Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ISBN
ISSN 0809-1021
Project No TFRN36
Program Access Networks
Security Gr. OPEN
No. of pages
Date 2006.01.19
Author(s)
Terje Tjelta, Lars Erling Bråten and Tor Ove Breivik
Subject headings
Attenuation due to melting snow and sleet
Abstract
There are a large number of radio links working under climate conditions where melting
snow should be taken into account, as well as other propagation effects. This is, in
particular, important since it is established that melting ice and snow particles attenuate
electromagnetic waves more than water particles with the same amount of liquid water.
This paper reviews some basics of propagation through sleet. It summarises the recently
proposed Bacon and Eden prediction method, applies it, and compare with measurements.
Experimental data provide evidence for critical parts of the prediction method and full
monthly distributions compares well with the predicted ones in the shallow regions likely
caused by melting snow.
The Norwegian Defence Logistic Organisation, Telenor Nordic Fixed and Norkring are
jointly financing the project.
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or utilized in any form or
by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, or by any
information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher.
Contents
1 Introduction ......................................................................................2
5. Experimental evidence....................................................................8
5.1. Observations in Japan and Canada .................................................................... 8
6. Conclusions .....................................................................................12
8. References ......................................................................................13
1 Introduction
It has been known for over 50 years, that melting ice or snow particles attenuate
electromagnetic waves more than water particles with the same amount of liquid water.
Also the first attempts to estimate the excess attenuation compared to what droplets with
the same amount of water causes are old. It is now well established that sleet, or melting
snow, can cause attenuation several times more than that caused by rain of the same rainfall
rate intensity.
Correct dimensioning of radio systems is important from the point of view of providing
satisfactory service and making best possible use of the frequency spectrum. Rather than
using an arbitrary additional margin to account for sleet attenuation it is of great interest to
make use of an accurate prediction method. This also minimise the misuse of spectrum
improving the overall economy of radio systems. This has been an un-solved problem for
many years.
However, recently a method has been proposed to predict the attenuation distribution due to
both rain and sleet on any line-of-sight radio link. There are several reasons for the
slowness of developing a prediction method for wet snow compared to predicting the
attenuation due to rain only. The problem is complicated both from a theoretical as well as
practical measurements points of view. Several theoretical results give confidence in the
estimated extinction coefficients for sleet particles, but there is a great variability due to the
particle shape and the mixture of liquid water with snow and ice. The measurements are
difficult because it is important to only estimate the effect of sleet in the atmosphere and
not antenna wetting or wet snow effects on the antenna radomes.
Until recently, there have not been available global maps describing meteorological
features to help describing the amount of wet snow in the total rainfall at any point of the
surface of the Earth. However, recently Bacon and Eden suggested a method that makes use
of global maps and indirect information to make an estimate of the amount of sleet and an
average attenuation profile to obtain excess attenuation in the melting layer. It further
assumes a certain distribution of the height of rainfall, or zero-degree isotherm, as well as a
fixed shape of the melting layer excess attenuation as a function of the position in the layer.
With this information it is possible to predict the attenuation distribution on any link taking
both rain and sleet into considerations.
This report reviews some basics of propagation through sleet and is based on [1]. It
summarises the Bacon and Eden prediction method and applies it and compare with
observed results published. In particular data from Japan obtained in the fifties to seventies
have been found very interesting, in addition to data from Canada. These data provide
attenuation and precipitation during sleet events. There have been a number of reports from
several parts of the world indicating excess attenuation due to the melting layer. Analysis of
new data from recent measurements in Norway is compared with the predictions. In spite of
limited amount of measured data available, the proposed prediction method is promising. A
detailed description of the measurement set-up is given in [2].
-200
Relat ive height (m) to the ra in height
-400
-600
-800
-1000
-1200
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4
Melting layer mult iplication factor
⎧0 , 0<h
⎪⎪
( )
g h =⎨ (
a 1 − eh / b )
2
h≤0 (1)
( )( ( )
,
⎪⎩ ⎜⎝
)
⎪ ⎛1 + 1 − e − ( h / c ) 2 2 a 1 − e h / b 2 − 1 ⎞
⎟
⎠
where the constants a = 4 ,b = 70, and c = 600. As a crude indication the three coefficients
have an impact on the maximum multiplication factor, its position relative to the top and
the depth of the layer, respectively. The function goes asymptotic to 1 for large negative h
values, in practical term it is 1 for h < -1400 with a, b, and c as indicated.
