You are on page 1of 10

Leisure and Life-Style

Author(s): Robert J. Havighurst and Kenneth Feigenbaum


Source: The American Journal of Sociology, Vol. 64, No. 4 (Jan., 1959), pp. 396-404
Published by: The University of Chicago Press
Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/2773953 .
Accessed: 14/02/2011 07:39

Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use, available at .
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp. JSTOR's Terms and Conditions of Use provides, in part, that unless
you have obtained prior permission, you may not download an entire issue of a journal or multiple copies of articles, and you
may use content in the JSTOR archive only for your personal, non-commercial use.

Please contact the publisher regarding any further use of this work. Publisher contact information may be obtained at .
http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=ucpress. .

Each copy of any part of a JSTOR transmission must contain the same copyright notice that appears on the screen or printed
page of such transmission.

JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.

The University of Chicago Press is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to The
American Journal of Sociology.

http://www.jstor.org
LEISURE AND LIFE-STYLE
ROBERT J. HAVIGHURST and KENNETH FEIGENBAUM

ABSTRACT
The Kansas City Study of Adult Life, studying the social role performance of people aged forty to
seventy, gave ratings of performance on various social roles. When leisure activity was related to the pat-
tern of social role performance (called "life-style"), four general life-styles were found: community-cen-
tered, home-centered high, home-centered medium, and low level, the adjectives for altitude referring to
level of social role performance. The most successful life-styles, judged by the level of role performance,
involved patterns of leisure which were active and similar rather than contrasting with the other social
roles. Middle-class people may be community-centered or home-centered in life-style and in leisure, but
working-class people are either home-centered or generally low in social role and leisure performance.

Leisure has generally but vaguely been about his favorite leisure activities, what
seen as a source of satisfaction and even of they meant to him, why he liked them, whom
delight. In a society in which most people he did them with, as well as a number of
had to work, and to work hard and long, questions about vacations, reading, televi-
leisure was scarce and was regarded either sion, radio, and movies, and what he did
as a reward to be earned by work and to around the house.
be enjoyed because one had worked so hard On the basis of this interview, ratings
for it or as a good thing conferred by in- were made of the competenceof the individ-
herited wealth or by marriageto wealth. ual in his social roles. Rating scales were
With the coming of more leisure in the devised to represent the general American
lives of the common people, not all the rosy expectations or definitions of these roles.'
promises have been realized. Some people The rating scale for user of leisure time
have found themselves with more leisure follows:
than they really wanted. The values of in- a) High (8-9).-Spends enoughtimeat some
creased leisure to welfare and the quality leisureactivity to be ratherwell knownamong
of living of society as a whole have been his associatesin this respect. But it is not so
seriously questioned. It is clear that modern muchthe amountof leisureactivityas its qual-
leisure is not an unmixed blessing. This sug- ity whichgives him a high rating.He has one
gests the desirability of studying the uses or morepursuitsfor whichhe gets publicrecog-
that people make of their leisure, what sat- nition and appreciationand which give him a
isfactions they get out of it, and how it fits realsenseof accomplishment.
Chooseshis leisure activities autonomously,
into the rest of their lives. not merelyto be in style. Gets fromleisurethe
Using the concept of "life-style" to de- feelingof being creative,of novel and interest-
scribe a person'scharacteristicway of filling ing experience,sheerpleasure,prestige,friend-
and combining the various social roles he is ship,andof beingof service.
called on to play, we may see how leisure fits b) Above average (6-7).-Has four to five
into it. To do so, the Kansas City Study leisureactivities.Leisuretime is somewhatpat-
of Adult Life interviewed a sample of men terned,indicatingthat he has plannedhis life
and women aged f-;om forty to seventy to to providefor the satisfactionof the needsmet
get an account of the way the person spent throughthese activities.
his time and the significance to him of his Leisureinterestsshowsomevariety.Displays
real enthusiasmfor one or two-talks about
major social roles-those of parent, spouse,
homemaker,worker, citizen, friend, club or 1 For the other role-performance scales and for

