Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Richard E. Albright
v2
Key Points
Portfolio Management is a Process
The key link among strategy, product development, and operational processes. Multiple portfolios of markets, offers, products/platforms, and technologies.
Portfolio Management:
In the Context of Business Processes
Portfolio Management: a critical linking process Cross-functional responsibility:
Strategy + Marketing + Product Development.
Process View of Business Process View of aaBusiness
Marketing & Sales Process
Market Segmentation Create Offers and Mktg Plans Sales & Delivery
Manage
Develop prototype With development The product in the market The market
Offers Offers
~ Tens Hundreds
A roadmap defines a product with links to strategy, market, technology. Roadmaps for offers link products, markets, strategy. Roadmaps include the drivers and plans to manage the technology portfolio.
Roadmapping
is a Learning process for the group. is a Communication tool for the group.
Product-Technology Roadmap
A Business Planning Tool
Feature Evolution Plan
Last Year Now + 1 Year +2 Years +3 Years VISION
Product Architecture
Antenna Display RF Battery
Risk Roadmap
Risk Categories
NOW
Risk m1 [.4] Risk m2 [.5]
+2Q
+4Q
+6Q
LONG-TERM
Risk m3 [.2]
Market
(growth,strategy, product attributes, etc.)
market events
Technical
(component or system performance) test events
Risk t1 [.2]
Risk t2 [.1]
Risk t3 [.5]
Baseband
Map to Investments
(deliverables) completion events
Schedule
Risk s1 [.3]
Risk s2 [.1]
1999 $89.21
2000 $79.21
2001 $60.00
2002 $45.00
2003 $39.00
Target $28
Source
Economic
Risk e1 [.2]
Risk e2 [.1]
Component #2
$20.00
$19.53
$18.00
$17.00
$15.00
$10
Disruptive Resource
$150.00
Component #3
$10.50
$9.38
$8.45
$4.37
$2.05
$2
Monitor
Risk Consequence:
Component #4
$15.40
$14.11
$12.30
$8.50
$8.30
$8
Attack
Minor
Major
Show Stopper
Implications
Scope
(what can be varied in the product)
Product Driver/Targets
KEY DRIVERS: KEY DRIVERS: 1. Product Driver #1 1. Product Driver #1 2. Product Driver #2 2. Product Driver #2 3. Product Driver #3 3. Product Driver #3 SECONDARY DRIVERS SECONDARY DRIVERS 4. Secondary Product Driver 4. Secondary Product Driver 5. Secondary Product Driver 5. Secondary Product Driver 6. Secondary Product Driver 6. Secondary Product Driver
D river #1
Specialized Labor
$5.00
$4.50
$4.30
$4.10
$3.10
$5
COGS
Competitive Landscape
Metric
C p ometitor S gth (+ a d tren s ) n Bonding (sh base) are; w n ea (how to gaink esses(-) C pn oma y
(x% y ) ;%
advantage)
C C p cy ore ometen
S tegicG ls tra oa
XX X
Current Current Position Position lag lag lag lag Parity Parity
1 .0 0
Map to Elements
Installation $9.43 $8.33 $7.95 $6.58 Misc. $4.67 $4.35 $4.23 $4.21
$100.00
Differentiating
Product/Process Differentiation
$6.34
$4
$4.15
$5
Product Drivers
$50.00
$154 $139 $115 $90 Technology Roadmap Product$15 Elements$5 Manufacturing Cost $25 $7 Material Cost
$78
$62
Action Summary
Product & Technology Strategies: : Product & Technology Strategies Base
Lead in: Lead in: Lead in: Lead in:
Widespread and Shared
Defend
$4
$5
Architectural Fit
$0.00 1999 2000
TOTAL COST
$179
$122
$95
$82
COST TARGET
$170
$104
$75
$67
$67
TE2 TE3
Tech. Area
Area #1 Area #2
Now
Acquire
Driver #1
+2Q
+4Q
Partner
+6Q
Driver #1
Develop
Vision
Product #1 Product #1
1 .0 19 97
19 98
19 99
20 00
20 01
20 02
20 03
20 04
Value Functionality
Technology Source
Product E1
$?M/ ?HY
Driver #1, Driver #2
