You are on page 1of 4

p

pm  
    
 
p
pWhat does WorldCom¶s experience teach us about corporate wrongdoing?

Y p p p 

p
p   p 
p 

p  p  p p   p  p p


 p  
p p p p 
p p  p 
p pp  p   p   p
Y p p p  p
  p  p p !pp


p ppp p  "  p 


pp p  p ppp  p p# pp  pp

pp   p p 


pp  p pp pp ppp p p 
p pp
p  p  p   p   pp

Y p p p p p 


p pp  p Y p p 
ppp p !p  p p
pp  p  pp p
  p  p p
 pp

Y p pp p 


!
pp pp p  p p p 
p p 
pp

$p  p p  p  


!
p p p p  p  p p  p  p p #p  p    p p
 
!
 p
%p  p p p  p
pp p  pp p p
p p
 pp
p
&'What does Cynthia Cooper¶s experience teach us about courage?

p  

p p p p  p  p p p  p  p   p p p   "   p
(

p pp
ppp p p  "   p)p p 

p p p%p
 pp 
p  p p
p p p p p p p
 pY p pp p
 p p  p p p p p  p p p
pppp * 
  p 
p
p
  p p p   p 
  p
p   p Y p  #p  p p  
p p  p %p  p p  p
 p p  p p
 p  p pp p+p

pp  p
p p

p* p p


* 
   p , p  p p p 

p p  p   p 
p   
p
p -.p 

/p
01222p#p
p  p p pp p p  p  p pp  p #p pp
  p+p p p #pp p  p  p  p p p p p 
ppp  p, p p
 p p pp  p p p  p ppp
p p p   pY p p
  p pp   p  pp p  p  p p# pp pp 
/pp
pp
 p #pp p  "  %p p
pp p #pp p p
 p

c  
 c   
p
m  
      
  
!
&'Who is right in this dispute National Semi-conductor or the Department of Defense? Explain your
answer.  p p %p 3  
p  ! p  p   p p  p   p , p  p
  "  p p p
pp

 ppp

p p
 p4 p


%p ppp p pp


 p  p 
p p p  p    p p 5
p  p  p 
p p  
p 
p p
 p p 
p p p # p p  p p 
 p +p p # p p  
p p  p p  p
  "  %p  p p  p  
p p  p   "  p p p  
%p p p p  p  
p

 pY p   "  p 
p #p  ppp p  p p p p p p pp
 p #p  p

p  p pp      pp5
p  "  p 
p p
p
p
p  

pp p  p
p p p p pp p  p   ppp  p  p

p p  p p p  p  p p  p p 3  
p 
p 

p p  p p  p


  p +p 
p 6p p  p  
%p p  p p   p Y %p p  p p 
p  p
3  
p ! p p  p p p  pp
p
&pWhat are the practical consequences of accepting the position of the Department of Defense? Of
accepting the position of National Semi-conductor? In light of these practical consequences, which
position do you think society should adopt? p
p
Consequences of accepting the position of Department of defense are mentioned below- p
p
1.p Y p
p pp 
p
pp 
p pp p p p p   p  p
p p p p pp  
p  %p p p p  pp  p p  
p pp
 p p pp
p p  p  p p p p p  p p p p p
 ! p p 
    p p   p ÷. Y p  p p p #p  p  
p
 
p p  p  p p  p  p 
p p p p p  p   p 3  
p

pp p  p p p

p 
pp p+p
pp
pp  
p p p
 %p p # pp

p  p  p p p p
p pp

 p, p p
 p  "  p p p 
p p  
p p p p p  p7  p  p  p p


pp p  "   pp
÷.p p
Consequences of accepting the position of Department of defense are mentioned below- p
p
1.p +p p  p   p p  
p p p 
p p p  pp
p p pp
p  
p  
p p p pp
  
p p
p p  p÷. 
p p p p
 pp p  p   ppp  p  p
p p p pp p pp
 p p 3  
p 
p 

p p  p p  p   p +p 


p 6p p  p
 
%p p pp  pppp 
 p p %p  
p ! p
p
p  p  p  
p p p  p   p +p
 p p  p   
p 7 %p  p
 
p p p  pp pp p, pp # p p  p  p p
 
p  
p   p p %p p p p 

p p p  
p   p  pp pp
  p p p p   p  p
p
p
p
p
p

c  
 c    
p
m  
 "# $  
p
&pWhat are the systemic, corporate and individual ethical issues raised by this case? p
p
Systemic ethical issues: Y p p 
p  p pp p p p p

