Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Mubarak Abdessalam argues that “Failure has never been an objective in itself, though it sometimes
imposes itself on people at the end of a project. It has never been welcome. It is subject to reject, refute,
unfriendliness. In a word it is a pest. What do you think, however of a person who works hard to be a
"successful" failure? Nonsense! It is not easy to long for failure unless you know quite well what it is all
about. Logically, it is awkward and strange that a person has failure for an aim in life.”
[ABDESSALAM 2001].
Tim Berry stated that“ Product and brand failures occur on an ongoing basis to varying degrees within most
product-based organizations. This is the negative aspect of the development and marketing process. In most
cases, this “failure rate” syndrome ends up being a numbers game. There must be some ratio of successful
products to each one that ends up being a failure. When this does not happen, the organization is likely to
fail, or at least experience financial difficulties that prohibit it from meeting profitability objectives. The
primary goal is to learn from product and brand failures so that future product development, design,
strategy and implementation will be more successful.”
[BERRY 2000].
The book “Qualities can replace defects” written by Ardelean Gheorghe Cornel, writes about the failure is,
[CORNEL 2010].
The article “ NEW MORNING FOR MOUNTAIN DEW” in Strategic Brand Management book written by
Kevin Lane Keller tells about the Mountain Dew that “This branding brief is all about the first launch of
mountain dew in 1969 in US. Pepsi company marketed Mountain Dew with logo that “YAHOO
MOUNTAIN DEW” when it was unsuccessful in its first attempt in early 1980 it changed it strategies and
came with a new slogan “do the dew” by focusing on out doors action scene in its ads. Since then it has
been capturing the market share and most recently it had introduced Mountain Dew Code Red its first line
extension and still focusing on improving further.”
[KELLER 2002]
Interview
According to KARIM.A.KHAN(Regional Sales Manager of PEPSI.CO) following are the reasons that lead
the Mountain Dew to fail and the new strategies that adopted for Relaunching of Mountain Dew:
Positioning:
Mountain dew is positioned as “Refreshing, Unique and Energizing soft drink at a very reasonable price
with new convenient packaging”.
Product Line:
Mountain Dew will be launched in Different Packaging after getting a success in a market.
Price:
Mountain’s Dew price is same as of its competitors.
Distribution Outlets:
To increase the distribution of mountain dew in the remaining 4000 untapped retail outlets.
Sales Force:
Currently operational with 10 sales promotional officer who are responsible for the direct sales to
institutions, marriage halls, caters, offices, schools and teashops.
Sale Promotion:
Sales promotion will take form through giving consumers and retailers and distributors by offering them
benefits. For retailers and Distributors sales discount and to consumer by offering them free drink on
purchase of every two drinks.
Advertising:
Mountain Dew uses the advertising initially for consumer awareness of the product and its benefits.
Heavily spending on advertisements to get the vacancy in the market and in consumers mind. It will also
use billboards, banners, and posters.
Marketing Research:
We at mountain dew have the motto to satisfy the customer and consumers efficiently and effectively, in
order to achieve this motto mountain dew’s marketing team will constantly keep in touch with consumers
to iden6tify their buying preferences and their changing taste and benefits sought by the product.
Total Customer Cost:
The monetary cost of the mountain dew is Rs. 15 which is going rate price but increased quantity of 50 ml
and will be widely available around the city in around 11,000 retail shops.
Satisfaction:
Satisfaction: is the person’s feeling of pleasure or disappointment resulting from comparing a product
perceived performance in relation to their expectations? Mountain dew’s motive is to delight the customers.
If customers are delighted with quality, taste, quantity, availability and perceived performance, it will
create emotional bond with the brand not just rationale preferences resulting in brand loyalty.
The value deliver system of mountain dew includes communication channels, experiences consumers will
have on the way to obtaining the product. In order to keep the track of the customers satisfaction or
dissatisfaction mountain dew will adopt certain ways, which are as under:Complaint & suggestion
Systems:
Mountain Dew will provide store customer suggestions and customer complaint form which will be
delivered directly to Mountain Dew, which will give Mountain dew opportunity to learn about customers
and their preferences.