The actual multiplication factor to use in prediction is made up as an integral of the
multiplicative factors weighted with the relative melting layer height probability density
function along the path. The multiplication factor is made relative to the 0-degree isotherm
height. The isotherm will vary over the year and this is as well found from an ITU-R
recommendation, if more accurate local data are not available. See the next section for
details.
Two features have to be established and used in the procedure: the mean rain height derived
from the zero degree isotherm height, and its variation or distribution. The rain height data
are given in Recommendation ITU-R P.839. The data are found from the website
(http://www.itu.int/ITU-R/software/study-groups/rsg3/databanks/troposph/rec839). The
zero degree height data are shown in Figure 2.
A rain height distribution is suggested used, if not available from local data there is one
included in Rec. ITU-R P.452 [9] dealing with interference. The cumulative probability
function is provided in a tabulated form. The probability density function derived from the
tabulated cumulative probability function, has been slightly smoothed, but it is noted that
further smoothing would be reasonable. Also note that the tails have been forced towards
zero as the lower tail, at negative heights, actually increases in the end. The probability
density function is plotted in Figure 3 along with a normally distributed rain height
proposed recently. The latter allows easier adjustments for modelling purposes and is the
first step to derive a latitude-dependent rain height variability.
0.08
ITU-R Rec P.452
0.07 Proposal 2005
0.06
Probability 0.05
0.04
0.03
0.02
0.01
0
-2500 -2000 -1500 -1000 -500 0 500 1000 1500 2000 2500
Height (m) relat ive to the mean ra in height
For inclined paths it may not be correct to use one single multiplication factor for the whole
path. An average over the path may be more appropriate. Possible alternative multiplication
factors are shown in Figure 4, the averaged factor and the difference to the single one (as 0
degree gives). Note that the maximum becomes less, but the difference plot indicates that it
will average out. Some situation will now have excess attenuation since the paths in part
goes through the melting layer. It is straight forward to introduce the alternative factors and
use them for inclined paths, but the simple result shown here indicates that not much
difference can be expected.
500 500
Height (m) relative to the top of melting layer
0 0
-500 -500
0 deg. 0 deg.
1 deg. 1 deg.
2 deg. 2 deg.
-1000 -1000
3 deg. 3 deg.
4 deg. 4 deg.
5 deg. 5 deg.
-1500 -1500
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 -1.5 -1 -0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5 2
Multiplication factor Difference in multiplication factor
5. Experimental evidence
Evidence of the effects of melting particles in sleet has been known since more than 50
years [10]. Atlas et al [11] and Gunn and East [12] review thinking that water covered
particles would behave like large particles as it was water, hence explaining the
significantly larger attenuation under such conditions compared what particles consisting of
the same amount of liquid water would result in.
The problems wet snow may create for microwave links have been known for many years,
and also techniques to minimise the negative effects. In a report from 1958, edited by
Asami, the propagation mechanisms as well as basic information on frozen precipitation,
are described along with experimental results [13]. In 1966 Takada and Nakamura
published significantly more attenuation over a 14.3 km link operating at 11 GHz [14].
Averaged over the whole path the attenuation for periods with sleet seemed to be 6 times
heavier compared to a case with the same precipitation rate of liquid water. The are several
potential reasons for excess attenuation: the wet snow along the path, attenuation in wet
snow accumulating on the antenna radomes (or on non-protected antenna structures), non-
hydrofobic radomes, and distortion of the antenna diagram due to the accumulated snow. A
lot has been done to avoid the latter sources of problems, whilst the wet snow in the
atmosphere cannot be removed and has to be accounted for.
Recently operators in the UK claim to have experienced higher than expected outage times
for links in the 23 GHz and 38 GHz band. An experiment performed in the Southern UK
verified that sleet/hail/snow may lead to significant time periods of link degradation [15].
