Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Cristiane Gurgel Lin, Laurel Anne Schaider, Daniel Joseph Brabander and Alan David
Woolf
Pediatrics published online Mar 15, 2010;
DOI: 10.1542/peds.2009-1396
The online version of this article, along with updated information and services, is
located on the World Wide Web at:
http://www.pediatrics.org
Downloaded from www.pediatrics.org. Provided by FDA Biosciences Library on March 15, 2010
Pediatric Lead Exposure From Imported Indian Spices
and Cultural Powders
WHAT’S KNOWN ON THIS SUBJECT: Lead is a neurotoxin, and AUTHORS: Cristiane Gurgel Lin, MD, PhD,a,b,c Laurel Anne
elevated BLLs in children are a public health concern. Immigrant Schaider, PhD,d Daniel Joseph Brabander, PhD,e and Alan
children are at risk because of additional exposure to imported David Woolf, MD, MPHb,f
culture-specific leaded products. Lead contamination in many aPediatric Residency Program, Department of Medicine, and
imported products has not been characterized.
fPediatric Environmental Health Center, Division of General
Pediatrics, Children’s Hospital Boston, Boston, Massachusetts;
bDepartment of Pediatrics, Harvard Medical School, Boston,
WHAT THIS STUDY ADDS: We report here lead-poisoning cases Massachusetts; cDepartment of Neonatology, Pediatrix Medical
from Indian cultural powders or spices. Imported products Group, Seton Medical Center, Austin, Texas; dDepartment of
surveyed contained lead, and chronic exposure could increase Environmental Health, Harvard School of Public Health, Boston,
the prevalence of elevated BLLs. These results increase leaded- Massachusetts; and eDepartment of Geosciences, Wellesley
product awareness and aid lead-poisoning prevention. College, Wellesley, Massachusetts
KEY WORDS
pediatric lead poisoning, childhood plumbism, spices, herbal
products, cosmetics, religious powders, lead contamination,
Indian, sindoor, culture-specific exposure
abstract ABBREVIATIONS
CDC—Centers for Disease Control and Prevention
BACKGROUND: Significant lead poisoning has been associated with BLL— blood lead level
FDA—Food and Drug Administration
imported nonpaint products. IEUBK—integrated exposure uptake biokinetic model for lead in
OBJECTIVES: To describe cases of pediatric lead intoxication from im- children
PEHC—Pediatric Environmental Health Center
ported Indian spices and cultural powders, determine lead concentra- XRF—x-ray fluorescence
tions in these products, and predict effects of ingestion on pediatric NIST—National Institute of Standards and Technology
blood lead levels (BLLs). LOD—limit of detection
SBET—simple bioaccessibility extraction test
PATIENTS AND METHODS: Cases and case-study information were ob- XRD—x-ray diffraction
tained from patients followed by the Pediatric Environmental Health ZPP—zinc-chelated protoporphyrin
Center (Children’s Hospital Boston). Imported spices (n ! 86) and CI— confidence interval
cultural powders (n ! 71) were analyzed for lead by using x-ray fluo- www.pediatrics.org/cgi/doi/10.1542/peds.2009-1396
rescence spectroscopy. The simple bioaccessibility extraction test was doi:10.1542/peds.2009-1396
used to estimate oral bioavailability. The integrated exposure uptake bio- Accepted for publication Nov 16, 2009
kinetic model for lead in children was used to predict population-wide Address correspondence to Cristiane Gurgel Lin, MD, PhD,
geometric mean BLLs and the probability of elevated BLLs ("10 !g/dL). Neonatology Department, Seton Medical Center, 1201 W 38th St,
Austin, TX 78705. E-mail: cristiane.lin@gmail.com
RESULTS: Four cases of pediatric lead poisoning from Indian spices or PEDIATRICS (ISSN Numbers: Print, 0031-4005; Online, 1098-4275).