Customer Satisfaction Survey:
Mountain Dew will conduct surveys quarterly to or yearly in order to identify the customer’s satisfaction
and dissatisfaction level.
After gathering the information and data about the customer satisfaction and dissatisfaction, Mountain Dew
will implement those changes, which is being suggested by consumer to satisfy them efficiently and in cost
effective way.
Analyzing Environments:
Karim.A.Khan argued that “Marketing Environment is very important for any business (of any
sort),anywhere in the world to analyze the global macro environmental forces, the demographic, economic,
natural, technological, political-legal and social cultural, therefore to determine that do the people of the
country where it is operating have the ability to purchase (purchasing power).
MD management has analyzed all these macro environmental forces, as to identify, anticipate and plan for
the re-launch of Mountain Dew.
Demographic Environment,The first of the macro environmental force that MD examines is population
because people make up markets and the company is interested in the size, density and growth rate of
population of the city.
As, Mountain Dew is only being re-launched in Karachi, there for we have to analyze the age and
household patterns of the city.
Population varies from their age mix. Population of Karachi can be subdivided into five different age
groups: school-age children, teenagers, young adults age 25 to 40, middle-aged adults age 40 to 65, and age
65 and up.
The ‘traditional house hold’ consists of a husband, wife, and children living with parents and grandparents
(in some case husband wife and children) five to six people averagely in a household.
The company is searching for ways to attract the decision makers (aging 25 to 40) to purchase the newly
launched drink.
Economic Environment ,Purchasing power of the population determines the economic environment of a
country. The available purchasing power in an economy depends on current income, prices, savings, debts,
credit availability and very importantly the spending power.
The income level of people in Karachi is very low, trend of saving is not there, credit availability is very
low and the overall economy is depending on foreign debts (loans). In other words, there is no trend of
discretionary income as not much amount of income is left after the income (disposable) utilized on
necessities (food and health, clothing and shelter).
Pakistan basically a subsistence economic country, hence vast majority of the people are engaged in the
agricultural sector. People in Karachi are usually salaried or self-employed in different fields. The average
family income of people in Karachi specially is around Rs. 3000 or even less.
Natural Environment,The deterioration and descent of the natural environment is a major concern for the
company.
As, there is scarce presence of the natural resources.
Shortage of raw materials, the increased cost of energy, increased government intervention, increased
pollution levels, threat and fear of terrorism, nuclear power and arm race in the region are the major threats
faced by Pakistan.
The earth’s raw materials consist of the infinite, the finite renewable, and the finite nonrenewable
resources.
Infinite resources, such as air and water, pose no immediate problem, although some groups see a long run
danger. Finite resources such as forest and food, oil and increasing inflation in the country has to be
considered, in order to re-launch Mountain Dew successfully in the market.
Pricing strategies would be developed for the drink keeping into consideration these factors.
We are looking for ways to protect the environment and trying to eliminate and get rid of the discharge of
waste material (such as plastics, non biogradable bottles, chemicals, nuclear wastes etc) from the factories,
as to prevent the quality of the natural environment. The overall pollution level in Karachi is rising at an
alarming rate.
Technological Environment,New technological advancement can be a source of creative destruction. We
have monitored the changing technological trends in the society but we don’t consider it an important
factor in the production of cola drink.
Political Legal Environment,Marketing decisions are strongly affected by developments in the political and
legal environment.Pakistan has a very unstable political scenario due the instability of the government,
which disturbs the momentum of the companies and gives negative signals to the foreign investors. Hence,
the general outlook of the government towards business practices and ethical issues is uncooperative.
Pepsi has been having problems in decision-making, as decisions are strongly affected by the development
in the political and legal environment, which consists of law enforcement agencies, government, and media
that poses restrictions and hurdles in the operations of companies. Therefore, Pepsi for itself has contracted
with some agencies over sea for the responsibility of regulating business, as they do not want to have any
sort of negative impact on Mountain Dew, because its being re-launched.
