You are on page 1of 2

INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF

PROJECT
MANAGEMENT
International Journal of Project Management 22 (2004) 347–348
www.elsevier.com/locate/ijproman

Book reviews

Applied Project Management: Best Practices on describes how she achieved excellence in the project
Implementation management process throughout a company, only to see
Harold Kertzner, Wiley, New York, 2000, ISBN: 0-471 everything dismantled in a downsizing operation that
36352-9, xv + 534 pp. (hardcover) £52.50 replaced her enlightened mentors with other high exec-
utives who regarded project management as Ônice to
This is a well-organized text that accurately fulfils the haveÕ rather than an essential function deserving com-
bookÕs title. It forms a natural extension to this authorÕs pany resources. However, that failure was an extreme
highly regarded book Project Management: A Systems example, not typical of the many other personal ac-
Approach to Planning, Scheduling and Controlling, also counts reported in this book.
published by Wiley and (at the time of this review) in its Chapters 3–12 cover the following topics:
seventh edition. Both books have the same distinctive  The driving forces for maturity.
cover design and general presentation style, and it is  Project management methodologies.
apparent that these works are intended to be associated  Strategic planning for excellence in project manage-
with each other. The older book deals comprehensively ment.
with the techniques and methodologies of project man-  The maturity of modern project management.
agement, whereas the current volume takes the subject  Integrated processes (examples include, for instance,
further, into the difficult areas of implementation, cul- concurrent engineering and total quality manage-
ture, general acceptance and the attainment of project ment).
management maturity and excellence. There is some  Culture.
duplication of subject matter between these two books,  Management support.
particularly in the introductory chapters, but this is  Training and education.
unavoidable if each book is to stand alone as a fully self-  Informal project management.
contained text.  Behavioural excellence.
Applied Project Management falls into two main Chapter 13 rounds off the first section of the book by
sections. The first of these sections takes up some 60% of listing and describing nine companies under the title
the main text space and contains 13 chapters. The first ÔRising stars and future directionsÕ.
two of these chapters set the scene by describing the Numerous charts, checklists and well-designed illus-
growth of project management from the 1960s to the trations support the text. Almost every chapter ends
present and then defining, in detail, the terms ÔsuccessÕ, with a generous set of multiple-choice questions, some
ÔmaturityÕ and ÔexcellenceÕ. discussion questions and, less usefully, a simple cross-
The project management life cycle is described as word puzzle.
having five stages. These are: The second main section of this book contains 26 fairly
1. Embryonic. detailed case studies, each describing the project man-
2. Executive management acceptance. agement experience of a company. Each of these case
3. Line management acceptance. studies, like the chapters in the first section of the book,
4. Growth. also concludes with generous lists of questions. However,
5. Maturity. the total number of cases described far exceeds those
These are the stages leading to a mature project contained in this second main section. Descriptions of
management capability and culture throughout a com- other companies and the telling personal observations of
pany. Unlike the life cycle for an individual project that many managers are scattered liberally throughout all the
usually has a well-defined finish, the project manage- chapters. These make fascinating reading and mature
ment [implementation] life cycle leads to a result that is readers will undoubtedly recognize parallels with their
never final or stable, but must be maintained and may be own attempts (successful or otherwise) to develop a pro-
at risk for several reasons, including management reor- ject management culture in organizations where they ei-
ganization, acquisitions, mergers, business process re- ther work or have carried out consultancy assignments.
engineering and downsizing. Indeed one of the many The core material for this text resulted from the kind
respondents to Professor KerznerÕs extensive research of research more usually associated with a higher degree
348 Book reviews / International Journal of Project Management 22 (2004) 347–348

dissertation or doctoral thesis. Over 300 companies were could also be read by those senior executives who,
investigated and most were sent survey questionnaires, through their personal commitment and the authoriza-
followed up where appropriate with interviews. Profes- tion of resources, should be prepared to support and
sor Kerzner is to be congratulated not only for per- maintain the drive towards project management maturity
suading so many of these companies to respond in such and excellence in their organizations. The possible bene-
great detail but also for the skillful selection and pre- fits are too often either overlooked or simply not under-
sentation of the results. So, although apparently starting stood at the corporate executive level.
as an academic exercise, the outcome is a thoroughly Apart from a few minor typographical errors (not
practical textbook, full of relevant personal experiences sufficient to damage readability but enough to suggest
and constructive advice. that the publisher should review its proofreading ar-
This book is not for beginners. It is clearly not intended rangements) this book is very well produced. It is well
for budget-strapped students studying for a business de- presented and bound in durable hard covers. This book
gree where project management forms only a small part of makes a significant contribution to the literature and is
a wider curriculum. Its value will be appreciated by more good value at the price.
advanced students specializing in project management, by
practising project managers, and by project management Dennis Lock
consultants. The wealth of case studies and discussion 29 Burston Drive, Park Street
questions provide a particularly useful source for college/ St. Albans, Herts
university lecturers, for whom a companion instructorÕs AL2 2HR, UK
manual is available from the publisher. I wish this book E-mail address: dennis.lock@ntlworld.com

doi:10.1016/S0263-7863(02)00076-5

Systems Development – A Project Management App- the back of the book. There is a good table of contents
roach and a comprehensive index. The appearance of the book
Raymond McLeod Jr. and Eleanor Jordan, published is excellent as one would expect from a product pro-
by Wiley and Sons duced by Wiley and Sons.
Systems Development – A Project Management Ap-
Systems Development – A Project Management Ap- proach is a solid undergraduate textbook which many
proach is aimed at undergraduate university students. It teachers at this level will find useful indeed. This is not a
is clearly a beginners book which is thoroughly written book aimed at information systems project management
and thus comprehensive in scope. In the 524 pages the professionals. The only drawback that the book has is
authors manage to address all the main topics and issues that it is rather American and this is perhaps best il-
that need to be taught at undergraduate level. This lustrated by the opening words in the case study in-
textbook does everything that the authors promise. The stallment 1 that appears on page 2 and which begins
style of the book is good. It is very accessible and easy to with the words ‘‘Hey Gary! Wanna team up again this
read. Each chapter commences with a useful list of semester?’’
learning points which I have always found a great help At a price of £28.95 the book represents value for
especially when teaching undergraduate classes. The money.
book is well supplied with explanatory figures and ta-
bles. At the end of each chapter there is a list of key Dan Remenyi
terms used as well as a set of problems for the students School of Systems and Data Studies
to undertake. In addition some chapters contain case Trinity College Dublin
problems. There is also an appropriate bibliography at Dublin 2, Ireland
the end of each chapter and there is a useful glossary at E-mail address: dan.remenyi@tcd.ie

doi:10.1016/S0263-7863(03)00010-3

You might also like