Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Unitary – derived from the Latin words unitas (unity) – unus – “one”. Emphasizes the
oneness of a state and implies a high degree of international homogeneity and
cohesiveness. Unitary state has one strong focus.
Federal – origins in the Latin word foederis meaning “league”. implies alliance, contact,
and coexistence of the state’s internal diverse regions and people.
Size – should not be too big. Larger states tend to straddle more than one cultural region,
intensifying centrifugal forces.
Compact Shape – fragmented, prorupt, and elongated states give way to more obstacles
including unity, and cohesion. More likely to have racial, religious, and linguistic
differences
Dense Population – no vast territory with separate concentrations of population
interspersed with empty and unproductive areas. Should come close to representing a
nation state.
Only One Core Area – theoretically one core area in the middle of the compact state,
that way peripheral areas are always the shortest distance away from the main core area.
Multicore areas reflect strong regionalism, which is undesirable in a unitary state.
3. Why is France often cited as the best example of a unitary state? Why is a unitary
system of government probably a bad choice for the United Kingdom?
France is relatively compact – one core area (Paris) with long history in the Paris basin –
at France’s core is a large, politically conscious population with much historical
momentum and strong traditions.
4. What are the only Latin American nations to have federal systems of government?
5. What are the only Asian nations to have federal systems of government?
India, Malaysia
6. It is important to stress that few unitary states approach the ideal. List, and discuss, the
two geographic factors which demonstrate this.
Centralized – stability by virtue of the homogeneity of the population and the binding
elements of culture and traditions. Usually possess one core area, and are generally older
and in Europe. Ie – Denmark, Sweden, Netherlands
Highly Centralized – internal dissention/diversity, ethnic heterogeneity, that threaten to
disrupt state system are countered by tight and omnipotent control. Leader usually
represents a minority group within a country, or one party system. Ie – former communist
sphere, dictatorships.
8. “Federal states evolve and change over time.” Discuss this statement while comparing,
and contrasting, the development of the balance of powers in The United States of
America, Canada, and Australia.
USA – intended: strong state govt, weak fed – Actual: weak state, strong fed
Canada – intended: strong fed, weak prov – Actual: weak fed, strong prov
Australia – intended: strong state, weak fed – Actual: weak state, strong fed
9. “Theoretically, the federal framework is especially suitable for states in the large and
very large categories.” Discuss.
Poor communications and ineffective occupation of large areas within the country are
impediments to contact and control, which may disrupt a unitary state – federal
framework may be more accommodative of such centrifugal forces
Elongated states possessing more than one core area may also turn to a federal system.
Federal states can adjust to the presence of more than one core area more easily than
unitary.
10. What types of territorial morphology are highly conducive to the adoption of
federalism?
11. Why are states with multiple cores highly conducive to the adoption of federalism?
12. Why are states with multiple ethnic highly conducive to the adoption of federalism?
13. What three characteristics make Quebec a “nation within a nation” and how do these
characteristics make Quebec’s presence in Canada highly conducive to the adoption of
federalism?
14. Federal states such as Australia, Brazil, and the United States of America often have
their capital city located in an area of federal territory set off within the state for the
specific purpose of administration. For what two reasons is this done?
15. List, and discuss, the three different types of federal states.
16. Increasingly, states around the world have approached a mid-way area between
federalism and Unitarianism referred to as the _Regional State_ state. What factors are
conducive to this? How has this happened in the United Kingdom?
17. The following questions are based upon Holden, W.N. (2006). "One
Concept and Two Countries: Federal Government Jurisdiction to Make
Environmental Law in Australia and Canada." Australian Canadian
Studies. 24 (1): 51-81.
f).List, and discuss, four things that make federal jurisdiction to pass
environmental law important.
The first reason for its necessity is that federal environmental law can
prevent a “race to the bottom” scenario wherein a regional
government reduces its environmental protection requirements in an
effort to attract pollution-intensive industries into its jurisdiction and
out of jurisdictions with more stringent and, presumably more
expensive, environmental protection regimes.
The fourth and final reason why federal governments should have the
jurisdiction to implement environmental law is the increasing
importance of international agreements as a basis for environmental
law.
1. The invasion of Iraq by the United States of America in 2003 is an excellent example
of how states can acquire territory, but not sovereignty, through _conquest_.
