Professional Documents
Culture Documents
MICRO FINANCE
model and the MFI model. The SBLP model SBLP. Internationally however, a lot of
has emerged as the dominant model in terms groundwork and consultative efforts had been
of number of borrowers and loans in progress since the 1980s, which set a
outstanding. In terms of coverage, this model backdrop for micro finance efforts in India. The
is considered to be the largest micro finance field of micro finance is diverse and still evolving.
programme in the world. The Reserve Bank, There is no single approach or model that fits in
NABARD and SIDBI have also taken a range of all the circumstances. The concept of micro
initiatives to provide a momentum to the finance implies informal and flexible approach
micro finance movement in India. The to the credit needs of the poor. As such, each
developments relating to evolution of various model has to be tailored according to the
models of the micro finance movement are circumstances and the local needs. It is in this
detailed in the present section. context that a study of different models of micro
finance developed internationally becomes
SHG-Bank Linkage Programme interesting. One of the oldest and most
5.7 The micro finance sector started getting successful models internationally has been the
recognition in India after the launch of the Grameen Bank Model in Bangladesh (Box V.1).
197
Report on Trend and Progress of Banking in India, 2007-08
5.8 As early as December 1984, the Fifth for channeling the flow of savings and credit
General Assembly of the Asia Pacific Regional between the rural poor and banks through
Agricultural Credit Association (APRACA) held SHGs and identify concrete projects for action
at Bangkok exhorted the agricultural and research in this field. Accordingly, in February
rural development finance institutions in the 1987, it was decided that a study team led by
region to mobilise savings from the rural areas NABARD and comprising of representatives
with the objective of providing loanable funds from various financial institutions, should be
for agriculture and rural development. The constituted to undertake the survey. The
experience in some of the countries where survey was undertaken in September 1987
informal self help groups (SHGs) of rural and the report discussed at the 18th
people which promoted savings among Executive Committee Session and 10th
members and used these resources for Foundation Anniversary of APRACA held at
meeting their credit needs, were considered New Delhi in November 1987. This survey
useful innovations. Further, the Third report laid the foundation of the SHG-bank
Consultation on the Scheme for Agricultural linkage programme in India launched as a
Credit Development (SACRED) held at Rome pilot project in 1992.
in 1985 called for active promotion of linkages 5.10 The pilot project was launched by
between banking institutions and SHGs as a NABARD after extensive consultations with
mean of improving the access of low income Reserve Bank, commercial banks and non-
group to banking services. The Executive Governmental Organisations (NGOs) with the
Committee Session of APRACA held at Seoul following objectives: (i) to evolve
in October 1985 approved the holding of a supplementary credit strategies for meeting
South-East Asian sub-regional workshop to the credit needs of the poor by combining the
devise ways and means of improving such flexibility, sensitivity and responsiveness of
linkages. The APRACA Regional Workshop the informal credit system with the strength of
held at Nanjing, China in May 1986 technical and administrative capabilities and
recommended national level consultation and financial resources of the formal credit
organisation of national surveys of SHGs in institutions; (ii) to build mutual trust and
collaboration with APRACA and other confidence between the bankers and the rural
agencies. poor; and (iii) to encourage banking activity,
5.9 The Sixth General Assembly of both on the thrift as well as on credit sides, in
APRACA held at Kathmandu, Nepal in a segment of the population that the formal
December 1986 considered a project proposal financial institutions usually find difficult to
on ‘promotion of linkages between banking cover.
institutions and SHGs in rural savings 5.11 The SHGs were expected to facilitate
mobilisation and credit delivery to the rural collective decision making by the poor and
poor’. It was decided that each member provide ‘doorstep banking’, the banks as
country would form a Task Force to conduct a wholesalers of credit, were to provide the
survey of SHGs and thereafter, formulate resources, while the NGOs were to act as
suitable national level programmes. agencies to organise the poor, build their
Consequent upon this, a Task Force was set capacities and facilitate the process of
up in India in the Ministry of Agriculture, to empowering them. It was expected that the
identify the existing SHGs, undertake a pilot project would prove advantageous to
survey of the groups and draw a plan of action both banks as well as the SHGs. The banks
198
Micro Finance
would gain by a way of reduction in their 5.13 Under the SBLP, the following three
transaction costs due to reduction in work different models have emerged:
relating to appraisal, supervision and
● Model I: SHGs promoted, guided and
monitoring of loans. The SHGs would benefit
financed by banks.
