Professional Documents
Culture Documents
, Philadelphia
T E C H N I Q U E
䡲 INDICATIONS/CONTRAINDICATIONS
Salvage of failed TAA is challenging because of the
large bony deficit and poor quality of the soft tissue
envelope. Other factors such as subtalar stiffness, and
arthrosis also contribute to the difficulty with manage-
ment. Indications for implant removal and arthrodesis
include pain and impairment due to aseptic loosening of
the TAA in patients who fail nonoperative efforts.2
Contraindication to implant removal and arthrodesis
include acute infection, which requires a staged proce-
dure such as debridement with antibiotic impregnated
spacer and intravenous antibiotics before fusion. Vascu-
lar assessment should be performed before any operative
FIG. 1. Lateral radiograph demonstrates subsidence of
talar component into the subtalar joint. (Copyright, Mayo
procedure. Patient compliance issues should be clarified
Foundation, Rochester, MN.) before proceeding with arthrodesis.
Preoperative Planning
clinical outcome.6 Another study noted methods for de- The patient with persistent or recurrent pain following
termining migration and loosening based on determina- implant surgery should undergo a careful history and
tion of the center of rotation of the prosthesis, and physical examination. The duration, location, quality, se-
changes between the center of rotation and fixed loca- verity of pain should be determined. Any early postop-
tions on the calcaneus and distal tibia.8 Rotational erative problems such as delayed wound healing persis-
changes in the position of the talar component in refer- tent drainage should be determined. The level of
ence to the calcaneus were also considered. This study impairment in daily activities is important in considering
described radiolucent zones of the implant-cement and treatment. Review of systems may be helpful to deter-
cement-bone interfaces that correspond to landmarks on mine causes of lower extremity pain such as ischemic
the prosthesis.8 A grading system was applied to the claudication, neurogenic pain, or infection. Examination
zones. Grade I was less than 1 mm radiolucency. Grade should include a general musculoskeletal exam, includ-
II had 1–2 mm lucency, and grade III had 2 mm or ing neurologic and vascular exam. The patient’s gait
greater lucency.8 There was a lack of clinical correlation should be examined. Skin condition including prior in-
with radiographic analysis in this study.8 cisions should be considered in the planning of any sub-
Management of complications involves nonoperative sequent procedure. Erythema, warmth, or drainage
and operative means. Nonoperative treatment is recom- should be documented. Range of ankle and hindfoot mo-
mended for stress fractures of the tibia or fibula. Persis- tion and pain with motion are important to determine the
tent hindfoot pain can be treated with an orthotic device cause of pain. Examination while standing is important
such as an ankle foot orthosis. Operative management is to assess alignment and leg length discrepancy.
based on the specific problem and may consist of revi- Plain film radiographs are reviewed for determining
sion arthroplasty in cases with no evidence of infection, extremity alignment, subtalar joint disease, bone loss,
good bone stock, failure due to correctable technical bone quality, and location and size of the implant. It is
Volume 1, Issue 1 61
N. B. Bruggeman and H. B. Kitaoka
important to obtain weightbearing AP ankle, weightbear- ration should only be used on the skin as they are bac-
ing lateral ankle, and mortise views, as well weightbear- teriostatic and may alter growth of bacteria.11
ing AP foot, weightbearing lateral foot, and oblique foot In cases where the determination of the cause of pain
views. Loosening and migration of the prosthesis should is uncertain, a bone scan may be helpful. Again, this
be noted as discussed previously. The condition of the study is very nonspecific, but may clarify the location of
subtalar joint is important in preoperative evaluation. A pathology. Selective injections of the ankle joint, areas of
symptomatic, arthritic subtalar joint may require arthrod- impingement, or the subtalar joint may be both diagnos-
esis. If the subtalar joint is in good condition, fixation tic and therapeutic.
across it should generally be avoided. After the diagnosis of failed arthroplasty is made,
The patient should undergo evaluation with appro- optimum treatment of the specific patient should be de-
priate laboratory studies to determine if the arthroplasty termined. In some instances of aseptic loosening, there is
is associated with sepsis. Determination of sepsis can a role for nonoperative treatment such as long-term use
often be made based upon history and exam. There is of an ankle-foot orthosis. Operative treatment could be
data available for infection after other joint arthroplas- considered, such as implant removal and arthrodesis
ties,11 which is relevant to TAA laboratory studies, in- (Figure 2, 3). A general medical evaluation prior to sur-
cluding complete blood count with white blood cell gery is needed. Postoperative management should be dis-
count. This test should be performed, although following cussed and compliance should be determined.
