Professional Documents
Culture Documents
-------------------------------------------------------2
-------------------------------------------------------3
-------------------------------------------------------5
-------------------------------8
-------------------------------12
------------------------------------------------------18
------------------------------------------------------24
------------------------------------------------------27
----------------------------------------28
------------------------------------------------------33
---------------------------------------36
---------------------------39
------------------------------------------------------42
-------------------------------------------------------------60
-------------------------------------------------------62
-------------------------------------------------62
-------------------------------------------------------------------------64
2-1 ---------------------------------------------------------------------5
2-2 ------------------------------------------------------------17
3-1 ---------------------------------------23
3-2 ------------------------------------------------------------------------27
4-1 ---------------------------------------------------------37
4-2 ---------------------------------------------------------40
4-3 ------------------------------------------------------------41
4-4 ------------------------------------------------------45
4-5 ---------------------------------------------------------46
4-6 ----------------------------------------------- ------49
4-7 ---------------------------------------------------------50
4-8 ---------------------------------------------54
4-9 ------------------------------------------------55
4-10 -------------------------------------------58
4-11 ----------------------------------------------59
1-1--------------------------------------------------------------------4
83
5
88 12
70 77
86
1450 87
2540 88 2830
86 1692
3745 87
1.
2.
3.
1-1
Principle
Agent
1.
2.
3.
Eisenhartd1989
2-1
1.
2.
3.
1.
2.
3.
1.
2.
Eisenhard, K.M.(1989)
Outside
owners
NPV 0
Myers1977
10
Demsetz1983
NPV
NPV > 0
DeAngelo1987
11
Jensen & Meckling 1976
Convergence-of-interest Hypothesis
26
12
1990
1995
24.63
35
1997
1998
expense preference
13
behavior
Demsez1983
0 5
5 25 25
1990
25%
25%40%
40%
1992
14
15
3 5
29
33
16
202
246
56 9 7
23287
193
192
216
30
17
26
197
22-1
10
18
157
157-1
193
19
72 6 3
21648
3-1
3-1
29
33
202
20
246
23287
192216
30
26
197
1/2
22-1
10 1/2
157
(6 )
157-1
192216
193
21648
197
21
2500
89
22
5000 6000
5000
23
76
81
86 6 25
24
3-2
1/3
25
3-2
26
1.
:
3%
2.
1.
10%
2.
25%
25%
1.
