You are on page 1of 72

The Future of

Satellite Navigation
(PNT)
Professor Brad Parkinson
Stanford University
Much Credit and
many thanks to
Inside GNSS &
"You've got to be very careful GPS World for photos

if you don't know where you are going,


because you might not get there." –
-- Yogi Berra

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007


Purpose of this Talk
Discuss the Future of PNT:

• Navigation Satellite Systems


• Augmentation Systems
• Applicable Technology and
• User Applications
plus
• Issues for sustaining Civil Capability
For Satellite-based PNT

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 2


CONTEXT: The “Big Five”
Civil Goals for GPS (GNSS) (As recommended by the IRT)

1. Assured Availability of GPS signals-Including


impaired situations (mountains, urban areas, foliage, etc.)

2. Resistance to Interference (RFI)


3. Accuracy
4. Bounded inaccuracy to limit wild points
5. Integrity - eliminating HMI, meeting
required time to alarm
Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 3
The Outline - What’s New?
 Satellites
 Augmentations
 Summary of New Signals and Payoffs
 New Technology
 New Applications
 Cautions
 Conclusions
Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 4
The Eras of Satellite Navigation
Focus on the future
1960 1965 1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2015 2020

Pioneers -Transit

D-1 IOC

Competition GPS Synthesis & Dev.


GULF IRAQ
Our Focus
Deployment
and
Applications Development
Upgraded GPS +
Galileo and
Glonass GLONASS
“Robustening”
Augmentations – WAAS et.al.

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 5


An Expanding GNSS World –
Basic Satellite Systems

 GPS

 GLONASS (Russia)

 Galileo (Europe)

 QZSS (Japan)

 Compass (China)

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 6


System Comparisons (courtesy Prof. Hein and Inside GNSS)

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 7


GPS Next Steps and Future

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 8


GPS Space Vehicle Comparisons
Our Focus
Category Block I Block II Block IIA Block IIR Block IIR-M Block IIF

444 Kg 860 Kg 860 Kg 1039 Kg 1074 Kg 1453 Kg


SV Dry Mass
(978 Lbs) (1896 Lbs) (1896 Lbs) (2291 Lbs) (2368 Lbs) (3204 Lbs)

EOL Power 410 W 710 W 798 W 1061 W 1061 W 2405 W

Design Life 5 years 7.5 years 7.5 years 10 years 10 years 12 Years

20 May2005
May 2005 2006
Q4 2008
First Launch 22 Feb 1978 14 Feb 1989 26 Nov 1990 23 Jul 1997
(Scheduled) (Scheduled)

Launch Vehicle Atlas E/F Delta II Delta II Delta II Delta II EELV (Both)

L1
L1 C/A,
C/A, L1L1 P(Y), L1 C/A, L1 P(Y),
P(Y),
EC Nav Payload L1 C/A, L1 P(Y), L1 C/A, L1 P(Y), L1 C/A, L1 P(Y), L1 C/A, L1 P(Y) L1 M, L2 C,
L2L1M, L2C,
P(Y), L2 C,
(Signals) L2 P(Y) L2 P(Y) L2 P(Y), L3 L2 P(Y), L3 L2 P(Y), L2 P(Y),L2 M,
L1 M, L2 M,L2M,
L3
L3, (+L5) L3, L5

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 9


GPS Block IIR/IIRM Technical Specifications

Space Vehicle Weight


• 1,039kg (2,291 lbs)
Launch Vehicle – Delta II
Design Life – 10 Years
Payload Power
• Solar panels generate up to 1061 watts (EOL)
Signals
• L1 C/A, L1 P(Y), L2 P(Y), L2 C/A, L1M, L2M, L3
(+ L5)
Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 10
GPS Block IIF Technical Specifications
GPS IIF Space Vehicle Weight
- 1,672 kg (3,758 lbs)
Launch Vehicle
• EELV (Delta IV, Atlas V)
Improvements/Upgrades from prior satellites
include:
• Design life of 12 years
• Twice the payload power of IIR satellites (2.440 kW)
• Signals: L1 C/A, L1 P(Y), L1 M, L2 C/A, L2 P(Y), L2 M,
L3, L5
Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 11
Summary GPS – The Future
 IIRM(last) to add L5
 IIF to be Launched – end of 2008
 GPS III in Source Selection (RFP last July)
• Backwards Compatible
• All IIF (IIRM+) signals
• L1C – International Civil Signal
• Higher Power with Flex
• Improved Position and Timing Accuracy