C p ometitor #1
(x% y ) ;%
Baseband circuit
Customer Drivers
C p ometitor #2
(x% y ) ;% Cmetito C ustom er Driver #1 op r #3 (x% y% ; )
MaptoProductDrivers
*, * Best Other Vendor
$10.00
1.0 0
Dashed lines represent improvement rate expected from 80% slope on learning curve
Technology Roadmap
TE4 TE5 TE6
ACA 1 83 2 CM O S B ip ola r d iscretes 8 bit C IS C 1 6 bit C IS C m icro co n troller 1.4m m 6 la ye r 1m m 4 -lin e L C D N a vig a tio n k eys M en u d rive n N iC d - 4.8V L inea r - 5 0% effic ie n t M o du le T rip le con ve rsio n D u al b and , H ig h g ain V c elp E xp an d e r P iez o ele ctric D ou ble co nv ersion D iv ersity IT U , Q ce lp 1 3 IS -99 D a ta B E R Im p rov em ent/e c ho c a nc el. F irs t o rd er g rad ien t (F O G ) N oise c an ce lling e arpiec e, m iniatu riz e d F un ding sta tu s: S taffe d S tee ring array CF CF C o nfigu ra ble N iM H - 3.6V S w itch ing (80 % eff.) M M IC -3 V H o m od y ne T u na ble , H om o dy n e 1 .7m m th ic k 6 la ye r 1.5 m m 2-lin e L C D In teg rate d C a ll sig na l proc . CF
Area #3
.
Product #1
$?M/?HY
Product #1
Interoperability
Now
Area #4
$?M/?HY
Product #4
P ro du ct d riv ers C o re tec hn olog y A re a W e ig h t/siz e In te rfa ce A S IC DSP A u dio co de c A u dio f ro nt en d M ic roc ontro ller
Last Yr
$/unit
Service/Support
57 35 C hip
+1 Year
+2 Year
+3 Year
V IS IO N
Im po rt.
C o m p et. P o sition
Area #5
CF C F C F C CF CF CF CF C F CF CF F C CF CF CF CF C F C F CF C F CF CF CF CF CF C F CF C F CF F C F CF CF C CF M o lde d-in V oic e Interfac e F CF
$?M/?HY
Product #4
Architectural Fit
$1.00 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001Ease of training 2002 2003 2004
1 .0 19 9 19 9 and7use8 19 99 20 00 20 01 20 02 20 03
TE7S in glend B as e ba
C h ip
S o ft R ad io
Area #6
$?M/?HY
20 04 PD2
H ou sin g PW B E ase o f u se D isp lay U ser in te rf ac e S oftw are T alk tim e B attery P ow e r sup ply P o w er a m p R a dio
Product #1
Value Functionality
Product Roadmap
Interoperability
Market Definition
C ustom er Driver #4 C ustom er Driver #5
Market Size
250 Market Size ($M) 200 150 100 50 0
-1 0 +1 Segment/Product Segment/Prod
Last Year
NOW
+ 2Q
Service/Support
+4 Q
Version 2. 1 (defeatured)
+6 Q
+8 Q
VISION
PD7
Software Products
1
-1 25 O urCo Lags
Revenue ($M) 20 15 10 5 0
+5 -1 0
0
Fraction of market captured
(segment #1)
O urCo Leads
20% O urCo rel. position
Segment/Product
25%
Inte rnal
R e sea rc h
15% 10%
RF
Segment/Product B Segment/Product C +1 +2 +3
5%
Segment/Product +2 +3 +4
+4
+5
Time
Time
250
Market (Units)
Segment/Product A Segment/Product B Segment/Product C
25
200
20
System Products
(segment #1)
Leonardo
Medici
Galileo
150
15
Michaelangelo
Technology Roadmap
100
10
50
-1
+1
+2
+3
+4
+5
-1
+1
+2
+3
+4
+5
Time
Time
Product Roadmap
Know-what
Push (capabilities)
Product Roadmap
Pull (requirements, drivers)
Decide how the product will be differentiated to win in key segments. Translate overall customer drivers into product drivers for this specific product. Set multi-year targets.
Know-how
Technology Roadmap
What technologies are most important? Link product drivers to hardware, software, and manufacturing technologies. Identify multi-generation technology investments to maintain competitiveness.
To-Do
What resources and investments are needed? Plan projects with the highest priorities. Are technology investments in the most important areas? Identify and track risk areas.
