Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442 Filed01/12/10 Page1 of 5

1 GIBSON, DUNN & CRUTCHER LLP

Theodore B. Olson, SBN 38137
2 tolson@gibsondunn.com
Matthew D. McGill, pro hac vice
3 Amir C. Tayrani, SBN 229609
1050 Connecticut Avenue, N.W., Washington, D.C. 20036
4 Telephone: (202) 955-8668, Facsimile: (202) 467-0539

5 Theodore J. Boutrous, Jr., SBN 132009

tboutrous@gibsondunn.com
6 Christopher D. Dusseault, SBN 177557
Ethan D. Dettmer, SBN 196046
7 Sarah E. Piepmeier, SBN 227094
Theane Evangelis Kapur, SBN 243570
8 Enrique A. Monagas, SBN 239087
333 S. Grand Avenue, Los Angeles, California 90071
9 Telephone: (213) 229-7804, Facsimile: (213) 229-7520

10 BOIES, SCHILLER & FLEXNER LLP

David Boies, pro hac vice
11 dboies@bsfllp.com
333 Main Street, Armonk, New York 10504
12 Telephone: (914) 749-8200, Facsimile: (914) 749-8300

13 Jeremy M. Goldman, SBN 218888

jgoldman@bsfllp.com
14 Theodore H. Uno, SBN 248603
1999 Harrison Street, Suite 900, Oakland, California 94612
15 Telephone: (510) 874-1000, Facsimile: (510) 874-1460

16 Attorneys for Plaintiffs

KRISTIN M. PERRY, SANDRA B. STIER,
17 PAUL T. KATAMI, and JEFFREY J. ZARRILLO

18 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

19 NORTHERN DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

20 KRISTIN M. PERRY, et al., CASE NO. 09-CV-2292 VRW

21 Plaintiffs,
and DECLARATION OF REBECCA JUSTICE
22 LAZARUS IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’
CITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO,
OPPOSITION TO HAK-SHING WILLIAM
23 Plaintiff-Intervenor, TAM’S MOTION TO WITHDRAW
v.
24
ARNOLD SCHWARZENEGGER, et al., Trial Date: January 11, 2010
25 Defendants, Judge: Chief Judge Walker
and Location: Courtroom 6, 17th Floor
26
PROPOSITION 8 OFFICIAL PROPONENTS
27 DENNIS HOLLINGSWORTH, et al.,
28 Defendant-Intervenors.

Gibson, Dunn &

Crutcher LLP
09-CV-2292 VRW DECLARATION OF REBECCA JUSTICE LAZARUS IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’
OPPOSITION TO TAM’S MOTION TO WITHDRAW
 Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442 Filed01/12/10 Page2 of 5

1 I, Rebecca Justice Lazarus, declare as follows:

2 1. I, Rebecca Justice Lazarus, am an attorney at law, duly licensed to practice before all
3
courts of the State of California and before the United States District Court for the Northern District
4
of California. I am an associate with Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher LLP, counsel of record for Plaintiffs
5
in the above-captioned matter. I have personal knowledge of the facts stated herein and could and
6

7 would testify competently thereto if called upon to do so.

8 2. On January 12, 2010, I directed my colleague, Serena Liu, to access Dr. Tam’s

9 website at http://billtam.homsestead.com/articles.html and retrieve “Articles on Parenting.” Attached

10
hereto as Exhibit A is a true and correct copy of a print out of this webpage.
11
3. On January 12, 2010, I directed my colleague, Serena Liu, to access Dr. Tam’s
12
website at http://billtam.homsestead.com/articles2.html and retrieve a page containing additional
13
articles on topics related to Proposition 8. Articles on this page include those titled: “Articles on
14

15 Science and Creation,” “Articles on Spousal Relationships,” “Articles on Social Issues,” and

16 “Miscellaneous Topics.” Attached hereto as Exhibit B is a true and correct copy of a print out of this

17 webpage.
18
4. On January 12, 2010, I directed my colleague, Serena Liu, to access Dr. Tam’s
19
website at http://billtam.homsestead.com/articles.html and click on “Brokeback” to retrieve a Chinese
20
language document, which the webpage indicates is about how “Brokeback Mountain breaks
21
families.” Attached hereto as Exhibit C is a true and correct copy of this article.
22

23 5. On January 12, 2010, I directed my colleague, Serena Liu, to access Dr. Tam’s

24 website at http://billtam.homsestead.com/articles.html and click on the “Divorce” link to retrieve a

25 Chinese language article. Attached hereto as Exhibit D is a true and correct copy of this article.
26
6. On January 12, 2010, I directed my colleague, Serena Liu, to access Dr. Tam’s
27
website at http://billtam.homsestead.com/articles.html and clicked on the “Homosexuality” link to
28
1
Gibson, Dunn & 09-CV-2292 VRW DECLARATION OF REBECCA JUSTICE LAZARUS IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’
Crutcher LLP OPPOSITION TO TAM’S MOTION TO WITHDRAW
 Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442 Filed01/12/10 Page3 of 5

1 retrieve a Chinese language article. Attached hereto as Exhibit E is a true and correct copy of this
2 article.
3
7. On January 12, 2010, I directed my colleague, Serena Liu, to access Dr. Tam’s
4
website at http://billtam.homsestead.com/articles.html and click on the “ssm_kids” link to retrieve a
5
Chinese language article. Attached hereto as Exhibit F is a true and correct copy of this article.
6

7 8. On January 12, 2010, I directed my colleague, Serena Liu, to access Dr. Tam’s

8 website at http://billtam.homestead.com/articles2.html and click on the “ss_marriage.htm” link under

9 “Articles on Social Issues” to retrieve a Chinese language article. Attached hereto as Exhibit G is a
10
true and correct copy of this article.
11
9. Attached hereto as Exhibit H is a true and correct copy of the Traditional Family
12
Coalition Newsletter, Volume 3, Issue 3 (July-Dec. 2008), bates number DEFINT_PM_005075,
13
which was produced on December, 28, 2009 in Defendant Intervenor’s Seventh Production.
14

15 10. On January 12, 2010, I directed my colleague, Serena Liu, to access Presence

16 Ministry's website at http://presencefamily.org and click on the “Products” link and then click on the

17 link for the “FAQ: Same-Sex Marriage & Homosexuality” DVD. Attached hereto as Exhibit I is a
18
true and correct copy of a printout of this webpage where this product is for sale.
19
11. On January 12, 2010, I directed my colleague, Serena Liu, to access Presence
20
Ministry's website at http://presencefamily.org and click on the “Products” link and then click on the
21
link for the “Sexual Brokenness Conference” DVD. Attached hereto as Exhibit J is a true and
22

23 correct copy of a printout of this webpage where this product is for sale.

24 12. On January 12, 2010, I directed my colleague, Serena Liu, to access Presence
25 Ministry's website at http://presencefamily.org and clicked on the “Products” link and then clicked on
26
the link for the “Church, Stand Up As Salt and Light” book. Attached hereto as Exhibit K is a true
27
and correct copy of a printout of this webpage where this product is for sale.
28
2
Gibson, Dunn & 09-CV-2292 VRW DECLARATION OF REBECCA JUSTICE LAZARUS IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’
Crutcher LLP OPPOSITION TO TAM’S MOTION TO WITHDRAW
 Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442 Filed01/12/10 Page4 of 5

1 13. Attached hereto as Exhibit L is a true and correct copy of the cover letter to the
2 supplemental production of documents being produced in accordance with Magistrate Judge Spero’s
3
Order of January 8, 2010, sent from Nicole Moss to Rebecca Justice Lazarus on January 10, 2010.
4
14. On January 10, 2010, I e-mailed Nicole Moss, counsel for Proponents to inquire
5
whether Proponents intend to produce all responsive documents authored or received by William
6

7 Tam that were, as of January 6, 2010, in Proponents’ possession, custody or control. Ms. Moss

8 responded to that e-mail on January 11, 2010 and stated that she would need to check with Dr. Tam’s

9 counsel in order to respond to my inquiry. Attached hereto as Exhibit M is a true and correct copy of
10
that e-mail chain.
11
15. I did not receive any further communication on this point from Ms. Moss.
12
16. On January 12, 2010, my colleague, Ethan Dettmer, sent an e-mail message to Terry
13
Thompson, counsel for Dr. Tam, and Nicole Moss, counsel for Proponents inquiring as to (1) when
14

15 Plaintiffs can expect to receive all responsive documents authored or received by Dr. Tam in his

16 possession, custody or control; and (2) arrangements for his appearance at trial, if any. I was copied

17 on that e-mail message. Attached hereto as Exhibit N is a true and correct copy of that email
18
message.
19
17. We have not received any response to this e-mail message.
20
18. Attached hereto as Exhibit O is a true and correct copy of selected portions of the
21
transcript of Hak-Shing William Tam’s deposition taken December 1, 2009.
22

23 I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is true and correct. Executed this 12th
24 day of January, 2010.
25
By: /s/
26 Rebecca Justice Lazarus

27

28
3
Gibson, Dunn & 09-CV-2292 VRW DECLARATION OF REBECCA JUSTICE LAZARUS IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’
Crutcher LLP OPPOSITION TO TAM’S MOTION TO WITHDRAW
 Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442 Filed01/12/10 Page5 of 5

1 ATTESTATION PURSUANT TO GENERAL ORDER NO. 45

2 Pursuant to General Order No. 45 of the Northern District of California, I attest that

3 concurrence in the filing of the document has been obtained from each of the other signatories to this

4 document.

