Professional Documents
Culture Documents
1 APPEARANCES:
2
MR. ROBERT J. CURTIS
3 Attorney at Law
405 Tombigbee Street
4 Jackson, Mississippi 39201
5 REPRESENTING HARRIS CLAIBORNE FRAZIER
6
MR. JOHN W. CROW, JR.
7 Attorney at Law
203 Wagner Street
8 Water Valley, Mississippi 38965
9 REPRESENTING BANCORPSOUTH
10
MS. EILEEN N. SHAFFER
11 Attorney at Law
401 East Capitol Street, Suite 316
12 Jackson, Mississippi 39201
13 REPRESENTING BANCORPSOUTH
14
MR. G. TODD BURWELL
15 Latham & Burwell
618 Crescent Boulevard, Suite 200
16 Ridgeland, Mississippi 39157
17 REPRESENTING CLUB WOODLANDS, LLC, SHELBY
BRANTLEY AND STEVE DAVIDSON
18
19 MR. PAUL M. ELLIS
Butler, Snow, O'Mara, Stevens & Cannada
20 210 East Capitol Street, Suite 1700
Jackson, Mississippi 39201
21
REPRESENTING ST. PAUL TRAVELERS
22
23 MR. DEREK A. HENDERSON
Attorney at Law
24 111 East Capitol Street, Suite 455
Jackson, Mississippi 39201
25
BANKRUPTCY TRUSTEE AND ATTORNEY FOR TRUSTEE
3
1 APPEARANCES:
2
3 MR. JAMES L. MARTIN
Attorney at Law
4 388 Highland Colony Parkway
Ridgeland, Mississippi 39157
5
REPRESENTING THE HINES FAMILY AND KAY ATWOOD
6 VAN SKIVER
7
MS. ROSAMOND H. POSEY
8 Mitchell, McNutt & Sams
1216 Van Buren Avenue
9 Oxford, Mississippi 38655
10 REPRESENTING DIANE BAILEY
11
12 ALSO PRESENT: Gerald Talmadge Braddock
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
4
1 TABLE OF CONTENTS
2
3 Style........................................... 1
4 Appearances..................................... 2
5 Table of Contents............................... 3
6 Exhibit 1 (Agreed Order).................... 7
7 Examination by Mr. Crow......................... 7
8 Examination by Ms. Shaffer...................... 45
9 Exhibit 2 (Copy of Bankruptcy Schedules).... 46
10 Exhibit 3 (Order Granting Examination)...... 58
11 Exhibit 4 (Settlement Statement)............ 58
12 Exhibit 5 (Closing Disbursements Sheet)...... 58
13 Exhibit 6 (Assignment of LLC Interest)...... 58
14 Exhibit 7 (Amendment to Operating Agreement) 58
15 Exhibit 8 (Operating Agreement)............. 58
16 Exhibit 9 (Amendment to Operating Agreement) 58
17 Exhibit 10 (Legacy Bank Documents).......... 58
18 Exhibit 11 (December 15, 2005, Email)....... 58
19 Exhibit 12 (Escrow Closing Statement)....... 58
20 Exhibit 13 (Seller's Escrow Agreement)...... 58
21 Exhibit 14 (Six Shooter Operating Agreement) 58
22 Exhibit 15 (Amendment to Operating Agreement) 58
23 Exhibit 16 (April 24, 2006, Document)........ 58
24 Exhibit 17 (Assignment of Six Shooter Land).. 58
25 Exhibit 18 (Assignment of LLC Interest)...... 58
5
1 (Oath administered)
2 MR. HENDERSON: My name is Derek Henderson.
3 I'm the bankruptcy trustee and the attorney for the
4 trustee in the bankruptcy case
5 MR. MARTIN: I'm Jim Martin, attorney for the
6 Hines family and also Kay Atwood Van Skiver.
7 MS. POSEY: I'm Rosamond Posey and I'm here
8 on the behalf of Diane Bailey.
9 MR. ELLIS: Paul Ellis representing
10 Travelers.
11 MR. BURWELL: Todd Burwell representing Club
12 Woodlands, Shelby Brantley and Steve Davidson.
13 MS. SHAFFER: Eileen Shaffer representing
14 BancorpSouth.
15 MR. CROW: John Crow representing
16 BancorpSouth in connection with the civil case,
17 BancorpSouth vs. Van Buren Group and others.
18 MR. CURTIS: Bob Curtis representing
19 representing Claiborne Frazier.
20 MS. SHAFFER: Mr. Frazier, I'm Eileen Shaffer
21 representing BancorpSouth. You're here present today
22 pursuant to an agreed order regarding a motion for
23 Rule 2004 Examination of you on behalf of BancorpSouth
24 as well as others. Are you familiar with that order?
25 THE WITNESS: Yes.
7
1 civil suit?
2 A I am.
3 Q Okay. Now, you obtained a $5.4 million loan
4 from BancorpSouth. Correct?
5 A I did.
6 Q All right. Can you tell me who you dealt
7 with initially when the loan process started for the
8 bank?
9 A Right. This was back in 2001. I dealt with
10 a guy named Bobby Little.
11 Q Okay. Did you deal with anyone else from
12 that point forward in connection with your loan with
13 the bank?