Ireland partitioned in 1922 into the Republic of Ireland (a sovereign country) and
Northern Ireland (remained part of UK)
India, a British colony, was partitioned in 1947 into Pakistan and India.
3. From 1867 until 1931, the Dominion of Canada was a _territory of intermediate
status_. Why did the Dominion of Canada automatically go to war with Germany in 1914
when the British Empire declared war on Germany?
Canada had no foreign affairs – as Britain went to war with Germany, Canada went to
war as “part of the empire” of Britain.
Most of the continent has been formally claimed by a number of different countries. All
claims are, however, frozen by the 1959 Antarctica Treaty.
5. What are the two types of organizations which lead to “insurgent states?” In the
Philippine context, how do the National Democratic Front of the Philippines and the
Moro Islamic Liberation Front demonstrate these two types of organizations which lead
to “insurgent states?” What will make one of these organizations constitute an “insurgent
state?”
7. What are the two examples of territories having been placed under international
supervision and/or control?
German South West Africa (Namibia) was assigned to South Africa by the League of
Nations after WWI.
UN administered East Timor between 1999-2002 while Indonesia was relinquishing it
8. List, and discuss, the eleven trends which are leading to an erosion of “state
sovereignty” and “state power?”
The technique of comparing maps of electoral results with maps of geographic and other
factors.
3. List, and discuss the four aspects of voting which can be explained in part by
examining the geographic background of an election.
Rotten borough – refuse to make a borough smaller, even though it has a smaller
population if it has a history of supporting a party
Excess vote technique – drawing boundaries to concentrate one group of voters in the
fewest districts
Wasted vote – drawing lines in such a way to break up a concentration of voters so their
votes become diluted
1. List, and discuss, the five major ways by which indigenous peoples have been abused.
2. List, and discuss, the major international agreements affecting the rights of indigenous
peoples.
United Nations Declaration of the Rights of Indigenous Peoples
Provides substantial rights for indigenous peoples which are binding upon all
signatories to it.
3. The following question is based upon Davis, W. (2002) “The Naked Geography of
Hope: Death and Life in the Ethnosphere.” Whole Earth Spring (2002): 57- 61.
a). Much is made about the erosion of biodiversity in our world today. However,
according to Davis, the ethnodiversity of the world is being eroded, and at a much greater
rate. Accurately define the ethnosphere.
4. The following questions are based upon Holden, W.N., and A.A. Ingelson (2007)
“Disconnect between Philippine Mining Investment Policy and Indigenous Peoples’
Rights.” Journal of Energy & Natural Resources Law. 25 (4):375-391.
a). How does the Mining, Minerals, and Sustainable Development report define
“indigenous peoples?”
b). In the Philippine context, what is it that gives a group of people the characteristic of
being “indigenous?”
c). Explain the spatial distribution of (and the colloquial monikers used to describe) the
two major broad groups of indigenous people in the Philippine archipelago.
d). What statute governs the affairs of indigenous peoples in the Philippines? Did Isagani
Cruz and Cesar Europa v. Secretary of Environment and Natural Resources et al
conclusively uphold this statute? Why? What is, arguably, the biggest problem with this
statute?
Did not uphold – split decision – the IPRA is a landmark piece of legislation. It
is, however, poorly implemented because indigenous people are not a
high priority of the government.
e). What government agency is responsible for administering the affairs of indigenous
peoples in the Philippines?
f). In the Philippines, what is the “Regalian Doctrine”? What court case abolished the
“Regalian Doctrine”?
Provides the Philippine State with the right to all land that is not
privately owned.
The Valenton decision was overturned by the United States Supreme
Court in the 1909 decision Carino v Insular Government, wherein a
unanimous ruling of that court, written by Oliver Wendell Holmes,
overruled the Regalian Doctrine with respect to lands continuously
occupied by indigenous peoples.
g). Why is it problematic to say that the plight of indigenous peoples in the Philippines
could be improved by an endorsement of the United Nations Declaration on the rights of
indigenous Peoples?
1. _Imperialism_ occurs when some countries seek to acquire the territories of other
states and nations.
2. How did Saul Cohen define “colonialism?” To Cohen, how was “colonialism”
different from “imperialism?”
