Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Lending is one of the main functions of a commercial Bank. n formulating a credit judgment the credit
officers of BRAC Bank must be equipped with all information needed to evaluate a borrower.
n all kinds of business dealings, officers and employees must be guided by the principles of honesty,
integrity and safeguard the interest of the depositors and shareholders of the Bank. They should strictly
adhere to the Banking Laws, Rules and Regulations of the Govt. of Bangladesh, the instructions issued
by the Bangladesh Bank/Head Office from time to time that affect the business practices of the Bank.
Credit Risk Management is defined in six wings.
(1) Wholesale Credit
(2) Retail Underwriting
(3) SME Underwriting
(4) Central Collection Unit
(5) Special Asset Management, SME and Retail Banking.
(6) Special Asset Management & Credit nspection, Wholesale Banking & Medium Business
(1) WhoIesaIe Credit & Medium Business
To understand Wholesale/ Corporate Credit, we first need to understand, who will be considered as a
corporate client. Other than individual, business entities such as proprietorship concern, partnership
concern, co-operative society, club, Non-Government Organization (NGO) and limited company both
public and private are considered as corporate client.
Corporate Credit means a Contractual agreement in which a corporate client receives something of value
now and agrees to repay the lender the principle with interest at some later date.
Thus, the credit decision taken in approving a loan means that the bank is lending money to the corporate
client.
Objectives of the Team:
The objectives of the team are as follows:
- Managing credit risk
- Managing credit risk exposure
- Compliance with the rules/guidelines of Bangladesh Bank
- Compliance with the rules/policies of BRAC Bank
ResponsibiIities of the Team: Broadly, support Approval and post disbursement Monitoring. At a glance
overall the team responsibilities are as follows:
a) Analyze various corporate organizations and their debt structure.
b) Conducting credit reviews, discuss with Head of Corporate Banking as appropriate.
c) For new transactions/customer, analyze, ensure compliance with BBL and BB guidelines, ensure
compliance with relevant checklists/policies, ensure purpose and justification are satisfactory, identify
all risk issues, and place the proposal to Chief Credit Officer with recommendation by Head of Credit,
Wholesale Banking & Medium Business.
d) Develop and maintain peer group analysis for a particular industry sector.
e) Ensure excess documentation is reviewed and completed within the relevant time scales.
f) Actively develops relations with Front office and provides exceptional service and advice.
g) Monitoring the entire corporate portfolio after disbursement, maintaining updated database, preparing
various reports for internal and external purpose, and preparing Basel reports for Bangladesh Bank.
h) For each corporate relationship, credit rating is mandatory as per BB guidelines, which is to be
verified by CRM, i.e. Wholesale Credit team.
i) Monitoring of Early Alert Accounts (EAA) which may be reported due to breach of Terms and
Conditions, incomplete documentation, overdue nature, financial deterioration, management
problems, etc.
j) Post-disbursement activities such as Portfolio Review, reviewing stock report, factory/godown/office
visit, preparing Consolidated Exception Report for Credit Committee, preparing Expired and Excess
Over Limit (EOL) accounts report, etc.
k) Review credit exposure by risk grade. Conduct adequate trend and migration analysis to identify any
deterioration in credit quality. Report on Credit Concentration on the basis of risk grade and migration
analysis.
Types of faciIities we can offer to Corporate CIient: Broadly two types: (i) Funded and (ii) Non-funded.
(i) Funded faciIity: means financing through cash.
Product types:
a. Overdraft: A convenient and flexible form of short-term financing for routine operating
expenses and overheads of the company.
b. Import and Export Loans: Under this category products are Payment Against Documents
(PAD), Loan Against Trust Receipt (LATR), Revolving Loan (RL), nland Bills Purchase/
Discount, etc.
c. Long Term Ioans: Under this category products are Term Loans, Lease Finance, which we
extend to finance the fixed assets the corporate business needs (such as equipment,
machineries etc.). t may be a Greenfield project or an expansion of an existing plant.
(ii) Non-funded faciIity: non-involvement of fund/cash. Banks extend this type of facility against some
documents to third party on behalf of corporate clients.
Product types:
a. Import and Export Loans: Letter of Credit.
b. Guarantees and Bonds: Performance Guarantee, Advance Payment Guarantee, Bid Bonds.