14 A Yes. There was a Ron Winford that was
15 involved, and I dealt with two others -- I can't think
16 of their names right now -- that would sit in. And I
17 also had relations with BancorpSouth because they
18 bought a lot out at one of my developments in Madison
19 back in 2003, and they were somewhat involved with the
20 Van Buren loan. I'm thinking -- I can't remember
21 their names right now.
22 Q They were bank officers?
23 A They were.
24 Q All right. Did they have anything to do
25 with the Van Buren financing?
9
1 William Smith.
2 Q All right. And did you later deal with a
3 law firm by the name of Watkins & Eager?
4 A When Taylor, Covington & Smith merged, I did
5 deal with Watkins & Eager, but the best I recollect, I
6 had already sold most of the units at this point.
7 Q All right. Do you remember the name of the
8 attorney or attorneys that you dealt with at Watkins &
9 Eager?
10 A It would have been the same ones. I
11 referred at the time to the Taylor, Covington & Smith
12 group because I dealt with them, you know, since I'd
13 been in the real estate business.
14 Q Then you don't remember any other lawyers
15 that -- Taylor, Covington & Smith merged with Watkins
16 & Eager. Is that not correct?
17 A That's correct.
18 Q And you don't remember any names of the
19 Watkins & Eager firm members that you might have dealt
20 with?
21 A None others that had anything to do with the
22 Van Buren.
23 Q Looking at some of the documents that I have
24 in this case, I see the name of Ben Williams. Did you
25 deal with him --
13
1 A I did.
2 Q -- in connection with disbursing any of the
3 proceeds of these sales?
4 A I don't recall Ben handling anything on the
5 Van Buren today. I would -- there was Bobby
6 Covington's secretary who, I believe, went to Watkins
7 & Eager with the merger. Her name was Sidra and she
8 would prepare documents, and I never knew -- it was my
9 understanding -- this was back in '03/'04 -- that she
10 was wrapping up Bobby Covington's work while he was
11 slowly retiring and moving somewhere in Georgia where
12 his kids were. You know, Ben could have prepared some
13 documents and given them to Sidra for me to pick up.
14 I'm not sure.
15 Q Do you remember a Roger W. Williams?
16 A I do.
17 Q All right. What would Bobby Covington do
18 for you in this process? Or Taylor, Covington &
19 Smith, what role did they play in the sale of these
20 units?
21 A Well, let me clarify. They prepared all of
22 the condominium documents, the declaration, the rules
23 and regulations, everything down to the closing
24 documents.
25 Q Did you -- when you say "closing documents,"
14
1 A I don't recall.
2 Q What about Unit 309? That's the last one
3 that had not been sold that you lost at a municipal
4 tax sale. You didn't have any type of agreement at
5 that time that fell apart thereafter, 309?
6 A No. I recall hearing some of the owners in
7 Van Buren making lowball offers, but at this point,
8 and it's still my understanding, there is a Dana Kelly
9 involved and I've been keeping in touch with him every
10 month or so and they were doing a judicial foreclosure
11 on that unit and going to credit the judgment, and
12 that's the last conversation I had with him.
13 Q I want to talk a little bit about the
14 process of the closing of a unit. Were you provided
15 with a closing statement in connection with the sale
16 to John and Lynn Albritton?
17 A Yes.
18 Q What about Langston-Oxford Properties?
19 A Yes.
20 Q Lynn Grenfell?
21 A Yes.
22 Q John Lee?
23 A Yes.
24 Q Norma Bordeaux?
25 A Yes.
19
1 A Yes.
2 Q How long did she work for you before?
3 A She worked for -- she actually worked for
4 the construction company, which was owned by my father
5 and brother, and the best I recall, she started around
6 1995.
7 Q And so she was let go or did she quit or was
8 she terminated or what?
9 A She -- we were taken over by our bonding
10 company, St. Paul Travelers, the construction company
11 was. She worked for them for a short stint wrapping
12 up some unfinished business, and I don't know where
13 she is or what she's doing now.
14 Q When was the last time you talked to her?
15 A Back in 2007, and I don't recall what month.
16 Q And why did you talk to her? Do you
17 remember?
18 A She was at the office where I had an office,
19 and at this point, our bonding company had come in and
20 taken over control and I just saw her there in the
21 office. I remember because I was moving some of my
22 things out.
23 Q In connection with the Albritton sale, of
24 course, we weren't paid. The account, your loan, was
25 not reduced with those sales proceeds. Is that
24
1 correct?
2 A I don't recall.
3 Q Well, do you remember what you did with that
4 money? Because the bank didn't get it.
5 A Again, it's my testimony that all of the
6 money that went in the Van Buren account and was used
7 for the project.
8 Q Well, who put it in there?
9 A It would have either been someone on behalf
10 of my company or there were times I recall that Sidra
11 Allison, Bobby Covington's assistant, would make
12 arrangements to get releases signed, would send a
13 runner if the purchaser lived here in the Jackson
14 area. She was the go-between. She would have
15 documents ready for me.
16 I would run to either Taylor, Covington &
17 Smithing or Watkins & Eager's office where it is now,
18 here in downtown Jackson, and I would run by and sign
19 documents, but I don't remember the specifics of each
20 transaction.
21 Q The payments -- you remember making payments
22 on the loan, don't you?
23 A Not -- that's broad. I don't remember each
24 payment that I made on the loan, no.