by getting access to a larger quantum of
resources, as compared to their meager ● Model II: SHGs promoted by NGOs/
corpus generated through thrift. The banks Government agencies and financed
were expected to provide credit in bulk to the by banks.
group and the group, in turn, would ● Model III: SHGs promoted by NGOs and
undertake on-lending to the members. The financed by banks using NGOs/formal
quantum of credit given to the group by the agencies as financial intermediaries.
bank would be in proportion to the savings
5.14 Model II has emerged as the most
mobilised by the group and could vary from
popular model under the SBLP programme.
1:1 to 1:4. It was prescribed that the purposes
Commercial banks, co-operative banks and
for which the group would lend to its members
the regional rural banks have been actively
should be left to the common wisdom of the
participating in the SBLP.
group. The rate of interest to be charged by the
SHG to its members was also left to the group Micro Finance Institution Approach
to decide. The pilot project envisaged linking
of only 500 SHGs to banks. By the end of 5.15 While the SBLP model remains the most
March 1993, 225 SHGs were actually linked. widely used model of micro finance in India, the
With the figure reaching 620 at the end of MFI model has also gained momentum in the
March 1994, the pilot project was a success. recent past. The MFI model in India is
characterised by a diversity of institutional and
5.12 The programme has since come a long legal forms. MFIs in India exist in a variety of
way from the pilot project of financing 500 forms like trusts registered under the Indian
SHGs across the country. It has proved its Trust Act, 1882/Public Trust Act, 1920;
efficacy as a mainstream programme for societies registered under the Societies
banking with the poor, who mainly comprise Registration Act, 1860; Co-operatives
the marginal farmers, landless labourers, registered under the Mutually Aided Co-
artisans and craftsmen and others engaged in operative Societies Acts of the States; and non-
small businesses such as hawking and banking financial companies (NBFC)-MFIs,
vending in the rural areas. The main which are registered under Section 25 of the
advantages of the programme are timely Companies Act, 1956 or NBFCs registered with
repayment of loans to banks, reduction in the Reserve Bank. These MFIs are scattered
transaction costs both to the poor and the across the country and due to the multiplicity
banks, doorstep “saving and credit” facility for of registering authorities, there is no reliable
the poor and exploitation of the untapped estimate of the number of MFIs. The most
business potential of the rural areas. The frequently used estimate is that their number
programme, which started as an outreach is likely to be around 800. Attempts have been
programme has not only aimed at promoting made by some of the associations of MFIs like
thrift and credit, but also contributed Sa-Dhan to capture the business volume of the
immensely towards the empowerment of the MFI sector. As per the Bharat Micro Finance
rural women. Report of Sa-Dhan, in March 2008, the 223
199
Report on Trend and Progress of Banking in India, 2007-08
member MFIs of Sa-Dhan had an outreach of 24, 2008, in addition to entities already
14.1 million clients with an outstanding micro permitted earlier, subject to appropriate due
finance portfolio of Rs.5,954 crore. diligence.
200
Micro Finance
set up by NABARD in 1999 of which the maximum flexibility with regard to micro
Reserve Bank was a member. The Task Force lending. Such credit was to cover not only
looked into the entire gamut of issues related consumption and production loans for various
to micro finance, particularly regulatory farm and non-farm activities of the poor, but
issues. Recognising the growing importance of also include their other credit needs. Banks
micro finance, the Reserve Bank constituted a were asked to delegate adequate sanctioning
micro credit special cell in the Bank in 1999 to powers to branch managers and to keep the
suggest measures for mainstreaming micro loan procedures and documents simple for
credit and accelerating flow of credit to MFIs. providing prompt and hassle free micro credit.
