Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Prepared for
JUNE 2010
June 2010
Historical Records Review and Site Inspection Report
FINAL
Army National Guard Training Site - Camp Edwards,
Massachusetts Military Reservation, MA
Page 2 of 4
June 2010
Prepared for:
Prepared by
15299457
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
TABLE OF CONTENTS
TABLE OF ACRONYMS........................................................................................................V
i
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
ii
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
7. CONCLUSIONS............................................................................................................ 7-1
LIST OF APPENDICES
LIST OF TABLES
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure ES-1: Closure Programs for MRSs and AOCs – Camp Edwards/MMR.........................xv
Figure 2-1: Location Map – MMR ......................................................................................... 2-3
Figure 2-2: Draft Occupancy Map (February 2007)............................................................... 2-6
Figure 2-3: Operational Range Delineations – Camp Edwards.............................................. 2-7
Figure 4-1: Bayonet Ranges BY1, BY2 and BY4, as cited in CTT Range Inventory
iii
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
iv
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
TABLE OF ACRONYMS
Acronym Definition
AAATC Anti-aircraft Artillery Training Center
ACSIM Assistant Chief of Staff for Installation Management
A-E Architect-Engineer
AEC Army Environmental Command
AEDB-R Army Environmental Database-Restoration
AFCEE Air Force Center for Engineering and the Environment
A/I Active/inactive
ANG Air National Guard
AO Administrative Order
AOC Areas of concern
ARID Army Range Inventory Database
Army U.S. Army
ARNG Army National Guard
ARS Advance Range Survey
ASP Ammunition Supply Point
ASR Archives Search Report
BOMARC Boeing Michigan Aeronautical Research Center
BRAC Base Realignment and Closure
CERCLA Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and
Liability Act
CFR Code of Federal Regulations
CHPPM U.S. Army Center for Health Promotion and Preventive Medicine
CSM Conceptual Site Model
CTC Cost-to-Complete
CTT Closed, transferring, and transferred
DERP Defense Environmental Restoration Program
DMM Discarded military munitions
DoD Department of Defense
DVA Department of Veterans Affairs
EDMS Environmental Data Management System (here, an MMR website)
EDR Environmental Data Resources
EOD Explosive ordnance disposal
EPA U.S. Environmental Protection Agency
E&RC Environment and Readiness Center (of the Massachusetts Army
National Guard)
FUDS Formerly Used Defense Sites
v
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
Acronym Definition
FY Fiscal year
GIS Geographic information system
HE High explosive
HRR Historical Records Review
IAGWSP MMR Impact Area Groundwater Study Program
INRMP Integrated Natural Resources Management Plan
IROD Interim Record of Decision
IRP Installation Restoration Program
ITRC Interstate Technology and Regulatory Council
LPA Limited public access
MAANG Massachusetts Air National Guard
MAARNG Massachusetts Army National Guard
MADEP Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection
MC Munitions constituents
MEC Munitions and explosives of concern
mm Millimeter
MMR Massachusetts Military Reservation
MMRP Military Munitions Response Program
MRS Munitions Response Site
MRSPP Munitions Response Site Prioritization Protocol
mph Miles per hour
NAVDT Derivation not known
NGB National Guard Bureau
OAFB Otis Air Force Base
OANGB Otis Air National Guard Base
OE Ordnance and explosives (now referred to as MEC)
OPAREA Operating Area
ORIS Operational Range Inventory Sustainment (A U.S. Army GIS)
PA Preliminary Assessment
PAVE Perimeter Acquisition Vehicle Entry Phased Array Warning
PAWS System
PCM Post Closure Monitoring
POW Prisoner-of-war
RAC Risk Assessment Code
RCRA Resource Conservation and Recovery Act
RCS-1 Reportable Concentrations for S-1 Soils
RDX Cyclotrimethylenenitramine
RG Record group
vi
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
Acronym Definition
RI Remedial Investigation
RI/FS Remedial Investigation/Feasibility Study
ROD Record of Decision
SARA Superfund Amendment and Reauthorization Act
SDWA Safe Drinking Water Act
SI Site Inspection
SOP Standard Operating Procedure
TNT Trinitrotoluene
U.S. United States
USACE U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
USAF U.S. Air Force
USCG U.S. Coast Guard
U.S.C. U.S. Code
USGS U.S. Geographical Survey
UTES Unit Training Equipment Storage
UXO Unexploded ordnance
WMM Waste military munitions
WWII World War II
°F Degrees Fahrenheit
vii
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
viii
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
GLOSSARY OF TERMS
Closed Range – A military range that has been taken out of service as a range and that either
has been put to new uses that are incompatible with range activities, or is not considered by
the military to be a potential range area. A closed range is still under the control of a
Department of Defense (DoD) component.
Defense Site – All locations that were owned by, leased to, or otherwise possessed or used
by the DoD. The term does not include any operational range, operating storage or
manufacturing facility, or facility that is used or was permitted for the treatment or disposal
of military munitions.
Discarded Military Munitions (DMM) – Military munitions that have been abandoned
without proper disposal or removed from storage in a military magazine or other storage area
for the purpose of disposal. The term does not include unexploded explosive ordnance,
military munitions that are being held for future use or planned disposal, or military
munitions that have been properly disposed of consistent with applicable environmental laws
and regulations. (10 U.S.C. 2710(e)(2)).
Explosive Ordnance Disposal (EOD) – The detection, identification, onsite evaluation,
rendering safe, recovery, and final disposal of unexploded ordnance by a military response
unit. It may also include explosive ordnance that has become hazardous by damage or
deterioration.
Explosives Safety – A condition where operational capability and readiness, personnel,
property, and the environment are protected from unacceptable effects of an ammunition or
explosives mishap.
Formerly Used Defense Site (FUDS) – A DoD program that focuses on compliance and
cleanup efforts at sites that were formerly used by the DoD. A FUDS property is eligible for
the Military Munitions Response Program if the release occurred prior to October 17, 1986;
the property was transferred from DoD control prior to October 17, 1986; and the property or
project meets other FUDS eligibility criteria.
Military Munitions – Military munitions means all ammunition products and components
produced for or used by the armed forces for national defense and security, including
ammunition products or components under the control of the DoD, the USCG, the
Department of Energy, and the Army National Guard (ARNG). The term includes confined
gaseous, liquid, and solid propellants, explosives, pyrotechnics, chemical and riot control
agents, smokes, and incendiaries, including bulk explosives and chemical warfare agents,
chemical munitions, rockets, guided and ballistic missiles, bombs, warheads, mortar rounds,
ix
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
artillery ammunition, small arms ammunition, grenades, mines, torpedoes, depth charges,
cluster munitions and dispensers, demolition charges, and devices and components thereof.
The term does not include wholly inert items, improvised explosive devices, and nuclear
weapons, nuclear devices, and nuclear components, except that the term does include non-
nuclear components of nuclear devices that are managed under the nuclear weapons program
of the Department of Energy after all required sanitization operations under 42 U.S.C. 2011
(Atomic Energy Act) have been completed. (10 U.S.C. 2710(e)(3)(A) and (B)).
Military Range – “Active range” and “inactive range” as these terms are defined in 40 CFR
§226.201.
Munitions and Explosives of Concern (MEC) – This term, which distinguishes specific
categories of military munitions that may pose unique explosives safety risks, means
unexploded ordnance, DMM, or munitions constituents (e.g., Trinitrotoluene [TNT] or
Cyclotrimethylenetrinitramine [RDX]) present in high enough concentrations to pose an
explosive hazard.
Munitions Constituents (MC) – Any materials originating from unexploded ordnance,
DMM, or other military munitions, including explosive and non-explosive materials, and
emission, degradation, or breakdown elements of such ordnance or munitions. (10 U.S.C.
2710)
Operational Range – A range that is under jurisdiction, custody, or control of the Secretary
of Defense and that is used for range activities or, although not currently being used for range
activities, is still considered by the Secretary to be a range and has not been put to new use
incompatible with range activities. (10 U.S.C. 101(e)(3)(A) and (B)). Also includes “military
range,” “active range,” and “inactive range” as those terms are defined in 40 CFR 266.201.
Other than Operational Range – Includes all property that is under jurisdiction, custody, or
control of the Secretary of Defense that is not defined as an Operational Range.
Range – A designated land or water area that is set aside, managed, and used for range
activities of the Department of Defense. Such term includes the following:
(A) Firing lines and positions, maneuver areas, firing lanes, test pads, detonation
pads, impact areas, electronic scoring sites, buffer zones with restricted access, and
exclusionary areas.
(B) Airspace areas designated for military use in accordance with regulations and
procedures prescribed by the Administrator of the Federal Aviation Administration.
(10 U.S.C. 101(e)(5))
x
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
Transferred Range – A range that is no longer under military control and had been leased
by the DoD, transferred, or returned from the DoD to another entity, including Federal
entities. This includes a military range that was used under the terms of an executive order,
special-use permit or authorization, right-of-way, public land order, or other instrument
issued by the Federal land manager. Additionally, property that was previously used by the
military as a range, but did not have a formal use agreement, also qualifies as a transferred
range.
Transferring Range – A range that is proposed to be leased, transferred, or returned from
the DoD to another entity, including Federal entities. This includes a military range that was
used under the terms of a withdrawal, executive order, special-use permit or authorization,
right-of-way, public land order, or other instrument issued by the Federal land manager or
property owner. An active range will not be considered a transferring range until the transfer
is imminent (generally defined as the transfer date is within 12 months and a receiving entity
has been notified).
Unexploded Ordnance (UXO) – UXO are military munitions that:
(A) Have been primed, fused, armed, or otherwise prepared for action.
(B) Have been fired, dropped, launched, projected, or placed in such a manner as
to constitute a hazard to operations, installations, personnel, or material.
(C) Remain unexploded, either by malfunction, design, or any other cause. (10
U.S.C. 101(e)(5))
xi
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
xii
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The Military Munitions Response Program (MMRP) is conducted under the Defense
Environmental Restoration Program (DERP) to address Department of Defense (DoD) sites
with unexploded ordnance (UXO), discarded military munitions (DMM), and munitions
constituents (MC) located on current and former military installations. This report is a
combined Historical Records Review and Site Inspection (HRR/SI) and concludes the SI
process for Active Army MMRP-eligible sites at Camp Edwards and the Massachusetts
Military Reservation (MMR) in Barnstable County, Massachusetts.
The first step of the SI was the Historical Records Review (HRR) in which potential
Munitions Response Sites (MRSs) and Areas of Concern (AOCs) at Camp Edwards/MMR
were evaluated through document searches and reviews, interviews and site visits. A draft
HRR Report summarizing the findings was submitted in 2008. Following regulatory review
and the decision by the Air National Guard (ANG) to evaluate USAF MMRP sites
independently of the Active Army, it was determined that none of the sites identified were
eligible for the Active Army MMRP. As a result, the HRR and SI Reports have been
combined into this HRR/SI Report submittal. All information originally reported in prior
drafts regarding these sites is still provided for the sake of completeness. The ANG has
indicated they will incorporate all information developed as part of the Active Army effort in
their own MMRP site evaluations and equivalent Archive Search Report.
This HRR/SI is conducted under the Active Army MMRP and includes Army National
Guard (ARNG) sites. It does not include sites which are potentially eligible for the Formerly
Used Defense Sites (FUDS) MMRP, or sites on parcels controlled by the ANG or any other
DoD component.
In 2003, the Army conducted the MMRP equivalent of a Preliminary Assessment (PA) at
Camp Edwards/MMR resulting in the report, U.S. Army Closed, Transferring and
Transferred Range/Site Inventory for Camp Edwards Training Site, MA,. (Malcolm Pirnie,
Inc., September 2003, referred to herein as the CTT Range Inventory Report). That
assessment identified 10 potential MRSs, 3 of which were determined to be ineligible for the
MMRP because they had no history of, or reason to suspect, munitions-related activities, and
7 of which were deemed to be MRSs, given an Army Environmental Database-Restoration
(AEDB-R) number, and referred forward in the MMRP.
These seven MRSs were reviewed more fully, and an additional five potential sites or areas
of concern (AOCs) were identified and reviewed.
Overall, 15 potential MRSs and AOCs have been identified to date at MMR as candidates for
the MMRP (Figure ES-1) and were evaluated under this SI. Based upon discussions with US
xiii
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
ANG and Air Force Center of Engineering and the Environment (AFCEE): Sites identified
on Air Force-leased property will be addressed by ANG and AFCEE in their MMRP. The
ANG is considering the inclusion of these sites within the Federal Facilities Agreement
(FFA) for MMR.
xiv
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
Figure ES-1: Closure Programs for MRSs and AOCs – Camp Edwards/MMR
PAVE
PAWS
Camp Edwards
Mock Village
MMR-001-R-01
FFA
Stables Area
MMR-007-R-01 Otis Target Butt
ARNG / IAGWSP - SDWA MMR-005-R-01
Referred to ANG / AFCEE
BY1 BY2
AOC, No AEDBR # AOC, No AEDBR #
ARNG / IAGWSP - SDWA Referred to ANG / AFCEE
xv
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
xvi
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
1. INTRODUCTION
The U.S. Congress established the Military Munitions Response Program (MMRP) under the
Defense Environmental Restoration Program (DERP) to address Department of Defense
(DoD) sites with unexploded ordnance (UXO), discarded military munitions (DMM), and
munitions constituents (MC) located on current and former military installations(10 United
States Code (U.S.C.) Sections 2703 & 2710). Sites that are not eligible for the Active Army
MMRP include: sites that had releases after September 30, 2002; properties classified as
operational military ranges; permitted disposal facilities; operating munitions storage
facilities, and sites eligible for the Base Realignment and Closure (BRAC) or Formerly Used
Defense Sites (FUDS) MMRP. The U.S. Army’s (Army) inventory of closed, transferring,
and transferred (CTT) military ranges and defense sites with UXO, DMM, or MC identified
sites eligible for action under the MMRP. The MMRP has distinct characteristics, but
follows the process established for the Comprehensive Environmental Response,
Compensation, and Liability Act (CERCLA, see Section 1.3 for more detail).
1-1
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
1-2
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
1-3
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
“4.3 Limit, to the extent practical, the potential for explosives mishaps and the damaging
effects of such to personnel, operational capability, property, and the environment.
“4.4 Resolve conflicts between explosive safety and other requirements with the
objective of minimizing explosives hazards.
“4.5 Design and use operational ranges and the munitions used on them, to the extent
practical, to minimize both potential explosive hazards and harmful environmental
impacts and to promote resource recovery and recycling.
“4.6 Enhance the ability to prevent or respond to a release or substantial threat of a
release of munitions constituents from an operational range to off-range areas.”
(DODD 4715.11)
Implementing authority for these operational range policies are given to the DoD
Components (military services) in the directive’s Section 5.4.
Army DERP Management Guidance for Active Installations, (U.S. Army Assistant
Chief of Staff for Installation Management (ACSIM), November 2004)
This document presents the Army’s implementation guidelines of the DoD DERP
Management Guidance (2001) at active installations. [A parallel guidance was presented
concurrently for Army BRAC facilities.] This guidance includes most eligibility
requirements for the program under its Section 2.3. One of the three conditions for Active
Army MMRP eligibility (requiring releases to have occurred prior to 30 September 2002),
has subsequently been rescinded by the Office of the Under Secretary of Defense (via 29-
Dec-08 memorandum, Interim Policy for Defense Environmental Restoration Program
(DERP) Eligibility.
Munitions Response Site Prioritization Protocol (MRSPP) (32 CFR Part 179)
The MRSPP was promulgated in October 2005, in compliance with Section 311 of the
National Defense Authorization Act of FY02. This protocol provides the method by which
DoD will assign a relative priority for munitions responses to each MRS in the inventory of
defense sites known or suspected of containing munitions and explosives of concern (MEC)
or MC.
The September 2001 Management Guidance for the DERP and the National Defense
Authorization Act FY02, described above, established the MMRP. The DERP and the
MMRP provide guidance and methods for conducting a baseline inventory of defense sites
containing, or potentially containing, UXO, DMM, or MC, and the MRSPP provides the
method for DoD to assign a relative priority for subsequent munitions response. Data
collected during the SI will be used to prepare the MRSPP for each MRS.
1-4
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
1.2.1. Eligibility and Ineligibility for Munitions Response under the MMRP
The Army DERP Management Guidance for Active Installations allows munitions responses
to address UXO, DMM and/or MC at sites when:
• “The release is at a site that is not a FUDS, an operational range, an active munitions
demilitarization facility, or an active WMM [waste military munitions] treatment or
disposal unit that operated after 30 September 2002; and
• “The site’s MMRP costs were not identified or included in the Army Environmental
Database-Restoration (AEDB-R) prior to 30 September 2000.” 1 (ACSIM, 2004)
The guidance further states that “Funds appropriated for activities to address UXO, DMM, or
MC cannot be used for:
• “A facility that is used for or was permitted for the treatment or disposal of military
munitions.” (ACSIM, 2004)
Sites are excluded from the Active Army MMRP, for funding source reasons, when they are:
• Sites where there is no reason to suspect the presence of UXO, DMM, or a release of
MC to the environment.
• Sites where all MEC and MC concerns have been or are being addressed under other
programs at least as rigorously as they would be under the MMRP.
1
An additional condition, that “The release occurred prior to 30 September 2002,” was rescinded in a memorandum of 29-Dec-
08, from the Office of the Under Secretary of Defense, Subject: Interim Policy for Defense Environmental Restoration
Program (DERP) Eligibility.
1-5
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
component of the MMR. MMR is an active military installation, with a land area of
approximately 21,000 acres. Portions of it are owned by the U.S. Government and by the
Commonwealth of Massachusetts, and it is leased and used by several different military, non-
military government, and private entities. After Camp Edwards (at approximately 15,000
acres) the Otis ANG Base (OANGB, approximately 6,000 acres) is the next largest
component of MMR.
1-6
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
• Revised Ordnance and Explosives Archives Search Report and Hazardous, Toxic and
Radiological Waste Preliminary Assessment for Massachusetts Military Reservation,
Barnstable County, Massachusetts, (U.S. Army Corps of Engineers [USACE], 2001,
1-7
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
hereafter referred to as the ASR. Note: The original ASR, Ordnance and Explosives
Archives Search Report for Massachusetts Military Reservation, was completed in
1999, and is referenced as USACE, 1999.)
• Draft Final Technical Team Memorandum 02-6—Phase IIB Report Camp Edwards,
Massachusetts Military Reservation, Cape Cod, Massachusetts (hereafter referred to
as the Draft Final Phase IIB Report, AMEC, 2003b)
• MAARNG GIS
• ARID
• Section 1 – Introduction
• Section 2 – Camp Edwards and MMR Description
• Section 3 – Data Collection and Document Review Process
1-8
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
1-9
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
1-10
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
2.1. LOCATION
MMR is an active military installation located in Barnstable County, on Cape Cod, MA
(Figure 2-1). MMR is located in the towns of Bourne, Sandwich, Mashpee, and Falmouth. Its
land area is approximately 21,000 acres. Camp Edwards is the largest component of MMR,
covering approximately 15,000 acres. OANGB and other occupants cover the remaining
6,000 acres.