25 Q Well, do you remember making a payment for
25
1 Bobby Noah?
2 A I don't.
3 Q Tim Ford?
4 A I don't.
5 Q John Lee?
6 A What I do remember about John Lee, he
7 purchased two units, and I remember him coming down
8 and purchasing the unit and dealing with -- I had
9 signed some documents and he dealt with a Ron Winford
10 and that's all I remember about John Lee.
11 Q Do you remember making any payments on
12 behalf of the sale to Langston-Oxford Properties?
13 A I don't.
14 Q And I'm referring to payments to the bank.
15 So you can't say that you did?
16 A I don't recall the specifics of each
17 transaction.
18 Q All right. Would Sammie Sartain be the one
19 that would deliver a check to BancorpSouth as far as
20 sales proceeds? Would she be the one?
21 A As I testified earlier, it could have been
22 someone on behalf of my company or it could have been
23 Taylor, Covington & Smith or Watkins & Eager.
24 Q When you say someone on behalf of your
25 company, you're referring to Sammie Sartain?
26
1 A Correct.
2 Q Would it be anyone else with your company?
3 A Could -- could have been my father if I was
4 out of pocket at times. I would narrow it down to
5 Sammie, my father, C.E. Frazier, myself or Sidra at
6 Taylor, Covington & Smith.
7 Q Did you ever tell Sidra at Taylor, Covington
8 & Smith or Bobby Covington or anyone at the firm of
9 Watkins & Eager not to send a check to BancorpSouth
10 Bank in connection with the sale?
11 A No.
12 Q Lynn Grenfell: Do you remember making a --
13 that unit was sold to her. Do you remember making a
14 payment to the bank for that sale?
15 A I don't.
16 Q Norma Bordeaux?
17 A I don't recall.
18 Q And you had one bank account that all these
19 proceeds went in, possibly another one, in the Oxford
20 area?
21 A Correct.
22 Q And those accounts would reflect all
23 disbursements made including construction costs and
24 payments on the debt?
25 A Yes.
27
1 proceeding?
2 A Yes.
3 MS. SHAFFER: If I could have those marked
4 as BancorpSouth's Exhibit No. 2, please.
5 (Exhibit 2 marked)
6 BY MS. SHAFFER:
7 Q Mr. Frazier, I'm just going to ask you a
8 couple of questions regarding those schedules because
9 I know we went into them in depth at your 341(a)
10 hearing, but did you review these schedules before you
11 signed them?
12 A Yes, I did.
13 Q Okay. I believe at the 341(a) hearing, you
14 testified that your address has changed since your
15 bankruptcy petition was filed. Is that correct?
16 A Correct.
17 Q And can you give me that address again?
18 A Yes. It's 775 Unit 36 Gulf Shore Drive,
19 Destin, Florida 32541.
20 Q And have you begun receiving mail at that
21 address?
22 A Just last week, yes.
23 Q Do you know why mail mailed to that address
24 would be returned?
25 A Only because the unit is in my stepfather
47
1 like that.
2 Q Okay. If I can call your attention to
3 Schedule A, which is a listing of real property on
4 your schedules, I just want to clarify a question that
5 was asked of you earlier. It's about four pages -- or
6 three pages over.
7 A Okay.
8 Q Do you see the second entry, Mathena
9 Wetlands?
10 A Right.
11 Q And I believe Mr. Crow asked you if there
12 was any debt on that property, and I understood you to
13 say that there was none.
14 A There is none, and let me --
15 MR. CURTIS: That's an error.
16 A Rob and I corrected this, and apparently it
17 has not been resubmitted, but it's corrected here on
18 his copy. There is no debt on Mathena Wetlands.
19 BY MS. SHAFFER:
20 Q So as I understand, the $750,000 that's
21 listed here as a debt is not correct?
22 A That's not correct.
23 MR. CURTIS: We need to amend that, Eileen,
24 to take that off because that's just an error.
25 BY MS. SHAFFER:
49
1 Country Club?
2 A I don't.
3 Q And when did you divest yourself of that
4 stock?
5 A Oh, gosh, over a year ago.
6 Q And did you sell that?
7 A There were some bills that were due. And
8 you can't sell the stock -- well, I won't say you
9 can't, but you only get like $2,000 or so, and I
10 recall them just -- there was some -- I was behind on
11 my dues there at the Country Club and they pulled that
12 money out. I recall getting a check in the mail for
13 $100 or $200 or so.
14 Q Do you own stock in any other country club?
15 A I do not.
16 Q Did you ever have an interest in Tiger
17 Enterprises, LLC?
18 A I did.
19 Q And when did you divest -- do you still have
20 an interest in that property?
21 A I don't.
22 Q And when did you divest yourself of that
23 interest?
24 A 2005 or 2006.
25 Q And what did you do with that property?
54
1 A Correct.
2 Q So do you still have an interest in the
3 company?
4 A I do not.
5 Q Do you have an interest in any other
6 companies that have not been listed previously?
7 A No.
8 Q I believe you also testified at the 341(a)
9 hearing, as well as briefly today, that you had a bank
10 account for Van Buren, LLC, at BancorpSouth. Is that
11 correct?
12 A Yes.
13 Q Did you only have one bank account at
14 BancorpSouth for Van Buren?
15 A Yes, for Van Buren.
16 Q Did you have any other business accounts at
17 BancorpSouth?
18 A Yes.
19 Q So is it my understanding that any proceeds
20 that you received as a result of the sale of the
21 various condos and units that Mr. Crow asked you
22 about, would those monies have been deposited only in
23 that BancorpSouth account?