The observed events had durations exceeding those predicted for rain attenuation durations.
Additional outage on microwave links, probably caused by sleet precipitation, has also been
observed in Scotland [16].
The melting layer is also known to produce excess attenuation for satellite-Earth links
[17][18][19]. There are a number of other observations with clear indications that the
attenuation due to the melting layer is significant. Some details are provided in the nest two
sections using results from Canada, Japan, and Norway.
Among several Japanese studies the two experiments in [14] and [20] have measured
attenuation on several radio links. Figure 5a shows excess attenuation due to sleet observed
during three winter months in 1962 using a 14.3 km vertical polarised link at 11 GHz. It
should be noted that the attenuation due to sleet is about 5 times larger for than for rain with
the same precipitation rate.
Observations from British Columbia in Canada [21] indicate considerable higher
attenuation from melting layer than from rain only. Data taken in 1982 from a 41.3 km link
at the frequencies 4 GHz and 7 GHz show values of up to 40 times more attenuation than
what rain would give, with values typically ranging between 10 and 20. The rainfall rate for
these events varied as is indicated in Figure 5b.
5 40
Rain
4.5
Snow 35
4 Mixed
30
3.5
2.5 20
2
15
1.5
10
1
5
0.5
0 0
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 5 0 2 4 6 8 10 12
A verage precipitation over the path (mm/km) over 6 min A verage rain rate (mm/h)
a) b)
Figure 5 Observed excess attenuation due to the melting layer from a) Japan [14] and
b) Canada [21]
The Canadian results are discussed further in [22] where not only observation and
modelling of excess attenuation are covered, but also the phenomenon of abrupt changes in
signal strength with changes in the meting layer itself.
m m
500 500 500
10 0 10
km Grande K-factor
k-factor
1.33
1.33 Kopparen km
(Ørlandet radio) Forest Urban Fie ld Mountain/Ice Water
Figure 6 Coastal area with experimental link indicated and terrain profile
This region of Norway has a typical costal climate. The winters are mild with only limited
amount of snow, the summers typically have day temperatures between 15 and 20 degrees
and varying weather conditions. The antennas are monitored, and still-pictures recorded
every second minute, see Figure 7.
a) Grande b) Kopparen
Measured monthly distributions are given for nine months, Figure 8, from February through
mid October 2005. Note that data became available form the 17 February, at mid-day.
1: propos a l 2002, 2: propos a l 2005, 3: propos a l 2005 inlc ina tion a dde d
0
10
Ra in + we t s now (1)
Ra in + we t s now (2)
-2
10
-3
10
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50
Ate nua tion (dB) (s olid line : Ye a r, broke n line : W ors t m onth)
The results in Figure 8 shows that no heavy rain effects have yet been observed, except for
February. In the range up to 10 dB there is more observed attenuation than predicted with
the current ITU-R method, see Figure 9. Although it is limited evidence it seems that a
combined rain and sleet method works better. The three methods given in Figure 9 are (1)
the method from 2002 [3], (2) is the one listed in Annex 1, and (3) is a modification to (2)
using the method illustrated in Figure 4. Note that the path inclination has minimal effect in
this case. In the prediction of rain attenuation version 3 of Rec. P.837 was used. The revised
method in [6] will only show very small, if any, difference at 18 GHz.
15 15
Snow depth Snow depth
Precipitation Precipitation
10 Tempe rature Temperature
10
5
0
5
-5
-10 0
0 5 10 15 20 25 0 5 10 15 20 25 30
Day Day
The meteorological data plotted in Figure 10 gives three measures: the temperature, the
amount of precipitation over a period of 6 hours and the snow depth on the ground. It is
noted that likelihood for sleet is quite high for several of the events in February and also in
April. Similar picture are seen for March and May, but not June.
6. Conclusions
Precipitation in the form of sleet may cause significant anomalous attenuation for fixed
terrestrial links operating in climate regions such as coastal Norway. This may be a problem
for telecommunication operators guaranteeing reliable service with short outage times
independent of weather.