associationmember,and user of leisure time. the pattern analysis mentioned later see Robert J.
Havighurst, "The Social Competence of Middle-
About a quarter of the interview was de- aged People," Genetic Psychology Monographs,
voted to leisure. The individual was asked LVI (1957), 297-395.
396
LEISURE AND LIFE-STYLE 397
them in such a way as to indicate that he has ment of talent; instrumentation or expres-
put considerable energy into acquiring profi- siveness; relation of leisure to work; gre-
ciency or the requisite understanding and skills gariousnessor solitude; service or pleasure;
and prides himself on it. status and prestige; relaxation; ego integra-
c) Medium (4-5).-Has two or three leisure
tion or role diffusion; new experience or
activities which he does habitually and enjoys
mildly-reading, television, radio, watching repetition; vitality or apathy; and expan-
sports, handwork, etc. May do one of these sion or constriction of interests.
things well or quite enthusiastically, but not The results of the several methods of
more than one. Gets definite sense of well-being studying leisure were related to one another
and is seldom bored with leisure. and to a set of social and personal variables,
TABLE 1
LEISURE, PERSONALITY, AND SOCIAL VARIABLES*
Personal Manifest Social
Social Adjust- Complex- Mo- Con- Signifi- Mean-
Sex Age Class ment ity bility tent cance ing
Content........+++ +++ +++ + ++ + ...... +++ +++
Objective signifi-
cance......... + + ++ +++ +++ ++ +++ . ++
Subjectivemean-
ing ........... + - + + + + + +++ +++ + ......
* + = a smaUdegree of relationship (not more than two or three of the content or significanceor meaning variables are
reliably related to a social or personalvariable)
+ + = a fair degree of relationship
+++ = a high degreeof relationship(morethan half of the leisurevariablesare reliablyrelatedto a social or personalvariable)

Leisure activities are somewhat stereotyped; including age, sex, social class, personal ad-
they do not have a great deal of variety. justment, and manifest complexity of life.
d) Below average (2-3).- The interrelationsare summarizedin Table
(1) Tends to take the line of least resistance 1.
in leisure time. Needs to be stimulated. Looks
for time-fillers. The procedure in studying life-style was
May have one fairly strong interest but is
based upon the use of the scores for per-
content with this one which brings him some
sense of enjoyment. Leisure time is usually formancein the eight social roles previously
spent in passive spectatorship. Or: mentioned.A life-style was defined as a pat-
(2) May have very little spare time. What tern of role-performancescores shared by
time he has is taken up with activities related a group of people.
to his job or profession or with work around Life-styles in this sense were discovered
the house viewed as obligatory and not as a among the 234 persons in the Social Role
pastime. Sample of the Kansas City Study of Adult
e) Low (0-1).- Life. There were actually twenty-seven
(1) Apathetic. Does nothing and makes no
2 In addition, two other aspects of the person's
attempt to find outside interests. Or:
favorite leisure activities were studied: (1) the
(2) Tries anxiously to find interesting things content of the favorite leisure activities (eleven
to do and fails to find them. Is bored by leisure categories of content) and (2) the subjective mean-
and hurries back to work. Dislikes vacations ings of the favorite leisure aetivities (a set of twelve
and cannot relax. statements of the kinds of satisfaction a person
might get from a leisure activity, from which the
Not only was the person's use of leisure respondent picked the meanings most applicable
time rated according to the foregoing scale to his favorite activities). For details concerning
but the objective significance of his favorite the significance, content, and meaning studies see
activities was evaluated according to a set Robert J. Havighurst, "The Leisure Activities of
the Middle-aged," American Journal of Sociology,
of nineteen variables,2 of which the most
LXIII (September, 1957), 152-62; Marjorie N.
useful appear to be: autonomy or other- Donald and Robert J. Havighurst, "The Meanings
direction; creativity; enjoyment; develop- of Leisure" (MS).
398 THE AMERICANJOURNALOF SOCIOLOGY
specific patterns, or life-styles, each char- A. Community-centered.-This is a pattern
acterizing from 8 to 34 members,with some of uniformly high performance scores in all
people belongingto two or more. The specific eight social roles. It is called "community-cen-
patterns were grouped into four major tered" for the sake of contrast with the follow-
groups, using broader criteria for member- ing group, though the performance scores in the
community roles of citizen, club or association
ship in a group than in a pattern, and these member, and friend are not higher than those
four groups may be regarded provisionally in the family areas but about the same. The
as life-style groups.Their characteristicrole- social class distribution of these people in the
performance scores are shown in Figure 1. Kansas City Metropolitan Area is shown in
The names given to the life-style groups,and Table 2.
a brief description of each, follow: B. Home-centered high.-These people have

C-)

1 _..,,,, __. __ _ ____,.

