Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The purpose of this study was to examine relations between shyness-sensitivity and social
competence, school performance, and psychological well-being in Chinese children with
rural and urban backgrounds. Participants were students in rural migrant children schools
and city schools in China (Ns = 411 and 518, respectively; M age = 10 years). Data were
obtained from peer evaluations, teacher ratings, self-reports, and school records. It was
found that shyness was associated with social and school problems and depression in
urban children. However, shyness was generally associated with indexes of adjustment
such as leadership, teacher-rated competence, and academic achievement in rural migrant
children. The results indicate the role of context in defining the functional meaning of
social behavior in children’s adjustment.
http://psychology.uwo.ca/faculty/chen_res.htm
Activitatea de cercetare
Research Activities
My research focuses on children and adolescents’ socioemotional functioning and its role
in social, school, and psychological adjustment from a contextual-developmental
perspective. I am interested in the developmental processes of social competence,
shyness-inhibition, and aggression, and dispositional and socialization factors that are
involved in the processes. In the past 15 years, I have conducted, in collaboration with
my international colleagues, a series of longitudinal projects in Chinese, Canadian and
several other societies. The projects are based largely on a conceptual framework I
proposed concerning how social-cultural context is involved in two fundamental systems
of socioemotional functioning, social initiative and self-control, in human development.
The projects have tapped (1) the joint and interactive contributions of early
temperamental characteristics and parenting practices to development, and (2) the role of
peer relationships and social networks in mediating and moderating contextual influence
on individual development. In addition, my students and I have conducted several studies
concerning adjustment experiences including difficulties and strengths of different
generations of Asian children and adolescents in North America.
A central issue concerning the role of context in human development is how social and
cultural norms and values affect the significance or functional meanings of behaviors.
Our research has indicated that adaptive and maladaptive social behaviors may be defined
similarly or differently in different societies. We have found that, consistent with the
Western literature, prosocial-cooperative behavior is positively associated with indexes of
social adjustment such as peer acceptance and school achievement in Chinese children.
We have also found that aggression-disruption is related to indexes of social
maladjustment such as peer rejection and school difficulties in both Chinese and North
American children. Unlike aggressive children in North America who display mainly
externalizing problems, however, aggressive children in China experience pervasive
difficulties including both externalizing and internalizing problems such as feelings of
loneliness and depression, which is due in part to the fact that children’s behaviors are
regularly and publicly evaluated by teachers, peers, and self in Chinese schools.
Furthermore, inconsistent with the Western literature in which shyness-inhibition is
regarded as socially incompetent and immature, shy and restrained behavior is thought to
be associated with virtuous qualities such as cautiousness and modesty, indicating
accomplishment and mastery, in traditional Chinese culture; shy-inhibited children are
perceived as well behaved and understanding. Accordingly, we have found that, whereas
their counterparts in Canada experience social and psychological difficulties, shy-
inhibited children in China are accepted by peers, well adjusted to the school
environment, and less likely than others to develop psycho-emotional problems.
We are currently investigating how the social and cultural changes in the past two
decades in China affect the developmental significance of social functioning. Since early
1990s, China has carried out a full-scale reform towards a market economy, which has
led to dramatic changes in economic and social structure and organization. The
systematic changes in the society offer a unique opportunity for the exploration of
temporal and contextual influence or “era effects” on socialization and development. The
results from our recent studies have indicated that the macro-level social, economic, and
cultural changes have a pervasive impact on children’s socioemotional functioning and
adjustment.
Our research programs have provided valuable information not only about
children’s social and emotional functioning in specific societies, but also about the
developmental processes and mechanisms in general. The findings from these programs
have important practical implications for developing culturally appropriate and sensitive
policies, programs and strategies in school education and in helping youth with social,
school, and psychological problems.