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 12


Summary - Spectrum of Modernized GPS Signals
C/A Earlier GPS
P(Y) Dual Frequency w/
Semi-codeless P(Y)

New! Block IIR-M


L2C Launch 2005
L5
M Dual Frequency
L1 C/A & L2C (+L5)

Block IIF
L5 Launch 2008
Three Frequency
L1 C/A, L2C, & L5

Block III
L1C
Launch 2013
L1C, L2C, L5,
& L1 C/A Code
L5 L2 L1
ARNS/RNSS Band RNSS Band ARNS/RNSS Band

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 13


GPS Satellite Status 9 July 07
Pla Slo PR Type Launch Active life Pla Type Launch Active life
NORAD Input date Slot PRN NORAD Input date
ne t N SC date (months) ne SC date (months)

1 9 22700 II-A 26.06.93 20.07.93 166.9 1 2 28474 II-R 06.11.04 22.11.04 31.5

2 31 29486 IIR-M 25.09.06 13.10.06 8.8 2 11 25933 II-R 07.10.99 03.01.00 90.2

A 3 8 25030 II-A 06.11.97 18.12.97 114.7 D 3 21 27704 II-R 31.03.03 12.04.03 50.8

Legitimate Concern for Future:


4 27 22108 II-A 09.09.92 30.09.92 176.8 4 4 22877 II-A 26.10.93 22.11.93 163.5

5 25 21890 II-A 23.02.92 24.03.92 180.8 6 24 21552 II-A 04.07.91 30.08.91 190.2

1 16 27663 II-R 29.01.03 18.02.03 52.5 1 20 26360 II-R 11.05.00 01.06.00 85.2

B
Satellites 30 → 24 ??
2

3
30

28
24320

26407
II-A

II-R
12.09.96

16.07.00
01.10.96

17.08.00
128.4

82.8
E
2

3
22

10
28129

23953
II-R

II-A
21.12.03

16.07.96
12.01.04

15.08.96
41.9

130.8

4 5 22779 II-A 30.08.93 28.09.93 164.7 4 18 26690 II-R 30.01.01 15.02.01 76.6

5 12 29601 IIR-M 17.11.06 13.12.06 6.8 1 14 26605 II-R 10.11.00 10.12.00 78.9

1 6 23027 II-A 10.03.94 28.03.94 158.7 2 26 22014 II-A 07.07.92 23.07.92 179.4

2 3 23833 II-A 28.03.96 09.04.96 133.6 3 13 24876 II-R 23.07.97 31.01.98 113.2
F
C 3 19 28190 II-R 20.03.04 05.04.04 39.0 4 23 28362 II-R 23.06.04 09.07.04 35.9

4 17 28874 IIR-M 26.09.05 13.11.05 18.6 5 29 22275 II-A 18.12.92 05.01.93 173.1

5 7 22657 II-A 13.05.93 12.06.93 168.5 6 1 22231 II-A 22.11.92 11.12.92 174.7

Total 30 Satellites Average Age 8.9 yrs.


Standard Deviation 5.0 yrs. Oldest: operational 15.9 yrs – (Launched 4 July 1991)

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 14


GLONASS : Global Orbiting Navigation
Satellite System (Russia)
Nominally Comparable
to GPS.
Orbit
• 64.8 deg inclination Glonass - M
• 3 orbit planes
• 19,100 km circular (8 day repeat track)
Design Life -1 to 2 years
24 Active Satellites when Operational

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 15


GLONASS : Global Orbiting Navigation
Satellite System (Russia)
Accuracy: 50-70 meters C/A signals
(10-20 meter accuracy military signals)