Work Parent Spouse Hone- Le sure Friend Ci izen Clubs and


naker Associations

ROL E AREA
FIG. 1.-Life-styles of middle-aged people: A, community-centered; B, home-centered high; C, home-
centered medium; D, low level.
LEISURE AND LIFE-STYLE 399

performance scores in the roles of parent, community-centeredstyle of leisure tend to


spouse, homemaker, worker, and user of leisure be more autonomous, that is, to "choose
time which are about the same as those of the activity with purposeand regardfor its func-
community-centered, but they fall far below tion in one's personal life" and to engage
the latter in the roles of friend, citizen, and in activities in which there was some ele-
club or association member. These people and
the community-centered group have the highest
ment of novelty. They are more instru-
personal adjustment scores and the highest mental and more inclined to "play a game
scores on a rating of manifest complexity of or participate in an activity for some goal
life-style. beyond the game or activity (philanthropic
C. Home-centered medium.-These people activity, etc.)." "Benefit for society" was
have a family-centered pattern, though below given quite often as the motive.
that of the home-centered high group in role- Community-centerednessis the favorite
performance scores. leisure style of upper-middle-classpeople.
D. Low level.-This is a pattern of generally Being successful in business or a profession
low role-performance scores, with the family induces them to join business and social or-
TABLE 2
SOCIALCLASSDISTRIBUTIONOFLIFE-STYLES
(Per Cent)
Commu- Home- Home-
nity-cen- centered centered Low Un- Total
Social Class Sex tered High Medium Level grouped Group
U&UM . M. M 7 3 1 0 2 13
F 6 3 3 0 1 13
LM ........... M 8 11 10 3 1 33
F 5 4 17 3 4 33
UL ........... M 4 8 18 8 2 40
F 2 5 23 7 3 40
LL ............ M 0 0 6 7 1 14
F 1 0 5 7 1 14
Total group. .. M 19 22 35 18 6 100
F 14 12 48 17 9 100
NOTE.-The actual distributionof indivualsin the Study Samplewas the basis for this table, but the figureshave
been adjusted to fit the true social class distributionof adults in the Kansas City MetropolitanArea, as determined
by Richard Coleman(unpublishedworkingpaperin the files of the Committeeon Human Development). Sincesome
people fell into two groups, they were assignedto the particulargroupswhich they fitted most closely.