24 A Yes.
25 Q Do you know of any reason why there would
56
1 Is that correct?
2 A Correct.
3 Q Take a look at Exhibit 4.
4 A Okay.
5 Q Is that the closing statement for the
6 purchase of that property by Flowood Developers, LLC?
7 A Yes.
8 Q Did Frazier Development, LLC, ever make any
9 capital contributions to that LLC?
10 A Yes.
11 Q What were they?
12 A When the property was not cash flowing for
13 the first year or so, we would make the bank payments
14 to satisfy the monthly note.
15 Q Okay. And how many payments did you make?
16 A Well over 12. I don't recall the amount.
17 Q Okay. Did Frazier Development, LLC, put up
18 any cash in terms of an investment at the beginning or
19 in the formation of Flowood Developers, LLC?
20 A I don't recall.
21 Q In connection with the purchase of the
22 property, that LLC got a loan for the full amount of
23 the purchase price. Correct?
24 A I don't recall the exact purchase price.
25 Q Look at the Exhibit 4 in front of you and
61
1 it reassessed?
2 Q Yes. Is that something you were supposed to
3 be doing?
4 A That is something Steve Davidson and I were
5 collectively working on.
6 Q Did you have any tenants at that property
7 out there?
8 A We did.
9 Q And who were those tenants?
10 A There was a Tandy Wansley who operated some
11 grain storage along the railroad tracks that came in
12 at some point. There was a Bekeson Glass that was the
13 original tenant that occupied about 5 percent of the
14 space. And there was some welding company, and I
15 don't recall their name.
16 Q Is it C. West (phonetic)?
17 A That's it.
18 Q Okay. Who was responsible for collecting
19 the rent from those tenants on behalf of the LLC?
20 A Again, my father, C.E. Frazier, Sammie Satin
21 or myself.
22 Q Were all rents collected from the tenants
23 who were leasing properties from that LLC deposited in
24 the Merchants & Farmers account?
25 A I don't recall.
64
1 A Yes.
2 Q Dividend payments?
3 A Yes.
4 Q Attorneys' fees?
5 A I don't recall.
6 Q Now, at any time, did Flowood Developers,
7 LLC, sell any of the property that it owned while
8 Frazier Development was still a member?
9 A There were no physical properties sold.
10 Q Were there any properties sold by Flowood
11 Developers to John Laws --
12 A Let me -- that rings a bell. Yes, there was
13 a small piece of property sold, yes.
14 Q Take a look at Exhibit 5 for me.
15 A Okay.
16 Q Is that a closing disbursement sheet from
17 the sale of that small piece of property by Flowood
18 Developers to John Laws and Janice Laws Nance?
19 A Yes.
20 Q Now, that document, Exhibit 5, is not signed
21 by you. Do you remember signing that document?
22 A I remember the document, and, yes, I recall
23 signing this when we sold the land to Laws.
24 Q Now, looking at Nos. 3 and 4 on that closing
25 disbursement statement, can you tell me -- excuse me,
70
1 Metro.
2 Q And what was Frazier Development's interest
3 in Jackson Metro Properties?
4 A I don't recall.
5 Q Was it more than 50 percent?
6 A At a point in time.
7 Q Was Frazier Development, LLC, the manager of
8 Jackson Metro Properties, LLC?
9 A Yes.
10 Q Okay. And who on behalf of Frazier
11 Development, LLC, was authorized to act on its behalf?
12 A My father and myself.
13 Q Take a look at Exhibit 8. Can you tell me
14 what that document is?
15 A It's the operating agreement of Jackson
16 Metro Properties.
17 Q Okay. I want you to take a second and look
18 through that. This is not a signed copy, but I want
19 you to review it and let me know if it's the final
20 version, what you remember of the final version of the
21 operating agreement of Jackson Metro Properties, LLC.
22 A This is the final operating agreement, but
23 it was amended as other members bought into the
24 properties.
25 Q Understood. Okay. If you would, look on
76
1 A I don't.
2 Q If I told you that Jason Young bought his
3 interest -- his 12.5 percent interest for $175,000 in
4 2003, would you be able to dispute that?
5 A As an apples-to-apples comparison, yes, I
6 would.
7 Q What do you mean by that?
8 A We did not own the amount of land in 2003
9 that the company should still own now.
10 Q Do you have any information to dispute that
11 Jason Young bought a 12.5 percent interest in that LLC
12 for $175,000?
13 A No.
14 Q Take a look at Exhibit No. 15 for me,
15 please. Is that the first amendment to the operating
16 agreement for Six Shooter Land & Timber, LLC?
17 A Yes.
18 Q And on the last page of Exhibit 15, is that
19 your signature, third up from the bottom?
20 A Yes.
21 Q And does this amendment acknowledge and
22 ratify the addition of John Davidson and Jason Young
23 as members in the LLC?
24 A Yes.
25 Q When did you first assign your interest in
90
1 A Correct.
2 Q Read Line 1 for the court reporter.
3 A "We acknowledge a debt of $390,000 to Club
4 Woodlands, LLC, and agree to repayment in six weeks."
5 Q And the "we" is talking about Claiborne
6 Frazier, Frazier Development and Frazier Construction?
7 A Right.
8 Q Okay. Did you pay Club Woodlands, LLC,
9 $390,000 within six weeks of April the 26th of '06?