other joint arthroplasty operations only 15% of patients
with infected prostheses had leukocytosis.11 Erythrocyte
sedimentation rate (ESR or sed rate) values of greater 䡲 TECHNIQUE
than 30 to 35 mm per hour are considered abnormal and
indicative of infection unless proved otherwise.11 While Chuinard and Peterson14 described an ankle arthrodesis
the ESR is a nonspecific test, when used in conjunction technique featuring a corticocancellous block of iliac
with history and physical exam, it can be helpful. C- crest interposed between the resected tibial and talar
reactive protein (CRP) has been used as an acute phase bone surfaces15 (Fig. 3). In the original description of the
reactant, and a nonspecific indicator of inflammation. procedures, no fixation was used due to soft tissue com-
The CRP has been shown to be more sensitive and spe- pression secondary to distraction during the procedure.
cific than ESR for infection after joint arthroplasty.11 Because of the interposed graft, this procedure does not
CRP levels of greater than 10 mg/l are considered ab- further shorten the limb. A modification to this procedure
normal. While neither study is diagnostic of infection was proposed by Stauffer,12 in which external fixation
alone, a combination of ESR and CRP may improve was used specifically for patients with failed TAA.
accuracy of diagnosis. The patient is placed supine on the operating table.
Radiographic studies are helpful in the diagnosis of After anesthesia is administered, the lower extremity and
infection after arthroplasty. Determination of loosening the ipsilateral hip should be prepared and draped. If sep-
of a prosthesis on plain films can be an indication of deep sis remains a question, prophylactic antibiotics should
sepsis. Magnetic resonance imaging is usually not appli- not be given until tissue from the ankle is obtained for
cable due to artifact from the metal components, and is pathology and deep cultures. The prior incision may be
not recommended. Other options include the technetium- used, which often is anterior. Another option, if the soft
99m bone scan. This study may be helpful; however, it is tissue envelope permits (i.e., quality of skin and distance
considered sensitive but not specific for infection. Mul- from prior incision), is to use medial and lateral inci-
tiple conditions, such as fractures, tumors, heterotopic sions. If the old incision is used, care should be taken to
ossification, and inflammatory disorders result in in- make full thickness flaps to lessen the potential for skin
creased uptake in periprosthetic tissues.11 Another study necrosis. The anterior soft tissue structures at risk for
available is the white blood cell (WBC) tagged indium injury include the deep peroneal nerve, anterior tibialis
scan. The indium scan offered improved specificity, es- tendon, extensor hallucis tendon, as well as branches of
pecially when used in combination with technetium the superficial peroneal nerve. The exposure may be dif-
scans in patients following hip and knee arthroplasty.11 ficult due to distorted anatomy, and adhesions. The soft
Preoperative aspiration of the ankle for culture can be tissues should be elevated off the tibia. After exposure of
performed prior to proceeding with surgery, if sepsis is a the joint, specimens should be sent for culture. Speci-
diagnostic consideration. Standard aerobic, anaerobic, mens may also be sent to pathology for evaluation of
and fungal culture with sensitivities should be performed acute inflammation. Values greater than 5 polymorpho-
on specimens obtained through aspiration. The results of nuclear leukocytes (PMN) per high power field has been
this test will be improved by stopping antibiotics 2–3 used as a sign of infection in total hip arthroplasty.19 If
weeks before aspiration. Local anesthetics prior to aspi- the intraoperative pathology is negative the case may
proceed as planned, recognizing that cultures are more including removal of the implant and cement, as well as
definitive for infection. all nonviable bone and scar tissue. After debridement, a
If pathology is suggestive of infection, and gross generous volume of crystalloid fluid should be used for
findings correlate, joint debridement must be performed irrigation. An antibiotic-impregnated methylmethacra-
Volume 1, Issue 1 63
N. B. Bruggeman and H. B. Kitaoka
FIG. 3. Techniques of ankle arthrodesis for failed arthroplasty. (A) Malleolar resection. (B) Modified Chuinard arthrodesis.