5 /s/ Theodore Boutrous, Jr

Theodore Boutrous, Jr.
6

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28
1
Gibson, Dunn & 09-CV-2292 VRW DECLARATION OF REBECCA JUSTICE LAZARUS IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS’
Crutcher LLP OPPOSITION TO TAM’S MOTION TO WITHDRAW
Case3:09-cv-02292-JW Document442-1 Filed01/12/10 Page1 of 3

Exhibit A
Articles Page 1 of 2
Case3:09-cv-02292-JW Document442-1 Filed01/12/10 Page2 of 3

Articles on Parenting
The following articles are written in Chinese. Most of them were published by Chinese Christian Herald.
Please click on the link to view.

Parenting
Academics When children have problems with academics .....

Again If only time can let them 'reboot' ......

Boy The difficulties of boyhood ......

College What your children are learning in college ......

Courage Courage does not mean no fear .....

Creativity Develop your child's creativity ......

Dating "Mom, when can I start dating?"

Divorce The death of a marriage ........

Food Wise eating starts at young age .....

Games What's capturing your boy's heart?

Gifted Gifted children needs special care, too ......

Harry Potter A good guy? A bad guy?

Homosexuality Cause and prevention, an interview with Dr. Melvin Wong ......

Let Go Letting go with your child, a parent's toughest job .....

Let Go 2 What? One more time?

Materialism Yes, it is a learned behavior. It can be unlearned too .......

Music Know the music ......

New Age Understand the New Age Movement, it's everywhere ......

Obey Is it good if your children always obey you ?

Parenting Are you fit for parenting?

Perfection The problem with perfectionism ......

Political Train them in political wisdom .....

Poisonous words Don't use it on your family ......

Rebel Is it always bad if your children rebel against you ?

Righteous Righteousness is a lost virtue; it's up to you to bring back to your family .....

Sad Let's share your saddness ......

http://billtam.homestead.com/articles.html 1/12/2010
Articles Page 2 of 2
Case3:09-cv-02292-JW Document442-1 Filed01/12/10 Page3 of 3

Sc Fiction Your child's fanatasy world of science ......

Schools What's wrong with public schools?

Sex safety Protect your children from sexual perpetrator ......

Sleepy A new generation of sleep-deprived youth ......

ssm_kids How same-sex marriage would harm our children .....

son Like father, like son?

Web games Addicted to internet games ......

Without God What happens to the society without God?

Wisdom True wisdom is hard to get .....

Brokeback "Brokeback Mountain" breaks families

Cream See the status of some cream of the crop students

Click here to
More articles: Science/creation,
Relationships,
Social issues,
homosexual issues, etc.

http://billtam.homestead.com/articles.html 1/12/2010
Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-2 Filed01/12/10 Page1 of 3

Exhibit B
 Page 1 of 2
Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-2 Filed01/12/10 Page2 of 3

Bill Tam, Ph.D.

The following articles are written in Chinese. Most of them were published by Chinese
Christian Herald. Please click on the colored buttons to view content.

Articles on Science and Creation :

animal.jpg biosphere.jpg earth.jpg et1.jpg et2.jpg

Did animals evolve? Man-made earth? Earth is alive?

NEW

incarnation.jpg Miller.htm monkey.htm organs.htm 2nd_law.htm

Former life? Stanley Miller's Monkey to man? Learn from 2nd law of thermodynamics
experiment artificial organs

Articles on Spousal Relationships :

blood_no_tears.doc middle_age.htm

Articles on Social Issues :

Affirmative Action
Gay_genes.htm sad_song_of_SF.htm Same Sex Marriage ss_marriage.htm

Miscellaneous Topics :

chem_weapon.htm Depression.htm Emperor.htm slimming.jpg Bush.htm B_vs_K.htm

The Emperor's Club

http://billtam.homestead.com/articles2.html 1/12/2010
 Page 2 of 2
Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-2 Filed01/12/10 Page3 of 3

Home

http://billtam.homestead.com/articles2.html 1/12/2010
Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-3 Filed01/12/10 Page1 of 3

Exhibit C
「斷背山」---破壞家庭的電影 Page 1 of 2
Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-3 Filed01/12/10 Page2 of 3

「斷背山」---破壞家庭的電影

譚克成
1/17/06

李安導演的「斷背山」，被荷李活譽為羅曼蒂克的愛情故事，故事描述六十年代兩青年牛

郎在斷背山上看羊時，由友誼關係發展成同性戀的性關係，後來二人分別與女子結婚生子，可

是不能禁止同性戀的情慾，屢次欺騙妻子到斷背山幽會，後來其中一人為此而離婚，另一人要

求兩人同居，但因社會環境保守而不能如願，電影最終以一人意外身亡而落幕。

「斷背山」不論拍得如何美化，也遮掩不了它的醜惡一面：

1. 破壞男子漢的形像

美國中部的牛郎 (cowboy)，是男子漢的形像，以往持有像尊榮 (John Wayne)和奇連依士活

(Clint Eastwood)的剛強和英雄的形像，是美國男孩子追求的模範，這套電影把他們醜化為好

勇鬥狠，頭腦簡單的人，不斷以蠻力和打鬥來解決問題，而兩男主角的性愛，也是充滿了野

獸般的粗野。

2. 誤導男人間的友誼昇華時就變成性接觸

很多男人在各種不同工作的環境或許需要作近距離的相處，例如軍隊、童子軍、球隊、大學

宿舍等。此電影將「性」帶入了兩男人的工作關係中，不單染污了男性間單純的友誼。對於

愛模仿電影中的人物的年輕人，現將這可能性向他們宣場，後果不堪設想。

http://billtam.homestead.com/brokeback.htm 1/12/2010
「斷背山」---破壞家庭的電影 Page 2 of 2
Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-3 Filed01/12/10 Page3 of 3

3. 同性戀關係較男女婚姻崇高

「斷背山」可能沒有明顯推崇這觀念，而且還描寫了同性戀婚外情對妻子的傷害，但影評

家、荷李活和傳媒都莫視了這一點，反而高舉這段同性戀情，是值得犧牲家庭的；片中又暗

示有妻子和兒女的家庭是多麼麻煩，同性戀是多麼浪漫，作妻子的不明白，可是作女兒的卻

明白，體諒與母親離婚的父親，間接地教導下一代要接受同性戀，這些隱藏而帶破壞性的信

息，對下一代為害無窮。

4. 暗示社會禮教是害人的

此片描述這段同性戀情的痛苦，使主角以罵妻子、打架、嫖男妓等方式來發洩。最後以一方

死、一方愁的悲劇收場，表面是表現同性戀負面的信息，但暗裏卻抱怨這悲劇的發生是因為

六十年代社會太保守，不能容許同性伴侶，否則他們會活得很快樂。

荷李活高捧這套同性戀的電影，不單止給與好評，還頒發４個金球獎，娛樂界要極力介紹同

性戀的電影，是要打破傳統的禮教，讓放縱情慾的人，可在無罪惡感的情況下自由自在地繼續

放縱，而社會需要無條件地接受。利用潮流文化來推廣破壞家庭的電影，是現代文化的悲劇；

李安導演拍這種片子，等於加入破壞的行列，是華人的悲劇。

http://billtam.homestead.com/brokeback.htm 1/12/2010
Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-4 Filed01/12/10 Page1 of 3

Exhibit D
健康的父親：家庭的祝福 Page 1 of 2
Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-4 Filed01/12/10 Page2 of 3

婚姻非兒戲

譚克成

二月十四曰是「情人節」，當各地的夫妻或情人互送禮物，溫馨慶祝時，三藩市的紐森市長卻聚集了一羣同性戀者，在市政府大

樓開記者會，慶祝他在去年「情人節」時向四千多對同性戀者頒發結婚證書，並揚言雖然他的做法被州政府否認了，但他還會為同性

婚姻爭取合法地位，他「英雄」式的宣言，在三藩市的電視和報章上，也得到英雄式的宣傳。

現代兒戲婚姻

在去年二月，三藩市政府頒發同性婚姻證書時，最義正嚴詞、令人囑目的人物便是紐森市長和估值官鄧式美，他們的論調是：只

要任何兩人相愛便可結婚，他們可以享受的婚姻，同性戀者也可享受。當時看來，他們是多麼的追求婚姻的好處，可惜還不到一年，

在今年一月，紐森市長和鄧式美女士，都分別和他/她們的配偶辦離婚手續，他們一方面推崇同性婚姻，一方面自己的婚姻正在瓦解，

新時代的婚姻莫非真是如此兒戲？

離婚 = 婚姻的死亡

當一個人病危死亡前，家人一定都盡力挽救；可是當一段婚姻死亡時，夫妻雙

方都有責任導致它的滅亡。離婚不是偶然發生，而是經年累月，夫妻因自私自

大，不願顧及對方的利益和感受，做出傷害對方的事，而引至離婚，而這決定

多半是雙方放棄這段婚姻而讓它死亡。

圖表顯示單親家庭在三十年來不斷增加
看看離婚的原因，不外是因婚外情、賭博、醉酒、吸毒、虐待、工作狂等因素， 來源: The Cultural Index, by William Bennett.