10%
2.
10%
1.
2.
1/3
87 12 11
27
28
29
30
82 87
()
()
50
300
80-20%
3-2
3-2
82
83
84
85
86
87
161
161
126
126
185
185
141
141
203
203
179
179
297
297
236
236
320
320
267
267
341
341
1507
1507
949
949
31
PROE /
1 0 0
L e v e r a g e / 1 0 0
32
100 100
C D R O E / 1 0 0
S D R O E / 1 0 0
()
0.05 0.5
1000 100
33
ASM ( )/ 2
1 0 0
()
Beaver1970
ROE( 0.49)
Penman1991 FamaFrench1992
PROE
ROE PROE
PROE
()
A S H / 2
1 0 0
()
SIZE
34
Warner1977
Log
S I Z E L o g ( )
()
I C F O T /
1 0 0
()
1995
Lintner1956
35
()
MODEL1
PROEi=0+1ASMi+2 ASHi +3PROEi,t-1+4ID 1+5ID 2+6ID 3+7ID 4+8ID 5+9ID 6 + i
MODEL2
PROEi=0+1ASMi+2ASHi+3PROEi,t-1+4ID 1+5ID 2+6ID 3+7ID 4+8ID 5+9ID 6+10YD1+11YD2+
12YD3+13YD4+14YD5+ i
36
MODEL1 MODEL2
1.PROE
2.ASM
3.ASH
4.i t
5.YD
8287 6 5
6.ID
7 6
ID1
ID2
ID3
ID4
ID5
ID6
MODEL3
LEVERAGEi=0+1ASMi+2SIZEI+3ID 1+4ID 2+5ID 3+6ID 4+7ID 5+8ID 6 + i
MODEL4
37
YD3+12YD4+13YD5+ i
MODEL3 MODEL4
1.LEVERAGE
2.ASM
3.SIZE
4. i
5.YD
8287 6 5
MODEL5
CDROEi=0+1ASMi+2ICFOTi +3CDROEi,t-1+4ID 1+5ID 2+6ID 3+7ID 4+8ID 5+9ID 6 + i
MODEL6
CDROEi=0+1ASMi+2ICFOTi+3CDROEi,t-1+4ID 1+5ID 2+6ID 3+7ID 4+8ID 5+9ID+
10YD1+11YD2+12YD3+13YD4+ i
MODEL7
38
MODEL8
SDROEi=0+1ASMi+2SDROEit-1+3ID 1+4ID 2+5ID 3+6ID 4+7ID 5+8ID 6 +9YD1+10YD2+
11
YD3+12YD4+13YD5+ i
MODEL5MODEL7 MODEL6MODEL8
1.CDROE
2.SDROE
3.ASM
4.ICFOT
5. i t
6.YD
7.ID
4-1
39
PROE
1/4
PROE 10 1/4
0 PROE 60
-40.5 100
Leverage
Leverage
3/4
1/4
CDROE
4-1
3/4 18.8
15.47
SDROE
4-1 85.22
100
67.83
40
ASM
100 0 1/4
40 1/4 0
ASH
24.7721.98
ICFOT
4-1
12.47 10
80
4-182 87
3/4 1/4
PROE(%)
Leverage(%)
5.41
46.51
9.34
65.91
10.53
5.24
0.35
-40.5
42.92 339.65
65.34
36.19
15.04
41
CDROE(%)
15.47
33.17
312.5
18.80
SDROE(%)
67.83
37.84
100
100
85.22
41.52
ASM(%)
24.65
26.53
100
42.08
15.02
1.58
ASH(%)
24.77
13.96
81.86
33.71
21.98
13.54
2.14
SIZE()
15.77
1.00
19.13
16.36
15.68
15.08
13.37
ICFOT(%)*
12.47
13.65
86.64
18.02
9.32
3.74 -28.46
* 83 87
Pearson Correlation
4-2
1.
1%ASMPROE
PROE1
PROE 0.58
ASH PROE
2.
42
1%Leverage
0.32SIZE
3.
1%
CDROE
ICFOT
CDROE1
4.
4-2 1%
ICFOT
SDROE1
4-2
PROE
ASM
ASM
-0.08
(0.0021)
PROE1
0.58
-0.17
(0.0001) (0.0001)
ASH
0.10
-0.25
(0.0001) (0.0001)
PROE1
0.18
(0.0001)
Leverage ASM
ASM
0.32
(0.0001)
SIZE
0.26
0.08
(0.0001) (0.001)
43
CDROE
ASM
ASM
-0.11
(0.0001)
ICFOT
-0.14
-0.03
(0.0001) (0.4277)
CDROE1
0.38
-0.15
(0.0001) (0.0001)
ICFOT
-0.17
(0.0001)
SDROE
ASM
ICFOT
ASM
0.04
(0.1567)
ICFOT
0.21
-0.02
(0.0001) (0.5608)
SDROE1
0.35
0.13
0.13
(0.0001) (0.0001) (0.0001)
PROE
Leverage
CDROE
SDROE
ASM
PROE1
ASH
SIZE
ICFOT
CDROE1
SDROE1
4-3
44
ASM
PROE1
ASH
IND1
IND2
IND3
IND4
IND5
IND6
Y83
Y84
Y85
Y86
Y87
VIF
1.1619
1.1131
1.1229
1.3092
1.2286
1.2691