Syndication Loan:
Syndication means joint financing by more than one bank to the same client against a common
security. This is done basically, to spread the risk. t also provides a scope for an independent
evaluation of risk and focused monitoring by the agent / lead bank.
PortfoIio: WhoIesaIe credit (WC) team mainIy Iooks after two kinds of portfoIio.
1) Under Corporate Business, WC team assesses and approves proposals from
a. Large Corporate: Financing businesses which are already established in the industry in which
they operate.
b. Emerging Business: Financing businesses which are still in their infant/ early years of
operation and would require financing to nurture and sustain the growth of business.
2) a) Medium Business: Financing businesses which have crossed their early years but has not yet
become a large corporate entity as per our definition.
b) Shomriddhi Loan (previously known as Trade Plus) and Shompod Loan (previously known as
Business Equity Loan) under Small and Medium Business (SME) as their nature of facilities
coincide with that of Corporate loans.
ApprovaI Authorities of the Corporate Loans:
. Head of Credit, Wholesale Banking & Medium Business
. Chief Credit Officer
. Managing Director & CEO
V. Board
The approval authority may change time-to-time based on business volume and person behind the desk.
Bangladesh Bank guidelines are always followed irrespective of the limit.
Due to large ticket size of loan facility, most of the proposals received by Wholesale Credit team are
approved by the Board of Directors.
Members of Credit Committee:
At present, Credit Committee consists of four persons:
a. Managing Director & CEO
b. Chief Credit Officer
c. Head of Corporate Banking
d. Head of Credit, Wholesale Banking & Medium Business
SingIe Borrower/Group Exposure Iimit:
As per Bangladesh Bank BRPD Circular no.05 dated 09.04.2005, banks can extend credit facilities to
single borrower/group up to 35% of bank's total capital except export oriented organization / borrower, but
funded facilities not exceed 15% of bank's total capital at any point of time. However, BRAC Bank policy
is to take exposure to single / group borrowers up to 30% of its capital, but funded facilities not exceed
15% of total capital.
AnaIyzing tooIs and techniques to evaIuate a corporate proposaI:
General 5C's are-
1. Character - ntention to pay loan- Management structure, Age, successor, experience etc.
2. Capacity - Borrower's competence in the field of employment to fund profitability, ability to generate
income and capability to repay the loan - Financial analysis, ratio analysis, cash flow etc.
3. CapitaI - Financial strength to recover the risk- nvestment
4. Conditions - ts business condition- ndustry analysis, Demand Supply analysis, Supplier buyer
analysis etc.
5. CoIIateraI mplies additional securities- Comfort at time of default for e.g. in the form personal
guarantee from directors of the company.
Large Loan:
As per Bangladesh Bank BRPD Circular no.05 dated 09.04.2005, loan granted to an individual,
organization, or group of companies or institutions, which is 10% or above the Bank's Capital would be
treated as Large Loan.
Lending Cap:
Lending Cap means establishing a specific industry sector exposure cap to avoid over concentration in
any one-industry sector. BRAC Bank's policy is to take total exposure of maximum 20% in one particular
industry.
Special Assets Management-SME & Retail Banking is a special department under CRM. ts vital role is to
recover the bank's bad portfolio. SAM deals with Bank's non-performing loans through legal
persuasion/procedure and facilitates external and internal recovery forces to maintain Bank's portfolio at
risk (PAR) at a steady position. Presently SAM has more focused on its expansion as day by day this is
becoming more challenging for managing the huge NPLs.
SAM department established the finest structure in the Banking industry of the country. Based on priority,
SAM is designed mainly as SME unit and Retail unit and also two separate units for Legal support & MS
and a Monitoring unit which acts as internal audit of the both portfolio.
For better performance and case to case close monitoring, it has segregated SAM-SME unit into four
separate Regions i.e Central, South, North and East. At the same time, SAM-Retail unit has divided into
two separate wings i.e Retail-Recovery and Retail-Legal. SAM-Retail-Recovery wing is a combination of
in-house recovery team and 3
rd
party recovery agencies.