10 A No.
11 Q If you'll look at Exhibit 17 for me, do you
12 recognize this document?
13 A Yes.
14 Q Is this an assignment of membership interest
15 in Six Shooter Land & Timber, LLC?
16 A Yes.
17 Q Turn to the second page of that document.
18 Is that your signature on the left-hand side under
19 "Assignor"?
20 A Yes.
21 Q And what is the date of your signature?
22 A 05/18/06.
23 Q Did you sign more than one assignment in
24 connection with your interest in Six Shooter Land &
25 Timber, LLC?
92
1 A Yes.
2 Q The date of this is September 1st of 2006?
3 A Right.
4 Q The members of Club Woodlands, LLC, are
5 Steve Davidson and Shelby Brantley. Is that correct?
6 A That's correct.
7 Q And turning to the back page of this --
8 excuse me, the next to last page of this document, is
9 that your signature on the upper left-hand side where
10 it says "Frazier"?
11 A Yes.
12 Q And then on every page at the bottom of the
13 page, are those your initials?
14 A Yes.
15 Q Did you put those initials there?
16 A Yes.
17 Q Whose initials are "A.F."?
18 A My brother, Austin Frazier.
19 Q Did he put those initials there?
20 A Yes.
21 Q Turning to the next to last page of that
22 document, is that Austin's signature next to the
23 bottom of that page?
24 A Yes.
25 Q Is that your signature at the bottom of that
94
1 page?
2 A Yes.
3 Q And this document was signed September 1st,
4 2006?
5 A Yes. Well, let me clarify. It's dated
6 September 1st of 2006. I'm not sure when I signed
7 this document.
8 Q Do you have any reason to dispute that it
9 was signed September the 1st of 2006?
10 A Yes, I do.
11 Q And why is that?
12 A It was routine for the doctors in the group
13 to fight over documents such as the operating
14 agreement, us refinancing the loan, items of that
15 nature. It was very hard to make decisions up there
16 with those guys -- being Brantley, one of the members,
17 Carroll McLeod and Steve Davidson -- by virtue of us
18 not having a Six Shooter Lodge operating agreement at
19 the time we built the lodge because people would talk
20 about the language.
21 So it was not routine for a document to be
22 dated, for example, 2004 and not be signed by
23 everybody for six or seven months later.
24 Q So you don't have any personal recollection
25 as to when this was actually signed, then, do you?
95
1 A I do not.
2 Q On the first page of Exhibit 18, Paragraph
3 2, provides that there is a right to repurchase. In
4 essence, that paragraph says that for $300,000 plus
5 interest, you could repurchase the interest you had
6 assigned in Six Shooter Land & Timber. Is that
7 correct?
8 A Correct.
9 Q If that payment was made before June the 1st
10 of 2007. Correct?
11 A Correct.
12 Q Was the $300,000 plus interest ever paid
13 back to Shelby Brantley, Steve Davidson or Club
14 Woodlands, LLC, by June the 1st of 2007?
15 A No.
16 Q If you would look at Exhibit 18 -- excuse
17 me, 19. Can you identify that document?
18 A Yes, it's another assignment of limited
19 liability company interest to Club Woodlands.
20 Q And what's the date of that assignment?
21 A October 12th, 2006.
22 Q Okay. Turn to the next to last page, Page
23 3, of Exhibit 19. Is that your signature on that
24 page?
25 A Yes.
96
1 sales that took place and pay down the loan that Van
2 Buren, LLC, owed. Correct?
3 A I don't recall.
4 Q You were the managing member of Van Buren,
5 LLC --
6 A Yes.
7 Q -- as manager of Frazier Development, LLC.
8 Correct?
9 A Correct.
10 Q Did Shelby Brantley put up any other cash in
11 connection with Van Buren, LLC, that you're aware of?
12 A No.
13 Q All right. If you'll look at the next
14 exhibit, Exhibit No. 21, can you identify that
15 document for me?
16 A Yes, it's the operating agreement of
17 Gluckstadt, Restaurant, LLC.
18 Q And on the signature page of that document,
19 is that your signature?
20 A Yes.
21 Q Okay. Who were the members of Gluckstadt
22 Restaurant, LLC?
23 A Shelby Brantley and Frazier Development.
24 Q Who was the manager of that LLC?
25 A Let's see. Frazier Development.
102
1 Q As individuals?
2 A There was really -- it was a homemade
3 trailer. It was never titled.
4 Q Okay. And you said it was "homemade." Did
5 y'all pay for the trailer or did you make it
6 yourselves?
7 A We hired out welders and they made it for
8 us.
9 Q Where is that trailer now?
10 A It's at my stepfather's office.
11 Q Is it still for sale?
12 A No.
13 Q Where is your stepfather's office?
14 A I-55 in Jackson.
15 Q Do you know the address?
16 A 4705 I-55 Frontage Road.
17 Q What is the business located in that office?
18 A Josten's Class Rings and National Awards.
19 Q And do you, your father and brother own that
20 trailer equally?
21 A Yes.
22 Q There is no LLC agreement or operating
23 agreement for Six Shooter Lodge. Is that correct?
24 A There is one that four of the six members
25 signed.
