Professional Documents
Culture Documents
20
Measure as few as 10 cells in less than 10 minutes—with a single-step protocol
2,000
for quantifying intracellular ATP. From basic research to high-throughput drug
Luminescence (RLU)
10
1,600
0
1,200 0 100 200 300 400 screening, the CellTiter-Glo Assay is judged the best. It enables you to easily
800
estimate cell number, measure cell viability or quantitate cytotoxic effects.
400
0
Discriminating scientific minds agree; CellTiter-Glo is the perfect assay.
0 10k 20k 30k 40k 50k
3171MC
Cells per Well See for yourself. For a FREE SAMPLE visit: www.promega.com/celltiterglo
illustra
www.gehealthcare.com/illustra
COVER DEPARTMENTS
The grass Sorghastrum nutans, one of 1511 Science Online
a dozen plant species that dominate 1512 This Week in Science
native North American prairies. 1516 Editors’ Choice
Biofuels produced from diverse mixtures 1518 Contact Science
of prairie plants can provide greater 1519 Random Samples
energy yields and environmental 1521 Newsmakers
benefits than food-based biofuels 1614 New Products
such as corn ethanol and soybean 1615 Science Careers
biodiesel. See page 1598.
Photo: Jason Hill EDITORIAL
1515 Show Us the Money
by Donald Kennedy
ESSAY
GE Prize-Winning Essay: The Emergence of Cells 1558
During the Origin of Life
1530 I. A. Chen
CONTENTS continued >>
New
FlexiPlate siRNA from QIAGEN is a giant leap forward for more flexible, cost-effective
RNAi screening!
I Maximum flexibility to select siRNAs for human and mouse genes, controls, scales,
and 96-well plate layout
I Economical options allow screening of more target genes within budget
I Cutting-edge siRNA design minimizes off-target effects and maximizes potency
I Fast and easy access via QIAGEN’s GeneGlobe™ Web portal
For up-to-date trademarks and disclaimers, see www.qiagen.com . RNAiFlexiPlate1206S1WW © 2006 QIAGEN, all rights reserved.
W W W. Q I A G E N . C O M
CONTENTS
SCIENCE EXPRESS
www.sciencexpress.org
GEOCHEMISTRY
Late-Neoproterozoic Deep-Ocean Oxygenation and the Rise of Animal Life BIOCHEMISTRY
D. E. Canfield, S. W. Poulton, G. M. Narbonne An Inward-Facing Conformation of a Putative Metal-Chelate–Type
A record based on iron species in minerals implies that the deep ocean only ABC Transporter
became oxygenated after the last major Precambrian glaciation, just before H. W. Pinkett, A. T. Lee, P. Lum, K. P. Locher, D. C. Rees
the rise of metazoans. A pump moves molecules out of cells by coupled changes in the nucleotide-binding
>> News story p. 1529 domain and the membrane-spanning helices, which switch the accessibility of the
10.1126/science.1135013 central cavity from outside to inside.
MOLECULAR BIOLOGY
10.1126/science.1133488
Secondary siRNAs Result from Unprimed RNA Synthesis and Form a CHEMISTRY
Distinct Class Organic Glasses with Exceptional Thermodynamic and Kinetic Stability
T. Sijen, F. A. Steiner, K. L. Thijssen, R. H. A. Plasterk S. F. Swallen et al.
A distinct class of small antisense RNAs is synthesized by RNA-directed RNA Organic molecules can form stable glasses when deposited from a vapor onto a
polymerase from siRNA templates in Caenorhabditis elegans. substrate cooled only 50 kelvin below their usual glass transition temperature.
10.1126/science.1136699 10.1126/science.1135795
EVOLUTION
REVIEW Group Competition, Reproductive Leveling, and the 1569
EVOLUTION Evolution of Human Altruism
Five Rules for the Evolution of Cooperation 1560 S. Bowles
M. A. Nowak Early human practices requiring language and sophisticated
>> Perspective p. 1555 cognition enhanced the contribution of altruism to group survival,
perhaps selecting for altruistic traits.
BREVIA >> Perspective p. 1555
ECOLOGY PLANETARY SCIENCE
Ebola Outbreak Killed 5000 Gorillas 1564 Present-Day Impact Cratering Rate and 1573
M. Bermejo et al. Contemporary Gully Activity on Mars
Successive waves of Ebola virus infection and hunting pressure M. C. Malin et al.
are threatening the great apes of West Africa with extinction. Images of Mars taken 7 years apart reveal 20 new impact craters,
>> News story p. 1522 close to the predicted rate, some with gullies indicating the presence
of flowing water in the past decade.
RESEARCH ARTICLES >> News story p. 1528
MICROBIOLOGY
Engineering Yeast Transcription Machinery for 1565 REPORTS
Improved Ethanol Tolerance and Production ASTRONOMY
H. Alper et al. A Brown Dwarf Mass Donor in an Accreting Binary 1578
Yeast genetically altered to tolerate higher ethanol and glucose S. P. Littlefair
concentrations may prove useful for biofuel production. Accurate measurements of eclipses finally capture a white dwarf
cannibalizing an unseen brown dwarf companion star, confirming
long-standing predictions. >> Perspective p. 1550
Look no further
I Bone marrow, fresh and cryopreserved
CD34+ cells from bone marrow
stem cells
I
I CD34+ depleted bone marrow
N A T I O N A L D I S E A S E R E S E A R C H I N T E R C H A N G E
CONTENTS
REPORTS CONTINUED...
ASTRONOMY MOLECULAR BIOLOGY
Deep Mixing of 3He: Reconciling Big Bang and 1580 Synthesis-Mediated Release of a Small RNA 1601
Stellar Nucleosynthesis Inhibitor of RNA Polymerase
P. P. Eggleton, D. S. P. Dearborn, J. C. Lattanzio K. M. Wassarman and R. M. Saecker
Three-dimensional models of giant stars show that deep convection When bacteria are starved, a small RNA inhibits transcription
of supposedly stable layers destroys 3He to levels consistent with the by folding to mimic a legitimate promoter target, after which
Big Bang predictions. >> Perspective p. 1551 adding nucleotides can restart transcription.
CHEMISTRY MEDICINE
Operation of a DNA Robot Arm Inserted into a 1583 Dual Infection with HIV and Malaria Fuels the 1603
2D DNA Crystalline Substrate Spread of Both Diseases in Sub-Saharan Africa
B. Ding and N. C. Seeman L. J. Abu-Raddad, P. Patnaik, J. G. Kublin
A mechanical DNA device mounted within a crystalline Malaria infection increases HIV blood levels and HIV patients are
DNA lattice retains its functionality, providing a step toward more susceptible to malaria, a synergy that probably contributes to
nanoscale computation and manufacturing. the HIV epidemic in Africa.
>> Perspective p. 1552
MICROBIOLOGY
CHEMISTRY A Positive Feedback Loop Promotes Transcription 1607
Enzyme-Free Nucleic Acid Logic Circuits 1585 Surge That Jump-Starts Salmonella Virulence Circuit
G. Seelig, D. Soloveichik, D. Y. Zhang, E. Winfree D. Shin, E.-J. Lee, H. Huang, E. A. Groisman
Single-stranded DNAs are used to create a series of computation Activation of a two-component signaling pathway required
gates, circuits, and devices in a modular fashion. for Salmonella virulence triggers a burst of transcription
>> Perspective p. 1552 that may allow rapid adaptation to new conditions.
PHYSICS NEUROSCIENCE
Microwave-Induced Cooling of a Superconducting 1589 Sequential Interplay of Nicotinic and GABAergic 1610
Qubit Signaling Guides Neuronal Development
S. O. Valenzuela et al. Z. Liu, R. A. Neff, D. K. Berg
A microwave cooling technique can lower the temperature of a qubit Acetylcholine changes chloride transporter levels, triggering a switch
to 3 millikelvin, much lower than the temperature of the surrounding from excitatory to inhibitory signaling in the embryonic chick brain.
bath, enhancing its stability. >> Perspective p. 1549
ANTHROPOLOGY
U-Pb Isotopic Age of the StW 573 Hominid from 1592
Sterkfontein, South Africa
J. Walker, R. A. Cliff, A. G. Latham
Dating of cave deposits establishes the australopithicine “little foot,”
as 2.2 million years old, surprisingly recent and contemporaneous
with tool-using Homo species.
DEVELOPMENTAL BIOLOGY
A Complex Oscillating Network of Signaling Genes 1595
Underlies the Mouse Segmentation Clock
M.-L. Dequéant et al.
The segmentation clock, which forms repeated body structures during
development, generates many oscillating RNAs that regulate common
developmental pathways.
ECOLOGY
Carbon-Negative Biofuels from Low-Input 1598
High-Diversity Grassland Biomass
D. Tilman, J. Hill, C. Lehman
1551 & 1580
Sustainable, higher-diversity grasslands with low-fertility soils can
yield more biomass and consume more CO2 than equal acreages
planted with monocultured biofuel sources.
SCIENCE (ISSN 0036-8075) is published weekly on Friday, except the last week in December, by the American Association
for the Advancement of Science, 1200 New York Avenue, NW, Washington, DC 20005. Periodicals Mail postage (publication No.
484460) paid at Washington, DC, and additional mailing offices. Copyright © 2006 by the American Association for the Advancement
of Science. The title SCIENCE is a registered trademark of the AAAS. Domestic individual membership and subscription (51 issues): $139
($74 allocated to subscription). Domestic institutional subscription (51 issues): $650; Foreign postage extra: Mexico, Caribbean (surface
mail) $55; other countries (air assist delivery) $85. First class, airmail, student, and emeritus rates on request. Canadian rates with GST
available upon request, GST #1254 88122. Publications Mail Agreement Number 1069624. Printed in the U.S.A.
Change of address: Allow 4 weeks, giving old and new addresses and 8-digit account number. Postmaster: Send change of address to AAAS, P.O. Box 96178, Washington, DC 20090–6178. Single-copy sales:
$10.00 current issue, $15.00 back issue prepaid includes surface postage; bulk rates on request. Authorization to photocopy material for internal or personal use under circumstances not falling within the
fair use provisions of the Copyright Act is granted by AAAS to libraries and other users registered with the Copyright Clearance Center (CCC) Transactional Reporting Service, provided that $18.00 per article is
paid directly to CCC, 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923. The identification code for Science is 0036-8075. Science is indexed in the Reader’s Guide to Periodical Literature and in several specialized indexes.
CONTENTS continued >>
www.ScienceCareers.org
• Search Jobs
now part of
• Next Wave ScienceCareers.org
• Job Alerts
• Resume/CV Database
• Career Forum
To order your copy call
• Career Advice
877.464.0527
or by visiting • Meetings and
www.spectrumchemical.com Announcements
• Graduate Programs
SCIENCENOW
www.sciencenow.org DAILY NEWS COVERAGE
City Bird, Country Bird
Great tits change their tune when they move to the city. Doing science in China.
Anion in the Interstellar Garden
Astronomers detect the first negatively charged molecule SCIENCE CAREERS
in space. www.sciencecareers.org CAREER RESOURCES FOR SCIENTISTS
How Bird Flu Could Come to America
Team models spread of virus to Western Hemisphere. GLOBAL: Special Feature—Scientific Opportunities in China
A. Kotok
Read about the opportunities and pitfalls, as well as the experiences
of researchers who have worked in China.
EUROPE/CHINA: Looking East for Research Experiences
N. Anscombe
With improving budgets, facilities, and leadership, China is
becoming a popular destination for young European scientists.
US/CHINA: A Primer on Doing Science in China
A. Kotok
Get an overview of China’s research system and environment, with
tips for China-bound Western scientists.
US/CHINA: Chinese Medicine, Western Style
J. Kling
Western pharmaceutical companies are providing employment
opportunities, but mostly for Chinese nationals trained in the West.
US: Opportunities—Intellectual Property, Part 2
Posteriorly localized Oskar in a developing fly oocyte. P. Fiske
If you think that invention belongs to you, think again.
SCIENCE’S STKE
www.stke.org SIGNAL TRANSDUCTION KNOWLEDGE ENVIRONMENT
PERSPECTIVE: What Is So Special About Oskar Wild?
W. O’Gorman and A. Akoulitchev SCIENCEPODCAST
The function of an mRNA extends beyond encoding protein.
PERSPECTIVE: PI3 Kinases in Cancer—From Oncogene Listen to the 8 December
Artifact to Leading Cancer Target Science Podcast to hear about
J. J. Zhao and T. M. Roberts impact cratering on Mars,
Identifying the roles of different PI3K isoforms may facilitate the threat of Ebola virus to
the use of their inhibitors in cancer therapy. great apes, and the intricacies
of entrepreneurship in science.
www.sciencemag.org/about/podcast.dtl
Separate individual or institutional subscriptions to these products may be required for full-text access.
Mars Changes in Real Time can cool the qubit to 3 millikelvin, appreciably placement and operation of specific devices at
The thin martian atmosphere does little to protect lower than the several-hundred-millikelvin tem- this size scale is a key step in the development
its surface from bombardment by even small perature of its thermal bath. of nanorobotics. Seelig et al. (p. 1585) have
objects from space. Malin et al. (p. 1573; see the designed a set of single-stranded DNA molecules
news stories by Kerr) have found new impact that can be used in a modular fashion to build a
craters that pockmark the surface of Mars through Helium to Burn series of logic circuits such as AND, OR, and NOT
differencing images from Mars Global Surveyor Stars like the Sun produce 3He as they burn, and operators, as well as an amplifier and a thresh-
taken 7 years apart. The impact cratering rate when they finally swell to red giants at the end of olding device. The devices work by letting an
they measured is comparable with that seen for their lives, the 3He should mix into the convect- input DNA strand bind to an exposed or
the Moon. Also, they spotted recent changes in ing outer layers and ultimately be lost in stellar unpaired segment of a gate device, which
the walls of two craters that they interpret as winds. However, very little 3He is seen in inter- causes a strand displacement.
evidence for recent trickles of liquid water. stellar space beyond the predicted amount from
Big Bang nucleosynthesis. Eggleton et al.
and malaria parasite coinfection in a high-risk region of Africa. The authors tested their model on
17050 Montebello Road
data gathered from Kisumu, Kenya, and found that a synergy operates between the pathogens that Cupertino, California 95014
explains the propagation of many thousands of HIV infections and almost a million malaria Email: AAASinfo@betchartexpeditions.com
episodes since 1980. On the Web: www.betchartexpeditions.com
It is.
W i t h t h e “ K e e p M e P o s t e d ” a l e r t i n g f e a t u re , S c i F i n d e r s e n d s y o u
automatic updates on areas you—and your competitors—are interested in.
You can monitor specific research topics, companies, authors, substances, or sequences, and choose
how frequently you receive notifications: daily, monthly, or weekly.
The service isn’t just convenient, it’s incredibly current. Journal article records often appear in
SciFinder before they’re even in print. New references, substances, and sequences are added daily.
Patents from all the major offices are added within two days of issuance.
As with all SciFinder features, Keep Me Posted is integrated with your workflow. At any point in a
search (including the beginning), simply click on the Keep Me Posted button. SciFinder tracks your
steps and will generate the appropriate alert— even for complex topics. When you receive a
notification, you can follow each reference as you would in a search: find citing or cited articles (with
links to the electronic full text), and follow referenced substances and reactions for further information.
Comprehensive, intuitive, seamless—SciFinder doesn’t just alert you, it’s part of the process. To
find out more, call us at 800-753-4227 (North America) or 614-447-3700 (worldwide) or visit
www.cas.org/SCIFINDER.
self-interest and instead tell the administration and Congress and the public what it can accom-
plish for our society.
– Donald Kennedy
10.1126/science.1137742
ECOLOGY/EVOLUTION
A Web of Spiders
Arthropod sociality is largely confined to insects—chiefly ants, bees,
wasps, and termites. Less well known and far less diverse are the social spi-
ders—about 20 species, many of which are cobweb spiders—in which
large numbers of individuals occupy a communal web and cooperate in
the capture of prey. Like social arthropods, the colonies tend to have a
highly female-biased sex ratio.
Avilés et al. describe the unusual biology of an Ecuadorian social spi-
der. These spiders live in colonies of one to several thousand individuals,
proliferating and dispersing with a “boom-and-bust” dynamics whereby
large colonies fragment into many smaller colonies, perhaps stimulated
by the preference of an associated predator to inhabit and prey on the
larger colonies. Intriguingly, the females of this species come in two sizes,
which is suggestive of alternative reproductive strategies or even a caste
system—possibilities that remain to be explored but are highly unusual
outside the social insects. — AMS
Biotropica 38, 743 (2006).
CREDITS (TOP TO BOTTOM): AVILÉS ET AL., BIOTROPICA 38, 743 (2006); ISSA AND EDWARDS, CURR. BIOL. 16, 2217 (2006); COHEN ET AL., NANO LETT. 6, 10.1021/NL0620233 (2006)
A N I M A L B E H AV I O R bered, and eaten. Thus, it seems that ritualized CHEMISTRY
submission serves to increase the chance of sur-
Submit or Perish vival for the subordinate crayfish, as it does in
Keeping the Charges in Line
Social animals often pursue a hierarchical mammals—an intriguing example of the conver- Materials that convert sunlight into electrical
lifestyle, whose expression can be observed by gent evolution of social behavior. — GR current not only form electron-hole pairs upon
third parties in the form of ritualized dominance Curr. Biol. 16, 2217 (2006). light absorption but also must efficiently trans-
displays. Primates, for example, use the relatively port the carriers to prevent charge trapping and
complex behavior of pseudocopulation between IMMUNOLOGY recombination. Disc-shaped liquid crystalline
males as a means of affirming and signaling materials such as the contorted hexabenzo-
social relationships.
Losses and Gains coronenes, which naturally form columnar con-
Issa and Edwards show that crayfish not only Cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTLs) monitor the body’s duit structures, have been studied for use in
adopt dominance postures but also exhibit cells for damage or infection by detecting changes photovoltaic devices.
pseudocopulation. Dominance relationships are in fragments of proteins presented on the cell sur- Cohen et al. find that photoconduction in
face by major histocompatibility complex (MHC) films of these molecules is exclusively one-
molecules. The spectrum of peptides presented dimensional. Optical absorption spectroscopy
depends on cellular machinery that chops the pro- indicates that the puckered molecular geometry
teins into small pieces, and on endoplasmic reticu- disrupts full delocalization of the π-bonding
lum aminopeptidases associated with antigen pro- network. As the molecules stack, the six phenyl
cessing (ERAAP), which lop off N-terminal residues rings at the edges interact weakly; only the
to generate peptides of the correct length for bind- nearly planar core regions overlap sufficiently
ing to MHC complexes. for effective π-conjugation. Density functional
Hammer et al. show that mice deficient in calculations were used
ERAAP display a large gap in the peptide reper- to quantify this obser-
Procambarus clarkii. toires presented. However, this hole is filled by a vation and indicated a
new set of peptides; these peptide-MHC combina- 3.2-eV gap between
generally established quickly in pairs of male tions were immunogenic because they stimulated the highest-energy
crayfish, with the dominant individual displaying CTL and antibody production by B cells. Neverthe- occupied and lowest-
typical male courtship behavior, including flip- less, the complexes were structurally distinct from energy unoccupied
ping the subordinate onto his back. In more than those of wild-type cells and appeared unstable molecular orbitals in
half of the pairs, the subordinate then adopted a because they rapidly disappeared from the cell the core, in contrast to
passive supine posture reminiscent of female mat- surface. It will be of interest to investigate the a 5.6-eV gap in the
ing behavior. Pseudocopulating pairs spent less activity of this editing enzyme in situations such as outer rings. As a result,
time fighting, with no mortality occurring in the tumor surveillance and viral infection, perhaps Top and side views of these outer rings form
first day. In pairs that did not pseudocopulate, the with a view to modulating its activity therapeuti- hexabenzocoronene an insulating cladding
dominant males were persistently aggressive, and cally. — SJS (core, yellow; that promotes one-
half of the subordinates were killed, dismem- Nat. Immunol. 7, 10.1038/ni1409 (2006). cladding, blue). dimensional conduc-
show arsenite-dependent JNK phosphorylation, and inhibiting JNK signaling attenuated arsenite-
mediated cell death. Arsenite acted through IKKβ–NF-κB to increase the abundance of growth
arrest and DNA damage–inducible (GADD) 45α, whose up-regulation was required for arsenite-
induced phosphorylation of JNK. Analysis of fibroblasts from knockout mice implicated the
NF-κB1 subunit (p50) in arsenite’s cytotoxic effects, and further analysis suggested that
GADD45α up-regulation depended on p50-dependent inhibition of ubiquitination and
proteasomal degradation. Thus, arsenite-mediated cytotoxicity appears to involve IKKβ–NF-κB-
dependent activation of JNK signaling through a mechanism that depends on the accumulation of
GADD45α rather than transcriptional activation. — EMA
J. Cell Biol. 175, 607 (2006).
S ENIOR E DITORIAL B OARD J. M. Claverie, CNRS, Marseille Bernhard Keimer, Max Planck Inst., Stuttgart David S. Schimel, National Center for Atmospheric Research
Jonathan D. Cohen, Princeton Univ. Elizabeth A. Kellog, Univ. of Missouri, St. Louis Georg Schulz, Albert-Ludwigs-Universität
John I. Brauman, Chair, Stanford Univ. Stephen M. Cohen, EMBL Alan B. Krueger, Princeton Univ. Paul Schulze-Lefert, Max Planck Inst., Cologne
Richard Losick, Harvard Univ. Robert H. Crabtree, Yale Univ. Lee Kump, Penn State Terrence J. Sejnowski, The Salk Institute
Robert May, Univ. of Oxford F. Fleming Crim, Univ. of Wisconsin Mitchell A. Lazar, Univ. of Pennsylvania David Sibley, Washington Univ.
Marcia McNutt, Monterey Bay Aquarium Research Inst. William Cumberland, UCLA Virginia Lee, Univ. of Pennsylvania George Somero, Stanford Univ.
Linda Partridge, Univ. College London George Q. Daley, Children’s Hospital, Boston Anthony J. Leggett, Univ. of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign Joan Steitz, Yale Univ.
Vera C. Rubin, Carnegie Institution of Washington Judy DeLoache, Univ. of Virginia Michael J. Lenardo, NIAID, NIH Thomas Stocker, Univ. of Bern
Christopher R. Somerville, Carnegie Institution Edward DeLong, MIT Norman L. Letvin, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center Jerome Strauss, Virginia Commonwealth Univ.
George M. Whitesides, Harvard University Robert Desimone, MIT Olle Lindvall, Univ. Hospital, Lund Tomoyuki Takahashi, Univ. of Tokyo
Dennis Discher, Univ. of Pennsylvania Richard Losick, Harvard Univ. Marc Tatar, Brown Univ.
B OARD OF R EVIEWING E DITORS W. Ford Doolittle, Dalhousie Univ. Ke Lu, Chinese Acad. of Sciences Glenn Telling, Univ. of Kentucky
Jennifer A. Doudna, Univ. of California, Berkeley Andrew P. MacKenzie, Univ. of St. Andrews Marc Tessier-Lavigne, Genentech
Julian Downward, Cancer Research UK Raul Madariaga, École Normale Supérieure, Paris Michiel van der Klis, Astronomical Inst. of Amsterdam
Joanna Aizenberg, Bell Labs/Lucent Rick Maizels, Univ. of Edinburgh
R. McNeill Alexander, Leeds Univ. Denis Duboule, Univ. of Geneva Derek van der Kooy, Univ. of Toronto
Michael Malim, King’s College, London Bert Vogelstein, Johns Hopkins
David Altshuler, Broad Institute Christopher Dye, WHO Eve Marder, Brandeis Univ.
Arturo Alvarez-Buylla, Univ. of California, San Francisco Richard Ellis, Cal Tech Christopher A. Walsh, Harvard Medical School
William McGinnis, Univ. of California, San Diego Christopher T. Walsh, Harvard Medical School
Richard Amasino, Univ. of Wisconsin, Madison Gerhard Ertl, Fritz-Haber-Institut, Berlin Virginia Miller, Washington Univ.
Meinrat O. Andreae, Max Planck Inst., Mainz Douglas H. Erwin, Smithsonian Institution Yasushi Miyashita, Univ. of Tokyo Graham Warren, Yale Univ. School of Med.
Kristi S. Anseth, Univ. of Colorado Barry Everitt, Univ. of Cambridge Edvard Moser, Norwegian Univ. of Science and Technology Colin Watts, Univ. of Dundee
Cornelia I. Bargmann, Rockefeller Univ. Paul G. Falkowski, Rutgers Univ. Andrew Murray, Harvard Univ. Julia R. Weertman, Northwestern Univ.
Brenda Bass, Univ. of Utah Ernst Fehr, Univ. of Zurich Naoto Nagaosa, Univ. of Tokyo Daniel M. Wegner, Harvard University
Ray H. Baughman, Univ. of Texas, Dallas Tom Fenchel, Univ. of Copenhagen James Nelson, Stanford Univ. School of Med. Ellen D. Williams, Univ. of Maryland
Stephen J. Benkovic, Pennsylvania St. Univ. Alain Fischer, INSERM Roeland Nolte, Univ. of Nijmegen R. Sanders Williams, Duke University
Michael J. Bevan, Univ. of Washington Jeffrey S. Flier, Harvard Medical School Helga Nowotny, European Research Advisory Board Ian A. Wilson, The Scripps Res. Inst.
Ton Bisseling, Wageningen Univ. Chris D. Frith, Univ. College London Eric N. Olson, Univ. of Texas, SW Jerry Workman, Stowers Inst. for Medical Research
Mina Bissell, Lawrence Berkeley National Lab R. Gadagkar, Indian Inst. of Science Erin O’Shea, Harvard Univ. John R. Yates III, The Scripps Res. Inst.
Peer Bork, EMBL John Gearhart, Johns Hopkins Univ. Elinor Ostrom, Indiana Univ. Martin Zatz, NIMH, NIH
Dianna Bowles, Univ. of York Jennifer M. Graves, Australian National Univ. Jonathan T. Overpeck, Univ. of Arizona
Robert W. Boyd, Univ. of Rochester Christian Haass, Ludwig Maximilians Univ. Walter Zieglgänsberger, Max Planck Inst., Munich
John Pendry, Imperial College Huda Zoghbi, Baylor College of Medicine
Dennis Bray, Univ. of Cambridge Dennis L. Hartmann, Univ. of Washington Philippe Poulin, CNRS
Stephen Buratowski, Harvard Medical School Chris Hawkesworth, Univ. of Bristol Maria Zuber, MIT
Mary Power, Univ. of California, Berkeley
Jillian M. Buriak, Univ. of Alberta Martin Heimann, Max Planck Inst., Jena David J. Read, Univ. of Sheffield
Joseph A. Burns, Cornell Univ. James A. Hendler, Univ. of Maryland Les Real, Emory Univ. B OOK R EVIEW B OARD
William P. Butz, Population Reference Bureau Ove Hoegh-Guldberg, Univ. of Queensland Colin Renfrew, Univ. of Cambridge
Doreen Cantrell, Univ. of Dundee Ary A. Hoffmann, La Trobe Univ. John Aldrich, Duke Univ.
Trevor Robbins, Univ. of Cambridge
Peter Carmeliet, Univ. of Leuven, VIB Evelyn L. Hu, Univ. of California, SB Barbara A. Romanowicz, Univ. of California, Berkeley David Bloom, Harvard Univ.
Gerbrand Ceder, MIT Olli Ikkala, Helsinki Univ. of Technology Nancy Ross, Virginia Tech Londa Schiebinger, Stanford Univ.
Mildred Cho, Stanford Univ. Meyer B. Jackson, Univ. of Wisconsin Med. School Edward M. Rubin, Lawrence Berkeley National Lab Richard Shweder, Univ. of Chicago
David Clapham, Children’s Hospital, Boston Stephen Jackson, Univ. of Cambridge Gary Ruvkun, Mass. General Hospital Ed Wasserman, DuPont
David Clary, Oxford University Daniel Kahne, Harvard Univ. J. Roy Sambles, Univ. of Exeter Lewis Wolpert, Univ. College, London
adopted in recent years by most European countries, calls for a ban on patterns, life spans, pathologies,
the export of all hazardous wastes—which includes electronics and dietary habits. The museum’s
because of their toxic components—from rich to poor countries. science director, Richard Lane,
But as richer countries try to discourage throwing e-waste in landfills, notes that people of Tasmania,
the “recycling” business has grown apace. About 80% of the world’s which separated from mainland
high-tech rubbish ends up in Asia—90% of that in China, and most of Australia about 12,000 years ago, were
that in Giuyu, north of Hong Kong. After workers extract a few desirable “quite different” from mainland dwellers.
parts, most is left to pollute the environment. For example, he says, unique and varied
1878 photo of
Even goodwill gestures are ending up as junk, according to UNEP types of mitochondrial DNA have been
Trucannini, the “last”
Director Achim Steiner. More than half of the computers donated to Tasmanian aborigine. found in Tasmanians.
Africa are obsolete or unusable because of lack of technical support. The handover follows many years of
There’s been some progress at addressing e-waste, however. Last negotiations and passage of a new Human Tissue Act that permits
month, for example, three Asian countries signed on to a pilot scheme British institutions to deaccession such holdings. TAC plans to cre-
for the collection and environmentally sound disposal of “end-of-life” mate the remains.
mobile phones. Museum Director Michael Dixon says, “We do not believe that the
scientific value should trump all other claims.” But Smithsonian
Institution anthropologist Douglas Owsley says, “The loss of
[remains from] any of these rare groups is very unfortunate.” He
NETWATCH >>
notes that the planned research will be “no substitute” for tech-
niques that are bound to come along in the next decade or so.
Reef Watching
With reefs under threat from pollution, coral-breaking fishing nets,
diseases, climate change, and a host of other causes, keeping an eye Waltzing on the Lawn
on their environment is ever more important. The Coral Health and At right is a work by New York
Monitoring Program from City sculptress Mara Haseltine
the National Oceanic that has been donated to Cold
and Atmospheric Spring Harbor Laboratory in New
Administration provides York by Human Genome Sciences
baseline atmospheric and Inc., the company founded by
oceanic data for reefs in the artist’s father, William
the United States and the Haseltine. Called Waltz of the
Caribbean. The site con- Polypeptides, the 24-meter-long
nects to two monitoring sculpture, based on observations
networks. One offers from state-of-the-art cell-imag-
hourly readings of air ing techniques, depicts a ribo-
temperature, wind speed, and other variables for eight Florida reefs; some in the act of producing an
the other collects data on additional features such as salinity and light infection-fighting protein.
levels at different wavelengths and depths. >> www.coral.noaa.gov
There’s only one source for news and research with the greatest impact – Science.
