Professional Documents
Culture Documents
I. INTRODUCTION contacts for the injection of both holes and electrons into the
same material are possible, e.g., by bilayer source/drain con-
There has been an increasing interest in organic electron- tacts. Also, a high work function, nonoxidizing metal 共gold兲
ics in recent years. Organic field-effect transistors 共FETs兲 are as source/drain contact material can give good performance
particularly attractive for low-cost and low-performance ap- for both p- and n-channel transistors.5 The low electron mo-
plications, such as organic displays,1 organic complementary bility values can be caused by charge trapping in the semi-
circuits,2–5 and all-polymer integrated circuits.6–8 One of the conductor or at the semiconductor-insulator interface. In the
challenges for polymer electronics is the realization of second case, extrinsic impurities are important. Indeed, cur-
complementary metal-oxide-semiconductor 共CMOS兲 circuits rent limiting trap states can be avoided by improved techno-
requiring both n- and p-channel transistors on the chip. Ad- logical processing. Thus, the data presented in Ref. 10 pro-
vantages of digital circuits using complementary logic in- vide evidence that silanol groups present at the commonly
clude lower power dissipation, more robust operation, better used SiO2 dielectric interface can quench n-channel activity
noise margins, and ease of circuit design. This counts, of of organic semiconductors.
course, also for organic-based electronics. Both p- and n-channel operation in a single organic
Organic semiconductors are usually unintentionally field-effect transistor is realized in so-called ambipolar or-
p-doped, i.e., application of a negative gate voltage in or- ganic TFTs. The first report on ambipolar operation was for a
ganic thin-film transistors 共TFTs兲 results in the formation of device employing a heterostructure with two separate or-
a hole accumulation layer at the semiconductor-insulator in- ganic semiconductors as active layers; one electron- and one
terface forming the current channel. For the reversed polar- hole-conducting material.11 In this structure, identical Au
ity, an inversion layer of electrons should appear, but this is electrodes as source and drain contacts are used, leading to a
usually not observed. This has been attributed, on the one limitation of electron injection. In another ambipolar hetero-
hand, to the difficulty in engineering the metallic source/ structure organic FET with two active organic semiconductor
drain contacts for efficient injection of both electrons and layers, source and drain electrodes of Au and Mg,
holes,9 and on the other hand, to the fact that in the past respectively,12,13 are used to optimize hole and n-electron
reported electron mobilities are usually several orders of injection. In order to achieve n- and p-channel conduction, as
magnitude lower than those of the holes. But, good ohmic well as efficient injection of both types of carriers in the
same material, a single layer device based on an interpen-
a兲
Corresponding author. Electronic mail: g.paasch@ifw-dresden.de. URL: etrating network of two materials as active layer was
http://www.ifw-dresden.de/institutes/itf/members/paasch realized.14 Even single layer devices with an active layer
Downloaded 15 Apr 2011 to 115.249.41.221. Redistribution subject to AIP license or copyright; see http://jap.aip.org/about/rights_and_permissions
054514-2 Th. Lindner and G. Paasch J. Appl. Phys. 102, 054514 共2007兲
Downloaded 15 Apr 2011 to 115.249.41.221. Redistribution subject to AIP license or copyright; see http://jap.aip.org/about/rights_and_permissions
054514-3 Th. Lindner and G. Paasch J. Appl. Phys. 102, 054514 共2007兲
For silicon electronics, the different processes determin- In the case of impedance measurement a large frequency
ing inversion layer formation have been analyzed in Refs. range is accessible 共f = 10−3 , . . . , 107 Hz, meas
3 −7
31–33. For temperatures below ⬇410 K generation recom- = 10 , . . . , 10 s兲.