SAM Structure:
a) SAM-SME (Central, South, North, East)
b) SAM-Retail (Recover, Legal)
c) SAM-Legal Support & MS
d) SAM-Monitoring
We have an excellent external and internal team encompasses of our Recovery Executives, Officers,
Managers and Lawyers working together across the country. We have an expedient Policy and
Processes which works as a guideline and recommendation to control classification and provision
expenses of the Bank.
SAM Activities:
The basic activity of SAM is RECOVERY of SME and Retail impaired loans through
1. recovery channel
2. cost effective legal procedures
3. amicable settlement
4. execution of decrees
5. repossession of car
6. arrangement of auction to sell the mortgaged property; collateral security
7. external 3rd party agencies
8. write-off management
9. waiver process
t is not the department to solicit/facilitate all legal services to every department. SAM department deals
with the legal actions regarding mitigation of bad portfolio under SME & Retail Banking Division.
FiIe Transfer:
Files transfer to SAM from SME when the loan reaches at DPD 180. SAM receives the file from Retail
when the loan reaches at DPD 360.
LegaI Action:
SAM processes the following types of cases:
a) Negotiable nstrument Act-1881, under section 138
b) Artha Rin Adalat Ain-2003
c) Civil Procedure code-1908
d) Penal Code-420/406/109
e) Appeal/Review/Revision
f) Writ Petition
g) Legal proceedings filed against BBL Staff in relation to recovery of loans.
Lawyer recruitment:
Generally 2 (two) lawyers would be enlisted in each district. f the cheques are
destroyed/damaged/utilized case to be filed in Artho Rin Adalat Ain-2003. f the loans are non-collateral,
SAM files cases under section 138 of N Act-1881. f the cheque is dishonored/returned for insufficient
fund. SAM files cases under N Act-1881, section 138
LegaI Notice:
Legal notice issued to SME at DPD 145 and for Retail at DPD 360, SAM-S&R would arrange to serve 1st
legal notice for warning the default borrower to adjust the total outstanding and 2nd legal notice would be
served after bouncing the cheque or before litigation under Artha Rin Adalat Ain 2003. 1
st
legal notice
served centrally across the country and 3
rd
party recovery agencies are working with retail defaulters. 15
(fifteen) days in 1
st
legal notice and 30 (thirty) days in 2
nd
legal notice under N Act given to the defaulter
to adjust the total outstanding.
Legal name of cheque dishonored case is case under Section 138 of Negotiable nstrument (N) Act-
1881.
Artha Rin Adalat Ain-2003 is a civil nature law. SAM filed case for recovery of loan against a deceased
borrower under Artho Rin Adalat Ain-2003.The legal successor/s of a deceased borrower, the third party
guarantor/s (if any) and the third party mortgagor/s (if any) will be the necessary opposite parties in an
Artha Rin case against recovery of loan of a deceased borrower. The principal debtors, the third party
guarantor/s (if any), and the third party mortgagor/s (if any) will be the necessary opposite parties in an
Artha Rin case. f the decree holder wants to execute any judgment of Artha Rin Adalat, he/she should
file an execution suit (Artha Jari) within 1 (one) year of expiry of stipulated time. Bank files cases to
recover their claim under Artha Rin Adalat Ain 2003. SAM will offer Auction to recover the overdue loan
against mortgaged properties before filing the case under section 12 of Artha Rin Adalat Ain 2003.
SAM file case under Penal Code-420/406/109 for committing criminal breach of trust, unauthorized sale
of mortgaged property or assets created out of bank loan, fake loans, closing of a/c where from security
cheques are provided etc. SAM has to obtain special recommendation from the respective Unit Heads if
they want to file a criminal case under section 420/406/109 of Penal Code.
Write- off Management:
BRAC Bank has a specific Write-off policy developed based on BB circulars. SAM takes initiative to write-
off bad portfolios as per policy if following criteria satisfied,
a) Classification status will be BL
b) 100% provided
c) Litigated (under any kind of Law of the land)
Waiver process:
SAM with its country wide recovery structure takes initiative to settle bad loans amicably by giving
delinquent customer waiver facility. The waiver amount will be fixed on judgmental basis i.e. affected by
sidre, natural calamities, demise, business closed etc. however, in any cases; waiver of principal portion
is not awarded.
Case Withdraw:
SAM withdraw the case when a litigated defaulter adjusts outstanding amount in full with updated interest,
legal costs and other expenses if any, and/or upon amicable settlement SAM withdraws the case against
such defaulters on receipt of clearance certificate from Operations.