We recently examined the relations between shyness and social, school, and
psychological adjustment in urban China in three cohorts (1990, 1998, 2002) of
elementary school children (Chen, Cen, Li, & He, 2005). The results indicated that
whereas shyness was positively associated with peer acceptance, leadership, and
academic achievement in the early 1990s, it was negatively associated with peer
acceptance and teacher-rated social competence and positively associated with peer
rejection and depression in 2002. The patterns of the relations between shyness and peer
relationships and adjustment variables were nonsignificant or mixed in the 1998 cohort.
The results indicated that shy, anxious, and wary behavior that impedes exploration and
self-expression in stressful situation is no longer be regarded as adaptive and competent
in social and psychological adjustment in the new competitive environment.
Consequently, shy children are at a disadvantage in obtaining social approval and
experience adjustment difficulties.
There are substantial regional differences within China, particularly between
urban and rural areas. The massive social and economic transformation has been largely
limited to urban centers and cities whereas families in rural China have lived mostly
traditional agricultural lives. We have recently been studying whether children with
different backgrounds within China differ in social functioning and adjustment.
Comprehensive longitudinal data have been collected for three large groups (urban, rural,
and rural-to-urban migrant) of elementary school children. Initial evidence indicates that
rural parents and children endorse more traditional values such as responsibility and
behavioral restraint than urban parents and children. Like their urban counterparts in the
early 1990s, rural shy Chinese children were still regarded as competent and well
adjusted socially and psychologically. We are currently examining, from a developmental
perspective, (1) how children, especially sociable-assertive and shy-sensitive children, in
rural, urban, and migrant groups differ from each other on social and psychological
adjustment, and (2) how personal and social factors (individual and social beliefs,
participation in social activities, family and peer support systems) affect the development
of children with specific behavioral qualities in the groups.
Laboratory
My laboratory for “Children’s Social Behaviour and Peer Interaction Study” located on
the second floor of the Westminster Hall. Graduate students, visiting scholars, and
undergraduate students work on different projects including children’s peer conflict, self-
regulatory behaviors, dynamic interaction processes between shy and non-shy children,
peer bullying and victimization in the school, and family interactions.
http://www.jenrussell.webs.com/research/commresearch.htm
THE IMPORTANCE OF ENVIRONMENT: THE EFFECTS OF GENDER AND
ENVIRONMENT ON COMMUNICATION APPREHENSION AMONG
INDIVIDUALS IN AN UNFAMILIAR ENVIRONMENT
INTRODUCTION
Communication apprehension is a barrier that many college students encounter as
individuals in a new and unfamiliar environment. Colleges and universities consist of a
diverse pool of students from different areas and backgrounds. Communication
apprehension affects how college students think, act, feel, and speak (Lewis-Holmes,
1997). However, communication apprehension is not isolated to the college
environment. In fact, it can follow a student into adulthood, potentially affecting future
interactions within the workplace and everyday life. McCroskey (1984) believes that
once a person enters adulthood his/her communication apprehension traits will not
change.
There are many different causes of communication apprehension (McCroskey,
1984). The purpose of this study was to examine whether a person’s primary social
environment and gender affects his/her communication apprehension levels.
How can primary social environment affect communication apprehension levels?
Neuliep and Ryan (1998) argue that culturally different individuals view each other as
strangers, which leads to communication apprehension, although cross-cultural research
regarding communication apprehension is limited (Sarquisse, Butler, & Pryor, 2003).
Social behavior between urban and non-urban individuals is also different (Witt,
1988). Social behavior includes communication with other populations, and the area in
which an individual was raised has a direct effect on social behavior (Witt, 1988). In a
review of the literature, McCroskey and Richmond (1978) found that college students
who came from rural areas had higher communication apprehension than students from
more urban areas. Unlike the aforementioned research, this study factors in the subjects
gender as well subjects from a suburban background.