1.3826
1.3865
1.2688
1.8920
1.9802
2.3351
2.4154
2.5055
ASM
SIZE
IND1
IND2
IND3
IND4
IND5
IND6
Y83
Y84
Y85
Y86
Y87
VIF
1.0827 ASM
1.0972 ICFOT
CDROE1
1.3471 IND1
1.2122 IND2
1.2654 IND3
1.3541 IND4
1.3795 IND5
1.2824 IND6
1.8858 Y83
1.9643 Y84
2.3016 Y85
2.4007 Y86
2.4986
VIF
1.0866
1.1776
1.1128
1.3001
1.2156
1.2696
1.3223
1.4306
1.2493
1.8104
2.0062
2.2585
2.3226
ASM
ICFOT
SDROE1
IND1
IND2
IND3
IND4
IND5
IND6
Y83
Y84
Y85
Y86
VIF
1.0734
1.0847
1.1667
1.3051
1.2063
1.2803
1.3081
1.4254
1.2423
1.8067
1.9725
2.2361
2.2965
ASM
PROE1
ASH
SIZE
ICFOT
CDROE1
SDROE1
ID1~ID6
Y82~Y87
4-4 4-5
82 0.0336P 0.0843
83
-0.0328P 0.0919
2 (84 0.082 87
45
0.0058P 0.4537
PROE
PROE 6
82 0.7935P 0.0001
83 0.4790
P 0.0001
84 0.8429P 0.0001
85 0.5500
P 0.0001
86 0.5277P 0.0001
87 0.6190
P 0.0001
0.5920P
0.0001
Beaver1970
Penman1991
FamaFrench1992
ASH
86
0.0634P 0.0135 87 -0.1087P
0.0158
83 84 85 82
-0.0028P 0.8481
]
46
4
83 2.1916P 0.0066
84 1.7866P 0.0235 87 2.3221P 0.0014
85 -1.9538P 0.0079
1.
82 83
2.
3.
47
4-4MODEL1
ASM
PROE1(+)
ASH
IND1
IND2
IND3
IND4
IND5
IND6
R-square
Adj R-sq
82
83
84
P
0.6418 0.6060
2.4781 0.0684
0.7955 0.5707
0.0336 0.0843*
-0.0328 0.0919*
0.0082 0.6501
0.7935 0.0001***
0.4790 0.0001***
0.8429 0.0001***
-0.0462 0.1334
0.0015 0.9644
0.0273 0.4212
-1.1474 0.4141
3.7581 0.0115**
-0.1722 0.9058
-0.0862 0.9572
0.9578 0.5934
0.2181 0.9019
1.6185 0.2579
3.4918 0.0195**
-0.5051 0.7354
-3.45178 0.0057***
2.9872 0.0278**
-1.7546 0.1911
0.1199 0.9352
1.3031 0.3881
-0.4171 0.7849
3.4893 0.0898*
2.4179 0.2187
-2.8976 0.1146
0.706
0.4287
0.5528
0.6882
0.3990
0.5320
85
86
87
48
ASM
PROE1(+)
ASH
IND1
IND2
IND3
IND4
IND5
IND6
R-square
Adj R-sq
P
-0.6678 0.6172
-1.1477 0.2756
5.5972 0.0019***
-0.0099 0.5572
-0.0027 0.8393
0.0311 0.1338
0.5500 0.0001***
0.5277 0.0001***
0.6190 0.0001***
0.0405 0.1837
0.0634 0.0135**
-0.1087 0.0158**
-3.1169 0.0350**
3.7047 0.0018***
-0.5760 0.7595
-1.2754 0.4416
-0.1218 0.9276
-1.9668 0.3792
1.0915 0.4682
2.4965 0.0420**
-0.9840 0.6306
-2.4355 0.0736*
4.2339 0.0001***
-2.3829 0.1882
0.7172 0.5936
-1.0419 0.3215
-0.5939 0.7215
-1.9206 0.1994
-0.0730 0.9504
-0.9927 0.6107
0.4321
0.4726
0.2068
0.4144
0.4573
0.1853
(+)(-)
* < 0.1** < 0.05*** < 0.01
ASM
PROE1
ASH
IND1 IND11 IND1 0
IND2 IND21 IND2 0
IND3 IND31 IND3 0
IND4 IND41 IND4 0
IND5 IND51 IND5 0
IND6 IND61 IND6 0
4-5 MODEL2
ASM
PROE1(+)
ASH
Y83
Y84
Y85
Y86
Y87
IND1
IND2
IND3
IND4
0.8521
0.0058
0.5920
-0.0028
2.1916
1.7866
-1.9538
0.1905
2.3221
0.4341
-0.6395
1.2547
-0.3354
P
0.2966
0.4537
0.0001***
0.8481
0.0066***
0.0235**
0.0079***
0.7933
0.0014***
0.5109
0.4078
0.0667*
0.5833
49
IND5
IND6
R-square
Adj R-sq
-0.2544
-0.3827