cultural powders are described. Twenty-two of 86 spices and foodstuff
Copyright © 2010 by the American Academy of Pediatrics
products contained "1 !g/g lead (for these 22 samples, mean: 2.6 !g/g
FINANCIAL DISCLOSURE: The authors have indicated they have
[95% confidence interval: 1.9 –3.3]; maximum: 7.6 !g/g). Forty-six of 71 no financial relationships relevant to this article to disclose.
cultural products contained "1 !g/g lead (for 43 of these samples, mean:
8.0 !g/g [95% confidence interval: 5.2–10.8]; maximum: 41.4 !g/g). Three
sindoor products contained "47% lead. With a fixed ingestion of 5 !g/day
and 50% bioavailability, predicted geometric mean BLLs for children aged
0 to 4 years increased from 3.2 to 4.1 !g/dL, and predicted prevalence of
children with a BLL of "10 !g/dL increased more than threefold (0.8%–2.8%).
CONCLUSIONS: Chronic exposure to spices and cultural powders may
cause elevated BLLs. A majority of cultural products contained "1
!g/g lead, and some sindoor contained extremely high bioaccessible
lead levels. Clinicians should routinely screen for exposure to these
products. Pediatrics 2010;125:e828–e835
e828 LIN et al
Downloaded from www.pediatrics.org. Provided by FDA Biosciences Library on March 15, 2010
ARTICLES
Lead is a neurotoxin that can cause assess lead contamination among var- (2) religious powders (used in reli-
permanent neurocognitive deficits in ious commercially available imported gious or cultural practices, not in-
children.1–3 The current Centers for Indian spices and ceremonial prod- tended for consumption, not labeled
Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) ucts sold in stores in the Boston, Mas- for use as medication). When more
blood lead level (BLL) of concern is 10 sachusetts, area, and (3) predict the than 1 store carried the same brand of
!g/dL, although a BLL of #5 !g/dL prevalence of elevated BLLs in children a given product, it was only purchased
also may result in cognitive deficits.4–8 caused by chronic exposure to these once. The name, manufacturer, manu-
A national objective of Healthy People products by using the integrated expo- facturer’s location, packaging loca-
2010 is to eliminate elevated BLLs in sure uptake biokinetic model for lead tion, lot number, expiration date, store
children. As part of this effort, the CDC in children (IEUBK).23 name, and purchase date were re-
has worked to identify at-risk popula- corded when available. For compari-
tions and nonpaint sources of lead ex- PATIENTS AND METHODS son, 10 types of spices produced by US
posure.3,9 Among those at risk are im- Case-Study Information manufacturers were purchased at a
migrant children, who are more likely large New England supermarket, al-
Case-study information was acquired though in most cases, the country of
than US-born children to have an ele-
through the review of medical charts origin was not listed.
vated BLL through exposure to non-
of patients who were referred to the
paint lead sources.10,11 Culture-specific To assess variability between lots of
Pediatric Environmental Health Center
nonpaint lead sources have been iden- the same product, all products that
(PEHC) at Children’s Hospital Boston
tified, including imported utensils,12 contained "10 !g/g lead were repur-
from 2006 to 2008 for an elevated BLL.
foods such as Mexican tamarind chased for additional analysis. In addi-
The cases represent $2% of new pa-
candy,13 cosmetics such as kohl14 and tion, 10% of the spices and powders
tient referrals to the PEHC. All patients
henna,15 and ayurvedic traditional were randomly selected for repur-
were asymptomatic. Home environ-
medicines16,17 and Mexican digestive chase and reanalysis.