With over 700,000 weekly print readers, and millions more online, Science ranks
as one of the most highly read multidisciplinary journals in the world. And for
impact, Science can’t be beat. According to the recently released Thomson ISI
Journal Citation Report 2005, Science ranked as the No. 1 most-cited
multidisciplinary journal with a citation factor of 31. Founded in 1880 by inventor
Thomas Edison, and published by the nonprofit AAAS, Science’s reputation as
the leading source for news, research, and leading edge presentation of content
continues to grow. Looking for news and research that will impact the world
tomorrow? Then look in Science.
www.sciencemag.org
To join AAAS and receive your own personal copy of Science every week go to www.aaas.org/join
NEWSMAKERS
EDITED BY YUDHIJIT BHATTACHARJEE
and later campaigned against academic mis- will transform ecology, intellectually and
conduct, died on 23 November in Beijing after MOVERS logistically. And as a scientist, I’ve always
a battle with lymphoma. He was 83. BACK TO SCIENCE. William Schlesinger, dean been fascinated by new ways of looking at
Educated at Cambridge, Tsou led a Chinese of Duke University’s Nicholas School of the the world.
team in the 1950s that joined the A and B Environment and Earth Sciences, will leave in
chains of bovine insulin, which paved the way June to become president of the Institute of
for the total chemical Ecosystem Studies (IES) in Millbrook, New York.
synthesis of the protein His departure has been driven in part by his
in 1965. He resumed unhappiness with Duke’s administration.
research after the In his 6 years as dean, Schlesinger boosted
Cultural Revolution fundraising and increased enrollment by 66%.
ended in the mid- But he recently had disagreements with univer-
1970s, tackling ques- sity administrators over management of the
tions such as how school’s policy institute. Schlesinger wanted the
enzymes work. institute to report exclusively to him instead of
Tsou also spoke out him and the provost. “I was a little frustrated,”
against academic mis- he admits. Adding to the headaches, a $72 mil-
conduct in China, most lion donation pledged in 2003 by the school’s
famously, exposing a Chinese-American founding donors has not yet materialized.
researcher who gained the trust of political At IES, Schlesinger, 56, will have a chance to
leaders to back his dubious work using mes- focus on ecosystem science—his specialty. He
senger RNA to influence goldfish develop- is taking over from Gene Likens, who founded
ment. Pei Gang, director of the Shanghai the institute in 1983. Got a tip for this page? E-mail people@aaas.org
1527 1528
ECOLOGY report, Ebola killed 91 of the 95 animals.
The scientists found that the lag time
Tracking Ebola’s Deadly March between deaths in neighboring groups was
11.2 days—similar to the 12-day human
incubation period. Combined with a north-
Among Wild Apes to-south pattern of deaths over time, the
researchers say, the evidence is very strong
It is grim work to document the deaths of Barcelona, suffered the disappearance of that the virus is spreading from one social
nearly all your study subjects. Primatologist 130 of the 143 gorillas she and her col- group to another.
Magdalena Bermejo and her colleagues leagues had painstakingly habituated Although he initially favored the reser-
have watched as dozens of the gorillas they for study. Deter mined to voir theory, virologist Stuart
had studied either disappeared or turned up document what was happen- Nichols of the U.S. Centers
dead over the past 4 years. The suspect is ing, the researchers identi- for Disease Control and Pre-
Ebola, a hemorrhagic fever that has also fied seven other social groups vention in Atlanta, Geor-
killed dozens of people in the region strad- in the area and monitored gia, says the recent
dling the border between Gabon and the their sleeping nests twice a evidence has con-
Republic of the Congo. On page 1564, the week. Between October 2003 vinced him. Combined
researchers present evidence that the dis- and January 2004, they with genetic studies
ease has wiped out as many as 5000 gorillas o f the viral strains
in the region surrounding the Lossi Sanctu- Central African
that have caused out-
Cameroon
ary, a much higher number than previous Republic breaks over the past
estimates. They also suggest that ape-to-ape 30 years, “it really does
transmission is a major factor in the spread look like we have this epi-
of the disease—which some experts say zootic wave spreading gener-
offers a glimmer of hope for attempts to ally westward through the Congo basin,” he
Eq. Guinea
slow its deadly progress. says, with ape-to-ape transmission on a
As the disease has swept through several local scale.
Gabon
wildlife sanctuaries and national parks, Lossi By extrapolating from more wide-ranging
killing off chimpanzees and gorillas alike, transect surveys they conducted, Bermejo
Republic
virologists and great ape specialists have of Congo
and her colleagues conclude that in a
been frustrated in their efforts to explain 2700-square-kilometer region surrounding
how the disease is spreading. For years, sci- the Lossi Sanctuary, roughly 5000 gorillas
entists sharply disagreed on whether apes have succumbed to the current epidemic.
caught Ebola primarily from a reservoir “It is impressive data from a difficult area
species, such as bats or birds, that could to work in,” Nichols says, but the estimate
carry the virus without getting deathly ill, or is not as solid as the group’s smaller-scale
EUROPEAN RESEARCH
in the arm for science when he launched the work abroad, and luring expats back to Europe. researcher who led a petition against bureau-
SOURCE: EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT
first draft of FP7: some €73 billion over “Capacities” contains some €4.1 billion for cracy and in favor of the ERC in 2004.
v
7 years, which would have roughly doubled the new research infrastructure, such as radiation That kind of criticism is “not fair,” Potocnik
E.U.’s annual contribution to research and sources, data banks, and telescopes. The last says. “We have millions of examples of how
innovation. That 2005 plan got stranded in a category, “Ideas,” funds the ERC. Also [Framework] makes people work together
crisis over the E.U.’s budget (Science, 24 June approved—although technically part of across Europe.” And although battling the
2005, p. 1848)—a “missed opportunity,” given another treaty—is €2.8 billion for Europe’s bureaucracy is “a long journey” in Brussels, he
that Europe is still far from its stated goal of nuclear energy organization, Euratom, most of promises that FP7 will require less of it.
▲
‡ Fixed-angle rotor
F-35-6-30
‡ Fixed-angle rotor
FA-45-30-11
Choose
up to 11
different
rotors
year’s fundraising and hamper research in Pediatric immunologist Alain Fischer of the region. The lack of prestige and opportunities in
areas beyond the immediate target. Hôpital Necker–Enfants Malades in Paris, the sciences drives the vast majority of Arab
Thousands of volunteers help raise cash although “very upset,” says he believes that the researchers abroad to study and work. However,
each year for the Téléthon, which grossed a flap won’t affect the revenues of this year’s “having big educational investments will hope-
record €104 million in 2005, some 60% of drive, slated for 8 and 9 December. The peo- fully raise the level of public awareness,” he
which was spent on research into rare neuro- ple who strictly follow the Church on moral says, and may entice Arab scientists back home.
muscular diseases. But since early Novem- issues “now form a small minority in France,” –JOHN BOHANNON
ber, several bishops have taken aim at AFM Fischer says. –MARTIN ENSERINK
CREDITS (TOP TO BOTTOM): Y12 NATIONAL SECURITY COMPLEX: LAWRENCE LIVERMORE NATIONAL LABORATORY
have “credible minimum lifetimes in excess this Trident II missile. Administration wants to build
of 100 years.” Its conclusion, notes a report a new pit factor y and a new
from a group of outside scientists known as plutonium samples weapon—called the Reliable
the Jasons, reduces “near-term concern and examined the metal’s strength, density, Replacement Warhead (RRW)—that
regarding [the pits’] safety and reliability.” and compressibility. New technologies would use less nasty chemicals and be dif-
The spherical plutonium pit is at the allowed scientists, some of whom hadn’t ficult to detonate if stolen by terrorists. A
core of a nuclear weapon, providing the worked on plutonium before, to try differ- multiagency panel reviewing early designs
f ission reaction that triggers a thermo- ent approaches. Putting both decades-old of the proposed weapons said last week
nuclear explosion. Siegfried Hecker, a and new samples in the same pressure that plans for the new weapon should
metallurgist and former director of Los chamber, for example, “was a first for this progress despite the plutonium findings.
Alamos National Laboratory, calls the program,” says Bruce Goodwin, weapons But those plans are controversial. An
material “an engineer’s nightmare.” chief at Lawrence Livermore National aide to Representative David Hobson
Among other problems, uranium, a radia- Laboratory in California. The result was, (R–OH), outgoing chair of the House panel
tion product, damages the metal’s own lat- “the old stuff basically [performed] like the that funds the nuclear weapons complex,
tice structure, leaving voids that make the new stuff,” he says. says that DOE officials have used the shelf
plutonium less compressible and more To find out how aging would affect even life of plutonium as a key measure of the
brittle. Those changes make the pits older samples, researchers doped pluto- arsenal’s health. “That chain of logic makes
tougher to implode to achieve critical nium samples with faster-decaying iso- plutonium aging central to the RRW ration-
mass. The new analysis indicates that some topes to speed up the aging process, incu- ale,” says the aide, who says the new data
fraction of the plutonium atoms resettle bated the samples in climate-controlled undermine the RRW argument.
back into spots in the lattice, however, cells alongside newer plutonium, and The new analysis “buys us time to do the
helping to preserve the metal’s integrity. measured swelling. The researchers then right thing for RRW,” says physicist Roy
In their 7-year study, DOE scientists used the 100-teraflops IBM Blue Gene Schwitters, chair of the Jason steering com-
used a combination of guile and silicon. machine at Livermore—the crown jewel mittee. Next month, the group begins a
Researchers scoured stockrooms for applicable of DOE’s formidable supercomputing review of RRW itself. –ELI KINTISCH
ism could spawn future megatsunamis. that such research could allow researchers to
Sicily, Stromboli, and other volcanic create chimeras. Less-contentious provisions
Ripple effect. An Etna collapse 8000 years ago islands should be monitored closely, says include prohibiting minors or women who have
spawned a huge tsunami. Grilli. But the worst nightmare may be never given birth from donating eggs. Also
spawned farther afield. Last year, scientists banned are donations in which coercion
tute of Geology and Volcanology (INGV) in warned that a massive collapse of Cumbre between donor and recipient is possible—such
Italy, whose team announced its findings at a Vieja, a volcano in the Canary Islands, as a junior researcher donating for an experi-
press briefing in Rome on 5 December. would trigger a towering tsunami that could ment, as had occurred in Hwang’s lab.
The paper may solve a long-standing puz- pummel coasts on both sides of the Atlantic. Although barred from selling eggs, donors can
zle about the cause of an ancient, devastating Such a collapse could be 10 times larger be compensated for their expenses. After the
tsunami known from sea-floor sediments. than the Etna slide—an “immense geologi- committee decides whether to propose a
“This is a very careful and reasonable work,” cal event,” says Pareschi. Forget Atlit-Yam: nuclear-transfer ban, the rules would require
says Stéphan Grilli, an ocean engineer at the Such a doomsday wave could overwhelm approval from the National Assembly before
University of Rhode Island, Narragansett. Not settlements with familiar names, like New they become law. –D. YVETTE WOHN
everyone agrees. The INGV model has fatal York, Miami, and Lisbon. –JACOPO PASOTTI
flaws, argues Costas Synolakis, a top tsunami Jacopo Pasotti is a writer in Basel, Switzerland.
flowed down two gullies sometime during the ravinelike features ery in January 2006, MOC resur-
past few years, even though liquid water can’t cut by some fluid— veyed 21.5 million square kilome-
long persist on the cold, nearly airless martian presumably water— ters of Mars that had last been
surface. “This is the sort of thing you dream in the slopes of cliffs imaged i n 1999. The sur vey
about, what everybody’s been waiting for,” and crater walls. The turned up 20 impacts during the
says planetary scientist Jennifer Heldmann of tens of thousands of 7 years, ranging in crater diame-
NASA’s Ames Research Center in Mountain gullies now known ter from 2 meters to 148 meters.
View, California. The discovery lends support often look so fresh That’s a surprisingly heavy
to the existence of liquid water so near the sur- that they might have barrage of impactors—surprising
face, at least in places, that it can spurt out on formed in recent to some, at least. Crater formation
rare occasions. And where there’s liquid years, but it could Martian weeping. New deposit is the ticking of the clock that
water, there could be life. have been millions of (bottom, left) formed since top image planetary scientists use to gauge
MOC also found signs of more violent years ago. was taken may be water-borne debris. how old a surface is: The fewer
craters, the younger the surface. To find an could be bad for dating, but if so, MOC older craters, he says, just now revealed by
age for small, relatively young features like shouldn’t have seen any new craters. the wind blowing bright dust away.
glaciers and gullies, researchers must use the The MOC result “is a calibration of the Both active gullies and new craters cry out
more abundant small craters. But they actual impact rate at Mars,” says cratering for scientists’ perennial wish: more data. As
haven’t been able to agree on where most specialist Clark Chapman of Southwest luck would have it, MOC’s successor—the
small impactors come from (Science, 26 May, Research Institute in Boulder, Colorado. far more capable High Resolution Imaging
p. 1132). Do they fall in a steady drizzle from “That’s an amazing and excellent result.” But Science Experiment (HiRISE) camera
the asteroid belt, like sand through an hour- it isn’t likely to settle the debate right away. aboard Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter—
glass? That would be helpful for dating, and Chapman notes that these new craters are started routine operations just last month. So
the MOC discoveries roughly fit the latest smaller than the ones a few hundred meters McEwen, principal investigator of HiRISE, is
estimate of the rate of such a steady drizzle. across used in most dating. And planetary targeting both new craters and active gullies
Or do they mostly come in bursts when really geologist Alfred McEwen of the University in the coming weeks. MOC’s observations
big impacts splatter the planet with bits of of Arizona in Tucson has his doubts about the “are definitely important,” he says, “so let’s
debris once in a million years or so? That modernity of the small craters. They may be take a closer look at them.” –RICHARD A. KERR
GEOCHEMISTRY
oxygen in the atmosphere between 2.4 billion older environments. The results showed that oxygen levels remains unclear. It may go back
and 0.58 billion years ago had not pene- the deep sea was probably oxygen-free dur- to the invasion of land by rock-weathering
trated below surface ocean waters. ing the Gaskiers glaciation of 580 million fungi and lichens, or a burst of mountain
To tease out the history of oxygen around years ago—the last and least of three great, building. Cracking that one will take a lot
the time of the first animals, two groups possibly globe-enshrouding glaciations late more information. –RICHARD A. KERR
interdisciplinary biomedical research. After envy and skepticism. HHMI has spent
hearing Rubin give a talk at a meeting of $500 million to build Janelia, which will
HHMI investigators at the institute’s head- cost $100 million a year to run once it
quarters in Chevy Chase, Maryland, Eddy reaches its capacity of 250 researchers by
didn’t hesitate. He walked up to Rubin and 2009. That investment is an imprudent gam-
said: “Sign me up. This is exactly how I ble, say some scientists, adding that bio-
want to do my science.” medical research would have been better
Now Eddy, at 41, has that chance. In served if HHMI had spent the money to
August, he gave up the university life expand the network of 302 university-based
and moved to Janelia Farm, a sprawling investigators it now supports.
400-hectare research park about 65 kilo- Critics also say that Janelia’s predefined
meters west of Washington, D.C., in Ash- Handpicked. Gerry Rubin has recruited scientists focus on neurobiology violates the spirit of
burn, Virginia. His new six-person lab, with a hunger for interdisciplinary research. open-ended research that drove the two labs
Open science. Rafael Viñoly’s sweeping glass tect Rafael Viñoly, the struc-
building follows the contours of the land. ture is shaped like an arc
about 275 meters long, with
it is seeking to emulate: the Laboratory for floors that jut out of the hill-
Molecular Biology (LMB) in Cambridge, side like steps. The walls are
U.K., and AT&T’s Bell Labs in Murray made of glass, giving the
Hill, New Jersey. And some are turned off building the appearance of a
by the implicit claim that Janelia will pro- giant fishbowl.
vide a better environment for long-range, The interior is designed
interdisciplinary science than is found in to maximize interactions
academia. “To say that the way science is between researchers, with
currently done in America is not effective,
that having scientists write grants and
food as an essential element. A
subsidized cafeteria is open
A Work in Progress
teach students is counter productive— from 11:30 a.m. to 1 p.m., an
that’s just pure arrogance,” says Richard intentionally short window in
Morimoto, a biochemist at Northwestern order to increase the odds that
University in Evanston, Illinois. “Unless scientists will run into each
these guys produce some extraordinary other during lunch. There’s Eric Dmitri Sean Scott
accomplishments, they’ll be ridden out of also a state-of-the-art gym and Betzig Chklovskii Eddy Sternson
CREDITS (TOP ROW): PAUL FETTERS; (2ND ROW) PAUL FETTERS (3); MATTHEW SEPTIMUS; (3RD ROW) SUSAN DOOLEY; BARBARA RIES; TOM KLEINDINST; PAUL FETTERS; (4TH ROW) PAUL FETTERS (2)
Group leaders say they are eager to pursue Some HHMI investigators worry that aries between fields, questions Rubin’s deci-
projects that might be deemed too risky for HHMI’s financial commitment to Janelia could sion to adopt what she sees as a narrow scien-
funding by the National Institutes of Health have an adverse impact on their own funding. tific mission. “I wish they had not chosen to
(NIH), including Janelia’s goal of developing “This is a huge money sink,” says one investi- restrict their goal to studying fruit flies and
imaging tools and linking neural circuits to gator who spoke to Science on the condition of worms,” she says. Andreasen also questions
specific behaviors such as feeding. Dmitri anonymity. “Instead, they could have appointed the wisdom of discouraging frequent travel.
Chklovskii, for example, a neuroscientist another 100 HHMI investigators. That would “I wonder how much time [Rubin] has spent
who’s moving to Janelia from CSHL, intends have made more sense in the current [difficult] on airplanes working on papers and jotting
to collaborate with computational biologists funding climate for biomedical research.” down ideas,” she muses.
and imaging experts to automate a three- Rubin admits that most HHMI investiga- Rubin has ready answers to such criticism.
dimensional rendering of the fly brain. tors were skeptical of the project during its The intellectual focus was chosen after a long
“There’s so much skepticism in selection process involving
the community about whether HHMI investigators, he
that can be done that I wouldn’t notes, and it was essential for
waste any time asking NIH to creating a common ground
fund it,” Chklovskii says. between the different research
Scott Sternson, finishing up groups that the campus was
a postdoc at Rockefeller Uni- seeking to attract. Understand-
versity in New York City, is ing the neurobiology of organ-
planning an array of experi- isms, he says, is no less broad a
ments to pinpoint the behav- mission than Bell Labs’ goal
ioral output of neural circuits in of developing communica-
the hypothalamus, a poorly tions technologies. Rubin
understood structure of the plans to combat any isolation-
brain. Rather than gathering a ist tendencies by bringing in
lot of preliminary data on a spe- outside scientists for meetings
cific behavior, Sternson plans and for longer, paid stints. And
to “take a wider view” and look he sees informal peer review
at multiple behaviors, for of ideas at weekly seminars
which he will need to develop and other internal meetings as
new tools and tests. “By trust- Thirst for knowledge. Researchers are encouraged to socialize and dine at Janelia’s a substitute for the vetting of
ing my judgment,” he says, elegant in-house pub. grant proposals.
“Janelia is allowing me to take Roger Nicoll, a cell biol-
a scientific risk.” Rubin’s plan to spark new planning phase 5 years ago but claims that his ogist at the University of California, San
ideas by bringing different disciplines together proselytizing has turned the tide. “Gerry did a Francisco, and a member of HHMI’s scien-
also seems to be working. Geneticist-turned- great job of bringing us around,” says tific review board, agrees that “there is a cer-
neuroscientist Julie Simpson, a group leader Nobelist Eric Kandel of Columbia Univer- tain hubris and arrogance” associated with
who is imaging the fly brain, says lunchtime sity. And he says critics are missing the point: Janelia that could be a “turn-off ” to some
discussions with Betzig and other optical Janelia is a riskier enterprise than nurturing academics. But if the venture pays off, he
experts are helping her to refine experimental HHMI investigators. “Some years ago, we says, everybody stands to gain. Nicoll
techniques and get higher resolution pictures. realized that even the investigators HHMI expects the model to have “a trickle-down
“We are also discussing how to automate some funds at universities tend to shy away from effect. … As a result of resources that HHMI
of the dissection and staining procedures to high-risk research,” he says. is investing in Janelia, new imaging tech-
speed up prep time for more brains,” she says. Northwestern’s Morimoto and others are nologies and discoveries will come out of
annoyed at what they see as Rubin’s attempt to there that will benefit other researchers.”
Risky business project Janelia as a much-needed alternative Rubin says his biggest challenge will be to
Although outsiders praise the talent level of to academia. “It’s a false statement to say that keep Janelia’s scientists focused on the long
Janelia’s initial pool of researchers, some ques- universities haven’t been doing interdiscipli- term even as they churn out discoveries and
tion whether those scientists will be able to nary science,” says Morimoto. “The reason innovations. Group leaders will face both
accomplish anything more remarkable than that yeast, flies, and worms have become such annual evaluations and 6-year assessments of
what they might have achieved elsewhere. great biological models is that a remarkable their performance, he says, with an emphasis
Skeptics also wonder whether Janelia’s remote mix of academic scientists has been working on the problems chosen and their collaboration
location will make it harder to create a vibrant on them.” He also disagrees with the notion with other groups rather than on the number of
CREDIT: Y. BHATTACHARJEE/SCIENCE
intellectual atmosphere. “It will be a relatively that assured funding automatically fosters cre- publications. (Group leaders who are renewed
small enterprise compared to Bell Labs, and it ativity. “When you are asked to write a grant can stay on or transfer to other institutions as
will not have LMB’s advantage of being situ- [application], you benefit scientifically from HHMI investigators, he notes.) In fact,
ated within a major research university having to articulate your plan,” he says. Rubin says a torrent of papers could under-
[Cambridge],” says William Newsome, an Nancy Andreasen, a psychiatrist at the mine the whole idea of Janelia. “If we have
HHMI investigator at Stanford University University of Iowa College of Medicine in too many [publications],” he jokes, “I’d say our
School of Medicine in Palo Alto, California, Iowa City, who chaired a 2004 National researchers aren’t being ambitious enough.”
who is otherwise enthusiastic about the project. Academies’ report on breaking down bound- –YUDHIJIT BHATTACHARJEE
been a rapidly rising Baltic. there was a big flood that changed everything
At some point, as glaciers dramatically, or if it changed step-by-step,”
receded northward, the land says Friedrich Lüth, SINCOS’s co-director
along this coast began to sink, and the head of the German Archaeological
and over the centuries the sea Into the deep. Archaeologist Harald Lübke (right) watches a diver Institute’s Roman-Germanic Commission.
moved in, submerging the hunt- descend to an ancient hunting camp 3 meters below sea level. In addition to mapping the coast, the team
CREDITS: (TOP, LEFT TO RIGHT) A. CURRY/SCIENCE; M. MEYER, Ph.D. THESIS/GREIFSWALD UNIVERSITY (2002); (BOTTOM) HARALD LÜBKE/STATE AGENCY OF CULTURE AND CULTURAL HERITAGE MECKLENBURG-VORPOMMERN, GERMANY
5400 years BP. To some, the evidence sug-
gests that the first 3.5 meters flooded in very
rapidly, possibly within days. “It’s clearer and
clearer that it was a massive, sudden flood,”
says Lüth. “Log boats were lost, fish traps
were lost—it can’t have come in centimeter
by centimeter.” To Lübke, the evidence
seems more ambiguous; he thinks the flood
could have taken decades.
to-read geologic record. Best of all, its cold, have pounded anything out of existence,” ments of deloading from ice usually assume
brackish water, low in oxygen, preserves says archaeologist Geoff Bailey of the Uni- it’s uniform, [but] there’s evidence that there
organic materials. versity of York, U.K. But, he says, “when are local differences,” says geologist William
Using the deep-water research vessel coastlines have convoluted features, archaeo- Hay of the University of Colorado, Boulder,
Professor Albert Penck, Harff began survey- logical materials may have survived.” For who evaluated the SINCOS project for the
ing the sea bottom in 1999 using video sleds, example, it’s long been assumed that the German Research Foundation in 2003.
side-scan sonar, sediment echolocation, and rough, storm-tossed North Sea is an archaeo- Researchers at Dresden Technical Uni-
core samples. His first look at the ocean logical wasteland. But in the past few years, versity’s Geodesy Institute have constructed
floor was a revelation. Submerged forests of archaeologists have found evidence of whole a computer model incorporating the data
tree trunks and stumps lay where they fell villages 11 meters beneath the water in shel- from the last 10,000 years. Lüth hopes the
8000 years ago. Ancient topography—valleys, tered channels near the Isle of Wight. model will enable the team to make a reason-
hills, river channels, inlets, and bays—could In the last few decades, archaeologists able attempt at predicting what’s to come.
all be easily seen on sonar surveys. “It was a have found underwater prehistoric settle- There are a lot of factors involved. As sea
drowned coast,” says Harff. “It was the same ment sites and artifacts stretching back as levels rise and the Baltic’s volume increases,
landscape, just underwater.” much as 500,000 years near South Africa, for instance, the German coast will sink
Europe, Japan, the Middle East, the United faster under the weight. “We can put it all
“Nirvana” States, and Canada. The discoveries are together to give an outreach for the future,”
Studies of the Baltic are part of a recent wave often made possible by interdisciplinary says Lüth. “The system [that] worked for the
of exploration targeting submerged pre- cooperation: archaeologists using maps of last 8000 years should work for the next 200 to
historic sites around the world. Ancient land the sea bottom prepared by geologists for 300. It could give the basis for planning and
bridges, huge fertile plains, and long coast- oil companies, for instance. Such data, development decisions.”
lines have been submerged since the last gla- added to what climate-change researchers The SINCOS collaboration is a reminder:
cial maximum, when sea levels were as much know about sea levels, provide a new guide “We’re not the only ones faced with a retreat-
as 120 meters below where they are today. to how and where ancient hominids might ing coast,” Harff says. “Our ancestors also
Yet it is only recently that prehistoric have traveled across the now-submerged had to leave their settlements to the ocean.”
underwater archaeology has begun to take landscape. “As more academics start to get –ANDREW CURRY
off. One reason: Excavations are still expen- involved, the dots join together,” says Andrew Curry is a writer in Berlin, Germany.
the complex molecular biology behind Rett year or more. Girls who once loved to turn researchers led by Qiang Chang and Rudolf
syndrome, scientists are exploring hints that the pages of a book as a parent read to them Jaenisch of the Whitehead Institute for Bio-
the disorder, or at least some of its symp- can make only stereotyped wringing move- medical Research in Cambridge, Massachu-
toms, may one day be treatable. ments with their hands, Schanen says. Dur- setts—authors of one of the 2003 Science
Several research teams have also ing their regression, girls often become papers—reported abnormally low levels of
recently found MECP2 abnormalities in withdrawn, anxious, and irritable. They fre- BDNF in a strain of mice missing the mouse
people with autism and related disorders, quently become more social later in life, but version of MECP2, called Mecp2. These
suggesting that the insights gained from other problems persist, including profound mice exhibit several features of Rett syn-
studying this gene are not limited to Rett cognitive and movement def icits and drome, including reduced brain weight and
syndrome. The protein encoded by MECP2, breathing abnormalities. hind-limb clasping, a behavior reminiscent
called MeCP2, is normally incredibly abun- Hundreds of MECP2 mutations have of the repetitive handwringing in Rett girls.
dant in neurons, says Adrian Bird, a molecu- been associated with Rett syndrome. Some The same symptoms appeared when
lar biologist at the University of Edinburgh, render the gene unreadable, leaving cells Jaenisch’s team selectively disabled the
Top quality research depends on comprehensive support. governments around the world. And only AAAS Funding
AAAS is present at every stage of the process – from Updates – sent out monthly – provide continual coverage
advising on funding policy initiatives to tracking the US of R&D appropriations. By actively working to increase
Federal R&D budgeting process. As the experts, we support for research, AAAS advances science.
brief Congressional staffers and representatives from To see how, go to www.aaas.org/support
COMMENTARY
For young readers How stars Life science prize essay
produce elements
LETTERS
edited by Etta Kavanagh
Response because we assumed that they would operate is more in the way these people at age 20 or so
ONE AIM OF THE INVESTMENT MODIFICATION within a more general framework that includes can then develop and realize their life plans.
of the life-cycle principle was to present a such principles as no racial and no sexual dis- This is something that can be, if not fully real-
clear alternative to two principles for the crimination. Hence, the investment modifica- ized, then progressively realized after age 20
allocation of influenza vaccine in a pan- tion principle gives higher priority to a white or so. Much will be fulfilled before 65. This
demic: (i) save the most lives, which would adolescent than a white infant; we reject giving gives a reason to give priority to all adoles-
give higher priority to the elderly, and (ii) a higher priority to a white adolescent than a cents, not only those who have a higher likeli-
CREDIT: ROBERT GIROUX/GETTY IMAGES
pure life-cycle principle (or save the most life black adolescent or a girl over a boy. hood of living until 65. We thought we made
years), which would give higher priority to Although society might benefit more from this clear when we rejected the World Health
the youngest infants. We were aiming to saving the more productive than the less pro- Organization’s disability-adjusted life years
advance a principle that is committed to the ductive, that is not the sort of “investment” (DALYs) with its prioritization based on those
equal worth of all persons and yet recognizes that is embedded in the investment modifica- who are “contributing to the well-being of
morally relevant distinctions among them. tion of the life-cycle principle. The investment others” through earning power or caregiving.
Holmberg charges that we would favor the in youths is from childrearing, education, Finally, we do not understand how Holm-
“most profitable.” We did not articulate every love, and attention, and their own efforts at berg would want to give weight to the “com-
ethical principle relevant to this issue, mainly self-development; the “return on investment” mon good” as opposed to individuals. If some-
one wants to forego receiving a vaccine for Costing out the expenses associated with and circumstances that continue despite provi-
the sake of the common good, he can always providing ARV treatment to those who sero- sion of the best prevention services, which are
do so. convert reveals the weakness of arguments provided to all study participants. Importantly,
Doubtless, any principle of rationing will suggested by Grant et al., that offers of “a reported risk behavior routinely decreases dur-
offend many. We think it unlikely that this is lifelong guarantee of treatment could exhaust ing prevention studies, including HIV vaccine
an issue that can be fruitfully resolved by a limited research resources and does nothing trials (2) and chemoprophylaxis, whether post-
referendum or public opinion poll, and so for those who elect not to participate in exposure (3, 4) or pre-exposure (5).
although we would welcome a lively debate, research.” If ARV treatment costs are as mod- Contrary to the authors’ assertion, the
we think that policy-makers must assume est as we project (and we strongly recom- annual cost of treatment cited would dwarf
the responsibility of producing the princi- mend that formal cost analyses be done), prevention research budgets when multiplied
ples that are most ethically defensible. sponsors of clinical HIV research can surely out to lifelong commitments. According to
EZEKIEL J. EMANUEL AND ALAN WERTHEIMER afford to provide the additional resources their calculations, provision of antiretroviral
Department of Clinical Bioethics, The Clinical Center, necessary to ensure ARV treatment to those treatment for newly infected participants in
National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD 20892–1156, who seroconvert during trials. Providing this current trials alone would cost $1,783,518 or
USA.
benefit will also protect those who do not par- $1,053,897 annually. Because treatment will
ticipate in research, because persons receiv- need to be sustained lifelong once begun, the
The Cost of Access to ing supportive ARV treatment and associated total cost is in fact more than 20 to 30 times
HIV Treatment care will be less likely to transmit their infec- this amount. Additionally, we can anticipate
tion to others in their communities. a minimum of 8 to 10 new HIV prevention
OUR RESEARCH (1) CATALOGED ALL RANDOM- PAUL GALATOWITSCH1 AND NANDI SIEGFRIED2 efficacy trials beginning enrollment in the
ized, controlled trials of interventions for 1Coordinator, HIV/AIDS Clinical Education, St. Vincents next 2 to 3 years, including evaluation of
HIV/AIDS that were conducted in Africa Medical Center, New York, NY 10011, USA. 2Nuffield microbicides, pre-exposure prophylaxis, and
Medical Fellow, University of Oxford, Oxford OX2 7LG, UK.
from 1987 to 2003. We identified 77 trials vaccines. Prevention research resources are
overall; of these, only 10 were testing References and Notes barely sufficient to pay for the costs of the
approaches to HIV/AIDS prevention. After 1. N. Siegfried, M. Clarke, J. Volmink, Br. Med. J. 331, 742 research, which includes provision of stan-
reading the exchange “HIV research and (2005). dard prevention for all participants, medical
2. M. Badri et al., PLoS Med 3, e4. 2006 (Epub 6 Dec. 2005).
access to treatment” by M. Warren and “Re- evaluation, safety laboratory testing, HIV
3. The authors are grateful to Ruanne Barnabas and
sponse” by R. M. Grant et al. (Letters, 13 Timothy Law Snyder for their comments on an earlier testing, recruitment, retention, and commu-
Jan., p. 175), we attempted to quantify the version of this letter. nity education and participation. In many
number of seroconversions occurring in the places, research monies are used to treat sex-
53,144 participants included in all 10 trials. Response ually transmitted infections and adverse
Trials were conducted in seven countries and events related to study participation.
differ in terms of length of follow-up, partici- WE ADVOCATE STRENGTHENING TREATMENT Diverting prevention research funds to
pant risk profile, and seroconversion rate, programs for all people, including those treatment programs would limit the speed
presenting a challenge to economic model- who seroconvert during prevention trials. with which promising prevention strategies
ing. At an estimated overall annual serocon- The Global Fund, PEPFAR, and other treat- can be evaluated and more infections averted.
version rate of 2.5% and using the numbers ment programs currently receive substantial Additional ethical and logistical issues would
from these trials, we estimate that 1329 peo- funding from sponsors who also support arise from requirements that researchers take
ple would contract the virus each year. prevention research. Long-term HIV care primary responsibility for ensuring that treat-
Because cost-effectiveness data are lim- for people who become infected during HIV ment is available for trial seroconverters,
ited, we used data from a recent South prevention trials is not the moral obligation rather than helping to strengthen treatment
African study (2) measuring the cost of anti- of researchers (1), any more than long-term programs for everyone. Would this coverage
retroviral (ARV) provision (including moni- treatment of cardiovascular events is the extend to persons found to be infected before
toring, related care, and hospital inpatient moral obligation of investigators in primary enrollment? To persons who become infected
days, but excluding indirect costs) to esti- prevention trials of cardiovascular disease. after the trial ends? Would treatment for
mate the costs of treating 1329 serocon- HIV infection has not been an adverse spouses/partners be available, and if not,
verted participants. At current South African event of prevention study participation. would drug sharing occur? How would care
public-sector costs of $1342 per person per Rather, HIV infection arises from behaviors be provided to those who move away?
year, annual provision of antiretroviral treat- Because the majority of HIV care is required
ment to all participants would cost many years after seroconversion, new finan-
$1,783,518. At anticipated public-sector cial mechanisms would be needed to assure
prices for locally manufactured drugs, per- Letters to the Editor funds were available when needed. These
person per-year costs would drop to $793, Letters (~300 words) discuss material published financial mechanisms would provide no bene-
in Science in the previous 6 months or issues of
reducing the overall costs for all those sero- fit to people with HIV who need treatment
general interest. They can be submitted through
converting to $1,053,897. These annual the Web (www.submit2science.org) or by regular now, nor to those who choose not to partici-
costs are modest and would remain so even mail (1200 New York Ave., NW, Washington, DC pate in research.
if doubled or tripled to account for longer 20005, USA). Letters are not acknowledged upon Effective prevention is the only hope for
durations of follow-up and for potentially receipt, nor are authors generally consulted before sustainable universal treatment. Success in
higher costs for small numbers of treatment publication. Whether published in full or in part, the fight against AIDS depends on mutually
cohorts or for areas whose treatment costs letters are subject to editing for clarity and space. enabling cooperation between prevention
may exceed those of South Africa. and treatment advocates.