Time
(Sources: Tom Kappel; Phaal, R., Farrukh, C., and Probert, D., Fast-start Technology Roadmapping; Richard Albright.)
Know-when
7 2002 The Albright Strategy Group, LLC
First to market with CDMA Low-cost GSM phone Mass market (retail outlets) Low size and weight Personalized terminal Strategy Global wireless leadership Defend market share Continue quality program Increase US capacity Fast follow new technol. #2 in everything Make CDMA dominant Control standard Countermeasures Move market to be style/feature based
+ Wireless focus + Brand name recognition 50% + Quality focus + Low cost advantage + Supplier management 40% + Low cost manufacturing
Internet
Analog
(25%; 25%)
Move to outsourced manufacturing. Partner with chipset suppliers Bring new internet features to market early
Competitor C
20
30%
20%
Customer Drivers
120
10
10%
0
-1 yr now +1 yr +2 yr +3 yr +4 yr +5 yr
0
-1 yr now +1 yr +2 yr +3 yr +4 yr +5 yr
0%
-1 yr now +1 yr +2 yr +3 yr +4 yr +5 yr
Antenna RF Battery
Display
100
TARGET GROWTH SEGMENTS: Digital and Internet TARGET GROWTH SEGMENTS: Digital and Internet
80
Market %
60
40
KEY/TARGET CUSTOMERS: Carrier 1, SvcProv 2, Pink KEY/TARGET CUSTOMERS: Carrier 1, SvcProv 2, Pink
Baseband
20
Talk Time
Price
Style
In Touch
Customer Driver
2. Product Roadmap:
Wireless Handset Example
Customer Drivers
Price Style Talk Time In Touch Battery Life Info Access
Antenna Display RF
$1,000 $800 $600
Product Drivers
Cost: Materials Assembly time Size Weight
1000
Now
+1 Yr
+2 Yr
+3 Yr
+4 Yr
10
Target: Size
Competitor
100 Hours.
Qcompetitor A Competitor B Good
Baseband
Target:Weight
10
-1 yr now +1 yr +2 yr +3 yr Vision
1
-1 yr now +1 yr +2 yr +3 yr Vision
1,000
700
differentiates or disrupts, differentiates or disrupts, product platforms, product product platforms, product realization methods, realization methods, production production
elasticity, competition level, elasticity, competition level, regulatory climate, market regulatory climate, market learning potential learning potential
100 0.1
0.2
0.4
0.7
20
40
70
100
10
3. Technology Roadmap:
Organized by Drivers
Price Style Talk Time
Product drivers Core technology Area Baseband circuit W eight/size Interface ASIC DSP Audio codec Audio front end Microcontroller 8 bit CISC 1.7m thick m 6 layer 1.5m m 2-line LCD Menu driven NiCd- 4.8V Linear - 50%efficient Module Triple conversion Dual band, High gain Vcelp Expander Piezoelectric Internal Double conversion Diversity ITU, Qcelp13 IS-99 Data BER Improvement/echo cancel. First order gradient (FOG) Noise cancellingearpiece, miniaturized Research Funding status: Staffed Planned Unplanned Steering array
Cost
+2 Year
Integrated Call signal proc.
5735 Chip
CF CF CF CF C F C F CF CF CF CF CF CF CF CF CF FC CF CF CF CF CF CF CF
$150
Housing PWB Ease of use Display User interface Software Talk tim e Battery Power supply RF Power amp Radio
C ost
CF CF CF CF CF CF CF CF
TARGET
$100
Antenna Audio quality Voice coders DSP noise algorithms Microphone Receivers
$50
CF CF CF CF CF
$0
Comp "A" Now +1 yr +2 yr +3 yr +4 yr Target
11
Decision Support
Market Segmentation
Competitive Strategy
Conceive Concept
Define Proceed
Develop Launch
Product Roadmap
Action Plan
12
Page 2 3 4 5 9 10 11 13 14
BB u snn e s sSS r a a e e g y :GG o o wL L u c e nssww ir e le s st e emm in a lb b u s in e s sfrfr o m4 4 Mu u n itsto 7 7 .5MMu u n itsinin4 4y e e as sww h ileh h o ld in g u s i i e s s t tr t t g y : r r w u ce nt t ir e le s s r in a l u s in e s s o m M n its .5 n its ar h ile o ld in g t r to y r
2 0 % m k t s h a r e b y o ff e r in g s m a lle s t , lig h te s t p h o n e o n m a r k e t a t a v e r y , c o m p e t it iv e p r ic e . T a r g e t C D M A & G S M s e g m e n t s 2 0 % m k t s h a r e b y o ff e r in g s m a lle s t , lig h te s t p h o n e o n m a r k e t a t a v e r y , c o m p e t it iv e p r ic e . T a r g e t C D M A & G S M s e g m e n t s b b yb b e in gf ir ir t tt o omm ak e e tww h hlig h h tw e ig h tCC D M Ap p h o n ea a n du u ltr alolo wc c o s tGG S M p p h o n e . EE n te rmm a s smm ak k e t/e ea a il o ulele ts . y e in g f s s t a r rk t it it lig tw e ig h t D M A h o n e n d ltr a w ost S M hone. n te r ass a r r e t/ r r t t il o u t t ts . E v e n t u a lly e x it t h e a n a lo g p h o n e m a r k e t . E v e n t u a lly e x it t h e a n a lo g p h o n e m a r k e t .