bination is dominant; for higher temperatures diffusion be- Transport is characterized by the dielectric relaxation
comes dominant 共in these devices a bulk region is present兲. time for the carrier species “j,”
Thereby, generation recombination through traps in the junc- 0
tion region is much more effective than through surface d,j = , 共2兲
j
states, since only trap levels near midgap and close to the
Fermi level contribute significantly. The minority carrier re- where j = en j j is the electrical conductivity of the respec-
sponse time is then determined by generation 关see Eq. 共3兲 tive species with concentration n j and mobility j. The car-
below兴. For minority carriers in silicon at room temperature riers can follow the external signal for d,j meas 关or equiva-
the response time is typically 0.01− 1 s, i.e., they respond to lently n j j 0 / 共emeas兲兴. For an unintentionally p-doped
a maximum frequency of 100 Hz. The fact that silicon tran- polymer 共n j = p = 1017 cm−3兲 with a relatively high mobility
sistors operate also at GHz frequencies is due to a third as required in a transistor, say j = p = 10−3 cm2 V−1 s−1,
mechanism: In the conventional transistor structure minority one has 共 = 3 as typical value兲 for majority carriers d,p
carriers can be injected easily from the source and drain re- ⬇ 10−8 s and this condition is fulfilled not only for the qua-
gions, which are doped oppositely to the substrate and which sistatic regime according to Eq. 共1a兲 and 共1b兲, but also for
are in close contact to the channel region. the frequency response up to f ⬇ 107 Hz 共compare Fig. 2兲.
In organic electronics based on large band-gap organic Under this condition the p-accumulation layer can be formed
materials, the generation process is very inefficient. More- 共if the contacts are ohmic for holes兲 for large negative gate-
over, another device structure is used, usually the thin-film bulk and gate-source voltages, respectively. Since the semi-
design with bottom or top source/drain contacts. In addition, conductor capacitance increases strongly in accumulation,
the usual MOSFET has a back contact which is missing in one measures then the oxide capacitance 共see Figs. 3 and 6兲
the TFT, but is present in capacitors used for C − V and C because both are in series.
− f measurements. Thus, for organic electronics there is a It must be mentioned here that the response time of the
need to consider anew the processes determining inversion. carriers depends on the actual concentration n j, which varies
For a qualitative understanding of C − V and C − f char- within the MOS device by orders of magnitude. Therefore,
acteristics, it is useful to discuss the relevant time constants the carrier response time is locally different within the device
characterizing the measuring process, transport, and genera- depending on the variation of the carrier concentration n j.
Downloaded 15 Apr 2011 to 115.249.41.221. Redistribution subject to AIP license or copyright; see http://jap.aip.org/about/rights_and_permissions
054514-4 Th. Lindner and G. Paasch J. Appl. Phys. 102, 054514 共2007兲
Downloaded 15 Apr 2011 to 115.249.41.221. Redistribution subject to AIP license or copyright; see http://jap.aip.org/about/rights_and_permissions
054514-5 Th. Lindner and G. Paasch J. Appl. Phys. 102, 054514 共2007兲
Downloaded 15 Apr 2011 to 115.249.41.221. Redistribution subject to AIP license or copyright; see http://jap.aip.org/about/rights_and_permissions
054514-6 Th. Lindner and G. Paasch J. Appl. Phys. 102, 054514 共2007兲
FIG. 5. Hole and electron densities in the middle of the MOS capacitor from
the bulk contact 共y = 0兲 to the insulator interface 共y = 0.15 m兲 at an applied FIG. 6. Simulated quasistatic C − V characteristics of the TOC transistor
voltage of VGB = + 20 V. Compared are density profiles before 共dashed line兲 关Fig. 1共b兲兴 共ramp rate 0.1 V / s兲 for different values of the band gap. The
and after 共dotted line兲 the waiting time of 100 s at VGB = + 20 V with equi- work function of the source- and drain-contact material is always aligned
librium distribution 共solid line兲. with the maximum of the valence band, so its absolute value changes with
the band gap 共ohmic contact, accumulation contact兲. The gate contact area is
3 m ⫻ 1 m and 1 m ⫻ 1 m for source and drain. Other parameters
discussed in connection with Fig. 4共b兲 inversion builds up as in Fig. 3.