ROBERT M. GRANT,1,2 SUSAN P. BUCHBINDER,3 again, or have a home worth returning to? Of Proc. R. Soc. London B doi:10.1098/rspb.2006.3713
JOHN P. MOORE,4 JAVIER R. LAMA,5 MYRON S. (2006).
course, some captive breeding is worth- 13. J. A. Pounds, M. P. L. Fogden, J. M. Savage, G. C. Gorman,
COHEN,6 MARK A. WAINBERG,7 KATHLEEN M. while, especially for research and education, Conserv. Biol. 11, 1307 (1997).
MACQUEEN8 but its efficacy in preserving nature should 14. Supporting Online Material of Mendelson et al. (see
1Gladstone Institute of Virology and Immunology, 1650 not be oversold. www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/full/313/5783/48/DC1).
Owens Street, San Francisco, CA 94158, USA. 2University of There is no substitute for putting the
California, San Francisco. 3San Francisco Department of
Public Health. 25 Van Ness Avenue, Suite 710, San Earth on a safe path. The Amphibian Con- Response
Francisco, CA 94102, USA. 4Weill Medical College of Cornell servation Action Plan recognizes this—stat- THE AMPHIBIAN CONSERVATION ACTION
University, New York, NY 10021, USA. 5Asociación Civil ing, for example, that global warming must Plan (ACAP) reflects the need for a global,
Impacta Salud y Educación, Grimaldo del Solar 805, Lima,
Peru. 6University of North Carolina, 130 Mason Farm Road
be addressed, and proclaiming amphibians comprehensive response to amphibian ex-
CB# 7030, Chapel Hill, NC, 27599, USA. 7McGill University “canaries in the global coal mine” (14). tinctions and is a consensus position reached
AIDS Center, Montreal, QC H3T IE2, Canada. 8Family Health Mendelson et al., however, say nothing about by 76 international scientists and conser-
International, Post Office Box 13950, Research Triangle stemming environmental deterioration (be- vationists (including two of the Letter’s authors,
Park, NC 27709, USA.
sides habitat loss) and would instead put the Pounds and Carnaval).
References canaries under intensive care. To suggest that Our Policy Forum identified chytrid-
1. C. Weijer, G. LeBlanc, J. Law Med. Ethics 34, 793 (2006). this alone can halt the extinctions under- iomycosis [caused by the fungus Batrach-
2. B. N. Bartholow et al., J. Acquir. Immune Defic. Syndr.
39, 90 (2005). mines scientific credibility and engenders ochytrium dendrobatidis (Bd)] as
3. J. N. Martin et al., AIDS 18, 787 (2004). false hope and complacency among a case study because of its
4. M. Schechter et al., J. Acquir. Immune Defic. Syndr. 35, voters and consumers. recent emergence, global
519 (2004).
5. L. Peterson et al., paper presented at XVI International Biodiversity loss warns that distribution, and ability
AIDS Conference, Toronto, Canada, 2006. humanity’s life-support system to cause extinction. We
is crumbling. Those who real- argued that captive hus-
ize this may become responsi- bandry is a necessary
Responding to ble global citizens, demanding and timely response to
Amphibian Loss sound governance and account- The Panamanian
Golden Frog,
this threat.
ability. Through outreach, we Pounds et al. (i) dis-
IN THEIR POLICY FORUM “CONFRONTING must foster an international “war Atelopus zeteki. agree with some spatio-
amphibian declines and extinctions” (7 July, on environmental deterioration” temporal dynamics of Bd
p. 48), J. R. Mendelson III and colleagues with initiatives on the scale of the spread, not mentioned by us;
offer a strategy for “stopping” the wide- Manhattan and Apollo projects. Society (ii) are skeptical about captive
spread losses of frogs, toads, and salaman- faces critical choices, and the clock is running. breeding programs; and (iii) suggest that a
ders. Disease research and captive breeding J. ALAN POUNDS,1* ANA CAROLINA CARNAVAL,2 focus on captive breeding would distract
figure prominently in their call for action. ROBERT PUSCHENDORF,3 CÉLIO F. B. HADDAD,4 from other solutions to amphibian extinctions.
Mendelson et al. imply that the main chal- KAREN L. MASTERS5 Pounds et al.’s citations (1–4) do not
lenge, apart from curbing “familiar threats” 1Monteverde Cloud Forest Preserve, Tropical Science Center, support their statement that where chytrid
such as habitat destruction, lies in combating Santa Elena, Puntarenas 5655-73, Costa Rica. 2Museum of fungus is present, there are no major
Vertebrate Zoology, University of California, Berkeley,
the chytrid fungus Batrachochytrium dendro- Berkeley, CA 94720–3160, USA. 3School of Marine and declines because these articles all report
batidis. This pathogen may well be a central Tropical Biology, James Cook University, Townsville, declines potentially attributable to chytrid-
proximate cause of mortality, but we question Queensland 4811, Australia. 4Departamento de Zoologia, iomycosis. The loosely worded statement
I.B., UNESP, Av. 24 A, 1515, Bela Vista, 13506-900 Rio
the belief that it spreads gradually across large Claro, S.P., Brazil. 5Council for International Educational
that “many populations survive such epi-
regions, spelling doom for amphibian com- Exchange, Monteverde, Puntarenas 5655-26, Costa Rica. sodes” misrepresents the severity of de-
munities wherever it arrives (1–4). The obser- clines. Strong evidence demonstrates that
*To whom correspondence should be addressed: E-mail: Bd is one of the few diseases capable of
vations that ostensibly support this “extinc- goldtoad@racsa.co.cr
tion-wave” model are open to interpretation, causing extinction of species (5), not just
and the chytrid inhabits many places where References population extirpation. Nevertheless, we
major losses have not been observed (5–8). 1. W. F. Laurance, K. R. McDonald, R. Speare, Conserv. Biol. readily acknowledge instances where Bd
10, 406 (1996).
Furthermore, evidence suggests that climate 2. K. R. Lips, Conserv. Biol. 13, 117 (1999).
was detected but where amphibian popula-
change and other factors may contribute to 3. K. R. Lips, J. R. Mendelson III, A. Muñoz-Alonso, L. tions were little affected (6).
declines by triggering disease outbreaks, Canseco-Marquez, D. G. Mulcahy, Biol. Conserv. 119, Pounds et al. exaggerate our focus on
555 (2004). captive programs and suggest that captive
which might travel varying distances in wave- 4. K. R. Lips et al., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 103, 3165
like patterns (9–12). In any case, many popu- (2006). programs “engender false hope and compla-
lations survive such episodes (13) yet face an 5. T. W. J. Garner et al., Emerg. Infect. Dis. 11, 1639 cency among voters and consumers,”
(2005). yet they offer no empirical support for
uncertain future as environments deteriorate, 6. M. Ouellet, I. Mikaelian, B. D. Pauli, J. Rodrígues, D. M.
regionally and globally. Green, Conserv. Biol. 19, 1431 (2005). these claims or provide alternative actions.
Protecting populations in centers for cap- 7. L. J. Rachowicz et al., Conserv. Biol. 19, 1441 (2005). Captive programs are a single tool repre-
8. A. C. Oliveira de Queiroz Carnaval, R. Puschendorf, O. L. senting a case-specific response that can
tive breeding may evoke Noah’s ark. In real- Peixoto, V. Kruth Verdade, M. Trefaut Rodriques,
ity, these centers would be high-tech Ecohealth 3, 41 (2006). forestall extinctions (7). Control of Bd in the
CREDIT: RON HOLT
lifeboats, costly and of uncertain design, 9. J. M. Kiesecker, A. R. Blaustein, L. K. Belden, Nature 410, wild is not currently possible, but it is likely
afloat indefinitely on perilous seas. Of the 681 (2001). to continue causing extinctions of amphib-
10. J. A. Pounds, Nature 410, 639 (2001).
species that would obtain the inevitably lim- 11. J. A. Pounds et al., Nature 439, 161 (2006). ians; these realities warrant captive assur-
ited seats, how many would make it home 12. J. Bosch, L. M. Carrascal, L. Duran, S. Walker, M. C. Fisher, ance colonies as a last resort for species
endangered by this disease. mental deterioration” would address the Breeding Specialist Group, Apple Valley, MN 55124, USA.
10IUCN/SSC-CI/CABS Biodiversity Assessment Unit, c/o
We did not say that conservation should amphibian crisis, and that the clock is run-
Conservation International, Washington, DC 20036, USA.
focus solely on chytridiomycosis, nor rely ning, but even under the best-case scenario, 11Conservation International, Washington, DC 20036,
solely on captive programs. We endorse the that is a decades-long project, during which USA. 12Universidade Federal Rural do Rio de Janeiro,
ACAP Declaration, which clearly provides time many additional species may be lost IB-DBA, CxP 74524, CEP 23851-970, Seropédica, RJ,
Brazil. 13Department of Biology, University of Puerto Rico,
research and conservation priorities for all (9). Our Policy Forum and ACAP offer spe- Píedras, San Juan, Puerto Rico 00931-3360. 14Department
threats to amphibians. cific, large-scale, immediate responses to of Conservation Biology, Chicago Zoological Society,
We disagree with the vague call to reverse conserve amphibians. Brookfield, IL 60513, USA. 15Escuela de Biología,
JOSEPH R. MENDELSON III,1* Universidad de Costa Rica, San Pedro, Costa Rica. 16Museo
environmental deterioration “[t]hrough out-
de Zoología, Centro de Biodiversidad y Ambiente, Escuela
reach” as a solution to amphibian extinc- KAREN R. LIPS,2 JAMES E. DIFFENDORFER,3 de Biología, Pontificia Universidad Católica del Ecuador,
tions. First, dealing with both the proximate RONALD W. GAGLIARDO,4 GEORGE B. RABB,5 Apartado 17-01-2184, Quito, Ecuador. 17National
and ultimate causes of amphibian extinc- JAMES P. COLLINS,6 PETER DASZAK,7 Aquarium in Baltimore, Baltimore, MD 21202, USA.
18Museum of Vertebrate Zoology, University of California,
tions is the most effective strategy. Pounds ROBERTO IBÁÑEZ D.,8 KEVIN C. ZIPPEL,9
Berkeley, Berkeley, CA 94720, USA.
et al. seem to think that only addressing ulti- SIMON N. STUART,10 CLAUDE GASCON,11
mate causes will prevent ongoing ex- HÉLIO R. DA SILVA,12 PATRICIA A. BURROWES,13 References
ROBERT C. LACY,14 FEDERICO BOLAÑOS,15 1. T. W. J. Garner et al., Emerg. Infect. Dis. 11, 1639
tinctions, but we disagree because many (2005).
LUIS A. COLOMA,16 KEVIN M. WRIGHT,17
amphibians will go extinct before the global 2. M. Ouellet, I. Mikaelian, B. D. Pauli, J. Rodrígues,
DAVID B. WAKE18
environment responds (8). Second, focused, D. M. Green, Conserv. Biol. 19, 1431 (2005).
forward-thinking plans are encouraging 3. L. J. Rachowicz et al., Conserv. Biol. 19, 1441 (2005).
1Zoo Atlanta, Atlanta, GA 30315, USA. 2Department of 4. A. C. Oliveira de Queiroz Carnaval, R. Puschendorf,
to the general public, policy-makers, and Zoology, Southern Illinois University, Carbondale, IL O. L. Peixoto, V. Kruth Verdade, M. Trefaut Rodriques,
donors. Since publication of our Policy 62901–6501, USA. 3Illinois Natural History Survey, Ecohealth 3, 41 (2006).
Forum, the ACAP has received endorsement Champaign, IL 61820, USA. 4Atlanta Botanical Garden, 5. K. R. Lips et al., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 103,
Atlanta, GA 30309, USA. 5Chicago Zoological Society, 3165 (2006).
from IUCN, unsolicited gifts from founda- Brookfield, IL 60513, USA. 6School of Life Sciences, 6. P. Daszak et al., Ecology 86, 3232 (2005).
tions, queries from the public, and coverage Arizona State University, Tempe, AZ 85287–4501, USA. 7. K. Krajick, Science 311, 1230 (2006).
7Consortium for Conservation Medicine, Wildlife Trust, New
in the popular media. This attention broadly 8. IPCC (International Panel of Climate Change),
supports amphibian conservation, not spe- York, NY 10001, USA. 8Smithsonian Tropical Research Climate Change 2001: Impacts, Adaptation, and
Institute, Unit 0948, APO AA 34002-0948, USA, and Vulnerability (Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge,
cific causes or programs. Departamento de Zoología, Universidad de Panamá, 2001).
Both groups agree that “war on environ- Panamá, Republica de Panamá. 9IUCN/SSC Conservation 9. S. N. Stuart et al., Science 306, 1783 (2004).
ila ite
va l S
e
bl
e A na
ns tio
ce u
Li stit
In
STKE gives you essential tools to power your For more information go to www.stke.org
understanding of cell signaling. It is also a vibrant To sign up today, visit promo.aaas.org/stkeas
virtual community, where researchers from around
Sitewide access is available for institutions.
the world come together to exchange information
To find out more e-mail stkelicense@aaas.org
and ideas.
I
f your holiday gift lists include children Here we present our
or young adults whose interest in science short descriptions of the
you are trying to encourage, we offer as 17 finalists chosen by pan-
suggestions the finalists for the 2007 Science els of librarians, educators,
Books and Films Prizes for Excellence in and scientists. Full reviews of
Science Books. The prizes are intended to each book have been published or
honor books that promote an understanding will appear in Science Books and
and appreciation of science in younger read- Films, and AAAS members can
ers. Sponsored by the AAAS and Subaru, read these reviews on the
they are awarded in four categories: chil- Web. The four winners for
dren’s science picture book (for readers in 2007 will be announced at the
grades K–4), middle grades science book AAAS Annual Meeting in San Fran-
(grades 5–8), young adult science book (high cisco in February.
school), and hands-on science/activity book The criteria for evaluating the books readers to turn to science books for enjoy-
(any age). The titles considered for the 2007 include a clear and accurate presentation of ment as well as for information.
prizes were published between September scientific concepts. But we join the judges in –Heather Malcomson,1 Barbara Jasny,
2005 and August 2006. hoping that the finalists will entice young and Sherman Suter
Children’s Science Picture Book kept a book of drawings called “her inventions” and designed improve-
ments to the machines she worked with in factories that improved their
Boy, Were We Wrong About Dinosaurs! Kathleen V. Kudlinski, with illus- efficiency and helped keep workers safe. She confronted prejudice
trations by S. D. Schindler. Dutton Children’s, New York, 2005. 32 pp. against women and won a patent for a paper bag–making machine that
$15.99. ISBN 0-525-46978-8. enabled her to go into business
Demonstrating how scientific knowledge grows as new facts become for herself. The story is one both
known, the author and the illustrator present once-common ideas about girls and boys can enjoy.
dinosaurs that have been overturned or called into question. Among their
examples are the thumb spike of Iguanodon, posture, coloration, skin What Is Science? Rebecca Kai
covering, maternal behavior, and the evolutionary fate of these extinct Dotlich, with illustrations by
animals that have long fascinated children. Sachiko Yoshikawa. Holt, New
York, 2006. 32 pp. $16.95.
An Egg Is Quiet. Dianna Aston, with illustra- ISBN 0-8050-7394-9.
tions by Sylvia Long. Chronicle, San Francisco, Naturally curious about the world
2006. 30 pp. $16.95. ISBN 0-8118-4428-5. around them, children love to
Striking and accurate drawings of all types of ask questions. To spark interest in
eggs—from the very tiny blue crab egg to the science, this delightful book
hefty ostrich egg—bring this book to life. The encourages them to do just that. A group of inquisitive children and their
beautiful illustrations and simple yet informa- dog explore the exciting world of science through a variety of activities
tive text show why eggs are different shapes such as visiting an oilfield, twirling in a hurricane, flying a spaceship to
(seabird eggs are pointy at one end, so they Saturn, biking through the mountains, looking at the stars, and more.
roll around in safe little circles, not off the Young readers will relish the whirlwind tour that encompasses stars,
cliff), colors (to camouflage themselves), and planets, rocks, soil, sea and sky, hurricanes,
textures (amphibian eggs are “gooey”, which keeps them from drying out). volcanoes, earthquakes, and snow. The
The author excellently captures the incredible variety of eggs while cele- bright, bold illustrations will cause children
brating their form and function. to reach for the book on their own.
Marvelous Mattie. How Margaret E. Knight Became an Inventor. Emily Wings of Light. The Migration of the Yellow
Arnold McCully. Farrar, Straus, and Giroux, New York, 2006. 32 pp. $16. Butterfly. Stephen R. Swinburne, with illustra-
CREDITS (TOP): GETTY IIMAGES
will fly alongside the butterflies as they sail above the Yucatan rain
forests, over the Gulf of Mexico, and on to land again in the southern
United States. The story is nicely personalized by the book’s focus on a
single butterfly “with a notch in its wing”—a thoughtful middle ground
between an excessively abstract description of the whole population and
the alternative of cutesy anthropomorphism so often seen in young chil-
dren’s insect books.
Many children when asked what they want The book starts by capturing a humorous day
to be when they grow up will reply, “a vet- in the life of Diane France as she walks in
erinarian!” This book will further develop the heels needed for a conference while
their interest in veterinary medicine. Filled transporting (more or less successfully) a
with full-color, behind-the-scenes photo- brain in a bucket full of formalin. The author
graphs, it captures the drama and excite- then paints an engaging picture of France’s
ment of an animal emergency room. The youth and adolescence in a small town in
author provides a brief history of veterinary medicine as well as accounts of Colorado and her subsequent education. The
real-life pets and their treatment at the animal hospital. book also presents fascinating descriptions
of some actual forensic anthropology cases. It conveys France’s spirit of
adventure but does not leave out emotionally painful aspects of her work
Team Moon. How 400,000 People
or difficult parts of her life. Readers will learn about the science and may
Landed Apollo 11 on the Moon. Catherine
well be inspired by France’s motto, “If you have really good adventures,
Thimmesh. Houghton Mifflin, Boston,
then you’ve had a good life.”
2006. 80 pp. $19.95. ISBN 0-618-
50757-4.
Cool Stuff and How It Works.
This book takes readers behind the Chris Woodford et al. DK, New York,
scenes of the mission that first placed 2005. 256 pp. $24.99, C$32.99 ISBN
humans on the Moon—dramatically 0-7566-1465-1.
telling, for example, the story of the Teens who enjoy taking “stuff” apart
near-catastrophe the astronauts faced in order to find out how it works will
when they were less than 35,000 feet spend hours poring over this eye-
from the lunar surface. The pictures do the story full justice, and it was opening book. The book’s carefully
good to see the emphasis on the team who made an historic event possible. worded descriptions, colorful graph-
ics, and clear fonts and line spacing
Oh, Rats! The Story of Rats and People. Albert Marrin. Dutton Children’s, help the reader more easily under-
New York, 2005. 48 pp. $16.99. ISBN 0-525-47762-4. stand today’s modern tools. Using
To many, rats are pesky pests: voracious consumers of our foods and cutting-edge imaging techniques, the
garbage and spreaders of contagion and disease. To some, they are menu authors dissect everyday items, such
FICTION
“W
orms. Monsters. Methane. have to flee inland. The shipping, fishing,
Natural disasters. It was time and tourism industries grind to a halt. The
for a drink.” This is how marine ocean becomes a no-go zone. In painting
biologist Sigur Johanson sums up the state these scenarios, however exaggerated they
of the planet just days before all hell breaks may be, the author manages to show the
loose in Frank Schätzing’s eco-thriller reader how intimately our lives and well-
The Swarm. Following disaster movies such being are linked to the ocean—and how our
as The Day After Tomorrow and The Core, landlubbing species is often happy to ignore
the book focuses on a global threat set to end changes in the seas, until it is too late.
human civilization. Only this time, it comes Scientists feature prominently in this
from the depths of the ocean, and some of story as the only characters who are thinking
the book may be closer to reality than we about the big picture. They are the canaries
would like. in the coal mine, the main defenders against
Initially, the threat builds slowly. Fish and the enemy that is our own ignorance. Yet,
whales disappear. Invasive species foul ship they are also shown to be slow to communi-
hulls. Jellyfish and toxic blooms appear more cate their results, usually waiting for abso-
frequently and in unusual places. This proba- lute certainty.
bly sounds familiar. Indeed, these are the At one point in the story, marine scientist
usual reports from an ocean that is being Heiko Sahling warns, “We don’t have time They came from the deep. The Spanish-flagged
transformed on a global scale. While I am to leave anything to anyone [else]…. We bottom-trawler Ivan Nores hauled these fish up from
typing this, I look out on the Northwest know exactly what is going to happen.” But the depths of the North Atlantic Ocean.
Atlantic—one of the most overfished regions by then it is too late to stop the massive
of the world (2). I am reminded of my univer- blowouts of methane gas that later trigger a undergraduate years) are real people; others
sity years on the Baltic, where I studied nox- tsunami in the North Sea. are pure fiction. Similarly, while some of the
ious algal blooms that spoiled beaches. And In another scene that resonated with me, story is based on real information, most is
I think of the formerly fish-rich Benguela science journalist Karen Weaver discovers complete fabrication. My biggest concern is
upwelling system off Namibia, which is that the global circulation pattern is collaps- that it is almost impossible to disentangle
now dominated by millions of ing. She only sees the extent of the where the facts end and the author’s imagina-
tons of jellyfish (3), and the problem when the military gives tion takes over. Yet, this mixture has been
many other locations heading The Swarm her unlimited access to global hugely successful in raising people’s aware-
toward similar fates (4, 5). A Novel of the Deep satellite data, which has been ness and interests in the oceans. The book
Overall, these changes are by Frank Schätzing combined to “form the complete has sold millions of copies in Europe and has
gradual and, for most of us, Translated from the
history of oceanic mapping.” She reportedly led to large increase in the profile
difficult to see. However, there German (1) by Sally-Ann muses that “[p]roving the exis- (and funding) of marine science in Germany,
is a real concern that complex Spencer. ReganBooks tence of global changes meant where it was first published.
marine ecosystems can shift (HarperCollins), New obtaining data on a global scale.” For me, The Swarm only drags in the last
suddenly and catastrophically York, 2006. 893 pp. I agree. This is what emerges few chapters, when the action-adventure bit
(6). In The Swarm, the rate $24.95, C$32.50. ISBN as the most interesting message takes over and the science goes completely
of change is sped up by a few 0-06-081326-1. Paper, from the book: that the oceans overboard. The ensuing battle between good
orders of magnitude, we get Hodder and Stoughton, are changing on a global scale, and evil finds scientists and the military rac-
fast-forwarded into some of London. £12.99. that our understanding of these ing to apply their contrasting “cures” to the
ISBN 0-340-89523-3.
the scarier scenarios for our changes always lags behind them, world’s problems. Will the oceans be saved?
planet’s future, and we must and that too often we are too slow, Will reason—finally—prevail? The answers
face the several environmental crises simulta- too conservative, or simply too unimaginative are available in a bookstore near you.
neously: a rapid spindown of the Gulf Stream to put all the pieces together.
and Atlantic deep-water circulation, destabi- In preparing to write this novel, Schätzing References
1. F. Schätzing, Der Schwarm (Kiepenheuer and Witsch,
lization of methane hydrates on the sea floor, (a marketing executive in Cologne who has
CREDIT: KATE DAVISON/GREENPEACE
T
he idea that the United States domi- or currently planned R&D facility both views of corporate R&D. For example,
nates cutting edge science and technol- outside and inside the home country. in 2004 the National Science Foundation
ogy is challenged by the decline in the Respondents identified 145 facilities in devel- reported that 4% of U.S. industry expenditure
U.S. share of patents and the growth of corpo- oped economies (primarily the United States on R&D was for basic research, 19% was for
rate spending on research and development and Western Europe) and 90 in emerging applied research, and 77% was for develop-
(R&D) in emerging countries like China and economies (primarily China and India). They ment (1). By contrast, in our taxonomy, 38.8%
India (1–3). Because scientific discovery is were asked to characterize the technological of R&D at identified sites involves new sci-
critical to economic growth, these trends have and market focus of R&D at the site. The tech- ence, while 61.2% is familiar science.
sparked concerns as to what is driving compa- nological focus was defined as either (i) a The focus here is on the percent of effort
nies to conduct R&D in these countries and novel application of science as an output of the devoted to new science, regardless of whether
the implications for future competitiveness, R&D (it could be patentable or not) or (ii) it is for new or familiar markets. The his-
particularly given problems with the U.S. an application of science
patent system and improving protection currently used by the firm
45
of intellectual property (IP) in emerging and/or its competitors. We
40
economies (4–9). Similar concerns pervade refer to (i) as new science
Percentage of effort
35
European innovation policy initiatives (10). and (ii) as familiar science.
30
The popular press has fueled these concerns The market focus was de- 25
with reports of R&D moving to emerging fined as either (iii) to create 20
countries in search of low costs (11). products or services that are 15
A survey we conducted of 249 R&D- new to the firm or (iv) for 10
intensive companies headquartered primarily the improvement of prod- 5
in the United States and Western Europe ucts or services that the 0
revealed that respondents expect their R&D to firm already offers its cus- Familiar/familiar Familiar/new New/familiar New/new
Science/market
grow in emerging economies and to decline in tomers or where it has a
developed economies for complex reasons good understanding of the Type and purpose of R&D.
(12, 13). Lower R&D cost in emerging eco- end use. We refer to (iii) as
nomies was not the main reason; market new markets and (iv) as familiar markets. tograms in the chart (p. 1548) give responses
factors, collaboration with university scien- Combining these foci gives four types of for the percent of effort devoted to new sci-
tists, and quality of R&D personnel were all at R&D: new science to create new markets, new ence in developed versus emerging economy
least as important as cost (12, 14). science to improve familiar markets, familiar sites. The percent of effort devoted to new sci-
Here we focus on the type of R&D con- science to create new markets, and familiar ence in developed economy sites is more
ducted in different countries and argue that science to improve familiar markets. evenly distributed than it is for sites in emerg-
appropriate policies in the face of globaliza- To clarify, when Pfizer developed Viagra, ing economies. In the latter, almost 71% of the
tion should focus not only on the factors af- it was a new molecular structure with applica- sites conduct 25% or less new science. On
fecting location but also on the type of R&D tion in a market not served by Pfizer. It was average, 49.6% of R&D effort in developed
conducted. We categorize R&D according to a new science for a new market. Cialis, based economy sites is for new science; in emerging
taxonomy suggested by R&D executives as on the same molecular structure, was later economy sites, it is only 22%. The contrast is
one they use in tracking internal R&D. This developed by Lilly to serve a new market more striking when responses are weighted by
allows us to focus on the extent to which com- for Lilly. It was familiar science for a new the number of technical employees at each
panies use cutting-edge science and show that market. Once-a-week versions developed by facility: The weighted averages for new sci-
the type of industrial R&D differs substan- either company would be familiar science for ence are 56% in developed economy sites and
tially in developed versus emerging country familiar markets. 11.5% in emerging economy sites.
sites. An econometric model is used to relate We asked respondents for the percent of To identify factors behind the type of
the type of R&D at various sites to country effort at the site devoted to each of the four science at a site, a logistic regression ap-
characteristics. In the survey, respondents categories (see figure, above). The R&D exec- proach for grouped data was used to relate the
were asked to identify a recently established utives we interviewed claimed this classifica- ratio of new to familiar science in the identi-
tion is more relevant to their R&D than fied facilities to respondent views of a variety
J. Thursby is at Emory University, Atlanta, GA 30322 and M. the more “linear and sequential” taxonomy of other country-specific characteristics (16).
Thursby is at Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, GA of basic or curiosity-driven research, applied The model controls for industry, the firm’s
30308, USA. research designed for specific end use, or de- total worldwide technical employment, and
*Author for correspondence. E-mail: marie.thursby@mgt. velopment to improve products or processes whether the country of the facility is developed
gatech.edu (15). The two taxonomies provide different or emerging. Data for the other country char-
Percent of sites
for locating a facility there. research on university industry collaboration
For each factor, respon- 20 in the European economies that have adopted
dents were first asked the U.S. policies regarding university research
extent to which they agree shows similar concerns (19). This dynamic
or disagree that the factor 10 will only be accentuated as the quality of uni-
accurately characterizes versities in emerging economies improves.
the country in which the
facility is located. They 0 References and Notes
0 50 100 0 50 100 1. National Science Foundation, Science and Engineering
were then asked how im- Percent of effort devoted to new science Indicators (NSF, Washington, DC, 2006).
portant or central the fac- 2. J. Landefield, R. Mataloni, Working Paper 2004-06 (U.S.
tor was in the delibera- New science in developed and emerging economy sites. Bureau of Economic Analysis, Department of Commerce,
tions on location of the Washington, DC, 2004);
www.bea.gov/bea/working_papers.htm.
facility. Responses on agreement and impor- two IP factors were similar to those for quality 3. Economist Intelligence Unit, “Scattering the seeds of
tance were combined to create a measure of of personnel, in that the IP factors were statis- invention: The globalization of research and develop-
the extent to which a factor drove the location tically important in location decisions, but ment” (White paper, Economist, London, 2004).
