ngz;fs; jhd; vd;gJ Nghy; $Wfpd;wJ. ,J Mjhug;g+u;t khd nfhs;iff;F Kuzhd
nra;jpahfTk; cs;sJ.
epr;rakhf i\j;jhd; tpUk;Gtnjy;yhk; kJghdj;ijf; nfhz;Lk; #jhl;lj;ijf; nfhz;Lk; cq;fspilNa
gifik iaAk; ntWg;igAk; cUthf;fp my;yh`;tpd; epidtpy; ,Ue;Jk;> njhOifapy; ,Ue;Jk;
cq;fisj; jLj;J tpl;lhd;. vdNt mtw;iw tpl;Lk; ePq;fs; tpyfpf; nfhs;s khl;Bu;fsh? (my;Fu;Md;
5:91)

58 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

kdpju;fis topnfLf;Fk; i\j;jhd; jhd; ,iwtdpd; vjphp vd;W ,e;j trdk; $WfpwJ. Mdhy;
ngz;fs; jhd; topnfLf;Fk; $l;lk; vd;gJ Nghy; Nkw;fz;l nra;jp $Wfpd;wJ. ,jpypUe;Jk; Nkw;fz;l
nra;jp ,l;Lf;fl;lg; gl;lJ vd tpsq;fyhk;.

75. k`Uf;F msTz;lh?

''gj;J nts;sp ehzaq;fSf;Fk; Fiwthf k`u; fpilahJ.''


,ij egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs; vd [hgpu;(uyp) mtu;fshy; mwptpf;fg;gl;L ig`fP> jhuFj;dP> ,g;D
mjP Mfpa E}w;fspy; ,lk; ngw;Ws;sJ.
,jd; mwptpg;ghsu; thpirapy; Ie;jhtjhf Kg\;\pu; ,g;D cigj; vDk; ngha;au; ,lk; ngWfpwhu;. ,td;
`jP];fs; ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;litfshfTk;> ngha;ahdit fshfTk; ,Uf;Fk; vd ,khk; m`;kj;(u`;)
$Wfpd;whu;fs;.
',tu; `jP];fspy; Kw;wpYk; ntWf;fg;gl;l gytPdu;' vd mg+`hjk; $Wfpd;whu;fs;. `jP]; Jiwapy;
,tu; Gwe;js;sg;gl;ltu; vd jhuFj;dP $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ey;ytu; fspd; ngaiug; gad;gLj;jp ,l;Lfl;Lk;
egu; ,tu;. ,td; `jP];fis> GJik `jP];fs; vDk; thpirapy; jhd; Nru;f;f Ntz;Lk; vd ,g;D
`pg;ghd; $Wfpd;whu;fs;.
'',tu; mwptpfF
; k; nra;jpfs; ngha;ahdit. mrj;jpakhdit> ,l;Lf;fl;lg;gl;lit'' vd ,khk; m`;kj;
$wpajhf ,g;D mjP $Wfpd;whu;fs;. ',tu; `jP]; Jiw apduhy; ntWf;fg;gl;ltu;' vd ,khk; GfhuP
$Wfpd;whu;fs;. ,g;gb gyuhy; rhlg;gl;ltu; ,lk; ngWtjhy; ,J gytPdkhd nra;jpahfpwJ.
k`u; vd;gJ jpUkzk; nra;J nfhs;s cs;s ngz;zhy; epu;zak; nra;ag;gl Ntz;Lk;. ngz;zpd;
nghWg;ghsu; k`u; gw;wp NgrpdhYk;> me;j k`iu Vw;Wf; nfhs;sTk;> kWf;fTk; chpik nfhz;lts;
ngz; jhd;. ,JNghy; thq;fpa k`iu jhNd itj;Jf; nfhs;sNth> my;yJ fztDf;Fj; jpUk;gj;
je;jplNth chpikAk; ngw;wts;> ngz; jhd; vd;gJ ,];yhkpar; rl;lkhFk;.
Fiwe;j gl;rk; k`u; ,J jhd; vd epu;zak; nra;Ak; chpik vtUf;Fk; ,y;iy. gj;J nts;sp
ehzaq;fSf;F Fiwthf jug;gLk; k`iu itj;J jpUkzk; nra;jy; $lhJ vd;gJ Nghy; Nkw;fz;l
nra;jp $Wfpd;wJ. mjw;F Fiwthd k`u; ,Ue;J> mij me;jg; ngz; Vw;Wf; nfhz;lhy; mJNt
k`u; vd gpd;tUk; Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]; $WfpwJ.
xU ngz; egp(]y;) mtu;fsplk; te;J> ,iwj;J}ju; mtu;fNs! vd;id cq;fsplj;jpy;
xg;gilj;Jtpl;Nld;. (mjhtJ vd;id jpUkzk; nra;J nfhs;Sq;fs;) vd;W $wpdhu;. egp(]y;)
mtu;fs; mg;ngz;zpd; gf;fk; jpUk;gp mg;ngz;iz NkYk; fPOk; vdg; ghu;j;Jtpl;L jiy ftpo;e;J
nfhz;lhu;fs;.
jdJ fUj;J tp\akhf ve;j KbTk; vLf;fg;glhjijg; ghu;j;j mg;ngz; mku;e;J nfhz;lhu;. mg;NghJ
xU egpjN; jhou; xUtu; vOe;J> ',iwj;J}ju; mtu;fNs> ,g;ngz; zplk; cq;fSf;F vt;tpjj; NjitAk;
,y;iynadpy; vdf;Fj; jpUkzk; nra;J itAq;fs;' vd;W $wpdhu;. mjw;F egp(]y;) mtu;fs;
'cd;dplk; (k`u; ju) vd;d cs;sJ?' vd;W Nfl;lhu;fs;.
clNd mtu;> 'my;yh`;tpd; kPJ rj;jpakhf! vd;dplk; vJTkpy;iy ,iwj;J}ju; mtu;fNs!' vd;W
$wpdhu;. 'cd; FLk;gj;jhhplk; nrd;W VjhtJ cs;sjh? vd;W ghu;j;Jth' vd;W egp(]y;) $wpdhu;fs;.
Ngha; te;j mtu;> ',iwj;J}ju; mtu;fNs! my;yh`;tpd; kPJ rj;jpakhf vijAk; ehd; ngw;Wf;
nfhs;stpy;iy' vd;W $wpdhu;. ',Uk;G Nkhjpuk; cs;sjh?'vd egp(]y;) Nfl;lhu;fs;. mtu; nrd;W
jpUk;g te;J> ',iwj;J}ju; mtu;fNs! my;yh`;tpd; kPJ rj;jpakhf> ,Uk;G Nkhjpuk; $l ,y;iy.
MdhYk; ,e;j Ntl;b jhd; cs;sJ' vd;whu;. ,ij mwptpf;Fk; ]`;y; (uyp) mtu;fs; mthplk; Nkyhil
$l ,y;iy vd;W Fwpg;gpLfpwhu;fs;.
',e;j Ntl;bapy; ghjpia mg;ngz;Zf;Fj; jUfpNwd;' vd;W mtu; $wpdhu;. mg;NghJ egp(]y;) mtu;fs;
'cdJ ,e;j Ntl;bia itj;J vd;d nra;a KbAk;. ,ij eP mzpej ; hy; mg;ngz;zpd; clypy; vJTk;