Spacecraft
• 3-Axis stabilized, nadir pointing. Dual solar arrays.
Navigation signals (25 0.5625 MHz channels)
• 2 bands: 1602.5625 - 1615.5 MHz & 1240 - 1260
MHz.
• EIRP 25 to 27 dBW. -Right hand circular polarized.
 Cesium clocks provide time accuracy to 1000
nanoseconds.
Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 16
GLONASS status on 9 July 2007
(10 Operational Satellites – none older than 5 years)

Frequency GLONAS Cosmos Launch Outage Active life


Plane Slot Input date Notes
Channel S Number Number date date (months)
1 07 796 2411 26.12.04 06.02.05 26.5

2 01 794 2402 10.12.03 02.02.04 19.04.07 38.3 switched off

3 12 789 2381 01.12.01 04.01.02 59.5

4 06 795 2403 10.12.03 29.01.04 41.1


I
5 07 711 2382 01.12.01 13.02.03 09.07.06 36.1 switched off

6 01 701 2404 10.12.03 08.12.04 25.7

7 05 712 2413 26.12.04 07.10.05 18.2

8 06 797 2412 26.12.04 06.02.05 27.8

10 04 717 2426 25.12.06 03.04.07 2.7

II 14 04 715 2424 25.12.06 03.04.07 3.2

15 00 716 2425 25.12.06 Comssing

18 10 783 2374 13.10.00 05.01.01 25.05.07 66.5 switched off

19 03 798 2417 25.12.05 22.01.06 09.07.07 17.4 switched off

21 08 792 2395 25.12.02 31.01.03 49.8


III
22 10 791 2394 25.12.02 21.01.03 07.02.07 46.5 switched off
23 03 714 2419 25.12.05 31.08.06 8.9

24 02 713 2418 25.12.05 31.08.06 09.07.07 8.8 switched off

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 17


GLONASS Snapshot of Visibility

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 18


GLONASS the Future
 Renewed Funding and Support by Russia
 Apparently in negotiations with India
 FDMA signal not as useful as CDMA
• Notwithstanding, Combined GPS-GLONASS
receivers are important for impaired situations
• Apparently considering CDMA

 Central Issue remains Satellite Lifetime and


constellation sustainability/affordability

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 19


EU Galileo Satellite Constellation

 Constellation of 30 satellites in MEO


• 27 active satellites - 3 spares
• 23616 km height above earth
• 1+2/3 revolutions/day
• 56° inclination
 Cost Saving setup of
Galileo constellation
• Only 3 orbital planes compared to 6 with GPS
• 3 Soyuz (2 satellites per launch) +
3 Ariane5 (8 satellites per launch)
• Soyuz launches will be used during
the In-Orbit Validation (IOV) Phase

EADS-Astrium 2 0 0 20
3
Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007
Galileo – Technical Aspects

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 21


Galileo
Galileo Services

 Open Service (3 frequencies, free of charge)

 Commercial Service (3-4 freq., not free, +integrity)

 Safety of Life Service (airborne, railways etc.)

 Public Regulated Service (security related, military)

 Search and Rescue (compatible to COSPAS-SARSAT)

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 22


Frequency Plan

OS + OS / SOL / CS CS / PRS

E5A / L5 E5B E3 L2 G2 E4 E6
GPS/ GALILEO GALILEO GPS GLONASS GALILEO
1164 1188 1215 1216 1240 1256 1260 1300 MHz

Lower L-Band

OS / SOL / PRS Mission


Uplink
E2 L1 E1 G1 C1
GPS/ GALILEO GLONASS GALILEO
1559 1563 1587 1591 1610 MHz 5000 5010 5030 MHz

Upper L-Band C-Band

EADS-Astrium 2 0 0 23
3
Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007
First Galileo satellites

 Contracts awarded in July 2003

 GIOVE -A satellite

operational 12 Jan 2006 (by Surrey Satellite Technology Ltd (UK)

 GIOVE A2 on contract as frequency insurance

 EADS-Astrium (Munich) is building GIOVE – B (Launch

delayed to 2008?)