The special cell has since been converted into
5.25 The rapid development of the sector
a micro finance and financial inclusion
necessitated addressing the various issues
division in the Reserve Bank.
associated with the sector. In October 2002,
5.23 Several non-banking finance the Reserve Bank set up four informal groups
companies (NBFCs) and residuary non- to look into issues relating to: (i) structure and
banking companies (RNBCs) also started sustainability; (ii) funding; (iii) regulations;
entering the micro finance sector, gradually and (iv) capacity building of micro finance
recognising the potential in the sector. In institutions. Taking into consideration the
order to further facilitate the process, in recommendations of the groups, banks were
January 2000, all NBFCs and RNBCs were advised that they should provide adequate
advised by the Reserve Bank that those incentives to their branches for financing the
NBFCs which were engaged in micro financing SHGs and that the group dynamics of working
activities, licensed under Section 25 of the of the SHGs should be left to them.
Companies Act, 1956, and which were not
accepting public deposits were exempted from 5.26 Based on the recommendations of the
the purview of Sections 45-IA (registration), Advisory Committee on Flow of Credit to
45-IB (maintenance of liquid assets) and 45-IC Agriculture and Related Activities from the
(transfer of a portion of profits to Reserve Banking System (Chairman: Prof. V S Vyas),
Fund) of the Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934. which submitted its final report in June 2004,
it was announced in the Annual Policy
5.24 Based on the reports of the special cell
Statement for the year 2004-05 that in view of
constituted in the Reserve Bank and the Task
the need to protect the interest of depositors,
Force on Supportive Policy and Regulatory
MFIs would not be permitted to accept public
Framework, the Reserve Bank issued
deposits unless they complied with the extant
comprehensive guidelines to banks in
regulatory framework of the Reserve Bank.
February 2000 for mainstreaming micro credit
However, as an additional channel for
and enhancing the outreach of micro credit
resource mobilisation, the Reserve Bank in
providers. These guidelines, inter alia,
April 2005 enabled NGOs engaged in micro
stipulated that micro credit extended by
finance activities to access the external
banks to individual borrowers directly, or
commercial borrowings (ECBs) up to US$ 5
through any intermediary, would from then
million during a financial year for permitted
onwards be reckoned as part of their priority
end use, under the automatic route.
sector lending. Banks were given freedom to
formulate their own model/s or choose any 5.27 In order to examine issues relating to
conduit/intermediary for extending micro rural credit and micro finance, an internal
credit. Banks were also permitted to prescribe group (Chairman: Shri H.R. Khan) was set up
their own lending norms so as to provide in 2005. Based on the recommendations of
201
Report on Trend and Progress of Banking in India, 2007-08
the group and with the objective of ensuring scheduled commercial banks to follow the
greater financial inclusion and increasing the example set by some public sector banks and
outreach of the banking sector, banks were meet the entire credit requirements of SHG
permitted in January 2006 to use the services members, namely: (a) income generation
of NGOs/SHGs, MFIs (other than NBFCs) and activities; (b) social needs like housing,
other civil society organisations as education, marriage: and (c) debt swapping.
intermediaries in providing financial and Consequent upon this, in April 2008, banks
banking services through business facilitator were advised by the Reserve Bank to meet the