slowly, a depletion zone extends at first deep into the semi-
conductor, and with gradually increasing inversion layer for-
mation its width decreases until the inversion layer is com- structure 关Fig. 1共b兲兴 if source and drain are set to zero volt-
pletely formed leading to the gradual increase of the age while the voltage ramp is applied to the gate. The result-
capacitance for the sweep direction from negative to positive ing characteristics are depicted in Fig. 6, again for three dif-
gate voltages. However, the formation of this deep depletion ferent gap widths. Compared to the capacitor only the device
zone takes place very fast while its following reduction is a structure is changed, since in contrast to the bulk contact in
slow process. Due to the low carrier densities in that region the capacitor the source and drain contacts are separated by
the dielectric relaxation time is very large and therefore the the channel. In addition, the organic layer is only 50 nm
redistribution to equilibrium 共especially of the electrons兲 is thick. All other parameters are the same as for the quasistatic
very slow, in addition to the slow carrier generation. In Fig. C − V characteristics of the capacitor 共Fig. 3兲. As visible from
5 carrier density profiles are depicted from the bulk contact Fig. 6, the qualitative dependencies remain the same. The
to the insulator interface in the middle of the MOS capacitor oxide capacitance 共which is equal for both device structures兲
at VGB = + 20 V. It is clearly visible that the charge density is obtained for sufficiently large negative gate voltages. The
distribution at the end of the voltage sweep from negative to flatband voltage depends on the gap width for the same rea-
positive gate voltage 共dashed lines, before waiting time兲 is son as explained for the capacitor in Sec. IV A. Again, the
far away from equilibrium 共solid lines兲, even though the ox- appearance of inversion for sufficiently large positive gate
ide capacitance is nearly reached in the C − V characteristics voltages depends on the gap width. For a small gap, inver-
at this point 共compare Fig. 3兲. Solely direct at the interface sion charges can be generated fast enough and a usual qua-
the electron density is equal to the equilibrium value. Also, sistatic characteristic is obtained. In case of the large band
after the waiting time 共here 100 s兲, before starting the back gap the inversion layer is not formed, and for positive volt-
voltage sweep 共dotted lines兲, equilibrium is not completely ages there is only a transition of the C − V characteristics to
reached; carrier generation still takes place. This causes the the geometrical capacitance. In the TOC structure its value
C − V curve for the back sweep from positive to negative must be determined numerically. But a good estimate is ob-
voltage to start with a value below the oxide capacitance. tained if one considers, besides the smaller organic layer
Until equilibrium is reached, there is no effective recombi- thickness, only the area of source and drain as contact area,
nation 共because there are less charge carriers than in equilib- i.e., 2 ⫻ 共1 m ⫻ 1 m兲. With the common analytic expres-
rium兲 that results in a reduced hole current from bulk contact sions a value of 0.626 fF is then obtained for the geometrical
to the recombination zone connected with a lower capaci- capacitance compared to a simulated value of 0.656 fF ex-
tance. Simulation shows that this behavior at VGB = + 20 V is tracted from Fig. 6. Of course, for the value of the oxide
still present for a longer waiting time of 500 s, i.e., a fairly capacitance the whole device area of 3 m ⫻ 1 m must be
long time is necessary to reach the equilibrium charge carrier considered because the accumulation layer formed at the in-
distribution, because in approaching equilibrium the genera- terface to the insulator extends over the whole length of the
tion rate will decrease. device. Finally, for a medium gap width hysteresis arises. For
both sweep directions the increase of the capacitance is much
B. Thin-film top contact transistor
slower than in the capacitor. Because of the much thinner
Similarly, as in the capacitor 关Fig. 1共a兲兴 one can also organic layer the carrier generation zone cannot expand as
obtain quasistatic C − V characteristics for the TOC transistor much as in the capacitor. Therefore, in this transistor struc-
Downloaded 15 Apr 2011 to 115.249.41.221. Redistribution subject to AIP license or copyright; see http://jap.aip.org/about/rights_and_permissions
054514-7 Th. Lindner and G. Paasch J. Appl. Phys. 102, 054514 共2007兲
Downloaded 15 Apr 2011 to 115.249.41.221. Redistribution subject to AIP license or copyright; see http://jap.aip.org/about/rights_and_permissions
054514-8 Th. Lindner and G. Paasch J. Appl. Phys. 102, 054514 共2007兲
FIG. 8. C − f characteristics for the MOS capacitor according to Fig. 1共a兲 FIG. 9. Electron 共n兲 and hole concentration profiles from the bulk contact
with a reduced organic layer thickness of dorg = 50 nm for a positive gate- 共y = 0兲 to the interface to the oxide 共y = 0.05 m兲 for the C − f characteristics
bulk voltage of VGB = + 10 V 共a兲 and a negative gate-bulk voltage of VGB of Fig. 8 of the MOS capacitor with a reduced organic layer thickness of
= −10 V 共b兲. For the work function of the bulk contact material two differ- dorg = 50 nm for a positive gate-bulk voltage of VGB = + 10 V 共a兲 and a nega-
ent values are used: ⌽B = 3 eV and ⌽B = 5 eV. The curves with open sym- tive gate-bulk voltage of VGB = −10 V 共b兲. For the work function of the bulk
bols are for the equivalent circuit models. In 共a兲 also the imaginary part of contact material two different values are used: ⌽B = 3 eV and ⌽B = 5 eV.