59 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM
Collection of Weak Hadiths which contradicting & confusing muslims http://www.a1realism.com/hadith/false_hadees.htm

,Uf;fhJ. mg;ngz; mzpe;J nfhz;lhy; cdJ clypy; vJTk; ,Uf;fhJ' vd;W $wpdhu;fs;. ,ijf;
Nfl;l mtUk; mku;e;Jtpll
; hu;. rig(apd; Neuk;) mjpfj;jJ. (KbT vJTk; Vw;gltpyi
; y vd;gjhy;)
mtu; vOe;J nrd;W tpl;lhu;. mtiu mioj;J tUk;gb egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs;. mtu; mioj;J
tug;gl;lhu;.
mtu; te;jJk;> 'Fu;Mdpy; VNjDk; ck;kplk; kddkhf cs;sjh?'vdf; Nfl;lhu;fs;. ',d;dpd;d
mj;jpahaq;fs; vdf;Fj; njhpAk;' vd mtu; vz;zpf; fhl;bdhu;. ',tw;iw kdg;ghlkhf ePu; XJtPuh?'
vd;W Nfl;lhu;fs;. mtu; Mk; vd;whu;. 'Fu;Mdpy; ePu; njhpe;J itj;Js;s ,itfSf;Fg; gfukhf
,g;ngz;iz kzk; Kbj;Jj; je;Njd;' vd;W egp(]y;) mtu;fs; $wpdhu;fs;. ,J ]`;y;(uyp)
mtu;fshy; mwptpf;fg;gLfpwJ. E}y;fs;: GfhuP> K];ypk;
ntWnkd Fu;Md; trdq;fis k`uhf;fp> me;j k`iuAk; me;jg; ngz; kWg;NgJk; njhptpff ; hj
epiyapy; egp(]y;) mtu;fs; jpUkzk; nra;J itj;Js;shu;fs; vd Mjhug;g+u;tkhd `jP]; $Wfpd;wJ.
vdNt Fiwe;j gl;rk; gj;J nts;sp ehzaq;fshtJ k`uhf ,Ue;jhf Ntz;Lk; vd;w Nkw;fz;l
nra;jp ngha; vdg; Ghpayhk;.

vr;rhpf;if!

`jP];fspd; ngauhy; åju;fs; ,l;Lf;fl;b cs;sdu; vd;gij czu;e;J nray;gl Kd;tu Ntz;Lk;.
,jw;fhf `jP];fNs Ntz;lhk; vd;w nfhs;if nfhz;L miytJ eufpNyNa Ngha;r; Nru;f;Fk;
vd;gijAk; epidtpy; nfhs;f!

60 of 60 12/27/2010 8:17 AM

You might also like