2-1
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
separate from the original construction from the 1930s onward, with the boundaries not
shifting substantially or overlapping since then.
In 1940, the Army leased MMR from MAARNG and undertook a major World War II
mobilization construction program, with an initial contract to construct 1,300 buildings in the
cantonment area for the housing and training of 30,000 men by January of 1941. The
construction logistics for this operation were massive—18,343 employees working three
shifts, a weekly payroll in excess of $1 million, and completion of 30 buildings a day, with
overall project completion in 125 days (September 1940 to January 1941).
2-2
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
2-3
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
2-4
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
Figure 2-2, provided by the Environment and Readiness Center (E&RC), shows in draft the
occupancy of the MMR facility as of February 2007. (Property lease information was
updated in October 2009, the figures in this report do not incorporate the new data.) Only
three of these entities (MAARNG, MAANG, and USAF) are considered to be DoD
components; all other entities (USCG, DVA, Barnstable County, Bourne, and NSTAR) are
considered to be non-DoD.
As outlined in Army regulation ER 200-3-1, there are a series of criteria for determining
whether a property or project is eligible under FUDS. DoD use, ownership, or control prior
to, but not after October 17, 1986 is one of the criteria. The parcels shown as non-DoD
components at MMR were all transferred to those components by lease or other agreements
before 1986. Therefore, the non-DoD areas shown on Figure 2-2 are potentially FUDS-
eligible.
The MAANG- and USAF-controlled property will be addressed separately in their SI.
2-5
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
Legend
MMR Boundary
Occupants
MA Army National Guard
MA Air National Guard
US Air Force
Potentially FUDS
Eligible Parcels
US Coast Guard
Barnstable County
Town of Bourne
NSTAR
Dept. of Veterans Affairs
Dept. of Fish & Wildlife
Figure 2-2:
Draft Occupancy Map
(February 2007)
2-6
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
Legend
MMR Boundary
MA Air National Guard or
US Air Force property
Figure 2-3:
Operational Range
Delineations
Camp Edwards/MMR
2-7
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
2-8
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
were built, and if so, where they were located. BY1 is listed on the 1949 Range Layout
Map (1999 ASR Plate 3) and not on the following map circa 1970 (1999 ASR Plate 4).
Based on interviews and available maps, the period of use is estimated as 1941 to 1955.
Based on the size provided on Plate 3, BY1 is estimated as 13-acres. However, BY1
overlaps the Stables Area (described later in this report), so only the non-overlapping 10-
acre portion is reported in the inventory. Although railroad tracks are still present in this
area, it is currently an undeveloped wooded area. UXO, DMM, or MC are not suspected
to be at the site. There is no environmental impact from bayonet ranges.”
“BY2 – According to the 1999 ASR, new ranges constructed between September 1940
and July 1941 included bayonet qualification courses. BY2 is listed as a bayonet assault
course on Plate 3 of the 1999 ASR, and it also appeared on the undated Camp Edwards
Master Plan. Based on the size provided on Plate 3 of the 1999 ASR, BY2 is estimated as
13-acres. BY2 is located near the southern boundary of MMR immediately west of
Simpkins Road. BY2 is listed on the 1949 Range Layout Map (1999 ASR Plate 3) and not
on the following map circa 1970 (1999 ASR Plate 4). Based on interviews and available
maps, the period of use is estimated as 1941 to 1955. The area is currently an
undeveloped wooded area. UXO, DMM, or MC are not suspected to be at the site. There
is no environmental impact from bayonet ranges.”
“BY4 – According to the 1999 ASR, new ranges constructed between September 1940
and July 1941 included bayonet qualification courses. BY4 is located west of Greenway
Road near the eastern boundary of the installation. BY4 appeared on the undated Camp
Edwards Master Plan as BYI; however, it is listed here as BY4 because that is the
nomenclature used in the ASR. BY4 is listed on the 1949 Range Layout Map (1 999 ASR
Plate 3) and not on the following map circa 1970 (1999 ASR Plate 4). Based on
interviews and available maps, the period of use is estimated as 1941 to 1955. Based on
the size provided on Plate 3, BY4 is estimated as 13-acres. The area is currently an open
field which is fenced as part of the airfield crash zone. UXO, DMM, or MC are not
suspected to be at the site. There is no environmental impact from bayonet ranges.”
(Malcolm Pirnie, 2003)
2-9
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
rounds, blocks of TNT, pyrotechnics (booby traps) and offensive hand grenades. It is
believed the mock village was used only in the 1940s. Based on the 1941, 1947, 1949,
and the undated Camp Edwards/MMR Master Plan maps, the size of the Mock Village is
estimated at 15-acres.
“Currently this area is an off-limits area operated by the USCG to maintain several
communication towers. The Mock Village is in the northern portion of the USCG facility
which is mostly wooded. No remains of the Mock Village were evident, nor was evidence
of ordnance and explosives (OE) discovered by the team during the visual site inspection
portion of the 1999 ASR. Since 1981, there have been 5 discoveries of OE at the USCG
Communications Station. One discovery was of an 81 mm illumination mortar, while the
other 4 items are unknown because they were simply reported as ‘duds’. It is not known if
these discoveries are located within the former Mock Village.” (Malcolm Pirnie, 2003)
2-10
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
the 1999 ASR delineation of this former range and it’s appearance on the 1941, 1947,
1949, and undated Camp Edwards/MMR Master Plan maps, it is estimated at 187-acres.
On the historic maps, this range is labeled interchangeably as G, Ga/Gb, Known
Distance Rifle Range, and Rifle Range.
“This area was used as a BOMARC missile (for the Boeing Michigan Aeronautical
Research Center) facility from 1959 until it was deactivated in April 1972. In 1975, the
Unit Training and Equipment Storage (UTES) facility was established at the former
location of the BOMARC missile facility. The UTES still operates today at the same
location. Military vehicles, artillery pieces and other heavy equipment is stored and
serviced there.
“From the 1950s to the early 1970s, no range on Camp Edwards/MMR carried the
designation of G Range. In the early 1970s, a new G Range was established off
Greenway Road. In the late 1980s, G Range was relocated to its present location on
Pocasset- Forestdale Road east of Frank Perkins Road. These locations all correspond to
A/I range property.” (Malcolm Pirnie, 2003)
2.6.4. CTT Range Inventory Report Site Description – Old Grenade Courts
“In 1941, dummy grenade courts were constructed in a location currently north of the
intersection of Kittredge Road and General’s Boulevard. The site is also near the
southern installation boundary. The purpose of the courts was to provide practice in
throwing hand grenades from various distances at trenches; through cellar, first, second
and third story windows; at circular ground targets; and at unseen trenches. A total of 12
layouts with the above features were constructed. Ordnance use at the courts would have
been limited to practice or dummy hand grenades.
“A live grenade court was built in 1941 near the same location as the dummy grenade
court. Soldiers threw live grenades from a trench towards a designated impact area.
Accuracy of throw and effect of the grenade was viewed from two parapets located 30
feet behind the throwing trench. Ordnance used at the live grenade court was limited to
high explosive (HE) fragmentation grenades. In the early 1940s the AAATC trained on
the grenade court and utilized fragmentation grenades.
“The 1999 ASR classifies the dummy and live grenade courts together as Area O
consisting of 39-acres. The practice and live grenade courts were used in the 1940s and
1950s. Both courts existed next to each other near the intersection of Kittredge Road and
General’s Boulevard. A trench network and several mounds were discovered in this
location. Currently the area is idle land that is thickly vegetated except for areas cleared
for power lines. Expected ordnance use in Area O is limited to practice, dummy, and
2-11
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
fragmentation hand grenades. According to the 1999 ASR, there have been no reported
incidents involving OE at the Old Grenade Courts.” (Malcolm Pirnie, 2003)
2-12
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
2.6.6. CTT Range Inventory Report Site Description – Otis Target Butt
“A target butt is shown on a map included in the ‘Completion Report on Construction of
Various Additional Housing Facilities, Extension of Landing Strips, and an Air Support
Command Base’ dated July 1,1943. The target butt is shown on the southern edge of the
dispersal taxiway which surrounded the runways. From the scale of this map it is
estimated that the target butt was at the end of a 600 foot taxiway spur and
approximately 200 feet wide. From the map, it is also assumed that the direction of fire
was toward the southeast. No additional details about the layout of the range were
available. A memorandum describing a visit to Otis Air Force Base dated April 21, 1950
lists the ranges and butts at Otis Air Force Base. The memo states that a ‘shooting-in butt
for test firing aircraft which is in the process of extension to total length of 900 ft.’ From
this description it is estimated that the Otis Target Butt is approximately 1-acre. The Otis
Target Butt is visible on the 1947 aerial photo and the 1949 map; however, it is not
labeled as a target butt on either map. Based on the maps, report, and memorandum, it is
estimated that this range was used from 1942 to 1955. It is also assumed that only small
arms were used at this range based on the type of aircraft used during this period. The
area is currently part of the MAANG Otis Airfield and surrounded by the current runway
and support buildings. The site is located in the southeastern corner of the installation.”
(Malcolm Pirnie, 2003)
2.6.7. CTT Range Inventory Report Site Description – Small Arms Range
“During the 1940s, two skeet ranges existed at MMR. One was located in the northeast
corner of the current landfill, at the southwest corner of the intersection of Herbert and
Turpentine Roads. The other skeet range was located at the northeast corner of the
intersection of Herbert and Frank Perkins Roads. Only the range at the intersection of
Herbert and Turpentine Roads is included in this inventory because the other range is
located on A/I range property. This former range is located in the south-central portion
of the installation, at the northern edge of the cantonment area. No information
regarding the layout of ranges is currently available. However, given the typical nature
of skeet ranges, it is reasonable to assume that 10 or 12 gauge shotgun shells were
utilized at the ranges. This former range appears on the undated Camp Edwards/MMR
Master Plan as a skeet range. According to the training diaries of the AAATC, the
AAATC used one of the skeet ranges for firing shotguns, but it is not known which one. In
an interview with a WWII veteran from Camp Edwards, he states that occasional rifle
firing was conducted at a rifle range off of Turpentine Road near the cantonment area. It
is unknown if he is referring to this range or the Old G Range. This former range is
grouped with other small arms ranges in the 1999 ASR (Area B) because of similar use.
2-13
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
Based on the 1999 ASR delineation of this former range, it is estimated at 22- acres. The
period of use is estimated as 1941 to 1955 based on the usage of similar ranges at Camp
Edwards/MMR during this time period. The 1999 ASR summary of OE discoveries from
1980 to 1998 includes 7.62mm blank rounds (698 rounds) found December 23, 1993 at
the landfill. It is not clear if this discovery is associated with the landfill operations or the
former range.” (Malcolm Pirnie, 2003)
2-14
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
(1) The information in this table is as provided in the CTT Range Inventory
Report
2-15
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
2-16
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
• Review of existing Archives Search Reports and administrative records for adjacent
FUDS associated with Camp Edwards/MMR
• Interviews
• Review of data, reports, and Web sites for other environmental and munitions
programs at Camp Edwards/MMR, including the IRP and IAGWSP
3-1
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
3-2
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
3-3
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
3.2.1. Documents/Reports
Table 3-1 lists documents that provided relevant information regarding the operational
history of former ranges and training areas within Camp Edwards/MMR. Although every
document in the ASR was reviewed, these are not individually cited in Table 3-1.
3-4
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
3-5
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
3.2.3. Maps/Drawings
Maps and drawings were obtained from Camp Edwards/MMR, the National Archives, the
ASR, and a regulatory database company, Environmental Data Resources, Inc. (EDR). A
complete listing of maps reviewed for this HRR/SI is provided in Table 3–2. All maps and
drawings are included electronically in Appendix B.
Table 3-2: Summary of Maps and Drawings
Map
Coverage Ranges
General Includes of
Installation Range Concern
Map Name Date Map ID Information Areas Shown
Bivouac Areas Aug-39 ASR, L-1 X X
Range Map 5-Mar-41 ASR, L-2 X X X
General Range Map Jun-41 ASR, L-3 X X X
Otis Field and Camp Edwards Feb-43 ASR, L-4 X X X
General Plan - Training Areas, Sheet 1946 ASR, L-5 X X X
No. 47
Real Estate, Military Reservation Jun-48 ASR, L-6 X X X
Camp Edwards and Vicinity Circa 1949 ASR, L-7 X X X
Real Estate Map, Otis Air Force Base Mar-63 ASR, L-8 X X X
Camp Edwards Special Map circa ASR, L-9 X X X
1970s
Special Map (Artillery Positions) Dec-77 ASR, L-10 X X X
Special Map (Mortar Positions) Dec-77 ASR, L-11 X X X
Index of Ranges/Training Sites 15-Jan-92 ASR, L-12 X X X
Camp Edwards Special Map Aug-94 ASR, L-13 X X X
Anti-Aircraft Firing Range, 29-Oct-43 ASR, F-24 X
Popponesset Beach, Mashpee
CTT Ranges, UXO-DMM-MC Sites, Sep-03 CTT Report, X X X
Camp Edwards Figure E-1
USGS quadrangle (scale 1:62500) – 3 1893 EDR X X
maps
USGS quadrangle (scale 1:62500) – 1 1894 EDR X X
map
USGS quadrangle (scale 1:31680) – 1 1940 EDR X X
map
USGS quadrangle (scale 1:25000) – 1 1942 EDR X X
map
USGS quadrangle (scale 1:31680) – 6 1943 EDR X X
maps
USGS quadrangle (scale 1:25000) – 3 1947 EDR X X
maps
USGS quadrangle (scale 1:25000) – 8 1948 EDR X X
maps
USGS quadrangle (scale 1:24000) – 1 1949 EDR X X
map
USGS quadrangle (scale 1:31680) – 1 1951 EDR X X
map
USGS quadrangle (scale 1:24000) – 3 1957 EDR X X
maps
3-6
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
Map
Coverage Ranges
General Includes of
Installation Range Concern
Map Name Date Map ID Information Areas Shown
USGS quadrangle (scale 1:24000) – 1 1961 EDR X X
map1
USGS quadrangle (scale 1:24000) – 7 1967 EDR X X
maps
USGS quadrangle (scale 1:25000) – 3 1972 EDR X X
maps
USGS quadrangle (scale 1:25000) – 1 1974 EDR X X
map
USGS quadrangle (scale 1:25000) – 8 1979 EDR X X
maps
USGS quadrangle (scale 1:50000) – 2 1985 EDR X X
maps
Camp Edwards Training Site Map Jan-06 MAARNG X X X
(1:50000) GIS
Camp Edwards Training Site Map Jan-06 MAARNG X X X
(1:25000) GIS
Known and Suspected Areas 1-Feb-01 Phase II B, X X X
Containing UXO – UXO Technology Figure 2-2
Screening Report
• MAARNG GIS
• USACE/New England District layers to MAARNG GIS
• ARID
• IAGWSP GIS
• https://contractor.mmr-edms.org/
• IRP Administrative Record
The MAARNG GIS was particularly valuable in providing historical aerial photographs and
overlays for this HRR/SI.
3-7
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
Photographic coverage of sites of concern was available from 1943 to 2002; many of these
images were used in the ASR. A listing of aerial photographs is provided in Table 3–3. All
photographs are provided electronically in Appendix B.
Table 3-3: Summary of Aerial Photographs
Aerial Photograph, Date Photo ID
Camp Edwards/MMR Aerial, 1943 MAARNG GIS, 2007
Camp Edwards/MMR Aerial, 1955 MAARNG GIS, 2007
Camp Edwards/MMR Aerial, 1966 MAARNG GIS, 2007
Camp Edwards/MMR Aerial, 1977 MAARNG GIS, 2007
Camp Edwards/MMR Aerial, 1986 MAARNG GIS, 2007
Camp Edwards/MMR Aerial, 1991 MAARNG GIS, 2007
Camp Edwards/MMR Aerial, 1997 MAARNG GIS, 2007
Camp Edwards/MMR Aerial, 2001 MAARNG GIS, 2007
Camp Edwards/MMR Aerial, 2002 MAARNG GIS, 2007
Camp Edwards/MMR Aerial, 23-Sep-1947 – 8 photographs ASR, K-55 through K-62
Camp Edwards/MMR Aerial, 30-Apr-1958 – 11 photographs ASR, K-63 through K-73
Soil Conservation Service, East Sandwich Aerial, 22-Oct-1951 DPL-2K-22
Soil Conservation Service, Camp Edwards/MMR Aerial, 22-Oct-1951, DPL-2K-51, -52, -80, -81,
– 8 photographs
-82, -95, -96, -97
3.2.6. Interviews
The following interviews were conducted and recorded (Appendix D). These interviews
were conducted with base personnel (e.g., Gonser, Gallagher, Faux) and with those who
could provide more detail on a particular site or AOC that arose during the HRR/SI process.
Contact Position Date
Kent (Hap) Gonser Program Manager, IAGWSP January 31, 2007
William Gallagher Project Manager, IAGWSP January 31, 2007
Lt. Col. Christopher Faux 102nd Fighter Wing Environmental Management May 18, 2007
Officer
Dr. William F. Atwater Curator, U.S. Army Ordnance Museum May 23, 2007
Heather Sullivan Manager, FUDS/New England May 31, 2007
Dr. Susan Goodfellow Former Cultural Resources Manager for Camp Edwards June 12, 2007
Ray Cottengaim Realty Specialist/New England June 12, 2007
Barbara Gill Resident at Scorton Neck, Archivist June 13 and 14,
2007
John (Jack) Jillson Descendant of John F. Carleton, manager of the Carleton June 14, 2007
family estate, resident
3-8
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
• Revised Ordnance and Explosives Archives Search Report and Hazardous, Toxic and
Radiological Waste Preliminary Assessment for Massachusetts Military Reservation,
Barnstable County, Massachusetts (USACE, 2001)
The second of these is the ASR referenced extensively in this report. For the most part,
though not always, the 2001 report contains all information from the 1999 report. Both
reports are included in Appendix B (electronic only) of this HRR/SI.
IAGWSP Draft Final Phase IIB Report (AMEC, 2003b): The Phase IIB investigation was
conducted by the IAGWSP pursuant to Administrative Order Safe Drinking Water Act
(SDWA) 1-97-9019 (AO1) at training areas, ranges, and other sites selected by EPA. Field
sampling was conducted at the sites to characterize the nature and extent of possible soil
and/or groundwater contamination resulting from historical releases. The resultant Draft
Final Phase IIB Report contains site information and primary soil and groundwater sampling
data not found elsewhere, as well as information compiled from other IAGWSP memoranda
and reports. The Draft Final Phase IIB Report contains information relating to several sites
including the Old G Range, Old Grenade Courts, Otis Target Butt, and Small Arms Range.