and business correspondent models. entire credit requirements of SHG members,
5.28 All Regional Directors of the Reserve as envisaged in the Union Budget.
Bank were advised in April 2006 that
Recent Initiatives by NABARD
whenever issues relating to micro finance
were noticed in the areas under their 5.31 NABARD has been playing a crucial
jurisdiction, they may offer to constitute a developmental role for the micro finance
coordination forum comprising sector in India. NABARD has been organising/
representatives of SLBC convenor banks, sponsoring training programmes and
NABARD, SIDBI, State Government officials, exposure visits for the benefit of bank officials,
and representatives of MFIs (including NGOs, SHGs and Government agencies to
NBFCs) and NGOs/SHGs to facilitate enhance their effectiveness in the field of
discussion on the issues affecting the micro finance. The best practices and
operations in the sector and find local innovations with respect to the sector are
solutions to the local problems. widely circulated among Government
5.29 In May 2006, a joint fact-finding study agencies, banks and NGOs. NABARD also
was conducted by Reserve Bank and a few provides support for capacity building,
major banks. It was observed during the study exposure and awareness building of the SHGs
that some of the MFIs financed by banks or and NGOs.
acting as their intermediaries/partners were 5.32 NABARD launched the ‘Micro-
focussing on relatively better banked areas Enterprise Development Programme’ (MEDP)
and trying to reach out to the same set of poor, for skill development in March 2006. The basic
resulting in multiple lending and objective was to enhance the capacities of
overburdening of rural households. Further, matured SHGs to take up micro enterprises
many MFIs supported by banks were not through appropriate skill upgradation. The
engaging themselves in capacity building and programme envisaged development of
empowerment of the groups to the desired enterprise management skills in existing or
extent and banks did not appear to be new livelihood activities, both in farm and non-
engaging them with regard to their systems, farm sectors. The duration of training can vary
practices and lending policies with a view to between 3 to 13 days depending upon the
ensuring better transparency and adherence objective and the nature of training. During the
to best practices. Guidelines were, therefore, year 2007-08, 394 MEDPs were conducted
issued to banks in November 2006, advising covering 9,182 SHG members on activities like
them to take appropriate corrective action. bee-keeping, mushroom cultivation,
5.30 The Union Budget for the year 2008-09 horticulture and floriculture, vermi-compost/
announced that banks would be encouraged organic manure preparation and dairy. As on
to embrace the concept of total financial March 31, 2008, 674 MEDPs had been
inclusion. The Government would request all conducted covering 16,761 participants.
202
Micro Finance
5.33 In 2005-06, a pilot project for and Navi Mumbai involving grant of Rs.3.8
‘promotion of micro-enterprises’ was launched lakh. In addition, NABARD also provides
among members of matured SHGs. This is promotional grant support to NGOs, RRBs,
being implemented by 14 NGOs acting as DCCBs, farmer’s clubs and individual
‘micro-enterprise promotion agency’ (MEPA) volunteers and assists in developing capacity
in nine districts, viz., Ajmer (Rajasthan), building of various partner agencies. NABARD
Chandrapur (Maharashtra), Kangra has been making efforts to increase the
(Himachal Pradesh), Madurai (Tamil Nadu), number of partner institutions as self-help
Mysore (Karnataka), Panchmahal (Gujarat), promoting institutions (SHPIs).
24 north Pargana (West Bengal), Puri (Orissa) 5.35 NABARD launched a pilot project in
and Rae Bareli (Uttar Pradesh). The project is December 2003 to link post-offices with the
being implemented by each NGO in two blocks SHGs with the objective of examining the
in each of the selected district. As on March feasibility of utilising the vast network of post
31, 2008, 2,759 micro-enterprises were offices in rural areas for disbursement of
established under the project involving bank credit to rural poor on an agency basis (Box
credit of Rs.238 lakh. V.2).
5.34 NABARD also provides marketing 5.36 The SHG Federations are emerging as
support to the SHGs for exhibiting their important players in nurturing SHG,
products. During the year 2007-08, NABARD increasing the bargaining power of group
supported three exhibitions of products members and livelihood promotion. The
prepared by various SHGs at Bhopal, Chennai features and functions of SHG federation
203
Report on Trend and Progress of Banking in India, 2007-08
models promoted in the country vary, per cent of the total professional fees of the
depending on the promoting agencies. credit rating agency, subject to a maximum of
Recognising the growing role of the SHG Rs. one lakh. The assistance is available for
Federations and their value addition to SHG the first rating of MFIs with a minimum loan
functioning, NABARD, during the year 2007- outstanding of Rs.50 lakh and maximum loan
08 decided to support the Federations on a outstanding of Rs.500 lakh. During the year
model neutral basis. Support is extended to 2007-08, rating support amounting to Rs 3
the Federation by way of grant assistance for lakh to four agencies was provided.