4. R. Nelson, The Sources of Economic Growth (Harvard
decision. We then tested the hypotheses that were not significantly related to the ratio of Univ. Press, Cambridge, MA, 1996).
some of these factors are also central to the new to familiar science. Thus IP protection 5. Committee on Prospering in the Global Economy, Rising
type of R&D conducted (see table below). appears to be equally important for both Above the Gathering Storm: Energizing and Employing
Because one would expect the availability new and familiar science. In terms of the America for a Brighter Economic Future (National
Academies Press, Washington, DC, 2006).
of high-quality personnel to be important for Viagra/Cialis example, it would not be sur- 6. R. Freeman, NBER Working Paper 11457 (National
any kind of scientific research, it is not clear prising that Pfizer and Lilly consider IP pro- Bureau of Economic Research, Cambridge, MA, July
how the ratio of new to familiar science would tection equally important for both products, 2005).
7. A. Jaffe, J. Lerner, Innovation and Its Discontents: Our
vary (if at all) with the quality of personnel. even though the former represents new sci- Broken Patent System Is Endangering Innovation and
Our regression analysis showed that, although ence and the latter familiar. Progress (Princeton Univ. , Princeton, NJ, 2004).
quality of R&D personnel affects location The most striking result is that the factors 8. N. Zamiska, WSJ (3 June 2006), p. A3.
9. L. Branstetter, Q. J. Econ. 121, 321 (2006).
decisions, it is not significantly related to the related to universities (presence of university 10. Aho Group report, Creating an Innovative Europe
type of science. Cost was significantly related faculty with special expertise and ease of (European Commission, Brussels, 2006); http://ec.
to the type of science with an increase in cost collaboration with universities) had the europa.eu/invest-in-research/action/ research06_en.htm.
decreasing the ratio of new to familiar science. strongest impact on the type of science con- 11. Taken from 38 of 61 articles on R&D moving off-shore in
the WSJ and New York Times 2002–2006.
Growth potential and supporting sales were ducted. Each is statistically significant in the 12. J. Thursby, M. Thursby, Here or There? A Survey on the
expected to be more important for familiar regression, and an improvement in either Factors in Multinational R&D Location (National
than new science, because R&D in those leads to a substantial increase in new relative Academies Press, Washington, DC, 2006).
13. The companies included are R&D-intensive firms large
cases is likely to be product localization. An to familiar science (16). enough feasibly to have multiple R&D facilities. Because
increase in market potential or a facility that The relative importance of factors is of confidentiality agreements that made this study possi-
supports sales is associated with a decreased summarized in the table, left (17). With regard ble, firm-specific data are not available.
ratio of new to familiar science. Results for the to government and university policy, these 14. For R&D facilities in developed economies, the same
factors are important, except cost is not important and IP
results suggest that, for developed protection is important. Weak IP protection is a deterrent
Relative Factor Importance economies to maintain an advan- to locating in emerging economies.
tage for cutting-edge corporate 15. J. Marburger, Science 308, 1087 (2005).
Factor* Rank 16. Details are in the supporting online material.
research, the keys are maintaining 17. The most important factor has rank 1. The rank is based
University collaboration 1 excellence and accessibility of re- on the absolute size of the elasticity showing the impact
Faculty expertise 2 search universities. The new science of the factor on the type of science. The factors ranked as
“not important” are not statistically significantly related
Cost 3 at sites identified by our respon- to the type of science.
dents is largely conducted in devel- 18. www7.nationalacademies.org/guirr/Meetings.html
Growth 3 oped economies, and this is signifi- 19. F. Valentin, R. Jensen, Effects on Academia-Industry
Supporting sales 5 cantly related to university factors. Collaboration of Extending University Property Rights
www.cbs.dk/forskning_viden/fakulteter_institutter_centre/
IP protection Not important In the survey, respondents were institutter/oekonomi/biotech_business/menu/
Not important
more likely to agree that both fac- publikationer.
Ease of ownership 20. Supported by the E. M. Kauffman Foundation and
ulty expertise and ease of collabora-
Quality R&D personnel Not important tion with universities are greatest in Government University Industry Research Roundtable of
the National Academies.
developed economies.
*Costs of R&D are exclusive of tax breaks and government Nonetheless, there is a caution- Supporting Online Material
assistance; growth refers to market growth potential in that country, ary message. Although respondents www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/full/314/5805/1547/DC1
Ease of ownership is the ease of negotiation for ownership of IP from claim it is easier to collaborate with
research relationships, and IP protection refers to its strength.
universities in developed countries, 10.1126/science.1134257
Q
uantum computers could potentially qubits, one of which is
具2|IPC|2典
perform difficult calculations at un- the persistent current 具1|IPC|1典
paralleled speeds. Instead of being qubit or flux qubit stud- hν
based on conventional digital bits, ied by Valenzuela et al. It
however, such computers would use elemen- consists of a supercon- 具0|IPC|0典
tary units called quantum bits, or qubits. ducting loop interrupted
Temperature
Owing to its quantum nature, a qubit can exist by three Josephson junc-
in states spanning any combination of two tions (black regions be-
basic wavefunctions |0〉 and |1〉, whereas tween the green strips in <IPC >
classical bits have values of either 0 or 1. the figure). The Joseph-
Consequently, an operation on one qubit son junctions are engi-
causes simultaneous operations on each of the neered such that the
combination’s components, which can be used loop’s energy can be de-
to speed up certain kinds of calculations. scribed by discrete energy
Likewise, a single operation on a multiqubit levels (2, 3)—analogous Cooling a qubit. At lower left, the qubit (green) is surrounded by a readout
system can affect a huge amount of informa- to an atomic system— SQUID (blue) able to detect changes in the average persistent current (blue
curved arrow). At equilibrium with surrounding electronics (the “bath”), the
tion, compared with just changing a single bit contained in a two-well
ground-state current (blue rings) is countered by a small current (in green)
from 0 to 1. This property is called quantum potential. The relative caused by an undesired thermal population of the qubit first excited state |1〉.
parallelism and lies at the heart of quantum position of levels can be Cooling of the qubit is achieved by driving the thermal population of |1〉 to |2〉
information technology. Coherence, the ability selected by applying an with photons (red). State |2〉 (shown as a persistent current in the same direc-
to protect the quantum operations from deteri- external magnetic flux tion as the ground state one) decays quickly toward state |0〉, which leads to
oration, is the primary challenge for scientists through the qubit loop. qubit temperatures much lower than the bath temperature.
in this field. The |0〉 and |1〉 states of
Quantum information is very delicate and the qubit are the lowest levels and are localized perature, is decreased considerably.
its manipulation with laboratory electronics in separated wells. They are characterized by There is one trick, though: The |0〉 to |1〉
often proves to be a tremendous challenge. opposite directions of the persistent current equilibration rate and the |2〉 to |1〉 decay rate
Scientists are therefore constantly working IPC, namely counterclockwise and clockwise, have to be considerably smaller than the |2〉 to
on new methods to reduce the effect of noise with average currents 〈0|IPC|0〉 and 〈1|IPC|1〉, |0〉 relaxation rate (indicated by the blue arrow
and to preserve the coherence of a quantum respectively. A surrounding SQUID (super- in the figure). In the case of the persistent cur-
bit. On page 1589 of this issue, Valenzuela et conducting quantum interference device) rent qubit, the applied flux bias is such that
al. report a method to lower the temperature of is able to identify the different flux states state |1〉 and states |0〉 and |2〉 are localized in
a solid-state superconducting qubit by up to corresponding to different qubit states and different wells (with different current direc-
two orders of magnitude relative to the tem- is therefore used as a qubit readout. In tions but flowing inside the same loop, as
perature of the surrounding electronics (1). the experiment of Valenzuela et al., the device illustrated in the figure). Thus, the intrawell
The technique they used was originally was noise-shielded in a superconductive relaxation rate dominates the dynamics and
developed for atomic systems. Atoms are cavity and cooled in a cryostat to minimize active cooling of the qubit is possible. Here,
among the earliest and best studied quantum thermal effects. |0〉, |1〉, and |2〉 refer to qubit states, whereas in
entities, and their application to the quantum Further cooling of the qubit is achieved by optical sideband cooling they refer to atom
information field is nowadays pursued with a clever manipulation of its quantum states, states coupled with the confining trap states.
enthusiasm. At the same time, solid-state analogous to the method called optical side- Valenzuela et al. achieve activation of state
qubits—often called artificial atoms—have band cooling used to slow down vibrational |2〉 by applying classical electromagnetic
great prospects of being fabricated in large degrees of freedom of atoms (4). Consider the fields via an on-chip antenna located near the
numbers on electronic chips by means of con- state |0〉 as the ground state and |1〉 as the first SQUID-qubit structure. With this configura-
ventional lithographic techniques. Solid state excited state. The method requires the use of tion they identify three regimes. At high fre-
artificial atoms therefore combine easy fabri- an ancillary state (hence the term “side- quencies, several subgigahertz photons are
cation with our deep knowledge of quantum band”)—for instance, the second excited state used to resonantly activate the |1〉 to |2〉 transi-
atomic physics. |2〉 of the superconducting loop. The unde- tion (the red arrows in the figure). At interme-
There are several types of superconducting sired thermal population of state |1〉 is driven diate frequencies, the electromagnetic field
into state |2〉, which is then followed by a fast shifts the qubit levels nonadiabatically and
decay to the ground state |0〉. By repeating the modulates the resonant activation. At low
The author is in the Department of Physics, Florida State
University and National High Magnetic Field Laboratory, cycle a number of times, the thermal popula- field frequencies below 10 MHz, levels |1〉
Tallahassee, FL 32309, USA. E-mail: ic@magnet.fsu.edu tion of state |1〉, and therefore the qubit’s tem- and |2〉 exchange adiabatically their position
and population. Optimized cooling occurs ably fast, it takes only about 1 μs and the effect active cooling technique demonstrated here
when the electromagnetic field’s amplitude is persists for ~300 μs at 30 mK. This equilibra- could be used to lower the temperature of any
such that states |1〉 and |2〉 are in resonance at tion time decreases drastically, however, when oscillator-like part of a chip. Moreover, the
full swing in their oscillatory motion. bath temperature is increased. As a figure of method is in principle applicable to 3He refrig-
Despite the large size of the structure— merit, the ratio of equilibration and cooling erators working at ~250 mK, to bring the
compared with the optical cooling of atoms— times ranges between one and several hun- essential parts of the chip to millikelvin
Valenzuela et al. attain a remarkably low qubit dreds, depending on bath temperature. Such a temperatures. And finally, techniques devel-
temperature of just 3 mK above absolute zero. figure of merit could give an indication of the oped in quantum optics could be blended with
The procedure is robust when repeated at vari- effectiveness of the process. If it would take the rich physics of solid-state systems, yield-
ous bath (i.e., the substrate and surrounding longer to cool the qubit than it takes to warm it ing great benefits in the long run.
electronics) temperatures ranging between 30 back up, the process would not be efficient.
and 400 mK. Depending on the frequency Although the microwave cooling method References
regime, the qubit effective temperature is reported by Valenzuela et al. is acting on the 1. S. O. Valenzuela et al., Science 314, 1589 (2006).
2. J. E. Mooij et al., Science 285, 1036 (1999).
found to range between 3 and 50 mK. The adi- qubit only and not on the noise sources of 3. T. P. Orlando et al., Phys. Rev. B 60, 15398 (1999).
abatic (low-frequency) regime is particularly its surroundings, the study is an important 4. D. Leibfried, R. Blatt, C. Monroe, D. Wineland, Rev. Mod.
attractive for cooling because it results in a advance for quantum computing. It provides a Phys. 75, 281 (2003).
constant 3 mK qubit temperature, independent means to improve qubit readout, initial state
of bath temperature. Qubit cooling is remark- preparation, and resetting of the qubit. The 10.1126/science.1136100
ASTRONOMY
One class of binary stars, in which white dwarfs
A Ghostly Star Revealed in accrete material from low-mass companions, has
long been predicted, but their dimness has made
Silhouette observations difficult. Evidence that they exist
now comes from the Sloan Digital Sky Survey.
Pierre F. L. Maxted
I
f our current understanding of the evolution detection of a dead CV from a direct mass cally fainter by a factor of 100,000 than stars
of binary stars is correct, the Galaxy should measurement of the low-mass companion in visible to the naked eye—much fainter than
be littered with the remains of stars that the CV SDSS 103533.03+055158.4 (SDSS most known CVs (2). This is only partly due to
have been reduced to about 5% of the Sun’s 1035 for short). Why has it taken more than their being, on average, farther away than
mass (0.05M 䉺 ) by extensive mass loss 20 years to find a dead CV, and why does it known CVs; they are also intrinsically less
onto their white dwarf companions. White have such a dull name? The answer lies luminous than known CVs (i.e., they have low
dwarfs are the small, dense collapsed cores inside your digital camera. mass-transfer rates). The sample of CVs
of deceased stars. A Digital cameras use charge-coupled devices selected from the SDSS is also much less
binary star system in (CCDs) to detect light. CCDs have revolution- affected by sampling bias than existing sam-
Enhanced online at
www.sciencemag.org/cgi/ which a white dwarf ized astronomy because they detect up to 90% ples, so it is a good place to search for a miss-
content/full/314/5805/1550 accretes material from of the light falling on them, versus a few per- ing population of dead CVs. The challenge is
a companion (see the cent at best for photographic film. Large-for- to find a technique that can reliably measure
figure) is called a cata- mat CCDs are now relatively inexpensive, so the mass of an almost invisible companion to
clysmic variable (CV). Every kilogram of mate- it has become possible to build instruments a very faint star. Littlefair et al. have used
rial that falls onto the white dwarf gains the that use arrays of CCDs to survey large areas CCDs, a large telescope, and a bit of luck to
energy equivalent of a few kilotons of TNT. of the sky. The Sloan Digital Sky Survey meet this challenge.
Much of this energy is released as ultraviolet or (SDSS) is the most ambitious sky survey A typical CV is smaller than the Sun, so
x-ray radiation. Many CVs have been identified undertaken to date. Researchers in the SDSS there is a good chance that the orientation of the
from this highly variable, short-wavelength consortium have used a 120-megapixel cam- binary is such that the companion eclipses the
light produced by rapid mass transfer onto the era to measure the brightness of more than white dwarf once every orbit as seen from
white dwarf. However, most CVs should have 200 million celestial objects over a quarter Earth. This will lead to an apparent dimming of
evolved through this violent phase to become a of the sky at five wavelengths. Interesting the CV every orbit during the few minutes that
“dead CV” with a low-mass companion that can objects are then followed up by means of the companion blocks the light from the white
support only weak mass transfer. Extensive spectrographs fed by optical fibers that can dwarf. SDSS 1035 is an eclipsing CV, so there
efforts to confirm this long-standing prediction observe hundreds of objects simultaneously. is a wealth of information to be gleaned from
have failed to identify any CVs that have clearly The first phase of the SDSS obtained spectra the changes in brightness during the eclipse.
survived the rapid mass transfer phase of their for almost 1 million objects, including more These show, for example, that the mass trans-
evolution. Now, on page1578 of this issue, than 150 new CVs. It is clearly not possible to ferred from the low-mass companion forms a
Littlefair et al. (1) report the unambiguous make up interesting names for all 200 million disc around the white dwarf with a bright spot
stars and galaxies, so each object is named on its outer edge due to the inflowing material.
The author is with the Astrophysics Group, Keele University, after its position on the sky. The geometry of the binary can be determined
Staffordshire ST5 5BG, UK. E-mail: pflm@astro.keele.ac.uk The CVs identified by the SDSS are typi- by measuring the times at which different
It remains to be seen whether this nomencla- like SDSS 1035? The SDSS continues to be a 4. www.galex.caltech.edu
ture will also be adopted for companions to gold mine for finding examples of rare types
dead CVs. Whatever they are called, it is the of CV and other fascinating objects in the uni- 10.1126/science.1135545
ASTRONOMY
Computer models of evolving stars show the
discrepancy between the amount of helium-3
Big Bang Points to Stellar Mix-Up predicted and the amount actually observed in
the universe.
Philipp Podsiadlowski and Stephen Justham
O
ne of the major successes of the Big produced in the Big Bang, is always destroyed
Bang model is the prediction of light- inside stars by conversion into 3He, but 3He
element production, but some trou- itself can be both destroyed and produced.
bling inconsistencies have lingered. One of Standard models of low-mass stars predict
these has been known as the “3He problem.” that outside the stellar core, the abundance of
Although the predicted abundance of the 3He is increased by one to two orders of mag-
helium isotope 3He is consistent with its abun- nitude over the primordial 3He abundance. In
dance measured in the interstellar medium the final stage of evolution, when the star
(ISM), stellar evolution theory has long pre- ejects its outermost layer to form a planetary
dicted that low-mass stars (i.e., stars not much nebula (see the figure), this newly produced
more massive than the Sun) are copious pro- 3He should be ejected into the ISM, causing a
ducers of this isotope, and so we should gradual increase in the abundance of this iso-
observe much more of it than we actually do. tope with time. Such 3He overabundances
On page 1580 of this issue, Eggleton et al. have been observed in some planetary nebu-
(1) report a resolution to this cosmological lae (2), yet there is no evidence for a system-
puzzle in which they convincingly identify atic gradual increase of the 3He abundance in
the mechanism by which low-mass stars the ISM. Apparently, most low-mass stars do
avoid the overproduction of 3He. not produce and eject large amounts of this
Puzzling elements. Hubble Space Telescope image
Deuterium, one of the other light elements isotope. It has long been suspected that this of the planetary nebula NGC 6751. Planetary nebu-
requires an additional mechanism that mixes lae are produced in the final stage of a low-mass
material from the envelope deeper into the star, where a star ejects its envelope and enriches
The authors are in the Department of Astrophysics,
University of Oxford, Oxford, OX1 3RH, UK. E-mail: star, where the temperatures are high enough the interstellar medium with elements produced in
podsi@astro.ox.ac.uk for 3He to be destroyed. Most previous sug- its previous evolution.
gestions have invoked mixing due to rota- great deal of effort in both code development The example of the 3He problem and its
tional effects. However, we know from seis- and computational brute force. resolution illustrates that, to understand the
mological measurements of the Sun that its These results highlight the importance of origin and evolution of the universe, we need
core is essentially in solid-body rotation. This improving the underlying physics in stellar to understand stars, and vice versa. In particu-
precludes rotational mixing as an important models, especially because the driving phys- lar, the predictions of Big Bang nucleosynthe-
process at some distant time in the future ics in this particular case would be easy to sis have pointed to a problem in stellar model-
when the Sun evolves into a giant star. ignore; this apparently minor consideration ing. On the other hand, there are many exam-
The elegant new insight provided by can be seen to have very important results. ples where an understanding of stars in the
Eggleton et al. is that the distribution of 3He Djehuty is still a work in progress: Im- local universe would lead to a better under-
itself plays a key role in driving this additional pressive though their work already is, to model standing of the evolution of the universe and
mixing by establishing a distribution of 3He in binary stars they will require an aspherical its constituents on the large scale. Besides the
the star that is susceptible to a Rayleigh-Taylor gravitational potential and will need to in- 3He problem, there is also a 7Li problem. The
instability. This is similar to the well-known crease the number of hydrodynamic mesh Big Bang prediction of the 7Li is at least a fac-
instability in everyday life where a dense fluid points they use in the simulation by four orders tor of 2 higher than is observed in metal-poor
on top of a lighter fluid leads to the mixing of of magnitude (3). Even the addition of rotation stars (5), and in this case extra mixing cannot
the two fluids. Even though the unstable gra- will cross another interesting threshold. provide a simple explanation. Undoubtedly,
dient produced by 3He is tiny, the authors Stars cannot yet be genuinely evolved the resolution of this puzzle will provide new
demonstrate, using three-dimensional, hydro- through their lifetimes with Djehuty, even insights into the physics of stars, the Big
dynamic stellar calculations, that this leads to with the computing resources at LLNL; Bang, or even both.
rapid mixing and the destruction of 3He. in fact, the calculations presented by
These calculations are some of the first Eggleton et al. contain less than a day’s References
1. P. P. Eggleton, D. S. P. Dearborn, J. C. Lattanzio, Science
results of an ambitious project led by Eggleton worth of stellar evolution. To put this in 314, 1580 (2006); published online 26 October 2006
and Dearborn at the Lawrence Livermore perspective, for Eggleton’s one-dimen- (10.1126/science.1133065).
National Laboratory (LLNL) to realistically sional stellar evolution code, “an evolution- 2. R. T. Rood, T. M. Bania, T. L. Wilson, Nature 355, 618
(1992).
model stars in three dimensions using a com- ary sequence requires about 60 min from 3. D. S. P. Dearborn, J. C. Lattanzio, P. P. Eggleton,
puter code named “Djehuty.” The important the main sequence to the helium flash”— Astrophys. J. 639, 405 (2006).
difference between Djehuty and all other stel- and that was in 1971 (4). It will be a very 4. P. P. Eggleton, Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 151, 351 (1971).
lar evolution codes is the inclusion of three- long time before three-dimensional stellar 5. D. N. Spergel et al., Astrophys. J., in press; (astro-
ph/0603449).
dimensional hydrodynamics, which can evolution calculations can be done as rap-
account self-consistently for mixing and non- idly and routinely as today’s one-dimen-
spherical effects. This is a step requiring a sional codes. 10.1126/science.1134924
CHEMISTRY
Walter Fontana
C
omputing devices, like the information same class as the information itself. How, In the past decade, DNA (or RNA) se-
they process, are embodied in a mate- then, can we realize computation in the world quences have been used to find solutions to
rial substrate constrained by the laws of of molecules and their chemical reactions? On combinatorial problems by self-assembly (4),
physics (1). The design of modern computing page 1585 of this issue, Seelig et al. (3) pro- to encode complete decision trees for simple
devices has nevertheless succeeded to a vide an answer to this question. games like tic-tac-toe (5), and to build pro-
remarkable extent in separating hardware from One way to formally express computation is grammable sensors of cellular states (6).
software and questions specific to physics from in terms of rules that rewrite words. Molecules, DNA has also been used to build nanostruc-
questions specific to computation. In such a like words, are combinatorial structures, and tures and nanomechanical devices (7, 8), as
setting, abstract formalisms of the kind envi- chemical reactions can provide the required well as two-dimensional grids that can func-
sioned by Turing (2) can justifiably ignore the rules, if we can program chemistry. To exert the tion as frames of reference for placing such
nature of materials and issues such as energy necessary control over chemistry, we must be devices at specific locations (9). For example,
dissipation and material stability. able to specify which components in a mixture Seeman and co-workers (10) have developed
However, this separation between hard- of molecules interact when, and where. This a rotary device that consists of two DNA
ware and software—and hence physics and control can be achieved by designing appropri- strands woven into two pairs of helices, with a
computation—breaks down when device fea- ate single-stranded DNA (or RNA) sequences flexible hinge region in between. This device
tures approach atomic scales or when the that bind to each other like Velcro’s hook and can act as a programmable, molecular-scale
devices that process information are of the loop fasteners, but in an addressable manner. robot arm. On page 1583 of this issue, Ding
Based on this idea, Seelig et al. exploit a simple and Seeman (11) report the deliberate, func-
principle—strand displacement—to implement tion-preserving placement of such a device in
The author is in the Department of Systems Biology, Harvard
University, Boston, MA 02115, USA. E-mail: walter@ not just logic gates, but also a toolkit of devices a two-dimensional array of DNA tiles.
hms.harvard.edu for building molecular circuits of a digital kind. There are two reasons for the versatility of
DNA as a structural, mechanical, Toehold for A may also provide a means for choreo-
and computational substrate. First, graphing the assembly and operation of
the Watson-Crick base-pairing rules A A' B future nanometer-scale devices.
provide a natural foundation for Unlike electronic circuit elements,
programming the interaction spec- DNA gates and their inputs are used up
ificity of DNA sequences. Second, Toehold for B as the computation unfolds through
base pairing provides the free chemical reactions; hardware and soft-
energy needed to deliberately change B' C' D ware are one and the same. Yet, what
structures and move computation appear to be limitations may turn out
forward. A DNA strand will let go B to be intriguing opportunities. As
A' A
of its binding partner if a third Toehold for C gates are transformed by the very com-
strand offers base pairs that are putations they control, can new gates
energetically more favorable. A assemble as by-products? Could one
DNA sequence thus serves both as devise a computational gate “metabo-
a specific instruction and as the B' B
lism” that maintains an ensemble of
C' D
fuel needed for its own execution. gates through a catalytic cycle?
To illustrate the case of Seelig C Milner has devised a calculus (13)
et al., consider two sequences A' that views every component of a dis-
and B that form a complex A′B by tributed computational system as an
virtue of complementary seg- interactive process, whose channels
ments. In the presence of a strand are consumed upon communication.
D
A that offers more favorable base C' C Seelig et al. may unknowingly have
pairs to A' than B, a displacement come close to implementing design
reaction A + A'B → AA' + B will Gate composition. The translator gate A’B (gray box in top row) exchanges aspects of that calculus in chemistry.
strand A for B. B then triggers the “B AND C” gate (B’C’D, gray box in sec-
occur (see the figure). The DNA ond row). Together, the two gates form an “A AND C” gate that emits a D- Theoretical computer scientists may
complex A′B therefore stands for strand in the presence of inputs A and C (light green boxes). Open and find inspiration in a chemical model of
the statement “if A then B', be- filled bars represent complementary sequence segments. If D were A (or an influential abstraction. In return,
cause it yields B when it encoun- give rise to A, as accomplished by a translator D’A), the end product could modifications of this calculus may
ters A. In this scheme, the gate “B reenter the cascade at the top, creating a feedback loop. become useful in the design and analy-
AND C” translates into a state- sis of DNA gate systems.
ment like “if (B and C) then D”, which is a one input strand to cause the release of more Over the past half-century, the idea has
DNA complex designed to release strand D as than one output strand copy. This can be taken hold that physical processes, particu-
a result of two sequential displacement reac- achieved by a feedback construct involving larly in biological systems, can be under-
tions that require the presence of B and C (see two gates that mutually trigger each other (“if stood as computation. A back-and-forth be-
the figure). A then B + if B then A”) as soon as input tween transparent experimental models of
In such a system, logic gates are molecular strand A appears in the mixture. Alternatively, molecular computation and the development
(DNA) complexes that execute their logic the input strand has been used as a catalyst for of formal tools for reasoning about concur-
through reactions. Gates constructed in this refolding a metastable DNA complex in a rent behavior might lead to a better apprecia-
way can be concatenated, because the output process that also releases an output strand tion of what it means for cells to “compute,”
string released by one gate can react with (12). In this way, the same input strand can “organize,” or “process information” and,
another gate in the mixture, much like in bio- help to refold several complexes, leading to perhaps, evolve.
logical signaling cascades. For example, an output amplification.
“A AND C” gate can be implemented by using It can be difficult to design sequences References
a “B AND C” gate in conjunction with an “if that make up large circuits. Complementary 1. R. Landauer, Phys. Today 44, 23 (1991).
2. A. Turing, Proc. London Math. Soc. 42, 230 (1936).
A then B” construct that exchanges A for B regions in a DNA sequence can cause a strand 3. G. Seelig, D. Soloveichik, D. Y. Zhang, E. Winfree, Science
(see the figure). This is analogous to address to fold back upon itself, potentially blocking 314, 1585 (2006).
forwarding in a Web browser. further computation. Accidental complemen- 4. L. M. Adleman, Science 266, 1021 (1994).
5. M. N. Stojanovic, D. Stefanovic, Nat. Biotechnol. 21,
A test tube typically contains many copies tarities across sequences can lead to inter-
1069 (2003).
of a given gate complex that undergo displace- ference between computations, in analogy to 6. Y. Benenson, B. Gil, U. Ben-Dor, R. Adar, E. Shapiro,
ment reactions in accordance with the binding cross-talk in biological signaling systems. Nature 429, 423 (2004).
preferences programmed into their DNA Seelig et al. use a computational optimization 7. P. W. K. Rothemund, Nature 440, 297 (2006).
8. B. Yurke, A. J. Turberfield, A. P. Mills Jr., F. C. Simmel, J. L.
sequences. Because these reactions yield a procedure to design sequences that minimize Neumann, Nature 406, 605 (2000).
noisy output-strand concentration, digitiza- the likelihood of such complications. They val- 9. E. Winfree, F. Liu, L. A. Wenzler, N. C. Seeman, Nature
tion of the output yield as “high” (true) or idate their architecture and design tools with a 394, 539 (1998).
10. H. Yan, X. Zhang, Z. Shen, N. C. Seeman, Nature 415, 62
“low” (false) is required to interpret a DNA dazzling circuit of 11 gates and six inputs. (2002).
gate as a logic operation. What might this prototype technology be 11. B. Ding, N. C. Seeman, Science 314, 1583 (2006).
Seelig et al. provide a toolkit of DNA- good for? The authors envision analytical 12. G. Seelig, B. Yurke, E. Winfree, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 128,
based reactions for such digital signal pro- applications in systems biology, such as the in 12211 (2006).