這都是有一方認為自己的享受凌架於一切，不尊重自己結婚時所許下的諾言，

也不尊重對方的感受和傷害，更不顧及對孩子們做成的創傷，所以美國每年離婚

的個案，是結婚個案的一半，這便是「自我時代」 (me generation) 的產物。

離婚 = 破碎孩子的夢

離婚不但夫妻難過結怨，孩子們也感到失落，家庭由雙親變成單親，不是容易接受的事，他們表面可能裝作若無其事，但心裏卻

mhtml:http://billtam.homestead.com/marriage.mht 1/12/2010
健康的父親：家庭的祝福 Page 2 of 2
Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-4 Filed01/12/10 Page3 of 3

充滿了仇恨，也會感到自卑，對將來失去信心，對人也產生懷疑。在行為上，他們不喜歡回家，多在外溜連，亦可能會提早結交異

性、讓談情說愛來填補心裏的空虛，也有可能以濫交、吸毒、醉酒、參加幫派來表示向父母抗議和報復。單親家庭的孩子，較易在學

校產生搗亂和無心向學的問題。他日長大後，對自己的婚姻和教養子女，也會產生恐懼和逃避。若是單親家長再婚，他們便要對繼父

或繼母作新的適應，甚或要適應突然增加的兄弟姊妹，再要應付繼父繼母偏心的問題，這種種的壓力，當他想起是誰引起時，便會對

那位離開他原生家庭的父或母更怨恨，在他心目中，是這位離棄婚姻的父或母毀了他的夢。

唯恐世界不亂

聖經希伯來書13章4節說：「人人都應該尊重婚姻，婚床也不要沾污，因為神一定審判淫亂的和姦淫的人。」據研究顯示，美國異性

戀者一生人平均共有四個性伴侶，便已弄得一半婚姻以離婚收塲的局面，而同性戀者一生人平均有五十個性伴侶，你可想像他們的婚

姻能維持多久？現代的婚姻已有如此多的問題，自由派的政客自己的婚姻也搞不好，還要加插「同性婚姻」，我們的下一代是否遭

殃？

(作者網址：www.BillTam.org)

Feb. 14, 2005

mhtml:http://billtam.homestead.com/marriage.mht 1/12/2010
Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-5 Filed01/12/10 Page1 of 5

Exhibit E
Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-5 Filed01/12/10 Page2 of 5

誰的子女容易變為同性戀者？

訪問黃偉康博士

譚克成筆述

黃偉康博士是加州執業的心理學家,有多年輔導同性戀者的臨床經驗, 他也

幫助同性戀者恢復異性戀的生活,並經常作專題講座,由於近年華裔青少年同性戀

的個案增多,現將訪問黃博士的內容綜合以文章方式發表,希望可幫助家長們預防

子女變成同性戀者。

男同性戀者的形成

同性戀者多出自問題家庭,一個家庭中的爸爸如果不扮演好他的角色,例如常

不在家,或在家時情感上與子女脫節,是種下子女演變為同性戀傾向的根基,如果

作父親的性傾向不穩定,或自己也是從破碎家庭中由媽媽或婆婆養大,沒有享受父

愛, 不懂得如何與自己的兒子建立正常的父子關係, 或在感情上拒絕與兒子親密,

那麼子女對自己的價值和性的角色便大打節扣,傾向同性戀的機會便會增加。子

女在兩三歲時很需要父母的愛,如果父親不在,便單與媽媽建立密切的關係,而媽

媽缺乏丈夫的愛, 便將自己的感情完全寄托在兒子身上, 如果家中還有姐妹的話,

兒子習慣在多女性的圈子中生活,自己的感情和情緒發展的模式便變得女性化,

容易產生性向混亂(gender identity disorder) 的問題,而當他長大成為少年時, 仍沒

有機會改正這性向混亂的話,他會變為同性戀者的機會是 75%,這種情形下長大的
Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-5 Filed01/12/10 Page3 of 5

男孩子害怕與別的男孩子玩, 因為他們太粗暴, 感到與女孩子一起較為舒服, 他們

也不喜歡參加具競爭性的集体運動,反而愛好技術性的個人運動,如跳水和溜冰

等。

在一個不健全的家庭中, 每一個成員都經歷著一種感情上適者生存的掙扎,

爸爸常不在家時,媽媽缺乏了安全感,便轉向兒子身上處獲取,例如和年幼的兒子

同床睡和一起生活, 媽媽為了平衡自已心理上的空虛和不足, 要兒子來填補空缺,

完全支配了兒子的生活,但結果是吞噬了兒子建立男子氣概的机會,這種情形下的

男孩子性情較溫柔,善解人意,媽媽更加喜歡,但他暗中對男性有一種好奇,如果不

幸地遇上了戀童癖者,被其誘姦,便會以為與男性的關係是建立在性關係上,如沒

有父親的欣賞和關注,這种渴望便可能通過與其他年長男性的性關係來填滿, 得

到滿足, 於是對男性會產生性興奮的生理反應, 對觀感上和身体上的美很重視, 要

求自己達到美男子的地步,他長大後便變成典型的同性戀者,而且他也很可能誘姦

年幼的男童,由於大部份亞裔男童都較為溫順,容易被戀童癖者視為獵物,統計上

男同性戀者有百份之七十是小時曾被人性侵犯。

女同性戀者的形成

一個父親在女兒成長中也十分重要,她從母親身上看到女性的認同,但也需要

由父親來肯定自己女性的性向。 六、七歲的女孩子巳需要爸爸告訢她她很可愛,

十五、六歲的少女大都會打扮來吸引男性,可是如果爸爸常不在,要是一回家便打
Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-5 Filed01/12/10 Page4 of 5

打鬧鬧, 醉酒吸毒, 傷害媽媽, 而媽媽則逆來順受, 女兒看見做女人如此低賤, 便容

易心理上抗拒做女人, 因為覺得做女人沒有安全感, 對男人失去了信心, 她可能會

用濫交來對男性作身体上的征服,有些情形是媽媽失婚後另嫁他人或與人同居,女

兒若被後父或母親的男友性侵犯的話,心靈上的傷害很大,因而憎恨男人而變為女

同性戀的可能性很高, 統計上女同性戀者有九成小時後曾被人強姦, 被強姦後這

些女子會下決心不讓同樣事情再發生,於是她會避免打扮得女性化而改扮男性化,

心理上放棄了做女性, 而學男性粗獷的行為, 很多時也學會飲酒, 出入同性戀酒吧,

在這兒她可找到和自己相同遭遇的女同志, 肯定自已新的身份, 她更確定如果表

態自己基本上是男人的話,以前做女人時所受心靈和肉體的傷害便不會再發生,她

見到柔弱的女子時, 便會產生同情和保護的心態, 而被她們吸引, 對於男性化的女

同性戀者,她會產生仰慕和崇拜的心理,也受吸引。女同性戀者互相追求感情上的

安慰多于性方面的滿足,她們認為同性戀的愛比異性戀更為昇華高尚。

預防與醫治

以上的分析,看得出家中作父親的角色甚為重要,他需要作好丈夫也需要作好

爸爸,現代破碎家庭愈來愈多,引致同性戀者也愈來愈多,但有不少人藉口說同性

戀是天生的,一句話便解脫了做父親和丈夫的責任,只是自欺欺人。假若做父親的

能盡責,愛護太太和子女,不搞婚外情,在子女兩三歲時便多和他們建立親密和正

面的關係,向外要教子女在性方面保護自已,不要被人侵犯,那樣他們變同性戀的

機會便會很微。
Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-5 Filed01/12/10 Page5 of 5

若發現子女有同性戀傾向時,需鎮定應付,不要大吵大鬧,更不要將之速出家

門, 將他/她更快的推進同性戀的世界裏, 同性戀者多是受過傷害, 需要父母同情,

冰封三尺非一日之寒,最好全家一同接受心理輔導,要瞭解家庭的歷史和父母子女

的關係,才可慢慢作醫療的工作。(註：若有意作深入研究者,可參考黃博士的基督

徒心理健康網頁,地址是:www.ChristianMentalHealth.com.裡面有學術性和互助的

參考, 相信有一定的幫助。)

完
Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-6 Filed01/12/10 Page1 of 3

Exhibit F
 Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-6 Filed01/12/10 Page2 of 3

同性婚姻對兒童的害處
譚克成

繼三藩市後，紐約和俄立岡卅數個城市都紛紛向同性戀者派發結婚証書，同
性婚姻突然成為全國性新聞，在美國，有一半的婚姻會以離婚收場，禍及很多無辜
的兒童，二十一世紀的婚姻巳經是在危險邊緣，現在還被同性婚姻入侵，使這一代
的兒童更陷入危機狀態。

同性婚姻的背後

同性戀者堅持不讓他/她們結婚是對他們的歧視，便用「要求平等待遇」為
理由而爭取如同異性婚姻一樣的權益，是同性戀者慣用的藉口，也像是很合理的要
求，政客們不可不接受，可是大眾不明白同性婚姻只是同性戀運動的一項「煙幕彈
策略」。

