Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract—This paper presents small-signal stability studies of Vs Voltage magnitude of the STATCOM
a multimachine power system, considering Static Synchronous VAC AC terminal voltage of the
Compensators (STATCOM) and discussed control modes of the STATCOM
STATCOM. The Power Sensitivity Model (PSM) is used to
represent the electric power system. The study is based on modal VDC DC terminal voltage of the
analysis and time domain simulations. The results obtained allow STATCOM
concluding that the STATCOM improves the stabilization in the Vkref Reference voltage at bus k
electric power system. Vsref Reference voltage of the STATCOM
Index Terms—Electric Power System, Power Sensitivity Model, VDCref DC voltage reference
Static Synchronous Compensators (STATCOM). E0k Internal voltage of generator in bus
k
I. N OMENCLATURE R1km , R2km , R3km Coefficients of reactive power on the
transmission line k-m
A1km , A2km , A3km Sensitivity coefficients of the active
R1jk , R2jk , R3jk Coefficients of reactive power on the
power on transmission line k-m
transmission line j-k
A1jk , A2jk , A3jk Sensitivity coefficients of the active
Rk , RDC , Rc , RΨ Sensitivity coefficients of the reac-
power on transmission line j-k
tive power of the STATCOM
Ak , ADC , Ac , AΨ Sensitivity coefficients of the active
KS , KP , KC , KΨ Gains of the first order controllers
power of the STATCOM
xSDT Leakage reactance of the STATCOM
c, Ψ Control variables of the STATCOM
transformer
Ccc Capacitance of the STATCOM
x0d Direct axis transient reactance of the
IDC Electric current on the DC side of
generator
the STATCOM
Zkm Impedance of the transmission line
IS Electric current supplied or absorbed
between the busses k and m
by the STATCOM
Zjk Impedance of the transmission line
Ik Electric current of generator in bus
between the busses j and k
k
θs Voltage angle of the STATCOM
PGk Active power generated by generator
θk Angle of the voltage at bus k
installed in the bus k
θkm Difference between the angles of bus
Pkm Active power flow between the
voltages k and m (θkm = θk − θm )
busses k e m
Ωk Set of neighboring busses to the bus
PLk Active load on the bus k
k
PS Active power of the STATCOM
ωn Natural frequency of the electrome-
QGk Reactive power generated by
chanical loop
generator of bus k
ξ Damping coefficient
Qkm Reactive power flow between the
(r, m) Coordinate system (real and imagi-
busses k and m
nary axes)
QLk Reactive load on the bus k
QS Reactive power of the STATCOM
Sk Apparent power of the STATCOM II. I NTRODUCTION
installed at bus k
Tc , T Ψ
Vk
Time constants of the controller
Voltage magnitude at bus k N OWADAYS, it is necessary to improve the power trans-
mission system because there is a power consumption
increase due to industrial and home activities growth.
This work was supported by the National Counsel of Technological and This work discusses and compares different control tech-
Scientific Development (CNPq), Brazil. niques for damping undesirable inter-area oscillations in
A. Petean-Pina and P. B. de Araujo are with Universidade Es-
tadual Paulista (UNESP - Ilha Solteira), São Paulo, Brazil, e-mails: power systems [6], [7] by Static Synchronous Compensators
percival@dee.feis.unesp.br and aline pina@globo.com. (STATCOM) [4].
2
Vk
Studies referred to the inclusion of the FACTS (Flexible
Alternating Current Transmission Systems) [1] STATCOM de-
Transformer
vice in the PSM (Power Sensitivity Model) [2] are developed.
The aim is to study the electric power system stability under
CA terminal Vs
small perturbations.
FACTS devices were designed in order to control the power Is
flow on transmission lines and also to increase its transmission
capacity, providing a more reliable system [3]. Converter
With the introduction of this type of controller in power
systems, the stability presents more degrees of freedom to DC terminal CCC
large and small disturbances, since these devices have the
ability to add damping to electromechanical oscillations [3].
Fig. 1. Basic configuration of the STATCOM FACTS device
The damping of these oscillations will be the focus of this
work that use the PSM expanded to multimachine power
Vs
systems [2].
Controllers for the FACTS STATCOM device, which are Qs
described by first order blocks, are also suggested.
Two models are considered for the device: the first one Is
allows only the reactive power compensation, this will be
known as simplified model; while the other one allows the
reactive or active compensation, then it will be known as
enhanced model [5].