13. R. Milner, A Calculus of Communicating Systems
cessing. The tools include thresholds to situ detection, quantification, or amplification (Springer, Berlin/New York, 1980).
remove leaks and amplifiers to restore signal of microRNAs and transcription patterns. But
strength. For example, an amplifier permits this scalable molecular programming language 10.1126/science.1135101
F
rom the overall body plan of the neuron’s surface from the
an organism to the intricate vesicles carrying GluR1 are
three-dimensional fold of Axon the raw materials that allow
proteins, structure is a key deter- the spine to enlarge (see the
minant of function. Neurons, the Synapse figure). The recycling endo-
fundamental cells of the nervous some appears to be situated in
system, are no exception. The Neurotransmitter
? the right place, just below or
architecture of their dendritic and even within some spines, and
axonal arbors—the cellular exten- Exocytosis is of sufficient size to influ-
sions that receive and transmit Long-term ence spine volume. LTP-induc-
Spine
information—determines which potentiation ing stimuli mobilize these
Actin
neurons they can connect to, filaments endosomes from dendrites into
whereas the diameter of these spines, positioning the endo-
extensions determines the speed GluR1 some perfectly to fuse with the
Recycling Dendrite
and filtering of electrical signals endosome
spine surface. Blocking exocy-
that travel down them. Tiny femto- tosis from this compartment
liter (10−15 liter)–sized protrusions Balancing act. Long-term potentiation drives exocytosis of recycling endosomes, prevents spines from enlarg-
from neuronal dendrites, called providing dendritic spines with more membrane and receptors (GluR1). Actin poly- ing, strongly suggesting that
spines, receive a functional con- merization provides structural support. These processes are somehow balanced to the recycling endosome is a
nection from another neuron’s regulate the size of spines and the strength of synaptic connections. source of structural plasticity.
axon at a specialized area of con- Furthermore, the amount of
tact known as a synapse. A study by Park et al. Therefore, understanding how and why this surface area lost in the endosomal system
in a recent issue of Neuron (1) marks a large correlation between synapse strength and equals the amount gained by the spines, hint-
step forward in our understanding of how spine size exists will not only expand our ing at a direct transfer of material. Park et al.
spine size and synaptic strength are balanced. understanding of how synapses work, but may also directly visualize exocytosis with a pH-
A neuron can have up to 100,000 spines, have clinical relevance as well. sensitive fluorescence indicator that translates
each generally forming a single synapse. Park et al. elegantly combine serial section the pH change experienced during exocytosis
Spines function as chemical compartments electron microscopy and live cell fluorescence (the pH inside the recycling endosome is
for signaling molecules that become activated microscopy to afford us a view of the inner acidic, whereas in the extracellular space it is
by specific patterns of synaptic transmission workings of spines. The authors stimulated mildly alkaline) into a large change in fluores-
(2–4). This organization provides each syn- cultured mammalian neurons to generate a cence. By monitoring events simultaneously,
apse with a miniature caldron in which to stable increase in synaptic strength known as these experiments reveal that exocytosis takes
concoct a chemical brew to effect changes in long-term potentiation (LTP), and confirmed place directly in spines and that the amount of
connections between neurons (5). that the rapid increase in synaptic strength is exocytosis correlates extremely well with the
Interestingly, large spines contain strong accompanied by a matched increase in spine increase in spine volume.
synapses (robust transmission) and small volume. They then probed the molecular and Although this study elucidates how spine
spines have weak synapses (6, 7). A spine is at cellular mechanisms behind this correlation. size and synaptic strength are kept in check, it
least an order of magnitude larger than a Park et al. focused on the role of the recy- is not the whole story. Several groups have
synapse, and thus there is no physical require- cling endosome, an intracellular membrane- investigated the role of the actin cytoskeleton
ment for this correlation. The reason for this bound compartment that is part of the system in determining spine morphology (14, 15).
correlation between structure and function that transports membrane-bound proteins Indeed, LTP causes an increase in the amount
remains elusive, but an abundance of circum- onto and off the cell surface. Previous work by of filamentous actin in spines (16, 17), and
stantial evidence points to its importance. this group showed that the protein GluR1 is preventing the formation of filamentous actin
Stimuli that cause stable changes in synaptic delivered to the neuronal surface from the blocks structural (16) and functional (18, 19)
strength lead to corresponding stable changes recycling endosome through exocytosis, the changes during LTP. It is difficult to imagine
in spine volume (8, 9). Heritable forms of cell’s secretory process (12). GluR1 is a gluta- how lipids that are added to the spine mem-
mental retardation can present abnormalities mate receptor subunit that is inserted into brane could be sufficient to make a larger
in spine morphology as well as synaptic func- synapses during LTP and plays an important spine, rather than simply flow off into the
tion (10). Furthermore, Alzheimer’s disease role in mediating the increase in synaptic membrane of the dendrite. It is thus likely a
CREDIT: K. SUTLIFF/SCIENCE
may involve a loss of spines that is fundamen- strength (13). Blocking this delivery by combination of actin polymerization and
tally linked to a decrease in the number of neu- expressing mutant proteins that specifically the exocytosis of recycling endosomes that
rotransmitter receptors at the synapse (11). inhibit this exocytosis prevented the stable mediate spine enlargement during LTP.
increase in synaptic strength. Filamentous actin acts as a skeleton to support
The authors are at the Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory, Cold In the present work, Park et al. provide tan- a larger spine, whereas more lipids are the raw
Spring Harbor, NY 11724, USA. E-mail: malinow@cshl.org talizing evidence that the lipids delivered to material to increase the spine’s surface area.
EVOLUTION
Human cooperation may have evolved as a
T
he scale and complexity of human soci- Bowles proposes that competition between success in intergroup competition seems too
eties present an important evolutionary genetically differentiated groups led to the small and the costs too large to allow cooper-
puzzle. In every human society, people evolution of our prosocial psychology. Limited ation to evolve. After all, other primates live
cooperate with many unrelated individuals. migration between groups can lead to the in similar groups, but show little evidence of
Division of labor, trade, and large-scale con- buildup of genetic relatedness (which mea- group-level cooperation.
flict are common. The sick, hungry, and dis- sures how much the possession of a particular Bowles meets these objections with a
abled are cared for, and social life is regulated gene in one individual predicts the presence of combination of data and theory. First, he has
by commonly held moral systems that are the same gene in a second individual) among assembled data on the amount of genetic differ-
enforced, albeit imperfectly, by third-party group members. This means that group mem- entiation among human hunter-gatherer groups
sanctions. In contrast, in other primate species, bership can also be a cue that allows assorta- (or put another way, the level of relatedness
cooperation is limited to relatives and small tive interaction—genes that cause you to help within such groups). These data show that the
groups of reciprocators. There is little division members of your group can be favored level of relatedness within such groups is sub-
of labor or trade, and no large-scale conflict. because other group members are dispropor- stantially higher than previously supposed, a bit
No one cares for the sick, or feeds the hungry tionately likely to carry the same genes, below that of cousins. This means that
or disabled. The strong take from the weak even though you do not share a the cooperation will be favored
without fear of sanctions by third parties. On recent common ancestor. This as long as the benefits to indi-
page 1569 of this issue, Bowles (1) provides is an old idea. A version viduals are about 10 times
one explanation for the commonness of costly, appears in The Descent of the cost. Second, because
prosocial behavior in human societies. Man (2) and has reap- competition occurs be-
The behavior of other primates is easy to peared many times since tween groups and success-
understand. Natural selection only favors indi- then. It has never gained ful groups are able to colo-
vidually costly, prosocial behavior when the much traction, however, be- nize the territories of extinct
beneficiaries of the behavior are dispropor- cause there have been good groups, competition among
tionately likely to share the genes that are reasons to doubt its importance. relatives does not attenuate the
associated with the behavior. Selection can First, theoretical work raised doubts benefits derived from cooperation.
favor altruism toward close relatives because about levels of genetic relatedness being high Third, intergroup competition is common in
recent common descent provides a cue of enough to favor prosocial behavior toward small-scale societies, so the benefits derived
genetic similarity. The small size of primate group members (3). Second, limited migration from collective efforts to compete with other
families limits the size and complexity of the generates more competition within groups groups are plausibly substantial. Finally,
groups that can be formed through this than between groups. This means that helping Bowles notes that human foraging groups typi-
process. Thus, standard evolutionary theory others in your own group reduces your own cally have culturally transmitted norms and
provides a perfectly good explanation for the relative fitness and the fitness of your descen- practices, including food sharing and socially
behavior of other primates, but not humans. dants. In some plausible models of the evolu- imposed monogamy, which reduce fitness dif-
CREDIT: JOE SUTLIFF
tion of altruism when migration is limited, this ferences within groups. He makes the original
effect exactly balances increases in related- and interesting argument that such “leveling
The author is in the Department of Anthropology,
University of California, Los Angeles, CA 90095, USA. ness, eliminating selection for altruism toward mechanisms” act like redistributive taxes to
E-mail: rboyd@anthro.ucla.edu group members (4). Finally, the benefits of reduce the disadvantage of engaging in costly
prosocial behavior. The absence of these kinds have allowed humans to build larger coalitions with suggestions that people have innate,
of leveling mechanisms in primate groups may among nonkin than other primates (6). Others prosocial motivations, and that these feelings
explain why human societies differ from those have proposed that rapid cultural adaptation are elicited by cues of common group mem-
of other primates. generated cultural variation among groups, and bership. Other hypotheses seem to fit more
Make no mistake. This is not a “group intergroup competition subsequently favored easily with alternative views of human nature.
selection” hypothesis that competes with “kin the spread of culturally transmitted group-ben- These are old questions, but still important
selection” hypotheses [see the Review by eficial beliefs and practices (7). In both cases, ones. The kind of quantitative empirical work
Nowak (5) on page 1560 of this issue for a dis- the triggering factor (such as language or social that Bowles has done will help answer them.
cussion of conditions that favor the evolution learning) is supposed to have evolved for some
of cooperative behavior]. Both concepts are other reason; cooperation and prosocial prefer- References
1. S. Bowles, Science 314, 1569 (2006).
equivalent frameworks for describing the ences arose as a side effect. Of course, there is 2. C. Darwin, The Descent of Man (Project Gutenberg,
same evolutionary process. The group (also no reason why these hypotheses need be mutu- www.gutenberg.org/etext/2300), (1871).
known as multilevel) selection approach ally exclusive. Language or culture may have 3. A. R. Rogers, Am. Nat. 135, 398 (1990).
4. P. D. Taylor, Evol. Ecol. 6, 352 (1992).
describes all natural selection as going on in a led to the evolution of leveling mechanisms, 5. M. A. Nowak, Science, 314, 1560 (2006).
series of nested levels: among genes within an which then potentiated the spread of prosocial 6. E. A. Smith, in Genetic and Cultural Evolution of
individual, among individuals within a genes because these mechanisms reduced the Cooperation, P. Hammerstein, Ed. (MIT Press, Cambridge,
group, and among groups. The kin selection costs of cooperation. MA, 2003), pp. 401–427.
7. P. J. Richerson, R. Boyd. Not by Genes Alone. How Culture
approach accounts all fitness effects back to Research into evolutionary processes that Transformed Human Evolution (Univ. of Chicago Press,
the individual gene. Bowles adopts the multi- spawned our uniquely cooperative societies Chicago, IL, 2005).
level selection framework, but you can pose may help us understand the nature of our social
exactly the same argument in a kin selection preferences. Bowles’s hypothesis is consistent 10.1126/science.1136841
framework and if you do your sums properly,
you will get exactly the same answer. The real
questions are: Are amounts of genetic varia- ATMOSPHERE
tion observed among contemporary human
foraging groups representative of the Pleis-
tocene hominin populations in which distinc- An Ancient Carbon Mystery
tively human behavior probably evolved?
Were the benefits of success (survival) from Mark Pagani, Ken Caldeira, David Archer, James C. Zachos
intergroup competition in ancestral human
populations large enough to compensate for Sudden global warming 55 million years ago provides evidence for high climate sensitivity to
the individual costs of participating in such atmospheric CO2, but the source of the carbon remains enigmatic.
contests? And, do the kinds of leveling mech-
anisms observed among contemporary for-
A
bout 55 million years ago, Earth Furthermore, the ocean’s carbonate com-
agers exist and work in the same way in ances- experienced a period of global warm- pensation depth—the depth above which car-
tral populations? ing that lasted ~170,000 years (1). bonate accumulates on the sea floor— rose
The role of leveling mechanisms is espe- This climate event—the Paleocene-Eocene substantially at the start of the carbon isotope
cially tricky. In other primate species, access to Thermal Maximum (PETM)—may be the excursion (5). This change is consistent with
resources is usually regulated by social domi- best ancient analog for future increases in ocean acidification associated with a rapid
nance. Dominant males monopolize mating atmospheric CO2. But how well do we under- influx of CO2. Although the change in ocean
and dominant females get better access to food, stand this event? chemistry was not uniform throughout the
sleeping sites, and so on. There is little domi- Temperature records from the tropics to ocean (6, 7), the confluence of isotopic and
nance among human foragers, and access to the poles indicate that at the start of the sedimentological data supports the conclu-
resources is more egalitarian. Thus, it seems PETM, global temperatures increased by at sion that atmospheric CO2 was the primary
likely that the variance in reproductive success least 5°C in less than 10,000 years (2). The greenhouse gas driving the PETM. Yet, the
in human foraging groups is lower than in other rise in surface temperature was associated source of the CO2 remains a mystery.
primates. However, at least some of the leveling with changes in the global hydrological Biological responses to global warming dur-
mechanisms that we see in human groups seem cycle (3) and a large decrease in the 13C/12C ing the PETM include changes in the ecology of
to require a degree of prosociality not seen in ratio of marine (4) and terrestrial carbonates marine organisms, a mass extinction of benthic
other primates. Food sharing and dispute reso- (5) and of organic carbon (3). This carbon foraminifera (4, 8), and a global expansion of
lution, for example, could rest on exactly the isotopic excursion indicates that changes subtropical dinoflagellates at the earliest onset
same prosocial impulses that Bowles seeks to in the global carbon cycle were linked to of the event (9). Global warming also coincides
explain. It is certainly fair to invoke reproduc- global warming. with the appearance of modern orders of mam-
tive leveling to explain the stability of extended mals (including primates), a transient dwarfing
altruism among humans, but whether it is suffi- of mammalian species, and a migration of large
M. Pagani is in the Department of Geology and Geophysics,
cient to explain its origin is not yet clear. Yale University, New Haven, CT 06520, USA. E-mail:
mammals from Asia to North America (8).
The main competing explanations for the mark.pagani@yale.edu K. Caldeira is in the Department of According to one hypothesis, the PETM
distinctive level of human cooperation do not Global Ecology, Carnegie Institution, Stanford, CA 94305, was caused by the release of ~2000 PgC
suffer from this potential liability. Some USA. D. Archer is in the Department of Geophysical Sciences, from the destabilization of methane hydrates
University of Chicago, Chicago, IL 60637, USA. J. C. Zachos is
authors have argued that theory of mind, spo- in the Earth Sciences Department, University of California, (which would subsequently oxidize to form
ken language, and other cognitive innovations Santa Cruz, CA 95064, USA. CO2) (10). However, it is unlikely that meth-
(Thousands of ppm)
(Thousands of Pg)
3.5˚C
2.5˚C
5.5˚C
1.5˚C
(see the first figure) and the climate sen- –2 S. Bohaty, Geology 30, 1067 (2002).
␦ C of released carbon (‰, PDB)
–10
sitivity to CO2 doubling (including asso- –3 8. S. L. Wing et al., Eds., Causes and Consequences of
ciated system feedbacks). The source of –4 Globally Warm Climates in the Early Paleogene,
–20 –5 Geological Society of America special paper 369
carbon released (and climate sensitivity)
Terrestrial/marine organic carbon (2003).
can be estimated from the carbon iso- –6
9. M. Crouch, Palaeogeogr., Palaeoclimatol., Palaeoecol.
topic composition of the released carbon –30 –7 194, 387 (2003).
and the δ13C excursion it produced. For 10. G. R. Dickens, J. R. O’Neil, D. K. Rea, R. M. Owen,
example, assuming a carbon isotope –40 Paleoceanography 10, 965 (1995).
-5‰ -3‰
bon input of 1800 to 3500 PgC and a cli- –60 13. J. A. Higgins, D. P. Schrag, Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 245,
Methane
523 (2006).
mate sensitivity of 6.8 to 7.8°C per CO2
14. H. Svensen et al., Nature 429, 542 (2004).
doubling. Terrestrial/marine organic car- –70 15. M. Pagani, J. C. Zachos, K. H. Freeman, B. Tipple, S.
bon refers to organic carbon derived 1 3 10 30 100 Bohaty, Science 309, 600 (2005).
from the primary production of terres- Amount of carbon released
trial and/or marine plants. (Thousands of PgC) 10.1126/science.1136110
the Origin of Life RNA and the membrane lead to the emergence
of essential cellular behaviors.
Irene A. Chen
M
odern living organisms are organ- (9–11). To validate this experi- GE Healthcare and Science are active sequences. Genomic fit-
ized into cells. Fundamentally, a cell mental model, we showed that pleased to present the prize- ness (i.e., replicative ability)
consists of a genome, which carries the hammerhead ribozyme, winning essay by Irene A. Chen, would be translated into cellular
information, and a membrane, which separates which catalyzes a self-cleavage a regional winner for North fitness as the genome and mem-
the genome from the external environment. (or ligation) reaction, is active America who is the Grand Prize brane increased together, mov-
winner of the GE & Science
By segregating individual genomes from one when encapsulated in vesicles ing the evolutionary unit from
Prize for Young Life Scientists.
another, cellular organization is thought to be composed of fatty acid (myris- the replicating molecule to the
critical to the evolution of replicating systems toleic acid) and its cognate whole cell. As soon as replica-
(1, 2). Some of the oldest known rocks on glycerol monoester (12). tors became encapsulated, a
Earth (~3.5 billion years old) contain biochem- During the origin of life, primitive form of competition
ical signatures of life and also contain tantaliz- what behavior would demon- could emerge between cells
ing suggestions of cellular fossils (3). But how strate the emergence of the (see the figure). Remarkably,
did early self-replicating chemicals give rise to cell as a new level of biological this process does not require a
the “cell” as a unified entity? The combination organization? A defining be- chance increase in complexity
of a genome and membrane does not constitute havior of living systems is Dar- (e.g., addition of a new enzyme),
a unified cell unless interactions between the winian evolution, which may act but instead relies only on the
components result in mutual benefit. Was it a at any level, including that of physical properties of a semi-
lucky accident that genomes and membranes the gene and the cell. Using model protocells, permeable membrane encapsulating solute.
began to cooperate with each other (e.g., evo- we observed a competition between vesicles In a complementary experiment, we also
lution of an enzyme to synthesize membrane encapsulating RNA and empty vesicles (13). demonstrated how membrane fitness (i.e.,
lipids)? Or are there simple physicochemical Vesicles encapsulating high concentrations of growth) might contribute to cellular fitness.
mechanisms that promote interactions be- RNA experienced substantial osmotic stress, Fatty acid vesicles can grow spontaneously by
tween any genome and membrane, leading driving the uptake of fatty acid from un- incorporation of a feedstock, such as fatty
to the emergence of cellular behaviors? We stressed membranes. This resulted in the acid micelles (14). We found that membrane
explored such mechanisms experimentally, transfer of ~25% of the membrane from growth generated a transmembrane pH gradi-
using model protocells.
A protocell could be constructed by encap-
sulating a self-replicating genome inside a
chemically simple, self-replicating membrane
(1). This minimalist, forward-engineering Genome Membrane
approach is akin to early evolution, which must replication transfer Division
have also used a minimal set of components.
RNA is a particularly elegant genomic mate-
rial, because it can act as both information car-
rier and enzyme [e.g., as an RNA polymerase
(4)]. The discovery that the ribosome contains
a catalytic ribozyme core lends considerable The emergence of cellular behavior. Competition emerges as protocells containing replicating genomes
weight to the theory that an RNA world pre- steal membrane from protocells containing inactive molecules.
ceded the modern DNA-RNA-protein world
(5–7). For the membrane, fatty acids are sim- empty vesicles to vesicles containing RNA, ent, due to the faster flip-flop of protonated
ple amphiphilic molecules that self-assemble relieving the membrane tension caused by the fatty acid molecules incorporated into the
into bilayer vesicles. These vesicles have inter- osmotic gradient. The growth of the osmoti- outer leaflet of the membrane (15). Acidifi-
esting self-reproducing properties, including cally stressed vesicles and the reduction of the cation of the vesicle interior was measured by
the ability to undergo multiple cycles of unstressed vesicles were measured by the flu- an encapsulated pH-sensitive fluorescent dye
growth and division (8). Fatty acids have been orescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) (pyranine). Thus, a protocell might capture
synthesized under a variety of prebiotic condi- between fluorescent dyes incorporated into a substantial fraction (~12%) of the energy
tions and have been found on meteorites the membrane. released during membrane growth and store it
We suggest that a similar process took place in the form of a pH gradient. In modern biolog-
during early evolution—vesicles encapsulating ical systems, pH gradients are widely used for
The author is in the Division of Health Sciences and highly active genomic replicators would gener- energy storage and transduction. For a proto-
Technology at Harvard Medical School and the Massachusetts
Institute of Technology, Boston, MA 02115, USA. E-mail: ate osmotic pressure, causing them to “steal” cell, this energy might even be directly useful
ichen@post.harvard.edu membrane from other vesicles containing less for driving cellular processes, such as the
Kin Selection
previous round: a cooperation for a coopera-
tion, a defection for a defection. This simple
concept captured the fascination of all enthu-
signed to promote its own evolutionary success When J. B. S. Haldane remarked, “I will jump siasts of the repeated Prisoner’s Dilemma.
at the expense of its competitors. Yet we ob- into the river to save two brothers or eight Many empirical and theoretical studies were
serve cooperation on many levels of biolog- cousins,” he anticipated what became later known inspired by Axelrod’s groundbreaking work
ical organization. Genes cooperate in genomes. as Hamilton’s rule (1). This ingenious idea is that (12–14).
Chromosomes cooperate in eukaryotic cells. natural selection can favor cooperation if the But soon an Achilles heel of the world
Cells cooperate in multicellular organisms. There donor and the recipient of an altruistic act are champion was revealed: If there are erroneous
are many examples of cooperation among ani- genetic relatives. More precisely, Hamilton’s rule moves caused by “trembling hands” or “fuzzy
mals. Humans are the champions of cooperation: states that the coefficient of relatedness, r, must minds,” then the performance of tit-for-tat de-
From hunter-gatherer societies to nation-states, exceed the cost-to-benefit ratio of the altruistic act: clines (15, 16). Tit-for-tat cannot correct mis-
cooperation is the decisive organizing principle takes, because an accidental defection leads to a
of human society. No other life form on Earth is r > c/b (1) long sequence of retaliation. At first, tit-for-tat
engaged in the same complex games of cooper- was replaced by generous-tit-for-tat (17), a strat-
ation and defection. The question of how natural Relatedness is defined as the probability of egy that cooperates whenever you cooperate,
selection can lead to cooperative behavior has sharing a gene. The probability that two brothers but sometimes cooperates although you have
fascinated evolutionary biologists for several share the same gene by descent is 1/2; the same defected [with probability 1 − (c/b)]. Natural
decades. probability for cousins is 1/8. Hamilton’s theory selection can promote forgiveness.
A cooperator is someone who pays a cost, became widely known as “kin selection” or Subsequently, tit-for-tat was replaced by
c, for another individual to receive a benefit, “inclusive fitness” (2–7). When evaluating the win-stay, lose-shift, which is the even simpler
b. A defector has no cost and does not deal fitness of the behavior induced by a certain gene, idea of repeating your previous move when-
out benefits. Cost and benefit are measured in it is important to include the behavior’s effect on ever you are doing well, but changing other-
terms of fitness. Reproduction can be genetic kin who might carry the same gene. Therefore, wise (18). By various measures of success,
or cultural. In any mixed population, defectors the “extended phenotype” of cooperative behav- win-stay, lose-shift is more robust than either
have a higher average fitness than cooperators ior is the consequence of “selfish genes” (8, 9). tit-for-tat or generous-tit-for-tat (15, 18). Tit-
(Fig. 1). Therefore, selection acts to increase for-tat is an efficient catalyst of cooperation in a
the relative abundance of defectors. After some Direct Reciprocity society where nearly everybody is a defector,
time, cooperators vanish from the population. It is unsatisfactory to have a theory that can ex- but once cooperation is established, win-stay,
Remarkably, however, a population of only plain cooperation only among relatives. We also lose-shift is better able to maintain it.
cooperators has the highest average fitness,
whereas a population of only defectors has
the lowest. Thus, natural selection constantly
C C C C C D
reduces the average fitness of the popula-
C C
Mutation
C
Selection
D C Selection
D D D
tion. Fisher’s fundamental theorem, which
C C C
states that average fitness increases under
C C D D D D D
constant selection, does not apply here be-
cause selection is frequency-dependent: The
fitness of individuals depends on the fre- Declining average fitness
quency (= relative abundance) of cooperators in Fig. 1. Without any mechanism for the evolution of cooperation, natural selection favors defectors. In a
the population. We see that natural selection in mixed population, defectors, D, have a higher payoff (= fitness) than cooperators, C. Therefore, natural
selection continuously reduces the abundance, i, of cooperators until they are extinct. The average
fitness of the population also declines under natural selection. The total population size is given by N. If
Program for Evolutionary Dynamics, Department of Or-
ganismic and Evolutionary Biology, and Department of there are i cooperators and N − i defectors, then the fitness of cooperators and defectors, respectively,
Mathematics, Harvard University, Cambridge, MA 02138, is given by fC = [b(i − 1)/(N − 1)] − c and fD = bi/(N − 1). The average fitness of the population is given
USA. E-mail: martin_nowak@harvard.edu by ‾f = (b − c)i/N.
Table 1. Each mechanism can be described by a simple 2 × 2 payoff matrix, which specifies the
interaction between cooperators and defectors. From these matrices we can directly derive the nec-
essary conditions for evolution of cooperation. The parameters c and b denote, respectively, the cost
for the donor and the benefit for the recipient. For network reciprocity, we use the parameter H =
Group selection [(b − c)k − 2c]/[(k + 1)(k − 2)]. All conditions can be expressed as the benefit-to-cost ratio
exceeding a critical value. See (53) for further explanations of the underlying calculations.
Cooperation is…
Payoff matrix
C D ESS RD AD
Kin C (b c)(1 r ) br c b 1 b 1 b 1
r…genetic relatedness
selection D b rc 0 c r c r c r
Cooperators Defectors
Fig. 3. Five mechanisms for the evolution of Direct C (b c) /(1 w) c b 1 b 2 w b 3 2w w…probability of next round
reciprocity D b 0 c w c w c w
cooperation. Kin selection operates when the
donor and the recipient of an altruistic act are
Indirect C b c c(1 q) b 1 b 2 q b 3 2q q…social acquaintanceship
genetic relatives. Direct reciprocity requires re- reciprocity D b(1 q ) 0 c q c q c q
peated encounters between the same two individ-
uals. Indirect reciprocity is based on reputation; a Network C b c H c b b b
helpful individual is more likely to receive help. reciprocity k k k k…number of neighbors
D b H 0 c c c
Network reciprocity means that clusters of coop-
erators outcompete defectors. Group selection is b n b n b n n…group size
Group C (b c)(m n) (b c)m cn 1 1 1
the idea that competition is not only between selection c m c m c m m…number of groups
D bn 0
individuals but also between groups.
O Ebola virus (ZEBOV) has emerged repeat- home ranges separating it from the first group to
edly in Gabon and Congo. During each experience deaths (Fig. 1A). In particular, the
human outbreak, carcasses of western gorillas estimated time lag between deaths in successive
3500 (Materials and Methods)]. We lack the
density data necessary to make a similar esti-
mate for chimpanzees, but east-west differences
(Gorilla gorilla) and chimpan- in nest encounter rate (Fig. 1D) im-
zees (Pan troglodytes) have been ply a ZEBOV-induced decline of
found in neighboring forests (1). about 83% (table S1).
Opinions have differed as to the We hope this study dispels any
conservation implications. Were lingering doubts that ZEBOV has
these isolated mortality events of caused massive gorilla die-offs. The
limited impact (2)? Was ZEBOV Lossi outbreaks killed about as many
even the cause (3)? Or, were they gorillas as survive in the entire eastern
part of a massive die-off that gorilla species (Gorilla beringei). Yet
threatens the very survival of these Lossi represents only a small fraction
species (4)? Here, we report ob- of the western gorillas killed by
servations made at the Lossi ZEBOV in the past decade or indeed
Sanctuary in northwest Republic of the number at high risk in the next 5
of Congo, where ZEBOV was the years. Add commercial hunting to the
confirmed cause of ape die-offs mix, and we have a recipe for rapid
in 2002 and 2003 (5). Our results ecological extinction. Ape species that
strongly support the massive die- were abundant and widely distributed a
off scenario, with gorilla mortality decade ago are rapidly being reduced
rates of 90 to 95% indicated both to tiny remnant populations.
by observations on 238 gorillas in
References and Notes
known social groups and by nest Fig. 1. (A) Last day at which each group was at full size plotted against number of 1. E. M. Leroy et al., Science 303, 387
surveys covering almost 5000 home ranges separating that group from the first group to suffer deaths. (B) Day of (2004).
km2. ZEBOV killed about 5000 last full group size was not well predicted by latitude, as might be expected with 2. J. F. Oates, Primates 47, 102 (2006).
gorillas in our study area alone. spillover from a north-to-south reservoir epizootic. Assuming other reservoir 3. J. M. Sleeman, Oryx 38, 136 (2004).
4. P. D. Walsh et al., Nature 422, 611
Starting in 1995, we habitu- epizootic trajectories did not improve fit. (C) Gorilla nest distribution during 2004 (2003).
ated gorillas to our presence, and to 2005 surveys (after ZEBOV die-offs). Shading of each dot proportional to 5. P. Rouquet et al., Emerg. Infect. Dis. 11,
by 2002 we had identified 10 number of gorilla nests found on a 5-km survey segment. Blue line at 14.55°E 283 (2005).
social groups with 143 individu- longitude separates eastern from western sampling zone. Lossi Sanctuary in gray, 6. P. Formenty et al., J. Infect. Dis. 179,
als (fig. S1). In late 2001 and savannas in yellow, and roads in brown. (D) Chimpanzee nest distribution in 2004 S120 (1999).
7. D. Caillaud et al., Curr. Biol. 16, 489 (2006).
early 2002, human outbreaks of to 2005 surveys.
8. We thank P. Rouquet, X. Pourrut, and
ZEBOV had flared up along the E. Leroy for discussions; our field assistants
Gabon-Congo border (1). In June 2002, a gorilla groups (11.2 days) was very similar to the typical for their personal investment; the European Union (EU)
ECOFAC program, the Congolese Ministry of the Environment,
carcass was found 15 km west of the sanctuary. By length of the ZEBOV disease cycle of about 12
and T. Smith for facilitation; C. Aveling, J. Nadal, and
October, gorilla and chimpanzee carcasses began days (6). Assuming deaths were caused by spillover D. Vinyoles for advice, support, and encouragement; and
appearing inside the sanctuary. In the next 4 from a north-south reservoir epizootic did not fit the Energy Africa Oil Company, the EU Espèces-Phares program,
months, we found 32 carcasses. Twelve of the mortality pattern well (Fig. 1B). This implies that and the University of Barcelona (Socrates Project) for funding.
carcasses were assayed for ZEBOV, and 9 tested recent ape die-offs may not have been caused only Supporting Online Material
positive (5). From October 2002 to January 2003, by massive spillover from a reservoir host (1, 5). www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/full/314/5805/1564/DC1
91% (130/143) of the individually known gorillas Rather, group-to-group transmission may have also Materials and Methods
Fig. S1
in our study groups had disappeared. played a role in amplifying outbreaks, as transmis- Table S1
In June 2003, one fresh carcass appeared south sion within gorilla groups apparently has (7). References
of the sanctuary. In September, we identified seven The location of carcasses at the end of 2002 Movie S1
new social groups with home ranges straddling and suggested a sharp mortality frontier running north 27 July 2006; accepted 19 September 2006
to the east of the two rivers and monitored their to south at about longitude 14.55°E. The late-2003 10.1126/science.1133105
sleeping nests on a biweekly basis. Then in Oc- outbreak reemerged along this frontier, but nest
tober carcasses again appeared within the sanctu- surveys conducted in 2004 and 2005 suggest that 1Ecosystèmes Forestiers d’Afrique Centrale (ECOFAC), Box
2
ary. Ten carcasses were found in the following 3 it affected only a limited enclave centered on our Postale 15115 Libreville, Gabon. Department of Animal
months. From October 2003 to January 2004, study site. High gorilla densities still persist in 3 Biology, University of Barcelona, ES-08028 Barcelona, Spain.
Department of Evolutionary Biology, Uppsala University, SE-
Ebola spread sequentially from north to south, much of the region to the east of the 14.55°E 752 36 Uppsala, Sweden. Max Planck Institute for Evo-4
killing 91 of the 95 individuals (95.8%) in the frontier, but to the west a zone covering at least lutionary Anthropology, 04103 Leipzig, Germany.
newly monitored groups. One remarkable feature 2700 km2 was largely emptied of gorillas, with *To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail:
of this spread was that the onset of ZEBOV deaths nest encounter rates 96% lower than in the east magda_bermejo@yahoo.es
Tolerance and Production strains were isolated from plates, and plasmids
containing mutant genes were isolated and re-
transformed into a fresh background, then
Hal Alper,1,3 Joel Moxley,1 Elke Nevoigt,1,2 Gerald R. Fink,3 Gregory Stephanopoulos1* tested for their capacity to grow in the presence
of elevated glucose and ethanol levels. The best
mutant obtained from each of these two
Global transcription machinery engineering (gTME) is an approach for reprogramming gene
libraries was assayed in further detail and
transcription to elicit cellular phenotypes important for technological applications. Here we show
sequenced.
the application of gTME to Saccharomyces cerevisiae for improved glucose/ethanol tolerance, a
The sequence characteristics of these altered
key trait for many biofuels programs. Mutagenesis of the transcription factor Spt15p and selection
genes conferring the best properties (one Spt15p
led to dominant mutations that conferred increased tolerance and more efficient glucose
and one Taf25p) are shown in Fig. 1A. Each of
conversion to ethanol. The desired phenotype results from the combined effect of three separate
these mutated genes contained three mutations,
mutations in the SPT15 gene [serine substituted for phenylalanine (Phe177Ser) and, similarly,
with those of spt15 localized to the second re-
Tyr195His, and Lys218Arg]. Thus, gTME can provide a route to complex phenotypes that are not
peat element, which consists of a set of b sheets
readily accessible by traditional methods.