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 24


Looking Ahead - Galileo
 Galileo - operational 2013 – 2014 (?)
 Commercial Model evidently not Viable
• Difficult to compete with free resource
 World wide users will benefit from new
signals -Improved accuracy, higher reliability, better availability
Breakthrough: Instantaneous RTK
through combination of GPS & Galileo
Agreement on Interoperability with GPS
• But does this mean “Interchangeability?

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 25


Quazi –Zenith Satellite System (QZSS)
 Japanese Regional, Multi-use system
 Supplement to GPS System
 Includes WAAS like function
 Adds communications and reporting
1st satellite 2010 (following several years later)

 Orbits similar to USAF 621B of 1967


• Regional coverage - “elliptical-synchronous”

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 26


QZSS Orbit Constellation

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 27


QZSS Ground Track and Coverage

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 28


Original Planned Services of QZSS

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 29


QZSS Technical Capabilities

?
?
Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 30
Original QZSS Applications

Services of QZSS

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 31


Compass (Beidou) by China
The Satellites

Satellite Launch Location Constell. Loc. Ops? Comment

31 Oct GEO
BeiDou-1A Xichang CZ-3A Yes
00 140°E

21 Dec GEO
BeiDou-1B Xichang CZ-3A Yes
00 80°E

GEO
25 May
BeiDou-1C Xichang CZ-3A 110.5° Yes
03
E

GEO Recovered from a


BeiDou-1D 3 Feb 07 Xichang CZ-3A 58.75° ? solar panel
E failure

14 Aug
BeiDou-1E Xichang CZ-3A MEO ?
07

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 32


Compass (Beidou)
 Accuracy:
• positioning 10 meters, velocity - 0.2 meter per second timing
accuracy - 50 nanoseconds.
 System : To include at least 35 satellites
• five geostationary Earth orbit (GEO)
• 30 medium Earth orbit (MEO) satellites

4/14/2007 9:15:57 AM
China have successfully launched their second Compass
navigation satellite, which lifted off 4:11 am local time on
Saturday from the Xichang Satellite Launch Center. The
Long March 3-A launch vehicle placed the Beidou-2B
satellite in a 21,500 km orbit.

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 33


Compass Operational Concept
(A 2-way “active” system)

• Satellites transmit at 2491.75+/-4.08MHz


• Ground receiver transmits back at 1615.68MHz.
• The BeiDou reference - Beijing 1954 Coord. Sys.
• Time reference Chinese UTC
Consequences:
• Large, power-hungry equip.
• Location revealed
• Could institute user charges
• Limits on number of users

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 34


GPS has Fathered a
Number of Augmentations…
 Ground Based
• NDGPS (US) (Marine Beacons) + EDGPS (EU)
• LAAS (Future)
• (eLORAN) decision soon??
 Space Based
• WAAS (Operational)
• EGNOS
• MSAS We will only touch on a few
• GAGAN
• Commercial

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 35


European DGPS Beacons
 Corrections Broadcast
over marine beacons
 Similar to NDGPS (US)
 Accuracies typically 1-2
Meters
 Main Target is Marine
Users
 In US, congress
authorized at least 2
beacons for each state

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 36


Wide Area Augmentation
System (WAAS)

 Safer  Increased Capacity  Cost Effective

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 37


WAAS Prototype Results -May 1999
Vertical Accuracy - 3 Locations, 99.9% < 2.5m

Worst Accuracy of
100,000 Data points
Typical Errors was 7 Meters
less than 2 feet

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 38


Japanese MSAS Status (similar to WAAS)

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 39


MSAS Performance

Typically 1 to 2
meters 95%

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 40


Commercial Augmentations (OmniStar example)

 Well established Worldwide


service
 Partnered with GPS
equipment manufacturers
 Annual fee ~$1000
 Oil Exploration and
Agricultural Markets
 XP: "better than 20 cms" &
HP: "better than 10 cms",
95%CEP.
 Would compete with Galileo
Commercial services