0.6823
0.5998
0.3722
0.3663
(+)(-)
* < 0.1** < 0.05*** < 0.01
ASM
PROE1
ASH
IND1 IND11 IND1 0
IND2 IND21 IND2 0
IND3 IND31 IND3 0
IND4 IND41 IND4 0
IND5 IND51 IND5 0
IND6 IND61 IND6 0
4-6 4-7
4-6
82 0.3809P 0.0007
83 0.4157P 0.0001
84 0.3741P 0.0001
85 0.3757P 0.0001
86 0.3342P 0.0001
50
87 0.5106P 0.0001
0.4157P 0.0001
82 10.0321P 0.0002
83 10.4185P 0.0001
84 9.1021P 0.0001
85 9.0279P 0.0001
86 8.2501P 0.0002
87 8.9259P 0.0007
8.8444P 0.0001
4-7
IND1
7.4048P 0.0312
IND2 8.4550P 0.0270 IND3 (
-7.4420P 0.0344
IND4 8.0322P 0.0100
IND6
31.6209P 0.0001
1.
2.
51
3.
4-6MODEL3
ASM(+)
SIZE(+)
IND1
IND2
IND3
IND4
IND5
IND6
R-square
Adj R-sq
82
83
84
P
-125.3258 0.0037*** -130.9460 0.0006*** -111.5280 0.0016***
0.3809 0.0007***
0.4157 0.0001***
0.3741 0.0001***
10.0321 0.0002***
10.4185 0.0001***
9.1021 0.0001***
4.3735 0.6148
3.8583 0.6120
5.3530 0.4583
-4.9446 0.6182
-11.9149 0.1950
-5.5879 0.5161
-10.6617 0.2270
-12.7951 0.0963*
-7.2687 0.3181
13.0030 0.0893*
5.0270 0.4598
3.3519 0.6101
15.3711 0.0880*
6.3720 0.4131
1.0112 0.8926
13.4999 0.2905
15.9385 0.1031
18.2588 0.0404**
0.2280
0.2631
0.2181
0.1877
0.2298
0.1860
52
ASM(+)
SIZE(+)
IND1
IND2
IND3
IND4
IND5
IND6
R-square
Adj R-sq
85
86
87
P
-107.1194 0.0016*** -100.1610 0.0064*** -114.3941 0.0092***
0.3757 0.0001***
0.3342 0.0001***
0.5106 0.0001***
9.0279 0.0001***
8.2501 0.0002***
8.9259 0.0007***
5.5708 0.5571
12.9282 0.1022
8.3327 0.3623
1.7130 0.8363
17.6943 0.0466**
35.6567 0.0010***
-7.5195 0.3207
-5.8581 0.4696
-5.6335 0.5635
3.2252 0.6315
6.7126 0.3510
15.0162 0.0806**
-4.2382 0.5247
0.1155 0.9868
0.8837 0.9127
34.8743 0.0001***
25.5543 0.0012***
49.6908 0.0001***
0.2315
0.1626
0.2430
0.2102
0.1412
0.2248
(+)(-)
* < 0.1** < 0.05*** < 0.01
ASM
SIZE
IND1 IND11 IND1 0
IND2 IND21 IND2 0
IND3 IND31 IND3 0
IND4 IND41 IND4 0
IND5 IND51 IND5 0
IND6 IND61 IND6 0
4-7 MODEL4
ASM(+)
SIZE(+)
Y83
Y84
Y85
Y86
Y87
IND1
IND2
IND3
IND4
-107.7322
0.4115
8.8444
-2.4004
-3.8999
0.6420
-3.4263
3.0766
7.4048
8.7550
-7.4420
8.0332
P
0.0001***
0.0001***
0.0001***
0.5600
0.3346
0.8644
0.3586
0.4083
0.0312**
0.0270**
0.0344**
0.0100***
53
IND5
IND6
R-square
Adj R-sq
0.8270
31.6209
0.7954
0.0001***
0.2110
0.2041
(+)(-)
* < 0.1** < 0.05*** < 0.01
ASM
SIZE
IND1 IND11 IND1 0
IND2 IND21 IND2 0
IND3 IND31 IND3 0
IND4 IND41 IND4 0
IND5 IND51 IND5 0
IND6 IND61 IND6 0
4-8 4-9
4-8
P 0.05 84
-0.1797P 0.0368 85 -0.1258P 0.0284
54
-0.1005P 0.0048
ICFOT
82 83 83 P
0.05( 0.4750P 0.0402) 84
85 -0.2628P
0.0043
-0.1220P
0.0473
4-8
82 0.5192P 0.0001
83 0.2469P 0.0006
84 0.4019P 0.0001
85 0.2362P 0.0001
86 0.4299P 0.0001
0.3534P 0.0001
ID1
6.2999P 0.0455
ID5 -5.1588P
0.0868
55
1.