(C) Modified Campbell arthrodesis. (D) Posterior tibiotalocalcaneal arthrodesis. (Copyright, Mayo Foundation, Rochester,
MN.)
late bead or spacer can be placed into the defect. There transfixing (full) pins, with one placed transversely
are different protocols available for preparing the antibi- through the talar body and one through the neck. The
otic cement; the type and concentration of antibiotic can talar pins should be drilled from medial to lateral to
be varied depending upon the specific patient. One op- avoid neurovascular injury. After the first hole is drilled,
tion is 1.0 g of vancomycin and 1.2 g of gentamycin for the centrally threaded transfixing pin is placed in the
one-half batch of cement. Higher concentrations of an- talar body. A 2-pin holder is placed as a guide for the
tibiotics have been used successfully. The severity of second pin. The second hole is drilled in the talar neck,
necrotic tissue may warrant a further debridement in 2–4 the pin is placed, and the 2-pin holders are attached to a
days. Appropriate intravenous antibiotics should be ad- 2/3 ring. If fixation across the subtalar joint is needed,
ministered for 4–6 weeks, initially empirically, then these pins are placed into the calcaneus, from medial to
based upon cultures and sensitivities. Laboratory studies lateral, and are connected to the 2/3 ring. The ring is
can be followed to document resolution of inflammation placed anterior to the ankle, although some prefer plac-
such as CRP. Adequate treatment of infection should be ing it laterally.
used prior to attempts at arthrodesis. The short connecting rods are applied to the distal
In cases where pathology is negative for infection, ring and tibial pins placed at about the mid tibial level.
the procedure can continue as planned. The components The first tibial half pin is placed, making a 0.5 to 1 cm
should be removed. An effort should be made to preserve incision through the skin, and introducing the sheath and
as much bone as possible, as poor bone stock is a concern trochar onto the anteromedial tibia. The trochar is re-
for any successful arthrodesis technique. moved and both tibial cortices are drilled in a plane
After removal of the implants and cement (Fig. 2), a parallel to the ankle joint line. A half pin is placed. A
tricortical block of iliac crest is placed horizontally into 2-pin holder is placed onto the pin so that a 1/3 ring
the defect to act as a spacer. The method for obtaining
segment may be attached to the pin, with the ring on the
the graft is obtained by making an incision along the
anterior aspect of the leg. The ring should be spaced to
subcutaneous border of the iliac crest. The dissection
allow room for swelling. The 2-pin holder is used as a
should be taken down to the bone and should be sub-
drill guide for the next half pin. A third half pin can be
periosteal. The gluteal muscles should be dissected off
placed on the side of the ring opposite the first 2 pins
the inferior table of the ilium and the trunk muscles, as
(either above or below) in the anterolateral tibia. The pin
well as the iliacus muscle, should be dissected off the
should be placed roughly perpendicular to the other 2
superior ilium. A saw or osteotome may be used to re-
move the graft, which should be measured to fit the tibial half pins.
defect. After the graft is removed, a curette can be used The proximal and distal rings are attached to each
to remove more cancellous bone from the pelvis. Bone other by four connecting rods. The position and align-
wax or Gelfoam can be placed into the defect to avoid ment of the arthrodesis, as well bony apposition and
excessive bleeding. A drain is placed before closure.16 hardware placement, must be assessed visually and ra-
After placement of the graft, alignment is adjusted diologically. If satisfactory, bolts are tightened. The con-
and maintained temporarily by a percutaneous longitu- necting rods are used to apply compression to the ar-
dinal Steinmann pin through the heel, directed into the throdesis. The Steinmann pin is then removed. A drain
tibia. Additional cancellous graft is packed around the can be placed. A meticulous wound closure with gentle
tricortical graft. The external fixator should then be handling of the soft tissues is important to lessen the
placed. Numerous options for type of external fixation potential for skin necrosis. A compressive dressing is
are available, including the Ace-Fischer (DePuy Ace applied. Immediate elevation of the leg is important. The
Medical Company, El Segundo, CA), the EBI Dynafix advantage of the modified Chuinard procedure includes
ankle fixator (EBI Medical Systems, Parsippany, NJ), the good preservation of length, which is beneficial for leg
Calandruccio triangular compression device (Smith and length and tendon function15 (Figures 4, 5).