The report is held at draft final status, awaiting comments from EPA. The Draft Final Phase
IIB Report (text, figures, tables, and appendices) is included in Appendix B (electronic
version) of this HRR/SI.
INMRP (Camp Edwards, 2001): The Integrated Natural Resources Management Plan for
Camp Edwards, 2001 (http://www.mass.gov/guard/E&RC/INRMP), provided much of the
physical profile and background data used within Section 5 of this report. The INRMP is
included in Appendix B.
Range Condition Assessment (CHPPM, 2004): The draft Army National Guard Focused
Range Condition Assessment No. 38-EH-02VA-04 MARNG Camp Edwards Select Closed
Ranges, Barnstable County, MA (June 2004, CHPPM) provided useful information for
several of the sites reviewed in this report.
Architect-Engineer (A-E) Report (Main, 1941): The Architect-Engineer’s Report on Camp
Edwards, Falmouth, Mass (June 1941, Charles T. Main, Inc.) provides information for
3-9
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
several WWII-era sites not found in other documents. This A-E report is contained in
Appendix B within the ASR files (document E-4, within files ASR_APP_00E_002.pdf
through ASR_APP_00E_004.pdf).
3-10
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
4. SUMMARY OF FINDINGS
MAANG Property
Site referred to
ARNG / IAGSWP - SDWA
4-1
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
Closure Program: BY1 has no history or evidence of MEC or MC use. This site is on
operational range and will be addressed by the ARNG and IAGWSPO under the SDWA
Administrative Orders. BY2 and BY4 are within OANGB and these ranges have been
referred to the ANG and AFCEE.
4.1.2. Mock Village (MMR-002-R-01)
The Mock Village (Figure 4-2) was constructed in the early 1940s as a WWII-era training
site for military operations in villages and urban settings. The site straddled Jefferson Road,
with the majority to the north of the road in an area that was designated as operational range
in 2002 and was thus MMRP-ineligible. Only the portion of Mock Village south of Jefferson
Road (estimated as 15 acres) was considered Active Army MMRP-eligible in 2002 and
designated as an MRS in the CTT Range Inventory Report (see Section 2.6.2 above).
Greenway
Road Scale: 1000 yards (approx.)
0 500 1000
Figure 4-2: Mock Village and Old K Range as cited in CTT Range Inventory Report,
with updates from HRR
[Sources: CTT Range Inventory Report, and 2007 Operational Range Delineation]
In 1977 the USCG leased an area of MMR known as Parcel P (shown in red in Figure 4-2;
lease is contained in Appendix B). Parcel P extends north of Jefferson Road approximately
150 yards (in the area of the Mock Village), and includes the current USCG Communications
Station to the south of the road. In 2007 the Camp Edwards/MMR operational range
boundary was moved back to exclude all of USCG’s Parcel P. Figure 4-3 shows the effect
4-2
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
on the Mock Village MRS of this change in operational range delineation. The original site
(1.8 acres) can be seen in the small ellipse; the original MRS (estimated in this HRR/SI as 18
acres) suggested in the CTT Range Inventory Report extends below Jefferson Road; the
revised MRS (13 acres) is shown extending north to the revised operational range boundary.
The area of the Mock Village MRS should now be corrected to include the areas north of
Jefferson Road. Whether it expands or not, the Mock Village MRS is within an area
transferred out of DoD control prior to 1986 and could be considered for FUDS eligibility.
The Mock Village site has been inspected in 1998, 2000, and 2001 during the ASR and Phase
IIB studies. To date, several earthen structures and timber-reinforced pits or tunnels (prob-
ably used to operate pop-up targets) have been identified on the north side of Jefferson Road.
Figure 4-3:
Barlow Mock Village Training
Parcel P Site (WWII-era) and MRS boundaries suggested in
Road Boundary
CTT Range Inventory Report and in HRR. Legend
Operational
Range (2007)
Operational Range
USCG Leased Land Mock Village
Training Site
Mock Village
MRS, per CTT
Jefferson Range Inventory
Road
Revised Mock
Village MRS, w.
100 yard band
Figure 4-3: Mock Village Training Site (WWII-era) and MRS boundaries suggested in
CTT Range Inventory Report and in HRR.
[Image Source: 1953 Soil Conservation Service Aerial Photograph, CEM000248.tif]
In 2001, shallow soil samples (<6 inches) were taken from the bottoms of the three pits and
analyzed. The Draft Phase IIB Report (AMEC, 2003b) recommended no further action for
the site based on the following observations.
4-3
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
• Most metals detected in Mock Village soils that were reported in excess of
background were only marginally greater than the established Camp Edwards/MMR
concentrations.
• None of the analytes detected in Mock Village soils exceeded their respective
Massachusetts Contingency Plan (MCP) Reportable Concentrations for S-1 Soils
(RCS-1).
Summary: The Mock Village site boundaries have been changed to incorporate the
corrected delineation of Parcel “P” and to more properly match the constructed boundaries of
the village (with a 100 yard safety margin).
Closure Program: The USCG first leased Parcel P in 1977 and has been the leaseholder and
controller of the property since then. This site is located within a non-operational range
area. Low concentrations of metals and semi-volatile compounds have been detected in soil
at the site. A Remedial Investigation of this site will be conducted under the MMRP in
accordance with the FFA.
Army/ARNG
Operational
Range (2007)
Old G Range
Dolan Air Force/ANG
Road Property
Site referred to
ARNG/ IAGWSP
– SDWA
Site referred to
ANG/ AFCEE
BY4
Note: One site, BY4, was
considered in CTT
Range Inventory but
Scale: 1000 yards (approximately) showed no evidence of
0 500 1000 munitions use.
Figure 4-4: Old G Range and BY4 as cited in CTT Range Inventory Report, with
updates from HRR
[Sources: CTT Range Inventory Report, and 2007 Operational Range Delineation]
4-4
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
300-yard) rifle range for .30-caliber rifles. The site has also been known as the Ga/Gb Range,
the Known Distance Range, and the Rifle Range. In 1959, the BOMARC facility was
constructed over the northeastern portion of the Old G Range, and use of the Old G Range
was discontinued.
The CTT Range Inventory Report (see Section 2.6.3) identified the Old G Range as an MRS
covering approximately 187 acres.
Closure Program: The Camp Edwards/MMR operational range area was updated in 2007
and it now covers all of the Old G Range. The ARNG/IAGWSPO will address closure of
this site under the SDWA Administrative Orders.
Site referred to
ARNG/IAGWSP –
SDWA
Site referred to
KittredgeRoad BY2 ANG/AFCEE
BY1 Dunbar Road
Note: Two sites, BY1 and
BY2, were considered
in CTT Range Inventory
but showed no evidence
of munitions use.
Old Grenade Courts 0
Scale: 1000 yards (approximately)
500 1000
Figure 4-5: Old Grenade Courts and Stables Area as cited in CTT Range Inventory
Report, with updates from HRR
[Sources: CTT Range Inventory Report, and 2007 Operational Range Delineation]
4-5
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
Legend
Air Force/ANG
Reilly Property
Easton Street
Road
Grandyville Site referred to
Avenue ANG/AFCEE
Otis Target
Butt
0
Scale: 1000 yards
500
(approximately)
1000
Figure 4-6: Otis Target Butt as cited in CTT Range Inventory Report, with updates from
HRR
[Sources: CTT Range Inventory Report]
4-6
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
Closure Program: The Otis Target Butt (MMR-005-R-01) is contained within OANGB and
has been referred to the ANG and AFCEE.
Figure 4-7:
Old G Range
Small Arms Range as cited in CTT Range Inventory Report with updates from
Small Arms
HRR Range
Legend
Turpentine
Road CTT Range Invtry Report
MRS: Small
Herbert Arms Range
Road
Former
Landfill Operational Range
(Uncapped) as of 2002
ARNG/Army
Former Operational Range
Frank Perkins (2007)
Landfill
Road
(Capped) ANG/Air Force
Retention Property
Basin
Non-DoD Property
Area of
Common Borrow Pit
Figure 4-7: Small Arms Range as cited in CTT Range Inventory Report, with updates
from HRR
[Sources: CTT Range Inventory Report]
History: The installation training areas master plans of 1943 and 1946 (Figure 4-8, derived
from USACE, 2001, L-4 and L-5) identified two skeet range sites at the southeast and the
northwest ends of Herbert Road. The site in the northwest end is within the current
operational range area of Camp Edwards/MMR, and is thus ineligible for the MMRP and is
not considered further in this report. The other site, to the southwest of the intersection of
Herbert Road and Turpentine Road, is within the non-operational range area. This range is
4-7
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
referred to as the Small Arms Range (AEDB-R # MMR-0006-R-01) within the CTT Range
Inventory Report, and is the subject of consideration in this subsection.
Very little is known about the use of the skeet ranges. The ASR cites three sources, the 1943
and 1946 training area maps, (USACE, 2001, L-4 and L-5) and the AAATC Training Diary
(USACE, 2001, F-17). No range layout or standard operating procedures (SOPs) were found
for the sites, and it was assumed that 10- or 12-gauge shotguns were used there. The CTT
Range Inventory Report allocates 22 acres to the Small Arms Range.
The AAATC Training Diary (USACE, 2001, F-17) reported on December 3, 1943, “The new
skeet ranges were officially opened today. The ranges are to be used for teaching machine
gunners and automatic weapons crews’ leads.” No locational information was provided
within the diary to corroborate that the skeet ranges cited were those on Herbert Road. The
AAATC Training Diary (covering from July 2, 1942, through March 25, 1944) shows troop
training at the skeet range only between December 17, 1943, and February 15, 1944. No
other command’s training entries or skeet range utilization records were found.
Figures 4-9 through 4-17 show aerial photographs of the Small Arms Range from 1943 to
2002. The Small Arms Range MRS is shown on the map as a red rhombus in the lower
(southern) half of the picture. The southeast corner of the Old G Range is shown with the
yellow line.
Figure 4-9 (1943) shows the Small Arms Range area slightly disturbed and in use with dirt
roads, though lacking a large cleared shooting area other than the irregular line shown in its
southeast quadrant. A close-up of the Small Arms Range site (1951, Figure 4-10) shows an
irregular cleared area, which perhaps served as a training course, but lacked the firing fan
that would normally be seen on a skeet or small arms range for troop training.
Figure 4-11 (1955) shows the Small Arms Range area out of use, with brush growing
throughout the area, including over the irregular disturbances seen previously. Between the
1960s and 2002 (Figures 4-11 through 4-17) the base landfill is seen to be expanding over the
footprint of the Small Arms Range, ultimately covering it, as discussed below.
4-8
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
Howe
Road Old G
Figure 4-8: Small Arms Range vs. Skeet Ranges Identified
Range
in 1946 Training Areas Master
Plan
Turpentine Legend
Road MRS: Small Arms
Herbert Range
Road
Army/ARNG
Frank Operational Range
Perkins
Road Skeet Range Sites ANG/Air Force
Identified in 1943 and Property
1946 Master Plans
Base Landfill
Base Landfill
(Closed and Capped
(1941-1990)
1995)
Figure 4-8: Small Arms Range vs. Skeet Ranges Identified in 1946 Training Areas Master Plan
[Source: Underlying image is from 1946 Master Plan (ASR, L-5)]
Turpentine
MRS: Small Arms
Road Range
Old G Range
(Southwestern edge)
Small Arm
Range
Figure 4-9:
Small Arms Range
Aerial Photograph
– 1943
[Source: MAARNG GIS]
4-9
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
Figure 4-10:
Small Arms Range
Aerial Photograph –
1951 Closeup
[Source: NARA, CEM00250]
Old G Range
(Southwestern edge)
Figure 4-11:
Small Arms Range
Aerial Photograph
– 1955
[Source: MAARNG GIS]
4-10
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
Old G
Figure 4-12: Herbert Range
Small Arms Range Aerial
Road
Photograph – 1966
Legend
Figure 4-12:
Small Arms Range
Aerial Photograph
– 1966
[Source: MAARNG GIS]
Old G Range
(Southwestern edge)
Figure 4-13:
Small Arms Range
Aerial Photograph –
1977
[Source: MAARNG GIS]
4-11
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
Old G
Figure 4-14: Herbert Range
Small Arms Range Aerial
Road
Photograph – 1986
Legend
Small Arm
MRS: Small Arms
Range Turpentine
Range
Road
Old G Range
(Southwestern edge)
Figure 4-14:
Small Arms Range
Aerial Photograph –
1986
[Source: MAARNG GIS]
Old G
Herbert Range
Figure 4-15: Small
Road
Arms Range Aerial Photograph – 1991
Legend
Small Arm
MRS: Small Arms
Range Turpentine
Range
Road
Old G Range
(Southwestern edge)
Figure 4-15:
Small Arms Range
Aerial Photograph –
1991
[Source: MAARNG GIS]
4-12
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
Old G
Figure 4-16: Herbert Range
Small Arms Range Aerial
Road
Photograph – 1996
Legend
Small Arm
MRS: Small Arms
Range Turpentine
Range
Road
Old G Range
(Southwestern edge)
Figure 4-16:
Small Arms Range
Retention Basin Aerial Photograph
– 1996
[Source: MAARNG GIS]
Figure 4-17:
Small Arms Range
Retention Basin Aerial Photograph
– 2002
[Source: MAARNG GIS]
4-13
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
Area reuse within Base Landfill: The Camp Edwards/MMR Base Landfill was operated
from 1941 through 1990 in the 100 acres between Turpentine Road, Herbert Road, Frank
Perkins Road, and Connery Avenue. The area of the Small Arms Range was an active
landfill cell from 1970 through 1990 (Figures 4-12 and 4-13). The procedures followed for
this cell were described in a contemporary account: “The present operation consists of a
series of trenches in which refuse is dumped and then covered daily with excavated material.
The trenches are 30 feet deep, 50 feet wide, and 500 feet long.” (Metcalf & Eddy, 1983).
In December 1995, the landfill was closed and the three most recently used cells were
capped, including the “Post-1970” cell over the Small Arms Range site. The landfill cap can
be seen in 1991, 1996 and 2002 photographs (Figures 4-14, 4-15 and 4-16). The cap is
described as, “The cover system is composed of these low permeability caps built on top of
the three cells, an associated drainage system, and 70 gas vents designed to release gas from
the interior of the landfill” (CH2M Hill, 2005). “Since December 1995, monitoring
activities, including site inspections and groundwater and gas monitoring, have been
implemented under the Post Closure Monitoring (PCM) program to verify that the caps are
functioning as designed” (ibid). The Interim Record of Decision (IROD, ANG 1993) for the
landfill source area “required that AFCEE (Air Force Center for Engineering and the
Environment) conduct post-closure maintenance and monitoring of the landfill cover system
for a minimum of 30 years after construction” (ibid). These activities are conducted under
the MMR IRP as subject to CERCLA.
It is considered very unlikely from these photographs that the Small Arms Range area was
used for organized skeet training in the 1940s. Furthermore, if the site was used, it is
considered unlikely that any MEC or MC would remain following the surface scraping,
trenching, and landfill capping that occurred at the site.
Land Use: The Small Arms Range is located in a limited public access (LPA) area of Camp
Edwards/MMR. The original site is entirely covered by a capped landfill. The nearest
residential properties (public) are approximately ¾ mile north-northeast. A GIS estimate of
the area of the Small Arms Range (in the red rhombus) is 26 acres, versus the 22 acres
suggested in the CTT Range Inventory Report.
Probable Ordnance Used, MEC, and MC: If it was used at all, the Small Arms Range was
only used for skeet shooting involving 10- or 12-gauge shotguns, as described in Appendix
C. There was probably very limited pellet accumulation density, as no highly organized
firing line appears to have been constructed.
The ASR reports that 698 7.62mm blanks were found at the landfill. These did not originate
from the Small Arms Range site, as no records indicate 7.62mm weapons use there. The
CTT Range Inventory Report cited in summary Table ES-1, “Practice Ordnance (without
4-14
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
spotting charges)” as one of the munitions types at the Small Arms Range. This is considered
an error in the table, as there is no historical basis for it, and the ASR RAC scoring worksheet
does not show it.
Summary: The Small Arms Range (AEDB # MMR-006-R-01) was reported in the CTT
Range Inventory Report as a 22-acre site to the southwest of the intersection of Herbert Road
and Turpentine Road that was constructed around 1943 and used until the early 1950s for
skeet shooting, apparently both recreational and for troop training. This was reported as
possibly one of three skeet ranges used during the period, the other two of which are in the
Camp Edwards/MMR operational range and thus ineligible for the MMRP. Historical aerial
photographs and the records of use suggest that the Small Arms Range had only moderate if
any use as a skeet range. If the site was used, 10- and 12-gauge shotguns would have been
the weapons fired at the site, based on the AAATC Training Diary.
The Small Arms Range area coverage is revised from 22 to 26 acres, following GIS
interpretation. The aerial photograph review suggests that there was little organized use, and
thus very little if any likely MEC or MC hazard at the site.
The Small Arms Range area was used as a landfill cell between 1966 and 1995, and was
excavated to depths up to 30 feet as part of the trench and fill operation. In 1995, the landfill
was closed and subsequently capped as part of an IRP/CERCLA remedy. Had any MEC or
MC issues resulted from the Small Arms Range, the landfill operation and subsequent
capping remedy would have addressed them.
Closure Program: The Small Arms Range (MMR-006-R-01) is contained within OANGB
and has been referred to the ANG and AFCEE.
4-15
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
AEC) or by the executing office (Dennis Teefy, U.S. Army Aberdeen Test Center).
However, the field records maintained by John Webster (Tetra Tech Inc.), the field team
manager of the anomaly clearance action and a subsequent clarification by e-mail (both
contained in Appendix B), detailed the following items found during the investigation:
• Nails, electrical conductors, fence posts, barbed wire, tent stakes, horseshoes, bottles,
trash, buckets, pipes, and scrap metal.
Closure Program: The Stables Area (MMR-007-R-01) is contained within the Camp
Edwards operational range area, which was revised in 2007. The ARNG/IAGWSPO will
address closure of this site under the SDWA Administrative Orders.
4-16
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
Former Curtis
Figure 4-18: Former Ammunition Supply
Ammunition BoulevardPoint (WWII-Era)
Figure 4-18:
Former
Ammunition Supply
Point (WWII-Era)
Source: None, new AOC
4-17
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
Site referred to
ANG/AFCEE
Reilly
Street Figure 4-19:
Former Otis Bomb
Grandville
Avenue
Storage Magazine
Source: None, new AOC
Otis Target Butt
4-18
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
Closure Program: These off-base incidents are not recommended for further action because
there is no evidence that either MEC or MC remain or pose a hazard to public health or the
environment. However, FUDS may wish to address these incidents as part of their MMRP.
