Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Barbara L. Kojie
Tnlogy Department, University of Queensland, Saint Lucia, Queensland, Australis
and
Norman J. Quinn
Fisheries Departmeut, Papua New Guinea University of Teqhnologr, Lae, Papua, New Guinea
ABSTRACT
The mode and tining of reproduc'tion, abundance and distribution were studied in four congeueric species of
hern"matypic coral on Heron Island reef, Great Barrier \*f.. Poites and.rewsi, P. lobota, P. lutea and P. ,nunayen'
sis have stable gonochorism with the former three species having a short annual period ofegg and sperm release,
fertilization being external, and the latter'having internd fertilization and an ertended larval release period. P.
andrcwsi, P. lafutc and P. luiea reproduce asexually when pieces &om large colonies are broken off and dispersed
by waves and currents. The abundance of the four species ol Paites on Heron Islend reef flat is rel,ated to tbe
relative success of sexual and aserual recruitment (fragrnentation).
of gonads, 2-Bpm diameter could be determined. perpendicular axes and the average d.iameter deter-
Representative samples were treated histologically mined.
to verify observations of decalcified tissue with Colonies were saurpled from the top, middle and
regard to s€x and stages of gametogenesis, i.e. iime bottom on different sides of P. andrewsi (9 colonies;
of spermatozoan development and whether oocytes 3{ samples from each), P. lobata (1;?} and P. lutea
developed into ova, zygotes or embryos in situ. It is g; -12l.to determine if gonad development was syn-
important to use a fixative and preservative that chronized within colonies.
does not harden tissue, e.g. formalin. Alcohol To observe spawning and larval development,
hardened decalcified tissue making it rubbery and colonies of. P. andrewsi and P. lobata were held in
non-amenable to squashing. aquaria during the end of November and December
Shortly after spawning, the eggs of P. ondrewsi 19?8 and 1979;P. luteainJauuary 1979 and,P. Mur-
were pipetted onto a slide with no coverslip and rayensis between the end of November 1978 and
measured. Since spawning was not observed in P. February 1979, mid-November and end of December
lnbata and P. lutea, eggs were measured in 1979 and the end of October and beginning of
decalcified tissue collected close to the time of November 1980.
spawning. The tissue was carefully dissected and a The method of determining distribution and abun-
coverslip placed over the tissue. Only larger eggs dance of species from tratrsects (Fig. 1) is descriH
from the latter two species were measured since in Kojis and Quinn (1981). The size and mortality of
small eggs \il'ers lslqined after spawning. All eggs fourteen tagged colonies of P. nurrayensis were
were measured with an eyepiece micrometer on two recorded from 1978 to 1980.
EF CREST
l'hron lstand
transectsl and ?
transecl 3
transect tr
, 500m .
Figure 1. Map of sample and transect sites on Heron Island reef flat. Sample sites: J andS Poites lutea;2 P. laba,",,^ 4,5
and 6 P. andreusii A, general locale of P. muroyensis collections.
REPNODUCTIYE STRATEGIES IN P,ORITES
RESULTS
Figure 4. Sperm clusters within a colony were.at the same Figure 5, Just spawned.eCgs of Porites ondruwsii ;
&ag" of development {Poites andrcwsii); s' qperm above the sPawning colonY: e' eggs'
clusters: e, zooxanthellae.
In 19?8, no spawning was observed i:r aquarium In 19?8, P- lutea spawned betwren 20 Ja*-*:::
held colonies. A comparison of histological prepara- u"Jz F"t*uty (last qua*er moon, 1 FebruarS't;:..:;
tions of testes fron; colonies of P. attdrewsi held i" igrs Gtwein'rs Jiluarv and 5 Februarv-(Fje'
se;e.al w€eks in aquaria and from freld colonies in- with most spawning occurring before l! Jn::::s1:'
dicated delayed development in the former. (last quarter-moon' 21 Jaurrary),
-
In 19?9, spawning was observed in aquarium-held S"iiuffv mature colonies of all three -sp+;:r:r
colonies of p. onarewsi only. Dense clouds of sperm ;;;"""""4t. In tagged colonies sampleri-;-'
were released on 1,2,4,5,7 aad 8 December between sic"""sirr" y"atj {P. ondrewsi: N= 13' -1977^' r: " :
ZttOO-Zt:gO hrs. On ? December 19?9 at 21:45 hrs a i5ig n: 11, l9??, 19?8;P la-baca N :,3. !=l*
f*g" i"*Uo of tiny white eggs were s-een floating ""a p.-l"iin tt:i6;1et8, le?e, 1er80 *-':
igia,-ieffit
in an'aquarium {Fig. 5}. Eggs were also present lq-;a, 1-9y& 19?9) gonads were pre€ent ea€h 5*-'
throughiut the water colurnn owing to coutinued Also,'since no colony changed sex during sanpi::"'
spawning and water movement. Fewer eggs were fi-;;;;" not a function of colony s'ze' a ccl*:".
