Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Overview
International best practice in microfinance around the world suggests good financial
analysis is the basis for successful and sustainable microfinance operations. Some would
even say that without financial analysis your MFI will never achieve sustainability.
Sustainability means relying on commercially priced and internally generated funds rather
than on donors for growth.
Sustainability =
Loan loss +
1. Balance sheet
2. Income statement
3. Cash flow statement
4. Portfolio report
Revenue Expenses
Refers to money earned by an organization for Represent costs incurred for goods and services
goods sold and services rendered during an used in the process of earning revenue. Direct
accounting period, including expenses for an MFI include
An income statement
• Relates to a balance sheet through the transfer of cash donations and net profit (loss)
as well as depreciation, and in the relationship between the provision for loan
impairment and the impairment loss allowance.
• Uses a portfolio report’s historical default rates (and the current impairment loss
allowance) to establish the provision for loan impairment.
• Relates to a cash flow statement through the net profit/loss as a starting point on
the cash flow (indirect method).
• Starts at zero for each period (in contrast to the Balance Sheet which is cumulative
since the beginning of the organization’s operation).
• Classifies the cash flows into operating, investing and financing activities.
o Operating activities: services provided (income-earning activities).
o Investing activities: expenditures that have been made for resources intended to
generate future income and cash flows.
o Financing activities: resources obtained from and resources returned to the
owners, resources obtained through borrowings (short-term or long-term) as
well as donor funds.
• Can use either
o The direct method, by which major classes of gross cash receipts and gross cash
payments are shown to arrive at net cash flow (recommended by IAS)
o The indirect method, works back from net profit or loss, adding or deducting
noncash transactions, deferrals or accruals, and items of income or expense
associated with investing and financing cash flows to arrive at net cash flow.
Note: The Balance Sheet and Income Statement are accounting reports. The figures can be influenced by management’s choices
regarding accounting policies. A Cash Flow Statement cannot be changed by any accounting policy.
Portfolio Report and Activity Report
A portfolio report and activity report link the loan portfolio information of the three
previously discussed statements—income statement, balance sheet, and cash flow. The
purpose of the portfolio report is to represent in detail an MFI’s microlending activity,
present the quality of the loan portfolio, and provide detail on how the MFI has
provisioned against potential losses. Unlike other statements, the design of this report
varies from MFI to MFI. The content, however, should be consistent and must include
the following:
• Portfolio activity information,
• Movement in the Impairment Loss Allowance, and
• A Portfolio Aging Schedule.
Most MFIs depend on donor funds but do not realize to what extent and that donor money
is not limitless. We want to create financial statements that will show the impact of donor
funds on the MFI’s financial position and its relationship to sustainability.
So what’s different ?
• INCOME STATEMENT –
♦ Donor funds are treated “below the line.”
♦ Donor money is recorded after the net income (after taxes before donations).
• BALANCE SHEET –
There are three separate sources of equity from the income statement:
♦ Retained earnings/losses–current year (minus cash donations)
♦ Donations–current year
♦ Other equity accounts– including net nonoperating income
This is important because it allows one to see over time the proportion of equity that
is from the MFI itself versus the amounts contributed by donors.
Three Ways in Which MFIs Treat Cash Donations
Goals: 1. Grants are separated from operating income
2. Grants are fully disclosed in equity
IAS 20 Recommends Income approach
Considerations: Where to record them
When to record them
• What is the optimum level of each different operational expense including the cost of funds
• How to manage the costs of human resources as part of overall human resource management
• How to manage liquidity—i.e., how to keep solvent at the same time as disbursing the maximum
• What is the best financing structure, i.e., how much debt including from commercial sources and
• How to manage the fixed assets, i.e., the depreciation policy, how to finance them, are they insured,
are they safe?
• How to undertake trend analysis and to compare actual performance against planned performance
Indicators for Financial Analysis
Indicators generally compare two or more pieces of data, resulting in a ratio that provides
more insight than do individual data points.
Portfolio Quality
• Portfolio at Risk (PAR) Ratio
• Adjusted Portfolio at Risk (PAR) Ratio
• Write-off Ratio
• Adjusted Write-off Ratio
• Risk Coverage Ratio
• Adjusted Risk Coverage Ratio
Efficiency and Productivity
• Operating Expense Ratio
• Adjusted Operating Expense Ratio
• Cost per Active Client
• Adjusted Cost per Active Client
• Borrowers per Loan Officer
• Active Clients per Staff Member
• Client Turnover
• Average Outstanding Loan Size
• Adjusted Average Outstanding Loan Size
• Average Loan Disbursed
Portfolio Quality
Portfolio at Risk (PAR) and the Write-off Ratio are the preferred ratios for analysing
portfolio quality. The other ratios are more limited as noted in the ‘measurement’ column
below
.