4-19
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
4-20
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
Figure 4-20:
Scorton Neck
AAATC Layout
Scorton Neck
AAATC Camp Legend
FUDS Eligible
Property: Scorton Neck
AAATC Camp
Camp Edwards/MMR
Figure 4-21:
Scorton Neck
AAATC Location
[Source: MS Virtual Earth,,
new AOC site in this HRR]
4-21
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
4-22
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
Bracket of Popponesset
Firing Beach Firing Line
AAATC Camp
Figure 4-22:
Popponesset Beach
AAATC Layout
[Source: ASR, Appendix F-24]
Legend
FUDS Eligible
Property: Popponesset
Beach AAATC Camp
Camp Edwards/MMR
Popponesset Beach 0
Scale: 1.5 miles (approx.)
.25 .5 .75 1 1.5
AAATC Camp
Firing
Line Figure 4-23:
Popponesset Beach
AAATC Location
Buzzards
Bay [Source: MS Virtual Earth,,
new AOC site in this HRR]
4-23
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
The firing line is the area of concern for the Popponesset Beach AAATC Camp.
The CTT Range Inventory Report did not address the Popponesset Beach AAATC Site.
Closure Program: The Popponesset Beach AAATC Site is referred to the FUDS MMRP
for an eligibility determination because it is a property that is outside MMRP boundaries and
was controlled (taken) and disposed by DoD prior to 1986.
ANG and Air Force Center of Engineering and Environmental (AFCEE): Sites identified on
Air Force-leased property will be addressed by ANG and AFCEE in their MMRP. The ANG
is considering the inclusion of these sites within the Federal Facilities Agreement (FFA) for
MMR.
4-24
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
ARNG and IAGWSPO Safe Drinking Water Act (SDWA): Sites identified on operational
ranges will be addressed by ARNG through the IAGWSPO. These sites will be closed in
accordance with the requirements of the SDWA Administrative Orders.
Formerly Used Defense Sites (FUDS): Sites not located on MMR have been referred for
consideration by the FUDS Program.
• Scorton Neck AAATC Camp (No AEDB-R # assigned)
4-25
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
4-26
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
5.1.1. Climate
The climate of the region in which Camp Edwards/MMR is situated is temperate due to the
influence of the Atlantic Ocean. Winters are generally cold, with an average daily
temperature of 31 degrees Fahrenheit (°F), and summers are generally warm, averaging 68°F.
Mean relative humidity is 70 percent in mid-afternoon and 80 percent at dawn (Camp
Edwards, 2001). The following information summarizes the temperature and rainfall data for
nearby Hyannis, MA. Hyannis is approximately 14 miles to the east of Camp Edwards.
Table 5-1: Climatological Data for Hyannis, MA
YEAR
MAR
MAY
AUG
NOV
OCT
DEC
APR
JAN
JUN
FEB
JUL
SEP
Avg. Temp (°F) 49.1 28.4 28.9 36.5 44.9 54.6 64.2 70.4 69.6 62.2 52.5 43.8 33.6
Avg. High Temp (°F) 57.5 37.1 37.5 44.5 53.1 63.2 72.5 78.5 77.4 70.8 61.6 52.1 42.2
Avg. Low Temp (°F) 40.7 19.6 20.3 28.5 36.6 46.1 55.8 62.3 61.6 53.6 43.3 35.4 25.1
Avg. Precipitation 43.9 3.7 3.6 3.6 3.9 3.7 3.2 2.9 3.4 3.4 3.9 4.5 4.2
(Inches)
Source: as reported by www.weatherbase.com.
Thunderstorms occur on average 14 days a year, with most of the storms occurring between
May and August. The prevailing wind during winter is from the northwest, shifting to the
southwest in spring. Prevailing winds tend to shift back to the northwest in November. The
average annual wind speed is 11 miles per hour (mph). Winds of 30 mph or more can be
expected at least 1 day every month. However, gale force winds (>32 mph) are more
common in winter (USACE, 2001).
5-1
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
5.1.2. Geology
The landscape of Barnstable County owes its origin to the last continental glacier and to the
rise in sea level that followed glaciation. The sedimentary units present at Camp
Edwards/MMR are the Buzzards Bay Outwash deposits in the extreme northwestern portion,
the Buzzards Bay Moraine outwash plain in the west, the Sandwich Moraine deposits in the
north, and the Mashpee Pitted Plain covering the majority of MMR to the south and east
(USACE, 2001; AMEC, 2006). These sedimentary units are underlain by crystalline bedrock.
The Buzzard’s Bay Outwash consists of coarse sand and gravel of deltaic origin with locally
interbedded fine sand and silt. Coarse to medium sand and gravel is the predominant facies
type in sediments encountered in the boreholes of wells drilled in the northwest portion of
Camp Edwards (AMEC, 2006). Layers of fine-grained silty sands are dispersed
intermittently within the unit, except in the vicinity of the Cape Cod Canal, where the
sediments are predominately fine-grained. South of the Gallo Skating Rink (at the northwest
corner near the Bourne Bridge), the boreholes intercept the coarse sands and gravels
characteristic of the Buzzard’s Bay Outwash. Fine-grained layers are also encountered in
these boreholes. The total thickness of these sedimentary units (and depth to bedrock)
decreases from 280 feet to 150 feet from the base boundary.
Both the Buzzards Bay and Sandwich Moraines form the hummocky ridges characteristic of
the northwest and north side of MMR. Masterson et al. (1997) describe the moraine deposits
as generally consisting of gravel, sand, silt, and clay, with locally poorly to moderately sorted
sand and gravel. Numerous discontinuous lenses of fine-grained sediments, including
laminated silts and unsorted debris flow deposits, are also present in the moraines.
Masterson et al. (1997) report that the Buzzards Bay Moraine resulted from the meltwater
deposition of sorted sediments within a stagnant ice margin overlying a basal till. The surface
of the moraine is characterized by an abundance of boulders. The till in the lower part of the
Buzzards Bay Moraine is comprised of sand, silt, and clay, and scattered gravel in a
compacted, unsorted matrix. The upper part of the Sandwich Moraine resulted from glacial
deformation of material; the lower part consists of sandy sediments.
The Mashpee Pitted Plain consists of fine- to coarse-grained sands forming a broad outwash
plain that lies to the east and south of the moraines, interior to MMR. Masterson et al. (1997)
report that the lower part of the Mashpee Pitted Plain consists of fine-grained,
glaciolacustrine sediments comprised of fine sand, silt, and clay. This laterally persistent
facies can be encountered underlying the moraines.
5-2
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
5.1.3. Topography
The central, southern, and eastern portions of Camp Edwards/MMR are generally flat, with
elevations rising to the north and west from 100 to 200 feet above sea level. The terrain in the
northern and western portions of Camp Edwards/MMR is mainly hilly with some steep-sided
hills, depressions, and valleys. Elevations in these areas range from 200 to 300 feet. Pine
Hill, the highest point on Camp Edwards, has an elevation of 306 feet above sea level
(USACE, 2001).
5.1.4. Soil
Two major soil map units exist in the Camp Edwards/MMR area; the Enfield-Merrimac-
Carver Association and the Plymouth-Barnstable-Nantucket Association. Enfield-Merrimac-
Carver soils are nearly level to steep, very deep, well-drained and excessively drained, loamy
and sandy soils on outwash plains. The association consists of about 25 percent Enfield soils,
25 percent Merrimac soils, 25 percent Carver soils, and 25 percent soils of minor extent. This
soil association exists primarily in the central, southern, and eastern portions of Camp
Edwards/MMR (USACE, 2001).
Plymouth-Barnstable-Nantucket soils are nearly level to steep, very deep, excessively
drained and well-drained, sandy and loamy soils on moraines. The association consists of
approximately 45 percent Plymouth soils, 25 percent Barnstable soils, 5 percent Nantucket
soils, and 25 percent soils of minor extent. This soil association exists primarily in the
northern and western portions of Camp Edwards/MMR (USACE, 2001).
Soils taken to a depth of 6 feet, to the northwest of the intersection of Howe and Turpentine
Roads, were described in field notes as “Sand. Mostly fine-coarse well graded sand. Trace
fine-course rounded gravel. Light brown, damp” (Tetra Tech EM, 2002).
5.1.5. Hydrogeology
A single groundwater flow system, known as the Cape Cod aquifer, specifically the
Sagamore lens, underlies all of Camp Edwards. The Cape Cod aquifer has been designated as
a sole-source aquifer by the EPA. The aquifer is recharged by the infiltration of rainfall
(USACE, 2001).
The total thickness of the aquifer underlying Camp Edwards/MMR varies from
approximately 80 feet in the south to about 350 feet in the north. The top 90 to 140 feet of the
aquifer contain well-sorted, brown, medium to very coarse sand with some gravel.
Underlying these deposits is finer-grained sand, silt, and clay. The whole aquifer overlies
crystalline bedrock (USACE, 2001).
5-3
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
The groundwater table varies from a high of 69 feet above sea level in the Camp Edwards
impact area to a low of 15 feet above sea level along the northwestern Camp Edwards/MMR
boundary (AMEC, 2003b; AMEC, 2006). Groundwater flow is generally radially outward
from the high point in the water table, located in the east central portion of Camp Edwards
(AMEC, 2003a). Typical yields from the aquifer can be well in excess of 1,000 gallons per
minute (USACE, 2001).
5.1.6. Hydrology
No major rivers or streams exist within Camp Edwards’ boundaries because of rapid
infiltration of rainfall into the sandy subsurface materials. However, intermittent streams are
present during moderate or heavy rainfall events. Several small freshwater ponds, typically
less than 10 acres, exist within Camp Edwards’ boundaries. Several larger ponds and two
rivers exist just outside of Camp Edwards’ boundaries (USACE, 2001).
5.1.7. Vegetation
The predominant ecosystem of Camp Edwards/MMR is upland forest. Mixed woods of pine
and oak dominate this ecosystem, with pitch pine/scrub oak barrens and hardwood forest
comprising less of the total acreage. The native grassland ecosystem comprises a relatively
small portion of Camp Edwards, but is one of the primary habitats for State-listed rare
species. The wetland ecosystems that exist on Camp Edwards/MMR are all classified as
palustrine, in that they are well-vegetated and most often lack open water. The Camp
Edwards/MMR as a whole is a “massive wooded area on the Upper Cape that is largely
undeveloped, but fringed with highways, homes, and other development” (Camp Edwards,
2001).
5.1.8. Ecology
Seven major plant communities exist on Camp Edwards: mixed woods forest, pitch pine-
scrub oak forest, hardwood forest, scrub oak barrens, grasslands, wetlands, and disturbed
communities. The species diversity of the forests of Camp Edwards/MMR is generally quite
low. On average, 53 species of plants were documented in each plant community of Camp
Edwards, which, when compared to most fertile woods of western New England that
typically have up to 200 plant species, is relatively low (Camp Edwards, 2001). The ponds
and wetlands, which comprise only 55 acres, or 3.9 percent, of Camp Edwards, are the most
diverse plant community: a total of 67 plant species were documented in the wetlands. There
is a total of 395 acres of grasslands located on Camp Edwards. The grasslands are one of the
least diverse plant communities on Camp Edwards, with only 37 identified species (Camp
5-4
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
5.1.9. Physiography
The surface topography of Camp Edwards/MMR varies greatly between the northern and
western portions and the southern portion. The northern and western portion of Camp
Edwards/MMR is part of the Sandwich and Buzzards Bay glacial moraines, respectively.
Large glacial deposits dominate this area, with high topographic relief of rolling hills and
deep kettle holes. Slopes range from 0-15 percent, with a mean slope of 3.4 percent. The
greatest change in topographic relief in this area of Camp Edwards/MMR is approximately
90 feet. The highest point on Cape Cod—Pine Hill (318 feet above sea level)—is situated in
this western portion of Camp Edwards, atop the Buzzards Bay Moraine. In contrast, the
southern portion of Camp Edwards, which resides entirely within the Mashpee pitted
outwash plain, has relatively low elevation (approximately 100 feet above sea level) and little
topographic relief. Although slopes range from 0-15 percent in the outwash plain, the mean
slope of 1.5 percent is considerably less in the moraine. The majority of the outwash plain
has a slope of 0-2 percent, with the exception of the approximately 20 kettle holes within the
area. (Camp Edwards, 2001)
5-5
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
MAARNG has leased or licensed portions of Camp Edwards/MMR to USCG, USAF, DVA,
and the Otis Fish and Game Club (USACE, 2001).
USCG operates a transmitter site on Camp Edwards/MMR property and has six units
performing various missions there. USCG housing and other facilities are also present on
Camp Edwards/MMR (USACE, 2001).
USAF, specifically the 6th Space Warning Squadron, owns and operates a facility on Camp
Edwards/MMR known as PAVE PAWS. The PAVE PAWS radar facility is used to provide
detection and warning against sea-launched and intercontinental ballistic missile attacks
(USACE, 2001).
DVA owns a portion of Camp Edwards/MMR on which it maintains a National Cemetery
(USACE, 2001).
The Otis Fish and Game Club uses Camp Edwards/MMR property to operate a small arms
range. This organization is mainly comprised of retired military personnel, and the Camp
Edwards/MMR Range Control manages the club’s property (USACE, 2001).
5-6
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
5.2.7. Demographics
Camp Edwards/MMR is located in Barnstable County, on Cape Cod, in southeastern
Massachusetts. The predominant land use surrounding Camp Edwards/MMR is residential or
commercial development. Although MMR is situated within four towns—Bourne, Sandwich,
Falmouth, and Mashpee— the Camp Edwards portion of MMR lies only within the
boundaries of Bourne and Sandwich.
Within the towns of Bourne and Sandwich, as of the 2000 Census, populations were 18,721
and 20,136, respectively. Bourne’s population is 49.3 percent male, and Sandwich is 48.6
percent male. Racially, Bourne is 94.7 percent white, 1.4 percent black, 0.7 percent Asian,
and 3.2 percent other races. Sandwich is 97.8 percent white, 0.4 percent black, 0.5 percent
Asian, and 1.3 percent other races. Average family size is 2.9 in Bourne and 3.18 in
Sandwich. Average family income in 1999 dollars was $51,603 in Bourne and $66,553 in
Sandwich. The percentages of individuals below poverty levels were 7.1 percent in Bourne
and 3.1 percent in Sandwich (http://factfinder.census.gov/).
5-7
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
5-8
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
the vesper sparrow (threatened), and the northern harrier (threatened). Camp Edwards/MMR
is inhabited by at least 27 species of mammals. The most common of these mammals is
likely the white-footed mouse. Nine other small mammals have been captured on Camp
Edwards. Ten species of medium-sized small mammals have been documented from visual
observations. The only mammals that have been observed on Camp Edwards/MMR that
could be classified as large mammals are the coyote and the white tailed deer.
Twelve species of reptiles, five turtle species and seven snake species, have been observed on
Camp Edwards, including two species of special concern—the eastern box turtle and the
spotted turtle. A total of 10 species of amphibians have been observed on Camp Edwards.
Five fish species have been documented within the wetlands of Camp Edwards: golden
shiner, bluegill, pumpkinseed, brown bullhead, and largemouth bass. Although no Federally-
listed threatened and endangered species have been observed on Camp Edwards, 37 State-
listed (i.e., endangered, threatened, and special concern) and 7 species on the unofficial
watch list have been observed on Camp Edwards.
Three species of State-listed plants and six watch-listed plant species have been identified on
Camp Edwards.
5-9
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
5-10
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
6-1
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
6-2
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
7. CONCLUSIONS
Fifteen potential MRSs and AOCs were evaluated under the Active Army MMRP.
Conclusions regarding these sites were developed in consultation with US EPA and
MassDEP. The 15 sites and recommended Closure Program are summarized in Table 7-1
and as follows:
ANG and Air Force Center of Engineering and Environmental (AFCEE): Sites identified on
Air Force-leased property will be addressed by ANG and AFCEE in their MMRP. The ANG
is considering the inclusion of these sites within the Federal Facilities Agreement (FFA) for
MMR.
7-1
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
Formerly Used Defense Sites (FUDS): Sites not located on MMR have been referred for
consideration by the FUDS Program.
• Scorton Neck AAATC Camp (No AEDB-R # assigned)
7-2
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
Closure Program
ARNG / IAGWSPO
ANG / AFCEE
Referred to
SDWA
AEDB-R Site
FUDS
FFA
Site Name Number Acreage Comments
7-3
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
7-4
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
8. REFERENCES
Adjutant General of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, 1909. Annual Report – Year
Ending December 31, 1908.
Air National Guard, January 1993. Record of Decision Interim Remedial Action Main Base
Landfill (AOC LF-1) Source Area Operable Unit. Massachusetts Military Reservation,
Cape Cod, Massachusetts. (Prepared for Hazardous Waste Remedial Actions Program,
Oak Ridge, Tennessee, by ABB Environmental Services, Inc.).
AMEC Earth and Environmental, Inc., February 14, 2003a. Figure 1 Site Wide
Characterization of Perchlorate in Groundwater.
AMEC Earth & Environmental, Inc., March 31, 2003b. Draft Final Technical Team
Memorandum 02-6 - Phase IIB Report, Camp Edwards, Massachusetts Military
Reservation, Cape Cod, Massachusetts (referred to as the Draft Final Phase IIB report).
AMEC Earth and Environmental, Inc., February 15, 2006. Draft Northwest Corner Remedial
Investigation Report. Document ID 8427.
Camp Edwards, 2001. Integrated Natural Resources Management Plan for Camp
Edwards/MMR (http://www.mass.gov/guard/E&RC/INRMP/Chapter 6, Natural
Resources on Camp Edwards.pdf).
Cecil Group, Inc., April 2005. Camp Edwards Site Consolidation Plan, 2005-2015, prepared
for Massachusetts Army National Guard.
CH2M Hill, July 2005. Final Landfill-1 2004 System Performance and Ecological Impact
Monitoring Report, prepared for AFCEE/MMR.
Charles T. Main, Inc., June 4, 1941. Architect-Engineer’s Report on Camp Edwards,
Falmouth, Mass.
Department of Defense, January 10, 2003, DoD Directive 3200.15 : Subject: Sustainment of
Ranges and Operating Areas (OPAREAs)
Department of Defense, May 10, 2004, DoD Directive 4715.11: Subject: Environmental and
Explosives Safety Management on Operational Ranges within the United States
Department of Defense, Office of the Deputy Under Secretary of Defense (Environmental
Security), September, 2001, Management Guidance for the Defense Environmental
Restoration Program (commonly referred to as DERP Management Guidance)
Environmental Planning Division, February 2003. Determination of Eligibility, Building #
assigned200, 102nd Fighter Wing, Otis Air National Guard Base, Sandwich, MA.
