Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT: The process design, plant erection and operational experiences of a novel biogas upgrading plant that
produces approximately 100m³(STP)/h of fully-fledged natural gas substitute from about 180m³(STP)/h of raw
biogas will be presented. The upgrading is based on the membrane separation process Gas Permeation and allows
low energy consumption as well as very low methane losses. The quality of the upgraded biomethane is controlled
continuously regarding various unwanted or malicious substances to assure the agreement with the quality prescribed
by Austrian laws. The produced biomethane is introduced to the natural gas grid and delivered to the households of
the neighboring city Bruck/Leitha in Lower Austria. During the summer months the gas consumption in the local
grid is far too small compared to the produced biomethane stream and the excessive biomethane is compressed to
60bar and fed into the regional natural gas grid. The process of Gas Permeation is continuous, stable and relatively
easy to handle and to control; furthermore, no regeneration or chemicals are needed. Additionally, a dynamic process
simulation model has been developed to gain knowledge of startup and shutdown procedures, as well as to test
control strategies and parameterize the implemented PID controllers.
Keywords: biogas, methane, operating experience
defined by Austrian norm OEVGW G31 and G33 Figure 2: Principle of gas separation using the
membrane technique Gas Permeation
Natural
Biogas Unit
Gas The separation technique uses a dense polyimide-
Methane 45-70 - mol % membrane with different solubilities and diffusivities for
Carbon the various gas species contained in the raw biogas feed.
30-45 ≤2 mol %
dioxide As a result, the driving force for separation is the
Ammonia ≤1 000 0 mg/m³(STP) difference in the partial pressures of the various species
Hydrogen between the feed phase and the permeate phase. A high
≤2 000 ≤5 mg/ m³(STP)
sulphide flux through the membrane can be realized with high
Oxygen ≤2 ≤0.5 mol % pressure on the feed side and a low pressure (near to
Nitrogen ≤8 ≤5 mol % atmospheric pressure) on the permeate side of the
Water 37 at ≤-8 at membrane. Using this membrane material, most
°C
(dew point) 1bar 40bar unwanted gas species are quantitatively removed from
Combustion the feed stream and transported through the membrane to
6.7-8.4 10.7-12.8 kWh/m³(STP)
heat the permeate stream. Only nitrogen shows similar
Wobbe behavior as methane and therefore cannot be removed by
6.9-9.5 13.3-15.7 kWh/m³(STP)
index this technique but remains in the product gas stream, the
so-called retentate. Sufficient product gas quality and
quantity can easily be reached if only enough membrane
Biogas Desulphurisation Compression
area and adequate operation conditions are provided. The
production (preliminary) great advantages of this process compared to others are
the continuity, compactness, simultaneous drying and the
H2O/NH3- Desulphurisation Drying removal of the traces of hydrogen sulphide and ammonia.
Separation (complete) Since the mixture of NH3, H2S and very humid gas can
jeopardize the membrane material, some gas processing
before the gas permeation is necessary.
Separation of other Grid supply
The membranes are constructed as hollow fibres with
CO2-
contaminants
Separation (Odorisation) the high pressure feed/retentate stream on the inner side
of the tube and the low pressure (almost atmospheric)
Figure 1: Main steps of the biogas upgrading process permeate on the outside of the tube. Many of these fibres
necessary to reach aspired product gas quality are collected to form a membrane module that is fed with
pressurized biogas.
Quality
Adsorptive Two Stage
CHP Freeze Control
H2S Gas
(Gas Engine) Drying (Gas
Removal Permeation
Analysis)
Local Gas
Gas Grid Odorisation Distribution
Bruck/Leitha Station
Regional High
Gas Grid Pressure
(60bar) Compression
Figure 4: Process Integration of the biogas upgrading Figure 5: Outside view of the biogas upgrading
facility in Bruck/Leitha container
Fig. 4 also shows the second most important cleaning The supplied bio-methane is transported to the
step, which is the removal of hydrogen sulphide. Due to nearby city of Bruck/Leitha (Population: 7600) via the
its toxicity and corrosive effects only a very small public natural gas grid having a pressure of up to 3bar.
amount of hydrogen sulphide is allowed in the gas. The During the winter months the entire amount of bio-
current process incorporates three stages of methane is used to satisfy the gas demand of this city
desulphurization. The first one is the in-situ- (additional natural gas is required). During the summer
desulphurization by addition of special chemical months the gas demand is only a fraction of the produced
gas and the excessive biomethane is compressed to 60bar raw biogas and pressure in the grid have an influence on
and fed into the regional natural gas grid. This approach the process behavior. Therefore, a special control and
enables a constant operation of the biogas upgrading safety strategy had to be developed.
facility over the whole year and therefore optimized The whole process, especially the quality control and
workload and cost structure. the clearance of feed-in operation as well as all safety
As mentioned above the described process concept relevant aspects are completely automated. For this
has been realized at the biogas co-digestion plant purpose a state-of-the-art industrial PLC (Programmable
Bruck/Leitha in Lower Austria (40km from Vienna). Logic Controller) has been implemented and
This plant was designed to process about 180m³(STP)/h programmed completely from scratch (see Fig. 6).
of raw biogas and supply 100m³(STP)/h of biomethane.