Adjusted Unpaid Principal Balance of all loans The adjusted PAR reduces
Adjusted PAR Ratio
with payments > 30 Days past due + Value of the Gross Loan Portfolio
Renegotiated Loans by the Write-off
Adjusted Gross Loan Portfolio Adjustment.
Value of Loans Written Off Represents the percentage
Write-Off Ratio
Average Gross Loan Portfolio of the MFI’s loans that has
been removed from the
balance of the gross loan
portfolio because they are
Value of Loans Written Off + Write-off unlikely to be repaid. MFIs’
Adjusted write off
Adjustment write-off policies vary;
ratio
Average Adjusted Gross Loan Portfolio managers are
recommended to calculate
this ratio on an adjusted
basis.
is an account that represents the amount of outstanding principal that is not expected to
be recovered by a micro-finance organisation
it is a negative asset on the Balance Sheet and reduces the Gross Loan Portfolio. (An
alternative presentation is to show it as a liability.)
↓ They decrease the Impairment Loss Allowance and the Gross Loan
Portfolio
The provision for loan impairment expenses the anticipated loss of value in the portfolio gradually over
the appropriate periods in which that asset generates income, instead of waiting until the actual loss of
the asset is realized.
Provisions are only accounting estimates and entries, and they do not involve a movement of cash, like
saving for a rainy day.
A provision for loan impairment charged to a period is expensed in the Income Statement. The
corresponding credit accumulates over time in the Balance Sheet as an allowance shown as a negative
asset:
Write-offs do not affect the net portfolio outstanding unless an increase in the impairment loss allowance
is made. When write-offs are recovered, they are booked in the Income Statement as Value of Loans
Adapted from: Joanna Ledgerwood. Financial Management Training for Microfinance Organizations, Calmeadow, 1996.
Analytical Adjustments
Adjustments are additional, or hidden, costs incurred by the MFI that we need to recognize
for internal management purposes, for example, when calculating and analyzing efficiency
and profitability ratios. They are not to be included in the audited financial statements;
they are internal adjustments.
Which costs does an MFI incur that are not reflected in the expenses?
•Subsidies
•Inflation
•Portfolio at risk
REF. ACCOUNT EXPLANATION FORMULA
NAME
1. Subsidies
Examines the difference between {(Average Short-term
Subsidized an MFI’s financial expense and the Borrowings + Average Long-term
A1 financial expense it would pay if all Borrowings) x Market Rate for
Cost of Funds its funding liabilities were priced at Borrowing} – Interest and Fee
market rate. Expense on Borrowings
The difference between what the
MFI is actually paying for a
donated or subsidized good or
service and what it would have
to pay for the same good or Period Estimated Market Cost of
A2 In-kind Subsidy service on the open market.. [Accounts] – Period Actual Cost
Common examples of these in- of [Accounts]
kind subsidies are computers,
consulting services, free office
space, and free services of a
manager.
2. Inflation
The rationale behind the inflation
adjustment is that an MFI should,
at a minimum, preserve the value
of its equity (and shareholders
investments) against erosion due (Equity, Beginning pg Period x
to inflation. In addition, this Inflation Rate) – (Net Fixed
A3 Inflation
adjustment is important to Assets, Beginning pf Period x
consider when benchmarking Inflation Rate)
institutions in different countries
and economic environments.
Unlike subsidy adjustment,
recording an inflation adjustment
is common in many parts of the
world and is mandated by Section
29 of the International Accounting
Standards (IAS) in high inflation
economies.
3. Portfolio at Risk
Intended to bring as MFI’s
Gross Loan Portfolio x [Allowance
Impairment Impairment Loss Allowance in line
A4 Rated] – (Impairment Loss
Loss Allowance with the quality of its Gross Loan
Allowance)
Portfolio.
Intended to identify loans on an
MFI’s books that by any
reasonable standard should be
written-off. This adjustment can
A5 Write-off significantly reduce the value of Portfolio at Risk > 180 days
an MFI’s assets if persistent
delinquent loans are not counted
as part of the gross loan
portfolio.