8-1
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
Environmental and Readiness Center, Massachusetts National Guard, January 2003. State of
the Reservation Report.
ITRC, January 2003a. Characterization and Remediation of Soils at Closed Small Arms
Firing Ranges.
ITRC, November 2003b. Technical/Regulatory Guidelines for Munitions Response
Historical Records Review.
Malcolm Pirnie, Inc., September 2003. U.S. Army Closed, Transferring and Transferred
Range/Site Inventory for Camp Edwards Training Site, MA,. referred to as CTT Range
Inventory Report.
Masterson, John P.; Stone, Byron D.; Walter, Donald A.; and Savoie, Jennifer, 1997.
Hydrogeologic framework of western Cape Cod, Massachusetts 1997 HA 741.
Metcalf & Eddy, Inc., January 1993. Installation Restoration Program, Phase I Records
Search, Otis Air National Guard Base, Massachusetts.
Office of the Secretary of Defense, Deputy Undersecretary of Defense (Personnel and
Readiness), February 2006. Report to Congress on Sustainable Ranges (commonly
known as the “Section 266 Report”).
Office of the Under Secretary of Defense (Installations and Environment), 29 December
2008, “Interim Policy for Defense Environmental Restoration Program (DERP)
Eligibility”
Phelan, Dr. Robert F., 1990s. From Carrier Pigeons to Carrier Pilots: An Overview of WWII
Military Activity on Cape Cod and the Islands. [ASR, D-2].
Tetra Tech EM, Inc., September 10, 2002. BA-1 Training Area Munitions Survey Program
Phase 2, Camp Edwards, Massachusetts, Final Report.
U.S. Army Assistant Chief of Staff for Installation Management (ACSIM), November 2004),
Army DERP Management Guidance for Active Installations
U.S. Army Center for Health Promotion and Preventive Medicine (CHPPM), June 2004.
Draft Army National Guard Focused Range Condition Assessment No. 38-EH-02VA-04
Massachusetts Army National Guard, Camp Edwards/MMR Selected Closed Ranges,
Barnstable County, Massachusetts.
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, July 1, 1943. B-44 Completion Report on Construction of
Various Additional Housing Facilities Extension of Landing Strips and on Air Support
Command Base at Camp Edwards/MMR Massachusetts. U.S. Army Corps of Engineers,
Boston District, NARA I, RG 77, Entry 391, Box 27 (source: USACE, 2001, E-8).
8-2
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Rock Island District, and Defense Ammunition Center,
January 1999. Ordnance and Explosives Archives Search Report for Massachusetts
Military Reservation.
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, Rock Island District, October 2001. Revised Ordnance and
Explosives Archives Search Report and Hazardous, Toxic and Radiological Waste
Preliminary Assessment for Massachusetts Military Reservation, Barnstable County,
Massachusetts.
U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, January 2002. Article in The Corps Environment Web site,
Camp Good News cleanup discovers, destroys UXO by Timothy J. Dugan.
U.S. Army Headquarters, April1994: Technical Manual (TM) 43-0001027: Army
Ammunition Data Sheets - Small Caliber Ammunition [FSC 1305]
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Office of Solid Waste and Emergency Response,
August 1994. Revised Interim Soil Lead Guidance for CERCLA Sites and RCRA
Corrective Action Facilities, EPA OSWER Directive # assigned 9355.4.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, Letter of 26 May 2009, Lynne Jennings to Kent
Gonser, regarding Historical Records Review, Anny National Guard Training Site, Camp
Edwards, Massachusetts Military Reservation, Massachusetts
U.S. Government, December 28, 2001, Public Law 107–107: National Defense
Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2002
U.S. Government, Federal Register, October 5, 2005, 32 Code of Federal Regulations (CFR)
179, Final Rule, Munitions Response Site Prioritization Protocol (drawn from website,
http://www.thefederalregister.com/d.p/2005-10-05-05-19696)
8-3
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
8-4
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
APPENDICES
APPENDICES
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
APPENDICES
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
APPENDICES
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
APPENDICES
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
Heritage Research Center, Ltd. conducted archival research related to this installation.
The following lists the repositories visited and sources reviewed in that effort. The list
reflects the entries/collections and boxes we actually reviewed. It should be noted that
Heritage reviewed finding aids and catalogs extensively for each repository, entry and
collection to identify potentially relevant materials for review.
Textual Branch
RG 338, U.S. Army Operational, Tactical and Support Organizations, World War II-
present
• Entry 109, Operating Program Records, 1968-1978 – Finding aid did not include
reference for any information relevant to this installation.
• Entry 189, Historical Reports, 1950-1958, 8th Army
o Boxes 1495-1497 – No information relevant to this installation.
• Entry 242, Command Reports, 1951-1953
o Nothing relevant to this installation; materials concerned Korean War
operations.
• Entry 37042, Unit Histories, 1940-1947, Ordnance Detachments
o Boxes 5160-5164, 5027-5033, 5206-5216, 5276, 5284-5292 and 5993 –
No information relevant to this installation.
• Entry 42851, HQ 5th Army Ordnance Sec., Bomb Disposal Operation Reports
o Boxes 1-4 – No information relevant to this installation; concerned
operations overseas.
• Entry 42852, HQ 5th Army Ordnance Sec.
o Box 1 – No information relevant to this installation.
Documents
Checked?
Found?
Source
# Source Web Site (if any) Comments
DOD Information Sources
1 Air Force Historical Research Agency, http://www.maxwell.af.mil/au/afhra/ Air Force Historical Reports and Documents. Personal Papers in the AFHA.
Maxwell Air Force Base, AL http://www.maxwell.af.mil/au/afhra/personal_papers/personal_papers.html. This link had a list of entries by authors alphabetically. Did not pursue this
this link as it would consume too much time. Link accessed 1/28/07.
Numbered USAF Historical Studies. http://www.maxwell.af.mil/au/afhra/numbered_studies/studiesintro.asp. The historical studies listed in this link
have been prepared primarily for use within the Air Force, but are available for loan or purchase under certain conditions. There are 200 numbered
studies. Word search for "edwards" did not yield any hits in the titles of the numbered studies. Link accessed 1/28/07.
World War II. Research Division
Organizational History Branch. http://www.maxwell.af.mil/au/afhra/world_war2/world_war2.html. Army Air Force Statistical Digest.
http://www.maxwell.af.mil/au/afhra/aafsd/aafsd_index_table.html. This link provided pdfs of parts of the digest - cover pages, corrections, preface,
glossary, and list of tables. The preface pdf link indicated that this digest is a summary of statistics on AAF personnel, aircraft, equipment, combat
operations and other operations during WWII. The aircraft and equipment page -
http://www.maxwell.af.mil/au/afhra/aafsd/aafsd_list_of_tables_aircraftequipment.html - lists links to tables of aircraft and artillery used in different
combat theaters and when they were used. Table 86 - Combat and Transport Airplanes on Hand in Continental US, By Type of Airplane and By Air
Force or Command: Oct 1942 to Aug 1945.....Page 144 http://www.maxwell.af.mil/au/afhra/aafsd/aafsd_pdf/t086.pdf provides total numbers of combat
aircrafts used per year. Does not provide specific locations. It appears that most of these tables provide chronologic totals but no specific locations.
Additional links were not accessed due to time constraints and estimated that no relevant information will be retrieved. 1/28/07
Korean War. http://www.maxwell.af.mil/au/afhra/korean_war/korean_war.html. USAF Organizations in Korea.
http://www.maxwell.af.mil/au/afhra/korean_war/usaf_organizations_korea/usaf_organizations_korea.html. These links provide information pertaining to
combat operations and military organizations. Additional links were not accessed due to time constraints and estimated that no relevant information
will be obtained. 1/28/07
Vietnam War. http://www.maxwell.af.mil/au/afhra/vietnam_war/vietnam.html. Links were not accessed due to time constraints and estimated that no
relevant information will be obtained. 1/28/07
Army Air Forces in World War II, Vol VI. http://www.maxwell.af.mil/au/afhra/photo_galleries/aaf_wwii_vol_vi/Army_Air_Forces_in_WWII.htm. Photos
did not show relevant information. 1/29/07.
2 Defense Environmental Network & https://www.denix.osd.mil/ Word Search of "Camp Edwards" yielded the 33 links. Many of the 33 links provide estimated budgets for past fiscal years to clean up Camp
Information Exchange Edwards. Some relevant links are provided below.
RDX. https://www.denix.osd.mil/denix/Public/Library/MERIT/rdx_page.html. RDX contaminated soil and groundwater has been found at some ranges
located within the following military facilities: Fort Lewis (WA); Fort Richardson (AK); Yakima Training (WA); Massachusetts Military Reservation
(Camp Edwards section MA); Camp Shelby (MS); Camp Guersey (WY) and Fort Ord (CA). 1/29/07
MMRP Status of Installations with FY05 Completion Cost Estimated Less than or Equal to $5,000,000.
https://www.denix.osd.mil/denix/Public/News/OSD/DEP2004/appL-attach2.pdf. Camp Edwards listed in this table. 1/29/07
Massachusetts Military Reservation environmental clean up fact sheet. Shows clean up estimates projected to FY2022.
https://www.denix.osd.mil/denix/Public/Library/Cleanup/CleanupOfc/arc/Reports/FY1997/kis-mas.pdf 1/29/07
Alternative Causes of Widespread, Low Concentration Perchlorate Impacts to Groundwater, Strategic Environmental Research and Development
Program (SERDP), July 22, 2005.
https://www.denix.osd.mil/denix/Public/Library/MERIT/Perchlorate/newsroom/announcements/documents/PerchlorateAlternativeSources.pdf. This
report speculates that perchlorate contamination in groundwater at Camp Edwards may come from fireworks displays from Upper Cape Cod Regional
Technical School (p. 22). 1/29/07
Word Search of "Camp Sandwich" yielded no results. 2/8/07.
Word Search of "Cape Cod Munitions" yielded 11 links. Some pertinent links are provided below:
Dictionary of Army/DoD Environmental Terms and Acronyms https://www.denix.osd.mil/denix/Public/Library/Partner/REC/Infor_lib/dictionary.doc.
Provides description of Massachusetts Military Reservation, groundwater contamination, and EPA involvement, but does not say that contamination is
a result of munitions. 2/8/07
Word search for neighboring town names, Massachusetts Military Reservation and Otis Air Force Base with "munitions"' and "ordnance" did not yield
results. Town names include Sagamore, Sandwich, West Barnstable, Marston Mills, Mashpee, Wakeby, Forestdale, Hatchville, North Falmouth,
Cataurnet, Pocasset, Buzzards Bay, and Bournedale. 2/9/07.
Documents
Checked?
Found?
Source
# Source Web Site (if any) Comments
3 Defense Environmental Restoration http://www.lrb.usace.army.mil/derpfud January 2000 Fact Sheet. http://www.lrb.usace.army.mil/derpfuds/facts/fs-derpfuds.pdf. No relevant information. 1/30/07
Program—Formerly Used Defense Sites s/
(DERP-FUDS),
Risk Assessment Fact Sheet March 2002. http://www.lrb.usace.army.mil/derpfuds/facts/fs-risk.pdf. No relevant information. 1/30/07.
DERP FUDS Program Page. http://hq.environmental.usace.army.mil/programs/fuds/fuds.html. This page and its links did not provide relevant
information. 1/30/07.
4 Defense Supply Center Richmond, http://www.dscr.dla.mil/ No relevant information. 1/30/07.
Richmond, VA
5 Defense Technical Information Center http://www.dtic.mil/ Search for "camp edwards munitions" yielded several links:
Munitions Survey Project Expands to Include New Areas of Camp Edwards. April 9, 2002.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2002/apr9a.html. This news release provides useful information on possible locations of buried
munitions and UXOs at Camp Edwards. 1/30/07
US Army Environmental Command. Environmental Update. Winter 2004. Soil Cleanup Begins at Camp Edwards.
http://www.aec.army.mil/usaec/publicaffairs/update/win04/win0403.html. Soil and groundwater contamination cleanup begins at Demolition Area 1, a
former demolition area training site. 1/30/07.
US Army Environmental Command. Environmental Update. Winter 2005. Groundwater Cleanup Begins at Camp Edwards.
http://www.aec.army.mil/usaec/publicaffairs/update/win04/win0403.html. Groundwater contamination cleanup begins at Demolition Area 1. 1/30/07.
US Army Environmental Center. Tungsten Study at Camp Edwards. Small Arms Range Tungsten Evaluation.
http://www.aec.army.mil/usaec/publicaffairs/tungsten02.pdf.
Camp Edwards Schedules Unexploded Munitions Detonations. March 5, 2002.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2002/mar5.html. The items being blown-in-place include one rocket located in Demolition Area
I, and seven projectiles and one mortar located in the Central Impact Area. Detonations in the Central Impact Area also will include eleven 60-mm
mortars. These mortars are suspected to contain white phosphorous, a highly flammable substance, which makes them unsuitable for storage or for
destroying in the Contained Detonation Chamber. 1/30/07.
Munitions Detonation Planned at Camp Edwards. News Release. October 26, 2004.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2004/oct26.html. The items being destroyed include an explosives fuze that was found at a
former target in the Central Impact Area. The other items include three 40-millimeter (mm) grenades and 38 30-mm projectiles. These munitions items
were found in the former military training and defense contractor testing site known as the J-2 Range. 2/1/07.
Munitions Detonation Planned at Camp Edwards. News Release. July 12, 2004.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2004/jul12.html. Two of the munitions items, which include one 4.2" mortar round, and one 105-
millimeter (mm) projectile, were found at a former Central Impact Area target location being investigated in preparation for a future rapid response
action. The other item is an 81- mm mortar round found in the former training and defense contractor testing site known as the J-2 Range. 2/1/07.
Munitions Detonation Planned at Camp Edwards. News Release. February 20, 2002.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2002/feb20b.html. The Impact Area Groundwater Study Program announced it will conduct an
open detonation, or blow-in-place, of unexploded munitions, including three 105 mm projectiles and two 81 mm mortars, on Friday, February 22, 2002,
between 8 a.m. and 5 p.m. The detonation will be on the "J-1" Range located on the Southeast corner of Camp Edwards on the Massachusetts Military
Reservation. 2/1/07.
Munitions Detonation Planned at Camp Edwards. News Release. May 4, 2004.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2004/may4a.html. An open detonation to destroy 37 rocket motors is scheduled between 9
a.m. and 5 p.m. on Thursday at Camp Edwards on the Massachusetts Military Reservation.The rocket motors were found during clearance activities on
a former training and defense contractor testing site known as the J-3 Range. Six additional items were added to the open detonation schedule
following distribution of the release. These include four 81-millimeter mortar rounds found during road construction on the J-1 Range, and a 40-
millimeter mortar round and a 60-millimeter mortar round found during excavation activities in the former open burn and detonation area known as
Demolition Area 1 2/1/07
Documents
Checked?
Found?
Source
# Source Web Site (if any) Comments
Groundwater Cleanup Decision Issued for Part of Camp Edwards. US Army Environmental Command. Nov 2, 2006.
http://www.aec.army.mil/usaec/publicaffairs/news/news13.html. Plans to cleanup contaminated gw plume that is slowly migrating from a 7.4-acre
portion of Camp Edwards, approximately two miles northeast of the Otis Rotary in Bourne. 2/1/07.
Word Search "Massachusetts Military Reservation munition" yielded 1301 links. Here are a few relevant links:
Lessons of the Massachusetts Military Reservation. April 2001. Lt.Col.William F. Fitzpatrick Massachusetts Army National Guard.
http://www.aepi.army.mil/internet/mass-mil-reservation-lessons.pdf This research paper explores past actions at MMR and why environmental
stewardship did not work and how lessons learned can be applied to other active installations. 2/9/07
District sweeps Massachusetts property for munitions. USACE New England District. Vol 35, No. 8. Yankee Engineer. June
1999.http://www.nae.usace.army.mil/news/jun996.htm. At the request of the citizens of Sandwich, Massachusetts, the New England District, partnered
with the Huntsville District and Congressman William Dellahunt, conducted a limited site investigation for munitions at 12 residential lots along the
Massachusetts Military Reservation fence. The final lot was inspected on May 26. No dangerous munitions were found on any of the properties.
2/9/07
Fact Sheet 2001-2002. Groundwater Study Program at Massachusetts Military Reservation.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/community/facts/fact.html. Provides description of groundwater study program, its goals, adminstrative orders,
status of investigations, contaminated areas, and responses. 2/9/07.
USEPA Region 1. EPA Docket No.: RCRA 1-2001-0014. Adminstrative Order, As Modified, For Use Of Controlled Detonation Chamber for Waste
Munitions. Training Range and Impact Area, Massachusetts Military Reservation, National Guard Bureau and Massachusetts National Guard,
Respondents. Proceeding Under Section 7003 of the Resource Recovery and Conservation Act, 42 U.S.C. 6973.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/admin/orders/Ao4mmr.pdf 2/9/07.
Department of Defense MERIT. https://www.denix.osd.mil/denix/Public/Library/MERIT/Perchlorate/efforts/sites/ma/sites/MMR.html. "Live fire artillery-
training, infantry squad and platoon combat firing, open burn/open detonation (OB/OD) and other military training activities involving the use of
propellants, explosives and pyrotechnics was conducted on MMR from 1911 until 1997 when a series of Administrative Orders (AOs) were issued to
prevent the sole source aquifer underlying the region from becoming contaminated with munitions constituents from the training activities." 2/9/07
News Releases and Notices. Unexploded Munitions to be Detonated. News Release. Jan 2, 2002. http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2002/jan2.html. The
Http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/g three items are one 37MM projectile and two 81MM mortars. All are located near the center of the Camp Edwards Impact Area in the MMR. 2/1/07.
roundwater/news/2002
Unexploded Munition to be Detonated. News Release. Jan 8, 2002. http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2002/jan8.html. The item
is an 81MM mortar and is located near the center of the Camp Edwards Impact Area in the MMR.It cannot be moved safely and will be destroyed in
place. This method of disposal eliminates an unsafe situation for groundwater study field technicians. 2/1/07.
National Guard Removing Buried Ordnance at MMR. News Release. Jan 18, 2002.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2002/jan18.html. Several disposal areas have been uncovered at the J-1 and J-2 ranges. A
variety of materials, including propellant, inert munitions and burn residues were encountered during the recent investigations. The uncovered items
included 40 mm grenades, 81 mm inert mortars, 105 mm inert practice rounds, 105 mm cartridge cases and other miscellaneous items. These items
were primarily inert and judged to be remnants of former contractor and military use of the ranges. Over 500 items, classified as inert, have been
removed from these sites and placed in secure storage for appropriate disposal. Three items from these sites required special handling due to the
presence of propellant residue or live fuzes. These items have been placed in secure storage and will be destroyed in the Contained Detonation
Chamber (CDC) on base. The CDC allows safe disposal of items containing propellants and high explosives. 2/1/07.