A person’s sex could also have an effect on that person’s levels of communication
apprehension. One study involving four U.S. cities found that women within those urban
areas were more likely to display some kind of social phobia than men (Furmark, et. al.,
1999). Shy males are more reluctant to talk and display more social anxiety than shy
females, because females feel more of a need to be accepted by those with whom they are
communicating (Pilkonis, 1977). Due to the cultural differences between urban and non-
urban environments, males who were raised in a non-urban environment could display
more signs of communication apprehension than females who were raised in the same
environment, since females have a greater need for acceptance from others.
This study examined the effects of primary social environment and gender have
on an individual’s communication apprehension levels. Specifically, we hypothesized
that, when faced with an unfamiliar environment:
H1: Individuals who were raised in a non-urban environment will have higher
levels of communication apprehension than individuals who were raised in an urban
environment.
H2: Non-urban males will have higher levels of communication apprehension
than non-urban females.
H3: Urban females will have higher levels of communication apprehension than
urban males.
METHODOLOGY
Subjects
Seventy-five students (45 females, 30 males) participated in this study. The
subjects were volunteers from three introductory-level college writing classes at a
university in Pennsylvania, selected as a convenience sample of intact groups.
Procedures
The study was a double-blind, 2 (sex of subject) x 2 (primary social
environment--urban, non-urban) design.
The subjects were administered the four-dimensional McCroskey’s Personal
Report of Communication Apprehension (PRCA-24) and McCroskey’s Shyness Scale.
Both instruments are self-report instruments.
The questionnaires were administered by the professor who taught the three classes. The
professor read a short set of typed instructions (see attached test) to the classes before
administering the questionnaire. The professor then left the classroom so the subjects
could be debriefed on the nature of the study following completion of the questionnaire.
After all three classes had completed the questionnaire, the professor was also debriefed.
The PRCA-24 was used to test communication apprehension. According to Runey
(2001), McCroskey’s scales have been used in over 150 studies involving communication
apprehension. Subjects were also asked to disclose their major, class rank, and
hometown. Hometown was then categorized into urban or non-urban settings according
to U. S. Census Bureau data (non-urban populations were less than 10,000 people; urban
populations were 10,000 people or more). The urban and non-urban categories were
assigned so those subjects from a suburban background were eligible to be in this study.
The Shyness Scale was only administered so that subjects would remain unaware of what
the actual study was about until debriefing.
RESULTS
Hypothesis 3 stated that urban females will display higher levels of communication
apprehension than urban males. Urban males displayed lower levels of communication
apprehension (M = 50.692) overall than did urban females (M = 62.313). Results were
calculated using a t-test and 95% confidence interval, with (CV = 1.703, t = 2.03; p > .
05). The hypothesis was supported.
Furmark, T., et. al. (1999). Social phobia in the general population: prevalence and
sociodemographic profile. Retrieved December 8, 2004 from EBSCOhost database on the
World Wide Web: http://web10.epnet.com.
****
McCroskey, J.C. (1984). The communication apprehension perspective. In J.A. Daly &
J.C. McCroskey (Eds), Avoiding Communication: Shyness, Reticence, and
Communication Apprehension (pp.15-23). Beverly Hills: Sage Publications.
Neuliep, J.W. & Ryan, D.J. (1998). The influence of intercultural communication
apprehension and socio-communicative orientation on uncertainty reduction during initial
cross-cultural interaction. Communication Quarterly, 36, 88-100. Retrieved October 24,
2004 from Infotrac OneFile Database on the World Wide Web:
http://infotrac.galegroup.com
Runey, A. (2001, April 25). Theories and facts about communication apprehension.
University of Southern Maine. Retrieved October 24, 2004 from the World Wide Web:
http://students.usm.maine.edu/adam.runey/
Witt, A.L. (1988). Urban-nonurban differences in social cognition: locus of control and
perception of a just world. The Journal of Social Psychology, 129, 715-717
The Shyness Reading List
The books and articles listed here are resources on shyness. This list is maintained by The
Shyness Institute, a non-profit research institution dedicated to research regarding shyness,
social anxiety disorder, and related anxiety disorders.