“Process involving the settlement from a mother country generally into empty lands and
bringing into these lands the previous culture and organization of the parent society.”
- Imperialism as “rule over indigenous people, transforming their ideas, institutions and
goods”.
3. What, according to Frankel, was the difference between primary colonization and
secondary colonization?
Primary – the occupation of the lands and the domination of indigenous peoples
Secondary – the acquisition by colonial power of virtually empty territory
4. List, and discuss, the three categories of the modern colonial empire.
The empire built up primarily of overseas territories by the states of Europe during the
Age of Exploration from C15 to C19
The empires built up after the Napoleonic Wars, which were based on nationalism,
geopolitics, and religious proselytization.
5. What happened in the “first wave of colonialism,” and when did this occur? What
happened in the “inter-colonial interlude,” and when did this occur? What happened in
the “second wave of colonialism,” and when did this occur? Who were the dominant
colonial powers in these two different colonial periods?
6. The location of many British colonies were often determined by their proximity to
numerous strategic “choke points” on the world’s oceans. Discuss this with respect to the
Falkland Islands, Gibraltar, Egypt, Aden, South Africa, and Singapore taking care to
indicate the particular “choke point” and which oceans were involved.
7. What geopolitical factor was instrumental in the decision of the United States of
America to keep the Philippines as a colony?
The position between Singapore and Japan. Japan’s emerging dominance became a
“threat”
8. One of the most important events in the history of colonialism was the 1494 Treaty of
Tordesillas. What did this do? To what extent did the 1494 Treaty of Tordesillas
determine the spatial distribution of the Spanish and Portuguese languages in Latin
America? How did the 1494 Treaty of Tordesillas impact the Spanish administration of
the Philippines?
9. How does colonialism explain the continuing prevalence of the Russian Orthodox
Church in the American state of Alaska?
It is an artifact of previous Russian occupation of Alaska before the USA acquired it from
the Russians in 1867.
military imperialism – results in a radical change in the political and military status quo
by the extension of a state’s sovereignty over territory that is either empty or occupied by
peoples of different cultures.
Economic imperialism – tie country to another so tightly through economic means that
one becomes a de facto colony of the other
11. List, and discuss, the three main motives behind colonialism? Using the retention of
the Philippines by the United States of America, explain how these three motives
overlapped.
12. How did colonialism have profound implications for both the colonizers and the
colonized?
13. Discuss the spatial distribution of the colonies of the major colonial powers.
14. Discuss the major implications of colonialism on the “developing nations” of the
modern world.
15. In the cases of Peru, Indonesia, India, Burma, and Vietnam, explain how colonialism
led to a change in the capital cities of these countries.
16. What impact did colonialism have on the transportation systems of the “developing
nations” of the modern world.
17. Many African nations are notorious for internal strife between different ethnic groups.
How was this a legacy of European Colonialism?
The way in which colonists drew political borders without taking into consideration the
different tribe territories
18. Why did the Latin American nations break away from their Spanish and Portuguese
colonial masters during the early nineteenth century? What was the essential impetus for
the end of European colonialism in Southeast Asia?
Following the Napoleonic Wars, the colonial powers were weak, giving Latin America a
chance to gain independence.
The international environment following WWII provided an ideal opening for nationalists
and independence movements to arise in SE Asia.
1. What was one of the most subtle, yet critical factors in the end of colonization?
Independence, industrialization, wealth, and power were not reserved for Europeans.
3. How did World War I mark the “beginning of the end” of European Colonialism?
What two things after World War I reinforced and actually intensified these trends?
Trading patterns were disrupted during WWI, colonies began to understand their
dependence on Europe, and stimulated new interest in self-determination.
WWII and the Great Depression reinforced these trends (and intensified them)
4. List, and discuss, the three essential features of the League of Nations Mandate system.
- Mandate territories were divided into three classes based on their degree of
development
- it actually laid out the responsibilities of the mandatory powers
- had an unqualified right to supervise the mandates to be certain that their terms and
conditions were being carried out faithfully
5. What were the Class A League of Nations Mandates? What were the Class B League
of Nations Mandates? What were the Class C League of Nations Mandates?
6. List, and discuss, the three categories of the responsibility of the mandatory powers
under the League of Nations Mandate system?