Unexploded Munitions to be Detonated. News Release. Jan 23, 2002. http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2002/jan23.html. The
two items are a105MM projectile and a 155MM projectile. Both are located near the center of the Camp Edwards Impact Area in the MMR. 2/1/07.
Unexploded Munitions to be Detonated. News Release. Jan 29, 2002. http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2002/jan29.html. The
twelve items are nine 30MM projectiles, one 3.5" rocket, one 66MM rocket motor with hazardous fuze and one 60MM mortar. The 60MM mortar is
located near the center of the Camp Edwards Impact Area in the MMR; the other eleven items are located on the J-2 range. 2/1/07.
Documents
Checked?
Found?
Source
# Source Web Site (if any) Comments
Unexploded Munitions to be Detonated. News Release. Feb 5, 2002. http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2002/feb5.html. The
four items are a 105MM projectile, a 155MM projectile, a 81MM mortar and a 37MM projectile. All of the items are located near the center of the Camp
Edwards Impact Area in the MMR. 2/1/07.
Munitions Detonation Scheduled at Camp Edwards. News Release. Feb 13, 2002.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2002/feb13a.html. An open detonation, or blow-in-place, of unexploded munitions, including
three 81mm mortars and one fuze, will occur Friday, February 15, 2002, between 8 a.m. and 5 p.m., at Camp Edwards on the Massachusetts Military
Reservation. The items to be detonated are located in the "J-1" Range that borders the western edges of the Wind Song and Grand Oak Roads area.
2/1/07.
Munitions Detonation Scheduled at Camp Edwards. News Release. Feb 20, 2002.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2002/feb20b.html. The Impact Area Groundwater Study Program announced it will conduct an
open detonation, or blow-in-place, of unexploded munitions, including three 105 mm projectiles and two 81 mm mortars, on Friday, February 22, 2002,
between 8 a.m. and 5 p.m. The detonation will be on the "J-1" Range located on the Southeast corner of Camp Edwards on the Massachusetts Military
Reservation. 2/1/07.
Camp Edwards Schedules Unexploded Munitions Detonation. News Release. Mar 5, 2002.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2002/mar5.html. The items being blown-in-place include one rocket located in Demolition Area
I, and seven projectiles and one mortar located in the Central Impact Area. Detonations in the Central Impact Area also will include eleven 60-mm
mortars. These mortars are suspected to contain white phosphorous, a highly flammable substance, which makes them unsuitable for storage or for
destroying in the Contained Detonation Chamber. 2/1/07.
Camp Edwards Cleanup Requires Unexploded Munitions Detonation. News Release. Mar 13, 2002.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2002/mar13.html. The Groundwater Study Program has conducted a number of blow-in-place
detonations in recent weeks due to a large number of munitions being found during the investigation of the "J-1" training range. Historically, this area
was used as a defense- contractor test range. Past activities at this and two other contractor-operated ranges resulted in ordnance being disposed of
on and below the ground surface. "So far we've located more than 2,500 rounds of unexploded ordnance in this range alone," said Ben Gregson,
Program Manager for the Groundwater Study Program. 2/1/07.
Unexploded Munitions Scheduled for Detonation at Camp Edwards. News Release. Apr 2, 2002.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2002/apr2.html. Two unexploded 105-millimeter projectiles will be destroyed in an open or
"blow-in-place" detonation Thursday, April 4, at Camp Edwards on the Massachusetts Military Reservation (MMR). The detonations, which do not
affect the Sandwich neighborhood buffer zone, will take place between 8 a.m. and 5 p.m. There is no risk to residents of the nearby area.
Munitions Survey Project Expands to Include New Areas of Camp Edwards. News Release. Apr 9, 2002.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2002/apr9a.html. The Munitions Survey Project began after the 1997 discovery of 1,100 inert
81-millimeter mortars in a burial pit on a now inactive testing range located on the Southeast corner of Camp Edwards. The ten new sites constitute
Phase III of the Munitions Survey Project. Ongoing investigations at 15 other sites were initiated during Phase I and II. So far, 15 burial pits and five
burn pits have been uncovered in the Southeast corner of the ranges, Demolition Area 1, the ASP area and two ponds. These yielded a total of almost
9,900 items, which included mortars, projectiles, small arms ammunition and a variety of other munitions or cartridge casings. Excavations on the
Southeast Ranges uncovered a military tank and two cars. Another car and a freezer were found buried in one of the other sites. These also have been
removed 2/1/07
Two Unexploded Munitions Scheduled for Open Detonation. News Release. Apr 23, 2002.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2002/apr23.html. Two unexploded munitions found in the Central Impact Area at Camp
Edwards on the Massachusetts Military Reservation (MMR) will be destroyed in open or blow-in-place detonations between 8 a.m. and 5 p.m. on
Thursday, April 25. The items include an 81-millimeter mortar and a 75-millimeter projectile, which were found by Groundwater Study Program
contractors while clearing drilling sites for two new monitoring wells near the southeast corner of the impact area. The wells are being installed as part
of the program's investigation into groundwater contamination resulting from historic training activities. 2/1/07.
Documents
Checked?
Found?
Source
# Source Web Site (if any) Comments
Blow-In-Place Detonation Scheduled at Camp Edwards.News Release. May 1, 2002.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2002/may1.html. An open or blow-in-place detonation of ten items will be conducted on the
southeast corner of the ranges at Camp Edwards, Friday, May 3, 2002, between 8 a.m. and 5 p.m. The detonations will be in the former defense
contractor testing ranges near the Sandwich boundary. The items being destroyed include 10 fuzes, one of which is attached to a 66-millimeter rocket.
The fuzes were discovered during excavation of two burial pits in the J-2 range being investigated as part of the Impact Area Groundwater Study
Program's Munitions Survey Project. More than 250 munitions have been found in these burial pits. Most have been inert and will be demilitarized and
recycled. The site also contained 850 pounds of non-munitions-related scrap, which also will be removed. 2/1/07.
Munitions Scheduled for Detonation at Camp Edwards. News Release. May 14, 2002.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2002/may14b.html. Five munitions found in recent burial and burn pit excavations on the
southeast corner of the ranges at Camp Edwards will be destroyed in an open or blow-in-place detonation Thursday, May 16, 2002, between 9 a.m.
and 5 p.m. by contractors for the Impact Area Groundwater Study Program. The items being destroyed include four 66-millimeter HEAT projectiles
and one 81-millimeter mortar. The munitions were discovered during the investigation of a burial pit in the J-2 range. Excavation work, which was
completed last week, uncovered 789 munitions-related items and 500 pounds of scrap. Most of munitions were expended or inert and more than 750
items are scheduled for recycling. The remaining items will be moved to a safe storage area for future disposal in the Contained Detonation Chamber.
2/1/07.
Blow-In-Place Detonation Scheduled at Camp Edwards. News Release. May 17, 2002.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2002/may17.html. An open or blow-in-place detonation of a 3.5" rocket will take place
Tuesday, May 21, 2002, at Camp Edwards on the Massachusetts Military Reservation. Contractors for the Impact Area Groundwater Study Program
will conduct the munitions detonation between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m. The rocket was discovered during clearing activities for a new monitoring well being
installed to test groundwater in the Central Impact area. 2/1/07.
Blow In Place Detontation Scheduled Near Sandwich Boundary. News Release. June 5, 2002.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2002/jun5b.html. A 2.36-inch rocket, found northwest of the Massachusetts Military
Reservations’ Sandwich Gate, and other munitions, found on the northern portion of the J-2 range, will be destroyed in and open or blow-in-place
detonation Friday, June 7, 2002. Contractors for the Impact Area Groundwater Study Program will conduct the munitions detonations between 9 a.m.
and 5 p.m. 2/2/07.
Two Mortar Rounds Scheduled for Detonation at Camp Edwards. News Release. June 25, 2005.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2002/jun25.html. Two 81-millimeter mortar rounds will be destroyed in open or blow-in-place
detonations at Camp Edwards, Thursday, June 27, 2002, between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m. 2/2/07.
Open Detonations Scheduled for Thursday at Camp Edwards. News Release. Jul 9, 2002.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2002/jul9.html. Open or blow-in-place detonations of 12 military munitions will take place
Thursday, July 11, 2002, at Camp Edwards on the Massachusetts Military Reservation. All of the items, which include one 5-inch rocket, six 155-
milimeter practice projectiles and five 155-milimeter high-explosive projectiles, were found in the Central Impact Area, approximately two miles from
the Town of Sandwich boundary. 2/2/07.
Military Munitions Scheduled for Open Detonation on Thursday. News Release. Jul 30, 2002.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2002/jul30.html. Eight military munitions will be destroyed in open or blow-in-place detonations
between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m. on Thursday, August 1, 2002, at Camp Edwards on the Massachusetts Military Reservation. Groundwater Study Program
workers discovered the one 7-inch, one 105-millimeter and six 155-millimeter projectiles during the clearing of vegetation at the SCAR Rocket Site in
the Impact Area at the center of the base. The area is being cleared for a geophysical study as part of the Munitions Survey Project investigations into
unexploded ordnance and munitions disposed of or fired as a part of past training at Camp Edwards. 2/2/07.
Military Munitions Investigatin Begins Near Sandwich Boundary. News Release. Aug 13, 2002.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2002/aug13.html. An investigation of 10 possible military-munitions burial sites will begin
Wednesday, August 14, 2002, near Camp Edwards’ boundary with the Forestdale neighborhood of Sandwich. 2/2/07.
Documents
Checked?
Found?
Source
# Source Web Site (if any) Comments
Open Detonations For Three Items Set for Thursday. News Release. Aug 20, 2002.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2002/aug20.html. Open detonations to destroy three 155-millimeter projectiles will be
conducted at Camp Edwards, Thursday, August 22, 2002, between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m. The detonation area is approximately two miles from any of the
Massachusetts Military Reservation’s boundaries and there is no risk to residents of nearby areas.Groundwater Study Program workers discovered the
three projectiles during vegetation clearing for a geophysical study of the SCAR Rocket Site. This portion of the Impact Area, near the center of the
base, previously was used for subcaliber aircraft rocket and other artillery training. These projectiles failed to explode as expected when they were
initially fired. Explosive experts for the Groundwater Study Program have determined that they are unsafe to move and pose a potential risk to workers
in the area, so will need to be destroyed in place. 2/2/07.
Military Munitions Set for Destruction at Camp Edwards. News Release. Aug 27, 2002.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2002/aug27.html. Two 105-millimeter projectiles will be destroyed in open detonations at Camp
Edwards, Thursday, August 29, 2002, between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m. These projectiles failed to explode as expected when they were initially fired into the
SCAR Rocket Site, which previously was used for subcaliber aircraft rocket and other artillery training. 2/2/07.
Two Open Detonations Scheduled Thursday at Camp Edwards. News Release. Sept 17, 2002.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2002/sep17.html. Open detonations of unexploded military munitions will take place on two of
Camp Edwards’ Southeast Ranges, between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m. on Thursday. The detonation of 59 practice rockets will be conducted on the N Range,
a former defense contractor testing and training area. The rockets were found in a burial area on the western portion of the range. They are inert, but it
is possible that the attached fuzes contain explosives. The burial was uncovered in an investigation of potential burial sites that began in August.
Although several of the 13 sites investigated on the N Range contained empty military munitions casings, this is the first discovery of potential
unexploded ordnance. A second open detonation of five 57-millimeter projectiles will be conducted on the northern portion of the J-2 Range, another
former defense contractor testing and training area. These munitions also were found in a burial area. An investigation of the J-2 Range for potential
Military Projectile Scheduled for Open Detonation at Camp Edwards. News Release. Sept 24, 2002.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2002/sep24.html. An unexploded 105-millimeter projectile will be destroyed in an open
detonation on Camp Edwards’ Southeast Ranges, Thursday between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m. The projectile was found during site clearance for installation
of a new monitoring well on the northern portion of the J-1 Range, a former defense contractor testing and training area. The detonation will be on the
portion of the range furthest from the base’s Sandwich boundary and will not affect the Sandwich Neighborhood Buffer Zone. There is no risk to
residents of nearby areas. 2/2/07.
Detonations of Two Military Projectiles Scheduled for Wednesday. News Release. Oct 21, 2002.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2002/oct21.html. Two 155-millimeter projectiles will be destroyed in open detonations at Camp
Edwards Wednesday, between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m. This project is looking at 25 former training or defense contractor testing sites identified as potentially
containing munitions that were discarded, buried or failed to explode on impact and, if necessary, clear them of unexploded munitions that could
potentially pose a threat to public safety.A total of 14 areas, selected through geophysical surveys using magnetic readings to locate buried metal, are
being investigated on the SCAR Rocket Site as part of the project. The projectiles were discovered about 12 inches beneath the surface and were
determined to be explosive munitions that did not properly detonate when fired. 2/2/07.
Open Detonations of 400 Military Munitions Planned at Camp Edwards. News Release. Dec 17, 2002.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2002/dec17.html. Several open detonations are scheduled Thursday to destroy 349 3.5-inch
practice rockets and 51 40-millimeter practice projectiles. The 349 practice rockets were found on or just below the surface during clearing and
investigation of an area known as the U-Range. Located north of the Central Impact Area, this range formerly was used for practice firing with a variety
of rockets, mortars and similar military munitions. The 51 practice projectiles were discovered during the excavation of a munitions burial and burn pit,
in the area known as the J-2 Range. This is one of several ranges on the southeast corner of the base previously used for training and defense
contractor testing. 2/2/07.
Documents
Checked?
Found?
Source
# Source Web Site (if any) Comments
Unfired Depleted-Uranium Munition Item Reported at Camp Edwards. News Release. June 3, 2004.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2004/jun03.html. Trained munitions experts have identified an unfired 20-millimeter projectile
as a probable depleted-uranium or DU round. The projectile, which is approximately 2.5-inches in length and one-half-inch in diameter, was found
during cleanup activities at Camp Edwards. The munition item and the soil around it have been placed in safe storage until they can be disposed of in
accordance with applicable regulations. The corroded 20-millimeter round was found during the investigation of a potential burn pit in a former open
burn and detonation site known as Demolition Area 1. 2/2/07.
Open Detonations Scheduled at Camp Edwards on Thursday. News Release. Dec 7, 2004.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2004/dec7.html. Three munitions items will be destroyed in open detonations scheduled for
between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m. Thursday at Camp Edwards on the Massachusetts Military Reservation. The items being destroyed include two 37-
millimeter (mm) projectiles found in an area of the base about a mile southeast of the Bourne Rotary known as the Former A Range. The projectiles
were discovered during work to clear this former training range for the installation of a groundwater monitoring well. 2/2/07.
Impact Area Review Team. Meeting Minutes. June 28, 2000. http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/community/impact/minutes/2000/jun28.htm.
Meeting between USACE, EPA, MADEP, private citizens, etc. discussing storage of prohibitied munitions at Camp Edwards. Mr. Hugus (citizen)
explained that there are small-arms ranges along Greenway Road in Sandwich, which are within a couple hundred feet of a residential area..
Speculations about General Electric (GE) activities at Camp Edwards. Includes discussions on real estate, health concerns, detonations, groundwater
monitoring, data validation, etc. 2/2/07.
Open Detonations Schedule for Thursday at Camp Edwards. News Release. Apr 6, 2004.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2004/apr6.html. Two military munitions will be destroyed between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m. Thursday,
April 8, in open detonations at Camp Edwards on the Massachusetts Military Reservation. The items being destroyed include a 2.36-inch rocket and a
40-millimeter mortar.The items are being detonated at the site known as Demolition Area 1, which formerly was used for munitions burning and
detonation. 2/2/07.
Military Munitions Scheduled for Open Detonation on Thursday. News Release. Nov 18, 2003.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2003/nov18.html. Nine military munitions will be destroyed in open detonations at Camp
Edwards between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m., Thursday. The detonations will take place at least one-half mile from any residential areas and do not represent a
risk to nearby residents. The items being detonated include a 3-inch and a 5-inch projectile, a 40-millimeter practice grenade, a 4.2-inch mortar round,
an 81-millimeter mortar round and four 4.5-inch barrage rockets. The projectiles and grenade will be destroyed at the site known as Demolition Area 1,
which formerly was used for munitions burning and detonation. 2/2/07.
Two Munitions Scheduled for Open Detonation on Tuesday. News Release. Jan 9, 2004.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/news/2004/jan09.html. Two military munitions will be destroyed in open detonations on Tuesday,
Jan. 13, between 9 a.m. and 5 p.m., at Camp Edwards on the Massachusetts Military Reservation.The munitions are 81-millimeter mortar rounds
uncovered during road clearance being completed as part of the Groundwater Study Program's cleanup and investigation activities. 2/2/07.
AMEC. Powerpoint presentation. A case for background levels of arsenic in groundwater at the Massachusetts Military Reservation.
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/groundwater/papers/ArsenicConf2002Presentation.pdf. Provides data, graphs, maps, gw flow models, etc.
concludes that arsenic in groundwater not a result of military training activities. 2/2/07.
USACE Engineer Research and Development Center. Distribution and Fate of Energetics on DoD Test and Training Ranges: Interim Report 6. Nov
2006. http://el.erdc.usace.army.mil/elpubs/pdf/tr06-12.pdf. 308 page document. The objective of the study was to characterize the distribution and fate
of explosive residues from various training activities and impact to soil and groundwater. Discusses demolition areas, low order detonation sites, and
firing positions as potentials for accumulation of residues. Camp Edwards studies mentioned throughout this report. 2/2/07.
APR/FY06. MTA Camp Edwards, Massachusetts. Army Defense Environmental Restoration Program Installation Action Plan. June 2006.
http://www.aec.army.mil/dev/cleanup/aic-ma-02.pdf. Provides MMRP site descriptions and funding for cleaning up various ranges at Camp Edwards.
Discusses when ranges were built, uses, types of training, and munitions. 2/2/07.
Documents
Checked?
Found?
Source
# Source Web Site (if any) Comments
6 Defense Visual Information Center http://www.dodmedia.osd.mil/dvic/ind Searched "Camp Edwards". Photo from June 2005 - LVTP-7 tracked landing vehicles form a convoy after their landing on Scusset Beach and then
ex.htm move to Camp Edwards Army Base. They are part of the 36th Marine Amphibious Unit exercise. Rest of photos - "Edwards" appeared in photo
captions either as military personnel and/or photographer name. 2/2/07.