(5, 16). These specific triple mutations in the
taf25 and spt15 mutant genes are thus referred to
he production of desirable compounds TATA-binding protein (SPT15) and 14 other as the taf 25-300 and spt15-300 mutations.
A 1.2 B 1.2
1.0 1.0
Relative viable cell count
0.8 0.8
0.6 0.6
0.4 0.4
0.2 0.2
spt15-300 spt15-300
Control Control
0.0 0.0
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 0 5 10 15 20 25 30
Time (h) Time (h)
Fig. 2. Cellular viability curves to evaluate the tolerance of the mutant medium in the presence of (A) 12.5% and (B) 15% ethanol by volume.
under ethanol stress. Viability of the spt15-300 mutant strain compared The spt15-300 mutation confers a significantly enhanced viability at all
with the control is measured as a function of time (hours) and expressed as concentrations tested above 10% ethanol by volume (fig. S2). Error bars
the relative number of colony-forming units compared with colony count at represent the standard deviation between biological replicate experiments.
0 hours for stationary phase cells treated and incubated in standard Initial cell counts were ~3.5 × 106 cells per ml.
A B
ΔPHM6 (1.84)
18
Wild-type
log2 (OD600with spt15-300 / OD600without spt15-300) at 20 h
spt15-300 mutant
16
2.5 PHO5
PHM6
ΔPHO84 (2.18)
14 FMP16
ΔYHR140W (0.93)
Fold Improvement OD
2.0
12
ΔYGR043C (1.58)
ΔYAL061W (0.92)
ΔAQY1 (0.97)
ΔPHO5 (2.49)
ΔHSP26 (0.90)
ΔSRX1 (0.87)
ΔFMP16 (1.74)
ΔCOS12 (0.99)
1.5 10
ΔSGA1 (1.17)
ΔVTC3 (1.14)
8
ΔGCV1 (1.03)
1.0
6
0.5 4
2
0.0
0
-0.5 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140
Glucose (g/L)
Fig. 3. Gene-knockout and overexpression analysis to probe the the spt15-300 mutation on a plasmid to a strain containing the wild-type
transcriptome-level response elicited by the mutant spt15. (A) Loss-of- SPT15. All gene knockouts, except PHM6, resulted in slight to full loss of
phenotype analysis was performed using 12 of the most highly expressed phenotype. Control mutants for all of the gene knockout targets exhibited
genes in this mutant (log2 differential gene expression given in parentheses); similar growth yields. (B) Gene overexpression studies are provided for the top
two additional genes were chosen for further study (SOM text, part c). The three candidate genes from the microarray (PHO5, PHM6, and FMP16) and
tolerance (to 5% ethanol, 60 g/liter glucose) of 14 strains deleted in one of the assayed under 6% ethanol by volume as previously assayed (see also fig. S5).
14 genes, respectively, was tested by comparing the knockout strain containing The overexpression of these genes failed to impart a tolerance phenotype.
Table 2. Summary of model and notation. b and c: benefits and costs to deme members; pk: percent of deme k that are A’s; and p: percent of
metapopulation that are A’s.
Table 3. Parameter estimates. Benchmark values are in bold. Entries not in bold are alternative values (d = 0.4 not used).
Determinant Range explored Comment/method of estimation (13)
Interdemic genetic differentiation FST 0.007–0.170; 0.076 Genetic markers (recent foragers)
Reproductive leveling t 0.66, 0.33 Food sharing (recent foragers)
Gains − losses from contests per generation d 0.30, (0.40) Archaeological and ethnographic evidence
Per-generation probability of a decisive (2,0) contest k = d∕2 Based on estimates of mortality in ongoing conflict
Effect of percent altruists on deme survival lA 1
/2, 1 Arbitrary (see Fig. 1)
Effective deme size (one-third of census size) n 32, V Coalition of 5 median-sized bands
Cost to altruist c 0.0 to 0.08 Depends on behavior under consideration
Benefits to deme members (without a contest) b 0.05 As immediately above
hot enough to burn its nuclear fuel, to the long- Fig. 1. Evolution of a low-mass Pop I
lived MS state in which slow, steady nuclear star in a luminosity-temperature dia-
reactions keep the star in thermal equilibrium. gram. The model was computed in 1D,
After several gigayears (but depending strongly that is, spherical symmetry was as-
on mass), the nuclear fuel is exhausted at and sumed, using the code of (20, 21) with
near the center, the star becomes cooler, larger, updated equation of state, opacity, and
and more luminous, and it starts to climb the red nuclear reaction rates (22). Surface tem-
giant branch (RGB). Its outer layers become perature is in kelvins, luminosity in solar
turbulent and convective, and this surface con- units.
1
Institute of Geophysics and Planetary Physics, Lawrence
Livermore National Laboratory, 7000 East Avenue,
Livermore, CA 94551, USA. 2Physics and Applied Technol-
ogies Division, Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory,
7000 East Avenue, Livermore, CA 94551, USA. 3Centre for
Stellar and Planetary Astrophysics, Monash University,
Australia.
*To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail:
ppe@igpp.ucllnl.org
Fig. 2. (A) Profiles of the abundances of certain nuclei in a star that has (surface) abundance. (B) The same star later, when the SCZ reaches its
evolved to roughly the end of the MS (Fig. 1) (T ~ 5000 K; L ~ 2 L⊙). 1H is maximum inward extent (Fig. 1). The 3He peak has been homogenized to a
orange, 4He is red, 16O is blue, 12C is black, 14N is green, and 3He is yellow. factor of 8 larger than its initial value. The inert, H-depleted core is about
3
He shows a major peak where the abundance reaches ~18 times the initial 0.27 M⊙.
from center to photosphere, we economized on bulent and has the effect of diluting the inverse
mesh points by considering only the region be- molecular-weight gradient, but it cannot elimi- model makes this very likely. Although the m
low the SCZ. It is important for numerical pur- nate it. As the turbulent region entrains more of inversion that we find is somewhat above the
poses that the 1D and 3D codes use exactly the the normally stable region outside it, yet below main part of the H-burning shell, it is not far
same approximations for physical processes, for the normal convective envelope, it brings in fresh above, and we can expect some modest process-
3
example, equation of state, nuclear reaction He, which burns at the base of this mixing re- ing of 12C to 13C and 14N. According to (15), it
rates, and opacities. gion, thus sustaining the inverse molecular- appears to be necessary for some extra mixing to
The location of the starting model of the 3D weight gradient. Ultimately this turbulent region take place beyond the point on the RGB where the
calculation is shown in Fig. 1. If we had been will extend to unite with the normally convective SCZ has penetrated most deeply; that is exactly
clear before starting the 3D calculation that the envelope, so that the considerable reservoir of the point where our mechanism should start to
3
1/m bump was going to cause mixing, we would He there will also be depleted. If its speed of operate. In (15–18) it was suggested that rotation
have started further down, at the point where the ~500 m/s is maintained, the time for processed in the region between the SCZ and the hydrogen-
bump first presents itself, which is just above the material to reach the classically unstable SCZ burning shell might be responsible for the required
point labeled “deepest penetration of convec- is only about 1 month, whereas the time for the mixing. We do not dispute the possible importance
tion.” It has become clear that our unexpected H-burning shell to burn through the ~0.02 M⊙ of rotation; however, we emphasize that the mech-
mixing will begin around here, and in practice layer is more than 106 years. anism we have discovered is not ad hoc but simply
we expect that almost all of the 3He in the SCZ The above argument establishes that the arises naturally when the modeling is done in 3D.
will have been consumed by the time the model mixing in the SCZ is extended below the clas- This mixing occurs regardless of possible varia-
reaches the point where our 3D calculation sical convective limit and that it is very fast com- bles like rotation and magnetic fields. It seems
started. Because 3D modeling is very expensive pared with the nuclear time scales of either the possible to us that different rates of rotation might
of computer time, we have chosen not to redo the hydrogen-burning shell or the 3He-burning re- vary the efficiency of our process, and we intend
calculation for an earlier starting point. Figure 4 action. We estimate from the nuclear-burning to investigate models with rotation in the future.
is a cross-section of the starting model for the 3D rates that as the hydrogen shell burns outwards Correlations between abundance excesses
run and shows the m inversion as a ring well out- the 3He will be destroyed in 16 times as much and deficits of various elements and isotopes in
side the burning shell. mass as the hydrogen shell burns through. the low-mass evolved stars of globular clusters
After the early development of the initially We believe that the extra mixing that we have have been reported in (13). Although it is hard to
spherical shell on which 1/m has a constant value seen gives a satisfactory answer to the problem of distinguish star-to-star variations that may be
near its peak (Fig. 5), the surface has begun to matching the 3He abundance of Big Bang nu- due to evolution from those that may be due to
dimple after only ~800 s, and by 2118 s the dim- cleosynthesis. Although low-mass stars do in- primordial variation, we expect our mechanism
pling is very marked and the surface has begun to deed produce considerable amounts of 3He on the to lead to substantial evolutionary variations.
tear. Some points have moved ~2% radially, that MS, this will all be destroyed by the substantially Our investigation demonstrates particularly
is, ~106 m, indicating velocities of ~500 m/s. The deeper mixing that we now expect on the RGB. clearly the virtue of attempting to model in 3D,
mean velocity decreases slightly in the passage Our deeper mixing can also be relevant to where the motion evolved naturally and to a
from the second to the fourth panel. Other further problems. According to the classical mod- magnitude that was unexpected.
spherical shells, well away from the inversion on els of RGB stars, there is no further modification
either side, show no such dimpling, at least until to the composition in an RGB convective enve- References and Notes
1. I. Iben Jr., Astrophys. J. 147, 624 (1967).
the influence of the inversion has spread to them. lope after it has reached its maximum extent early 2. The initial value for 3He that we assumed is somewhat higher
A movie of which Fig. 5 is four frames is given as on the RGB. Yet observations persistently suggest than the mass-fraction (~5 × 10−5) implied by (19). This is
Movie S1 in the Supporting Online Material. that the ratios 13C/12C and 14N/12C both increase partly because we assume that primordial deuterium, of
The velocity we see is roughly consistent with appreciably as one goes up the RGB (13, 14). comparable abundance, is wholly burnt into 3He before the
computation starts. However, the important point is that the
the expectation that it should be v2 ~ g l Dm/m, Both these ratios can be expected to increase great bulk of the 3He in the RG phase is what was synthesized
where g is the local gravity and l is the local only if the material in the envelope is somehow from ordinary hydrogen during the MS phase, not what was
pressure scale height. The motion appears tur- being processed near the H-burning shell. Our there initially. The enrichment factor of 8 that we mention
Arm Inserted into a 2D DNA a fixed frame of reference. We report the develop-
ment of a cassette that contains both a rotary
device and the features that enable its insertion into
Crystalline Substrate an array at a specific site. A change in the device
control sequences or in the insertion sequences
Baoquan Ding and Nadrian C. Seeman* would result, respectively, in different controlling
elements or in a different site of insertion, all
The success of nanorobotics requires the precise placement and subsequent operation of specific within the context of the same cassette motif.
nanomechanical devices at particular locations. The structural programmability of DNA makes it a The PX-JX2 device is a robust, sequence-
particularly attractive system for nanorobotics. We have developed a cassette that enables the dependent DNA machine whose state is controlled
placement of a robust, sequence-dependent DNA robot arm within a two-dimensional (2D) by hybridization topology (5). It can assume
crystalline DNA array. The cassette contains the device, an attachment site, and a reporter of state. two structural states [termed PX (paranemic
We used atomic force microscopy to demonstrate that the rotary device is fully functional after crossover) and JX2 (paranemic crossover with
insertion. Thus, a nanomechanical device can operate within a fixed frame of reference. two juxtaposed sites)] that differ from each other
by a half-turn rotation of one end of the mole-
ranched DNA has proved to be a very ended cohesion (2). The development of stiff cule relative to the other end. Two different
Fig. 1. (A) A view perpendicular to the plane of the cassette in the PX state. The reporter hairpin is now behind the cassette, a point emphasized in (D). All
PX state is set by the green strands in the middle of the upper two domains. The drawings are in a virtual-bond representation produced by the program GIDEON
reporter hairpin is seen end-on protruding from the plane. The sticky ends on (13). (E) A 5% polyacrylamide gel run in TAEMg buffer (3). The two different
the bottom domain attach the cassette to the 2D array. (B) The same molecule is states are shown both for a cassette without a hairpin and for a cassette
shown obliquely so the reporter hairpin can be seen. (C) A view similar to (A), including a reporter hairpin. The single bands in each lane indicate that the
except that the cassette is in the JX2 state, which is set by the purple strands. The motifs are stable and monodisperse. BP, base pair.
Fig. 2. The arrays are shown schematically to demonstrate the two states black rectangle representing the domain of the tile that protrudes from
of the device in the cassette. The eight TX tiles that form the array are the rest of the array. Both the cassette and the marker tile are rotated
shown in differently colored outlined tiles. For clarity, the cohesive ends ~103° from the other components of the array (three nucleotides
are shown to be the same geometrical shape, although they all contain rotation). The PX arrangement is shown on the left, and the JX2 ar-
different sequences. The cassette and reporter helix are shown as solid rangement is on the right. The reporter hairpin points toward the marker
red components; the marker tile is labeled M and is shown with a solid tile in the PX state but points away from it in the JX2 state.
to reach half-activation (Fig. 3, left inset). The 2. D. Sprinzak, M. B. Elowitz, Nature 438, 443 (2005). 18. C. S. Lee, R. W. Davis, N. Davidson, J. Mol. Biol. 48,
3. R. R. Breaker, Curr. Opin. Biotechnol. 13, 31 1 (1970).
circuit with signal restoration has two ad-
(2002). 19. B. Yurke, A. P. Mills Jr., Genet. Program. Evolvable Mach.
ditional layers and takes 10 hours to achieve 4. M. N. Stojanovic, D. Stefanovic, Nat. Biotechnol. 21, 4, 111 (2003).
half-activation (Fig. 3, right inset). Despite 1069 (2003). 20. Materials and methods are available as supporting
the slow operation, in both cases a clear dif- 5. R. Penchovsky, R. R. Breaker, Nat. Biotechnol. 23, 1424 material on Science Online.
(2005). 21. D. E. Muller, in Application of Switching Theory in Space
ference between off and on states can be 6. M. Levy, A. D. Ellington, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. Technology, H. Aiken, W. F. Main, Eds. (Stanford Univ.
distinguished much earlier. Speeding up the re- 100, 6416 (2003). Press, Stanford, CA, 1963), pp. 289–297.
sponses of individual gates (e.g., by shorten- 7. M. N. Stojanovic, T. E. Mitchell, D. Stefanovic, J. Am.
22. G. Seelig, B. Yurke, E. Winfree, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 128,
ing recognition domains) or changing other Chem. Soc. 124, 3555 (2002).
12211 (2006).
8. Y. Benenson, T. Paz-Elizur, R. Adar, E. Keinan, E. Shapiro,
reaction conditions may improve overall circuit Nature 414, 430 (2001).
23. J. von Neumann, in Automata Studies, C. Shannon,
performance. J. McCarthy, Eds., vol. 34 of Annals of Mathematical Studies
9. Y. Benenson, B. Gil, U. Ben-Dor, R. Adar, E. Shapiro, Nature
(Princeton Univ. Press, Princeton, NJ, 1956), pp. 43–98.
Our success in creating large circuits can 429, 423 (2004).
24. R. Sarpeshkar, Neural Comput. 10, 1601 (1998).
be attributed to adherence to the tenets of dig- 10. B. Yurke, A. P. Mills Jr., S. L. Cheng, Biosystems 52, 165
(1999). 25. We thank N. Dabby for a very close reading of this paper
ital logic, toehold sequestering combined with 11. B. Yurke, A. J. Turberfield, A. P. Mills Jr., F. C. Simmel, and extensive revisions. B. Yurke built the custom
branch migration and strand displacement, re- J. L. Neumann, Nature 406, 605 (2000). fluorometer used for these experiments, and we are
duction of leak reactions by purification, and 12. A. J. Turberfield et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 90, 118102 further indebted to him for inspiration and advice.
(2003). G.S. was supported by the Swiss National Science
modularity of design. The logic gates devel- Foundation, the Center for Biological Circuit Design at
13. M. Hagiya, S. Yaegashi, K. Takahashi, in Nanotechnology:
oped here and the principles on which they are the California Institute of Technology, and the NSF grant
Science and Computation, J. Chen, N. Jonoska,
based can also be used to construct analog or G. Rozenberg, Eds. (Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Germany, CHE-0533065 (Chemical Bonding Center) to M. N.
hybrid circuits (24) and are likely to prove compat- 2006), pp. 293–308. Stojanovic. E.W. acknowledges NSF awards no. 0093846
and no. 0506468, and Human Frontier Science Program
ible with other approaches to building molecular 14. R. M. Dirks, N. A. Pierce, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A.
award no. RGY0074/2006-C.D.S. and D.Y.Z. were
automata in vitro and in vivo (5, 7–9, 13, 15, 16). 101, 15275 (2004).
15. F. J. Isaacs et al., Nat. Biotechnol. 22, 841 (2004). partially supported by a National Institute of Mental
Because evidence suggests that our logic gates 16. T. S. Bayer, C. D. Smolke, Nat. Biotechnol. 23, 337 Health Training Grant to the Computation and Neural
can use natural RNA as input and that they (2005). Systems option at the California Institute of Technology.
D.Y.Z. was partially supported by a California Institute of
behave correctly in the presence of mouse 17. In contrast to digital electronic circuits, analog electronic
circuits have not advanced rapidly because circuit design Technology Grubstake award.
total RNA, our hybridization-based circuits
remains more “art” than systematic engineering, making
might be adapted for in situ detection of com- the construction of large reliable circuits difficult. This is Supporting Online Material
plex expression patterns or even in vivo logic often attributed to the lack of the digital abstraction: In www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/full/314/5805/1585/DC1
processing. analog circuits even slight signal changes carry meaning Materials and Methods
(e.g., the value is 5.2 not 5.3) and thus restoration to Figs. S1 to S10
clean up noise or gate malfunction is not possible. The Tables S1 to S3
References and Notes lack of restoration also complicates circuit modularity,
1. F. J. Isaacs, D. J. Dwyer, J. J. Collins, Nat. Biotechnol. 24, because circuit behavior can be subtly changed when 14 July 2006; accepted 13 November 2006
545 (2006). subcircuits are combined (24). 10.1126/science.1132493
δ fq (mΦ0)
paper, we refer to the more conservative effec- observed to increase linearly with n for different 0 0
tive temperature obtained using the aggregate values of Tbath. Because the number of reso-
0.5
definition. nances in the qubit-step region is inversely Cooling 2 Equilibration
Figure 2, C and D, show the variation of proportional to n, the cooling at the individual Tbath =150 mK
Teff (mK)
Teff (mK)
100 100
Teff about A = A* for n = 5 MHz and n = 245 resonances depends only weakly on n when ν = 245 MHz
MHz, respectively, in the region marked with a using the convex definition Tefconvex
f (A*). 50 50
Tbath =150 mK
white rectangle in Fig. 2A (insets show the raw Figure 3C displays the measurement-fidelity 0 0 0
0 1 2 3 0 100 200
data). As seen in these figures, Teff typically F versus Tbath. Although the qubit is effectively t P (μs) t w (μs)
presents a minimum, where the cooling is most * << Tbath, over the range of Tbath in
cooled, Teff C1000
efficient and from which A* can be determined. Fig. 3, A and B, the readout SQUID is not
Equilibration
To determine whether the observation of a actively cooled, and its switching current dis-
sharp qubit step proves that the system makes tribution broadens with Tbath (fig. S2). At high 100
Cooling
transitions to the ground state, as opposed to temperatures, the fidelity F, defined in Eq. 2, 5 MHz
Time (μs)
65 MHz
125 MHz
10 185 MHz
A 50 B 245 MHz
80 300 mK
245 MHz
250 mK 1
215 MHz 60 30 mK
* (mK)
185 MHz
40 155 MHz 40
Teff
125 MHz
0.1
95 MHz 20 0 100 200 300 400
65 MHz
* (mK)
30 Tbath (mK)
35 MHz 0
5 MHz 0 200 400 600 800
ν (MHz) Fig. 4. Dynamics of cooling and equilibration.
Teff
C 1.0
(A) (Upper panel) State k0〉 population Psw as a
20 function of dfq and cooling pulse width tp (n =
245 MHz). (Lower panel) Teff versus tp extracted
Fidelity, F
Hominid from Sterkfontein, of a former talus slope (4, 5). The lower leg bones
are separated from the remainder of the skeleton
by part of flowstone layer 2C. This is due to par-
South Africa tial slumping of the middle section of the skeleton
before the formation of this flowstone (5). The
Joanne Walker,1 Robert A. Cliff,1* Alfred G. Latham2 flowstones are intact and show no signs of post-
depositional faulting that would indicate later
Sterkfontein cave, South Africa, has yielded an australopith skeleton, StW 573, whose completeness disturbance, and they are considered to lie in their
has excited great interest in paleoanthropology. StW 573, or “Little Foot,” was found 25 meters below original stratigraphic order.
the surface in the Silberberg Grotto. 238U-206Pb measurements on speleothems immediately above Previous work on the age of StW 573 has
and below the fossil remains, corrected for initial 234U disequilibrium, yield ages of 2.17 T 0.17 million been based on several types of evidence: fauna,
years ago (Ma) and 2:24þ0:09−0:07 Ma, respectively, indicating an age for StW 573 of close to 2.2 Ma. stratigraphic position relative to an indepen-
This age is in contrast to an age of ~3.3 Ma suggested by magnetochronology and ages of ~4 Ma based dently dated horizon, electron spin resonance
on 10Be and 26Al, but it is compatible with a faunal age range of 4 to 2 Ma. (ESR), paleomagnetism, and cosmogenic iso-
topes. StW 573 was initially dated at 3.5 to 3.0
terkfontein, 50 km northwest of of the pre-Cambrian Malmani dolomite (2) and million years ago (Ma) according to the strati-
Fig. 2. Isotopic data: (A) STA12, (B) STA09, (C) SKA3 from flowstone quadratic combination of errors from this correction with errors on the
layer 2C, (D) STA15 from flowstone 2B. The age values on the diagrams isochron slope. See tables S1 and S2 for detailed data from the individual
have been corrected for initial 234U excess; the errors are estimated by subsamples shown here.
Mouse Segmentation Clock time along the 2-hour segmentation clock cycle,
resulting in a 7-min time interval between two
consecutive time points (even though in reality
Mary-Lee Dequéant,1,2,3 Earl Glynn,3 Karin Gaudenz,3 Matthias Wahl,1,3 Jie Chen,4 the time points may not have been evenly
Arcady Mushegian,3 Olivier Pourquié1,2,3* spaced). This procedure allowed us to identify
statistically significant periodic patterns along
The segmental pattern of the spine is established early in development, when the vertebral with their corresponding periods. The period
precursors, the somites, are rhythmically produced from the presomitic mesoderm. Microarray with the most significant P value was selected for
studies of the mouse presomitic mesoderm transcriptome reveal that the oscillator associated with each profile. Six of the eight known mouse cyclic
this process, the segmentation clock, drives the periodic expression of a large network of cyclic genes—Hes1, Hes5, Hey1, Lfng, Axin2, and
genes involved in cell signaling. Mutually exclusive activation of the notch–fibroblast growth factor Nkd1—were identified with periods of 94, 102,
and Wnt pathways during each cycle suggests that coordinated regulation of these three pathways 112, 81, 102, and 112 min, respectively. These
underlies the clock oscillator. known cyclic genes were used as true positives to
refine filtering parameters that minimize the
he segmentation clock drives the expres- pattern of Hes1 expression detected on the number of candidate cyclic genes while max-
1
Fig. 1. Generation of a microarray time series of PSM samples along one period of the
Howard Hughes Medical Institute, Kansas City, MO 64110, segmentation clock oscillation. (Top left image) Lateral view of a 9.0-day-postcoitus (dpc) mouse
USA. 2Department of Anatomy and Cell Biology, University of
embryo labeled with Uncx4.1. Yellow box delimits the tail region, which contains the PSM
Kansas Medical Center, Kansas City, KS 66160, USA. 3Stowers
Institute for Medical Research, Kansas City, MO, 64110, USA. schematized to the right. Schemes represent dorsal views of the tail region. The right posterior half
4
Department of Mathematics and Statistics, University of PSM was dissected for the microarray analysis (red rectangle); the rest of the embryo including the
Missouri–Kansas City, Kansas City, MO 64110, USA. intact left PSM was saved for in situ hybridization with Lfng. On the basis of the position of the Lfng
*To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail: stripes in the left PSM (purple), each sample could be positioned retrospectively along one period
olp@stowers-institute.org of the segmentation clock cycle.
from Low-Input High-Diversity tion of degraded land LIHD biomass with coal
in existing coal-fired electric generation facili-
ties would provide a net gain of about 18.1 GJ
Grassland Biomass ha−1 as electricity (11). Converting LIHD bio-
mass into cellulosic ethanol and electricity is
David Tilman,1* Jason Hill,1,2 Clarence Lehman1 estimated to net 17.8 GJ ha−1 (12). Conver-
sion into gasoline and diesel synfuels and
Biofuels derived from low-input high-diversity (LIHD) mixtures of native grassland perennials can electricity via integrated gasification and com-
provide more usable energy, greater greenhouse gas reductions, and less agrichemical pollution per bined cycle technology with Fischer-Tropsch
hectare than can corn grain ethanol or soybean biodiesel. High-diversity grasslands had increasingly hydrocarbon synthesis (IGCC-FT) is estimated
higher bioenergy yields that were 238% greater than monoculture yields after a decade. LIHD to net 28.4 GJ ha−1 (10, 13). In contrast, net
biofuels are carbon negative because net ecosystem carbon dioxide sequestration (4.4 megagram energy gains from corn and soybeans from
hectare−1 year−1 of carbon dioxide in soil and roots) exceeds fossil carbon dioxide release during fertile agricultural soils are 18.8 GJ ha−1 for
biofuel production (0.32 megagram hectare−1 year−1). Moreover, LIHD biofuels can be produced on corn grain ethanol and 14.4 GJ ha−1 for
agriculturally degraded lands and thus need to neither displace food production nor cause loss of soybean biodiesel (14). Thus, LIHD biomass
biodiversity via habitat destruction. converted via IGCC-FT yields 51% more
usable energy per hectare from degraded in-
lobally escalating demands for both establishment, and otherwise grown with low fertile land than does corn grain ethanol from
Fig. 1. 6S RNA binding to Es70 inhibits polymerase binding to DNA. (A) Schematic of 6S
RNA secondary structure. The region from G42 to A57 (indicated by bar) has been
replaced with CAC in the M5 inactive mutant (8). Circled A43 is a G in M12. Arrows
indicate iron cleavage sites (see fig. S1). The sequence in 6S RNA complementary to the longest pRNA is boxed (see Fig. 2B). (B) Sequences of DNA
promoter and nontemplate oligonucleotide (12). (C) Labeled DNA duplex was incubated with buffer (lane 1); Es70 (lane 2); or Es70 preincubated with
6S RNA (lane 3); or the M5 control RNA (lane 4). Complexes were challenged with heparin before native gel electrophoresis. (D) Labeled nontemplate
oligo was examined for binding to Es70 as for (C) except without heparin challenge.
Fig. 3. Transcription
from 6S RNA occurs in
vivo and leads to re-
lease of 6S RNA from
Es70. (A) Reactions in-
cluded 6S RNA, Es70
and NTPs as indicated.
6S RNA* signifies that
[32P]6S RNA was used
with unlabeled NTPs;
pRNA* signifies that
[32P]a-CTP was included
with NTPs and unlabeled
6S RNA. Where indi-
cated, complexes were
challenged with heparin
before native gel elec-
trophoresis. (B) Stationary phase cell extract was incubated in the presence or Samples in (B) and (C) were treated with heparin before native gel elec-
absence of NTP. (C) Extracts from stationary phase cells (St) or cells after trophoresis. For (B) and (C), endogenous 6S RNA–containing complexes were
growth in LB medium with or without rifampicin (rif) for times indicated. detected by Northern analysis using a 6S RNA–specific probe.
1
Statistical Center for HIV/AIDS Research and Prevention, Fred
Hutchinson Cancer Research Center, Seattle, WA 98109, USA.
2
Center for Studies in Demography and Ecology, University
of Washington, Seattle, WA 98195, USA. 3Department of
Epidemiology, School of Public Health, University of North
Carolina at Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, NC 27599, USA.
4
International Health Program, University of Washington,
Seattle, WA 98195, USA. 5Clinical Research Division, Fred
Hutchinson Cancer Research Center, Seattle, WA 98109, USA. Fig. 1. The time course of HIV and malaria interaction in Kisumu, Kenya. HIV and malaria
*To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail: prevalences in Kisumu as compared with the baseline predictions in the absence of interaction are
laith@scharp.org (L.J.A.); jkublin@fhcrc.org (J.G.K.) shown. The measured prevalences were extracted from several studies (19).
South Africa, can intensify and possibly sta- We also tested the impact of a loss of sex- 2. R. W. Snow, C. A. Guerra, A. M. Noor, H. Y. Myint,
bilize malaria endemicity. ual activity during malaria episodes among S. I. Hay, Nature 434, 214 (2005).
3. World Health Organization, “Malaria and HIV interactions
Korenromp et al. have assessed the impact clinical malaria–infected patients (Fig. 4B). and their implications for public health policy” (report of
of HIV on malaria in sub-Saharan Africa and The impact on HIV is considerable, but it is a technical consultation, Geneva, Switzerland, 2004);
indicated that the overall impact is limited minimal on malaria. A 36% reduction in ac- (www.who.int/hiv/pub/prev_care/malariahiv.pdf).
because of differences in geographic distribu- tivity can remove all excess HIV prevalence. 4. N. French et al., AIDS 15, 899 (2001).
5. I. F. Hoffman et al., AIDS 13, 487 (1999).
tions and age patterns between the two dis- Avoidance of sex during, and for 8 weeks after, 6. M. R. Kamya et al., J. Infect. Dis. 193, 9 (2006).
eases, although the effect in the presence of malarial fever would considerably diminish 7. J. G. Kublin et al., Lancet 365, 233 (2005).
geographic overlap can be locally considera- HIV spread, but this degree of intervention is 8. J. Mermin et al., Lancet 367, 1256 (2006).
ble and is substantial in areas of high HIV probably impractical to implement despite key 9. P. Patnaik et al., J. Infect. Dis. 192, 984 (2005).
10. J. Whitworth et al., Lancet 356, 1051 (2000).
with unstable malaria as we predict (21). In successes in behavioral interventions such as in 11. L. Xiao, S. M. Owen, D. L. Rudolph, R. B. Lal, A. A. Lal,
some parts of Africa, the geographic overlap Uganda (24). A more-effective approach may be J. Infect. Dis. 177, 437 (1998).
may increase if HIV continues to spread from an emphasis on treatment of malaria and pro- 12. K. Froebel et al., Parasite Immunol. 26, 213 (2004).
urban centers to rural areas. Our analysis indi- tection against mosquitoes for HIV-infected 13. T. L. Pisell et al., AIDS 16, 1503 (2002).