the dielectric function is shown for ⌽B = 3 eV.
the p-type material at the interface to the oxide and Fig. 8共b兲
As mentioned above, a p-doped organic semiconductor for a negative gate-bulk voltage of VGB = −10 V, leading to
is considered 共NA− = 1017 cm−3 for dorg = 50 nm and NA− = 5 hole accumulation at the interface to the oxide. At first the
⫻ 1017 cm−3 for dorg = 150 nm兲. With such a doping a hole- situation will be analyzed for the positive gate-bulk voltage.
accumulation bulk contact is usually chosen 共we use in the Here, for the hole injection bulk contact with the larger work
simulation the bulk contact work function ⌽B = 5.0 eV兲 and function the geometrical capacitance is obtained for the
the notation 共p-兲accumulation 共inversion兲 refers to the charge whole frequency range. On the other hand, for the low work
at the interface when a negative 共positive兲 gate-bulk voltage function bulk contact one has a clear transition between the
is applied. However, being interested in an n channel in the p oxide capacitance at low frequencies and the geometrical ca-
material one could also consider the influence of a bulk con- pacitance at high frequencies with a transition frequency of
tact with electron accumulation; thus we consider also a bulk 2 ⫻ 105 Hz marking the maximum of ⑀⬙ in Fig. 8共a兲. In ad-
contact work function of ⌽B = 3.0 eV, but the notations dition, at higher frequencies there is a plateau of the capaci-
共p-兲accumulation and inversion will be used as defined be- tance, which is 1.04 fF slightly larger than the geometrical
fore. Thin-film MOS capacitors are considered with a thick- capacitance and the final transition to the latter is flattened
ness of the organic layer of dorg = 50 nm 共150 nm兲, which is and occurs at about 5 ⫻ 107 Hz. In ⑀⬙ a hint for a second
smaller 共larger兲 than the depletion length for the chosen dop- maximum is visible also. The reason for these dependencies
ing. The capacitance of the semiconductor layer is Corg becomes clear from the simulated concentration profiles de-
= 0orgA / dorg and the oxide capacitance is Cox = 0oxA / dox picted in Fig. 9共a兲. For the larger bulk contact work function
= 2.07 fF. Thus the geometrical capacitance is for the thinner the electron density is so small there, that in the thin layer,
organic layer Cgeo = 共Cox −1
兲 = 0.95 fF and 0.45 fF for
−1 −1
+ Corg inversion is not achieved at the interface to the oxide. Apart
the thicker layer. It should be noticed that in the inversion from a tiny region near the hole injecting bulk contact both
regime charge carrier generation/recombination is negligible concentrations are negligibly small, the layer is depleted, and
in the considered frequency range due to the large band gap hence only the geometrical capacitance occurs. But for the
as mentioned before. lower work function one has at the bulk contact and at the
In Fig. 8 the C − f characteristics are shown for the MOS interface to the oxide a high electron concentration, the mini-
capacitor with the thinner organic layer. Figure 8共a兲 is for a mum in between is n ⬇ 2 ⫻ 1015 cm−3, and the whole layer is
positive gate-bulk voltage of VGB = + 10 V, i.e., inversion of flooded by minority carriers. Disregarding first the transition
Downloaded 15 Apr 2011 to 115.249.41.221. Redistribution subject to AIP license or copyright; see http://jap.aip.org/about/rights_and_permissions
054514-9 Th. Lindner and G. Paasch J. Appl. Phys. 102, 054514 共2007兲
Downloaded 15 Apr 2011 to 115.249.41.221. Redistribution subject to AIP license or copyright; see http://jap.aip.org/about/rights_and_permissions
054514-10 Th. Lindner and G. Paasch J. Appl. Phys. 102, 054514 共2007兲
VII. CONCLUSIONS
In the usually unintentionally p-doped organics used in
TFTs with high work function metal contacts as source and
drain, a p-accumulation channel is formed as the on state for
negative gate voltage. For using the advantages of CMOS
FIG. 11. Hole concentration profiles from the bulk contact 共y = 0兲 to the circuitry, and also inversion, that means n-channel formation
interface to the oxide 共y = 0.15 m兲 for the C − f characteristics of Fig. 10 of
the MOS capacitor with the organic layer thickness of dorg = 150 nm for a is needed. Since the organic TFTs differ from the usual
positive gate-bulk voltage of VGB = + 10 V 共a兲 and a negative gate-bulk volt- MOSFETs by the missing back contact and usage of metals
age of VGB = −10 V 共b兲. For the work function of the bulk contact material for source and drain contacts, and since the organics for the
two different values are used: ⌽B = 3 eV and ⌽B = 5 eV.