111
1 Metro debt.
2 Q Okay. Well, if you look at Paragraphs 2 and
3 3, I think it says that it's related to those.
4 A It does. It does.
5 Q All right. But you don't dispute that you
6 signed this back in April of '06?
7 A I don't.
8 Q All right. So at a point in time, who
9 actually owes Club Woodlands? Do you personally owe
10 this debt or does Frazier Development owe the debt or
11 is it Frazier Construction that owes the debt or a
12 combination?
13 MR. BURWELL: Object to form.
14 A I would say it's a combination.
15 BY MR. HENDERSON:
16 Q Okay. And why do you say that?
17 A I was a member of Frazier Development. I
18 was the manager. I would say it would be more myself
19 and Frazier Development than Frazier Construction.
20 Q Did you personally owe Club Woodlands, LLC,
21 any money?
22 A No.
23 Q Okay. If you owe them 390- and then you
24 give them -- Club Woodlands, this Frazier Development
25 gives them an LLC, this agreement, but you don't know
118
1 how much credit you got, but you in your mind were
2 thinking 250- for the Flowood Developers?
3 A That's discussions that I had with Davidson.
4 Q Okay. So if you owed 390- and you got a
5 $250,000 credit after you gave them Flowood
6 Developers, did you just owe them the balance at that
7 point?
8 MR. BURWELL: Object to form.
9 A Yes, I owed them the balance. And as I
10 testified earlier, the only property that I had that
11 was unencumbered was the land at Six Shooter.
12 BY MR. HENDERSON:
13 Q Okay. Now, let's talk about that.
14 Exhibits 18 and 19 are two more assignments. Correct?
15 A Correct.
16 Q Do you remember these ones dated September
17 of '06, No. 18, and then No. 19 is dated October of
18 '06?
19 A I remember those from the meeting today. I
20 did not remember those prior to coming here today.
21 Q Okay. Let's talk about No. 18. I'll give
22 that back to you. It's dated first. This is dated
23 September of '06. Now, it's styled "Assignment." Is
24 that correct?
25 A It is.
119
1 A Correct.
2 Q And did you -- tell me why you gave this
3 assignment to Shelby Brantley. If you didn't owe him
4 any money and you didn't get any credit from him, why
5 would you sign this and give it to him?
6 A Because I was trying to repay them the debt
7 that was owed by Jackson Metro/Frazier Development.
8 And they approached me, being Davidson and Brantley,
9 at different times when they saw that the Colony
10 Crossing first sale had not gone through. It was my
11 intent to collateralize what was owed by Frazier
12 Development/Jackson Metro to Club Woodlands.
13 Q Okay. At the bottom of that first page,
14 Mr. Burwell pointed this paragraph out, Paragraph
15 No. 2, talking about the right of repurchase.
16 A Correct.
17 Q Okay. So it was clearly a purchase of
18 Mr. Brantley?
19 A Correct.
20 Q But you're telling me you still don't know
21 what the price was?
22 A That's --
23 Q I mean, isn't that what you're saying?
24 A That's what I'm saying, correct.
25 Q Okay. It also says at the top of that same
122
1 A Correct.
2 Q And that's between you individually and Club
3 Woodlands, LLC?
4 A Correct.
5 Q Okay. So this assignment is roughly a month
6 after the one you've already given Shelby Brantley
7 individually. Is that correct?
8 A Correct.
9 Q Okay. And you, again, personally are
10 assigning what in this agreement? What are you
11 transferring?
12 A My interest in Six Shooter Land & Timber.
13 Q Okay. And hadn't you just assigned that
14 same interest to Shelby Brantley on September 1st, the
15 agreement we just looked at?
16 A That's correct.
17 Q Okay. So you did it on September 1st, '06,
18 and then you turned around and did it again in
19 October of '06, but this time it didn't go to Shelby
20 individually, did it?
21 A Correct.
22 Q It went to Club Woodlands, LLC?
23 A Correct.
24 Q Okay. Was this considered to be a sale or
25 an assignment?
124
1 A In my opinion, an assignment.
2 Q Okay. And did you -- what did you receive
3 personally for signing this agreement?
4 A The Six Shooter land agreement, it was my
5 intention for it to collateralize and make up the
6 balance of the debt over and above the $250,000 that I
7 pegged for the Flowood assignment. And there were
8 several discussions that I had at different times with
9 Brantley and Davidson of when Colony Crossing sold, I
10 would pay them some $150,000, a hundred to a hundred
11 and fifty, and I would get the Six Shooter land back,
12 but that never happened. I never got the cash and I
13 was never able to make a sale from 2005 on that I got
14 any sizable amount of cash, you know, $10,000.
15 Q Well, there's no repurchase agreement in
16 this second assignment, is there?
17 A There is not.
18 Q Okay. The first agreement, you sold it to
19 Shelby, and the second agreement you gave Club
20 Woodlands an assignment?
21 A Correct.
22 Q Is that fair?
23 A That's fair.
24 MR. BURWELL: Object to the form.
25 BY MR. HENDERSON:
125
1 A Yes.
2 BY MR. BURWELL:
3 Q The 2,500 acres that Mr. Henderson asked you
4 about, you don't personally own any part of that 2,500
5 acres, do you?