Parallel to this grid supply the fermentation capacity of
the biogas plant is high enough to additionally operate
two gas engines to produce electrical power (2 x 830kW)
and district heat. The whole upgrading plant according to
the scheme depicted in Fig. 3 has been mounted inside a
standard 30foot-container by the plant constructor and
has been transported as a whole to the final location in
Bruck/Leitha. Fig. 5 gives an outside view of this
container. Fig. 6 shows the interior of the biogas
upgrading container where especially the compressor,
heat exchangers and the membrane modules are visible. Figure 6: Programmable Logic Controller (PLC) used
for the biogas upgrading plant Bruck/Leitha (GE Fanuc)
biomethane [m³(STP)/h]
39.6
suggest that the high methane quality, which is required 39.4
for the grid supply, is achieved within 10 minutes of 80
39.2
operation. This very fast startup behavior has been 60 39.0
confirmed by experimental results collected at the real 38.8
upgrading plant. 40
38.6
0 38.0
0.8
17.02.2008 17.02.2008 18.02.2008 18.02.2008 18.02.2008
0.7 12:00:00 18:00:00 00:00:00 06:00:00 12:00:00
0.6
0.5 Figure 10: Volumetric flowrate and upper heating value
0.4 (calculated according to EN ISO 6976) of the produced
0.3 biomethane monitored over a period of 24 hours
0.2
0.1 Fig. 11 shows the main components of the produced
0.0 biomethane stream, named methane and carbon dioxide
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500
monitored over the same period of 24 hours. It can be
Time [s]
seen that the quality-PID-controller is working very well,
Figure 9: Simulated methane volume fraction at startup keeping both parameters almost exactly on the desired
of the biogas upgrading plant after flushing with pure values (98.0vol% for methane, 1.80vol% for CO2).
nitrogen
100 5.0
98 4.5
CO2-content of produced
CH4-content of produced
96 4.0
5 OPERATIONAL EXPERIENCES
biomethane [vol%]
biomethane [vol%]
94 3.5
92 3.0
Already during the first commissioning phase it 90 2.5
became apparent, that the start-up procedure of the 88 2.0
upgrading plant is comparatively fast. 3-5 minutes after 86 1.5
the compressor start-up a relatively constant methane 84 1.0
CH4-content
content of the processed product gas of 98vol% +/- 82 CO2-content 0.5
2vol% can be reached. After that period it takes another 5 80 0.0
minutes for the control system to stabilize the methane 17.02.2008 17.02.2008 18.02.2008 18.02.2008 18.02.2008
content at the desired value and within the desired 12:00:00 18:00:00 00:00:00 06:00:00 12:00:00
boundaries. The control system is designed to guarantee Figure 11: Methane content and carbon dioxide content
a constant product gas quality according to the Austrian of the produced biomethane monitored over a period of
laws. After the product gas fulfills the requirements 24 hours
(normally within the first 10 minutes), it is supplied to
the public grid. This short startup time usually appears It has been shown, that the produced biomethane
after a normal plant start from warm standby. In this case does not contain any nitrogen or other inert gases and
the whole upgrading plant is filled with biogas or partly only contains a little amount of oxygen. Therefore, the
upgraded biomethane. Only in the uncommon case of content of CH4 has to be kept about 1 percent higher then
certain replacement activities parts of the plant have to be prescribed by the norm OEVGW G31 (97.0vol%
flushed with nitrogen as an explosion prevention corresponding to the upper heating value of at least
measure. A startup after this cold standby takes a little bit 10.7kW/m³(STP)) in order to meet the limit for carbon
longer (about 20 minutes) as it has been discussed in Fig. dioxide, which is 2.0vol%.
Finally, Fig. 12 shows the trace components of the This power consumption can be related to the thermal
produced biomethane stream over the monitoring period energy content of the produced biomethane of about
of 24 hours. The oxygen content of the gas can 10.82kWth/m³(STP) (upper heating value). As a result,
completely be ascribed to the oxygen dosing for the the upgrading of the biogas produced at the co-digestion
biological desulphurization. The usage of the actual, plant in Bruck/Leitha to natural gas quality including
quite rudimental oxygen dosing controller results in a grid supply consumes about 3.2% of the thermal energy
remaining oxygen content of 0.1 to 0.2vol% compared to content of the delivered gas based on the upper heating
the legislative limit of 0.5mol%. This first inaccurate value. If this amount of electricity would be provided
implementation of the controller is also responsible for using a CHP-gas-engine with a standard efficiency of
the steps in oxygen content occurring during changes of 38%, a biomethane amount of 8.4% of the delivered gas
the biogas volume flow through the biological would be needed to run the biogas upgrading facility.
