Professional Documents
Culture Documents
C O U R S E S Y L L A B U S
Course Objective
The objective of the course is to sharpen the analytical skills of MBA Finance
students.
Course Description
MAA is an advanced course with the MBA Finance electives set. There is an
assumption that the student has done well in first year finance and has considerable
familiarity with valuation methods. As such there will be a substantial amount of time
spent in advanced topics such as exchange ratios, buyout options, total risk versus
variable risk considerations, pat options of target shareholders, and the like.
Optionalities and option valuation methods will be value-added to the standard DFC
metrics. The course is therefore quantitative but not necessarily mathematical.
Class participation 50 %
Group Presentation 50 %
Total 100 %
Course Outline
In 1984, the SEC accused Paul Thayer and eight others of insider trading. Some of
Thayer's inside information came from his position on the board of Anheuser-Busch,
where he had learn about Busch's 1982 merger with Campbell Taggart before the merger
was publicly announced. The case deals with Busch's reaction after learning about the
SEC suit. In considering possible actions by Busch, students may explore the workings of
capital markets and attempt to estimate the amount of financial damage done to Busch by
the insider trading. Other issues involved ethics, the allocation of management resources
on costly legal battles, and the differing objectives of board members and managers.
SUBJECT: Finance; Beverages; Capital Markets; Ethics; Legal Aspects; Tender Offers
Provides a general description and overview of U.S. law on insider trading, including the
basic theories of liability, the responsibilities of securities firm managers to prevent and
detect insider trading, and the potential penalities for insider trading. May be used with
Mebel, Doran & Co.
The case is set in the midst of the attempted takeover of Walt Disney Productions by the
raider Saul Steinberg in June 1984. Disney's chief executive officer ponders whether to
fight the takeover or pay "Greenmail." One significant influence on the decision is the
"true" value of the firm. The case offers, either directly or through analysis of it, several
estimate of value. The valuation question invites a review of Disney's past performance
and current competitive position. Other significant influences on the decision are the
ethics and economics of paying greenmail. The rich range of issues raised in the case
(Strategy, valuation, performance measurement, and ethics) help make it an effective first
case, review case, or final exam in a corporate finance course.
SETTING: U.S.
This case describes the acquisition of Dumez by Lyonnaise des Eux in 1990. The case is
written from the point of view of Suez, a French holding company that is also the most
important shareholder of Lyonnaise. As a holding company, it is supposed to verify that
Lyonnaise does not pay too much for Dumez and that the acquisition makes sense.
TEACHING PURPOSE: The case is used to illustrate the Discounted Cash Flow method
in valuing acquisition targets. It highlights the difference between value creation and
earnings/sales maximization by showing how maximization earnings per share and
maximizing sales are incompatible with value creation.
SETTING: France
SETTING: Chicago, IL
3
Mergers, Acquisitions & Analytics
Presents a framework for analyzing strategic decisions. Takes as given the practice of
value-based management where by managers use value as a primary criteria when
making financial, strategic, or investment decisions. Through a simple valuation model, it
shows how equity value is related to three value drivers--profitability, advantage horizon,
and reinvestment. Also presents a numerical example to illustrate the model as well as
empirical evidence to support the relation between value creation and the value drivers.
Candace Kendle and Christopher Bergen, the CEO and COO of Kendle International, Inc.,
are reviewing ways to finance the growth of their privately-owned company. Kendle is a
contract research organization that conducts clinical drug trials for pharmaceutical and
biotechnology companies. To compete more effectively, Kendle plans to grow through
international acquisitions. It is now time to decide whether to go ahead with a full program
of two European acquisitions, a large debt financing through Nationsbank, and an initial
public offering to repay the debt and provide cash for future acquisitions. The falling stock
prices of Kendle's competitors add pressure to the situation.
SETTING: California
Exam
This case concerns the leveraged buyout of Norris, a watershed transaction in which
commercial banks provided the bulk of the acquisition financing. The case affords a
4
Mergers, Acquisitions & Analytics
detailed assessment of the buyout from many standpoints, including: (1) the seller, (2)
commercial banks, (3) mezzanine investors, and (4) equity investors.
(A)
Explains the equity cash flow method of valuation as it applies to leveraged buyouts. Also
explains: 1) earnings and cash flow forecasts, 2) debt structure and the cash sweep, 3)
the cashing out horizon and terminal valuation, and 4) the target IRR method of valuation.
(B)
Explains the equity cash flow method of valuation as it applies to leveraged buyouts. Also
explains how to implement the changing cost of equity method using the CAPM.
This case reviews the positioning of major players in the unfolding hostile-takeover
attempt on Belgium's largest corporation. This episode marked the turning point in
Europe's history of mergers and acquisitions toward an increased emphasis on acquiring
through hostile takeovers. In this case, the student is required to recommend show a
potential "white knight" should respond to the raider's tender offer. (The B case is F-
0882.) A student Lotus worksheet file is available on a computer diskette for use with this
case.
Despite 30 years of evidence demonstrating that most acquisitions don't create value for
the acquiring company, executives continue to make more deals, and bigger deals, every
year. There are plenty of reasons why value isn't created, but many times it's simply
because the acquiring company paid too much. It's not, however, that acquirers pay too
high a price in an absolute sense. Rather, they pay more than the acquisition is worth to
them. What is that optimum price? The authors present a systematic way to arrive at it,
involving several distinct concepts of value. In today's market, the purchase price of an
acquisition will nearly always be higher than the intrinsic value of the company--the price
of its stock before any acquisition intentions are announced. The key is to determine how
much of that difference is "synergy value"--the value that will result from improvements
made when the companies are combined. This value will accrue to the acquirer's
shareholders rather than to the target's shareholders. The more synergy value a particular
5
Mergers, Acquisitions & Analytics
acquisition can generate, the higher the maximum price an acquirer is justified in paying.
Just as important as correctly calculating the synergy value is having the discipline to walk
away from a deal when the numbers don't add up. If returns to shareholders from
acquisitions are no better in the next ten years than they've been in the past 30, the
authors warn, it will be because companies have failed to create systematic corporate
governance processes that put their simple lessons into practice.
This case considers the unusual terms by which Rhone-Poulenc, the large French
chemicals producer, acquired the US-based Rorer Group, Inc., in August 1990. Set a
year later, in August 1991, the case reviews the terms of the merger and the experience
of the new entity in its first year and invites the student to evaluate the "contingent value
right" (CVR) issued by Rhone-Poulenc in the merger.
6
Mergers, Acquisitions & Analytics