Petitioners from the trust territories were permitted to testify in person before the
trusteeship council or the UN General Assembly in addition to submitting written
petitions
The Charter provided for periodic visits by UN missions to the trust territories in addition
to written annual reports from the administering power
7. What caused Marxist ideology to become more attractive as a discourse for change in
the colonies?
9. List, and discuss, the three important differences between the League of Nations
Mandate system and the United Nations International Trusteeship system?
10. Taking care to list the important events in chronological order, discuss how South-
West Africa constituted a failure of the United Nations International Trusteeship system?
11. List, and discuss, the four things which keep the “Evil Empire” of the Union of Soviet
Socialist Republics intact? What was the crucial event which loosened the centrifugal
forces which held the “Evil Empire” of the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics together?
The red army, the communist party, the KGB, Settlement of ethnic Russians in nearly all
of the other nationality areas.
Humiliation in Afghanistan, communist party exposed as corrupt and inefficient.
1. List, and discuss, six activities which have been typical of new governments in recent
decades.
2. List, and discuss, four unfortunate side effects emanating from the heavy emphasis
placed upon fostering national unity in many newly independent nations.
4. Explain the genesis of the “debt crisis” during the 1970s. List, and discuss, three
reasons why the genesis of the “debt crisis” during the 1970s was not an immediate cause
for concern. What two events occurring in the early 1980s caused the “debt crisis” to
fully manifest itself? What was the most severe consequence of the “debt crisis?”
Oil shock of 1973 – gave OPEC nations lots and lots of petrodollars, which they invested
in banks in developed countries. The banks, now awash with petrodollars, began looking
to lend money to developing country’s governments. Second oilshock of 1979 –
developing countries began borrowing more money to pay for oil imports. Thus creating
a cycle.
- Many developing countries were oil exporters (mexico) so they did not have to borrow
for oil imports
- During the 1970s, almost all other commodities had high prices, so oil imports could
offset the effects of high oil prices with revenue from other commodities
- during the highly inflationary environment of the 1970s, the interest rates on these loans
were often lower than the rate of inflation so the real interest was often negative
-most of the loans made in the 1970’s were made on floating interest rates which shot up
-all commodities began to drop during the 1980’s during the global economy recession
via restrictive monetary policies
emergency measures to prevent debtor nations from defaulting on their loans contained
severe austerity measures
5. List, and discuss, four consequences of several small new countries choosing to keep
their foreign relations and economic activities to a minimum?
Boundaries were superimposed by colonial rulers with little regard for the interests of the
inhabitants
8. In the world today, one can see three broad bands of countries grouped together
according to their standard of living. List those three broad bands of countries according
to their geographic location in the world and their standard of living.
North stretching across NA, Euro, former USSR – high standard of living
Lower middle and lower latitudes, southern hemisphere – low middle class to desperately
poor
Far south – relatively rich and closely associated with the north
9. List, and discuss, three reasons why United States foreign aid is more political than
humanitarian.
Biggest receivers of foreign aid consist of former cold war adversaries, parties to us
sponsored efforts at conflict resolution, sources of illicit drugs consumed by americans
10. Using Indonesia and Colombia as examples, explain how the United States has few
problems with providing foreign aid to countries with dismal human rights records.
Indonesia – 1965-66, 1-2 million people killed in purge of the communist party
Columbia – people are routinely killed by paramilitary death squads
11. “The United States is asymmetric in granting refugee status to people from countries
with poor human rights records.” Discuss.
12. List, and discuss, six reasons why the campaign for a “new economic order” has
stalled out.
- benefits derived from this have not justified the efforts expended on it
- the end of the cold war led to lower levels of ODA due to reduced political needs for it
- the benefits of a healthy world economy are still unlikely to flow to the poorest
countries of the world
- other problems have come to the forefront since 1973
- the support of the members of defunct Warsaw Pact has been lost
- the widespread acceptance of neoliberalism (hyper-capitalist ideology) among many
developing countries
13. What is “neocolonialism?” What is the most obvious and important manifestation of
“neocolonialism?”
situation where former colonies, essentially become satellites of the great powers through
the pervasive influence of their former colonial masters in their affairs.
- the current pattern of international trade