released-during spawning on 8 December. Mobile, pi"Utlfv does not change sex during iis lifetin:-
ciliated larvae-developd approximately 23 h after
spawning. Tbenty tarvae were pipetted into a 2-1
taree mouth jar (Kojis and Quinn 1981) and four set- l\
til/ iI
polyps survived onlY a few weeks. I
' Aiproximate dates of spawning wery t
I
I
iiit
{educed
trom-the pr€sence or absence of gonads in field c
t
samples and, in the case at P. andrewsl, aquarium
spawaing observations. It is suspe+ted that spawn-
s.
i:ng in these species, as in Goniastrea australensis
8.'
{Kojis aud Quintl 1981}, is influenced by the lunar
cvcie. In 1977, P. andrewsi spawned irnmediately llll [n
tFIr!
prior to 6 December (last quarter moou 4 December)'
io 19?8, spawning oicurred between l'l-23 Finure 6. Period of gonad development and spawnir-'
- -poirn"
December (last quarts moon' 23 December) tFig' 6) andrewsiiind P. lutea on Heron Island reei :--
and in 19?9 between 3-9'December {last quarter a"ti"" and summer 19?8-19?9' A'different *":':
moon, 1l December). l+;"November l9?8 to earlv Februarv lui:'
;;;? "oti"e
' Sampling for P. labata during the - summer .'..:
September {all colonies collected 21 September had species in each transect with only P. and'rewsi and
gonads) and larval release began as early as mid- P. tnurrayensrs presant in all frve lrausects.
November. Reproductive colonies have either The patchy distribution o:f, P. lobata and P. lutea
sperm, eggs or eggs and larvae. The presence of was reidily apparent on the reef flat. Colonies ofP.
eggs and larvae simultatreously within a colony in- Iuteawete eoutmon ouly near Transects 1 and 2 (Fig.
dicated that larvae may develop and be released 1l where this species forms interconnected "step-
repeatedly over a single larval release s€ason. ping siones" from the mid-reef flat to the crest.
Larval release at Heron Island reef occurs from Microatolls af P. lobata were often clumped in wide
November to April, over approximately five months ly separate locations. On sandy substrate on tbe reef
of the year. flat SE and NE of Heron Island, they often formed
On 8 December 19?8, settled polyps and free mono-specific patches. Small, drscrete colouies of
swimming larvae were observed in aquaria in which these two species were found infrequently. In con-
colonies bad been placed several days earlier. Lar- trast, small colonies of P. and'rewsi and P- m.urro,yen-
vae continued to be released from colonies through' sis were cornmon on the reef flat' These species are
out December 19?8 to the beginning of February found in almost half the 15-m segments
19?9 when the field trip ended. Also, three out of six
field samples collected on 27 March 1979 had larvae; Table 2. The percent occlurence of four Pontes species in
while aone of 6 samples collected on 13 May had Tlansects 1-5 on Heron Islandreefflat. Tbansects were
gonads. Larvae were released on 20 November 1979 divided into 15-m segments. Figures refer io the percen-
tage of segments in which a species was recorded.
from eolonies placed in aquaria several days earlier
and continued to be released until the end of the
field trip in the last week of December. In 1980, col- Speies
onies placed in aquaria the first week of November
did not release lanrae, Thus, larval release at Heron P. andrewsi 4L.4
Island reef occurs from November to April over ap- F. mundyensis 40.5
proximately five months of the year. P. Iabato 7.6
The larvae of P. murmyensis were brown with P. lutea 6.0
abundant z,ooxanthellae ia the endoderm and had an
average dismeter of 6?9 rm (range 401'8?2 pm;
N:11). Released at an advanced developmental
stage, i.e. well developed stomodaeum" mesenteries Table 3. Relative abundaace lVo Eve coral cover) of four
and mesenterial filaments, they generally settle Poites speeies in Tlansects l'5 on Heron Island reef
rapidly, many within the first 24 hrs. flat.
the species apparen[ly rcproduces more than
once in its life time since colonies from 1.3-5.5 cm Tlansect No.
radius.had larvae. It is unknowB whether colonies Species
relea# larvae annually, since no colonies were
tagged and sampled over successive years.
P. andretusi 6.35 ?.36 9.51 6.22 6,82
DISTRIBUTION AND ABUNDANCE
Table 1 shows the relative abundance of the four
P. murrayensis
P. Iutea
1.25
1.20
2-84
2.88
2.05
0.58
I.27
'j'
P. lobeta 1.85 2-O3
Porites species in terms of perceat live coral cover
and Table 2 the number of 15-m segments in which
eaeh species occurs; the latter measurement gives
the relative number of colonies for each species. ASEXUAL COLONY REPRODUCTTQN BY
Table 3 shows the percent live coral cover of the FRAGMENTATION
Table l. The relative abuadance of four Pontes species on
Heron Island reef flat.
