Professional Documents
Culture Documents
By
Student Name
Presented to the
Department of _______________________
Introduction
Financial statements are often called “the language of business.” Thus, any leader in
every area of business and non-profit management will need to know and understand how to
read, analyse, and interpret the meaning and decision making implications of financial
statements. Every accountant and financial analyst will need to be able to calculate financial
ratios and analyse related non-financial data in order to see whether the company is
successful or not and suggest what can be improved in the operations if needed. Therefore,
there was thorough financial investigation of BHP Billiton, Transfield Services Limited and
Woolworths Limited. In order to investigate these companies activity, the 2008 and 2009
annual reports were retrieved from official companies’ websites. Also general information on
industry averages for various ratios was obtained from financial websites as well as ASX
website. Specific events that could have impacted a company’s operations were followed on
the related web-links. In order to make a financial decision, financial analysis of financial
In order to have the most necessary information following ratios were considered to
company’s earning ability, in the broad categories of margins and returns. The major margins
in our case were gross profit and net profit margin. Gross profit margin identifies how much
of the sales dollar remains after covering the cost of the goods or services sold. The higher
the percentage, the better the company is doing in generating potential profitability. Net
profit margin reflects the residual of all items of revenue and expense from the Income
Statement and the percentage value of the ratio identifies what percentage of a dollar of sales
ends up as net profit (Horngren et al., 2010). Other financial ratios considered within the
analysis were the ratios indicating financial strength of a company, e.g. debt ratio, current
Student Name Course Name Assignment Name 3
ratio, times interest earned. Also return on assets and returns on equity were analysed in order
to watch for efficient use of available resource in profit generation and returns to
shareholders.
segments of food and grocery, liquor, petrol, general merchandise and consumer electronics,
hotels group and wholesale group. The Company represents some of the most recognisable
and trusted brands in retailing (Woolworths Ltd.). Food and grocery, liquor and petrol outlets
as well as supermarkets comprise the supermarket division of the Company’s operations. BIG
W discount department stores are a part of the general merchandise group. Dick Smith
Electronics, Tandy and Dick Smith Electronics Powerhouse stores are included into the
consumer electronics group. The hotels group offers accommodation, food, on premise liquor
sales, gaming and venue hire. State-wide independent wholesalers (SIW) comprise the
wholesale group for the Company (Corporate Information, 2010). Woolworths Limited
primarily operates in Australia and New Zealand, but also has partnership with TATA group
in India as well as its own Asian buying office in Hong Kong (Woolworths Limited, 2010.).
The partnership with the largest private sector group in India is aimed at developing a
network of consumer electronics retail store in the country, where the Company provides
wholesaling and some retail management expertise (Woolworths Limited 2010). The
Company’s Asian buying office was created with the aim of increasing the amount of direct
sourcing for general merchandise products, which are produced in Asia so that to gain greater
control over product quality, factory compliance and traceability (Woolworths Limited 2010).
According to the Annual Report for the fiscal year 2009, Woolworths Limited operated 3,162
in Australia and New Zealand, 951 supermarkets under the Woolworths and Safeway brands
in Australia and under Woolworths, Countdown and Foodtown brands in New Zealand, 542
Student Name Course Name Assignment Name 4
co branded Woolworths/Caltex petrol canopies across Australia, 156 BIG W stores and 436
electronics outlets across Australia and New Zealand as well as 280 premium hotels. Within
the partnership with Tata group, Woolworths Limited provides wholesale services to 33 retail
Woolworths Limited is listed on the Australian Securities Exchange, where its stock
has been traded in the price range from AU$ 25.31(as for February 9, 2010) to AU$ 28.85 (as
for August 27, 2010) since January 2010. The Company is listed the first out of 213 in the
consumer sector by market capitalisation of $34,720 million as of June 10, 2010 (ASX,
2010).
Since the beginning of the year the stock price was falling until February 24 when
Woolworths Ltd declared dividends to be payable in March. Since then the price for the
Company’s stock fluctuated in the mentioned above price range in response to the
movements in world financial, oil, and gold markets. By July 29 the price fell to the level of
AU$ 25.56 due to two factors – first, the concern over weakening growth in China and a
slower growth than had been earlier expected and forecasted by the Company (Koons, 2010).
