Professional Documents
Culture Documents
q
+ = = V
4 1
3 3
v
v v v
= V
v
v
= VO
Now in Fourier space the equation is v ik
v
= O and hence the amplitude is v k
v
= O. Differentiating
the continuity equation (6) w.r.t. conformal time and putting the value of v
v
, the equation we get
..(7)
[where
2
1
3
s
p
c
v
v
= = for photon dominated fluid. This is the sound speed in the fluid.]
The solution to the oscillator equation can be specified given two initial conditions (0) O and
(0) O , and the solution is
(0)
( ) (0) cos( ) sin( )
s
ks ks
kc
q
O
O = O + , ..(8)
[where the sound horizon
0
s
s c d
q
q' =
}
]
This oscillation continued until recombination. At recombination free electron density drops
drastically and the photons freely stream to the observer and the pattern of acoustic oscillations on the
2 2
( ) ( ) 0
s
k c k k O + O =
recombination surface seen by the observer becomes the acoustic peaks in the temperature anisotropy.
Assuming negligible initial velocity perturbations (i.e. (0) 0 O ~ ) we get the temperature distribution
at recombination:
* *
( ) (0)cos( ) ks q O = O (9)
Hence for
*
ks nt = (where 1, 2, 3... n = ) the temperature distribution will have the extrema. In the
limit of sales large compared with the sound horizon ks 1, the perturbation is frozen into its initial
conditions. Hence large-scale anisotropies measured by COBE directly measure the initial conditions.
Fig8: Large scale anisotropy due to the initial baryonic distribution.
4.2. Gravito-Acoustic Oscillations:
So far we have neglected the effect of gravitational forces in our discussion. Considering the
perturbation to the metric elements the FRW line element for flat cosmology is written as:
2 2 2 2
[ (1 2 ) (1 2 ) ] ds a d dx q = + + + + u
We can think of this curvature perturbation as changing the local scale factor (1 ) a a +u ,
and hence
a a
a a
+u. Hence the continuity equation (3) now is written as
( ) 3 3 .
d a
n n n n v
d a
v v v v v
o
q
= u V
or,
1
3
kv
v
O= u .(10)
The time-time piece of the metric perturbation ( + ) modes the momentum conservation equation
and we get ( ) v k
v
= O++ . And now the solution of the forced simple harmonic oscillator
equation is
2
2 2
3
s
k
c k O+ O= +u ..(11)
The solution with adiabatic initial condition and consideringu~ +, can be written as:
[ ]( ) [ ](0)cos( ) ks q O++ = O++ (12)
Now ( O++) is the observed temperature fluctuation. Photons lose energy climbing out of
gravitational potentials at recombination and so the observer at the present will see
T
T
A
= O+ +
Therefore from the perspective of the observer, the temperature field will oscillate with larger
amplitude.
4.3. Baryonic effects:
Now we need to consider the inertial effect of baryon on the fluid as baryon momentum became
comparable to the photon momentum at recombination stage. Baryons add extra mass to the photon-
baryon plasma leading to the enhancement of the momentum density of the plasma. Now the
conserved momentum density of the joint system is written as
( ) ( ) (1 )( )
b b b
p v p v R p v
v v v v v v
+ + + = + +
Where ( ) /( )
b b
R p p
v v
= + + and
b
v v
v
= as photon and baryon were tightly coupled.
Then the momentum conservation equation becomes
[(1 )( ) ] 3 (1 )( ) (1 )( )
d a
R p v R p v p R p
d a
v v v v v v v v v
q
+ + = + + V + + V+ (13)
Now combining (13) to the continuity equation (10) we get
2 2
1 1
[(1 ) ] (1 ) [(1 ) ]
3 3
d d
R k k R R
d d q q
+ O + O= + + + u (14)
Now for the matter dominated approximation where += u= constant and neglecting the initial
velocity perturbation the solution of (14) is
[ (1 ) ]( ) [ (1 ) ](0)cos R R ks q O+ + + = O+ + + ..(15)
With the modified sound speed 1/ 3(1 )
s
c R = + .
4.3.1. Effects of Baryon loading:
- The amplitude of oscillations increases by a factor of (1+3R) as
1
[ (1 ) ](0) (1 3 ) (0)
3
R R O+ + + = + + due to the initial condition
2
(0) (0)
3
O = + .
- Next the equilibrium point of the oscillation is now shifted. So in the plot of effective
temperature the even and odd peaks have different amplitudes. In particular, baryon
loading increases the heights of the odd peaks over the even peaks
.
Fig9: (Adopted from Hu and Drodelson (2002) Baryons add inertia to the photon-baryon plasma displacing
the zero point of the oscillation and making compressional peaks (minima) larger than rarefaction peaks
(maxima).
- The lowering of the sound speed changes the acoustic scale as
* * s
s c q = .
Discussion:
The discovery of cosmic microwave background (CMB) is the most important discovery in the field
of observational cosmology. CMB temperature anisotropies have and will continue to revolutionize
our understanding of cosmology. NASA COBE mission (during 1992) clearly confirm the primary
anisotropy. The 2nd peak was definitively detected by WMAP showing the small scale temperature
fluctuation. Works are still going on for complete understanding of the temperature and polarization
field. Here it is a brief discussion of very basic things about CMB revealing the motivation study of
microwave background.
References
1. The Cosmic Microwave Background for Pedestrians: A Review for Particle and Nuclear
Physicists ( Authors: Dorothea Samtleben, Suzanne Staggs and Bruce Winstein).
2. CMB Temperature and Polarization Anisotropy Fundamentals (Author: Wayne Hu).
3. Cosmic Microwave Background Anisotropies (Author: Wayne Hu & Scott Dodelson)
4. Fluctuation in Cosmic Microwave Background (NASA)
5. Book: An Introduction to Relativity (J.K. Narlikar)
6.Book: Modern Cosmology (Scott Dodelson)
7.Wikipedia