active layer are until now usually wide gap materials and
have a low mobility, inversion layer formation has been ana-
middle of the layer one has bulk concentrations since the lyzed for organic field-effect devices. This work is intended
layer thickness is larger than the depletion length. Thus, in partly also to stimulate experimental investigations on the
all cases one has a bulk region with the hole concentration inversion layer formation in organic TFTs and MOS struc-
given by the doping level and a negligible electron concen- tures. So far, only steady-state measurements have been re-
tration. But for the low work function contact one has a ported on the ambipolar devices, where an inversion channel
depletion zone of holes of a width ddepl = 39 nm. In inversion is formed.
and for the hole injecting contact there is a depletion zone A general insight is obtained comparing relaxation times.
near the interface to the oxide with ddepl = 32 nm, and for the For the chosen characteristic mobility values 关for very low
electron injecting contact there are depletion zones on both gap 共Eg ⬍ 0.75 eV兲 one has d,n inv meas兴, the inversion
sides of the layer, the total width of which is ddepl = 49 nm. layer is formed by the minority carrier current without gen-
Thus, the model 共A1兲 can be simplified by setting the resis- eration. For somewhat larger gap, generation dominates
tance of the depletion layer as very large. Then one can de- compared with minority carrier current, the formation of the
scribe the system by an equivalent circuit model, which is a inversion layer is slowed down, and since recombination for
series connection of the oxide capacitance with the capaci- the back voltage sweep is fast, one has in this region a hys-
tance Cdep of the respective depletion layer and with a paral- teresis. For a gap Eg 1.25 eV, the measurement is faster
lel connection of the bulk capacitance Cbulk and resistance and there is no inversion layer formation.
R p,bulk, the latter with the bulk hole concentration and a More details are obtained from the numerical simula-
length dbulk = dorg − ddepl. The total capacitance is then given tions taking into account the geometry of MOS capacitors
by and TFTs and the type of contacts. For the MOS capacitors
with different gap widths Eg = 2.0, 1.2, and 0.8 eV of the
organics and a hole injecting bulk contact, the qualitative
1 + 2 1 2 expectations are confirmed. For a large band gap transport of
C = Cins , 共8兲 minority carriers is negligible, and compared to the ramp rate
1 + 222
generation of minority carriers is too slow for the formation
of the inversion layer and the layer becomes fully depleted
for larger positive gate voltage; whereas for small band gap a
CoxCdep usual quasistatic C − V characteristic is obtained indeed with-
Cins = , 共9兲
Cox + Cdep out generation of minority carriers. In case of the medium
Downloaded 15 Apr 2011 to 115.249.41.221. Redistribution subject to AIP license or copyright; see http://jap.aip.org/about/rights_and_permissions
054514-11 Th. Lindner and G. Paasch J. Appl. Phys. 102, 054514 共2007兲
band gap, during the measuring period inversion is formed 1 = R 1C 1, 2 = R 2C 2, 1,ox = R1Cox, 2,ox = R2Cox .
slowly, whereas the reduction of the inversion layer takes
place rather fast and the characteristics for the sweep direc- Actually, a closer inspection shows that one has only two
tion from positive to negative voltages are identical with the resonance frequencies. The relaxation time for the lower fre-
common quasistatic characteristics. Simulated profiles of quency is given by
current densities, concentrations, and recombination support
this interpretation in detail and also a peculiar dependency low = 1 + 2 + 1,ox + 2,ox = R1共C1 + Cox兲 + R2共C2
occurring when changing the sweep direction at larger posi-
tive voltage. + Cox兲 → R1共C1 + Cox兲 for R1 R2 , 共A2兲
The qualitative dependencies and the influence of the
gap width remain the same for quasistatic C − V characteris- and that one for the higher frequency is determined by
tics of a top contact transistor 共source/drain at zero voltage兲
while the voltage ramp is applied to the gate. Quantitative 1 low
=
differences occur only due to the different geometry and high 12 + 12,ox + 21,ox
冉 冊 冉 冊
layer thickness.