and work roles somewhatabove the external ganizations where they interact with each
roles. This grouphas very low scores on per- other to formwider circles of social and busi-
sonaladjustmentand on complexity. ness contacts. Membership in the country
We shall first answer the question, "What club is part of their proper and accepted
are the 'leisure styles' of the four life- style of living. The community-centeredin-
styles?" By "leisure style" we mean the dividuals also tend not to have young chil-
Gestalt formed when one observes an in- dren at home, which allows freedomfor out-
dividual's kinds and number of activities. side activity.
The community-centeredstyle of leisure In contrast, the people who enjoy the
emphasizes activities engaged in away from home-centered style of leisure engage in
home. The individual uses entertainment most of it around their residence.This style
institutions, such as the theater or the con- is strongest in lower-middle-and upper-low-
cert, or social institutions, such as the coun- er-class individualsand falls off in the lower-
try club, Rotary, chamber of commerce, lower class, where family values lose some
Red Cross, etc., as the context for a major importance and the few pastimes become
part of it, either jointly by the members of sex-differentiated, the men going fishing
a family or individually. On the basis of the alone or to the bar or poolroom with the
significance ratings people employing the "boys."
400 THE AMERICANJOURNALOF SOCIOLOGY
Leisure activities are engaged in jointly usually no broader than the kind of ac-
by the membersof the family for the major- tivities listed in circle 6. In graphic form
ity of the home-centered, whether it be a this illustrates the socially and spatially re-
church outing, a fishing trip, or watching stricted nature of the leisure of the home-
television. Sex-differentiatedactivities, such centered.
as sewing and embroideringfor the women Two examples, one of a community-cen-
and carpentryand "fixingaroundthe house" tered man with a high rating as a user of
for the men, still allow for conversationand leisure and the other of a high leisure home-
interaction between spouses. Friendship centered man, may further the reader's
and sociability are cultivated by visits from image of the difference between the two
neighborsrather than through any member- styles of leisure.
ship other than in the church or perhaps a Mr. X is a fifty-year-old executive vice-
fraternialorganization.For some people the president of a bank, with a pattern of leisure
family-centered style was not one of choice activities which is the prototype of the com-
but of necessity, owing to the presence of munity-centeredstyle of leisure. He is presi-
young children. dent of one country club, a member of
A numberof activities such as fishing and another, a Shriner, and a member of the
traveling during vacations were common to executive council of a national Boy's Club
both leisure styles, with some differentiation movement and of a number of charity or-
as to the mannerof them. In the community- ganizations. Mr. X's favorite leisure activity
centered style travel consists of going to is to go on trips during his vacation, to
resorts and sightseeing, while for the peo- New York City to see the Broadwaytheater,
ple engaged in home-centeredleisure travel and to see exhibitions of modern art. He is
consists of a car trip to relatives in other active in encouraging the local art museum
cities. For the upper-lower-class members to acquire examples of modern art. He en-
of the home-centered style travel may be joys playing golf once or twice a week at
quite circumscribed; one spoke of "taking the country club, playing cards, painting
a trolley trip to see the city." his garage, and entertaining business peo-
In spite of the relationship between life- ple both at home and at the club. He does
style and social class position, there were not own a television set, preferringthe good
people whose life-styles did not correspond music on the radio. He goes with his wife
with their class positions, as would be ex- to the movies and to all the musicalcomedies
pected in a society with a considerable de- that come to Kansas City. As for friends,
gree of social mobility. From Table 2 it Mr. X calls ten to twelve couples "close."
appears that some 10 per cent of the popu- He met them through various activities:
lation may have patterns above their class "My business connections here at the bank,
level and 5 per cent below it. civic clubs, church, etc." With his wife he
This scheme of leisure activities can be goes out to eat once a week and entertains
further comprehendedby consulting Figure other couples.
2. Each of the concentric circles contains In contrast to Mr. X, Mr. Y, a fifty-eight-
examples of the type of activities engaged year-old social worker, is an example of an
in by the subjects making up the sample. individual who employs the home-centered
The center of the concentric circles is com- style of leisure. His favorite activity is gar-
mon living in the home, the other radiating dening, in which he spends one-half hour
circles representing the physical and psy- to an hour a day during the growing season.
chological distances of activities from it. Mr. Y's hobby is model railroading,which
The "activity radius" of the community- he engages in with his wife in the basement
centered group is much greater than that of his home. He also does some woodworking
of the home-centered group, whose leisure and woodcarving and manual work around
activities never transcend circle 8, and are the home. Once in a while he reads historical
LEISURE AND LIFE-STYLE 401

fiction.The television set plays for two hours The differences between the home-cen-
an evening, showing sports events, quiz tered high, home-centeredmedium,and low-
shows, and plays. With his wife he reads, level life-styles as far as leisure is concerned
plays cards, does model railroading, and are mainly those between high, medium,
takes walks. Living in a neighborhood of and low ratings on the scale of competence
younger adults, he claims that he has few as a user of leisure. A higher role perform-
friends and that a large part of his time is ance is associated with the following signifi-
spent taking care of the two children of his cance variables: autonomy, creativity, get-
son. Mr. Y's "going out" consists only of ting strong pleasure from the activity, in-
movies (with wife) and American Legion strumental, high energy input, ego integra-
meetings once a month. tion, vitality, and expansion of interests and
From this one can see that both in num- activities.
ber and in kind of activities engaged in out-
side the home the "leisure complexity" of Have those whose leisure is home-cen-
Mr. X is far greater than that of Mr. Y. tered different personalities from the com-