ments were assessed for lead by the
remedies.18
Massachusetts Department of Public
Culture-specific lead sources have Heavy-Metal Analysis
Health via dust wipe and direct sam-
placed South Asian and Indian commu- pling of surfaces and by the PEHC via Samples were labeled with a numeri-
nities at risk. Woolf and Woolf19 re- environmental inventory and soil- cal identifier only. Four grams of each
ported 2 cases of pediatric lead poi- testing. In all cases, no other signifi- sample were transferred into x-ray flu-
soning from imported Indian spices. In cant sources of lead were found. orescence (XRF) analytical cups (Pre-
addition, a Thai infant suffered lead mier Lab Supply, Port St Lucie, FL) with
poisoning from a powder applied to his Collection Methods: Market-Basket 4-!m windows (Spex Certiprep,
tongue,20 and an Indian child devel- Survey Metuchen, NJ) after thorough homog-
oped an elevated BLL from ingestion of In this article, we use the terms “cul- enization. Repurchased products re-
sindoor (a powder applied to a wom- tural powder,” “religious powder,” and ceived new numerical identifiers, and
an’s scalp as a marriage sign).21 Re- “ceremonial powder” interchangeably. 2 aliquots of each repurchased prod-
cently, the US Food and Drug Adminis- Collection and analysis of spices and uct were analyzed.
tration (FDA) recalled a brand of powders were based on the protocol The concentration of lead in each sam-
ceremonial Indian powders because of outlined by Saper et al.16 Boston-area ple was determined by using a Spectro
lead contamination and confirmed stores that sell spices and religious XEPOS polarized energy-dispersive XRF
cases of lead poisoning.22 powders were identified through an instrument (Spectro Analytical, Kleve,
To date, few studies have systemati- online national directory of Indian gro- Germany). Measurement accuracy
cally investigated the lead content of cery stores24 and a New England area was determined by using a standard
imported Indian spices and ceremo- Indian community business directo- reference material (National Institute
nial powders and considered related ry.25 In early 2008, 15 randomly se- of Standards and Technology [NIST]
risks posed to children living in the lected stores were visited within 20 2709, San Joaquin [California] soil).26
United States. The goals of our investi- miles of Children’s Hospital Boston. The measured mean lead concentra-
gation were to (1) describe recent Spices and ceremonial powders were tion for NIST 2709 (18.5 % 0.9 !g/g; n !
cases of pediatric lead poisoning purchased if they were manufactured 48) was consistent with the certified
caused by contaminated Indian spices in India and were (1) spices/foodstuffs value (18.9 % 0.5 !g/g). The limit of
and religious powders, (2) survey and (edible, used in food preparation) or detection (LOD) is $1.0 !g/g.
e830 LIN et al
Downloaded from www.pediatrics.org. Provided by FDA Biosciences Library on March 15, 2010
ARTICLES
TABLE 1 Examples of Cosmetics, Hair Products, and Ceremonial Powders Purchased tistical analysis (Table 3). These sin-
Product Name Brand Name Uses door lead concentrations are compa-
Cosmetics and hair products rable to those in published reports.21,38
Aritha powder Hesh Shampoo Cosmetics and ceremonial powders
Henna Al-aroosa, Ancient Secret, Ayur, Dulhan Hand decoration
Kajal Shingar Ltd, Western Indian Chemical Co Eyeliner had similar lead concentration and
Hairwash Meera Shampoo ranges (Table 3).
Sandalwood Nirav Cosmetic, medicinal
Ceremonial powders
Abil Bhavani, Nirav Pooja ceremony
Indian Spices and Foodstuff
Gulal MDHD, Swad, Durbar Pooja ceremony Eighty-six food products manufac-
Kumkum Shringar, Topaz, Butala Emporium Bindi
Sindoor MDHD, Swad, Nirav, Butala Emporium Marriage symbol
tured by 53 companies were pur-
chased (Table 2). Sixty-three prod-
ucts listed packaging location, and 38
The family discontinued use of this seed (0.6 !g/g), asafoetida (0.8 !g/g), products listed lot numbers. Thirty-
powder, and over the next 8 months, and turmeric (1.4 !g/g). The family eight products were categorized as
the patient’s BLL decreased to 8 !g/dL. discontinued use of all imported common spices, used daily in food
spices, and the patient’s BLL declined preparation, whereas 48 were catego-
Case 4 to 14 !g/dL within 6 months. rized as foodstuff, including spice
A 12-month-old Indian boy was re- mixes, food coloring, or other food ad-
ferred for an elevated BLL (28 !g/dL), a Religious Powders ditives, which may be used less fre-
ZPP level of 103 !mol/mol, and a hemo- Seventy-one religious products manu- quently. Of the 86 products tested by
globin level of 9 g/dL. Analyses of factured by 28 companies were pur- XRF, 22 (26%) contained "1 !g/g lead,
spices, herbal remedies, and religious chased (Table 1). Forty-three products with a mean lead concentration in
powders revealed that several Indian listed packaging location, and 5 prod- these 22 samples of 2.6 !g/g (95% CI:
spices, used daily, contained lead: an ucts provided lot numbers. Sixteen 1.9 –3.3) and a maximum of 7.6 !g/g
herb mix (11 !g/g), brown mustard products were categorized as cosmet- (sea salt). Food products had a lower
ics and hair products for daily use, and percentage of samples with detected
55 were categorized as ceremonial re- lead and lower mean lead concentra-
TABLE 2 Examples of Spices and Foodstuff
Purchased ligious powders for daily to monthly tion compared with religious prod-
Product Name Brand Name use. ucts. Spices and foodstuff contained
Spices Of the 71 cultural products tested, 46 similar ranges of lead concentration
Black pepper Laxmi, Swad, Deep (65%) contained "1 !g/g lead. The (Table 3).