PP oo d u c t&& TT e c h n o lo g ySS tr a e e g y : rr d uct e c h n o lo g y tr a t t g y : L e a d i n c e ll p h o n e c o s t a n d w e ig h t ( $ 5 0 / 7 0 g m b y 0 3 ) - A g g r e s s iv e ly r e d u c e c o s t s a n d lo w e r s iz e v ia r e m o v a l o f L e a d i n c e ll p h o n e c o s t a n d w e ig h t ( $ 5 0 / 7 0 g m b y 0 3 ) - A g g r e s s iv e ly r e d u c e c o s t s a n d lo w e r s iz e v ia r e m o v a l o f d is c r e te s , c o n s o lid a tio n o f Ic s , u s e o f s m a lle r , s u r f a c e m o u n t c o m p o n e n ts a n d n e w m a te r ia l d e v e lo p m e n ts ( s u c h a s n e x t d is c r e te s , c o n s o lid a tio n o f Ic s , u s e o f s m a lle r , s u r f a c e m o u n t c o m p o n e n ts a n d n e w m a te r ia l d e v e lo p m e n ts ( s u c h a s n e x t g e n e r a tio n b a tt e r ie s a n d P W B s ) . g e n e r a tio n b a tt e r ie s a n d P W B s ) . L e a d i n d a t a c o n n e c t iv it y b y b e in g fir s t to m a r k e t w ith a n IP b a s e d te le p h o n e u s in g a d v a n c e d e r r o r c o r r e c tio n L e a d i n d a t a c o n n e c t iv it y b y b e in g fir s t to m a r k e t w ith a n IP b a s e d te le p h o n e u s in g a d v a n c e d e r r o r c o r r e c tio n a lg o r ith m s . A c t iv e ly p r o m o te w ir e le s s in te r n e t s t a n d a r d s . a lg o r ith m s . A c t iv e ly p r o m o te w ir e le s s in te r n e t s t a n d a r d s .
T h is is a n e x a m p le o f a r o a d m a p fo r a b u s in e s s p r o d u c in g w ir e le s s h a n d s e t s , d e s ig n e d t o illu s tr a te f o r m a t a n d t h e r o a d m a p p in g p r o c e s s . T h is r o a d m a p h a s b e e n d e v e lo p e d fo r illu s t r a t iv e p u r p o s e s o n ly - - it d o e s n o t r e p r e s e n t a n a c t u a l L u c e n t b u s in e s s .