\ 9~~~0\

FI.2 aTecrlen nglisr


402 THE AMERICANJOURNALOF SOCIOLOGY
munity-centered?Or is the differencecaused upper-middle-class people near the city's
by some external factor, such as residence center.
in a suburbversus residencein an apartment The foregoing facts point to the conclu-
area in the center of the city, or having sev- sion that the personality,more than the situ-
eral young children versus having one or ation, determinesthe leisure style.
none? It has been suggested by David Reis-
man3 and by Margaret Mead,4 among For each of these life-style groups there
others, that the trend toward suburban are some people with relatively high leisure
living and the trend toward larger numbers performancescores and some with relatively
of childrenare making for values and leisure low scores. By comparing these two sub-
activities that are more home- and family- groups, it is possible to compare the leisure
centered. characteristicsof people with high and with
Riesman speaks of "suburban styles of low leisure scores within a life-style. How-
life and thought" and stresses the suburban ever, the range of leisure performance
constriction of leisure to the family and the scores within a life-style is relatively small.
living-room-garden-televisionset, at the ex- Within the community-centeredlife-style
pense of theater, concert hall, downtown group there is one pattern with seventeen
meetings, country clubs, and heterogeneous memberswhich consists of people with rela-
social groups. Margaret Mead says that the tively high leisure scores, and another group
generation which has marriedsince the war of nine people with somewhat lower scores.
is much more concerned with home and The individuals of the higher leisure pat-
family life than earlier generations and is tern show more creativity and more auton-
busy trying to turn home life into "a self- omy in their leisure and a sense of vitality
rewarding delight." in it. The individuals of the lower leisure
To explore the differencesbetween home- pattern are less enthusiastic and speak of
centered and community-centered people, pastimes as something of a burden; they
we compared a community-centeredgroup join the country club because it is expected
with a similar number of home-centered that they do so, but they do not enjoy it
people, equating the groups for age and intrinsically. Business activity dominates
socioeconomic status. There was no differ- the lives of some; they claim that they have
ence between the two groups in the propor- relatively little leisure time and that they
tions of suburban dwellers and the propor- had more in the past when they were not
tions who lived in single-family houses with so busy. The low leisure individuals with
gardens and recreationrooms. However, the the community-centeredlife-style engage in
home-centered had more children living at the same kinds of activities as the high but
home. This suggests that the presence of are not so active in them and do not engage
children in the home, together with the de- in as many.
sire to have children and to have a home- In the home-centeredhigh group the indi-
centered life, are more influential than the viduals with the higher leisure pattern are
actual physical location of one's house in more creative than those in the lower leisure
determiningleisure style. It should be borne group (woodworking versus watching tele-
in mind, however, that Kansas City does vision), and they are more instrumental in
not have many apartment dwellings for their activities, being members of PTA and
3 David Riesman, "The Suburban Dislocation," church service groups, being leaders in Boy
Annals of the American Academy of Political and Scout work, etc. In the home-centeredme-
Social Science, CCCXIV (November, 1957), 123- dium group the same differencesappear be-
46. tween those of the higher and those of lower
'Margaret Mead, "The Patterns of Leisure in
leisure.
Contemporary American Culture," Annals of the
American Academy of Political and Social Science, In general,within a life-style groupwhich
CCCXIII (September, 1957), 11-15. is large enough to permit some variation in
LEISURE AND LIFE-STYLE 403