Cardamom DEEP
Chili powder Saras, Noer, Swan
mean lead concentration in 43 sam- On the basis of a direct comparison of
Coriander MDHD, Periyar, Swad, Swan ples with detectable lead (excluding 3 10 types of spices (US brands and im-
Fennel powder Deep high-lead sindoor products) was 8.0 ported) analyzed by inductively cou-
Fenugreek Swad
!g/g (95% confidence interval [CI]: pled plasma mass spectrometry, im-
Garam masala MDHD, Swan
Garlic power Shalimar 5.2–10.8 !g/g), with a maximum of ported spices had a mean lead
Ginger powder Himgiri, Swad 41.4 !g/g (kajal). Three sindoor prod- concentration of 0.5 !g/g (95% CI:
Paprika Swad ucts contained "47% lead by weight 0.18 – 0.72), which was twice the mean
Sindav salt Deep, Swad
Turmeric Laxmi, Nirav, Swad, Swan and were treated separately in the sta- lead concentration of US-brand spices
Foodstuff
Food coloring Bush, Bhavani, Narmada,
Vesco TABLE 3 Mean Concentration, CI, and Range of Lead in Spices, Foodstuff, Cosmetics, Ceremonial
Dabelli masala Bombay Magic Powders, and High-Lead Sindoor With a Detectable Lead Level by XRF
Fish curry MDH Product No. of Samples With Lead Level, Mean Range, !g/ga
Vada mix MTD Samples Detectable Lead, % (95% CI), !g/ga
Chappli kabab Roopak Spices 38 24 2.6 (1.2–4.0) 1–7.6
masala Foodstuff 48 27 2.6 (1.8–3.4) 1–6.3
Vermacelli mix MTR Cosmetics 16 81 7.6 (1.3–13.9) 1–41.4
Tulsi powder Bhavani Ceremonial powders 52 58 8.2 (6.0–10.4) 1–39.9
Karela powder Swad High-lead sindoor 3 100 559 000 (463 000–655 000) 469 000–638 000
Asafoetida Laljee Godhoo, Ruchi, Swad a Serial dilutions of NIST 2709 suggest that the LOD (based on the criteria that samples run in triplicate maintain #10%
Amchur powder Deep
relative SD) is 1.0 !g/g (data not shown). LOD estimates based on serial dilution of NIST 2709 were supported by 15 replicate
Hajmola candy Dabur India Ltd analyses of NIST 1515 (apple leaves) in which a 20% SD was observed for an expected lead concentration of 0.47 !g/g.