However, a positive kick in was from early election call, which, according to Michael
Luscombe, will not affect the sales during holiday season and provide for high sales for
discretionary retailers (Fenner, 2010). The price for the Woolworths Limited’s stock increase
after the Company announced about its intention to return $700 million to shareholders
through share buy-back scheduled for September-October 2010. In the press-release, it was
claimed that return of over $1 billion to shareholders combined with $1.3 billion in dividends
and $325 million capital buy back that occurred in the first half of calendar year, “the
shareholders will benefit from the improved earnings per share, improved dividends per share
and improved return on equity following the Buy-Back” (Woolworths Limited, 2010).
Student Name Course Name Assignment Name 5
However, the stock buy back as well as capital buy-back are intended to be funded via long-
term debt, which will impact capital structure and reliance on debt. Nevertheless, according
opportunities available, the Company will focus on maintaining high credit ratings and
enhancing shareholder value (Woolworths Limited, 2010). The closing price as of August 28
went up by $0.31 and 1.13% change from previous close, whereas on the announcement day
the price of stock had 2.38% in positive change from the previous close on August 25.
The Company’s annual reports and financial statements reflect quite healthy condition
of its operations. The sales and net profit figures have been increasing over, though at a
slower rate for the last fiscal year 2010 as estimated in the Company Results for the year
ended 27 June 2010. Thus, for the fiscal years 2008 and 2009 the sales were $47 and $49.6
respectively, which provided for 5.5% growth for the period, whereas growth in 2010 was
4.2%. The interim financial report as of January 3, 2010 also shows increase when compared
against the same period of 2009. The sales during fiscal year 2010 increased by 4.2%. The
return on net sales has shown an upward trend as well and was 3.5%, 3.6%, and 4.1% in
fiscal years 2008, 2009, and half year 2010 respectively. Although the growth in sales did not
prove the expectation of being in upper single digits, the net profit after taxes increased in
line with expectations for the last fiscal year and by 10.1%, when the NPAT in previous years
of 2008 and 2009 was 25.7% and 12.8% respectively. However, a slowdown in growth rate
of sales and net profit may also be attributed to the tightened conditions in the consumer
market.
Return rates for Woolworths Limited were stable for the previous years and increased
in the year ended June 27, 2010. Thus, the return on assets for the fiscal years 2008 and 2009
was 11% and 11.4% respectively, whereas in 2010 ROA is 15%. However, when compared
Student Name Course Name Assignment Name 6
to the industry average of 0.48 and sector average of 2.06, the return on assets at Woolworths
Limited is quite high implying that the management efficiently uses its assets to generate
sales.
Return on equity for the years 2008 and 2009 was 28 and 28.1 percent respectively,
whereas in the fiscal year 2010 it is estimated to be 26 percent. However, the return on equity
is likely to improve when the Company executes stock buy-back, which would result in
The financial strength of the Company indicated by the measures of ability to pay
debt, namely debt ratio amounts to 60.2, 58.69, and 57.7 percent for the fiscal years 2008,
2009, and 2010 respectively. Whereas debt to equity ratio is 151.4, 142 and 136,48 for the
fiscal years 2008, 2009, and 2010 respectively. Thus, Woolworths Limited strongly relies on
debt financing, which to some extent may endanger returns to shareholders when compared
to the industry average of 24.69 and sector average 27.52. However, the debt to equity ratio is
lower than S&P 500 average of 186.51. Nevertheless, interest coverage for Woolworths
Limited indicates the company’s strengths and ability to generate enough operating income to
cover financing charges risk default on debt obligations and amounted to 10.96, 11.97, and
Earnings per share declared in the financial statements of the company were 134.89,
150.71, and 164.01 cents in 2008, 2009, 2010 respectively, which indicate EPS growth of 9%
in the last fiscal year. EPS for 2010 and the market closing price of Woolworths’ stock on
August 27 of AU $27.85 indicate the price to earnings ratio of 16.98, which is significantly
higher than industry average 5.73, though a little higher than sector average of 14.45. The
dividend yield for the last accounting period is 3.96, and dividends increased by 10.58
percent.