Calculating Adjustments
DESCRIPTION
Adjustment for Subsidized
A1 Cost of Funds
a. Average Short-term Borrowings
b. Average Long-term Borrowings
c. Average Loang and Short Term Borrowings
d. Market Rate, End of Period
e. Market Cost of Funds = c x d
f. Interest and Fee Expense on Borrowings
g. Adjustment for Subsidized Cost of Funds =e - f
Adjustment for In-kind
A2 Subsidies
a. Personnel Expense
b. Administrative Expense
c. Adjustment for In-kind Subsidies = a + b
A3 Inflation Adjustment
a. Equity, Beginning of Period
b. Inflation Rate
c. Inflation Adjustment to Equity = (a x b)
d. Net Fixed Assets, Beginning of Period
e. Inflation Adjustment to Fixed Assets = (d x b)
f. Net Adjustment for Inflation = c - e
• Interest Rate Management: The MFI must make sure that the use of funds generates
more revenue than the cost of funds.
• Asset Management: Funds should be used to create assets that produce the most
revenue (are most “productive”).
• Leverage: The MFI seeks to borrow funds to increase assets and thereby increase
revenue and net profit. The term leverage indicates the degree to which an MFI is using
borrowed funds. At the same time, the MFI must manage the cost and use of its
borrowings so that it generates more revenue than it pays in Interest and Fee Expense
on those borrowings.
• Liquidity Management: The MFI must also make sure that it has sufficient funds
available (“liquid”) to meet any short-term obligations.
Asset/Liability Management Ratios
Interest rate management
Asset Management
Adjusted Liabilities
debt/Equity Adjusted Equity
Liquidity Management
Cash + Trade Investments
Current Ratio Demand Deposit + Short-term Time
Deposit + Short-term Borrowing +
Interest Payable on Funding Liabilities +
Accounts Payable and Other Short-term
Liabilities)
Calculating Asset/Liability Management Ratios
Ref. DESCRIPTION
R4 Yield on Gross Portfolio Ratio = a/b
a Cash Received from Interest, Fees,and Commissions on Loan Portfolio
b Average Gross Loan Portfolio
R4 Yield on Gross Portfolio Ratio = a/b
Adj
R6 Adjusted Cost of Fund Ratio
a Adjusted Financial Expenses on Funding Liabilities
b Average Deposits
c Average Borrowings
d b+c
Adj
R6 Adjusted Cost of Fund Ratio = a/d
R7 Debt to Equity Ratio
a Liabilities
b Equity
R7 Debt to Equity Ratio = a/b
Adj
R7 Adjusted Debt to Equity Ratio
a Liabilities
b Adjusted Equity
Adj
R7 Adjusted Debt to Equity Ratio = a/b
Efficiency is related to Productivity in terms of serving clients and keeping costs low.
Adjusted Operating
Expense Ratio Adjusted operating Expense The adjusted ratio usually increases
Average Adjusted Gross Loan Portfolio this ratio when the affect of
subsidies are included.
Cost per Active Operating Expense Provides a meaningful measure of
Client Average Number of Active Clients efficiency for an MFI, allowing it to
determine the average cost of
maintaining an active client.
Adjusted Average
Outstanding Loan Adjusted Gross Loan Portfolio The adjusted ratio incorporates the
Size Adjusted Number of Loans Outstanding Write-off Adjustment.
Profitability and sustainability ratios reflect the MFI’s ability to continue operating and
grow in the future.
Adj
R1 Financial Self-Sufficiency Ratio
a Financial Revenue
b Adjusted Financial Expense
c Adjusted Impairment Losses on Loans
d Adjusted Operating Expense
e b+c+d
Adj
R1 Financial Self-Sufficiency Ratio = a/e
Adj
R2 Adjusted Return on Assets (AROA)
a Adjusted Net Operating Income
b Taxes
c a-b
d Adjusted Average Assets
Adj
R2 Adjusted Return on Assets (AROA) = c/d
Adj
R3 Adjusted Return on Equity (AROE) = c/d
a Adjusted Net Operating Income
b Taxes
c a-b
d Adjusted Average Equity
Adj
R3 Adjusted Return on Equity (AROE) = c/d
Use of Ratios
They can help answer two primary questions that every institution involved in
microfinance needs to ask.
Is this institution either achieving or progressing towards profitability?
How efficient is it in achieving its given objectives?
No one ratio tells it all. There are no values for any specific ratio that is necessarily
correct. It is the trend in these ratios which is critically important.
Ratios must be analyzed together, and ratios tell you more when consistently
tracked over a period of time.