training, capacity building and exposure visits
5.39 Recognising the need for upscaling the
of SHG members. NABARD has also
micro finance intervention in the country, the
formulated the broad norms for deciding the
Union Finance Minister, in the budget for the
grant of financial assistance to SHG
year 2000-01, announced creation of a Micro
Federations. During the year 2007-08, grant
Finance Development Fund (MFDF). The
assistance amounting to Rs 10 lakhs was
sanctioned to two federations. objective of the MFDF is to facilitate and
support the orderly growth of the micro
5.37 Recognising the role played by MFIs, in finance sector through diverse modalities for
extending micro finance services in the enlarging the flow of financial services to the
unbanked areas, NABARD extends support to poor, particularly for women and vulnerable
these institutions through grant and loan sections of society, consistent with
based assistance. NABARD has been sustainability. Consequently MFDF with a
selectively supporting MFIs for experimenting corpus of Rs.100 crore was established in
with various micro finance models such as NABARD. The Reserve Bank and NABARD
replication of Grameen Model, NGO contributed Rs.40 crore each to the fund,
networking (bigger NGOs supporting smaller while the balance was contributed by eleven
NGOs), credit unions and SHGs federations, select public sector banks.
among others, to meet credit requirements of
the unreached poor. NABARD provides loan 5.40 As per the Union Budget
funds in the form of revolving fund assistance announcement for the year 2005-06, the
(RFA) on a selective basis to MFIs to be used MFDF was re-designated as ‘Micro Finance
by them for on-lending to SHGs or individuals. Development and Equity Fund’ (MFDEF) with
This loan has to be repaid along with service an increased corpus of Rs.200 crore. The fund
charge, within a period of 5 to 6 years. During is being managed by a board consisting of
the year 2007-08, RFA amounting to Rs.8 representatives of NABARD, commercial
crore was sanctioned to six agencies taking banks and professionals with domain
the cumulative credit sanctioned to Rs.36 knowledge. The Reserve Bank is a member of
crore covering 35 agencies. the Advisory Committee of the MFDEF.
5.38 In order to identify, classify and rate 5.41 The MFDEF maintained by NABARD is
MFIs, NABARD introduced a scheme for used for promotion of micro finance through
commercial banks and RRBs to enable them scaling-up of the SHG-bank linkage
to avail the services of accredited rating programme, extending RFA and capital
agencies for rating of MFIs. Banks can avail support to MFIs and undertake various
the services of credit rating agencies like promotional initiatives. During 2007-08,
CRISIL, M-CRIL, ICRA, CARE and Planet Rs.27 crore was utilised from the fund
Finance for rating of MFIs and avail financial towards micro finance related activities
assistance by way of grant to the extent of 100 (Box V.3).
204
Micro Finance
(v) Rating of MFIs and self regulation. (v) Administrative subsidies and grants.
Management Information Services (MIS) (vi) Administering Charges.
(i) Supporting systems management with regard to MIS, Management of Fund
accounting, internal controls, audits and impact
The Fund is being managed and administered by NABARD.
assessment.
The interest accrued/ income earned from the fund is
(ii) Building an appropriate data base and supporting ploughed back to the fund. The administrative charges
development thereof. incurred by NABARD in conduct of Advisory Board meeting
Regulatory and Supervisory Framework and salaries, allowances of the NABARD staff involved in
micro finance programmes will be met out of the Fund on
Recommending regulatory and supervisory framework such basis as may be determined from time to time. As per
based on an on-going review. extant practice, meetings of the banks contributing to the
Studies and Publications MFDEF will be convened from time to time in which they
will be informed regarding the status and utilisation of
(i) Commissioning studies, consultancies, action
fund.
research, evaluation studies, etc., relating to the
sector. Advisory Body to MFDEF
(ii) Promoting seminars, conferences and other The Advisory Board guides and renders advice on the
mechanisms for discussion and dissemination. various aspects relating to the micro finance sector. The
(iii) Granting support for research Board determines its own procedures for day-to-day
(iv) Documentation, publication and dissemination of working, including constitution of committees and task
micro finance literature. forces, among others, for examination of various issues.