desulphurization column. However, though the oxygen Compared to other techniques, this value is remarkably
content can only be slightly lowered in the product gas low.
stream by means of Gas Permeation, this parameter is no
problem for the feed-in operation. The same is true for
the moisture content. This value usually drops below 6 SUMMARY AND OUTLOOK
40ppmv after 30 minutes of operation and reaches
(depending on the temperature of the surroundings) The process design, plant erection and some
values of 2 to 10ppmv compared to the legislative limit operational experiences of an innovative biogas
of about 80ppmv. These extremely low water contents upgrading plant have been presented. The plant produces
originate from the high dehumidifying potential of the approximately 100m³(STP)/h of fully-fledged natural gas
polyimide membranes. The coarse drying of the gas is substitute (biomethane) and delivers this stream to the
done by condensation (cryogenic cooling, high mass public natural gas grid either on a local grid level (up to
flows of condensate) and the fine drying down to only a 3bar) or, during the summer months, to a regional grid
few ppmv is accomplished by the membrane modules. level with up to 60bar. The upgrading is based on the
The content of hydrogen sulphide usually varies between membrane separation process Gas Permeation and allows
0 and 1.0ppmv with a weak daily fluctuation caused by low energy consumption as well as very low methane
the temperature of the biological desulphurization, which losses. The quality of the upgraded biomethane is
mainly consists of a huge, black column. With all three controlled continuously regarding various unwanted or
instances of desulphurization working this parameter malicious substances to assure the agreement with the
usually does also not obstruct the feed-in operation. quality described by Austrian laws.
0.50 5.0
The relevant legislative framework concerning the
gas quality which is given by the Austrian laws OEVGW
H2S- and H2O-content of produced
0.40 4.0
upgrading necessities to produce such a gas have been
biomethane [ppmv]
biomethane [vol%]
0.35
H2O-content 3.5
0.30 3.0
developed. The requirements for a continuous online gas
0.25 2.5
analysis system for several gaseous species have been
0.20 2.0 shown.
0.15 1.5 The biogas upgrading plant commissioned in
0.10 1.0 Bruck/Leitha has been presented in detail and some
0.05 0.5 information on the plant behavior has been given. It has
0.00 0.0 been shown that the upgrading process is very stable and
17.02.2008 17.02.2008 18.02.2008 18.02.2008 18.02.2008 continuous concerning gas quality and quantity. Finally,
12:00:00 18:00:00 00:00:00 06:00:00 12:00:00
some conclusions on electrical power consumption and
Figure 12: Oxygen content, hydrogen sulphide content energy efficiency of the biogas upgrading process have
and moisture content of the produced biomethane been made.
monitored over a period of 24 hours Subsidiary, a dynamic process simulation model for
the Gas Permeation plant has been developed to act as a
The main consumer of electrical power in the biogas test field for the planned control strategies. Together with
upgrading plant is the biogas compressor with a some plant specific data even the parameterization of the
connected load of 55kW and a nominal power implemented PID-controllers has been supported.
consumption of around 33kW for a full load scenario. Moreover, deeper insight into the dynamic phases of
Together with all other power consumers in the plant like plant startup and shutdown has been generated.
blowers, coolers, drives, sensors and electronics (no In the near future, reliable and well-founded data on
power for heating is needed) the total power consumption overall performance parameters will be compiled. These
has been summed up and is given in Table II. parameters will include power consumption and
electrical efficiencies for the whole range of possible
Table II: Total consumption of electrical power for product gas flows, methane slip in the plant Offgas for
biogas upgrading plant for a raw biogas methane content several load scenarios as well as a first estimation on
of about 65 to 68vol% membrane life expectancy. The last point might be one of
the most interesting questions of this new process. The
Product gas flow Total power consumption dynamic process simulation model will be further
65 m³(STP)/h 23.5kW evaluated using experimental data from simple and small
80 m³(STP)/h 28.6kW laboratory scale plants as well as from more complex
100 m³(STP)/h 37.8kW upgrading plants like Bruck/Leitha. Additionally, a
detailed scientific analysis of another Gas Permeation
biogas upgrading plant will be carried out. This plant is
situated in Margarethen/Moos, comprising quite similar
process technology, but has about a third the size of
Bruck/Leitha. Besides, this plant does not feed the
produced biomethane to the public natural gas grid but
feeds its own Bio-CNG-fuelling station. The biomethane
is compressed up to about 250bar and can be fuelled into
any commercial CNG-vehicle as a 100% renewable
automobile fuel. This might be a very interesting concept
in times of huge discussions on the maximum blending
percentages of renewable fuels to gasoline and diesel.
Furthermore, the application of the presented
technology to other gas separation tasks will be
examined.
7 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
8 REFERENCES