e832 LIN et al
Downloaded from www.pediatrics.org. Provided by FDA Biosciences Library on March 15, 2010
ARTICLES
e834 LIN et al
Downloaded from www.pediatrics.org. Provided by FDA Biosciences Library on March 15, 2010
ARTICLES
116(2). Available at: www.pediatrics.org/ vironmental Protection Agency; 2002. EPA 43. Fraser DA, Fairhall LT. Laboratory study of
cgi/content/full/116/2/e314 9285.7– 42 the solubility of red lead paint in water. Pub-
20. Woolf AD, Hussain J, McCullough L, Petranovic M, 32. Zaragoza L, Hogan K. The integrated expo- lic Health Rep. 1959;74(6):501–510
Chomchai C. Infantile lead poisoning from sure uptake biokinetic model for lead in 44. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
an Asian tongue powder: a case report & children: independent validation and verifi- Blood lead levels: United States, 1999 –2002.
subsequent public health inquiry. Clin Toxi- cation. Environ Health Perspect. 1998; MMWR Morb Mortal Wkly Rep. 2005;54(20):
col (Phila). 2008;46(9):841– 844 106(suppl 6):1551–1556 513–516
21. Vassilev ZP, Marcus SM, Ayyanathan K, et al. 33. Lynch RA, Boatright DT, Moss SK. Lead- 45. National Nutrition Monitoring Bureau, Indian
Case of elevated blood lead in a South Asian contaminated imported tamarind candy Council of Medical Research. Report of second
family that has used Sindoor for food color- and children’s blood lead levels. Public repeat survey: rural (1996 –97). Available at:
ing. Clin Toxicol (Phila). 2005;43(4):301–303 Health Rep. 2000;115(6):537–543 www.nnmbindia.org/NNMB-PDF%20FILES/
22. US Food and Drug Administration. Recall: 34. Boston Public Health Commission. Health of Bos- Report!OF!2nd%20Repeat!Survey-96-97.pdf.
firm press release, January 16, 2008. Avail- ton, 2009: environmental health. Available at: Accessed May 22, 2009
www.bphc.org/about/research/hob/Forms% 46. National Nutrition Monitoring Bureau, Indian
able at: www.fda.gov/Safety/Recalls/
20%20Documents/7.%20EnvironmentalHealth% Council of Medical Research. Diet and nutri-
ArchiveRecalls/2008/ucm112341.htm. Ac-
20Print!22Apr09!with%20pics.pdf. Accessed tional status of tribal population: report on
cessed August 21, 2008
May 22, 2009 first repeat survey (1998 –1999). Available at:
23. US Environmental Protection Agency. Guid-
35. Massachusetts Water Resource Association. www.nnmbindia.org/NNMB-PDF%20FILES/
ance Manual for the Integrated Exposure
Tap water delivers: 2007 annual drinking wa- Report-%20for%20the%20year%201998-
Biokinetic Model for Lead in Children. Wash-
ter report. Available at: www.mwra.com/ 99.pdf. Accessed May 22, 2009
ington, DC: US Environmental Protection annual/waterreport/2007results/metro.pdf.
Agency; 1994. EPA/540/R-93/081; NTIS PB93- 47. Binder S, Sokal D, Maughan D. Estimating
Accessed May 22, 2009
963510 soil ingestion: the use of tracer elements in
36. US Food and Drug Administration. Total Diet estimating the amount of soil ingested by
24. Immihelp.com. Indian grocery stores in Study. US Department of Health and Human Ser- young children. Arch Environ Health. 1986;
USA: yellow pages. Available at: www. vices, 2007. Available at: www.fda.gov/Food/ 41(6):341–345
immihelp.com/yellowpages/indian-grocery- FoodSafety/FoodContaminantsAdulteration/
stores-usa.html. Accessed January 28, 2008 48. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
TotalDietStudy/default.htm. Accessed August 21,
Lead poisoning-associated death from Asian
25. New England Desi Community. Aap Ka 2008
Indian folk remedies: Florida. MMWR Morb
Manoranjan, 2008. Available at: www. 37. US Environmental Protection Agency. Short Mortal Wkly Rep. 1984;33(45):638, 643– 645
bombaycinema.com/beta/grocers.php. Ac- Sheet: IEUBK Model Bioavailability Variable.
