Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CARNIVAL CORPORATION
d/b/a CARNIVAL CRUISE LINES,
Plaintiff,
vs.
Defendants.
_______________________________________/
COMPLAINT
LINES (“CARNIVAL”), and for its causes of action against defendant OPERADORA
ACE USA (“ACE AMERICAN”) and JOHN DOES 1-10, and each of them, alleges as follows:
GENERAL ALLEGATIONS
1. Subject matter jurisdiction is based on 28 U.S.C. Sections 1331 and 1333, in that
this is an admiralty or maritime claim within the meaning of Fed. R. Civ. P. 9(h) and 14(c). The
claims underlying this matter are based upon the Jones Act, 46 U.S.C. 688, and general maritime
2. The parties are citizens of a state and citizens or subjects of a foreign state, but
none of the defendants are citizens of the same state as the plaintiff, and the amount in
corporation licensed to transact business in the State of Florida and with its principal place of
Defendants”), and therefore sues said Doe Defendants by such fictitious names; that when the
true names and capacities of said Doe Defendants are ascertained, Plaintiff will amend this
Complaint accordingly. Plaintiff is informed and believes, and thereon alleges, that each of said
Doe Defendants fictitiously designated herein were negligent and/or otherwise responsible in
7. Venue lies within the Southern District of Florida pursuant to 28 U.S.C. Section
1391(b)(2)-(3) and (d) in that at all relevant times the contractual agreement between
CARNIVAL and AVIOMAR contained a forum selection provision, designating the Southern
District of Florida as the appropriate forum for disputes among the parties, including the claims
Page 2 of 12
Mase, Lara, Eversole
Case 1:11-cv-20687-JLK Document 1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/28/2011 Page 3 of 12
CARNIVAL CORPORATION
vs.
OPERADORA AVIOMAR S.A.
de C.V., ACE AMERICAN, et al.
8. Plaintiff owns and operates the vessel CARNIVAL SPIRIT (“Vessel”) which is
used for purposes of passenger cruises. On February 29, 2008, CARNIVAL employed MARIA
9. On February 29, 2008, while the Vessel was docked in the port of Acapulco,
Mexico, Javier claims she sustained personal injuries in the course of her employment during an
ATV tour excursion owned, conducted, operated and controlled exclusively by AVIOMAR
10. Plaintiff believes and alleges Omar Hernandez Paredes, an employee or agent of
AVIOMAR, was the driver of the subject ATV at the time of the Incident.
11. In connection with the excursion, AVIOMAR obtained liability coverage under
(“Insurance Policy”), from ACE AMERICAN. The Insurance Policy provides liability insurance
for, among other things, damages resulting from incidents such as the Incident involving Javier.
The Insurance Policy was in effect on the date of the Incident. See Insurance Policy attached
12. Further, CARNIVAL, as an additional insured under the Insurance Policy, also
obtained liability coverage from ACE AMERICAN. The Insurance Policy provides liability
insurance for, among other things, damages resulting from incidents such as the Incident
involving Javier. The Insurance Policy was in effect on the date of the Incident. See Exhibit A.
13. As a result of Javier’s alleged injuries, through no fault of its own, CARNIVAL
has paid and/or continues to pay Javier maintenance, cure, and unearned wages (“Maintenance
and Cure”) as required under federal maritime law, in excess of $400,000 to date and continuing.
14. In addition to seeking and obtaining Maintenance and Cure, Javier filed suit
Page 3 of 12
Mase, Lara, Eversole
Case 1:11-cv-20687-JLK Document 1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/28/2011 Page 4 of 12
CARNIVAL CORPORATION
vs.
OPERADORA AVIOMAR S.A.
de C.V., ACE AMERICAN, et al.
against CARNIVAL and others in the United States District Court, Southern District of
California, Case No. 09 CV2003LAB WMC, for her alleged injuries claiming a violation of the
Jones Act, 46 U.S.C. 688, including claims for Jones Act Negligence and Unseaworthiness and
Maintenance and Cure. Said lawsuit was dismissed as against CARNIVAL on grounds that
decided in accordance with U.S. (maritime) law. AVIOMAR remains liable to CARNIVAL for
any settlement, award, or judgment resulting from any claim by Javier. Case No. 09
CARNIVAL and subject to the terms of the “Standard Shore Excursion Independent Contractor
Agreement”) wherein AVIOMAR expressly agreed: (a) under paragraph 9 to procure and
maintain liability insurance against any and all injuries related to its shore excursions and to
include CARNIVAL as an additional insured for the same; and (b) under paragraph 10 to
indemnify, save, protect and defend and hold harmless CARNIVAL (and its agents and
employees) for all losses, claims, liabilities, damages, causes of action, legal fees, and costs and
expenses which may arise or be claimed against CARNIVAL related to, in connection with, as a
provided to CARNIVAL and its guests, as well as any breach of the Indemnity Agreement.
AVIOMAR expressly agreed to be fully liable for acts of any of its employees, officers,
consequence of any of its shore excursions. See Indemnity Agreement attached hereto as Exhibit
“B.”