For TOC and BOC TFTs with a wide gap organic layer 1 Cgeo 1 Cgeo
= 1− + 1−
accumulation and inversion are possible if the source and R 1C 1 C1 R 2C 2 C2
drain contacts are from different materials, one hole injecting
and the other one electron injecting. Such structures have
been used in ambipolar TFTs, but the disadvantage of such
→
1
冉
R 2C 2
1−
Cgeo
C2
冊 for R1 R2 . 共A3兲
冕
14
dorg
E. J. Meijer et al., Nat. Mater. 2, 678 共2003兲.
Rox 1 1 15
H. Reisch, W. Wiesler, U. Scherf, and N. Tuytuylkov, Macromolecules 29,
Ẑ = Rlead + + dx 8204 共1996兲.
1 + iRoxCox A 0 共x兲 + i0org 16
K. Takimiya, K. Kato, Y. Aso, F. Ogura, and T. Otsubo, Bull. Chem. Soc.
Jpn. 75, 1795 共2002兲.
17
with the integration perpendicular to the organic layer. The E. E. Havinga, W. ten Hoeve, and H. Wynberg, Polym. Bull. 共Berlin兲 29,
119 共1992兲.
specific conductivity is = e p p + enn. It is often sufficient 18
ISE-TCAD, Integrated Systems Engineering AG, Zürich, Switzerland,
to replace the integral by a series connection of two parallel 1995–1999兲.
19
R − C terms. Supposing Rox to be large and Rlead negligible P. H. Nguyen, S. Scheinert, S. Berleb, W. Brütting, and G. Paasch, Org.
共which is in experiment not always the case兲 one has Electron. 2, 105 共2001兲.
20
S. Scheinert and G. Paasch, Phys. Status Solidi A 201, 1263 共2004兲.
21
G. Paasch and S. Scheinert, J. Appl. Phys. 101, 024514 共2007兲.
22
1 R1 R2 G. Paasch and S. Scheinert, Synth. Met. 122, 145 共2001兲.
Ẑ ⬇ + + . 共A1兲 23
A. Nesterov, G. Paasch, S. Scheinert, and T. Lindner, Synth. Met. 130, 165
iCox 1 + iR1C1 1 + iR2C2 共2002兲.
24
G. Paasch, A. Nesterov, and S. Scheinert, Synth. Met. 139, 425 共2003兲.
25
How the two capacitances and resistances should be assigned S. Scheinert, G. Paasch, S. Pohlmann, H.-H. Hörhold, and R. Stockmann,
Solid-State Electron. 44, 845 共2000兲.
to regions in the organic layer depends on the bulk contact 26
S. Scheinert and W. Schliefke, Synth. Met. 139, 501 共2003兲.
and the applied voltage. Formally, one has in this system the 27
S. Scheinert, G. Paasch, M. Schrödner, H.-K. Roth, S. Sensfuß, and Th.
following four relaxation times: Doll, J. Appl. Phys. 92, 330 共2002兲.
Downloaded 15 Apr 2011 to 115.249.41.221. Redistribution subject to AIP license or copyright; see http://jap.aip.org/about/rights_and_permissions
054514-12 Th. Lindner and G. Paasch J. Appl. Phys. 102, 054514 共2007兲
28
S. Scheinert, G. Paasch, and T. Doll, Synth. Met. 139, 233 共2003兲. 31
E. H. Nicollian and J. R. Brews, MOS (Metal Oxide Semiconductor) Phys-
29
T. Lindner, G. Paasch, and S. Scheinert, J. Mater. Res. 19, 2014 共2004兲. ics and Technology 共Wiley, New York, 1982兲.
30 32
P. Stallinga, H. L. Gomes, H. Rost, A. B. Holmes, M. G. Harrison, and R. S. R. Hofstein and G. Warfield, Solid-State Electron. 8, 321 共1965兲.
H. Friend, J. Appl. Phys. 89, 1713 共2001兲. 33
A. Goetzberger and E. H. Nicollian, Bell Syst. Tech. J. 46, 513 共1967兲.
Downloaded 15 Apr 2011 to 115.249.41.221. Redistribution subject to AIP license or copyright; see http://jap.aip.org/about/rights_and_permissions