男同性戀者因為大都生活放縱，患上愛滋病和其他重病而死亡的人很多，於
是需要吸引新血進入同性戀的行列；另外，有不少同性戀者玩弄的對像是青少年及
兒童，所以吸引兒童成為同性戀者是一項維持人數和保存新鮮感的主要方法。要是
同性婚姻合法化，吸引兒童便比現在容易得多了，到了那時，學校會從幼稚園就向
兒童教授同性戀是正常，同性家庭多幸福等，孩童得了先入為主的觀念，到青少年
期更在學校接受同性戀性行為的性教育，嚐試同性戀的可能便大大增高，父母若說
同性戀不對，也有可能被控「仇視罪行」，不單如此，電視、電影、玩具和一切娛
樂媒體，也會因見到一個新市場而大量推出同性戀的商品，女性化的男人或男性化
的女人，會變成新時尚，我們的孩子能抵得住這風氣的引誘嗎？

改低合法性交的年齡

同性婚姻的背後跟着的要求是要將合法性交的年齡改低，在歐洲，當一個國
家將合法性交的年齡改低時，上街跳舞慶祝的大都是同性戀者，據Dr.James
Dobson在Bringing_up_Boys一書內記載，英國在數年前巳將合法性交的年齡改低
到十六歲，而法國和瑞典則改為十五歲，加拿大、德國、意大利和冰島已降低到十
 Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-6 Filed01/12/10 Page3 of 3

四歲，最驚人的是西班牙、葡萄牙和荷蘭，巳將合法性交的年齡改低到十二歲。將
這些年齡降低，引誘青年者便不容易受法律制裁。

將罪惡合法化

不單如此，毒品合法化、娼妓合法化和多人婚姻合法化，也是同性戀運動最
終要追求的目標。
在荷蘭，除了多人婚姻還未合法外，其他同性戀運動追求的大都達到了，遠
在八十年代，荷蘭已娼妓合法化，同性婚姻更在2001年合法化，而現在的咖啡室
內還售賣毒品，在Rotterdam中央火車站外的一個叫Platform_Zero的廣場內不少青
年人公開地蹲下地上吸食毒品，警察視若無睹，更可惜的是荷蘭現已成為全球最大
的「搖頭丸」出口國，鄰國的青年也深受其害。在丹麥，同性婚姻在九十年代初合
法化，到了現在，丹麥教育部授權製作的性教育光碟內，竟然包含「人獸性交」和
「人吃糞便」(註：吃糞便是一些同性戀性交中的常例)的畫面，一名國會議員還將
這光碟內容放上自己的網站，讓孩子們也可觀看。最近在加拿大 北克省的梅毒新
病例，幾乎全部都來自同性戀者，可是加拿大政府還是要將同性婚姻合法化。在挪
威有一个自由派的城市叫Nordland，那裡百份之八十的嬰兒都是未婚媽媽所生，
因為沒有爸爸的關係，孩童便由政府來拇養，就像牛楠的小牛出生後，由農夫飼養
一樣。這些國家現有的問題，亦可能是美國將來的寫照。

要將一種無恥與墮落的行為合法化，必需要有一個無恥與墮落的政府來配合
，現在美國法律還未讓同性婚姻合法，但一些民主黨市政府和法庭的法官已使用權
力逼美國人接受同性婚姻，他們不會罷休，而我們的孩子將會是無恥與墮落一羣的
獵物。現在布希總統和共和黨則主張保衛一男一女傳统婚姻。親愛的父母們，忠誠
地提醒你，你的反對聲音和選票，將是保衛你兒女的有力武器。
(作者綱網址：www.BillTam.homestead.com)

完
Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-7 Filed01/12/10 Page1 of 3

Exhibit G
ssmarriage Page 1 of 2
Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-7 Filed01/12/10 Page2 of 3

同性婚姻不是同等權利

在二月十二日三藩市紐森市長下令頒發同性婚姻証書，由市估值官鄧式美為同性婚姻主持儀
式，打破了人類歷史以來設訂一男一女的婚姻定義，現在讓我們分析他們的論點是如何不合
理。

市長說：同性戀者是小數族裔，不應歧視他們。

同性戀者不是小數族裔。小數族裔的意思是天生皮膚膚色是黑或?等，是由父母的遺傳基因而決
定了下一代的膚色，下一代沒有選擇，也不可自改膚色，所以一出生自然成為小數族裔，所以
「天生不能改」是成為小數族裔的必需條件。

同性戀則不同，現在科學家還找不到引至同性戀的遺傳基因，同性戀是一種愛好的行為，而科
學家卻公認行為是受環境影響下學習得來的，與遺傳基因無關，故同性戀不可能是天生的，也
因這原故，有不少同性戀者經過自制、心理輔導和宗教而成功地脫離了同性戀，很多還與異性
結婚生子，既然他們可以改為異性戀，就証實了同性戀非天生，繼而証實他們不應被列入為小
數族裔。

同性戀者利用「小數族裔」的自稱，博得人同情，是聰明的策略，我們不可受愚弄。

市長說：同性戀者大家相愛，讓他們結婚，是對他們平等待遇。

結婚不可以用平等待遇為理由而給于証書。在所有文明社會中，結婚只限於非有血源關係的一
男一女；不允許兄妹、父子、母女、父女、母子、人獸或成人與孩童通婚，因為這些都被視為
不道德的行為，或會引起畸形後代的問題，所以合法婚姻的必要條件是合道德倫理和顧及後代
為標準的，而不是以平等待遇為標準，也不是單以相愛為標準的。若是三藩市市長或鄧式美要
以平等待遇為理由給同性戀者結婚証書，那他/她也應讓兄妹、父子、母女、父女、母子、兄弟
等結婚，否則他/她們也是歧視這等人。

用「要求平等待遇」為理由而爭取權益，是同性戀者慣用的理由，也是很嚇人的理由，在要求
工作上平等待遇還說得通，但在婚姻上則說不過去，若給他們合法婚姻，他日亂倫者也會以平
等待遇為理由要求結婚証書，社會就倫常大亂了。

結語

http://billtam.homestead.com/ss_marriage.htm 1/12/2010
ssmarriage Page 2 of 2
Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-7 Filed01/12/10 Page3 of 3

若同性戀是正常的行為，就不會出現如愛滋病、肝炎、肺炎等致命的疾病。同性戀在古代也
有，同性戀若是人類的自然演變的話，現代的男同性戀者的直腸內理應長出子官、卵巢等器
官，得以繁殖下一代，女同性戀者也應長出男性生殖器官。故此同性戀是違反天理的不正常行
為，政客硬要我們接受同性戀是正常，還要將同性婚姻合法化，隨?是教科書會改寫，你我的下
一代要學習同性戀的性行為，電視、電影、音樂會歌頌同性戀，亂倫者他日也會要求合法化，
你可想像出將會變成如何的世界？反抗這狂潮，就在今天開始，請寫電郵給:

市長 gavin.newsom@sfgov.org

鄧式美 assessor@sfgov.org

卅長 governor@governor.ca.gov

http://billtam.homestead.com/ss_marriage.htm 1/12/2010
Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-8 Filed01/12/10 Page1 of 5

Exhibit H
 Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-8 Filed01/12/10 Page2 of 5