cessed January 28, 2008 Washington, DC: US Environmental Protec- 49. Encyclopedia Britannica. Hinduism. Available
tion Agency; 1999. EPA 540-F-00-006, OSWER at: www.britannica.com/EBchecked/topic/
26. Clark HF, Hausladen DM, Brabander DJ. Ur-
9285.7-32 266312/Hinduism. Accessed April 21, 2009
ban gardens: lead exposure, recontamina-
tion mechanisms, and implications for re- 38. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. 50. New York State Department of Health. Lead
mediation design. Environ Res. 2008;107(3): Sindoor alert. Available at: www.cdc.gov/ exposure risk assessment questionnaire for
312–319 nceh/lead/tips/sindoor.htm. Accessed Au- children. Available at: www.health.state.ny.us/
gust 21, 2008 environmental/lead/exposure/childhood/
27. Office of Solid Waste and Emergency Re-
risk!assessment.htm. Accessed September
sponse. Estimation of Relative Bioavailabil- 39. US Food and Drug Administration. Lead in candy
19, 2009
ity of Lead in Soil and Soil-Like Materials likely to be consumed frequently by small
children: recommended maximum level and 51. New Mexico Department of Health, Lead Poi-
Using in Vivo and in Vitro Methods. Washing-
enforcement policy. Available at: www.fda. soning Prevention Program. Should your
ton, DC: US Environmental Protection
gov/Food/GuidanceComplianceRegulatory young child be tested for lead poisoning?
Agency; 2007
Information/GuidanceDocuments/Chemical Available at: www.health.state.nm.us/eheb/
28. Ruby MV. Bioavailability of soil-borne chemicals: rep/lead/2%20column%20lead%20risk%
ContaminantsandPesticides/ucm077904.htm.
abiotic assessment tools. Hum Ecol Risk As- 20questionnaire%20for%20web%206-6-
Accessed August 21, 2008
sess. 2004;10(4):647– 656 07.pdf. Accessed September 19, 2009
40. Sattar A, Wahid M, Durrani SK. Concentra-
29. Schaider LA, Senn DB, Brabander DJ, Mc- tion of selected heavy metals in spices, dry 52. Wengrovitz AM, Brown MJ; Advisory Com-
Carthy KD, Shine JP. Characterization of fruits and plant nuts. Plant Foods Hum Nutr. mittee on Childhood Lead Poisoning, Divi-
zinc, lead, and cadmium in mine waste: 1989;39(3):279 –286 sion of Environmental and Emergency
implications for transport, exposure, and Health Services, National Center for Envi-
41. Commission of the European Communities.
bioavailability. Environ Sci Technol. 2007; ronmental Health; Centers for Disease Con-
Commission regulation of amending Regula-
41(11):4164 – 4171 trol and Prevention. Recommendations for
tion (EC) No. 1881/2006 as regards heavy met-
30. Clark HF, Brabander DJ, Erdil RM. Sources, als. Available at: www.bmu.de/files/pdfs/ blood lead screening of Medicaid-eligible
sinks, and exposure pathways of lead in ur- allgemein/application/pdf/sanco!1524! children aged 1–5 years: an updated ap-
ban garden soil. J Environ Qual. 2006;35(6): 2007!rev2.pdf. Accessed on February 23, 2009 proach ot targeting a group at high risk.
2066 –2074 42. Kaufman CA, Bennett JR, Koch I, Reimer KJ. MMWR Recomm Rep. 2009;58(RR-9):1–11
31. US Environmental Protection Agency. User’s Lead bioaccessibility in food web intermedi- 53. American Academy of Pediatrics, Commit-
Guide for the Integrated Exposure Bioki- ates and the influence on ecological risk tee on Environmental Health. Screening for
netic Model for Lead in Children (IEUBK), characterization. Environ Sci Technol. 2007; elevated blood lead levels. Pediatrics. 1998;
Windows(R) Version. Washington, DC: US En- 41(16):5902–5907 101(6):1072–1078
Downloaded from www.pediatrics.org. Provided by FDA Biosciences Library on March 15, 2010