CRIMINAL ADJUDICATION Fall 2011 Professor Ronald S. Sullivan Jr.

The casebook for the course is Allen, Stuntz, Hoffmann, Livingston & Leipold, Comprehensive Criminal Procedure (3rd ed. 2011).

THE IDEA OF DUE PROCESS 1. Fundamental Fairness and Incorporation Hurtado v. California (84) Duncan v. Lousiana (97) 81 104

THE CHARGING DECISION 2. 3. Prosecutorial Discretion 961 973

Inmates of Attica Correctional Facility v. Rockefeller (962) United states v. Batchelder (968) Limits on the Charging Power US v. Armstrong (974) 973 987

PRETRIAL SCREENING AND THE GRAND JURY 4. 5. 6. 8. Grand Jury Secrecy In re sealed case no. 99-3091 (994) The Subpoena Power US v Dionisio (1005) US v. R. Enterprises, Inc. (1011) Immunity and the act of Producing Documents US v. Hubbbell (1025) The Screening Function: PH and GJ Review Costello v. US (1039) US v. Williams (1044) 1034-1054 1018-1034 1004 1018 989 1004

BAIL AND PRETRIAL PROSECUTION 9. 10. Bail Stack v. Boyle (940) Preventive Detention US v. Salerno (946) 945 959 939 945

THE RIGHT TO COUNSEL AND OTHER ASSISTANCE 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. The Right to Appointed Counsel Gideon v. Wainwright (135) Alabama v. Shelton (148) The Scope of the Right to Counsel Rothergery v. Gillespie County, Texas (154) Halbert v. Michigan (172) Ineffective Assistance Strickland v. Washington (201) Rompilla v. Beard (216) Multiple Representation Cuyler v. Sullivan (242) Self-Representation Faretta v. California (257) US v. Gonzalez-Lopez (278) 257 288 232 257 199 232 154 199 133 154

THE SCOPE OF THE PROSECUTION 16. 17. The Right to a Speedy Trial Barker v. Wingo (1056) Doggett v. US (1068) Venue 1076 1103 1055 1076

 18.

US v. Rodriguez-Moreno (1078) Skilling v. US (1084) Joinder and Severance US v. Hawkins (1105) Zaifro v. US (1112) 1103-1117

DISCOVERY AND DISCLOSURE 19. 20. Disclosure by the Defense Williams v. Florida (1121) Taylor v. Illinois (1126) Disclosure by the Prosecution Kyles v. Whitley (1141) US v. Ruiz (1157) 1135 1163 1119 1135

GUILTY PLEAS AND PLEA BARGAINING 21. 22. 23. 24. The Plea process and Innocent Defendants US v. Broce (1174) North Carolina v. Alford (1177) Introduction to Plea Bargaining Brady v. US (1198) Bordenkircher v Hayes (1206) Restrictions on Plea Bargains Newton v. Rumery (1215) US v. Mezzanatto (1223) Marby v. Johnson (1232) Role of Defense Lawyers Ricketts v. Adamson (1236) 1236 1270 1214 1236 1186 1214 1165 1186

Santobello v. New York (1246) Hill v. Lockhart (1251) Williams v. Jones (1256)

THE JURY AND THE CRIMINAL TRIAL 25. 26. 27. Jury Size, Impartiality, Fair Cross-Section Ballew v. Georgia (1274) Batson Doctrine Batson v. Kentucky (1297) Miller-El v. Dretke (1313) Confrontation Rights Crawford v. Washington (1340) Davis v. Washington (1348) 1332 1370 1297 1332 1271 1284

DOUBLE JEOPARDY 28. 29. DP and Sentencing, Dual Sovereignty Heath v. Alabama (1533) Civil Penalties US v. Ursery (1548) 1545 1563 1533 1545

SENTENCING 28. 29. Introduction, Proportionality Ewing v. California (1408) More on Proportionality Roper v. Simmons (1423) 1423 1439 1403 1423

APPELLATE REVIEW 30. Appellate Review and Harmless Error Chapman v. California (1568) 1565 1580