Professional Documents
Culture Documents
INTRODUCTION TO ETHICS
HS30070
C Chakraborti
Dept of HSS
2008
C Chakraborti
IIT KGP Intro to Ethics, A-2010
Limitations of Utilitarianism
1. Problem of measurement:
2. 1.1. Are all ‘pleasures’, ‘pains’
quantifiable? E.g. Value of life,
health, etc.
3.
Non-consequentialist position:
Non-consequentialist position:
judges the rightness or wrongness of an
action based on properties intrinsic to
the action, not on its consequences
z ‘I should do this’
z ‘I should NOT do this’
Personhood:
Example:
Bhagavadgita : NISHKAMA KARMA
(action without any desire for
consequence).
1. Justice theories:
The aim …
zIs to develop good virtues, so that
the right choices become more of a
habit, followed by right actions
z Involves prohairesis: a virtuous
person will choose to do the virtuous
things
zTo avoid the vices, which also will
rule our choices, actions, and
eventually who we are.
Causing Harm
Criminal Intention
(Murder) (culpable homicide)
Manslaughter
X did by commission X did by commission
or omission or omission
so-and-so to Y so-and-so to Y
with the intention, or with without the intention,
the knowledge or without the
that thereby knowledge
X is likely to that thereby X is likely
cause the death of Y to cause the death of
Y.
Abetting a murder
CYBERETHICS
BUSINESS ETHICS
ENGINEERING
ETHICS
BIO ETHICS
C Chakraborti
IIT KGP Intro to Ethics, A-2008
A stakeholder:
“any group or individual who can affect or is
affected by the achievement of the
organization’s objectives” (Freeman 1984,
46)
C Chakraborti
IIT KGP Intro to Ethics, A-2008
Environmental Ethics
Ecology: First use attributed to German
biologist Ernst Haeckel in 1860s.
Two Greek words:
Eko (home, household) + Logos (Study,
discourse)
It is the logos / study of living organisms in
their home / natural habitat
Ecosystem:
A complex system of relationships among
living resources, habitats and residents of a
region.
-not just linear relations, but very
complex relationships within particular
species, and across the species [In Origin of
Species, Darwin referred to “web of
complex relationships”]
-not parts and whole
-not just causally connected in one
direction, but also there are feedback loops,
and marked interdependence among
various forms of life, and non-living
elements
WEB OF LIFE
C Chakraborti
IIT KGP Intro to Ethics, A-2008
ANCIENT VIEW:
Human-centeredness: ANTHROPOCENTRISM
*That the world belongs to humans alone
For example:
Aristotle: nature has made all things
specifically for the sake of man (Politics,
Bk. 1, Ch. 8)
Criticisms:
ECOLOGICAL ETHICS:
No ground for anthropocentric attitude, it
should be replaced by bio-centric
egalitarianism: everyone in a ecological
system has equal right to be there,
C Chakraborti
IIT KGP Intro to Ethics, A-2008
Ecofeminism:
More on Ecofeminism:
Ethics of care
Radical examples:
-Obligations that a mother (parents) feels for
‘caring for’ a child with terminal illness
- Obligations towards the bereaved family of
a departed, very good friend
Environmental Justice:
Key issue is the inequity in the distribution
of burden of environmental degradation +
depletion borne by certain groups (the poor,
the women, the racial minorities, the less
developed countries)
2. Conservation
Central Govt is empowered to declare some
areas as Ecologically Sensitive Areas (ESA)
or Ecologically Fragile Areas (EFA) and
thereby granting it a special protection
status.
-1989, Doon Valley, Uttaranchal
[prohibitsthe setting up of an industry in which
the daily consumption of coal/fuel is more than
24 MT (million tonnes) per day in the Doon
Valley.]
-1989, Murud-Janjira (fragile coastal ecology
& heritage), Maharashta,
-1992, Aravalli Hills, to save from large scale
mining
-1996, ‘No development zone’ 15 km radius
of Numaligarh refinery, to save Kaziranga
National Park, Assam
-2001, Mahabaleswar, Panchgani and 2003 Matheran,
to save from human impact and unplanned tourism
C Chakraborti
IIT KGP Intro to Ethics, A-2008
Concept of SUSTAINABLE
DEVELOPMENT: How to have the cake
and eat it too?
-To bridge the gulf between development
and environment
Defn 1. “Meeting the needs of the present
without compromising the ability of future
generations to meet their own needs”
(Brundtland Report, World Commission on Environment and
Development, 1987)