You are on page 1of 8

Surrogacy India News brought you by Rotunda 

But as those affected by surrogacy know, this is far from the reality. Having advised 
hundreds of families created through surrogacy, I know that parents do not choose that 
option lightly. The vast majority have heart‐wrenchingly long and painful journeys behind 
them (tales of miscarriages, stillbirths and gruelling years of IVF disappointments). For gay 
couples, surrogacy gives the hope of a much‐wanted family, and arrangements are entered 
into with planning and care. Surrogate mothers take pride in helping to create families and, 
whether or not they are paid, the parents involved do not treat the enormous and life‐
changing gift they make lightly. Children born through surrogacy arrangements are far 
from commodities or accessories. 

Canadians seeking Indian surrogates to carry their children. 

One of the most memorable stories I did this year was on reproductive tourism — infertile 
Canadians who are travelling abroad for surrogates and egg donors because of the law in 
Canada banning payment of donor sperm or eggs or surrogacy services. 

Those who counsel infertile couples told me that it is almost impossible for anyone who 
hasn't struggled with infertility to understand how overwhelming, and almost primal is the 
urge to have babies. 

Let's embrace surrogacy and recognise the hope and wonderful gift that it brings, and let's 
celebrate and support families created in this way. 

 
Intrusive laws set parent trap  

IN 21st-century Australia, the typical family who arrives at the complicated crossroads of
commercial surrogacy is afraid and demoralised.

While many commentators would have us think they are a gay couple wanting a designer baby,
they are more likely to be heterosexual.

Increasingly Australian women are leaving childbearing until their late 30s or early 40s, either to
establish a career or given the absence of a partner. No longer producing as many or as healthy
eggs, they commonly endure repeated miscarriages and unsuccessful IVF attempts, an emotional
tightrope that can place enormous strain on relationships. Research has shown the human desire
to parent can far outweigh other life goals. And so intending parents remain determined to
explore all options to create a family.

Most of these involuntarily childless go unnoticed; embarrassed to talk about their infertility,
they suffer silently. Many have looked into adoption, only to discover just a handful of
Australian babies available each year and waiting lists of five or more years for international
adoptions. Some look at fostering, yet are deterred by the fear the child may be returned to its
biological parents.

For some it is their doctor who suggests surrogacy. Do they know a long-time friend or family
member who may agree to carry their child for love alone?

For the tiny proportion who have a potential surrogate of the right age and motivation, the long
conversation begins. Public debate on surrogacy and IVF has rightly agreed the interests of the
unborn child need to be paramount.
In Greg Donnelly's opinion piece in this paper on January 5, he quoted from a paper by ethicist
Margaret Somerville in which she wonders whether science will someday show that having both
a mother and father does matter for children's wellbeing. That's the problem with ethicists. They
stew over possibilities without talking to those affected. More useful is to consider research that
has followed up children brought up by one parent, or two parents of the same sex. For decades
such research has consistently shown it is the processes of parenting rather than the family
structure that matters. Children in same-sex or single parent families do not demonstrate any
important differences in development, happiness, peer relations or adjustment.

But what about the psychological wellbeing of children conceived through surrogacy?
Researchers from City University London published a 2006 study in the journal Human
Reproduction comparing three-year-olds conceived via surrogacy, donor insemination and
natural conception. Absence of a genetic and-or gestational link with the parents raising them
was found to have no negative influence on parent-child relationships or the psychological
wellbeing of the children.

Back in the consulting room, the reality of altruistic surrogacy "Australian style" continues to
unfold for intending parents. Would all parties agree to psychological testing? Are they aware
they have no claim on the baby if their surrogate decides to keep the child? Are they and their
surrogate prepared to undergo mandatory counselling and psychological tests? Are they prepared
for a 12-18-month work-up process, allowing for all the necessary ethics approvals?

Such a tightly regulated process means most think twice before involving a female family
member, let alone a friend. In reality, Australia's improved altruistic surrogacy laws protecting
this process will assist only a handful of parents in each state each year.