Nature Of High Performance Businesses:
Karim.A.Khan stated that:Mountain Dew has identified the nature and characteristics of high performance
businesses which are as under:
Stakeholders.
Processes.
Resources.
Organization.
Today businesses are increasingly recognized that unless they nourish stakeholder, customers, employees,
suppliers, distributor and the business may never earn sufficient profits for the stockholders.
Mountain Dew aim to deliver satisfaction for its stakeholders that is:Delight its customers.
Perform well for its employee.
Deliver a maximum satisfaction to its suppliers.
Mountain Dew operates with a philosophy of creating high level of employee satisfaction, which will lead
to higher efforts resulting in higher quality products and services, which creates higher customer
satisfaction, which will give more repeat business, which will give higher growth and profits, which gives
high satisfaction of stockholders, resulting to more investments.
Mountain Dew will accomplish its satisfaction goal by linking and managing work processes. Mountain
Dew is focusing on the needs to manage core business processes such as:
Reengineering the Work Flow.
Building Cross Functional Teams.
New Product Development.
Customer Attraction and Retention.
Order Fulfillment.
Mountain Dew is a new product to the market, which will be distributed to 11,000 outlets through out
Karachi through Distributors and own Distribution Channels. Mountain Dew will build strategies to keep
customer attracted to the product and fulfill the requirements of the distributors to make their work more
efficiently in cost effective way.
To operate the resource Mountain Dew need labor, power, raw material, machineries information, energy
etc.
Mountain dew is equipped with modern machineries and technologies to carry out the work process. ISO
9002 also certifies Mountain DewThe company is a source of competitive advantage in that it makes a
significant contribution to perceived customers benefits, it has a potential breadth of applications to a wide
variety of markets like juices.
Mountain Dew consists of structures, policies and corporate culture, all of which can become dysfunctional
in a rapidly changing business environment.”
According to Karim.A.Khan “A person’s perception and awareness can be observed when he/she comes to
purchase a certain product but it is difficult to find out that who makes the decision as what to buy, why
and when to buy. Women are the main purchasers of household items in Pakistan and specially Karachi.
The chief of the house makes the decisions for the purchases of household eatables, foods and meals; hence
the housewives and mothers make the decisions.
Company is focusing on the chief of the house who can play a very vital role in purchasing and increasing
the sale of Mountain Dew.
Following are the roles people might play in a buying decision:
Initiator, Any person from household can be an initiator who can suggest the purchase of Mountain Dew.
Influencer, Media advertising, bill boards, friends, family members can be good influencers or advisors for
the purchase.
Decider, The final decision for the purchase of food items is of the chief in-charge of the house.
Buyer, The buyer of Mountain Dew can be either man or woman.
User, The users of Mountain Dew will be all the family members of all age groups.
Buying Behavior, The consumer decision-making varies with what type of buying decision he/she has
made.
Habitual Buying Behavior, Many consumers buy drinks or any other item under habitual buying behavior
just to fulfill the basic need and thirst. They have low involvement and only buy drinks, which they are
fond off. As, Cola drinker will continue with cola and lemon lime drinkers will continue with it, until they
are attracted to make a change of taste.
Variety Seeking Buying Behavior, The people go for different variety of brands, and can easily get
attracted and change switch over from one to another if that item attracts them more then they had been
having.”
Branding Challenges:
Karim.A.Khan listed the following branding challenges:
Brand Sponsor decision:
Mountain Dew is a manufacturer brand of Pepsi Cola Inc as all the soft drinks are made under the umbrella
of Pepsi Cola like Miranda, Teem.
Price Quality :
Karim.A.Khan argued that”Mountain dew is offered at an ongoing price as compared to competitors with
no superior quality. Mountain dew is following high value strategy.Mountain dew has considered the
factors in setting its pricing policy
Mountain dew has an objective to get maximum market share because the management believe that a
higher sales volume will lead to lower unit costs and higher long run profits.
In the economic sense, demand and price are inversely related: the higher the price, the lower the demand.
However, if too high a price is charged, the level of demand may fall.
