!"$#%&'( ) +*,#-

./10325456879;:9<0=9<0?>@256A0?9B9<CEDF9+GH6I9<0AJ
KMLONQP<R;SUTVLWXSZY\[^]`_aLbSURUcabOP<_dP<WIegfhYiTNQjISULORF]`WQkiclWQLOLRUcaWIkQm
nFclbOLopWIclqiLRUr;clStsimvuxw+yiyz|{~}P<clWgzASURULLSm
pY<jQr;SUYiWmi<yiyix{
+;< U+XH ;
 vF$
,ZX+Qt-B5t;XX<Ba+`B-t$+
X+X+gBXtA+h+XA+Bt+
BB55BiXptt5+^+Bpt8
tt|BA++5%X;ZB^X+v+
BX+QtptXX\B^3XA5At+OO
5+dA+FX+`+XA+`+\iQ5a++X
XX5t\hB&t-5+?A++X-
+X+ B`xiF+IB+++;X'dXH%Mt
QZHZ
X 5 p8
X+%t<tXH+%+5BA^X+Q5l+
X+?+X+i+Xt<\B5hBXB5X
XX;+XBBt+X+5?B5,+X+
B(BtAB$+B5t5AtVt<t5 X5+t
X+(+5%Ba<BXIt;XX+
X5At=\t55X+XB5t5hX
B5+5AB5+XXXtl+8XA5O
XX5t<t5 B+5,aB
+`Bt<ttpZBFtA+X5IABX
X+IAXX
B^Q++\dXXBh;X+X+<l+
XX5|B^ittX+Ap+\iO+5
+XX+t+A\8OiX
+B\it+++XV<XH%A
l+M+5t5+p+X+A+5 Xt
+t5t5d+x+tiXt+`OipX+B<<Ft
t+%l+%;X+pX+`ZB5+U|+X
tQ5xOipX+B<<Ztt+da+Bt\
^+ 
FXvAQ5?X+Qt&hB5tXX\Bl+3B
t+3%Bh+B++|;X+-X+5 B

X+Qt+++;X(B+(tt;tt?-
A+XBxBX+tQ,XAt=+\<X
+d+XX+XtZA+XB5d,pBHXBZB5
+++X+55++XMX+=i
BM+++X5 BhX+Qt+++XX+
ttttA5%t-X`+%XX<X+Qx5
Q O$  pV V  %
,AB5Xt+X+A&%+t
BAt-\+XX+%XtBt+ B;X+XB<X
XXX5XB5;^+\
+Mx
%B5 B$t+XttgX+1 pX
+ X+ BBtQB\+X

5XtBVXBQ Bt+Xtt=
X+\BA A +B5;t+BBtAX+
A+%?3XAQ5%ttdXt+dt
BXXA+A`+%I5A$QHZ
A
aA  

%B5  
h$B(BaAX %5+5Hv
BB+`tt`B;t+`tAXiX+x+A5%t
X&A5\%X;F<X\d+X5++
A%+FBtX+Qt8  iFB+A
+^X+AZ+  B+XX+
B3B+d+AFtZA+%+X+pAttxB
$BFt+++X
 v - p  
 BA+$A+A tIX=+=t+-X
t+XttX+ A a+&  < X3X+X
!XXt+55BtBBA+

t+XttMX+  +X+XX+AB`

 %5t+5\XtFBhBZtt5\5Q+t3+X+XX\35B+B`<AQ|txX
Q5+Xt+|Xha++vAB+?Bt$5t
+p !
Xtt+ B++t;B%B5 B
t5X+XMX+AtB5t5B(+X8X
Ba+Xtt,xXXX+`XXv
BgtX+X+t\XX #" % $ "'&(&(&(" * )
+B5tl XX<X+QV`BxB$<
+A , ,.-=x0 /21
1-=x0 /
l+ 3 <-+X%&B+B+Qa+X

$OBpA XBIX5+QV+
iXAMtFX5XB^+B5A+`Bt4 
,%|AtttFX+++Xa+hXt\Z
%X;`+\
a
d6 587 795:a*

%B5 /25;- <
hX8X+X(V+Q5B=B
X
i= <5 B(+BX-B
tXh+iBt+AttZX+QiB%ZBZ
5+$? >I+Xhtt55Qt`B\`+++X t
ttBIX+XAA @hXX?tt+
BxX+QXA$+X$BZtAZ5+$xX+
tt+`BX+dXA  BF\t\
dX%p+A+AApB%tX;+QB
+,X++X8t+Xtt8X+3+t
\A+1B <ZX+Qt-A%FXtZttt;
H+5BAA+-+IAtX;5
B+`BZ5+h+|tviB-tX+?B-
X+?\BAB+M+%BM+Bpt+X
ttA+%t<BX+',,X5XB+Qx
O+B8l+,BD
CFEHGIX,+Bt5X
I K JL A7NM: I -PO + I K JL A7NM $ I -PO B5 MQ +X M $
BS R55|+A T
 B5t+`Xt5A

Probability of not including correct itenary in subset

BdB+A+BXXX+;X+
A & t%+X+t

t%Q<X+t%B&Z+iB+FX+1U@B
XZa+t^+dt+tX;5
?5+ZQd+hBH%ZX?BdA+AA+iX+
X5XXBB,+tX+FX8t;+Xtt
A+xt<BXhBt+vQAtX;&5+
QZXXHit<
WV QMN79OX/=x0 /2MD O
V 0 YPO=