Fig. 2. Simplified representation of the STATCOM FACTS device
Is jxSDT Transformer
Fig. 4. Electric power system with a STATCOM operating (simplified model) CA terminal Vs
Is
c
The fundamental concept of the PSM is the application of Converter
active and reactive power balance in each bus of the system
[2]. Thus, for a generic bus k, connected to two other busses IDC CCC DC terminal
l and m (according to Fig. 5), generated active and reactive
power variations delivered to bus k (∆PGk and ∆QGk ) must VDC
be equal to the sum of active and reactive flows variations on
Fig. 6. Enhanced representation of the STATCOM FACTS device
transmission lines k-m (∆Pkm and ∆Qkm ) and k-l (∆Pkl and
∆Qkl ). To generalize this concept, consider the set of every
bus connected to bus k named Ωk , giving (7) and (8). Changing the ratio c anables the converter to adjust the
magnitude of the AC voltage (Vs ) and thus the exchange of
X reactive power with the network. Changing the phase shift
∆PGk − ∆PLk − ∆Pkm = 0 (7) Ψ between the network voltage and the voltage generated by
m∈Ωk the converter (Fig. 7) makes possible an exchange of active
X
∆QGk − ∆QLk − ∆Qkm = 0 (8) power, which is used for controlling the DC voltage (VDC ) at
m∈Ωk a reference value [5].
m
Vm m
Vs
Vk k
E’k Zkm s
Ik Pkm Qkm Vk
x’d
PGk QGk k
Zkl r
Pkl Qkl Fig. 7. Phasor Diagram: Voltages V̄k and V̄s
Vl l
electric power system occurs in a generic bus k, as shown in Seeing small variations around a stable equilibrium point,
diagram of Fig. 8. (18a) can be linearized, resulting in (19).
Vk k Vm m
6 7 9
∂∆V̇DC 1 cVk cos Ψ 1 5 4
k3CC = = (28c) 10 G4
G1
∂Ψ CCC xSDT
For Ψ, the control block is defined by the time constant TΨ , Eigenvalues ξ ωn (rad/s) ωn (Hz)
-0.2356 ± j6.2953 0.0374 6.2997 1.0026
representing the delay inherent in the firing of the GTOs, and -0.1585 ± j5.8779 0.0270 5.8800 0.9358
the static gain KΨ . For c, is defined similarly a constant Tc 0.0460 ± j4.1382 -0.0111 4.1385 0.6587
and a static gain Kc , which uses as input signal the changes
in power flow on the transmission line where the STATCOM
is installed. So that: Analyzing the data shown in Table I, it follows the existence
of three oscillation modes: two stable (negative real part) and
one unstable (positive real part).
∆PGk −∆PLk −
X
(∆Pkm )−∆Ps = 0 (29) The numerical values of the frequencies shown indicate that
m ∈ Ωk
the stable modes refer to local modes, whose typical frequency
X range is 0.7 to 2,0 Hz [9]. The unstable mode corresponds to
∆QGk −∆QLk − (∆Qkm )−∆Qs = 0 (30) an oscillation inte-arrea mode (which have frequencies in the
m ∈ Ωk
range 0.2 to 0.8 Hz). To make it stable the inclusion of the
then: STATCOM in the power system is proposed.
For the simulations will be adopted fixed values for the
parameters of the controllers (Kc = 200, Tc = 0.01, Ks = 1
and Kp = 1) for the simplified model. For the enhanced
Xjk ∆(θj − θk ) + A2jk ∆Vj + (A3jk − Ak )∆Vk −
A1
− [A1km ∆(θk − θm ) + A2km ∆Vk + A3km ∆Vm )]− model were considered Kc = 200, Tc = 0.01, KΨ = 150 and
m∈Ωk TΨ = 0.01.
(ADC ∆VDC + Ac ∆c + AΨ ∆ψ) = 0
(31) B. Performance of the STATCOM – Simplified Model
R1jk ∆(θj − θk ) + R2jk ∆Vj + (R3jk − Rk )∆Vk −
X Considering step perturbation of 0.05 pu in the mechanical
− [R1km ∆(θk − θm ) + R2km ∆Vk + R3km ∆Vm ]− torque of Generator 1 (G1 in Fig. 10), new simulations
m∈Ωk were performed. The results obtained for a frequency-domain
(RDC ∆VDC + Rc ∆c + RΨ ∆ψ) = 0 analysis are listed in Table II.