The vast majority will leave Australia to chase their dream of having children, risking much in
the process. Two Australian couples recently had their own embryos couriered to India in
preparation for implantation in a surrogate. On arrival, the embryos were refused entry, given
they lacked the correct paperwork. A Byron Bay man whose Thai surrogate bore twin girls found
himself a prisoner in his Bangkok apartment for weeks as mass demonstrations provoked
acurfew, street battles and arson.

A Queensland medical specialist ignored that state's laws banning commercial surrogacy and
entered an overseas contract, risking a criminal charge and being struck off as a doctor.

As well as such risks, intending Australian parents spend tens or hundreds of thousands of
dollars in medical, legal, travel and compensation costs in the hope of creating a family. A
Melbourne childless couple I know sold their large home, moving to a smaller one with a larger
mortgage, to afford the escalating costs in the US.

A NSW man was expecting twins by a surrogate in San Diego. He panicked when the surrogate
mother looked likely to deliver at 32 weeks. The US offers no medical insurance for twins born
to non-residents and he faced a potential neonatal intensive care bill of $US140,000, doubling his
costs.
On top of that, Australians in Queensland, the ACT and soon NSW (and Tasmania if its bill is
passed) risk a criminal penalty of $110,000, two years in prison or both, if they admit to creating
a family by compensating a woman for surrogacy overseas.

Labor MP Linda Burney, who tabled this criminalisation amendment in the NSW parliament last
December, believes children born through surrogacy "should have access to information about
the circumstances of their birth and their genetic history". I agree. Such insight is likely
important for a child's psychological wellbeing and their sense of identity.

But Australians utilising commercial surrogacy are now being pushed to do the opposite; to
conceal the child's biological parentage. Not because they don't believe in telling their child, but
to avoid a jail term.

Evidence is already showing such disincentives to commercial surrogacy are not changing
behaviour. Inquiries across Australia have shown that when faced with legal obstacles including
criminal sanctions, intending parents travel wherever necessary and pay whatever they can afford
to pursue their dream of children.

In 1938, the US magazine Fortune ran an article on contraception. The practice was still illegal in
many US states and restricted in the majority, viewed as distastefully as is surrogacy today; an
aberration of nature; an attempt by humans to interfere in God's will, robbing women of a
precious reproductive function. Yet the demand for contraception, like surrogacy, was too strong
to maintain its effective prohibition.

Western societies have seen similar problems when they have outlawed abortion, prostitution,
alcohol and illicit drug use. Australian legislators are clearly irked by the fear that surrogacy
commodifies and unfairly exploits female reproduction. Again they have not consulted the
literature or spoken with surrogates. Ironically, in the US, regardless of the monetary
compensation, the most common reason surrogates carry another's baby is to give the ultimate
gift to an otherwise childless parent. That's real altruism. In contrast, Australian legislators'
attempts to protect surrogates and intending parents are failing miserably.
The Surrogacy Lawyer Radio Program Presents Brenda Strong With 'Start the New Year Strong
With Fertility ... - Yahoo Finance

Watch: Elton John Surrogacy Birth Mocked in Video; Post Calls Furnish Elton's 'Wife' -
Towleroad

Taiwan's Next Media Animation offensively depicts Elton John and David Furnish as leather-
wearing disciplinarians who wrestle a surrogate to the floor to get her baby only after their
attempt to steal an infant from the Ukraine fails. In related news, the ...

Oprah Winfrey already weighed-in on global surrogacy, highlighting the practice in India and
happy US "customers." While involvement in global markets is important for marginalized
peoples, especially women, one should not underestimate the need for ...

This is really the main reason we have decided to open the British Surrogacy Centre in early
February," the Telegraph quoted Barrie Drewitt-Barlow as saying. But the couple believes that
the recent birth of Sir Elton John and his partner David Furnish’s ...

Marathi film on surrogacy to hit Indian screen on Feb 11 - New Kerala

Mumbai, Jan 7 : American-Marathi film on surrogate motherhood, ''Mala Aai Vhhaychy'',


directed by debutant director-producer Samruodhhi Porey is all set to hit the screens in the US on
January 15 and across India on February 11. The film shows an American ...

Gay couple to launch surrogacy centre

Many Catholic European countries have prohibited surrogacy altogether (although these
restrictions are increasingly proving untenable and reform is afoot in many places). At the other
end of the scale, certain US states, Ukraine and India allow enforceable ...