Recruitment by fragmentation may commonly oc-
cur among corals, especially those achieving a
Species Vo Live Coral Cover relatively large size. Connell (19?3) related obsenva-
tions of asexual recruitment in species of Acrcporu
andPoites, and Highsmith (19801 reported asexual
P- ondrewsi 6.02 colony "multiplication" in P. Iutea" On Heron
P. murtzyensis 1.?4 Islard, new colony formation by fragmentation
P. tutea 0.83 commonly occured in P. and.rewsr, less frequently
P. Iabata 0.78 in P. lobata and P. lutea arrd rarely, if ever, in P.
murrayensis.
150 KOJISANDQUI]{X
Formation of fragments begins with bioerosion oI colonies on Heron reef flat were all of a single coiar
eolonies at least partially separatingportious in situ and most were female.
and is often completed by physical forceg sueh as
storms acting to separate and disperse fragments.
Fragmentation works most obviously on the DISCUSSION
microatolle ol Poites.
Large microatolls of P. andrewsiwere at times in a Withiu the family Poritidae and the genusPorires
partiat state of collapse with fragments resting on two modes of reproduction have been observe*
the sand around the collapsed portion of a colony. Parites murrayeisis, P. stephensoni (Crpssland
Small branched fraguenti were sometimes totaliy 1952) {: P hpddani, Marshall and Stephenson
invested in tissue indicating frequent turning by 1933), P. asrewides, P. cl.auada {Vaughan 1d10} and :::
strong tidal currents or wa,re-actiott, and thus, c6nti- Goniopora queensland.iae decimd Eernard l{Yama-
nuing dispersal. When size prevented frequent turn- zato, pers. comm.l released Larvae, whileP. ondrewsi
i*
ing or colonies lodged betwen oEhers, the basal and by inference P. lobata and P. /rztea, spawued ::;
region became buried in sediment and supported the eggs and sperm, Gonochorism is the rrrle in the fami-
rest of the colony above the substrate. Invariably ly Poritidae as Goniopora qu,eenslandioe deeime
reef fl,at colonies were attached to substrate of. P. an- (Yamazato et al. 1975ll, P. lobata, P. compressa
drewsi origin indicating they had been derived from (Stimson 19?6) and the species in this study are
asexually produced fragments or were in situ rem- dioecious. ::1
nants of onee much larger colonies. The relative abundance of the four species of *S
Very large aud old microatolls of P. lpbata and P. Poites studied on Heron Island is related to the :]$
lateawere seldom single, discrete colonies. Death of relative success of sexual and asexual reandtment
parts of microatolls separatd portions. Bioerosion (fragmentation). P. andrewsi" the most abundant
$
and solution acting on the dead tops lowered the species in terms of percent coral cover and frequen' ..n
center in relation to the periphery and, eventually, cy of occurence in 15-m segments, reproduces sex- .i*
regrowth occurred in the center with subsequeat ually by seaeonal broadcast spawniug, once'a year.
separation (Fig. 7). Storms probably detach and The two least abundant species, P loban and P.
disperse portions of colonies. larea, probably spawn sirnilarly. Successful local
sexual recruitment in all three species appear€ to be
infrequent. This may be owing in part to extremely
high mortality of eggs, larvae and juveniles; a conse
quence of their small size (Chia f97a). Sexual
recruitment in P. Iobata and, P, lutea may be further
hampered by unsuccessful fertilization of ova owing
to the faucity of male colonies. This assumes that
development is not parthenogenic.
In all three species, fagnentation is probably the
primary mode of recruitment on the reef flat.
Fragmentation by mechanical forces rccurred more
frequently and fragments probably survived more
readily in P. andrewsi owing to its branching habit :t:
$79 pm versus 241 pp,l and 2) the extended larval Connell, J.H. f973. Population ecology of building
release psriod. Larvae of P. murrayensrs were corals. /n
O.A. Joaes and R. Eodean Biology
available for settlement for at least 5 months of the and Geology of Coral Reefs. VoL 2, 2A5"248.
New York: Academic Press.
year comparad with a few weeks far P. andrewsi
Fadlallah, Y. 1981. Tbe repreduetive biology of three
The low percent coral cover of P. murzuyensds com' species of corals from Centrd PN.D.
pared with P. a.nd.rewsi was due to the relatively Thesis, University of California at Santa r9s
small colony siee of P. munayeasrs rather than a p.
low numbs of colcniee. Highsmith, R 1980. Passive colonizetion end ualcol-
Species which achieve a small adult size relative ony multiplication in the nrsssive Poites
to others in the same taxa frequently produce large luteo, J. Exp. Mar. BioL EcoL 45(1h5$6?
eggs or larvae and develo,pment of eggs is lecitha' Hyman, L,N. 1940. lbe invertebrates. l.
trophic, bd protectine or viviparous {Chia 197a). through Ctenophora, New York 726
p.