(32)
TABLE II
Note that for this model of the STATCOM, both changes in E IGENVALUES – S IMPLIFIED STATCOM MODEL
the active power and reactive power are modified, differently Eigenvalues ωn (Hz) ξ Area
when the simplified model is considered. -0.1197 ± j1.3778 0.2201 0.0866 Inter-area
-0.2447 ± j6.2894 1.0017 0.0389 1
The full state system for the enhanced model can be found -0.1498 ± j5.8212 0.9268 0.0257 2
in [12].
6
For an analysis in time-domain, the internal angular varia- In figures 13, 14 and 15, the internal angular variation
tions of generators 2, 3 and 4 (G2 , G3 and G4 in Fig. 10) in Generator 3 referred to Generator 1, the variation of
with respect to the internal angle of G1 are shown in Fig. 11. the voltage magnitude in bus 8 (bus installation of the
STATCOM), and the variation of active power flow on the
transmission line between the busses 7 and 8, respectively, for
the STATCOM represented by the simplified and enhanced
models are shown.
C. Performance of the STATCOM – Enhanced Model Fig. 13. Angular variation in Generator 3 referred to Generator 1
(∆δ3 − ∆δ1 ). Simplified and enhanced STATCOM models
Simulations of the test system considering the operation
of the STATCOM represented by the enhanced model are
presented in this section. Results are presented in Table III.
TABLE III
E IGENVALUES – E NHANCED STATCOM MODEL
Eigenvalues ωn (Hz) ξ Area
-0.1341 ± j1.2118 0.1940 0.1100 Inter-area
-0.2449 ± j6.2892 1.0017 0.0389 1
-0.1506 ± j5.8209 0.9267 0.0259 2
Fig. 14. Variation of the voltage magnitude in bus 8 (∆V8 ). Simplified and
enhanced STATCOM models
D. Comparison Between the Modeling of the STATCOM – Fig. 15. Variation of active power flow on the transmission line between the
Simplified and Enhanced Models busses 7 and 8 (∆P78 ). Simplified and enhanced STATCOM models
consider Table IV which shows the steady-state values of resulting in a more complete model for the electric power
the voltage magnitude of the bus where the STATCOM is system.
installed (∆V8 ), the internal anglular variations of generators In the simulations performed in a test system that proved
2 and 3 referred to Generator 1 (∆δ2 − ∆δ1 and ∆δ3 − ∆δ1 , unstable due to an oscillation inter-area mode, the STATCOM
respectively) and active power flow on the transmission line was intentionally installed to add damping to this mode.
between the busses 7 and 8 (∆P78 ). Results allowed the comparison between the two models
studied and made it possible to conclude that the model
TABLE IV
S TEADY- STATE VALUES : ∆V8 , ∆δ2 − ∆δ1 , ∆δ3 − ∆δ1 , AND ∆P78 –
that allows both the reactive and active power compensa-
S IMPLIFIED AND ENHANCED STATCOM MODELS tion (enhanced model) not only adds a greater versatility to
the device, as well as increased complexity and improved
Model ΔV8 (pu) Δδ2 - Δδ1 (rad) Δδ3 - Δδ1 (rad) ΔP78 (pu)
Simplified -0.0456 -0.0160 -0.0698 0.0512
the power system performance against small perturbations,
Detailed -0.0618 -0.0199 -0.0920 0.0607 injecting greater amount of damping torque, compared with
the simplified model.
Analyzing the data presented, it can be concluded that VIII. R EFERENCES
the way the STATCOM is modeled in the electric power
[1] N. G. Hingorani, “High Power Electronics and Flexible AC Transmission
system alters the final values of the magnitudes considered. Systems”, IEEE Power Engineering Review, vol. 4, pp. 3-4, 1998
Furthermore, the enhanced model provides more deviations [2] S. M. Deckman, V. F. da Costa, “A Power Sensitivity Model for
for the measurements under study than the simplified model Electromechanical Oscillation Studies”, IEEE Transactions on Power
Systems, pp. 965-971, 1994.
(note that in all curves shown, those related to the enhanced [3] E. H. Watanabe, P. G. Barbosa, K. C. Almeida, G. N. Taranto, “Tecnologia
model are tending to higher steady-state values when they are FACTS- tutorial”, SBA Controle & Automao, vol. 9, pp. 3955, 1998
compared with the curves related to the simplified model). [4] Y. H. Song, A. T. Johns, “Flexible AC transmission system (FACTS)”,
The Institute of Electrical Engineers, TJ International, p. 592, 1999.