Student Name Course Name Assignment Name 7
indicate positive conditions for investing opportunities. Although, playing in the stock market
through constant buying and selling Company’s stock is not likely to bring instant benefits,
holding onto the Woolworths Limited’s stock is a safe investment in terms of guaranteed
BHP Billiton is the largest diversified natural resources company in the world, which
is engaged in extracting and processing minerals, oil and gas from its production operations
located primarily in Australia, the Americas and southern Africa (BHP Billiton Limited,
2010). It operates and sells its product worldwide, while centralizing its marketing activities
from Singapore, The Hague and Antwerp. Customer sector groups that the Company operates
in are petroleum, aluminium, base metals, diamonds and specialty products, stainless steel
There are two separate shareholder bodies of BHP Billiton and BHP Billiton plc,
which in fact operate as one business body with single management structure and single
Board of Directors. However, BHP Billiton Limited and BHP Billiton Group are
London, the United Kingdom. BHP Billiton Limited is listed to trade its shares on Australian
Securities Exchange and New York Stock Exchange. BHP Billiton Limited’s stock traded in
the range from AU$35.58 to AU$ 44.93 during last 52 weeks, and closed at AU$ 37.30 at the
Australian Securities Exchange on August 27, 2010 losing 0.09 (0.24%) in the price to the
previous close.
The fluctuations in the price for the Company’s stock are attributable to and
dependable on changes in prices and demand in commodity markets, which have proved to
be fairly unstable since the global financial crisis, as well as on macroeconomic activity of
Student Name Course Name Assignment Name 8
economies worldwide. The Company, however, has put great efforts into maintaining
profitability rates and returns to shareholders. For this matter, BHP Billiton sold one of its
nickel mines in Western Australia. Nevertheless, the Company did not take out or refused any
of its operating businesses. On the contrary, the Company constantly develops and negotiates
agreements on new mines and sources exploration. Thus, on June 13, 2010 BHP Billiton
signed framework agreement with Liberian Government to mine four iron leases (Reuters).
As well as month earlier the Company joined Mew Oil Gas Explorers to drill for gas off
South Africa’s west coast (Reuters). Furthermore, BHP Billiton is willing to take advantage
of market weakness due to financial crisis and looks for acquisition worldwide. However, last
takeover offer for Potash Corp. was rejected due to BHP Billiton downgrading Potash Corp.
The financial statement for BHP Billiton reveal that financial year 2009 was less
successful in terms of providing for growth in sales and profits. The sales in fiscal year ended
June 30, 2009 decreased by 15 percent from $59,473 million to $50,211 million whereas
profits declined by 25 percent. Nevertheless, such a decrease in sales and income was
attributable to both record commodity prices in many products and a collapse in demand,
commodity prices and collapsing demand presented a major challenge to market, the BHP
Billiton EBIT margin and return on capital remained, according to the Company, very
healthy at 40.1 per cent and 24.6 per cent respectively (BHP Billiton, 2009).
Fiscal year ended June 30, 2010, however, was more of positive growth for the
Company’s profit. BHP reported an increase in sales by 5.2 percent, whereas profit margin
amounted to 116 percent when compared to the previous fiscal year. The boost in profit is
explained from strong volumes in steel-making raw materials, price increases for iron ore
Student Name Course Name Assignment Name 9
plus base and precious metals, and a negative exchange rate impact from a weaker US dollar.
However, the result may be to a great part be attributed to the strategy of the Company to
deferral of lower priority capital expenditures, and suspension and sale of cash negative
operation.
Indicators of the Company’s financial strength were quite strong for fiscal years 2008,
2009, 2010 despite the fact that profits decreased in 2009. The Company’s ability to pay
current debt increased through years 2008-2010 from 1.32 in the fiscal year 2008, to 1.89 in
2009, and 1.92 in 2010. Although the ability to cover short term debt obligation increased,
the figure is still quite high when compared to the industry average of 0.69 and sector average
1.14, implying that the company holds on to its asset and uses them unwisely. However, the
higher ratio for BHP Billiton indicates fewer chances for problems associated with default
conditions and provides for a higher credit rating among creditors. Furthermore, the debt
decreased implying that the Company relies on capital financing of its operations and
investments (debt ratio for the fiscal years 2008, 2009, and 2010 were 45.9, 48, and 44
respectively). Although debt financing in the capital structure of BHP Billiton is slightly
higher than industry average of 25.8, it lower than sector average of 39.91. Reliance on
capital financing rather than debt financing significantly decreases the risk of default, but also
implies lower returns on investment to shareholders. Return on equity, which measures the
actual return to shareholders, was 40.1%, 14.7%, and 25.8% for fiscal years 2008, 2009, and
2010 respectively. The efficient use of assets to generate profit – return on assets – was
estimated to be 20.24%, 7.4%, and 14.4% respectively. The figures for ROA and ROE are
higher than industry, sector, and S&P 500 averages, implying quite good rate of returns for
There has been a downward trend in the BHP Billiton stock price, which closed at
$37.30 on August 26 and went down by $0.09 or 0.24%. However, given the EPS 228.6 cents
the price to earnings ratio as of August 27, 2010 is 16.32, which is lower than industry
average by 6 positions and may indicate the undervaluation of BHP Billiton’s stock.