leisure-role performance scores, those with television, and take care of the children, or
higher leisure scores are more autonomous, in the church. The relationship between the
more creative, more instrumental, and more spouses is good, and there is a general feel-
vital in their use of leisure. ing of contentment and emotional security.
It is this basically which accounts for the
It has been assumed up to this point that high adjustment scores of the group.
there was a close correlation between per- The group of individuals with high leisure
sonal adjustment and performance in the scores and low adjustment tend as a whole
leisure role. The correlation coefficient is to be maladjustedsocially or occupationally
.32 for men and .33 for women, with socio- and attempt to get through leisure what
economicstatus partialed out. Clearly, there they cannot get in the other roles. They use
are some exceptions to this rule. Study of their leisure as a compensation to make up
these exceptions may teach us something for their deficiencies and to give their life
more about the value of leisure. some meaning.
Accordingly, we selected the cases which The men in the group, often alienated
showed most markedly a high adjustment- from work, from spouse, or from the "com-
low leisure performance combination and munity," attempt to adjust to this alienation
those who combined low adjustment with by engaging in leisure activities where they
high leisure performance. There were nine invest a lot of energy and through which
of the former and twelve of the latter in they can enjoy themselves and see them-
the sample of 234 people. The criterion for selves as socially acceptable. One is a fac-
the high adjustment-low leisure combina- tory manager. He finds no satisfaction in
tion was an adjustment score of 6 or above this position but rather pictures himself as
on the ten-point adjustment scale and a an intellectual and therefore spends a great
score of 5 or below on the ten-point leisure deal of time reading. A second, an amateur
performancescale. The criterion for the low pilot, directs his leisure away from a home
adjustment-high leisure group was an ad- where some emotional difficultiesexist. An-
justment score of 4.5 or below and a leisure other man was trained as an engineer and
score of 6 or above. has shifted over the years from one job to
The content of the leisure and the sig- another, finally going into a business with
nificance ratings of the leisure activities of his wife, which he does not enjoy. Like the
the low leisure-high adjustmentpeople were factory manager, he pictures himself as a
similar to the general pattern of people with scholar and spends his leisure time reading
low leisure and low adjustment scores. oriental history. One of the men is a light-
There are low significance ratings as to the skinned Negro, cut off socially from both
autonomy of the leisure activity, the crea- the white and the Negro community, who
tivity expressed in it, some apathy with engages in leisure activities that he can per-
respect to the activity, and either a decline form alone or with his family, such as hunt-
in leisure interests or no expansion of in- ing and fishing-activities which do not put
terests. him in social contact with others.
These are people who get along very well The women in the group have difficulty
with little or no leisure. They show a great in relating to their husbands and are emo-
deal of vitality in the instrumentalactivities tionally insecure; there are degrees of feel-
of life. The men are busy with their jobs ings of unwantedness and not being loved.
and the women with their children, allowing They concentratetheir energiesinto a single
little time for leisure and restricting them activity which they engage in alone and
to leisure activities near home. Six out of where they can achieve a great deal of pro-
the nine in the group are females and follow ficiency, such as sewing, embroidery, or
this pattern. Their leisure activities are cen- petitpoint, or in church activities where
tered either at home, where they sew, watch they can spend time with the "women"and
404 THE AMERICANJOURNALOF SOCIOLOGY
achieve the feeling of "doing something dle-class people, but rarely are working-class
worthwhile." people community-centered.An individual
with a large family of childrenis more likely
CONCLUSIONS to be home-centered.However, his place of
1. The most successful life-styles, as residence-whether in a suburb, single-fam-
judged by the level of role-performance ily home, or city apartment-does not seem
scores, have concomitant patterns of leisure to affect his leisure style to any great degree.
activity. The community-centeredlife-style The personality of the individual appears to
includes a leisure pattern which spreads find its own leisure style.
from the home out through a variety of 3. There are a few exceptionalcases where
community circles. On the other hand, a the life-style and the leisure style are not in
successful home-centeredlife-style contains close relation. One group of such cases con-
a home-centeredleisure pattern. These suc- sists of about 5 per cent of adults. They are
cessful leisure patterns tend to be autono- people with little or no leisure activity who
mous, creative, instrumental, vital, and ego have a successful life-style and good per-
integrative, whether they be community- sonal adjustment. These men and women
centered or home-centered. generallyinvest most of their energy in work
The lower-level life-styles are lower in or in home and children,with little time and
performance in roles external to the home inclination for leisure.
than in the home roles. They also have Another group consists of about 6 per
lower-level leisure styles, with lower scores cent of adults. They have a high level of
on the values listed in the preceding para- leisure activity but are dissatisfied or inade-
graph. quate workers or parents or spouses who
2. The two major types of leisure style, attempt to compensate with a high leisure
the community-centeredand the home-cen- performance.
tered, appearto be equally accessibleto mid- UNIVERSITY OF CEICAGO

You might also like