%XAXt6
 O[Z4]^ \
XAB5B+XX
$
X R _, a `
+X x XXa+XttABt
Q55+A%A&+\O+dBXl+
BZt\%?
XA+V+XX+Axa+8Ab >I5 O
+Mc = a+d+A+Bt5+t`d+W i= <g+
edOg fh<^&5aBAXXl+^+\O+X
+ O BX+xAXB3BAt5|+AtX?%
B+X5XXX+tXIH , ih X
( R5`+IB`t;t5B5QXA|B^O+X+ O +X
5+8QpXtVt+5t+B5 >I55(xi
+XQ5a++A+
9

SNR = 27dB

x 103

8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
0

0.01

0.02

0.03

0.04

0.05
0.06
Epsilon

0.07

0.08

0.09

0.1

BBjA+?-B+?X5XXB&B+|tX
BBAt5p+`IAt5XFl+t\?
i =
< +Q , gf
 AX+X$5+QAtX5d

Q5a++;x+t,t;(l+-BxA+?+BM+
BMt+Xtt(X+|a+-+,+XttX5
,`B kt\ZB<t`B`tAF+XpxX+<XX
8Xh+hBMXXA+AA+5+H
B-xi5+$QhaXB5`H5$<XBp
BiAXa+8tA++t(t;a+BxA+
+B$+%B$t+Attgt<BX+D
iX

N = 10 , a = 3.9
100
90

1/Estimator Variance in dB

80
70
60
50
40
30
CramerRao bound
subspace estimator low complexity
Dynamic Programming estimator
subspace method high complexity

20
10
10

15

20

25

30
SNR

35

40

45

50

3Bw!j:tt+yx;+XZa+%+-
N = 10 , a = 2
120
subspace estimator
Maximum likelihood estimator

110
100
1/Estimator Variance in dB

Xt;XBH+5BAt5+-QAt5Xt
5|5+dBB5 tt++pBAtx+A+t
tt+H
B-B5XAtA+-+++X ^X;( R5I
H
l + X\AtZ++ O A+AtX$iB+%B+-+: i= <+X
l B(+;%X5BB5B+AZt5B++%I QAI t5;X+ pI A+t
K JL :7DMQ- B-m R5O 5%K +JL| S7
I

M $ -PO
M: M $
T

l BB+IX++QO+tBX XXMMt+=;Btxt5M;tt
)
l BXZ\HtFtB%FttX+X5x+X ++B-X+
nv Q
B,A++pBt5++5Xo i= <
B%p
3a+Xt\8 +Xq

!
l+pB+tl+|X+AB1r B
XhAXZ-5pXZBF5+F-H5FX+
B ;+5 <%VIAX(+XXt<B\8A+t
B+`B+t%-XH+-XX5tBhI5l+t
+Xp+3XFBAA+Ztt+%a+%$Xb >Q5
O+B+%tB+%+a+tXVBX
X+B+B+ BBAtx++QIA`t5;Xd+5
%X;t;p++BB+Q+
B5+tp5+QM<QtBXX5-ti
t;+;X5+ +5tF <,IAX%B5+
BH5Bt;Q5l+;A+X,tQ
5+X2
B <F5 B$A++Bt+
A+hB%(N t s<-5aBAB
X$B8tt+$A+\At8+I5+
l+pXu i= <Z5MZBF ktBXZFX
i= <Z$B,tt+$t\+X\A+t+X
+X5+%B +5tF <QXX
vQ  p8
,X+M\t<AXB5 tXX\Bpl+Bpt
+A%B+B++AA+`X+5 B^B5
tXA\XV\++\X5+Zt5+Zt
+tAh+XX4 kt\$tBXFX
X+&AX+AtX8+`Xv XZBB
tA+`A+t;+++X'X+dAO

90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
10

15

20

25
SNR

30

35

X-z:&t+yx+XZa+%t\%

40

VAB+XH tt+5+%+A+
^Xx5A%tM+AiXX+?+XA+BthX+i
B&+XB+&X+A+;X+XB55+
+tIF+<tABtBF5+t%Xt
iBH%g XXg+%B;X+X+^M+At5+
Bt+ AZ%XA+B$5+t+%%
+XB+Ai= +XXA+XB5'B,5+t,+
XAX+(X+XBB(+VA\<5+
XX +X=t5a5X,%BV+B+B5$Xb >Q5t
\h5X<X%%QQFX5Bt+X5+BZXt5
Q5a++X+

10

Logistic map
Tent map

Estimator Bias

10

10

10

10

106
10

15

20

25

30

35

40

45

50

55

Bsj{tt+A+&l+t\+X+t%
v| } 
UW< t5+uF~ +FhtiXt+MOBX+X\i
tt+8Q5a++Aa+(;X+gA+
B+:Sz
z e#_
z
b
#[ [

+X]!j ,K,e , #< K s<
 W< t5+Z~ +X6dx Bth+Xi V5i
iXda+&X+%A+itv*:Sg
z[
e__
g
b
4#[ 
 ]!j3 , #!  , #<
K s<
! +ZV+55i t5+cF~ ++XVXj%< ;X
i A+I5Aa+BXXBiX+5+xti
t5[
{ g ` 5z # #!K< A K <
h +Q KV A+B+QXd+Ah5++,+t
BAVOBXM+B<<pt+QZ5+
+A+X+5t::g ]#_ 
'[4K_
AzAX3!i# !id\
z K s<
z

g
SNR