Although financial statements for BHP Billiton Limited indicate some areas to
consider improvement into provide shareholders with greater returns, the market analysts
forecast quite good conditions for buying stock option from BHP Billiton due to several
factors: “As a supplier of basic raw materials as well as diamonds, precious metals, and oil,
BHP could function as a bellwether for the global economy, reflecting future industrial output
downstream. BHP clearly expects sales to weaken in the coming months and with demand
slowing, the company is not likely to increase prices. Emerging economies may help in the
interim, but until the global economy grows, the company is likely to report lower future
earnings. It’s also worth noting that depreciation and amortization (non-cash items) added
almost 2 percent to the reported 10 percent in earnings for the year. The company has a well-
reasoned expectation for good performance over the long term. For now, the chart has yet to
establish a bottom, and although oversold, the momentum is clearly to the downside” (Austin,
2010).
maintenance, asset management project and capital management services. The Company
operates in Australia, New Zealand, North America and the Emerging Markets of the United
Arab Emirates, Qatar, New Caledonia, South East Asia, India and Chile and Canada across
diverse industries, including mining and process, hydrocarbons, roads, rail and public
transport, water, power, telecommunications, facilities management and defence. TSE has
gained a strong reputation in the sphere of outsourcing wide range of services and has
Student Name Course Name Assignment Name 11
established a solid base of clients who are chosen for long-term cooperation. More than 80
percent of Company’s services are provided under secure, long-term asset management
contract, which ensure client retention rate over 95 per cent. TSE’s consolidated proprietary
systems place the Company into advantageous position for capturing growth domestically
and in Asia (Transfield Services Ltd, 2010). The major competitive advantage of the
Company is the breadth of service or industry diversity it provides outsourcing for, though
there are a number of competitors who compete in one or another outsourcing service or
industry. The competitors include Downer EDI, United Group, and Leighton.
The TSE stock price fluctuated in the price range between $3.00 and $4.80 during last
52 weeks and closed at $3.18 as of August 27, 2010 with $0.12 (3.92%) increase. Mostly the
stock price is sensitive to announcements form the Company. In this respect, the stock price
went down by 4.50% when TSE announced Construction of National Broadband Network
Site, then a decline by 3.64% was recorded when TSE was awarded a contract from a global
retailer. Another announcement on working project and securing contracts resulted in 2.45%
project, which should boost the price, in reality drives the stock price down. However, it may
be explained with the nature of projects and the timeline needed to accomplish them, which
as a result may dilute the gains from projects, and, consequently, impact stock price
positively at a later point in time (Transfield Services Ltd, 2009; Transfield Services Ltd,
2008).
The financial statements for TSE reveal that financial year 2009 was not quite
successful for the company as a net loss of $55 million was recorded. However, the financial
results for the fiscal year ended June 30, 2010 showed $73 million gain versus last period’s
loss. As well the company announced $4.1 billion in revenues including joint ventures.
Student Name Course Name Assignment Name 12
Although the company has announced profit in the fiscal year 2010, comparable
financial statements do not yet contain comparable information on actual figures. Therefore,
the figures for the fiscal years 2008 and 2009 are discussed further in the paper.
Unfortunately the available information shows that TSE incurred great loss in previous
financial year, which affected margins and returns negatively. Thus, though the gross profit
margin is 53.87, net profit, operating profit and EBITD are negative and equal -1.60, -1.89,
and -0.50 respectively. Returns on assets and equity are also negative – -2.84 and -7.60 –
which implies the company does not generate enough sales to provide for its own operations.