Nephew, Memphis, TN), the Orthofix fixator (Richard- Malleolar resection arthrodesis is a simpler technique
son, TX), and others. Most of these systems are modular of ankle arthrodesis for a failed TAA (Fig. 3). This pro-
and the specific frame construction and pin placement cedure involves implant and cement removal, as well as
can be tailored to the patient. Some are uniaxial and thus resection of the margins of the tibia, talus, and fibula to
have a lower profile. While internal fixation may be suc- achieve satisfactory bone apposition. Supplemental bone
cessfully applied, the small talar bone stock following graft can be placed; however, no interpositional graft is
implant loosening may not allow adequate purchase for placed. Rigid external or internal fixation is then applied.
screw fixation. If internal fixation is used, it is important to avoid place-
The Ace Fisher frame consists of partial rings con- ment of hardware into the subtalar joint. The advantages
nected by bars that compress the joint. The talar pins are of this procedure are the greater direct bony apposition
Volume 1, Issue 1 65
N. B. Bruggeman and H. B. Kitaoka
FIG. 4. A 57-year-old male carpenter had a painful total ankle arthroplasty. (A) Preoperative radiograph. (B) Immediately
after implant removal and modified Chuinard procedure with external fixation. (C) Three years later, the patient had no
significant pain, returned to work without functional restrictions. (D) Lateral radiograph shows good alignment and pres-
ervation of ankle height. (Copyright, Mayo Foundation, Rochester, MN.)
achieved without structural graft, which adds to the po- applied in compression. This procedure is useful in large
tential for rapid union. Malleolar resection is useful in defects. The procedure, like the modified Chuinard pro-
the treatment of failed TAA with history of sepsis where cedure, does require a separate incision for iliac crest
avascular bone graft is less attractive. The disadvantage harvesting.16
of this procedure is the degree of shortening caused by Posterior tibiotalocalcaneal arthrodesis (Fig. 3) is a
resection. Shortening can contribute to leg length dis- procedure described by Russotti et al.18 It is an operation
crepancy and tendon dysfunction.16 involving fusion of both the tibiotalar and the subtalar
The modified Campbell arthrodesis technique in- levels for patients with failed TAA and hindfoot disease
volves vertically oriented struts of tricortical iliac crest requiring arthrodesis. This procedure is considered when
bone graft inserted into a rectangular shaped mortise the talar component has subsided into the subtalar joint,
(Fig. 3). The mortise created by osteotomies in the origi- in cases of severe talar bone loss, and subtalar arthrosis.
nal report17 is similar to the gap created by removal of an The patient must be placed prone on the operating table.
ankle implant. Morcellated corticocancellous graft is A longitudinal incision is made on the lateral border of
then placed around the struts, and an external fixator is the Achilles tendon. The tendon is transected and the
FIG. 5. Radiographs of a 41-year-old man with a painful ankle after total ankle arthroplasty. (A) Anteroposterior (AP) view
shows loosening, subsidence and malleolar impingement. (B) Lateral radiograph. (C) AP view 14.5 years after successful
modified Chuinard operation with external fixation. (D) Lateral view. (Copyright, Mayo Foundation, Rochester, MN.)
ankle and subtalar joints are exposed through the interval sider the condition of soft tissues. Full thickness flaps
between the flexor hallucis longus tendon medially and should be created. Excessive traction on the skin should
peroneus brevis tendon laterally. The implant and cement be avoided and this may require longer incisions. A me-
are removed and a trough is created in the posterior tibia, ticulous closure is very important. With good attention to
talus, and calcaneus. Morcellated iliac crest bone graft is soft tissues, risk of wound necrosis can be decreased.
packed into the trough and an external fixator is applied. The positioning of the ankle arthrodesis should ad-
Posterior tibiotalocalcaneal arthrodesis procedure has the here to the principles outlined by Morrey et al.19 The
advantage of using a posterolateral approach in which ankle should be placed in neutral flexion, zero to 5 de-
the soft tissue envelope is less disturbed. This procedure grees of valgus angulation of the hindfoot and 5 to 10
also requires a separate incision for iliac crest graft.15 degrees of external rotation. This position allows the
Regardless of the procedure chosen, care should be greatest compensatory motion at the foot and places less
taken to plan incisions based on prior incisions and con- strain on the knee.19
Volume 1, Issue 1 67
N. B. Bruggeman and H. B. Kitaoka