7 Department of Defense Publications www.defenselink.mil/pubs/archive.htm http://www.defenselink.mil/sites/e.html ► Searched under E for "environment" ► http://www.acq.osd.mil/ie/safety.htm
Archive l ►https://www.denix.osd.mil/denix/Public/Library/Sustain/Ranges/sustainableranges.html this is a page on sustainable ranges, but has no site specific
information about Camp Edwards. Searched under L for "land mines" which yielded no entries for "land mines"; Searched under M for "munitions"
which yielded no entries for "munitions". 2/2/07
8 DoD Explosives Safety Board (DDESB) http://www.ddesb.pentagon.mil/ DoD Ammunitions and Explosives Safety Standard. Oct 5, 2004. http://www.ddesb.pentagon.mil/DoD6055.9-STD%205%20Oct%202004.pdf. No site
specific information. 2/2/07. Did not print document.
Army Regulation 385-64. US Army Explosives Safety Program. Feb 1, 2000. http://www.army.mil/usapa/epubs/pdf/r385_64.pdf. No site specific
information. 2/2/07. Did not print document.
Department of the Army Pamphlet 385-64. Dec 15, 1999. http://www.army.mil/usapa/epubs/pdf/p385_64.pdf. No site specific information. 2/2/07.
Did not print document.
link to NAVSEA OP-5 Service Standard - not allowed access. 2/2/07.
OPNAVINST 8020-14. http://neds.daps.dla.mil/Directives/8020_14.pdf. Page not found. 2/2/07
AFMAN 91-21. Oct 18, 2001. http://www.e-publishing.af.mil/pubfiles/af/91/afman91-201/afman91-201.pdf.
http://www.army.mil/usapa/epubs/pdf/p385_64.pdf. No site specific information. 2/2/07. Did not print document.
MCO 8020.13. Oct 14, 2003. Explosives Safety Review, Oversight and Verification of Response Actions Involving Military Munitions.
http://www.ddesb.pentagon.mil/MCO8020/MCO802013.pdf. No site specific information. 2/2/07. Did not print document.
MCO P8020.10. Apr 3, 2002. Marine Corp Ammunition Management and Explosives Safety Policy Manual.
http://www.ddesb.pentagon.mil/MCO8020/MCO8020P10A.pdf. No site specific information. 2/2/07. Did not print document.
Special Meeting DoD Explosives Safety Board (323rd). Jun 19, 2002. http://www.ddesb.pentagon.mil/Special_Meeting_19_june_02.pdf. No site
specific information. 2/2/07. Did not print document.
Removal of 7-bar designation from the Air Force Modular Storage Magazine and Actions Being Taken to Restore…
http://www.ddesb.pentagon.mil/msm_7_bar_rescind%20_letter_28_mar_02.pdf. No site specific information. 2/2/07. Did not print document.
Updated Guidance on 12-inch Thick Substantial Dividing Walls (SDW) - Jan 15, 2003 http://www.ddesb.pentagon.mil/Updated%20SDW_15Jan03.pdf.
No site specific information. 2/2/07. Did not print document.
Federal Register Notices of Change for DoD 6055.9-STD. May 11, 2005.
http://www.ddesb.pentagon.mil/fed%20reg%20Notice%2011%20May%2005.pdf. No site specific information. 2/2/07. Did not print document.
"Guidance for Clearance Plans" Jan 27, 1998 http://www.ddesb.pentagon.mil/guidanceForclearancePlans27Jan(Feb)98.pdf. No site specific
information. 2/2/07. Did not print document.
Explosion Effects Software Working Group (EESWG).Questionnaire for Developers of Explosion Effects Software.pdf. Ju 30, 2004.
http://www.ddesb.pentagon.mil/Questionnaire%20for%20Developers%20of%20Explosion%20Effects%20Software.pdf. This document is a
questionnaire. No site specific information. 2/2/07. Did not print document.
DoD 4145.26-M, "DoD Contractors' Safety Manual For Ammunition and Explosives," 09/1997
http://www.dtic.mil/whs/directives/corres/html/414526m.htm ►http://www.dtic.mil/whs/directives/corres/pdf/414526m_0997/p414526m.pdf. No site
specific information. 2/2/07. Did not print document.
Documents
Checked?
Found?
Source
# Source Web Site (if any) Comments
NAVFAC P-397, AFR 88-22 Structures to Resists the Effects of Accidental Explosions. Departments of the Army, the Navy, the Air Force. Nov 1990.
http://www.ddesb.pentagon.mil/tm51300.htm ►http://www.ddesb.pentagon.mil/TM%205-1300,%20November%201990.pdf. 1,796 page document.
Appears to be general procedures, specifications, and policies. Do not anticipate any site specific information. 2/2/07. Did not print document.
Interim Hazard Classification. http://www.ddesb.pentagon.mil/HazardClass/interimhc.htm. No site specific information. Did not print document.
2/2/07.
Links to JHCS and ESMAM https://www3.dac.army.mil/es/usatces/default.asp?page=8 and https://www3.dac.army.mil/esidb/login/ No site specific
information. 2/2/07.
Technical Papers Link: http://www.ddesb.pentagon.mil/techpapers.html
TP 12 - FRAGMENT AND DEBRIS HAZARD https://secureweb.hqda.pentagon.mil/ddesb/ You are not authorized to view this page 2/2/07
TP 13 - PREDICTION OF BUILDING DEBRIS FOR QUANTITY-DISTANCE SITING April 1991 http://www.ddesb.pentagon.mil/tp13.pdf No site
specific information. Did not print document. 2/2/07.
TP 14 - METHODS and ALGORITHSMS USED in the SAFER MODEL September 2003 http://www.ddesb.pentagon.mil/TP14.pdf No site specific
information. Did not print document. 2/2/07.
TP16- METHODOLOGIES FOR CALCULATING PRIMARY FRAGMENT CHARACTERISTICS https://secureweb.hqda.pentagon.mil/ddesb/ You are
not authorized to view this page
Documents
Checked?
Found?
Source
# Source Web Site (if any) Comments
TP 17 - DDESB BLAST EFFECTS COMPUTER VERSION 6 USER’S MANUAL AND DOCUMENTATION
https://secureweb.hqda.pentagon.mil/ddesb/ You are not authorized to view this page 2/2/07.
TP 18 - MINIMUM QUALIFICATIONS FOR UNEXPLODED ORDNANCE (UXO) TECHNICIANS AND PERSONNEL Dec 20, 2004.
http://www.ddesb.pentagon.mil/TP18_122004.pdf No site specific information. Did not print document. 2/2/07.
TP 19 - SAFETY ASSESSMENT FOR EXPLOSIVES RISK (SAFER) USER'S REFERENCE MANUAL Web address not provided. 2/2/07.
9 Explosive ordnance disposal detachments Google search "Explosive ordnance disposal detachments camp edwards" yielded a newsletter which had trouble displaying. USMC Explosive
at nearby military facilities Ordnance Disposal Newsletter. May 2004. Published by MCD, NAVEODTECHDIV, Indian Head, MD. Pdf newsletter. 2/6/07
10 National Imagery and Mapping Agency, http://www.nima.mil/ Requires login to access site. http://www.nima.mil/portal/error_display.jsp http://www.nima.mil/portal/index.jsp?epi-content=LOGIN Unable to access
Bethesda, MD site. 2/2/07
11 Naval Construction Battalion Centers, http://www.ncbc.navfac.navy.mil/ Cannot find server. This page cannot be displayed. 2/2/07.
Port Hueneme, CA
12 Naval Facilities Historian’s Office, Port http://www.ncbc.navfac.navy.mil/cecm Cannot find server. This page cannot be displayed. 2/2/07.
Hueneme, CA useum/historian.htm
13 Naval Historical Center, Washington, DC http://www.history.navy.mil/ Online Reading Room: Publications, Documents, and Subject Presentations: http://www.history.navy.mil/library/online/readingroom.htm#subject
Bronze Guns of Leutze Park, Washington Navy Yard. 23 August 2005. http://www.history.navy.mil/cannons/cannons.html. No site specific
information. Did not print webpage. 2/2/07.
Bombing As a Policy Tool In Vietnam: Effectiveness, [1972] http://www.history.navy.mil/library/online/bombing_tool.htm. No site specific information.
Did not print webpage. 2/2/07.
Navy Department Library. http://www.history.navy.mil/library/index.htm►http://www.history.navy.mil/library/guides/guides.htm This weblink provided
several more links - bibliographies and research guides. Did not access due to time constraints and anticipation that no specific information will be
obtained. 2/2/07.
14 U.S. Air Force Safety Center, Kirtland http://afsafety.af.mil/ Error 403 Access Denied. 2/2/07
AFB, NM
15 U.S. Army Center for Health Promotion of http://chppm-www.apgea.army.mil/ Searching for "camp edwards".
Preventive Medicine, Aberdeen Proving No documents matching your query were found. Additional searches for "munitions", "land mines", "mortar", "grenade" did not produce any relevant or
site specific weblinks, webpages, documents. 2/2/07
Ground, MD
16 U.S. Army Center of Military History, http://www.army.mil/cmh-pg/ http://www.army.mil/cmh-pg/CMH/index.htm►Search CMH Library Catalog ► http://141.116.72.18/ ► Cannot Find Server. The page cannot be
Fort McNair, Washington, DC displayed. 2/5/07.
CMH Publications Catalog http://www.army.mil/cmh/catalog/browse/title.html#a. Search for the following words did not produce relevant or site
specific publication titles: artillery, grendade, land mine, munitions, ordnance. 2/5/07.
17 U.S. Army Soldier and Biological http://www.sbccom.army.mil/about/sb Cannot Find Server. The page cannot be displayed. 2/5/07.
Chemical Command ccom.htm
18 U. S. Army Corps of Engineers District http://www.usace.army.mil/where.html Error 404. Object not found. 2/5/07.
Offices
19 U. S. Army Corps of Engineers Office of http://www.hq.usace.army.mil/history/ Link to brief history of USACE http://www.hq.usace.army.mil/history/brief.htm. No relevant information found. 2/5/07.
History, Alexandria, VA
Online Resources. Articles link. http://www.hq.usace.army.mil/history/the.htm. Searched "artillery", "environment", "ordnance", "weapons" subject
listings and did not find site specific information. Other subject listings did not appear to have specific information on Camp Edwards. 2/5/07.
Documents
Checked?
Found?
Source
# Source Web Site (if any) Comments
search for "camp edwards" led to a redirected search page ►http://usasearch.gov/ search for "camp edwards" led to the following relevant links
2/5/07:
http://mass.gov/guard/Camp_Edwards/history.htm. This link provided history, environmental information, and photos of ranges at Camp Edwards.
2/5/07. Additional links for environmental information were mometarily offline. 2/5/07.
20 U.S. Army Corps of Engineers http://www.tec.army.mil/ TEC Imagery Office http://www.tec.army.mil/tio/index.html ►http://www.terraserver.com/index.asp►http://www.terraserver.com/search/city_results.asp
Topographic Engineering Center (TEC), this link provided many downloadable images for Camp Edwards. 2/5/07. Printed out the latest high resolution (AirPhoto USA 2003) and latest low
resolution (Land Voyage 15m Satellite 2000) aerial photos. 2/5/07.
Alexandria, VA
Newsroom link led to the following link: http://www.erdc.usace.army.mil/pls/erdcpub/WWW_WELCOME.Navigation_PAGE?tmp_Next_Page=41 ►
http://www.erdc.usace.army.mil/pls/erdcpub/www_welcome.navigation_page?tmp_next_page=51428. No site specific information anticipated based
on titles. 2/5/07.
21 U.S. Army Military History Institute, http://carlisle-www.army.mil/usamhi/ Army Heritage Collection Online. http://www.ahco.army.mil/site/index.jsp ► http://ahecwebopac.carlisle.army.mil:4525/F?func=file&file_name=basic
Carlisle, PA Search "camp edwards" - no specific information concerning munitions or uxo's. 2/5/07.
Resource Guides / Finding Aides. http://www.ahco.army.mil/site/finding_aids_brief.jsp. Searched bibliographies by subject. Nothing in titles that
would suggest specific information on Camp Edwards. 2/5/07.
22 U.S. Army Ordnance Museum, Aberdeen http://www.ordmusfound.org/ Searched museum website's photo gallery. http://www.ordmusfound.org/Littledavidslideshow.htm. There were no photo captions. 2/5/07.
Proving Ground, MD
Museum collection. http://www.ordmusfound.org/muscollection.htm. No site specific information. 2/5/07.
23 U.S. Army Safety Center, Fort Rucker, AL http://safety.army.mil/home.html Cannot find server. Page cannot be displayed. 2/5/07.
24 U. S. Army Technical Center for http://www.dac.army.mil/es/ Unable to access website because a user ID and password are required. 2/5/07
Explosives Safety, McAlester, OK
25 U.S. Army Technical Escort Unit Google search: http://www.cbiac.apgea.army.mil/products/newsletter_pdfs/vol6_num1.pdf. No specific information. 2/6/07.
Historical Office, Aberdeen Proving
Ground, MD
26 U.S. Army Test and Evaluation Command http://www.atec.army.mil/ No specific information. 2/5/07.
27 U.S. Army War College Library, Carlisle http://carlisle-www.army.mil/library/ USAWC Library Catalog. http://catsipac.carlisle.army.mil/ipac20/ipac.jsp?profile=awc#focus. Searched for "camp edwards". No information. 2/5/07
Barracks, PA
MERLN Group Catalog. http://firstsearch.oclc.org/fsip?db=Merln_Catalog&screen=basic. Unable to access link without user ID and password. 2/5/07
28 U.S. Naval District, Washington, DC http://www.ndw.navy.mil/ Environmental/Safety link did not provide site specific information. Only provided information pertinent to Washington Navy Yard. 2/5/07.
29 U.S. Naval Explosive Ordnance Disposal https://naveodtechdiv.navsea.navy.mil Cannot find server. The page cannot be displayed. 2/5/07.
Technology Division, Indian Head, MD / B-2
Documents
Checked?
Found?
Source
# Source Web Site (if any) Comments
30 U.S. Naval Ordnance Safety and Security http://www.nossa.navsea.navy.mil/. No specific information. 2/6/07.
Activity, Ordnance Environmental
Support Office
31 U.S. Naval War College Archives, http://www.nwc.navy.mil/ Library http://www.nwc.navy.mil/library/ ►Central Search http://www.nwc.navy.mil/library/CentralSearch.htm
Newport, RI ►http://cw3xq8qy9r.cs.serialssolutions.com/errors/error401 Do not have permission to access this page. 2/6/07.
Websites link http://www.nwc.navy.mil/library/favorite_websites2.htm Homeland Security link ► https://www.hsdl.org/?auth/login&dest= Access
requires e-mail and password. 2/6/07.
32 U.S. Navy Safety Center, Naval Air http://www.safetycenter.navy.mil/ Cannot find server. The page cannot be displayed. 2/6/07.
Station, Norfolk, VA Other Federal Government
Information Sources
34 Department of the Interior Bureau of Land http://www.blm.gov/ Search for "camp edwards" did not produce specific information. 2/6/07.
Management
35 Department of the Interior, U.S. http://www.usgs.gov/ Due to time constraints, did not pursue links on this website as titles indicate that information specific to Camp Edwards would be anticipated. 2/6/07.
Geological Survey (USGS)
36 Federal Geographic Data Committee http://www.fgdc.gov/ Library link. http://www.fgdc.gov/library/articles/index_html. Searched for "camp edwards.
(geographic information systems) ►http://www.fgdc.gov/search?SearchableText=camp+edwards&path=%2Ffgdc%2Flibrary. No specific information. 2/6/07.
37 General Services Administration http://www.gsa.gov/ Catalogs and Publications link. http://www.gsa.gov/Portal/gsa/ep/contentView.do?programId=11530&channelId=-
16402&ooid=17843&contentId=17848&pageTypeId=8199&contentType=GSA_BASIC. No specific information. 2/6/07.
Environmental Services link. http://www.gsa.gov/Portal/gsa/ep/contentView.do?contentId=10126&contentType=GSA_OVERVIEW. This link provides
services that GSA can provide through contractors. No specific information. 2/6/07.
38 The Library of Congress, Geography and http://www.loc.gov/ Search for "camp edwards", "camp edwards artillery" and "camp edwards munitions" http://www.loc.gov/search/. Results provided historic
Map, and Prints and Photographs photographs of buildings at Camp Edwards, photos of training and personnel. 2/6/07
Divisions, Washington, DC
39 U.S. EPA Environmental Photographic http://www.epa.gov/nerlesd1/land- Search for "camp edwards" did not produce specific information. 2/6/07.
Interpretation Center (EPIC) sci/epic/default.htm
40 U.S. National Archives and Records http://www.archives.gov/ Research link. http://www.archives.gov/research/ http://www.archives.gov/research/arc/topics/ http://www.archives.gov/research/arc/topics/war-
Administration (NARA) dept.html. Has some information on Camp Edwards, but not available for viewing online; indicates where documents are located (at National Archives
in College Park, MD). Descriptions of documents appear to be administrative in nature with some photographs. However, no specific information about
Camp Edwards and munitions, ordnance, etc. appear to be readily available. 2/6/07.
Documents
Checked?
Found?
Source
# Source Web Site (if any) Comments
State and Local Information Sources
44 City and county clerk’s office (court http://199.232.150.242/ALIS/WW400 Reviewed Barnstable County Land Records,
documents, fire and police records, civil R.PGM
and criminal indices, property suits,
ownership and title, proven association
with property, dates of original
construction)
45 Commercial property history
46 Corporate records
47 Local law enforcement offices
48 Local libraries Visited Sandwich Pulic Library, Archive Section (June 14, 2007.
49 Local newspapers http://barnstablepatriot.com/ The Barnstable Patriot newspaper. Nov 19, 1998. National Guard Scrambles to Keep Camp Edwards.
http://barnstablepatriot.com/news_november_nat_guard_scrambles_to_keep_camp_edwards_archives_45_2351.html. National Guard says that
contaminated groundwater did not originate from Camp Edwards, but from fuel spills south of the base. Congressman Delahunt is proposing to turn
the camp into a wildlife refuge. 2/6/07
The Barnstable Patriot newspaper. Aug 12, 1999. Camp Edwards to become a state conservation area.
http://barnstablepatriot.com/news_august_camp_edwards_to_become_state_conservation_area_archives_45_1624.html. Some military training will
still be allowed at Camp Edwards, firing live rounds would not be part of it. The Coast Guard, Army National Guard, Air National Guard and Marine
Corps would continue to operate on the base's southern 5,000 acres. 2/6/07.
50 State and local historical organizations
51 State government archives
Air Force Center for Environmental http://www.afcee.brooks.af.mil/ Halfway to the goal: AFCEE reviews progress at the Massachusetts Military Reservation. 11/17/06.