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 41


eLORAN as Augmentation to GPS
Overall 95% accuracy 16.4 m
30

 Demonstrated capability East of 70 52.2W, 95% = 11.7 m


West of 70 52.2W, 95% = 18.3 m

for NPA
20

 Robust back-up signal


10

North Error - m
 Potentially “seamless”
0

backup for GPS users -10

 Relative cost is small -20

 Studied by IAT of IDA -30


-40 -30 -20 -10 0 10
East Error - m
20 30 40

 A potential deterrent to Example Marine Data: Boston Harbor


deliberate interference

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 42


Some Technologies of the Future

 More use of “Real-time” Kinematic

 New Signal Structures (e.g.L1C)

 Beam Steering Antennas

 Chip Scale Atomic Clocks

 Deeper “system-level” integration

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 43


Real-Time Kinematic: Today

10 km

2 cm accuracy
 L1 Code and Carrier
 L2 Carrier
 Data Link
Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 44
Galileo – How will
RTK improve ?

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 45


GPS Satellite Visibility for RTK

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 46


GPS+Galileo Satellite Visibility for RTK

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 47


RTK Accuracy-some improvement with Galileo

1 Cm

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 48


Instantaneous RTK Reliability

1000 times better


failure rate at 25 km

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 49


CSAC (Chip Scale Atomic Clock)

 In April 2005, Symmetricom demonstrated


a 10 cc, 200 mW
Miniature Atomic Clock (MAC) -
surpassed DARPA's stability objectives
 CSAC technology evolving to a smaller size
and lower power, next demonstrate a laboratory prototype of a 1 cc,
30 mW atomic clock.
 At 100 seconds of integration time, the MAC stability is 4 parts in 10^11,
equivalent to gaining or losing 1 second every 10,000 years
 GNSS Payoffs
• Quicker acquisition/re-acquisition
• Longer integration Times
~10 Seconds to drift ½
a GPS wavelength
• Can substitute for a satellite

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 50


Beamforming Antenna Technology
 All Digital
(improved affordablity)

 Adapt to Satellite location


(MEMS-IMU helps)

 Reduced interference and


Multipath
 Space-Frequency Adaptive
Processing can be included
 Rejection ratios of 20dB or
more possible
 Caution - small phase shifts:
• Carrier up to 100o
• Code up to 1 Meter Courtesy Inside GNSS and Prof Lachapelle

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 51


L1C will hopefully be MBOC(6,1,1/11)
Common signal provides
hope for
“interchangeability”
 Codeless channel for
long integration times
 BOC vs MBOC Courtesy Inside GNSS and Prof. Hein

• MBOC provides more power in higher frequencies


- Crisper definition of “edges’
- Better multipath rejection
This signal is symbolic of International Cooperation
Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 52
So what are the major new (or
expanded) applications going to be?
"Predicting the future is easy. It's trying to figure out
what's going on now that's hard.“ - Fritz R. S. Dressler

 Expanded Crustal Tracking


 Precicion Tracking and Reporting
 Robotic or Assisted Control
 Cell/GPS explosion – where will this go?

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 53


GPS is Vastly Increasing our Understanding of Crustal Motion and
Earthquakes

Slow “earthquakes” are


observed in Cascadia
and Japan along the
subduction zones.

In Canada, these events take about 15 days,


propagate northward, and occur every 16-18
months.

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 54


The Northridge Earthquake Affected the
Sierra Madre Fault 30 Km Away
JPL’s GPS station changed its motion as a result of
the earthquake Sierra Madre Fault

Residual Longitude (cm)


1
meter
• The earthquake probably triggered shallow slip on the Sierra Madre Fault.
• This was the first time that long range fault interactions were observed.
• Recent GPS Results Show Concentrated Deformation Near Downtown Los
Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 55
Angeles
Tracking Applications Have Proliferated

GPS
is
the key

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 56


Another Precision Tracking Example
(Optimizing Skiing Trajectories- courtesy “Inside GNSS” magazine

• GPS/IMU smoothed trajectory


• Also to be Applied to Autos
• Authors
•Adrian Wagli & Jan Skaloud

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 57


Robotic Use Of GPS
Autonomous Model Helicopter
Note four
antennas to GPS Position, Velocity and Attitude
provide 0.1o
Attitude

Tracking Test @ 5 m/s – worst error ~


3 inches!