TRADITIONAL

COALITION
VOLUME 3, ISSUE 3

FA M I LY
T F C N E W S
ொ⛔ኅᐸଦㅴᦩ
JULY–DEC 2008

փኈ ொ⛔ኅᐸଦㅴᦩදഥㅢㆊ╙8⯳ឭ᩺
࿷ㅡਅඨᐕ㧘‫ޟ‬ொኅ‫ޠ‬ദ ะධടᎺ⊛ᢎᦩትொ㧘㥏ൢ ኅ㐳㧘ਗ࿷㔚ⷞ෴⥜ㄕ⺰㧘
ொኅഥ╙8 1 ജදഥዂ৻↵৻ᅚᇕᆪୃᙗ⊛8 ઁ୞෴⥜଻ⴡᇕᆪ⊛ⴕേ‫ޕ‬ ⷹ⌔෻ᙥᄢㇺ⹺ห⼄ඳ჻⊛
⯳ឭ᩺ㅢㆊ ⯳ឭ᩺ᚑὑടᎺᖵผ㧘⼄సᚑ ઁ਽࿷ౌ࿾⊛㔚บዞ8⯳ឭ ⷹ㤭‫ޕ‬
ඳ჻⥜‫ⴡ଻ޟ‬ᇕᆪ⡧⋖‫ޠ‬ว ᩺ㄕ⺰๺ធฃ⸰໧‫ޕ‬੦෴ട  ਃ⮲Ꮢផ಴ੌKឭ
ὑੲ㤘⊔⿠ 1 ૞㧘࿷੟ⵧਛផേ8 ⯳ឭ᩺㧘 ੌ‫ޟ‬ᣂ⟤࿡ᇦ㜚‫⥞ޠ‬ㄐ⊛౐ ᩺㧘᰼ዂᇉᅭวᴺൻ㧘‫ޟ‬ொ
╙8⯳ឭ᩺ ઁ࿷ᄙᚲᢎᦩ‫ޔ‬࿪㜚‫ޔ‬㔚ⷞ‫ޔ‬ ੱㄕ⺰ᄢᦩ‫ޕ‬ਗᐎഥ8⯳ឭ ኅ‫ޠ‬Ꮿ㗔␠ᦩ
㔚บ‫ޔ‬ႎ┨⊛⸰໧ਛ ੱ઀ถ㐿⸥⠪
֭਍ႚอദ 2 ⊔⸒㧘ᒁዉ౏ⴐੌ⸃ ᜗ᓙᦩᒝജ⴫
ৗऱॹ֟‫ڣ‬ ଻ⴡொ⛔ᇕᆪ⊛㊀ⷐ ␜෻ወ‫ޕ‬
ᕈ‫ޟޕ‬ொኅ‫⟤ޟ⥜ޠ‬
TFC HELPS 3
PASSED ࿡࿁ᱩ⌀␹ㆇേ‫ޠ‬ว 11᦬4ᣣ㧘
PROP 8 ૞㧘࿷9᦬ઝ⥞ㄐੌ଻ ᗵ⻢␹㧘ㆬ᳃
YOUTH FOR 3
ⴡᇕᆪ⊛ ᛩ␿ㅢㆊੌ8
MARRIAGE ⑨๔ᄢ ⯳ឭ᩺㧘ุ
ᦩ㧘᦭৻ ᳿ੌ4 ⯳ឭ
WHY I HELP- 3 ජᄙੱ಴ ᩺๺K ឭ
STARTED Ꮸ‫ޕ‬࿷10 ᩺‫ޕ‬ொ⛔ᇕ
PROP 8 ᦬12ᣣ࿷ ᆪᓧએ଻
WHAT CAN 4 ਃ⮲Ꮢ⪇ ሽ㧘หᕈᇕ
YOU DO? ၟ⥞ੌᡰᜬ8⯳ឭ᩺⊛㓸ᦩ㧘ᄢ ᩺❢ㇱ⡧⛊๺ฦ ᆪ㆑ᴺ‫ޕ‬დ
⚂੖⊖ੱ಴Ꮸ‫ޕ‬࿷10ᣣ19ᣣ࿷ ᮪ᢥઙḰ஻⊛Ꮏ૞‫ޕ‬ ⢝೨ㅢ⍮ኅ㐳ᧂ₪ㅢㆊ㧘⠰
Cupertino⥞ㄐੌ੖ජੱ⊛଻ⴡ ਃ⮲Ꮢਇធ⚊ᇉᅭวᴺൻ‫ޕ‬
ᇕᆪᄢㆆⴕ㧘㆐೔ੌትொ⊛ല 㒰ੌ8 ⯳ឭ᩺ᄖ㧘‫ޟ‬ொ ‫ޟ‬ொ⛔ኅᐸଦㅴᦩ‫ޠ‬࿷଻ⴡ
ᨐ‫ޕ‬ ኅ‫ޠ‬੦ᡰᜬ╙4⯳ឭ᩺㧘⿇ ᇕᆪ਄ኮਅੌᖵผᕈ⊛৻
หᎿ  ⼄ඳ჻਽ౌᐲ೔ᵡ᧖⏷ หᧂᚑᐕዋᅚდ⢝ᔅ㗇ㅢ⍮ 㗁‫ޕ‬

x ₺᳗ା’Ꮷ, ⫃੐ᦩ
ᚒὑੲ㤘෴⥜⊔⿠╙౎ภឭ᩺⼄సᚑ
ਥᏨ
ᚒේᧄᤚ୘᥉ㅢ⊛ၮ〈ᓤ㧘 㾎㕢೟ⱘᅌ᷵ϡԚ≦᳝‫⧚׿‬䘧ᖋ ⡧ว೔౏⡱ᦩ෻ወ㧘ᚒⵍ᜸ㆬ૞
x ൏ષ␽’Ꮷ, ⫃੐ᦩ ਄਄ᢎᦩ㧘໒໒⹞㧘⡱⡱㆏㧘 ᬭ㚆ˈড㗠ᬭᇢ੠෍仞ᅌ⫳ᬒ㐅 ෻ወ৻ᣇ౔ਛઍ⴫⪇ⵧ⊛⻠ຬ㧘
೽ਥᏨ តត๶Δ৬‫م‬ԫଡψငᔞഎω ⱘᗱᛇ੠㸠⚎ˈ䗭。。໪՚ⱘ㸱 ⇧ᄤᚒឭᣧඨዊᤨ೔㆐౏⡱ᦩ
EQOHQTV\QPGΖॾ‫׌‬ழՖࠝ‫נ‬ ᪞ˈህㅫ⠊↡㛑ᓎゟϔ‫عן‬ᒋⱘ Ⴑ㧘⋴⷗ᢞ⊖หᕈᚆ⠪Ꮗ㔼૖ੌ
x ẘ჻┵’Ꮷ, ⽷᡽⒁ ‫׈‬լՆΔ‫ᦰݺ‬መլ֟ඒᖄ৘࿙ ᆊᒁ⪄๗ˈгϡֱ䀐‫ܦ‬ཇϡᅌ ᦩႱ㧘ᚒ⥜ዊᢞ෻ወ⠪ထ࿷᫹਄
ᦠ ऱ஼ᤄΔ‫א‬੡‫׽‬Ꮑ৬‫م‬ԫଡ೜ າDŽ ╬୥㧘࿷ㅡඨዊᤨ㑆㧘ᢞ⊖ฬห
ൈऱ୮அ⪄๗Δঁ‫ױ‬ᐿ塄‫ߪנ‬ ᕈᚆ⠪┢࿷ᚒ୞㕙೨㧘↪ᦨ㜞⊛
㿜ࡗकⱘଳ⼎ᐕ㧘⇧቉ሶ
x ⼄సᚑඳ჻, ❢ᐙ੐ ֨೜٤ऱ৘՗Δ‫ױ‬ਢ઎ߠषᄎ ୞໗ዊቑᤨ㧘 ਃ⮲Ꮢ⊛ᢎ⢒ㇱⷐ ⡪ᶉ๺ᦨ‫ۆ‬៘ऱߢ፿ಫᒼ‫ݺ‬ଚΔ
Ղࡉ࿯ῖ⬠ᕜ໮ⱘາᕅ䷓ˈϡ ࿷耮荓襦谷茡翰聐ὑ ૶篯赸葟૷ ‫ړ‬լ୲࣐࿛ࠩֆᦫᄎၲࡨΔ‫ࢤٵ‬
䂟㞾՚䁬Ҏຂ㨑ⱘֵᙃˈᇡᆊ ⱘৠᗻ។Ёᖗˈᢎዉ๺テዉቑ↢ ᧐ᝑ୉࿇ߢழΔ‫ݺ‬ଚᙩᙩ‫ᦫڇ‬Δ
ᒁ੠‫ܦ‬スⱘᠧ᪞ᕜ໻ˈᕠ՚ⱐ หᕈᚆ⊛↢ᵴᣇᑼ㧘ᣈᤚၮ〈ᓤ  ‫ݺࠩ܀‬ଚ࿇ߢழΔ
( ਅធ╙ੑ㗁)
DEFINT_PM_005075
 Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-8 Filed01/12/10 Page3 of 5

TFC NEWS PAGE 2

ᚒὑੲ㤘෴⥜⊔⿠╙౎⯳ឭ᩺
➖਄㗁
‫ঁृ᧐ࢤٵ‬೏ᜢษߢࡃᒼΔ ⭊ᰮ៥䲶䭟᳗ๆᰖˈᡓফ 㮽ᏖⓆ䗣њᬭ㚆䚼ǃᏖᬓ
።መ‫ݺ‬ଚऱᜢଃΔᅝ‫ګݙݺ‬ њܽ‫ן‬໮ᇣᰖⱘ㿔䁲䖅㕉੠ ᑰǃᎲᬓᑰǃ䝿Ⱆ″ᾟǃ࿯
࿇ߢ‫ڃ‬ஆழΔ๯Գංᐳࡉ‫ٷ‬ ᘤ౛ǃᛳ㾎ህ‫ڣ‬㊒⼲Ϟ㹿ᔋ ῖ㟛‫ڇ‬ၦˈ䘨ࠄ੐乼୮䲼ⱘ
ՑֽΔ‫ڶ‬Գ‫׻‬ψዞ‫ڃ‬խഏ ྺϔῷˈ᳈ⳟ⏙Ἦ੠储᳗ࠄ ഄℹDŽ۞ൕ3115‫ڣ‬Կᢋؑో
‫װ‬ωΖᅝඡ່‫ݺח‬ᣄ‫ࡉݱ‬௛ ৠᗻ។䘟ࢩⱘⳳ䴶ⳂˈҪ‫ץ‬ ཤؑ९ሔऄ‫چ‬ቇ࿇‫ࢤٵ‬ദৗ
ᐬऱਢ઎ߠ‫ृ᧐ࢤٵ‬ᜰದᑑ 䙌᪛ᕲᬭ㚆ܹ᠟ˈ݊Ёϔ‫ן‬ ဳ஼ழΔ‫ঁݺ‬ቃறࠩึ‫ڶ‬ԫ
፿ᐊՂψ壀ਢ‫ृ᧐ࢤٵ‬ωΔ Ⳃⱘᰃ㽕ᄽス᥹ফৠᗻ។DŽ ֚Δ‫ࢤٵ‬ദৗലᄎ‫ٽڠףڇ‬
঺໪᳝ϔҎ催㟝ϔᔉ໻⍋ ⭊ᰮ៥ಲࠄᆊЁˈⳟࠄᄽᄤ ऄ֏Δ‫א‬৵‫ޢ‬ԫ৘࿙ຟ๯ቔ
ฅˈϞ䴶ᰃܽ‫ן‬䌸㻌㻌ⱘ⬋ ‫ץ‬໽ⳳഄ䖢Ϟ՚᪕ᢅ៥ᰖˈ ᚐ‫ױ‬ፖ‫ࢤٵ‬ऱԳ࿨ദΔቫᇢ ᝮᓮ‫ףݺ‬Գ‫ה‬ଚऱૠቤΔᜤ
スϞ䑿✻⠛ˈ݊Ёϔ⬋ス䙘 ᖗᑩ᳝䁾ϡߎⱘᖿᝄˈ䲪✊ ‫᧐ࢤٵ‬ऱॹ֟‫ڣ‬ᄎᏺ‫ף‬Δຍ ‫ٽ‬նଡԳऱ᡽‫ټ‬Δലঅᥨദ
೼ਂ᠟ᣛ丁ˈ㗠Ϟ䴶ᆿⴔҪ ៥‫ץ‬ফњὉ䞡ⱘວ࡯ˈԚॏ ലᄎਢ‫ޢ‬ԫ‫ۯ‬୮९ऱ༞ኄΔ ৗଥᖆ೯ᤜᎠՂ‫ڠڠף‬೭
‫ץ‬䳔㽕㿜ࡗकⱘᄫῷDŽ᳔ᕠ ᬥњϡᇥϝ㮽Ꮦⱘᄽᄤˈ‫ܡ‬
Ոਢषᄎऱ༞ኄΖ ৵ࠐΔ‫ף‬ ହΔଥᖆऱය֮ᎅΚψ‫ڠף‬
ᬭ㚆䚼ⱘ㺕≎ᰃপᶖ࿷Ёᅌ ফৠᗻ។ᬭ㚆ⱘ⋫⾂DŽ
‫ڠ‬ऱഗᅮඒᏆ๱‫مګ‬Ա ચࢭᎁԫߊԫՖऱദৗ੡‫ٽ‬
䀁ゟৠᗻ។Ёᖗⱘᓎ䅄ˈা ㄀9㰳ᦤḜⱘ⫶⫳!⬅:1ᑈҷ QspufduNbssjbhf/dpnΖ3118 ऄω 㧘ᓟૼ⛫ㆊ៓㓸⿷ജ᡽
೼ᬭ㚆䚼Ёᖗ䀁ゟৠᗻ។䓨 䭟ྟˈ៥ⳟࠄৠᗻ។㗙೼ϝ ฬ⠰ข‫س‬Աร 8 ⯳ឭ᩺‫ޕ‬
‫ࢍڣ‬ΔQspufduNbssjbhf/dpn
ᇢᅸDŽ