2.
3.
4.
IND1
ID5
56
4-8MODEL5
82
83
84
7.8346 0.2960
10.4546 0.1092
21.1875 0.0010***
ASM(+)
-0.0140 0.4659
-0.1045 0.2089
-0.1797 0.0368*
ICFOT(-)
0.0940 0.3868
0.4750 0.0402**
-0.3803 0.0512
CDROE1(+)
0.5192 0.0001***
0.2469 0.0006***
0.4019 0.0001***
IND1
6.4995 0.5288
11.0687 0.2185
2.6083 0.7556
IND2
-10.4401 0.3667
-0.8974 0.9342
-6.2926 0.5269
IND3
21.6611 0.0496**
8.6440 0.3695
6.9658 0.4185
IND4
-3.8562 0.6881
1.1022 0.9065
-11.8122 0.1325
IND5
-4.8512 0.6600
-13.7589 0.1601
-6.4468 0.4613
IND6
-8.6287 0.5412
-1.8016 0.8672
-8.0510 0.4355
R-square
0.3140
0.1521
0.2182
Adj R-sq
0.2625
0.0956
0.1791
85
86
57
17.2848 0.0001***
6.4029 0.0361**
ASM(+)
-0.1258 0.0284**
-0.0371 0.2751
ICFOT(-)
-0.2628 0.0043***
-0.1098 0.1401
CDROE1(+)
0.2362 0.0001***
0.4299 0.0001***
IND1
7.2456 0.1917
5.0246 0.2677
IND2
-10.6914 0.1036
-1.1904 0.8154
IND3
-0.2406 0.9659
-3.4517 0.4342
IND4
-8.1327 0.1411
-1.6244 0.6917
IND5
-4.7650 0.3366
-2.1875 0.5706
IND6
-7.1599 0.2217
0.3576 0.9337
R-square
0.2098
0.2980
Adj R-sq
0.1800
0.2741
(+)(-)
* < 0.1** < 0.05*** < 0.01
ASM
ICFOT
CDROE1
IND1 IND11 IND1 0
IND2 IND21 IND2 0
IND3 IND31 IND3 0
IND4 IND41 IND4 0
IND5 IND51 IND5 0
IND6 IND61 IND6 0
4-9MODEL6
ASM(+)
ICFOT(-)
CDROE1(+)
Y83
Y84
Y85
Y86
IND1
IND2
IND3
IND4
IND5
16.5968
-0.1005
-0.1220
0.3534
-0.7606
-0.8244
-5.8858
-6.8237
6.2999
-5.4076
4.6898
-4.4394
-5.1588
P
0.0001***
0.0048***
0.0473**
0.0001***
0.8274
0.8026
0.0645*
0.0291**
0.0455**
0.1383
0.1459
0.1390
0.0868*
58
IND6
R-square
Adj R-sq
-3.7594
0.2822
0.2205
0.2100
(+)(-)
* < 0.1** < 0.05*** < 0.01
ASM
ICFOT
CDROE1
IND1 IND11 IND1 0
IND2 IND21 IND2 0
IND3 IND31 IND3 0
IND4 IND41 IND4 0
IND5 IND51 IND5 0
IND6 IND61 IND6 0
4-10 4-11
4-10
4-11
0.0969P 0.0101
59
ICFOT
4-10 86
82 0.5147P 0.0366
83
0.5733P 0.0048
84 0.4084P 0.0491
85 0.3218P 0.0050
4-11
0.3402P 0.0001
4-10
82 0.4762P 0.0001
83 0.4974P
0.0001
84 0.4010P 0.0001
85 0.4360
P 0.0001
86 0.4052P 0.0001
IND1
82 -17.1106P
0.0591
85
-16.1527P 0.0241
86
-10.4732
P 0.0942
4-11
-7.2788P 0.0306
60
1.