Stanford Robot Tractor

Blind Landing Tests – 110 straight successes


with one go around

Typical Accuracy- “Sandstorm” Vehicle negotiating difficult


Four Inches Terrain

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 58


GPS in GSM Receivers 2011
(69% of the Market, by units)

Current ASP ~ $2
At $4 per unit-
100% of high end
GSM Market
At $2 per unit –
100% of the total
GSM market

? IMPLICATIONS ?

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 59


Some Other Interesting Applications

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 60


Towards Auto-guided Automobiles
Vector Kinematic
Recievers
MEMS/IMU
Radars
Cooperative Tracking
of other vehicles

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 61


And Perhaps the most Humanitarian:

Removing Unexploded Ordinance

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 62


A Caution:
Three Critical Issues
for GPtS

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 63


GPS Applications have Proliferated

 Military
 Civil
• Transportation
- Aviation
- Automobile
- Maritime
- Rail Control
• Public Services
• Timing &
Frequency
• Surveying
• Surveillance
• Other

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 64


We are Victims of our success:

GPS Enormous Capability

Worldwide Dependency
What must we do to insure that the
Trust in GPtS
is not misplaced?

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 65


THE “Big Five” Civil Goals for GPS

1. Assured Availability of GPS signals-Including impaired situations


(mountains, urban areas, foliage, etc.)
• Number of GPS Satellites/Geometry
• Interoperability and Standardization with Galileo et al
2. Resistance to Interference (RFI)
• Additional Satellite RF power and Frequency Diversity
• More jam resistant GPS receivers
3. Accuracy
• Require Prediction Accuracy (Satellite Clocks and Age of Update)
• Improved Satellite Geometry is essential
• Augmentations: WAAS, LAAS,EGNOS, MSAS, NDGPS, PLs
4. Bounded inaccuracy to limit wild points

Three of top four Goals
Concerned with the 1% or less “wild data points”
• areGeometry
Good Satellite driven by the number
Coverage of satellites –
is Imperative
5. Integrity - eliminating HMI, hence DSB
meeting & IRT
required time to alarm
• WAAS 30+X satellite recommendation
• RAIM

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 66


GPS Issue #1 – (Availability)
Constellation Sustainment

 Average on-orbit life 8.9 years


 First IIF currently available for launch:
May 2008
 First GPS III currently available for
Operations - April 2014
It is imperative the we avoid “GPS Brownouts”

Needed: Sustained, high-level support


for earlier GPS III delivery and availability

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 67


Illustrating why current number of Satellites
is Minimal (Courtesy GPS World and John Lavrakas)
 DOP is strongly driven by Masking Angle and
number of satellites (the impaired user’s problem)
 Above 10o, less than 30 satellites destroys
accuracy and availability

Th
Monthly Availability eK
ne
of 24 sats 92 to 100% e

DOP vs. Mask Angle (degrees)

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 68


GPS Issue #2 –
GPS Robustness (Deterrence)
Constellation size of 30+X for users in
impaired environments (the GDOP imperative)
Need: Full, urgent Commitment by US
Affordable GPS Receiver Interference
Rejection Technology (inertial integration and
digital beam steering technology)
Needs full development
GPS Backup – Loran?
Needs decisions
Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 69
GPS Issue #3 –GPS and Galileo-
True, Total Interoperability

Payoff – Availability, Accuracy and


Robustness
 Real Measure: Interchangeability “Mix and
Match” with same ranging accuracy
• L1C defined, implemented, and operable
• Seamless WAAS/EGNOS/+ ?
• True clock Synchronization and common grid

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 70


As providers of GtPS
we must insure the Service
is Always Available - To meet:
the Safety, Economic, and Convenience
Needs
of the World

Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 71


Conclusions: The Future
New GPtS signals means better fulfillment of
the “Big Five”
Resulting Applications will increasingly be
dependent on robustness, accuracy, and
availability
Caution: the next six years may have degraded
performance if new systems continue to slip

Limited only by Imagination!


Copyright B. Parkinson July 2007 72

You might also like