The Modern Language Assn. is holding its annual conference in Los Angeles -- during the first
week of January, for the first time in many years, rather than between Christmas and New Year's.
Professors and post-graduate students of English and the ...

Japanese Head to U.S. for Fertility Treatments - Wall Street Journal

Due to Japan’s ban on surrogacy and the restrictions placed upon egg donation ... The U.S. is the
most popular destination by far, though lower-cost countries such as India are catching on. As a
result of this boom, the demand for Asian female egg donors ...
.

 Fertility, IVF And Surrogacy Centres, Hospitals India- Low Cost IVF
We Care India in association with our partner IVF and Surrogacy specialist doctors maintain a
vast database of surrogate mothers. These ladies are recruited after a vast selection procedure of
investigations, counseling and medical and ...
 Intrusive laws set parent trap - The Australian
Intrusive laws set parent trap The Australian Two Australian couples recently had their own
embryos couriered to India in preparation for implantation in a surrogate . On arrival, the
embryos were ... and more »
 Surrogacy India, Surrogacy, Egg Donation, in India – Indian ...
Surrogacy India’s focus is in fertility, not infertility. Making babies, is possible. ‘Possible’ is
what we believe in. We understand, that infertility is not about being ...
 'Ordering' a baby from India still a legal minefield | Radio ...
Commercial surrogate motherhood has been legal in India since 2002. As prices are lower than
in the US an increasing number of American prospective parents have found their way to Indian
surrogate mothers. A number of Dutch couples have ...
 Surrogacy in India: After the Devastation : The Next Family
Kerrie Olejarz is attempting to use a surrogate in India but missed a round due to a damaged vial.
 Indian hospital transplant surgery - PRLog (free press release)
Medical Tourism India Care Medical Tourism Nigeria Heart Surgery Eye Surgery Orthopedic
Surgery Cosmetic surgery Chennai spinal surgery Chennai etc. doctors details in Chennai
Professionals Hospitals India Surrogacy India IVF Treatment in Nigeria.
 Surrogacy india, Surrogacy clinics in india, surrogacy in india
Delhi Ivf : A best place to Surrogacy india, Surrogacy clinics in india, ivf centers in india,
surrogacy in india
 Surrogacy - Surrogacy in India - IVF Clinic India - EGG Donors
Surrogacy in India, IVF Clinic India, Surrogacy ,Egg Donors - Surrogacy Abroad offers a wide
range of options to fulfill your dreams of parenthood With the most well-equipped ...
 OUR JOURNEY TO SURROGACY IN INDIA ~ BLAZE'S STORY: WE ARE HAVING ...
Much of our search turned up empty when looking into options for surrogacy . This is why we
started this BLOG to help others learn more about options for Surrogacy in India . Good Luck
with your journey and hope we have helped shed a ...
 Surrogate Mothers in India - Outsourcing Surrogacy to India ...
Customer service, tech support...these days we outsource everything to India. So why not
pregnancy? Here is a report on the growing number of Indian women willing to carry an ...
 SurrogacyIndia's Online Support Group :: Home
Surrogacy India Support Group ... Announcement: First Trip to Mumbai: Posted: Karon @ Mon
Dec 20, 2010 9:25 pm
 'Couples should go for adoptions' - Times of India
'Couples should go for adoptions' Times of India HYDERABAD: India could have become a
hub for surrogacy but senior gynaecologists gathered at the 54th All India Congress of Obstetrics
and Gynaecology ...
 13 MLA panels we missed - Los Angeles Times
The Modern Language Assn. is holding its annual conference in Los Angeles -- during the first
week of January, for the first time in many years, rather than between Christmas and New Year's.
Professors and post-graduate students of English and the ...
 Marathi film on surrogacy to hit Indian screen on Feb 11 - New Kerala
Mumbai, Jan 7 : American-Marathi film on surrogate motherhood, ''Mala Aai Vhhaychy'',
directed by debutant director-producer Samruodhhi Porey is all set to hit the screens in the US on
January 15 and across India on February 11. The film shows an American ...
 Surrogacy in India - Low Cost Indian Surrogacy
Low Cost Surrogacy in India. Indian surrogacy procedure, costs, overview and FAQ’s. Know
more about commercial surrogacy in India and availability of surrogate mothers in India.
 Tony and Barrie Drewitt-Barlow have five children from surrogate mothers - BBC News
Tony and Barrie Drewitt-Barlow have five children from surrogate mothers BBC News "Over
the years we have managed to build a database of surrogates and eggs donors, along with centres
in around the USA and India , that have very good ...
 Gay couple to launch surrogacy centre in Essex - BBC
Based in Maldon, the British Surrogacy Centre, opens in February ... along with centres in
around the USA and India, that have very good statistics," he said. "It is about sharing what we
have found out, and giving the knowledge to other people," added ...
 Japanese Head to U.S. for Fertility Treatments - Wall Street Journal
Due to Japan’s ban on surrogacy and the restrictions placed upon egg donation ... The U.S. is the
most popular destination by far, though lower-cost countries such as India are catching on. As a
result of this boom, the demand for Asian female egg donors ...
 Commercial surrogacy in India - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Commercial surrogacy in India is legal. The availability of medical infrastructure and potential
surrogates, combined with international demand, has fueled the growth of the industry. ...
 Surrogacy In India
Surrogacy, IVF, India, Egg Donor, oneinsix.com, Bobby, Nikki
 Interested in surrogacy in India? « Trying To Conceive
But despite many developed countries' regulations against commercial surrogacy , it might still
be extremely expensive for a surrogate mother to carry your baby. In India , surrogate mothers
and high quality fertility clinics are ...
 India Surrogacy
India Surrogacy arranges IVF and surrogacy services in India for couples and individuals around
the world. Why India? Because India offers the most favorable combination of:
 Surrogate India, Surrogacy in india, Egg Donor in India, Surrogate ...
Yashoda Infertility & Healthcare services, Surrogacy in india, Surrogate in india, Egg Donor in
India, Surrogate mother in india, committed team of IVF specialist & experience ...
 The Surrogacy Lawyer Radio Program Presents Brenda Strong With 'Start the New Year
Strong With Fertility ... - Yahoo Finance
About Theresa Erickson, Esq. Ms. Erickson is the managing partner of Erickson Law and the
founder and chair of Conceptual Options ( http://www.conceptualoptions.com ), The Surrogacy
and Egg Donation Center. In addition, Ms. Erickson is the author of the ...
 