By analyzing the curves shown in figures 11, 12 and 13, and [5] Cigré Task Force, “Modeling of Power Electronics Equipment (FACTS)
by comparing the damping rates, it is clear that the enhanced in Load Flow and Stability Programs”, 1999
model has a better performance with regard to introduce [6] P. Anderson, A. A. Fouad, Power System Control and Stability. IEEE
Power System Engineering Series, Iowa State University Press, 2003, p.
damping to the electric power system, i.e., the enhanced model 568.
is providing more damping to the test system (it is emphasized [7] M. Klein, G. J. Rogers, P. Kundur, “A Fundamental Study of Inter-area
that this statement is correct for the considered operating point Oscillation in Power Systems”, IEEE Transactions on Power Systems,
vol. 6, n. 3, pp. 914-921, 1991
and adjustment of controllers using typical values found in the [8] L. Gyugyi, “Dynamic Compensation of AC Transmission Lines by
related literature). Solid-state Synchronous Voltage Sources”, IEEE Transactions on Power
Delivery, vol. 9, n. 2, pp. 904-911, 1994
[9] N. G. Hingorani, L. Gyugyi, Understanding FACTS: Concepts and
VII. C ONCLUSIONS Technology of Flexible AC Transmission Systems. IEEE Press- John
Wiley, 1999, p. 452.
This paper presented two models for the STATCOM FACTS [10] “Power System Technology. Proceedings. POWERCON ’98
device: one called “simplified” and another called “enhanced”. International Conference, 1998”. (July 2009) Rule-based control for
These models differ in both composition and functioning of the STATCOM to increase power system stability. [Online]. Available:
http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/stamp/stamp.jsp?tp=&arnumber=728989
device. These models were used to obtain preliminary results &isnumber=15699.
of the study of stability to small perturbations, which allowed [11] A. L. S. Pereira, “Utilização de Redes Neurais Artificiais no Ajuste
the linearization of these models. de Controladores Suplementares e Dispositivo FACTS STATCOM para a
Melhoria da Estabilidade a Pequenas Perturbações do Sistema Elétrico de
Equating of the STATCOM FACTS device in its simpli- Potência”, Ph.D. These, Faculdade de Engenharia, Universidade Estadual
fied form was developed. In this model, the STATCOM is Paulista, UNESP - Ilha Solteira, Brazil, 2009.
represented by a controllable current source connected in shunt [12] A. P. Pina, “Comparação entre Modelos do Dispositivo FACTS
STATCOM para o Estudo da Estabilidade a Pequenas Perturbações”,
mode with the electric power system; due to not controlling M.Sc. These, Faculdade de Engenharia, Universidade Estadual Paulista,
the phase of this current source, this model can only perform UNESP - Ilha Solteira, Brazil, 2010.
the compensation of reactive power.
After deduction of the simplified model, a first order con- IX. B IOGRAPHIES
troller for actuation in the control variable of the device (IS )
was modeled, whose input signal chosen was the variation of
active power on the transmission line between the busses in Aline Petean Pina obtained the B.Sc. and M.Sc. from Universidade Estadual
one of which the STATCOM was connected. Paulista (UNESP - Ilha Solteira), in 2007 and 2010, respectively. She is
currently towards the Ph.D. degree at UNESP - Ilha Solteira, Brazil. Her
Likewise, the enhanced model was developed. In this main research interest is on Small Signal Stability in Electric Power Systems.
model, the voltage magnitude entered by the FACTS device
is controllable via the ratio c, while the voltage phase is
controllable by the phase shift Ψ. Thus, the STATCOM Percival Bueno de Araujo obtained the B.Sc. degree from Universidade Es-
device can perform reactive power compensation in addition tadual Paulista (UNESP - Ilha Solteira), the M.Sc. degree from Universidade
to exchange active power with the electric power system. Federal de Santa Catarina (UFSC) and the Ph.D. degree from Universidade
de So Paulo (USP), in 1982, 1988 and 1998, respectively. He is currently an
After obtaining their linearized equations, the modeling of Assistant Professor at Electrical Engineering Department of UNESP - Ilha
the controllers of the control variables c and Ψ was held. These Solteira, Brazil. His main research interest is on Small Signal Stability in
equations were combined to the original MSP-multimachine, Electric Power Systems.