Furthermore, TSE relies on debt financing as 62.79% of capital structure comes from debt,
which puts the company at default risk if it does not improve revenue and profit margins. For
this matter, it is suggested to consider operating expense as namely this part of cost structure
was improved in fiscal year 2010 and resulted in a net profit rather than net loss. Therefore,
financial strength measures indicate quite weak condition of the Company at the time
The estimated valuation measure indicate the EPS of 21.9, 16.3 and negative -5 for
the years 2007, 2008 and 2009 respectively. Despite all the negative figures and loss from the
previous fiscal year 2009, taking into consideration the announced NPAT of $73 million, the
Company is going to pay out dividends of $0.12 per share payable in September.
stage from the loss it incurred in the fiscal year 2009. However, the Company management
assures in bright prospects for the company operations due to sufficient and effective
targeting at mid-single digit growth in net profit for the 2010/11 financial year, excluding any
restructuring or cost reduction initiatives. Also, according to Goode, TSE CEO “the group's
the business would continue into 2011” as well as “the ongoing business efficiency
Student Name Course Name Assignment Name 13
improvements and lower cost base of the US business would drive growth in 2010/11”
Decision Making
of the three companies, the financial statements of Woolworths Limited, BHP Billiton, and
Transfield Service Limited were analysed within financial ratio analysis. The general
information on industry and sector averages was obtained in order to compare ratios of a
company actions that could have impacted the financial figures and the valuation in the
market was considered for making the decision. In general, financial ratios are very valuable
evaluating current and future financial situation of a company, and identification of potential
This project enabled us with understanding about the reasons why the financial
statements are analysed. In general, financial ratios provide an insight for the senior
management, investors, and other stakeholders involved in the investment activity. Financial
ratios enable to understand financial risks and forecast ROI (Return on investments) in a firm.
Moreover, the financial analysts are able to develop a main framework that can be used
After careful analysis of the companies, Transfield Service Limited is the most
unattractive company for investment in regards to the last fiscal year’s loss and no particular
action plan for the future. Although, its stock’ prospects for earning dividend yield are quite
appealing, the negative earnings and negative returns make the option not desirable at the
moment. However, those who hold on to the Transfield Service Limited stock now will
The most stable entity for investment is Woolworths Limited, which has positive
trends in its financials and stock market price. However, despite the fact that there are some
minor negative changes in BHP Billiton stock price, the forecasts of financial analysts are
positive in terms of future returns when demand for natural resources and overall economic
health stabilizes. Therefore, in order to safeguard investment 80 percent of it, namely $8,000,
is suggested to invest into safe option of Woolworths stock and 20 percent – $20,000 – into
BHP Billiton’s stock that will bring greater benefits at a later point in time.
Woolworths Limited
2008 2009 2010
(49,594.8- (51,694.3 - 49,594.8)/
Sales Growth 47,034.8)/47,034.8*100%=5,5% 49,594.8*100%=4,2%
Return on net
sales 1,651.5/47,034.8=3.5% 1,860.0/49,594.8*100%=3.6% 2,038/51,694.3*100%=4.1%
ROA (return
on assets) 1,651.5/15044.3*100%=11% 1860,0/16378.7*100%=11.4% 2,038/17873.9*100%=15%
ROE (return
on equity) 1,651.5/5880.75=28% 1,860.0/6646.3*100%=28.1% 2,038/7399=26%
References
Austin C. (2010) BHP Billiton (BHP) Pins Performance to Emerging Economies. Wall Street
Cheatsheet. [internet] Available at: http://wallstcheatsheet.com/trading-markets/bhp-
billiton-bhp-pins-performance-to-emerging-economies/?p=17091/ [Accessed 27
August, 2010].
Australian Securities Exchange (ASX). (2010) Consumer Sector Profile 2010. Australian
Securities Exchange [Online] Available at:
http://www.asx.com.au/research/pdf/consumer_sector_factsheet.pdf [Accessed 27
August, 2010].
BHP Billiton Limited (2008). Annual Report 2008. BHP Billiton Limited [Online] Available
at: http://www.bhpbilliton.com/annualreports2008/2008-business-review-and-annual-
report [Accessed 27 August, 2010].
