Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Essay
Topic: Explain why the Articles of Confederation were unsuccessful, and prove that the
Constitution was a more effective piece of writing that really helped the United States grow
politically.
Introduction Paragraph:
Hook: “The Constitution is the guide which I never will abandon.”
-George Washington
Major event that showed that the A.O.C was too weak was:
-Daniel Shays' Rebellion:
-1786
- soldiers hadn’t received payments
-Massachusetts people had to borrow money to pay their taxes and
support their families (borrowed from American merchants)
-no commercial banks loans and debt got confusing
-when prices went down merchants asked for loans back
-famers and laboring people hit hard
- could not pay state taxes
- losing farms
- Sept armed men closed at court at Worcester
-when more threats appeared governor sent 600 militiamen to protect
state S.C
-500 insurgents gather under the leadership of Daniel Shay (a
popularly revolutionary war captain) more men joined
-Governor Bowdoin financed army of 4,400 men
-January 26, 1787 Shays led 1,200 men toward the federal arsenal at
Springfield. When they arrived, its frightened defenders opened fire,
killing four of the attackers and sending the Shaysites into retreat. By
the end of February, the rebellion was over.
-******showed that the A.O.C. are too weak
- needed a new constitution
-James Madison = “Father of Constitution” he was very involved in the making of it,
thought of the Virginia plan, and helped write it
- Virginia Plan (large states liked)
1. Bicameral Congress
Upper House (senate)
-chosen by the lower house
-reps/state/population: proportional
Lower House (house of reps)
-chosen by the people
- reps/state/population: proportional
2. presidential election have Electoral College
- New Jersey Plan (small states liked)
- everything should be equal not proportional
-Virginia Plan won
-smaller states threatened to leave
-Great Compromise (“Connecticut compromise”)
proportional in House of Representatives
Senate is equal
-makes large and small states happy
-***Constitution***
New Strengths
1. power to tax
2. congress could regulate tread
3. devise a plan for citizenship
4. print money (states could no longer)
5. legislate
-supremacy clause
-proper and necessary
-Opposing views:
-Federalists (Jay, Hamilton, Madison)
- more government involvement
-loose interpretation
-Hamilton
-tariffs
-national bank
-opposite of antis
-Anti-Federalist (Luther Martin)
-less govt is more
- pro-French
-opposed national bank
-oppose tariffs
-oppose ppl of wealth in gov
-support farming
-strict construction
-great compromise helped to try to make a balance of equal power among states
-house proportional
-senate 2
-Whiskey Rebellion
- Pennsylvania – Pittsburgh
- Federal Troops sent 13,000 to stop rebellions
**Showed Effectiveness of Government**
Conclusion:
Sum it up