Page 4 of 12
Mase, Lara, Eversole
Case 1:11-cv-20687-JLK Document 1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/28/2011 Page 5 of 12
CARNIVAL CORPORATION
vs.
OPERADORA AVIOMAR S.A.
de C.V., ACE AMERICAN, et al.
16. The Incident occurred in the course of a shore excursion subject to and within the
17. CARNIVAL has tendered its defense and sought reimbursement and indemnity
for all past and future damages, claims, expenses and/or judgments incurred by CARNIVAL on
18. Through its timely claim for insurance coverage, CARNIVAL has also sought
reimbursement and indemnity for all past and future damages, claims, expenses and/or
described above, from ACE AMERICAN, who wrongfully denied CARNIVAL’s claim.
20. All conditions precedent to the bringing of this action have occurred, been
22. Javier claims to have been injured during a shore excursion operated and
23. Javier has sought and continues to seek Maintenance and Cure from CARNIVAL
and has filed suit as set forth above as a result of the Incident.
24. The shore excursion and Incident are subject to the Indemnity Agreement as set
forth above.
Page 5 of 12
Mase, Lara, Eversole
Case 1:11-cv-20687-JLK Document 1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/28/2011 Page 6 of 12
CARNIVAL CORPORATION
vs.
OPERADORA AVIOMAR S.A.
de C.V., ACE AMERICAN, et al.
25. Under the express terms of the Indemnity Agreement, CARNIVAL is entitled to
be indemnified, defended, insured, and held harmless by AVIOMAR with respect to any and all
claims or judgments by or on behalf of Javier, including Maintenance and Cure, and any other
28. In spite of timely and reasonable demand therefore, AVIOMAR has refused and
AVIOMAR, for damages, pre-judgment and post-judgment interest to the extent allowed by law,
costs, attorneys’ fees pursuant to the Indemnity Agreement, and for any further relief the Court
31. Javier claims to have been injured during a shore excursion operated and
32. Javier has sought and continues to seek Maintenance and Cure from CARNIVAL
Page 6 of 12
Mase, Lara, Eversole
Case 1:11-cv-20687-JLK Document 1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/28/2011 Page 7 of 12
CARNIVAL CORPORATION
vs.
OPERADORA AVIOMAR S.A.
de C.V., ACE AMERICAN, et al.
and has filed suit as set forth above as a result of the Incident.
33. Under the express terms of the Insurance Policy, ACE AMERICAN is obligated
to pay CARNIVAL “those sums that the insured becomes legally obligated to pay as damages
because of ‘bodily injury’ or ‘property damage’ to which (the) insurance applies.” See Exhibit
A.
34. In spite of timely and reasonable demand therefore, ACE AMERICAN has
breached the Insurance Policy by refusing to pay CARNIVAL for the aforementioned damages
35. As a direct and proximate result of ACE AMERICAN’s breach of the Insurance
AMERICAN, for damages, pre-judgment and post-judgment interest to the extent allowed by
law, costs, attorneys’ fees pursuant to the Insurance Policy, and for any further relief the Court
37. Javier claims to have been injured during a shore excursion operated and
38. Javier has sought and continues to seek Maintenance and Cure from CARNIVAL
and has filed suit as set forth above as a result of the Incident.
39. CARNIVAL is informed and believes Javier alleges AVIOMAR and its
employees and agents were negligent in their operation of the subject shore excursion or are in
Page 7 of 12
Mase, Lara, Eversole
Case 1:11-cv-20687-JLK Document 1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/28/2011 Page 8 of 12
CARNIVAL CORPORATION
vs.
OPERADORA AVIOMAR S.A.
de C.V., ACE AMERICAN, et al.
some other actionable manner legally responsible for the Incident and for proximately causing
40. CARNIVAL herein denies it is in any way responsible for the events or
a result of the Incident, or for proximately causing the same. However, if CARNIVAL is held
responsible to Javier for any of the matters set forth above, it is entitled to total equitable
indemnity from the Defendants for any loss suffered or expense incurred or judgment paid,
including any costs, attorneys’ fees, Maintenance and Cure, and other expenses which have been,
or in the future may be, incurred in that CARNIVAL’s liability will be based (if at all) on only
passive or secondary negligence arising as a legal result of the active and primary negligence of
the Defendants.
AVIOMAR’s acts or omissions, and for any further relief the Court deems just and proper.
alleged or claimed by Javier as set forth above. In the event, however, CARNIVAL is held liable
for the alleged Incident, claims or damages incurred by Javier, which liability is specifically
Page 8 of 12
Mase, Lara, Eversole
Case 1:11-cv-20687-JLK Document 1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/28/2011 Page 9 of 12
CARNIVAL CORPORATION
vs.
OPERADORA AVIOMAR S.A.
de C.V., ACE AMERICAN, et al.
AVIOMAR, requiring that it be responsible to CARNIVAL for AVIOMAR’s pro rata share of
liability, and for any further relief the Court deems just and proper.