C o n ta c t s / R o a d m a p O w n e r :
Jane Q . R oadm apper + 4 4 -x x x - x x x - x x x x h a n d le @ lu c e n t. c o m e le c tr o n ic v e r s io n : h tt p : //B U .lu c e n t. c o m / r o a d m a p 9 9 F o r a s s is ta n c e w ith r o a d m a p p in g , c o n t a c t t h e L u c e n t T e c h n o lo g y O f fic e : R ic h A lb r ig h t + 1 9 0 8 -5 8 2 -3 5 8 6 r a lb r ig h t@ lu c e n t .c o m h tt p :// in f o v ie w .lu c e n t.c o m / lu c e n t/ c to
r w u c e n ts ir e le s s in a l u s in e s s o m M n it s . n its ar h ile o ld in g B u s i n e s s S t r a t e g y :GG o o wL L u c e n tsww ir e le s ste r mm in a b b u s in e s sfrfr o m 4 4 M u u n it st o o7 75 5MMu u n itsinin4 4y e e as sww h ileh h o ld in g r te r l t . y r 2 0 % m k t s h a r e b y o ff e r in g s m a lle s t, lig h t e s t p h o n e o n m a r k e t a t a v e r y ,c o m p e titiv e p r ic e . T a r g e t C D M A & G S M s e g m e n ts 2 0 % m k t s h a r e b y o ff e r in g s m a lle s t, lig h t e s t p h o n e o n m a r k e t a t a v e r y ,c o m p e titiv e p r ic e . T a r g e t C D M A & G S M s e g m e n ts b b yb b e in gf ir ir t tt o omm ak e e tww ithlig h h tw e ig h tCC D M Ap p h o n ea a n du u r a alolo wc o o t t G S Mp p h o n e . EE ne e rmm a s smm ak e e t/e ea a il o ulele ts . y e in g f s s t a r r k t ith lig tw e ig h t D M A h o n e n d lt lt r w c ss G S M hone. nt tr ass a r r k t/ r r t t il o u t t ts . E v e n t u a lly e x it t h e a n a lo g p h o n e m a r k e t. E v e n t u a lly e x it t h e a n a lo g p h o n e m a r k e t.
B u s in e s s S tr a te g y :
PP oo d u c t&& TT e c h n o lo g ySS r a a e e g y : rr d uct e c h n o lo g y t t r t t g y : L e a d i n c e ll p h o n e c o s t a n d w e i g h t ( $ 5 0 / 7 0 g m b y 0 3 ) - A g g r e s s iv e ly r e d u c e c o s ts a n d lo w e r s iz e v ia r e m o v a l o f L e a d i n c e ll p h o n e c o s t a n d w e ig h t ( $ 5 0 / 7 0 g m b y 0 3 ) - A g g r e s s iv e ly r e d u c e c o s ts a n d lo w e r s iz e v ia r e m o v a l o f d is c r e te s , c o n s o lid a tio n o f Ic s , u s e o f s m a lle r , s u r fa c e m o u n t c o m p o n e n t s a n d n e w m a t e r ia l d e v e lo p m e n ts ( s u c h a s n e x t d is c r e te s , c o n s o lid a tio n o f Ic s , u s e o f s m a lle r , s u r fa c e m o u n t c o m p o n e n t s a n d n e w m a t e r ia l d e v e lo p m e n ts ( s u c h a s n e x t g e n e r a tio n b a tte r ie s a n d P W B s ) . g e n e r a tio n b a tte r ie s a n d P W B s ) . L e a d i n d a t a c o n n e c t iv it y b y b e in g fir s t to m a r k e t w it h a n I P b a s e d te le p h o n e u s in g a d v a n c e d e r r o r c o r r e c t io n L e a d i n d a t a c o n n e c t iv it y b y b e in g fir s t to m a r k e t w it h a n I P b a s e d te le p h o n e u s in g a d v a n c e d e r r o r c o r r e c t io n a lg o r ith m s . A c t iv e ly p r o m o te w ir e le s s in te r n e t s ta n d a r d s . a lg o r ith m s . A c t iv e ly p r o m o te w ir e le s s in te r n e t s ta n d a r d s .
Competitive Impact
Roadmaps Manage Multi-Product Offers Roadmaps are the basis for the technology portfolio
Technology Investment
Disruptive
Potential to change the basis of competition
Differentiating
Product/Process Differentiation
Base
Voice Coder
Technology Source
13 2002 The Albright Strategy Group, LLC
Why Roadmap?
Roadmapping is just good planning, with a heavy dose of technology (not just an afterthought). Roadmaps link business strategy and market data with product and technology decisions using a series of simple charts. Roadmaps reveal gaps in product and technology plans. Roadmaps prioritize investments based on drivers. Roadmapping helps set better targets: more competitive and more realistic. Sharing roadmaps allows strategic use of technology across product lines. Roadmapping communicates business, technology and product plans to team members, management, customers and suppliers. Roadmaps provide a guide to the team, allowing the team to recognize and act on events that require a change in direction.
15 2002 The Albright Strategy Group, LLC
16
17