The Advisory Board meets at such intervals as deemed
Others necessary but in any case once in a quarter to review the
Any other activities recommended by the Advisory status and progress of outflow and to render policy advice
Board to Fund. for orderly growth and development of the sector.
205
Report on Trend and Progress of Banking in India, 2007-08
5.42 The North-Eastern Council (NEC), position in the Indian micro finance sector.
Shillong parked a fund of Rs.50 lakh with Today, SIDBI is one of the largest providers of
NABARD during the year 2007-08 for micro finance through the MFIs.
facilitating miscellaneous training
5.46 SIDBI’s pilot programme of 1994
programmes involving Government/bank
brought out one of the major shortcomings in
officials, NGOs, SHGs from States in the NER
micro finance lending programme. It showed
and Sikkim. During the year 2007-08, 73
that collateral-based lending does not work
programmes were sanctioned out of the fund
insofar as micro finance is concerned. NGOs/
involving a total grant assistance of
MFIs acting as financial intermediaries do not
Rs.45 lakh.
have tangible collateral to offer as security for
the loans. Doing away with collateral-based
Micro Finance Initiatives by SIDBI
lending in MF necessitated that a mechanism
5.43 SIDBI launched its micro finance be developed which would minimise the risks
programme in February 1994 on a pilot basis. associated with lending. With a view to
The programme provided small doses of credit catering to this objective, SIDBI pioneered the
funds to the NGOs all across the country. concept of capacity assessment rating (CAR)
NGOs acted as financial intermediaries and for the MFIs. As part of its developmental
on-lent funds to their clients. Limited amount agenda, SIDBI encouraged a private sector
of capacity building grant was also provided to development consulting firm to develop a
the NGOs. rating tool for the MFIs which was rolled out in
5.44 With a view to reducing the procedural 1999. Today, rating is a widely accepted tool in
bottlenecks, expanding the outreach, meeting this sector. SIDBI has also succeeded in
the huge unmet demand of the sector and developing a market for rating services. Two
striving towards its formalisation, SIDBI mainstream rating agencies, viz., CRISIL and
reoriented its policy and approach to create a CARE have also started undertaking micro
sustainable micro finance model that would finance ratings, besides M-CRIL. SIDBI has
significantly increase the flow of credit to the also adopted the institutional capacity
sector. To take the agenda forward, the SIDBI assessment tool (I-CAT) of access development
Foundation for Micro Credit (SFMC) was services (ADS), a private sector consulting
created in January 1999. SFMC’s mission is organisation, for rating of start-up/small and
“to create a national network of strong, viable mid-sized MFIs.
and sustainable Micro Finance Institutions 5.47 SIDBI introduced a product called
from the informal and formal financial sector ‘transformation loan’ in 2003 to enable the
to provide micro finance services to the poor, MFIs to transform themselves from an
especially women’’. informal set up to more formal entities. This
5.45 SIDBI was one of the first institutions loan is a quasi-equity product with longer
that identified and recognised NGO/MFI route repayment period and features for conversion
as an effective delivery channel for reaching into equity at a later date, when the MFI
financial services to those segments of the decides to convert itself into a corporate
population not reached by the formal banking entity. Consequently, a number of MFIs went
network. As a result of bulk lending funds ahead with the transformation and some of
provided, coupled with intensive capacity them have now grown significantly and are
building support to the entire micro finance serving millions of clients across several
sector, it has come to occupy a significant states. Recognising the need to offer the MFIs
206