Excellence http://www.afcee.brooks.af.mil/ms/msp/center/vol5no3/2.asp. Provides progress of groundwater clean up but no mention of cause of contamination
from munitions or ordnances. 2/8/06
Center Views: Spring 2005 - Vol. 11 No. Navy veteran still involved with water. http://www.afcee.brooks.af.mil/ms/msp/centeCenter Views: Spring
2005 - Vol. 11 No. 1 r/vol11no1/12.asp. Describes wastewater treatment operations at MMR using granulated activated carbon to clean solvent and
fuel contaminated groundwater. 2/8/07.
APPENDICES
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
APPENDICES
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARSDS/MMR
Appendix B\Stables Area UXO Study File\Tetra Tech Material - John Webster
AEC Main Proveout SITE MAP Rev1.pdf
AEC Maps.exe
AEC Maps.ZIP
AEC Proveout-Satellite SITE MAP Rev1.pdf
MMR AEC Main and Satellite Site write.doc
MMR AEC Area Map.pdf
(The following sheets are for munitions potentially used at the Small Arms Range.)
Source: Technical Manual (TM) 43-0001027: Army Ammunition Data Sheets - Small
Caliber Ammunition [FSC 1305], U.S. Army Headquarters, April 1994
APPENDICES
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
APPENDICES
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
Description:
These are rifle-projected grenades that, except for the M11 series, contain a simple impact inertia, base detonating
fuze. The painting and markings for each grenade are either light gray or light green with yellow markings.
Diameter: 51mm
Length: 287mm
Weight: 712g
Explosive: Smoke mix, HC
Disposal: Detonation
Description:
These are rifle-projected grenades that contain a simple impact inertia, base detonating fuze.
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
Photo reference:
https://www.denix.osd.mil/denix/Public/Library/Explosives/UXOSafety/Photogallery/Pyrotechnics/pyrotechnics.html
Multiple Uses
Examples;
-These flares are used to illuminate a large area for reconnoitering and bombing, and also as a blinding effect on the
operators of antiaircraft weapons.
-This is an electric initiated pyrotechnic illuminating device. This device is used to illuminate ambushed enemy
personnel.
PYROTECHNIC SUBSTANCES- Military pyrotechnic substances are used to send signals by visual means, such
as color, to illuminate areas of interest, to simulate other weapons or activities, and as ignition elements for certain
types of weapons. Pyrotechnic compositions, with respect to rapidity of action, are low explosives because of their
low rates of combustion.
The functional characteristics of pyrotechnic compositions are their luminous intensity (candlepower), burning rate,
color, color value, and efficiency of light production. Thus, for military use, pyrotechnic compositions must have
acceptable explosive as well as burning characteristics.
A military chemical agent is a substance that produces a toxic (casualty) or an irritating (harassing) effect, a
screening smoke, and incendiary action, or a combination thereof. These agents include compounds and mixtures
other than pyrotechnics and are used as fillers in artillery shell, mortar shell, grenades, rockets, and bombs. They are
classified according to tactical use, physiological effect and purpose.
Reference: http://www.ordnance.org/classifi.htm
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
TYPE OF
EXPLOSIVES UTILIZATION
Trinitrotoluene (TNT) forms pale yellow crystals of specific gravity 1.65 that have a melting point of 82° C (180°
F). Its low melting point allows it to be melted and poured into artillery shells and other explosive devices. It burns
in the open at 295° C (563° F), but it may explode if confined. In the absence of a detonator, it is a rather stable
material, TNT does not: attack metals, absorb moisture, and is practically insoluble in water. High-velocity
detonators, such as mercury fulminate and nitramine, induce its violent and explosive decomposition. A secondary
hazard of TNT is the fact that it can be absorbed through the skin, causing headache, anemia, and skin irritation.
During World War I, TNT was the high explosive most generally employed.
Cyclonite (RDX) is also called hexogen is a white crystalline solid usually used in mixtures with other explosives,
oils, or waxes; it is rarely used alone. It has a high degree of stability in storage and is considered the most powerful
and brisant of the military high explosives. Incorporated with other explosives or inert material at the manufacturing
plants, RDX forms the base for the following common military explosives: Composition A, Composition B,
Composition C, HBX, and H-6.
Pentaerythritol tetranitrate (PETN) has characteristics similar to those of cyclonite and is mixed with TNT to form
the explosive pentolite. It also forms the core of the explosive primacord fuses used for detonating demolition
charges and the booster charges used in blasting.
Secondary high explosives (Composition A, Composition B, Composition C, Composition D, TNT, PETN and
RDX) are relatively insensitive to shock, friction, flame, or heat and are, therefore, less hazardous to handle and use.
However, as a result of their relative insensitivity, the secondary high explosives must be initiated or detonated by a
very strong explosive wave. Consequently, primary explosives are used to detonate secondary explosives.
Secondary explosives comprise the largest single class of explosives and have detonation velocities ranging from
9,000 to over 26,000 feet per second.
Hexahydro - 1, 3, 5 Trinitro-8-Triazine (HBX) is a form of high explosive made from TNT, RDX, aluminum,
lecithin, and wax. HBX was developed during WWII that replaced the more shock-sensitive TORPEX used in depth
bombs and torpedoes. The warhead for the 2.75-inch "Mighty Mouse" rocket was filled with HBX (40 percent
RDX, 38 percent TNT, 17 percent aluminum powder, and 5 percent desensitizers) or composition B (59 percent
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
RDX, 40 percent TNT, and 1 percent wax). All Navy warhead filling activities in the TNT Plant ceased in early The
major longer range improvements resulting were the Navy's development of HBX type explosives together with
asphaltic, "hot melt" liners for bombs and other munitions. The hot melt liners were developed to coat and eliminate
metal-to metal pinch points. After the Naval Magazine, Port Chicago, CA accident of 17 July 1944 , HBX and H-6
explosives were developed that incorporated wax and other chemicals to desensitize the explosive and hot melt
liners were introduced for lining bombs and warheads to give some thermal protection and eliminate potential pinch
points from cracks or fissures in the bomb or warhead case. Later, plastic-bonded explosives were developed for
increased thermal protection and fragment impact resistance.
High Melt Explosive (HMX) The 1960s brought new explosives such as HMX that was chemically analogous to
RDX, but even more powerful to give soldiers greater lethality capability. Picatinny laboratories also developed
precision warheads for several missile systems, including the DRAGON-MAW, a Medium Antiarmor Weapon.
The Army uses RDX and HMX as basic explosives for munitions and tactical missiles as well as propellants for
strategic missiles rather than TNT because of their superior energy.
Black powder is a low explosive, composed essentially of a mixture of potassium nitrate or sodium nitrate, charcoal,
and sulfur. It is hydroscopic and subject to rapid deterioration when exposed to moisture. It is also one of the most
dangerous explosives to handle because of the ease with which it is ignited by heat, friction, or spark. Although the
use of black powder as a propellant and as a projectile bursting charge has ceased, it remains an explosive that will
be encountered in ammunition and ammunition components.
(CMP)
References: http://www.ordnance.org/hbx.htm
http://www.pofwah.com.pk/products/explosives.htm
http://www.globalsecurity.org/military/systems/munitions/explosives.htm
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
A B
C (practice)
http://www.strategypage.com/gallery/articles/military_photos_2005111523.asp
Description:
WP (photo A): The cartridge has a point detonating (PD) fuze, a 2inch extension, WP filler, a thin walled shell, fin
assembly, an ignition cartridge, and a percussion primer. The body is internally threaded to accept the fuze and
designed to hold the casing of the burster assembly. One of 2 types of burster assemblies can be used, differing only
in construction of the steel burster casing. On impact the fuze ignites the burster charge which ruptures the chell and
disperses the WP filler. The WP burns producing heavy white smoke in the air.
Diameter/Length: Unknown
Weight: 4.10lbs.
Illumination (photo B): The complete round consists of a body tube, a tail cone assembly, an illuminant charge, a
parachute assembly, a time fuze, a fin assembly, 4 propellant increments, an ignition cartridge and a percussion
primer. The illuminant assembly consists of a first-fire charge and an illuminant charge is contained in a boxboard
casing which is attached to a parachute with a suspension line. An expelling charge directly below the fuze, ejects
the illuminant and parachute assembly.
Diameter/Length: Unknown
Weight: 4.15lbs.
Reference: www.uxoinfo.com
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
A B C
Description:
The Mk 2 (photo A) is a fragmentation (frag), antipersonnel, delay-detonating hand grenade which is commonly
referred to as "pineapple" because of its shape and external serration.
The Mk 2 grenade is painted olive drab, with a yellow band around the top of the fuze well.
Diameter: 57mm
Length: 114 mm
Weight: 589.68g
Explosive: TNT, flaked
Disposal: Detonation
The M26, M26A1, and M61 (photo B) are fragmentation (frag), antipersonnel, delay-detonating hand grenades
which have a notched fragmentation coil liner.
The M26, M26A1, and M61 grenades are painted olive drab, with yellow markings stenciled on the body.
Diameter: 57mm
Length: 99mm
Weight: 453.60g
Explosive: Composition B
Disposal: Detonation
Diameter: 75mm
Length: 84mm
Weight: 227g
Explosive: CN
Disposal: Detonation
A B C D E
Description:
The M30 and M62 (photo A) are standard, practice, delay-detonating hand grenades. The M30 is the practice version of
the M26 and M26A1 grenades; the M62 is the practice version of the M61 grenade.
The M30 and M62 grenades are blue, with a brown band around the body or neck. Markings, if any, are stenciled in white
This grenade (photo C) consists of a fragmentation body with a filing hole in the base, an Igniting Fuze M206, a small
charge of black powder, and a cork plug in the filling hole. Extra fuzes, charges, and plugs are supplied separately, so that
the grenade body can be reused.
The body is light blue.
The Mk 2 (photo D) is a fragmentation (frag), antipersonnel, delay detonating hand grenade which is commonly referred
to as "pineapple" because of its shape and external serration. The M21 is the practice version of the Mk 2.
The M21 practice grenade is painted blue, with a brown or blue band; markings, if any, are white.
The M69 (photo E) is a standard-delay practice version of the M33 and M67 grenades. The M33 and M67 are
fragmentation (frag), antipersonnel (apers), delay-detonating hand grenades.
The M69 is blue with a brown band around the body or neck.
Photo reference:
https://www.denix.osd.mil/denix/Public/Library/Explosives/UXOSafety/Photogallery/SmallArms/smallarms.html
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
APPENDICES
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
APPENDICES
FINAL HISTORICAL RECORDS REVIEW AND SITE INSPECTION REPORT JUNE 2010
ARMY NATIONAL GUARD TRAINING SITE, CAMP EDWARDS/MMR
CONTACT/INTERVIEW REPORT
Date: January 31, 2007 Originator: Mark Pape and Victor Gonzalez (URS)
Contact by: Telephone ____ Meeting _X__ Other ________________________
Site: Camp Edwards/MMR
Name, Title and Organization: Kent (Hap) Gonser, Senior Program Manager, IAGWSP
William Gallagher, Senior Analyst, IAGWSP
Address and Telephone Number: IAGWSP, Building 1803, West Outer Road, Camp
Edwards, MA 02542
508-968-5107 and 508-968-5622
Summary Review of MMRP Sites, Areas of Concern and Programmatic Issues at Camp
Edwards/MMR
Programmatic Background: The Impact Area Groundwater Study Program (IAGWSP) started
in 1996 to investigate groundwater and soil contamination in and around the impact area on base.
The IAGWSP is overseen by the U.S. Army Environmental Command (AEC).
The Installation Restoration Program (IRP) is primarily focused on the Otis Air National Guard
base. It is run by the Air Force Center for Environmental Excellence (AFCEE).
More detail on these programs can be found at several websites, including
http://groundwaterprogram.army.mil/ and http://www.mmr.org/.
Environmental programs at Camp Edwards/MMR are complex, interconnected and need to be
well understood as the MMRP progresses. Stakeholders include the Army, the Air Force, the
National Guard Bureau, the Massachusetts Army National Guard, leaseholders, USEPA, and
MADEP. Camp Edwards/MMR has had a very active and involved local population, with
Citizens’ Advisory Groups, Technical Advisory Boards and Restoration Advisory Boards all in
place and active.
A challenge will be to ensure that we have a good definition of the property/parcel owners and
leaseholders at the Camp Edwards/MMR.
Munitions Response Sites
Mock Village: This site was investigated in the Phase IIB investigation (AMEC, Draft Final
2003). There is question on whether or not the Mock Village is entirely in the operational range
area or whether some crosses Jefferson Road and falls within Coast Guard boundaries. Samples
have been taken with coordinates, including sampling of the several pits found there. Refer to
the Phase IIB Report which suggests there are no likely munitions. No formal geophysical
survey has been done. Work with Bobby Cannon (USCG) to get a copy of the lease and
delineate the area.
Old G Range: Also part of the Phase IIB investigation. The area of the old range (and range
fan) includes part of the BOMARC missile site. Will need to determine if this is in the
operational range area or not. There are good aerial photos of the Old G Range.
Old Grenade Courts: IAGWSP may have some aerial photos of this. The high explosive (HE)
live grenade court may have been paved over, and it is possible that the area was not cleared
before being paved over. The dummy grenade court has not been paved over. It is possible that
the Air National Guard is the owner of this parcel.
Old K Range: This is distinct from (in the same area but with a different orientation) the Former
K Range. AFCEE has investigated this as a PCB site, based on circuit disposal in the area.
Ordnance was found in the CG area and was BIP (blown in place). Check with AFCEE, the
Corps UXO group and Corps FUDS group on this. The MRS will most likely fall under FUDS.
Otis Target Butt: This is on Air Force/Air National Guard property. This is described in the
ASR, though not much is known about it. Jon Davis (AFCEE/IRP) should be contacted. Also
will need to check its status relative to BRAC.
Small Arms Range: Will need to determine where it is located – within the landfill or the
operational range parcel, BA-1. The area was dug/scraped to as much as 10 feet in gathering
cover for the landfill.
Stables Area: This is near a pitch-and-putt golf course. This was an old bivouac site as well as a
stables area. A geophysical survey was conducted here around 2001-2002 as a background
sample. They found a large number of anomalies including nails, horseshoes and possibly some
UXO. George Robataille (AEC) was the project manager and Aberdeen Test Center conducted
the survey.
Areas of Concern: There were reports of rounds that went off base and landed just beyond Route
28 (? or 6 ?). This was cleaned up/cleared, but the holes were left.
Useful Contacts and Data Sources
• Col. Bill Fitzpatrick: may be particularly helpful with property ownership and leases
• 102nd Civil Engineering may have a master plan for the Camp Edwards/MMR. Contact
Dick Menochenowitz (sp?) or Jon Davis
• UXO Study has a lot of information both in and out of the operational range area.
Contact Gina Kaso, Thom Davidson and Matt Walsh (all with USACE/New England)
• Phase IIB Report has a lot of good information
CONTACT/INTERVIEW REPORT
CONTACT/INTERVIEW REPORT
CONTACT/INTERVIEW REPORT
Date: May 31, 2007 Originator: Heather Sullivan, returning call from Mark Pape
Contact by: Telephone __X_ Meeting ____ Other ________________________
Site: Camp Edwards/MMR – Otis Air National Guard Base
Name, Title and Organization: Heather Sullivan,
Manager, FUDS / New England
Address and Telephone Number: U.S. Army Corps of Engineers/New England District
696 Virginia Road, Concord, MA 01742
978-318-8543
Summary Camp Edwards/MMR FUDS Sites: Campbell School and Former ASP,
Popponessett Beach and Scorton Neck
Heather Sullivan replied to an e-mail inquiry and voicemail message left with the following.
Campbell School was a FUDS site, addressed as a component of the Camp Edwards/MMR
FUDS property (FUDS ID # D01MA0009). The school has been removed and the site is now
considered closed (No Further Action). As part of the actions at the Campbell School, the New
England Corps also investigated the area known as the Former ASP (Ammunition Supply Point).
No further actions are considered necessary at the Former ASP and that area is considered closed
within the Campbell School actions.
The Campbell School and the Former ASP are on portions of the Camp Edwards/MMR that are
held by the Massachusetts Air National Guard. Because this is a Commonwealth of
Massachusetts and not a Federal Government entity, and because it has been held as such since
prior to 1986, the site is FUDS eligible.
Popponessett Beach and Scorton Neck: The Corps of Engineers/FUDS program has not done
any actions regarding these two Anti-Aircraft Artillery Training Command (AAATC) sites. She
checked with Bill Holtham and he confirmed that no action had been done at either site.
The other AAATC site off of Camp Edwards/MMR, Camp Wellfleet (D01MA0033), has been
addressed under the FUDS program and is considered closed.
We discussed why Camp Wellfleet might have been addressed, but not the Popponessett Beach
and Scorton Neck AAATC sites. We came to no conclusion on the issue, but realized there were
probably prior discussions that determined that these need not be done.
CONTACT/INTERVIEW REPORT
• Dr. Michael Ciaranca, E&RC, 508-968-5121 – may have reports, if any submitted. [I left
message with Dr. Ciaranca 12-Jun-07.]
• Gina Kaso, UXO Study Manager, 978-318-8180 – may have worked on site during the
clearance. [I checked with Ms. Kaso. She did not work at the site for that study, but
recommended I call John Webster or Rob Foti, both at ECC, 508-563-9767.]
Popponessett Beach and Scorton Neck
Dr. Goodfellow and the cultural resources and historical staff at Camp Edwards/MMR had
looked at both Popponessett Beach and Scorton Neck AAATC training sites during the time of
the ASR. They were not able to find any records of ownership on the sites, so had not carried
them forward. She believed the Scorton Neck camp was on leased property and that the
Popponessett Beach property may have been purchased and then disposed. She suggested
checking with Kevin Bartsch, MAANG GIS Manager, 508-968-5120 about aerial photos or
ownership info for the sites. [I checked with Mr. Bartsch. The GIS and the historical
photographs do not extend to the either Scorton Neck or Popponessett Beach. He was not aware
of other sources for these.]
CONTACT/INTERVIEW REPORT
CONTACT/INTERVIEW REPORT
CONTACT/INTERVIEW REPORT
After the war, the property continued as a farm under the direction of Mr. Jillson’s uncle, Jack
Carleton. Jack Carleton died in 1963, and Mr. Jillson then took over management of the
property for the Carleton family. He and the other heirs decided to subdivide the Carleton farm
and sell it as residential properties (on 1+ acre lots).
Since that time, over 100 houses have been built on the property. No live ordnance had been
found during the development and construction of these properties.
We toured the firing line area. Other than clearings for parking and properties it has mostly been
overgrown with pine and brush.
Mr. Jillson noted that he path to the beach during WWII was a corrugated road of railroad ties
wired together. This “road” was rough enough that when the AAATC sent out a duck boat to
rescue a downed target plane, it punctured the hull. The duck boat sank a short distance from
shore.