The recent proposed prediction method for melting layer attenuation on any link in the
works has been presented. Measurement data from various regions of the world confirms
critical parts of the prediction method and observed monthly distributions from a link in
coastal Norway provide evidence that the prediction method can be used.
The results have been submitted to the ITU-R Study Group 3 meeting in Cleveland 2005
and are currently included in the Chairman’s report, see Annex 1 for further details. The
next ITU-R meeting will consider adopting the method in ITU-R Recommendation P.530.
The work is part of a collaborative effort supported by the Norwegian Defence Logistic
Organisation, Telenor Nordic Fixed and Norkring are jointly financing the project.
Acknowledgements
The authors thank the Norwegian Meteorological Institute for providing meteorological
data.
8. References
[1] Tjelta, T., Bråten L. E., Bacon D., “Predicting the attenuation distribution on line-of-
sight radio links due to melting snow,” In Proc. ClimDiff, Cleveland, U.S.A., 26-27
Sept. 2005
[2] Bråten, L.E., T. Tjelta, and D. Larsen, "Excess attenuation caused by sleet on coastal
terrestrial radio links in Norway", Telenor R&D Scientific Document R&D N
66/2003, 2003.
[3] ITU-R, "Development towards a model for combined rain and sleet attenuation", ITU-
R Document 3M/62E, International Telecommunication Union, Geneva, 2002.
[4] Jain, Y.M. and P.A Watson, "Attenuation in meting snow on microwave- and
millimetre-wave terrestrial radio links", Electronic letters, 21(2), 17 January 1985.
[5] Kuznetsov, G.G., C.J. Walden, and A.R. Holt, "Attenuation of microwaves in sleet",
Final Report to the Radiocommunications Agency AY 3564, Dep. of mathematics,
University of Essex, Colchester, Aug. 2000.
(Available from http://www.ofcom.org.uk/)
[6] ITU-R Recommendation P.837-4, "Characteristics of precipitation for propagation
modelling", International Telecommunication Union, Geneva, 2003.
[7] ITU-R Recommendation P.839-3, "Rain height model for prediction models",
International Telecommunication Union, Geneva, 2001.
[8] ITU-R Recommendation P.530-11, "Propagation data and prediction methods required
for the design of terrestrial line-of-sight systems," International Telecommunication
Union, Geneva, 2005.
[9] ITU-R Recommendation P.452-12, "Prediction procedure for the evaluation of
microwave interference between stations on the surface of the Earth at frequencies
above about 0.7 GHz", International Telecommunication Union, Geneva, 2005.
[10] Kerker, M., P. Langleben, and K.L.S. Gunn, "Scattering of microwaves by a meting,
spherical ice particle", Journal of Atmospheric Sciences, 8(6), pp. 424-424, 1951.
[11] Atlas, D., M. Kerker, and W. Hitschfeld, "Scattering and attenuation buy non-
spherical atmospheric particles", Journal fo Atmospheric and Terrestrial Physics, 3,
pp. 108-119, 1953.
[12] Gunn, K.L.S., and T.W.R East, "The microwave properties of precipitation particles",
Quarterly Journal Meteorological Society, London, 80, pp. 522-545, 1954.
[13] Asami, Y. (editor), "Microwave propagation in snowy districts", Monograph Series of
the Research Institute of Applied Electricity, No. 6, Sapporo, Japan, p. 198, 1958.
[14] Takada, M. and S. Nakamura, "Attenuation of 11 Gc Waves by Wet Snowfall",
Review of the Electrical Communication Laboratory, 14(1-2), pp. 27-42, January
1966.
[15] Thurai, M. and J.M. Woodroffe, "Precipitation induced co and cross-polar effects
from a 9 km link operating at 38 GHz", in Proc. of International Conference on
Antennas and Propagation (ICAP), Conf. Publ. No. 436, 2, pp. 222-225, 14-17 April
1997.
[16] Walden, C.J., C.L. Wilson, J.W.F. Goddard, K.S. Paulson, M.J. Willis, and J.D.
Eastment, "A study of the effects of meting snow on communications links in