44. As a result of AVIOMAR’s actions, an actual controversy has arisen and now
exists between CARNIVAL and AVIOMAR concerning their respective rights, duties and/or
financial obligations with respect to the Incident and the injuries or damages alleged to have
been suffered by Javier. CARNIVAL asserts and has asserted that in the event and to the extent
it is subject to any liability to Javier in any action, including arbitration or otherwise, or for any
claim or expense related to the Incident, including past and future payment of Maintenance and
Cure, it is entitled to be indemnified by AVIOMAR for the full amount of any loss suffered or
judgment or expense paid by CARNIVAL to Javier, if any, including all costs, reasonable
attorneys fees and other expenses which have been, and in the future may be incurred.
CARNIVAL is informed and believes that AVIOMAR disputes this contention and denies
liability to Javier and to CARNIVAL arising out of the facts and circumstances set forth herein.
45. CARNIVAL desires a judicial determination of its respective rights and duty of
AVIOMAR with respect to the damages, claims and other relief sought by Javier as set forth
CARNIVAL and AVIOMAR for damages, Maintenance and Cure obligations, and other claims
or expenses (if any) and a declaration that AVIOMAR is obligated to insure, defend and hold
Page 9 of 12
Mase, Lara, Eversole
Case 1:11-cv-20687-JLK Document 1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/28/2011 Page 10 of 12
CARNIVAL CORPORATION
vs.
OPERADORA AVIOMAR S.A.
de C.V., ACE AMERICAN, et al.
46. Such a declaration is necessary and proper at this time in order that CARNIVAL
may ascertain its rights and duties with respect to the claims of Javier as set forth above
including past and future liability for Maintenance and Cure, any judgment resulting from the
case filed by Javier in United States District Court, Southern District of California, and/or any
AVIOMAR is obligated to (1) indemnify CARNIVAL for the full amount of any Maintenance
and Cure paid by CARNIVAL to Javier as a result of the Incident, including all past and any
future payment of the same, and (2) defend CARNIVAL in any action or arbitration by Javier
against CARNIVAL related to the Incident and indemnify CARNIVAL for the full amount of
any loss suffered and judgment paid by it as a result of the same and for the full amount of such
costs, attorneys’ fees and other expenses CARNIVAL may be required to incur in the conduct of
the defense of such action or arbitration, and for any further relief the Court deems just and
proper.
48. As a result of ACE AMERICAN’s actions, an actual controversy has arisen and
now exists between CARNIVAL and ACE AMERICAN concerning their respective rights,
duties and/or financial obligations with respect to the Incident and the injuries or damages
alleged to have been suffered by Javier. CARNIVAL asserts and has asserted that in the event
and to the extent it is subject to any liability to Javier in any action, including arbitration or
otherwise, or for any claim or expense related to the Incident, including past and future payment
Page 10 of 12
Mase, Lara, Eversole
Case 1:11-cv-20687-JLK Document 1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/28/2011 Page 11 of 12
CARNIVAL CORPORATION
vs.
OPERADORA AVIOMAR S.A.
de C.V., ACE AMERICAN, et al.
of Maintenance and Cure, it is entitled to be indemnified by AVIOMAR for the full amount of
any loss suffered or judgment or expense paid by CARNIVAL to Javier, if any, including all
costs, reasonable attorneys fees and other expenses which have been, and in the future may be
incurred. CARNIVAL is informed and believes that ACE AMERICAN disputes this contention
and denies liability to CARNIVAL arising out of the facts and circumstances set forth herein.
49. CARNIVAL desires a judicial determination of its respective rights and duty of
ACE AMERICAN with respect to the damages, claims and other relief sought by Javier as set
CARNIVAL and ACE AMERICAN for damages, Maintenance and Cure obligations, and other
claims or expenses (if any) and a declaration that ACE AMERICAN is obligated to insure
50. Such a declaration is necessary and proper at this time in order that CARNIVAL
may ascertain its rights and duties with respect to the claims of Javier as set forth above
including past and future liability for Maintenance and Cure, any judgment resulting from the
case filed by Javier in United States District Court, Southern District of California, and/or any
AMERICAN is obligated to (1) indemnify CARNIVAL for the full amount of any Maintenance
and Cure paid by CARNIVAL to Javier as a result of the Incident, including all past and any
future payment of the same, and (2) defend CARNIVAL in any action or arbitration by Javier
against CARNIVAL related to the Incident and indemnify CARNIVAL for the full amount of
any loss suffered and judgment paid by it as a result of the same and for the full amount of such
costs, attorneys’ fees and other expenses CARNIVAL may be required to incur in the conduct of
Page 11 of 12
Mase, Lara, Eversole
Case 1:11-cv-20687-JLK Document 1 Entered on FLSD Docket 02/28/2011 Page 12 of 12
CARNIVAL CORPORATION
vs.
OPERADORA AVIOMAR S.A.
de C.V., ACE AMERICAN, et al.
the defense of such action or arbitration, and for any further relief the Court deems just and
proper.
Respectfully submitted,
18110/CP#24v2
Page 12 of 12
Mase, Lara, Eversole