ExternaI 3rd party agency Management:
SAM hands over the files to 3rd party recovery agency after one month of issuance of 1st legal notice.
Only the retail loan files, which are delinquent (if minimum 30% of outstanding is not recovered within 30
days after 1st legal notice) are handed over to outsource. SAM takeover the files from 3
rd
party recovery
agency after 90 days.
(6) SpeciaI Asset Management & Credit Inspection, WhoIesaIe Banking
& Medium Business (SAM & CI, WB & MB):
The department is split up from the Corporate CRM to maintain and ensure appropriate recovery
strategies are implemented as per policy guideline.
The department functions under three major areas which are as follows:
(1) Credit nspection through File and Field level area
(2) Early Alert Account
(3) Legal Procedure
1. Credit Inspection:
Credit nspection through file and field level area deals with all matters relating to credit inspection,
ensuring compliance of BBL policy towards credit granting process, corporate portfolio review and
physical inspection of client's premise and files, including security documents, for providing management
information reports on a regular and ad hoc basis.
Working area of Credit Inspection:
Following activities are fulfilled by credit inspection team.
nspect document file preserved with Origination Department.
nspect document file preserved with Wholesale Credit.
nspect document file preserved with Corporate Banking Department.
File inspection report generation.
Report vetting with concerned department for minimizing error level.
Final report published for modifying findings.
Summary report generation of file inspection.
Summary report publishing for modification.
Update the relevant modification.
Customer's office, factory, store visit.
Stock verification.
Visit report generation and publishing.
Prepare and maintain SAM & C related database.
Prepare meeting minutes for SAM & C meeting.
Meeting arrangement for reschedule, interest waiver.
Recovery of NPL.
Response of BB queries.
Corporate & Medium Business loan file documents review.
Corporate Classified Loan dentification.
Corporate Loan Regularizing & Recovery.
Call report & visit report preparation.
2. EarIy AIert Account (EAA):
Early Alert Process is an effective tool & technique that will help us in detecting any deterioration in
corporate and medium enterprise clients account and trigger out problem accounts at an early stage so
that proper attention can be given to avoid any losses. An Early Alert Report (EAR) is developed by
respective RM and sent to CRM within 07 days for identification of weakness and other discrepancy.
Reporting of EarIy AIert Account:
Despite a prudent credit approval process, loans may still become troubled. Therefore, it is essential that
early identification and prompt reporting of deteriorating credit signals be done to ensure swift action to
protect Bank's interest. The EAA symptoms are identified on the basis of 6 (six) typical characteristics of
the client which are ndustry & Competition, Ownership & Management, Balance Sheet, Cash Flow/
Repayment sources, Performance and Expired Limit/ncomplete documents. rrespective of the credit
score obtained by any obligor as per the proposed risk grade score sheet, the grading of the account
highlighted as Early Warning Signals (EWS) account.
On the basis of market information/ industry position or other subjective issues which has some strong
ground, CRM may recommend transferring the status of a regular account to EAA status.
The CRM should submit a consolidated EAR to the Credit Committee.
Redemption of EAA:
An account may be declassified to a regular account from the EAA status when the symptoms, causing
the EA classification have been regularized or no longer exist. The concurrence of the Credit Committee
is required for conversion from Early Alert Account status to regular account status.
3. LegaI Procedure:
SAM & C deals with managing impaired assets, Non-Performing Loan and the associated legal aspects.
Account Transfer Procedure:
When an account is being downgraded to SS and below, a Request for Action (RFA) along with a
checklist should be completed by RM with the help of CRM division and forwarded to Head of Special
Asset Management & Credit nspection (HOSAM&C) for acknowledgement.
Non Performing Loans: ReaIity and ChaIIenges
Nonperforming loans ("NPLs) refer to those financial assets from which banks no longer receive interest
and/or installment payments as scheduled. They are known as non-performing because the loan ceases
to "perform or generate income for the bank.
NPLs can be classified into different varieties usually based on the "length of overdue of the said loans.