6 A That's correct.
7 Q Do you know if John Davidson has signed any
8 consent or ratification to the assignment of your LLC
9 interest in Six Shooter Land & Timber?
10 A I don't know that.
11 MR. BURWELL: That's all I have.
12 MR. ELLIS: Let's go off record for a
13 minute.
14 (Off record)
15 EXAMINATION
16 BY MR. ELLIS:
17 Q Mr. Frazier, my name is Paul Ellis. I
18 represent Travelers. In my motion for the Rule 2004
19 Examination, we requested some documents. Have you
20 brought -- which was granted by the Court. Have you
21 brought those documents to the examination today?
22 A No. I just saw it last night when I met
23 with my attorney.
24 Q Okay.
25 A And I'll be glad to get to you I'd say
135
1 within 30 days --
2 Q Okay.
3 A -- what I have.
4 MR. CURTIS: We don't have most of what was
5 on the list. We don't have most of what was on the
6 list.
7 MR. ELLIS: Okay.
8 MR. CURTIS: There were a good many
9 documents there. Most of that is not available to us.
10 BY MR. ELLIS:
11 Q All right. When did you enter into the
12 charging order with the Hines with respect to I think
13 it was the Tupelo Development, LLC?
14 A I'd have to look. I don't recall. I don't
15 recall the exact date.
16 Q What year?
17 A 2006.
18 Q Do you recall about which month?
19 A I don't.
20 MR. CURTIS: May I interrupt for just a
21 moment to interject something? We did bring you some
22 of the documents, very limited, but we do have a few
23 things for you.
24 MR. ELLIS: Okay. I would appreciate
25 whatever documents you have.
136
1 A 2002.
2 Q Okay. And what was the purpose of the
3 formation of that limited liability company?
4 A To develop a shopping center in Madison.
5 Q Okay. And if you can, look on Page 20 and
6 just tell me the members and their membership
7 interest?
8 A Frazier Development and LEG Properties.
9 Q Okay. And both had a 50 membership
10 interest. Correct?
11 A Correct.
12 Q And you were the manager of Madison Market.
13 Correct?
14 A Yes.
15 Q And you were in charge of the day-to-day
16 operations?
17 A Yes.
18 Q And you were authorized by the operating
19 agreement to purchase, hold and sell property on
20 behalf of Madison Market. Correct?
21 A Yes.
22 Q Okay. The third exhibit, I believe it's 26,
23 is the HUD settlement statement from the sale of
24 Madison Market?
25 A Yes.
141
1 A I don't.
2 Q Okay. Did you give notice of the sale to
3 the members?
4 A No.
5 MS. POSEY: Okay. I think that's all the
6 questions I have.
7 EXAMINATION
8 BY MR. MARTIN:
9 Q Mr. Frazier, I'm here on behalf of the Hines
10 family and also Kay Atwood Van Skiver. Looking at
11 Exhibit 26, which appears to be the closing statement
12 for the sale of the Madison Market Shopping Center, it
13 reflects a payment to Watkins & Eager for either
14 25,000 and change or 35,000 and change; I can't
15 discern the exact amount. Do you know what those
16 funds were paid to Watkins & Eager for?
17 A Not exactly.
18 Q Do you know whether or not that represents
19 the legal fee for handling this one transaction?
20 A I assume so.
21 Q Or was it other work that you or any of your
22 companies may have engaged Watkins & Eager on?
23 A It could have been, but I'm not sure.
24 Q Okay. And you were asked about the bank
25 that had the mortgage on this property. Line 610
145
1 Plantation?
2 A My wife has dealt with several brokers, and
3 I don't recall -- I don't recall the companies, but
4 these are houses that are in foreclose and/or short
5 sales.
6 Q And so your testimony is that you personally
7 have no interest in any property at Kelly Plantation
8 at this time?
9 A I do not.
10 Q Nor have any under contract?
11 A I do not.
12 Q Where is your wife employed or does she
13 work?
14 A Presently she's employed for Fox-Everett.
15 Q In Jackson?
16 A Correct.
17 Q Where did you -- did you hunt this past
18 hunting season?
19 A I did.
20 Q Where did you hunt?
21 A In Belzoni, Mississippi.
22 Q At what club?
23 A Both my stepfather's club and Mathena
24 Wetlands.
25 Q Your stepfather's club is named what?
149
1 Development, LLC?
2 A I did.
3 Q When was that?
4 A I want to say it was 2004.
5 Q And how did you -- what exchange -- what did
6 you pay for it?
7 A It was assigned to me at the request of the
8 bonding company at the time and there was nothing
9 paid.
10 Q Did you assign or convey your interest in
11 the construction company --
12 A I did not.
13 Q -- to Austin?
14 A I never owned any of the construction
15 company. Now, let me take -- the Jackson construction
16 company. We did have a company at the time in Tupelo,
17 and I think I assigned that to him back then.
18 Q You assigned your interest in the Jackson
19 construction company or the Tupelo construction
20 company?
21 A Tupelo. I never owned any of the Jackson
22 construction company.
23 Q What is or was the name of the Tupelo
24 company?
25 A It started as Pryor & Frazier Construction,
151
1 A Yes.
2 Q On your statement of intention, you have
3 indicated that you assigned the proceeds of the sale
4 of Duck & Rice Farms, LLC, to Billy Atwood. Do you
5 recall that?