8pp
p p  p  %p 
p p #  p p  p  p p 9  p p + p  p p  p #  p

p ppp  
p#p
#p
  p p 
%p   p p p p p p p p  pp

+p:222%pY p  p p,   p


  p p#p pp p
pp p 
 "p

p p
  p, p p pppp p 
   pp

 
p p 
 p   p  %p   p  %p   p  
p   %p
   %p p pp  
p 
p    p   p#p p  p, p
 p p #p p p ppp p p p 
pp p p pp p 
p   pp
p
Corporate ethical issues: 3p
p p p p
p p p 
p  p p p p  pp


p p 
p # p  p#p p p p p pp p
 p; #p) pp
%p %p+ p< #ppppp% %p p p
#p =%3
p(p p p pp

3p 
p  
p  # p   p  p
p  p    p  p p   p p  p
p
p  
p
#p p  
p 
p p, p

 p p 

p pp
p
Individual Ethical issues:  pp p
pp   pp p
   pp pppp

p
%p
p 
ppp#  p p#p

 p, p p  p pp9  p


p+ p p#  p p p pp#p

 pp
Y p  p p   %p   p p    p p p  p p p p  p %p   
p #p p

  p p 
%p   p p p p p p p p p  pp

&pIn your view is the kind of child slavery discussed in this case absolutely wrong no matter what,
or is it only relatively wrong ,i.e., if one happens to live in a society (like ours) that disapproves of
slavery? p
p
+p #p p p %p p p p p  p p p# pp
p
p pp
 
pp
 p p 

p pY p p

p 

p p  p p  pYp  p p
p pp
 p#p

p p

pp
 
 pp
p
&p Who shares in the moral responsibility for the slavery occurring in the chocolate industry;
African farmers? African government? American chocolate companies like Hershey, Mars, Nestley
and Kraft foods? Distributers like Archer Daniels Midland Co., Barry Callebaut and Cargill Inc?
Consumers like you and I who know about the situation but continue to purchase tainted
chocolate? p
p
+p  #p p p  p  
p p  p p  p  p p p  
p   p +p p p

 p p  
p
#p   p  %p   p  %p p   p  
p  %p
   %p  p p  p 4 p p  p p  p    p  p 

p  p p
   pp

p 
p #p  p%pp p p p p p
pp
p
p #p p  p
p

c  
 c   
p
m  
 %&'  (
p
&pWas Tiwari justified in placing the order on the pretext that prices could go up? p
p
3%pY   p pp p

p   p p
 p  p pp  p  
pp  p pY p  p
pY   p p p pp p
 
p p p  pp p  pp
Y   p 
p p
p p  pp
 p ppp

Y p  p  p 
pp #p
p ppp


   p Y   p  p  p   p  %p  p p 
 p   p p p p  
p
p p

p p  p p p p p  
p p p p p p
p p p  p p

p
 #p
 pp

Y   p 
p
p p
p9  %p p   p pp p pp

)p pp  p p


 p pp p9  p pp
p
&pWhat action should be taken so that such problems do not recur? What action, if any, should be
taken against Tiwari? p
p
Y p

 ppp  p pp #pp p p


ppp 8pp
Y p  p
pp 
pp pp
"pp

  p p 
pp p p 
pp  p p p pp p p p p
pp

Y p  p
p 
pp pp  pp

p  


p     p  
p p   p p  p p  # p p 
p   p  p
5pp   p  p p p  p  pp
p
Y   p 
pp  pp p  #p p p p p p p p pp pp
 
p  p p  p )p  
p p  p p  p   p  p p  p 
 p p  p
 p #p  p p 
pp p5 
pp p
ppp p p p  #p
pp  p

c  
 c   
p