P. murrayensr} releases relatively large planulae Kojis, B.L. and N.J. Quinn. 1980. Mode and Lg of agx-
and achieves a nraxirnum diamets of 20 cm, while ual "reproduction in some members of the her-
the other three species release small eggs and col- matypic coral family Faviidae. Am.Znl. 819.
onies achieve a size of >2 m. 1981, Aspects of sexual repro snd
Maximum size achieved by corals may be related larval dwelopment in the sballowwater
to two factor$ l) the amount of energy expended oa coral, Goniastrea australensis
growth and reproduction as indicated by the Haime 185?). Bull. Mar. Sci. {in prees).
iumber of montis per annum gonads and/oriarvae L€wis. J.B. 1974. Settlement and growth factr influone-
are present and 2) the longevity of colonies of a ing the contagious distribution of some Atlantic
reef cords. Prrc. 2nd Ini. Coral Reef
species. Both P. munvyensis and P stephensoni
2t
201-205-
{Stephenson 1933} release planulae over 4n extend- Loya, Y. 1972. Community structureatrd species
ed p€riod and are small in size. AlBo, the maximum of hermatypic coralg at Eilat, B€d Sea.
age-of P rnurrayensis may be relatively young. The 13:1fi}'123.
largest of 14 tag8Bd colories ( > 10 cm diameterl did 19?6. Settlement, mortality recruit-
in situ, whereas the smaller colonies survived. In ment of a Red Sea coral population. .lz G. . Mackie
coatrast, there was no morbality among the larp {ed.). Coelenterate Ecology and Behavior. 8F99.
taCged colonies af P. andrewsi P. lpbato and P. New York Plenum Publishing Corp.
lztea These species pmbably achieve a larger size Marsball, S.M. and T.A. Stephenson. 1933- The
than P. murrayemsis and P. stephensoni because of the corals. Sci. Bep. Great Barrier
1928-1929. 3:2L9-245.
they grow faster and are longer livd. Morrissey, J. 198t). Community struciure and nof
nacroalgae and hermatypiccorals on a reef
flat of Magaetic Island (queenslard,
Aquatie Botaay 8:91-139.
ACKNOWLEDGAMENTS Rinkevich, R. and Y. Loya. 1979. The of the
Red Sea Coral, StybpftomPistilhta l. and
firis r€search was supported by grants from the planulae. Mar. EcoL Prog. Ser. 1:133-144.
University of Quee.n"leld, tbe Great Barier Reef Marine Stephenson, TJq,. 1939. Developmenl and fon of
Park Authority and the Ecological Society of Australia- colonies of Po cillopotz and Porfees, Part l.
Rep.
We *ould Iike to thenk Ms. L. Daddow for assisting with Great Barrier R€ef Exped. 1928-f929, 3:1 3-134.
histological preparatious, Prof. Ir{. Pichon for iudentifying Stimson, J.S. 1976. Rsproduclioa in
some coEmor
specimens of Porites and Mes. V. Harriott, L. Keyes, I. Hapaiian reef corals. /n
G.O- (ed.l.
Stejskal and many others for their assistance fu the fieH- Coelenterate Ecology and tsehavior. pp. 2?1-180.
The uee of lleron Islaud Research Station is Sratefully New York: Plenum Press.
ackaowledged . 19?8. Mode and timing cf rel bion in
some common bermatypic corals of ii and
Enewetak. Mar. BioI. 48:1?3-184.
Stoddsrt, D.B" 1969. Ecology and morpbologr recent
REFEBENCES coral reefs- Biol. Rev. 44:438-498.
Vaughan, T.W. f910. lbe recent na of
Bak, RP.M. aqd Epgel M.S 19?9. Distribution, abun southern Florida. Yb. Carnegie Wash.
dance and survival of juvenile hermatypic corals 9:135-144.
(seleracbiuia) and the ot i!6 history Yamazato, K., M. Oshiro and E. Oshiro. 192S.
strategy in tbe parent coral community. Mar, Biol. tive biology of a scleracbinisn coral
54(4):341-352. qtaensbndioe decima^ 13th Pacific
Chia, F.S. 19?4. Clagsificatiou and adaptive sis.ifcance greee Proc. 1:135,
of developnental patt€rns in marin* inve'rtebrates. Yonge, C.M. 1963. The biology of coral
Thalassi:a Jugoslavica lO: 121.13O. Mar. Biol. l:20S260.