6 A I do recall that.
7 Q Okay. Have you executed a document that
8 assigns your interest in Duck & Rice Farms, LLC?
9 A I remember executing a document, among some
10 other things, in an effort to pay Billy Atwood back,
11 and I can't recall what all -- without looking at the
12 document what all was up there, but Duck & Rice Farms
13 sold, I don't know, about two or three years ago.
14 Q Did Mr. Atwood receive any of the proceeds
15 from the sale of Duck & Rice Farms?
16 A No.
17 Q Who are or were the members of the Duck &
18 Rice Farms, LLC?
19 A Frazier Development or Claiborne Frazier
20 owned 50 percent; I can't remember which one. The
21 other partner is a guy named Steve Grisham who is a
22 local farmer in Belzoni.
23 Q Okay. Do you remember executing a
24 promissory note to Kay Atwood Van Skiver --
25 A I do.
154
1 Q -- of $75,000?
2 A I do.
3 Q Is that a copy of the note?
4 A Yes.
5 MR. MARTIN: Let's have this marked.
6 (Exhibit 27 marked)
7 BY MR. MARTIN:
8 Q Did Mrs. Van Skiver loan you $75,000?
9 A She did.
10 Q That was September 15 of '06?
11 A Correct.
12 Q So you would have received her check or her
13 cash sometime around September 15th of '06?
14 A Correct.
15 Q How did you -- what did you represent to her
16 as to how you would repay that note?
17 A This document.
18 Q Okay. Among other things, it says that it
19 would be paid out of the proceeds of the sale of Duck
20 & Rice Farms, LLC.
21 A That's correct.
22 Q Okay. And you indicated that Duck & Rice
23 Farms, LLC, did sell its land?
24 A It did.
25 Q How much acreage did Duck & Rice Farms own
155
1 at that time?
2 A About 850 acres.
3 Q Okay. Do you remember who you sold it to?
4 A I don't specifically.
5 Q Okay. Would you agree with me that the sale
6 of that property occurred in October of '06?
7 A That sounds right, yes.
8 Q Okay. Let me hand you another document.
9 Does that appear to be a distribution check out of
10 that sale made payable to you as manager of Frazier
11 Development?
12 A Yes, it does.
13 Q Okay.
14 MR. MARTIN: Let's have that marked.
15 (Exhibit 28 marked)
16 BY MR. MARTIN:
17 Q Would you agree that out of the sale of Duck
18 & Rice Farms, you or Frazier Development received
19 $209,217.25?
20 A Yes.
21 Q And do you also agree on the back of --
22 well, the document that you have in front of you,
23 Exhibit 28, is a photocopy of the front and back of
24 that check?
25 A That's correct.
156
1 A Everything.
2 Q And how long has Mr. Parker been performing
3 accounting work for you and your family companies?
4 A 2004.
5 Q Since 2004?
6 A Correct.
7 Q On Page 3 of your means test calculation, on
8 Part 3 you indicate that your family income is $56,000
9 -- actually, $56,168. Is that any part of income that
10 you would have received or earned?
11 A We're still flipping.
12 MR. CURTIS: On Page 3? Oh, okay. Okay.
13 That's the -- that's the median family income for a
14 household, but he did not complete the means test
15 because his debts are primarily nonconsumer debts.
16 Apparently, that's a default figure that was
17 just put in there based on the government standards
18 for household of five people. It calculated his three
19 children in there, but actually he didn't complete
20 that. That's not really his income figure.
21 BY MR. MARTIN:
22 Q Mr. Frazier, how many people live in your
23 household?
24 A It depends on which household right now.
25 When I'm in Destin, my two kids. When I'm here at
160
1 A Robin Word.
2 Q And when did Robin Word quit being your CPA?
3 A '03.
4 Q And why did he quit being your CPA?
5 A I don't know that he quit. We, through our
6 office manager, found Bob Parker. So I don't view him
7 as quitting.
8 Q You've been asked a lot of questions about
9 the sale of property owned by Jackson Metro
10 Properties. Was there a prepayment penalty associated
11 with the sale of that property?
12 A There was.
13 Q And do you know how much that was?
14 A I don't.
15 Q Did any of the money from the sale of
16 property owned by Jackson Metro Properties go to
17 Frazier Construction?
18 A Yes.
19 Q Do you know how much?
20 A I don't.
21 Q Do you know what for?
22 A Yes. There were two large anterior
23 build-outs there were done within the Jackson Metro
24 Properties. One was for Icon Office Solutions and
25 there was monies that went to the construction company
166
1 CERTIFICATE OF REPORTER
2
3 I, MOLLY A. BENOIST, Registered Professional
4 Reporter and Notary Public in and for the State of
5 Mississippi, do hereby certify that the above and
6 foregoing pages contain a full, true and correct
7 transcript of the Rule 2004 Examination of
8 CLAIBORNE FRAZIER, taken in the aforenamed case at the
9 time and place indicated, which proceedings were
10 recorded by me to the best of my skill and ability.
11 I also certify that I placed the witness
12 under oath to tell the truth and that all answers
13 were given under that oath.
14 I certify that I have no interest, monetary
15 or otherwise, in the outcome of this case.
16
17 This the 1st day of April, 2009.
18
19 ________________________
20 MOLLY A. BENOIST, RPR
Mississippi CSR #1722
21
22 My Commissions Expires:
23 May 26, 2012
24
25