ʳ֭਍ႚอദৗऱॹ֟‫ڣ‬ʳ
⧒ҷ⠊↡᪨ᖗᄤཇ೼݀ ᅮ㕽ˈབᵰᬭᇢҎҔ咐㸠 ҞᑈⱘNj‫ڇ‬㍅ᆊᒁ֗䘆 ொ⛔ኅᐸଦㅴᦩ
ゟᅌ᷵㹿Nj⋫㜺nj㗠Ⳍֵ ⚎ᰃℷ⺎ⱘ䁅ˈ䗭֓ᰃϡ ᳗nj⤢ᅌ䞥ᰃ㽕∖催Ё៪
2008 ᖵผᕈⴕേ
ৠᗻ។ᰃϔ。ᰖᇮⱘ⫳⌏ 䘧ᖋњDŽ೼ৠᗻ។ⱘ䅄丠 ໻ᅌ⫳᪄ᆿ᭛ゴ䁾ᯢ⚎Ҕ
.ʳ
ᮍᓣˈ೼㄀㰳ᦤḜⱘ䂓 ϞˈNjᮄ䘧ᖋnjⱘᜟᑺ 咐㽕⦡ᚰϔ⬋ϔཇⱘ‫ڇ‬㍅
x ⥜଻ⴡᇕᆪ࿪㜚ว૞
ᶹЁˈϝकⅆҹϟⱘҎ໮ ᰃ˖䲪✊ⶹ䘧ৠᗻ។㸠⚎ ီ࿏ˈ៥‫ץ‬ᬊࠄ՚㞾ܼ೟
⊔⿠๺ផേ_G⯳ឭ᩺
ञ䋞៤ৠᗻီ࿏DŽ೼䘢এ ᰃϡ㞾✊੠᳝᧡䑿储ˈԚ ৘ᎲѠⱒ໮㆛ⱘᅌ⫳᭛
x ૙΍˘༱˟˼Њ_⯳ឭ
ѠकᑈЁˈ╂⌕᭛࣪੠ᬭ гϡৃҹᡍ䀩ৠᗻ។㗙ˈ ゴˈ㾷䞟ৠᗻီ࿏ⱘᬱ㰩
᩺⊛☃ฬ⴫ᩰ!
㚆ࠊᑺᏆᇛNj䘧ᖋnjⱘᅮ ಴⚎䗭ᰃҪཌྷ‫ⱘץ‬㞾⬅ ੠‫ڇ‬㍅ီ࿏ᇡᄤཇⱘ䞡㽕
x දഥ㩷_G⯳ឭ᩺ᚑὑච
㕽ᬍ䅞њˈ䘧ᖋॳᴀᰃߚ 䙌᪛DŽ঺ϔহ䁅䁾ˈ⼒᳗ ᗻDŽ៥‫ץ‬ᕜᖿᝄ㽟ࠄ䗭ѯ
৻᦬ᄢㆬឭ᩺!
䕼㸠⚎ⱘᇡ䤃ˈԚ⧒೼ॏ ࡉ䗴њϔҷNjᮕ㾔㗙njˈ ᅌ⫳㛑䗣䘢ⷨお੠ᗱ㗗ˈ
x ԩᛉΐэ੼ඈ‫఼ੰڱ‬
㹿ᬍ⚎䴲߸ᮋⱘᜟᑺ੠㞾 Ҫ‫ץ‬ᛯ㹪᠟ᮕ㾔ˈⳟ㽟Ҏ ⶁ㾷ࠄৠᗻ។ⱘᆇ㰩੠‫ڇ‬
䁸ܹ℻䗨ϡ᳗ࠊℶDŽ ㍅ီ࿏ⱘ‫ؐۍ‬DŽ ࿅Тّ૓‫ބ‬Ъ‫!̼ڱ‬
⬅䙌᪛⃞ˈ᠔ҹҹ⧒೼ⱘ
x јࠎ_G⯳ឭ᩺੟ⵧ㗔ዉ!
x ࿷ⴐᄙ౏ⴐ㓸ᦩ䇮⸰໧
ૢน૞ੲ㤘㧦 ๺ㄕ⺰ᦩਛὑ㩷_G⯳ឭ
᩺⊔⸒!
2/! ⊓⸥૞ㆬ᳃ ᦩຬ↳⺧⴫: 2008 ᐕᦩຬ⾌: $10
x ὑ㩷_G⯳ឭ᩺⚵❱ትொ
3/! Ⓧᭂᛩ␿! ⧷ᢥᆓฬ: ______________ ᝙᱅㧦AAAAAAAA
นᛌ࿔ 㓸ᦩ๺☊᱅!
࿾ဇ: __________________ x ͚޺[G⯳ឭ᩺!
4/! ട౉‫ޟ‬ொ⛔ኅᐸଦㅴ ⺧ነᓔ㧦
x ෻ወਃ⮲Ꮢᇉᅭวᴺ
ᦩ‫ޠ‬ὑᦩຬ㧘⍎⸃␠ᦩ _______________________
Traditional Family Coalition ൻ!
໧㗴!
_______________________ x ὑ㕍ᐕቑ↢⸳┙ₓቑ
848 Stewart Dr., #200 ㊄!
5/! ወᚒ୞⊔಴⊛ⴕേ๭☧ 㔚ㇷ: __________________
૞಴࿁ᙥ! Sunnyvale, CA 94085 x ᐎഥㅢㆊ㩷_G⯳ឭ᩺!
㔚⹤: __________________ x ᐎഥะ㜞╬ᴺ㒮㆘੤
6/! ወᧄᦩᡰᜬ᝙ഥ! ᡰᜬ_G⯳ឭ᩺⊛⸷⸩!
!
͑
DEFINT_PM_005076
 Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-8
VOLUME 3, ISSUE 3
TFC HELPED PASS PROP 8
In the second half of
2008, TFC was in the midst
of the history-making battle
defending 1-man-1-woman
marriage in California. As
a leader in the Proposition
8 campaign, Dr. Bill Tam
worked with ProtectMar-
riage.com to motivate
grassroots effort in the
Asian community. He
spoke at many churches,
radio and TV interviews,
and community groups
about the importance of
honoring traditional hetero-
sexual marriage. Working
with the leaders of the
America Return to God
YOUTH S U P P O R T I N G T R A D I T I O N A L M A R R I AG E
One of the worries
haunting parents is that
their children have been
“brainwashed” by the pub-
lic school and the media
into believing that being
gay is a fashionable life-
style. In the polls con-
ducted on Prop 8, people
below 30 are the group
that most supportive of
same-sex marriage. In the
last two decades, pop cul-
ture and education have
changed “morality” from
identifying right or wrong
WHY I HELPED START PROP 8
I used to be just an-
other Christian, attending
services, singing hymns,
doing visitations and build-
ing a comfort zone. After I
gave my life to Christ, my
first child was born and I
read many books on par-
enting. I had the notion
that if I prepared a healthy
and warm home, my chil-
dren would grow up
healthy, physically and
mentally. Yet after seeing
Prayer Movement, TFC
helped organized a prayer
rally for
marriage in
September,
a San Fran-
cisco Chi-
natown
rally on
October 12,
and a 5000
person rally
in Cuper-
tino on Oc-
tober 19.
Dr. Tam
traveled
twice to Los Angeles to rally
behavior into non-
judgmental attitude and
freedom of choice. There-
fore it becomes “immoral”
to instruct people how to
behave properly. In terms
of homosexuality, the new
attitude is that despite
knowledge that it is a
harmful lifestyle one
should not be criticized for
practicing it. It is a per-
son’s free choice. In other
words, we have a new
generation of “observers”
who would rather stay
all the vices being pro-
moted in the media, I saw
that family values are un-
der attack. I saw that
schools are not reliable
either because they are
not teaching moral and
ethics. Not only that, they
nurture rebellious
thoughts and behaviors. I
realized that building a
healthy home cannot en-
sure healthy kids.
Filed01/12/10 Page4 of 5
Page 3
Southern California churches
to protect traditional mar-
riage. He also debated on
radio and TV on Prop 8.
uninvolved than to reach
out and say “don’t do it”.
In this year’s TFC schol-
arship program, more than
200 high school and col-
lege students wrote es-
says on the importance of
traditional marriage ver-
sus same-sex marriage.
We are excited to see
many youths across the
country understand the
gravity of the matter and
vow to protect marriage as
defined by humanity
throughout history.
BY BILL TAM
In 1990, San Francisco’s
School District wanted to
introduce Project 10, a gay
center in every high school.
Seeing the danger that
would pose to regular stu-
dents, many parents
voiced their objection to
Project 10. I was asked to
represent the Asian par-
ents to speak at a public
hearing on Project 10.
That evening, I arrived 30
( Continued on page 4)
DEFINT_PM_005077
Other than Prop 8, TFC
supported Prop 4, Parental
Notice on Teen Abortion and
debated the issue on TV.
Proposition K, Decrimi-
nalization of Prostitution
was introduced to San Fran-
cisco. TFC led a group of
concerned citizens to object
to the proposition.
On November 4th, voters
passed Prop 8 and defeated
Prop 4 and Prop K. Califor-
nia reclaimed 1-man-1-
woman marriage, but lost
on the abortion issue. San
Francisco rejected prostitu-
tion.
Traditional Family
Coalition
2008 historical events
x Allied with
ProtectMarriage.com
x Sent out 12,000 petition
forms for Prop 8
x Got Prop 8 onto the
November ballot
x Spoke out against the
Supreme Court’s ruling
legalizing same-sex
marriage
x Asian grassroots
movement leader of Prop 8
x Spoke in numerous public
forums, interviews and
debates for Prop 8
x Organized rallies and
activities for Prop 8
x Supported Prop 4
x Against San Francisco’s
Prop K
x Launched scholarship
program for youths
x Helped pass Prop 8
x Helped file legal papers
with the Supreme Court in
support of Prop 8
 Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-8
www.tfccal.org
TRADITIONAL FAMILY
COALITION
848 Stewart Dr., #200
Sunnyvale
CA 94085
Phone: 408-636-0037
Fax: 408-636-0033
E-mail: tfccal@yahoo.com
⋡ ᮡ 㧦 એ ᢎ ⢒ ⸒ ⺰ ⥜ ⴕ േ ଻ ⴡ ஜ ᐽ ொ ⛔ ኅ ᐸ
WHY I HELPED START PROP 8
minutes before the hearing. The audito-
rium was already filled with hundreds of
gay activists called Act-Up. They stood in
front of us, a small group of opponents,
and shouted profanities and threats.
Although the police were there, they did
not intervene. When the hearing started,
four proponents of Project 10 spoke. We
sat quietly and took notes. When it was
our turn to speak, the gay activists
cursed us with verbal and physical in-
sults, and the police did nothing. Our
speeches were hardly heard by the
School Board. After I finished speaking, I
was pushed, spat on and cursed at.
Someone yelled, “Go back to China.” I
also saw signs that said, “God is Gay”
and “Jesus is Gay”. The most repulsive
sign was a man held up a big poster
showing two naked boys, one behind
another, sucking his thumb, and they
wanted Project 10. At that moment, I
Filed01/12/10 Page5 of 5
What can you do?
1. Register to vote.
2. Cast your vote wisely on election day.
3. Join TFC membership and get informed.
4. Respond to TFC’s call-to-action.
5. Donate to TFC.
Please cut and send application with Membership Application:
$10 payable to:
Name: ___________________
Traditional Family Coalition
Address: _________________
848 Stewart Dr., #200,
_________________________
Sunnyvale, CA 94085.
_________________________
============================
E-mail: __________________
TFC’s mission: Phone: __________________
To protect healthy traditional family 2009 membership: $10
values through speech, education
Tax deductible donation:
and action.
$ ___________
(CONT’D FROM PAGE 3)
realized that the gay activists are aiming They
at our young children. I saw the danger if in-
we did not fight for our children. The finalvited
ruling was that no gay center would be me to
put in schools, but the district would have join in
a gay center office in the district building.
the
After more than two hours of extreme mar-
noise and commotion, I went home feel- riage
ing that I had been mentally raped. I told ame-
myself that I must fight this horrifying ndm-
force. I was also glad that because of our ent
effort, many San Francisco students were initia-
spared of the indoctrination. tive.
We
Birth of Prop 8. Throughout the 90’s, I
col-
saw how gays infiltrated the education,
lected
government, health care and entertain-
enough voters signatures and
ment establishment, to the point that no
Prop 8 was born. Numerous
one can stand in their way. After Mayor
people have waken up and seen
Newsom illegally issued same-sex mar-
the need to protect our future
riage licenses, some pro-traditional family
generations from the indoctrina-
groups realized that same-sex marriage
tion of the gay agenda. Thank
would one day become legal in California.
God Prop 8 passed.
DEFINT_PM_005078
Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-9 Filed01/12/10 Page1 of 2