 
surrogacy australia,egg donation australia,adoption australia,ivf australia,surrogate australia,surrogacy Ireland,surrogacy France,surrogacy 
uk,egg donation uk,adoption uk,ivf uk,surrogacy usa,surrogacy laws usa,surrogacy agencies usa,,surrogate mothers usa,egg donation 
usa,adoption usa,ivf usa,surrogate usa,surrogacy spain,egg donation spain,adoption spain,ivf spain,surrogacy canada,surrogacy laws 
canada,surrogate mothers canada,egg donation canada,adoption canada,ivf canada,surrogacy agencies canada,surrogate agencies in 
canada,Same‐Sex Parenting: Creating a Strong Family Life as a Gay Couple,surrogacy United Kingdom,Surrogacy 
,enmark,Norway,Sweden,Finland, Scandinavian country,egg donation india,surrogacy india,surrogate india,sperm donor india,infertility india, 
ivf egg donation,india low cost egg donation,egg donation program india,ovum donation india,quality infertility treatments donation,surrogacy 
india,gestational surrogacy india,surrogacy agencies india,egg donation india,adoption india,ivf india,surrogate motherhood india,surrogacy 
india oprah,surrogacy india forum,surrogate india,gestational surrogacy india,surrogacy agencies india,egg donation india,adoption india,ivf 
india,surrogate motherhood india,Surrogacy Canada,surrogacy USA,surrogacy Australia,surrogacy Ireland,surrogacy France,surrogacy 
UK,Surrogacy India,Gestational surrogacy india,surrogacy,Gay Dads Canada,Gay Dads USA,Gay Dads Australia,Gay Dads Ireland,Gay Dads 
France,Gay Dads UK,Gestational surrogacy India,Mommy Mommy,Two Men and Two Babies,Gay Dads RockS,same sex,samesame,Same‐sex 
Couples 

You might also like