BHP Billiton Limited (2008). Annual Report 2008. BHP Billiton Limited [Online] Available
at: http://www.bhpbilliton.com/bbContentRepository/docs/annualReport2009.pdf
[Accessed 27 August, 2010].
Bhushan, A. (2010) Potash Corporation Rejects Australian BHP Billiton’s Hostile Bid, Next
– China’s Sinochem Brazil’s Vale. CEOWORLD Magazine. [internet] Available at:
http://ceoworld.biz/ceo/2010/08/23/potash-corporation-rejects-australian-bhp-
billiton’s-hostile-bid-next-chinas-sinochem-brazils-vale [Accessed 27 August, 2010].
Business Spectator. (2010) Transfield returns to FY profit Business Spectator [internet].
Available at: http://www.businessspectator.com.au/bs.nsf/Article/Transfield-returns-
to-FY-profit-8P3EJ?OpenDocument&rf=s [Retrieved August 28, 2010].
Business Spectator. (2010) TSI Fund sells Mt Miller wind farm for $191m Business
Spectator [internet]. Available at:
http://www.businessspectator.com.au/bs.nsf/Article/TSI-Fund-sells-Mt-Miller-wind-
farm-for-191m-pd20100531-5YAE3?OpenDocument [Retrieved August 28, 2010].
Chambers, M. (2009). Canada's First Quantum wins bid to revive Ravensthorpe nickel mine.
The Australian. [internet] Available at:
http://www.theaustralian.com.au/business/canadas-first-quantum-wins-bid-to-revive-
ravensthorpe-nickel-mine/story-e6frg8zx-1225808811378 [Accessed 27 August,
2010].
Corporate Information.(2010) BHP Billiton Limited: Corporate Information snapshots.
Corporate Information [internet] Available at:
http://corporateinformation.com/Company-Snapshot.aspx?cusip=C03691080
[Accessed 27 August, 2010].
Fenner, R. (2010). Australian Retailers to Benefit From Early Election Call, Woolworths
Says. Bloomberg, . [internet] Available at: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2010-07-
21/australian-retailers-to-benefit-from-early-election-call-woolworths-says.html
[Accessed 27 August, 2010].
Horngren, Best, Fraser, Willett. (2010) Accounting (6th ed.). Pearson Australia.
Student Name Course Name Assignment Name 16
Transfield Services Ltd. (2008) Transfield Services Limited Annual Report 2009.Transfield
Services Ltd. [Online]. Available at:
http://www.transfieldservices.com/page/News_Centre/RSS_Feeds/Latest_News_from
_Transfield_Services/Transfield_Services_2008_Annual_Report [Retrieved August
28, 2010].
Transfield Services Ltd. (2009) Transfield Services Limited Annual Report 2009.Transfield
Services Ltd. [Online]. Available at:
http://www.transfieldservices.com/page/News_Centre/RSS_Feeds/Latest_News_from
_Transfield_Services/Transfield_Services_2009_Annual_Report [Retrieved August
28, 2010].
Woolworth Limited (2009). Annual Report 2009. Woolworth Limited [Online] Available at:
http://www.woolworthslimited.com.au/phoenix.zhtml?c=144044&p=irol-
reportsannual [Accessed 27 August, 2010].
Woolworth Limited. (2010) Woolworths Announces $700 million Off-Market Share Buy-
Back. Woolworths Limited [internet] Available at:
http://www.asx.com.au/asxpdf/20100826/pdf/31s3kg350hgsqh.pdf [Accessed 27
August, 2010].
Woolworths Limited (2010). Corporate Information. Woolworths Limited [internet]Available
at: http://corporateinformation.com/Company-Snapshot.aspx?cusip=C03653970
[Accessed 27 August, 2010].
Woolworths Limited. (2010). Company Results Full Year Ended June 27, 2010. Woolworths
Limited . [internet]Available at: http://media.corporate-
ir.net/media_files/irol/14/144044/FY10AnalystPresentation.pdf [Accessed 27 August,
2010].
Woolworths Limited. (2008). Annual Report 2008. Woolworths Limited [Online] Available
at: http://www.woolworthslimited.com.au/phoenix.zhtml?c=144044&p=irol-
reportsannual [Accessed 27s August, 2010].