Exhibit I
FAQ: Same-Sex Marriage & Homosexuality Page 1 of 1
Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-9 Filed01/12/10 Page2 of 2

search...

About Presence Speakers Articles Products Theater Contact Us

Home > Products > DVD > FAQ: Same-Sex Marriage & Homosexuality
Main Menu Support Us
CD  DVD  Books  Mp3 Disc 

Home List All Products

Speakers
Church, Stand Up As Salt And Light Panel Discussion: "Protecting Our
Newsflash Children from the Moral Crisis Featured Products
FAQ: Same-Sex Marriage & Homosexuality 如何與孩子談性
Upcoming Events
Price: $10.00
Newsletters Ask a question about this product

Friends of Presence FAQ: Same -Sex Marriage & Homosexuality

View Full-Size Image Possible Cause of Same Sex Attraction and the Healing
Email Updates

Support Us Speakers: Bill Tam and Melvin Wong

$10.00

Family Add to Cart

Pastor's Legal Seminar
Quantity:  1 Add to Cart
Marriage

Parenting

Age 6-12

Faith $15.00

Add to Cart
Current News
培養孩子處理困境的能力
Apologetics

Engaging the Culture

Testimony

Other $25.00

Add to Cart
Articles

Products GoodSearch & GoodShop

YOU SEARCH OR SHOP...
WE GIVE!
Past Events

Raise money for Presence

Ministry just by searching the
web and shopping online!

Search the web now!

Money-saving coupons!

Add to your site

©2009 Presence Ministry

http://presencefamily.org/index.php?page=shop.product_details&flypage=flypage.tpl&pro... 1/12/2010
Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-10 Filed01/12/10 Page1 of 2

Exhibit J
Sexual Brokenness Conference Page 1 of 1
Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-10 Filed01/12/10 Page2 of 2

search...

About Presence Speakers Articles Products Theater Contact Us

Home > Products > DVD > Sexual Brokenness Conference

Main Menu Support Us
CD  DVD  Books  Mp3 Disc 

Home List All Products

Speakers
Set of 7 CDs - Parenting CDs by Agnes Ip The Exodus From Slavery Into
Newsflash Sonship Featured Products
Sexual Brokenness Conference 如何與孩子談性
Upcoming Events
Price: $15.00
Newsletters Ask a question about this product

Friends of Presence How Should Christians Respond to this Social Challenge Today?
Language: English
Email Updates View Full-Size Image Speakers:  Sarah Allis Yang,Melvin Wong, Carol Wagstaff, Bill
Tam, Darwin Ng, Agnes Ip
Support Us Set of 2 DVDs
$10.00

Family Add to Cart

Quantity:  1 Add to Cart
Christopher Yuan: Life-
Transforming Testimony
Marriage

Parenting

Age 6-12
Recently Viewed Products
 FAQ: Same-Sex Marriage & Homosexuality (Category:  DVD)
$12.00
Faith
Add to Cart
Current News Panel Discussion: "Protecting Our
Children from the Moral Crisis
Apologetics

Engaging the Culture

Testimony

Other $12.00

Add to Cart
Articles

Products GoodSearch & GoodShop

YOU SEARCH OR SHOP...
WE GIVE!
Past Events

Raise money for Presence

Ministry just by searching the
web and shopping online!

Search the web now!

Money-saving coupons!

