Professional Documents
Culture Documents
letters
Pogo stick spring
I enjoyed reading the manuscript Studying Hookes Law by Using a Pogo Stick by Nicols Silva in the May 2011 issue of TPT (p. 300). The idea of using the pogo stick was creative, the data were easy to read, and the experimental results were very reasonable. Hookes law for the compression spring states that the compression distance is directly proportional to the force applied, F= kx. The author correctly suggests that the data do not extrapolate to (0,0) because the pogo stick must have had some initial compression. The data suggest that the formula is F= kx + b, where b is the initial compression force and k is the coefficient of expansion/compression of the pogo stick spring. The authors data suggest F = 44.597x + 238.57. Analysis of the data agrees with k = (F b)/x.
Compression (cm)
2.0 4.0 6.0 8.0 10 12 14
k = (F b)/x (N)/cm
41.7 44.6 44.9 45.3 45.2 44.5 44.2 Avg. 44.3
k = F/x (N)/cm
161 104 84.7 75.1 69.1 64.3 61.3
k = F/x appears invalid for this data.
In a similar vein the formula F = kx + b also applies to an expansion spring where b is the initial tension of the spring. This initial tension is the force that tends to keep the coils of an extension spring closed and which must be overcome before the coils start to open. See Reminder about Hookes Law and Metal Springs in the Sept. 1999 (p. 368) issue of The Physics Teacher.
St. Johns Prep Collegeville, MN 56321 pfroehle@csbsju.edu
Peter Froehle