80
2.
3.
4.
4-10MODEL7
82
83
84
32.2967 0.0001***
26.9798 0.0002***
24.7546 0.0017***
ASM(+)
0.0455 0.3750
0.1531 0.0753
0.1625 0.0625
ICFOT(+)
0.5147 0.0366**
0.5733 0.0048***
0.4084 0.0441**
SDROE1(+)
0.4762 0.0001***
0.4974 0.0001***
0.4010 0.0001***
IND1
-17.1106 0.0591*
1.2461 0.8674
6.4800 0.4511
IND2
9.8106 0.3559
2.8965 0.7451
-4.3418 0.6801
IND3
-5.5130 0.5652
-2.0837 0.7913
-5.7418 0.5131
IND4
1.9276 0.8201
-0.5466 0.9435
-8.7652 0.2937
IND5
-2.2224 0.8156
2.3004 0.7722
13.2870 0.1353
IND6
6.9694 0.5732
-5.2430 0.5521
14.2560 0.1744
R-square
0.3240
0.3557
0.2345
Adj R-sq
0.2720
0.3118
0.1940
85
86
87
61
43.6747 0.0001***
45.9584 0.0001***
ASM(+)
0.0488 0.2787
0.0595 0.1952
ICFOT(+)
0.3218 0.0050***
0.1512 0.1415
SDROE1(+)
0.4360 0.0001***
0.4052 0.0001***
IND1
-16.2567 0.0241**
-10.4732 0.0942*
IND2
-10.3440 0.2038
-9.5861 0.1715
IND3
-3.7730 0.5847
0.6688 0.9149
IND4
-13.5873 0.0457**
4.7709 0.3980
IND5
-2.9948 0.6228
2.0199 0.7037
IND6
-1.3554 0.8526
0.9504 0.8762
R-square
0.2583
0.2364
Adj R-sq
0.2289
0.2097
(+)(-)
* < 0.1** < 0.05*** < 0.01
ASM
SDROE
IND1 IND11 IND1 0
IND2 IND21 IND2 0
IND3 IND31 IND3 0
IND4 IND41 IND4 0
IND5 IND51 IND5 0
IND6 IND61 IND6 0
4-11 MODEL8
ASM(+)
ICFOT(+)
SDROE1(+)
Y83
Y84
Y85
Y86
IND1
IND2
IND3
IND4
IND5
IND6
36.8671
0.0969
0.3402
0.4286
0.4187
-8.4690
2.0514
4.5339
-7.2788
-4.0486
-3.6370
-3.5016
1.8498
2.0402
P
0.0001***
0.0101**
0.0001***
0.0001***
0.9096
0.0158**
0.5437
0.1685
0.0306**
0.3009
0.2874
0.2729
0.5582
0.5836
62
R-square
Adj R-sq
0.2709
0.2608
(+)(-)
* < 0.1** < 0.05*** < 0.01
ASM
SDROE1
IND1 IND11 IND1 0
IND2 IND21 IND2 0
IND3 IND31 IND3 0
IND4 IND41 IND4 0
IND5 IND51 IND5 0
IND6 IND61 IND6 0
63
64
80
65
1/4
42 1/4
66
1.
-
85
2.
87
3.
289
88 1 82-85
4.
290
88 2 64-67
67
5.
84
6.
79
7.
-- 77
79
8.
86
9.
80
10.
34
87 3 90-97
11.
-
45 88 2 89-98
Book-to-Market
Equity.
GRSP
working
Paper
361,
69