Add to your site

©2009 Presence Ministry

http://presencefamily.org/index.php?page=shop.product_details&flypage=flypage.tpl&pro... 1/12/2010
Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-11 Filed01/12/10 Page1 of 2

Exhibit K
Church, Stand Up As Salt And Light Page 1 of 1
Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-11 Filed01/12/10 Page2 of 2

search...

About Presence Speakers Articles Products Theater Contact Us

Home > Products > Books > Church, Stand Up As Salt And Light
Main Menu Support Us
CD  DVD  Books  Mp3 Disc 

Home List All Products

Speakers
Christopher Yuan: Life-Transforming Testimony FAQ: Same-Sex Marriage &
Newsflash Homosexuality Featured Products
Church, Stand Up As Salt And Light Pastor's Legal Seminar
Upcoming Events
Price: $5.00
Newsletters Ask a question about this product

Friends of Presence Book Title: Church, Stand Up As Salt And Light!

 
Email Updates View Full-Size Image
Authored by Bill Tam 
Support Us Book comes in two languages: English and Chinese.
$15.00

Family Quantity:  1 Add to Cart

Add to Cart
移風易俗的同性戀運動

Marriage

Parenting

Age 6-12
Recently Viewed Products
 Sexual Brokenness Conference (Category:  DVD)
 FAQ: Same-Sex Marriage & Homosexuality (Category:  DVD) $10.00
Faith

Add to Cart
Current News
The Exodus From Slavery Into
Sonship
Apologetics

Engaging the Culture

Testimony

Other $12.00

Add to Cart
Articles

Products GoodSearch & GoodShop

YOU SEARCH OR SHOP...
WE GIVE!
Past Events

Raise money for Presence

Ministry just by searching the
web and shopping online!

Search the web now!

Money-saving coupons!

Add to your site

©2009 Presence Ministry

http://presencefamily.org/index.php?page=shop.product_details&flypage=flypage.tpl&pro... 1/12/2010
Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-12 Filed01/12/10 Page1 of 2

Exhibit L
Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-12 Filed01/12/10 Page2 of 2
Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-13 Filed01/12/10 Page1 of 2

Exhibit M
Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-13 Filed01/12/10 Page2 of 2
Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-14 Filed01/12/10 Page1 of 2

Exhibit N
Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-14 Filed01/12/10 Page2 of 2
Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-15 Filed01/12/10 Page1 of 7

Exhibit O
 Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-15 Filed01/12/10 Page2 of 7
22
Hak-Shing William Tam December 1, 2009
San Francisco, CA

1 invitations? Did you -- how did they --

2 A I receive invitations.

3 Q I see. So you would receive an

4 invitation to go speak at a church and you would

5 go speak at the church?

6 A Yes.

7 Q Can you say about how many such

8 meetings you attended during that time period,

9 January to November 2008?

10 MS. MOSS: I am going to -- again I am

11 going to object on First Amendment grounds to the

12 extent that you are asking him to discuss things

13 that were not public and that were part of his

14 sort of private, personal political activities

15 that are not publicly known. If you want to ask

16 him about things that he did that were public with

17 radio, media, television, that sort of thing, that

18 is fine. But I think we are getting into areas

19 where his answer is going to necessarily require

20 him to reveal his private associational

21 activities.

22 MR. DETTMER: Okay. And, you know, I

23 know we -- just we are going to have a lawyer

24 discussion here for just a second, and you are

25 obviously welcome to listen.

Alderson Reporting Company

1-800-FOR-DEPO
 Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-15 Filed01/12/10 Page3 of 7
23
Hak-Shing William Tam December 1, 2009
San Francisco, CA

1 I mean, I do want to know those things

2 and I think we have a right to it. But obviously

3 that is being litigated right now.

4 MS. MOSS: Understood.

5 MR. DETTMER: I think maybe one thing

6 that we should just as a housekeeping matter work

7 out, I don't want to waste our time asking a whole

8 bunch of questions that you are going to instruct

9 him not to answer. But I also don't want you to

10 argue later that I have waived the right to ask

11 those questions. So can we just have an agreement

12 that I don't have to ask him a whole bunch of

13 questions that you are going to object to,

14 instruct him not to answer?

15 MS. MOSS: I think that is fair. I

16 think we both understand that this issue is beyond

17 us, it is being decided today down in Pasadena

18 potentially. And then we will obviously --

19 MR. DETTMER: Okay. So you are not

20 going to argue waiver just because we have not

21 gone through all the steps?

22 MS. MOSS: I am not going to argue

23 waiver. I am very clear I am going to object to

24 any question that we believe would intrude upon

25 the First Amendment privileges that we have

Alderson Reporting Company

1-800-FOR-DEPO
 Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-15 Filed01/12/10 Page4 of 7
24
Hak-Shing William Tam December 1, 2009
San Francisco, CA

1 asserted. I understand we have a disagreement

2 over that. I understand that Judge Walker has

3 made clear that if we ultimately do not prevail on

4 this that it may mean that you would have to

5 redepose Mr. Tam. And I am not going to argue

6 that -- I know you have to ask every question.

7 MR. PUGNO: Can I confer with her just

8 a moment?

9 MR. DETTMER: Sure. Shall we go off

10 the record?

11 THE VIDEOGRAPHER: The time is

12 9:24 a.m., and we are off the record.

13 (Recess 9:24 a.m.-9:28 a.m.)

14 THE VIDEOGRAPHER: The time is

15 9:28 a.m., and we are back on the record.

16 MR. DETTMER: Okay. So we just have

17 had a brief discussion off the record about this

18 paragraph 27 and sort of the extent of the First

19 Amendment privilege that defendant-intervenors are

20 asserting.

21 And what I have explained what I want

22 to get into is basically just sort of the

23 explanation behind this paragraph 27 and what

24 Dr. Tam did. And I made clear that I don't want

25 to get into the contents of his -- specific

Alderson Reporting Company

1-800-FOR-DEPO
 Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-15 Filed01/12/10 Page5 of 7
25
Hak-Shing William Tam December 1, 2009
San Francisco, CA

1 contents of his communications at this point

2 because of the First Amendment discussions that we

3 have been having a disagreement about. However, I

4 do want to get into the extent of his

5 communications, how often he had meetings with

6 people, you know, how many people attended,

7 basically fleshing out this first sentence of

8 paragraph 27, and actually all of paragraph 27.

9 I am not going to ask you about the

10 identities of specific individuals right now based

11 on, you know, the notion that I can come back

12 later and ask about those if we prevail on the

13 First Amendment issue and on the understanding

14 that you are not going to argue there is any kind

15 of waiver around that. And I understand that you

16 do not want me to get into even how many meetings

17 there were, how many people attended, or anything

18 like that.

19 MS. MOSS: Okay. To be clear, general,

20 general responses about the sorts of activities

21 that he was involved in as reflected in

22 paragraph 27 I don't believe are objectionable.

23 But to the extent that the answer would require

24 him to discuss the groups or organizations or

25 persons who he was meeting with, I believe that

Alderson Reporting Company

1-800-FOR-DEPO
 Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-15 Filed01/12/10 Page6 of 7
26
Hak-Shing William Tam December 1, 2009
San Francisco, CA

1 that information is covered by the associational

2 privilege of the First Amendment.

3 So to the extent that the answer is

4 about public activities, things that were publicly

5 known that he -- and by public, I mean open to --

6 available to the general public, not to specific

7 groups, I will let him answer those questions.

8 And so, you know, it may be that we have to do it

9 on a question by question basis. But as a general

10 matter I do not think that you have the right to

11 inquire into how many meetings he had or who he

12 spoke with or how many people were there if it is

13 private and not publicly available because it

14 implicates his associational political rights.

15 MS. STEWART: If we just have an

16 understanding for the record of what his private

17 versus what is public? Because if I am

18 understanding his earlier testimony, he said he

19 spoke to church groups. If he spoke to a

20 congregation of 100 people, is that public or

21 private? If the church was open to the public,

22 was that public or private? Let's get down to

23 brass tacks here. What is the deal?

24 MS. MOSS: I believe that that is

25 private.

Alderson Reporting Company

1-800-FOR-DEPO
 Case3:09-cv-02292-VRW Document442-15 Filed01/12/10 Page7 of 7
44
Hak-Shing William Tam December 1, 2009
San Francisco, CA

1 Q Let me read this second paragraph into

2 the record. It says, I hope we all wake up now

3 and really work to pass Prop 8. We have only 48

4 days left. Even if you have church building

5 projects, mission projects, concert projects, et

6 cetera, please consider postponing them and put

7 all the church man/woman power to work on Prop 8.

8 We cannot lose this critical battle. If we lose,

9 this will very likely happen -- and then there is

10 an ellipsis.

11 Point 1 under that is -- and I will

12 read it into the record -- same sex marriage will

13 be a permanent law in California. One by one,

14 other states would fall into Satan's hand.

15 Do you believe that to be true?

16 MS. MOSS: On First Amendment grounds I

17 am going to instruct him not to answer.

18 A I am not going to answer that.

19 BY MR. DETTMER:

20 Q Okay. Let me ask you a slightly, I

21 guess, broader question. Do you believe that

22 Satan is behind the same sex marriage movement?

23 A I'm not going to answer that.

24 MS. MOSS: Again I am going to object

25 on First Amendment grounds.

Alderson Reporting Company

1-800-FOR-DEPO