14. T. C. Quinn et al., N. Engl. J. Med. 342, 921 (2000).
cates that the impact on malaria is at its maxi- persons. Thus, linking health services for HIV
15. C. D. Pilcher et al., J. Infect. Dis. 189, 1785 (2004).
mum when the number of advanced HIV cases and malaria would be advantageous. The combi- 16. M. J. Wawer et al., J. Infect. Dis. 191, 1403 (2005).
reaches its zenith shortly after the HIV epidem- nation of cotrimoxazole prophylaxis, antiret- 17. M. S. Cohen, C. D. Pilcher, J. Infect. Dis. 191, 1391
ic peaks (Fig. 1), a trajectory akin to that of roviral therapy, and insecticide-impregnated (2005).
tuberculosis (22). Nonetheless, the malaria bednets can reduce the incidence of malaria by 18. J. A. Whitworth, K. A. Hewitt, Lancet 365, 196
(2005).
peak lags behind that of HIV at most by 1 year, 95% in HIV-infected persons (8). 19. Materials and methods are available as supporting
in contrast to that of tuberculosis, which lags Our model shows that transient but repeated material on Science Online.
by 7 years (23). elevated HIV viral loads associated with recur- 20. G. Macdonald, Trop. Dis. Bull. 49, 813 (1952).
Our model can be expanded to accommo- rent co-infections, such as malaria, can amplify 21. E. L. Korenromp et al., Emerg. Infect. Dis. 11, 1410
(2005).
date general intervention measures such as HIV prevalence. This finding suggests one more 22. D. Maher, A. Harries, H. Getahun, Trop. Med. Int. Health
provision of condoms and insecticide-treated independent explanatory variable for the high 10, 734 (2005).
bednets, but here we have focused on mea- HIV incidence and rapid spread of HIV infection 23. P. Nunn et al., Nat. Rev. Immunol. 5, 819 (2005).
sures that target the interaction in co-infected in sub-Saharan Africa. Diseases that are not 24. W. L. Kirungi et al., Sex. Transm. Infect. 82 (suppl. 1), i36
(2006).
persons. Thus, we have specifically modeled sexually transmitted can thus affect the natural 25. L. J. Bruce-Chwatt, West Afr. Med. J. 12, 199 (1963).
the effect of malaria treatment of HIV-infected history of HIVand impact the process of infection 26. C. Rogier, A. B. Ly, A. Tall, B. Cisse, J. F. Trape, Am. J.
patients, assuming either that such treatment spread. Our work highlights the need for field Trop. Med. Hyg. 60, 410 (1999).
shortens the period of heightened HIV viral load studies that better characterize the parameters of 27. M. A. Quigley et al., Trop. Med. Int. Health 10, 894
(2005).
or that prophylaxis prevents malaria infection the interaction and explore the impact of inter-
28. C. Cohen et al., Clin. Infect. Dis. 41, 1631 (2005).
from being established in HIV-infected patients vention measures. However, such studies must 29. K. Grimwade et al., AIDS 18, 547 (2004).
in the first place (8). We varied the malaria in- account for the ethical considerations posed by 30. This publication resulted from research supported by
fectious period (gametocytaemia) from 0 to 60 the recent findings of Mermin et al. (8) that there the University of Washington Center for AIDS Research,
days in HIV-infected patients (Fig. 4A) and ob- are effective interventions to reduce the incidence which is an NIH-funded program (P30 AI 27757).
served a steady decline in excess HIV prev- of malaria in HIV-infected persons. Finally, we Supporting Online Material
alence as we cut back the duration of malaria emphasize the need for more-concerted health www.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/full/314/5805/1603/DC1
episode. However, the outcome showed that services for early and effective treatment and Materials and Methods
malaria treatment is more effective in reducing prevention of malaria in HIV-infected persons. Figs. S1 and S2
Tables S1 to S6
malaria prevalence than it is at reducing the
References and Notes References
prevalence of HIV. Shortening gametocytaemia 1. Joint United Nations Programme on HIV/AIDS (UNAIDS)/
to less than 27 days eliminates all HIV-induced World Health Organization, “AIDS epidemic update 11 July 2006; accepted 1 November 2006
malaria prevalence. 2005” (www.unaids.org/epi/2005/doc/report_pdf.asp). 10.1126/science.1132338
Salmonella Virulence Circuit with repressing (10 mM) to inducing (50 mM)
Mg2+ concentrations. Occupancy of the mgtA
and pmrD promoters by the PhoP protein, which
Dongwoo Shin,* Eun-Jin Lee, Henry Huang, Eduardo A. Groisman† was detected immediately after the shift, peaked
at 20 min and then decreased to reach new
The PhoP/PhoQ two-component system is a master regulator of Salmonella pathogenicity. Here we steady-state levels (Fig. 2A) (12).
report that induction of the PhoP/PhoQ system results in an initial surge of PhoP phosphorylation; The decrease in promoter occupancy and
the occupancy of target promoters by the PhoP protein; and the transcription of PhoP-activated gene transcription taking place 20 min after in-
genes, which then subsides to reach new steady-state levels. This surge in PhoP activity is due to duction of the PhoP/PhoQ system could reflect
PhoP positively activating its own transcription, because a strain constitutively expressing the PhoP degradation of the PhoP protein and/or a re-
protein attained steady-state levels of activation asymptotically, without the surge. The strain duction of its activity. We could rule out the first
constitutively expressing the PhoP protein was attenuated for virulence in mice, demonstrating that possibility because the PhoP protein levels
the surge conferred by PhoP’s positive feedback loop is necessary to jump-start Salmonella’s increased for at least 60 min (Fig. 2B), which
virulence program. is in agreement with the PhoP/PhoQ system
autogenously activating its own expression (Fig.
nlike obligate parasites, which live in b-galactosidase. To determine the changes in 1B) (13). We have previously demonstrated that
Volumetric Titrator
The Aquacounter Karl Fischer Volumetric Titrator (AQV-2100) has a wide detection range
from 100 ppm to 100%. The AQV-2100 offers the capability for automation and future
upgrades. A large color LCD screen provides all the information an analyst requires,
including real-time titration curves that help in developing new methods. The automatic
background compensation function allows accurate volumetric measurements of trace
moisture levels. The AQV-2100S model can be converted to a two-channel volumetric-
volumetric titrator or a two-channel volumetric-coulometric titrator.
JM Science For information 800-495-1678 www.jmscience.com
The Division of Intramural Research, National Institute on Deafness and A five year post-doctoral fellowship is currently avail-
Other Communication Disorders (NIDCD), located in Bethesda, MD, is
seeking a tenure-track scientist to establish an independent research program
able on a competitive basis at the NCI for a productive,
to study molecular and/or cellular mechanisms of hearing and balance. We highly-motivated, and energetic individual. The opening
welcome applications from candidates with a wide range of expertise. Prefer- is in a laboratory studying T cell tolerance to tumor anti-
ence will be given to candidates whose experimental approaches complement
those of our existing strong programs in the genetics, development and cell
gens. Opportunities exist to study cellular and molecular
biology of hearing. The successful candidate will join a dynamic group of aspects of T cell responses to tumor antigens as well as to
scientists in a growing intramural program that is at the forefront of research study inflammation and cancer using contemporary murine
on communication disorders.
models. A dynamic research environment and outstand-
The NIDCD offers an exceptional working environment including well- ing resources are available for enthusiastic individuals.
equipped research laboratories and numerous opportunities for collaboration. Requirements include an M.D., Ph.D., or equivalent
Candidates for this position must possess a Ph.D. and/or M.D., post-doctoral
degree and experience in Immunology research. Candi-
experience, and an outstanding publication record. Salary is commensurate
with education and experience. date must have excellent verbal, written, communication
and organizational skills and an ability to handle multiple
Please submit a curriculum vitae including bibliography, three reprints of projects simultaneously. More information on research
recent relevant publications, statement of research interests, an outline of
your proposed research, and the names and addresses of three references to: projects can be found at (http://ccr.cancer.gov/staff/staff.
Ms. Trudy Joiner, Office of the Scientific Director, NIDCD, 5 Research asp?profileid=7740). Interested individuals should send
Court, Room 2B28, Rockville, MD 20850 (joinert@nidcd.nih.gov). their CV and a letter of research interests to Dr. Arthur
Applications will be accepted until December 15, 2006.
Hurwitz: hurwitza@ncifcrf.gov.
The National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID), Division of Intramural Research (DIR) is recruiting a Senior Investigator (tenured) in the Labora-
tory of Immunoregulation (LIR), Immunopathogenesis Section. The NIAID is a major research component of the NIH, the Department of Health and Human Services
(DHHS).
The LIR is seeking a scientist to develop an independent research program on the study of the immunopathogenesis of HIV disease with a special interest in natural antiviral
and immunomodulatory factors, particularly chemokines and other molecules with HIV-suppressive activity. He or she will also attempt to develop novel therapeutic or
prophylactic strategies against HIV based on such natural factors. The ideal candidate will have an M.D. or Ph.D. degree with a specialization in microbiology, immunology
and/or infectious diseases and have considerable experience in HIV virology and immunology.
The scientist selected for this position will receive independent and committed resources to conduct laboratory research; these include space, technical and postdoctoral
fellow support, and an allocated annual budget to cover services, supplies and salaries. Additional resources may be provided for the development of clinical research
related to HIV infection. A senior investigator in the DIR, NIAID, is equivalent to a full tenured professor in a university or medical School. Salary will be based on the
individual’s qualifications and experience. Other incentives may be available.
Interested candidates may contact Marybeth Daucher via e-mail at mdaucher@niaid.nih.gov for additional information about the position.
Application Process: To apply for the position, candidates must submit a curriculum vitae, bibliography, and detailed statement of research interests (1-2 pages). In addition,
three letters of recommendation must be sent directly from the referees. All materials may be sent via e-mail to Felicia Braunstein at braunsteinf@niaid.nih.gov or by
U.S. mail to: Ms. Felicia Braunstein, DIR Committee Manager, LIR Search Committee, 10 Center Drive MSC 1349, Building 10, Rm 4A-30, Bethesda, Maryland
20892-1349. Complete applications MUST be received by January 5, 2007. Please note search #003 when sending materials. For additional information on this position
and instructions on submitting your application, please see our website at http://www.3.niaid.nih.gov /about/working/joblistings/open_positions.htm. All information
provided by applicants will remain confidential and will only be viewed by authorized officials of the NIAID.
The National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID), a major research
component of the NIH and the Department of Health and Human Services, is recruiting
for a Staff Scientist (Core Laboratory) in the Respiratory Viruses Section, Laboratory of
Infectious Diseases (LID). LID has an active vaccine development program to generate
live attenuated virus vaccines for flaviviruses including the four dengue, West Nile
encephalitis, St. Louis encephalitis, and Tick-borne encephalitis viruses and respiratory
viruses including the three parainfluenza viruses, two respiratory syncytial viruses, and
the human metapneumoviruses. Vaccines are also being developed against viruses of
interest to biodefense.
Responsibilities: 1) generate documents constituting the Investigational New Drug
Application (IND) for the vaccines being developed; 2) work closely with members of the
Sponsor of the IND, another unit of the Intramural program of NIAID, to generate final
IND documents for submission to the FDA; 3) coordinate efforts of LID staff involving
vaccine manufacture and preclinical testing of the vaccine candidates; and 4) organize the
response of NIAID to the comments of the FDA regarding IND submissions.
The successful individual will ideally possess an M.D. or Ph.D. degree and have experience
with IND preparation for infectious agents, but individuals without one of these degrees
will also be considered if they have extensive experience in the field. Experience with
generation of investigational vaccines, especially cDNA derived vaccines, and testing of
investigational vaccines in animals and human subjects is desired. Salary range is $73,178
- $159,657 and is commensurate with research experience and accomplishments.
Please send CV/Bibliography and three references to Dr. Alexander Schmidt, Bldg. 50,
Room 6511, 50 South Drive, MSC 8007, Bethesda, MD 20892-8007. Applications
must be received by January 5, 2007. For additional information on this position, contact !!" #
Dr. Alexander Schmidt at schmidta@niaid.nih.gov.
FACULTY POSITIONS IN
NEUROSCIENCE/NEUROLOGY
Faculty positions at all levels are available in the Departments of Neuroscience/Neurology at the Albert
Einstein College of Medicine for individuals applying techniques of molecular genetics in various model
organisms to study different areas of normal neural development and/or diseases of the nervous system. Faculty Positions
Possible areas of concentration include neuronal and glial specifications, stem and progenitor cell biology, Plant Biology and Microbiology
synaptogenesis, pattern formation, axonal guidance, cell-cycle regulation, developmental and pathological
cell death, neural repair mechanisms, genetics of neurodegenerative diseases and epigenetic control of
gene-environmental interactions during neurological development and in health and disease. Hunan University (Changsha, China) seeks
candidates for 2 Professor positions immedi-
This is part of an ambitious recruitment effort aimed at significantly increasing the complement of
interdisciplinary neuroscience investigators at the Rose F. Kennedy Center for Research in Mental ately, in the area of plant biology and micro-
Retardation and Developmental Disabilities. It is expected that the successful candidates will have biology, at the Bioenergy and Biomaterial
established or will develop independent research programs that will provide essential links in the long- Research Center (BBRC) jointly established
standing tradition of academic excellence in neuroscience research at Einstein. recently by the Hunan University and the
Albert Einstein College of Medicine (AECOM) is a major biomedical institution that maintains a strong Chinese Academy of Agricultural Sciences.
focus on basic science research and interdisciplinary collaborations. Of particular relevance to this search Successful candidates are expected to develop
are the extensive opportunities for interactions with faculty members in the Departments of Molecular independent research programs aimed at
Genetics, Developmental and Molecular Biology, Cell Biology, Anatomy and Structural Biology, Physiology understanding basic molecular mechanisms
and Biophysics, Pathology, and Psychiatry, as well as those to be housed in the Price Center for Genetic and
Translational Medicine, a new research building on campus that will open in early 2008. governing development or metabolisms in
plants or microbials. A start-up fund of up to
This position offers the opportunity to mentor graduate students with a strong interest in basic science $0.5 million is provided for each position.
and translational research. In addition to the approximately 400 PhD students that are actively
pursuing graduate studies, Einstein maintains one of the largest and most highly regarded MD/PhD
programs. Further, state-of-the-art genomics, epigenomics, proteomics, and neuroimaging facilities, as Qualified candidate should electronically
well as extensive dedicated mouse housing are available to all members of the Einstein community submit: (1) CV and reprints of publica-
http://www.aecom.yu.edu. tions, (2) research accomplishments
The Albert Einstein College of Medicine is located in a pleasant residential section of the Bronx with easy access and detailed future research plan, to
to Manhattan, Westchester County and other communities of the New York Metropolitan area. Applicants xuhongy@gmail.com, by February 1, 2007.
should submit their curriculum vita, a short description of future research plans, and have at least three letters In addition, 3 letters of reference should be
of reference forwarded to the Neuroscience/Neurology Search Committee care of: Ms. Maura Gabriele, sent directly to: BBRC Search Committee,
Kennedy Center 906, AECOM, 1410 Pelham Pkwy., Bronx, NY 10461. The deadline for receipt of application
is Feb 1, 2007. EOE. c/o Hongyun Yang, Department of MCDB,
UCLA, Los Angeles, CA90095-1606, Email:
ALBERT EINSTEIN xuhongy@gmail.com. BBRC will have addi-
tional positions opening in the next two years.
COLLEGE OF MEDICINE Interested candidates may also apply after the
Advancing science, building careers above deadline for future considerations.
�
gap between ecology and medical epidemiology
!
" # $ by fostering interdisciplinary research and train-
%
& ing. Opportunities exist for collaborations with
'
(
# )
faculty at the Yale School of Medicine, Yale
&
'
& &
�
School of Forestry and Environmental Studies,
'# and Departments of Ecology and Evolutionary
�
Biology, and Geology and Geophysics. The posi-
tion is partially funded by the Yale Institute for
� Biospheric Studies through the newly formed
Center for EcoEpidemiology.
Candidates should have a Ph.D. in ecology and
! " # $
% postdoctoral experience in infectious diseases
&
' '
of humans, animals or plants, and would be
( )
%
' expected to develop an extramurally funded
research program in disease ecology, and teach an
' &
%
interdisciplinary graduate course in the School of
' )
'
% Public Health/Department of Epidemiology and
' (
Public Health. For full consideration, applicants
�
%
should submit a statement of research interests,
' ( &
'
+ a complete curriculum vitae, and the names of
, +
- '
%
five references by February 1, 2007 to: Durland
Fish, Search Committee Chair, Yale School of
.,,'''%
%%,% /
-
Public Health, Yale University School of Medi-
.
cine, P.O. Box 208034, New Haven, CT 06520-
0 1
- - 2
- - # 8034; Email: durland.fish@yale.edu.
. 34546676$##- /(. 345466$6 4$- 8. %
9%
Yale University is an Affirmative Action/Equal
'
Opportunity Employer. Men and women of
/ " # $%
diverse racial/ethnic backgrounds and cultures
*
are encouraged to apply.
Faculty Position in the
IN 2007 Institute of Marine Affairs
(NSYSU), Taiwan
CNRS IS RECRUTING
MORE THAN 400 TENURED RESEARCHERS IN ALL SCIENTIFIC FIELDS* Institute of Marine Affairs (IMA) and
Department of Marine Environment and
*Mathematics; Physics; Nuclear and High-Energy Physics; Chemistry; Engineering (MEE) of National Sun Yat-
Environmental Sciences ; Life Sciences; Humanities and Social Sciences; sen University at Kaohsiung City, Taiwan,
Engineering Sciences; Earth Sciences and Astronomy; Communication are seeking candidates for five tenure-track
and Information Technology and Sciences.
positions at all levels. Four staff members for
IMA are sought with specialization in marine
This recruitment campaign is open to junior and senior researchers from all over policy and law, fishery resource management,
the world. One of the major objectives of this campaign is to encourage international marine environmental studies, or coastal
scientists to apply to CNRS. zone management. One staff member for
MEE must have a major in environmental
planning and management. IMA offers
CNRS researchers work in an enriching scientific environment:
master degree and is newly formed at 2005.
›› numerous large-scale facilities Candidates must hold a Ph.D. with proven
›› highly-skilled technical support track records of accomplishments. English
›› multiple networks throughout Europe and across disciplines speaking candidates without Mandarin
›› access to university research and teaching knowledge are welcome to apply.
›› lab-to-lab and international mobility
Applications should include, a curriculum
At CNRS, the long-term vision of excellence in basic research provides a solid vitae, selected reprints and publication lists,
foundation for cutting-edge technological research. Successful candidates to the statements of teaching and research interest,
CNRS benefit from the dynamics, stability and stimulation of belonging to a major two recommendation letters (at least), before
January 15, 2007 (or until the position is
research organization.
filled). All correspondence shall be sent to:
Prof. Chiu L. Chou, Director of Institute
Application deadline: January 15th 2007 of Marine Affairs, National Sun Yat-sen
University, 70 Lien-Hai Road, Kaohsiung
www.cnrs.fr City, Taiwan, or Email to: syvia@staff.
nsysu.edu.tw. Applicants for MEE position
please send to Prof. Chonlin Lee, or Email
to: linnohc@mail.nsysu.edu.tw.
Center for Metabolism and Obesity Research Center for Sensory Biology
The mission of the Center for Metabolism and Obesity The Center for Sensory Biology seeks to understand the
Research (CMOR) is to study and support integrative fundamental processes underlying the primary senses –
research in the field of metabolism and systems biology. vision, touch (including pain), chemosensation (taste and
Our objective is to advance our understanding of the smell) and hearing. Research within the Center is based on
biological mechanisms that regulate metabolism and how the recognition that sensory systems use conserved biological
they are dysregulated in attendant disorders, such as processes for signaling, adaptation and modulation, and for
obesity and diabetes. CMOR seeks to recruit faculty protection from injury, environmental insult, and degenera-
interested in applying in vitro and in vivo models to further tion. The Center is recruiting new faculty interested in
our understanding of the regulation of energy sensing, working on diverse sensory systems and applying new tools
nutrient sensing, and endocrine responses and how these and experimental approaches in a collaborative, interactive
processes are altered by disease. Our goal is to create a and interdisciplinary environment.
multidisciplinary and collegial center.
J884YYY
+N,+2[
/.974J
Q8J G4+68OG287 +6G -NQ7GN[ +77Q-K+8G. ;K8J 8JG '+.7;Q68J G28G68JG
6G7G+6-JK28G27K:G N+,Q6+8Q6[ Q0 8JG G; ;Q6M #8+8G G4+68OG28 Q0 *G+N8J
#-KG28K787 K2 8JG #-JQQN Q0 and research duties only, with no patient care
9,NK- *G+N8J +2. 8JG '+.7;Q68J G28G6 789.[ 49,NK- JG+N8J K779G7 06QO .691 6G7K78+2-G 8Q GOG61K21 responsibilities. The successful candidate will
K20G-8KQ27 +2. G2:K6Q2OG28+N 8QZK-+287
$JG[ +N7Q K2:G78K1+8G ,+7K- ,KQNQ1K-+N 46Q-G77G7 8J+8 -Q286K,98G 8Q have demonstrated potential for establishing a
J9O+2 JG+N8J +2. .K7G+7G
$JG N,+2[ +6G+ +N7Q J+7 7G:G6+N Q8JG6 K278K898KQ27 ;K8J 786Q21 6G7G+6-J vigorous independent research program in the
46Q16+O7 6GN+8G. 8Q -+2-G6 1G2QOK-7 K2-N9.K21 "G277GN+G6 QN[8G-J2K- +278K898GN,+2[ /G.K-+N QNNG1G cellular/molecular basis of diseases of the lower
8JG J+6O+-G98K-+N "G7G+6-J +278K898G+2. 8JG 6.;+[ "G7G+6-J +278K898G +2. 8J978JG6G K7 Q9878+2.K21 urinary tract. Preference will be given to candi-
4Q8G28K+N 0Q6 6G7G+6-J -QNN+,Q6+8KQ27
dates with experience in basic urological research
7 8JG -+4K8+N -K8[ Q0 G; ;Q6M #8+8GN,+2[ 46Q:K.G7 Q9878+2.K21 -9N896+N +2. 6G-6G+8KQ2+N Q44Q6892K8KG7
+8 and a track record for obtaining research grants.
O+K28+K27 + :K,6+28 7O+NN-K8[ NK0G 78[NG ;JKNG ,GK21 ;K8JK2 G+7[ -QOO98G
JQ9678Q O+LQ6 OG86Q4QNK8+2
Please submit curriculum vitae, a letter of
-G28G67 K2-N9.K21 G; ;Q6M K8[Q78Q2 +2. /Q286G+N
interest, and References to: Alan J. Wein, MD
44NK-+287 O978 79,OK8:K+ GO+KN+ -966K-9N9O :K8+G+2. + 79--K2-8 78+8GOG28 Q0 -966G28 +2. 09896G 6G7G+6-J Chief, Division of Urology, c/o Peter Ather-
K28G6G787
$JG7G 4Q7K8KQ27 6G59K6G + J
/
Q6 G59K:+NG28 .G16GG K2 KQNQ1K-+N KQOG.K-+N Q6 .K0G
#-KG2-G7 06QO + -QNNG1G Q6 92K:G67K8[ +--6G.K8G. ,[ + %
#
G4+68OG28 Q0 .9-+8KQ2 Q6 K28G62+8KQ2+NN[ ton, Univ. of Pennsylvania Sch. of Med., 3400
6G-Q12K\G. +--6G.K8K21 Q61+2K\+8KQ2
44NK-+287 O978 +..6G77 K2 8JGK6 +44NK-+8KQ27 8JGK6 +,KNK8KG7 8Q ;Q6M ;K8J Spruce St., 4029 Maloney, Philadelphia, PA
+2. K27869-8 + -9N896+NN[ .K:G67G 4Q49N+8KQ2
19104-4283; athertop@uphs.upenn.edu.
+28G6G78G. K2.K:K.9+N7 7JQ9N. 79,OK8 O+8G6K+N7 8Q .[2.+ /-M3YK8\72K:/67K8[ +8 N,+2[2/ K7-3:/6[ The University of Pennsylvania is an Equal
6K:/Z/-98K:/ #9K8/ "/277/N+/60;
O+KN 1/23OK-7+N,+2[
/.9 Opportunity, Affirmative Action Employer.
$JG %PKX/67K8[ +8 N,+2[ K7 +2 +" /ORNQ[/6
Women and minority candidates are strongly
encouraged to apply.
Experimental Neuropathologist
The Department of Pathology
University of California, San Francisco
The Department of Pathology at the University of California, San
Francisco, is seeking outstanding candidates for a tenure track
position in experimental neuropathology, specifically in the areas
of degenerative diseases of the nervous system. The successful
applicant will be provided a start-up package and space to establish
a strong independent research program and will be a member of
the Biomedical Sciences Program. The applicant is expected to
participate in teaching residents, fellows, and graduate and medi-
cal students. Applicants must have the MD or MD/PhD degrees,
be eligible for California medical licensure and be Board certified
or eligible in Anatomic Pathology and Neuropathology. Salary and
appointment rank will be commensurate with the applicant’s experi-
ence and training.
Applicants should send curriculum vitae, a brief statement of
research plans and contact information for three letters of recom-
mendation by January 31, 2007 to:
Chair of Search Committee #M2860
C/O Shirley McFaden, Personnel Manager
UCSF Department of Pathology at Mount Zion
1600 Divisadero Street, Campus Box 0506
San Francisco, CA 94143-0506
UCSF is an Affirmative Action/Equal Opportunity Employer.
The University undertakes affirmative action to assure equal
employment opportunity for underutilized minorities and women,
for persons with disabilities, and for Vietnam-era veterans
and special disable veterans. UCSF seeks candidates whose
experience, teaching, research, or community service has pre-
pared them to contribute to our commitment to diversity
and excellence.
The Stanford University School of Medicine, the Stanford Institute for Stem Cell Biology and Regenerative Medicine (ISCBRM),
and the Stanford Cancer Center are holding open searches for two tenure-line faculty in the areas of cancer gene discovery,
cancer stem cell biology, and cancer genomics; oncology with research involving the use of targeted immune therapies, adult
tissue stem cell biology, and embryonic stem cell biology; and research leading to the production and characterization of nuclear
transfer to produce human pluripotent stem cell lines. Positions are open at the assistant, associate or full professor level.
Successful candidates will have an outstanding record of research and a strong interest in translating these discoveries into pre-
clinical research and potential therapies. All appointments to the Institute for Stem Cell Biology and Regenerative Medicine or in
the Stanford Cancer Center will be in departments at Stanford University. Interested candidates need to indicate preferences for
potential department affiliation. Appointees, however, will work on location in the Institutes for Medicine laboratories or Cancer
Center, and will participate in their research and teaching activities. While excellence in teaching is an important criterion, the
appointments will be based primarily on research accomplishments and the promise of future research and translational medicine
advances. Salary will be commensurate with the level of employment, relevant experience, and accomplishments.
Please address and mail letters of interest, along with full curriculum vitae and the names and addresses of three references
to:
Beverly S. Mitchell, MD
Deputy Director, Stanford University Cancer Center
Stanford University
800 Welch Road, MC 5796
Palo Alto, CA 94304
Stanford University is an Equal Opportunity Employer and is committed to increasing the diversity of its faculty.
It welcomes applications from, and nominations of, women and members of minority groups, as well as others who
would bring additional dimensions to the university’s research, teaching, and clinical missions.
BioDuro is a U.S. based global life science outsourcing company with locations in La Jolla,
CA and Beijing, China. Bioduro has built an integrated suite of discovery capabilities
Faculty Positions Available including synthetic, medicinal, and computational chemistry, biological screening, and
ADME profiling. With over 175 employees and growing rapidly, many career opportunities
LSU Health Sciences Center exist. BioDuro is seeking highly motivated and skilled scientist to join its growing team of
professionals in the newly opened state of the art research facility in Beijing, China
in New Orleans providing integrated and value added scientific solutions to Pharmaceutical and
Biotechnology companies.
The basic science departments at Louisiana State University Health Protein Expression & QA Auditor (Beijing)
Sciences Center in New Orleans (LSUHSC-NO) have a long tradi- Purification Scientist & Qualified candidates will have a BS/BA and
tion of research and educational excellence. In spite of the disruptions Group Leader (Beijing) experience in industry GLP environment. Verifies
compliance to applicable Standard Operating
produced by Hurricane Katrina, these departments have resumed Qualified candidates will have Masters or Ph.D.s Procedures (SOPs) and regulations by performing
building and expanding their research programs. As a result, a number in Biochemistry, Protein Chemistry, internal inspections and supplemental audits.
BioProcessing, with minimum two years Assists team with interpretation of regulatory
of fulltime, tenure-track faculty positions are currently available for industrial research experience to be part of our requirements (e.g., GLP), SOP requirements, and
talented, dedicated academic scientists of all ranks. The Departments growing protein expression group. Candidate other guidance documents. Will participate in
will lead or assist in the development, client audits.
of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology, Cell Biology and Anatomy, optimization and scale-up of production &
Genetics, Microbiology, Immunology and Parasitology, Pharmacology purification processes for recombinant proteins. Toxicology Study Director
Need demonstrated expertise in several areas:
and Experimental Therapeutics, and Physiology have strengths in a broad insect, bacterial or mammalian protein (Beijing)
expression systems, cell culture with an Qualified candidates will have an advanced degree
range of research areas. emphasis in 10-20L bioreactors or other (PhD preferred) in Toxicology or a related scientific
advanced cell culture technologies and discipline and 3-5 years industry experience
LSUHSC-NO has extensive Core Laboratories including Genomics, Pro- facilities, & protein purification ranging from mg- conducting small and/or large animal research.
teomics, Imaging, Flow Cytometry, and available Animal Care facilities. multi gram, using standard biochemical Knowledge of both US and international GLP
techniques and advanced equipment. regulations. Will be responsible for designing
Successful candidates will also have opportunities for interaction with studies, monitoring studies, analyzing data, and
the Centers of Excellence in Alcohol Research, Cancer, Cardiovascular VP of Toxicology writing protocols and reports in addition to
planning and executing laboratory research,
Biology, Neuroscience, and Oral Biology as well as the Program in Based in U.S. Qualified candidates must have a directing a study team, and communicating
PhD in toxicology or a related field, or equivalent effectively with Sponsor and consultants.
Gene Therapy. Successful candidates will have a demonstrated ability combination of education (MS, MD, DVM) and 8-
or a potential to establish an externally funded research program, to train 10+ years of experience working in
toxicology/safety assessment in the
In vitro DMPK Scientist
graduate students/postdoctoral fellows and to participate in the teach- pharmaceutical industry. This position will be (Beijing)
responsible for business development activities
ing activities of the departments. Applications will be forwarded to the and help develop and execute nonclinical safety Qualified candidates will have a Masters or Ph.D
degree with industry experience in DMPK, in
appropriate department and should include curriculum vitae, reprints drug development plans and effectively
vitro Toxicology or Cell Biology. Position is
communicate the relevance and interpretation of
of three publications, three letters of reference, and a statement of cur- study findings to internal and external teams. responsible for early drug metabolism studies.
Must have knowledge of FDA and ICH guidance Experience with the use of in vitro models to
rent interests, future goals, and teaching experience. Please send these documents, regulatory toxicology requirements predict ADME properties and extensive cell
electronically, if possible, to: and US and international GLP regulations and culture expertise (with hepatocyte and/or
experience in writing and reviewing relevant mammalian cells) is desired. The ability to
Wayne L. Backes, Ph.D. sections of regulatory submissions including IND maintain laboratory notebooks and data quality
Associate Dean for Research and NDA (CTD) submissions. is critical.
