Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Case
11/3/2010
The case has been prepared by Ankit Jain for use in Clinch the Deal event at Backwaters v2.10.
Introduction
The age is about the fortune at the bottom of the pyramid. Increasingly, the various businesses are looking at tapping the potential wealth that exists amongst the poorer sections of the society. A large chunk of untapped potential exists amongst the rural population; the only catch is that they would not be willing to spend One strategy being adopted by the companies is that of M&A. Amongst the leaders in this area is the banking sector. Providing financial solutions to the more economically feasible sections is a profitable venture owing to the volumes, but the weaker sections provide opportunities for higher margins. The Indian Standard Bank is looking to acquire and merge with banks that have a foothold in the rural financing department. The various players in this field in the industry have been listed, but how do they decide which is the bank that will provide an apt synergy? Should they go for a merger or an acquisition? How do they go about financing the deal? What price should they be willing to pay? How should they negotiate? How should the capital for the acquisition be raised? These questions are what are bothering the management. The details of the 3 players have been listed. The criteria for the short-listing by the bank: 1) 2) 3) 4) The institutions model should not be one that is non-profitable. The institution should have been in operation for at least three years. There should be a way of improving profitability of the institution. The CAGR should be at least 5% for next 4 years.
Constraints 1) Assume there are little constrains except for the financial synergies and appraisal of the target. 2) Raising capital is very much possible through either means. 3) Only one of the 3 target institutions can be acquired.
The case has been prepared by Ankit Jain for use in the event Clinch the Deal at Backwaters v2.10
Over the past 5 years their standing in the country has improved from being the 8 th largest private player to being the 4th largest in terms of deposits and advances. Most of their revenues come through the interest side, i.e. interest income (40%) NPAs are about 3% of total assets, NII is around 2%.
Balance Sheet
2008 Capital Equity Reserves and Surplus Deposits Borrowings Other Liabilities and Provisions Total Assets Cash and Balances with RBI Balances with Banks, Money at call and short notices Investments Advances Fixed Assets Other Assets Total Contingent Liabilities Bills for Collection 112.28 168.42 2276.2 22188.7 3932.2 28565.52 2009 122.04 183.06 2474.1 24118.2 4274.1 31049.46 2010 135.6 203.4 2749 26798 4749 34499.4
The case has been prepared by Ankit Jain for use in the event Clinch the Deal at Backwaters v2.10
*Share price has never gone above Rs. 1100 (3 years ago) and never below Rs. 550 (19 months ago) *Data displayed in graph is for the past 129 working days
The case has been prepared by Ankit Jain for use in the event Clinch the Deal at Backwaters v2.10
Interest Income Other income Total income Interest expense Total expenses PAT LTV ratio Savings to loan ratio Number of accounts Number of loans disbursed Loan value D/E
Balance sheet
2008 Capital Equity Reserves and Surplus Deposits Borrowings Other Liabilities and Provisions Total Assets Cash Balances with Banks, Money at call and short notices Investments Advances Fixed Assets Other Assets Total Contingent Liabilities 18.72 28.08 379.4 3698.1 655.4 4760.98 2009 20.36 30.54 412.4 4019.7 712.4 5175.04 2010 22.6 33.9 458.2 4466.3 791.5 5749.9
269.2 93.4
292.7 101.6
325.2 112.8
The case has been prepared by Ankit Jain for use in the event Clinch the Deal at Backwaters v2.10
The company is not listed and its shares are held closely by the promoters. The growth rate in interest income is expected to be around 7-8% CAGR over the next 4 years. The savings to loan ratio has been increasing, NPAs are around the industry average for micro finance institutions @ 3% of total assets. Savings deposits are considered as debt in calculation of D/E. Rate of Interest being charged is 26%. The rate of interest on deposits is 9.25%.
2009 Interest Income Other income Total income Interest expense Total expenses PAT LTV ratio Savings to loan ratio Number of accounts Number of loans disbursed Loan value D/E 422.4 341.6 764 384 664 44 1.2 0.48 20618 25600 1760 25
2010 528 427 955 480 830 55 1.5 0.6 25772 32000 2200 25
The case has been prepared by Ankit Jain for use in the event Clinch the Deal at Backwaters v2.10
Balance Sheet
2008 Capital Equity Reserves & Surplus Deposits Borrowings Other Liabilities & Provisions Total Assets Cash Balances with Banks, Money at call & short notices Investments Advances Fixed Assets Other Assets Total Contingent Liabilities 33.68 50.5 6656.6 1179.7 8603.3 2009 36.61 54.9 742.2 7235.5 1282.2 9351.5 2010 40.68 61.0 824.7 8039.4 1424.7 10390.5
Growth rate in interest income is expected to be around 10% CAGR in next 4 years. Savings to loan ratio has been stagnant in the past 4 quarters increasing slightly from 0.55 to 0.6. Rate of Interest being charged is 25.5%. The rate of interest on deposits is 9.50%.
The case has been prepared by Ankit Jain for use in the event Clinch the Deal at Backwaters v2.10
2009
2010
Interest Income Other income Total income Interest expense Total expenses PAT LTV ratio Savings to loan ratio Number of accounts Number of loans disbursed Loan value D/E
187 15.3 202.3 170 182.8 9.35 1.275 0.68 5950 7650 680 31
Balance Sheet
2008 Capital Assets Reserves and Surplus Deposits Borrowings Other Liabilities and Provisions Total Assets Cash and Balances with RBI Balances with Banks, Money at call and short notices Investments Advances Fixed Assets Other Assets Total Contingent Liabilities 13.48 20.22 273.1 2662.6 471.9 3427.82 2009 14.64 21.96 296.9 2894.2 512.9 3725.96 2010 16.28 24.42 329.9 3215.8 569.9 4140.02
193.9 67.3
210.7 73.1
234.1 81.2
Rate of Interest being charged is 27%. The rate of interest on deposits is 9.00%.
The case has been prepared by Ankit Jain for use in the event Clinch the Deal at Backwaters v2.10
Assumptions:
1. All 3 targets are not banks, they are financial institutions 2. NIM for the 3 targets are around 6% 3. Use of technology in case of the poorer sections is minimal, however the institutions use decent levels of technology to keep their operations efficient 4. The 3 targets are unlisted and the stocks are held closely by the promoters 5. Savings provided by the institutions are through tie ups with banks. These institutions collect funds from the people and use them for savings with various banks. Thus the instruments are similar to any bank operating in the country 6. There are no restrictions imposed by the government or the RBI
(All figures in crores except ratios, numbers of savings accounts and loans)
The case has been prepared by Ankit Jain for use in the event Clinch the Deal at Backwaters v2.10