The buyers are fully aware of the soft drinks and they are very price sensitive, to keep the consumers
awareness in mind we are providing the unique product in taste in the same category of white soft drink at
ongoing prices.
Mountain dews offer is superior, we can charge more as compare to our competitors but the consumers are
more prices sensitive and they are not risk takers if the price is charged too high they will prefer other drink
instead of mountain dew. In order togain the market share and convince consumer to try our product we at
mountain dew will be charging the same price of our competitors.”
According to Karim.A.Khan “Mountain Dew bases its prices largely on competitors, that is the firm
charging the same price as of its competitors. In Pakistan all the soft drink industry leaders follow either its
new or old product. If price is charged lower than competitors the product is perceived to be low in quality
as well and if the prices are charged more than competitors consumer hesitate to try and adopt the product
launched in the market, this is what happened with Mountain Dew in its last experience it was charging
premium price for it but failed to receive the consumer response so in order to relaunch it we will be
charging Going Rate Pricing which is Rs.10 but we will be giving them more of the quantity in the same
price.
Mountain Dew will practice the price discount and allowances strategies for its product in order to increase
its sales and getting the payments on time to reinvest in inventories or other operation and this will benefits
customers to further sell it on, going rate pricing which will maximize their profits and can offer other
channels more profits to sell our products, which will increase the consumption of the products from
distributors and retailers and increased point of sales promotion to sell mountain dew more because they
will be getting more profits in it.
With price discounts and allowances company will also offer Promotional Pricing maximize sales.”
Distribution Situation:
Karim.A.Khan argued that “Company is using 2 channels for distribution of Mountain Dew
• Retail outlets (Indirect Channel)
• Sales promotion officers (Direct Channel)
There are 14,000 retail outlets in Karachi, which provide every day consumable items to the consumers.
Mountain Dew is distributed to 10,500 of these outlets. 75% percent of the mountain dew’s sales would be
through indirect channels.
Mountain Dew is being distributed to institutions like government institutes, offices, teashops, caters,
schools, colleges, universities, net cafes airport, and marriage halls. Company has a sales team of 50
members for the direct sales promotion for the initial sales, which will be reduced once getting hold of the
market. This channel will constitute 25% percent of the total soft drink’s sales.
Marketing channels are set of interdependent organization involved in the process of making a product
available for use or consumption.
Distribution plays a vital role in a success of a company, with the growing population and growing number
of new localities, it is not possible to serve the market completely. Mountain Dew has its own distribution
channels as well as they have contracted different distributors according to localities. Mountain Dew has
acquired five distributors through out Karachi to make its product available for consumption.
Distributors are divided in North, East, South, West and District, Malir, which is the other quarter of
Karachi.
Channel Function and FlowMarketing channels performs the work of moving goods from producer to
consumers. It overcomes the time, place and possession gaps that separate goods and services from those
who need and want them. Mountain Dew motive to acquire distributors due to several reasons, the will
perform several function which are as under:
They gather information about potential and current customers, competitors and other forces in the
marketing environment.
They develop and disseminate persuasive communications to stimulate purchasing.
They acquire funds to finance inventories at different level in the marketing channel.
Mountain Dew will be using its own distribution force and will assign distributors according to districts. It
is using Intensive Distribution strategy to ma make its product available everywhere in the city. Reason
for Mountain using its own distribution channel is to reach those isolated area where distributors can not
reach or does not think of market potentiality e.g, Korangi Industrial Area, Orangi Town etc.”
[KHAN 2010,www.pepsi.com].
Reference List:
Textbook:
Ardelean Gheorghe Cornel 2010 Qualities can replace defects, USA
Website:
http://www.geocities.com/abdessalami2001/
http://www.copernicusmarketing.com/univers/reasons_for_product_failure.shtml
http://articles.mplans.com/product-and-brand-failures-a-marketing-perspective/
http://www.pepsi.com/
Dictionaries:
The Dictionary of Business and Management Wiley; 3 edition (November 12, 1992)
Personal Communication:
KARIM.A.KHAN ,pers. comm. 26 Nov 2010 interview by Regional Sales Manager