LSUHSC-NO School of Medicine
533 Bolivar Street, New Orleans, LA 70112 Interested applicants should forward
MSfacultyrecruit@lsuhsc.edu their resume to: careers@bioduro.com.
For more information please visit our website.
LSUHSC is an Equal Opportunity/Affirmative Action Employer. www.bioduro.com
THE CHINESE UNIVERSITY OF HONG KONG
Division Leader
The Theoretical (T) Division at Los Alamos National
The Division of Earth and Ocean Sciences in Duke University’s Nicholas Laboratory is a multidisciplinary organization with a
School of the Environment and Earth Sciences (NSEES) anticipates hiring distinguished history, including 175 permanent Ph.D. sci-
the second of two Jeffrey and Martha Gendell Chairs in Energy and the entists, an annual budget of over $80M, and the Center
for Nonlinear Studies. Members conduct basic and applied
Environment. We seek a physical scientist who is a recognized authority on research in theoretical physics, chemistry, biology, and
current and future energy resources. This individual’s expertise would ideally mathematics. The Division carries out theoretical and com-
encompass the availability of energy resources, the technologies and addi- putational research in support of the nation and Laboratory
tional resources needed to extract, process, distribute and generate power from programs in weapons physics, basic science, materials
science, threat reduction, and energy. Division Leader
them, and the environmental impacts of the resource use. An understanding responsibilities include scientific leadership, recruit-
of the current and future demand for energy resources within the evolving ment and retention of staff, prudent fiscal management,
geopolitical landscape of the world is highly desirable. So too are new ideas infrastructure management, long-term planning, program
on the efficient utilization of energy resources. We are equally interested in development, project delivery, effective interaction with
laboratory programs, and communication with sponsors and partners.
candidates with a commitment to, and proven record of, interdisciplinary col-
laboration on problems at the intersection of energy with climate and water. Required: Record of leading large, innovative technical organizations for
simultaneous excellence in fundamental science and applied research. Major
The appointment is open to all levels: assistant, associate and full professor. accomplishment in a relevant scientific discipline as demonstrated by a
Candidates should possess a portfolio of experience and accomplishments record of outstanding publications and international stature. Success in sci-
commensurate with rank, a strong interest in teaching and mentoring students, entific management including effective resource management, teaming, con-
and the capacity for playing an active role in the School’s Energy and Environ- flict resolution, advocacy, negotiation skills, and strategic planning. Record
of promoting scientific excellence by attracting and retaining outstanding
ment Program. This role will include participating in collaborative initiatives research staff. Excellent communication skills. Commitment to institutional
between NSEES and other Duke Schools (Pratt School of Engineering, Fuqua goals in the areas of health, safety and environmental protection, safeguards
School of Business, the Law School, the Terry Sanford Institute for Public and security management, workforce diversity, and employee development.
Policy, and Trinity College) which are developing a broad, interdisciplinary Ph.D. in relevant technical field of physical science. Ability to obtain a DOE
Q clearance, which usually requires U.S. citizenship.
program that addresses society’s need for affordable, sustainable, safe and
clean energy. Desired: Knowledge of Laboratory, DOE, and other national programs.
Experience in developing collaborations among national laboratories, univer-
The Nicholas School includes 50 faculty representing a divesity of disciplines. sities, and industry. Record of fostering new scientific programs, developing
We offer professional and graduate degrees, and we direct Duke’s undergradu- new initiatives, and promoting cross-disciplinary research activities outside
ate environmental programs. his/her own specialty.
Letters of interest should include a curriculum vitae and names of three ref- To Apply: Send a comprehensive cover letter and CV/resume to
erences, and be sent to: Chair, Gendell Professorship Search Committee, jobs@lanl.gov referencing Job# 213775 in the subject line. AA/EOE
Earth and Ocean Sciences, Nicholas School of the Environment and Earth
Sciences, Box 90227, Duke University, Durham, NC 27708. Applications
are due by January 1, 2005.
Duke University is an Equal-Opportunity/Affirmative Action Employer.
Women and minorities are encouraged to apply. www.lanl.gov/jobs
GRADUATE PROGRAM
DUAL MASTERS IN
“BRAIN AND MIND SCIENCES”
Faculty Positions in Immunology Université Pierre et Marie Curie in partnership with the Ecole
The UNC Lineberger Comprehensive Cancer Center and the Normale Supérieure and University College London
Department of Microbiology and Immunology are searching for This 2-year international Masters level programme in Brain and Mind
individuals with promising or established research programs in the Sciences is offered by three of Europe’s most prestigious centres of research
broad areas of immunology. Candidates should have a Ph.D. and teaching in cognitive studies and neuroscience.
and/or M.D. with a strong record of recent accomplishments as a Applications for places for the 2007-2009 session are invited from
postdoctoral fellow or sustained productivity as an established outstanding students with applications from countries outside the European
faculty member. Candidates chosen will be placed in tenure-track Union equally welcomed.
positions at The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. The
The programme will include a year spent in LONDON and a year in PARIS.
search will be coordinated by Jenny Ting, Ph.D., Alumni
Students will graduate with a Masters from UCL, a Masters level university
Distinguished Professor and Immunology Program Leader, diploma from UPMC/ENS and a DUAL MASTERS DEGREE IN BRAIN
Lineberger Comprehensive Cancer Center. AND MIND SCIENCES awarded by the three institutions in partnership.
Areas of interest include but are not limited to: Cancer Students will be rigorously selected on the basis of academic excellence and
academic recommendation. A maximum of 20 students will be accepted per
immunology, immunity and infection, inflammation and cancer,
academic year, 10 starting in PARIS and 10 in LONDON with cross-over
innate immunity, macrophage and dendritic cell biology, immune after a year. Fees will be payable. For further information please contact one
signaling, and molecular immunology. Applicants should send a of academic course directors below. Scholarships may be available.
curriculum vitae, a description of research plans, and three letters
of reference to: The programme is designed to give students a personalized programme of
study in neuroscience and cognitive studies relevant to the Brain and Mind
Sciences, through lectures and research projects conducted in both cities.
Melissa Stroud Mack Students will be able to re-orient, to apply different disciplines/competencies
UNC Lineberger Comprehensive Cancer Center, CB# 7295 already acquired in pre-Masters study (eg engineering, mathematics,
University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill genetics), to study basic and clinical neuroscience or cognitive science
Chapel Hill, NC 27599-7295 topics in depth or broadly. The overarching educational aim is to give a
grounding in Brain and Mind Sciences from a multi-disciplinary perspective
The University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill is an equal and to provide a sound basis for choosing an appropriate topic and supervisor
opportunity/ADA employer. for doctoral research.
Women and minorities are encouraged to apply. The course is designed to cater for students’ individual interests and needs
by access to major themes through existing established Masters programmes
from which their curricula will be constructed:
• Theme A: Neuroscience - from molecules to systems (UPMC, ENS and
UCL)
• Theme B: Clinical neuroscience (UCL)
UNIVERSITY OF AARHUS, • Theme C: Language, linguistics and semantics (ENS & UCL)
DENMARK • Theme D: Cognitive psychology and neuropsychology (UCL)
• Theme E: Cognitive neuroscience (ENS and UPMC)
• Theme F: Biology of neurons (ENS)
• Theme G: Philosophy of sensation, emotion, action; philosophy of mind
Professor in Nano-Foodscience (ENS and UCL)
INTERDISCIPLINARY NANOSCIENCE CENTER Depending on choice of modules students can aim to obtain:
(1) A theoretical grounding in neurobiological and cognitive research
including philosophy of science, methods (including imaging,
psychophysics and neuropsychology), molecular, cellular, genetic and
Applications are invited for a permanent position integrative neuroscience.
as professor in Nano-Foodscience at Interdiscipli- (2) An appreciation of the way Brain and Mind questions can be approached
theoretically and experimentally in humans and other model systems.
nary Nanoscience Center, University of Aarhus, (3) An appreciation of the interaction between theory, modelling and
empiricism in tackling Brain and Mind problems
Denmark. (4) Practical experience of investigating Brain and Mind problems from
two cultural and historical perspectives (in the two cities).
The position is open as soon as possible. Students should be prepared to follow lectures in English and French.
Language classes will be available in both cities. Examinations and
dissertations may be written in English in both cities.
Before applying for this position, please read the For further information consult http://www.ion.ucl.ac.uk/education/msc-
full job description at http://nat.au.dk/stilling. brain-mind.htm and/or http://diu-neuro.snv.jussieu.fr.
The deadline for receipt of all applications is Applications in either English or French should be sent to either:
• Dr. Caroline Selai, Institute of Neurology, Queen Square, London
January 5, 2007, at 12.00 noon. WC1N 3BG, UK (c.selai@ion.ucl.ac.uk), or
Please number the application 211/5-25 • Dr. Ann Lohof, Laboratoire DVSN, UMR 7102, Case 14, Université
P et M Curie, 9 quai St Bernard, 75005 Paris (Ann. Lohof@mail.snv.
jussieu.fr), or
• Dr. Andrea Dumoulin, Laboratoire de Biologie Cellulaire de la
Synapse, Inserm U497, Ecole Normale Supérieure 46, rue d’Ulm,
75005 Paris (adumoul@biologie.ens.fr)
in the form of a curriculum vitae with achieved or expected examination
scores, a personal statement/letter of motivation of not more than 1 A4 page,
and the names and email addresses of 2 academic referees.
Picture yourself as a
AAAS Science & Technology
Policy Fellow!
(Biology, Biotechnology), and 50 doctoral students in two Ph.D. programs /K2KO9O 6G59K6GOG287 K2-N9.G + / J
36 / J
;K8J + OK2KO9O 30 0K:G
(Neurobiology, Cell and Molecular Biology). The Department of Chem- [G+67 30 GZ4G6KG2-G +7 +2 773-K+8G 630G7736 36 G59K:+NG28
$JG 79--G7709N
-+2.K.+8G K7 GZ4G-8G. 83 J+:G + .K78K219K7JG. 6G-36. 30 7-J3N+6N[ +-8K:K8[
istry has 15 tenured/tenure-track faculty members, approximately 145 -328K29397 0+* "
+2. 38JG6 GZ86+O96+N 092.K21 +2. 6G59K7K8G 8G+-JK21
undergraduate majors, 12 graduate and 11 doctoral students. GZ4G6KG2-G K2 + OG.K-+N16+.9+8G -966K-9N9O
6G498+8K32 036 ,9KN.K21
K28G6.K7-K4NK2+6[ 46316+O7 +2. GZ4G6KG2-G ;K8J 79--G7709NN[ OG2836K21 16+.9+8G
Review of submitted applications will begin immediately and will con- +2. OG.K-+N 789.G2874378.3-836+N0GNN3;7+2. L92K36 0+-9N8[ K7 +N73 6G59K6G.
tinue until the position is filled. Applicants who are not U.S. citizens must 44NK-+287 7J39N. 79,OK8,[ GO+KN+ NG88G6 79OO+6K\K21 8JGK6 59+NK0K-+8K327 +2.
state their current visa and residency status. Applicants must submit a letter K28G6G787 K2 8JG 437K8K324630G77K32+N 13+N7-966K-9N9O :K8+G +2. 8JG 2+OG7 +2.
of application, a dated current curriculum vitae, a description of current -328+-8 K2036O+8K32 30 0K:G 6G0G6G2-G7
3O4NG8G. +44NK-+8K327 O978 ,G
79,OK88G. 83 /7 &+2/77+ [/6
X+[/6J/+N8J
970
/.9
3O4G8K8K:G 78+6894
research and research plans, a statement of teaching philosophy, and the 4+-M+1G7 +2. 7+N+6KG7 ;KNN ,G 463:K.G. -3OOG2796+8G ;K8J GZ4G6KG2-G
"G:KG;
names, postal addresses, and e-mail addresses of three individuals who 30 +44NK-+8K327 ;KNN ,G1K2 G-GO,G6
+2. ;KNN -328K29G 928KN 8JK7
can provide recommendation letters. Application materials should be sent 437K8K32 K7 0KNNG.
(36 O36G K2036O+8K32 4NG+7G :K7K8 8JK7 ;G,7K8G
to: Proteomics Search Committee, 1.620 BSE, The University of Texas J88RJ7-
970
/.9O/.K-K2/637M+OR)-J+K6)+22392-/O/28
J8ON
USF Health is committed to increasing its diversity and will give individual consideration to
at San Antonio, One UTSA Circle, San Antonio, Texas 78249-0661, qualified applicants for this position with experience in ethnically diverse settings, who
or electronically to PROT@utsa.edu. Applications will be treated as possess varied language skills, or who have a record of research issues that
support/benefit diverse communities or teaching a diverse student
confidential. Budget approval for position is pending. population. The University of South Florida is an Equal
Opportunity/Affirmative Action/Equal Access Institution. For disability
UTSA is an Affirmative Action/Equal Opportunity Employer. accommodations, contact Vanessa Ayer at 813-974-8349 within 5 days of
Women, minorities, veterans, and individuals with disabilities are an event. According to Florida law, search records, including applications
and search committee meetings, are open to the public.
encouraged to apply.
POSITIONS OPEN POSITIONS OPEN POSITIONS OPEN
ASSOCIATE DEAN JOHN J. CRAIGHEAD ENDOWED CHAIR NEW FACULTY POSITIONS
FOR RESEARCH AND DEVELOPMENT The Division of Biological Sciences (DBS) at the Department of Pharmacology, Toxicology,
Website: http://www.cnsm.csulb.edu University of Montana invites applications for an and Therapeutics
The College of Natural Sciences and Mathematics ENDOWED CHAIR (tenure-track) at the AD- University of Kansas Medical Center (KUMC)
at California State University, Long Beach (CSULB), VANCED ASSOCIATE PROFESSOR/FULL The Department of Pharmacology, Toxicology,
seeks an Associate Dean for Research and De- PROFESSOR level, to begin August 2007. This and Therapeutics under the direction of Curtis
velopment starting fall 2007. The ideal candidate position has been established to honor the distin- Klaassen, Professor and Chair (website: http://
has strong involvement in public/private partner- guished career of Dr. John J. Craighead and to www.kumc.edu/pharmacology/), is continuing its
ships and research/grant collaborations across science, carry on his research interests in the study and con- expansion by inviting applications for two ASSIST-
technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) servation of large mammals in the wild. The position ANT PROFESSORS, tenure-track faculty positions
disciplines; significant administrative and academic involves responsibilities in the Wildlife Biology Pro- to augment the strength of our eight recent hires.
governance experience; experience with assessment gram (WBIO) and DBS. The successful candidate is Preference will be given to candidates in areas such
and grant evaluation. Will facilitate faculty collabo- expected to develop a vigorous externally funded re- as nuclear receptors, toxicology, or xenobiotic dis-
ration and promote interdisciplinary research and search program in the ecology and conservation of position (absorption, distribution, metabolism, ex-
research centers. Promote and support student re- large mammals, mentor M.S. and Ph.D. students in cretion) that complement existing strengths in the
search and student organizations. Position is 0.75 DBS and WBIO, teach a graduate level course in Department and the Medical Center. This expansion
time base as a 12-month Associate Dean at Admin- area of interest, and interact with state, federal, and is supported by a new Centers of Biomedical Re-
istrator III level, and a 0.25 time base as an academic private conservation organizations. Requirements search Excellence (COBRE) grant entitled Nuclear
year tenured, full Professor. (Ph.D. required in one of include a Ph.D., demonstrated international recog- Receptors in Liver Function and Dysfunction, a re-
the natural sciences, mathematics, or math/science nition of research achievement in the area of large cently renewed training grant in environmental
education or closely related field to qualify applicant mammal ecology and conservation in the wild con- sciences, and a new research building. Broad areas
for retreat rights as full Professor with tenure to a sistent with Dr. Craighead_s legacy, demonstrated of strength at the Medical Center include cancer,
department in the College.) Evidence of very strong success in securing grant funding, demonstration of neuroscience, reproductive biology, renal pathophys-
publications, research, and grant acquisitions. Evi- a potential for or a record of teaching excellence, and iology, and growing efforts in liver biology. A
dence of ability to work collaboratively with a diverse a proven ability to communicate effectively with competitive startup package and appropriate space
faculty and University staff. professionals and the general public. Preference will will be offered. Standard support facilities are present,
For a more detailed job description visit website: be given to applicants whose research profile in- including biotechnology, transgenics, proteomics,
http://www.csulb.edu/aa/personnel/jobs, re- cludes carnivore ecology, international experience, and a state-of-the-art imaging center. The Depart-
cruitment number 149. and those who possess experience directing graduate ment also has excellent molecular biology (robot, real
Review of applications to begin on February 1, student research. Send a one to two-page summary time PCR, sequencer), and liquid chromatography/
2007. Applicants should submit the following: letter of research interests and plans, curriculum vitae and mass spectrometry facilities. Applications will be
of application addressing qualifications, curriculum names of at least three references to: Dr. Kerry R. reviewed as they are received until the positions are
vitae (include e-mail address), three letters of recom- Foresman, Search Committee Chair, HS104, filled. Anticipated appointment date is as early as
mendation directly from referees, the names, addresses, Division of Biological Sciences, The University July 1, 2007. Applicants must be proficient in the
telephone numbers of two additional professional of Montana, Missoula, MT 59812 U.S.A. Tele- use of the English language. Applicants should
references, and official Ph.D. transcript (required of phone: 406-243-4492. Inquiries may be made by provide curriculum vitae, statement of research in-
finalists) to the Search Committee at: Stephen e-mail (e-mail: foresman@mso.umt.edu) but no terests, and names of three references. To review the
Mezyk, Chair, Search Committee – Associate faxed or e-mail applications will be accepted. A de- position description and apply online go to website:
Dean for Research and Development, College of tailed position description is available on the DBS http://jobs.kumc.edu and search for position
Natural Sciences and Mathematics, California website: http://biology.dbs.umt.edu/dbs. Re- J0020073. Paid for by KUMC. The University of Kansas
State University, Long Beach, 1250 Bellflower view of applications begins 15 January 2007. Affir- Medical Center is proud to be an Equal Opportunity/Affir-
Boulevard, Long Beach, CA 90840-4501. E-mail: mative Action/Equal Opportunity Employer. mative Action Employer.
jbright@csulb.edu; telephone: 562-985-1521; fax:
562-985-2315. ASSISTANT DEAN
CSULB is an Equal Opportunity Employer. FOR GRADUATE EDUCATION
The School of Medicine at the University of North NEW YORK STATE INSTITUTE FOR BASIC
Carolina at Chapel Hill is searching for an Assistant RESEARCH IN DEVELOPMENTAL
Dean for Graduate Education (ADGE). The ADGE DISABILITIES
CHAIR OF BIOLOGICAL SCIENCES
will create, develop, and administer a new umbrella STAFF RESEARCH SCIENTISTS (four posi-
Michigan Technological University
graduate admissions program for students entering tions): will be hired to complement and strengthen
The Department of Biological Sciences at Michigan Ph.D. programs in the biological and biomedical the New York State Institute for Basic Research
Technological University invites applications for the sciences, in both the School of Medicine and the (IBR) in Developmental Disabilities_ ongoing clini-
position of Chair to begin in the 2007-2008 aca- College of Arts and Sciences. The successful candi- cal and research studies of autism. The successful
demic year. The successful candidate will have a date will supervise a staff that will work closely and applicants will have an established research program
Ph.D. in the biological sciences or a related area, a effectively with the graduate directors of 13 Ph.D. and nationally recognized contributions related to
distinguished record of research and teaching, evi- granting programs and campuswide curricula. ADGE autism in one or more of the following areas: neuro-
dence of leadership in procurement of extramural applicants should hold a Ph.D. or M.D. in a biological biology, molecular biology/genetics, biochemistry,
funding, and be eligible for appointment as FULL or biomedical discipline, have substantial research ex- and child psychology/applied behavior analysis.
PROFESSOR. The Chair is expected to maintain a perience, and demonstrate a strong leadership record Positions are open until filled. Compensation will
dynamic research program compatible with existing in innovative training of graduate students. The be commensurate with experience in accordance with
departmental strengths in biochemistry and molec- ADGE will be vested with a tenured faculty position conditions set by the New York State Department
ular biology, ecology and limnology, and the health in an appropriate academic department (rank to be of Civil Service with salary range of $70,000 to
sciences. determined) and will be expected to either maintain $140,000. New York State offers an excellent bene-
We seek an individual with the vision and skills to an active research program or participate in depart- fits package. Please submit curriculum vitae indicating
lead the Department to national prominence in mental teaching responsibilities. Applicants should position of interest to: Dr. Ted Brown, Director,
biological research, further our strong tradition of send curriculum vitae, names of three reerences, and Institute for Basic Research in Developmental Dis-
educational excellence, grow our M.S. and Ph.D. a brief statement of relevant experience to: abilities, 1050 Forest Hill Road, Staten Island,
programs, and advance the Department_s position as NY 10314, fax: 718- 494-7917, or by e-mail:
ADGE Search Committee
a key player in interdisciplinary strategic initiatives ted.brown@omr.state.ny.us.
Office of Research, School of Medicine
such as sustainability and biotechnology.
CB-7000, 43 MacNider
Review of applications will begin January 5, 2007,
University of North Carolina
and continue until the position is filled. For a broader
Chapel Hill, NC 27599-7000
position description see website: http://www.bio. POSTDOCTORAL POSITION
mtu.edu/. Applicants should send: a letter of in- Review of applications will commence Decem-
ber 1, 2006. A NIH-funded position in enzymology is available
terest; curriculum vitae; statements of research,
in the laboratory of Dr. Marilyn Jorns at Drexel
teaching, and administrative philosophies; and names
POSTDOCTORAL POSITION to study mo- University College of Medicine, Philadelphia, Penn-
of four references to:
lecular and cellular mechanisms of angiogenesis, with sylvania. The position involves mechanistic studies
Dr. Casey Huckins, Search Committee Chair particular emphasis on neovascular eye diseases such on nikD, a flavoenzyme important in the biosyn-
Department of Biological Sciences as diabetic retinopathy. Prior background in mo- thesis of nikkomycin antibiotics (website: http://
Michigan Technological University lecular and/or cell biology would be helpful, but is www.drexelmed.edu/documents/biochemistry/
1400 Townsend Drive not essential. Send curriculum vitae and names of faculty/resume_jorns.htm). Candidates must have
Houghton, MI 49931 three references to: Dr. E. Duh, Johns Hopkins experience in protein purification, enzyme kinetics,
Michigan Technological University is an Equal Opportunity University School of Medicine, 1550 Orleans and mutagenesis. Please forward curriculum vitae
Educational Institution/Equal Opportunity Employer/Affir- Street, Room 143, Baltimore, MD 21231. E-mail: and the names/contact information of three refer-
mative Action Employer. eduh@jhmi.edu. Equal Opportunity Employer. ences to e-mail: marilyn.jorns@drexelmed.edu.
GRANTS
Fourth Call
Paseo de Recoletos, 10
28001 MADRID - SPAIN This call is directed at research projects involving international cooperation, especially with
Fax: (34) 91 374 34 44 Latin America.
POSITIONS OPEN POSITIONS OPEN POSITIONS OPEN
ORGANISMAL BIOLOGIST RESEARCH SCIENTIST: STROKE/ The U.S. Geological Survey_s Patuxent Wildlife Re-
The Biology Department of Wilkes University CEREBRAL ISCHEMIA search Center in Laurel, Maryland (website: http://
invites applications for a tenure-track position in The Central Illinois Neuroscience Foundation www.pwrc.usgs.gov/), seeks a RESEARCH BI-
biology at the ASSISTANT PROFESSOR level, (CINF), a nonprofit foundation dedicated to the OLOGIST to concentrate on threatened and endan-
starting August 2007. We seek a broadly trained Or- enhancement of neurological health through educa- gered species, and work with Patuxent_s captive flock
ganismal Biologist with research experience and tion and research, seeks a researcher to oversee its of breeding whooping cranes. Experience working
teaching ability in one or more of the following areas: preclinical stroke/cerebral ischemia laboratory affili- with cranes is not required. Research results will
conservation biology, population genetics, phylo- ated with the Department of Biological Sciences and contribute to advancements in the conservation of
genetics, biostatistics, landscape or ecosystems ecology, the Program of Excellence in Neuroscience and Be- threatened and endangered species through captive
or functional morphology, to complement existing havior at Illinois State University (ISU). breeding, restoration techniques, management of
strengths in plant ecology, plant physiology, and Qualifications include: (1) a Ph.D. or its equiva- restored populations, or other aspects of the ecology
animal behavior. We seek an individual who is ded- lent in neuroscience, neurobiology, or a related field, and biology of imperiled species. Specific research
icated to innovative teaching and research in an (2) at least five years of experience studying stroke expertise for this work may come from a range of
undergraduate setting. Responsibilities will include or ischemia in the laboratory, (3) a strong publica- organismal and ecological disciplines; one can qualify
upper-level courses in area of expertise, participation tion record in stroke, cerebral ischemia, or related through the Office of Personnel Management stan-
in general biology, and research activities to enhance fields, (4) the ability to develop a research program dards as a PHYSIOLOGIST, ZOOLOGIST, or
a new Institute of the Environment. A Ph.D. is re- that utilizes the intraluminal thread model of focal ECOLOGIST. Apply online before 21 December
quired, postdoctoral experience is preferred. The cerebral ischemia in rodents to study neurodegen- 2006, at website: http://www.usgs.gov/ohr/
successful candidate will be expected to develop a eration, neuroprotection, neuroregeneration, or func- oars/. Details on the position and application are
strong research program involving undergraduates. tional recovery, (5) previous experience in attracting provided at the website.
Applicants should provide digital copy of application extramural research funding, and (6) the ability to VISITING ASSISTANT PROFESSOR
letter, curriculum vitae, statements of teaching and mentor biology graduate students (M.S. and Ph.D.) Washington College
research goals, reprints (PDF), and three reference and neurosurgical residents in preclinical stroke Academic Year 2007-2008
letters to: Dr. Ken Klemow, Search Chair (e-mail: research.
kklemow@wilkes.edu). A separate copy of applica- The position offers the opportunity for adjunct Washington College is seeking a full-time VIS-
tion letter and curriculum vitae should be sent to: faculty appointment at Illinois State University, the ITING ASSISTANT PROFESSOR (nontenure-
Wilkes University (Reference # BI0006), P.O. Box chance for interaction with a diverse array of neuro- track/sabbatical replacement) in microbiology for
3924, Scranton, PA 1505. Application review will scientists at ISU (website: http://lilt.ilstu.edu/ academic year 2007-2008. Teaching responsibilities
begin January 8, 2007. Wilkes University is an Equal POENB/), and clinical research possibilities at local include introductory biology, microbiology and
Opportunity/Affirmative Action Employer committed to a hospitals and clinics through collaboration with local another upper-level course (immunology preferred)
diverse faculty, staff, and student body. Women and minority physicians and CINF_s clinical research staff. and supervision of undergraduate research. See
candidates are strongly encouraged to apply. The position also provides access to a well-equipped website: http://hr.washcoll.edu/ for full applica-
laboratory and rodent animal care facility, a graduate tion details. Washington College is an Equal Opportunity
research fellowship, and initial intramural funding of Employer. Women and minorities are strongly encouraged to
FACULTY POSITION, MICROBIAL research expenses. apply.
ECOLOGY/PHYSIOLOGY This is a full-time, 12-month appointment with
Miami University invites applications for a tenure- competitive benefits, and a salary commensurate with MARKETPLACE
track ASSISTANT PROFESSOR position in mi- experience. The anticipated start date is winter/
crobiology, with a research emphasis in microbial spring 2007, based upon availability of the successful
ecology and/or environmental microbiology, with a applicant.
background in microbial physiology, to begin in Interested applicants should submit curriculum Modified Oligos
August 2007. Applicants must have a doctorate in mi- vitae and a letter describing their research interests
crobiology or closely related field, and postdoctoral along with three (p)reprints of publications, and ar- @
research experience. Responsibilities will include range for three letters of recommendation to be sent
maintaining an externally funded research-active lab- to: Research Scientist Search, Central Illinois Neu- Great Prices
oratory, directing M.S. and Ph.D. students, teaching roscience Foundation, 1015 South Mercer Avenue,
undergraduate and graduate courses, including mi- Bloomington, IL 61701. Review of applications
will begin immediately and continue until the posi-
Get the Details
crobial ecology, and microbial physiology or general
microbiology, and service to the University. More tion is filled. For more information about CINF visit www.oligos.com
information about the Department of Microbiology our website: http://cinf.org. CINF is an Equal
and Miami University is available at website: http:// Opportunity Employer.
The Midland Certified Reagent Co, Inc.
www.cas.muohio.edu/micro/. Screening of appli-
cations will begin on January 1, 2007, and continue 3112-A West Cuthbert Avenue
until the position is filled. Applicants should sub- The Office of Science, Department of Energy is Midland, Texas 79701
mit curriculum vitae, three reprints, statement of seeking a motivated and highly qualified individual 800-247-8766
research interests and goals, statement of teaching to serve as the ASSOCIATE DIRECTOR, Office
philosophy, and have three letters of reference sent of Biological and Environmental Research. As such,
to: Dr. Gary R. Janssen, Department of Micro- you will provide leadership and direction in estab-
biology, Miami University, Oxford, OH 45056. lishing vision, strategic plans, goals, and objectives
E-mail: janssegr@muohio.edu. Campus crime and for the research activities supported. You may apply
safety report, website: http://www.muohio.edu/ through two different methods, one is for a SENIOR Diverse Small Molecules
righttoknow. Hard copy available upon request. EXECUTIVE SERVICE appointment and the sec-
Miami University is an Equal Opportunity Employer/Affir- ond is for an INTERGOVERNMENTAL PER-
Ready for Screening
mative Action Employer. SONNEL ACT appointment. The announcement High Quality & ChemBridge
Drug-Like
number is SES-SC-HQ-005. The announcement opens Corporation
on November 6, 2006, and closes on December 21, Pre-Plated in DMSO
RESEARCH FELLOWSHIPS 2006. Visit website: http://www.usajobs.opm.gov/
Australian Research Council for more information and for instructions concerning Very Competitively
Priced
Centre of Excellence, Australia application procedures.
Upwards of 200,000 Website: www.chembridge.com
The Australian Research Council Centre of Ex- Compounds Email: sales@chembridge.com
cellence for Coral Reef Studies is an international Toll Free : (800) 980 - CHEM
research centre, administered by James Cook Uni- A POSTDOCTORAL POSITION is open to
versity, in partnership with the Australian National study the role of ubiquitylation in the control of Tel: (858) 451-7400
University, the University of Queensland, and 23 stem cell self-renewal/differentiation. Collabora-
other institutions and industry partners in nine tions with proteomic facilities and stem cell core
countries. The following three-year Research Fellow- laboratory at the Hillman Cancer Center will be in-
ship Positions are available: (1) biodiversity of coral volved. Candidates with strong background in stem
Find your future here.
↓
reefs, (2) tropical marine palaeoecology, and (3) cell biology (human embryonic stem cell culture)
modelling of coupled social-ecological systems. are encouraged to send their curriculum vitae and
Closing date is 12 January 2007. three references to: Dr. Yong Wan Ph.D., Uni-
Details available from website: http://www. versity of Pittsburgh Cancer Institute, Hillman
coralcoe.org.au/employment.html. Cancer Center, 5117 Centre Avenue, Room 2.6C,
Equal Opportunity in Employment is University policy. Pittsburgh, PA 15213. E-mail: yow4@pitt.edu.
The University reserves the right to invite applications or not Laboratory website: http://www.cbp.pitt.edu/
to make an appointment. faculty/yong_wan.
*New members only. International orders will receive Science digital edition — to place an order outside the U.S., go to promo.aaas.org/giftn.