NPLs are viewed as a typical byproduct of financial crisis: they are not a main product of the lending
function but rather an accidental occurrence of the lending process, one that has enormous potential to
deepen the severity and duration of financial crisis and to complicate macroeconomic management. This
is because NPLs can bring down investors' confidence in the banking system, piling up unproductive
economic resources even though depreciations are taken care of, and impeding the resource allocation
process.
According to the qualitative judgment criteria, bank managers classify any loan if it forecasts the
uncertainty of recovery of the loan due to the following reasons:
O Credit extended without approval of competent authority or without any logical basis (under
pressure).
O ncomplete documentation.
O nsufficient security or drastic fall in the value of security.
O Borrower sustains heavy loss in capital due to natural calamity or business condition.
O Frequent overdraw of limit
O Rescheduling terms are not maintained.
O Borrower cannot be traced or death of the borrower.
O Filing a suit against the borrower for recovery of credit.
NPL Account Monitoring:
As the account is handed over to SAM & C, WB & MB, the account is assigned to an account manager
within SAM, who will review all documentation, meet the customer with RM and prepare a Classified Loan
Review (CLR) report. The CLR should be approved by the Chief Credit Officer and copied to the Head of
Corporate Banking. The initial CLR should highlight any documentation issues, loan structuring
weakness, proposed workout strategy and seek approval for any loan loss provisions that are necessary.
Step Overdue
Period
Action Plan nitiative taken
Department / Division
0 days For each corporate customers, letter to be generated to inform
about expiry of the existing limit, at least two months ahead of
the expiry date and due date for installment
Corporate Banking
Division
1 1 to 30
days
Pursue over telephone for adjustment/payment of overdue
installment / interest and make a diary note.
ssue letter-informing about account fallen overdue and
request for regularization
Corporate Banking
Division
2 31 to 45
days
Persuasion over telephone to be continued
ssue 1
st
reminder
Corporate Banking
Division
3 46 to 59
days
ssue 2
nd
reminder for adjustment
Visit customer and submit a visit report
Check security documents
Corporate Banking
Division
Wholesale Banking
Operation
4 60 to 89
days
ssue 3
rd
reminder for adjustment
Report as EAA by Corporate/CRM
Call report
Corporate Banking
Division
Corporate CRM
SAM & C, WB & MB
5 90 to
179
days
Treat as SMA
Charge interest into Suspense
ssue notice to the borrower at least one month ahead of
classification stating that the account is going to be classified
Final reminder demanding payments and informing of the
consequences i.e. warning of legal action in case of default.
Corporate Banking
Division
6 180 to
269
days
Borrower to be transferred to SAM & C through prescribed
format with proper justification
Letter to Guarantor referring to above efforts seeking their
cooperation/asking for adjustments
Corporate Banking
Division
SAM & C, WB & MB
7 270 to
329
days
Review all documents (internally/Externally)
Meet the customer
Classified Loan Review Report
SAM & C, WB & MB
8 330 to
420
days
Meet the customer
Site visit
Strategy preparation for reschedule/exist/case filling under N
Act and Artha RN
Circulate the defaulter names to different Banks/NBF
SAM & C, WB & MB
LegaI Procedure:
Process flow for case filing under:
NI Act 1881
1 Within 15 days after 420 days Cheque Bounce SAM & C, WB & MB
2 Within 30 days of the cheque return days Serve legal notice SAM & C, WB & MB
3 Within 30 days of the acceptance of legal
notice
Case filing SAM & C, WB & MB
Artha Rin AdaIat Ain 2003
1 Within 30 days after 420 days Serve legal notice SAM & C, WB & MB
2 Within 45 days of notice period expiry Auction notice to be published
in the News Paper
SAM & C, WB & MB
3 Within 60 days of the expiry of auction
period
Case filing SAM & C, WB & MB
Activities of SAM & CI in case of LegaI procedure:
Following activities are done by the department.
a. Filling case under N Act 1881 & Artha Rin Adalat Ain 2003.
b. Court attendance.
c. Persuasion for transferring case from CMM to District Judge.
/. Executing arrest of warrant.
e. Communicating with local police station & pursuing for execution of arrest warrant.
f. Communicating with lawyer & discussing about every sections of the case.
g. Visiting & finding out default clients actual business & resident address for those clients who are
not communicating with the bank.
h. Checking & verifying lawyer bill submission.
i. Maintaining case register.
j. Corporate MS case maintaining.